Latest / Cultural Wars | America Out Loud News / The state of psychoanalysis today
Transcript
- 0:00Informed dissent, the intersection of healthcare and politics with Dr.
- 0:05Jeff Barkey, board certified primary care physician.
- 0:09And Dr.
- 0:10Mark McDonald, board certified child, adolescent, and adult psychiatrist.
- 0:15We are rolling.
- 0:17Well, listen, we're here with another great episode of informed dissent.
- 0:22My podcast co-host Mark McDonald right now is missing in action.
- 0:28But I bet he'll join us any minute.
- 0:30He's probably caught up in LA traffic.
- 0:32Um so we'll see what happens.
- 0:35But like we always try to do on informed descent.
- 0:38We try to bring you really interesting guests with super interesting topics.
- 0:44And we got one of them tonight, and that is Cece Evans Puglis.
- 0:50Did I pronounce that right?
- 0:51If you were speaking in Italian, you would say polyacy, but the marathon version is Paglisi.
- 0:58Okay.
- 0:59Very good.
- 1:00Well, Cece, welcome to Informed Descent.
- 1:03Thank you for having me.
- 1:05It is my pleasure.
- 1:06Little circuitous route, how you got to me.
- 1:10I'll tell a quick little story.
- 1:12I was blessed to be the co-founder of a wonderful charter school out in the city of Orange called Orange County Classical Academy.
- 1:20We're affiliated with Hillsdale College, and we opened during the pandemic of all times.
- 1:26And so annually we have a gala to try to raise some money.
- 1:30We bring in interesting speakers.
- 1:33Last year we had Kirk Cameron, uh, who's become a dear friend of mine and somewhat of a mentor?
- 1:39And during the gala, we auction off stuff.
- 1:42Somebody suggested that I auction off a morning message appearance for the kids.
- 1:47And there are a few people that bought them.
- 1:49And one of the people that bought them did a bait and switch.
- 1:52They texted me and said, Hey, I got this thing at the auction, but I want you to meet my friend who also happens to have kids at the charter school, because she's got a new book coming out that I think it would be fantastic to talk about.
- 2:06And that's how we ended up with Cece on informed descent.
- 2:10Did I get that about right?
- 2:12Yes, you sure did.
- 2:14Katrina.
- 2:15First of all, before we talk about your book that's coming out soon.
- 2:18Yes.
- 2:19Tell us about what you do.
- 2:21My understanding is you're a psychoanalyst.
- 2:23Is that right?
- 2:24Yes, I am.
- 2:25I'm a psychoanalyst and a concierge mindset coach.
- 2:28And um what does that mean?
- 2:31Explain what that means.
- 2:33Psychoanalyst.
- 2:35So a psychoanalyst is really interested in the unconscious mind.
- 2:41And how if the unconscious is does not become conscious, it can direct your life.
- 2:47Carl Jung had a quote, and he said, if the unconscious does not become conscious, it will direct your life and you will call it fate.
- 2:57One more time.
- 2:59If you do not make the conconscious conscious, it will direct your life, and you will call it fate.
- 3:08Wow.
- 3:09Well, that's most people, isn't it?
- 3:12Yes, it is.
- 3:14Most people don't spend any time trying to dive into the bowels of their mind to figure out what their unconscious is talking about.
- 3:22Maybe they should.
- 3:25Well, it's a very interesting feel, but you really can pick up what people are the stories, the narratives that people are telling themselves, and they're so unconscious, and they're often on such repeat that people aren't even aware of it, but you can feel someone's narrative.
- 3:44You can feel someone's narrative.
- 3:46You what do you mean you can feel it?
- 3:48You can feel by the way if you listen to if you really listen well, you can hear what people's inner dialogue is like.
- 3:57You can hear their inner world when you're really listening.
- 4:01Meaning you can you can feel and hear that they're saying things that are coming from the subconscious, and they may not even be aware of it.
- 4:11That's precisely what I'm saying.
- 4:14Uh-huh.
- 4:14So you must be super fun at a party because you hear this thing and you just have this urge to grab them by the scruff of their neck and say, dude, you got so much work to do, you need my help.
- 4:26No, I actually never do it unless I'm on the clock.
- 4:29It's too it's tiring, but it's important work.
- 4:34I'm very mission-minded.
- 4:36I believe that what we tell ourselves dictates how much of uh our calling, our mission will live out.
- 4:44And we have slow, we have subtle, we have undermining stories that change our narrative.
- 4:51Yeah.
- 4:51And help people, I believe that everybody's here on a call, they have a destiny, they have a purpose, and we can get in our own way, and we need help.
- 5:00Do you think there's anybody that that anybody without help that just naturally is able to connect the unconscious with the conscious?
- 5:09Yes, but I think it takes some work.
- 5:12I think it takes some self-reflection.
- 5:15I think it takes solitude.
- 5:17I think it takes a lot of the disciplines that we live in a culture that tricks us out of discipline.
- 5:24Our phone, our smartphones, they trick us out of attention.
- 5:30And so, and there's this slowness that's required to really consider how we're moving our life, how we're moving the needle or how we're not.
- 5:40It takes a consciousness, it takes an awareness.
- 5:43And but it's an important one, it's the most important one.
- 5:49When you say it takes some work, I mean, do you think there are people that they wake up one day and they go, you know, I got all this unconscious stuff going on in my mind, and I want to work on it to bring it to the level where I'm now aware of it and I can actually do something about it.
- 6:04Is that what you mean?
- 6:07Yes, well, I think we we can get in our own way.
- 6:10We can just get in our own way.
- 6:12When I think of Katrina, who is the reason why I'm here.
- 6:15When I I had a real revelation a decade ago, a Katrina the hurricane.
- 6:21No, Katrina Munoz, who had set this up for us.
- 6:24Oh, gotcha, got it.
- 6:26Okay, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 6:27So we've been childhood best friends since we were 13.
- 6:30Uh-huh.
- 6:30And I had a total epiphany a decade ago.
- 6:36It was 2016.
- 6:38And in 2016, I was always identified as the therapist.
- 6:42And there's something in me that almost refused the label.
- 6:46I didn't like it because I didn't want to be associated with people's problems.
- 6:50I really wanted to be associated with a potential.
- 6:53Okay.
- 6:55Well, well, well, I'm glad that uh Dr.
- 6:58Mark McDonald had the time to join us today.
- 7:00He must have been caught up in traffic in LA or was abducted by some alien or what have you.
- 7:07Mark, welcome.
- 7:08Welcome to informed uh dissent.
- 7:11Glad you could join us.
- 7:12It takes a lot of time to put a whole group of people on a 5150.
- 7:18It does.
- 7:20So Cece, we we have learned is a psychoanalyst, and uh helps people as she describes it, gets their subconscious to a conscious level, because those that don't do that tend to be slaves of things that they are unaware of.
- 7:38Sounds like 80% of the women in Los Angeles who are all you think is just women or men too.
- 7:45Well, the men are more functional.
- 7:49They're they're uh they're they're equally troubled, but for different reasons.
- 7:53I don't think it's personality disorders as much as it is uh a loss of um good role models in masculinity.
- 8:00I think the women are just personality disordered for the most part.
- 8:02Narcissism and borderline is really sort of the the norm in Los Angeles where I live.
- 8:08You're not here, I assume you're in a different city.
- 8:10She's in Orange County.
- 8:11Oh, you're in Orange County.
- 8:12Oh, it's much better down there.
- 8:14It's probably only 40%.
- 8:17I was telling Dr.
- 8:18Barkey, Dr.
- 8:19Mark, that I uh the Yoon quote, which was and I'm sure you've heard this, but he said, unless you make the unconscious conscious, it will direct your life and you will call it fate.
- 8:32Sounds about right to me.
- 8:34And so we were kind of unpacking that a little bit before you got on.
- 8:39Well, that's something that I studied for quite a number of years.
- 8:42But for uh for Dr.
- 8:44Barkey, it uh it may be a little bit more uh novel.
- 8:49Is your unconscious conscious mark?
- 8:51Let me let me check in and see.
- 8:56It's one of those, it's one of those things that you you you don't really often know uh what you don't know, which is kind of the challenge, and that's why we use you know therapists of different uh types, particularly psychoanalysts who have uh more in-depth training to help um elicit that because this is the problem, isn't it?
- 9:16Really, with with therapy in general, uh especially therapy today, in my view, is that most therapists really are only trained to work with the conscious mind.
- 9:26And although it can be helpful problem solving and hand holding and being uh uh you know emotional receptacle for patients, it doesn't generally uh aid in overcoming really long term embedded difficulties, especially those that occurred early in development and childhood, because those are definitionally unconscious, and solving the surface problems is uh just playing whack-a-mole.
- 9:52And I think that's what most therapists do right now is they just focus on cognitive behavioral therapy and other forms of um.
- 10:00Intellectual problem solving rather than getting to the core of the identity, which is really, as we said in our in our training years ago, we don't really generally have to treat the adults in the room.
- 10:09We have to treat the children.
- 10:12The inner child.
- 10:14Yeah, essentially.
- 10:15That's where most of the problems come in.
- 10:17Because the adult problems, you can probably hash out with your friends at the bar.
- 10:22Sure.
- 10:23So definitionally is the unconscious mind a trauma created mind.
- 10:31Could be.
- 10:33Not definitionally, but it could be.
- 10:37Sure.
- 10:37Well, we all have that, right?
- 10:39Is that the mind that we where we have an inner dialogue, a nonstop inner dialogue that just keeps talking to us?
- 10:44Well, I'm I'm being I'm being a bit jokey here only because I think the word trauma has been overstated.
- 10:50Uh, you know, not being able to find the right milk at the grocery store is not traumatic.
- 10:56And yet that's the way that people will talk about trauma dumping today.
- 11:00Maybe it is for some people.
- 11:02Well, listen, when they're out of raw milk, that's pretty traumatic for me.
- 11:09For my daughter too.
- 11:10My daughter Jordan is the same way.
- 11:12She's come home crying that sprouts is out of raw milk.
- 11:16Exactly.
- 11:17So what is the definition of a psychoanalyst and how is that different than a therapist?
- 11:23Well, a psychoanalyst is really trained to listen to the unconscious and really figure out how what the person is saying is getting in their own way of what they want to accomplish.
- 11:33First, for example, if someone were really overweight and they want to talk about losing weight, but they can never can because they keep getting in their own way through their own habits.
- 11:44There's a narrative underneath the habits that needs an intervention.
- 11:50And I find that the best way to intervene and change the narrative is to find out what they're passionate about, what they feel like they're called toward, what they really want.
- 12:02And we really can get seduced into complacency in this culture and forget that we are created to bring purpose, to bring meaning, to bring mission.
- 12:13And so I was telling Dr.
- 12:16Barkey this right before you came, but I had a big change about 10 years ago.
- 12:22And the change was I always felt a little bit self-conscious, calling myself a therapist.
- 12:27I did not want to be associated with people's problems.
- 12:31I really wanted to be associated with people's potential.
- 12:36And what they could do if they got out of their own way and how they would get out of their own way is by changing how they talk to themselves and changing how they show up and changing getting a very clear idea of where they want to go.
- 12:53And so at that point, 10 years ago, I really shifted away, even though I kept, you know, as you both know, no matter what you do, if you changed your title, you'd keep all your degrees, right?
- 13:05You'd keep all your degrees, but you can absolutely change your trajectory and what you want to go after.
- 13:11And I wanted to go after people that were burning with mission and had a lot of passion, but could not figure out how they kept undermining themselves, how they kept sabotaging themselves.
- 13:25And so I really rebranded myself 10 years ago.
- 13:31Yeah, I get that.
- 13:33How do you find clients?
- 13:35I have all self, all referrals from clients that I've worked with.
- 13:41My clients drive all my referrals.
- 13:44I've never had advertised.
- 13:48Which is which is amazing.
- 13:50And most I recall, I think you told me we were at a dinner party together at uh weren't we at Kelly Jones's house?
- 13:58Yes.
- 13:59Yeah.
- 13:59And I think in super interesting, first of all, you you charge a lot of money and good for you.
- 14:06Um, and you work mostly with men, as I recall.
- 14:10I started off thinking I was working with women.
- 14:13I thought I I love women, I love men, but women often have more support than men do.
- 14:20They often have more support.
- 14:22They more support.
- 14:23I mean, like girlfriends that they can talk to and so forth.
- 14:26Yes, we can open up, we can meet another woman and open up our whole lives over a glass of wine, over a cup of coffee.
- 14:35And men often don't have that same ability.
- 14:38So when I started off with women, all the referrals they would send me were men, important men in their lives that they thought needed my help.
- 14:48And so now my practice is predominantly men.
- 14:51I do see both, but predominantly men.
- 14:54Mark, do you currently or have you done psychoanalysis?
- 14:58Yeah, I actually was involved in a psychoanalytic training program here in Los Angeles uh for about eight years, actually.
- 15:07And I completed uh eight years of psychoanalysis myself as an analysant, as well as several years of psychoanalytic psychotherapy before that.
- 15:17So probably about 12 years of 20 hours a week of time commitment and investment.
- 15:21Wow.
- 15:22Before I decided to relinquish uh my entire status and participation at the institute in 2020.
- 15:32And I did that for one very specific reason, although there were others, including um the difficulty of maintaining a psychoanalytic practice today and actually making money, which is nearly impossible.
- 15:44I would say it actually is impossible.
- 15:45There's maybe four people in the country that are still doing that, uh, and they're all on the East Coast.
- 15:51So the reason why I decided to leave was essentially that I lost respect for the analytic community, the traditional analytic community, because they all shut down their practices and went remote in 2020.
- 16:07And they were the people that uh in their 70s and 80s, a lot of these mentors had been telling me for years how important it is to express courage with your patients.
- 16:17Um we don't in psychoanalysis, we don't have clients, we have patients.
- 16:21And I well, I don't what's the distinction?
- 16:26What's the distinction?
- 16:27Uh clients are clients work for barbers, uh, lawyers, the uh hai dressers.
- 16:33Um, you know, they go in and say, dye my hair, defend me against a court case.
- 16:38Uh, here's the money I pay you for your service.
- 16:41Um doctors don't have clients either.
- 16:44Uh, doctors have patients, and there is a difference because um transgender children uh are clients of you know, surgical mutilators, they're not doctors.
- 16:54They go in and ask to have their penis cut off and they get the service.
- 16:57Those doctors don't have any ethical parameters, they just they take the money and they cut the penis off.
- 17:02So as long as you're a client, you can ask for what you want and get it by paying money.
- 17:06If you're a patient, then the doctor has the right and the obligation to refuse.
- 17:10And so does a therapist.
- 17:11I'm really troubled by the way that um this is this is really a side tangent.
- 17:16That's that's redundant, right?
- 17:18That's a tangent, but the the invasion, the takeover of clinical care and mental health, especially more specifically psychiatry, but also in the therapy community by the behavioral therapy model, which is social science, social services, essentially, social services has taken over this field, uh, which is a client-based, you know, matching services to clients.
- 17:42That's what social services are, get a house for the homeless lady.
- 17:45She's not a patient, she's a client.
- 17:47That's taken over therapy.
- 17:49So now you have uh, you know, MFTs, L CSWs, MSWs, all being trained by social workers, as well as CITES and even to some degree PhDs now, who are taught that the people who are suffering and their patients are not actually patients, they're just clients that are in need of services.
- 18:06And I think that's an abomination.
- 18:08I think it's it's destroyed the profession.
- 18:10Um, it's it's in it's going into medicine as well, especially psychiatry.
- 18:14I think it's wrong.
- 18:15I think it's unethical.
- 18:16I don't think that people are coming for services.
- 18:18I think they're coming because they're injured, they need to be healed.
- 18:20But um the reason why I left psychoanalysis was that all of the psychoanalysts who had patients, they just disappeared, shut their practices down and abdicated their role as the provider and protector of their patients to sit with them in the room and actually care for them because they were scared.
- 18:41So they displayed a lack of courage, they displayed cowardice, and I can't respect um anyone, especially a mentor that is a coward.
- 18:50And so I dropped out of the program and I never looked back.
- 18:52And um, I'm not really interested in traditional psychoanalysis anymore.
- 18:56I think it's um it's largely defunct.
- 18:59Um you mean you you as a provider of it, or you as a potential patient of it.
- 19:04Uh as a member of the community, the psychoanalytic community as an as an institution, let's say, kind of like uh, you know, the like pediatrics, for example, uh, or or surgery or internal medicine.
- 19:19Those those systems have all been kind of taken over by politics and ideology.
- 19:23And I think psychoanalysis has as well.
- 19:25I get announcements now.
- 19:27I mean, I just got one last week, for example, from an institute in Los Angeles that's a different institute than the one I went to uh on a lecture series for psychoanalysts and psychoanalysis and training to discuss using psychoanalysis for homeless people, or they call them the unhoused.
- 19:43I just started laughing.
- 19:43I said, You you can't have a homeless person in psychoanalysis.
- 19:46First of all, who's gonna pay for it?
- 19:47He's not gonna he's any money.
- 19:49If you don't pay for this for the psychoanalysis, you're not gonna be engaged.
- 19:53And someone who's homeless is probably on drugs, he's probably got serious mental illness, he's failed at every aspect of his life, he's living on the
- 20:00Street, he doesn't need psychoanalysis, he needs a social worker.
- 20:03Uh, so I I really don't think that psychoanalysis uh today as an institution, the way that it's taught and understood expresses a lot of courage or a lot of um uh I think ethical standards.
- 20:17I think it's just been taken over by woke leftists, just like everything else.
- 20:20Um I love the the history.
- 20:22I love the people who who brought it up and began it a hundred years ago, but the way that it's practiced today, I think it's a joke.
- 20:28So if if if the goal of ultimately being a healthy human being is to get in touch with your subconscious and bring it to a conscious level, and psychoanalysis is the primary tool to do that.
- 20:42What's somebody to do then that wants to get healthy?
- 20:47Well, they don't go to psychoanalysts, psychoanalysis is not it's not available for poor people.
- 20:53So they just go on a market on this.
- 20:56Uh well, they go to their coach uh online, uh, who their boss has given them credits to pay $20 for a coaching session, or they go to a um, you know, master's level trained supportive therapist, or they go to do CBT, or now actually I think most of the coaching-based therapy and support is going to be completely replaced by very advanced level um AI tools.
- 21:21Um all of the coaching can be done online using AI now.
- 21:25Um, I'm not saying I just can AI can't psychoanalysis.
- 21:29No, that's that's the whole problem.
- 21:30That's why it's not you have to have a human being in the room to do psychoanalysis.
- 21:34Why it costs a lot of money because the only way to assist someone in a psychoanalytic frame is to actually be a human being.
- 21:44Computers are not able to reflect on an unconscious process by definition.
- 21:48They can only solve problems.
- 21:50Psychoanalysis is not about problem solving.
- 21:53It's not the point.
- 21:54So CeCe, somebody who wants to get in touch with that conscious part of their body, their mind, and bring it to a conscious level, unconscious to conscious, but now doesn't have access to a psychoanalysis because they don't live in Orange County, and or they can't afford what you or others are charging.
- 22:12What are they to do?
- 22:15Well, I think it's interesting.
- 22:17I would I agree with you actually, Dr.
- 22:19Mark, entirely.
- 22:20The field has always been woke.
- 22:23Even even in graduate school, forever, it was always a woke field.
- 22:27It was very left-leaning.
- 22:29And always, but and I don't I identify with the training because I got great training.
- 22:34I studied the masters.
- 22:35They pioneered the fields, like they were they were revolutionaries in their own right.
- 22:41And so while I wouldn't say that that is you and asked me what the definition of a psychoanalyst was, Dr.
- 22:48Barkey.
- 22:48And so that's what I was referring to.
- 22:50But I believe that I walked away, I kept the depth.
- 22:54I kept the depth of thought, but I don't do psychoanalysis anymore.
- 23:00But but I love the depth of it.
- 23:02There's there's nothing like it.
- 23:06And so I that is what that's the piece that I have taken with me that will never leave me.
- 23:11To listen on that level to another human being is the honor of my life.
- 23:19And so I you can keep that.
- 23:21Even though that's what you're doing now, right?
- 23:24Is I recall when we were talking at that dinner party.
- 23:27Um you were talking about helping generally men more than women find their purpose, and then be effective at whatever that purpose is.
- 23:41Yes, that's what I'm passionate about.
- 23:43And I'm really passionate about I'm I believe that there's an absolute place for people that don't know their purpose.
- 23:51They are not, they they have small things or important things that they want to deal with.
- 23:58I'm very attracted to people who know what they want and are clear about it.
- 24:03Sure.
- 24:04So those are the people that I like to be inspired.
- 24:08I I work a lot.
- 24:09I want to come to work, and I want to be inspired by the people that I see, and I am.
- 24:14When you work with a client, what does that look like?
- 24:16How many is it once a week, more than once a week?
- 24:19Once a week, once a week.
- 24:22Once a week is generally an hour and a half every week.
- 24:26And you know, sometimes vacations change things, or I work remotely and I do a lot of things.
- 24:32So sometimes that changes, but this standard, yeah, you can uncover a lot in an hour and a half a week.
- 24:39For sure.
- 24:39And you say you work remotely.
- 24:41So uh, do you call them clients or patients?
- 24:45And do they physically see you, or they on like a Zoom call or something of that sort?
- 24:49Well, I have patients all around the world.
- 24:52And so a lot of it zoom, some of it's called and then if someone's relatively local, they come in.
- 24:58But the one thing that COVID did do is it opened up the forum for all different kinds of work.
- 25:06And so it exploded my practice in that time because what I thought had to be done in person.
- 25:12Turns out I could do it online, even though Dr.
- 25:15Mark, I want you to know I never I never shut down.
- 25:19I never shut down.
- 25:20If someone was willing to come in, I wanted to see them.
- 25:24That did not change for me.
- 25:26I think there's something really important about face-to-face contact.
- 25:30I I totally agree.
- 25:32I I have a therapist I've been seeing for a long time.
- 25:34I really adore the guy.
- 25:36He's a uh Christian, you know, we we've not friends is too strong of a word.
- 25:42We don't hang out outside, although I would love to do that.
- 25:45Um seeing him physically in person in his office uh is so much better.
- 25:53There's been a couple times where we've done remote stuff.
- 25:56I just I'd rather not even do it than you know, not being able to see a person.
- 26:01Now, that being said, um, you know, you know, we're gonna take a quick break, and when we come back, I'm gonna finish that thought about in-person versus remote therapy.
- 26:12And then we didn't get to this, but it's important that Cece has a book out about narcissism, and I want her to talk to us about that.
- 26:20It's coming out soon.
- 26:21So we'll be back uh in just a minute.
- 26:24Well, get ready, my fellow Americans, July 2nd, 3rd, and 4th.
- 26:29America Outloud.news in partnership with Clear and the Wellness Company invites you to Nashville, Tennessee for a red, white, and blue celebration.
- 26:40You'll never forget.
- 26:41We're saluted 250 years of America and 10 incredible years of America Outloud News, standing strong for truth, justice, and the nation we all love.
- 26:52Three days of high impact speakers, powerhouse voices delivering dynamic, unforgettable insights that will fire up your patriot spirit.
- 27:01And on July 4th, well, brace yourself because you'll experience America's most explosive firework show, lighten up downtown Nashville in pure patriotic glory.
- 27:12You can reserve your spot with early bird cryson right now at America Outloud dot news forward slash Nashville.
- 27:20It's America Outloud News 25010 Nashville, be there.
- 27:24Struggling with your health, energy, and constantly feeling hungry, want to save money on the rising cost of groceries and dramatically improve your health.
- 27:33Go to chemicalfree body.com forward slash out loud today, get nature's super multivitamin, doctor formulated green 85 juice formula, empower your immune system, cut your grocery bill, and save 20% on your first order.
- 27:47Your heart is crucial.
- 27:48Are you supporting it as you age?
- 27:49Try the wellness company's healthy heart formula with taurine, derribose and coenzyme Q10.
- 27:54Designed by Dr.
- 27:55Peter McCullough, Healthy Heart helps boost heart function and support cardiac strength.
- 28:00Get 20% off your first order plus free shipping at TWC dot health forward slash out loud with code out loud.
- 28:07Oral hygiene hasn't changed in 50 years, but our diet and the way we eat has creating an environment in your mouth for bacteria to wreck havoc on your teeth and gums for better oral health.
- 28:18Get spray dental defense and oral care line designed to combat acid-creating bacteria.
- 28:24The toothpaste, mouthwash, mints, and gum all contain xylitol and natural ingredients shown to dramatically improve oral health.
- 28:33Sprite can be found online and at all fine natural retailers.
- 28:39Well, only when the government vows to the people will America become great again.
- 28:45So this is Malcolm Outlaw here.
- 28:47Join me in pushing back against censorship, my fellow Americans.
- 28:52Right at the top of America Outloud Doc News are the words.
- 28:56Many voices won freedom, united in the first amendment.
- 29:04Now is our time, my fellow Americans.
- 29:08America outlaw.
- 29:15All right.
- 29:16We are back with Ceci, psychoanalyst to the stars.
- 29:19She's got a book coming out about narcissism called The Fog of War, Unmasking Narcissism, Breaking Illusions, and Becoming Victorious in the face of defeat.
- 29:32Before we talk about the book, I just want to finish that thought about online remote work as a therapist, a counselor, psychoanalyst versus in person.
- 29:41You know, there was several talk radio psychologists.
- 29:45There was David Viscott, Dr.
- 29:47Famous Dr.
- 29:48Laura.
- 29:49There's a patient of mine, he passed a couple years ago.
- 29:53Um, and he did a lot of radio psychology to the point that he believed his name was John.
- 30:00Jolith, really wonderful man.
- 30:02He believed that he actually was more effective by not being distracted by seeing somebody's physical presence and just listening to their voice by doing remote therapy.
- 30:14Now, maybe it was a rationalization, I don't know.
- 30:17But that was his shtick that he actually felt more effective by talking to people from far away, and he had clients around the world, etc.
- 30:25I don't know.
- 30:25What do you what's your thought about that, Mark?
- 30:29I'm a little how would I put it?
- 30:34Um more accepting now of remote consultation and therapy, but with a sort of caveat that there's information that you miss that you can't get when you're not in the room with someone.
- 30:48And so I think your expectations have to be more measured.
- 30:52I think coaching can be done really well over the internet.
- 30:54Sure.
- 30:55Um psychoanalysis, um, no.
- 30:58Um psychotherapy to some degree, sure.
- 31:03What's the difference?
- 31:04Well, psychotherapy, if it's pure psychotherapy and not even psychoanalytically informed, it's not really dealing with unconscious processes, it's dealing with what's on the surface, what's conscious.
- 31:15You can talk about what's conscious very easily.
- 31:17You don't really need any other cues.
- 31:19But as soon as you start focusing on unconscious processes, you really have to have a much more in the moment exchange uh to have the full spectrum of information.
- 31:29You can gather some, but I think you're gonna miss something when you're just looking at a screen and people sitting in a chair.
- 31:34So you need rolling, you need tears welling up, you know, no facial expressions.
- 31:39No, you get all that from the screen.
- 31:41I'm talking about motion, movement, uh, what people's energy uh is uh, how they're shifting in their chair, what they're looking at in the room that's being shared between the two of you.
- 31:52You don't have any shared experience when you're sitting in front of a screen in different parts of the world, you might not even be in the same time zone.
- 31:59So you're gonna miss a lot.
- 32:01That's the problem with it.
- 32:03But I do think you can certainly talk and see expressions on people's faces, certainly better than a telephone call and do um really good work uh remotely.
- 32:14I just think people's expectations need to be tempered.
- 32:16And I think what upset me in 2020 was that a lot of professionals, because they were more concerned about maintaining their social status, not their not their health, they couldn't care less about that.
- 32:28It was a joke, their social status, their professional status, they all of a sudden turn their backs on what they had been professing for decades, especially analysts, which was if you're not in the room with the patient, then you're not doing real work.
- 32:40And then suddenly they said, well, fake Dr.
- 32:43Barbara Ferrar in Los Angeles, who has a doctoral degree in social work and has never had one therapeutic interaction in her life, she told us that we all have to and can work with our patients remotely over a video interface, so we're all gonna do it.
- 32:56And suddenly 150 years of psychoanalytic tradition just went out the window.
- 33:00Sure.
- 33:00And and nobody said boo about it.
- 33:03And I was so upset and disappointed by everyone, including the analysts involved in the institutes that I just left, as I said earlier.
- 33:11So I I do I do think we can use these interfaces.
- 33:15We can use video, we can I'm not against it.
- 33:18I just think we have to be honest about what we're what we're using it for and what it's what's lacking, rather than suddenly pretending that a political stance can just supplant all of our, as you were saying earlier, uh, you know, decades, a century plus of masters of teaching who all taught us one thing, and suddenly we just pretend like it doesn't exist uh because uh Anthony Fauci said it doesn't, you know, like a magic wand.
- 33:44And I I don't like deception, I don't like lying, I don't like rationalizations, and and I found I just found that to be all very offensive from top to bottom.
- 33:55What did you do with your own practice?
- 33:57Like what happened inside of your practice?
- 34:01Mm-hmm.
- 34:02I kept it open for one thing, and I told patients that I insisted that they come in unless they had an actual medical reason not to, and that would be that they're sick.
- 34:10And I said, but that hasn't changed.
- 34:12I said, if you're sick, I don't want you in my office.
- 34:14I've always said that.
- 34:15If you're not sick, then you have to get your butt in the door.
- 34:18And if patients that refuse to come in for no rational reason, I said, Look, um, I'm here to treat your mental illness.
- 34:25And if your expression of mental illness is refusing to come in, then we're avoiding the whole the whole reason why you're here because staying home is a form of mental illness.
- 34:35So I just refuse to see them.
- 34:37And uh, I mean, I didn't refuse to see them.
- 34:39I I told them I wanted to see them, but they refused to come in.
- 34:42So they just left.
- 34:44And the ones that stayed were the ones that came in physically, and I kept seeing patients that way and kept my practice open the entire time.
- 34:55At that point, I was no longer seeing psychoanalytic patients, uh, although I was still in the program.
- 35:02And so for me, uh, most of my patients were either weekly therapy patients or they were medication management patients.
- 35:09And the ones that wanted in-person treatment stayed, and the ones that didn't, um, they just left and went somewhere else.
- 35:15So it was kind of like a filtering effect.
- 35:17Sure.
- 35:18What did you keep from the psychoanalytic world, that form of thought, all your training?
- 35:24You were you were steeped in it.
- 35:26What did you end up keeping?
- 35:27What did you take away?
- 35:29Well, at the beginning, what I maintained was the psychoanalytic stance, which was the lack of personal investment, objectivity, uh, listening, listening to myself as much as the patient, feeling my own reactions and emotions to patients.
- 35:47As you know, when a borderline walks in the room, you can feel it immediately.
- 35:50That's their biggest sign that the person is borderline or narcissistic, cluster B types of disorders.
- 35:57So for patients that had unconscious problems that were personality disordered, I maintained that stance of being able to be a sounding board to them through myself.
- 36:07But after a while, and I would say in the last few years, maybe the last two years, what I've decided, and this is a conscious decision on my part, is I'm just not dealing with personality disorders anymore.
- 36:17Uh, I'm not gonna try to work with them or treat them.
- 36:20I just don't have the energy or the patience.
- 36:22Um, I think that people today who come in with expectations from their therapist that they're going to magically cure them of their what is ultimately a personality disorder, are not worth my time and my energy.
- 36:39Uh, and I think you do get ground down working with personality disordered patients because they take something from you every time you see them.
- 36:46And I think it my own mental health is is I need to prize that above all else.
- 36:52And so um, that's one reason why I don't work with them anymore therapeutically.
- 36:56I mean, I might see them in medication management, but I'm not going to work with them as a therapist.
- 37:02Um I just don't think that they're amenable to treatment, and I think that they grind the therapist down when you try to work with them.
- 37:09And uh, I'm just not willing to do it anymore.
- 37:14Makes perfect sense to me.
- 37:16So CC, let's get into your book.
- 37:18The fog of war.
- 37:20What an interesting title.
- 37:21Uh subtitle, unmasking narcissism, breaking illusion, and becoming victorious in the face of defeat.
- 37:28Tell us about that.
- 37:31Okay.
- 37:32One thing I have to tell you is since I told you the book is in final editing stages.
- 37:37It's the subtitles change.
- 37:39It's the fog of war, reclaiming yourself on ground.
- 37:44Ah, very good.
- 37:45So that's change.
- 37:46I don't, that's a that's a pejorative word.
- 37:49It's a it's a uh inflammatory word, and I don't want that to be the reason why people pick up the book.
- 37:56My hope is that I feel like narcissism was in almost in the bloodstream of my family line.
- 38:05And I was as even as a child fighting an invisible war.
- 38:10Can you define narcissism?
- 38:13Well, the DSM could find define it better than I could.
- 38:17But the what the the chief weapon that's used in narcissism is it creates a very destabilizing, very disoriented feeling on the other side.
- 38:31Like Dr.
- 38:31Mark says, you can feel them energetically when they walk in the room.
- 38:36There's a change, there's this subtle humiliation, there's a subtle, there are digs, and sometimes it's so refined.
- 38:47The only someone on the other side of when their comments can feel the blade.
- 38:52It is a very, it's a very uh sophisticated way that they move and manipulate you.
- 39:01And my hope is that I unpack all the ways that narcissists do manipulate us so they feel like I'm can I give you a story?
- 39:14Sure.
- 39:15I have five girls, Dr.
- 39:16Mark.
- 39:16I uh and my oldest was in jujitsu.
- 39:20And jujitsu, I don't know if you know the whole philosophy about jujitsu, but it's fascinating.
- 39:26It is a really fascinating martial art because instead of combating aggression with aggression, you combat aggression with posture, with position with leverage.
- 39:41You learn how to use opponent's strength against them.
- 39:46Right.
- 39:47And so, and they call it the the human chess, like it's human chess.
- 39:53You were you were thinking two to three moves above your opponent.
- 40:00And I want to train people to really recognize how they're getting manipulated.
- 40:07So they have more standing inside of themselves.
- 40:11And they are less likely to be manipulated and bullied by them.
- 40:16Is narcissism a personality disorder?
- 40:18It is a personality disorder.
- 40:20I don't know.
- 40:22We all sort of and like Dr.
- 40:24Mark said, it is a very grim diagnosis.
- 40:29Wouldn't you agree, Dr.
- 40:30Mark?
- 40:30It's a it's not amenable to change.
- 40:33It's pretty much not, in my opinion.
- 40:35To me, I uh would say in the medical world, and you can correct me, you can give me a different one.
- 40:41But if someone's diagnosed with narcissism, it's like saying you have stage four pancreatic cancer.
- 40:50Like there's there's a chance, there's a chance, of course, there's always a chance, but it's not good.
- 40:58And so my passion is never going to be in changing that.
- 41:02So there's you know, just Webster dictionary on my phone.
- 41:06I know that doesn't really do it justice.
- 41:08There isn't really a definition, it's defined as egotism, egocentrism, um, narcissistic personality disorder, they don't really define it, and then there's love of or sexual desire of one's own body.
- 41:23So, how how do you define narcissism, Mark?
- 41:28Well, I think the simplest definition is an unhealthy obsession with the self, but there's also I think distinctions that have to be made because narcissism is not pathologic in and of itself.
- 41:43If we don't have any narcissistic tendencies, then we just roll over and die.
- 41:48You have to be preoccupied with yourself in order to survive.
- 41:51So there's nothing wrong with it, yeah, yeah, to a certain extent.
- 41:55But when it's an unhealthy preoccupation, then it winds up crowding out the space for you to be involved with in a healthy way with other people, and also to see that other people have needs that are not necessarily yours.
- 42:08There's, I think, two kind of specific subgroups of narcissists that that I've seen and that I think refreshted back in the psychoanalytic literature, and some are very pathologic.
- 42:17One group is a very pathologic, harmful, explosive narcissist that's the the type that we're most familiar with raging, selfish, obnoxious, nobody wants to be around.
- 42:28But the other one that's more subtle that I think creates a lot of injury and pain for people who are good and want to be helpful, um, are these brittle narcissists, the people that have these really hollow cores inside, no sense of identity, very low self-esteem, poor self-worth, and they're so easily injured that people try to be nice to them and crack their shell, and then they turn on them.
- 42:51Uh, they ghost them, they cut off communication, and then the the injured person says, Well, what what did I do?
- 42:59Uh why what's happening here?
- 43:01I thought I was just being nice, and this very, very fragile narcissist that gets so easily injured with just a casual critique, um, turns into a um a kind of hurtful, passively sadistic character.
- 43:15And I see this very, very often in Los Angeles.
- 43:18Um, it's very common, I think, with with women, this subtype.
- 43:23Um, the raging narcissists are more commonly, I think, men more aggressive.
- 43:28Uh, but you have very fragile injured creatures traveling from all over the world to come to LA who don't know who they are, and they want fame and fortune, and they want uh daddy's love from Hollywood that they never got, and these women are they tend to be very attractive, very seductive, and as soon as they receive some kind of uh critique or injury or failing, their whole shell breaks and they they have nothing inside and they get revealed as being very empty, and then they act out and they harm people and they destroy relationships and burn bridges.
- 43:59So I think we're a magnet in Los Angeles for fragile narcissists uh for women and sort of raging narcissists for men.
- 44:05That's my just first hand experience having been uh a resident and a physician here for a number of years.
- 44:13I I imagine most people that are narcissists are not self-aware that they are.
- 44:20I think that's very fair to say.
- 44:22And how and your your book, it's designed to help victims of narcissism or narcissists themselves to overcome this personality disorder.
- 44:33People on the other side of narcissism, so they're their parent, their child, their spouse, their brother, their sister, it's to help the people on the other side because everything I agree with everything you said, Dr.
- 44:49Mark.
- 44:49The one thing that I think is really a telling degree of it is that almost structural absence of empathy, they lack empathy in such a way that you they do not relate to you as a person with your own needs, your own worth, your own wholeness, they relate to you as an object in their world, and so you're constantly being manipulated by the So your book is sort of like the Al-Anon equivalent for alcoholics.
- 45:24I hope it will be an antidote to anyone who's really suffered this kind of invisibility that you can feel on the other side when every argument you craft, when every point you make, when at any time you really try to confront them and they're how they injure, you you're dismissed, you're invisible to them.
- 45:51It's almost like how if you're coming, if we're going up to see Dr.
- 45:55Mark, or he's coming down here and you see litter on the side of the freeway, you can feel that invisible in their presence.
- 46:02They do not see you as a whole person.
- 46:05So this was a big part of your life growing up, huge, yeah, and you were able to overcome it.
- 46:12Yes, I think that there's something really exciting about thinking that everything we've walked through, all the suffering, if none of it's in vain, and we can learn to help someone else through what we've been through.
- 46:32To me, that's the biggest gift.
- 46:35What role does what role does religion or a uh higher power belief system have in alcoholics anonymous, for example?
- 46:43Maybe there's narcissist narcissistic narcissism anonymous, I don't know, but an AA giving giving up your self to a higher power you can't control what's going on, and you need to give it up.
- 46:57Is there a is there an equivalent in narcissistic abuse relationships?
- 47:04I've not seen an AA model, Dr.
- 47:08Mark.
- 47:08Do you have you heard of something like that?
- 47:10For I have not, I have no because alcoholics anonymous is is based on uh an acknowledgement that you have an addiction.
- 47:20Uh I don't see any narcissists showing up acknowledging that they're narcissists.
- 47:25Right, but the victims of it show up, and then you're oh sure, sure.
- 47:30They are alcoholic.
- 47:31There are there are groups for uh the victims of of alcoholics and well, that's called Al Anon.
- 47:36Yeah, I don't remember what Alan stands for, but so but equivalently the victims of all personality disorders, not just narcissism.
- 47:44I imagine there are recovery programs for them as well.
- 47:48Yes, yes, but I so I guess a couple of things.
- 47:51I don't know what if you were asking me that personally, like uh is there a theological side to what I'm saying?
- 47:57Were you asking me that, or are you saying in general with a they talk about it?
- 48:01Well, I'm sure I'm interested in both.
- 48:02Um, you know, what role does a higher power play in recovering from uh being in a relationship with a narcissist?
- 48:13Well, I can only speak personally for me, but I would say it's huge.
- 48:17I believe Romans 828 that everything that comes at us, we can use like everything, God can reshape everything we've encountered and write a totally new story.
- 48:30So for me, that is very huge.
- 48:32And one of the main reasons, and I don't know, Dr.
- 48:34Mark, you'll have to tell me because I know you're you were steeped in the literature, like I was, and but I found except for kind of the founding fathers of psychoanalytic thought, there is such grim research, there are boring clinical vignettes.
- 48:53There are it's it's not it, it's a dark, you're swimming in darkness, you're trying to get help, people are looking for help, and they have this sea of dark literature with people that you read and they don't sound impressive because you're right.
- 49:09I think that the brittle narcissism that you're talking about, that's fascinating because you think about anyone whose dominant narrative is victimhood, right?
- 49:17That's what you're talking about, right?
- 49:19And what they're everywhere.
- 49:20You talked about what was the analogy that you said someone's out of milk, it's not trauma.
- 49:26But what about like you get you go through McDonald's and you spill coffee on yourself and you you you you litigate and you win, right?
- 49:34There's so much victimization, right?
- 49:38And but my hope is that I've changed the conversation about what can happen if you let all that has come at you actually forge you into a weapon.
- 49:52And so that is really the hope of the fog of war.
- 49:54I hope that I bring a lot of light and a lot of hope, because in my belief.
- 50:00God is hope.
- 50:01And so write a book without hope.
- 50:04Are there uh but it's not, I gotta just be clear.
- 50:07I'm sorry.
- 50:08I don't mean interrupt, but just let me know.
- 50:09No, you're good.
- 50:11My hope is not for the narcissist.
- 50:14My hope is for the person on the other side of narcissist.
- 50:18And you tell a lot of stories in your book about people that have gone through this and recovered.
- 50:22I have thousands of hours of stories, and they are good because I've seen amazing people that have changed my life because of how they show up.
- 50:35And so in very disguised detail, they're in there.
- 50:38Is narcissism more common in men or women?
- 50:42I think it shows up differently.
- 50:44I I I think I think we have I think we have I think we have plenty of folk on both sides.
- 50:51What do you think, Dr.
- 50:53I was just thinking about a quote by Tanner Goosey, men's style consultant and also part-time philosopher in a reel that he posted recently, where he said, I think that our valorization of ugly is wrecking our society.
- 51:15We should be valorizing and pursuing beauty, not ugliness.
- 51:19And one example of that he gave is our obsession with trauma.
- 51:23At its core, trauma is ugly.
- 51:25Yes.
- 51:26Now it doesn't mean you shouldn't be working on cleaning out the ugly and overcoming whatever your trauma is in order to live a beautiful life.
- 51:33But remaining mired in your trauma is the same thing as marrying the ugly.
- 51:40And I think we have given far too much support and valorization to people, as well as reinforcement, like you said, money for spilling coffee to remain stuck and not just stuck, but actually validating and elevate our ugly, i.e.
- 52:05our trauma, in the same way that we prayed to the altar of fear for two, three, four.
- 52:10I would say it's even ongoing now, number of years since 2020, rather than worshiping the altar of sacrifice and courage, and what you worship is what you become.
- 52:19And we worshiped fear endlessly for two, three, four now, even five years ongoing.
- 52:24And look what it's got us.
- 52:26We're a bunch of pussies and crybabies.
- 52:29And the same thing with this trauma.
- 52:30We're a nation of victims, and that is a expectable, anticipated, necessary consequence of worshiping the ugly, i.e.
- 52:40trauma in the psychological mental health community.
- 52:44And I think we need to get out of it.
- 52:45I think we got to stop doing it.
- 52:47We ought to treat the wounds and move on rather than then holding up our arms and being proud of all these weaknesses and injuries, as if somehow that makes us a better person.
- 52:56In other words, what is what is more ugly is not more real.
- 53:03The more that we define reality as as ugly and the uglier it is, the more real it is, the more we get away from a beauty, and beauty is an aspiration towards a divine, worshiping piss Christ, worshiping dogs urinating at the museum uh as a as a piece of art, worshipping cacophonous music.
- 53:20Um praising people for looking cool and hip because they have four colors of hair, scarifications on their face, tattoos, and rings.
- 53:30That is not what we should be doing.
- 53:32We should be saying that's ugly.
- 53:33Make yourself beautiful, make everything beautiful.
- 53:36And we're not doing it.
- 53:37We're debasing ourselves and we're pulling ourselves downward.
- 53:40We're pulling our humans into the gutter as uh as an act of worship rather than looking down at the gutter and saying, I want to get higher up.
- 53:47I want to, I want to go above and beyond my circumstances.
- 53:50I think this is actually anti-religious.
- 53:54I think it's it's actually uh if you want to call it a conflict that's more spiritual.
- 53:59I think it is actually.
- 54:00I think we're in a spiritual conflict, and I think we're being pulled into dirt and filth, and and we're we're calling it beauty, and it's not.
- 54:07You know, beauty is is is up there.
- 54:10And I I think this is a problem everywhere, and I don't think that the uh you know mental health community is escaping it.
- 54:17What is your hope inside of mental health?
- 54:20What do you see?
- 54:21What what do you see is the trajectory?
- 54:23What are your thoughts?
- 54:24What do you see?
- 54:25I think it's I honestly, I think it's over.
- 54:28I I think therapy is done.
- 54:29I think it's cooked.
- 54:31I think therapists are gonna be rapidly out of work, and most of them are women now.
- 54:35So we're gonna have a huge contingent of unemployed women because everyone's gonna go to coaching, which is two or three dollars a month with a very, very rapid processor AI tool and agent that knows everything about you and that can solve a lot of your problems, not your personality disorders, but solve your day-to-day problems on your own and give you support on your phone as you're going down the street, giving you creating little messages for you that are very personal.
- 55:00So I think most therapists are gonna be out of work because right now people don't have the money to pay for it.
- 55:05It's a very rarefied group of people that can afford to pay for therapy.
- 55:09Most people can't.
- 55:11Uh, the ones that need it are unable to.
- 55:13So I think we're gonna see a calling of the herd.
- 55:15We're gonna have a very uh select group of elite therapists who work with uh wealthy people on a cash-based basis, and um everyone else is is just gonna be left for AI.
- 55:26I I'm I'm not like trying to be pessimistic.
- 55:29I just see that's what's going already happening.
- 55:32I think most women are gonna be unemployed in the next two to three years because women generally work in air conditioned buildings doing work that doesn't require physical labor, and almost all of those jobs are gonna be replaced by AI in the next one to five years, except for obviously nurses, teachers where you actually need hands-on care and work where you need a relationship.
- 55:52That's where women do great.
- 55:53But working in offices, doing admin work, uh doing work that requires computers, they're all gone.
- 55:59And obviously, the men are gonna be gone too, but we still need men to you know to dig holes to build power lines to manage nuclear reactors.
- 56:09We need men for police and military.
- 56:11Uh, no women perform those those labors.
- 56:13Uh, and if they do, they they end up becoming problematic because they end up shooting people uh unnecessarily and getting kidnapped and raped.
- 56:20But we don't have single woman managing power lines in Alaska, not one.
- 56:26So men are still gonna be needed for those jobs, but the other jobs, they're gonna be fired too.
- 56:31So I think we're gonna have a huge, huge problem of unemployment, and I think therapy is gonna be one of the first professions that's gonna blow up, and very few people are gonna be left.
- 56:38That's what we're CCM Mark.
- 56:40We are just at about out of time.
- 56:42CeC, share with us how people can find you if they want to either follow you on social media, learn more about your book, or if they're super interested in the work that you do as a therapist.
- 56:54Uh, how do they get a hold of you?
- 56:56Okay, thank you for asking Instagram, Facebook, my website, everything's under CC Evans Poglisi, just my whole name.
- 57:05C C Evans, E V A N Sh Puglisi, P-U-G-L-I-S-E.
- 57:11Yes.
- 57:13Perfect.
- 57:13Yes, we we ran we ran a bit over.
- 57:16I apologize for cutting everybody off, but we gotta run.
- 57:19Uh CC, it's been a pleasure.
- 57:21Time went by so fast.
- 57:22When your book comes out, we're gonna have to have you back on, and I look forward to reading that book myself.
- 57:27Thank you.
- 57:28Thank you both very much for the time today.
- 57:30Of course.
- 57:31Thanks for joining us on Informed Descent.
- 57:33Goodbye.
- 57:34Have a great night.
- 57:36You've been listening to informed dissent with Dr.
- 57:39Jeff Barkey, board certified primary care physician, and Dr.
- 57:44Mark McDonald, board certified child, adolescent, and adult psychiatrist.
- 57:50Informed dissent, the intersection of health care and politics.