Latest / Politics with Paul / What Would the Founding Fathers Think of America Today? | Politics with Paul #94
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:05political science and civics.
- 0:07I am your host, Paul Reider.
- 0:10I think with the upcoming two hundred
- 0:12and fiftieth anniversary of America, it's a particularly salient topic to talk about.
- 0:18What would the founding fathers really think about today's politics?
- 0:22The founding fathers of America were brilliant thinkers whose prescient writings and speeches
- 0:28still hold considerable relevance today.
- 0:31And because of said relevance and foresight, a lot of people understandably, myself included,
- 0:37look back at many of their words that they wrote over two hundred years ago for some
- 0:41guidance and people across the political belief spectrum do this.
- 0:47And in this day and age where negativity about political culture is the norm and divisiveness
- 0:53reigns, it's an increasingly common refrain for people to say that the founding fathers are
- 1:00rolling in their graves or they'd be disgusted by what America has become.
- 1:06But is that true?
- 1:08It's incredibly difficult to prove what dead people
- 1:10would think if they were alive today, but it's a worthwhile discussion, though one that's
- 1:15partially rooted in misunderstandings of what the founding fathers believed, as well as
- 1:21partisan and ideological biases.
- 1:23Let's talk about what the founding fathers would think about America today if they were
- 1:28still around, and that includes some of those key misunderstandings about the Founding
- 1:32Fathers, how these misconceptions are relevant to today's politics, and ultimately what it all
- 1:38means for America's Two Hundred
- 1:40And Fiftieth Anniversary.
- 1:42Let's begin.
- 1:44First of all, there's a lot about the Founding Fathers that we don't necessarily get wrong,
- 1:51but is at least off the mark.
- 1:53Even though we intuitively realize that the founding fathers did not all think the same
- 2:00way, you know, you're not going to have a whole group of people be the exact same way on
- 2:05everything, but we kind of treat them monolithically sometimes.
- 2:08The very question of, well, what would the founding fathers think of America today?
- 2:12Sort of already does that.
- 2:14It almost kind of implies that there's going
- 2:16to be a singular reaction,
- 2:20at least in some people's minds, there would be a singular reaction.
- 2:24And there's a lot about the founding fathers and by extension framers of the constitution or
- 2:30just early statesmen in general that may be considered founding fathers.
- 2:34There's a lot about these people that is inaccurate, if not outright misunderstood.
- 2:41And sometimes it's just that it's not properly taught or it's overly simplified.
- 2:45Sometimes we might learn it really early on in school age and it never really gets updated.
- 2:52Could be a whole bunch of different reasons why.
- 2:54And sometimes appraisals of the founding fathers are rooted in biases.
- 2:58On one side, you might have some people try way too hard to downplay the bad parts of American
- 3:03history that if you talk about the negative parts of history that you're you're poo pooing
- 3:09America, that it's being unpatriotic or hateful towards America, including if you say anything
- 3:15critical about the founding fathers themselves, and therefore, don't wanna hear these
- 3:18criticisms.
- 3:19But then you have the other side that also swings the pendulum too far where some people
- 3:24just disregard the many great contributions that the founding fathers made because of some
- 3:29of their transgressions, and many of these transgressions don't even apply to all of them,
- 3:34Haikau.
- 3:34Some were slave owners, and that should be criticized.
- 3:37Sure.
- 3:37But kind of painting people with a broad brush stroke if you're just talking about, well, they
- 3:42were slave owners or that they all had a bias against women or nonproperty males or
- 3:49minorities.
- 3:49Yes.
- 3:50A lot of them did, but that's also kind of a ham fisted response too.
- 3:55And that and so they might say that talking about these guys positive too positively might
- 4:00be whitewashing or bigoted to have too much of the focus on these positive contributions.
- 4:05So one side overly romanticizes America, and then one side goes too far in anti romanticism.
- 4:14And there is a lot to venerate the founding fathers for, but like any other human beings
- 4:19that have ever existed in history or in today, they are not above criticism.
- 4:25You can understand some of the more unsavory aspects that were common beliefs for their
- 4:30time, but still understand that that doesn't justify them, and you can make that honest
- 4:35distinction.
- 4:37And, of course, there are partisan biases at play as well.
- 4:42Conveniently, when we talk about the founding fathers, conveniently, if you're the party in
- 4:47power, you might say that the founding fathers, oh, they would be on our side.
- 4:51They they would love what's going on right now.
- 4:53All our policies and actions, this is exactly what they would support, and this would make
- 4:58them proud.
- 4:59And then if you're not the party in power, you're gonna say that the founding fathers are
- 5:04rolling in their graves, and all the current administration's policies and actions are
- 5:10directly antithetical to what the Founders envisioned.
- 5:15So you have to take the positive with the negative.
- 5:18You have to acknowledge the biases that some people have when they talk about, you know,
- 5:22what would the Founding Fathers think about today?
- 5:26And these misunderstandings need to be discussed before we can really try to assess
- 5:31what the Founding Fathers would think
- 5:33of America today.
- 5:34Again, hard to really put words in dead people's mouths, but we need to at least talk
- 5:41about a more accurate appraisal of what they said and did way back when.
- 5:49And there
- 5:49are three key misunderstandings I want to focus on in this regard when it comes to the founding
- 5:55fathers, things that we don't quite get right.
- 5:58They're not necessarily entirely inaccurate, but we don't quite hit the mark.
- 6:03And one is that they simply weren't that sharply divided about politics or they at least
- 6:09readily put aside their differences to work together.
- 6:12People often recognize the slavery aspect, but that's the one issue that they kind
- 6:18of focus on.
- 6:19They forget about all the other issues that were divisive
- 6:25for the founding fathers as well.
- 6:26Number two, misunderstanding that the founding fathers despised and firmly stood against
- 6:33political parties.
- 6:34Now, parties did not exist right at the very beginning, and they weren't necessarily gung ho
- 6:39about parties.
- 6:40There were some factions that were similar to parties that existed right at the beginning,
- 6:45but they weren't as opposed to political parties as people make it out to be.
- 6:50And then three, that they did not intend career public servants, which does have a lot of truth
- 6:56to it, but it isn't the full story.
- 6:59So let's get into each one of these specific misunderstandings, apply it more to what the
- 7:06founding fathers would really think, and what it all means for America's 200 birthday.
- 7:12So first of all, the founding fathers and today's divide in America, more generally, that
- 7:20there's this misconception that people think that the founding fathers just weren't that
- 7:24sharply divided except maybe on slavery or that they were very willing to put aside their
- 7:29differences to work together.
- 7:30And this is more specifically relevant to the drafting of the US constitution, but it
- 7:37happened before and after that as well.
- 7:40A lot of times when we hail the founding fathers, they're treated as if they had some
- 7:44sort of otherworldly ability to bridge divides, that they all put their interests aside for the
- 7:51good of the country, and they came together to make America the best it could
- 7:54be and if only we'd just do the same thing.
- 7:57Well, I can definitely agree with the second part of that idea, but the first part of that
- 8:03idea isn't quite what happened.
- 8:07Division has always existed in America, even very sharp division.
- 8:13But the patriots, those who fought for independence,
- 8:16who supported independence, at the beginning, they
- 8:19really were just held together by wanting independence.
- 8:22They all agreed that Britain sucked and that we were not gonna be under them anymore, that we
- 8:27were gonna shut ourselves from their control, and then we'd figure out what's gonna happen
- 8:32afterwards.
- 8:33But once the American Revolution was over, the states fairly quickly took to squabbling over a
- 8:40whole bunch of issues.
- 8:42Sometimes they even used their own currency or, you know, when one of them wanted to sue the
- 8:48other in court, there wasn't really any way to enforce that because the central government of
- 8:53America was purposely designed to be weak under the articles of confederation.
- 8:58The response was, well, the British crown was too heavy handed, so we don't want a strong
- 9:03central government.
- 9:06And, of course, the Articles of Confederation were shown to be very ineffective because the
- 9:11central government couldn't do anything and states kept bickering and arguing about
- 9:16everything, But what to do about the articles of confederation was not a consensus.
- 9:22Some of the founding fathers believed that the articles were flawed, but totally worth saving.
- 9:29Some of them love the articles of confederation and were just not willing to have any sort of
- 9:34revision to them.
- 9:35And then some of the founding fathers took the opportunity to use what would become the
- 9:40constitutional convention originally meant to just amend the articles of confederation to
- 9:45create a brand new US constitution.
- 9:49And when the US Constitutional Convention was over, it was met with significant backlash
- 9:55because a lot of people felt that the wool was pulled over their eyes, especially the people
- 10:01who would become the anti federalists.
- 10:03They saw this as, if not illegal, or they definitely saw it as illegal under the Articles
- 10:09of Confederation, and it technically was because the Articles of Confederation, in order
- 10:13to amend articles, they needed all the states to agree.
- 10:18But more than that,
- 10:21some of them even thought that making
- 10:25the US constitution was borderline, if not outright treasonous.
- 10:29And one of the most notable opponents to the US constitution that some people may be shocked to
- 10:34find out was Patrick Henry.
- 10:35Patrick Henry was not a fan of the US constitution to begin with.
- 10:40He was very firmly in the camp of the Articles of Confederation.
- 10:45And if you know anything about Patrick Henry, you know how brilliant of an orator he was.
- 10:50So it was a very tall order to get people to not be convinced by Patrick Henry and to be
- 10:58able to ratify the constitution, but James Madison did take him on during the debates over
- 11:05ratification.
- 11:06And so, obviously, tensions were high after the US constitution was drafted and it was being
- 11:15taken around to be ratified.
- 11:16But even before that point, during the constitutional convention, not everybody was on
- 11:22board with what exactly was happening.
- 11:24Yeah.
- 11:25Some of them might have said, okay.
- 11:26Yeah.
- 11:26We do need to completely scrap the articles of confederation, but that didn't necessarily mean
- 11:33they liked all of the provisions that were being talked about.
- 11:35Tensions were very high, and it threatened to derail the convention multiple times.
- 11:40Some convention delegates didn't even attend the whole time.
- 11:44That partly was because the weather was very hot during those summer months in Philadelphia
- 11:49for the convention.
- 11:50But also, some of them just were very dissatisfied with how the convention was
- 11:54progressing.
- 11:55And obviously, slavery was the most divisive part of figuring out what to do with the US
- 12:02constitution.
- 12:03But there was also heated disagreement about how to apportion representation in congress,
- 12:09what to name the head of the executive branch, whether the executive branch would be led by
- 12:14one or three people.
- 12:15Yes.
- 12:15We could have possibly had three presidents instead of one.
- 12:19Whether we would have term limits for Congress or not, how long term lengths would be for
- 12:24Congress?
- 12:25All sorts of things that people were very adamant about what to do.
- 12:29And so the constitution basically is one giant compromise where nobody left fully satisfied,
- 12:36but some people thought, you know what?
- 12:38This is the best we can do.
- 12:39And even when the US constitution was ratified, there was sharp disagreement about how to
- 12:43interpret it.
- 12:45So before the US Constitution, during Constitutional Convention, while the US
- 12:50Constitution was being ratified, and after it was being ratified, there was all sorts of
- 12:55contention about it, and there's still contention about it now.
- 13:00Namely, at least at the time, crux of the issue, even though anti federalists slowly but
- 13:06surely started to come around and accept that the US Constitution was the law of the land,
- 13:11Federalists generally believed in implied powers from the Constitution where basically as
- 13:17long as the Constitution did not specifically forbade or forbid the federal government from
- 13:22doing it, the federal government could do it, Whereas for anti federalists who thought that
- 13:27this was going way too far back into the pendulum of strong central government, they
- 13:32thought that we should stick to just enumerated power.
- 13:36So only if the constitution specifically said the federal government can do it, the federal
- 13:41government can do it.
- 13:45But, of course, there are plenty of other instances of polarization that reign just in
- 13:50general.
- 13:50All sorts of rivalries, and some of them you've already heard about.
- 13:53Alexander Hamilton versus Thomas Jefferson, both in George Washington's cabinets and always
- 14:02at odds basically on any issue.
- 14:05Thomas Jefferson versus John Adams went up against each other in the election of eighteen
- 14:11hundred.
- 14:11Once very good friends, then turned bitter enemies and eventually would rekindle that
- 14:18friendship.
- 14:19Aaron Burr, a great guy he was, versus Thomas Jefferson.
- 14:25Thomas Jefferson had him arrested for treason because he was treasonous.
- 14:30And then, of course, Alexander Hamilton versus Aaron Burr.
- 14:33Most people know about it already, but in case you don't, the two of them had a duel.
- 14:38Aaron Burr killed Alexander Hamilton even though duels were sort of accepted.
- 14:44They were frowned upon, but it was also frowned upon for you to not accept a duel.
- 14:49So Alexander Hamilton, that was part of why he ultimately went and did it even though he
- 14:55didn't really intend to kill Aaron Burr.
- 14:58Thomas Paine and George Washington.
- 15:01Thomas Paine, he of the pamphlet common sense was very much at odds with George Washington.
- 15:08You'll actually find when you dig just a little bit deeper, George Washington was not
- 15:13universally beloved in terms of his policies.
- 15:16He was very much revered for his role in the American Revolution, but his actual
- 15:22presidential policies, there are a
- 15:24lot of people that were constantly at him there.
- 15:28Although they didn't necessarily argue that somebody should have run against him because
- 15:33nobody did run against him in the two elections he won.
- 15:36And Thomas Jefferson versus John Marshall, are actually cousins,
- 15:40which I just figured out
- 15:42within the last couple days.
- 15:43John Marshall being a US Supreme Court chief justice and also ruled on a case that dealt
- 15:51directly with appointments from John Adams that he made as he was leaving office after Thomas
- 15:57Jefferson defeated him in the presidential election.
- 16:01Campaign mudslinging was very prominent in this time already by the time that Adams and
- 16:07Jefferson were running for president.
- 16:09It's not a new phenomenon.
- 16:11It's not even a relatively new phenomenon.
- 16:13It's been there since basically almost since the very beginning, once they actually started
- 16:19having elections where, you know, there was uncertainty about who was going to win the
- 16:26election.
- 16:26Prominent newspapers were outright biased before the days of official journalistic
- 16:33standards and ethics, and some of them were even against the otherwise venerated George
- 16:38Washington.
- 16:39So we talk a lot about biased media today, and there's a lot of it, but it's also not
- 16:44a new phenomenon either.
- 16:46Papers back then were very biased and it
- 16:49was even harder to fact check them back then because you don't have the Internet.
- 16:56Literacy rates weren't nearly as high then, so it's hard to keep these sources accountable
- 17:03even more so than it is now.
- 17:06So what would the founding fathers say about the divide in America today?
- 17:12I highly doubt they would be surprised.
- 17:14Sometimes when people say, Well, the founding fathers would be rolling their graves, it kind
- 17:18of implies that they think the founding fathers would be shocked at the level of division.
- 17:22They might be distressed at just how divided we are, but the fact that we are sharply divided,
- 17:29I don't think they would find that surprising at all because they had already seen plenty of
- 17:34vicious divisions when they were still alive.
- 17:36In fact, some of them participated in said vicious divisions.
- 17:41And today, there's still debate over how to fundamentally interpret the US constitution.
- 17:47And a lot of it is still that whole implied versus enumerated powers debate.
- 17:52It's not used with that same kind of language.
- 17:54It's more in the specific focus of federal versus state, which is still closely tied to
- 18:02it.
- 18:02But, you know, how many or what powers are delegated to the states as through the tenth
- 18:09amendment of the US constitution and which ones still belong to the federal government.
- 18:14That debate over federalism, which responsibilities belong to which level of
- 18:18government and then which responsibilities are shared between those two levels of government.
- 18:24Some fathers after their political careers did find ways to make amends with each other, and I
- 18:29mentioned Thomas Jefferson and John Adams who were friends and then turned bitter rivals.
- 18:35But then towards the end of their life their lives, fortunately, they did find a way to
- 18:40reconcile.
- 18:42And remarkably, they both died on July '64 excuse me, fifty years after the Declaration of
- 18:50Independence.
- 18:52And so you think about all of the friendships, romantic relationships, family relationships
- 19:01that have been severed over politics, and that's not anything new either.
- 19:07But nonetheless, I'm sure the founding fathers would be disappointed about that as well.
- 19:12And since they obviously aren't around to participate in the divisive politics of today,
- 19:17they might have a more even keeled take on what is happening in America today.
- 19:22They could even use their own experiences as examples.
- 19:24It's a lot easier to take to have a more neutral opinion or, you know, try to
- 19:31be as balanced as you can, try to take yourself out of things when you haven't been the one
- 19:37that's been participating in it.
- 19:38That's just basic psychology.
- 19:43And so that brings me to another
- 19:45very related misconception about the founding fathers that really has a lot
- 19:52of relevance to this overall question of what they would think about America today, and
- 19:56that's the founding fathers and their views on political parties.
- 20:00And the misconception is that they all despised and firmly stood against political parties,
- 20:06that they were just adamant like this is not going to happen.
- 20:10Reality is that political factions that would eventually become parties started to coalesce
- 20:16almost immediately following the Constitutional Convention in 1787.
- 20:20We just talked about them, the Federalists and the Anti Federalists, and then the Anti
- 20:23Federalists would eventually become the Democratic Republicans.
- 20:27And so this is obviously similar to the previous section we just talked about with just
- 20:31the general divide in politics during the founding fathers' time, but I wanted a section
- 20:36specifically focusing on political parties because it does warrant its own section.
- 20:41And also people like to talk about how the founders never envisioned parties and that
- 20:46Washington especially was above the partisan fray.
- 20:52To some extent, that's true, but that's not the full story.
- 20:55It is true that the founders did not initially intend to create political parties.
- 21:00They did not appear right away.
- 21:02Yes.
- 21:02They coalesced into factions, but to actually make them full fledged organized parties, that
- 21:08wasn't quite at the beginning.
- 21:11And James Madison in Federalist paper number 10 talks about factions, and factions come up in
- 21:17other Federalist papers, but number 10 most prominently.
- 21:21And parties aren't even mentioned in the US constitution, so you'll you won't see anything
- 21:26about Republicans or Democrats or independents or anything like that.
- 21:33But all that being said, the founders still fairly quickly gravitated to the parties and
- 21:40not just the ones that are universally accepted as founding fathers, but early statesmen as
- 21:45well if you wanna count them as founding fathers.
- 21:49By the fourth congress, which began in 1795, full fledged parties in the federalist and the
- 21:55democratic republicans had formed, and they sort of there
- 22:01was sort of a proto party existence for both of them even before that during Washington's
- 22:07administration, but they were mostly just called pro administration and anti
- 22:11administration that then he got official names towards the very end of his tenure as
- 22:16president.
- 22:18With, again, with those federalists with the implied powers, they believed in a strong
- 22:22central government as they were reacting to the failures of the Articles of Confederation.
- 22:29They were pro British, not in the sense of, oh, I hope British Britain takes us back over.
- 22:33No.
- 22:34They believed that we needed strong economic ties to Britain to become a strong nation
- 22:40because back then, America was not the superpower that it is today, not even remotely
- 22:45close.
- 22:46And they were heavily supported by the commercial sector, which was really strong in
- 22:52the Northeast Of The US.
- 22:54And then Democratic Republicans, once again, more enumerated powers, but they were also for
- 23:00very limited central government because they're still thinking back to why the articles of
- 23:05confederation were made in the first place.
- 23:08They were actually very pro France because during that time, France was having its own
- 23:12revolution, and the French had helped out The US in the war against Britain because back
- 23:19then, France and Britain well, they did not send each other Christmas cards.
- 23:22You could put it that way.
- 23:23And they were also very agrarian based, so they had a lot of power in the South.
- 23:28And so the parties fought each other on all sorts of things, even trying to restrict each
- 23:33other through extrajudicial, if not illegal means.
- 23:37And the biggest example of that is probably the Alien and Sedition Acts under John Adams, which
- 23:43was a federalist law targeted at Democratic Republicans because it was obviously meant to
- 23:49tamp down on on sedition and just it's the word I'm looking for.
- 23:58Criticism of the Adams administration, and that just happened to target immigrants who also
- 24:06typically became Democratic Republicans, and some prominent Democratic Republican officials
- 24:13were arrested as a result of this law.
- 24:17And there's actually a piece of it that is still in effect today, the Alien Enemies Act.
- 24:21And these Alien Sedition Acts were so controversial even then that prominent
- 24:27Democratic Republicans, James Madison and Thomas Jefferson, authored the Virginia and
- 24:32Kentucky resolutions in response to the Alien Sedition Acts, and they basically argued that
- 24:39states could nullify federal laws that they saw is unconstitutional, which is sort of a break
- 24:46for James Madison, at least, from what he had originally intended because he was much more of
- 24:52a federalist at the beginning.
- 24:54He's called the founder or the father of the constitution.
- 24:58But Democratic Republicans would come to adopt the and accept the constitution themselves.
- 25:06They still but they
- 25:07still had a very limited interpretation of it.
- 25:09But nullification would play a significant factor in the slavery debates, especially.
- 25:16Not just the slavery debate, but that was its most prominent use because a lot of states used
- 25:20it to threaten and said any laws that were for that were giving power to free states that was
- 25:28unconstitutional, and we're gonna leave this union if you try to limit our power to be able
- 25:34to own other human beings.
- 25:35And so that was one of the biggest factors for what ultimately became the civil war.
- 25:43But then they also fought each other, the parties did, on things like a central US bank.
- 25:49Federalists supported a Central US bank.
- 25:52Democratic Republicans didn't.
- 25:54Tariffs.
- 25:55Federalists typically supported high tariffs.
- 25:58Democratic Republicans wanted lower tariffs.
- 26:00Federal infrastructure, federalists believed that federal infrastructure was in the purview
- 26:06of the federal government.
- 26:07Democratic Republicans did not.
- 26:09Stark divides between the parties in the sense that there wasn't a whole lot of federalists
- 26:13that stepped out of the Federalist line.
- 26:16There wasn't a lot of Democratic Republicans that stepped out of the Democratic Republican
- 26:20line.
- 26:21But it wasn't just issue differences between the parties where they just didn't like each
- 26:26other's party platforms.
- 26:28There was just straight up enmity between the Federalists and Democratic Republicans that
- 26:33became so bad that historian James Roger Sharp argues that they practically saw each other as
- 26:40irredeemable, kind of like today.
- 26:44And he argues, mister Sharp does, that there was basically no acceptance of the idea of a
- 26:49loyal opposition, that both parties believed that there was an objectively determinable
- 26:56public good that could be arrived at through debate and discussion, but they also believed
- 27:00that their vision exclusively was the public good and that the other party simply operated
- 27:05counter to it.
- 27:06So it's not just, hey, you disagree with me, but we all have the same goal.
- 27:11It's, no, you are so unbelievably dumb and stupid and sometimes even evil to think this,
- 27:19that you are completely screwing over this nation, we cannot have you be elected.
- 27:26And instead of seeing election defeats as legitimization of the other side's views, a
- 27:32party saw it as evidence that voters had been temporarily misled by dishonest leaders.
- 27:38It wasn't this other the other party just made better arguments, and and, yeah, you don't hear
- 27:44that today anyways.
- 27:45You're not gonna hear people say that publicly, but there's a difference between, you know, not
- 27:52saying that, hey, they just ran a better campaign.
- 27:55They just ran or just made better arguments.
- 27:59And then saying like, These people are scumbags who have pulled the wool over everybody's eyes.
- 28:05So what would the founding fathers say about political parties today?
- 28:10Well, they wouldn't be a foreign concept because they came into existence during
- 28:16lifetimes.
- 28:18They would probably be disappointed at the level of partisan polarization we see today,
- 28:23but they would also see a lot of themselves in it as well, just as we see how much Republicans
- 28:28and Democrats find each other as completely unsavable.
- 28:35There was a lot of that feeling between Federalists and Democratic Republicans at that
- 28:39point, and sometimes even spilled over into violence or threatened to spill over into
- 28:44violence.
- 28:44And they even recognized the founding fathers even recognized that polarization in their
- 28:53lifetimes through correspondences with each other or other people.
- 28:57I just brought up John Adams and Thomas Jefferson as maybe the biggest example of that.
- 29:07They might be a little bit surprised at what
- 29:09the parties have become though.
- 29:10Yes.
- 29:10They probably or not probably.
- 29:13They definitely saw the parties changing over time just like how they saw the government
- 29:16changing and evolving over time that it wasn't gonna stay
- 29:19the same over two hundred fifty years.
- 29:22But the
- 29:25exact status of the parties, like which parties are in existence and what their coalitions and
- 29:31everything, that's probably gonna be surprising to them because few, if any, of the founders
- 29:37were alive when the Federalist Party ceased to exist in the late eighteen twenties.
- 29:41Probably none of them were still alive by the time the Whig party formed to take the place of
- 29:47the Federalist Party and then the all the founders were definitely long gone by the time
- 29:52the Republican Party formed after the Whigs had disintegrated in the 1850s.
- 29:58And also party platforms have changed drastically over the years as coalitions of
- 30:03voters have realigned, more citizens are able to participate in the electoral process and the
- 30:09most pressing issues have in many ways changed.
- 30:13You mean,
- 30:16was not really a thing then.
- 30:20LGBTQ policies, whether it's gay marriage or transgender participation in sports, none of
- 30:27those kinds of issues were were a
- 30:32thing then.
- 30:33And even when they were a concept back then, they were never talked about.
- 30:41Or just some things just from a technology standpoint, like, obviously, artificial
- 30:45intelligence and the Internet and how you regulate these things.
- 30:48Those weren't around then.
- 30:49But a lot of the key underlying arguments were still around then about what does the
- 30:54constitution say about this?
- 30:56What should be the government's role in all this?
- 31:00It's you know, the more things change, the more they stay the same in a sense where there is a
- 31:06lot of the foundational parts are still there.
- 31:11And I think in that sense, the founding fathers could still have some sort of say about what
- 31:18they think about these issues that they never experienced, but the underlying foundations of
- 31:23them, they could probably talk a little bit about.
- 31:27So I think the it would be erroneous to say that they'd be completely taken aback by how
- 31:34much partisan polarization there is because they wouldn't be because they experienced a lot
- 31:38of it themselves, participated in it a lot themselves.
- 31:42But with the hindsight of
- 31:43two hundred fifty years and with what they started to think towards the end of their
- 31:49lives, they might have
- 31:52some useful knowledge and advice to give in regards to how we could navigate the partisan
- 31:59polarization we see today.
- 32:02And then the last point or the last misconception I want to cover about the
- 32:08founding fathers was their opinions on career public servants, that they did not want career
- 32:15public servants.
- 32:17Yeah, there's some truth to that, but that's not the whole story.
- 32:21It is true that the founders didn't necessarily want a ton of people serving in office for
- 32:28their whole lives.
- 32:29I mean, there are plenty of such people that the founding fathers had already seen in
- 32:35America when America was still under the control of the British, and I imagine did not
- 32:41care for a lot of those career public servants.
- 32:45And many of the founding fathers did idealize the Roman idea of the citizen statesman where
- 32:52basically the citizen comes up, takes a little bit of time to serve their country in a public
- 32:57capacity, and then once they're done, they
- 32:59just go back home.
- 33:01It was an idea that was espoused by Roman philosophers thousands of years before then.
- 33:09But many of the founding fathers also became career public servants themselves, serving in
- 33:16governments or around governments for a long time.
- 33:20Whether you consider being around government but technically not working for the government
- 33:23as public service, whatever the case may be, they were around that kind of thing for a very
- 33:28long time.
- 33:29So it wasn't as if the founding fathers, even if they did outright say, We don't want any
- 33:35career public servants.
- 33:36It's not like they had listened to their own advice.
- 33:41Now, in a similar vein, there was some debate during the constitutional convention about
- 33:47whether to enact term limits on presidents, Congress, federal judges as sort of a way to
- 33:55prevent people being entrenched in governments.
- 33:57That was at least part of the discussion.
- 34:01Ultimately, that didn't happen.
- 34:03Federal judges get lifetime appointments.
- 34:06Congress does not have term limits.
- 34:08Presidents, at least not yet.
- 34:10Presidents now has term limits, but back then,
- 34:13it was it was just a two term precedent, no pun intended,
- 34:18where George Washington served two terms and then every president after him until FDR.
- 34:23If they won reelection, they served a second term and then left.
- 34:26That wasn't actually made law until Harry Truman, who succeeded FDR, Franklin Roosevelt,
- 34:34until Truman became president, that two term limits was not actually installed.
- 34:40Although, it can actually be ten years for a president if said president takes over over
- 34:45past the halfway point of a previous president's tenure and then wins two full terms
- 34:50themselves.
- 34:51Little fun fact there.
- 34:55But at the same time, these officials didn't make the kind of money that they do now, both
- 35:00from serving in office and getting outside money due to their status.
- 35:04Arguably also didn't have the same level of power back then as they do now as government
- 35:10was more decentralized then.
- 35:13And also government positions were more based on the spoil system back then where jobs were
- 35:19awarded based on whether you were a loyal supporter of that president in their campaign
- 35:24and helping them get into office and you did all these other things for them.
- 35:28You showed that you were a good boy and or good well, at that point, you didn't really have
- 35:32women in public service, at least almost at least you almost never did.
- 35:36So you had all these good boys that did the bidding of the the president, and they were
- 35:42rewarded with a position in government.
- 35:45So turnover was a bit more expected at that point, but a lot of that had also changed with
- 35:51civil service reform during Chester A.
- 35:54Arthur's administration in the eighties, and people could then stay in governments a lot
- 35:59longer.
- 36:00But there were still career public servants back then during the time of the founding
- 36:06fathers.
- 36:07So what would the founding fathers say about career public service today or public servants?
- 36:12So the founding fathers certainly knew that some of these people would become career public
- 36:16servants, so they wouldn't be surprised that they exist.
- 36:20Contrary to how some people think that the founding fathers felt that the idea of career
- 36:25public service was unthinkable, it was not unthinkable.
- 36:29Some of them became those career public servants and many of those other early
- 36:35statesmen that are not necessarily considered founding fathers became career public servants
- 36:39as well, whether it's career politicians or just working elsewhere in the government.
- 36:44They might be surprised, however, at just how many career public servants there are, and by
- 36:52extension, just how many people make up the federal government.
- 36:56Though the founding fathers knew that it would grow in size long after they died, But they
- 37:02might not have imagined that federal government would be this big.
- 37:05But society has also become a lot more complex, leading to an expansion of government regarding
- 37:11a variety of issues.
- 37:12Now, I'm not endorsing or imposing just how big the government is, but some expansion was
- 37:18inevitable and necessary.
- 37:20And I think the founding fathers for the most part would have recognized that even if they
- 37:25would have been very disgruntled about it.
- 37:28But in terms of, you know, would they be disappointed in the amount of the number of
- 37:33career public servants today?
- 37:35They might not like how many there are, but they are not necessarily going to be opposed to
- 37:39the fact that there are any at all.
- 37:40In fact, they're not gonna be because some of them were career public servants.
- 37:46And so to end things off on this episode, I want to talk about what the founding fathers
- 37:54would say about America coming up to its two hundred and fiftieth anniversary.
- 38:00It's always an important question to think about, a fascinating topic to to talk about,
- 38:07but it's even more salient now with two fifty years just about under our belts.
- 38:16When we talk about what the founding fathers would say about American politics today, we
- 38:20often run to the pitfall of painting this one group monolithically.
- 38:25The question sometimes assumes that the founding fathers would largely, if not all,
- 38:29think one way about America, and they would all say that America has lost its way.
- 38:38I mean, how often do you see polls ask the question,
- 38:44do you believe America is heading in the right direction or the wrong direction?
- 38:49And we see upwards of 65, seventy, seventy five, 80% of people say wrong direction.
- 38:55Even for some voters whose party is in power, they'll still say that.
- 39:01And I'm curious how many people back in the
- 39:04times of the founding fathers would say that the country was heading in the wrong direction
- 39:09if we have the capability to pull that question back then.
- 39:13We didn't have the ability to pull like we do now.
- 39:16But I would not be surprised if you found a lot of people even back then saying that America
- 39:24was heading in the wrong direction.
- 39:27Because it's very easy to fall into this trap of declinism where the country or the world is
- 39:32heading towards a bleak future and that the best was behind us when politics isn't
- 39:38happening the way that you expect it to or that you want it to.
- 39:44And you see that in a lot of commentary about what the founding fathers would think about
- 39:48America today.
- 39:49And conveniently, when it's the party in power, they think they're doing the founding fathers
- 39:54proud and that the founding fathers would support everything they do.
- 39:57And if it's not the party in power, that they think the founding fathers would be immensely
- 40:01disappointed, angry, shocked, appalled, and that they wouldn't support what is going on
- 40:08with the current party in power.
- 40:11But I
- 40:12think while I obviously can't ask any of them today because they're dead, I think the
- 40:19opinions of the fathers of the founding fathers about America today would be a lot more
- 40:25complicated than many citizens and political commentators might think.
- 40:29And a lot of times, not for citizens really, but for political commentators and politicians,
- 40:35they'll often invoke the founding fathers for partisan or ideological reasons and not because
- 40:41we're actually admiring what these men who lived long before us did for this country.
- 40:50But I think the founding fathers would have a more complex, more nuanced reaction to things.
- 40:59Many of our situations are different on the surface.
- 41:01Some of the most pressing issues that we talked about, geopolitical shifts, election dynamics,
- 41:07and so
- 41:08on.
- 41:09But a lot of these core problems that we experience are the same as they ever were.
- 41:14What should be
- 41:14the role of government in people's
- 41:16lives?
- 41:17Where do federal powers begin and end?
- 41:20Where do state powers begin and end?
- 41:22How should we interpret The U.
- 41:24S.
- 41:24Constitution?
- 41:25How do we most effectively ensure freedom and liberty?
- 41:28What are our civic responsibilities towards each other?
- 41:33The founding fathers and those early statesmen thought about those very same things that we
- 41:38just did because ultimately that's what underlies all these issues.
- 41:45And some political observers and citizens think the politics of today would be totally bizarre
- 41:51to the founding fathers, but really they'd see a lot of themselves in what is happening today,
- 41:56both good and bad.
- 41:58I'm sure they wouldn't care for having their names being bandied about for partisan and
- 42:02ideological gain rather than having their words and philosophies genuinely and fundamentally
- 42:07listened to.
- 42:09But I'd also wager that the founding fathers would be impressed and heartened by the fact
- 42:14that America has gone two fifty years despite many of the same fundamental problems existing
- 42:21and being debated.
- 42:22I mean, this is despite states threatening to secede, a civil war where some states
- 42:28ultimately did secede, two world wars, the Red Scare, multiple economic crashes and crises,
- 42:37including the Great Depression and the Great Recession, political violence, the nineeleven
- 42:42attacks, seismic partisan and ideological shifts, so many more things, and we're still
- 42:47going.
- 42:48And it's very easy
- 42:49to focus on the bad and the negative.
- 42:52I am no exception.
- 42:53Believe me, you know, for all the
- 42:57things I say, I can be very pessimistic a lot of times, both personally and professionally
- 43:02and in all sorts of different ways.
- 43:05But despite all these issues, America is still going strong for two and a half centuries.
- 43:13Now, are the founding fathers going to like everything that happens in America today?
- 43:17Of course not.
- 43:19Quite frankly, none
- 43:20of us should like everything that's going on.
- 43:22You should always be looking for better.
- 43:24You should always be expecting better.
- 43:27Because if you're not and you're just content with every single thing that the current
- 43:31government is doing, doesn't matter who the president is, doesn't matter if it's a
- 43:35Republican, a Democrat, an Independent, whoever, if you're just going to accept
- 43:40everything that they say and do, that means we are not thinking critically and hard enough,
- 43:46that we're being too content, that we're just yes manning whoever the current powers are,
- 43:51that we're just letting our biases speak for us.
- 43:53Oh, somebody that we support's in office?
- 43:55Oh, everything is going great.
- 43:56And then we're ignoring all of the frustrations that other people feel.
- 44:03But we shouldn't be pessimistic about everything either.
- 44:09The founding fathers often advised on how fragile freedom was and many statesmen since
- 44:18then have advised us on how fragile freedom is and it's still just as fragile as it ever was.
- 44:27And I imagine that the founding fathers would remind us of that
- 44:32no matter what they would think about and say about today's politics.
- 44:40So that is going
- 44:42to wrap things up for today's episode of Paul Tweets with Paul.
- 44:45Thank you all so much for listening.
- 44:47Please like, comment, subscribe to the podcast on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple Podcasts.
- 44:54Links to the show notes.
- 44:55Got my five day educational email course about a very relevant topic here about how to more
- 45:01effectively mitigate polarization in America.
- 45:05And my Facebook, LinkedIn, medium.com profile, my book on Amazon, email PaulRayderWritesgmail
- 45:12dot com and my website, paulrayder.org.
- 45:17And so going to wrap
- 45:18it up here.
- 45:19Thank you all so much for listening and we'll see you next time.