Latest / Culture Project: Writers, artists & creative life / The Weight of Hometown Eyes: Carrying Expectations in Creative Life | Culture Project
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of silence that falls over your hometown when you mention what you do for a living, and it is heavier than any stone you have ever carried. It’s not that they don’t love you; it’s just that they can’t quite fit the shape of your dreams into the small boxes they built for you. I was sitting in a café last Tuesday, the kind with exposed brick and too much espresso, trying to write a scene that refused to come alive on the page. I kept looking at my phone, half-expecting a text from home, even though I hadn’t spoken to anyone there in weeks. And then it hit me. Not a notification, but a memory. The memory of standing in my grandmother’s kitchen, flour dusting my hair like snow, telling her I wanted to leave the town behind to chase this vague, terrifying thing called 'art.' She didn’t yell. She didn’t cry. She just stopped kneading the dough, looked at her hands, and said, 'Well, who will buy the bread then?' That question has followed me for ten years. It wasn’t really about the bread. It was about utility. About function. About the idea that a life must be measurable, tangible, and safe. When we grow up in tight-knit places, expectations aren't shouted at us; they are woven into the fabric of daily life, thread by careful thread. You learn early on that deviation is a luxury, and creativity is often seen as a distraction from the real work of surviving. So you carry this invisible map with you everywhere you go. A map that doesn't show streets or landmarks, but rather judgments, raised eyebrows, and the quiet disappointment of people who only want you to be happy in the way they understand happiness. Let’s sit with that for a moment. Because it’s easy to paint our hometowns as villains, isn’t it? To say they stifled us, held us back, didn’t get it. But it’s rarely that simple. Usually, it’s love. It’s fear. It’s the profound, aching desire of the people who raised you to keep you safe from the very things that make you feel most alive. Your mother worries because she knows how hard the world is. Your father remembers his own abandoned dreams and projects that regret onto you, hoping you’ll choose the path he didn’t. This burden of expectation is heavy, yes, but it is also rooted in care. What did that feel like in your bones? For me, it felt like guilt. A deep, rotting guilt that I was choosing something abstract and uncertain over the concrete security they had worked so hard to provide. I remember turning down a stable job offer in finance because I wanted to write instead. My uncle told me I was throwing away my future for a fantasy. He wasn’t wrong. In a practical sense, I was. But he couldn’t see that the fantasy was the only thing keeping me sane. We often confuse safety with stagnation. Our hometowns offer us the comfort of the known—the same faces, the same routines, the same stories retold at every dinner table. But creativity demands the unknown. It demands risk. And when you ask someone to take a risk, especially one they didn’t sign up for, their instinct is to pull you back toward the shore. There is another layer to this, one that is quieter but perhaps more painful. It’s the ghost of potential. In a small town, everyone knows your trajectory before you’ve even started running. They know you were good at math, so you should be an engineer. They know you’re nice, so you should teach. They have already written the biography of your life, complete with chapter titles and a predictable ending. When you step off that path, you become a character in their story that doesn’t make sense. You become confusing. And confusion makes people uncomfortable. I used to think that if I just succeeded loud enough, if I published enough books or sold enough paintings, they would finally see. That validation would wash away the doubt. But success doesn’t erase the past. It just adds a new footnote to the old narrative. Sometimes, seeing you succeed actually makes the expectation harder, because now they feel they need to justify why they doubted you. Or worse, they feel left behind. There is a particular loneliness in outgrowing the place that made you. You look at your friends who stayed, living the lives you once imagined for yourself, and you wonder if you made a mistake. Did I lose my community to find my voice? Is it possible to have both? I’m still learning that answer. But I know this: the silence I mentioned earlier isn’t always empty. Sometimes it’s full of everything they couldn’t say. They couldn’t say, 'I’m proud of you,' because they didn’t understand what you were doing. They couldn’t say, 'I’m scared for you,' because admitting fear feels like weakness. So they stay quiet. And we fill that silence with our own insecurities. So, how do we carry this without letting it crush us? How do we hold space for their love while honoring our own wild, untamed hearts? I think it starts with redefining what loyalty means. We are taught that loyalty to family means staying close, staying similar, staying safe. But true loyalty might mean becoming exactly who you are meant to be, even if that person is unrecognizable to them. When I first opened my bookshop, I invited my parents to visit. They walked through the aisles, touching the spines of the books, and I saw their eyes glaze over slightly. They didn’t see magic; they saw inventory. They saw hours of labor. But then, my mother picked up a poetry collection—a slim, battered thing—and read a line aloud. Her voice cracked. Just a little. And in that moment, I realized she didn’t need to understand the mechanics of my art to respect its value. She just needed to see that it mattered to me. That’s the shift. We stop waiting for them to validate the what and start inviting them to witness the why. It’s not about convincing them that writing is a viable career. It’s about showing them that writing is your lifeline. It’s about letting them see the joy, however messy, that comes from the act itself. You don’t have to explain the alchemy. You just have to let them smell the smoke. This requires boundaries, and I know boundaries can feel like betrayal when you’re coming from a culture of collective identity. But here is the truth: you cannot pour from an empty cup, and you cannot create from a place of resentment. If you are constantly fighting their expectations, you have no energy left for your work. You have to protect your creative space fiercely. This might mean limiting phone calls. It might mean changing the subject when conversations turn to your career. It might mean visiting less often. It sounds harsh, doesn’t it? Like cutting off roots. But sometimes, you have to prune the tree so it can grow taller. I learned to set gentle boundaries. I tell my family, 'I’d love to hear about your garden, but I’m not ready to talk about my manuscript yet.' And I stick to it. I don’t apologize. I don’t justify. I just hold the line. Over time, they began to respect it. Not because I forced them, but because I respected myself. When you treat your art as non-negotiable, others eventually follow suit. It’s a slow process. There were days I broke down crying after a call with my dad, feeling like a bad daughter for prioritizing my novel over his news. But those tears washed away the guilt, bit by bit. What did that feel like in your bones? It felt like standing up straight for the first time in years. It felt like breathing air that wasn’t recycled through other people’s hopes. Eventually, something strange happens. The weight begins to lighten. Not because the expectations disappear—they never truly do—but because you stop carrying them as a burden. You start carrying them as data. You realize that their skepticism tells you something about their fears, not your failures. Their confusion tells you something about their limitations, not your worth. You begin to see your hometown not as a cage, but as a foundation. Those values of hard work, community, and resilience? They are still in you. They fuel your art, even if you don’t use them to bake bread anymore. You take the spirit of that place and translate it into your medium. Maybe you write stories about small towns. Maybe you create art that explores isolation and connection. Maybe you just build a new community of your own, people who speak your language of creativity. That’s the magic bit, isn’t it? We don’t escape our origins; we transmute them. We turn lead into gold. We take the heaviness of expectation and forge it into the anchor that keeps us steady when the winds of doubt blow hard. You are allowed to miss them. You are allowed to love them. And you are allowed to be completely, unapologetically different. The two things can coexist. Love and distance. Respect and rebellion. Past and future. They are not opposites; they are partners in the dance of becoming who you are. So, to you, listening right now, wherever you are in your journey: check in with that heavy feeling. Is it yours? Or is it borrowed? Take a moment to separate their voices from your own inner critic. Whisper back to them, 'I hear you. I love you. But this is my life.' You don’t need their permission to exist fully. You don’t need their understanding to create meaningfully. You just need your own courage. And remember, you are not alone in this silence. There are thousands of us, scattered across the globe, holding ink-stained fingers and watercolor brushes, trying to make sense of the gap between where we came from and where we’re going. We are building a new map, one that charts not just geography, but soul. And it’s okay if it looks messy. It’s okay if it’s unclear. The beauty is in the walking. Keep going. Keep creating. Keep being the person they didn’t expect, but the one they’ll be proud of, someday, when they finally see the light in your eyes. Let’s sit with that for a moment. That light. It’s been there all along. Thank you for letting me into your day. I’m Meabh Swift, and I’ll be right here next week, ready to listen. Until then, be gentle with your heart, and brave with your pen. Goodnight.