Latest / Film And Whiskey / Dunkirk / Chivas Regal Mizunara
Transcript
- 0:00As we get into today's episode, I just want to take a second and
- 0:03remind you that there's a ton of extra content available to the
- 0:06members of Film and Whiskey Nation who support us through
- 0:09our Patreon. Check us out on patreon.com/film
- 0:14Whiskey In 2017, Director Christopher Nolan and star Finn
- 0:20Whitehead gave the world a stunningly quiet war drama that
- 0:23flies in the face of World War Two epics.
- 0:26In 2023 we make a return trip to the UK to try a specially
- 0:31finished Scotch. The film is Dunkirk.
- 0:35The whiskey is Shivas Regal Mizunarra Finish.
- 0:38And we'll review them both this is.
- 0:41The Film and Whiskey podcast. Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 1:03Podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 1:06glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 1:09I'm Brad Gee. And this week we are looking at
- 1:11Christopher Nolan's 2017 war epic that still only runs 100
- 1:16minutes long. Dunkirk.
- 1:20Dude, when I started this film and I saw that there's an hour
- 1:24and 47 minutes on the clock, I was super pumped.
- 1:29Is this the shortest war movie in like the last 50 years?
- 1:32I just can't believe that that he successfully made a World War
- 1:36Two movie in less than two hours.
- 1:39Yeah, and honestly, like. The film finished and I think
- 1:43there's like 9 minutes of credits.
- 1:45So like it's legitimately like an hour and 38 hour and 39
- 1:49minutes. It's the shortest war film ever
- 1:52made. Ever.
- 1:53We're just going to call it now. That's it, man.
- 1:58You know, it's really funny that you mentioned that I was
- 1:59actually looking today. About a year ago, I watched John
- 2:03Houston's adaptation of the book The Red Badge of Courage.
- 2:08Which is a movie that he made like in the early 50s and it was
- 2:112 hours long and then the studio took it from him and cut it down
- 2:14to like 65 minutes. So it's it's like a super short
- 2:18movie, Brad. It is one of the best war movies
- 2:21I have ever seen in my life and I was looking for it on Blu-ray.
- 2:25It is not available on Blu-ray. I can't fight it anywhere.
- 2:28Disappointing. Yeah.
- 2:29Pissed me off a little bit. I wanted to buy.
- 2:30It come on criterion. What are you doing?
- 2:32I can't wait till the day where we get to watch that 65 minute
- 2:35masterpiece, Brad. Yeah, I'm in, dude.
- 2:38Was it streaming somewhere? It was when I watched it.
- 2:41I don't think it is now. So you just can't watch the
- 2:44movie? You can pay.
- 2:45I guess you could find like a VHS or something.
- 2:47Well, you can pay $4.00 and watch it on any of the
- 2:50streamers, but you know it's not streaming with your subscription
- 2:53anywhere, is what I'm saying. I mean, I will say like your
- 2:57$4.00 doesn't go quite as far if you're only getting 65 minutes
- 3:00of content. That's what I'm saying.
- 3:01You got to spend that on, like, Gone With the Wind or something,
- 3:04man, Exactly $1.00 per hour. All right, man, let's start
- 3:10talking about Dunkirk. A movie that is, I'm hesitant to
- 3:15call a classic. You know, we start the podcast
- 3:18off by saying a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 3:21This movie's only like 6. Years old?
- 3:23Yeah, we do. We do say that too.
- 3:25Sure. Sure.
- 3:26It's a six year old movie. It's one of the more recent
- 3:28films we've done on the show. But you know we've broken down
- 3:32before what a classic means in in general parlance.
- 3:36And I'd always talk about how when I was growing up, TNT had
- 3:39that series that they called new Classics.
- 3:42Which was just like movies that Ted Turner wants to get
- 3:45residuals off of. So he's putting, and this seems
- 3:48very much like that. Like if a classic has a lot to
- 3:50do with being a very popular movie by a very popular
- 3:54filmmaker, then this certainly fits the bill.
- 3:57Yeah, and I it's interesting though.
- 3:59I was looking at this on IMDb. It has a 7.8 I believe and I
- 4:05feel like that makes this the least.
- 4:09Nolan, Broy. Nolan Movie Ever to Be Noland.
- 4:14Yeah, you know what? When this movie came out, I
- 4:16remember a lot of people went to see it and made, I think, almost
- 4:191/2 billion dollars worldwide. And by the time the Oscars
- 4:23rolled around, the general vibe on this movie was incredible.
- 4:28Craftsmanship, signature Nolan chronology.
- 4:33You know, mess up. And then.
- 4:37Not much else. Like, I feel like this movie
- 4:39left a lot of people very cold and kind of underscored for a
- 4:44lot of people what Nolan's trajectory has kind of become,
- 4:47especially with Tennant after this, where his characters get
- 4:51less and less fleshed out to the point where in Tennant the main
- 4:54character's name is the protagonist.
- 4:56Like he doesn't even have a name and.
- 4:59That feels like an old Charlie Chaplin type of.
- 5:01Title. I love that.
- 5:04I would have watched that more than Tenant, honestly, but this
- 5:07movie does kind of feel like it has one foot in his crowd
- 5:11pleasing Hollywood blockbuster mentality and 1 foot in his
- 5:16desire to kind of push the boundaries of what narrative can
- 5:20be. I'm really excited to talk to
- 5:22you about it, Brad, because I don't know that it entirely
- 5:24works for me, but I really respect it.
- 5:28Yeah, I think overall coming into this film, I I knew that
- 5:32there was like some time warp type of things.
- 5:35And I knew that a lot of people focused on just that, that they
- 5:39were like it's just no one doing his stupid time stuff again.
- 5:43And I feel like that was just kind of the vibe I got about the
- 5:46movie and I am very happy to say I thought this movie was
- 5:49incredible, Bob. Yeah, it's a really good movie.
- 5:52I remember I I saw it in the theater.
- 5:55And then after it came out on video plug for the Akron Public
- 5:59Library. I talk about the library a lot
- 6:01on here at the main library campus.
- 6:04Brad, they have this big like 500 seat auditorium that they
- 6:08show free movies on when they come out.
- 6:10And it's like. Nice.
- 6:11It's like going to the movies for free.
- 6:12It's pretty great. And so I took my dad to go see
- 6:15Dunkirk. He hadn't seen it yet, and it
- 6:17was like a great time at the movies, watching Dunkirk for
- 6:20free in a library Grade A. Dad, hangout time you know is.
- 6:26That like, was that like a hangout where you and your dad
- 6:29were like repairing your relationship and and all those
- 6:32lost years and stuff? You were just the worst man.
- 6:36I hope he never listens to this show.
- 6:38He's he's going to think that. That's what I think of him.
- 6:41You always do this. The worst thing is, I've never
- 6:44even met your dad. I.
- 6:45Know you're out here just shooting on him all the time,
- 6:49man. No, I'm I'm not shooting on him.
- 6:52I'm shooting on your guys's relation.
- 6:53No, thank you. Thank you for clarifying that.
- 6:55I appreciate. That no problem.
- 6:57All right man, let's dive into talking about the movie proper
- 7:01and and out of some weird familial history you're
- 7:04concocting for me. And let's get to our first
- 7:07segment of the day, which we call Brad Explains.
- 7:10Brad's gonna give us the movie plots with only 60 seconds
- 7:13ticking on the clock, so let's go ahead and do your take with
- 7:17this little segment that we call Brad explains.
- 7:20Brad Explains is the part of the podcast.
- 7:22Asked where Brad breaks down the plot of the movie, which he has
- 7:26just seen often for the first time.
- 7:28This was not Brad's first time seeing Dunkirk.
- 7:31I know that for a fact. Yes, it was.
- 7:34What? Really.
- 7:36I thought you just told me, like last week, that you'd seen this
- 7:39already. No, I've never seen Dunkirk.
- 7:41Wow, I did not know it for a fact.
- 7:44I just like keeping you on your toes, Bob.
- 7:46Wow, I man, I just lied very boldly, I guess in the middle of
- 7:51this show. So this was your first time
- 7:53seeing Dunkirk on a tiny screen? In my basement.
- 7:57As Nolan did not intend. Yes, yes, 100%.
- 8:01The TV that I have, Bob, I just everybody needs to know that I'm
- 8:07like a spender on certain things and yet a miser on others.
- 8:12I bought like a 46 inch television in 2013 and baby it
- 8:19is still going strong. Now I know why you always score
- 8:22the movies lower than me. Why did this movie look so bad?
- 8:27Well Brad, it's because you're watching it on a decades old
- 8:29television. Oh man, hey, it's a flat screen
- 8:33at the very least. There you go, man, moving up in
- 8:36the world. All right, so this is your first
- 8:38time having seen Dunkirk. You have 60 seconds on the clock
- 8:43to break down the plot. I don't know that you need 60
- 8:45seconds, unless you really want to get into the weird chronology
- 8:48of the movie. But hey, do with this minute as
- 8:51you will and go. The film Dunkirk is about the
- 8:56Dunkirk evacuation early in World War 2.
- 9:01When hundreds of thousands of Allied soldiers, French,
- 9:05British, Belgian, are stuck on the shores of Dunkirk, France,
- 9:11and the story follows the army on the shore and their attempts
- 9:17to escape, It follows the Air Force as they battled to keep
- 9:22the troops safe as they evacuated, and it follows the.
- 9:26Civilian Navy that is called in the service to go to Dunkirk and
- 9:31bring back as many soldiers alive as possible.
- 9:36Boom. Question mark.
- 9:38There's a lot of, there's a lot of booms, actually, truly,
- 9:41truly, Do you do you want me to just end boom, boom, boom, boom,
- 9:45boom, boom, boom. I don't know where to start with
- 9:47this movie, Brad. I have a lot of thoughts, but
- 9:50they're all very kind of disparate thoughts.
- 9:53Like as I watch it, I was like, oh, I want to comment on that
- 9:55thing. I want to comment on that thing.
- 9:57But there's not a lot of, I don't know, like connecting
- 10:02tissue for me in terms of forming an opinion about this
- 10:06movie. It's just kind of like.
- 10:08I don't know. I have a lot of disconnected
- 10:10thoughts. Help guide me through this
- 10:12journey, Brad. Please open us up with a 2
- 10:16minutes monologue talking about the upper half of Tom Hardy's
- 10:20face. Honestly, let's do it man.
- 10:23Let's talk Tom Hardy. Tom Hardy's in this movie.
- 10:25He is the most famous person in this movie except maybe Kenneth
- 10:28Brunag cause this Harry Styles. Well yeah yeah I was going to
- 10:32say this was this was I guess this was peak One Direction or
- 10:36like right after. This might have been like the
- 10:38first Harry Styles album. So yeah, pretty famous.
- 10:40I'll give you that. Tom Hardy is able to do so much
- 10:46with his body language in this movie, especially towards the
- 10:50end. So he plays a pilot who is
- 10:52basically the hero of Dunkirk, just getting in dog fights left
- 10:56and right on the English Channel.
- 10:58Swooping in down like 7 different different enemy
- 11:02fighters and a bomber like I I think 5 is an ace so he he gets.
- 11:08A good day, yeah. He really get a great day.
- 11:10Swoop if you will. Towards the end of the movie
- 11:14where he has lost fuel and he knows he's going down and he
- 11:19just decides to kind of glide over the beach, you see hit the
- 11:24realization kick in. And you see him get very
- 11:27resolute about it and kind of up like, you know, clinch up a bit
- 11:32and then you see him relax and it is all done in one shot.
- 11:35And it is like he does so much acting with the top half of a
- 11:40face covered in goggles and his mouth covered by a, you know, a
- 11:44mask. And you just watch the guy's
- 11:47shoulders relax and you're like, I get what's going on inside
- 11:50this person's head. It really is truly a thing of
- 11:53beauty as a physical performance.
- 11:56Yeah, I I think Tom was my favorite actor in the film.
- 11:59I think that he's far and away the best actor in the film, and
- 12:05he does so much with his eyes and he does so much with his
- 12:09vocal intonation. Like, I I don't think we really
- 12:13talk a ton about actors. Ability to control their their
- 12:18vocal chords and ability to control how they present
- 12:22themselves in that way. Yeah, I mean when you freeze it
- 12:25like that though, it it kind of seems like a baseline
- 12:28expectation that they that people can control their vocal
- 12:31chords, You know, like if someone doesn't control their
- 12:34vocal chords, I feel like that's worthy of talking about.
- 12:37Yeah, that's what I'm saying though.
- 12:38Like it it's. It's it just seems like
- 12:42something that we overlook that there's a lot of actors who, you
- 12:47know just sound okay and then there's other actors who really
- 12:50know how to use their voices for maximum effect.
- 12:54And I I think Tom Hardy is one of those people and you can't
- 12:56have somebody in the cockpit of the movie The entire time and
- 13:00and get away with an average voice acting performance.
- 13:06Brad, I think maybe the way to structure the rest of this front
- 13:09half of the episode is to follow Nolan's structure with this
- 13:12movie. So as you said, there are three
- 13:14separate story strands going on at the same time and eventually
- 13:18they all converge at one specific point.
- 13:21And the longest of those strands is what Nolan calls the mole,
- 13:25which is the name of, you know, it's it's not the mole as in
- 13:28there is a. Mission Impossible.
- 13:31Yeah, like an enemy among us. They're talking about the people
- 13:34on the beach, on land. And that story takes place over
- 13:38the course of one week. It is intercut with a story on
- 13:42the sea, which is all these civilians coming across the
- 13:45channel to rescue the people at Dunkirk, which takes place over
- 13:48the course of one day and then the air battles which are taking
- 13:52place over the course of one hour.
- 13:54And they're intercut equally throughout the movie.
- 13:57You don't quite realize you're on different storylines unless
- 14:00you did a good job of reading in the first few minutes, but I
- 14:03think for a lot of people. They didn't really piece it
- 14:06together until the end of the movie, which I've always found
- 14:09really interesting because Nolan.
- 14:10It's the first time Nolan gives you the answer to the key, like
- 14:14right in the first few minutes, and I actually really appreciate
- 14:17that he wasn't trying to be cute about it.
- 14:19Having the different storylines really does build tension and
- 14:24momentum and intercutting them in a, you know, a a non
- 14:30chronological way, it didn't detract from the movie this time
- 14:34around for me. No, not at all.
- 14:36I honestly, I think it might be one of his cleverest uses of of
- 14:41time warping. Yet they're like, he's just so
- 14:45open about it. He's like, hey, here's the Army.
- 14:48Their story takes place over a week.
- 14:50Here's the Navy, their story takes place over a day.
- 14:53Here's the Air Force. Their story takes place over an
- 14:55hour. But.
- 14:58That's it. Like, it's not hard to
- 15:00understand, I guess I'm just going to go out on a limb and
- 15:03say. People are stupid if they didn't
- 15:05understand that. Well, I think The thing is,
- 15:07like, if you want to make this story cinematic, you kind of
- 15:11have to do something like that. It is an incredibly heroic and
- 15:16harrowing tale to read in a book, right?
- 15:19But when you're talking about watching something on film, you
- 15:24would just be if you put this movie in chronological order, it
- 15:26would suck because it would just be guys sitting around for six
- 15:29days. And then the last one, seventh
- 15:31of the movie would be full of action, right?
- 15:34So you have to do something to give the movie forward momentum.
- 15:37And anyway, I said all that to to get us back to talking about
- 15:41the mole sequence or or strand of storytelling.
- 15:44Let's talk about these young soldiers and also Kenneth
- 15:47Branagh that we see on the beach starting with I guess the
- 15:52person. Sir Kenneth Branagh to you, Bob.
- 15:54That's true. You're you're just a peasant
- 15:57talking about Kenneth like you're on an equal.
- 15:59Turn. I mean, I like Kenneth.
- 16:00Brad. I think he's really good in this
- 16:01movie. I'm such a big fan.
- 16:03I want to talk about the ostensible star of the movie,
- 16:06though. Theon, Whitehead and I can't.
- 16:08I've heard it pronounced both Theon and just Finn.
- 16:11I'm going to go with Finn because I'm an American and I
- 16:14butcher people's languages, so I'm just going to go ahead and.
- 16:17Do the butchering that feels most comfortable to me, we'll
- 16:19say Finn Whitehead. Some sort of like cultural
- 16:22appropriation to try and pronounce it the way that they I
- 16:25don't know. Pronounce it?
- 16:26I don't know, man. It's Finn.
- 16:27Finn Whitehead. OK, Finn.
- 16:30Here's the thing about Finn Whitehead.
- 16:32He's only been in a few movies post Dunkirk.
- 16:34He was a pretty unknown actor before this.
- 16:37And you know, he's a young man, but he's a grown man.
- 16:40So I can say it. He's not a good actor, Brad.
- 16:42He's he's very, very wooden. I don't believe most of what he
- 16:47does in this movie, even when he's like being pulled from
- 16:50burning wreckage of a ship and laying on, you know, the deck of
- 16:54a boat covered in oil and panting.
- 16:57And then he has this line where he just says Take Me Home and
- 16:59it's supposed to be like this big release at the end of the
- 17:02film. I don't buy it for a second,
- 17:04dude. I just don't think he's very
- 17:06good actor. You are incredibly rude, Bob,
- 17:12but you are not wrong. Not wrong at all, man.
- 17:18Yeah, he is like OKI think that there's moments throughout the
- 17:23film where he works. I think the, I think the part
- 17:26when he is like fighting for his French friend that he didn't
- 17:30know is French. I think he shows a little bit of
- 17:32passion, a little bit of chutzpah and I'm like, OK, I'm,
- 17:36I'm down with him here. But at the end of the day, when
- 17:40he's trying to deliver that line, as you said of like I'm
- 17:44coming home or whatever the heck he says, you know he's not that
- 17:49good. Well, and then they put like the
- 17:51emotional weight of the movie on him, Obviously throughout the
- 17:54film, but especially at the end, after they've been rescued,
- 17:56after they've been taken back to England and they're on the
- 17:58train. And Harry Styles is inconsolable
- 18:01about thinking that they have failed.
- 18:04And then he reads the transcript of what Churchill has just
- 18:07proclaimed to Parliament and he reads it in the most monotone,
- 18:13mumbly Guy Pierce in Memento Voice.
- 18:18And and the editing there is incredible.
- 18:21Like that montage is pitch perfect, that cinematography
- 18:26gorgeous. The Hans Zimmer score is the
- 18:29best. It's been the whole movie in
- 18:31that one little moment. And I still can't quite connect
- 18:36with it the way Nolan wants me to connect.
- 18:38It's one of the few times that I think Nolan is honestly,
- 18:42earnestly going for, like, sentiment.
- 18:45Like Spielbergy kind of sentiment at the.
- 18:47End of genuine feel good ending. And it doesn't quite land for
- 18:52me. It's almost there, like almost
- 18:54all the components work, but then there's one component that
- 18:58all the others are trying to make up for.
- 19:01Is that components named Finn? It is.
- 19:06It is. No, I'm I'm with you, man.
- 19:08It's a it's a slightly disappointing ending to an
- 19:11otherwise incredible movie. And and you're right, like that
- 19:15moment is super important. And you know unfortunately they
- 19:20cast who they cast. But I I just wish that he had a
- 19:23little bit of passion behind him like a little bit of something
- 19:27at like. To to go from thinking that you
- 19:31were completely defeated and broken and the worst military
- 19:34defeat in history into like this inspiring speech, like I I wish
- 19:39that his voice moved with that story, but it just doesn't at
- 19:44all. So yeah, I'm I'm 100% with you
- 19:46there, man. I've got a question for you
- 19:48about the whole mole thread, and it kind of goes against
- 19:54everything we we know to be true, which is that short movies
- 19:57are great. I almost wish this movie was
- 19:59about 10 minutes longer, Brad, And I wish they.
- 20:02I wish they'd put all ten of those minutes into fleshing out
- 20:06the mole thread a little bit more, even though it is by far
- 20:09the bulkiest part of the movie. There were, there were moments,
- 20:13you know, in doing the research for this movie, they heard a
- 20:18story about guys just walking into the sea because they were
- 20:21so hopeless that they would ever get rescued.
- 20:23And there's a great moment in this movie where that happens,
- 20:25and it is very harrowing. And I felt like those were the
- 20:28only moments where this felt like a lived in world and not
- 20:34simply a collection of action scenes that had been strung
- 20:38together in a really suspenseful way.
- 20:40And I wanted to feel more empathy, more sympathy with
- 20:45those soldiers on the beach, but the way that the movie is edited
- 20:50together. I didn't even get the sense that
- 20:53they were there for a week, even though it told me it was a week.
- 20:56You only see it be nighttime, like one time, you know what I
- 20:58mean? And so it it seems like, OK,
- 21:01maybe they were there three days, but what happened to the
- 21:03other four days? Like, I want to see more of the
- 21:06paranoia of them getting bombed all the time and the the
- 21:11emotional toll it's taking on those men on the beach.
- 21:14I just wish there was a little bit more to that thread.
- 21:16Yeah, no, I I'm actually with you there, I think that.
- 21:21You need something like I was the the obvious movie comparison
- 21:28for me in this is 1917. And I think that there's that
- 21:33scene in 1917 where you know, the main character you're
- 21:36following throughout the whole movie finds kind of refuge for a
- 21:40moment with a, I don't know, war refugee who's like still living
- 21:46in their house under the city. Do you remember that?
- 21:50Like they needed a few moments like that where everything's
- 21:54quiet and the troops are just sitting around a fire.
- 21:57And honestly, like this movie's already super quiet.
- 22:00I don't even know if they needed to say anything.
- 22:03Like if you have the right actors and the right, like, you
- 22:06know, you hear the snap of a twig and everybody kind of
- 22:09freaks out and it's twitchy and paranoid, like.
- 22:12Man, you you set the stage for for what's going on, you know,
- 22:17while you're intercutting back and forth with the other stuff.
- 22:20But I I'm with you. I think you could have spent
- 22:22just a little more time establishing how long it felt,
- 22:27You know, how long those six days felt.
- 22:29Yeah, and I don't even need a scene where they all, like, sit
- 22:32around and say like, oh, back home, my gal Abigail.
- 22:35Like, no, I don't care about that.
- 22:36Like. Can you spell the strawberries,
- 22:38Mr. Frodo? Like all I need is a couple more
- 22:42scenes that establish, you know, the character of Killian Murphy
- 22:46in this movie. He's got the shell shocked thing
- 22:49going on and you find out very quickly why he why he came to be
- 22:52that way. I want to see more of that from
- 22:55the guys on the beach. I want to see what the emotional
- 22:58toll is being taken upon them because of this repetitive
- 23:02hellscape that they're in that they can't escape from.
- 23:05So anyway, yeah, that's my thoughts on the Mole.
- 23:07Why don't we talk about the sea sequences?
- 23:11Yeah, featuring Academy Award winner Mark Rylance showing up.
- 23:15I think this might have been his first movie after he wins his
- 23:18Oscar and. What did he win an Oscar for?
- 23:21Bridge of Spies. The Steven Spielberg movie?
- 23:24Oh dude, good movie. You need to watch that.
- 23:26Movie not not seen. Bridge of Spies.
- 23:28That's another dad movie. Like it's a Cold War movie
- 23:31starring Tom Hanks. Directed by Spielberg.
- 23:34Great Dad movie. OK.
- 23:37Anyway, he shows up and he's carrying around Barry Keogan,
- 23:43who would go on to be one of our brightest shining young actors.
- 23:46I'm a huge fan of him and this is a really early role for him.
- 23:50What did you think of all the people in the sea sequences,
- 23:53Brad? I really like them.
- 23:56Yeah. I think that they are the
- 23:57strongest part of the movie. I think that, like, Tom Hardy's
- 24:01incredible. And the the dog fighting
- 24:04sequences are great, but there's not, you know, a ton of
- 24:07character development there. I think that you really have Tom
- 24:12Glenn Carney and Barry Keegan and Mark Rylands in roles where
- 24:19they are the ones you get to connect with because they have
- 24:24weirdly like you feel the most. At stake for them, like they
- 24:30didn't have to get on the boat and go try and save them.
- 24:34Like the the Navy would have sent some men on their boat and
- 24:37yet like that, that willingness to die for country is important.
- 24:43And when you hear the the tiny little bit of, you know, oh, his
- 24:47older son died in the Air Force in the early weeks of the war,
- 24:50like it's just little moments like that where you understand.
- 24:55You know, Rylances, motivations as a character and his stoicism
- 24:59and his willingness to to sail off into the face of danger.
- 25:04I'm going to make light of their story thread for a little bit,
- 25:07but I will say this upfront like theirs is the best acted of the
- 25:12three strands I would say. I don't know that it's the
- 25:15strongest of the three though, and I think that's just because
- 25:17the stakes feel lower. For part like, at least part of
- 25:21their journey. Not that like their personal
- 25:23stakes are very high, like you said, because they're going into
- 25:26battle and didn't need to go there.
- 25:28But when you're cutting between images of like soldiers getting
- 25:32dive bombed on the beach and destroyers getting blown up and
- 25:36men burning alive and they cut back to like Barry Keogan, just
- 25:39like laying laying down on the floor.
- 25:42And they're like, should I give him a cup of tea?
- 25:44What should I do? And then, like, they put the
- 25:46same ticking clock score behind all that that they do behind,
- 25:53like Tom Hardy shooting planes out of the sky.
- 25:56It's like, okay this this feels less vital than Tom Hardy
- 26:01shooting down bombers. All right, I so I SNL you can
- 26:06hire me whenever you want. This would have been This would
- 26:08have just killed in like 20 early 2018.
- 26:12They need to do an SNL sketch. Where they intercut the actual
- 26:17scenes from the movie of the the army and the the Royal Air Force
- 26:22and all that. And then they'll have Killian
- 26:24Murphy come guest host. So he'll be there and they'll
- 26:28intercut it with them on the boats, Killian Murphy and then
- 26:32cast members of SNL pretending to be Barry Keegan and all them.
- 26:36And they're all trading stories about how they got that scar on
- 26:41the boat on the way to rescue everyone.
- 26:43Now what I think they should do is like instead of Barry Keogan
- 26:46getting like a, you know, life ending knock on the head, they
- 26:50keep cutting back to what's happening on the boat and
- 26:52they're all just having, like, minor inconveniences happen.
- 26:57Yeah, I nicked my finger cutting, cutting this lemon
- 26:59wedge for my tea, that. Would chip in my hand.
- 27:04Yeah, so like, and I think that that story thread suffers the
- 27:08most in terms of the way the chronology is laid out because
- 27:11like we said, with the Mole, it's seven days, but the action
- 27:14only happens in the last day. But because Nolan inserts
- 27:18different things for them to do throughout the week, like
- 27:21sneaking onto an abandoned ship, he gets, he introduces action
- 27:24into that. Whereas the sea.
- 27:27There's only so much you can do showing them Bob across the
- 27:30English Channel. And so like all the action in
- 27:33that story thread happens in the movie's last 30 minutes, and it
- 27:38gets really tense and really exciting and very heroic.
- 27:41But all of the memorable stuff from that story thread is really
- 27:46backloaded, and I feel like the front part of it does kind of
- 27:50drag for me a bit. Yeah, I mean, I'll push back a
- 27:54little there. I think that the fact that they
- 27:57basically have them shove off from England and then
- 28:00immediately find Killian Murphy is like meaningful, right?
- 28:04Like I think that Nolan is trying to accomplish what you
- 28:08asked for earlier and that, you know, his shell shock is
- 28:12supposed to show you the horrors of the six days leading up to
- 28:16their rescue. And so I think there is some
- 28:18action happening there. I I do think that it's.
- 28:23You know, it feels a little contrived when he's like trying
- 28:27to fight them for control of the ship and and he falls and knocks
- 28:30his head and it that definitely is one of the weaker parts of
- 28:35the script. But I think that Killian Murphy
- 28:37is an incredible actor and sells the whole shell shock incredibly
- 28:43well. For sure.
- 28:45I also like when they pick up the other pilot that crashes.
- 28:48Jack Loudon is the actor's name. Excellent, excellent actor.
- 28:53He reminded me a ton. Maybe it was just the the outfit
- 28:56he was wearing too, but it reminded me a ton of Richard
- 28:59Attenborough in The Great Escape.
- 29:01Like he just he had so much of that energy going for him.
- 29:06One of my favorite performances in the whole movie, I think.
- 29:09I thought he had a lot of Peter O'Toole look about him, like
- 29:12with the blonde hair and the Super blue eyes and like.
- 29:16He just had a bright earnestness about him that reminded me of
- 29:19Lawrence of Arabia. Well, there you go, 2 glowing
- 29:22recommendations from us. Yeah, dude, let's talk about the
- 29:26last story thread. The error.
- 29:27I mean, we kind of already have, because it really only consists
- 29:30of two characters. It's Tom Hardy and Jack Loudon.
- 29:33I do think that that is where the movie felt like the most,
- 29:38purely. I don't know cinematic to me
- 29:42like the. Spectacle.
- 29:43Like not even just spectacle, but like wow, how did they pull
- 29:46off that shot? How much of this is done in
- 29:48camera? How much of this is practical?
- 29:51You get those shots from like down on the beach every time a a
- 29:54a German plane is going to come dive bomb them.
- 29:57And what the cinematographer does in a lot of instances is
- 30:00he'll have like an Outoffocus head looking up at the sky and
- 30:03it like the the camera will be behind this person.
- 30:07And then, like, way off in the distance, you see this tiny
- 30:09little speck, and it's in, like, pitch perfect focus, like the
- 30:13way they choreograph the air sequences.
- 30:18It almost breaks every rule of how you're supposed to do it.
- 30:21Like, I don't know if you remember in the movie The
- 30:22Aviator, they talk about why isn't this turning out?
- 30:26And he's like, there's no clouds in the sky, there's no frame of
- 30:29reference to show how fast they're going.
- 30:31In this movie, it feels like they're just they're flying
- 30:34against a a wall of Gray clouds and almost black looking sea
- 30:40underneath them. And so you don't get a great
- 30:42sense of the speed of the dog fights, but the way that they
- 30:46weave these planes in and out of the shots, I almost don't care.
- 30:50It has like a very, I don't know like poetic kind of rhythm to
- 30:55it. It's it was so interesting to
- 30:56me. Yeah, that's that's the word I
- 30:59was going to use. It's just a beautiful rhythm.
- 31:01And I think that there's a reason like the Top Gun movies
- 31:05have done so well back in the 80s and you know, now in the
- 31:09twenty 20s, there's just something totally rad about dog
- 31:14fighting in the air. And I like, I could get a movie
- 31:19completely silent, you know? Well, no, no dialogue of just.
- 31:25Planes, dog fighting. And I think I would just be
- 31:27mesmerized by it. Like as long as it's done well.
- 31:30And as you said, Bob, they do it incredibly well here in Dunkirk.
- 31:35All right, man. Any other thoughts on the
- 31:37performances before we go into our whiskey for the day?
- 31:41Dude, I love Kenneth Branagh. He's so good.
- 31:44Dude, he milks when he puts his his eyes up to those binoculars.
- 31:49And when, when you first see the Armada coming over the Crest
- 31:52there, right? He milks it so much, you see the
- 31:56realization set in. And then from behind his hands,
- 31:59you see the smile start to creep in.
- 32:02And then he kind of gasps for his words, but he waits until he
- 32:05takes those GD binoculars down. And then he takes one more
- 32:10breath and he goes home. And I'm like, yeah, home.
- 32:15We're we're all British in this moment, you know?
- 32:20You get the sense that he didn't actually believe what he was
- 32:25telling everyone else until that moment.
- 32:28It's such a hammy performance and it works.
- 32:31So freaking well, It's perfect. Yeah, Like.
- 32:34And and the reason it's perfect is because it's a real story and
- 32:39there's just so many military stories like that that are just
- 32:42ridiculous. Like the Germans should have
- 32:44smashed them, completely destroyed them.
- 32:47There should have been no chance of them escaping.
- 32:49And yet somehow, they made it back.
- 32:52We'll talk about all this in the second-half, because I have many
- 32:54thoughts both on German military strategy and on the way Nolan
- 33:00depicts it. But I'm with you, dude.
- 33:03Yeah, let's get into this Chivis Regal, Mitsunura Cask.
- 33:08Let's do it, man. All right, everybody.
- 33:16Today we are looking at Shivas Regal MSU Nara Cask finish.
- 33:21We haven't had a Shivas Regal product on this show, Brad,
- 33:23since either season one or season 2.
- 33:25It's been a long time since we tried that affordable, popular
- 33:30blended Scotch whiskey. I'm really excited to dive back
- 33:33into it with this kind of special edition they have here.
- 33:36This is one that I picked up in the Ohio Liquor Bureau's Last
- 33:42call section. They were getting rid of this.
- 33:44And I was like, hey, this is I think I spent like $40.00 on it
- 33:47and I was like, yeah, I'm going to try it and it's because it
- 33:50said Mizunarra on it. We've never done anything with
- 33:54Mizunarra Oak before. So Brad, if you don't mind I'm
- 33:57going to launch into a small little the more, you know with
- 34:01Bob here I'm reading off of. Bob, you go right ahead.
- 34:04I'm reading off of wineenthusiast.com.
- 34:07They have a nice little article about Mizunarra because I to be
- 34:10fair, Brad. I don't know a thing about
- 34:12Mizunarra Oak other than there were a lot of whiskeys about two
- 34:15years ago that used it. It got really popular for a
- 34:18minute and now it's like the market got got saturated and
- 34:22they've moved on to other kinds of oak now.
- 34:24So we're coming in at the tail end of the craze here.
- 34:28Mizunar Oak is a specific kind of oak that is grown in Japan.
- 34:33Apparently the name actually means water oak in Japanese.
- 34:38Because something about about the moisture content of the
- 34:41trees themselves make them more prone to holding water and then
- 34:45leaking. But when they are aged properly
- 34:49they are like exceptional casks to use for wine for spirits
- 34:53aging. They say that now like a single
- 34:55cask might cost a producer $6000 to buy.
- 34:59And it says when left to mature correctly, a missing Nara aged
- 35:02whiskey offers complex notes. Of sandalwood, coconut spice and
- 35:07Japanese incense, which makes me really, really excited to see
- 35:12what a Scotch finished in that will smell and taste like bread.
- 35:17Yeah, I am very excited for this.
- 35:20This is like maybe a first for a few seasons now, Bob.
- 35:24I am actually drinking this live and I believe you've already
- 35:28done your tasting. Wow, we have really reverse
- 35:30roles tonight, man. Yeah, I did mine a couple days
- 35:32ago. I took very brief notes because
- 35:36I want to see what you think about it and I don't want to tip
- 35:39my hand too much. Just a few more notes on this.
- 35:41It's aged for at least 12 years. It is a blend of Scottish green
- 35:45and malt whiskeys. Let's freaking dive in, man.
- 35:48What are you picking up on the nose?
- 35:50Yeah, this is a really nice nose for me.
- 35:53It's a little bit nutty. There's some like almond going
- 35:57on. It is very light and floral
- 36:00there. There's some fruitiness.
- 36:04I don't know if I want to say citrus maybe maybe like a maybe
- 36:10like a Peach kind of feel to it. I really like this nose a lot.
- 36:15I'm going to give it an 8 out of 10.
- 36:17The note that I took to start with on the nose was pear, pear,
- 36:21Pear. I have never had this much like
- 36:23green. What is that, a Bartlett?
- 36:26I don't know what kind of what my pears are.
- 36:28It it smelled like the juicy pear Jelly belly.
- 36:31It is like the most decadently pear forward thing, and I love
- 36:36pears, so I was like super pumped about this.
- 36:40I got some melon on it and then after you let it sit in the
- 36:43glass for a couple minutes, that fruitiness kind of dissipates a
- 36:46bit and you're left with, like layers and layers of brown sugar
- 36:50and caramel. It takes on like an almost
- 36:52bourbony decadence to it at the end.
- 36:55I loved this note. As I said, beautiful in my
- 36:58notes. I'm going to give it a nine out
- 36:59of 10. Yeah, and then I got into the
- 37:02pallet. Here.
- 37:04The pallet is just feels really rich.
- 37:08There is a lot of honey. That nuttiness stays in there
- 37:12for me, but the longer I sit with it, the more the floral
- 37:16notes come through. And the more that I I would
- 37:20agree with you that kind of the pear for me it it it still feels
- 37:24a little juicier than that it feels peachy but it it's got
- 37:28that nice stone fruit feel to it.
- 37:31I am I'm a big fan of this Bob. I'll give it an 8 1/2 on the on
- 37:34the pallet. Yeah, for me it was like a
- 37:37bottle of really sweet white wine.
- 37:39Was the kind of fruitiness I was getting on it really, really
- 37:42good. And then almost.
- 37:44Almost a grainy barley for me. There was a lot of barley malts
- 37:48on this, a little bit of char towards the back of the palate
- 37:52and then it finished off. This is not really a finished
- 37:54note, but like the last thing I get when I go to swallow it gets
- 37:57really creamy and it reminds me almost of like vanilla soft
- 38:00serve. It's Brad.
- 38:02This is a flavor experience we don't typically get on Scotch
- 38:06and especially on like a blended Scotch.
- 38:08The barrel here I think is really imparting a lot and I
- 38:11didn't pick up coconut on the palate.
- 38:14But I could see why a lot of people tip towards that because
- 38:16that creaminess for me came across as like vanilla ice
- 38:19cream. But I could see it being like a
- 38:21cream of coconut For somebody. I'm going to give it an 8 on the
- 38:23palate and then on the finish I'm also going to give it an 8.
- 38:27It gets just a bit bitter, but it's still really, really nice.
- 38:31The prickliness of the alcohol doesn't really make itself known
- 38:34until the finish, but once again, like way above average.
- 38:38So 8 on the finish for me. I actually think that this, the
- 38:41finish is kind of where this excels.
- 38:44I love that note of like vanilla soft serve because that was
- 38:48coming through for me strong on the finish and I think that
- 38:52there's an oakiness here. But it's it's unique, it's
- 38:56different. It's not the same wood note that
- 39:00you get on any other whiskey. Bob, this is truly a a delicious
- 39:05whiskey. I'll give it a nine out of 10 on
- 39:07the finish and as far as bounce goes like.
- 39:11I can't imagine them doing many things better on this whiskey,
- 39:14like all of the flavors work together.
- 39:17It's a beautiful, sweet, floral whiskey that hits all the right
- 39:24notes for a blended Scotch. I I really like this lot.
- 39:28I'm going to stick it a nine out of 10 on the balance.
- 39:30I'll also give it a nine on balance.
- 39:32There is just a slight drop off from the nose to the finish for
- 39:35me, but that's just because the nose was one of the best.
- 39:39Scotch noses I've ever smelled, so it's a nine for me.
- 39:44Value is going to be interesting, Brad.
- 39:45So like I said, I paid about $40.00 for this.
- 39:48I'm assuming that it's getting harder to find out there like
- 39:52this was a limited edition release.
- 39:54I saw a couple search results come up that it's selling for
- 39:57like $200.00 now, but then I saw other stores that have it in
- 40:00stock and they're selling it for like $50 now.
- 40:03I don't know man, what are you seeing on your end?
- 40:05I've been seeing in general anywhere from like 45 to $60.00,
- 40:10so I don't know. Let's set it at like a $55 price
- 40:13point. Yeah, I was going to say even 60
- 40:14because if you're buying it online, like you're going to pay
- 40:16shipping. So even if you get the $45.00,
- 40:18you're probably true. Let's call it a $60.00 bottle of
- 40:21Scotch. Listen, I know it's a blended
- 40:23Scotch. It is better than a multitude of
- 40:26single malts that we have had. At $60.00.
- 40:30This is kind of a nobrainer for me, man.
- 40:31I'm going to give this a nine out of 10 on value.
- 40:35Yeah, I'm with you. I'm at an 8.5 on value, Bob.
- 40:39I'm coming out to a 43 out of 50 here.
- 40:43Brad, I am coming out to a 43 out of 50 here.
- 40:48I love it when we are in unison on something and when, to be
- 40:52fair with you, man, like I I bought this like a year ago and
- 40:56I've been kind of waiting to work it in.
- 40:58It wasn't like chomping at the bit to try it.
- 41:01I thought maybe it'll be okay. I am very pleasantly surprised.
- 41:05This is one of the best whiskeys we've had all season.
- 41:07It has achieved that 40 and above mark where it kind of
- 41:11becomes a nobrainer. If you see it on the shelf, pick
- 41:14it up. If you see it at the bar, it is
- 41:16absolutely worth a poor. I can't recommend this highly
- 41:19enough, man. Yeah, this is a delicious
- 41:21whiskey that if you're still able to find it by the bottle
- 41:24immediately. All right, man.
- 41:27Well, I'm feeling very good right now.
- 41:29Let's get back into talking about Dunkirk.
- 41:31Let's get to it. All right, everybody.
- 41:37That was Shivas Regal Misanura. That I can't say that word.
- 41:42Misanarra. Misanarra.
- 41:44Mozzarella marinara. You're.
- 41:47Fucking me up now, Italian oak cask.
- 41:52I did marinara sauce. It previously held marinara
- 41:57sauce. Now it has whiskey in it.
- 42:01Tastes like a tomato. All right, you got to bring us
- 42:09back then all. Right, everybody.
- 42:10That's what Shivas Regal Mizunarra Cask.
- 42:13A whiskey that is beyond description as well as a name
- 42:17that is beyond pronunciation. So we're getting back into
- 42:21talking about Dunkirk, which also begs a pronunciation
- 42:25question. Everyone in the movie calls it
- 42:27Dunkirk. We're going to Dunkirk.
- 42:30I don't know if that's because of it comes from the French or
- 42:33what, but I don't know, Brad, how do you say it?
- 42:35You say Dunkirk, Dunkirk. I mean, I say it as the French
- 42:38do Duke. That's it.
- 42:44That's it. All right, man.
- 42:46We're going to, we're going to go off the rails really quickly
- 42:50if we don't get into our next segment, which we call 2 facts
- 42:54in a falsehood. Brad is going to try to stumpy
- 42:57ball. You are right and what is wrong?
- 43:032 facts in a falsehood. That's right, everybody. 2 facts
- 43:06in a falsehood. The segment where Canada cheers.
- 43:11First of all, we're recording this like a a week or so in
- 43:14advance. I hope that Canada is recovering
- 43:17from these wildfires. Like, yeah, I don't know if you
- 43:20can hear the scratchiness in my voice.
- 43:22I live in northern Ohio. And the smoke from the wildfires
- 43:26has been so bad that like, the air quality in my area is off
- 43:30the charts. They say don't go outside.
- 43:33And if you do wear a mask to go outside, it's really bad guys.
- 43:37So first of all, Brad and I are are praying with and for Canada
- 43:43because it's been rough, man. Yeah, yeah.
- 43:46Honestly, I'm kind of glad that we've been dedicating this
- 43:49segment to Canada for so long that it's, it's our sincere
- 43:52support. For everything that's going on
- 43:55up there that like, yeah, I mean we get that some out West and in
- 43:59California and but man they have a lot more trees than us.
- 44:04Bob, I'm. Going to feel real bad if I lose
- 44:06this week now, Brad. You know, it's like they got to
- 44:09win one for the Gipper here. So yeah, I am.
- 44:12Maybe. Maybe Canada's on my side
- 44:14though, Bob. That's, that's true.
- 44:16We will see how I do at 2 facts in a falsehood.
- 44:19This is where obviously Brad presents three items to me.
- 44:22As fact about making this movie and I have to figure out which
- 44:26one is the lie, Brad, hit me with your two facts in a
- 44:30falsehood. Fact number one According to Sir
- 44:34Kenneth Branagh, roughly 30 Dunkirk survivors, who are in
- 44:37their mid 90s at the time, attended the premiere in London.
- 44:41When asked about the movie, they felt it accurately captured the
- 44:43event, but that the soundtrack was louder than the actual
- 44:46bombardment. Fact #2.
- 44:49Director Christopher Nolan had long wanted to direct a film
- 44:52about the Dunkirk evacuation, ever since he did a class
- 44:55project on it in primary school, saying that it was one of the
- 44:58most inspirational stories that he had ever heard.
- 45:03Fact #3, the scene in which Farrier Spitfire lands on the
- 45:07Dunkirk beach was real, done on location with an actual
- 45:10Spitfire, and it was the first time a plane had landed on that
- 45:14beach since 1940. Well, that's.
- 45:16Cool. Right.
- 45:18Huh. So #3 is interesting because
- 45:23when they actually show the plane landing on the beach, you
- 45:26don't see the town in the background.
- 45:28They the background is the ocean or the channel I guess.
- 45:33So doing it on location doesn't really make a ton of sense
- 45:37because unless you're going to show Dunkirk in the background
- 45:40like it could have been, it could have been Myrtle Beach,
- 45:42you know what I mean? Like no one knows the
- 45:43difference. So there's there's just like
- 45:47bikini clad women running around in the background, It's.
- 45:50Just a guy in like a Joe's Crab Shack tshirt, so I'm immediately
- 45:55suspicious of 3/2. Sounds pretty plausible.
- 45:59I know that Nolan had been wanting to make a Dunkirk movie
- 46:01and developing it since the late 90s.
- 46:03I assume he heard this story as a boy growing up in England.
- 46:07One also sounds very plausible, so I think I'm.
- 46:11I have a pretty equivalent chance of getting this wrong
- 46:13regardless. Canada.
- 46:14I'm so sorry. I'm going to go with three as
- 46:18the falsehood. Brad.
- 46:20Bob, you are back under 500. No.
- 46:25Fact number two was the falsehood.
- 46:28Man, Christopher Nolan did not like this story.
- 46:31As a child, he hated it. He actively was rooting against
- 46:36the English. At that point, it was actually a
- 46:38bet between him and his brother that he lost and his brother was
- 46:42the one who loved the story. Oh, interesting.
- 46:45No, I'm, I'm completely. Oh, you're making that up too.
- 46:48Man, I believed you. This is the problem with two
- 46:51facts and a falsehood. You've you've got me gas lit at
- 46:55this point, man. Oh man.
- 46:57OK, let's talk about this movie a little bit.
- 47:00And we don't usually do the like we're history buffs.
- 47:04Let's let's compare this to how it really happened.
- 47:07But there are a couple things in the movie itself that didn't
- 47:10work for me, Brad. And I think that you have to
- 47:14kind of bring the historical record into it a little bit to
- 47:16highlight them. The first of which is that at
- 47:18the end of the movie they say that 300,000 people get off of
- 47:22the beach and get rescued. At no point in this movie does
- 47:28it look like there is anything remotely approaching 300,000
- 47:31people on that beach. Like you see the planes going
- 47:33overhead and there's like a string of 20 people that are
- 47:36like, and I think that Nolan is really good at.
- 47:43Taking small stories and making them appear to have huge scope.
- 47:48Like I think about the scene in The Dark Night where you get
- 47:52that, the showdown of the Joker and Batman on that abandoned
- 47:56like Chicago St. when he flips the semi truck and stuff.
- 48:01Like literally that is just two guys and a semi truck and it's
- 48:04like it's an iconic action scene now, even though nothing really
- 48:08happens. But I feel like it's almost the
- 48:11inverse. When Nolan has a gigantic scale
- 48:14to work with, like this movie doesn't have the heft and the
- 48:19scope and the scale that I feel like it needs, You needed to get
- 48:23more extras on that beach or CGIA.
- 48:25Couple people in like we would have forgiven you for CGI ING a
- 48:29couple soldiers in there, dude. Like I know most of this is is
- 48:32done practically, but he had like 30 guys on the beach and
- 48:36they were like, look at the 300,000 soldiers.
- 48:39Yeah, no, I I'm with you. I think that.
- 48:42I mean, honestly, if you want to pause this episode right now,
- 48:44just go Google the Dunkirk evacuation and go to the
- 48:48Wikipedia page. Right at the very start, there's
- 48:51a picture of the beach and there's just countless troops in
- 48:55lines on the beach. And I'm like just literally just
- 48:58recreate that shot. Like, how cool would it have
- 49:01been if the opening shot of the film was like a grainy film reel
- 49:05of that exact, you know, still. And then slowly morphed into
- 49:11color and you see them all moving about.
- 49:14And then a plane swoops in and tries the bomb on.
- 49:16Like, that would have been an incredible shot.
- 49:18And yeah, it, you know, it should be too hard to find
- 49:21300,000 extras. They don't even be easy.
- 49:24Like The thing is, you know when they make like sports movies.
- 49:30They usually only get enough extras to fill one section of
- 49:33the stadium, and then when they cut to the other side, they just
- 49:36move the extras. Like all you got to do is get
- 49:38like 1000 people and then just make it look like 300,000.
- 49:42I don't know. Anyway, that's that's always
- 49:44bothered me about this movie, like the execution of the movie,
- 49:49the craft of the movie is incredible.
- 49:51But then there are just certain things about it where it's like,
- 49:54am I supposed to not notice that there's only like 30 guys on
- 49:58this beach, like? In what world would this would?
- 50:02Would you even find a corner of the beach where you'd only have
- 50:0430 guys? Yeah.
- 50:06And the other half of that is the, the naval part of the
- 50:10equation, right? Like at the end of the day they
- 50:12show quite a few, you know, civilian boats heading there.
- 50:17But you got to think like even if each boat carried 40 people
- 50:21on it, you still need. What is that, 1000 boats or
- 50:2610,000 boats? Well, I assume that they made
- 50:28many trips back and forth, right?
- 50:30But the way the movie portrays it, it's like we scooped them
- 50:33all up. We're done and left.
- 50:35We're going back, yeah. Yep, exactly.
- 50:37And and so that's like, that's the the hard part where you're
- 50:43like, show me some more boats, show me some more men like it.
- 50:46It would have been pretty incredible to just see the scope
- 50:50of it and honestly like. It makes me think about the
- 50:53opening of Saving Private Ryan. Like that movie captures the
- 50:59scope of the D-Day invasion incredibly well, where you just
- 51:03see thousands of men storming this beach and there there's an
- 51:08impact of the size of it. So yeah, I'm I'm there with you,
- 51:12man. I I think that they could have
- 51:13done a little bit better at at showing the the scope and size
- 51:18of it all. So I was talking to Google's A I
- 51:23Barred about Dunkirk. I was asking the questions about
- 51:26the movie Dunkirk and the real life historical events of
- 51:29Dunkirk. And I'm going to read you an
- 51:32excerpt from the transcript I have with Google Bar.
- 51:35We're introducing a I. We're introducing a I Yeah Man,
- 51:39Who? Would have thought that it would
- 51:40have come from an event 8090 years ago.
- 51:43So I was asking it questions like what are some of the
- 51:45inaccuracies in the movie Dunkirk?
- 51:48Then I asked it like. Were the soldiers really just
- 51:51hanging out on the beach? Were they not getting shot at by
- 51:53the enemy more than this? And then Google bar got very
- 51:56snippy with me and said the soldiers on the beach at Dunkirk
- 51:59were not just quote hanging out, they were under constant threat
- 52:03of attack. And it goes to talk about like
- 52:06how often they were getting bombed and shot at from behind
- 52:09the barricades and I asked it what kind of attacks were coming
- 52:13from behind them and. It just seemed like in this
- 52:15movie you don't really have this constant threat of what's behind
- 52:20the walls. And I think that no one really
- 52:23could have leaned into some of the more horror aspects of
- 52:27movies like Memento or even Inception and had that kind of
- 52:30creeping sense of something is is creeping up on them from
- 52:34behind and they are trapped by this wall of water on the other
- 52:37side. It felt more to me the rhythm of
- 52:40the movie, the pace of the movie.
- 52:43Like they made it to the beach and they were like, well, we
- 52:45just got to wait till they get here.
- 52:47So we're just going to sit here and not so much like we are
- 52:49being actively pursued. Like, you know, Pharaoh and his
- 52:54Chariots are chasing us to the edge, you know what I'm saying?
- 52:57Like, I I want something like that where the desperation of I
- 53:01cannot move any farther, but I am getting pursued from behind.
- 53:05I think that's another element that is missing from this movie
- 53:08for me. So for you it didn't work that
- 53:12he doesn't show any German troops other than like half a
- 53:15second when they capture Tom Hardy.
- 53:18I mean, I I like that this kind of like a faceless presence, but
- 53:21you only, you know, that's very offscreen.
- 53:24You get a couple bullet holes in the hall of the ship they're
- 53:27hiding in. But even if they had just had
- 53:29more shots where Finn Whitehead, you know, the cameras pushing in
- 53:34on his back and then he turns around because he knows there's
- 53:37something there, even if you can't see it like.
- 53:40Just to increase the paranoia of it a little bit.
- 53:44Yeah, I mean, I I think that the opening sequence kind of
- 53:47establishes that a little bit when when Finn is escaping, you
- 53:51know, he's the lone survivor of his troop that is killed by
- 53:54Germans in the town of Dunkirk. And honestly, like that opening
- 53:59scene was incredible. It, it's the most colorful part
- 54:01of the movie. And I I remember thinking I was
- 54:03like, man, this is just a beautiful opening shot of this
- 54:06film. And then everything else is kind
- 54:08of just Gray and blue and and sad, as it should be.
- 54:14It's a good proper British film. But I I think that you're right.
- 54:19I I think that there's places where the the drama could have
- 54:22been extended. I just for me, I think that the
- 54:25focus on the troops and the focus on you know the Air Force
- 54:30and the the naval part of the film was more than enough to
- 54:34keep my attention, I feel like. You're going to give this movie
- 54:39like an 8 1/2, and yet it feels like you're talking about it
- 54:42like it's A7. That's The thing is, like, I'm
- 54:46not going to say my score, but I respect this movie and I want to
- 54:51give it like the recognition it deserves.
- 54:53It's kind of like this movie gets nominated for Best Picture,
- 54:56but it like no one thought it was going to win.
- 54:58It was nobody's favorite movie of the year.
- 55:01Except yeah, I guess we came to find out later.
- 55:02Tarantino loves this movie, but. But it's kind of like, yeah, it
- 55:07totally deserves to be nominated for everything.
- 55:09It is like an impeccably crafted film.
- 55:12It just doesn't all click for me.
- 55:16Yeah, that's that's crazy, man. I mean, maybe it was just my
- 55:19first time through that that it hit for me.
- 55:21I thought that this was incredibly well done.
- 55:24Like, I'm with you, there's flaws.
- 55:26It's not a perfect film. But I think it's one of the
- 55:30better war films that I've ever seen.
- 55:32I think that it captures a lot of the fear and terror of of
- 55:37what it's like to be at war. I think the few moments where
- 55:40you see real human terror and, you know, just walking off into
- 55:46the ocean basically to commit suicide, like that's brutal.
- 55:51And I think Killian Murphy gives an incredible performance
- 55:54showing how. Desperate you feel in moments of
- 55:58of feeling that shell shock and PTSD at for me so many avenues
- 56:03of this film worked well and I and I'll say like most all of
- 56:08this film was like a B + 2 an A minus.
- 56:11You know it's it's not perfect but none of it was ever like a C
- 56:16minus. The only part that kind of
- 56:18struggled was Finn Whitehead. So I, I just.
- 56:23I come at this movie and go, man, I I just think this is a
- 56:25really technically brilliant and beautifully shot movie that I
- 56:30I'm, I'm in for. Okay.
- 56:32So I was going to talk more about what I was asking the A I,
- 56:35but I don't think I want to do that anymore because you just
- 56:38have set us up for a perfect segue into our final two
- 56:42segments of the day, the first of which we call Let's make it a
- 56:45Double. Near the end of the episode.
- 56:48So thanks for listening to the film and whiskey show.
- 56:51Let's pair another film with this one, even if it's
- 56:53struggling. It's a final segment of the day.
- 56:55Now let's make it a double. Let's make it a double is the
- 56:57part of the podcast where we pick a movie to pair up with
- 57:01this one to make the perfect double feature.
- 57:04Brad, you are the you're the fan of this movie.
- 57:07I want to see what you pair this up with.
- 57:09Man, this is an interesting one. I I remember hearing somebody, I
- 57:14don't know if they talked about it or if it was a video I
- 57:16watched that talked about cinematic universes and you
- 57:20know, we have the MCU and then all the other spinoffs that
- 57:22never actually worked. But they talked about how in
- 57:26history there's like historical movie universes, the largest one
- 57:32being the World War Two movie universe.
- 57:37And I I think you kind of have to stay in that realm for
- 57:40Dunkirk. I'm trying to.
- 57:43I'm trying to remember the name of the movie.
- 57:45I liked it a lot. Was it The King's Speech?
- 57:49Yeah, that's that's nothing like Dunkirk.
- 57:52But yeah, the the movie with Colin Firth where he has a
- 57:56speech impediment and he. Yeah, yeah.
- 57:59Oh yeah, totally reminds me of Dunkirk.
- 58:01I'm going to pair that with Dunkirk because I think that
- 58:04there's something of capturing the element.
- 58:07Of what's going on at home in England and the struggles
- 58:10they're facing there with the military operations that are
- 58:15happening, I think there's something worth watching there.
- 58:18And so I and I also just really like The King's Speech.
- 58:22So I'm that's what I'm pairing up with.
- 58:24Bob scoff at me all you'd like. Scoff, scoff, Sir.
- 58:28All right, I'm going to pair this up.
- 58:30With a movie that I went to the movie theater to see this and it
- 58:33freaking blew my mind at the time.
- 58:35It's a documentary that was made by Peter Jackson, the director
- 58:38of the Lord of the Rings films. It's not The Beatles
- 58:40documentary, although that would have been really funny if I had
- 58:43done that. It's a movie called They Shall
- 58:45Not Grow Old. It is basically Peter Jackson
- 58:49and all of his folks at Weta Digital.
- 58:52They were given access to hours and hours and hours of original
- 58:57footage from World War One. And they took it, they colorized
- 59:01it, they upscaled it all to 4K, they restored it, they took all
- 59:06the pops and scratches out of it.
- 59:07And basically what they did was they recreated, they hired
- 59:11people from like different different areas of England based
- 59:15on the patches they saw on the soldiers uniforms to read the
- 59:18lips of what they saw in this footage.
- 59:21And they just recreated what life was like for soldiers in
- 59:24World War One. It brought this war that was 100
- 59:28years old at the time. Into the modern day.
- 59:31And it was like it was a game changer for me to see that,
- 59:35Brad, because I'd never seen, you know, once in a while you
- 59:37see colorized World War Two footage.
- 59:40This was colorized and updated World War One footage.
- 59:43And there was just something about the way that Jackson
- 59:47imparted such a humanity to these people in small strips of
- 59:53film from 100 years ago. It really is just like it
- 59:57balances out for me. What this movie's lacking in
- 1:00:01terms of character development, and so I think it'd be a perfect
- 1:00:04double feature with Dunkirk. There you go.
- 1:00:07I think that's a great, great pairing, dude.
- 1:00:10Well, thank you very much, Sir. No scoffing here.
- 1:00:14Oh man. What?
- 1:00:16What's your final score on this, Bob?
- 1:00:18I'm really curious where you're gonna end up.
- 1:00:21I think, like objectively, this movie should be given an 8 out
- 1:00:26of 10. I think that I enjoy it, a 7.5
- 1:00:31out of 10. It's a like and that feels weird
- 1:00:35to say because like this is a much better made movie than 90%
- 1:00:39of three Star Movies, right? Like it's just it's incredible
- 1:00:43to look at. You can tell there's a genius
- 1:00:45behind the camera and also writing the script, but it just
- 1:00:49doesn't all click for me. It leaves me feeling a little
- 1:00:52detached, a little cold, and I think for that reason I can't
- 1:00:55really go above a 7 1/2 on this one.
- 1:00:59Yeah, I this just worked for me, man.
- 1:01:01I I think that the action sequences are brilliantly shot.
- 1:01:04I think he captures the claustrophobia of being in a
- 1:01:08sinking ship incredibly well there.
- 1:01:11There's just so many brilliant moments throughout this movie
- 1:01:15that just like took my breath away.
- 1:01:17So I'm going to give it a nine out of 10.
- 1:01:19I I think that this is a stellar movie and one of the better
- 1:01:22World War 2 movies that we've gotten in a very long time.
- 1:01:26All right, so I'm giving it a 7 1/2.
- 1:01:28Brad gives it a nine. That brings our average to an
- 1:01:308.25 out of 10. But I'd like to know what you
- 1:01:35think. Film and Whiskey Nation seems
- 1:01:37like I'm more in line with the general public on this, But if
- 1:01:41you're a Nolan fan, then I have a feeling you probably
- 1:01:44appreciate this movie a little bit more.
- 1:01:46So let us know what you think. You can find us on social media
- 1:01:49at film, whiskey, on Instagram, Facebook, TikTok, YouTube,
- 1:01:54Facebook, all the things. At Film Whiskey.
- 1:01:58Or you can jump on the Discord, which I'm sure will be bought
- 1:02:02into the Metaverse at at some point.
- 1:02:04You can join the conversation on Discord.
- 1:02:07There's a link to it at the end of every single one of our show
- 1:02:09notes. Brad, next week we are just
- 1:02:12fully diving into the Japanese stuff.
- 1:02:14We we we dipped our toe into it with Mizonara this week.
- 1:02:18Next week we are introducing Akira Kurosawa.
- 1:02:21I cannot freaking wait, man. We're starting with his 1950
- 1:02:25masterpiece Rashomon. How pumped are you dude?
- 1:02:29I am incredibly excited to jump in to Kurosawa.
- 1:02:34It's it's something that, like I've wanted to do for a while,
- 1:02:37but I've held off because I know we're going to do it on the
- 1:02:39podcast. So here we are and I am so, so
- 1:02:43pumped for it. All right.
- 1:02:44We will see you guys next week for Rashomon.
- 1:02:47But until then, I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad G.
- 1:02:50And we'll see you next time.