Latest / Newcomer Pod / Roko's Basilisk (w/Nathan Benaich)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome. Hey, everybody.
- 0:13Welcome to Dead cat. This is Eric newcomer, Tom and
- 0:16Katie are here. I've totally lost my voice.
- 0:19I am mustering through sickness to make sure that someone here
- 0:24who has been writing about AI is on the podcast.
- 0:27Because Katie and I are just here to And you are AI.
- 0:33Standards are here. The first generative podcast, we
- 0:37have Nathan, who's the founder Soul.
- 0:40General partner of are Street Capital.
- 0:42I feel like I started covering European Tech.
- 0:45And like, we started exchanging a lot of messages.
- 0:48And yeah. So I've been looking for an
- 0:50excuse to do something with you and then finally I got on the AI
- 0:54hype train and you've been thinking about AI for many years
- 0:57and you're like, everybody Welcome to the party or
- 0:59whatever. Yeah, glad to have you.
- 1:02Yeah. What's it feel like now that
- 1:03everyone's obsessed with a? I all of a sudden as have been a
- 1:06shock or what sort of your reaction to the Mania of the
- 1:10moment hasn't quite been a shock because sort of expecting this
- 1:14to happen in a way. It's great that, you know, like
- 1:16a new advanced technology domain gets attention from creasing,
- 1:20Lee generalist investors or investors, who focus on
- 1:23different Industries because almost then, you know, reaffirms
- 1:26that like the technology is for real and probably has
- 1:29applications in all sorts. Of domains.
- 1:31Yeah, I know your portfolio. Companies can get marked up like
- 1:33you just have to hope you got in a lot of the deals explain to me
- 1:37what happened. Exactly because I mean if we're
- 1:39just going to trace the chronology of the last year, in
- 1:42Venture investing obviously 2020 21, may be the first half of
- 1:48this year has been about crypto and you saw all these funds
- 1:52rebranding themselves as crypto focused funds.
- 1:54And all of these VCS that I used to talk to all the time about
- 1:57their old Investments are, like, what the hell are you talking
- 1:59about? Delivery to me.
- 2:01I don't do delivery. I'm a crypto investor now, you
- 2:03know, and I mostly do crypto and it seems like that's all been
- 2:07forgotten. Now like that's all the memory
- 2:09holds and like they all switch their hats and they took off
- 2:11their Dottie th on their hat and they put on a I like explain to
- 2:16me what has happened over the last year, the real like
- 2:19inflection point was when you could Master this first viral
- 2:27use case of machine learning, which is images and video like
- 2:30before when you had text models that were working with you,
- 2:33well, and you could generate like a script or you could talk
- 2:35to a bot. There's something that's
- 2:37fundamentally less, interesting, reading a script with a bot,
- 2:40then looking at these epic images, that never existed.
- 2:43Before that you designed with your own instructions on your
- 2:47mobile phone. So I'd almost call it like the
- 2:49consumerization of machine learning or at least a product
- 2:52the output of machine learning. Which is understandable and much
- 2:57more tangible to almost everybody who uses the internet.
- 3:01Then the products that came before and while those tools
- 3:04like stable diffusion and Dolly from open a I were available to
- 3:09people in the know for a while. They really came out what like
- 3:13late August September and that has really sort of kicked this
- 3:17off just because a Publix very aware.
- 3:20Yeah and I think their distributions also been quite
- 3:23interesting. From how the Machinery Mark has
- 3:26evolved because the central dogma is always been that
- 3:28centralization winds, which is like to be good at machine
- 3:31learning, you need to have all the data, all the top people,
- 3:35all the computers and then the product and you mix it together
- 3:39and then you get sort of, you know, great machine learning on
- 3:42the other side and cook, those been the counterbalance to that,
- 3:44which is just decentralize everything, give power back to
- 3:47everybody and yeah. Over the first few months of
- 3:49this year, the fact that you can now like arm the rebels as it
- 3:53were are These open source communities which are basically
- 3:56called themselves like research collectives and they either
- 3:59gather on disk or other forms that might not even be companies
- 4:03or corporate entities and provide them with access to
- 4:06compute, which is what stability really did.
- 4:09It's of liberates, the creativity of individuals who
- 4:11couldn't participate because they weren't part of the, you
- 4:14know, the Gap, the elites, the in a big technology company
- 4:17Elite. And that's actually led to like
- 4:19massive open sourcing which then busts up the centralization
- 4:22hypothesis and shows you that there.
- 4:24Like another path to building and distributing machine
- 4:27learning based products thing. That's what I like a lot of
- 4:29folks are getting excited about to how important was Dolly as a
- 4:34product and I guess for our listeners that haven't used it
- 4:37out there mean. This is the tool that the Eric
- 4:39was mentioning like open a.i. released.
- 4:41And it allows you through fairly direct instructions.
- 4:44You've got to be direct because it's not always that smart.
- 4:47You've got to basically say like in the style of Monet or in I
- 4:50feel like the key is to like yeah give it a realistic, right?
- 4:54Exact right, right. Clip art.
- 4:56But basically, you can give instructions to, you know, it
- 4:59says some software and it will generate with less than a
- 5:01minute, some fairly creative depiction of what you drew and
- 5:06it's like very easy to use and is like a very clear product of
- 5:11what a I can do. So like how important do you
- 5:14think just that being released even on a beta level and then
- 5:17more openly played into the excitement from investors.
- 5:21That there's like a whole opportunity here.
- 5:23I think the community Was like pretty Blown Away with the
- 5:25results of Dalian specially like Delhi to but then they get back
- 5:29to this question of. Can you build businesses on the
- 5:31apis, on the clothes, the apis of the large companies and know
- 5:35there's a few that are built on gbt.
- 5:37So I think that that excitement got even greater ones like these
- 5:41models became reproduced in the open source World by folks like
- 5:44stability a looser, Etc. So, I think it's really just as
- 5:49this notion of like, busting up centralized entities, and
- 5:51providing tools to everybody else.
- 5:54I think they've also landed really well, just because we
- 5:56kind of live in this like a tick tock generation of short form
- 5:59images, video, and images, and Instagram, and the outputs of
- 6:03these models are like perfect fodder for those platforms.
- 6:07Well, what's interesting to me about Dolly and this lady of
- 6:10generative images is that it's something that you can very
- 6:13easily explain to someone like I think it passes the dinner table
- 6:17test that crypto certainly had a very difficult time doing.
- 6:21You know like prove to us has a hard time passing the Tests
- 6:25showed that grandma just trust me.
- 6:28Put all your money in this right?
- 6:30Different dinner table conversation especially with
- 6:32older people. But yeah, you know it's like
- 6:35everyone, I'm assuming all of our listeners spent last
- 6:37Thanksgiving trying to explain to their uncle's or even worse.
- 6:40Having their uncle's explain to them the value of crypto and
- 6:44like what it can do and then whereas with this, it's like oh
- 6:47why don't you think of some words and let me put it into a
- 6:49prompt and I can enter it and it'll draw an image.
- 6:52And at the very least you're like, oh wow, that is
- 6:53impressive. Technology that I can't and out.
- 6:55We need you saying you can grasp and I mean, I know it seems like
- 6:59really simplistic to put it in these terms.
- 7:01But is that how investors felt as well?
- 7:03It's like, oh, I get this, this is cool.
- 7:06I think there's probably a bunch of like I get this.
- 7:08And this looks like consumer technology that have been used
- 7:10to investing for a very long time.
- 7:12I think the other thing too, is some investors realizing that
- 7:15they don't have like a bet in a. I like, what is my big bold
- 7:19debt? And when I like the proverbial
- 7:21investors, sees the opening eyes were half a ton of money.
- 7:24Do you mind doing some great things that there are some new
- 7:27offshoot Labs that we provide in our state of the air report that
- 7:29are raising tons of money? You know build a billion people
- 7:32that they're kind of all these adjacencies that you can apply
- 7:36machine learning to sort of get to just drum themselves up into
- 7:40this fomo. Can you break down just like
- 7:43generative AI versus with everything else?
- 7:45Or I feel like all of a sudden, we're talking about generative
- 7:48AI. Yeah.
- 7:49But textbook, definition you basically have like to kind of
- 7:52categories of machine learning. You have like, It's called
- 7:54discriminative machine learning which is basically like given a
- 7:58data set. How can I draw a boundary
- 8:00between two categories in that data set?
- 8:03So to decide is just like images and animals, whereas the
- 8:06boundary, that separates one species from another and then
- 8:10you train this model on this data set.
- 8:12And then it's tasks. When it sees new data is to just
- 8:15classify, the species is present in the image.
- 8:17And that's discriminative by contrast like generative is
- 8:20basically where the model is trying to learn like the
- 8:23statistics The probability distribution of a data set like
- 8:27learned something intrinsic about it, such that you can ask
- 8:30the model to basically generate to synthesize and you example
- 8:34that fits that data distribution.
- 8:37And so like at a high-level busy, what we've done is created
- 8:40models that are like able to sort of learn like increasingly
- 8:44complex datasets in this case, like the entire internet or the
- 8:48entirety of like Flickr or whatever in pairs of, you know,
- 8:52text descriptions to Image representations such that when
- 8:56you ask it to generate, like some arbitrary seen like, with
- 8:59some very specific prawns, like it's seen different combinations
- 9:03of these things before and can smush them together in a way
- 9:06that like looks nice. So you could, you could probably
- 9:09argue that like a lot of the generative AI that like we're
- 9:11talking about today which is images and video and text sort
- 9:15of like a rebranding of like creative AI that I used to see I
- 9:18five years ago or so. When especially this technology
- 9:21called Gans regenerative adversarial Networks.
- 9:24Hmm which were like you know very hot and IP a couple of
- 9:27years ago we basically get like one model that generates an
- 9:31image and then another model that says like is it good or is
- 9:33it bad when you sort of put them together against one?
- 9:36Another it early and then at some point like the image
- 9:39generated comes good because it can fool the network that saying
- 9:42is a good or bad. So it's sort of like not new and
- 9:44is like fundamentally part of like textbook machine learning,
- 9:48you know, I feel like I'm going to ask the most obvious question
- 9:50here, so bear with me. But how does Human creativity
- 9:55work alongside generative AI. It is a compete with generative
- 10:00AI you know if we can do so much based on extraordinary Works
- 10:06already, created in the past that we all love and admire and
- 10:10we imagine that a I could create really pleasing interesting
- 10:15thought-provoking work based on that.
- 10:18Where does human creativity sit alongside that I think it?
- 10:22Awaits you in creativity will just A guide almost.
- 10:26And then these generative models would just help you explore our
- 10:29like this search space of what you could possibly make.
- 10:32And I think I got a high level. It's kind of beautiful with
- 10:34these machine learning models that, you know, synthesize more
- 10:37data than any human could ever do in their entire career.
- 10:40If they tried to become expert at something, is that kind of
- 10:43spread over like Humanity's history, we can sort of get to
- 10:46like more local Optimum solutions to things.
- 10:50If you remember the alpha, go to the case study.
- 10:53It's like if You train the system on, like, as many
- 10:56simulations, is physically possible in the space of time,
- 10:58than you're probably get some gameplay.
- 11:01That's better than what we've seen before.
- 11:03And so it turns out that like all of human expertise passed on
- 11:06from one generation to another yields a local Optimum, that's
- 11:09not the best that exists. And so I think, you know, in a
- 11:12way that is generative systems are sort of guides to get us two
- 11:16more Optimal Solutions. And this applies to making
- 11:19pictures prettier and prettier but also applies to making more
- 11:23potent. Drug molecules and
- 11:25pharmaceuticals is funny to hear this answer in the domain of
- 11:29creativity though. You're like they're going to be
- 11:31they're going to rank in a higher percentile of creativity
- 11:34than we have. And it's like very subjected to
- 11:37because it takes things like Picasso and turns him into sort
- 11:41of raw material. It turns him into a commodity,
- 11:44right? Yeah, in order to generate more
- 11:48images. Yeah.
- 11:49I wanted to build on sort of Katies question, which is just
- 11:52also the sort of late in like plagiarism stuff or just like
- 11:56the machines taking advantage of like past human, creativity to
- 12:00become smarter. There's sort of the
- 12:02philosophical question in that, where I think some artists feel
- 12:06like, well, they're taking my data to build these future
- 12:10drawings and really, I'm not getting the cut of that.
- 12:13You don't know. It needed me.
- 12:15So there's partially. It's just like philosophical,
- 12:17but I am curious also like as an investor.
- 12:20Is there any like the eagle risk here?
- 12:22Someone was talking to me. You know, like this generative
- 12:25work could be done in like, video games or something.
- 12:28And you can imagine, like, the set of video games as much
- 12:31smaller, and it could be much more obvious.
- 12:34If you're sort of building sort of an algorithm off of existing,
- 12:38sort of, You Know, video game IP, I don't know.
- 12:41How do you think about sort of the intellectual property of
- 12:44what goes into these systems? Yeah, I think it depends on
- 12:48that. The scale of the data set that
- 12:50the models learning from because you could probably argue if the
- 12:53model is sucking up the entirety of the internet and what is one
- 12:56incremental like blog? Authors blog going to help this
- 12:59model and how can they justify that unless perhaps like there's
- 13:04so iconic in their style like in the artistic space with Picasso
- 13:07or it could be the grounds for the largest class action lawsuit
- 13:10of all time. Yeah so that my words were
- 13:14stolen in front of the large length model and I believe all 7
- 13:16billion people on earth, have the claim to that.
- 13:19I love it. When big law firms together with
- 13:22technology. Yes.
- 13:24Wait a second. So I think that's probably one
- 13:26of the only ways that like one can legislate against these
- 13:30systems, which is like it. The entirety of like a
- 13:32significant pool of people to legislate, or two or kapha
- 13:36lawsuits, because the individual consumers, not going to have a
- 13:40say, I'd love to see that advertisement on TV.
- 13:42Have you or your words been used as part of a large language
- 13:45model that you feel is impeding on your personal rights and
- 13:47creativity. You may be entitled to a
- 13:50settlement. Hey, we have a prediction in the
- 13:52state of the air report that will I have some fun like,
- 13:55content lawsuit, that will. I think at some point just give
- 13:58rise to I can use for licensing agreement, which is like a, for
- 14:02example, like I'm Reddit. And in order to train on the
- 14:05entirety of my Corpus of conversations, Etc, then you
- 14:08have to abide by blah, blah, blah fascinating.
- 14:11So, there actually, could theoretically be some sort of
- 14:13Licensing elements of this that has to be taken to account for
- 14:16these large language models. Yeah, I mean, I think if you're
- 14:19a big content owner, the best part is like your future
- 14:21monetization stream and that's a wave.
- 14:24You to participate in this teacher, that's pretty
- 14:26inevitable. I think what's open source like
- 14:28gets their hands on something? It's kind of an inevitable
- 14:30direction of travel. So then the question is, like,
- 14:32are you Wikipedia, are you Encarta?
- 14:35So, as one of the reasons why there's such a rush to go in
- 14:38early, you know, is one reason that investors sort of see this
- 14:43on the horizon which would slow growth.
- 14:45So get in. Now while there are still a lot
- 14:47of room for very quick movement, I think yes or no, but I think
- 14:50if sure early then you probably might suffer from like being the
- 14:53tallest pop. P and sort of being the target,
- 14:55you know? And then once like to label and
- 14:58has been cast, then the fast followers can move in, and I
- 15:02think that's been proven captures gone Spotify.
- 15:05Is he like, you know? Yeah, exactly.
- 15:07I think that kind of dynamic can happen, but it is also true that
- 15:10in open source and just in communities, in general, like
- 15:13once you get momentum it's hard to stop it.
- 15:16Unless you really screw things up or something new pops up.
- 15:19And so that it's tough to think about what are these competitive
- 15:22long-term modes that you can. Apply to sort of keep your pole
- 15:26position. Did you follow the whole
- 15:28conflict? This week between stability, Ai
- 15:31and Runway. Yes, but yesterday, actually,
- 15:34and yes, I tweeted, I was like open source AI for all like,
- 15:38what can you recap? It here is very obscure.
- 15:41It's happening on hugging face, which is like The Message Board
- 15:45of the sort of, the AI world. So I always deep in, but
- 15:49basically these two companies both back by CO2, you know, the
- 15:53huge investor Better stability. AI is basically the company that
- 15:57put out stable diffusion with some other researchers and then
- 16:01this company Runway I think they're co-founder participated
- 16:06in the research with stable. Diffusion, they put out like an
- 16:09update to stable diffusion without stability.
- 16:12A is permission and then stability.
- 16:14A I basically said this was a violation of their IP and
- 16:18threatened them and then eventually somehow Runway got
- 16:21them to back down, but it's like clear.
- 16:24These sort of Open Source projects are not as open source.
- 16:29Maybe as represented different people want to own them and
- 16:32people are raising it billion dollar valuations off
- 16:36Technologies. Where it's not clear who
- 16:38controls them, Nathan died gloss that right?
- 16:41Or what am I missing? Or what do you think's
- 16:42interesting about the whole incident?
- 16:45I think you got it quite right. The other interesting thing is
- 16:49like the core technology and paper and busy research that
- 16:52underpins like stability came. From academic environments that,
- 16:56you know, were sort of enabled by large compute infrastructure.
- 17:00And so that's sort of also been like increasingly ignored is
- 17:03perhaps like this ecosystem to become financialized by applying
- 17:07large valuations to companies. So I was surprised, it's just
- 17:12rise of the keyword of like stability IP because I thought
- 17:16in all the marketing but there is no IP because it's all open
- 17:19source by default. It's basically open source and
- 17:22you understand this better than I do.
- 17:23It's Source, but then stability. I basically spent a ton to run
- 17:29simulations of it, or whatever, or where to train it, right?
- 17:32And that costs a lot of money. Yeah.
- 17:34But then, even the training work helps everybody because that
- 17:38system is just out there or yeah, stability.
- 17:41AI isn't able to say we paid to train it.
- 17:43We only get the better version or yeah.
- 17:45I mean, so like this, this sort of like the model code and then
- 17:49you train it and, you know, you can train it on whatever say
- 17:52like, you have a data set, I have a Dataset will sort of get
- 17:55a different model because we've trained it on a different data
- 17:57set and the difference is just expressed by what's called
- 18:00weights. So basically this model has like
- 18:03tons and tons of knobs and then you need to tune like billions
- 18:07of knobs. And so if you train it on
- 18:09different, datasets will get slightly different, knob
- 18:11configurations. And then you can like list these
- 18:14knob configurations on plugging face and then you can download
- 18:17them and then and then apply them to your model without like
- 18:20retraining your own model and then you've got the same model
- 18:23basically. So these are what's called like,
- 18:25model checkpoints weights that kind of thing.
- 18:28But yeah, I mean, these architectures are largely in the
- 18:31public domain and then the data set that was trained on is in
- 18:34the public domain and says, Master dies.
- 18:36I called lie on. So, unless I think a company
- 18:40takes the open source model and then trains it on their own
- 18:43Corpus of like images or video, and then someone steals that
- 18:49that's like theft of Ip. But then if they just published
- 18:52the model, back on the Internet with the new ways and then say
- 18:56can be used for both commercial and research purposes than its
- 18:59Open Access than its connection. If theme, that's like Tom and
- 19:03Katie and I have like, discussed over the years and it's always
- 19:06interesting. Technology is like a sense of
- 19:09like fatalism in Tech where it's like if something's happening
- 19:14Silicon Valley doesn't always want to have like some huge
- 19:16ethical debate about it because there's just sort of a realism
- 19:19that like what the cats out of the barn.
- 19:22I mean, I think we saw with like, Opening.
- 19:25I write like dolly was slower to be open access than some of
- 19:30these others and then like stable diffusion basically
- 19:33jumped the gate and then dollies like fuck it will be out there
- 19:37too. I mean do you think like this is
- 19:41like a controlled enough situation where anybody can be
- 19:44thoughtful about, like how technology should develop or do
- 19:48you think this is just sort of like a Mad Dash where it feels
- 19:52like this has happened? Inning.
- 19:54I should be the one to monetize it before somebody else.
- 19:58Well, I don't think the primary motivation for stability is
- 20:01monetizing. I think it's really Distributing
- 20:03like systems to anybody who wants to run them and who can
- 20:07benefit from them. But I do think it has some
- 20:10implications over, like the kind of alignment and safety and
- 20:13guard wills and things like this around these systems.
- 20:15And I mean the canonical like example was open EI and big tech
- 20:20companies that have their own views as to what people could
- 20:23use these tools. As for in the form of filtering,
- 20:25certain prompts that Woodgate, the model from creating certain
- 20:29things. There were deemed to be like
- 20:31unsavory. And then, the alternative is
- 20:33like stabilities. Anybody can go do this, but in a
- 20:35way, like, who should decide who gets worked, and how in a way
- 20:40you could say that, you know, the entirety of humanity that's
- 20:43going to work on these open source models could potentially
- 20:46get to a better place than a few people, in a single company.
- 20:51That's pretty much the experiment that's getting run at
- 20:53the moment because as you say, like, once one company goes,
- 20:57open source, it's for game theoretical everybody else has
- 21:00to if you want to be relevant, hence, the like Wikipedia versus
- 21:03Encarta analogy, that I think is quite topical here.
- 21:07You know whether either of them end up being good.
- 21:09Let lucrative companies is like another question, but this is
- 21:12only like the first-order effect.
- 21:14You have all the second order effects, which is what other
- 21:16fields are going to benefit from these Innovations.
- 21:19And that's where I mean spending like a lot of time.
- 21:21And especially as these kinds of models touch like problems in
- 21:24biology and chemistry, and physics and Drug Discovery and
- 21:27things like that. And that sort of occurring of
- 21:29the in the shadows because it's slightly Technical and goes back
- 21:32to like the non-viral consumer e, these cases of machine
- 21:34learning, but it's very real. We're all writers.
- 21:38How terrified you think we should be that generative?
- 21:42AI will successfully replace writing like some PCS say, oh,
- 21:47writings even easier than images right?
- 21:51Hard. Like I mean, somebody wrote like
- 21:55one Masters and one PhD thesis and I try and write a newsletter
- 21:58as good as Eric's, but like this is hard.
- 22:01So I can use classic like perrito.
- 22:02Like, I think you can do, you know, 80% of the job.
- 22:05And then the question is, like, how easy is it?
- 22:07As a user experience to solve the last 20?
- 22:10And I think in many of the writing assistance that I've
- 22:12tried, it's like, you know, generates text, but then you
- 22:14kind of get halfway through you like this garbage.
- 22:16Like, this is not good enough. One of the newsletter writers
- 22:20did Ali-A, I driven tweet storm, that went viral and he said it
- 22:24was like his best and I guess my throwback on this writing
- 22:28question is almost like, My worry is about the audience.
- 22:32Like, I think, like, you me, like we're writing the 80 to 100
- 22:35is very different. It's like, oh, this looks like
- 22:38good writing. Yeah, it is incoherent.
- 22:40The people you're referencing aren't real or like whatever,
- 22:43you know, the actual Logic, the key.
- 22:45The real key part is not there but the Aesthetics of it, that
- 22:49it looks like something you would say.
- 22:50It feels like Like has takes like it feels like a clean
- 22:54solution to a problem that's there.
- 22:56And so if the audience is dumb enough, you know, then you could
- 23:00make money off of it, you could build a large audience and I
- 23:03feel like that's sort of terrifying that like, part of
- 23:06what's been protecting. The world is just that the
- 23:08people doing the writing want to believe that.
- 23:11It's like coherent. But if you just like, unleash a
- 23:15sort of generative AI, it's like, well, can people tell the
- 23:18difference or not? I mean, do you think that's too
- 23:20cynical? Or do you see my sort of fear
- 23:22there that the humans need to be good at like they need to care
- 23:26enough that it makes sense. Yeah I mean I'm kind of from a
- 23:30positive like if I can get like a that's a low bar to be more
- 23:34positive than invite guests, system that can deal.
- 23:37Take my like English written newsletter and writing in like
- 23:40God knows how many different languages or create different
- 23:42formats or create hot takes that are shareable on different
- 23:46platforms or can just speak it in the same way than I've spoken
- 23:49and I've tried to do that manually.
- 23:51It's a pain. Like I'm happy being like 10
- 23:53bucks a month for that. Like and I wouldn't be really
- 23:55not concerned with take my job right at the belt, like, you
- 23:58know, amplifying the things that I'm already doing but like
- 24:01moving some of the like real work, whether it ends up like
- 24:04entirely replacing me. I think, obviously, that's just
- 24:06like, very hard to tell and by that point, maybe I'll have
- 24:09found something else. I want to do.
- 24:11So, and language is so filled with Nuance, in terms of word
- 24:15choice translation. It's interesting.
- 24:16You brought that up translation is actually in some ways.
- 24:18Extremely hard, because straight trans Ation often does not
- 24:22capture meaning at all. So it's a, you know, language is
- 24:27very tricky. Imagine a straight translation
- 24:29of The Iliad. I mean, that wouldn't really
- 24:30work, right? Yeah, may I, somebody was just
- 24:33telling me yesterday that AI is very appealing in the sort of
- 24:36cross cultural context, because you could imagine, like, novels
- 24:41where right now, the novel's talks about like New York city
- 24:43where the authors from, but if you want to sell to a
- 24:46mass-market audience, like you could say, oh this machine's
- 24:49going to figure out, This readers and like Beijing or
- 24:52whatever, and we'll replace it with like their favorite like a
- 24:55local shop and even if it's like you know imperfect and doesn't
- 24:59get the language, right? It's still like better than
- 25:02today where there's no effort made to sort of Pander to the
- 25:06reader. So I mean, we could enter this
- 25:08world where I like stuff is really sort of catered to that
- 25:13literature is, would it be better to read like Lord of the
- 25:16Rings and have it set in Washington d.c., right?
- 25:19Yeah, like Let's replace, Middle-earth, you know, I would
- 25:24go with the Capitol Hill and you will toss the ring into the
- 25:27fires of the Rotunda don't want to imagine a world.
- 25:30I've never seen before. That's not the fucking point of
- 25:33fiction. Yes, it is actually the fucking
- 25:34point of picture. Well, you know, it's interesting
- 25:36though is that like that kind of piggybacks onto this idea of all
- 25:40content being catered to our personal tastes?
- 25:43And this sort of social media-driven idea of, you know,
- 25:46algorithmic driven consumption. And like, why shouldn't you know
- 25:50the next? I don't even know what popular
- 25:52book series are out there these days but you know like the next
- 25:54Nobel winning book, be iterated towards the different audiences
- 25:58because that's the way people consume everything else.
- 26:01You know, there's no advantage to Central entertainment,
- 26:03centralized experiences, something that you have to, you
- 26:06know, relate to other people's point of view that's done with
- 26:09that's over. That's the old one.
- 26:11However, I would like to see a Hunger Games La version.
- 26:14Sure. Yeah, I mean, in a way it's like
- 26:16Mass personalization everybody gets their own version but in a
- 26:20way it's kind of sad because that it's like loss of opinions.
- 26:23It's also a loss of a cohesive experience, it's lost.
- 26:27I mean like women this is ages ago and I didn't read these
- 26:30books until much later because Eric made me but Harry Potter is
- 26:33a great example of a series of books, that created a creative
- 26:39imaginative experience that people across cultures age
- 26:44groups, socio-economic groups, races and genders could all
- 26:49encounter together. And do we not want to have
- 26:52things that bring people together anymore?
- 26:54Like any good Millennial. I militantly insisted the Katie
- 26:58read. It was really intense.
- 27:01It was a lot of pressure. It was a long queue monthly
- 27:03month-long campaign. I like how sad for you.
- 27:06And my request is an exchange for house-sitting.
- 27:09Yes, a you read her. I left you.
- 27:11Like my own copies or switch was like so intense because they're,
- 27:17like, Mormons out there. There were like, chill out a
- 27:19little bit more busty. You don't have to leave it
- 27:22everywhere. Yeah.
- 27:25I don't know. It's funny.
- 27:26I mean you want me to have that experience because you wanted
- 27:30right? And so we could be friends and
- 27:32understand me, right? Like if we don't have that shit
- 27:36anymore, that we share, that's not of our own personal
- 27:38preference like what what do we have?
- 27:40But you know where I could see that concept being actually very
- 27:43appealing to Publishers is the idea of stuff being, you know,
- 27:46of its time and like not aging very well.
- 27:49I don't mean like a thematic lie but I mean like we're Choice or,
- 27:52you know, the stuff in between Huckleberry, Finn example.
- 27:55Yeah, Choice. Yeah.
- 27:59I mean, yeah. I don't even know what like the
- 28:01a I woke version of Huckleberry Finn would call, you know.
- 28:04Mr. Jim but like yeah it's all those things.
- 28:07Anyway, I don't want to spend time on that but my point is, I
- 28:09can see actually that idea being like, well why can't a book?
- 28:12Be like a dynamic thing. And over time, a I can identify
- 28:16what are the problematic themes and words in the book and update
- 28:20in a way that you know, Doesn't offend people in a way that it
- 28:23might have at the time that it was written.
- 28:24I mean, it seems so starts in the video game environment of,
- 28:27like programming. These non-player characters that
- 28:30have certain behaviors respond in certain ways and therefore
- 28:33give like a unique experience to the game player.
- 28:36And like the way they're trained is quite cool to where you can
- 28:39like import an example of a conversation or a script and
- 28:43then sort of like, tune some knobs based on personality
- 28:46traits, say, you know, I don't know they behave like Zeus or
- 28:49something and then the agent knows that.
- 28:51Because it's like read all of Wikipedia and stuff like this.
- 28:54So it was pretty wild to see that.
- 28:56And so perhaps it's like more in these Virtual Worlds with this
- 28:58will happen. And in the beginning of our
- 29:00conversation, I mean you were sort of nodding to the fact
- 29:02that, you know, a lot of the way I work is very open source and
- 29:07like sort of not totally like Financial driven.
- 29:10I don't know. But is there like a clear, like,
- 29:14AI researcher sort of like ideology or like, what are the
- 29:17sort of like camps in terms of the culture?
- 29:20That's Emerging in this space. As you see it or is it just too
- 29:24big to have something like crypto was unique?
- 29:26Because I had the financialization to sort of get
- 29:29everyone in line and sort of creature culture.
- 29:32Does a I have something like that same sort of shared
- 29:36culture, I think then what are the new demarcations I've seen
- 29:40as Iran safety and Alignment. Like those a very, very, very
- 29:43small number of people that are working on this topic of like,
- 29:47if we invent a GI, like how do we make sure that it aligns
- 29:50broadly with Preferences. This is based on the concept
- 29:54that like any prior species that was smarter than the one that
- 29:57came before it like generally made a pretty bad experience for
- 30:01the species that was there before.
- 30:03And so like there's a construction of people that
- 30:06don't want to work on capabilities anymore, which is
- 30:09broadly, like making ahead better.
- 30:11And they only want to work on making a, I say 40 more aligned,
- 30:14then you're supportive of that skeptical of that or do you have
- 30:17a personal point of view? Yeah.
- 30:19I think I'm generally supportive of that.
- 30:21That's like anthropic, right? Is a big company in that space.
- 30:24Yeah. And throughout the small one in
- 30:26London called conjecture this one called Redwood research.
- 30:29There's a few people that open the eye, that a couple dozen
- 30:32people, how do they make their money?
- 30:34Is it just like, tithes from the actually profitable companies
- 30:37to, like, feel good about themselves for the moment?
- 30:40They don't, you have to the Moon, they do.
- 30:41They've just been through a Venn diagram overlap between safety
- 30:45and alignment and effective altruism.
- 30:48And so, we've seen for example, like Dustin moskovitz, Events
- 30:51that we philanthropy and send back and treated FTX who funded
- 30:55a lot of these projects. And as BF did the massive round
- 30:59anthropic. So, none of these companies are
- 31:02revenue-generating at. I don't know if they have
- 31:04aspirations to be, but they certainly want to create better
- 31:07tools for alignment. And you're very specific point
- 31:10that, you know, more sophisticated or more advanced
- 31:14species, you know, sort of crush, the one below that, you
- 31:18know, I study philosophy in college and I'm a big lie.
- 31:21Like you know, bite the bullet. Type person on moral intuitions
- 31:25and there's a certain type of argument that if you're like a
- 31:27die-hard utilitarian and you find out like that this new
- 31:31super a I like experiences more utility than human beings can
- 31:37and gets like, more joy, more, whatever the utility calculus
- 31:40is, they get like more of it than you should sort of route
- 31:43for the AI to Wipeout human beings.
- 31:46Like, if resources could more efficiently, go to the AI, which
- 31:49gets better, Use that. It makes sense for it to go
- 31:53there, which I think is sort of a hysterical.
- 31:54Like, I'm gonna bite the bullet, all the way on this one and Say,
- 31:57Goodbye human beings. That sounds like an argument and
- 32:00a, I would make error, sorry. I don't know.
- 32:04I'm also very worried about rocas basilisk.
- 32:07So I guess this would be a very, you know, a that also sounds
- 32:10like something we've talked about that.
- 32:21This Overlord a I already that sort of exists like across time.
- 32:26And so to save yourself, you need to be working towards its
- 32:29existence because anyone who doesn't will be like terribly
- 32:34punished and so, yeah, you should.
- 32:36This is, this is the plot of Verizon 0.5.
- 32:41I know how that one Ends music. By the way, I imagine that's a
- 32:45big use case for this technology, right?
- 32:47Yeah. Well, music is one that was
- 32:49again. Like tried several?
- 32:51Years ago. And that maybe now is that an
- 32:53inflection point to. So we had a business a couple
- 32:56years ago called Juke deck which eventually sold to by dense but
- 33:00they were like one of the oh geez that machines creating
- 33:03music. And now it's probably a ton
- 33:06better but I'm kind of like excited about maybe like the
- 33:09more esoteric applications that are not super obvious that could
- 33:13have a business called intense eye, which does help and safety.
- 33:16Basically, like, protecting individuals and Manufacturing,
- 33:19industrial environments, who Ooh, unfortunately get injured
- 33:22because those environments are dangerous or, you know,
- 33:25accidents happen and this is great documentary on Netflix,
- 33:29which is like a perfect primer for why?
- 33:31This is an issue called American Factory?
- 33:33Sure the Obama Doctrine. Yeah, yeah, exactly.
- 33:37So this is like a solution in a way to some of the problems that
- 33:39manifest, their where you're trying to like have good health
- 33:43and safety practices, but it's just hard to do that walking
- 33:47around with a clipboard trying to instruct people who don't
- 33:50wear the right. Active equipment things.
- 33:52So they use computer vision to apply this.
- 33:54It's are like a cyber security solution for the real world and
- 33:57like we've already seen that, like, some large companies that
- 34:00implement this immediately, you know, after like a week or two
- 34:02weeks, see huge reduction, and alerts and dangerous, behaviors
- 34:07telling, that's like one like I didn't really know anything
- 34:10about before I encountered this company and watch this
- 34:12documentary and realize like shit.
- 34:14This is massive with like big implications and makes your
- 34:18system pretty cool machine learning but it's like just like
- 34:21Number one, or number two priority for a certain category
- 34:23customer was really excited about these sort of domains
- 34:26rather than like, the, what's in like the glitzy.
- 34:28Obvious Limelight, that every VC is going to kind of vibe with
- 34:33see that feels like, it's even more aligned with.
- 34:35Are its argument that the AI should wipe us all out because
- 34:38if we as humans can't even protect ourselves without using
- 34:41an AI, you know, it's like protect ourselves from each
- 34:44other, it would seem like there's no hope, right?
- 34:46I mean I would argue that some people think that that kind of
- 34:49use of AI is Wiping humans out. I mean we have seen some of
- 34:53these things especially Industries like long-haul
- 34:56Trucking where more and more of the decisions that one can make
- 35:00are being given over to a machine and a person is sort of
- 35:04peripheral to the process and it's not necessarily.
- 35:07Well, it is physically reducing things like accidents.
- 35:10What do you think about what's happening to the human beings
- 35:13involved? You could argue that there are
- 35:15other negative consequences that perhaps haven't been
- 35:17anticipated. So I don't know, Tommy, well,
- 35:20maybe we'll have it both. Ways humans will be wiped out
- 35:23either way, right? Right.
- 35:25The richest destitute for the jobs that were taken away from
- 35:27us by a eyes or, you know, we just don't use the aib, just all
- 35:31died of massive injuries in our factories.
- 35:34Yeah, yeah. These are going to guys are.
- 35:36Come on, you're optimistic about it, right?
- 35:39I mean I think it's pretty amazing.
- 35:40I think this is gonna be the biggest like productivity gain
- 35:43for human beings and like a long time I think it's going to be a
- 35:47massive Revolution. I'm like yeah, it's true.
- 35:50So true. Believer in like AI changing
- 35:53human existence far more than crypto and like very happy to
- 35:56see Silicon Valley. Yes, moving back this.
- 35:59Yeah, I agree with. I mean, I think that you're
- 36:01totally right by the productivity gain, I just am not
- 36:03sure their productivity gain is the Baseline measurement for
- 36:08whether or not humanity is getting better or worse.
- 36:10Well, government needs to do something to say, okay.
- 36:13We've made these productivity gains therefore, you know, we're
- 36:16not going to just keep grinding every human being out or it
- 36:19requires Paul. Let's see maybe to cash in some
- 36:23of the benefits for people instead of just me.
- 36:26I think, the, my Baseline is like what kinds of problems like
- 36:30weren't addressable before that now become addressable because
- 36:33we have this new technology, right?
- 36:35So, some of that might drive productivity ends, some of them
- 36:39might not, but I think that's like the coolest unlock.
- 36:42It's like what can you do if a solution requires, more than
- 36:46like a web app in a database, like a nice UI or something?
- 36:51Peter's dominate Us in chess, they can dominate Us in,
- 36:55presumably drug Discovery or whatever.
- 36:57Once we figure that, I mean, that was what I took you to be
- 36:59saying earlier, it's like, yeah, we're not the best in the world
- 37:02at games that we've been playing for much of sort of
- 37:06sophisticated Humanity. It's very likely, we're not
- 37:09going to be the best at other things.
- 37:11We can do especially of games that we need better tools to
- 37:14understand. Right.
- 37:15Right. Well, it seems like, I mean, if
- 37:17I could delineate the 80/20 issue here, you know, 80 is
- 37:21being like we've developed an AI that can beat us all in
- 37:23Jeopardy, but like, the last 20% is, like, developing an AI that
- 37:26can host Jeopardy. And that seems like it's the
- 37:31hardest thing to do. I mean, we hardly can host it
- 37:33ourselves. Well, yeah, we get to set the
- 37:34expert. I mean, that's why people think,
- 37:37you know, if anything a I could be good for sort of emotive
- 37:42interpersonal tight or professions.
- 37:45Yeah, because humans get to set the score on that and say we
- 37:49actually we prefer I mean like yeah, it's true.
- 37:52Like I'm a friend right now who's in the hospital with
- 37:55cancer and I think she'd rather have the bad news delivered to
- 37:59her by a human being. He held her hand and be
- 38:03emotionally connected to her in a real way rather than a I yeah.
- 38:07I think I think it's going to be hard to replace that.
- 38:11Yeah, this is true but I think I'd even in that example, we
- 38:13have a company that is not part of a bigger drug Discovery,
- 38:17business called xen cheetah. But like in every case like the
- 38:20doctor is trying. To make an assessment as to,
- 38:22which therapeutic strategy is the best for this patient.
- 38:25And that's really, it's really hard choice to make.
- 38:28And at the moment, like, what they've been doing is at best
- 38:31sort of like, doing a biopsy and sequencing and seeing what is
- 38:34the gene that might be causing the cancer?
- 38:36And then just taking a drug that, you know, in theory fights
- 38:40that specific mutation. But this company that we
- 38:42invested in, they actually take that same biopsy and base if you
- 38:45run like a clinical trial in the dish.
- 38:48By having that biopsy and the presence of like one of hundreds
- 38:52of different cancer agents and you can functionally measure,
- 38:55whether this drug is, you know, fighting the cancer or not.
- 38:59And they've actually proven that like you see, statistically
- 39:02higher survival rates because you're functionally assessing
- 39:06cancer, drug performance against the patient's.
- 39:08Tumor versus just in a very reductionist way like doing
- 39:12mutation and Drug matching and that step I have.
- 39:14No doubt is going to make huge advances.
- 39:16And I'm just saying that like, Somebody has to hold her hand
- 39:18and say, you're going to die. I think most people would rather
- 39:21have that news delivered by a human being.
- 39:23Yeah and also like we saw a lot of this to during the pandemic.
- 39:27When people had to do things like give birth by themselves,
- 39:31just alone messages coming into their phone.
- 39:34For some reason didn't really feel that comforting.
- 39:36They didn't really like that was an optimal experience.
- 39:39They still wanted a human being one of a new standing next to
- 39:43them while they did this but they just couldn't have it.
- 39:45Yeah, I think for the most intimate and personal of
- 39:48interactions in a, I should never replace it.
- 39:50Like, it's not something that unless you're absolutely lonely.
- 39:53And, you know, that's a whole other thing to people chat, you
- 39:56having conversations. I mean, that's just the essence.
- 39:58The essence of being human is being lonely, right?
- 40:00Right. But I mean, that would probably
- 40:02like the last, you know, quarter of the last, you know, moment of
- 40:05humanity is like us helping ourselves, you know, into our
- 40:09obsolescence and, you know, eventual destruction as we
- 40:12Comfort ourselves into our death.
- 40:15But isn't it so interesting, they were even having a
- 40:16conversation. Firming.
- 40:18The idea that in life's most intimate moments, we actually
- 40:21want human interaction just in case anybody.
- 40:25Yeah, just just reminding ourselves but like I said the
- 40:29last human, you know, Comforts The Lassie the second-to-last
- 40:32human or vice versa you know in the a Eyes Were Watching us
- 40:35through their screens and saying it is almost done.
- 40:38This is such clear this this is an AI derived modification of
- 40:43William Faulkner's Nobel acceptance speech, clearly Why?
- 40:49So you'd like the last puny voice of humankind bringing it
- 40:52up, you know, across the hills that I like this.
- 40:55Like his last day. Yeah.
- 40:57Comforts the last day. I I knew what I can add those
- 41:01conversations that I like you. Nice there that does not have
- 41:04found. Is that I've met I like working
- 41:06on like practical Solutions like real problems.
- 41:09Like not not this thing when you're gone, her friends, I
- 41:12think. Sighs about what a generally.
- 41:19I will mean, and I'll write, I mean, it's not just sort of the
- 41:23mass, I mean, right? You spent a lot of time with
- 41:25these are nine exercises? Yeah.
- 41:27I actually don't spend a lot of time thinking about generally, I
- 41:29to be honest because you think it's sort of just a total mind
- 41:33game distraction or you just like don't find any, I think it
- 41:36is a bit of a distraction to some degree like it's a bit of a
- 41:39short term for me in terms of traction.
- 41:40Like I've no idea when this will happen and I don't know about
- 41:44you know, like these surveys that ask people, you know, over
- 41:47What space of time? Do you think Jolly?
- 41:49I can can arise the in many cases like those questions are
- 41:52formulated in a way that presupposes, an answer and so
- 41:55they kind of bias around a bit but you're saying the survey say
- 41:58sooner than you think is credible or yeah to what degree?
- 42:01I don't know. But yeah it does feel a bit
- 42:03sooner and by the way like the date is like been getting closer
- 42:07well and also people are incentivized to make it sound
- 42:09like it's sooner than it is because that makes it sound like
- 42:11a reasonable investment. What's I saw was driving car.
- 42:13Yeah. Cars.
- 42:18They can't predict general intelligence cool.
- 42:22Thanks so much for coming on. Yeah, thanks for having me.
- 42:25And Tom are we wrapping on this or you want to do more?
- 42:28Sure. If you guys wanna stick around,
- 42:29we can spend a few minutes on the email.
- 42:30We can do that. But Nathan, thanks so much for
- 42:33coming on. Really, really appreciate great
- 42:35to talk to you. Thanks again, thanks.
- 42:37Thank you. Do you want to spend a few
- 42:42minutes on the email or do you a rabbit as a foot email that he
- 42:46sent about pronoun? Yeah, so this Was the, I guess
- 42:48now, former CEO of mail, mail chimp mail came.
- 42:52The reason I wanted to go through it is not because, you
- 42:55know, I mean, the email itself I thought was pretty hysterical,
- 42:57but also it does touch on a few things that I've actually been
- 43:00themes on the show before, and so beyond, just like laughing at
- 43:03this guy, for sending a 1500 word email to is.
- 43:06She was, you know, she never liked any HR person, Eddie HR
- 43:11person would have like, throwing themselves off a building to
- 43:13stop it from happening, but you know, no one, no one tells these
- 43:16things to CEOs. I don't know how dedicated you
- 43:19think these HR people or their companies that yeah, yeah,
- 43:22clearly a couple, you know, like I'm email marketing firm has
- 43:26acquired by insults like HR person.
- 43:28If you're thinking about throwing yourself off, a
- 43:29building on behalf of your company, you need to wake up.
- 43:32Let me just read through the email, we could just reflect it
- 43:34for a little bit and then if we see, it's getting longer, it's
- 43:37boring because just we could just call the episode.
- 43:39Okay, so again, this is an email that was sent by the now, ousted
- 43:43CEO MailChimp, which is an email marketing firm.
- 43:46The story was broken by Former. And so we shiver who's the
- 43:49writer there? So this is the email, sorry, the
- 43:52guy's name is something Chestnut or something?
- 43:55I don't know him. By the way, big Chestnut,
- 43:58Chestnut. No.
- 44:00Hi team. I've been really impressed by
- 44:02how well the new employee onboarding is be going lately.
- 44:04We're bringing on so many new peeps.
- 44:06Oh, yeah, that's the thing. In the email.
- 44:07He calls people peeps. The whole time through.
- 44:10We're bringing on so many new peeps and in turn, they're
- 44:12bringing on their own great questions and making the chats
- 44:14very Lively. Kudos, I want to take a quick
- 44:17moment. So lightly recalibrate something
- 44:19before it goes too far. This is where it starts.
- 44:22I've never read this. So I'm like, experiencing this
- 44:25life, okay? I'm sure Katie hasn't either
- 44:27because she has other things to do, I am noticing that whenever
- 44:31new employees introduced themselves in Zoom before asking
- 44:33your question, they're also announcing their pronouns.
- 44:37This is completely unnecessary when a woman parentheses, who
- 44:40was clearly a woman to tell us that her pronouns are quotes she
- 44:44/ her and a man parentheses who was clearly a man to tell.
- 44:47Tell us that his pronouns are quote, he / him.
- 44:51However, if there is an employee with gender dysphoria, in the
- 44:53room, who feels more comfortable, this is coming from
- 44:56the CEO. By the way, to all of the, like,
- 44:58all the employees of the company, just want to make that
- 45:01clear. There's an employee with gender
- 45:02dysphoria in the room who feels more comfortable if we know
- 45:04about and use a non-obvious pronoun.
- 45:07For them on obvious means that they might appear to be one
- 45:09gender to others. But in their minds, they
- 45:11consider themselves to be another gender.
- 45:13They are very welcome to Proclaim that pronoun to others
- 45:15in the room and for the record. It is my desire.
- 45:17That MailChimp is a respectful place that will honor that
- 45:19request, the name of inclusion. So basically like the guy is
- 45:22trying to explain himself and they why is writing this email
- 45:26and do it in a way that's very thoughtful and, you know, he's
- 45:29not trying to say, I have a direct issue with people
- 45:31claiming their one gender or another, you know, it's going to
- 45:33be very, you know, whatever. But this is where the problems
- 45:36kind of cut, crop out the next paragraph.
- 45:38It seems as though there is a very kind and compassionate
- 45:40intention by someone somewhere in onboarding to accommodate our
- 45:44co-workers who use non-obvious pronouns, but making them feel
- 45:47comfortable Durable enough to announce their pronouns.
- 45:49Indeed, an intimidating thing to do in front the crap.
- 45:52What a mess. The logic seems to be that if
- 45:56everyone else is announcing their pronouns, and that is the
- 45:59logic. I know where you're going with
- 46:01this dude. And that is exactly the logic.
- 46:04Yeah, we all see what will logic becomes a key word here as
- 46:07you'll soon. Find out the logic seems to be
- 46:09that. If everyone else is announcing
- 46:10their pronouns, then they are making it easier and more
- 46:12comfortable for the trans. Last gender-fluid employee to
- 46:15announce their own, that is truly kind.
- 46:17And I We love that intention. Yeah, but in the law, but here's
- 46:20the but right, so far, so good. But in the long run, this
- 46:25approach does more harm than good.
- 46:28There are there are three reasons for this first, there is
- 46:33a tiny there's a very tiny number of peeps at MailChimp.
- 46:36Who would consider themselves transgender forcing either with
- 46:39orders or through guilt, approximately 1390, other peeps,
- 46:43to adopt the new communication Paradigm that Humanity has never
- 46:47had to use. In our 300,000, Your Existence
- 46:50and in our hundred and fifty thousand years of spoken
- 46:52language. I don't know where those numbers
- 46:53and we would definitely not want any peeps who've not yet
- 46:56publicly identified as such to feel comfortable doing.
- 46:59So we want to keep that number, really small here MailChimp.
- 47:02We don't want any more people feel uncomfortable talking about
- 47:05their gender because it goes against three hundred thousand
- 47:07years of tradition. In order to make things
- 47:10additions that were bad that we get rid of, I'm gonna throw
- 47:13slavery out there as one, but continue.
- 47:15Yeah. They never, you know, in ancient
- 47:16Sumeria, they Announce their pronouns and I think we should
- 47:19honor it in order to make things slightly more comfortable.
- 47:23For an extremely small group of peeps is completely illogical
- 47:26group. They were trying to keep a small
- 47:27possible. Yeah, that's Rising say like
- 47:29very small transgendered people to.
- 47:31They're all just little tiny little tiny, you know.
- 47:34Anyways, what's the harm? Well, why did with the harm?
- 47:38Yes, you may be asking yourself, you know, 300 words into this
- 47:41email, what is the harm or what is the purpose of this email?
- 47:44You will now find out. Well, I believe that whenever
- 47:47One is forced to comply with something that they know is
- 47:49illogical. No matter how kind the intention
- 47:52they will eventually believe anything and do anything even if
- 47:56it's vicious. We're undermining logic and
- 47:58reason which undermines independent thinking Which
- 48:01history has shown always leads to disastrous consequences
- 48:05forcing, majority of peeps to behave.
- 48:07A certain way is the opposite of inclusion.
- 48:10So basically at this point he decides to go like slippery
- 48:12slope with the whole argument and say like if we start
- 48:15announcing people's pronouns in meetings, when it's only a small
- 48:17number Of people, we are bringing about the ruination of
- 48:20civilization. Wow, because never in history,
- 48:24even recent history. Have we asked the majority of
- 48:28people who do not get agree with unchanging social Norm to
- 48:33comply? We've never done.
- 48:36Yeah, I just don't know how to write like interracial marriage.
- 48:42We've never, we've never tried to pave the way for those
- 48:45things, socially through things like Language and legislation.
- 48:50One of my reactions to this, which is very like somewhere in
- 48:54this sort of management space. It just feels like if he has an
- 48:58issue with this and the best lever he has is to reach out to
- 49:02the whole company instead of trying to get his subordinates
- 49:06or whatever in line and saying, this is how we want to handle
- 49:09onboarding. It's sort of a miss, it shows
- 49:12like a lack of a handle over the company and sort of like, hey,
- 49:16wouldn't he want? Does speak to other people
- 49:19before. He sent this email to see if ya
- 49:21ain't nothing. Get your deputies to agree with
- 49:24you or yeah. Yeah.
- 49:26Well, he seems to be pinpointing it on some process and
- 49:28onboarding, which is like an HR function.
- 49:31And yes, it would seem like if you have to have this
- 49:33conversation because it is just fucking killing you, all the
- 49:36illogic that's going on because it's only tiny transgendered,
- 49:39people that should be announcing their pronouns.
- 49:41You could handle this in a smaller group that every single
- 49:44employee at the company, I am personally, very skeptical that
- 49:48this pronouns announcing thing is going to stick in our
- 49:52culture. I am not like going to be one of
- 49:56these people like protesting it, but I just don't, I feel like
- 50:00already the discussion, like, on my Tick, Tock feeds among like
- 50:04progressives is like, is it good to be centering gender?
- 50:08So much in like our introductory conversations and Katie to your
- 50:12point. They like, sure, maybe you're
- 50:15making it easier for people to come out because Ask you, but
- 50:18you're also pressuring people to make a gender statement, like
- 50:22one of the first things they say to everyone.
- 50:24So, I just think even in the world of like just Progressive
- 50:28argumentation, I am not sold on the fact that these gender
- 50:34intros are going to stick and I do think it's reflective of
- 50:37extremely heavy handed HR like progressivism, which is the
- 50:43worst form of progressive culture, like LinkedIn,
- 50:46basically forcing everyone. One to put their gender and
- 50:49their LinkedIn is not an eye-opening thing.
- 50:51It is exactly the sort of like statist force, morality of the
- 50:55left that no one likes and will not win people over.
- 50:59So while I agree that these people protest way too loudly
- 51:02about like gender shit and like who cares about having to see
- 51:06her pronouns but I do think the instincts of it are like I'm not
- 51:11sure it's a winning issue for the left.
- 51:13I mean I don't think that it will stay around forever but not
- 51:16for the reason you've said I mean, Like I think that it's
- 51:18something that's happening now, in order to pave the way for a
- 51:22group of people who do not feel comfortable to feel comfortable
- 51:26and that once they feel more comfortable and we don't need to
- 51:29have this happen. It won't happen.
- 51:32Once people are trained to just like not washing machine.
- 51:36Just like we've all been trained, not to assume that
- 51:37somebody is married to a woman just because I'm a man.
- 51:40So, when I meet a man, I don't say oh, how's your wife?
- 51:43If I see a ring because I don't assume that he's married to a
- 51:46woman. It took a really long time to
- 51:49get there but now we're all trained.
- 51:50And so some of the linguistic things that it took to get
- 51:54there, have also faded away and I will say, you know, as
- 51:57somebody who's friends with now, multiple parents of children,
- 52:02who do not identify with the sex that they were born with.
- 52:05It is really, really painful. I mean, like this is not, this
- 52:09is it's really difficult. And so I think that you're right
- 52:12that we won't always have to send her gender in this way.
- 52:15But that there's a reason why it's happening.
- 52:17You're saying the Miss gendering is painful or the whole extra
- 52:20thing. The whole topic, I think that
- 52:23there's a lot of the topic is inheriting that there's a lot of
- 52:26pain to go around and it goes beyond just simply misgendering
- 52:29and so it's not only to make people who are having questions,
- 52:35other gender or gender non-conforming feel comfortable.
- 52:37It's also it make their families feel comfortable and makes their
- 52:40parents feel like malt. My kid is entering a world, you
- 52:44know? I mean, I think that one of the
- 52:46things that they fear is that their children, I'll be beaten
- 52:48up or harmed I mean I think any so any acknowledgement that kind
- 52:52of seems even if it's your point it doesn't work right?
- 52:56Anything that creates some feeling of like the world.
- 52:59I mean it's always crazy volume because conservatives are like
- 53:03you want to be performative Lee kind to everybody like what's
- 53:07wrong with you. Yeah it is a thing.
- 53:13It's like God. Like, just like I was going to
- 53:19say just like, I think it's good that we don't assume that every
- 53:22woman who walks in wearing a wedding ring is married to a man
- 53:25and that it's totally and that we had to be kind of
- 53:28performative. Lee kind to get Society to that
- 53:32place. We did it's clearly like an
- 53:33awkward part in the like you know movement towards being a
- 53:36more inclusive and Kinder gentler world but actually a lot
- 53:38of the topics that you guys are bringing up come up in the next
- 53:40couple paragraphs. And I really want to bring it
- 53:43up. Oh, there's like 20 more.
- 53:45I was the end. Oh my God.
- 53:46Oh my God, no. No, no, no, right.
- 53:48Have one point the more points you have the more people can be
- 53:51mad about. Right.
- 53:52Okay. So that was that was a slippery.
- 53:54Slope argument. That what we're doing is we're
- 53:56descending into world of a logic and like soon, we'll have like
- 53:58fucking ants wearing hats because it doesn't make sense,
- 54:01you know, for people to announce their gender pronouns.
- 54:02If it's very obvious, what their gender is, okay?
- 54:05Second and by direct one-on-one conversations with a small
- 54:08subset of that, small population of transgender employees.
- 54:11Let me emphasize again. These are very, very small.
- 54:13People. I have found that they don't
- 54:17even need I want all this accommodation.
- 54:19All right. This is this is interesting,
- 54:21they don't and I'm sure I'm assuming if these people exist
- 54:24and he's not making this whole thing up.
- 54:25This is interesting, there is an employee who started as a woman
- 54:29but the transition into a man during transition, he politely
- 54:32came to me and other leaders. And respectfully asked us all to
- 54:34honor their transition by using new pronouns, it was our
- 54:37pleasure to honor that request. He now uses he/him pronouns has
- 54:41used, the men's restrooms has never wanted a gender neutral
- 54:43restroom, and additionally has worked damn hard to earn a new
- 54:46career. His New place in life and most
- 54:48important, I'm sure has achieved peace in his mind.
- 54:51Just providing a place where they could learn a living and do
- 54:54good hard, meaningful work, helped him find inner peace.
- 54:57And in fact, it's happening at MailChimp is a little weird side
- 55:00point, but every company takes this section, I'm not disturbed
- 55:04by, I'm no on the contrary, I think this is his most, this is
- 55:07a most, like, accommodating and like well-intentioned part.
- 55:10Well, it's all supposed to be well, intentioned, but the one
- 55:11that like actually makes the most sense, right?
- 55:13Because it's based on real people, not like your, I think
- 55:15that's what's frustrating about some of these culture.
- 55:17We're issues is like, well, when faced with a real moral decision
- 55:20around a specific person, I feel like I acted morally.
- 55:24And yet I get yelled at, by the HR department, like certainly I
- 55:27think a lot of us are sympathetic to that kind of
- 55:30right point of view, right? So, I don't want to read through
- 55:32this whole paragraph, but you get the point.
- 55:33Basically, the CEO is saying, I've talked to a few transgender
- 55:36employees that we have here and they've all xu4 specifically
- 55:39requested that we don't do this because it's uncomfortable for
- 55:42them and I want to honor that. So it's like, okay, okay,
- 55:44interest well good good, there's a different way to do.
- 55:47This email, I'm seeing it right now, but continue.
- 55:50Yeah, okay, so here's where things.
- 55:51Get very interesting to me. Third, this used to be about
- 55:54fostering, a creative productive, work environment
- 55:57with that intention in mind Dan. And I on Diana's, have always
- 56:01wanted MailChimp to be an inclusive meritocracy a place
- 56:05where no matter your lifestyle gender race, nationality, or
- 56:07economic background, you could be an independent thinker and
- 56:10speak up. Not only would you in feel
- 56:12emboldened to speak up, your fellow peeps would listen and
- 56:15take your customer Centric. Advice it was.
- 56:17The name. Yeah it was all in the name of
- 56:21work but now everything is incredibly politicized.
- 56:24That's probably true lesson. I long for the days when I could
- 56:28have a workplace, it's not completely.
- 56:30Yes, I got that. This is the part where like, you
- 56:33know, his argument is verging. It's uncomfortable territories.
- 56:36But I actually probably agree with right?
- 56:38I am finding that peeps. No longer feel motivated by
- 56:41meaningful work. They are motivated to make
- 56:43political statements that is definitely true.
- 56:46Yes. And now I'm in my arms.
- 56:47I'm sympathetic with a lot of what this guy's saying, so I get
- 56:50to the really difficult part. But yeah, because this is like
- 56:53every but that's always a minority.
- 56:55I mean, it's a because vocal minority who feels motivated by
- 56:58like protest. The most people do just want to
- 57:00clock in and clock out, do your fucking job, right?
- 57:02Like, even if meritocracy is a fucking farce, like it's a
- 57:06necessary fake belief of capitalism like, I'm sorry.
- 57:11Okay. Let me finish up this paragraph
- 57:12because that I want to unpack them or they're using company
- 57:15time and Company resources to win a game.
- 57:17Their opponents in that game, that is Raging in their minds
- 57:20and on social media understandably.
- 57:23So our society is becoming increasingly divided and it
- 57:26feels truly like our social fabric is being torn apart at
- 57:29the seams by radical Politics. On both sides coercing, peeps
- 57:33into proclaiming their pronouns is not about creating an
- 57:35inclusive creative productive work environment, it's about
- 57:38becoming a political statement. The only thing I would have to
- 57:41say to that, by the way is like it's a very brief political
- 57:44statement. You know.
- 57:45Like if you really are all about political statements just do
- 57:47like More land acknowledgements and shit.
- 57:49Like those things take a long time you know, you're spending a
- 57:51lot more time on that one than just saying.
- 57:53Like my name is Tom. He him but but whatever.
- 57:56As righteous as some peeps might think that that is it should all
- 57:59keep singing really does make me really?
- 58:01Really makes it undermines everything hit him.
- 58:05Yeah, yeah. There's really no, there's no
- 58:07coming back from that personally, but hard as
- 58:10righteous as some people might think that this is, they should
- 58:12also consider that there are others in this world.
- 58:14And on the opposite end of the political Spectrum, who feel
- 58:17Righteous about their beliefs understanding and respecting
- 58:20that fundamental concept at grown adults can have different
- 58:22views as a part of being American and part of being a
- 58:25mature, adult peeps of all the different political leanings are
- 58:29free to vote the way that they want to and see our country
- 58:31governed is he basically trying to say that saying, pronouns, is
- 58:35triggering conservatives and the company and making them feel
- 58:40political whenever this comes up, right, right.
- 58:43I don't even need to read any more.
- 58:44You guys get the point of what he's saying here in this
- 58:46paragraph and like there The reason that I liked this, this
- 58:49part of it is because this gets to two things that we talked
- 58:51about a ton on the show, which is that trans issues, which were
- 58:56always talking. Yeah.
- 59:17Environment the fact that I, you know, and you probably see this
- 59:20board, the then we'll certainly more than Eric does a little
- 59:22more than I do Katie but like yeah, thanks a lot with a
- 59:24sizing, his work environment. It's just an employee of watch
- 59:29looking. Yeah, I haven't play now.
- 59:31We're going to start sending these emails out.
- 59:32Eric. Yeah, it's all your shopping
- 59:34with us before you hit. Send dear nukes.
- 59:37You know, is that what you call your employees who are now we
- 59:42do? Yeah.
- 59:45So yeah, I know, it's this idea that like workplace is Is
- 59:47becoming this Battleground for some employees to.
- 59:51Yeah, I agree with the CEO here. Like I do think there are very
- 59:53vocal. I'm sure minorities but people
- 59:56that are trying to you know, and I think minority not because I
- 1:00:01think these issues are important but simply because even if you
- 1:00:05look at like big workplace, I think the Washington Post did a
- 1:00:09great story on this like the Starbucks employees moving to
- 1:00:12unionize. It is a real thing and it's
- 1:00:14really important and I I think that this is a real movement
- 1:00:19that has legs and it's not just something made up at the same
- 1:00:24time. It's clear.
- 1:00:25Even from that story, that many, many people are just clocking in
- 1:00:28because they need money and they're like, really not
- 1:00:31engaging, you know, there's like maybe I'll wake up one day and
- 1:00:34be a unit employee mean Army. Final agonies class presidents
- 1:00:38trying to push right, right. But there's the line between the
- 1:00:41Trader Joe's in the Starbucks employees and what's going on.
- 1:00:43The most of these companies were there all white collar workers.
- 1:00:45And, you know, the ones that are very vocal are trying to, I
- 1:00:49don't know, realized they're policia on college campuses to
- 1:00:52where the students are trying to unionize the employees.
- 1:00:56But it's like, these students are leaving after four years and
- 1:00:58the people who are working in security or her working in
- 1:01:02dining services. They are not leaving after four
- 1:01:05years. So you have it's not a
- 1:01:06professional class, but it's a group of students who feel very
- 1:01:09passionate. And I understand why I'm not
- 1:01:12saying they're wrong. I'm just saying that the
- 1:01:14incentives are very different for these two groups of people
- 1:01:16and people will A and the people who will go, right, but it is
- 1:01:20very distracting inside these companies.
- 1:01:22I mean, every Google now and that company is like, borderline
- 1:01:25paralyzed, like, certain departments that are because of
- 1:01:29the activism and outspokenness by certain people at the
- 1:01:32company. And I'm not saying it's a good
- 1:01:34or bad thing. I'm saying, it's a reality and
- 1:01:36it's also just the result of years.
- 1:01:39And years of all of these companies, telling their
- 1:01:41employees that your personal beliefs should be wrapped up in
- 1:01:43the mission of this company. And that what you stand for is
- 1:01:47what you are. Working on.
- 1:01:48And this was always going to happen.
- 1:01:50In my opinion, there's always gonna be a point where people
- 1:01:52got disillusioned by the mission and felt way my personal
- 1:01:54beliefs. If the only place where I can
- 1:01:56express, my personal beliefs is at the company that I work, then
- 1:01:59I used to spend all of my time making sure that everyone knows
- 1:02:02how I feel because otherwise it doesn't make any sense to me and
- 1:02:05sort of like Elite white-collar left has become very content
- 1:02:10with like statements of solidarity as some like major
- 1:02:14like political Victory instead of staying.
- 1:02:17Oak is done actually like I don't know, material conditions,
- 1:02:21or right, you know, actual political achievements.
- 1:02:24They're like, yeah, I know you don't but get on them.
- 1:02:28No, I'm like if you guys want to be activists in your company's,
- 1:02:31you should be demanding your companies to pay their fucking
- 1:02:33full Freight and corporate taxes, but that's just oh yeah.
- 1:02:36You know, my mom, that's my favorite thing.
- 1:02:39I think anyone has ever said, in this podcast, when you're like
- 1:02:41apple, not enough taxes. The biggest political issue of
- 1:02:45our time. Is for the government to like do
- 1:02:58cool functions, like whatever you're right?
- 1:03:03Because all the Apple employees that, you know, spent months and
- 1:03:05months, complaining about, you know, whatever culture issues,
- 1:03:07they had of the company. I don't think a single one was
- 1:03:09like, why are we incorporated and Ireland?
- 1:03:11Right. Right.
- 1:03:13And why can't we enforce voting rights?
- 1:03:16Like the ones we have on the Looks like why does it take so
- 1:03:19long? Why is her Criminal Justice
- 1:03:20System ground to a halt? Like, why are there not enough
- 1:03:23people to investigate? White-collar crime, why?
- 1:03:25Yeah, yeah. And so, like, you know, the
- 1:03:27whole discussion about gender pronouns on both sides, I mean,
- 1:03:30look, I yeah, you really came into this Tom.
- 1:03:32Like, we were just going to eviscerate this email.
- 1:03:34I actually don't think this podcast is like, so happy to
- 1:03:39eviscerate on the grounds of, like, what a dumb fucking thing
- 1:03:41to write, like he should have actually, he'd said, he
- 1:03:44interviewed people who are Transit his company got another
- 1:03:47Our thoughts and written an email that started.
- 1:03:49I've had really important conversations with members of
- 1:03:53our community and no peeps members our community.
- 1:03:56And I want to know whether or not there is ways to figure out.
- 1:04:01If there's a way to figure out, you know, why we are centering
- 1:04:05gender with the use of pronouns. There is some discomfort coming
- 1:04:08from the very group of people were hoping to make comfortable
- 1:04:11and so what does that mean? Can we discuss it as a community
- 1:04:14and hope with a different plan? And that's also a much shorter
- 1:04:17email. That email can be a communist
- 1:04:18words for paragraphs, for short paragraph, and the takeaway
- 1:04:22should have been there. Something deeply wrong with the
- 1:04:25human resources, professional. We need to, we need to get rid
- 1:04:31of these in the family hired for legal ability to be sure.
- 1:04:35Because because because here's the thing, Katie, if that was
- 1:04:37actually the problem here, he would have sent that email and
- 1:04:40it would have gotten accomplished something that
- 1:04:42would have actually benefited. The very, very small, we have to
- 1:04:45include that number of trans people at If it's like the Lord
- 1:04:49and you're trying to keep it small buddy, right?
- 1:04:51I got a great job that's clearly not.
- 1:04:53What's going on here. He was triggered by the use of
- 1:04:57these. The private use of these words,
- 1:04:58he's like using the small number of trans people at MailChimp to
- 1:05:01hide behind because he's pissed about something which is also
- 1:05:04like oh God I mean just it's so fucked up but like why didn't he
- 1:05:10call us to write this email for him?
- 1:05:11Why didn't he give us a ring? We could have done this.
- 1:05:14Yeah I mean it goes into the sort of Who is politicizing what
- 1:05:19between the left and right, right?
- 1:05:20Like the left is like, I don't know, we're just seeing people's
- 1:05:23pronouns and then we like have a fucking meeting and the right
- 1:05:26obviously, reacts very negatively and then it's sort of
- 1:05:30hard to say which move is the politicization, right?
- 1:05:34Like if his claim is that he's not being political, right?
- 1:05:36He's trying to remove politics from the wolf, but he's
- 1:05:39basically saying that When people have to say pronouns and
- 1:05:43people on the right have to do it there, they're feeling like
- 1:05:46it's a political act and they're basically being forced to sort
- 1:05:51of, you know, go against their principles by doing something
- 1:05:54that they yeah, bristle. At.
- 1:05:56And we've seen different versions of this playing out in
- 1:05:58Tech with like, the CEO of Kraken and like his super based
- 1:06:01work culture where he wanted people to be expressing.
- 1:06:04Only dark web ideas. And if you don't like it, you
- 1:06:06can leave. And you know, the Brian
- 1:06:08Armstrong at coinbase stuff. I mean, it always very tight.
- 1:06:11Yup. It was all very tied up in
- 1:06:13crypto, but like, it is a very real thing that's happening at
- 1:06:15these tech companies and the decision by CEOs to claim we can
- 1:06:19be non-political by sending out emails like this is it
- 1:06:22completely wrong headed, way of doing it.
- 1:06:24Of course it's going to backfire and the MailChimp guy he stepped
- 1:06:27down. Yeah, he's gone.
- 1:06:28He's gone. And we don't know if it was
- 1:06:29because of this but like was it right after, you know, the story
- 1:06:33didn't, which I think was a bit of a shortcoming with the story.
- 1:06:35It didn't really explain why but that, you know, they had gotten
- 1:06:38acquired by into it. I think he actually made quite a
- 1:06:40bit of From that whole transaction.
- 1:06:43He's to do this bullshit. He can have his own.
- 1:06:46Like, he can have all his staff. He can do whatever he wants.
- 1:06:49Never tell them their gender if you want some.
- 1:06:51Yeah. Hey Candace.
- 1:06:52Have no staff. He's like, I'm moving to a model
- 1:06:55where I had no staff. No people who messy.
- 1:06:58No HR department's. I mean people stepping down and
- 1:07:03like overreacting to employee revolts is another part of the,
- 1:07:07I mean, I think that sort of calm down somewhat.
- 1:07:09Like, I would be interested to know Now, if you was really
- 1:07:12ousted over the street, I wouldn't make sense.
- 1:07:14I mean, the email was, I can't imagine why anyone should be
- 1:07:19fired over this. Although does to Eric's earlier
- 1:07:22Point indicate that he's a bad manager and so I wouldn't be
- 1:07:26shocked if you scratch the surface beyond, the email will
- 1:07:30find stuff that right kind of weird.
- 1:07:32Right. Clearly don't.
- 1:07:32Let's go advice go to your Executives and say, are we
- 1:07:35aligned with this is like out of control?
- 1:07:37I'm sure most of them would be like, listen, we're trying to
- 1:07:40meet our Sales quota in. This is not like you driving
- 1:07:45decision, like, who cares? Like, we're going so fast
- 1:07:48please. Right.
- 1:07:49Exactly. But he's like, but he's trying
- 1:07:53to say here, you know that, like, all of the pronoun
- 1:07:55discussion is distracting us from a real fulfilling work of
- 1:07:58running MailChimp and like, he's just like, I got a way to fix
- 1:08:01it. We're not getting our numbers.
- 1:08:03You actually may be the bigger issue.
- 1:08:05Is, you're only offering people MailChimp in the same way that,
- 1:08:08you know, like the fed, you know, the only thing they can do
- 1:08:10to control. Roll inflation, is by raising
- 1:08:12interest rates. He's like the only thing it can
- 1:08:14do to increase. Productivity is sending 2,000
- 1:08:16were emails. Eviscerating, our pronoun policy
- 1:08:20and he's like that's it for the only trick.
- 1:08:21I got my bad focus. Our company more than a divisive
- 1:08:26email from. I remember Habsburg seen
- 1:08:29companies really cook together, running around the shitty mess
- 1:08:32of your boss is evil. They would say something is
- 1:08:35saying, I would spend half the day being like what the fuck
- 1:08:38does this mean? And everybody would like just
- 1:08:39ignore it like who cares? Is like those emails of the most
- 1:08:43distressed. There's like, why am I worrying
- 1:08:45for overlords? That are so out of touch with
- 1:08:47like the core product that we deliver?
- 1:08:50I mean talk about like the use cases for AI.
- 1:08:53How could there not be like a super Advanced clippy on all
- 1:08:56boss emails that says like, it seems like you're writing a very
- 1:08:59ill conceived. Email about what pronouns there
- 1:09:01were employees. Are you sure you want to send it
- 1:09:05this exists? Did you not see this?
- 1:09:06I saw it on Twitter. Somebody ran this email through
- 1:09:09some like I don't know. I woke censorship app and it was
- 1:09:13gave this like a 0%. Like we're 14 just like a lot.
- 1:09:18Like a common sense out of anything like this is it's a
- 1:09:24little weird that software exists to be.
- 1:09:26Like this is what I'm saying is, was that indeed the software, or
- 1:09:30was it just like, I don't know, I was so we don't we don't know
- 1:09:34what this software was, but yeah, there's not much more to
- 1:09:38say about this than like, you know, Ears up for everyone at
- 1:09:42MailChimp. One thing that I'm interested to
- 1:09:44talk about that. I don't think we should get into
- 1:09:47this episode, but I do want to sort of just plant.
- 1:09:49The seed is getting to a point where our political debates we
- 1:09:52can, like, shrug our shoulders on some of the more we've
- 1:09:55basically gotten into a political culture where we've
- 1:09:59tried to like amplify the importance of every political
- 1:10:02issue. And So then whenever there's
- 1:10:04disagreement and feels like a real, I don't know, right?
- 1:10:08Severing point and There aren't these issues where it's like,
- 1:10:13people just say to each other. Yeah, I disagree with you.
- 1:10:16I don't care about this issue that much, you know, you would
- 1:10:18be seen as like, obviously like a bigot or anti-trans to say,
- 1:10:22like, this is below my line like Chemung.
- 1:10:25I mean term off basically saying there's like a hierarchy of
- 1:10:28political views he cares about and one was was low.
- 1:10:31I mean people went ballistic, you ultimately survived, but
- 1:10:34there does have to be a true ranking of issues.
- 1:10:38You're willing to like put your whole life.
- 1:10:41My own and I think it can be different for everyone like you
- 1:10:44can get in trouble for not prioritizing.
- 1:10:46I mean, I think that I think what your mouth got in trouble
- 1:10:49for was coming across as an excessive dick?
- 1:10:51I mean, I think and I think I was criticism and I think that
- 1:10:54most people prioritize social issues that are swirling around
- 1:10:59us based on what's important and pertinent to their lives.
- 1:11:01I don't think that they may be like, staggering them and write
- 1:11:04a blog post about it, like he might, but I think if you are,
- 1:11:09for example, I mean, The way I grew up, you know, growing up in
- 1:11:13the 80s and 90s with not very much money in a dying
- 1:11:17blue-collar town. You know, there were a lot of
- 1:11:20social issues happening at that time, but the ones that were
- 1:11:22most important for like, the people I knew were economic
- 1:11:25issues. One like there was obviously a
- 1:11:28lot happening with gay rights like it was the 80s and 90s.
- 1:11:31There were people being beaten to death and that was for some
- 1:11:35people a lower priority issue because we didn't know anyone
- 1:11:37who was gay or for people who are closeted in my town.
- 1:11:41That was the highest priority issue.
- 1:11:43I think that's fine. That's totally fine.
- 1:11:45And I don't think that we should ever have to declare what our
- 1:11:48high priority is. She was and why and defend that
- 1:11:51like that makes literally no sense to me.
- 1:11:54Well there's also no way back to this email that like for the CEO
- 1:11:58in the people that were annoyed for whatever reason by having to
- 1:12:00say their gender pronouns. That it was a high priority
- 1:12:03issue for them. It's like you're using
- 1:12:05MailChimp. Your highest priority issue.
- 1:12:07Dude, should be like, why do people use this product that?
- 1:12:11Like has the most dumb-looking user interface ever.
- 1:12:14Like I feel like I'm in kindergarten when I use it but
- 1:12:16like nobody really likes but you know it's like maybe that's your
- 1:12:20high priority that you're getting your business and being
- 1:12:23stolen by, you know, sub stack. I would just other and look,
- 1:12:27maybe the CEO had no ability to answer those questions and so
- 1:12:30for him he felt like he will like the battle that I can.
- 1:12:32I be waged as for what about gender prove, that that would be
- 1:12:35a great. I would love the case to be the
- 1:12:37guys like fuck. Like I have no vision for This
- 1:12:41product just naturally like this, right?
- 1:12:44It's like the Republicans basically decided like our
- 1:12:46vision is completely popular solution.
- 1:12:49We fight about some other shit. Like that's that's so if that's
- 1:12:55the truth here, that is some like 11 degrees of Chess, I
- 1:13:00would love that that I would love to see.
- 1:13:02Oh, this guy that was just like the board comes, never like all
- 1:13:06right. What's the 12 year?
- 1:13:08Plan to tell people that it's like Welsh or worse?
- 1:13:11Basically all we have left are internal culture wars that we
- 1:13:14adjudicate / /. Yeah.
- 1:13:16And you know, hopefully I can bring up some name recognition
- 1:13:19because these emails will leak and you know people remember
- 1:13:22MailChimp because the last thing I thought about was when they
- 1:13:24advertised on cereal and for those people who love parlor,
- 1:13:28they will use MailChimp over the based emailing platform and I
- 1:13:33don't know you. I think you might be a writer, I
- 1:13:36think there are some multiple layers at this guy strategy
- 1:13:38because aside from that it seems thin broth.
- 1:13:41Anyway, we went there. All right, this was fun.
- 1:13:43All right, fine. Thanks Gary.
- 1:13:45Thanks goodbye, goodbye.
- 1:13:59Goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye goodbye.
- 1:14:02Goodbye.