Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E076: Bitcoin Enables Ethical Finance with Harris Irfan
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous extra
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of gutless 1974198792972000.
- 0:17And whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same
- 0:20thing over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we. Sell, I say, when we sell.
- 0:33All right everyone, welcome back to the last trade.
- 0:35This week we have my Co host Michael Tanguma and Brian Cabela
- 0:39and we are joined by Harris or Fond Harris.
- 0:42Great to have you on the show. We were just chatting before we
- 0:45hit record here. We we feel like we've known each
- 0:47other for a while, but it's actually our first time we're
- 0:50conversing. But of course, I've been
- 0:51following the work you are doing with Ralph and the MENA region.
- 0:55But thanks for coming on. How are you doing, Harris?
- 0:58Great. Thank you.
- 0:58Thanks for having me, Jackson. Excellent.
- 1:02Well, we could get right into it.
- 1:04Harris, like I said, I've, I've heard you on plenty of other
- 1:07shows, but really excited for you to come on to the last
- 1:10trade. I think you'll be bringing a lot
- 1:13of fresh and new perspectives to a lot of our audience.
- 1:16So maybe if the best place for us to start would just be to
- 1:19give some insights and overview into your background in
- 1:23traditional finance, Islamic finance, how how's your career
- 1:28progressed over the decades and what do you find yourself
- 1:31working on these days? OK, sure.
- 1:34Well I'm an investment banker by training.
- 1:37I started out in a small British merchant bank in the early and
- 1:40the mid 90s. I used to be a management
- 1:44consultant or I used to trainee before that straight out of
- 1:46university and I worked in an area called project finance.
- 1:51So project finance is the financing of infrastructure,
- 1:55roads, railways, hospitals, schools.
- 1:56And I felt that it was a somewhat more noble endeavour in
- 2:01the City of London than a lot of the other stuff that investment
- 2:04bankers do. And you know, for a while that
- 2:08was, that was my field. We worked in a lot of the what
- 2:11we call public private partnerships or PFI in the UK,
- 2:15the private finance initiative. This was the, the Tony Blair's
- 2:19government introducing semi privatizations to infrastructure
- 2:24in the UK, which then was rolled out across the world.
- 2:27And I moved to Deutsche doing the same work in the in about
- 2:3198. So I was with Deutsche for 11
- 2:33years. They moved me to Dubai.
- 2:35We opened a new office in Dubai in 2001.
- 2:38And I was just fortunate that around the time that I arrived
- 2:42in Dubai, they'd started up a a new financial center called
- 2:46DIFC, which is the Dubai International Financial Center.
- 2:50And I guess I was just in the right place at the right time.
- 2:53So I arrived in the region with the remit of originating
- 2:57Deutsche Bank's corporate finance business in the region,
- 3:01which is quite exciting for somebody who was really a junior
- 3:03to mid ranking banker. And, and actually when I
- 3:08arrived, a lot of clients said, can you do these deals on a
- 3:12Sharia compliant basis? Now we didn't really know
- 3:15anything about Islamic finance. It's just something I sort of
- 3:18vaguely read about, but I Co founded the Islamic finance team
- 3:22at Deutsche and it turned out that Deutsche was almost the
- 3:26perfect place to found a team that did Islamic finance.
- 3:30Because up until that point Islamic finance had been a sort
- 3:33of very parochial backwater, like very sleepy, very stagnant.
- 3:39It had originally been established in the early 60s in
- 3:42an experiment in Egypt and that graduated into a, a commercial,
- 3:48you know, commercial banks being launched in Dubai and in Saudi
- 3:51in the mid 70s. And then the Malaysians kind of
- 3:54took up the baton in the 80s. But it's sort of had been very
- 3:58restricted financial products coming out of the Islamic
- 4:01finance space where, you know, not very exciting, didn't really
- 4:06cover a range of different asset classes and structures.
- 4:10So here we were, this sort of what was at the time of very
- 4:12entrepreneurial investment bank really, you know, snapping at
- 4:18the heels of the big American banks, the Goldmans and the
- 4:21Morgan Stanley's and the JP Morgan's and Deutsche Bank was,
- 4:25was in a, in a sense, a more entrepreneurial place than the
- 4:30rest of Wall Street and the City of London.
- 4:32And we decided that we would take our best brains from places
- 4:37like our equity derivative structuring team and get them to
- 4:41solve the new puzzles in the Islamic finance space.
- 4:45So Islamic finance has never previously had structured
- 4:48investment products or hedging and treasury management
- 4:51platforms or a big leverage buyouts or acquisition finance
- 4:58through sukuk for Islamic bonds. These were brand new concepts
- 5:01and we essentially invented every single one of those
- 5:04concepts in the early 2000s. So there was a seismic shift.
- 5:08It was almost you could call it Islamic finance, 2 point nought.
- 5:11When this newcomer comes along in the Middle East, sets up an
- 5:14office in DIFC and starts to attract the world's top scholars
- 5:18to advise us. We had somebody that we called
- 5:22that was known as the grandfather of Islamic finance.
- 5:25It was a gentleman called Sheikh Hussain Hamid Hassan, a
- 5:28theologian and comparative lawyer and an expert on
- 5:32contemporary finance. And it was that kind of
- 5:35individual who helped to shape an architect the financial
- 5:39products that were being put out for the first time.
- 5:42And he liked working with us, right?
- 5:44It's the first time that he had come across these sort of
- 5:47Western educated, quite dynamic investment bankers.
- 5:50He'd been used to these sleepier parochial domestic institutions.
- 5:56And there's never any pushback really.
- 5:58And we pushed back in a very respectful way.
- 6:01So we would say, hey, what is it possible to do, you know, a
- 6:04structured investment product that works like this?
- 6:07And if you'd asked that question of the what they call the Sharia
- 6:11coordination departments of the Islamic banks in the Middle East
- 6:14up to that point, you know, these are gatekeepers to the
- 6:17scholars. And their standard response
- 6:18would be doctor says no, right? They don't bother to tell you,
- 6:22OK, we can we actually, we can figure out a way to make these
- 6:24products work. But for the first time, we were
- 6:27speaking direct 1 to one with the scholars and we were saying,
- 6:30OK, we know that you can't do this traditionally, but what if
- 6:33we tried a different contractual structure?
- 6:35What if we tried to solve this puzzle and look at it in a
- 6:38different way? Remember, you know, derivative
- 6:39structuring teams in in bulge bracket investment banks are
- 6:42basically mathematicians and physicists.
- 6:44They solve complex puzzles for a living.
- 6:47They are paid for their cleverness.
- 6:49So here we were with a new set of rules.
- 6:52This time, not only is it tax and commercial and legal and
- 6:56other things, but this time we're overlaying Sharia
- 6:59parameters. So there is a body of
- 7:01jurisprudence in Sharia law, which is which deals with
- 7:05commercial and financial law. And how do we implement those
- 7:10principles into a financial product.
- 7:12And we're just taking a set of rules.
- 7:15And it's a puzzle. We're solving that puzzle.
- 7:18So this was the first time the financial services industry had
- 7:21taken this approach to Islamic finance.
- 7:24And the net result was we essentially reinvented the
- 7:27industry and it took off. So that's really my introduction
- 7:31to Islamic finance and and I guess the story moves on a
- 7:33little bit. I left Deutsche in 2008 and did
- 7:37a few other things after that. That's excellent.
- 7:40Harris. You know, one thing that stuck
- 7:42out to me in that journey that you took us through for Islamic
- 7:44finance from you mentioned the 60s to really present is that
- 7:48you described it as an experiment early on.
- 7:51And I can't help but see that there's a lot of parallels with
- 7:53how Bitcoin has, I guess, traversed the past decade and a
- 7:59half from an experiment or this idea that was shared on a
- 8:03mailing list in 2008 to going live in 2009.
- 8:06And over the course now, 15, nearly 16 years of being live,
- 8:10things have changed quite dramatically.
- 8:13We've gone from an asset or a technology that doesn't have a
- 8:16market price to something that is now trading nearly $2
- 8:20trillion market cap. And I'm sure we'll get into, but
- 8:23we think that it will go much further than that.
- 8:25So quite interesting to hear your background as it relates to
- 8:28just being on the earlier side and really bringing all the
- 8:32sophistication of what you mentioned, Deutsche Bank and
- 8:35investment banking from London into the Middle East and
- 8:38aligning with the Sharia principles and helping to really
- 8:41pioneer this new form of finance.
- 8:44Are you ready to secure your future with Bitcoin?
- 8:47At Onramp, we're revolutionizing how you can save for retirement.
- 8:51Onramp has just launched the industry's first Bitcoin IRA
- 8:53product with multi institution custody, designed to give you
- 8:57unparalleled security, transparency, and Peace of Mind.
- 9:00With Onramp, you can verify your assets on chain and protect them
- 9:04with the support of three independent institutions,
- 9:06reducing risks and enhancing security.
- 9:09At Onramp, we believe that Bitcoin is the most important
- 9:12asset of the 21st century. The hard part is securing it,
- 9:15right. There are shortcomings with
- 9:17keeping your coins on an exchange, but also with setting
- 9:20up your own self custody arrangement.
- 9:22Onramp solves for these concerns.
- 9:24Our multi institution custody solution maximizes security and
- 9:27minimizes counterparty risk, ensuring that your Bitcoin
- 9:30remains securely in your possession and provides built in
- 9:33inheritance planning to ensure your family is protected as
- 9:36well. On Ramp provides Peace of Mind
- 9:39for your Bitcoin journey, whether for your whole stack or
- 9:41for part of it as a complement to your existing self custody
- 9:44setup. For more information about our
- 9:46services as well as our new Bitcoin IRA product, check us
- 9:50out at on rampbitcoin.com. So I think there's a couple
- 9:55dynamics that we'll get into later in the show.
- 9:57But Harris, something you mentioned about the existing
- 10:01financial partners that were in the Middle East used to saying
- 10:04no and finding this healthy friction between the West and
- 10:08the innovation in the Middle East, I think is something that
- 10:11there's a conservative nature in the Middle East.
- 10:13And then there's the natural innovation happens to the West
- 10:15that we're starting to see that, you know, balance or that
- 10:18dynamic start to intertwine more as we have like a global asset.
- 10:23But then there's something else that you referenced that
- 10:26following your work that really resonated early was this notion
- 10:30when somebody rocks or gets Bitcoin, they start to think
- 10:32about, you know, from first principles, other parts of the
- 10:35market and realizing that the foundation might have been shaky
- 10:39across the board. It wasn't just in the money.
- 10:41And so when the hearing you speak about Islamic finance and
- 10:44some of the things that maybe kind of got, you know, changed
- 10:47or manipulated, it made complete sense because I gravitated all
- 10:52the way to like Austrian economics in the sense of like
- 10:54Islamic finance and Austrian economics.
- 10:56They have these, like connotations when somebody hears
- 10:58them and they think of this like, it's almost like a
- 11:01pejorative in a roundabout way. He's like, oh, this like fringe
- 11:04versus like Islamic finance. And I think you like to use
- 11:06ethical finance, finance and Austrian economics is like, just
- 11:10like practical economics. It's just first principles,
- 11:12obvious thinking. And so just curious maybe to, to
- 11:16add a little bit of light of like, what is the, you know,
- 11:19Sharia compliant and ethical finance around?
- 11:22Like, you know, Reba and usury are really easy examples of
- 11:25maybe there's a, there's way to align incentives that do not,
- 11:29you know, put the, the person that is the participating in, in
- 11:33a secondary position, but in, in put together.
- 11:36Because I think in the West, that's something that's been
- 11:39missing. And most people don't even know
- 11:40that there's any way to construct in a financial or
- 11:43participate in a financial construct without effectively
- 11:46being on the other side of it and having, you know, a long
- 11:48term obligation by the way of debt.
- 11:50Yeah, I think Jackson picks up on something interesting there,
- 11:55this word experiment. I would contend that this
- 11:59experiment started with good intentions back in 1963 and the
- 12:04specific experiment is something called a Mid Gomer experiment.
- 12:07Mid Gomer is a town about 80 kilometers from Cairo and a very
- 12:10famous economist set up what is essentially a social Savings
- 12:15Bank, a deposit institution. It takes deposits from local
- 12:18people and that money is invested in local industry and
- 12:22then the profits from that local industry is shared with
- 12:25depositors. So it's a very simple investment
- 12:27management relationship and that's the essence of the
- 12:31Islamic Economic model. It is risk sharing and it is
- 12:34real economy that's going to have some real activity taking
- 12:37place. So this modern concept of
- 12:39financialization is anathema to Islamic finance.
- 12:43It it, it just doesn't gel. So creating Islamic financial
- 12:47institutions today and Islamic banks based on fractional
- 12:50reserve banking, which of course is money creation, that's
- 12:53absolutely not within the boundaries of the Islamic
- 12:56Economic model. So as much as I think there has
- 12:59been much progress in the Islamic finance industry over
- 13:02the years, not all of it has been positive.
- 13:06So we talked about this idea of an experiment that maybe didn't
- 13:09hold true to its ideals. It's kind of moved away from
- 13:13that. And we can we can analogize that
- 13:16maybe to Bitcoin. We have this experiment where
- 13:18we're talking about sound money, low time preference, you know,
- 13:23resistance money, freedom money. We use these concepts as
- 13:25bitcoiners, as maximalists. And then we see what's happening
- 13:29right now. We look at Bitcoin ETFs and, you
- 13:32know, black rocks getting involved and governments are
- 13:34talking about, hey, you know, maybe the digital currency is
- 13:37not a bad thing. Why don't we try CBD CS and, and
- 13:40does that experiment hold true to its original ideals or does
- 13:44it end up becoming distorted? My contention with the Islamic
- 13:46finance industry is unfortunately, it has become
- 13:49distorted. We've ended up with these ideals
- 13:52that talked about this investment management
- 13:54relationship with depositors, put their money in and they take
- 13:57real risk on real industry, the real economy.
- 14:00And what we have now is Islamic banks, which are frankly
- 14:05regulated by central banks just like a a conventional,
- 14:09traditional financial institution.
- 14:12And they have the power to create money from nothing.
- 14:15Well, if you have the power to create money from nothing, then
- 14:18money on money or money from zero is itself a definition of
- 14:24riba. The word riba in Arabic is is is
- 14:28a word that means surplus or excess.
- 14:31It doesn't just mean interest. It's actually any transaction
- 14:35from which money can be created from nothing or from money
- 14:40itself without there being any real underlying activity or
- 14:43trade taking place. So the scriptures in Islam are
- 14:47very clear on this. Trade is halal, it's religiously
- 14:50permissible, whereas riba usually interest, creating money
- 14:54from nothing is forbidden. And I think one of the
- 14:59difficulties we have in the Islamic finance industry is
- 15:01we've ended up with these Islamic banks that are regulated
- 15:05by central banks who have a duty to the whole financial services
- 15:09industry. And in order to level the
- 15:11playing field, they've decided let's just treat them exactly
- 15:14like banks. So we give them the license to
- 15:16create money every time a credit transaction takes place, every
- 15:20time you lend money, whatever, whatever fancy sounding
- 15:25contracts you overlay on top of it.
- 15:27And we use fancy Arabic words like Musharraf, al mudara by
- 15:30Stisna and so on. And we we analogize them to
- 15:34things like lease structures or investment sharing structures or
- 15:37partnership structures. But underneath all of this, you
- 15:40have an institution that has the right to create money from
- 15:44nothing. New digits appear in your bank
- 15:46account. How did that happen?
- 15:48You created money from nothing. So fundamentally, there is a
- 15:50disconnect. And I would like to see the
- 15:54Islamic finance industry return to those pure principles that
- 15:58were espoused back in 1963 in the Mitt Gomer experiment.
- 16:02I believe it's possible a lot of bankers will disagree.
- 16:06There's a controversy in the industry right now.
- 16:08There is a standard setting body in the industry, a global body
- 16:12called AAOFI AAOIFI. It's an organization that that
- 16:16sets the commercial parameters, the legal and Sharia parameters
- 16:20for certain for all financial products in the Islamic finance
- 16:23space. And they just introduced or
- 16:25about to introduce a new standard called standard #62.
- 16:29Now AAOFI standard #62 says that all Sukuk meaning Islamic bonds
- 16:35should henceforth be issued on a real economy risk sharing basis
- 16:41in which there is asset transfer or ownership.
- 16:44This by the way is a a grenade being thrown into the the
- 16:49bankers trading floor, right? Because currently the sukuk, the
- 16:54Islamic bonds that they issue for companies are essentially
- 16:59bond like they have a purchase undertaking which says that the
- 17:02company issuing this, this bond, this sukuk will purchase back
- 17:07that bond or secure at maturity at par value.
- 17:11So in fact, the risk is the credit risk of the obligor.
- 17:14It's not a risk of some underlying trade activity taking
- 17:17place. No matter what these fancy
- 17:19documents say underneath. Usually they'll do something
- 17:21like they'll, they'll securitize or they'll, they'll wrap a, a
- 17:24property owned by the company into the SPV that issues the
- 17:27bond. And they say the rent coming
- 17:32from that property is the coupon being paid to the suku holders.
- 17:35But the reality is you've got a purchase undertaking, you've got
- 17:38the credit risk of the obligor. So how is it different from a
- 17:41bond? And of course, if you tell the
- 17:42bankers guys you can't do this anymore, you have to have a real
- 17:45economy trade underpinning that sukuk in accordance with this
- 17:49new standard #62 it blows their mind, right?
- 17:52It, it melts their minds. They, they simply can't
- 17:54comprehend how you can have a non debt financial instrument.
- 17:58And I think it's this, it's this sort of received wisdom that the
- 18:01world has to run on financialization, on this idea
- 18:05that debt must proliferate throughout society, throughout
- 18:08the world, that we must all become economically dependent on
- 18:12this institution that we call a bank.
- 18:15It's a master slave relationship.
- 18:16It's completely asymmetric. And that's the problem that that
- 18:20banks have, that bankers have and that's why they can't move
- 18:23away from these concepts of the current types of secoup that
- 18:26they have. I'm very keen, yeah, that to
- 18:28return economic finance to its go ahead.
- 18:31Yeah, that's very well put. It's it's something Brian and I
- 18:34were just talking about these concepts to somebody that
- 18:37understands a Bitcoin. There are like a Rosh art, a
- 18:39Rorschach test, like in you think about multi institution
- 18:42early writers. And what you just described is
- 18:44there is no question it has to go there with a sound money
- 18:47standard because of this came up last week in conversations
- 18:51around, well, what's the cost of capital?
- 18:53And when it's the money sound, it's like, well, the cost of,
- 18:55you know, GDP growth plus something because if you're
- 18:57going to move the asset, right, the deflationary nature of the
- 19:01asset and your reference point to master slave relationship to
- 19:06to bring it. So something tangible,
- 19:09especially here in the United States, but I think this is in
- 19:11most Western countries is I think of college education.
- 19:15They print money out of thin air.
- 19:17It's in negative incentive alignment because you assume you
- 19:20have to go there. You basically have shackles post
- 19:22leaving from from a thing that gives you effectively haven't
- 19:27gotten anything. If everyone gets the same
- 19:28degree, but now you have to go to that job, you have 150,000 to
- 19:32$200,000 debt. The the actual product is bad
- 19:36because the alignment isn't there versus if there was an
- 19:38actual public, private or private partnership and you have
- 19:41some kind of profit sharing or there's a new term that's been
- 19:45coming up the past decade. I think it's called income
- 19:47sharing agreement where like how good you educate and where you
- 19:51go, then you benefit. So there's all these different
- 19:53ways that you can construct this existing system, but we just
- 19:57haven't had the incentive. And we all know the negative
- 19:59alignment post college, the depression, all the things
- 20:03people do working at Starbucks with their degrees and all the
- 20:05long like standing manifestations that this have.
- 20:08This is a very small micro example, but again going back.
- 20:10It's not necessarily just Islamic finance, this is just
- 20:13ethical finance and doing things in a way that aligns incentives
- 20:16for everyone. Yeah, I don't even think it's a
- 20:18micro example. I I think it's, it's probably
- 20:20the most egregious example of that master slave relationship.
- 20:24You know, student debt is I, I, I find it a fascinating subject
- 20:27and I, I don't know why it's being called, it's not being
- 20:29called out by more people. And you take a young person at
- 20:33the start of their career, you load them up with a hundred
- 20:35$200,000 worth of debt, which they probably have to pay off
- 20:39for a great proportion of their working lives.
- 20:43It's, it's astonishing to me that we've created an industry
- 20:47in which education is just corporatized.
- 20:50You know, it's, it's run by private equity firms and you'll
- 20:53sell all manner of terrible university courses.
- 20:56I don't know what value they have just so that university can
- 20:59make more and more money. And at the end of it, you saddle
- 21:02these students who have been incentivized, they've been
- 21:05persuaded to take on these, you know, third rate degrees at
- 21:09universities that wouldn't previously have been considered
- 21:11universities. At least that's, that's a
- 21:13position. That's, that's something that's
- 21:14happened in the UK over the last 20-30 years.
- 21:17You know, and I've got these, in my opinion, fairly worthless
- 21:20pieces of paper in their hand and they're saddled with a huge
- 21:22amount of debt. I think that is a, that's a
- 21:25tremendous, you know, evil that's been perpetrated on
- 21:30society to, to saddle people with so much debt.
- 21:33It's just not necessary. We don't need to have that debt
- 21:36in society. And the reason why inflation and
- 21:38the reason why inflation exists is because we have to pay off
- 21:42our debt. We've got more and more of it to
- 21:44pay off. So now you have two in my
- 21:46parents day, you know, 1 member of the household would, would,
- 21:49would bring in the, the salary, right?
- 21:51That was enough for everybody's needs.
- 21:53Now at the very least, households have at least two
- 21:56breadwinners in order to just bake, meet their basic needs.
- 22:00You know, society has fundamentally changed and that
- 22:02is a direct consequence of inflation caused by money
- 22:07supply, caused by the de pegging of the dollar since 1971.
- 22:12These are all knock on effects. Any system that we can find that
- 22:15reverts us back to a fixed supply of money, something that
- 22:20is sound money, something that is scarce, something that is
- 22:22finite, something that is fungible, something that cannot
- 22:25be manipulated by a small group of people, that's something we
- 22:28have to return to if society is going to return to those
- 22:31wholesome values that we had. Absolutely.
- 22:36All really good points One thing I wanted to mention going back
- 22:40to the analogy being made between sort of these these two
- 22:45experiments, right, whether it's Islamic finance or or Bitcoin
- 22:49itself. I think there's another sort of
- 22:51element of that analogy that we can pull on where, you know, if
- 22:55you look at all of the crypto assets that are proliferated
- 22:59post Bitcoin, right? Like those are effectively, you
- 23:04know, an extension of the original idea, but then losing
- 23:08the principles, right? Losing those initial sound
- 23:11money, proof of work principles wherein anyone can spin up a new
- 23:16currency, if you will. And so I, I would liken that to
- 23:20some of what you described in terms of, you know, adding
- 23:23complexity to these things so that you sort of skirt around
- 23:26the rules in some way. So just wanted to pull on that
- 23:30thread of like, you know, the analogy is, is certainly
- 23:33meaningful in that sense. I'm curious, Harris, in your
- 23:36view, like, you know, or I guess first, you know, when did you
- 23:42come to Bitcoin in this journey of studying Islamic finance?
- 23:45And and I guess when did it begin to click for you that
- 23:48maybe this is this is a roundabout way to sort of
- 23:52reinfor reinforce those initial principles with a with a sound
- 23:56money? Yeah.
- 23:59So in 2014, I published a book called Heaven's Bankers, which
- 24:04was essentially a a description of what had happened in the
- 24:10Islamic finance industry in the previous sort of 15 years or so.
- 24:14And my intention was to show readers and, and this was not a
- 24:19for necessary for finance specialists.
- 24:22It was a a book intended for the layman.
- 24:24It was to show readers, you know, this is an industry that
- 24:27has been born fairly recently. Its intentions were good at one
- 24:32point and it's been somewhat distorted over time.
- 24:36And, you know, once I'd published that book, I, I
- 24:38started delivering lectures on the subject.
- 24:40And I think I was delivering a lecture in 2017 and somebody in
- 24:45the audience said it just the QAQA session.
- 24:49They stuck their hand up and they said, what do you think of
- 24:50Bitcoin? And I, I didn't know anything
- 24:53about Bitcoin. I, I just thought it was some
- 24:55kind of magic Internet money. And I said, look, you're going
- 24:59to have to explain it to me. How does it work?
- 25:00What does it do? And he explained it to me, you
- 25:02know, he, he, he went through all those usual baby steps that
- 25:05we all go through at the beginning.
- 25:06And he explained how it's, it's decentralized, it's scarce, it's
- 25:10finite, it cannot be manipulated.
- 25:14You know, it's fungible, etcetera, etcetera.
- 25:17And very importantly, it's saleable across space and time.
- 25:20And the more I listen to this guy, I was thinking to myself,
- 25:24he's describing gold, or at least some modern form of gold
- 25:28to me. And you know, as somebody who
- 25:31recognizes the benefits of having 700 years of a, an
- 25:36Islamic gold dinar, which was the standard of the Islamic
- 25:40empire for 700 years, that led to fluid friction free trade
- 25:46across nations, across continents, even into Southern
- 25:50Europe. You had traders coming down the
- 25:52silk route from China through Persia, through Arabia into
- 25:56Southern Europe. And a, a frictionless trade
- 26:00where you set up money changers and invented new concepts like
- 26:04checks. The word check comes from the
- 26:06Arabic word sack from which we get the plural sukkuk meaning
- 26:09Islamic bond. So you know, there's many of
- 26:12these concepts that filtered their way into Europe.
- 26:14And you know, we've we've got this history of a sound money
- 26:20using the gold dinar and that's something I always believed in,
- 26:24but it's not implementable today because it's impractical.
- 26:26It requires a trusted intermediary and 8000 tons of it
- 26:30had held in one place in the US and etcetera, etcetera.
- 26:33So there's reasons why gold is not a very good sound currency
- 26:36today. This guy's describing something
- 26:39that seems to solve all these problems.
- 26:42So I'm like, OK, you know what? What you had just explained to
- 26:46me and that this is an orange pill moment, right?
- 26:48What you just explained to me, it's kind of mind blowing.
- 26:51I'm going to have to go away and verify what you've said is true
- 26:54because it sounds too good to be true.
- 26:56And I did. And we all put in our, you know,
- 26:58100 hours or thousand hours or whatever it is that we spend
- 27:01studying the subject. And during the course of 2017, I
- 27:05realized that this really is something that is not just not
- 27:11just it's, it's more than just a form of money.
- 27:13Actually, it's something that encourages low time preference
- 27:17in society and moves us all towards a more healthy
- 27:21relationship with our fellow human beings.
- 27:24And that's that's really the true value add of this
- 27:28particular concept. It's more than about making
- 27:30money. It's more than about AI got into
- 27:32Bitcoin in 2017. So I'm going to be rich.
- 27:34Whoopee. That's not the point here.
- 27:36And people always and I'm sure they ask you guys, yeah.
- 27:38What do you think about where's the price of Bitcoin going to go
- 27:40next year? I don't know.
- 27:41I don't care. You know, I believe in the
- 27:43concept. I believe in the ideal because
- 27:46it's low time preference, because I believe that it's a
- 27:49form of money that the profit peace be upon him would himself
- 27:53have sanctioned because it has all the characteristics of sound
- 27:57money. And we have many instances in
- 28:00our scriptures that talk about gold as a form of money and
- 28:03people misinterpret that. They they think that just
- 28:06because gold has been mentioned in, for example, the Quran, that
- 28:10it is the only form of sound money.
- 28:11No, the characteristics of it have been mentioned in
- 28:14traditions of the prophet and his sayings and they've been
- 28:18mentioned in the Quran because that's a form of money that is
- 28:21good for society. So if we find a modern form of
- 28:24that, there's no reason why we cannot adopt that and still be
- 28:27Sharia compliant. So you might sometimes see
- 28:29people saying, oh, the Bitcoin is Haram, it's religiously
- 28:32impermissible, it's been forbidden by the scholars
- 28:34because of and then the usual FUD, you know, they talk about
- 28:37government hasn't guaranteed anything and it's not backed by
- 28:39anything. It's not real, it doesn't have
- 28:41intrinsic value, it's volatile. It's this, it's that these are
- 28:44all nonsense arguments that we know how to rebut, but they have
- 28:47sound logical reasons why these are not true things.
- 28:50But you know, I, I think people, Muslims in particular, they,
- 28:54they misinterpret that. And, and what, what they don't
- 28:57realize is this is such a, a pure form of money, a pure sound
- 29:00form of money, analogous to gold in its heyday, when it was a
- 29:04global standard, The gold standard was something that was
- 29:09good for nations, good for civilizations.
- 29:11It reduced friction between nations.
- 29:13It led to less hostility, less war.
- 29:16These are all good things for society and civilization.
- 29:19Bitcoin can do that. Bitcoin has that capability.
- 29:22What if you married this low time preference sound money with
- 29:27a financial system that deals with real economy and real
- 29:32trade, not financialization and proliferation of debt and
- 29:36loading students with $100,000 of debt that they have to pay
- 29:39off during their lifetime and create a master slave
- 29:42relationship with some some rich people sitting on a trading
- 29:45floor. That's not ethical, that's not
- 29:48Islamic, that's not Christian. You know, these are not things
- 29:52that a good society should be doing.
- 29:55We're creating the Society of debt slaves, and we're doing
- 29:57that because of Fiat money. So let's combine ethical finance
- 30:01with sound money. And so Harris, that was in 2017,
- 30:06you mentioned that you'd given that lecture on your book
- 30:11Heavens Bankers. And so there is the context of
- 30:13presenting these these principles and ideas of Islamic
- 30:16finance. And you'd mentioned that is when
- 30:18someone asked you about Bitcoin. And I'm sure that probably the
- 30:21context of you presenting on the topic of ethical Islamic
- 30:25finance, and I presume the history of it, it probably made
- 30:29you a little bit more receptive to the idea of someone bringing
- 30:32Bitcoin up in a conversation. And so could you take us now
- 30:35from 2017 to present almost eight years later And how do you
- 30:40see Bitcoin realigning the principles of Islamic finance?
- 30:44Because you had mentioned that in the 1960s, it was an
- 30:47experiment in the 1990s, you saw that Islamic finance was was
- 30:53moving away from the core principles and alignment that
- 30:56you saw early on when this was introduced in Egypt.
- 31:00And now how do you see in the twenty 20s and beyond, how does
- 31:04Bitcoin play a role in addition to all the other work that
- 31:07you're doing in the space? How does Bitcoin play a role in
- 31:11realigning Islamic finance and creating, or I guess adding to
- 31:17the proliferation and realignment of this sound reform
- 31:20and more ethical form of finance?
- 31:22Yeah. So until I've been introduced to
- 31:24Bitcoin, I hadn't realized that I was naturally somebody who
- 31:28aligned with Austrian economics. And I didn't even, you know, I'd
- 31:32never come across it before. It's not something that's taught
- 31:35in universities, you know, it is.
- 31:37We're all subjected to the received wisdom of Keynesianism.
- 31:40So it's just something that we don't get exposed to.
- 31:44So here I was a believer in a form of Islamic economics.
- 31:49Islamic economics being one in which investors and investees,
- 31:55if I can use that term, are aligned.
- 31:57They are partners. There is not this asymmetric
- 32:00relationship between them. They they have a symmetric
- 32:02relationship. The Prophet himself was a an
- 32:07investment manager, a word I can use as modaric, that's the
- 32:10Arabic word. And Modaric is in manager of
- 32:12people's capital. So his first wife was a, a, a
- 32:18rich merchant in the in the city of Mecca and she employed him as
- 32:23a manager of her capital. So the capital goes to the
- 32:26Madarik, the manager of the money, and he deploys it on the
- 32:29caravan trade. You know, he buys whatever
- 32:33spices and textiles and brings them back within the city walls
- 32:36and then trades them in the market.
- 32:37And then the profit is split with the investor of the money.
- 32:42And she was so impressed by his work that she proposed to him
- 32:45when they were married. This is a a very interesting
- 32:50early example of that financial arrangement that I think under
- 32:55what should underpin Islamic finance and underpins the
- 32:59Islamic Economic model. And it so happens is something
- 33:02that that works in the context of Austrian economics and
- 33:05Bitcoin as well. Because if Bitcoin is a form of
- 33:10sound money, freedom money, money that is used purely as a
- 33:14medium of exchange and a store of value, not money that is
- 33:19traded for its own intrinsic purpose.
- 33:24So today we live in a society where debt and cash flows are
- 33:28traded, where money itself is traded, where I can make money
- 33:32out of money by lending you and demanding an interest rate in
- 33:35return, not worrying about the underlying trade or the
- 33:38underlying business venture that we are financing.
- 33:40I think bankers like to say that they take risk.
- 33:43They like to say that we assess risk and we do due diligence,
- 33:45but they don't really. I mean, if you fail, they're
- 33:47going to have the shirt off your back.
- 33:49They've got some collateral, you know, they've got some security.
- 33:53And it's that Goodfellas scene of F you pay me, you know, your
- 33:56house burned down, I don't care F you pay me, right?
- 33:59So it's, you know, these are these are things that we are now
- 34:02used to in the modern world. But actually, if we go back to
- 34:05the roots of Islamic economics, it's really about an underlying
- 34:08trade. And as an investor, you have to
- 34:10take market risk. It has to be a free market.
- 34:14You have to be somebody who assesses what that risk is and
- 34:17does due diligence and takes care to enter into commercial
- 34:21relationships with good partners.
- 34:23And if we as a society did this, we'd end up having a healthier
- 34:27economy, not one in which some of us are masters and some of us
- 34:30are slaves, which is where we are today.
- 34:33So that's that's where I think the alignment comes in and I
- 34:37think the way that we might move towards an Islamic finance
- 34:42industry that is based on Bitcoin probably needs to happen
- 34:46in a couple of stages. I think the first stage is we
- 34:50have to have financial instruments that are Islamic
- 34:53finance and Sharia compliant. It's not going to come from the
- 34:56banks. I think it's going to come from
- 34:58non bank financial intermediaries.
- 35:00I set up one called CCM or Cordova Capital Markets.
- 35:03And the purpose of this company was to create a trade finance
- 35:07instrument that investors can put their money into, is listed
- 35:11on a Stock Exchange, and it finances businesses on this
- 35:17arrangement that goes back to the roots of the Islamic
- 35:20Economic model. So this idea of prophetic
- 35:23economics where an individual acts as a mudarev, a manager of
- 35:27people's capital, and shares the profits in a business activity
- 35:31on which both investor and investee have done their due
- 35:34diligence. So what I wanted to do is to go
- 35:36back to this idea of prophetic economics where you take a
- 35:40specific trade activity and you securitize that trade activity
- 35:45and you list that trade activity on a Stock Exchange and
- 35:48investors can put their money into it and they know exactly
- 35:50what risks they're taking. And yes, they are taking risk.
- 35:54Yes, they are exposed to something because that's what
- 35:56the market is. And I think that's a very
- 35:59healthy arrangement. Now if I can put that in a
- 36:02format that is bond like or secook like that is that is
- 36:07issued through an international financial center, in our case at
- 36:10Jersey and the Channel Islands, that is regulated.
- 36:14And I know regulation is a is a controversial world in our word,
- 36:18in our space, because you know, we like a world without KYC and
- 36:21AML because we think of Bitcoin as resistance money and freedom
- 36:24money. But I think we need to go
- 36:26through those steps first. We need to convince the industry
- 36:30that there is a form of financial instrument that's good
- 36:32for everybody, that will make us all money, that will share this
- 36:36the spoils evenly amongst us, that won't create these
- 36:39asymmetric relationships. And if we can make that
- 36:42financial instrument commercially sound and
- 36:45commercially successful, then the next stage is building it on
- 36:49an econ, on a monetary base that is Bitcoin and not Fiat.
- 36:54And it I'm sort of at the intersection of that now.
- 36:56I'm about to progress from 1:00 to the other.
- 37:00Yeah, that's a great recap. I think there's a couple things
- 37:03I took notes of. One of them is you mentioned the
- 37:06profit and you know, having a recognition of capital returning
- 37:11and was chosen like that doesn't come from out of nowhere.
- 37:13He had to have been a merchant previously and had experience to
- 37:17make that capital back. And similar to yourself having a
- 37:20background in entrepreneurship and seeing these markets, you
- 37:23created CCM and so you created a financial product and products
- 37:27that are innovative by today's standards, not by, you know,
- 37:30hundreds of years ago. And when we when we met, I think
- 37:33there's a lot of alignment with the things we're doing with
- 37:35early riders in this notion of, you know, alignment, you know,
- 37:39returning a sound for a capital. And I think that's where this is
- 37:43all a function of time before the market recognizes you need
- 37:47investment managers who have experience and backgrounds
- 37:49because it's become very hazy when everything's financial eyes
- 37:52and everybody goes to school to be a venture capitalist or an
- 37:55asset manager. And then they tell a good story,
- 37:59but it's very hard, you know, whenever when this is happening
- 38:03to discern what is actually real or not in generally the, the
- 38:05time horizons are long. So it takes time to figure that
- 38:08out. The other component of that
- 38:11that's described as the like 0 is, is an acceptable thing, But
- 38:15we haven't accepted that as a market in the sense of like
- 38:18investments go to 0. But because we, we re re
- 38:23leverage, we re underwrite opportunities, we consistently
- 38:26build more and more leverage. Where to your point, if you you
- 38:29profit share and you also risk risk share and the market starts
- 38:32to discern who knows what they're doing and who doesn't
- 38:35because some things go to zero and then eventually this is how
- 38:37free banking operated. You just don't go to the bank if
- 38:40they don't return the capital. So these are all just things
- 38:42that, you know, volatility is a healthy part of a market.
- 38:46It's just we don't allow it and we're basically are prolonging,
- 38:51you know, long term volatility. So is that one part the other
- 38:54thing that's just something that's fascinating to call out
- 38:57and curious hear your thoughts is you reference a lot of these
- 39:00topics that have permeated society.
- 39:02Like at the very like base level in the western side of there's a
- 39:07built in fallacy of like who will build the roads?
- 39:10So when I talk with family members and people I care deeply
- 39:12about, we talk about well, you know, Bitcoin or less government
- 39:15and all these concepts, it's like, no, but well, who who will
- 39:17build the roads? And right, the roads are proxy
- 39:19for who will build the schools and who will build everything
- 39:22and something. So it struck me again, tying
- 39:23back to Islamic finance is the term of zakat.
- 39:25And I think if I get it right, it's the the recognition of the
- 39:28requirement from a believer to participate in 3% of their
- 39:32annual well, other wealth total. I don't know if it's total of
- 39:35that year or total altogether cumulative, but either way to,
- 39:40to give back. And it's this under, under.
- 39:43And this kind of like aligns with the Reba incentive because
- 39:46if you're making money on money, then it's a misalignment from
- 39:49giving money back because you're like, well, why would I give
- 39:51that one? I can make money.
- 39:52That's one concept. But the other one is this notion
- 39:54of like, if we're all humans and we all want to live in a
- 39:57prosperous society, it's a very bearish and negative take us and
- 40:01as as human beings that we would just let people suffer and let
- 40:05our roads, our road and all the things versus if we are all
- 40:09winning together and we're all moving forward, that individuals
- 40:13wouldn't build the schools and the roads and all these ideas
- 40:15that they just like incepted our or a given that we will we will
- 40:19just let everything like break unless we have a form of
- 40:21government that inserts itself. So just curious like your
- 40:24thoughts on that and how like Islam like ties into it and and
- 40:27yeah. Yeah, I think the zakat is a is
- 40:30a good example, actually. It's a zakat is the arms tax.
- 40:34As you say, it's the attacks on a person's wealth.
- 40:36So every year every Muslim is required to give 2 1/2% of their
- 40:40total wealth, their aggregate wealth to charity.
- 40:44And and that's not even, that's considered a cleansing of their
- 40:48wealth. So it's interesting to me that
- 40:52an economist like Thomas Piketty proposes a wealth tax.
- 40:56I don't know if you propose it on everybody or just the rich,
- 40:58but everybody does. They lose their minds.
- 41:00Oh, my God, what an amazing genius idea.
- 41:02Yeah, we should have a wealth tax.
- 41:03And hey, this idea has been around for 1400 years.
- 41:05You know, this this idea that if everybody paid a flat small rate
- 41:10on all of their wealth, then it allows wealth to circulate in
- 41:13the economy. And that's healthy for
- 41:15everybody. So how does one finance roads
- 41:18and infrastructure and so on? There is, in my opinion, there's
- 41:21still a role for government. I mean, in, in Islamic and early
- 41:24Islamic history, there was a concept of the Beta al Maal,
- 41:27which was this literally the word stand for House of treasury
- 41:30or House of wealth, which was a, a government treasury.
- 41:33And it was there to provide for widows and orphans and the
- 41:36infirm and the elderly and so on.
- 41:39It was an institution that was designed to protect the more
- 41:42vulnerable people in society. And arms taxes went to that
- 41:46institution. So there is some role for
- 41:48government. There is some role, role for
- 41:51government in protecting the people.
- 41:54What we live in a world today where government has taken over
- 41:57all of those roles and there's almost no role for society
- 41:59anymore. And you know, you know, we we
- 42:02joke about being unable to do simple things for ourselves in
- 42:06the nanny state and health and safety and so on.
- 42:09We're no longer human beings that are able to assess risk for
- 42:12ourselves. We have to be told in a 30 page
- 42:14document by the government what is good and what is bad.
- 42:17We're, we're not, we don't behave like intelligent human
- 42:20beings. Every we seem to have regressed.
- 42:22That's how it feels to me. So I, I do think there is a role
- 42:26for government, but not, not in the way that, that it's
- 42:28progressed to modern times. You know, I there's another
- 42:32example of government intervention in monetary matters
- 42:37in early Islam, and that is that a royalty.
- 42:41I said the word royal. I didn't mean royal.
- 42:42I mean, a government mint was set up in order to verify that
- 42:48gold coins were of the necessary purity and weight and they were
- 42:54stamped accordingly. So, you know, that is a, a, a
- 42:59role that that government in early Islam did take.
- 43:02But they did not intervene in matters of money.
- 43:05They did not manipulate the money supply.
- 43:08They did not inject new money into the economy simply by
- 43:12printing. You know, there were certain
- 43:14restricted roles that the government held and verification
- 43:18of gold at that time was one of those.
- 43:20Of course, the beauty of Bitcoin is we don't require a government
- 43:24to do that for us because there are thousands of nodes around
- 43:27the world that do that for us. So this is this is the beauty of
- 43:30this modern digital form of of gold.
- 43:33And that's why I was so fascinated by it when I first
- 43:36heard about it in 2017. Does your Bitcoin custody setup
- 43:40keep you up at night? Maybe you still have coins
- 43:42sitting on an exchange worried about hackers.
- 43:45Or maybe you've set up your own self custody, but don't feel
- 43:47safe with your Bitcoin savings stashed on a little plastic
- 43:50device in your desk drawer. Gain Peace of Mind with On Ramp
- 43:54and our multi institution custody solution.
- 43:57Here's how it works. On Ramp creates a dedicated
- 44:00multi sig vault just for you. 3 separate institutions each hold
- 44:04a key on ramp bit go and coin cover, but none can move funds
- 44:09unilaterally. Instead only you have control
- 44:12over your coins. With on Ramps multi institution
- 44:15custody you'll sleep better at night knowing your Bitcoin is
- 44:18stored with best in class security on chain with fault
- 44:21tolerant multi sig. If you believe your Bitcoin is
- 44:24going to be worth a lot someday, don't jeopardize that future by
- 44:28exposing your coins to hackers on exchanges, $5 wrench attacks
- 44:32in the real world, or perhaps most importantly, the risk that
- 44:35you might screw something up with a highly technical self
- 44:38custody set up. On ramps, multi institution
- 44:41custody, eliminates single points of failure, reduces your
- 44:45personal attack surface and technical burden, and provides
- 44:48access to financial services that allow you to confidently
- 44:51secure your Bitcoin, including inheritance planning, insurance
- 44:55backed warranties for all balances and transactions, low
- 44:57cost trading and more. Bitcoin is a once in a species
- 45:01asset. Secure it right.
- 45:03Learn more at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 45:06Yeah, Harris, you made a great point too, just with how we have
- 45:10regressed in many ways as civilization and we have these
- 45:14sovereigns that are over encumbered by debt and we have
- 45:17these egregious tax rates here in in the USUKEU most of the
- 45:23Western world had just you're shovelling so much money of your
- 45:26so much of your earnings into taxes.
- 45:29And now, of course, in the United States, there is this
- 45:31push with the Department of Government efficiency Doge to
- 45:35really curtail a lot of the spending to manage the excess
- 45:39within the country. And you would think that there
- 45:42would be a recognition by both sides, right, that this would
- 45:44ultimately be a good thing to look into, right?
- 45:47Let's maybe shrink some of the excess, get rid of a lot of the
- 45:51waste. We have more money to we have
- 45:55more money for ourselves, first and foremost to allocate how we
- 45:59see fit. And I, you know, like the idea
- 46:02of the Zocat as well where you, where you are defining, I guess
- 46:07you said 2 1/2% per year is mandated, right?
- 46:09Where you give that to people who are more in need.
- 46:12And just imagine if we could get rid of so much of the waste, we
- 46:15have more money for ourselves to, to provide for our families.
- 46:18We'd maybe get back to a world where, you know, 1 income is
- 46:20sufficient to provide for a family.
- 46:23And then you also have plenty of excess capital to help those in
- 46:26need and to provide to charities that you see fit within your
- 46:29local communities. And then we also have so much
- 46:33more efficiency as a private sector, right, where we could
- 46:36actually get a lot of the function that is currently
- 46:38residing with the government to be back at least in some part in
- 46:42the private sector. And we could have so much more
- 46:44GDP growth. And ultimately Bitcoin aligns
- 46:46with that as well. Because if we take this sound
- 46:49money and incorporate it some way into whether it's Bitcoin
- 46:52denominated debt or it's Bitcoin on the balance sheet of
- 46:55sovereign nations, this will allow these countries to be more
- 46:58prudent with their spending and also to help recapitalize and I
- 47:03think reinvigorate a lot of these economies.
- 47:05One, one element there I think worth highlighting is, you know,
- 47:10if if we were better, if we had better transparency into where
- 47:15our tax, tax dollars went, I think that in and of itself
- 47:19better aligns incentives, right? So what you're describing here
- 47:22as you know, if you knew that 2 1/2 percent of your wealth was
- 47:26going somewhere that was useful and needed as opposed to we have
- 47:32no idea where our tax dollars go, that that is indicative of
- 47:36the benefits of aligning incentives effectively.
- 47:39And then the other, the other notion I wanted to pull out was
- 47:43at a very high level, like the, the waste and the misallocation
- 47:49of resources and ultimately the, the endless printing of dollars.
- 47:54It's simply just a function of, of high time preference and
- 47:57effectively saying it's not my problem.
- 48:01Let's keep kicking the can down the road.
- 48:03This will be the next generation or the next generation's issue
- 48:05to sort out. But this right now helps me in
- 48:09the moment like that is if you really boil it down, like that's
- 48:12what it comes down to for me. Yeah, there's so much to unpack
- 48:17there. I'm not even sure where I can
- 48:18start. But the first thing I will say
- 48:20is Bitcoin is anti river. Bitcoin is anti inflation.
- 48:26We know that, right? We know that it's anti
- 48:28inflation. We know that it can't be created
- 48:31out of nothing. We know that it can't be
- 48:33injected into an economy by a government simply by printing.
- 48:36So that in itself is a huge advantage because it means that
- 48:40it is. It will not flood the money
- 48:43supply and cause inflation and require us to hold two jobs in
- 48:48order to pay for everything. And it's anti riba because it
- 48:52can't be created from nothing. So at a stroke it is.
- 48:57We are unable to lend Bitcoin and create new Bitcoin out of
- 49:03nothing as a fractional Reserve Bank.
- 49:05Sure there will be people who will create financial products
- 49:09that will lend Bitcoin at interest.
- 49:11Yes, of course it's inevitable. That's human nature.
- 49:14But this idea of money creation through banks is just not
- 49:18possible with Bitcoin. So that I think is a is a really
- 49:21important because it means that you lead to a de
- 49:23financialization of the world. You lead to a world in which GDP
- 49:28is now not the the most important metric to measure
- 49:32human progress. So GDP only measures the
- 49:35exchange value of goods and services.
- 49:37But if the exchange value of goods and services is stuff that
- 49:40we don't actually need, what we're doing in order to support,
- 49:43you know, paying our monthly mortgage, which is inflated
- 49:47because the asset value of our houses inflated because of a
- 49:50money supply and B proliferation of debt, quantitative easing and
- 49:55so on. You know, this is a never ending
- 49:57cycle. So if we can find a way to break
- 50:00that cycle, BTC is is breaking that cycle.
- 50:03It's anti rebut, it's anti inflation.
- 50:06It means that we will start to focus on metrics of human
- 50:09progress that are not just exchange value of goods and
- 50:13services, but experiential value of our lives.
- 50:17Our literacy rates, suicide rates, divorce rates,
- 50:20environmental pollution, all of these things that are more
- 50:23important than how much money is sitting in our bank account.
- 50:26Sure, we want to be rich. Sure we want to have nice
- 50:28things, of course. But if we have a sound money, we
- 50:32are incentivized towards deferred gratification.
- 50:36We make long term investment decisions, not decisions.
- 50:40That decision determine how our next quarter is going to be, but
- 50:43how the next quarter of our lives is going to be for our
- 50:47children's lives or our grandchildren's lives.
- 50:49So that's a very different mindset.
- 50:51It's a fundamental change. It's how we used to be as a
- 50:53civilization. We used to think like that, but
- 50:55we don't think like that anymore because post 1971 we're only
- 50:58worried about which way the stock price is going to go up in
- 51:01the next 15 minutes, right? That's the problem that we have
- 51:05a society right now. So I think this move towards
- 51:07long term decision making and deferred gratification is an
- 51:10important by product of going towards a Bitcoin monetary
- 51:13standard. It's such a great point that you
- 51:17reference that I think a lot of people feel what we haven't been
- 51:20able to articulate is a lot of the boomer generation, I just
- 51:23experienced this. They conflate tech innovation or
- 51:27the, the apps we have on our phone with a better society or
- 51:30better, you know, like experience in life when they're
- 51:34literally the off of it, right? Like, because I know very well
- 51:37meaning individuals that are like, you guys have it easy.
- 51:39And it's just like objectively, you know, when you think about
- 51:42millennials and number of jobs and the debt and all these
- 51:45things, it's like, no, it's easy because you got the phone and
- 51:47you got the, you know, the DoorDash or whatever delivers.
- 51:49But the reality of what you just described, it's this like
- 51:53permutation of, you know, since 71 of number go up, so stock go
- 51:58up, real estate go up by the denominator of amount of capital
- 52:01coming in. And so like that's the unit and
- 52:04they don't understand like, well, that is increased for
- 52:08them. It is also increased
- 52:09disproportionately for everyone else because their cost of
- 52:11living has not kept pace and they're just missing it.
- 52:14And it's like this notion of incentives, Dr. everything if
- 52:17they're sitting on their nest egg in retirement, the one way I
- 52:21figured out to kind of spark them into action is realizing
- 52:23that like, well, you're, you're inherited or your retirement
- 52:27specifically people that retire is like, well, it's kind of, you
- 52:29know, you, you feel it every year on your vacation, it's kind
- 52:32of bind you less and less. So you're either what your
- 52:35retirement you thought was going to be may end soon or whatever
- 52:39you're leaving in your family is going to be much less than you
- 52:41thought. And so we call them like there's
- 52:43a funny joke like Spike coiners where they just start buying
- 52:46Bitcoin. Like I'm Speaking of like in
- 52:47laws and they didn't really listen this, but if they did,
- 52:49they'd laugh is like they buy and you find they have a
- 52:51position, but they don't buy it because they believe you.
- 52:53They buy it because like you can't, they can't afford to be
- 52:55wrong. If they've been sitting for, you
- 52:57know, 7 plus years at dinner listening to this guy talking
- 53:00about this asset and it went from 3000.
- 53:02Now it's 100K while also, you know, everything else has
- 53:05increased. Yeah, 100% agree with that.
- 53:08That's I, I like that spike when excellent.
- 53:12Yeah. We, we need to stand in the
- 53:16shoes of the people that we talked to.
- 53:17And I think one of the dangers of us as a community, as Bitcoin
- 53:21is, is we tend to be a little bit toxic at times.
- 53:24So, you know, we're trying to shove this thing down people's
- 53:26throats and we say have fun staying poor.
- 53:28And you know, we, we call everything that's not Bitcoin
- 53:31shit coins. And we, you know, we, we use
- 53:33this language that sometimes alienates us and we just need to
- 53:37find that way or what it, what it is.
- 53:39People are convinced it's hearts and minds.
- 53:42You know, often people are convinced by the emotional
- 53:44argument more than the logical argument.
- 53:47Sometimes logic doesn't, doesn't work on people.
- 53:49Sometimes you need to use the argument of freedom money or
- 53:52resistance money of, oh, you know, you have relatives in, in
- 53:56troubled parts of the world. Maybe they're in Lebanon and
- 53:58Gaza. Maybe they're in, I don't know,
- 54:00in, in other parts of the in other parts of the world where
- 54:03their currency is depreciating massively.
- 54:06You know, what's a lifeline for them?
- 54:09You know, sometimes it's those arguments that work on them.
- 54:11And then those at that point, they'll say, oh, yeah, OK, maybe
- 54:14I didn't think of it in those terms.
- 54:16So you just have to find the right argument that works with
- 54:18people. Yeah.
- 54:19And that's the foundation of this whole business, if you put
- 54:22in its essence, is meeting people where they're at.
- 54:24We've been so early to Bitcoin historically.
- 54:26The fundamental is to have it right, but they're unwilling to,
- 54:30you know, have the discussion and, and it's like there's a
- 54:33joke. I don't even know if it's
- 54:34exactly this, but I like saying it's like, do you want to make
- 54:36money or do you want to be right, right.
- 54:38And it's like, do you, if you want to be right, like, sure,
- 54:40you can have it all, but like that doesn't, doesn't make any
- 54:42money. You just are there and you get
- 54:44to sit there in the corner versus just meet the market
- 54:46where they're at. And then ultimately, once you
- 54:47meet them there, they can come to your conclusion.
- 54:49But if you never get to start the conversation.
- 54:52So a lot of these concepts, well, we know them internally.
- 54:55We, we, we don't share them on the pod because it's, it's good
- 54:58to talk through, but we kind of try to take a more diplomatic
- 55:01approach because to your point, when people just call everything
- 55:04bullshit, even though we know it is, they're just like
- 55:06immediately, like put in their head, like all these guys are
- 55:09dogmatic. They are closed minded versus
- 55:11like, look, let's just have an open discussion and we have a
- 55:14framework and we'll help you get there.
- 55:15But we're open to, you know, here an easy example of this we
- 55:19talked about on a previous pod with Bram.
- 55:22He was referencing how do you talk about crypto versus Bitcoin
- 55:24and think Brian's helped me with this.
- 55:26And this is I think a thing that we mostly take internally when
- 55:29we talk with institutional investors is think of crypto
- 55:32like a venture style bet. We have a thesis that majority
- 55:35of them go to 0, if not all of them, but look at it as a more
- 55:37speculative asset versus Bitcoin is a different form of capital,
- 55:41more store value competing with bonds in gold.
- 55:44And so you should isolate how you think about them, how you
- 55:46secure them and just like leaving that as it is.
- 55:49And obviously on this call, and most people listening know that,
- 55:52you know, they're all going to 0.
- 55:54But at the same time, if you tell that to most people,
- 55:56they're just going to like, look, these guys don't like, you
- 55:59know, especially if they have bags, right?
- 56:00It's very hard to tell people that have already invested in
- 56:03certain things to have an open dialogue because people will
- 56:06have the some cost fallacy and they don't want to hear somebody
- 56:08explain to them why their investments going to 0.
- 56:11Yeah, they, they either they either have bags or for better
- 56:15or for worse, they've, they've seen some level of social proof
- 56:19from institutions, VCs who are investing in this stuff.
- 56:25You know, we go to some of these, you know, blockchain
- 56:28conferences here and there. And it's like that's so that's,
- 56:32you know, a type of social proof that reinforces bad ideas
- 56:37effectively. And so you're also competing
- 56:40with that. But Michael, you're totally
- 56:41right is, you know, you just you have to put them in different
- 56:44buckets and and be generous about your description
- 56:48effectively so that you don't, you know, come off too
- 56:53aggressive. But it is, you know, the the
- 56:55easiest sort of bifurcation is yes, speculation versus wealth
- 57:00preservation. Like those are two very
- 57:02different things. And if you can just sort of
- 57:05compartmentalize the segments of the market in that way, it, it
- 57:09goes a long way to at least shedding some light on sort of
- 57:13the deeper understanding that we allude to when we start talking
- 57:16about Bitcoin versus crypto. But again, that's like a, it's a
- 57:19long journey, like someone doesn't get there in a few
- 57:21sentences of understanding the core differences.
- 57:24But if you can frame it in that high level way, it's it's
- 57:26certainly helpful. We think this particular.
- 57:29Problem. Sorry, go ahead.
- 57:31I was to say one thing because this is something I just thought
- 57:34of IS, and I don't know if you have IS, this is eerily similar
- 57:37to your description of Islamic finance and getting kind of Co
- 57:40opted by traditional finance because Bitcoin is very similar
- 57:44in the sense that Bitcoin came in.
- 57:46And then traditional finance has taken this approach of trying to
- 57:50effectively Co-op because you can't really make money, right?
- 57:53Like you have to make money in a very low time preference way in
- 57:56Islamic finance, in the same way you have to make money in a very
- 57:58insanely low time preference way in Bitcoin.
- 58:00There's not a lot of ways to make money.
- 58:02And so that's where you see all this conflation and crypto and
- 58:06putting people out on the risk curve, which it effectively
- 58:08keeps people away from the underlying because they're
- 58:11conflating again, digital assets with with that notion.
- 58:15And so there's that just like sparked in my head is the beauty
- 58:19where I think Bitcoin can will obviously, you know, be able to
- 58:23have unfair advantages. The number go up.
- 58:26So this notion of low time preference, you wait by the the
- 58:30you wait by the the river. You wait by the river long
- 58:33enough for the bodies of your enemies to float by.
- 58:36Is that because you hold a form of money, it increases in
- 58:38purchasing power, you increasing your low time preference by
- 58:41building a brand and a reputation.
- 58:44And over time, because you're on the winning side of that, the
- 58:48market's basically like showing everyone else all the FT XS and
- 58:51block fired Celsius of the world that this is kind of how you you
- 58:54bring about this standard. But anyway, just reminding me of
- 58:58the your your notion of Islamic finance and how it kind of got
- 59:01manipulated. We have this particular problem
- 59:04in the Muslim community, which is that as a group of people, we
- 59:08often defer our guidance and our decision making to scholars, to
- 59:15theologians, and scholars end up opining on all sorts of things
- 59:19as they should because, you know, there is jurisprudence
- 59:24behind everything and any innovation in society.
- 59:27The problem that we've had over the last several years is that
- 59:31many scholars have been extremely misinformed about this
- 59:34subject and often work for governments or banks, for
- 59:37example, or worse still, they're just social media scholars who
- 59:40have a following on TikTok and Instagram.
- 59:43So you know, they're applying on this subject of Bitcoin and say
- 59:46it's Haram, it's religiously impermissible because of them.
- 59:48Then again, the usual FUD that I mentioned earlier.
- 59:51And so they haven't really deep dived into it.
- 59:53They haven't. They equate Bitcoin with crypto.
- 59:57So all the 99% of scams and rug polls out there, they think is
- 1:00:01is all part of the Bitcoin world as well.
- 1:00:04And the Muslim community has deferred their decision making
- 1:00:09to people who are simply misinformed on the subject.
- 1:00:13And they haven't bonded to look behind, look under the hood and
- 1:00:16work out what is this thing called Bitcoin?
- 1:00:17How does it work? What is it?
- 1:00:19Is it insecure? You know, is it, does it not in
- 1:00:23fact have intrinsic value? Is it actually volatile?
- 1:00:25Is it this is it that you know? But one of the ways I, I tried
- 1:00:29to persuade them is say, look, we as Muslims are low time
- 1:00:34preference people. We want to store up good deeds
- 1:00:37in this life because we believe in A reckoning with God and a
- 1:00:40hereafter. And you know, if we have done
- 1:00:43good deeds in our life, then that's an eternity or bliss.
- 1:00:47It's a Christian concept as well.
- 1:00:49And you know, one of the arguments I use is we are the
- 1:00:53ultimate low time preference people.
- 1:00:55You know, in the month of Ramadan, we fast for 30 days in
- 1:00:57a row and deny ourselves food and water for in some parts of
- 1:01:01the world, you know, 16-18 hours a day.
- 1:01:04You know, that's pretty low time preference.
- 1:01:06You know, we train our bodies, we train our minds.
- 1:01:09We, we believe in low time preference family values, we
- 1:01:13believe in educating for the future.
- 1:01:15We believe in investing for the future.
- 1:01:17Bitcoin should be a natural fit for you.
- 1:01:20You know, it's the ultimate low time preference monetary base.
- 1:01:23So you, you really ideologically, you should fit
- 1:01:26with it. You know, it should make sense
- 1:01:28to you, this idea that governments have to control
- 1:01:30everything we do, including our money supply.
- 1:01:33Well, actually the history of Islam has been very different.
- 1:01:36Governments and the judiciary have been historically
- 1:01:40separated. You know, the ruler and the
- 1:01:43judges are, are meant to be independent of each other.
- 1:01:46The law is independent. The monetary system needs to be
- 1:01:49independent. The markets need to be
- 1:01:50independent. There's a very famous
- 1:01:52traditional saying of the of the profit peace be upon him, which
- 1:01:56is that he was asked by a group of companions.
- 1:02:00Prices are getting out of control of certain commodities.
- 1:02:04Can you fix the prices for us? And he thought about this, and
- 1:02:08he realized that that would be a great injustice on people if he
- 1:02:12were to start fixing prices, centralizing prices.
- 1:02:16And he said that prices are in the hands of God.
- 1:02:19In other words, they should be allowed to move according to the
- 1:02:21market. I'm sure we can do certain
- 1:02:23things to protect the weak and vulnerable.
- 1:02:25There are some things that we can do as a government, as a
- 1:02:28ruler. But I can't fix the prices for
- 1:02:31you because if I did that, I'd be guilty of perpetrating a
- 1:02:34great injustice on the people. So this idea of free markets is
- 1:02:38intrinsically Islamic. And a lot of Muslims don't
- 1:02:40realize that, right? And now we're, what we're doing
- 1:02:42is suggesting, and here's a form of money that can lead to free
- 1:02:46markets, that can lead to risk sharing trade, right?
- 1:02:49That's actually truly the basis of the Islamic Economic model,
- 1:02:53not what you're seeing with the Islamic banks.
- 1:02:55That's just a, that's just a, a reverse engineering of what
- 1:02:59conventional banks do. Yeah.
- 1:03:02And there's to your point, Harris, there's so much
- 1:03:05entrenchment of high time preference thinking within both
- 1:03:09Islamic finance and also just traditional finance.
- 1:03:12You know, Brian and I both have traditional finance backgrounds
- 1:03:15and I remember from those days speaking with fund managers and
- 1:03:20the conversations are always about quarter, quarterly
- 1:03:23performance, right? Why is a fund manager
- 1:03:25underperforming a benchmark in a given quarter?
- 1:03:28And it was constantly me having to re explain the thesis on
- 1:03:31behalf of the fund manager to financial advisors or their
- 1:03:34clients that well, they have a they have a secular investment
- 1:03:38thesis or they take they take positions with high conviction
- 1:03:42that they expect to play out over a three or five or 10 year
- 1:03:45period. And there's such an entrenched
- 1:03:49philosophy or behavior of high time preference where we face
- 1:03:54this with Bitcoin as well where we want to articulate that
- 1:03:57Bitcoin is a long term store of value.
- 1:04:00It's an asset that should not be held for a year or two years.
- 1:04:03We believe that should be held at least for a four year cycle.
- 1:04:07And the data is there to back that as well, both on the
- 1:04:09absolute and risk adjusted basis where the lowest taker is about
- 1:04:1420% or so over a four year period, right.
- 1:04:16So if you can, if you can ditch the high time preference
- 1:04:21thinking that's so entrenched within this system and realign
- 1:04:25your investment philosophy, you can potentially see very
- 1:04:28outsized returns that are also in a form of money like you said
- 1:04:32that are more fair, just transparent.
- 1:04:35And that's a win, win proposition for everyone.
- 1:04:37And my concern as well as it's, I think it was articulated by
- 1:04:40both you and Michael, is that you're starting to see Bitcoin
- 1:04:43be Co opted. And there's really nothing we
- 1:04:45can do about that. Of course, because there are
- 1:04:46these natural incentives where you have asset managers stepping
- 1:04:50into the ring, they now want to make money off their product.
- 1:04:53But, and while there are great things about the ETFs in
- 1:04:56particular, it's really not aligned with Bitcoins.
- 1:05:01The idea of Bitcoin in terms of self sovereignty and ownership
- 1:05:05and savings technology or a form of peer-to-peer money.
- 1:05:09Now you're seeing it financialized, you're seeing it
- 1:05:12centralized, which is presenting hidden risks to investors as
- 1:05:16well. And I expect that will only
- 1:05:18become more pronounced over time, unfortunately.
- 1:05:21But it's great to have advocates for like you in the space, not
- 1:05:24only from traditional finance, but from Islamic finance as
- 1:05:27well, and being able to offer what I think are still fairly
- 1:05:31uncommon and asymmetric views on how Bitcoin can play a very
- 1:05:36significant role in realigning incentives and creating a more
- 1:05:39just and fair their monetary standard.
- 1:05:42Yeah, I think I agree that there's, there's, you know,
- 1:05:45there are some potential advantages to this modern, this
- 1:05:51recent phenomenon of Bitcoin ETFs and financial institutions
- 1:05:55getting in on the ACT. But you know, there is a, there
- 1:05:58is a, a solid alternative to self custody.
- 1:06:03Self custody doesn't work for everybody.
- 1:06:05You know, it's I mean, you know, my mother wouldn't be able to do
- 1:06:08it. You know, she just it's just
- 1:06:10just complicated for her. You know, this, the one of the
- 1:06:13reasons why I was so keen to work with Ralph and Michael and
- 1:06:16others and Enra Mina was because I felt that this was an
- 1:06:20essential addition to the Bitcoin ecosystem to have multi
- 1:06:24institutional custody. And you know, I think for those
- 1:06:28individuals and enterprises for for whom, you know, there is a
- 1:06:32risk that if you give the keys to one individual, and that's a
- 1:06:35massive risk that you're placing on an organization.
- 1:06:38This idea of of, of utilizing this inherent nature of Bitcoin
- 1:06:43to allow for multi signatory authority.
- 1:06:46This is a, this is an extremely important addition to the
- 1:06:49ecosystem and one I think that is going to be of increasing
- 1:06:54importance in the coming years. Yeah, it's an interesting
- 1:06:57something. I've sometimes like the
- 1:06:59hyperbolic statements are the things that make, you know, kind
- 1:07:01of just like the punch. And one of the things that I've
- 1:07:03kind of gravitated towards is people just let their money go
- 1:07:05to 0 versus buy Bitcoin. To your point, if they have to
- 1:07:08do self custody. And what I mean by that is
- 1:07:11because everyone knows that if they buy Bitcoin and they lose
- 1:07:13it, it goes to 0. And they hear all the tropes
- 1:07:16around self custody and landfills and in North Koreans
- 1:07:18hacking all these things. So it's just, it's just innate
- 1:07:22to be like, well, I'll just like if, if I'm losing in real
- 1:07:25purchasing power, 5%, right? So nominal return is five and
- 1:07:29I'm losing, you know, inflation is 10.
- 1:07:30So I'm losing 5% is like, well, at least I didn't lose it all
- 1:07:33right? Like I didn't lose it because I
- 1:07:35invested in this wrong asset. So people will just naturally
- 1:07:37not invest no matter how hard we explain and what we explain
- 1:07:40about all these things here, unless they know that it's
- 1:07:43bulletproof, unless they know that they allocate and again,
- 1:07:46that maybe the investment is the wrong investment.
- 1:07:50But then they wouldn't put material wealth if that was the
- 1:07:52case. But they can understand that.
- 1:07:54But there's no other asset. That's what I like.
- 1:07:56And Bitcoin is such a great product market fit for $2
- 1:07:58trillion. And people invested with the
- 1:08:02notion that they can lose all the Bitcoin the next day if the
- 1:08:04exchange goes down or their self cuts the setup, which means that
- 1:08:07that's an incredible product market fit.
- 1:08:09But at the same time, we still have so much opportunity to go.
- 1:08:11And it's that delta we talked about yesterday's pot about.
- 1:08:13That's the reason why it's not ten trillion is because this
- 1:08:16underlying market structure around the custody which has a
- 1:08:20lot of embedded transparency built in.
- 1:08:22When you think about gold and where we ultimately failed with
- 1:08:25gold is this notion of too many claims on the underlying well
- 1:08:29that is impossible to have. But if you construct it the
- 1:08:31right way where you know where the Bitcoin sits, you know any
- 1:08:34kind of claims against it and you can do that math you can
- 1:08:37have a bank run. There's a lot of thing in one
- 1:08:39entity doesn't hold it all similar to a coin base where we
- 1:08:42don't really ever know how much Bitcoin these they have.
- 1:08:44But then secondarily, if you ever is Bitcoins not scalable
- 1:08:47for the number of people on the earth.
- 1:08:49If you need to issue some notes against it, but there's actually
- 1:08:51no, we're away from a central party, but there's a lot of
- 1:08:54embedded financial products that will occur post this kind of
- 1:08:58like a creation of multi institution in custody.
- 1:09:02Absolutely. Yeah, one of the one of the big
- 1:09:04things there as well as there there is the, I guess the more
- 1:09:10idealistic Bitcoiner or the hardcore Bitcoin maxi that does
- 1:09:17not want to see the ETF succeed or or does not like the idea of
- 1:09:20the ETFs soaking up all these all this liquidity and being the
- 1:09:25most successful financial products that we've seen at Wall
- 1:09:27Street. But the idea really the the core
- 1:09:29thing there is that that speaks to the lack of Bitcoin native
- 1:09:34solutions that do meet people where they're at, which is why
- 1:09:36I'm excited about multi institution custody.
- 1:09:38And I encourage other people that are building in the space
- 1:09:41or want to build in the space to look for market gaps and build
- 1:09:45solutions so that all the Bitcoin doesn't end up in
- 1:09:48Coinbase in an ETF product, right?
- 1:09:50Like if that's something that people don't want to see as the
- 1:09:53future of Bitcoin, then the products need to exist where the
- 1:09:55only choices aren't leaving it with an exchange or managing it
- 1:09:59yourself and kind of being on an island and your family not
- 1:10:03having certainty about them being able to access it.
- 1:10:05And then also the incentive for violence and kind of pushing us
- 1:10:08back into a barbaric time. So it's really a challenge then
- 1:10:10for people who want Bitcoin to succeed and want it to be
- 1:10:14adopted in a way that's aligned with the idea and the experiment
- 1:10:19of 16 years ago. You have to take it upon
- 1:10:22yourself, right, to join a company or to build a company
- 1:10:24that's going to offer alternatives to Bitcoin sitting
- 1:10:28in one institution and being just another financial product
- 1:10:32that's shield by the largest asset managers in the world.
- 1:10:34So it's really a challenge to people who want to get involved.
- 1:10:37There's there's plenty of opportunities to do it.
- 1:10:39And what we're doing here at on ramp is just one example of
- 1:10:43something that took technology that's existed for over a decade
- 1:10:46now with multi sig right, and we've just provided a new
- 1:10:49implementation or flavor of it that didn't exist in the market
- 1:10:52five years ago. So there's going to be more
- 1:10:55maturity of the market, there's going to be new solutions
- 1:10:57brought to market, and really there's such a massive
- 1:11:00opportunity now to provide these solutions that are aligned with
- 1:11:03the ethos and experiment and ideals of Bitcoin.
- 1:11:06So really excited about that in particular.
- 1:11:10Yeah, maybe, yeah. But for my particular area of
- 1:11:14interest, geographical area of interest, which is the Middle
- 1:11:17East, you know, there aren't any UTF's out there.
- 1:11:21You know, the markets are not as sophisticated and therefore I
- 1:11:26think it's essential that this particular service is provided.
- 1:11:29I mean, that's something that obviously all right, MENA is
- 1:11:31working on. You know, multi institutional
- 1:11:34custody is going to get there before ETFs get there.
- 1:11:37And you know, I'm very pleased about that because I have mixed
- 1:11:40feelings about ETFs. I recognize that there's going
- 1:11:42to be a lot of investors who, you know, they're just never
- 1:11:44going to self custody. They're just never going to go
- 1:11:47there. So the next best thing is for
- 1:11:49their four O 1K or in the UK we have the SIP, the SIPP, which is
- 1:11:53the equivalent. You know, that's there's no,
- 1:11:57there's no, there's no other way they can do this.
- 1:12:00So I think for the Middle East it's particularly interesting.
- 1:12:04Yeah, I'm glad you brought that up because it's a perfect
- 1:12:05transition to your interest and excitement.
- 1:12:09What's what's happening there? I think, well, from an
- 1:12:11individual perspective, you know, obviously it's, it's the
- 1:12:14cost of Bitcoin, it's never been higher.
- 1:12:17I think that from my entrepreneurial perspective,
- 1:12:20risk adjusted, there's never been a better time to come into
- 1:12:22this space and build a position because the entrepreneurs, the
- 1:12:26individuals that grok the market, understand the
- 1:12:28underlying mechanics of Bitcoin to Jacksons point, will be able
- 1:12:31to build much better products than anybody on Wall Street.
- 1:12:34And that's how you compete with Wall Street is you just build
- 1:12:36better products. You play a different game.
- 1:12:38That's what multi institution is, that's what delivery, that's
- 1:12:40what all the education that we can offer.
- 1:12:42There's nobody on planet Earth that could do this because it's
- 1:12:45still a nascent asset class. So that's the opportunity and
- 1:12:48where Mina is so fascinating and we talked about it on the
- 1:12:51yesterday's plot is that the conservative nature mixed with
- 1:12:54the commodity understanding of commodities and oil rich is
- 1:12:59primed for the asset Bitcoin. The problem when we went out
- 1:13:02there is that there's so much crypto and they, they tell
- 1:13:05themselves as being innovative in these new emergent, you know,
- 1:13:08economies like the UAE and in Saudi Arabia and Bahrain, as
- 1:13:12they, they kind of all overshot the innovation.
- 1:13:15Like they have the ministry of AI and all these things, but
- 1:13:16then they're trying to get too cute with the crypto and stable
- 1:13:19coins. So we went there.
- 1:13:20It's like had all this innovation, but there was
- 1:13:22nothing related to Bitcoin. And it's just this like gap.
- 1:13:26It's a desert in the desert of offerings.
- 1:13:28And so curious like how you think about the, the space there
- 1:13:31and the opportunity to leapfrog almost the West in the learnings
- 1:13:34because we've had to go through a lot of pain in 15 years of all
- 1:13:37the craziness. So curious how you think about
- 1:13:40that in the Middle East? Well, Dubai in particular is a
- 1:13:43very interesting place because they're extremely commercially
- 1:13:45dynamic and whatever they, they choose to focus on, they, I
- 1:13:50mean, there, there is this idea of overshooting, isn't there?
- 1:13:52And they're certainly doing that with crypto right now.
- 1:13:55But you know, they, they attract good people.
- 1:13:58You know, it's a low tax environment.
- 1:13:59It's, it's, it's a good place to live.
- 1:14:03You know, they've set up a, a strong set of they've set up a
- 1:14:07strong financial district, you know, with strong robust
- 1:14:12legislative environment and a regulatory environment, a
- 1:14:15reputation is good. And you know, they, they see an
- 1:14:20opportunity in the world and they jump on it and they've
- 1:14:22clearly seen this opportunity in crypto.
- 1:14:26I don't know how we are going to tackle that, to be honest.
- 1:14:29I don't know how we are going to be able to convince people that
- 1:14:31it's good that you've, you've recognized the opportunity here,
- 1:14:35but we just need to focus you a little bit.
- 1:14:37Let's just get a lens around this and start to focus your
- 1:14:39direction here. I, I'm not sure what the
- 1:14:42solution is there, but I do know that there is a, a merchant
- 1:14:49mindset in a place like Dubai and they really want to be a
- 1:14:53hub, whether that's a, a port, you know, that physically
- 1:14:57transports goods from one place to another, whether that's a
- 1:15:00financial center, you know, they are, have historically been very
- 1:15:04good at that kind of thing. So, you know, let's let's hope
- 1:15:06we can channel their efforts into something more meaningful
- 1:15:10than than crypto scams and red polls.
- 1:15:14My optimistic take is there's a couple 1 is that talking with
- 1:15:18the regulators, they were very close to almost being rugged by
- 1:15:21the SPFS of the world, in particular SPF who was trying to
- 1:15:24raise capital from sovereigns before that blew up.
- 1:15:27But then also the experience in in another part of the world, in
- 1:15:30Texas, specifically around the conservative nature of Bitcoin
- 1:15:34and going into a room looking people in the eye, building
- 1:15:36relationships and, and basically explaining the difference
- 1:15:39between gold and crypto, because nobody tells that story.
- 1:15:42So if you're able to do that enough times and and be
- 1:15:45consistent, you overtime again goes back to low time
- 1:15:48preference. The market sorts it all out
- 1:15:50because we all know that this just has, it's just a matter of
- 1:15:53time before, you know, something crazy happens and it ends up in
- 1:15:56losses. So that's our hope or that's the
- 1:15:58plan, right? To go there and that's in the
- 1:16:00playbook is to be conservative, to explain it, to meet people
- 1:16:02where they're at. And to your point, there's no
- 1:16:05real structure products that are spot Bitcoin that allow for
- 1:16:07delivery in these things that the pensions the UK found very
- 1:16:10sophisticated. So it's an incredibly exciting
- 1:16:13market. Yeah.
- 1:16:17Harris, what do you see? And I know we're coming up on
- 1:16:20time here, but real quick, what do you see just in terms of
- 1:16:23sovereign nations competing? Do you think that will start to
- 1:16:25play out in 2025 or is that a little bit longer dated from
- 1:16:29where we are currently? Because I don't know if you, if
- 1:16:32you've heard, but I've certainly heard a lot of rumors about
- 1:16:35sovereigns in the Gulf potentially purchasing Bitcoin
- 1:16:39and holding it on their balance sheets.
- 1:16:41We know that there is sovereigns that have been directly involved
- 1:16:44in Bitcoin mining for some years now.
- 1:16:46But do you think that Sovereign Game Theory will play out in
- 1:16:492025, or is that still a ways away?
- 1:16:53I don't have a crystal ball, unfortunately, so I just don't
- 1:16:56know the answer. But I can tell you that if you
- 1:16:58talk to our colleague Ralph Ralph Gibran in in Dubai and you
- 1:17:02jump in a car with him, I'm sure he'll drive you around parts of
- 1:17:05Abu Dhabi where you might find some evidence that mining is
- 1:17:09already taking place. So I'm sure it's being done on
- 1:17:13the quiet by many nation states around the world.
- 1:17:17And I think that's just game theory because, you know, if the
- 1:17:21US is talking about a strategic reserve, then everybody better
- 1:17:24get on it very quickly before the US starts buying up.
- 1:17:27Because if it does happen and you're left without any coins,
- 1:17:31then, you know, you're in big trouble.
- 1:17:34So it's a relatively low cost option for nations to start
- 1:17:37building up their Bitcoin reserves and getting involved in
- 1:17:39mining and so on. So if everybody stays true to
- 1:17:43game theory, then yeah, sure, 2025 could be a very good year
- 1:17:46for Bitcoin. But you never know.
- 1:17:48I've been trying to advocate it for certain nations.
- 1:17:51I'm personally, I'm a Pakistani heritage.
- 1:17:53So I speak to relatives and and people in Pakistan and I say,
- 1:17:57you know, you guys got to jump on Bitcoin because you are an
- 1:17:59economically troubled country. You're a politically troubled
- 1:18:02country. You know, you've got a lot of
- 1:18:04problems and there are a lot of things that having a vibrant
- 1:18:08economy can fix. And if you want to have a
- 1:18:10vibrant economy, have a vibrant monetary system.
- 1:18:12And if you want a vibrant monetary system, jump on Bitcoin
- 1:18:15when it was $10,000 when I told you it's now $100,000.
- 1:18:18So what are you guys waiting, still waiting for Anyway?
- 1:18:22I hope they get there, but as I say, nobody has a crystal ball.
- 1:18:27Fair enough. Michael and Harris, you guys
- 1:18:31will be out in in Abu Dhabi in a couple weeks or I guess about a
- 1:18:35week's time or so. Any thoughts as it relates to
- 1:18:38the Bitcoin MENA conference and the Institutional day before we
- 1:18:41wrap up here? Yeah, go ahead.
- 1:18:45There we go. Very excited.
- 1:18:49We have experience going to the Bitcoin Magazine events and they
- 1:18:53can be very eventful and chaotic.
- 1:18:55So we decided to put together a side event, an institutional day
- 1:19:00event that focuses on, I won't list them all, but like mining,
- 1:19:04custody, financial services and other things in relation to the
- 1:19:08region. Have an amazing guest list of
- 1:19:12speakers. Harris and I will be speaking,
- 1:19:14so if you're interested in attending, we'll link to it in
- 1:19:16the show notes. But excited to see everyone out
- 1:19:18there. I think given the recent price
- 1:19:21action and to Jackson's point, the geopolitical conversation as
- 1:19:25it's come up, I think it's going to be a very productive and
- 1:19:28fruitful week. That would have maybe not have
- 1:19:30been the case. I think it would have always
- 1:19:32been to get close to individual we've been working with and
- 1:19:35talking to. But six months ago, I think the
- 1:19:38price being, you know closer to 40, five, $50,000 leaves the
- 1:19:42sentiment very different than sitting at $100,000 strategic
- 1:19:45reserves and everything else that's coming into 2025 S pretty
- 1:19:48exciting to see what comes from it.
- 1:19:50Yeah, I'm excited as well. I mean, I would say that I'm,
- 1:19:53I'm a quite a sober former banker.
- 1:19:55So, you know, my natural, my natural environment is other
- 1:20:01sober professional and institutional people.
- 1:20:03And I probably don't fit in so well to your typical Bitcoin
- 1:20:07conference, but I think I probably fit into the
- 1:20:10institutional day. Perfect.
- 1:20:12Well. Thank you, Harris.
- 1:20:15For those who want to learn more about what you're doing and get
- 1:20:18in touch with you directly, what would be the best way for them
- 1:20:21to do so? I'm on Twitter under Harris
- 1:20:24Irfan. I'm also on LinkedIn.
- 1:20:27I occasionally publish blogs on, on LinkedIn and my activities
- 1:20:32through CCM Cordova Capital Markets.
- 1:20:34We are regularly publishing and and socializing the things that
- 1:20:38we are up to. I, I think personally that we're
- 1:20:41at the next phase of evolution of the Islamic finance market.
- 1:20:45And if we can combine that with Bitcoin, then that's just,
- 1:20:49that's the end game, I think. Yeah.
- 1:20:52So I would second that and encourage searching Harris's
- 1:20:54name in like podcast feeds because there's a lot of great
- 1:20:57content if you like this that you can find where he talks more
- 1:21:00about a lot of these concepts we discussed today.
- 1:21:04Excellent. Thanks, Harris, for joining us
- 1:21:05today. It was a pleasure.
- 1:21:06Thank you. Thanks, Harris.
- 1:21:08Really appreciate it. Cheers.
- 1:21:10Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:21:13If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:21:15episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:21:17app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:21:19today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:21:22Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Ramp Media is
- 1:21:25for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:21:27nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:21:31Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:21:33to hear from you. Visit on rampbitcoin.com/contact
- 1:21:37to schedule a consultation with one of our private Client
- 1:21:39advisors.