Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De'ah 286:22-287:2. Mezuzah: Owning Vs Renting a Home, Vacation Rentals; Which Doorways Are Obligated

Transcript

Yoreh De'ah 286:22-287:2. Mezuzah: Owning Vs Renting a Home, Vacation Rentals; Which Doorways Are Obligated · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:00
  Evolved siphoff bays. I will just mention one word
• 0:03
  about siphoff Aleph and that is that we were talking about a
• 0:07
  single Pesach that has a post in the middle, whether it's
• 0:10
  considered to be 1 doorway or whether it's considered to be
• 0:12
  two doorways. So one thing which that Mohammed
• 0:16
  does not say, but it would seem to me Misvara, that this would
• 0:19
  be push it, is that if there are two mashkraifs, there's two
• 0:23
  lentils. So then clearly it's 2 doorways.
• 0:26
  In other words, the entire Suffolk is only talking about a
• 0:30
  case where you have a single mashkaif, you have a single
• 0:32
  lentil going from post to post with another post in the middle.
• 0:36
  So that's where this Suffolk applies, whether that's
• 0:38
  considered one doorway or two doorways.
• 0:41
  But when you have two separate lentils on either side of the
• 0:46
  middle post, so then there's much more of it's ad.
• 0:49
  It would seem to me to say that that would be considered 2
• 0:52
  doorways. That's just Misvara, OK, Siphov
• 0:56
  base, Hasaic herbais Bahutz Lauretz, Bahadar Bopundik
• 1:00
  Bahritz Israel. That's extraordinarily negay at
• 1:05
  this time of year in Eretz Israel.
• 1:07
  And that states as follows. Somebody who rents a home in
• 1:11
  Hutz Lauretz or one who lives in a pundit in Eretz Israel is
• 1:18
  Potter MI Mezuzah Schleischemiheim.
• 1:20
  He's Potter from Mezuzah Schleischemiheim.
• 1:22
  We'll come back to that in a second, but I say for bias by
• 1:25
  Eretz Israel, but someone who rents a home in Eretz Israel or
• 1:30
  an apartment in Eretz Israel, Hayev mezuzum Miyad Misha meshev
• 1:34
  Eretz Israel, he's Hayev immediately Misha meshev Eretz
• 1:38
  Israel. Now, a lot of these words are
• 1:40
  very debatable in what the what the precise meaning is, but
• 1:47
  let's see. First, let's see the gras.
• 1:49
  The gras in Sivkotten Aleph says, I'm sorry, I apologize.
• 1:54
  Not the gras, rather rather the Guillian marshaw.
• 2:00
  The Guillian marshaw over here in this print, the Simon is very
• 2:04
  similar. The Guillian marshaw says
• 2:06
  Hasaika Bias. The Guillian marshaw, as we
• 2:08
  mentioned once, is not the Marshall.
• 2:09
  It's your Pslaima Edgar who's also the Masha bias Mashma Dima
• 2:15
  bias, Shaloy Hayev Miad. In other words, the the fact
• 2:18
  that the Mahabhar discusses a tenant who's renting a home
• 2:23
  indicates that if somebody owns the home, so then there's no
• 2:26
  question that he's Hayev immediately.
• 2:28
  And that's whether you're in Hotz Lauretz or whether you're
• 2:30
  in a Aritz Israel. And I was, this is a very, very
• 2:34
  common misconception. People buy a home in Hotz Laretz
• 2:38
  and they move in and there's no Mazuza.
• 2:40
  And you say, where's your Mazuza?
• 2:41
  And they say, oh, well, I have 30 days.
• 2:43
  You don't have 30 days if you own, if you're the homeowner
• 2:45
  says RIP slime megger high of me yad.
• 2:49
  OK, now another very important of Schlameiger, he continues the
• 2:52
  Hein hassafer Anna Hayev gamla akashlation yam Kimi dirabana.
• 2:58
  If you are a tenant renting an an apartment or a home.
• 3:03
  So we say that after 30 days in Hutz Lauretz Yakayev.
• 3:07
  In other words, again an owner in Hutz Lauretz is Hayev
• 3:10
  immediately. A tenant in Hutz Lauretz is only
• 3:13
  Hayev after 30 days. Now, when an owner is Hayev
• 3:15
  immediately that's a Hayevde Raisa.
• 3:18
  When a tenant is 5 after 30 days, is that a day race or is
• 3:21
  there a Bunan that's only there a Bunan?
• 3:23
  It's not a day race. It's not Lakui Alma.
• 3:28
  No, it's not at all Lakui Alma. It's a big Maclachus, but that's
• 3:31
  the Hakra. It's generally accepted opinion
• 3:33
  amongst our our training is that the fee of of a tenant is only a
• 3:38
  fee of their abundant and that's whether the tenant is in
• 3:41
  Hutzlawritz or in Eretz Israel. Either way, the fee of a tenant
• 3:46
  is their abundant. So what's an AFG Amina if it's
• 3:48
  their abundant of the rices? There's a lot of nafgaminas, but
• 3:52
  one of the most common nafgaminas is that a tenant
• 3:54
  often moves into an apartment and there are already mezuzahs
• 3:58
  there and sometimes those mezuzahs are not.
• 4:00
  According to his mimic Serabal, Yashi was of the opinion that
• 4:04
  OK, since it's only a fief derabonen, one could be Makal
• 4:07
  and you don't have to replace the mezuzahs that they be in
• 4:10
  accordance with your mimic, whether it's Beziasif, Arizal or
• 4:14
  a result of Beziasif or even spare the mezuzahs for an
• 4:17
  Ashkenazi rebel. Yashiv held that one can use a
• 4:20
  mezuzan that Kafim in Hogaye because the fief is only the
• 4:25
  Rabonen. Now let's just see.
• 4:27
  I'll be in. I don't know if you have it.
• 4:29
  Every shulkanar has a different print, but in the necklace V, he
• 4:33
  says mashma, the afim sakhar habais al Shana tamima Ana
• 4:38
  keveya hamizuza adla akashlash. Just wanted to see those few
• 4:42
  first few words. So this is also a tremendous,
• 4:45
  tremendous maclegas afrinum. In other words, we say that a
• 4:49
  tenant is putter for 30 days, right?
• 4:52
  Again, if you own a home, you're hired immediately.
• 4:54
  If you're a tenant, you're only hired to 30 days.
• 4:57
  There are many Afrinum that say the Naseebus holds this way.
• 5:01
  Ravshak interestingly has a piece in Aviyazri where he says
• 5:05
  this way. And there are a number of other
• 5:07
  Afrinum that say this as well, that if somebody rents an
• 5:11
  apartment and you sign a contract for a year, let's say,
• 5:13
  I think that's the most standard contract.
• 5:16
  There's a year contract. So then they hold you hive
• 5:19
  immediately. In other words, because the
• 5:20
  reason why we say that a tenant is not hive for 30 days is
• 5:25
  because there's a lack of queers.
• 5:27
  That's when you own the home. So your kavua right away, the
• 5:30
  minute you move in, it's your home.
• 5:32
  You just spent $1,000,000 on this house, you're moving in
• 5:35
  your kavua immediately. But if you're a tenant and you
• 5:38
  have a landlord, so there's a lack of a of permanence in your
• 5:43
  residency in this abode and therefore for 30 days, we're not
• 5:49
  mahay of you. So there are those that say,
• 5:51
  yeah, OK, but if you sign a contract for a year, so then
• 5:55
  there's no lack of, of, of permanence.
• 5:58
  It's, it's permanent immediately.
• 6:00
  And therefore they hold that this cooler does not apply to
• 6:03
  such an individual, whereas many other Akranium disagree.
• 6:07
  And they say that Khazal do not differentiate between someone
• 6:10
  who signs a contract and someone who does not sign a contract.
• 6:13
  And therefore if someone's in this situation, they should ask
• 6:16
  the local Orthodox rabbi because it is a very big machlaucus.
• 6:19
  Now we did discuss a pundit. So what, what is a pundit?
• 6:22
  So there are a number of different the definitions of a
• 6:25
  pundit, but in common parlance we would refer to a pundit as a
• 6:29
  simmer or a hotel room. Now if somebody rents a hotel
• 6:33
  room, so he's putter for 30 days.
• 6:37
  If somebody rents it simmer and other.
• 6:39
  OK, let's back up a step. We said that a tenant in Aritis
• 6:44
  Trail is hive right away. A tenant in Hoods Lawrence is
• 6:47
  only hive after 30 days. A tenant in Aritis Trail is hive
• 6:51
  right away. OK, so I'm renting at simmer for
• 6:53
  four days up north. I'm a tenant.
• 6:55
  I'm Kayev right away. No, a pundit.
• 6:58
  You're not Kayev right away. A pundit you put there for 30
• 7:01
  days and a pundit is defined as a.
• 7:05
  So again, there are there are different definitions given for
• 7:09
  it. Some say that it's something
• 7:11
  that's rented by the day rather than by the month, OK, or by the
• 7:16
  year, right? So something that you rent, you
• 7:18
  pay per night, right? So that's a pundit.
• 7:21
  Others say that a pundit is a place where you have no, you
• 7:27
  have no Kenyan in the muck him. In other words, if you rent an
• 7:30
  apartment and you want to hang up a picture of the Bubba Sally,
• 7:33
  so obviously you can hang up a picture of the Bubba Sally.
• 7:35
  I'm renting the apartment for a year.
• 7:36
  I could hang up on the wall whatever I want.
• 7:39
  If you rent the timber up north and you start hanging up
• 7:41
  pictures on the wall, right, the guy's going to shoot you.
• 7:44
  Why? Because it's not yours.
• 7:45
  You're just renting the histamptious of the mucken.
• 7:49
  Whereas when you rent an apartment, you're not renting
• 7:51
  the histamptious of the mucken, you're renting the physical
• 7:53
  things. That's some of the differences
• 7:55
  between a punda and irregular cirrus.
• 7:58
  OK, says there are more who have been the shell bias deny Kasaja.
• 8:04
  And as let's say your your friend lives half the year in
• 8:09
  Florida and you're going to be in wherever for a week and you
• 8:14
  call him up and you say, Schlemme, you mind if I borrow
• 8:16
  your house for a week? He said sure, no problem.
• 8:18
  Here's the combination. Make yourself comfortable.
• 8:20
  So that's a shell. So a shell also is going to be
• 8:23
  putter for 30 days, right? And as if the guy that you're
• 8:29
  borrowing from is not religious and he doesn't have mezuzah up.
• 8:32
  So you put there for 30 days. Hov gimmel hasseka bias Migoy
• 8:37
  Hayev in mezuzah. If you rent A home from a
• 8:41
  gentile, you are high in mezuzah says the Shah.
• 8:46
  Well, after isolation you in the Hutzlarz like like before after
• 8:49
  30 days in Hutzlarzabehritz Israel Miyad.
• 8:52
  If you rent the home from an Arab, you hive right away.
• 8:55
  So what's the fiddish now? We just said this in the
• 8:57
  previous sift. What's the fiddish that the
• 8:59
  landlord is is a is a guy rather than a Jew.
• 9:03
  Camache Milan the lawyer I'm renown cave on Shahabaya
• 9:06
  Shalaya. You might have a half a minute
• 9:10
  to say when is a tenant hive in mezuzah when the owner is
• 9:14
  Jewish. But what if the what if the
• 9:19
  owner is a non Jew? So maybe the diva is part there.
• 9:22
  So we don't say that as long as there's no Sakana, as if the non
• 9:32
  Jewish landlord is going to see a mezuzah and he's going to flip
• 9:36
  out because he's going to say you're doing kishuv or, or
• 9:40
  whatever's going on over there and it's going to come to a
• 9:42
  Sakana. So then you would be part there.
• 9:45
  But if the landlord is just renting the apartment and he's a
• 9:48
  regular normal non Jew who's not going to get nervous if you put
• 9:51
  up a mezuzah, so then you hive in mezuzah.
• 9:55
  What if the owner is Jewish and it's he he has a deal just to
• 9:58
  rent out as a rental? Is he hired to put up a mezuzah?
• 10:02
  The question being asked is that you have a massacre and a sofa.
• 10:05
  You have a landlord and a tenant.
• 10:07
  So let's say the landlord does not have a tenant, right?
• 10:10
  You own an apartment and there it's Israel.
• 10:12
  For instance, the guy lives in Teaneck, he owns an apartment
• 10:15
  and there it's Israel. He rents it out.
• 10:17
  Now, at the moment it's been empty for the last three months.
• 10:21
  Is it hive and misses or not? That's the question I think that
• 10:24
  evasive is asking. The answer is that it's Potter.
• 10:26
  Somebody who owns an apartment and does not live there is
• 10:31
  Potter from Mezuzah. So for instance, last night I
• 10:34
  went to Urushalayam because I have a cousin who bought an
• 10:37
  apartment in Urushalayam and he called me up a few months ago
• 10:42
  and he said he needs mezuzahs because he has his apartment in
• 10:44
  Yerushalayim. So I said, well, you know, you
• 10:47
  live in Lakewood, why do you need mezuzahs?
• 10:51
  Is anybody living there? He said no, nobody's living
• 10:53
  there. So this is exactly your
• 10:54
  question. So I told him it's part they're
• 10:55
  from mezuzahs. So he called me up two days ago
• 10:58
  and he told me that his sister-in-law is moving in
• 11:00
  tomorrow today, right? The system was moving in today,
• 11:04
  so now he needs mezuzahs because someone's going to be living
• 11:07
  there. So I said OK, you're right.
• 11:09
  So I went last night and I put up mezuzahs for him.
• 11:11
  Are you going to say they're only moving in today?
• 11:14
  Client Kennievski talks about that.
• 11:16
  We'll discuss that some other time.
• 11:18
  But once the point is that as long as nobody's living, so if a
• 11:22
  guy the issue, no, there's no fee of mezuzah.
• 11:25
  There's no fee of mezuzah. As long as there's nobody living
• 11:27
  in the apartment, there's no fee of mezuzah.
• 11:30
  Last night I made a bracha. Even though the apartment was
• 11:34
  empty. Of course, it's within a day or
• 11:36
  two of somebody coming. So a prime Kanewski, I said a
• 11:40
  prime Kanewski I referenced before, and that's why I made a
• 11:42
  bracha, because since his refrigerator is there and his
• 11:44
  furniture is there, and his beds are there, so Prime Kanewski
• 11:47
  says that within a day or two of the people arriving to live
• 11:52
  there, one can make a bracha. There's No Fear of very big
• 11:56
  mistake. People say that once the
• 11:59
  furniture is there, it's high because the base, it's like a
• 12:02
  store, it's like a, it's like a Maxan, right?
• 12:04
  I'm storing 6 beds there and a refrigerator and a dining room
• 12:08
  table. So I'm high in Mezuza medin
• 12:10
  Maxan. So that's not correct for two
• 12:13
  reasons. First of all, we saw that there
• 12:14
  are those that hold that a Maxan is only high in Mezuza if IT
• 12:18
  services your home. But over here, the guy lives in
• 12:21
  Lakewood. The fact that he's storing a
• 12:22
  dining room table in middle of Urushilayim is not servicing his
• 12:27
  home. Are you going to say it is his
• 12:28
  home? Well, if it's his home, then
• 12:30
  it's not his storage room, says Ribil Yashev.
• 12:33
  In other words, Ribil Yashev is pointing out that there's a
• 12:36
  Mahsan and there's Adira. So Yukayev to put a mezuza on a
• 12:41
  mahsan when it's a mahsan. But this guy bought an apartment
• 12:45
  in Urusha lion. He didn't buy a mahsan in Urusha
• 12:47
  Lion. He bought a base dira in Urusha
• 12:49
  Lion. And no one's living in the base
• 12:51
  dira. So a base dira that no one's
• 12:53
  living in is not a base dira. It's Potter, even though it's
• 12:56
  furnished. Even though it's furnished, says
• 12:58
  Irfan Kadyevski. But a day or two before the
• 13:00
  person moves in, then already you can put that's already
• 13:03
  called tilas Dior and and you can put up a mezuza.
• 13:07
  So that's what I that's what I did for the guy last night.
• 13:11
  Boy owns the furniture. If a guy owns the furniture, it
• 13:16
  doesn't make a difference if he owns the furniture.
• 13:18
  I'm renting the apartment. If he were living in the
• 13:20
  apartment with you would be no. So that's a Shiloh.
• 13:23
  That's a Shiloh. If you have, let's say, I'll
• 13:25
  tell you where it would be Negea.
• 13:26
  If you have a from person in Harvard, right and he's renting
• 13:30
  an off campus apartment. So you have one or two Jews
• 13:33
  living in an apartment with one or two games.
• 13:35
  So that's Mama shirts. So that's where you would have
• 13:37
  the Shyla. So that's what there are more we
• 13:39
  saw said that the shirts versus Potter, right.
• 13:42
  So there are those that want to say that maybe on the room and I
• 13:44
  was let's say the two Jewish guys have their own room in the
• 13:47
  apartment and maybe that room would be high if that's a
• 13:50
  discussion. OK, rage pay Zion sif aleph in
• 13:54
  Hapesa Hayeb mezuzah LMKN yashleh state Mezuzah.
• 13:58
  By the way, I'll just mention that Rabiruk official Perlau and
• 14:02
  other place came hauled in the case that I was talking about
• 14:05
  where the guy has the apartment in the urinal and he does not
• 14:07
  live there. He's he is Hayef.
• 14:09
  So I'll give you an example. You have a person he he's a he's
• 14:12
  a you know, a well off person. He owns an apartment in America.
• 14:16
  He owns an apartment in arts Israel.
• 14:17
  He owns an apartment in Florida, right.
• 14:20
  He goes to all three Yomtiff, whatever summertime and then and
• 14:23
  he says, you know what, I have an extra 20 million in the bank.
• 14:26
  I'm going to buy a cabin in Switzerland right now.
• 14:30
  I'm going to go to Switzerland once a year for two weeks.
• 14:34
  So he buys the cabin and he pays somebody to set it up for him
• 14:37
  and it's furnished and it's ready And there's, there's a
• 14:39
  cereal in the pantry. You know, the the property
• 14:43
  manager tells him whenever you want get on a flight, it's
• 14:46
  ready. The linens are on the bed, says
• 14:48
  a roofing official. Pearlot and others that he is
• 14:52
  high of not like what I told you before, because they say that a
• 14:56
  that that a Deira based Deira is a residence.
• 15:00
  So once it's ready to be inhabited, knows the linens are
• 15:03
  on the bed, this cereal in the pantry.
• 15:05
  So that's your residence now, as DIRA doesn't mean I actually
• 15:10
  have to have slept there. Dira means that it's a residence
• 15:14
  of mine. So once it's ready now, as long
• 15:16
  as it's still doing construction, it's part that's
• 15:18
  the coulee Alma. But once it's ready and the beds
• 15:21
  are in and the cabinets are in and the refrigerators in, so
• 15:24
  then that's a residence. The residence is kind of that's
• 15:26
  what they hope, but we don't we don't pass in that way.
• 15:28
  Simon rage pay Zain and ASA pezza hyebi mezuzah Aloha aleph
• 15:34
  aina pezza hyebi mezuzah. LMK mezuzahs humashka if you
• 15:39
  have to have two posts and a lentil.
• 15:43
  So there's a shack and a taz over here.
• 15:46
  Let's see the taz. He speaks it out a little more
• 15:48
  by Ritas Petour cost of him aina mashkev shadel zakovolov lamala
• 15:52
  yoshar. So this is just Thomasoid
• 15:54
  halacha. Ella Evan Nicholas Vevenyatze.
• 15:57
  Aisha Aina Mazuzi Yoshara. Ella Evan Nicholas Vevenyatze
• 16:00
  Potter. This is similar.
• 16:03
  We mentioned this a few days ago.
• 16:06
  There's something called a Pesach and there's something
• 16:07
  called a pirza, right? So like in the cartoons when the
• 16:10
  guy goes through the wall, right?
• 16:12
  So you have technically it's a doorway, right?
• 16:16
  Yeah. I could walk through that now,
• 16:17
  right? It's it's life-size, but it's
• 16:19
  still going to be putter. Why?
• 16:21
  Because it's appeared. So what defines it as appeared?
• 16:23
  So rather than a Pesach, this taz the fact that it's uneven,
• 16:27
  it's jagged. A regular doorway has smooth
• 16:31
  posts and a smooth lentil and it's a normal entryway.
• 16:34
  But if you have a jagged thing knows you have, you know, you're
• 16:39
  hired Arabs to make you a halal and they come with a
• 16:42
  sledgehammer and they bust a hole in the wall right which
• 16:45
  they're walking through. That's how they're doing the
• 16:47
  construction for you. So if it's a pass F to the halal
• 16:51
  Teret says no, because it's not smooth posts.
• 16:53
  It's jagged. That's this task task continues
• 16:57
  Pasaf Shanley ella mezuzah akas. What if a passive only has one
• 17:01
  post Rashi, a tour, a tour, right.
• 17:08
  This is the tour. But it's shame the rush that he
• 17:10
  that he's quoting now. Kagaine Shamit said effort over
• 17:12
  a Kaisala Hollomi passive. Kazaire sad.
• 17:16
  You mean Kazakh smile, Potter. So what he's saying is there's
• 17:21
  pictures emotional to ours, but I made my own pictures over
• 17:24
  here. Let's say you have a person is
• 17:28
  walking into the apartments over here on the right side, you have
• 17:32
  a wall that's flush straight across and knows there's no post
• 17:36
  on the right side. Where's the post?
• 17:38
  The post is on the left side. So such an instance is going to
• 17:42
  be putter. However, according to the rush,
• 17:44
  what about this case? We have a post on the right side
• 17:47
  as you're entering and it's the left side that's flush.
• 17:50
  So then you would be putter. So this is very, very, very
• 17:54
  common in hallways, especially here in apartment statements and
• 17:58
  Arity Shrell extremely common. You're in the living room, the
• 18:01
  salon as it's known, and you're walking into the hallway.
• 18:04
  It's very common that you will have one of these two scenarios
• 18:08
  that you'll have a post on one side, but the other wall is
• 18:12
  flush. So that's what this Taz is
• 18:14
  quoting, the shame, the tour who's quoting the rush that that
• 18:18
  would be high. So this is a Makhlakis hat
• 18:20
  place, Kim, right? The Mahabir says clearly you
• 18:22
  need 2 posts and a lentil. So according to the Spaden,
• 18:26
  there's nothing to talk about. But according to others, right,
• 18:30
  the rush specifically, if you have one post, if that post is
• 18:35
  on the right side, you're going to be high.
• 18:37
  If now where? Bozner points out that that's
• 18:40
  only if there's something on the left side, right, like the
• 18:43
  picture we just saw. So there's a post on the right
• 18:46
  and there's a wall on the left. But sometimes the person's
• 18:49
  apartment is situated such that there's a post on the right as I
• 18:52
  go in the hallway, but on the left side there's nothing.
• 18:55
  You know, the kitchen is on the right side and the salon is on
• 18:58
  the left side and and the bedroom is pushing into the
• 19:03
  salon. So the hallway starts on the
• 19:06
  right side with a post in the salon, but the left side is
• 19:11
  still the kitchen. It's open.
• 19:12
  There's no wall over there. So it wasn't says that's not
• 19:14
  right according to anybody. So a wall very good.
• 19:20
  So the question being is, is what's called in in halotic
• 19:24
  parlance, a safe Kaisel, a safe Kaisel or a safe Tikra?
• 19:28
  Is that a HIV? Which means we're exactly the
• 19:31
  way you described it, where a wall ends knows do you need an
• 19:35
  actual post or if the wall just ends?
• 19:39
  And again, this is most common by hallways.
• 19:41
  When you're entering the hallway from your salon, living room,
• 19:45
  dining room into the hallway to the bedrooms.
• 19:48
  It's very, very common that there's no posts at all.
• 19:52
  But there is a Hess over there. There's a there's a doorway that
• 19:56
  you're you're entering into a tunnel, right.
• 19:59
  So, so this is a so this is a Shyla.
• 20:01
  This is a big this gets too long to go into now.
• 20:04
  It's a big Shiloh. Every case needs to needs to be
• 20:07
  asked because they are very delicate nuances that can change
• 20:13
  the Shiloh mamish from the one foot or even 1 inch to to the
• 20:19
  next. So it's a discussion base by
• 20:23
  Ashley, Mezuzah, Mikano, Mikan the keeper.
• 20:26
  Come in, Cassius, I'll say ha Mezuzais, the Mochem Hamashgif.
• 20:42
  So this is also one of the most this is one of the most lengthy.
• 20:49
  This is one of the most lengthy and complicated hellafic
• 20:52
  sections of Hilfis mezuzah, which is also very negate the
• 20:55
  Hilfis Ariven. And you can give a week's worth
• 20:58
  of shiram on this, but the Mahabir says it in two lines,
• 21:03
  and that is if you have what's known in English as an arch, an
• 21:06
  archway. So an archway.
• 21:09
  The Mahabir says over here that in order to be Hayev, you have
• 21:13
  to have mizuza mikan O Mikan, a post on the right and the left
• 21:19
  the keeper come in Cassius, I'll stay how mezuzahs.
• 21:22
  And on top of the two posts you have an arch bemock and hamash
• 21:26
  gave in lieu of a lentil. So that's what the Mahabir is
• 21:29
  saying. And Yezhba gave a ham mezuzahs.
• 21:32
  If the two posts are 10 fathim high or yezer Hayev.
• 21:37
  So then this doorway needs a mezuzah because why?
• 21:42
  Because the the archway is in lieu of in place of a lentil now
• 21:51
  as we consider the arch as a lentil.
• 21:54
  But again, he's making a proviso that you have two posts that are
• 21:58
  at least 10 Falcom high. What?
• 22:00
  What's he coming La Fouque? Is coming La Fouque, an archway
• 22:05
  that starts from the floor, right?
• 22:07
  Where somebody actually sent me a picture yesterday of a brand
• 22:10
  new apartment in Florida and he wanted to know, showed me a
• 22:14
  picture, I could show it to you of of an apartment that actually
• 22:18
  has in the living room, dining room area, an archway that
• 22:23
  starts from the floor. I never saw such a thing before
• 22:26
  in normal living quarters, but that's the way they have it.
• 22:33
  Yeah. OK, so there you go.
• 22:35
  So according to the macabre, this would be Potter.
• 22:37
  According to Rashi, it's Hayat and many Iranians say that one
• 22:41
  should be Machmere to be Rajeshvi Rashi.
• 22:43
  But the macabre baskins that it's Potter then ain't like
• 22:46
  assert for him Potter? If so, if you don't, you know,
• 22:50
  if you don't have posts of tent for him high, then it's Potter
• 22:53
  Nation ain't like Mashkaif. Because what the macabre is
• 22:56
  saying is that if it starts from the ground, so then you don't
• 22:59
  have a lentil. If I have posts that are tent
• 23:02
  vachem high, then I consider the arch as a lentil.
• 23:06
  But if it starts from the ground, where's your lentil?
• 23:09
  That's the Mahabir's taina, and therefore the Mahabir says it's
• 23:13
  partly. Now there's a separate mahlakis,
• 23:15
  which we don't have time to go into about where do you put the
• 23:18
  mezuza? Now let's say the Mahabir's
• 23:21
  case. You have posts that are tent
• 23:23
  vachem high and then you have an arch that goes on top of that.
• 23:26
  So the doorway, so tenths far from high is only waist high.
• 23:29
  The doorway itself is 7 feet high, right?
• 23:32
  Let's say it's a wide doorway and and you have an archway.
• 23:36
  So where do you put the mezuza? You put the mezuza by your
• 23:38
  waist, put the mezuza tefa below your waist, put the mezuza on
• 23:42
  the arch. But the Mahaba seems to be
• 23:44
  saying that the arch is the lentil.
• 23:45
  If the arch is the lentil, can't put you mezuza on your lentil.
• 23:48
  So this is so this is a very, very big Macleicus.
• 23:54
  There's a safer called inside stamp that has diagrams and
• 23:57
  gives some basic guidelines. But if you look in any safer on
• 24:00
  health is Mazus, you'll see that they they tell you where to put
• 24:04
  the Mazus. If the posts themselves are like
• 24:10
  that, the pastas is that that would be the same as like as
• 24:14
  that. That's the that's like a shrift
• 24:17
  also come in shrift. So I believe if I'm not
• 24:19
  mistaken, has the same din as a. The boards are there for a
• 24:31
  different thing. The boards are there so that the
• 24:33
  string of the a RIV is directly above the post.
• 24:37
  They're nervous that the that the string might move, so they
• 24:40
  make a wider base at the bottom to ensure that the string is
• 24:43
  above the post. If you look at the TAZ, he says
• 24:46
  an astonishing astonished. Actually we're not up to it yet.
• 24:50
  Let's foresee the Ramadan. We'll see what I think is an
• 24:53
  astonishing pass Hagar the culture Kane pass actually by
• 24:56
  Greba Assarat for him the pottery missus.
• 24:59
  So this actually is more negae than you think It's again, very
• 25:03
  often people make what's called a crawl space.
• 25:05
  Why is it called a crawl? Why is it called a crawl space?
• 25:08
  Because you have to crawl to be inside of it.
• 25:11
  So where is that? That's usually either a storage
• 25:14
  area that's created under a staircase or an attic, right?
• 25:19
  Somebody has in their attic. So in such instances there is a
• 25:23
  door, but that door is not 1012M high says there I'm a so it's
• 25:27
  Potomi Mezuza. And then here there I'm a quotes
• 25:31
  the famous Mariel with the Mariel says I'm meaning this
• 25:34
  passionate with Medina Zelu. There is a mimic that has spread
• 25:39
  the rave Olum most of the veldt Sainton al mezuzah akhas the
• 25:44
  assignment on a single mezuzah chaisen al pasar batheem that
• 25:49
  they make at the entrance of their home, meaning they don't
• 25:53
  have any other mezuzahs the aini nothing.
• 25:56
  This mimic is wrong. The aim lahem almache ismaku.
• 26:01
  There's no limit source lahain call Eurasia Mayim attacking
• 26:06
  basic adinai the collapse of him and therefore a person is erasia
• 26:10
  mayim should put up missus's. Now if I was reading this or
• 26:15
  writing this, I would say why should Erasia mayim put up
• 26:17
  missus? Because this guy even missus
• 26:20
  right says it has something. I don't know.
• 26:22
  It's very I don't know. Pick your own adjective, says
• 26:26
  the taz and sifkat and dalid. The enlahem al nashi is because
• 26:30
  they have nothing to rely on. Should call me shinoga yirasili
• 26:33
  Kimberly by anyone who has an iota of Yira Shamayim who writes
• 26:38
  Aleisha Bethak MI Mira rujais Royce and he wants to have
• 26:43
  security in his home. Haas Vishalam, yeah, me Mary
• 26:48
  Rufus Royce has to show him, yes, and mezuzah is the hopes of
• 26:51
  her. So the task seems to be saying
• 26:53
  the exact opposite of the famous Rambam.
• 26:56
  There's a very famous Rambam where the Rambam more or less
• 26:59
  says that anybody who puts up a mezuzah for protection is a
• 27:02
  Russia and an Epicurus and he's going straight to go ahead and
• 27:05
  then and ain't like Felix Leila Mahaba and whatever.
• 27:11
  Very not nice things that the Ramam has to say about such a
• 27:14
  person. So what's the Ramam point?
• 27:16
  Why should you put up a mezuzah? Because Hashem said put up a
• 27:19
  mezuzah. It's one of the 613 mitzvahs
• 27:21
  period. There happens to be a side
• 27:24
  benefit that you get protection, which is very nice.
• 27:26
  I'll take it. But that's not why you put up a
• 27:28
  mezuzah. Now again, so if I was reading
• 27:31
  this Rama and I was saying the inland Mamachi ismiku will hang
• 27:34
  your eyes, your mind should put up a mezuzah because you're high
• 27:37
  of says the taz. No, you should be.
• 27:39
  No, you should put up a mezuzah because if you have any Irish
• 27:42
  shamayim and you want to be safe, put up a mezuzah.
• 27:47
  I don't know. It's very funny thing to say.
• 27:50
  Yeah, but it would seem from the Rambam that that if that's going
• 27:53
  to be your pitch better not to be Makarov, then that's the
• 27:57
  Rambam was a was a hardliner.