Latest / re:Play with Greg Off / Charlie Rosen — Building the Great Video Game Songbook
Transcript
- 0:00kind of like you're like an interior designer
- 0:01right it's like the architect builds a building
- 0:03and the interior designer can be like cool this
- 0:05is great but if we knock down this wall and make
- 0:07an open floor plan and put this kind of furniture
- 0:09in and like update this hardware and paint the
- 0:11walls this color the house will still have its
- 0:13character but it can be like this whole new feeling
- 0:15you know that's what an arranger does right so
- 0:18i'm used to doing this with broadway music all
- 0:19the time and a little bit of film and tv and
- 0:21so i thought i'm going to do this with my favorite
- 0:22video game music Hello, everyone. Welcome to
- 0:31Replay. I'm Greg Off. My guest today is one of
- 0:34the most interesting figures making music in
- 0:36and around games right now. And he didn't even
- 0:38start there. He grew up in the San Fernando Valley,
- 0:41the son of a classical bassist and an organist.
- 0:44He started playing rock guitar at 10, switched
- 0:47to drums in high school jazz band, picked up
- 0:49the bass somewhere in the middle, and then moved
- 0:52to New York City at 17 years old, straight out
- 0:54of high school to play at Broadway Pit. 12 Broadway
- 0:58credits later, he's a Tony Award winner for Some
- 1:01Like It Hot. And along the way, he started something
- 1:03on the side. A 35 to 65 piece jazz orchestra
- 1:08dedicated to the proposition that video game
- 1:11music belongs in the canon. The 8 -Bit Big Band.
- 1:16Five albums in, three Grammys, including a win
- 1:19this February for, of all things, a gospel arrangement
- 1:22of a Super Mario themed medley. He calls what
- 1:26he is building the great video game songbook,
- 1:29and he's dead serious about it. His name is Charlie
- 1:32Rosen. Charlie, welcome to Replay. Charlie, welcome
- 1:42to Replay. Thanks for having me. Great intro.
- 1:45Thank you. Yeah, it's a mouthful, but you got
- 1:48a lot going on my friend. And before we even
- 1:51dive in, I mean, we have a lot to talk about.
- 1:54I wanted to tell you like from the bottom of
- 1:57my heart, your music brings me joy. Oh man, thank
- 2:00you. I appreciate that. Well, it's a joy to make,
- 2:03so I'm glad it's translating. I love it. And
- 2:06thankfully, the algorithm gods at YouTube somehow
- 2:09surfaced up your channel a while back, about
- 2:12six, seven months ago. And I binge listened to
- 2:16everything. So I just want to say when you compose
- 2:41like these, you know, for me, epic pieces of
- 2:45some of the most iconic songs in gaming, and
- 2:47then they come together, you know, what does
- 2:49that feel like for you? Yeah, I mean, I've always
- 2:53been a fan of like big, like big sounding ensembles,
- 2:58big orchestras, big film scores, now recently
- 3:00video game scores, large ensemble jazz orchestras,
- 3:03like anything that involves like a large group
- 3:05of musicians playing together at the same time.
- 3:07that's always been like the thing that draws
- 3:09me in because there is like like a greater than
- 3:13the sum of its parts musical experience of having
- 3:15like that much air just like moving towards you
- 3:17as an audience member or yeah conducting that
- 3:20much air and being in front of an ensemble that
- 3:22size and feeling it hit you uh you know there's
- 3:25something like very magical and human about large
- 3:27ensemble music in general so i've always been
- 3:29drawn to that Uh, and I've always wanted to arrange
- 3:32or compose for those kinds of things. And so,
- 3:35you know, this naturally, I sort of want to lead
- 3:37into like how the band got started and a little
- 3:39bit more about my history, but it's like, is
- 3:41it time for that? Or is that the answer to your
- 3:43question? Absolutely. No. And I, I was going
- 3:46to go straight there next, you know, I didn't
- 3:48want to get too far ahead of ourselves. Um, I
- 3:50just, I just needed a, you know, I, the music
- 3:53itself is just, it's. so amazing. And, you know,
- 3:57hearing it in that way with, with a big, huge
- 3:59band like that, it just, it's kind of blows me
- 4:02away. So I just, I had to get that out there
- 4:04before we jumped in. There's a great variety
- 4:06of different ways to approach expanding music
- 4:09for a large ensemble like that, which we can
- 4:11get more into later. Absolutely. I hope we will.
- 4:14Sounds good, my friend. So yeah, let's get back
- 4:16to it. So, you know, before we get to the band
- 4:19and the Grammys and all of those things, you
- 4:21know, I want to start where, where you started,
- 4:23which was San Fernando Valley, your mom's a classical
- 4:27bassist, your dad's an organist, I believe also
- 4:31a banjo player. You clearly are from a family
- 4:37that loves music. I think you started on guitar
- 4:40at an early age, maybe 10 or so. And by high
- 4:43school, you're a drummer in the jazz band. Yeah.
- 4:46Was there a moment growing up where music and
- 4:49games were already wired together? It's kind
- 4:52of funny, and this probably will naturally lead
- 4:54into the origin story of the band, which if you're
- 4:56curious about, I will happily segue myself into.
- 4:58Please. Okay, great. Go for it. I actually started
- 5:01on piano when I was really young. When I was
- 5:04three years old, I was playing piano. Wow. You
- 5:06know, and my parents figured out that I had perfect
- 5:09pitch at a very young age. And so that sort of
- 5:11naturally led into wanting to learn instruments.
- 5:13And luckily, yeah, both of them are very diverse
- 5:17musicians themselves. And so recognized early
- 5:19on, like, oh, there's something he has perfect
- 5:21pitch. And it actually runs in my family. My
- 5:23dad has perfect pitch. And so did his mom. Kind
- 5:24of a funny thing. So I was taking like piano
- 5:27lessons from a young age. And actually, before
- 5:29I started playing guitar, I was taking some flute
- 5:31lessons and some cello lessons. And it wasn't
- 5:33until like. you know, you start to get into your
- 5:36early teenage years that you start to develop
- 5:37like your own musical sense and everybody wanted
- 5:40to play in bands. My friends were playing in
- 5:41bands and I wanted to play the guitar. So I started
- 5:42learning guitar and, uh, and you know, bass and
- 5:46drums at the same time when I was in high school,
- 5:48like you said, I was playing drums mostly. I
- 5:51thought, okay, I'm going to be a drummer. This
- 5:52is going to be great. Uh, and then every single
- 5:55bass player's origin story basically is, uh,
- 5:58there was nobody to play the bass. So I started
- 5:59playing bass that that's just sort of like most
- 6:02of the time how bass players are born into existence
- 6:04and so this was no exception i was playing in
- 6:07an after -school jazz program that needed a bass
- 6:09player i started playing bass i was playing bass
- 6:11in some of my band my friends bands also and
- 6:14then i ended up going to college as a bass player
- 6:16off and on at berkeley school of music mostly
- 6:18because i played a lot of instruments and i thought
- 6:20what's the instrument i'm most likely going to
- 6:22get in on based on the amount of those instruments
- 6:24that are at the school and i needed a scholarship
- 6:27and so i chose bass and then i became that's
- 6:29how i like became a bass player, like my university
- 6:32instrument, the instrument I've spent the most
- 6:34money learning how to play is the bass is the
- 6:36way I like to put it in terms of lessons and
- 6:38tuition, you know? Yeah. And so I spent then,
- 6:42like you said, I moved to New York to play in
- 6:45a Broadway musical when I was 17. And I've had
- 6:48like a pretty involved theater career since then.
- 6:50And in the 2010s, I was mostly playing bass in
- 6:53New York in pits and as a side musician in bands
- 6:55and for people's gigs and for singers and that
- 6:57kind of thing. And slowly over the course of
- 6:59the 2010s, my desire to do more like arranging,
- 7:02composing, conducting, music directing, mostly
- 7:05in theater, kind of slowly overtook being a side
- 7:08musician. Now, mostly that's what I do. Maybe
- 7:11a couple times a year, I still play bass in a
- 7:13gig as purely a side musician that I'm not actually
- 7:16band leading. But mostly my bass, sadly, my upright
- 7:20bass that I've spent way too much money on mostly
- 7:22sits in the closet these days, sadly enough.
- 7:26as far as the band's origin story uh i've always
- 7:30been you know the first game console i ever had
- 7:32was 1996 it was the nintendo 64 that was the
- 7:34first one which i fell in love with and then
- 7:37after that me and my father went to a lot of
- 7:39like garage sales and looking in magazines like
- 7:42one was called the penny saver do you remember
- 7:43the penny saver oh yeah absolutely before there
- 7:46was craigslist you would like before craigslist
- 7:48yeah that's right and we would it would be like
- 7:50oh atari 2600 with 40 cartridges for 50 bucks
- 7:54let's go buy it Oh, Super Nintendo or Nintendo
- 7:56or Genesis. So I had all these like old game
- 7:58consoles growing up that I really loved. And
- 8:00I had a Game Boy, eventually a PS2. Anyway, the
- 8:03point being is like, I've always been a musician.
- 8:05I've always been a gamer. And just consequently,
- 8:08you know, these themes are like really legendary
- 8:10from a lot of these games, you know, growing
- 8:13up and they really stuck in there. So I would
- 8:14learn to play them on the instruments that I
- 8:16was playing. Or, you know, my mom plays many
- 8:18different woodwind instruments, actually. And
- 8:20she had an ocarina around the house. So I like
- 8:21learned all the ocarina songs on her ocarina.
- 8:24you know and things like that and so i've always
- 8:25grew up listening to all kinds of music but the
- 8:30soundtracks of video games were always very prevalent
- 8:32because i was a gamer and that's going to become
- 8:34important in a sec um in high school i started
- 8:38fooling around with arranging music for my school's
- 8:41band and i think i i actually did an arrangement
- 8:43of bob on battlefield for my high school jazz
- 8:46band which i have no idea what happened to it
- 8:48it's long gone it probably sucks i don't want
- 8:51to see it it's probably terrible but i did do
- 8:53it and i remember like downloading audacity and
- 8:55recording like a song from super mario sunshine
- 8:57on the guitar and stuff like that anyway fast
- 9:00forward about 20 years it's like 2016 17 uh i
- 9:06me and my girlfriend at the time and i don't
- 9:09say that because we broke up i say that because
- 9:10we're now engaged uh we took a like congratulations
- 9:13thank you thank you we took um like a very impromptu
- 9:18trip to japan it was like 2017 we found these
- 9:22tickets from some discount website it was like
- 9:24a 700 round trip ticket plane ticket to japan
- 9:27which is if people travel japan is like really
- 9:29cheap to go to japan you know so we were like
- 9:31let's go let's just do it and we did it and we
- 9:34were staying in kyoto in these airbnbs and one
- 9:36of the airbnbs that we were staying in happened
- 9:38to be on the same block as this very old japanese
- 9:41musical instrument store and when i go to countries
- 9:43i like to buy like a local instrument from the
- 9:46area or something and maybe take a lesson and
- 9:48like connect with the musician so i bought a
- 9:50shamisen which is like a traditional japanese
- 9:51guitar shaped instrument doesn't have frets it
- 9:55has three silk strings and you you play it with
- 9:58this gigantic guitar pick that kind of looks
- 10:00like a putty knife uh and i've like always wanted
- 10:02one great so i bought one that instrument the
- 10:06store has been open for like 300 years or something
- 10:08crazy And a friend of mine who plays in my band's
- 10:11name is Zach Zinger, and he plays a Japanese
- 10:12flute called a shakuhachi. And he studied in
- 10:16Japan, so he had all these friends that play
- 10:18these various traditional cultural Japanese instruments.
- 10:21And he said, oh, you should meet my friend who
- 10:23plays koto and shamisen. He'll give you a lesson
- 10:26in Tokyo. So I went to Tokyo, and I met up with
- 10:31this guy, and his name is Kazushi Okimasa. And
- 10:33he plays shamisen and koto. And specifically,
- 10:36well, we had a lesson. on the shamisen and koto
- 10:40he taught me a little bit of both it was really
- 10:41fun we really connected it was awesome and after
- 10:44the lesson i saw that on his desk he had like
- 10:47a soundtrack of a somewhat obscure video game
- 10:51in the states but it's way more popular in japan
- 10:53the series is called ganbare goemon um in the
- 10:56u .s the n64 was translated as mystical ninja
- 10:59starring goemon ninja yeah which is a game that
- 11:01like I love so much, and I really loved as a
- 11:05kid, and I loved the soundtrack, but didn't get
- 11:07a lot of love, I feel like, in the U .S. But
- 11:10I'm like, oh, is that Ganbare Goemon? I love
- 11:12that game. And he was like, oh, do you like video
- 11:13game music? And I had never really thought about
- 11:17it. I'm like, yeah, I do. I mean, I'm a musician.
- 11:19I play games. Yeah, great. He was like, let me
- 11:21give you my album. Here's a gift. And his album
- 11:24is all video game music arranged for traditional
- 11:26Japanese ensembles, so like shamisen, koto, shakuhachi,
- 11:29taiko drums, those kinds of things. And I was
- 11:32listening to it on the plane and he had all these
- 11:34great arrangements. I'm like, this is so cool.
- 11:35Like I want to make a video game music album.
- 11:38And so that, by the way, his ensemble is called
- 11:41Famikoto. So Famicom's Nintendo in Japan, Koto,
- 11:44Famikoto. Everyone should check them out. Yeah,
- 11:47we'll have to throw a link for sure up there.
- 11:49You definitely should. That's like the origin
- 11:50point for my idea. And he knows it. And we hang
- 11:53out when I'm in Japan these days and he's super
- 11:55cool. We stay in touch. I was sort of like, well,
- 11:59my main career is like as a Broadway arranger
- 12:03and orchestrator. And, you know, the thing about
- 12:06Broadway arranging is, you know, and this is
- 12:11true of video games, too. People talk about Broadway
- 12:13music like it's a genre of music. Oh, I love
- 12:17musicals. Really, if you really look at it, Broadway
- 12:21musicals are not necessarily a genre in as much
- 12:24as they are like. Every genre, a Broadway show
- 12:27takes a genre of music and like repurposes that
- 12:33genre for the sake of storytelling in that show.
- 12:36And it could be any genre. And so that just means
- 12:38that whoever is working in that music department
- 12:40or orchestrating it or arranging it or composing
- 12:42it has to have a familiarity with the vocabulary
- 12:44of that genre to make it authentic. You know,
- 12:48if you're deriving these various textures from
- 12:50other genres and video games are the same thing.
- 12:52A video game music can be any genre. Video game
- 12:54music itself is treated as a genre, but it's
- 12:56not really a genre. It's a delivery vehicle,
- 12:59as is Broadway musicals. So I have kind of specialized
- 13:03in this sort of old school style of Broadway
- 13:07arranging and Hollywood style arranging and big
- 13:09band and very mid -century modern is what I like
- 13:12to call myself, of the TV and Broadway and film
- 13:16and jazz orchestras of the mid -century. That's
- 13:18what I love. And so I thought, okay, well, I'm
- 13:21going to take those skills. It's basically the
- 13:23same skill. In a Broadway show, you're presented
- 13:25with an existing song, and what we do as arrangers
- 13:27or orchestrators, whatever you want to call it,
- 13:29producers, whatever, we hear the unrealized potential
- 13:32when looking at a piece of music's raw bones.
- 13:35It's melody, it's harmony, it's chords, it's
- 13:38rhythm. We look at those things, and as arrangers,
- 13:41we say, oh, I see the potential in that to do
- 13:42all these other... things with the music kind
- 13:45of like you're like an interior designer right
- 13:47it's like the architect builds a building and
- 13:49the interior designer can be like cool this is
- 13:51great but if we knock down this wall and make
- 13:53an open floor plan and put this kind of furniture
- 13:54in and like update this hardware and paint the
- 13:56walls this color the house will still have its
- 13:59character but it can be like this whole new feeling
- 14:01you know that's what an arranger does right so
- 14:03i'm used to doing this with broadway music all
- 14:05the time and a little bit of film and tv and
- 14:07so i thought i'm going to do this with my favorite
- 14:08video game music so i got home and i started
- 14:10arranging like nine or 10 songs. And that became
- 14:13the first album of the band, not really having
- 14:16any awareness that there was like such a massive,
- 14:19massive scene for covers of video game music
- 14:22that exists primarily on YouTube and the internet
- 14:24and otherwise, uh, we're sort of like in this
- 14:27golden era of video game music covers. Uh, and
- 14:30so YouTube is kind of like the tin pan alley,
- 14:32you know, a video game to use an outdated reference.
- 14:36But the cool thing, I released this album and
- 14:39I released all the videos on YouTube and really
- 14:40rapidly we started getting these fans and it
- 14:43started growing. And what I quickly realized
- 14:45is the similarities between jazz and video game
- 14:47music. The big picture thing that's so great
- 14:50about it is like learning to play jazz music.
- 14:54We have these things called jazz standards, right?
- 14:56Where when you learn to play jazz, every single
- 14:58person, when they start learning to play jazz,
- 15:00learns the same set of songs as like. standards
- 15:03that everyone knows. So jazz musicians can walk
- 15:05into any jazz club and say, let's play this.
- 15:08Great. We all know this song. Usually those songs
- 15:10are from pop music from the way early last century.
- 15:15Like for example, one song is called all the
- 15:17things you are. Right. And so everybody who learns
- 15:19to play jazz learns all the things you are. It
- 15:21is the like standard, standard jazz song, but
- 15:24nobody alive today has seen the 1930. eight or
- 15:30whatever production of very warm for may on broadway
- 15:33by jerome kern that that song came from like
- 15:34no nobody has no there's no way it's impossible
- 15:37but yet we all this song now has another life
- 15:40beyond its original vehicle much in the same
- 15:43way that like bob on battlefield even though
- 15:45you know we were alive but a lot of like younger
- 15:48musicians who are playing video game music and
- 15:51there's now like jazz clubs playing video game
- 15:52music and you know They all know Bob on Battlefield.
- 15:55It's like a video game music standard. But like
- 15:58some of them weren't alive in 1996 when that
- 16:01game came out. But there's still like a whole
- 16:03scene for it. And the song has gone on to have
- 16:05like another life as a standard repertoire of
- 16:08like a canon of music. Jazz musicians, always
- 16:10their job has been to take canons of music and
- 16:13reinterpret them. It could have been Great American
- 16:14Songbook or Motown or The Beatles or Tin Pan
- 16:16Alley or Broadway musicals or film scores. whatever.
- 16:21And now that we're 40 years into video game music,
- 16:23there is now a collective body of a canon of
- 16:26music that jazz musicians can do that same thing
- 16:28to. Whether we were around for the actual games
- 16:31themselves or not, now that there's a collective
- 16:33generation of knowledge of this music, it can
- 16:35go on to become its own standalone repertoire,
- 16:38like all of these other things I just listed.
- 16:40So that is something I really realized and thought,
- 16:43there's really something to this. I think I should
- 16:44keep going. So we started making more albums
- 16:46and posting more. starting to play live and it
- 16:50just has, you know, been a journey from there.
- 17:12I mean, that's really cool. And I mean, amazing
- 17:15that, that, you know, you found that that path
- 17:19that that niche i guess for lack of a better
- 17:21word and um how you've got it you know i know
- 17:25there are plenty of other you know other artists
- 17:27out there doing something similar but uh the
- 17:30fact that you you know you've decided to go and
- 17:32start arranging this music and That has taken
- 17:36off. You've made albums. You're touring. There's
- 17:41Grammys. Also, one other thing I noticed at the
- 17:43time is even in 2016 and 17, it was not that
- 17:47long ago, but there were other large ensemble
- 17:52video game music concerts and albums, but a lot
- 17:54of them were very classical. They're super orchestral.
- 17:57They're very formal. Or they're orchestral metal.
- 18:00There's a lot of orchestral metal in video games.
- 18:03But they're very like serious. They're very serious.
- 18:05You know, there wasn't a lot of like the lighter
- 18:07side of orchestral music, like the way that like
- 18:09Ella Fitzgerald and the Rat Pack, you know, and
- 18:12like this like jazz orchestra with more like
- 18:14banter and having fun and soloists and singers
- 18:16and special guests. And it's like, we're not
- 18:18here to wear tuxes. Like I'm all for wearing
- 18:20tuxes and appreciating the majesty of video game
- 18:23music. Yes, 100%. But there's like a whole other
- 18:27side of like pops orchestra style music that's
- 18:29more fun that I didn't totally see. people necessarily
- 18:33doing it in a big scale. I mean, there's little
- 18:35people here and little bands and big people doing
- 18:38like one song and their big band that's maybe
- 18:40from Mario, but not purely dedicated to it. Now
- 18:43there's maybe like, at least to my knowledge,
- 18:46maybe three or four or five jazz, you know, video
- 18:49game music, big bands now releasing albums. I
- 18:51don't want to take credit for it, but there were
- 18:53not, that was not really happening as much in
- 18:552017. Absolutely. You're kind of on that cutting
- 18:59edge. you know so to speak um can we can we take
- 19:04it i really want to take one step back because
- 19:05it's just really interesting to me you're kind
- 19:07of your path from you know uh like high school
- 19:12you know doing music and then ending up you know
- 19:15on broadway like how did that happen how did
- 19:17that even come about like purely by chance truly
- 19:20i mean right place right time isn't that life
- 19:22yeah it really was yeah when i was in high school
- 19:25in los angeles i was a sophomore in high school
- 19:28so i was 15. And there's this institute in Los
- 19:33Angeles called Center Theater Group, and they
- 19:36produce a lot of musicals. And they also have
- 19:38this scholarship for high schoolers called the
- 19:42Spotlight Awards that I auditioned for as a sophomore
- 19:45and didn't win. Nothing. I didn't get past the
- 19:48first round. Nothing happened. Okay, whatever.
- 19:50But then they happened to send out an email to
- 19:53everybody who had ever auditioned to say like,
- 19:56hey, we're doing this new musical. The musical
- 19:58is about being in middle school. It's called
- 20:0013, the musical. And we need a cast of actual
- 20:05teenagers. And the composer has requested that
- 20:07the pit of the musical also be teenagers. No
- 20:10way. Which is a crazy ask. That's a crazy. It's
- 20:13never happened before. Never happened again as
- 20:15far as probably won't ever. But he was really
- 20:18insistent. So they had this massive audition
- 20:20for all these musicians, these high school musicians.
- 20:24And we all were in this big room. There was like
- 20:25100 of us. And I auditioned on a bunch of instruments
- 20:28and I got this gig. So I did this development
- 20:30process of it as a sophomore. And then when I
- 20:32was a junior, they produced the musical properly
- 20:34at Center Theater Group and I had this production.
- 20:36And then that production ended up transferring
- 20:38to Broadway when I was 17. And so I moved to
- 20:42New York to play in that pit, not really knowing
- 20:45I was going to fall into the world of Broadway
- 20:48musicals. For my skill set, it really couldn't
- 20:51have been a better place in terms of being a
- 20:52multi -genre, multi -instrumentalist and an arranger.
- 20:57And yeah, once I did that, I sort of was on the
- 20:59ground of this blossoming contemporary musical
- 21:04theater scene. I was meeting all these other
- 21:05composers and musicians and music directors and
- 21:08really just fell into this 2010s, 2000s and beyond
- 21:14musical theater landscape. And that really has
- 21:16led to... Yeah, no, I think he said 12 Broadway
- 21:19shows, but actually I just did my 13th that I
- 21:21orchestrated the last couple of months ago. So
- 21:23now I'm up to 13 of them. That's crazy. Yeah,
- 21:27it's been quite a journey. Well, what did being
- 21:31a pit musician, what did those years or what
- 21:35did that time teach you that you might not have
- 21:38learned at school or conservatory? So many things
- 21:41actually. And two of them, one of them is like
- 21:45kind of practical in terms of what it, what I
- 21:47do now. And one of them is kind of philosophical
- 21:49of what I do now. Two of them, actually, I would
- 21:52say two philosophical things and one practical
- 21:54thing. There's a lot of like, I get a lot of
- 21:58messages from high school and college age kids
- 22:02who like want to be an arranger and a conductor
- 22:04and they want to learn how to do this. And colleges,
- 22:07of course, they have composing programs and they
- 22:09have arranging programs, sort of. I mean, the
- 22:11more like contemporary music oriented colleges
- 22:13have more like arranging programs. But. The only
- 22:17thing that like, there are a few blind spots,
- 22:20I think, in these programs. And one of them is
- 22:21like a big focus on being like the things that
- 22:25your computer can do and play back to you as
- 22:28you're arranging are not possible on real instruments.
- 22:32And that actually is one of the big challenges
- 22:34of arranging video game music, especially early
- 22:36video game music. This stuff was never intended
- 22:39to be performed by live musicians, you know.
- 22:42The beautiful thing about the early eight bit
- 22:44and even like 16 bit stuff is like they were
- 22:47working with incredibly limited technological
- 22:50infrastructure. Right. Especially the eight bit.
- 22:53They had three like notes, three synth sounds
- 22:56that could make three notes at the same time.
- 22:58And like one noise sound that could go, you know,
- 23:01and they had to apply chords and harmony. And
- 23:03so they did all these creative things with programming
- 23:05to like. run these notes very quickly under to
- 23:08imply chords and jump around octaves and change
- 23:11the pitch. And it's amazing. It was never meant
- 23:15to be played live. And so adapting that stuff
- 23:17to live instruments is an amazing challenge.
- 23:20And that's where you run into trouble. An inexperienced
- 23:24arranger might just take those notes and put
- 23:26them directly onto a page of music and not have
- 23:29enough real world experience either playing those
- 23:32instruments or working with those types of instruments
- 23:34to know. what actually feels okay to play. A
- 23:38computer can play back anything, but that's a
- 23:39trap. And so the first practical thing is playing
- 23:43a lot of different pits, a lot of different Broadway
- 23:45musicals, sight reading a lot of music, a lot
- 23:48of different composers' music, a lot of different
- 23:49other arrangers' music, and really being like,
- 23:51that works, that doesn't work, that's fun to
- 23:54play, that's difficult to play, but it's for
- 23:55the right reason, that's difficult to play, but
- 23:57it's impossible and should never have been written,
- 23:59this should be on this instrument, just noticing
- 24:01those kinds of things. that work and don't work
- 24:04that you can only get just from like being on
- 24:06the ground and like just reading and playing
- 24:09music. And then similarly, before the 8 -Bit
- 24:12Big Band even, I had this other big band in New
- 24:13York called Charlie Rosen's Broadway Big Band
- 24:15that was in residency at a club called 54 Below,
- 24:17where I basically did the same thing as I do
- 24:19now with the 8 -Bit Big Band with Broadway music.
- 24:21And so I did that for like seven years and used
- 24:24that as a laboratory to like try stuff out. and
- 24:26be like oh that's working that's not working
- 24:28this is easy like the trumpet players love me
- 24:30the trumpet players hate me the singer loves
- 24:31me the singer hates me i'm stepping all over
- 24:33the singer there's too much trombone you know
- 24:35stuff like that you can really only work out
- 24:38just from doing it and hearing it back in real
- 24:40time uh and then the other philosophical thing
- 24:43that i feel like i've learned from my time in
- 24:45theater that i apply to everything that i do
- 24:47now including arrangements for the 8 -bit big
- 24:49band and this is something they don't teach in
- 24:52arranging class they don't teach in composing
- 24:54class it's like Thinking philosophically about
- 24:56the why, the why you're writing this, the dramaturgical,
- 25:00to use a fancy word, the dramaturgical reason
- 25:03why what you're arranging should exist. And by
- 25:08that, I mean, it's like storytelling through
- 25:13arranging, right? An arrangement should feel
- 25:15like a journey from start to finish for the listener.
- 25:18And we control these various parameters of sound,
- 25:21high notes, low notes, loud notes, soft notes,
- 25:23long notes, short notes. like gentle sounds,
- 25:26various colors in our instruments, all of these
- 25:29parameters that we control to create a dynamic
- 25:31listening experience over time. But if it's not
- 25:33motivated by a reason, then it's not as exciting
- 25:38to listen to. And so I like to say that like
- 25:40all of my arrangements, you can say in an English
- 25:43spoken sentence, like why they're meant to be
- 25:45and why they work and like what their dramaturgical
- 25:47seed is that blossoms into an arrangement. For
- 25:49example, we do this sort of like Frank Sinatra.
- 25:54style arrangement of still alive from portal
- 25:56you know and so we have these basically i sort
- 25:59of have two approaches with the band sometimes
- 26:00i listen to it and i say oh composer i know what
- 26:03you were going for i totally get it maybe it
- 26:05was the 90s you couldn't go all the way i'm going
- 26:07to really take your idea and i'm going to run
- 26:09with it and i'm going to take every additional
- 26:10genre that's like in the network of genres related
- 26:12to your genre i'm going to put it all in there
- 26:14and we're going to take it farther other times
- 26:16in the case of portal which was a fully produced
- 26:18pop song from the 2000s. I'm like, great, that's
- 26:21amazing. I'm going to take the bones of your
- 26:22song, the lyrics and the melody and the chords,
- 26:24which are amazing. And since they're amazing,
- 26:26they can hold up to being arranged in pretty
- 26:28much any style. And I'm going to go a totally
- 26:30other direction. That other direction is going
- 26:32to be based on the dramaturgical seed of what
- 26:36if Frank Sinatra had played Portal? Boom. And
- 26:38then the rest of the arrangement sort of comes
- 26:40into focus. So, and I feel like every decision
- 26:43we make as an arranger or a composer or... a
- 26:45lighting designer or a director or anything,
- 26:48it should all be motivated by some reason to
- 26:52be, you know, and that I think is what makes
- 26:54good theater and film and albums and arranging
- 26:56and songwriting and whatever. It's like, it's
- 26:59this like reason that any of your choices, all
- 27:02the choices we make as an artist should feel
- 27:03motivated by something, you know? So that's what
- 27:06I like. Is that like your North star when you,
- 27:09you know, you look at a piece of music and you're
- 27:11deciding what, like what that criteria of like
- 27:13how. how I'm going to translate this into the,
- 27:16you know, your arrangement. Yes. I feel like
- 27:19it should be any arrangement I do should have
- 27:22some sort of guiding principle behind it. And
- 27:26even in the more micro section by section, it
- 27:30can even be as simple as like, well, we just
- 27:31heard this really loud full band section. And
- 27:34so to keep things dynamic and to refresh the
- 27:36ear, why don't we break it down and just have
- 27:38like this one instrument play the melody now.
- 27:39So it doesn't have to necessarily be like a big
- 27:41picture. thematic idea, but more in the more
- 27:45microcosm of the arrangement, you should be able
- 27:47to like talk about the journey of the arrangement
- 27:49spoken, you know, for it to be successful. And
- 27:53if I might get nerdy about arranging one more
- 27:55thing, there's a really great arranger named
- 27:56Don Sebesky who did a ton of jazz arranging and
- 28:00Broadway arranging and TV and film. And he wrote
- 28:02a book that talks about how the human ear and
- 28:06brain has evolved this really cool skill. to
- 28:09be able to distinguish important audio information
- 28:13in the foreground from what it conceives as less
- 28:16important in the background. For example, you're
- 28:19in the forest and there's like birdsong, there's
- 28:21crickets, there's the rustling of the leaves,
- 28:23you know, but you hear a cougar's roar. That's
- 28:26more important, right? That's more important
- 28:28than the rustling of the leaves. That means I
- 28:30better pay attention and do something, you know.
- 28:31So what that means for arranging or producing
- 28:34or songwriting or whatever you want to call it,
- 28:35arranging is that... We should be able to manipulate
- 28:38that skill to make sure that what we want to
- 28:42be in the foreground of an arrangement, the lyrics,
- 28:44the melody, the sax solo, we should have control
- 28:47over what these levels of importance that the
- 28:50human brain conceives to make a dynamic and interesting
- 28:53listening experience wherein like maybe the bass
- 28:55is in the background, the sax is in the foreground,
- 28:57but the bass could play the melody and be in
- 28:59the foreground. The strings could be in the sort
- 29:01of middle ground playing the chords with the
- 29:02piano. But then maybe the strings could take
- 29:05over and then maybe the horns could pop in and
- 29:06play a counter melody against the main melody.
- 29:08And so the way that you move around these like
- 29:10levels of importance is also what makes a great
- 29:14arrangement. It's amazing. Did you know that
- 29:17you, you know, did you always want to, you know,
- 29:20kind of go into arranging music? I mean, you
- 29:22know, going from someone who is a musician who
- 29:25played to then, you know, transitioning to...
- 29:28doing this arranging like is that something like
- 29:31in the back of your mind that was a goal of yours
- 29:33or was that was there a moment where it was like
- 29:35aha this is this is my calling i think it's something
- 29:39i kind of always did a little bit in terms of
- 29:43like i remember getting garage band for the first
- 29:45time and recording songs and like playing all
- 29:47the instruments in and figuring out like oh it'd
- 29:49be cool if the bass played this you know that
- 29:51is arranging basically the some people would
- 29:54call it producing but producing arranging they
- 29:56really overlap If, you know, if you're, if you're
- 29:59telling instruments what to do, then you're arranging,
- 30:01you know, arranging is a more formal term for
- 30:04it. Sometimes you could just call it, well, I'm
- 30:05the band leader and we're in a rock band and
- 30:07I'm telling the drums to play this. That's, you
- 30:09know, that's arranging. That's still, that's
- 30:10also arranging. So I've always kind of done that
- 30:13like on the side, but it wasn't until I think
- 30:15I got into this world of Broadway and, you know,
- 30:19in the world of Broadway, we use the word orchestrations
- 30:21and orchestrator orchestrating. And arranging
- 30:25and technically they're like two slightly different
- 30:27jobs, but on every piece of music, it will say
- 30:29like arranged by this orchestrated by this. I'm
- 30:31like, well, you know, when I was 17, it's like,
- 30:33well, what is that? I've been fooling around
- 30:34with big band arranging in high school. And like,
- 30:36I want to look more into that. So it's, it's
- 30:39like, it was never something I put definite terms
- 30:41on as a kid, but once I got into the professional
- 30:43world and I could put a label on it, it was like,
- 30:46oh yeah, that's, I want to do that. Well, once
- 31:21you kind of dove in, you know, headfirst into
- 31:23doing video game music, was there a challenge
- 31:30convincing all of these other amazing musicians
- 31:33who presumably you were working with to kind
- 31:37of come along for the ride? You know, not really.
- 31:41I mean, over the years of the seven years living
- 31:43in New York, I've built up like quite a network
- 31:46of... performers and musicians and engineers
- 31:49and designers from various other projects along
- 31:52the way who had either done my previous big band
- 31:55or played in Broadway shows with me or done other
- 31:57recording sessions or I knew from college. And
- 32:00so when we first started out with the band, you
- 32:03know, I do pay everybody. And at the beginning
- 32:05of the band, I didn't pay them enough. And now
- 32:07I pay them more and it's probably, you know,
- 32:09it's based on their talent level, still not enough,
- 32:11but it is more standard along the lines of what
- 32:14musicians expect to be paid for a recording session.
- 32:16But back in the day it was not enough. And so
- 32:18it was like really relying on like my friends
- 32:20to be like, I have this crazy idea. Can you help
- 32:23me? Like, can you help me get it off the ground?
- 32:25We'll see what happens. You know? And luckily
- 32:26I had enough friends who were willing to do that
- 32:29for me that we could figure it out. And now,
- 32:31now that we've built up like a sizable audience
- 32:33and a sizable, like, it's not a King's ransom
- 32:37or anything. I mean, nobody starts a big band
- 32:38to get rich. There's no orchestrators getting
- 32:41rich off financing, large ensemble jazz in 2026,
- 32:45but you know, we get by and basically like I
- 32:48make pretty good money working in musical theater.
- 32:50And I usually take a chunk of that and say, great,
- 32:51this is for the next album, you know, and, and
- 32:54pay them fairly at that point. But yeah, luckily
- 32:56I had a network of musicians in the early days
- 32:58to help me start it. Are they, are the majority
- 33:02of them gamers or at least understand the allure
- 33:04of like, you know, arranging these, these pieces
- 33:09into like the music that you make? Yeah, I would
- 33:12say probably like 75 % of them. Not that it's
- 33:15like criteria to play in the session. It's just
- 33:17because of the age range that I am and how prevalent,
- 33:21you know, video games have become in the culture.
- 33:24There's usually whenever we're recording a song.
- 33:28there will always be like a large percentage
- 33:31of the people be like, I remember that song.
- 33:32Unless we do really niche ones. However, we've
- 33:34been doing some more slightly more modern ones
- 33:36that because most of the band are like millennials
- 33:39or older, they're like, what's megalovania, you
- 33:43know? Like, so what's undertale, you know? So
- 33:46there's sometimes they know, sometimes they don't
- 33:48like our lead trumpet player. He, he always like,
- 33:52we, there's this part in the live shows where
- 33:55I usually like, banter with the audience. And
- 33:57I'm like, make some noise if your first video
- 33:58game console was N64. PlayStation 1, original
- 34:02Nintendo, Atari 2600. And then I always take
- 34:06a moment. I go, make some noise if your first
- 34:08video game console was the Commodore 64, the
- 34:11ZX Spectrum. And he's the only one in the back.
- 34:12He goes, whoo. He's not as familiar with a lot
- 34:16of the songs. But most of them have experience
- 34:19with games in a big way. There's very few people
- 34:22in the ensemble that have never played a video
- 34:24game. It's amazing. And I read this before that
- 34:30you said that the goal was to give video game
- 34:32music the large ensemble and pedagogical respect.
- 34:36We give things like the Great American Songbook,
- 34:40which is really, that's a thesis statement. Tell
- 34:45me more about that. Totally. Sort of expanding
- 34:49on what I was saying before. It's like, what?
- 34:52What? What makes a body of work? You know, usually
- 34:57a body of work comes about because there is a
- 35:01scene or a collection or a place, like a hotbed
- 35:05of some kind of style or genre or medium that
- 35:10calls for music to be written surrounding the
- 35:13container of this medium. And over time, and
- 35:17usually I feel like it's like a 10 to 30 year
- 35:20period. there develops people who become fans
- 35:23of that medium and therefore become fans of the
- 35:25music. So for example, you know, the great American
- 35:29songbook really is like intertwined with early
- 35:32Broadway when Broadway musicals were pop music
- 35:34and those Broadway shows would have, everyone
- 35:36would see the shows. Then the songs would become
- 35:39popular and people would having had a great experience
- 35:42watching this stage production would say, I want
- 35:45to go buy that sheet music and take it home and
- 35:47play it myself. And my friends are going to come
- 35:48over and we're going to sing the song. And we're
- 35:50going to have a great time. We're having a parlor
- 35:52party, you know, and we're sitting around the
- 35:53piano singing the sound of music or whatever.
- 35:56And now separate of the original thing, separate
- 35:59of seeing the sound of music, these people have
- 36:02an emotional experience with this music and their
- 36:05friends and a community thing. And that continued
- 36:08to happen through Broadway music. Same thing
- 36:10happens with film scores. You know, the Harry
- 36:12Potter scores, John Williams scores, Hans Zimmer
- 36:15scores. People listen to these scores. for fun
- 36:18and you know separate of the movies or not and
- 36:20so we have this like huge canon you know the
- 36:23beatles those songs have way transcended their
- 36:25generation that way transcended the time and
- 36:27the place that they were made to become something
- 36:29greater motown you know there's like canons of
- 36:33music that exist and like i was saying now that
- 36:35we're 40 years in the video game music we have
- 36:38thousands and thousands of games and we have
- 36:40some games that are popular and some that are
- 36:42not and some themes like the super mario bros
- 36:44theme You could have never played a game in your
- 36:46whole life and you still know that theme, right?
- 36:48And so now we have an established canon of work
- 36:52separate from the original, like you're saying.
- 36:54So orchestras have always put these kinds of
- 37:01music on display in very formal and very professional
- 37:04settings. And the greatest arrangers of all time
- 37:07and the greatest singers of all time have all
- 37:09done. orchestra tributes to george gershwin for
- 37:12example and it happens at carnegie hall and it's
- 37:14very fancy you know what i mean that happens
- 37:16all the time and now that we're 40 years into
- 37:20video games and we have these legendary status
- 37:23composers some of which are composing like epic
- 37:26symphonic music what our responsibility is now
- 37:31as arrangers is to once again create versions
- 37:35of those songs removed from their original function
- 37:39Same as film scores, same as Broadway shows.
- 37:41A song in a Broadway show and a song in a film
- 37:43score or a score in a film score or a score in
- 37:46a video game, these things have function. And
- 37:48their function is to underscore or be material
- 37:51that connects plot or be transition material.
- 37:54Or in this case of a video game, it's very much
- 37:56more dynamic because it's nonlinear. So it has
- 37:59to loop. It has to build based on what's on screen.
- 38:02The player is kind of the arranger. You know,
- 38:04it has function. to take that music out of that
- 38:07stuff and showcase it on its own as listening
- 38:09music takes a skilled arranger to change the
- 38:13function of it to be a listening experience instead
- 38:16of a interactive experience or a underscoring
- 38:19experience. And so I think that because of its
- 38:23origins and because even though we're 40 years
- 38:26into video game music, the first 20 years were
- 38:28technologically very limited. I think there's
- 38:30a general thought that it's like, well, it's
- 38:32not real music. It's just, you know, blips and
- 38:34boops and it's not a thing anymore, you know?
- 38:36And so now we're like in this transitional period
- 38:38where if we have highly skilled arrangers and
- 38:41performers playing this music at a professional
- 38:44level, but making sure that it's been reformatted
- 38:47and retooled to be a concert level, professional,
- 38:50high level listening experience, then I think
- 38:55it can stand alongside the great composers in
- 38:59orchestral repertoires. and beyond as long as
- 39:02it's treated with the same amount of respect
- 39:03and care as we treat John Williams. Yeah. When
- 39:10you decided we're going to go for this music
- 39:16track and rearrange it and pick the style and
- 39:19all that, we talked a little bit about your North
- 39:24Star and your criteria. That criteria, do you
- 39:30sit there and listen to it? Do you collaborate
- 39:32with your other bandmates and say, okay, this
- 39:35is where we need to go with this piece? Mostly,
- 39:39I would say 99 % of the arranging is myself.
- 39:45I mean, if we're talking about jazz and you're
- 39:47talking about a jazz quartet, a small group of
- 39:49people. you don't need to really plan out ahead
- 39:52of time what exactly you're going to do. It's
- 39:54about improvising and feeding off of each other
- 39:56and live contributing. That's what makes jazz
- 39:58really cool. However, when there's like 33 plus
- 40:01people in a room, you really have to plan ahead
- 40:04of time about what they're going to do and what
- 40:06they're going to play. But within that, there
- 40:08is a little bit of freedom. Like I don't write
- 40:10out every single note that the drummer is going
- 40:12to play, especially drums, bass, guitar, and
- 40:15piano. Those four... And the solo, so like a
- 40:18sax solo, like an improvised solo. Those still
- 40:21remain like those musicians' compositions in
- 40:23a way. I just give them the general idea of what
- 40:26the drum groove should look like, and then the
- 40:28drummer will take it from there and fill in and
- 40:30improvise and work around it. But it's more like,
- 40:34I would say it's like 75 -25 in terms of 75 %
- 40:38me writing it out and figuring everything out
- 40:40ahead of time, 25 % them improvising. The structure
- 40:43is set. Unlike in a jazz quartet, where a solo
- 40:45can just be open -ended until they feel like
- 40:47stopping. Like when we go into the studio and
- 40:50record these tracks, it's like, no, no, no, you're
- 40:51getting 16 bars and then we're moving on, you
- 40:53know? So it's, it's a slightly different approach.
- 40:56Sometimes there's been, maybe there's been three
- 40:58times when I've worked with another arranger,
- 41:00co -arranged a song. And the first one was Meta
- 41:04Knight's Revenge. I did with Button Masher, Jake
- 41:06Cohen. Yep. I've done a chart with Carlos in
- 41:09Sane in the Rain, Carlosini. If you know him,
- 41:12he's a great musician and video game cover artist.
- 41:14And then more recently, the Super Mario Praise
- 41:16Break, which I did with my friends, Matthew Whitaker
- 41:18and Brian Carter. And in those times, it was
- 41:21sort of like, hey, I have this idea. I know I
- 41:25want it to be this certain thing, but you three
- 41:27have specific musical vocabularies that Venn
- 41:30diagram with mine, but don't completely overlap.
- 41:32And I need your input to make this be the most
- 41:35successful version of it that we need. And so,
- 41:38you know, it can be collaborative like that,
- 41:40too, for sure. Was there, was there a tune that
- 41:44you tried to arrange and you just had to put
- 41:46it down because it couldn't be cracked? Yeah.
- 41:49Most of the time that's happened a few times.
- 41:50And usually what it is, is like, it's a tune
- 41:54that I really want to arrange, but I can't come
- 41:56up with any ideas that are a fresh take on it.
- 42:00You know, like, like there are, there's so many
- 42:04like, like Kyle's theme or like, I've had this
- 42:07arrangement from Mega Man X that I started and
- 42:10I just can't like. I can't come up with a thing
- 42:12that's really going to make it work and be unique
- 42:15and make people go, Oh, like, Ooh, cool. Never
- 42:17thought of it like that. You know, think of,
- 42:19you know, like, and that's actually why I, for
- 42:23a long time, I wanted to arrange still alive,
- 42:25but I couldn't think of a way to do it that would
- 42:27make it unique. And it wasn't until I had this,
- 42:29that idea that, you know, in the shower one day
- 42:31it was like, Oh, that's, that's it. That's the
- 42:32idea. You know? So there's a, there's a bunch
- 42:34of, there's probably five or six arrangements
- 42:36in my Dropbox that are like, 25 finished because
- 42:40i'm like yeah this isn't really like interesting
- 42:43enough to make it worth reinventing you know
- 42:47yeah i get it Let's take a moment, speaking of
- 43:23collaborations and kind of going specific. In
- 43:282022, you and Jake Silverman, right, at Button
- 43:30Masher, win the Grammy for Best Arrangement,
- 43:33right? Instrumental for Acapella, for Meta Knight's
- 43:37Revenge, from Kirby Superstar. First Grammy in
- 43:40that category for a video game arrangement. And
- 43:43I think that's the third time ever video game
- 43:46music had been nominated for anything at the
- 43:48Grammys. So I would love to like... What did
- 43:52the morning of nominations feel like? What did
- 43:55the night feel like? Actually, I'll tell you
- 43:58all that. This video is also going to be used
- 44:01and the audio, just out of curiosity. Yeah, this
- 44:03will be on YouTube and also... I only asked because
- 44:06while you were asking that question, I was making
- 44:08this thinking face. And that's because I was
- 44:11like, wait, is that true about the category?
- 44:13And then I remembered that Baba Yetu, that was
- 44:15in a different category because it had vocals.
- 44:17Got it. Yes. Okay, good. Yeah. And yeah, we can
- 44:21cut back and forth. The editor will make sure
- 44:23there's... Okay, cool. Which I'm not embarrassed.
- 44:25You can put it in. I just was like, disclaimer,
- 44:28this is why I was making that face. Because I
- 44:30couldn't remember if Baba Yetu from Civilization
- 44:324 was in our category or not. But it was not.
- 44:34So you're correct. I'm glad I was correct. Yeah,
- 44:37you are correct. But yeah, you know, what was
- 44:41really cool about that is it was the third time
- 44:43video game music had ever been recognized at
- 44:45the Grammys. The first one being Baba Yetu from
- 44:48Civilization IV, which was nominated in Best
- 44:50Arrangement with vocals and won that year. And
- 44:54that's insane. That was very groundbreaking.
- 44:56That's unbelievable. Then the second time was
- 44:58Austin Wintory's Journey soundtrack, which is
- 45:01an amazing soundtrack. And what's crazier about
- 45:04that is he quote unquote lost. And the reason
- 45:07I say quote unquote lost is because there was
- 45:09no video game music score category. So he was
- 45:12like. nominated with john williams and on zimmer
- 45:15and like like these huge film scoring games and
- 45:19so like that is a huge huge win and then you
- 45:23know when i was thinking about the grammys i
- 45:26was like i became a member of the recording academy
- 45:28in 2022 really cool like oh wow that's awesome
- 45:31i can vote in the grammys oh i can submit i can
- 45:34submit for the grammy school well like this is
- 45:36the craziest long shot that has ever happened
- 45:38in the history of music but like what if i submitted
- 45:41Some stuff from the 8 -Bit Big Band. I mean,
- 45:43at the time, I was sort of like, this is so niche,
- 45:46what I'm doing. We have this audience on YouTube,
- 45:49and that's cool. And we have some thousand followers
- 45:52on Instagram. But this is the Grammys we're talking
- 45:55about. There's no way. That's crazy. But why
- 45:56not, right? So I submitted it and just kind of
- 46:00forgot. This will never be a thing. And I was
- 46:02actually in London working on a movie at the
- 46:04time. And me and a friend were at a board game
- 46:07cafe playing. I don't even remember what game
- 46:10because I just started getting all these texts
- 46:13on my phone that were like, dude, you just got
- 46:15nominated for a Grammy. And I was like, huh?
- 46:18What? No. What the? Are you kidding? I'm sorry.
- 46:23I guess. Hold on. Hold on. I'm really sorry.
- 46:25I'm so sorry. Give me one sec. You know, like
- 46:27called to verify that this was real. I called
- 46:30Jake. I was like, is this real? Like, are we
- 46:32nominated for a Grammy? Very crazy. Still feels
- 46:35like an insane long shot fluke that that happened.
- 46:38And then. to be at the Grammys. And, you know,
- 46:41again, we're at the Grammys, we're dressed up.
- 46:43It's like the first Grammys after COVID. So everyone's
- 46:46like, wow, this is crazy. We're here at the Grammys.
- 46:48You know, it's like, everyone's really excited
- 46:49and we're sitting there and I'm sitting next
- 46:51to Jake. I'm like, Hey man, listen, you know
- 46:54what? This it's huge that we're here. Like it's
- 46:57a win that we're sitting here at all. That's
- 46:58crazy, man. You know, shaking, just soak it in.
- 47:00Right. That's awesome. Like we're probably not
- 47:03going to win. Like there's no way we're going
- 47:04to win, but like, dude, come on. How awesome
- 47:05is this? And then they said our names and we
- 47:09just like had an out of body float up to the
- 47:12stage. Like, are you kidding? This is crazy.
- 47:16This is so crazy. Did you have something prepared?
- 47:20So me and Jake, no, we did not really actually,
- 47:23to be honest, because I did not like, in what
- 47:26world was I about to win this Grammy? So me and
- 47:29Jake went two totally different directions, which
- 47:31I think is a good yin and yang is he was so like.
- 47:35overwhelmed with joy that he he like got choked
- 47:38up and it's very beautiful and he was like you
- 47:40know it's very beautiful and i was like business
- 47:43okay holy shit i gotta thank you okay i was like
- 47:47and i just like sort of like went into like hyper
- 47:49focus mode and like thanked the people that i'm
- 47:51like i must thank these people and i must you
- 47:54know like do these various things and then when
- 47:55we came off stage i was like oh my god did that
- 48:00just happen what just happened literally very
- 48:03crazy And then, you know, if we fast forward
- 48:06to February this year, Grammy number three. Yeah.
- 48:10Right. Super Mario Praise Bake. We talked about
- 48:12that with Brian Carter and Matthew Whitaker.
- 48:15Yeah. Which is gospel. It's gospel arrangement
- 48:18of Mario, you know, different Mario themes. Yep.
- 48:20How did that come together? And how did you,
- 48:23when did you know that was going to even work?
- 48:25Yeah. So me and, so me and Brian and Matthew,
- 48:29I haven't known Matthew. I've known Matthew a
- 48:31few years now, but I've known Brian for like
- 48:33over 10 years and we've done tons of gigs together
- 48:35and we've played together in all sorts of musical
- 48:37contexts. And Brian and Matthew both of course,
- 48:42like grew up as church musicians and Matthew
- 48:44is the minister of music at his church. And so
- 48:47Brian through like a long time, I like in college,
- 48:50I like started really getting into gospel music
- 48:52as a bass player because like, the gospel music
- 48:55of black church in general is like always, always
- 48:58been on the vanguard of pushing. Yeah. Like what
- 49:02these instrumentalists can do. It is a hotbed
- 49:04of, of these instruments and musicianship levels,
- 49:08insanely high, like high energy. And anybody
- 49:12who like plays bass and drums or keyboards, you
- 49:14know, or guitar, like for me, it's like, you
- 49:18know, I'm white and Jewish. I obviously didn't
- 49:20grow up in the church, but like, There has to
- 49:24be an acknowledgement and appreciation that these
- 49:26musicians in the last century and now have always
- 49:29been on the forefront of pushing popular music
- 49:31and pushing instrumentalists and these instruments
- 49:36to new ground and what they can do. So I've always
- 49:40really liked gospel music. And me and Brian were
- 49:44always sharing praise breaks, videos, and other
- 49:47tracks and stuff. And I just sort of had this
- 49:51idea. you know, that was kind of like, there's
- 49:56all these praise breaks that I really liked.
- 49:58And they were always these, like, a lot of them
- 49:59are like, you know, 20, 30 minute medleys of
- 50:02like insane things that these arrangers would
- 50:05throw in there for these praise and worship services.
- 50:07And like, there was something about video game
- 50:10music, fandom and the community of video game
- 50:13music, especially surrounding like the cover
- 50:17music scene. And the way that video games can
- 50:20serve as like an escape for people and like a
- 50:23home and a thing to like be a community and kind
- 50:26of like a religious way that just really struck
- 50:29me. And so I was sort of like, Brian, I have
- 50:31this like crazy idea, but you have to tell me
- 50:33if it's the worst idea I've ever came up with.
- 50:36Like you have to tell me. And, you know, so together
- 50:39we sort of concocted this idea and yeah, that's
- 50:43kind of how it came about. You know, it was just,
- 50:45it was for all those kids who came home, you
- 50:47know, playing. after church played super mario
- 50:49bros and like grew up with this music in their
- 50:51household and yeah it's it just it's like it's
- 50:55a thing that sounds too crazy to work but it
- 50:58works you know yeah i mean it is a brilliant
- 51:00piece honestly and again going back to you know
- 51:03that that music you know bring bringing joy it
- 51:06certainly does for me you know every time I listen
- 51:08to it so it is probably the most fun recording
- 51:11session I've ever done and also it was like very
- 51:15important you know to me and and to me and Brian
- 51:17and Matthew to like and Matthew played on it
- 51:20he played organ on it but it was really important
- 51:21that we like we get some like real church musicians
- 51:24in the studio to really play this and make sure
- 51:26that like brilliant It should never feel like
- 51:29satire. It should never feel like parody. All
- 51:32the times in the 8 -Bit Big Band that I try to
- 51:33do these other genres that are maybe from other
- 51:36countries or from other time periods or places
- 51:38or cultures, what's important is that we try
- 51:41to not make them satire or parody or caricaturization.
- 51:45We want to try to do them authentically, even
- 51:48though it's video game music. People are already
- 51:50going to raise their eyebrow at it, so it's important
- 51:52that we really try to do it right. Yeah, absolutely.
- 51:57And, you know, talking about like, you know,
- 51:59the awards you've won, you know, kind of in between,
- 52:01you know, those Grammy wins that you had, you
- 52:03also won a Tony, right? For Some Like It Hot.
- 52:06I've got two Tony's actually. Amazing. That's,
- 52:10that's crazy. And you got nominated, uh, for,
- 52:13well, Grammy also won for best musical theater
- 52:15album. Yeah, that's right. Um, yeah. Um, and
- 52:20again, in 2005 for last surprise for, for persona
- 52:23five nominated. So yeah, I mean, amazing. Uh,
- 52:27do you, I guess regarding all that, you know,
- 52:30between Broadway and also, you know, the video
- 52:32game music, do you feel like the same musician
- 52:35on Broadway and on the eight big, big band albums
- 52:38or. I do. Are those two different people? To
- 52:42me, it's all the same because it all really is.
- 52:45There's one difference. But in general, yes,
- 52:48I do basically treat them the same except for
- 52:51this one difference that I'll tell you. But they're
- 52:54the same skill. When you're working on a Broadway
- 52:57show, you get usually just the piano playing
- 53:04and the singing. That's all you get. So Broadway
- 53:07musicals rehearse. Most of the time, just with
- 53:10somebody playing the piano and the actors singing
- 53:12and that's it until I get ahold of it. And they
- 53:14say, okay, this is what the score is. Here's
- 53:17the piano part. We're going to have this many
- 53:19instruments in the pit. Go for it. Do your thing.
- 53:22Here's what we're thinking. Here's our influences.
- 53:24Do your thing. So again, it's, it's that skill
- 53:27of understanding the context, the dramaturgy
- 53:31of the song, what its function is within the
- 53:34show, what objective it needs to. get emotionally
- 53:37and then hearing that unrealized potential to
- 53:42make sure that the instruments are doing what
- 53:43they need to do to sell that idea of your arrangement
- 53:46or sell that idea of the emotion you're trying
- 53:48to convey or sell that dance break or sell that
- 53:51scene change or sell that I want song or whatever
- 53:54the situation is. It's about understanding the
- 53:56context and having the musical vocabulary to
- 53:58express it. Same skill. Same skill in the 8 -bit
- 54:01big band. It's like where I'm taking the raw
- 54:03bones of a thing. I'm stripping the house down
- 54:05to the foundation and I'm going, what can I now
- 54:08build out of that? The only difference is in
- 54:11the 8 -Bit Big Band versus on a Broadway show,
- 54:13in the 8 -Bit Big Band, I'm not working for anybody.
- 54:16It's like whatever musical ideas I have, that's
- 54:19the answer. That's going to work. I can do whatever
- 54:21I want. There's no limits. And every time I record
- 54:24a song, I can have different kinds of instruments
- 54:26on it, whatever I need. Oh, this song, we need
- 54:28this instrument. Sure. Let's find somebody. Whereas
- 54:30in a Broadway show, it's more practical. It's
- 54:32like, ultimately you're working for the director
- 54:33and the composer and they have opinions that
- 54:35you have to say, great, that makes sense. I'll
- 54:36do that. You want that? No problem. I got it.
- 54:39And you're limited by the amount of musicians
- 54:41you have in the pit. So the 8 -bit big band is
- 54:44like, yes, they're the same. And the 8 -bit big
- 54:46band is even, I think, more an expression of
- 54:49my unadulterated, unfiltered musical brain. Love
- 54:54it. And, you know, going back to what we were
- 54:57talking about earlier about, you know, the...
- 54:59The great American songbook, which you talked
- 55:02about, like Gershwin, Porter, Ellington. I'm
- 55:06curious, from your perspective, who's in the
- 55:09great video game songbook right now, in your
- 55:12view? Who would you put in that category? Koji
- 55:15Kondo. Yeah, clearly. I would say Nobuo Uematsu,
- 55:23of course. Of course, yes. Thinking off the top
- 55:28of my head. Sorry to put you on the spot. No,
- 55:31of course. Yoko Shimomura is amazing. We love
- 55:36Yoko Shimomura. I'm trying to think of people
- 55:41that the games are so beloved that everybody
- 55:46would know them, even if they know who they are
- 55:48or not. Help me. Can you think of anybody? I'm
- 55:52really bad with names, so I will... I can name
- 55:56the games, but maybe not the musicians themselves.
- 56:00Yeah. Maybe David Wise. You know David Wise?
- 56:03Absolutely. People love Donkey Kong Country.
- 56:06I also love Donkey Kong Country. Yeah. Yeah.
- 56:10I should know this. For some reason, I'm drawing
- 56:12a blank, but the composer for Castlevania, the
- 56:16Castlevania series. Oh. Most amazing, iconic
- 56:20music. Some of my favorite. Yeah, that's amazing
- 56:23stuff. Okay, Michiru Yamane. Yeah, so good. Yes,
- 56:27that's awesome. Yeah. I mean, too many to count,
- 56:33right? There's just so many amazing iconic pieces
- 56:35in video games that just don't even get their
- 56:37due. I wish I knew. I need to know better. I
- 56:41feel like Sonic the Hedgehog has had so many
- 56:42different composers that it's hard. They have.
- 56:44You know what I mean? Yeah, absolutely. Like
- 56:47who wrote Green Hill Zone? Which composer wrote
- 56:49Green Hill Zone? Yeah. Oh, that was Yuzo Koshiro.
- 56:54Another amazing, amazing, talented musician.
- 56:58But yeah, for Sonic, like the, if you actually
- 57:01beat the first Sonic game, there's a medley that
- 57:04plays during the credits of all the different
- 57:06songs. Oh yeah. I didn't know that. So good.
- 57:11Check it out. I'm sure it's on, you know, I'm
- 57:12sure someone's recorded on YouTube, but amazing.
- 57:15So is, is there speaking, you know, kind of,
- 57:20Moving along those lines, is there a piece of
- 57:23game music? Well, I'm sure there's some already
- 57:25you're looking at next, but is there one that
- 57:28you think is, you know, canonical, but hasn't
- 57:31gotten its due yet? You know, something you're
- 57:32trying to put into the songbook? Like a more
- 57:35recent one? Or you mean like... Yeah, sure. Any,
- 57:37any, like, you know, is there something like,
- 57:39you're like, wow, I would love to, you know,
- 57:41tackle this. What's on the list? We are actually
- 57:48currently in process of recording album six right
- 57:51now. We did a recording session like three days
- 57:53ago. Love it. Yeah. You're welcome to share any
- 57:57tidbits that you want. I mean, there's going
- 58:00to be, there's going to be some, some actually
- 58:05Dragon Quest of all things. We've never tackled
- 58:07Dragon Quest. And I do feel like Dragon Quest,
- 58:10not quite as popular in the West as it is in
- 58:12Japan, but like. It's huge though. yeah and that
- 58:15music is amazing it's that is like incredible
- 58:18and actually koichi sugiyama the composer he
- 58:21was really ahead of his time because like in
- 58:23the 90s he was doing these like orchestral concerts
- 58:27of dragon quest music yeah in the early 90s like
- 58:30that people weren't doing that back then so that's
- 58:32pretty cool he was kind of ahead of his time
- 58:33so we're doing some dragon quest obviously there's
- 58:36lots there's more nintendo stuff there's always
- 58:37more nintendo stuff um It's deep, the music for
- 58:42Nintendo. For the 8 -bit big man, Nintendo is
- 58:44always the easiest stuff to adapt because it's
- 58:46so melodic. We're doing Paka Mitai from the Yakuza
- 58:52series. That's cool. Fun. And then we're doing
- 58:57a song from Hades 2, which is pretty cool. I
- 59:00think that the Hades stuff can be a strong candidate.
- 59:04Especially the songs. The songs with lyrics from
- 59:06the Hades series are a strong candidate for...
- 59:08songbookification i feel yeah super cool yeah
- 59:14well yeah trigger there's some corona trigger
- 59:16coming up too of course you got a lot of good
- 59:20stuff Do you have any aspirations or even like
- 59:48opportunities to compose like original scores
- 59:52for games? You know, I definitely have aspirations
- 59:55to do it. I haven't been asked to do it yet,
- 59:58which is kind of funny, but you know, maybe one
- 1:00:00of these days, if you're a game developer and
- 1:00:03you're listening to this, I would love to score
- 1:00:05your game, you know, maybe not for free. And
- 1:00:07I would highly recommend that you do reach out
- 1:00:09to Charlie for sure. Some of the best music I've
- 1:00:12ever heard, honestly. Yeah, get at me. And we'll
- 1:00:16make sure we'll, I got one more question. We'll
- 1:00:19wrap it up and make sure we, you know, give you
- 1:00:22the opportunity to talk about all the places
- 1:00:23where people can find, find your music. But,
- 1:00:27you know, I kind of end every episode the same
- 1:00:30way. You know, the show, the name of the show,
- 1:00:32of course, is replay. So it's an easy question.
- 1:00:36If you could go back and replay one game, experience
- 1:00:40it again completely fresh, what would it be?
- 1:00:44But why also? Yes, very, very easy question for
- 1:00:48me. I don't know if anybody has ever interrupted
- 1:00:49you because they already had the answer. No,
- 1:00:51good. Most were like, oh, you just put me on
- 1:00:54the spot. This is great. This is a real softball
- 1:00:57for me because the answer to that question is
- 1:00:59Outer Wilds. great game that's interesting though
- 1:01:04of all the games why outer wilds because okay
- 1:01:07just so people listening some people know outer
- 1:01:09wilds some don't i don't mean the outer worlds
- 1:01:12that's a different game so not the outer worlds
- 1:01:15outer wilds is a i think to me the best example
- 1:01:22of non -linear storytelling i've ever experienced
- 1:01:25in the game self -guided But the game has enough
- 1:01:30of a gentle hand to slightly edge you in the
- 1:01:33right direction. Completely self -guided exploration.
- 1:01:36And the beautiful thing about the game, without
- 1:01:38spoiling it, is once you know the game has this
- 1:01:42feature in it where the same thing repeats every
- 1:01:4420 or so minutes, over and over, the whole game
- 1:01:47resets. And the game technically is only 20 or
- 1:01:50so minutes long. And it resets like a Groundhog
- 1:01:52Day style thing. If you know the secret of the
- 1:01:56game, if you know how to beat the game, if you
- 1:01:58understand what's going on in the 20 minutes,
- 1:02:00you can start the game and beat it in like, speed
- 1:02:03runners beat it in like four minutes or something,
- 1:02:04you know, five minutes. They get to the end sequence
- 1:02:07of the game. And so it's this like amazing journey
- 1:02:10of discovery through all of these, this self
- 1:02:12-guided exploration of lore and figuring out
- 1:02:14what's going on in this little solar system.
- 1:02:16But once you know it, you can't unknow it. You
- 1:02:18can never replay it. And so the only joy you
- 1:02:21can derive. It's through being a shepherd for
- 1:02:24other people's journey. Yeah. To be like, have
- 1:02:27you checked out this yet? Maybe give that another
- 1:02:30look. I don't know. I don't want to spoil it,
- 1:02:31but maybe try going back to that planet, you
- 1:02:33know? And so like, I wish I could just wipe my
- 1:02:35brain and play that again for the first time,
- 1:02:37but you can't, you can't. Amazing. I thought
- 1:02:40for sure you were going to say Ocarina of Time.
- 1:02:41I just had a hunch that that would be here. Although
- 1:02:44I do like, that's the thing is I have, I have
- 1:02:46replayed that and I have found joy in like just
- 1:02:49doing the journey again. yeah even knowing but
- 1:02:52you know what there's there was something more
- 1:02:55i wish i could replay outer wilds because it
- 1:02:57was like the discovery of figuring out what was
- 1:03:00going on in that game was just so like oh my
- 1:03:02god this is amazing you know but ocarina time
- 1:03:06is probably my favorite game of all time so oh
- 1:03:08there we go it's a twofer Okay, Charlie, where
- 1:03:12can people find the 8 -Bit Big Band, you know,
- 1:03:14your work and follow kind of what you're building
- 1:03:16next? We're truly like anywhere that you could
- 1:03:20ever want to find somebody on the internet. So,
- 1:03:23you know, Instagram, our social, we have post
- 1:03:26behind the scene clips and we announce shows
- 1:03:28and I communicate with people on Instagram and
- 1:03:30TikTok and X and threads. I would say primarily
- 1:03:34Instagram, TikTok is probably our social media.
- 1:03:37home. I personally have an account. So our 8
- 1:03:39-Bit Big Band is at the 8 -Bit Big Band. I'm
- 1:03:41at C -Rosen Music on Instagram and all these
- 1:03:43things. The 8 -Bit Big Band also has a very robust
- 1:03:45Discord community that you can join through the
- 1:03:48links and any of the bios. And of course, I'd
- 1:03:50say the flagship 8 -Bit Big Band platform is
- 1:03:53YouTube. We have a big YouTube channel there
- 1:03:54where we post all the in -studio music videos
- 1:03:57of what we do. And you can join our Discord there
- 1:03:59or follow any of those links there. And then
- 1:04:01of course, wherever you listen to music, stream
- 1:04:03it, or band camp, we're on there. The 8 -Bit
- 1:04:07Big Band, I love when people stream everything.
- 1:04:09Bandcamp is also amazing. I give away all the
- 1:04:11music for free, but I'm welcome to... I'd love
- 1:04:13a donation if you give it to me. And then outside
- 1:04:17of that, if you just keep an eye on social media,
- 1:04:20we play live shows maybe four or five times a
- 1:04:23year around the US. We played a live show in
- 1:04:25London recently. We're looking to expand. The
- 1:04:288 -Bit Big Band has some shows in October. in
- 1:04:31the northeast and we have some in seattle and
- 1:04:33we have an la show in the winter this is the
- 1:04:35ape at big band so all the so we're you know
- 1:04:38or wherever mostly i would say join the discord
- 1:04:40follow us on instagram and uh watch our videos
- 1:04:44on youtube absolutely and i would i would second
- 1:04:47all that and definitely check out the youtube
- 1:04:49videos because there's some great stuff on there
- 1:04:51um you guys i love even the animations that you
- 1:04:55use on some of the videos are just really fun
- 1:04:58you just you You do it all. It's great. We do
- 1:05:01it all. Love it. For a holistic jazz experience.
- 1:05:04Yeah. Charlie Rosen, thank you so much for your
- 1:05:08time and joining. I really enjoyed the conversation
- 1:05:11and getting to know more about what you got going
- 1:05:13on. And hopefully you'll come back in the future
- 1:05:16and talk more. Of course. The pleasure is truly
- 1:05:19all mine. I had a good time. Thank you. Thank
- 1:05:21you, my friend. And that's Charlie Rosen, three
- 1:05:24-time Grammy winner, Tony Award winner, and band
- 1:05:27leader of the 8 -Bit Big Band. Links to Charlie
- 1:05:31and everything he mentioned are in the show notes.
- 1:05:33If this conversation made you curious, the band's
- 1:05:35new album, Orchestrator Emulator, is where I'd
- 1:05:38start. Follow or subscribe to Replay wherever
- 1:05:41you listen. I'm Greg Off. This is Replay.