Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Navigating Title VII and the California CROWN Act with Tracy Sanders Rucker, Kathiana Aurelien
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to today's program, Freedom of Expression
- 0:06in the Workplace, navigating Title VII and the
- 0:09California Crown Act. I'm Alapoli Castro, CLE
- 0:13advisor for the Beverly Hills Bar Association,
- 0:15and I'm delighted to introduce this afternoon's
- 0:18speakers, Tracy Sanders -Rucker and Katiana Aurelian.
- 0:21Tracy Sanders -Rucker is an accomplished attorney,
- 0:25author, and speaker. She established Natural
- 0:28Hair and the Law, an organization formed to provide
- 0:31publications addressing legal issues related
- 0:33to hair texture in the workplace and schools.
- 0:37Tracy is also the author of The Crown Act Handbook,
- 0:40Natural Hair Affirmations, and Natural Hair in
- 0:43the Workplace. What are your rights? Tracy is
- 0:45the recipient of many prestigious awards for
- 0:48her work in community service, such as a certificate
- 0:50of special recognition from our Los Angeles mayor,
- 0:53Karen Bass. She's a frequent speaker at law schools
- 0:55and universities and contributor on various nationally
- 0:59syndicated news and talk shows. Tracy established
- 1:02the attorney Tracy Sanders Foundation to help
- 1:04undeserved students achieve their education and
- 1:07career goals. Our second speaker, Katiana Aurelian,
- 1:10is counsel in Wilkie Farr's Labor and Employment
- 1:13Group. She focuses her practice in California
- 1:16employment issues. And her practice includes
- 1:18counseling and representing her clients on a
- 1:21wide range of issues, including employment implications
- 1:23of corporate transactions, workplace investigations,
- 1:27evaluations of worker classification, and implementation
- 1:31of reduction in force, as well as defense against
- 1:33discrimination and retaliation claims. Katiana
- 1:36is a frequent writer and speaker on employment
- 1:39related topics ranging from cannabis in the workplace
- 1:41to the impact of the Dodd -Frank on employers.
- 1:45She currently serves as on the board of the Black
- 1:48Women Lawyers Association of Los Angeles and
- 1:51is the co -chair of the pro bono and community
- 1:53outreach committee for the labor and employment
- 1:55section of the American Bar Association. We're
- 1:58so excited to have them here with us today and
- 2:00can't wait to hear what they have to share with
- 2:02us. Thank you so much. So, first and foremost,
- 2:09we'd like to thank the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 2:12for your courage to present Freedom of Expression
- 2:16in the Workplace Navigating Title VII and the
- 2:20California Crown Act. I do believe we have a
- 2:24moderator who will help us navigate the slides.
- 2:27So if we could move to the next slide, please.
- 2:30What we'd like to do in this CLE is to help you
- 2:34understand the Crown Act. And we don't want to
- 2:36take anything for granted in terms of having
- 2:39acronyms, because some of you may be familiar
- 2:42with the Crown Act and others. This may be a
- 2:44niche topic. So we are not insulting your intelligence
- 2:48by taking a very elementary approach to this
- 2:51topic. The CROWN Act stands for creating a respectful
- 2:55and open world for natural hair. And the CROWN
- 3:00Act has been enacted to prohibit hair texture
- 3:03discrimination in the workplace of schools. And
- 3:06don't worry if you never have to wake up a day
- 3:08in your life thinking. an inkling about your
- 3:12texture or discrimination. It sounds like an
- 3:15oxymoron. My esteemed co -speaker and I will
- 3:18take you through those issues and break down
- 3:21some definitions for you. So the Crown Act has
- 3:24been enacted in 27 states. So even if you are
- 3:30not familiar with Black culture, Black hair,
- 3:32if you think no one's filing these cases, You
- 3:36know, wait a minute, it could impact you anyway,
- 3:39especially as an employer or if you're in -house
- 3:42providing counsel to employers. And you could,
- 3:45in fact, find yourself needing guidance as a
- 3:48plaintiff. The Crown Act has been enacted in
- 3:5127 states and 40 localities. In the interest
- 3:54of time, I won't go over all 27 states, but do
- 3:58know that on the West Coast, California and Nevada
- 4:02and on the East Coast, New York and Connecticut,
- 4:05at New Jersey, for example. The Crown Act has
- 4:08also been enacted in U .S. territories such as
- 4:11Puerto Rico and U .S. Virgin Islands. So many
- 4:14of you may be conducting international business.
- 4:18especially during our current political climate,
- 4:21which we will not discuss. But if you are in
- 4:24global trade or international affairs, the Crown
- 4:26Act may be implicated. So this is especially
- 4:29important for employment lawyers who advise on
- 4:33employment law as well as human resources matters.
- 4:36And it could also be helpful to educational institutions.
- 4:41If we were together in person, I'd ask how many
- 4:43of you have seen the cases in the media where
- 4:46kids were expelled, or suspended from school
- 4:50because of hair texture. Those cases might involve
- 4:53the Crown Act as well. So we will move on to
- 4:56the next slide, please. So the Crown Act, as
- 5:00I mentioned, had been passed in 27 states, but
- 5:03in the interest of time, you will receive this
- 5:05PowerPoint and some relevant cases that Ms. Aurelian
- 5:10and I have pulled so you will be well aware of
- 5:13the issues. But to know that because this is
- 5:16the Beverly Hills Bar Association and we're in
- 5:18the state of California, we're going to focus
- 5:21on the California Crown Act. And moving along
- 5:26to the next slide. Let's go over what the CROWN
- 5:29Act means. So it stands for creating a respectful
- 5:32and open world for a natural hair. In some states,
- 5:37you might see it as an open workplace. Those
- 5:40terms are interchangeable. If you see the CROWN
- 5:43Act, just think of two words, hair texture and
- 5:46discrimination. So usually California, the most
- 5:50progressive state in the nation, is always the
- 5:52first of everything. California, in fact, was
- 5:55the first state to enact the Crown Act. It became
- 5:58effective during COVID, January 1, on 2020. So
- 6:03this CLE seminar is not pro -plaintiff, it's
- 6:07not pro -management. Currently, as an entrepreneur
- 6:10providing legal education, I have experience
- 6:13on both sides. Miss Aurelian is management, but
- 6:17we are taking an objective approach today. And
- 6:20I'm going to take you through some nuances related
- 6:23to the employee's rights. And Miss Aurelian will
- 6:27go over some employer rights and compliance issues.
- 6:31Also, as we go to the next slide, please be aware
- 6:34that even though we are in an anti -DEI climate,
- 6:38and it doesn't matter if you're in a red state
- 6:41or a blue state. Right now, I'm at a lake in
- 6:45South Carolina, as red as it can be. I live in
- 6:49California part of the year, blue state. It doesn't
- 6:52matter. we should still be aware of the Crown
- 6:55Act and employment laws because we are still
- 6:58one nation. And as practicing attorneys, we want
- 7:02our clients to be well aware of labor and employment
- 7:05law. So I have a quick poll for you all. If you
- 7:08see this slide, and Katiana will come on soon
- 7:12to take you through some samples of your styles,
- 7:14one of which she's modeling. But before we do,
- 7:19let's go through the difference between employment
- 7:21and labor law. Again, I believe in being very,
- 7:25very simple because you gain more by going broad
- 7:28and coming narrow. So if we were together and
- 7:31I asked, do you think discrimination based on
- 7:34here is that employment law, centric or labor
- 7:38law? And you all can type in the chat if you
- 7:41will. Discrimination based on here. labor law
- 7:45or employment law? And the lawyerly answer would
- 7:47be both. But if you're focusing on primarily
- 7:50filing a claim in court, are you going to pull
- 7:53labor law or employment law? What about wrongful
- 7:56termination after reporting discrimination? Labor
- 8:01law or employment law? Union organizing? Employment
- 8:06law? Labor law? Collective bargaining? labor
- 8:10law, or employment law. What about wage theft
- 8:14and unpaid overtime? Labor law or employment
- 8:18law? And finally, retaliation for union activity.
- 8:24labor law or employment law. And the reason why
- 8:28Katiana and I thought it might be good to just
- 8:30do a refresher is because you'd be surprised,
- 8:33especially if you're not practicing labor and
- 8:36employment law. A lot of times the two can be
- 8:39intermeshed. But as I turn it over to Katiana
- 8:42and we go to the next slide. you'll see that
- 8:45a lot of the issues can be intermingled. But
- 8:48before Katiana takes you through the different
- 8:51samples in terms of hairstyles so you understand
- 8:54what we're talking about, know that Crown Act
- 8:59legislation, and there are a few cases in California
- 9:02which we will discuss, primarily employment law,
- 9:06because employment law is the relationship between
- 9:08the employer and an employee. There could be
- 9:11labor law implications if you are representing
- 9:15unions or if you have organized labor and if
- 9:19you have Black plaintiffs or plaintiffs with
- 9:22textured hair who are complaining about being
- 9:25discriminated. So if you are practicing labor
- 9:28law, Please don't think that this is an exempt
- 9:32practice area. There could be labor law implications.
- 9:36Now, freedom of expression, and I promise you'll
- 9:38hear from the next generation because we're taking
- 9:41an intergenerational approach. Freedom of expression
- 9:44in the workplace, generally you think of remember
- 9:47constitutional law and the F word and the draft,
- 9:51which I won't say because I'm not a potty mouth.
- 9:54Usually people think about freedom of expression
- 9:56and the First Amendment. They think about the
- 9:58flag or t -shirts of vulgar language? Well, freedom
- 10:03of expression and the First Amendment does have
- 10:06intersectionality with the Crown Act because
- 10:08it's no different than freedom to behave in a
- 10:12certain way in terms of words that may be used.
- 10:15It's just how we present ourselves in terms of
- 10:18care. So just know that there could be First
- 10:21Amendment implications based on freedom of expression
- 10:24if a government agency is implicated. So if you
- 10:27work for the government or work in a school and
- 10:29it's a public school. or if it's a religious
- 10:33reason. So Katiana is wearing a hairstyle. I'll
- 10:37let her tell you about her hairstyle and how
- 10:41a person might find that the Crown Act is implicated
- 10:45through their hair, First Amendment, if it's
- 10:48religion, right? So there could be a Crown Act
- 10:50plain and First Amendment. And she's going to
- 10:53take you through some hairstyles as we go to
- 10:56the next slide. I wrote a book called The Crown
- 10:59Act Handbook. Instead of me shamelessly promoting
- 11:03my book, Katiana is going to take you through
- 11:06some of the graphics. For those of you who might
- 11:08not know the difference between natural hair
- 11:10and natural hairstyles, and then she's going
- 11:12to explain the different hairstyles. Thanks,
- 11:19Tracy. Next slide, please. I think we might have
- 11:26skipped the slide. I'm sorry. Can we go back
- 11:28one? There we go. So what is natural hair? And
- 11:34what do people mean? When they talk about natural
- 11:38hair, what does that mean? And bottom line, different
- 11:42people have different ideas around what natural
- 11:46hair constitutes. When people talk about natural
- 11:49hair, they might mean hair that hasn't been chemically
- 11:53altered. It might mean hair that's not chemically
- 11:57relaxed to be straight. I've seen workplace policies
- 12:02around restrictions for employee hair as far
- 12:06as hair color. Employers have had policies where
- 12:11they don't restrict an employee from dying their
- 12:14hair, but they do say that if you're going to
- 12:17dye your hair, if you're going to have hair color,
- 12:19it has to be something that's naturally occurring
- 12:22in the world for humans. When you think about
- 12:26that kind of policy, What they're trying to get
- 12:29at is, fine, dye your hair. We don't care. But
- 12:33don't come to work and think you're being compliant
- 12:36with our policy if your hair is pink or purple
- 12:40or some other color that's not thought of as
- 12:44naturally occurring. For some people, natural
- 12:47hair means hair that's not dyed at all. In certain
- 12:50communities, and Tracy kind of touched on this
- 12:53a bit in her earlier slide, references to natural
- 12:59hair means wearing your hair as it naturally
- 13:02grows from your scalp, your natural hair texture.
- 13:05Whether that means naturally wavy, naturally
- 13:09curly, tightly coiled, some hair textures described
- 13:13as kinky hair. It could also include what's described
- 13:18as protective styles. And that's a term that
- 13:22we see in several of the various different Crown
- 13:26Act statutes that have been passed in different
- 13:29states and municipalities, right? They don't
- 13:33necessarily define the term protective styles.
- 13:35What they tend to do is give examples where they
- 13:38include things like locks or braids, which Tracy
- 13:41mentioned. My hair is braided, right? So within
- 13:46the statutes of different crowns, including California,
- 13:51braids is described as an example of a protective
- 13:55hairstyle, and in many communities, described
- 13:57as a natural style. Protective styles are essentially
- 14:02styles where hair is tucked away or protected.
- 14:08and usually referring to the ends of the hair
- 14:11from the elements, whether that's from the elements
- 14:14or heat or frequent manipulation. So that's what
- 14:19we think of when we think of protective styles.
- 14:20It could also be a wig. It doesn't have to be
- 14:22braids or locks or bantu knots. And when we go
- 14:25through some of the illustrations that Tracy
- 14:27flagged, you'll get to see a few of those styles.
- 14:33And in passing the California Crown Act, the
- 14:37state legislature was sort of getting at sort
- 14:40of hair texture discrimination. And in some of
- 14:46the legislative history, they find that there
- 14:49are ways in which employers and just societal
- 14:53norms have been sort of steeped into sort of
- 14:56Eurocentric ideas of what constitutes professionalism
- 15:01and relatedly have associated traits that are
- 15:07associated with blackness or black communities
- 15:10as unprofessional. And so in trying to tackle
- 15:13that and give certain protections, that's where
- 15:15the Crown Act kind of comes in to fill in the
- 15:18gaps of certain anti -discrimination laws that
- 15:21you currently have already on the books. Next
- 15:25slide, please. So very first slide, very first
- 15:31illustration here. I think of as a pretty recognizable
- 15:35a hairstyle, but I do appreciate that maybe not
- 15:40everyone knows, but this is an afro, right? Popular
- 15:44probably a few decades ago, but still very prevalent
- 15:48today. And because of the way that courts have
- 15:53tackled defining race and interpreting anti -discrimination
- 15:59statutes currently on the books in the federal
- 16:03statutes, I mean, Afros are a protected hairstyle.
- 16:08They're a protected category under Title VII,
- 16:11and of course, as well as the various different
- 16:14chronic statutes. And interestingly, in one of
- 16:19the earlier sort of cases after the passage of
- 16:23Title VII, but a couple decades later, this was
- 16:27in 1981, a employee of an airline, brought a
- 16:34claim alleging discrimination and saying that
- 16:39her employer's policy violated Title VII because
- 16:44she wore her hair in braids, but cornrow braids.
- 16:47They are different than the ones I have on that
- 16:50I'm wearing my hair now, but she had her hair
- 16:53styled in cornrows and she was an employee of
- 16:56this airline and they said, hey, you would have
- 16:59to change your hairstyle in order to comply with
- 17:02our work culture. We don't allow for corneros."
- 17:07And she went to court and the Southern District
- 17:11of New York ruled in favor of the employer and
- 17:14against the employee and essentially said, well,
- 17:17look, Title VII does provide some protection,
- 17:19but not for what they considered more styles
- 17:24that could be changed. And I want to get the
- 17:26language right, but it took the position that
- 17:28braided hairstyles were not a product of natural
- 17:33hair growth and an easily changed characteristic.
- 17:39Even if it is socioculturally associated with
- 17:41a particular race or nationality, braids were
- 17:44not protected under Title VII and they weren't
- 17:47going to expand that far. But they did go on
- 17:49to say, you know, had you had an Afro, but that
- 17:52might have been different because that is something
- 17:55that we connect with race and not braids. And
- 17:58so that was an interesting early case. And later
- 18:01we'll talk about another more recent case and
- 18:03how that played out as well. And, you know, spoiler
- 18:07alert hadn't changed much under Title VII. Next
- 18:11slide. So here we have yet another very familiar
- 18:18style here. This is what we would call braids
- 18:22or twists. And while this style would not be
- 18:28at least under current case law protected under
- 18:30Title VII, it would be under most of the various
- 18:34Crown Act statutes that have recently passed.
- 18:38Same for the next slide here. These are locks
- 18:43and there are a couple cases that we'll talk
- 18:45about later where folks have brought claims.
- 18:49because their hair is locked and it's either
- 18:52running up against their employer's policies
- 18:55or deemed unprofessional for some reason or another.
- 19:02Next slide. Last here is what are referred to
- 19:06as Bantu knots. And it's another protective style,
- 19:09which as I talked about earlier, tucks away the
- 19:12hair. There's not much manipulation there. It's
- 19:14kind of going to sit like that for a while. And
- 19:17that's a protective style, which would be covered
- 19:20under the Crown Act, but not under current case
- 19:23law, Title VII. Next slide. So I've mentioned
- 19:30now Title VII a few times, and it's a federal
- 19:32statute that prohibits employment discrimination.
- 19:36There are protected categories under the statute.
- 19:41I'm sure some of you are very familiar with Title
- 19:43VII. For those who are not protected categories
- 19:45under this statute include race, color, and national
- 19:48origin, religion, and sex. So generally, it applies
- 19:56to employers who have 15 or more employees. And
- 20:00when it comes, as I was mentioning earlier, to
- 20:02hand texture and hairstyle protections, there
- 20:07isn't a lot of, you know, we're gonna expand
- 20:12this. It's really limited to Afros per the case
- 20:15law. Now, a more recent case than the 1980s case
- 20:19I mentioned earlier is this EEOC v. Catastrophe
- 20:22Management Solutions case, where in 2016, the
- 20:2711th Circuit affirmed a lower court ruling, finding
- 20:31that the employer had not violated Title VII.
- 20:34After rescinding, an offer that it had given
- 20:37to an employee who or to an applicant rather
- 20:41because that person had not started because they
- 20:43refused to cut their locks she took the position
- 20:47that you know she could wear her hair up and
- 20:49so she could comply with their policy but the
- 20:53employer um took the position that that was going
- 20:58to violate the policy and it went up to the 11th
- 21:01circuit and um they had similar reasoning to
- 21:06the earlier Senate District of New York case
- 21:08from a few decades before. And the court basically
- 21:13said that the protections aren't extended to
- 21:15hairstyles culturally associated with any specific
- 21:18race and instead to sort of what they draw the
- 21:22distinction between mutable and immutable characteristics.
- 21:28the rationale is you know afros are sort of an
- 21:31immutable characteristic whereas lox because
- 21:34they can be changed you know if you know anything
- 21:37about lox they take a really long time to form
- 21:39and grow but that falls in the immutable category
- 21:42um next slide oh so tracy's going to take us
- 21:51through some of the eoc guidance Thank you. That
- 21:55was a great overview of natural hair and protective
- 22:00styles. So Katiana is modeling a natural hairstyle
- 22:06and I'm also modeling another form of a natural
- 22:10hairstyle as she mentioned. A person might, and
- 22:15this is kind of a sensitive topic because most
- 22:20HR professionals and lawyers will agree, you're
- 22:25not going to go up to an employee. And if there's
- 22:28a foul playing saying, hey, we inspected or policed
- 22:32your hair and it's natural versus natural hairstyle.
- 22:36But the reason why this is also important is
- 22:38because there could be an underlying medical
- 22:41condition where the ADA might be implicated.
- 22:45So if someone has, if it's a male and he has
- 22:49PFB, which are razor bumps, and that's like a
- 22:52huge issue, right now in the U .S. military,
- 22:56Marines in particular, there could be an underlying
- 22:59medical condition. And then sometimes for women,
- 23:03if you are contending with alopecia or a hair
- 23:07loss in the workplace, which is why I initially
- 23:10wrote the book back in 2016. And it's not as
- 23:14if this is a hobby and I have nothing else to
- 23:16write about. But it's deeply personal to me because
- 23:20about 10 years ago, I started going through the
- 23:23process of hair loss and having to work at that
- 23:27time at a larger law firm and didn't know what
- 23:31to do. So I had to wear what is called artifice.
- 23:34So when Katiana mentioned the law and if it's
- 23:37your own hair or artificial hair, a person's
- 23:41natural hair growing out of their follicles could
- 23:44be protected by Title VII. But unfortunately,
- 23:48if it's someone who faced my situation and you're
- 23:51dealing with hair loss and you're having to cover
- 23:54up hair loss in a protective style, then so sad,
- 23:58too bad. That was before the Crown Act. So the
- 24:01Crown Act where it has been adopted is now filling
- 24:05the gap and for employment council know when
- 24:09you're screening you should also screen for underlying
- 24:12conditions even if your management side you don't
- 24:16want to be surprised because if it is in fact
- 24:19an underlying medical condition why this person
- 24:22is wearing a certain hairstyle not hair colors
- 24:25we're talking about protective hairstyles even
- 24:28if you're not in a crown act state that could
- 24:32be another exception in terms of violation of
- 24:36possible dressing grooming codes. So what are
- 24:39dressing grooming codes? Even if you don't know
- 24:44about the Crown Act until today, you think you
- 24:46might not ever see a Crown Act case. Because
- 24:49we are in a current anti -DI climate, It is highly
- 24:54advisable and Katiana is going to take me through
- 24:57this as well in terms of best practices to check
- 25:01your employee handbooks. and advise your clients
- 25:06to make sure those employee handbooks have been
- 25:09updated in terms of grooming standards. Grooming
- 25:12standards have been suggested by the EEOC, such
- 25:15as this slide. Generally, you want grooming standards
- 25:19that are gender neutral and race neutral. So
- 25:22in this particular slide, there is an example
- 25:24of one person being able to wear sideburns and
- 25:29long hair, and that employee was white, whereas
- 25:32a Black employee is not able to wear an afro
- 25:35inside burns. Next slide, please. And you all
- 25:39probably know that EEOC is an acronym for the
- 25:43Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. So we
- 25:46provided for you cases where the EEOC actually
- 25:50initiated claims on behalf of plaintiffs who
- 25:53believe that they were not treated fairly based
- 25:56on grooming standards. So when you're advising
- 25:59clients, Always go to .gov. When I do CLEs, I
- 26:04always say go to .gov because whether we like
- 26:07it or not, we're still the United States. And
- 26:10all of our main legislation is going to come
- 26:13first federal. So if you go to EEOC .gov, look
- 26:17for grooming standards. Find out what EEOC is
- 26:21stating. That's your first place in terms of
- 26:24compliance and legal risk management. And believe
- 26:28it or not, the EEOC has been writing about this
- 26:31for decades. It's just now becoming a little
- 26:34more in vogue or mainstream after the Crown Act.
- 26:38But there is a lot of cases, as Katiana mentioned,
- 26:43going back to hopefully before both of us were
- 26:46born. So I'm trying to claim some youth here.
- 26:49Next slide, please. And if you have any questions
- 26:54about how best to enact your individual employee
- 27:00handbook. Take a survey of your employees. They
- 27:03can voluntarily provide self -identification
- 27:06information, male, female, race, gender, because
- 27:10you don't want to spend a whole lot of time on
- 27:12this if it's not relevant to your workplace.
- 27:17But a great place to start is possibly doing
- 27:20a survey. And then make sure that your employee
- 27:24handbook is up to date based on the Crown Act
- 27:27and other relevant laws. Plane of sight, you
- 27:30want to make sure that you read the employee
- 27:32handbook. You can't march over to the EEOC and
- 27:36file a claim, A, if you've not read the handbook,
- 27:39and if you've not provided the employer with
- 27:42notice that you feel that you've been discriminated
- 27:44against. That's the first step of filing a claim.
- 27:47So if you feel you've been discriminated against,
- 27:50read the employee handbook. Let the employer
- 27:54know what your complaint might be, and then you
- 27:57would want to start documenting and gathering
- 28:00evidence. And Katiana is going to take us through
- 28:03a case today. In -and -out burger, don't throw
- 28:06tomatoes. I like in -and -out. But she's going
- 28:09to kind of mention that case. We don't know what's
- 28:11going to happen. It's pending legislation. But
- 28:14we do think that employers and employees should
- 28:17be aware that this is big business and you're
- 28:21potential business could be impacted. Even if
- 28:25the case is dismissed, you just don't want that
- 28:27kind of PR in the media. So let's go on to the
- 28:31next slide. I'm going to basically go over the
- 28:37Senate bill, and then Katiana is going to go
- 28:39over the next slides. But if you would like to
- 28:42actually read the Crown Act, it has been amended.
- 28:46to include not only workplace and schools, but
- 28:49now it includes also public spaces and public
- 28:53accommodations, but we're focusing on the workplace.
- 28:56But just know it's very broad, but today we're
- 28:59only focusing on the workplace. The original
- 29:01version was Senate Bill 188, and again, California
- 29:06was the first state. So a lot of states have
- 29:09modeled their Crown Act legislation after California,
- 29:13but please be aware If you are representing big
- 29:17practice, you have multi -state litigation. Some
- 29:20states only have Crown Act covering the workplace.
- 29:24Others, like Virginia or Arkansas, it's only
- 29:28to schools. And then others are all -inclusive
- 29:31like California of everything. So just be aware
- 29:35that the statutory codes differ by states. And
- 29:38plain of sight, Also be aware because if someone
- 29:43reaches out to you about a workplace issue and
- 29:47you're going to file in a state where it's only
- 29:50schools, then it's not going too far. So just
- 29:53know that each state has its own set of statutory
- 29:56codes. And I will turn over the next slide to
- 30:00Tatiana. Tatiana, sorry. All right, Jaycee, thank
- 30:04you. So Tracy kind of covered the intro on the
- 30:08California Crown Act, creating a respectful and
- 30:11open workplace for natural hair. You'll see that
- 30:15very different, slightly depending on the state,
- 30:19sometimes it's creating a respectful and open
- 30:21world, which is an ambitious sort of objective
- 30:25for natural hair. California is creating a respectful
- 30:28and open workplace. for natural hair. As she
- 30:32mentioned, it was the first in the nation to
- 30:35have this kind of statute back. It was signed
- 30:37in 2019, became effective in January. And what
- 30:43the law does is that it expands the protections
- 30:46that are provided under FIHA, the Fair Employment
- 30:50and Housing Act, and it amends the definition
- 30:53of race to include traits initially. traits historically
- 30:59associated with race -like hair texture and protective
- 31:02hairstyles. The amendment takes away the word
- 31:06historically because I've added a little bit
- 31:08of ambiguity there. So now it just says that
- 31:12it includes traits associated with race -like
- 31:14hair texture and protective hairstyles. The statute,
- 31:19so I know I mentioned earlier Title VII, which
- 31:22applies generally to employers with 15 or more.
- 31:26Employees, BHA has a little threshold where it's
- 31:30five or more employees that provide protections
- 31:34against discrimination and retaliation. The statute
- 31:37also, as far as the harassment protections are
- 31:40concerned, apply to all employers, whether you
- 31:43just have one employee. So for management side
- 31:49counsel here that are taking this webinar, you
- 31:55know, it's important to note the different thresholds
- 31:58and whether or not the statutes in different
- 32:00states apply to your particular client. The FIHA,
- 32:06like the federal statute, does have certain very
- 32:11narrow exceptions that might apply as a defense
- 32:15in certain situations. The California Civil Rights
- 32:19Department has some enforcement authority in
- 32:23California. previously called the Department
- 32:27of Fair Employment and Housing, DFEH, now it's
- 32:31the Civil Rights Department. Next slide, please.
- 32:38As I mentioned, Assembly Bill 1815, which was
- 32:43the more recent amendment to the, just last year
- 32:48passed, amending the original statute, removes
- 32:51the word historically. And also, as Tracy kind
- 32:55of referenced earlier builds on those protections
- 32:58by amending the honor civil rights act. So it
- 33:03goes outside of the just workplace protections
- 33:07previously provided. Next slide. So okay some
- 33:15of the more recent and again this is a recent
- 33:18set so I think case law is going to continue
- 33:20to develop statutes or rather claims are going
- 33:25to start being filed more in the various states,
- 33:31including California. But in December of 2019,
- 33:36the DFEH, because it had not yet gone through
- 33:39its rebrand to the CRD, issued a press release
- 33:43regarding a settlement that they had with the
- 33:48CEO of the business resource group where a former
- 33:52employee filed a complaint with the DFEH alleging
- 33:56that the company CEO was going around calling
- 34:00her unprofessional whenever she wore her hair
- 34:03either curly or in braids. And he would go the
- 34:07extra step of saying, oh, well, that looks good,
- 34:10or that looks professional. And these are the
- 34:13claims that she alleged in her complaint. But
- 34:16he would say, oh, that looks better when she
- 34:19wore her hair straight. And this is just a press
- 34:24release, so we don't have a lot of the facts
- 34:26here. But the agency did note that the CEO had
- 34:32agreed to compensate the former employees, some
- 34:36undisclosed some, and had agreed to a minimum
- 34:39of two hours of harassment prevention training.
- 34:45So that's one example that happened at the end
- 34:48of 2019. Next slide. The Thornton v. Encore group
- 34:54is an interesting one. This is back in 2021.
- 34:58And all we have here is a complaint that was
- 35:02filed in state court in San Diego, in San Diego
- 35:06County in November of 2021 here. The applicant
- 35:10who was a black job applicant, interestingly
- 35:14had worked for this company prior to COVID. So
- 35:19had worked for four years in Florida. for this
- 35:21company had not decided to lock um his hair yet
- 35:26at the time and so he worked for four years then
- 35:30was furloughed during the because of covid so
- 35:33during the furlough he opted to move to san diego
- 35:37and while in san diego received uh notice saying
- 35:42hey you know reach out to the company about restarting
- 35:45work and so he did and interviewed for um the
- 35:49same role that he previously held uh technical
- 35:53supervisor was the title and um they even at
- 35:57least in the allegations in the complaint went
- 35:59so far as to tell him that he was qualified he'd
- 36:02done the job before he was suitable for the role
- 36:05but he would need to cut um His hair and that
- 36:12now that he had locked his hair. He couldn't
- 36:14work there unless he he cut his hair and Again,
- 36:18we just have a complaint the company did issue
- 36:21a statement Saying that it was just a misunderstanding
- 36:24and that they had an offer open for him if he
- 36:28wanted to come back We don't have much more in
- 36:30terms of facts there, but that is something that,
- 36:32given these new protections and filling up the
- 36:36gaps in terms of hair texture and different hairstyles,
- 36:40it's important as employers to take a look at
- 36:42these policies and avoid situations like this
- 36:46where they are avoidable. The last recent case,
- 36:53and this one is a very recent, is the In -N -Out
- 36:57case. that was recently filed in California where
- 37:02we just, again, have a complaint. There's not
- 37:04much to report. This person though, the issue
- 37:09seems to be that the sideburns are the primary
- 37:12concern where he's alleged that his supervisor
- 37:16sort of kept nagging him and taking, being super
- 37:21critical of things that other employees were
- 37:24not given a second thought. about and um being
- 37:29requested to go be clean shaved and he didn't
- 37:33have any other facial hair other than sideburns
- 37:35and they thought that that was too long and asked
- 37:38him to go home during one of his shifts and to
- 37:40come back after he had shaved and he um decided
- 37:45well i'll come back for my next shift i'm not
- 37:47um changing my sideburns and was fired that's
- 37:51the allegations in the in the complaint we don't
- 37:53have more information there but again um it's
- 37:57a developing area of law because there aren't
- 38:01a ton of challenges around well what what all
- 38:04include is inclusive of protective hairstyles
- 38:07what's really going to be um related to to race
- 38:13in terms of traits right um so it's it's definitely
- 38:18an interesting and exciting area right now. And
- 38:23deeply personal to me. Yeah, I think is moving
- 38:35at least that was in the news recently. Oh, wow.
- 38:38Yeah, but. In terms of best practices for employers.
- 38:45Now that these laws are being enacted that let
- 38:48some employers have employees in. Various jurisdictions
- 38:51not just California right or maybe you're in
- 38:54if you're currently advising an employer who
- 38:58Just has pending legislation or it's always important
- 39:04to check updates to these different laws in California
- 39:07statute was only recently updated But you want
- 39:10to check the handbook. I know I mentioned grooming
- 39:13policies earlier with respect to hair color,
- 39:17but if there's a policy and you're in California
- 39:20that prohibits braided styles or prohibits locks.
- 39:25Maybe there's a BFOQ, bonafide qualification,
- 39:30a reason for that and maybe you can have that
- 39:33defense, but the rules are narrow and short of
- 39:36that, you would have to update the handbook or
- 39:40the policy to be compliant with the new state
- 39:44law. So it's important to train employees and
- 39:49particularly HR managers and supervisors around
- 39:54risks related to hair texture discrimination
- 39:58and how that ties back to race discrimination
- 40:02and race protections under the various statutes
- 40:05related litigation risks to those we know, even
- 40:09a nuisance complaint or a weak complaint. can
- 40:17still disrupt the workplace, can still be a drain
- 40:20on employee morale, can still be something that
- 40:24costs the company a lot of money. So implementing
- 40:27proactive internal complaint procedures is also
- 40:31key in managing workplace functionality, making
- 40:38sure that the workplace is something that is
- 40:41smooth for. as many people as possible. Auditing
- 40:46workplace policies is something to do. And again,
- 40:49this is sort of reviewing your policies, making
- 40:52sure you're compliant under federal and state
- 40:54laws. Some states don't have necessarily a Crown
- 40:58Act, but cities do. So there are different local
- 41:01statutes that have adopted, different localities
- 41:04that have adopted their own sort of smaller Crown
- 41:08Act. So it's important to... even if a state
- 41:11doesn't have it, check to see if a city does.
- 41:16And again, understanding how different hairstyles
- 41:23might be protected under different statutes and
- 41:27fostering sort of a workplace where employees
- 41:30don't necessarily harbor bad will towards the
- 41:35employer is always a plus, right? So if people
- 41:37feel like they're seen and heard, they're More
- 41:40likely to be happy, and then less likely to bring
- 41:42claims against their employers. Tracy. Thank
- 41:50you. Yes, you did a great job. Thank you. We
- 41:57do have about 15 minutes just to give you all
- 42:01a time time queue at the end. Our moderator is
- 42:06going to. Take questions if you have any questions,
- 42:11please put those in the chat and we both will
- 42:15answer as we wrap up with best practices for
- 42:19employees because we have a few more minutes
- 42:22than I thought. We're both respectful of your
- 42:25time. So we want it to be careful to not elongate
- 42:29anything, but quickly some of you may be in different
- 42:34states if your employees or if you're. Possibly
- 42:39filing a claim yourself, unfortunately, just
- 42:42know that Alaska, Arkansas, California, Colorado,
- 42:47Connecticut, Delaware, Illinois, Louisiana, Maine,
- 42:51Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Nebraska,
- 42:55Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Oregon,
- 43:00Tennessee, Texas, Virginia, Puerto Rico. as well
- 43:04as U .S. Virgin Islands have some form of the
- 43:07Crown Act. And then if you're in the District
- 43:10of Columbia, just know that there was some anti
- 43:13-hair discrimination laws going back to the 70s.
- 43:16So this is good for employees to know where you
- 43:19have Crown Act rights. And as Katiana stated,
- 43:23for employees, even if your state doesn't cover
- 43:27the Crown Act, for example, I did a COE for the
- 43:31Cleveland Bar Association. The state of Ohio
- 43:35has attempted to pass the Crown Act several times.
- 43:38It didn't pass yet, but the state didn't pass
- 43:42it, but several cities in Ohio did, Philadelphia
- 43:46as well. So just be very careful to be aware
- 43:50of even if you don't have state protection in
- 43:53terms of natural hairstyles. Then perhaps you
- 43:58could look to local, or even as I mentioned,
- 44:01some type of disability statute, if applicable.
- 44:05And of course, give and I just want to say, and.
- 44:09And I think we, we didn't mention this at least
- 44:13not several times, but. Could be there have been
- 44:17attempts to pass a federal Crown Act statute.
- 44:20It's just not been able to. Get all the way through
- 44:23to the finish line, but there have been times
- 44:26in the past to sort of fill in the gaps on a
- 44:29federal level for for different protections where
- 44:34title seven might. um fall short given current
- 44:37uh case law and interpretations of again you
- 44:40know how race is defined or how um certain anti
- 44:44-discrimination statutes are interpreted for
- 44:47the scope of their protections but um we we will
- 44:51see i i think there is a current one that's moving
- 44:54around in in congress somewhere i doubt that
- 44:57that's going to see the light of day in the next
- 45:00few years but um It is something that has been
- 45:04that many several attempts have been made and
- 45:06we'll, we'll, we'll see. It might just be for
- 45:08the next few years that more states or localities
- 45:11pass more. You know, state specific or city specific
- 45:16statutes. And we're saying that in a political
- 45:20way. Yes, it is pending. I think it was, we introduced
- 45:25maybe February of 2025. If you want us to follow
- 45:30up with another CLE, we'd be happy to dive in
- 45:35and review the legislation. I'll let you know
- 45:38why quickly based on the way I've seen it. It's
- 45:42a great attempt, but I think it's going to have
- 45:47to take a different path. To pass in the current
- 45:51U. S. Congress, but that would be a whole nother
- 45:54CLE, but as Katiana mentioned, it is a great
- 45:58attempt and we're very pleased that it has been
- 46:02passed because truly that's the only way to not
- 46:05have hodgepodge legislation. One state has it.
- 46:08One doesn't. The solution as Katiana mentioned
- 46:12is to have federal legislation and that would
- 46:16be short of defining title seven. Which I think
- 46:19would take a lot of momentum. But for now, the
- 46:22Crown Act, we're happy that we have a filler
- 46:25for those who are pro Crown Act. And for those
- 46:28who don't want another regulation, you have counsel
- 46:31to help you sort through. But as we mentioned,
- 46:38for employees, know your rights. So part of knowing
- 46:41your rights is knowing which state has enacted
- 46:43the Crown Act and to be aware of pending federal
- 46:46legislation. And if you are, in fact, in support
- 46:49of it, reach out to your local congressman or
- 46:52woman. Examples of other forms of protection
- 46:56might be found in Title VII. We went over the
- 46:59difference between employment law and labor law,
- 47:01so you might look to the NLRA. As well as California
- 47:06Crown Act, review employee handbook and make
- 47:09sure that. Employers, please don't take down
- 47:13any workplace employment posters. I know that
- 47:16we are in an era of uncertainty in terms of EOs,
- 47:20meaning executive orders, that might conflict
- 47:23with employee rights, but it is against the federal
- 47:26law to take down those posters. So for employers,
- 47:29don't take them down. For employees, continue
- 47:31to read them. Because even though executive orders
- 47:35are coming down a pipeline that may seem to negate
- 47:38employee rights, there is an order of authority.
- 47:42So generally, in our system of federalism, you're
- 47:45always going to look to case law, statutes, and
- 47:49executive orders. With that being said, I am
- 47:53definitely in favor of following all three. So
- 47:55you want to be aware of EOs, you want to be aware
- 47:58of statutes, and you want to be aware of case
- 48:01law. But we want to try to work with all three
- 48:03sets of law in tandem, keeping in mind the hierarchy
- 48:07of law. Be aware of internal HR policies and
- 48:13use the complaint channel effectively. So, for
- 48:16example, I've seen this over and over again where
- 48:20employees complain and they believe they have
- 48:23a strong claim, but they forgot one important
- 48:25point. You have to let your employer know, even
- 48:28if there's a concern about retaliation, be aware
- 48:32of potential whistleblower acts or some type
- 48:35of workplace protection, but you have to let
- 48:37your and for your know that you feel you've been
- 48:40discriminated against, even if it's something
- 48:43for a lot of people that might be as mean as
- 48:46hair. But for those who dealt with it, not discrimination,
- 48:50but feeling uncomfortable, hair can be a big
- 48:54deal because it's our appearance and people do
- 48:56judge us based on how we look. We would want
- 48:59that to be more performance, but it matters.
- 49:02And then also be aware of where to file a claim.
- 49:07So the civil right, the California civil rights
- 49:10department. CRD was formerly a different agency,
- 49:15the California Department of Fair Housing and
- 49:18Employment, but now it's changed to California
- 49:21Civil Rights Department. So just be aware of
- 49:23the name change, but you still have protection.
- 49:26And then employees participate in HR trainings.
- 49:30It's not about black. It's not about white. It's
- 49:32not about Hispanic or Asian or multiracial. Trainings
- 49:36can be effective even if it's not titled DEI
- 49:39or affinity group. there's still an opportunity
- 49:42to participate and provide feedback. And with
- 49:46that, I will turn it over to our moderator and
- 49:49ask if we have any questions. Just before we
- 49:52turn it over to questions, I think this is in
- 49:56again from the management side here, but some
- 49:59of the pushback against creating a new statute,
- 50:03either you don't want more regulation or you
- 50:05feel like Title VII, There is, you know, protections
- 50:09for afros, but as far as other hairstyles, feeling
- 50:13like, well, it's a neutral policy, which again,
- 50:16you know, some of the Crown Act statutes do sort
- 50:18of address in their own way. But there are also
- 50:21protections where, like in your case, Tracy,
- 50:23you mentioned it was tied to a health condition.
- 50:27So maybe then there's an ADA consideration. where
- 50:31it might be tied to a religious belief. So we're
- 50:33back in Title VII, but we're talking about religious
- 50:36protections in that instance, and not necessarily
- 50:38race, right? So I think it's important that we
- 50:42sort of go through the exercise of going through
- 50:45the different ways hair might be implicated,
- 50:49even if it's not necessarily tied to specific
- 50:51hairstyle and race, but maybe it's because there
- 50:54has to be an accommodation for a medical condition
- 50:56or accommodation for a religious practice. Absolutely.
- 51:01So, for example, we've had a slide showing the
- 51:04lots. And if I ask you, when we think of lots,
- 51:09what religion comes to mind? Exactly. So you
- 51:15want to be very careful. And then in some of
- 51:17the EEOC versus UPS, UPS has been seen a lot.
- 51:22So Benioir and Beer is representing UPS. You
- 51:25definitely want to watch this one again. There
- 51:28was a whole line of cases about hair. And believe
- 51:31it or not, it wasn't women. So we want to be
- 51:34careful also to be sex neutral because it is
- 51:38primarily men with long beards and they were
- 51:41Christian, they were a Christian set, or people
- 51:45wearing hijabs or burkas. right? So it's not
- 51:48always just hair, it could be head coverings,
- 51:52or if someone's Jewish and they're wearing a
- 51:54yarmulke. So there are a lot of different intersectionalities
- 51:58in terms of protected categories. As Katiana
- 52:01mentioned, it could be race, it could be religion,
- 52:03and now with the current administration and this
- 52:07definition of men and women as two sexes, we
- 52:11also want to be careful about transitioners and
- 52:14any type of Gender distinctions that might come
- 52:18into play with there. Maybe there is a rule that
- 52:20men can wear. Long hair or short hair and women
- 52:24can't so also check for hair length. And as we
- 52:28wrap up here, lens was a big issue because there
- 52:31was recently a case with a student in Texas who
- 52:35actually filed a Crown Act complaint. And the
- 52:38Crown Act did not mean. uh, jurisdictional muster
- 52:42court threw it out because it said that particular
- 52:45statute didn't mention hair length and it was
- 52:48a male student who was excluded from school for
- 52:51long. I believe you had dreads and perhaps there
- 52:55was a grooming code saying girls should have
- 52:57a certain length, boys should have a certain
- 52:59length or no mention of length at all. So there
- 53:02are a lot of different nuances and it just means
- 53:06if you're pro -crown at very broad to capture,
- 53:10and if you're anti more regulations, then you're
- 53:14going to fight for any way you can to have it
- 53:18dismissed. And with that, I'll actually ask for
- 53:21Katiana to provide some feedback. Do you think
- 53:23we're leading on a road of being overly regulatory,
- 53:27especially with companies leaving California
- 53:30for that very reason? There's a lot of pushback
- 53:32about that. I'll reserve any thoughts on that.
- 53:36Let's then just take it to questions. Yeah, well,
- 53:40I am brave here as an entrepreneur. I have a
- 53:43little more freedom. I'd say there has to be
- 53:45some type of a medium, right? Because we do want
- 53:50to protect employees, but I do understand the
- 53:54concern about being overly burdensome to employers.
- 53:58So I think as we learn in law school, it depends,
- 54:02but. There's definitely room for improvement
- 54:05in terms of how. Current legislation is being
- 54:09presented, but there are a lot of different issues
- 54:12that are not covered. So, we do have 2 more slides
- 54:22left for federal context and risk mitigation
- 54:25and then key legal takeaways. I'll turn that
- 54:29over to Katiana. For the federal risk, because
- 54:33I think it's mostly related to your clients.
- 54:36I'm concerned about compliance. Yeah, I think
- 54:40we touched on this earlier. It's the focus on
- 54:43risk prevention and. Making sure that you're
- 54:48compliant with where applicable both federal
- 54:51and and state. Um, rules and as far as the current
- 54:56climate is concerned, um, I mean, even with many
- 55:00of the executive orders, a lot of the. Language
- 55:03also does include the caveat that you're supposed
- 55:06to follow the law and. If employees going to
- 55:09bring a lawsuit, it's not going to be because
- 55:11they necessarily read the executive order closely
- 55:14and decided something. No, it's going to be.
- 55:16Under whatever applicable statute applies, whether
- 55:19federal or state, and so you want to be compliant
- 55:21with the law because it's still the law of the
- 55:23land. Um, and so. Do your trainings do review.
- 55:30It's really good to at least do a policy review
- 55:34every year, particularly when it comes to employment
- 55:37policies. But, um, you know, you've got a gold
- 55:41star. I think it's, it's every every at least
- 55:44twice. twice a year, maybe at the end of Q1,
- 55:48I mean, at the end of, I'm sorry, the first half
- 55:50of the year, so Q2, and then at the end of the
- 55:52year, when a lot of new employment statutes tend
- 55:55to get passed. And it's really important to have
- 56:02the policies in place for employees where they
- 56:05do feel like they've been harmed, have a means
- 56:08to report the alleged sort of bad act. right
- 56:14whether that's to a supervisor or um a sort of
- 56:18third party um outside of their reporting channel
- 56:22where they can reach out and and get the investigation
- 56:25going if necessary and um I tend to find this
- 56:29with my clients folks just want to be able to
- 56:32be compliant and they want guidance on how to
- 56:34do that they want to be able to treat their employees
- 56:36properly under the law and sometimes it's not
- 56:38clear as we got went through this these different
- 56:43slides, we see courts sometimes struggle with
- 56:46how to interpret the statutes. These are new
- 56:51statutes, so it's constantly evolving and so
- 56:55important for employers to frequently review
- 57:00their current handbook and workplace policies
- 57:03and make sure they have processes in place for
- 57:05employees to address concerns. What about the
- 57:13slide in terms of identity? How can we still
- 57:18allow employees to possibly associate with affinity
- 57:23groups or have some type of identity in the workplace,
- 57:28but not feel as though they're going to be a
- 57:31target in terms of discrimination? Yeah, I think
- 57:36that that's more than a hair. and hair texture
- 57:40or hairstyle sort of consideration there. Affinity
- 57:44groups are not an illegal sort of per se prohibited
- 57:49facet of the workplace. Many employers have,
- 57:54given the current climate, taken the approach
- 57:55of maybe removing affinity groups from the workplace.
- 57:59But generally speaking, if you have an affinity
- 58:01group, if it's open to everyone and not Restrictive
- 58:05of okay. Well, it's only open to these groups
- 58:07of people. There's not and something where you're
- 58:12violating the law there without seeing the policy
- 58:15without reviewing it. I can't say, you know,
- 58:17for sure, but. If any are permissible and they're
- 58:21under even the current executive orders that
- 58:23have been issued, it's just. They can't be restrictive
- 58:27to certain classes. Perfect. I think it's great
- 58:30that we mentioned that because a lot of. Employers
- 58:33are now going back for determining what to do
- 58:37based on conflicting EOs from current versus
- 58:41previous administration. So I'll wrap up in two
- 58:44minutes with key legal takeaways. The California
- 58:47Crown Act is legally enforceable in your workplace
- 58:50in California. And for those of us who are pro
- 58:54-human rights, I am definitely in favor of it.
- 58:57And if you would like to support the federal
- 58:59legislation, please contact Your state and federal
- 59:04representative employers must bring workplace
- 59:07policies around neutrality, not preferences even
- 59:11with. Affinity groups, as Katiana just mentioned.
- 59:15Employees have tools to protect their employee
- 59:17rights. They can also complain, right, through
- 59:22a formal channel in the workplace if they feel
- 59:25that they've been discriminated against based
- 59:27on natural hair and protective hair styles. Employees
- 59:31still have constitution as constitutional and
- 59:34civil rights, even with some of the current EOs,
- 59:38social justice is not dead, it's just being redefined,
- 59:42aligned with both sides, both state and federal
- 59:46standards for best results. And that's for both
- 59:48employers and employees. And with that, I am
- 59:52very pleased to say we started on time and we're
- 59:55ending on time. Well, we do want to, and I'm
- 59:58not sure if there are any questions, but to the
- 59:59extent we have questions. There aren't based
- 1:00:04on what I last thought. So, I'm always conscious
- 1:00:07to get you all that because I know it's probably
- 1:00:09work hour, but thank you on behalf of the Beverly
- 1:00:12Hills Bar Association and also the Black Women's
- 1:00:16Association of Los Angeles made this event possible.
- 1:00:20They're also media sponsor and Katiana, if you
- 1:00:24have any closing words. Thank you for your time
- 1:00:28and Tracy, thank you for, you know, sort of spearheading
- 1:00:30this. Terrific panel. I appreciate everyone for
- 1:00:34coming. Bye everyone. Thank you. You did great.