Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The New Rules of Rideshare: SB 623 and the Future of Uber and Lyft Injury Claims
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to the New Rules of Ride Share, Senate
- 0:07Bill 623 and the Future of Uber and Lyft Injury
- 0:10Claims. I'm Philip Vondra, Chair of the Beverly
- 0:13Hills Bar Association's Personal Injury Law Section.
- 0:17I'm delighted to introduce our speaker, Doris
- 0:20Chang, shareholder at Walk Up Melodia, Kelly
- 0:23and Schoenberger, who specializes in complex.
- 0:27injuries caused by third -party negligence and
- 0:30has obtained multi -million -dollar verdicts
- 0:32and settlements on behalf of disabled plaintiffs,
- 0:36including a $15 million verdict and two $19 million
- 0:40settlements. Ranked among the top 10 lawyers
- 0:43in Northern California, she was named best lawyer
- 0:46of the year in 2017, profiled on the cover of
- 0:51Super Lawyers Magazine in 2025. and received
- 0:54the inaugural Obota Champion of Justice Award
- 0:57in 2022. The 106th president of the Bar Association
- 1:03of San Francisco and a fellow of the American
- 1:06College of Trial Lawyers. She has trained trial
- 1:09lawyers and judges nationally and internationally
- 1:12and co -authored the Rudder Group California
- 1:15Practice Guide on personal injury. And now let's
- 1:18get started. Thank you so much, Philip. I so
- 1:23appreciate being here. And thank you, Beverly
- 1:26Hills Bar Association for welcoming me. I am
- 1:29the incoming president for the American Board
- 1:32of Trial Advocates National. And it's really
- 1:35fun to talk about the different things that our
- 1:38practice covers and the ways that it affects
- 1:42us as individuals and our continued pursuit for
- 1:46democracy. And the Seventh Amendment right to
- 1:49a civil jury trial. So those are all the things
- 1:52that I know are important to you. They're important
- 1:54to me. And with the Uber initiative, this was
- 1:59the incredible strain, I think, of the year 2026.
- 2:04And it started in November 2025. I'm going to
- 2:08share at least a PowerPoint with you. And we
- 2:12won't live in it the entire time. I do want to
- 2:16cover a few things just so that you have something
- 2:19to focus on here and there as we kind of go about
- 2:22this. So, you know, what happened? How do we
- 2:26get to this place? And I'm going to give you
- 2:29a little historical background, certainly from
- 2:32my perspective, because I think you don't know
- 2:34where we're going if you don't know where we've
- 2:36been. And where have we been? And let's take
- 2:39us back, you know, auto crashes have been around
- 2:41forever. We all know that, and we've experienced
- 2:44that. in our friends, our families, and as practitioners,
- 2:49I'm sure so many of you have been asked from
- 2:52some time or another, can you help out my friend?
- 2:55You know, those may be some of the smaller cases.
- 2:58And by smaller, I mean, you know, cases where
- 3:01there is a recoverable injury in terms of the
- 3:04physical recovery. You know, somebody got hurt,
- 3:08and maybe it is back injuries, uh maybe it is
- 3:14a concussion, maybe it is something like that
- 3:17where you know okay this is not the permanent
- 3:20type of injury you know that will disable you
- 3:23but a majority of the cases in California look
- 3:26just like that and people have rights. I remember
- 3:30being um with a judge one time who said how many
- 3:32of you here feel like there are too many lawsuits
- 3:34and there were a number of people who raised
- 3:36their hand and I was so proud of that judge who
- 3:39said well You know, one of the reasons that people
- 3:42bring lawsuits is because, well, or one of the
- 3:45reasons that you may think there are so many
- 3:47lawsuits is actually because in the United States,
- 3:50we have a lot of rights. That's not something
- 3:52that all countries can boast about. But we do.
- 3:56And so it is up to the individuals to decide
- 3:59whether they want to exercise that right. Your
- 4:02right to a First Amendment, your right to uh
- 4:06the fourth amendment your rights under the you
- 4:09know sixth and seventh as we said so we have
- 4:11rights we have tort rights uh and i'm going to
- 4:15take us back at least to 1988 and i mentioned
- 4:18this time frame because this was when colossus
- 4:23was developed and i wish i could see all of you
- 4:26here and ask you how many of you know what colossus
- 4:28is and uh this is a database so at a certain
- 4:32point in time looking at all the lawsuits, looking
- 4:35at the fact that you could, even in 1988, before
- 4:38we get to AI big data, there was computerized
- 4:43data collection about claims. And part of the
- 4:48reason for that was to start taking away the
- 4:53lack of uniformity in how people evaluated cases.
- 4:56And it was really on the claim side. Because
- 4:59before Colossus, people were relying upon claims
- 5:04adjusters who knew the area, knew the locality,
- 5:07knew how verdicts and judgments were being decided.
- 5:10And so one of the things about big data and any
- 5:13big data, today we are dealing with big data
- 5:16all the time. I'm just gonna take this down for
- 5:19a moment, but the reason that matters is how
- 5:22do we get to where we are? Okay, so when you
- 5:24looked at the big data, how did the claims adjusting
- 5:29side begin to uniform or make consistent the
- 5:34way that claims are being adjusted or settled,
- 5:38resolved. And metrics came out. What are the
- 5:43medical bills? What are the special damages?
- 5:46What factor of those economic damages became
- 5:49how jurors evaluated the non -economic damages?
- 5:54And there were patterns, just as you're gonna
- 5:56see patterns anytime that you put anything today
- 5:58into chat GPT. And so interestingly, those metrics
- 6:03became the foundation for how cases got evaluated.
- 6:09And anytime that somebody said, well, I've got
- 6:13to evaluate this case on the defense side. If
- 6:15you're the plaintiff's lawyer, Mr. and Mrs. plaintiff's
- 6:19lawyer, I want you to give me the medical bills.
- 6:21I want you to give me the wage loss. And very
- 6:25little then was about, well, what are the actual
- 6:27non -economic damages? that then became something
- 6:30that was tailored in, I would say less specific,
- 6:34you know, and unless you have like some horrific
- 6:36burn case, orthopedic cases, you know, soft tissue
- 6:43injury cases became standardized in a way. And
- 6:47interestingly, and even 2010, Allstate was one
- 6:51of the companies that was subject to lawsuit
- 6:55because they were in violation of regulations,
- 6:58right? Insurance regulations. And they paid quite
- 7:01a big sum of money at that time because they
- 7:03were alleged to have misused the software. So
- 7:08isn't that interesting? Because what did you
- 7:11see start to happen over the course of time?
- 7:13You started to see in California for us here,
- 7:16Howell, and that was a 2011 decision. And what
- 7:20did it do? It minimized or it reduced what you
- 7:24could actually introduce at trial. about medical
- 7:28bills, because guess what? People were evaluating
- 7:32non -economic damages based on your medical bills.
- 7:35And that was one way that certainly from the
- 7:38defense side it was, how do I get these numbers
- 7:40down? I don't fault the defense side for that.
- 7:42You must all now know I'm a plaintiff's attorney.
- 7:45Everybody actually has to do their job and each
- 7:47of us has a role. And I would say it's the right
- 7:50thing to do, right? This is why an adversarial
- 7:52system works. So I don't want any of you to think
- 7:54that I'm just advocating for one side. But here
- 7:57was Howell. And Howell, like I said, California
- 8:00Supreme Court decision, which now said you can't
- 8:03introduce more than what the insurance company
- 8:05paid. And as you all remember, in the course
- 8:08of 2011 up to today, we've had various iterations
- 8:12of what we can use for future values, for past
- 8:19values. And so I'm gonna, I think all of you
- 8:22do know how, as I just explained it is, you know,
- 8:25you can only introduce the amount that was actually
- 8:27paid or incurred. That was the language that
- 8:30we saw. And so if it wasn't your insurance company,
- 8:35I mean, medical insurance company paying for
- 8:38it, and you were then paying out of pocket, that
- 8:40was the amount incurred. Okay, so now let's talk
- 8:44about the Pebley case. PEBLY is a 2018 decision.
- 8:53So seven years later, what has been the outgrowth
- 8:57of, again, trying to make sure that there isn't
- 9:00one side taking advantage of the circumstance?
- 9:04I mean, because let's be realistic about what
- 9:10metrics are being used. If you are... uh older
- 9:13than 65 probably older than 63 you've got medicare
- 9:17the medicare we know is paying a lot less than
- 9:22say the person who's 40 years old using blue
- 9:24shield blue cross or uh say the person who's
- 9:28uninsured altogether and so again if people are
- 9:32using those numbers as the metric well then you've
- 9:35got really uh aggressive plane of lawyers who
- 9:39said well okay, why should my client actually
- 9:44use health insurance? Why should you rely, let's
- 9:47say on Medi -Cal, which we know is a public system
- 9:52where, and I don't know, so many of you have
- 9:55tried these cases. I've tried cases where we've
- 9:58known in MenMal, for instance, where I've got
- 10:02a disabled baby that then grows into childhood
- 10:05and needs services. You know, if they're on Medi
- 10:08-Cal, The backup for being able to get some of
- 10:11those services is so bad that you wish you could
- 10:14just pay out of pocket and find somebody immediately.
- 10:17Those are real challenges that I think people
- 10:20have to respect and understand. And so when you
- 10:23look at Pebley, don't look at it just as a jaundice
- 10:25eye or with skepticism that, oh, these are just
- 10:29plaintiff's lawyer trying to inflate the number.
- 10:32In the Pebley case, the plaintiff went out of
- 10:35network meaning they did have health insurance,
- 10:38but instead of using their health insurance,
- 10:41they got their care out of network. And the question
- 10:44that came up in that case was, if they had insurance
- 10:47and they chose not to use the insurance, could
- 10:50they then submit the full amount of the bill,
- 10:54the medical bills? Was that fair? Was that reasonable?
- 11:00And the court of appeal, And this was called
- 11:05a pebbly versus Santa Clara organics 22 Cal app
- 11:10fifth 1266 where the court of appeal held that
- 11:15if the person went out of network and did pay
- 11:18the full amount of the bill, they were treated
- 11:20as uninsured within the meaning of how within
- 11:23the meaning of how in its progeny, I should say.
- 11:25And so that was really important because that
- 11:28did say, all right, if the plaintiff didn't want
- 11:30to resort to, you know, whoever was in their
- 11:33network, which let's be fair, may not always
- 11:35be the best doctors. And if the plaintiff wanted
- 11:39a better doctor, they could actually seek out
- 11:42that care, pay the full rate, and get reimbursed
- 11:46in their third party claim. So that's what Pebley
- 11:51gave. uh license too and let me say that um the
- 11:54next case that came about just for your educational
- 11:57ceo lee uh the kadir versus uh figaroa this is
- 12:03a 2021 decision 67 cal app fifth 790 uh which
- 12:10same thing stuck to pebbly and said that's controlling.
- 12:14Look to howls at that's controlling. And evidence
- 12:18of a medical bill is relevant to prove or disprove
- 12:21the paid or incurred prong of past medical damages
- 12:25if it can be established the bill is actually
- 12:27paid or incurred. Okay, so how do we now get
- 12:32to the Uber situation? You've got the history
- 12:34of that. How do we get to, as I say, the incredible
- 12:37stress for everybody doing auto cases in 2026
- 12:43well in 2025 uh uber launched an initiative and
- 12:50say i'm going to take you just to here was the
- 12:53original ballot provision and filed november
- 12:572025 and the uh basic there if you take a moment
- 13:04to read it um you'll see there's an entire explanation
- 13:08of why they wanted to push the bill across But
- 13:12backed by Uber, basically, they formed this other
- 13:15little entity, a more affordable California that
- 13:18sponsored to put the campaign out there on this
- 13:21initiative. And they pursued the angle on this
- 13:26was the California Constitution to protect victims
- 13:29of automobile accidents from self -dealing billboard
- 13:33attorneys. It was pretty targeted, pretty specific.
- 13:38Not pretty, I should just drop the disclaimer
- 13:40on that. It was very specific. And it called
- 13:43out a segment of plaintiff lawyers and called
- 13:45them the self -dealing billboard attorneys. And
- 13:49let me say, what did it purport to do? Actually,
- 13:51before I get to this part, what was the goal?
- 13:55So when you do read that, the fight on that became
- 13:58okay. you know what there are these billboard
- 14:01lawyers out there who are self -dealing and now
- 14:04you've got people not using insurance at all
- 14:08and they are getting kickbacks from their doctors
- 14:12so you know the theory was that hey these plaintiff
- 14:17lawyers are trying to increase the medical bills
- 14:21by sending you to doctors that will only go on
- 14:24a lean basis. And in fact, the lawyers are getting
- 14:27a kickback from the doctors. And so that is the
- 14:30self dealing part. And, you know, I would say
- 14:34through the course of this fight, there was an
- 14:36acknowledgement that that was happening. I mean,
- 14:39you know, I would say this campaign, it didn't
- 14:41make it up. There were places where for sure
- 14:43this was happening. And so this bill was targeted
- 14:47at getting rid of that self -dealing. And the
- 14:50angle, as I said, it took was to cap the fees
- 14:55and medical bills at 25%. The flip of that was
- 14:59what was advertised. With this new bill, accident
- 15:03victims, car crash accident victims, would get
- 15:0775%. OK, that really is untenable. We'll get
- 15:11into the reasons why in a moment. The other thing
- 15:14that it was aiming to do was to set all of these
- 15:19medical rates at the Medi -Cal Medicare numbers,
- 15:23which we know was the lowest denominator. And
- 15:26as I said, and I'm sure there's was the strategy
- 15:29behind this was they knew this was gonna be a
- 15:32beginning place, not necessarily an ending place.
- 15:35I would say you would find with these incredibly
- 15:38smart and strategic people They knew this was
- 15:43not the end game, but it was certainly the beginning.
- 15:47And it was not just the medical bills and stuff
- 15:51that we're talking about. What else was out there
- 15:53for Uber? Why did Uber care? And there were some
- 15:56things that weren't talked about in this bill,
- 15:58but were on the horizon and that completely mattered.
- 16:01Uber sex assault cases. That gained so much traction.
- 16:06There were horrific stories. uh in the media
- 16:09and that were completely true about people women
- 16:13taking ubers who were getting assaulted by the
- 16:16drivers uh fake uber drivers rolling up not having
- 16:22a way to verify that this was the person that
- 16:25was supposed to be catching the ride and uh women
- 16:28getting violated raped be very plain about it
- 16:32and that was on the horizon and that was not
- 16:34good for uber what else was coming down the pipe
- 16:38uh for people in the bay area uh and and you
- 16:41know i think in southern california have you
- 16:43seen waymo i've seen waymo in san francisco uh
- 16:47they were roaming the streets for at least two
- 16:49to three years that was huge competition for
- 16:52uber isn't it huge competition for them now how
- 16:55many women would rather be in a waymo where there's
- 16:58no driver versus an uber where there is a driver
- 17:02and whether you have to make awkward conversation
- 17:04or be fearful that uh you'll be assaulted either
- 17:08way it eliminated that but where was uber going
- 17:11to go with that and what was the concern and
- 17:12worry so let me just suggest there were much
- 17:15bigger things out there this was like a small
- 17:18piece of the the fight and i would say just to
- 17:22have awareness about that matters for all of
- 17:24us when we think about where are we going in
- 17:26the future what's going to be happening in the
- 17:28future because Robo taxi is the future. It's
- 17:31actually the present. You know, currently in
- 17:33San Francisco, Waymo can't get on the freeways
- 17:36or highways, but it is all throughout the city.
- 17:38And I will say they've done a very good job of
- 17:42mapping out the city so that, you know, there
- 17:45are plenty of problems with it, but knowing the
- 17:49streets and not hitting anything so far. has
- 17:52actually been a big plus for Waymo. And that's
- 17:56a big downturn for Lyft and Uber. And so I would
- 18:00just say Uber because they backed it. But really,
- 18:02for the rideshare group and the people that were
- 18:06profiting from that, this has been a big concern.
- 18:09And so where was the attack? The attack was on
- 18:13the low hanging fruit, which was these auto cases.
- 18:16And where can you make a dent in that? Because
- 18:18remember, this initiative covered all auto cases.
- 18:22It didn't matter what kind. It didn't matter
- 18:24that it was specifically Uber or Lyft. It was
- 18:28any car accident. And that really was a big threat
- 18:32to the plaintiff's bar. And I would not just
- 18:36say just to the lawyers, because I would say
- 18:37it's not just about the lawyers. And this is
- 18:40where I do want to talk about the fees here.
- 18:43I mean, I focused a lot on the medical, because
- 18:45that's one of the metrics for getting the numbers
- 18:47down. But the other big attack, and we saw many
- 18:51of this in the 1890s, when there was the other
- 18:55round of attack on attorney's fees. And that
- 18:58isn't about attorneys. That is still about the
- 19:01right to choose counsel. Because you'll notice
- 19:04in all of these types of legislation, there is
- 19:07no cap on the defense side. There is no cap on
- 19:13how much insurance carriers can spend on defending
- 19:18a case against any plaintiff, not on the attorney
- 19:22side or the cost side. And so what happens? The
- 19:26same thing that generally happens that we're
- 19:27all worried about. Are you run by corporations?
- 19:30Are corporations so heavily leveraged because
- 19:33they have the money that they can choose lawyers
- 19:36and they can outspend you? You know, if anybody
- 19:39here has a case against a corporation, I won't
- 19:41name the corporations, but you know there are
- 19:44certain corporations. You were in it for the
- 19:45long haul. If you have filed the lawsuit, you're
- 19:47in it for four years because you will spend two
- 19:49years fighting over discovery. Is that fair?
- 19:53Is that right? It's an adversarial system. Is
- 19:56it a good use of time? we all have evaluated
- 19:59feelings about that. And so I'm going to say
- 20:01that this whole fee cap thing is a big issue
- 20:06because the people who cannot make those decisions
- 20:10are going to be the plaintiffs themselves. So
- 20:14what is it about contingency fee? And I want
- 20:19to talk about that a little bit. Why is there
- 20:23an existence of contingency fee? And I always
- 20:25explain this to you know, people that I meet
- 20:27my clients or that nobody ever socked away money
- 20:32to hire a personal injury lawyer. That's not
- 20:36how we live our lives. You know, you save up
- 20:40money for a house. You save up money for your
- 20:43car. You save up money for college. Nobody saves
- 20:46up money on the one day that you might need to
- 20:48hire an attorney. So the reality is that money
- 20:51is not there. All right. So how do you make sure
- 20:54that you can get representation Well, a model
- 20:58for that is on a contingency because the only
- 21:00place that you may be able to get that money
- 21:03is through the third party defendant who perhaps
- 21:07has the funds to pay you in the settlement in
- 21:10our compensatory system. And so what it does
- 21:14for the plaintiffs is allow a payment system
- 21:17for representation, but it's deferred. And that
- 21:20does mean that the attorney on the plaintiff's
- 21:22side is bearing all the risk and the cost. You're
- 21:26not taking your fees now. Guess what? The defense
- 21:28attorney gets paid hourly. Although I will say
- 21:31there are Kaiser cases, but even there, Kaiser
- 21:34cases on the MedMal defense side, they get a
- 21:36flat rate, but they're getting paid up front.
- 21:39They're not having to defer. The risk for the
- 21:41plaintiff's attorney is that it is being deferred.
- 21:44And what happens if the settlement is not what
- 21:47it's originally projected to be? We all know
- 21:49cases get better over time. Sometimes they get
- 21:51worse over time. And so what does that mean?
- 21:54And I'm just saying that to understand how the
- 21:57model works is so that my friends on the other
- 22:00side of the aisle aren't criticizing it. It is
- 22:03a way for people to be represented. I think all
- 22:06of us as lawyers have to believe that you are
- 22:08better off represented than unrepresented. So
- 22:11that attack on the attorney's fees really does
- 22:14matter. The other thing that this, and I'll come
- 22:20back to the PowerPoint now. Okay, so here was
- 22:27what was the proposed deal on the attorney's
- 22:30fees, as I just talked about the 75%, but it
- 22:34had a couple of other hooks in it that when you
- 22:37made the deal, because generally under our business
- 22:40and professions code 6147, it is negotiated by
- 22:46contract. And so everybody has free will. You
- 22:50could actually charge a third, you could charge
- 22:53uh 40 you could charge 50 I mean those are ranges
- 22:57that we have seen in our profession but it's
- 22:59by contract and it may be based upon how difficult
- 23:02the cases or various other factors but this was
- 23:05intended to cut that out and actually make it
- 23:07a misdemeanor if the attorneys uh tried to affect
- 23:11the rule so this was the proposal then limitations
- 23:15on the medical expenses was listed out okay unpaid
- 23:18past medical expenses was 125 % of the fee for
- 23:23service Medicare reimbursement. And actually,
- 23:25that's too low. If you did your own search, just
- 23:29using our regular Google, not even going into
- 23:32your wonderful AI capacity, you'll find that
- 23:35number is too low. That won't actually reimburse
- 23:38all the doctors. Is that fair to the doctors?
- 23:40Are they going to fully get paid? So these are,
- 23:45as I said before, Uber certainly knew what they
- 23:47were doing. They are not novices. at the legislation
- 23:51negotiation. And these are beginning points.
- 23:54So you could see what plaintiffs and plaintiff's
- 23:58attorneys were trying to overcome. But here's
- 24:00the other thing that is always so troublesome.
- 24:02Okay, let's change the burden of proof now. That
- 24:05was another, you know, hook in all of this. And
- 24:08then for future medical expenses, private insurance
- 24:11coverage, there was defined rules for that. Okay,
- 24:16there were a couple of other things, as we said,
- 24:18hooked in to this and one way to make it more
- 24:22palpable, take it out on the sexual harassment
- 24:24claims or sexual assault claims. And that was
- 24:29interesting, right? It's like if these this was
- 24:32a multi frontal attack, recognizing, as I said,
- 24:37that all of you do now, there are multiple issues
- 24:39in play in the tort realm. And this was only
- 24:43dealing with one small part to affect the rest
- 24:45of it. And so then you had a head on collision,
- 24:50seriously, a humongous battle. And so CAOC, the
- 24:55consumer attorneys of California came out very
- 24:57aggressively strong and gave examples of how
- 25:02this doesn't work. I mean, you can imagine we've
- 25:04got $100 ,000 defendants have let's say $100
- 25:10,000 auto policy, but somebody got hit in a crosswalk.
- 25:14is thrown out over the in the street has multiple
- 25:19orthopedic injuries is in the hospital for let's
- 25:22say a week. You know that the medical bills are
- 25:26way in excess of $100 ,000. You know that anything
- 25:30above that $100 ,000 is not collectible. And
- 25:33yet this would apply. That's a huge problem.
- 25:37Right? Is that fair for any of the parties involved?
- 25:41Does that what would effectively happen? As we
- 25:44know is like with the medical malpractice cases
- 25:47in 1975 when the cap for pain and suffering damages
- 25:51got hit at 250 ,000 remain there as all of you
- 25:54remember until the year 2023 what happened you
- 25:59had a whole bunch of lawyers who didn't take
- 26:01those cases and that's what it was intended to
- 26:03do all right and so is this actually going to
- 26:06affect the ability for people to exercise their
- 26:10right if they get hit And there isn't an attorney
- 26:15who wants to take that case because for all the
- 26:18work that has to get done, it may not be worth
- 26:21it. But that's a way to legislate a label on
- 26:26something that, like I say, the legislature would
- 26:29call it frivolous, even though that right should
- 26:32be as equal as any other right. And so this is
- 26:36the head -on fight that we were getting. For
- 26:42the ads, it was a slugfest. I will tell you,
- 26:45one of my partners, Doug Seltzer, who is the
- 26:48current president of the Consumer Attorneys of
- 26:51California, he was in the thick of it. And every
- 26:54which way he looked, it was, okay, there's an
- 26:57Uber with a blimp flying across one of the plaintiff
- 27:03organization conferences. And really, it got
- 27:09so ugly. and the plaintiff's attorneys really
- 27:14did band together because it was a humongous
- 27:19fight and there was no way to beat out Uber's
- 27:26available resources. What is Uber's market cap
- 27:32today? This is a billion dollar corporation.
- 27:36What does this mean about what they can spend?
- 27:39And so the plan of lawyers really did have to
- 27:41get together and find the same level of war chest
- 27:45because this was a fight on the American public,
- 27:50certainly in the California public consciousness,
- 27:53which is to make lawyers look bad. We know from
- 27:58the experience of trying to get the cap lifted
- 28:01on the medical malpractice cases, micro, you
- 28:05know, gosh, what was that? I can't even remember,
- 28:08was that 2014 or 2017? I honestly can't remember.
- 28:12But the big problem was the ads were about greedy
- 28:16plaintiff lawyers. And so this was not going
- 28:19to happen again, particularly on this fight.
- 28:21And there are many, many more lawyers handling
- 28:25auto crash cases than there are handling med
- 28:29mal. And so the massive amount of money that
- 28:32had to be in organized coalesce in order just
- 28:37to have a media presence. And that is so disappointing
- 28:41and so painful to say that, but it's both sides
- 28:46trying to equalize or democratize the amounts
- 28:53of money that are being spent in the media. And
- 28:56I would say that is what happened. And so countless
- 28:59hours and time in the war chest that was having
- 29:02to be raised on the plaintiff's side, You know,
- 29:04the plaintiffs are not personally injured. I
- 29:07mean, they're not corporations. They don't have
- 29:09market caps of like, you know, billions of dollars.
- 29:13And so that was a huge, huge organization. And
- 29:18I would say hats off to consumer attorneys of
- 29:21California, the Alliance Against Corporate Abuse
- 29:25campaign. I mean, the number of people who came
- 29:27to this fight really so that and I don't want
- 29:31to suggest that there was you know these big
- 29:33winners or losers on this and this is our adversarial
- 29:38system at work and sometimes it costs a lot of
- 29:41money and so the things that it cost and where
- 29:43the plaintiffs and I went to work on spending
- 29:45that money as I told you there was a lot of collateral
- 29:48issues going into play it wasn't just about auto
- 29:52crash cases this was about the uber sex assault
- 29:55cases this was about accountability. And that
- 29:58was, as I said, these people are incredibly smart,
- 30:01sophisticated, with, you know, much, much bigger
- 30:05issues than, as I say, just the single car crash
- 30:07case. And so these were the big three that were
- 30:12proposed initiatives, fighting back in the tort
- 30:15arena. And you know what, no one can feel bad
- 30:19about this fight. I had a my personal feeling
- 30:22is that, you know, if you're on the defense side,
- 30:24your feelings can't be hurt. It's like, well,
- 30:26Yeah, you launched a massive fight at a peripheral
- 30:29issue. It was not the head on issue. And that's
- 30:32I think something that everybody on this here
- 30:36should at least recognize that this was a multi
- 30:39front fight. And when you consider how much the
- 30:45rideshare companies are profiting from it. why
- 30:49should the individuals living in the city, you
- 30:52know, driving on the highways be penalized? Or
- 30:55should their rights be reduced so that we uplift
- 30:58the rights of people who are already making a
- 31:03lot of money? So that was the full, full blown
- 31:07out fight. And I won't get too far deep into,
- 31:13you know, there was a big compromise ultimately.
- 31:15And that did come about in June. So the compromise,
- 31:22it is now codified in, and you'll see it come
- 31:25into effect, uh, three, three, three, three point
- 31:28nine, uh, by January, 2027, the fight that I
- 31:32mean, and this is, was kind of fun. I was watching
- 31:34my partner Doug constantly on the cell phone.
- 31:36We would have lunch together at a restaurant
- 31:38and you know, he was texting the next news reporter
- 31:40about what they would have to say in response
- 31:42to something, you know, that was being thrown
- 31:45about to the governor. I mean, the, this was
- 31:48in every which way. a full, full aggressive battle
- 31:54of philosophies about, you know, pragmatism,
- 31:58about how the law should work for everyone. And
- 32:01I do mean that. I mean, I do really feel like
- 32:05when we look at what the law is supposed to do,
- 32:07it's supposed to create a harmonious way for
- 32:10all of us to be able to live together. And this
- 32:13is why you do have an adversarial system. Why
- 32:15I believe in an adversarial system because If
- 32:18it were all up to one side or one party, we would
- 32:22end up in, you know, a dictatorship with incredibly
- 32:25unhappy 50 % of the people. It just wouldn't
- 32:28be fair. And so, you know, I would say hats off
- 32:32to everybody here for the tremendous amount of
- 32:35effort to try to clean up the things that seem
- 32:39like, okay, kickbacks were dirty, kickbacks are
- 32:42bad. But, you know, look, corporate dominance
- 32:46shouldn't be the answer either. So here, 333
- 32:52.9. The provisions apply in any civil claim against
- 32:57a transportation network company. So now this
- 33:00is not all auto cases. This is targeted to the
- 33:05people who back the fight. Here was the resolution
- 33:11on how you deal with out of network bills. that
- 33:17there's the fair health bill charges and that's
- 33:21not Medicare. So there is the, and it's in caps
- 33:25because it's an acronym and please do look it
- 33:28up and you will find that in fact, these are
- 33:31different rates than these are not like, like
- 33:33I said, the Medi -Cal or Medicare rates. And
- 33:36if we're gonna have these lean based medical
- 33:39services, then they can't claim more than 70,
- 33:44percentile of the fair health bill charges. That
- 33:47was the resolution, the hammered out compromise
- 33:51about how to deal with the people who chose to
- 33:56go out of network for good or bad reasons. This
- 33:59was the equalizer. Amounts billed in excess of
- 34:03the maximum amount are void and unaffordable.
- 34:06So if a medical provider went out of that number,
- 34:11then it's just out. unlawful for an attorney
- 34:15with the contingency fee to refer a client to
- 34:18a medical provider in which the attorney or immediate
- 34:20family had a direct ownership interest. And this
- 34:23protects us on the ethics end. No fee splitting,
- 34:27no kickbacks or bonuses of referrals. And that
- 34:30was section one. Now section two. This does get
- 34:35to the heart of the issues that we were talking
- 34:37about, some of the collateral issues, background
- 34:39checks on all the drivers. prohibiting the employment
- 34:42of people with certain violent felonies, violent
- 34:45and dangerous misdemeanors. This was a really
- 34:47important, I think, win for the public. I mean,
- 34:52this is about dollars and cents on your settlement.
- 34:55This is about regulating the transportation network
- 35:00companies. and you know I would say some of this
- 35:05is small but it's important like I said for the
- 35:07harmony of society and that we're going to live
- 35:09together we better make sure that the people
- 35:11who are in power you know do at least some of
- 35:13the right things. All right so when you look
- 35:15at just the comparison overall the scope broad
- 35:21statewide automobile accident proposal okay now
- 35:25we're just talking about the narrow T &C ride
- 35:31share framework. attorney's fees, now we're just
- 35:35still back to where we were always. You can't
- 35:40get involved with the attorney's fees. And so
- 35:42we're staying with the no statewide contingency
- 35:46fee cap. This really deals with how you handle
- 35:50medical liens. And I really think this is important
- 35:52because whether you're on the plaintiff's side
- 35:54or the defense side, we don't want people interfering
- 35:59with our attorney -client relationship. by virtue
- 36:02of stepping in on fees. I don't think any defense
- 36:05lawyer wants that. No plaintiff lawyer wants
- 36:07that. It's not fair to either party or either
- 36:11side. And so, you know, that's important also
- 36:13for keeping the independence of the attorneys.
- 36:18So future paid and future medical bills, where
- 36:23before it regulated the paid bills and, you know,
- 36:27try to increase the burden of proof. Here, there
- 36:30really is no rewrite on that. The past liens
- 36:36where that proposal seemed hugely draconian.
- 36:40Here, there's now instead of like I said, the
- 36:44Medicare Medi -Cal, you're using a higher standard
- 36:47for looking at what is quote reasonable and now
- 36:51using the 17th percentile so that it would start
- 36:54to even out what an insurance company would do.
- 36:57And it also is a little more in favor of the
- 37:01insurance company and encourages people to use
- 37:04their healthcare insurance. So it does, like
- 37:07I say, it irons out a bunch of the issues and
- 37:11became the compromise. And I can't even tell
- 37:14you how many people plaintiff lawyers up and
- 37:17down the state really using their incredible.
- 37:21legal skills. I would say not everybody has the
- 37:24skill of writing legislation. Many of us did
- 37:26not like the idea of contracts. We just specifically
- 37:29went into torts because we don't like reading
- 37:32contracts. And so that means we actually don't
- 37:34like reading legislation. I mean, how many of
- 37:37you said, oh, you know, I'm going to take a restful
- 37:40evening and read the legislative history. Like,
- 37:43God, no. And being succinct and articulate and
- 37:47being able to codify something, right? the language,
- 37:50I can't tell you the number of people that were
- 37:53involved in the writing portion of it and how
- 37:56grateful I am. And I know you are for somebody
- 37:59who knows how to write and knows how to write
- 38:01in a way that is correctly interpreted in red
- 38:07under California statutes about how we interpret
- 38:09statutes. I mean, really all the stuff that most
- 38:13people hate doing and didn't like about law school,
- 38:16there was incredible lawyers on both sides. who
- 38:19have that skill set. So I would say they did
- 38:23a really, really good job. The collateral source
- 38:26rule, okay, now it doesn't abrogate the collateral
- 38:30source rule. We still live in the collateral
- 38:32source rule and the political outcome. So you've
- 38:37got the negotiated compromise, which means it
- 38:42passed through and the governor signed off on
- 38:45it. And I think that's also really important
- 38:50because this type of legislation that is aggressively
- 38:54a compromise, I think does demonstrate one of
- 38:57the best ways in which we create our laws. Instead
- 39:01of throwing it out for the public who is much,
- 39:05much less informed and relying on campaigning
- 39:09and slogans to dictate how our laws should be
- 39:12written. So this is the compromise. This is where
- 39:16we are. I just want to point out your Casey instruction
- 39:20is still going to be the same. It's just that
- 39:24when you get to this part about proof what you
- 39:26can actually admit, this language is the same,
- 39:28right? To recover damages for past medical expenses,
- 39:31plaintiff must prove the reasonable cost of reasonably
- 39:34necessary medical care. Well, you've got now
- 39:37some guidance based upon this language. that
- 39:41is going to get you there. And I think this will
- 39:43resolve some of the fights. I think you will
- 39:45still see some awkwardness and uncertainty as
- 39:50people start to apply it in 2027. But there is
- 39:56language in now Civil Code Section 3333 .9. And
- 40:02you may all need to look to it about how to get
- 40:04to this level of proof, what you can show, what
- 40:06you can't show, what it means and what you will
- 40:09be arguing. So I think this is something for
- 40:12all of us just to be mindful of us for you to
- 40:14keep in the back of your head that you need to
- 40:16actually look at civil code section 3333 .9 before
- 40:20you get to trial. While you're working up your
- 40:24case and when you get to trial you do need to
- 40:26know it and it's going to be in some kind of
- 40:28briefing. It's going to be in your trial briefing.
- 40:31So get ready for that and I would say both sides.
- 40:35as we know from various motions. How many of
- 40:38you have seen now the reptile motion? I see that
- 40:40so many times. I'm so sick of it. Can we all
- 40:43just get over it already? Everybody knows, you
- 40:47know, try to argue within bounds. And this too,
- 40:51this too shall come, you will start to see patterned
- 40:55motions in Lemonade about the admissibility of
- 40:57medical bills and judges are going to need that.
- 41:00I'm going to suggest to you that this is not
- 41:03going to be without a lot of effort. And I do
- 41:07hope the appellate lawyers, the good ones are
- 41:10all starting to weigh in and create these things.
- 41:13And I think we should expect CAOC to have one.
- 41:16I expect the California Defense Association to
- 41:22have one. And I think you're gonna all start
- 41:24to see the same motions and it's gonna happen.
- 41:27All right, so what about these cases? Where are
- 41:29these things gonna go? Just, I think this past
- 41:33week, Uber sex assault case that was supposed
- 41:37to go to trial in Austin just got settled. I
- 41:42don't know exactly how public that is. I don't
- 41:44know the amounts or anything like that. But we're
- 41:47going to see, I don't know, there's, I believe,
- 41:49something on the order of 4 ,500 different Uber
- 41:52assault claims. That's a big docket to try to
- 41:55manage around the country. And how much this
- 41:59affects that directly, indirectly is really the
- 42:02issue. But those are the things that you're going
- 42:05to see, I think, more of and in play, probably
- 42:09less of as we then go to, let me say, the robo
- 42:15taxi business. So Uber announced plans to deploy
- 42:21a whole bunch of robo taxis. You know, you've
- 42:23now seen, I think, Amazon's version, which is
- 42:25Zoox. You've seen Waymo. We're all seeing these
- 42:30things. This really is going to shift into product
- 42:33liability world. And we're still going to have
- 42:36to deal with some of these same issues about
- 42:38what is our order of proof. I think these cases
- 42:41are going to become harder. But how many more
- 42:44of them you're going to have, you know, with
- 42:46the improvement of all of these automated systems,
- 42:52it's moving fast. You know, I'm not here to predict
- 42:55how quickly you're going to see all of it replace
- 42:58the Uber person driver. I don't know, but These
- 43:03are the fights that we're gonna have. And I think
- 43:06we all have to be careful and mindful about how
- 43:09we're going to bring these fights. What are our
- 43:13rights going to be? If you get into a robo taxi,
- 43:17what should you expect? What is the consumer
- 43:19expectation for the safety, the efficacy, the
- 43:23ability for it to stop in time? ability for it
- 43:28to drop you off where you should be dropped off.
- 43:31I had the recent experience of taking a Waymo
- 43:35and it dropped me off two and a half blocks from
- 43:37where I told it to drop me off and it didn't
- 43:40seem to have a way for me to get to my actual
- 43:42destination. And it's late at night, it's dark,
- 43:46you could foresee some problems and issues there
- 43:49potentially on liability. And I think these are
- 43:53all things that, as I said, as a group, we should
- 43:55all be mindful of what are our rights, what should
- 43:57we come to expect, and what should we demand,
- 44:01especially for all of us who are paying collectively
- 44:07a big amount of money to corporations that will
- 44:11absolutely profit from this. and I don't say
- 44:13this that there's anybody evil in it. It is we
- 44:16all have to think about how to balance this as
- 44:18I said so that we are living harmoniously in
- 44:21a society that we want to live in where there
- 44:23isn't one group that has extremely high leverage
- 44:26over another. Let me take you back to the UM
- 44:30UIM thing. This did get passed 2026 and I will
- 44:33say I found this kind of painful. Particularly
- 44:37because, you know, ride share companies like
- 44:39Uber and Lyft are such big corporations, but
- 44:43this has reduced the UM UYM coverage. And I think
- 44:51what does this say? It was originally a million
- 44:56dollars that they had to have a million dollars
- 44:58UYM coverage. And this I thought got passed quietly
- 45:03and without it being uh really on anybody's radar
- 45:06for the big fight uh and i don't know what does
- 45:10that say for all of us do everybody here really
- 45:13should have um coverage uh that it probably would
- 45:18kick in and you're not going to be able to rely
- 45:21upon the um uber and lyft coverage so that raises
- 45:25an interesting point Because as we get to, as
- 45:28I say, all these robo taxis, how many of you
- 45:30are going to have a car anymore? How many of
- 45:32you have a 16 year old kid that actually doesn't
- 45:35have a driver's license? How many of their friends
- 45:38do not have driver licenses and don't plan to?
- 45:42What is going to be our rights, as I said, back
- 45:45to the consumer expectation on the robo taxi
- 45:48about what the a robot taxi should be able to
- 45:52do because if nobody or let me say if you have
- 45:54a reduced number of people who know how to drive
- 45:56in an emergency situation the passenger is not
- 45:59going to be able to get into the driver's seat
- 46:01and override anything. That's a frightening dystopian
- 46:05thought. I don't mean to fill your heads with
- 46:09scary sci -fi aliens or anything like that but
- 46:14when we think about the future I think we are
- 46:17going to find continuing smart lawyers who will
- 46:21look at, as I say, what are our rights? What
- 46:23should we come to expect? And why should we come
- 46:26to expect those things? Just the last bit on
- 46:30the future here with legislation, what is that
- 46:33going to mean? I think this was a really aggressive,
- 46:37I hope we don't see it again for a long time,
- 46:40because there was so much money put into this
- 46:44that could have been used in many, many different
- 46:46ways. And so I would hope that we don't see this.
- 46:50Are we in for more polarization in the future?
- 46:55I think many of us would say living in the times
- 46:58that we're living in, sadly, that is true. We're
- 47:03being deeply polarized, deeply divided on basic
- 47:08human rights issues. And back to, who is it?
- 47:16you know, back in the, what, early 90s riots,
- 47:19can we just all get along? And I really hope
- 47:23that, and I mean that, I think, you know, we're
- 47:26gonna find that hammering it out with both sides
- 47:31is part of what to expect in the future. But
- 47:34I hope it doesn't come at the massive cost that
- 47:37we've seen. And we've seen that, as you know,
- 47:41with, you know, even the fight on lawyers on
- 47:44the Perkins -Cooey, uh selection of lawyers fight
- 47:48in the penalties for all of that and I'm sorry
- 47:50I don't mean to get too deep into all of your
- 47:52politics but that has a lot to do with our right
- 47:55uh as to who we pick as attorneys and we should
- 47:59jealously guard those rights so on the um I don't
- 48:03see any questions uh I I think uh the materials
- 48:15are available um I think One question came in
- 48:20just now. Oh, here I see. Okay, maybe outside
- 48:26the scope of your lecture, but can you sue Uber
- 48:28in the US for something that happened abroad?
- 48:32I was recently assaulted. And I'm sorry, I don't
- 48:34know if you want me to read the whole thing.
- 48:36I apologize. So maybe you're not going to read
- 48:37all of that. But the main question is, can you
- 48:40sue Uber in the United States for something that
- 48:44happened abroad? And I think if I'm going to
- 48:47say that I think the answer to that is yes. I
- 48:54think though you have an issue with substantive
- 49:00law, which law applies and whether you're actually
- 49:04gonna end up getting removed in some fashion
- 49:09actually out of the country. So let me just say.
- 49:16I haven't researched that issue. So I'm going
- 49:18to make the disclaimer right now so that I don't
- 49:20sound like a complete idiot when some of my favorite
- 49:23really smart attorneys answer this question.
- 49:27But you know, the Uber is a US company that it
- 49:32happened somewhere else. Does it mean that your
- 49:36rights that you don't have any rights here? So
- 49:40at least I get to that by in a long winded way
- 49:43by saying I think that you do. I think that you
- 49:46can. But isn't a question mark for all of us?
- 49:52Well, does substantive law apply here or in the
- 49:58location where it occurred? You know, and are
- 50:01we implicating the driver? And I don't think
- 50:05that, you know, in other words, is Uber also
- 50:09vicariously liable for that driver? That has
- 50:12been a constant debate. And we are seeing more
- 50:15fights on that, and that is being brought to
- 50:18the court on, as I said, that vicarious liability.
- 50:22So we have seen, for instance, cases involving,
- 50:27we all know the Amazon case, Loomis and Bolger
- 50:30versus Amazon, where something happened here,
- 50:34but the manufacturer is actually outside the
- 50:36United States. And in that circumstance, Amazon
- 50:40is responsible as a in the vertical chain of
- 50:44distribution. Is there some analogy that works
- 50:47or fits there? I would say they're two different
- 50:49concepts and two different ideas. But when you
- 50:51get to the e -commerce platform, I do think we're
- 50:55gonna see very good briefing on these topics.
- 50:59So Benjamin, I'm sorry, I don't think I answered
- 51:01your question so directly or so definitively,
- 51:04but that is me shooting from the hip for what
- 51:07it's worth. Let's see, any other questions? Hello,
- 51:14Robert. Have there been changes in the ways Uber's
- 51:17or its insurers handle injury claims following
- 51:20the passage of this law in June or is it too
- 51:22early to tell? I'm going to say it's too early
- 51:26to tell. I do think that Uber having as much
- 51:29power as it does dictates the way that it is
- 51:33going to handle claims. I don't feel like it's
- 51:35dependent on how this legislation went. I think
- 51:38they evaluate things on a risk basis and what's
- 51:43going to come out at trial. And so are they fairly
- 51:46evaluating these cases? I will say for what it's
- 51:51worth, my experiences with Uber have been, they
- 51:58do a good job of evaluating whether they're gonna
- 52:01win this or lose this and what the mitigation
- 52:03is gonna be and whether they're using big data
- 52:05for that and whether we have the same resources
- 52:07on the big data, okay. I think that's a little
- 52:09unfair, parenthetically, but I think too. answer
- 52:14Robert. I think it is a little too early to tell
- 52:17if it matters in any way. I think, as I said,
- 52:19you're going to see it spill over more in the
- 52:22other ways on the robo taxi, on the Uber assault
- 52:25cases, and on, you know, like these UM claims.
- 52:30I do think you're going to see fewer UM claims
- 52:32just on the 2026 law. We have a few more minutes
- 52:42for other thoughts or questions. God, I hope
- 52:45this has been interesting. And here we go. OK,
- 52:50not necessarily a question, but a problem that
- 52:51I'm seeing on the horizon. Ride share passengers
- 52:54without health insurance may be faced with a
- 52:57problem regarding access to medical treatment.
- 53:00And Alastair had a recent conversation with a
- 53:02medical provider that historically provided treatment
- 53:06on a lean basis, pain management, neurology and
- 53:09psychology. Going forward, they roundtabled this
- 53:11legislation and will no longer offer treatment
- 53:14specifically to ride share case patients. I think
- 53:17that is such a good point. Is that going to be
- 53:21an issue? Are you going to have physicians who
- 53:26will not cooperate? And I think this is the reason
- 53:32they're not cooperating because they don't think
- 53:35they'll get paid or that they don't think they'll
- 53:37get paid enough. I think the question there is
- 53:41how I think with this legislation, that is absolutely
- 53:47affected. So I wonder if though, this is the
- 53:51interesting question, whether for a person who's
- 53:55not insured, does it default in essence to howl?
- 54:00Because really this bill, which this compromise
- 54:04is intended to fix that issue where people are
- 54:07insured, but choosing to go out of network. And
- 54:10so I think too early to tell does this mean that
- 54:13the courts are simply going to read the uninsured
- 54:16person the same as it had in Howell? Are you
- 54:21not going to change that? And I think that would
- 54:22be the fair way to look at it and approach it.
- 54:31I have Philip still with me. Any other thoughts
- 54:34here, Philip? This has been a very interesting,
- 54:37very interesting perspective. And Doug did a
- 54:40wonderful job. He sure did. I mean, I'm really
- 54:45so proud of my partner. Doug Seltzer. I think
- 54:48everybody is grateful to him for spearheading
- 54:52that and never shying away from the fight or
- 54:56the phone calls or any of the late night anything.
- 55:00So it was really tremendous. And I know I hope
- 55:03that you all feel like you got your time's worth.
- 55:07We like to make sure that whenever we put on
- 55:10a program that you get something practical from
- 55:13it, you get something legal from it, and you
- 55:15have something in your back pocket when you head
- 55:18to trial. So what else, Philip? I believe we
- 55:25have another question in the Q &A. Okay. How
- 55:31is product liability relevant to the self -driving
- 55:33liability framework? Well, remember, because
- 55:36you don't have a driver and it is being guided
- 55:41entirely by the software, that's the product.
- 55:46And so when you get to this, and I had a first
- 55:52Tesla product liability settlement was Huang
- 55:56versus Tesla and the state of California. Tesla
- 56:03settled before the case actually went to trial.
- 56:07The case then continued on against the state
- 56:09of California in a dangerous condition. issue,
- 56:14but the framework there or the issue there was,
- 56:17in fact, using autopilot and that early stage
- 56:20in 2018, it was not nearly as developed as it
- 56:23is today. But the issue there was, does autopilot
- 56:29work the way that the consumer expects it to?
- 56:32And so when now you're in the robo taxi world,
- 56:35the question is going to be, did this car in
- 56:40its automated way, drive the way that a consumer
- 56:43expect it to be. And if you're on the other route,
- 56:47KC 1204, was there a more reasonable alternative
- 56:51or feasible alternatives? Was this the thing
- 56:55that should have been used? And then I think
- 56:57you're getting into the fight of computer software
- 57:00and who has the better software? Who has the
- 57:04better camera? Who's using LIDAR? Who's using
- 57:07radar? those are among the fights and what should,
- 57:11as I said, you come to expect. So you're going
- 57:13to have to prove, you know, under Casey 1203
- 57:17and 1204, that's the design defect. You may be
- 57:20on the manufacturing path. You may be on the
- 57:23failure to warn path. Was there adequate warning
- 57:27that for instance, you know, this wouldn't do
- 57:29X, Y or Z or that you couldn't get out of the
- 57:32car? uh because the robo taxi locked you in and
- 57:37there wasn't a mechanism that you could find
- 57:39readily you know i mean i think those are any
- 57:42number of things that can come up i hope that
- 57:46answered the question daniel i hope i'm giving
- 57:50good answers god you know let me just remind
- 57:53you uh the advice is free so it's worth what
- 57:58you paid for it you only came for the talk the
- 58:02rest of this is just spitballing i must confess
- 58:07Okay. I really enjoyed being here. Thank you,
- 58:11Philip. Thank you. We really appreciate your
- 58:15time.