Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Hard Knocks: Who Are the Jehovah's Witnesses? (with Owen Morgan)
Transcript
- 0:01Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:24book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness. Truth Usian wisdom will
- 0:33come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start thinking.
- 0:42This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. Owen Morgan is
- 0:59an online act bist. He has a couple of YouTube channels. One is
- 1:03just the Owen Morgan channel. Together is called Fireside Chats, and he is
- 1:08the author of a couple of new books that I wanted to talk about.
- 1:14They are about the Jehovah's Witnesses. Oh yeah, we got to talk about
- 1:19the Jaws Owen Morgan. Good to see again, brother. How you doing,
- 1:22Thanks so much for having me? Yeah, doing really well. So
- 1:26I have to start with the basics. We're going to peel back the layers.
- 1:30But what have that Jehovah's Witnesses actually witnessed, right, I mean,
- 1:36we're just going to treat everybody, including in some ways myself, like,
- 1:38we don't know what the hell's going on. We know that they're out there,
- 1:42but who are that Jehovah's Witnesses. Yeah, so I wrote at length
- 1:48about their history technically to answer the question. They their name is a reference
- 1:55to a verse in the Book of Revelation about witnesses, two witnesses, so
- 1:59on and and so forth. The name Jehovah is kind of a sticking point
- 2:02with them. Really drives me nuts because it's not actually Jehovah. It was
- 2:08Yahweh. The name Jehovah was a method of preventing people from saying the real
- 2:15name of Yahweh for fear of blasphemy or you know, superstitious stuff. So
- 2:21anyway, Yeah, Jehovah's Witnesses. They've been around since the early nineteen hundreds,
- 2:27the late eighteen hundreds, and somehow my parents got pulled into it in
- 2:32the I think the seventies or the eighties before I was born. Hang on
- 2:37your second, o one, God is he who cannot be named. No,
- 2:42God's okay to be named. They just mistakenly think that the name is
- 2:46Jehovah not realizing that it's Yahweh. I've they come up with bizarre explanations for
- 2:53why they use the name Jehovah, But in reality, Jay's didn't exist until
- 2:59the fourteen hundred or so, fourteen to sixteen hundreds. So if you want
- 3:02to use the real name, it's y hwhg Yahweh. Right. I'm reminded
- 3:08of that line out of The God Delusion Richard Dawkins, where he was talking
- 3:13about the two major determiners of someone's religious faith. Where were you born,
- 3:19What was the religion of your parents? Was that true for you? Yeah,
- 3:23I was born in Connecticut. Personally, my parents they were actually like,
- 3:29not really religious at all until my mom got sucked into Jehovah's Witnesses.
- 3:32Absolutely wild story. They were both in the Air Force. That's where my
- 3:38parents met, and my mom eventually got divorced from my dad because they were,
- 3:45you know, they were fighting a lot basically, and I think four
- 3:49years passed they were divorced. My mom starts, you know, studying Jehovah's
- 3:54witness material and she tells, my dad join the religion with me, will
- 4:01get remarried. Who do you want to get remarried, and from her lips,
- 4:05she told me if you never or if you don't join the religion with
- 4:11me, you'll never see the kids again. Absolutely psychotic thing to say,
- 4:15but yeah, that was kind of how they got pulled in. I have
- 4:19two siblings that were born before they were in the religion, only like four
- 4:25and six years old, and then I have one more sibling who was born
- 4:28afterward, and it affected all of us very deeply. You know, all
- 4:33of us are out of the religion now. It had a negative impact on
- 4:39everyone's life. Isn't JW a patriarchal culture. What would your mom's role have
- 4:44been in the church? Yeah? Very patriarchal. Women are expected to submit
- 4:49to men completely. They can't have any role whatsoever in teaching or administrating or
- 4:58anything. But they can be full time door knockers if they want. So
- 5:00that's a privilege. I guess women are entitled too. If a woman tries
- 5:06or if a woman has no option but to lead or to teach, like
- 5:11I was like fourteen years old, just got baptized. But my mom was
- 5:15the spiritually mature person, if you will. In that case, she has
- 5:20to wear a head covering ahod job effectively an absolutely wild belief and absolutely wild
- 5:29practice to find in Christianity. Seems to me they're covering her for what,
- 5:33to shield the eyes of men from potential temptation like in Islam. No,
- 5:40actually, I think it refers to a verse that says that women should cover
- 5:44their heads when they pray. Looking back at the verse, I feel like
- 5:48it's kind of talking about their hair, just having like longer hair. But
- 5:54Jehovah's witnesses have a completely different interpretation of everything. So you've written a couple
- 5:59of books, and I want to go into those one hundred questions for Jehovah's
- 6:02Witnesses and understanding Jehovah's witnesses. Owen, I'm trying to picture you going door
- 6:09to door ding dong hi. I'm Owen, would you like to hear about
- 6:14I don't know what do you say? God? The church your pitch.
- 6:17Well, when I was in it, it's a little bit different today than
- 6:23it was when I was in the religion. I think I left in two
- 6:26thousand and seven, but all through the two thousands and the nineties, as
- 6:30knocking on doors and they give you at the time, they gave me a
- 6:34watch tower and an Awake. I think there were one or there were two
- 6:38of each every month, So all right, I'm sorry for those who don't
- 6:43know what is Watchtower and what is Awake. Right, the Watchtower in the
- 6:47Awake are They are periodical magazines thirty two pages long each, and the Awake
- 6:55is usually geared toward people who aren't really involved in the religion very much.
- 6:59It just kind of talks about like news articles, I guess to some degree.
- 7:03You can see the same articles on their website today, although I think
- 7:06they've either slimmed down or erased Theake the Awaken entirely, and the watch Tower
- 7:13is geared more toward people that are already in the religion. But since I
- 7:18left, it got a lot more intense, and they really, you know,
- 7:21they got a lot more serious about what goes into the watch Tower.
- 7:24It's really geared toward Jehovah's witnesses now. But I would pick out some story
- 7:30in the watch Tower or the Awake, if it was talking about how polluted
- 7:35the earth is or how it to raise kids or something. I would look
- 7:42for clues around the house, you know, did they have things in you
- 7:46know, toys in their yard, Do they have a nice garden things like
- 7:49that. I would go up to the door, I'd say hi, my
- 7:54name's Owen Morgan, and I just noticed you have some toys in your yard.
- 8:00You know, the Bible has some things to say about how to raise
- 8:03children. You ever seen that advice, you know, a fourteen year old's
- 8:07kid talking about how to raise kids to somebody anyway, that was the general
- 8:13pitch, and and then it's like, piss off kid, door slams in
- 8:16your face. Right to have been just a pretty much point day by day,
- 8:22hour by hour occurrence. I can see the temptation. Yeah, I'm
- 8:26sure you're a nice guy, but piss off. Oh when you saw a
- 8:30lot of that, yeah, most of the time people would just say not
- 8:35interested and close the door. They very clearly had just woken up. Kind
- 8:41of annoying to have somebody come around on a Saturday morning at nine am and
- 8:46waking you up after you just spent the entire week working. But usually they
- 8:50just say not interested and close the door. Every now and then i'd get
- 8:54somebody who wanted to debate some Bible principle like God's name or the Trinity doctrine
- 9:03or something like that. And even rarer than that. Every now and then
- 9:09I would get somebody who would accept the magazines, probably out of pity or
- 9:13something. Wait, wait a minute, you had to know that people were
- 9:16irritated. You're coming up to their castle, maybe on their day or hours
- 9:20off. You're inconveniencing them. You're conscious of that. No, I mean,
- 9:26don't you carry that baggage up to the doorbell. When I was in
- 9:30the religion, I viewed it as a mandate from heaven. I had to
- 9:35do this, and it was a privilege to do so because I was so
- 9:39much better informed than everybody else. I was given the opportunity to save their
- 9:46lives. And Jehovah's Witnesses for a long time believed everybody in the world has
- 9:50to hear the message of God before the end can come. I think they've
- 9:56backed up off of that a little bit, because how could they possibly People
- 10:00die and are born every single day without ever hearing about Jehovah's Witnesses, you
- 10:03know, especially like North Korea places China, it's banned. So anyway,
- 10:09Yeah, Jehovah's witnesses view it as a privilege ultimately, But I think they're
- 10:16backing off of door knocking a lot I think they're realizing it doesn't really bring
- 10:20in very many people, so well not to be labor it. Part of
- 10:24me wondered if it was about the act. It's not that you're racking up
- 10:28jewels in your ground, so to speak, by the number of conversions,
- 10:33but it was the act of obedience to go door to door. It was
- 10:37really more about you than the convert. Any truth to that, Yeah,
- 10:41I think that there is some truth to that, although Jehovah's Witnesses have,
- 10:48i mean the religion or the organization, like the structure at the top of
- 10:52the hierarchy, have very much backed off of it. When I was young,
- 10:56they said you had to get ten hours of door knocking per month to
- 11:00be considered an active Jehovah's witness, And if you're not an act of Jehovah's
- 11:05witness, you aren't invited to the you know, the parties that they hold,
- 11:09the talent shows and all of the other social events, and you're not
- 11:13allowed to have outsider friends. So you're kind of forced into this box.
- 11:18Now. I think Jehovah's Witnesses recently backed off of that by saying you don't
- 11:24have to turn your hours in anymore unless you're a pioneer. So unless you're
- 11:30getting like between fifty and seventy hours per month and you've committed to that for
- 11:35like twelve months consecutively, you don't have to turn them in anymore. And
- 11:39that's a pretty big deal. But what the hell is a pioneer? I
- 11:43guess I need to I need you to baptize me in terms the hierarchy of
- 11:48Jehovah's witnesses. Is that impossible? Oh yeah, absolutely. If you hear
- 11:52any terms that don't sound familiar, I'm sure there are people out there who
- 11:56are also unfamiliar with it. Pioneer are people who agree to get a certain
- 12:03number of hours every month for twelve consecutive months. They have auxiliary pioneers who
- 12:09agree to get I think it's like fifty or was fifty hours a month when
- 12:13I was in it for one month and then special Pioneers and missionaries are unique
- 12:22cases where they actually receive a stipend from their religion. But it's super rare.
- 12:26They've only had a few thousands since the founding of the religion, you
- 12:31know, in the early nineteen hundreds. I was reading both of your books
- 12:37and in preparation for today, but really because I'm interested. We've talked a
- 12:41lot about the big ones, you know, Christianity, Islam, and we've
- 12:45done some deeper dives into the Mormon Church. But JW is, I will
- 12:50admit, is one that I hadn't known much about. I came away from
- 12:52the books struck by that. It's really a religion of don't, isn't it.
- 12:58I mean there's a bunch of stuff that's just off limits, forbidden,
- 13:01restrictive. Can you list some of the don't in the JW's Oh yeah,
- 13:07Actually they have a real literal list in the Elder's Manual. People aren't supposed
- 13:13to know that that even exists, but it's easy to get online, so
- 13:18it's not like they're really hiding. Matter of fact, they were in a
- 13:20court case not too long ago and the prosecutor pulled to the Elders Manual out
- 13:24anyway, there's a big long list of it, you know, things like
- 13:31apostasy, hanging out with outsiders, and you know, these are broad categories
- 13:37that get a lot more specific, and they list some of those specific things
- 13:41too, abortion, getting politically involved, to any degree of voting, being
- 13:48in the military, or anything like that. It gets absolutely wild blood transfusions.
- 13:54Is that still on the list. You can't get a blood transfusion?
- 13:58Oh, yeah, that's on the list. Interestingly enough, blood transfusions.
- 14:03The verses that they use are from the Old Testament, and it says you
- 14:07should not eat blood. So I look into it a little bit deeper,
- 14:11and I find that the word that was actually used meant to devour through your
- 14:18mouth and into your stomach. It didn't mean to take a life saving medical
- 14:22treatment. They didn't have. You know, the Jews of the Old Testament
- 14:28and Christians never had a problem with that. There were medical practices back then
- 14:33that were backward. You know, blood letting and things like that. I
- 14:35have existed throughout history and Jews and Christians have never had an issue with doing
- 14:41that. But suddenly, seemingly out of nowhere, Jehovah's witnesses refuse to accept
- 14:48that. Now, this happened back in the I think it was between the
- 14:52fifties and the seventies when it really started getting serious, and I talk about
- 14:58it book. I have some evidence that the vice president of the Watchtower Society
- 15:07at the time, Fred Franz, wanted to make Jehovah witnesses feel like martyrs
- 15:13feel like victims, and he wanted to get in the news, and he
- 15:16pushed the president, Nathan Nor of the time to ban blood transfusions for that
- 15:22reason alone. I don't say that lightly because that's a pretty big claim.
- 15:28I found some sources on this and I listed it. It was specifically a
- 15:33book written about the history of medical objections in religions. Again, if you
- 15:41want to find the sources, you can find it on my website or Morgan
- 15:43dot com. Citations are all in there. Not just pick up the book
- 15:46because it's in there and it's rich. Tell me, Owen Morgan, tell
- 15:52me that you saw. I think this happened a few years ago, but
- 15:56they're still out there. The release on YouTube of these soup creepy anti masturbation
- 16:02videos that that Jehovah's Witness religion produced and distributed. You see those things.
- 16:07Oh yeah, pillow gate, pillowgate. So that was called definitely I saw
- 16:11that it was hilarious. Masturbation is the stroking or rubbing of the genital organs,
- 16:18commonly resulting in an orgasm. Okay, hang on, hang on,
- 16:22hang on, this needs music. So does a person have to use their
- 16:30hands to masturbate. For example, say a brother wears an undergarment that so
- 16:37tied it rubs his penis as he moves around, he gets aroused and even
- 16:42ejaculates. Is he masturbating, Yes, he is, because he's deliberately stimulating
- 16:52his genitals even though he's not using his hands. That poor guy drew the
- 16:57short straw. Didn't he given this talk? He had to really go into
- 17:02detail about when it's okay and not okay, like if you're rubbing up against
- 17:06a pillow, then it's a problem. You know. It was just absurd.
- 17:10And they talked about being gay, like is it gay if you are
- 17:15in a locker room with another guy, neither of you have clothes on.
- 17:18Well, that's not gay if you don't have feelings for the person. But
- 17:21you know what, if you start giving him a massage, again, not
- 17:23a problem as long as there are no feeling It's just absurd. These people.
- 17:26When I was younger, they had a Young People Ask Book. I
- 17:30think they still have a version of that. And before the Young People Ask
- 17:33Book, they had a book called Youth Getting the Best out of It is
- 17:37a red book. We had one in my house and it's bad. They
- 17:42say I'm sorry, we're talking about masturbation and a double on tondred just flies
- 17:48across the room. I'm sorry, go ahead, go, no problem.
- 17:52Yeah, youth getting the best out of it actually said that you'll you'll turn
- 17:56gay if you touch yourself for real. It's and it's said all kinds of
- 18:02other wild stuff in it. That was from the seventies and the eighties.
- 18:07They removed a lot of that, but they, you know, their view
- 18:11on gay people has morphed over the years into one where it's not like,
- 18:18it's not really a fear mongering type of thing where you know, being in
- 18:22a locker room can turn you gay. It's not like that now. It's
- 18:25more of we understand that, you know, being gay is just something that
- 18:29people are, but if you don't stop doing it, then they view you
- 18:34as like the epitome of all evil. Basically, you're just you're sick and
- 18:40demented and need to be dealt with. Basically. Now, when I saw
- 18:42these you know, older, stuffy, straight faced, largely white suited men
- 18:52who were giving instruction, you know, about the prohibitions, and I'm watching
- 18:56these guys, I'm like, you know, you know that these guys are
- 19:00all celebrating Palm Sunday. If you know what I mean. I'm just saying,
- 19:04the more they preach against it, the more you have to consider they're
- 19:08probably wildly hypocritical on that. I'm interested in the lack of education about what
- 19:15the JW's are. I've seen a ton of websites, but I hadn't seen
- 19:19a lot of books, which is another reason we're talking today. Tell me
- 19:23about each of the two, what they are, what they do with Start
- 19:29with the titles, if you would, sure. Yeah, the first one
- 19:32is Understanding to have his Witnesses. It's a long book and it's you know,
- 19:36when I went into the book, my intent was to tell somebody everything
- 19:41they needed to know about the religion, its origins from the eighteen seventies onward
- 19:48to present day, and I wanted to describe the culture. I years ago,
- 19:56I was looking at, you know, memes and things like that about
- 20:00archaeology. I found a meme that said, you know, I had a
- 20:04picture of a thing, just a weird object, and it had two people
- 20:10on the side saying, look what I made. I made this, and
- 20:12the other person says, no, don't say another word. I already understand.
- 20:15It's perfect and archaeologists are like, what was it. I don't understand.
- 20:22Like, if somebody from the far future looked at some of our writings,
- 20:26we'd be talking about eggs. You know, we're eating eggs, but
- 20:27what kind of eggs. If they don't know the culture, they would have
- 20:33no way of knowing that we ate chicken eggs at this point in history.
- 20:36So I wanted to communicate the culture beginning to end, to the best of
- 20:40my ability. For somebody who's never been a part of their religion, never
- 20:44even been to a meeting. I wanted to communicate it in such a way
- 20:48that they could seamlessly blend into the culture and understand the history of it.
- 20:52Not that they'd want to blend in, you know, seamlessly, but I
- 20:56wanted it to be available to people. So I go through the entire history
- 21:02of the religion and the culture, and I go through my experiences with the
- 21:07religion near the end, and then the final chapter is titled one hundred Questions
- 21:12for Jehovah's Witnesses, which is also the separate book. The second book,
- 21:18One hundred Questions is eighty two pages. I think, just kind of a
- 21:23shorter thing, and it's kind of like I intended it to be. Like
- 21:27the Cees Letter for Jehovah's Witnesses famously a list of questions that the Mormons can't
- 21:36answer, the Mormon Church can't answer. I wanted to do that for Jehovah's
- 21:40Witnesses too. So some of them are pretty straightforward and obvious, like why
- 21:45do you use the name Jehovah when it's actually Yahweh? But it contains sources
- 21:51to everything. And also I actually get into the weeds pretty deep. I
- 21:56talk about prophecies in the Book of Daniel and beliefs about a statue of Nebekinezer,
- 22:03and France and Britain battling each other, and all kinds of wacky stuff.
- 22:11Do the Jehovah's Witnesses have their own Joseph Smith like the Mormons do?
- 22:17Do you have a cornerstone figure? Fascinatingly, the founder was Charles tays Russell,
- 22:23and he was not really a great person. But the second president,
- 22:29the guy that came after him, was Joseph Ruthafford, and he was just
- 22:33straight up bad. He was a womanizer, an alcoholic, and he took
- 22:40the religion effectively in a hostile takeover in nineteen seventeen, immediately after the founder,
- 22:47Charles Tay's Russell died, he was the legal counsel previously supposedly a judge.
- 22:52I didn't find any hard evidence for that, but everybody called him the
- 22:55judge. And you know, I don't have any reason to like fight against
- 23:00the claim that he was a judge. I'm just like, I'm so skeptical
- 23:02about literally anything that I'm told by the Jehovah's witnesses. So anyway, Joseph
- 23:07Rutherford is still very revered by the religion. But if they really went back
- 23:11and looked at some of the wacky stuff that he said and did, and
- 23:15some of the deeply messed up stuff he did, I don't think they'd revere
- 23:18him like they like they do today. I was, you know, still
- 23:26a believer in the religion for years after leaving. But the thing that pulled
- 23:30me out seems inconsequential. But it was finding out that Joseph Rutherford had a
- 23:37mansion built indeeded to Bible characters and lived in it to keep it warm for
- 23:41them for like, you know, years and years until the end. Beth
- 23:45Serene was the name of it. You never know, what little thing is
- 23:48just going to click with somebody and make him realize that this is complete nonsense.
- 23:53Like all of it, it's just garbage. Okay, Coming up,
- 23:57I want to get into the one hundred and forty four thousand shunning. We're
- 24:03going to talk about Jesus and tight pants. Oh yeah, lots to do
- 24:11next talking here with author and activist and X jw Owen Morgan. Back to
- 24:26the one hundred Questions. You had written that before you're baptized into the church
- 24:32you have to take one hundred question quiz. Absolutely, it's kind of an
- 24:37interesting quiz. Actually, it's in the Organized to Do Jehovah's willbook, and
- 24:41that book's existed in some form for a long time. It's actually about sixty
- 24:45questions or sixty two, but in my congregation they called it the hundred Questions,
- 24:51and it's just things to make sure you understand the expectations culturally and doctrinally,
- 24:57things like what is God's name? And should you have outsiders as friends?
- 25:03Should you marry outside the religion? And how does God feel about this?
- 25:07And that it's split into two sections, doctrinal and cultural. So I
- 25:15listed some of those in the book, just a few of the questions to
- 25:18give an idea of what each section was about and how they were structured.
- 25:26But yeah, I guess you could say that I tried to mimic that to
- 25:30some degree. I even mimicked in the book the way that the formatting,
- 25:33you know, bolded questions with a little section underneath Bible verses and everything.
- 25:40All right, well, let me see if I understand. And this was
- 25:42one of the challenges that you had for JW's You ask, why do you
- 25:48hate gay people? Would that be a fair way to phrase it? Is
- 25:52that too strong? No? No, no, that's not too strong.
- 25:56They absolutely do they. I don't want them to get away with it because
- 26:00a lot of the time Jehovah's Witnesses, if you say they hate gay people,
- 26:03they'll refuse to accept that. They'll say, we don't hate gay people.
- 26:07We love everybody. We just don't approve of their lifestyle. I'm not
- 26:10letting them get away with that they hate gay people. Over the past decade,
- 26:15even very recently, you know, in the twenty twenties, Jehovah's Witnesses
- 26:21released various articles in their magazines that have had absolutely bizarre, unbelievable stories,
- 26:32like a story about a kid who supposedly lives in Australia, and the teacher
- 26:40in his school told the kids to separate themselves on each side of the room,
- 26:45one side that approves of gay people, on the other side that doesn't
- 26:48like who is doing this? Really, I'm sorry, I just can't believe
- 26:52that this happened. And the kid was, you know, the Jehovah's witness.
- 26:55He's the only one on the other side of the room that didn't approve
- 26:59of gay peopleeople, and they all jeered and mocked him and laughed at him
- 27:03in this fictional story. It's just wild that anybody accepts this without any kind
- 27:07of evidence whatsoever. But after saying that store, after telling that story,
- 27:15the Watchtower said, they're kind of like pedophiles in that they use an excuse
- 27:22that they're just born that way, and it's an unacceptable excuse. We don't
- 27:26accept it with pedophiles and we shouldn't accept it with gay people. Basically,
- 27:30that was the line. That's their current line that they hold, And in
- 27:33my mind, that's not loving somebody, but disapproving of something that they do.
- 27:41That's hating somebody. Well, you frame it against and I don't want
- 27:45to misrepresent you I may have to push back a little bit, so let's
- 27:48talk about it. You're like, why would you hate gay people? There
- 27:52are only a handful of verses in the Bible that are anti gay. We
- 27:56find them largely in the Old Testament. Jesus came with the New Covenant.
- 28:02Jesus himself never spoke out against homosexuality. So the Bible really isn't behind you
- 28:10on your hatred of gays. Was that the position you were making, Yeah,
- 28:14it's kind of a controversial position. I guess it's only mentioned in six
- 28:18verses total to any degree at all. Sodom and Gohemora being one of them,
- 28:22wasn't destroyed because of gay people, though it was actually destroyed because of
- 28:26their ill treatment of the poor. It says so in Ezekiel. Then Leviticus
- 28:30eighteen and twenty say that being gay is wrong. Those are the only three
- 28:33verses in the Old Testament that mention it. Leviticus is part of like it
- 28:37had the Mosaic law. That was part of the Mosaic law, and we
- 28:41don't follow that anymore. The other three are in I believe one Timothy,
- 28:45first Corinthians and Romans, and as far as I can tell, scholars recognize
- 28:51that it's not being having long term gay relationships this being criticized. It's other
- 28:57things like like pederasty, you know, the practice of taking a young boy
- 29:03as a pupil and doing unspeakable things to him, if you will. That
- 29:07was denounced in the Old or in the New Testament by Paul. That's what
- 29:12Romans was talking about Romans one twenty seven. Primarily, well, I mean
- 29:18Christ shows up and he says that the Old Testament law will be fulfilled.
- 29:22And then you've got Paul, who is Jesus as a guy, and he's
- 29:26writing in Romans that it is, you know, a man loving a man
- 29:30or woman loving a woman is shameful, lust and contrary to nature. And
- 29:34I think those are quotes. We could still say that those were sin and
- 29:41that God rejected those, and that could be sourced in the Bible. Someone
- 29:45could use the Bible to back that up, be it a JW or anybody
- 29:48else. I mean, I think that could be argued, Yes, oh
- 29:51absolutely, it could be argued. Generally, I try to argue more for
- 29:56progressive Christianity because, as you know, I'm an atheist. Of course,
- 30:02I don't believe in any of this stuff. But I feel like moving people
- 30:07from an extreme position to a more moderate one is kind of the approach that
- 30:12I've been taking over the past couple of years. But yeah, it,
- 30:17you know, it is in there. It's hard to deny. I like
- 30:21the idea of moving people into a more progressive interpretation or maybe just skipping over
- 30:26the weird and horrible shit altogether. I mean, I'm with you on that,
- 30:30but it doesn't change the fact that it's there. You know, we
- 30:33can skip over human sacrifice and slavery and genocide and fanticide, hell, all
- 30:40that stuff, but it doesn't mean that it's not there. So I can
- 30:41see how jw as, if they were fundamentalists, could use the scriptures to
- 30:48excuse So I'm just trying to figure out, you know, how does that
- 30:52tactic help them to, you know, to question their faith if they can
- 30:56always go back to the Bible and find anti gay verses. But you're saying
- 31:00you're trying to push them into a different perception on these verses. Yeah,
- 31:04generally, in a plain reading of the Bible, say Romans one twenty seven,
- 31:11it's the verse it's always trotted out. It's like the dead, you
- 31:15know, dead to rights. Verse about being gay hard to deny, you
- 31:18know, men giving up their affection for women and lusting after each other,
- 31:23so on and so forth. But when you look a little bit deeper,
- 31:29which Jehovah's witnesses pride themselves on the fact that they look a little bit deeper,
- 31:33I mean they don't, but the religion has looked a little deeper and
- 31:36discovered various things about the hell Fire doctrine and the Trinity doctrine and things.
- 31:41When you look a little bit deeper, you discover that the original language is
- 31:47a little bit more ambiguous than just saying they gave us they gave up lust
- 31:52for women to lust after each other in things. It's more than just that,
- 31:56And I wrote about it specifically like that, because when you dig deeper,
- 32:04you will find that the translations are all kind of different, and that
- 32:09the culture was different at the time and words had different meanings. So me
- 32:15not being a Greek speaker or a Hebrew speaker or Aramaic or any other language
- 32:20of the time, I have to rely on scholars, and a couple of
- 32:25scholars within the atheist sphere. Bart Ehrman had somebody on his blog to talk
- 32:31about this. He's talked about it on his YouTube channel about how Romans one
- 32:37twenty seven is not actually talking about gay people. Now, take the Bible
- 32:43in totality, six verses out of thirty two thousand mention it. I suppose
- 32:46you could say that's, you know, okay, being gay was not approved
- 32:52of generally, but I would argue that it wasn't the focus to any degree.
- 32:58Ever, it certainly not by Jesus, and it doesn't We don't understand
- 33:04the culture of the time adequately to make a judgment on what the Bible was
- 33:08trying to communicate. Actually, you know, you write in the book that
- 33:15the JW's are a culture of codes. I'm reminded of those like Bible code
- 33:20books. I think there's some Bible code movies. And for those who don't
- 33:23know what I'm talking about, and people get really wacky on this stuff,
- 33:27is like you take every eleventh letter out of every third chapter and you add
- 33:34them up, and you mix them up, and then you throw in some
- 33:36other ingredients and voila, it comes out with seven seven seven or the date
- 33:42of Jesus's return or some other hidden message. And the JWS have some of
- 33:47that going on, which I did not know you want to explain. Oh
- 33:51yeah, so Bible code, as you succinctly explained, it is the belief
- 33:55that you take the sixth letter in the third verse of the you know whatever,
- 34:00and add them all up and it says Hitler will die in nineteen forty
- 34:04five or whatever. They don't actually believe it in that way, but they
- 34:08believe. They take verses from the Book of Numbers, the Book of Daniel,
- 34:13the Book of Revelation, and they kind of squish them together to get,
- 34:17you know, kind of a new interpretation or a new prophecy, if
- 34:23you will. And of course they're qualified to do this because though they deny
- 34:29it, they do view themselves as profits the governing body. So specifically this
- 34:35came into play with their nineteen fourteen teaching. A lot of people probably heard
- 34:40about the nineteen fourteen teaching. They believe that Jesus came back in nineteen fourteen
- 34:45invisibly and picked the Jehovah's Witnesses as his chosen organization. In nineteen nineteen,
- 34:52after roaming around the Earth for three and a half years, now they've got
- 34:57you know, they get these numbers from all kinds of different places, and
- 35:00they're totally unconnected from anything at all, unconnected from each other. They rely
- 35:06heavily on the day year principle, which is kind of one of those old
- 35:10Bible code things from the seventeen eighteen hundreds where they believe that anytime the Bible
- 35:16uses the term yo meaning day or whatever, you can convert that to a
- 35:22year, or you can convert years to days. So anytime it says a
- 35:28week passed by, it really could mean seven years. And they do this
- 35:31selectively. So they found a verse in Daniel that talks about twenty three hundred
- 35:40mornings and evenings passing by. Like this is apocalyptic literature, so you're not
- 35:46really meant to understand it as the reader. Of course, that's just the
- 35:50style that it was written in. An angel comes in and explains it to
- 35:52you later. The angel was explaining, twenty three hundred mornings and evenings will
- 35:59pass, and Jehovahs whatnesses or their predecessors, and Millerites took that and converted
- 36:05it to years. Now we're dealing with twenty three hundred year. It said
- 36:07days like literal mornings. It didn't even say days, it said mornings and
- 36:12evenings. How do you mix the two up anyway? They take random numbers,
- 36:16completely random, from random places. A lot of them come from the
- 36:21Book of Daniel, and more come from Revelation, and they pick random anchor
- 36:27points throughout history. You know, the temple fell in six zh six BCE,
- 36:32even though they're wrong about that it fell in five eighty six BCE.
- 36:37Or they'll find the year that I don't know, one of the kings ordered
- 36:44the temple rebuilt, you know, four fifty seven BCE. And they'll add
- 36:50these random other numbers that they found twenty three hundred years or two thousand,
- 36:54five hundred and forty years or whatever. They find all this stuff all through
- 36:59the Bible and squish it together. I call that Bible code. I don't
- 37:01know how it could be confused as anything else. A few more questions for
- 37:07you, and I'm going to put links to the books in the description box
- 37:10because I found them impressive. I find them palatable and digestible for those of
- 37:15us who occasionally get overwhelmed by being introduced to whole religions in one shot.
- 37:22But who is this Tony Morris guy? You wrote about him? Who is
- 37:28he? And why did we care? I did? Yeah, I had
- 37:30a whole section devoted to Tony Morris. He was, he's an ex Governing
- 37:34Body member in the nineteen seventies, eighties, and nineties. You know what
- 37:40I think in the nineteen seventies is a guy named Ray Franz is the Vice
- 37:45president's nephew. He was on the Governing Body. He was the last person
- 37:50to leave the Governing Body since ever, maybe I'm not even sure that this
- 37:57has ever happened before. The Governing Body didn't exist in its current formula before
- 38:00the seventies, the sixties and fifties. But Tony Morris and Ray Franz are
- 38:07really, by and large the only two that have left. And Tony Morris
- 38:12left seemingly with like a whimper, if you will, it was just one
- 38:16day, for three days in a row, they posted on their little news
- 38:22section, brother Tony Morris is no longer one of Jehovah's witnesses. And then
- 38:27they removed it and didn't say another word about it. And it's so baffling
- 38:31to like, what did this guy do to be removed for them from the
- 38:35Governing Body? They aren't talking about it. Nobody can even find the guy.
- 38:39He's supposed to be anointed, which means he has a special role to
- 38:45play in God's Kingdom. You know, he's supposed to be raptured to Heaven,
- 38:49one of one hundred and forty four thousand people that'll be raptured to Heaven,
- 38:52given to Heaven's swords, and sent to slay his enemies in the end.
- 38:58He's supposed to hold a unique place within the religion as an anointed person,
- 39:02and as such, you're supposed to show up to the Kingdom Hall once
- 39:07a year and take communion publicly at something called the Memorial happens around Easter time.
- 39:15But he didn't. He's been gone for like multiple years now and nobody
- 39:20has any information on him. He's apparently not showing up to Kingdom halls.
- 39:24And he was a wild person. I think he turned the governing body into
- 39:30kind of a clown show, if you will. He was a field medic
- 39:37in Vietnam before adjoining the religion, and he saw some horrific stuff, as
- 39:43you know Vietnam veterans see, and that bleeds through, or bled through at
- 39:49least into his talks. He would say absolutely, he would describe in vivid
- 39:53detail, way more vivid than it needed to be, what was going to
- 39:58happen to unbelievers. The end, it was pretty clear that he was like
- 40:04going back to when he was in Vietnam trying to patch somebody up. He
- 40:09also had a serious problem or has with tight pants and with gay people.
- 40:17Yeah, tight pants. It seems like a one off thing, right,
- 40:21like, oh, he mentioned pants shouldn't be too tight. Okay, we'll
- 40:23move on, I guess. Except it wasn't just like that. He harped
- 40:29on it over and over and over. It even slipped into the kids cartoons
- 40:35Caleb and Sophia. And it wasn't just women either. You think to yourself,
- 40:38well, he just don't he wants women to be modest. No,
- 40:42he's talking about guys, young men. Is they're wearing these tight suits.
- 40:49The suit jackets tight and then the pants are tight all the way down.
- 41:00I'm a big guy, And some say, well, you wouldn't look good
- 41:05in one anyway. That's why you don't want one, you know, Sorry,
- 41:08buddy. I would never disrespect my heavenly father and dressed like that.
- 41:15And what it is is this SPANX, the skin tight stuff they wear.
- 41:21Now, are any sisters wearing it? In the ministry rule? I can't
- 41:25say I've ever seen that. But when they exercise, they leave their home
- 41:31and they're jogging in this stuff. Look at the verse. Is that appropriate
- 41:38to wear skin tight spanks or whatever they call it. That's not modest,
- 41:45and it's certainly not sounded mine. It's really not appropriate. He even went
- 41:51as far as to say, there are homosexuals quote unquote that control the fashion
- 41:58industry, and they want to see you in tight pants, and that's why
- 42:01they're making tight pants at all. Right, it's just wild. The guy
- 42:06was unhinged. Let me ask you this. We know the Mormon Church is
- 42:09big business, I mean massive, massive, major business. How about the
- 42:15JW's. We're talking about a corporation or a religion or both. Well,
- 42:20I've thought about this a lot, and something that I reveal in the book
- 42:24that I haven't really been public about is well, I guess I'm public about
- 42:30it now. I was involved in maintaining the servers that process their donations,
- 42:37their transactions. I was the guy that set up the donation servers that processed
- 42:45everything that I ran the DNS system. And this wasn't even like back when
- 42:51I was younger. I mean this was not even that long ago. I've
- 42:53worked with these people for a long time. And it's a series of kind
- 42:57of cutouts. You know, Jehovah's Witnesses have an other Jehovah's Witness that does
- 43:00this, and that Jehovah's Witness can hire contractors by doing so. The religion
- 43:07is not hiring outsiders. That's like very frowned upon. It's all in house.
- 43:13Even their lawyers by and large are all in house. But it is
- 43:16a corporation very much. And I think in the two thousands they split the
- 43:23religion and the corporation up, and maybe the twenty tens for liability purposes to
- 43:31protect themselves from liability. Judges see right through that kind of thing, so
- 43:37it didn't really matter ultimately. But they are very very rich in their own
- 43:43right. As you were saying about the Mormon Church, Jehovah's Witnesses don't have
- 43:49a lot of cash, probably a lot of liquid cash, but they own
- 43:53every kingdom hall from here to Texas and beyond. And the way that they
- 44:00have historically made money, aside from investing in the stock market and getting donations
- 44:06from their people, is they'll have their people build new kingdom halls. You
- 44:12know, they'll have a congregation to a quick build takes them like three days.
- 44:15They have all the materials delivered on Friday. On Monday, they're putting
- 44:20up the wallpaper, that kind of thing. It's kind of impressive actually,
- 44:22And I've taken part in these two. So they'll throw a whole Kingdom Hall
- 44:27together in like a weekend basically and sell off the old one. But they
- 44:32didn't really need to do that. They didn't need a new Kingdom Hall.
- 44:36Now. One of the most expensive parts of building a house or whatever is
- 44:43the labor. So really they're getting free labor out of the Jehovah's witnesses,
- 44:47and that is what pays for, you know, a variety of things,
- 44:54some sexual abuse lawsuits that they've been subjected to that they've lost because of their
- 45:00mistreatment of the situation and everything. It pays for all of their stuff.
- 45:07I've mentioned the creepy videos. There's certainly one that people have talked about from
- 45:13the Mormon Church. The LDS authorities take you in for the endowment ceremony,
- 45:17forbidden to the public. Certainly cameras forbidden. They didn't want anybody to know
- 45:22what was going on. Somebody snuck a phone camera in and wow, do
- 45:30the JW's have anything like that when they put on the creepy robes and you
- 45:34know, the ramshorn and chant over the you know, the Virgin. I'd
- 45:38ask the question, but is any of that stuff going on in the in
- 45:42the the Jehovah's witnesses, No, not really. Jehovah's Witnesses are very opposed
- 45:49to the quote unquote Freemasons, which is hilarious considering the founder Traility's Russell has
- 45:57a bunch of Freemason symbolism all over his you know, his tomb or his
- 46:01monument at his gravesite. But that's neither here nor there. Now they don't
- 46:06really have anything like that. Although when you're trying to get involved in the
- 46:12religion, it's a you know, a year or two long process that requires
- 46:20kind of an indoctrination into the culture in a unique way. You have to
- 46:24learn how they do everything start to finish until you've put on the new personality
- 46:30as they call it. I'm not even being flippant here. That's the name
- 46:34that they've given it in their literature, the new personality, and they've kind
- 46:39of become clones of each other now behind closed doors, when it's just other
- 46:44Jehovah's Witnesses. They can and do on occasion, discuss more esoteric beliefs,
- 46:52like the fact that they believe that Michael the Archangel is Jesus, for example,
- 46:55or that Jesus was created by God and then Jesus created every thing else.
- 47:00You know, they'll talk about some slightly less common beliefs, but they're
- 47:05not really hiding anything from the public. It's just that their new personality comes
- 47:08out a little bit. We are in the process of better understanding Jehovah's Witnesses.
- 47:17Our final segment with author and ex jw Owen Morgan. Next, Thanks
- 47:30for listening. Thanks for your support on Patreon. It makes a difference.
- 47:36You can choose just a few bucks a month or whatever you want to do.
- 47:38You can quit any time, but you get the show early in commercial
- 47:44free Patreon dot com slash Seth Andrew's speaking here with ex Jehovah's witness Now activist
- 47:52and author Owen Morgan. Do one hundred and forty four thousand go to Heaven
- 48:00and the rest are screwed? Because we always talk about the one hundred and
- 48:04forty four what's that about? Yeah, Well, according to the Bible,
- 48:08the verse that's used to back up the rapture as common Christianity understands that.
- 48:15I believe it's in First Thessalonians. Paul's talking about people who were dying before
- 48:23Jesus came back to earth, and everybody's like, what's happening. He's not
- 48:27you know, they're not supposed to die. He's supposed to come back and
- 48:30set up a kingdom and all that other stuff, you know. And Paul
- 48:32said, don't worry about it. When Jesus comes back, the ones that
- 48:37have died will come up out of their graves and meet Jesus halfway and escort
- 48:42him back to Earth, trying to quell fears. Now, Jehovah's witnesses accurately
- 48:46recognize that the rapture as it's understood in common Christianity is not actually biblical as
- 48:55is, you know, the Trinity not actually a biblical teaching, and a
- 49:00couple of other things. And they use that factual information about the history and
- 49:05the culture of the time to bolster their credibility in other areas. Now,
- 49:08as far as the one hundred and forty four thousand go, they get that
- 49:12number once again from combining a billion verses, one from Revelation, one from
- 49:16Daniel, a whole bunch of other stuff, and the verse in Revelation,
- 49:23I think it's Revelation chapter fourteen. It says this number shall be sealed twelve
- 49:30thousand from the tribe of Reuben, twelve thousand from the tribe of Asher,
- 49:32and Judas on and so forth, and it counts one hundred and forty four
- 49:37thousand, twelve tribes total. And they believe that the one hundred forty four
- 49:40thousand are people who just know, quote unquote that they've been chosen by God.
- 49:47Everybody else is going to stay here on earth and have a kind of
- 49:52Garden of Eden two point zero. But the one hundred forty four thousand go
- 49:54to Heaven with Jesus and rule over the earth is joint air to the throne,
- 50:00kings and priests alongside him, and they judge people, and well they
- 50:06will judge people when they get to heaven, and they will also execute judgment
- 50:09on people. You know, they'll actually go down with the heaven swords and
- 50:14make it happen and the whole nine yards. So that's what the one hundred
- 50:17and forty four thousand is. That's what they believe about it. They're predestined.
- 50:22I mean before they were born, they're designated. This is you're gonna
- 50:27you won the lottery, you get to go and sort of have dominion kind
- 50:30of deal. I'm not sure if they believe it's predestined. They don't actually
- 50:35address if it's predestined. But Calvinist religions believe in predestination. Jehovah's Witnesses don't
- 50:40believe in predestination. Like that, to become an anointed person, it's not
- 50:45something that you can work to achieve. It's just something that you know.
- 50:51That's it. If there's any doubt in your heart, then you're not We
- 50:54can't talk about that Jehovah's Witnesses without really getting into the sinister's shade of shunning.
- 51:01And more than I think most people know it's a shunning culture. What
- 51:06I find interesting is that it really is a snitch culture too, right.
- 51:10I mean, you tell on your body, then they give you a cookie.
- 51:15Right, you get a pat on the head, you get favor from
- 51:16the powers that be. So if somebody is going through something, or maybe
- 51:21they're doing something that's unto ward, or they have doubts about the religion itself,
- 51:27and they whisper it to a body, a parent, a friend,
- 51:30a child. They have to worry that they're going to get turned in and
- 51:34there will be consequences. Can we talk about the more insidious nature of this
- 51:37sort of snitch culture Owen, Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Jehovah's witnesses have
- 51:44not always shunned. I mentioned Ray Friends earlier. They've changed their shunning policy
- 51:51a lot since Ray Friends. It has existed in some form for like decades
- 51:57and decades, but they get that from a verse. I believe in First
- 52:01Corinthians it says a guy actually slept with his stepmother. That's real, that
- 52:07happened. That's what was described in First Corinthians. Well that's the situation that
- 52:12played out in First Corinthians. Paul wrote the letter to the Corinthian congregation saying,
- 52:16don't even dine with such a man who was bragging about it in church
- 52:21the way that this guy was. And the Corinthian congregation wrote back and said,
- 52:28we did what you said and it was absolutely terrible and we're not doing
- 52:30this anymore. And Paul said, yeah, you're right, this isn't right.
- 52:36This makes us look even worse than having people sleeping with their stepmother,
- 52:39so we probably shouldn't do any of this shunning stuff. So shunning started out
- 52:45kind of being biblical, but in the end is not supported or endorsed by
- 52:52the Bible. I'm no defender of the Bible. I'm just trying to get
- 52:57to true information here, and as far as I can tell, it's just
- 52:59not Jehovah's witnesses use that verse though. In First Corinthians to justify shunning.
- 53:06They refuse to have anybody communicate with people on the outside who have left the
- 53:12religion. In fact, it's a just fellowshipping offense. You talk to someone
- 53:15on the outside, you will be just fellowshipped too, and they heavily discourage
- 53:22communication with the outside world generally. I was this fellowshipped when I was young.
- 53:28I was I think I was eighteen years old, and it turned my
- 53:30life upside down, which is a point. They want to pull the rug
- 53:34out from under you, so you fall flat on your face and you serve
- 53:37as an example to everybody around you not to do that anymore. You get
- 53:40really heavy into your deconversion, deconstruction, whatever story in the book. But
- 53:47you know, I'm glad you busted out. How long have you been out
- 53:52of the jiws? I was I was homeschooled when I was fourteen, or
- 54:00well, I was twelve years old when I started, and then until I
- 54:01was sixteen, I was homeschooled, and that meant complete and total isolation from
- 54:07the outside world. To answer your question more directly, I was eighteen when
- 54:12I officially got disfellowshipped. But when I went to high school for the first
- 54:15time, got around people, I started doing things that might be disfellowshiping efense,
- 54:21like going to parties, hanging out with outsiders. I smoked a cigarette
- 54:25once, I drank alcohol, and that was unacceptable and led to my disfellowshipping.
- 54:35Now, again, as you said, I go through the story.
- 54:37There's a lot more to it than just that, but I go through it
- 54:40in the book. And after being disfellowshipped at eighteen years old, being kicked
- 54:47out of my house, I was in eleventh grade because I was held back
- 54:52a year from the homeschooling that I did. After being disfellowshiped in eleventh grade,
- 54:58I had to drop out of school and I had nothing and nobody,
- 55:02and I eventually finally pulled myself back up on my feet, and I think
- 55:09I was twenty three years old before I really started questioning anything. Oh.
- 55:15Regarding the thing that pulled me out, As I said earlier, it was
- 55:19beth Serene, the existence of that mansion. My brother in law at the
- 55:23time was sitting in the kitchen. He's a Jehovah's witness. He's not supposed
- 55:28to be talking to me. But you know, my sister kind of made
- 55:30some leeway and said, okay, you know, we'll talk to him.
- 55:34It's not a big Dailies family. So my brother in law was sitting in
- 55:37the kitchen and I'm like, I'm in the kitchen with him, and he
- 55:40says, you know that Joseph Rutherford had that mansion built, And I had
- 55:45no idea That was the thing that clicked me out of it. Twenty three
- 55:49before I realized this is nonsense. And Jehovah's witnesses had spent so many years
- 55:57of my life convincing me that every other church was nonsense and pointing out real,
- 56:02actual logical flaws in like the Catholic Church and the Methodist Church and things
- 56:08like that, completely ignoring their own logical flaws. Of course, so when
- 56:13I realized that Jehovah's witnesses were also full of it, I just kind of
- 56:16like walked away. I said, oh, this is all nonsense. It's
- 56:20good medicine, isn't it? To go out and blow the whistle? And
- 56:23the books are well written, they are well constructed. They are great reads.
- 56:30Understanding Jehovah's Witnesses and then more of a kind of a pocket book assummation
- 56:36of the last chapter or was it just the last chapter? Is it the
- 56:39exact chapter? It's the exact chapter, copy and paste except one hundred questions
- 56:44for Jehovah's Witnesses is basically copyright free. I put that in there so you
- 56:49can download a PDF of it, and you can have it printed as many
- 56:52copies as you want. It's just non commercial attribution. So keep the copyright
- 56:57page in and don't sell it to anybody. Yeah, I mean, the
- 57:00point is you want to get the word out, but we also want to
- 57:04support people who are doing what Owen Morgan is doing. And I know,
- 57:09being an author, I know authors don't get I mean, if you're not
- 57:13selling one hundred million copies, if you're not selling a if you're not selling
- 57:16one hundred thousand copies, you're not getting rich. The royalties on books are
- 57:21smaller than people realize, but I do. I do find that there's merit
- 57:25in supporting through purchases, and I would encourage everybody to go and buy Understanding
- 57:30Jehovah's Witnesses by author and activist Owen Morgan. Links are in the description box.
- 57:37I will also include links to your website and your channels. Really good
- 57:43stuff today, brother, and it's always good to chat. Thanks for coming.
- 57:45Yeah, thank you so much. I'm going to have to have you
- 57:47on my channel sometime soon too. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter
- 57:52for a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts
- 57:58featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and details
- 58:02on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinkingatheist dot com