Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Ally Faces Credit Crunch, GM Employees On The EV Train, The EV Slowdown Myth
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning, and welcome to the ASOTU Troublemakers. Today, on September 11th, we take a moment to remember the 2,977 lives lost 23 years ago today.
- 0:10I'm wearing this hat in honor of the courage of the 343 New York FD firefighters who made that ultimate sacrifice, along with their brothers and sisters and other first responders.
- 0:19This is a powerful reminder of the courage and selflessness that defined us that day. And we will never forget the pain and devastation of that tragic moment. It is important to remember that it didn't stop us.
- 0:29As a nation and as individuals, we moved forward, sometimes slowly, but always forward. That day tested us, but it also showed our resilience and our refusal to be stopped, and here we carry that same spirit.
- 0:41We come together from different places, different roles, all moving toward-- all moving forward with a common purpose. We grow, we innovate, we face challenges head-on, but we continue in our industry and in our lives.
- 0:53Let's honor those we lost by pushing forward, always stronger together, and please join me in a moment of silence.
- 1:00[instrumental music] Good morning.
- 1:25Thanks for pausing with us for that moment. Never too far from that to have a moment. DG, welcome to the show. Thanks for bringing us in. We're talking about Ally- Thank you... GM and the EV slowdown myth.
- 1:35Everywhere I go, the people really wanna know, who I is and who I be. Mm. Stop and stare when they see me. If I said it once, no need to repeat. Run up on me, watch you fall to your knees.
- 1:44Tip- DG, you, uh, you've got-- You're like a wordsmith, you know what I mean? I just appreciate your ability to communicate clearly. And when you have to r- And when you write it and read it, it's
- 1:58almost as good as when you ad lib. [laughs] No. Almost as-- No, nothing's better than the ad lib. I know. But that, I needed a bit of that. I had to sit down and put that one together.
- 2:07I thought it was just, you know, it really-- I mean, it's-- And it's like I said, it's us. We, we continued moving forward. Yeah. Um, and, and, uh, so I appreciate the opportunity.
- 2:15Yeah, no, I, I, you know, I think that, like, we-- Uh, I was so-- I was thankful that our writing team also took a moment to just, like, at the beginning of the email today, just recognize that.
- 2:25And, you know, you can, you can get removed from moments in history, um, and, and slowly start to, like, be disengaged with that moment.
- 2:36And whether it be, uh, the pandemic or 9/11 or World War, you, you kind of become disenfranchised from the idea that it impacts you or impacts the daily life of those around you.
- 2:47But, um, you know, uh, pausing to remember those, those things I think is important for us for sure.
- 2:54Um- Yeah, and if anybody's at, anybody's at a dealership and you guys maybe, you know, get some lunch for your local, you know, firefighters or paramedics- Right... or police.
- 3:03It might just be a nice thing to do today just to let them know, you know, we don't forget and we appreciate first responders. That's a gr- I mean, look, we could end the pod right there.
- 3:11Hey, go buy your- That's great... buy, buy some lunch for some, uh, local first responders. Uh, a, a great grab.
- 3:16Um, hey, uh, tomorrow we have an ASOTU Edge webinar, What's Holding Your Title Department Back?, uh, that you are gonna wanna check out.
- 3:25If you go to asotu.com, scroll down just a wee bit, you can register for that webinar. Uh, and would, would love to have you there.
- 3:33You know, title department is, uh, often forgotten, but never forgotten by customers who can't get their titles, can't get their work done, can't get their registrations, so- What's holding your titles back?
- 3:43What's, what is holding your title department back? I don't know. What is it with the titles?
- 3:48What-- Why d- why is it, [laughs] like every dealership that I've ever worked for, worked with, everything, it is a tough thing to deal with. Everybody's like getting second temp tags, the whole nine yards. It's brutal.
- 3:59You know. You know. I do. I mean, listen, fix car washes and fix titles, and it's like you've got two of the biggest pain points right there. Yeah.
- 4:06It's like car washes and titles are like our McDonald's, uh, ice cream machine. You know what I mean? I had to go there. That- I'm sorry... that's, if that's not it right there, I don't know what is.
- 4:15That was cold sliding. [laughs] That was our soundbite right there. That was cold sliding. [laughs] All right, let's get into it.
- 4:20Hey, first story today is Ally Financial is grappling with growing ch- uh, credit challenges as high inflation impacts borrowers, resulting in increased delinquencies.
- 4:30Uh, their shares plummeted, uh, 17.62% on September 10th, signaling the pressure the lender faces.
- 4:37Um, the delinquencies in their auto sector increased by 20 basis points in July and August compared to Ally's expectations.
- 4:45And net charge-offs, uh, meaning unrecoverable debts, increased by 10 basis points during the same period. Um, borrowers are-- h- have obviously been cutting back a lot.
- 4:55Uh, Ally has actually sold its lending business to Synchrony Financial to address its credit issue.
- 5:00Um, their CFO, Russell Hutchinson, specifically mentioned that the number of borrowers in the 61-plus day delinquency category has become a point of concern, with more underperformance expected in this bucket.
- 5:13Um, his quote, "A bor- our borrower is struggling with high inflation and now more recently, a weakening employment picture."
- 5:20So it's not just that initial lending, but, uh, what's happening to lenders and borrowers after the point of acquisition of a loan. Right.
- 5:29And I think also it's, you know, there's all, so much data out there, and it's like reading the tea leaves, right? So they're s- they're talking about their bout- their borrower.
- 5:36And where Allied might be, you know, where their credit portfolio might be lying is with credit scores that, you know, might be in those mid sixes, and that might track along with the nation's statistics.
- 5:46But, um, when you see that there's auto delinquencies that have ticked up a bit, um, and people that are in this 60-day or 90-day plus mark, like that's not across the credit spectrum. Yeah.
- 5:56Um, so it is a, it is a little flashing light, and it is, it is there certainly.
- 6:01Um, and I'm not suggesting that this problem only belongs to Ally, but if it's made that much of an impact for Ally, then it's kind of a telling story about where, you know, where they've been investing in their credit portfolio.
- 6:11Um, and I don't think we're telling anything new to anybody that, you know, that deals heavily in that credit band and/or anyone who deals specifically, you know, and relies on Allies or captive finance.
- 6:19I think they've probably been seeing that, um, because the cost of living, the cost of insuring and, and, and the cost of everything else have been on the rise now for almost two years.
- 6:27I do, I do think that that, that band of credit is really where you start to see the first crunch start, you know, to, to crunch, to use economic terms. Um, but I...
- 6:37And I'm not saying that there's not o- other warning signs across the industry, but I do think in this case, I don't wanna say it's isolated, I just think it's a bit more specific.Yeah, and for those just wondering, like that band, you know, Ally is a, a lit more, a bit more of a full-spectrum lender, not deep subprime, but a bit into subprime, mid-prime, and near prime.
- 6:55Uh, so you, you aren't dealing with that 740-plus, uh, as much, right? They do that in some captive lending, but, um, much more across the board, has a little like mid-prime, near prime.
- 7:06Um, and so you s- you, you get that crunch because of, like you said, income levels, uh, disposable income, typically slightly higher DTI ratios on, on some of that lending.
- 7:16So, uh, we'll see what, we'll see what continues to happen with this because...
- 7:20And, and I think we're actually gonna be talking on the wheelhouse this afternoon, uh, on the recording about like what the initial lending scenario is, because it's completely different, too, when you, when you look at, you know, just what's available, prices of cars, you know, LTV values going out, um, just to be able to cover some of the negative equity that we're experiencing from the past few years.
- 7:42Right. And people are coming to the table with, you know, now we're s- we're seeing an industry-wide average of negative equity that's coming into deals.
- 7:48Um, and I think that's also one of the reasons, if you ask most desk managers why they're having problems, you know, getting a lot of deals done, is just covering the negative. Yep.
- 7:56Um, but yeah, and we're, we're gonna, we're gonna dump out as many tea leaves as we can, um, and try to make some type of, of order out of it.
- 8:02Uh, 'cause you certainly have to take into account average, uh, not only your average interest rates, um, which really haven't gone down, especially on used cars, and then, um, just what the, what it looks like from the amount of credit applications that we're submitting.
- 8:14Yep. Absolutely. I got no segue for the second story, uh, but General Motors is intensifying its push toward an all-electric future, making it clear that salaried employees must align with its EV vision or move on.
- 8:29Uh, a series of organizational changes this year underscores GM dedication to selling only electric vehicles still by the year 20t- 35.
- 8:37Uh, they've downsized its global head, their whole glo- their global headquarters to streamline operations.
- 8:42Um, as we covered earlier this year, they revised how it evaluates employee performance with a stronger production and innovation focus. New bonus metrics even more closely align with the company's EV goals.
- 8:54Um, even remote work privileges have been reduced for some employees to promote, uh, more productivity and, and collaboration.
- 9:01Um, GM spokesma- person, uh, Kevin Kelly emphasized, "We're committed to making sure our teams have the right skills, are working effectively, and rewarded appropriately for delivering world-class vehicles to our customers."
- 9:13Uh, so it's not just an external push, it's an internal push toward making sure that everyone is aligned toward this EV vision and future. Interesting move. Yeah.
- 9:22How, how much of this is about production and how much of this is about, um, could, could, uh, could everyone please stop giving quotes to the press about how they don't think this is a good idea and it's not sustainable?
- 9:32[laughs] I don't know if this was more of a production line thing or more of a, a line of, you know, let's, let's align ourselves in our communication.
- 9:39And by the way, like, uh, y- your guys, you know, your, uh, your GM employee plan now only works on EVs. Right. Um, [laughs] that would be, that would be a pretty drastic move, and we'd see how they would react there.
- 9:51I think that, I think it's not a bad thing to try and- Well, I think we've actually seen that there's a h- there's a better incentive on EVs already, uh, for GM. 100%. I think Nissan moved to that as well.
- 10:00You know, you're seeing these o- Ford also. Yeah, Ford moved to that. Uh, y- you're seeing these, these manufacturers really, like, try and take an internal push.
- 10:07Um, which I guess, like, you know, just from w- working in dealerships, like, you're always trying to get people aligned with a vision on what you're selling, what you're interested in.
- 10:15You're trying to get, you know, people in the vehicle, the manufacturer, right? Whatever dealership you're at, you're like, "How can I get all my employees driving the- Mm-hmm... uh, driving the, the vehicle?"
- 10:24Um, so it, it makes a lot of sense. It's just, you know, the question on, on our minds is always, is this logical and practical, um, or is it a little bit too, too much too early? So...
- 10:36Right, because how much more do we know about exactly what 2035 is gonna look like- Pff... from GM's perspective or anybody else's, right? So, like, that's still the date that's just out there.
- 10:44But how we get there- Well, and every- everyone thought that 2024 was gonna lo- look a lot different than, than it was, and everyone's kind of backpedaled on their, their claims and their, their predictions for this year and their produ- productivity levels over the next three.
- 10:55So, how, how can you predict '10 and start to kind of move an internal narrative and focus on something like that that's so unpredictable? And you notice that it all stops just short of saying, "We are an EV brand."
- 11:08Right. Right? Like, it's, "Be aligned with our strategy." It's not saying we are- 'Cause those mar- 'cause those margins come, baby. Those margins come. [laughs] Right.
- 11:16And a little bit, it's a little Marshawn Lynch here, right? Like, we're here just so we don't get fined. [laughs] These EVs are here so we don't get fined. Oh, speaking of EVs so we don't get fined, I guess. Stop.
- 11:29Segway. Time. [upbeat music] That was a segue. That was a segue. Uh, this is a fun article.
- 11:35We're, we're gonna point this out that it's a very opinionated Electrek article, which if you've ever, if you've ever read up on Electrek, a lot of opinions in there.
- 11:42But despite misleading headlines claiming otherwise, this writer says that EV sales continue to rise globally, though in, the growth percentages have naturally slowed as the market expands.
- 11:53Uh, typically, media is reporting, obviously, over this first year, a slump, uh, in EVs.
- 12:00Um, uh, despite declines from automakers like GM, VW, and Tus- Tesla, overall EV sales in the US in Q1, so that's, like, the full data that we have, still increased by 7%, reflecting continued growth in the market.
- 12:13Um, and, uh, here's, here's a g- here's a fun quote from the Electrek article, then I wanna pull up a couple graphics.
- 12:19But, uh, this, uh, this, this journalist said, "Each journalist who has spent the last year perpetuating the myth of an EV sales slowdown should have read any one of our articles or Googled a single number showing year-over-year EV sales in any region or for most countries and most brands and found that they are still going up.
- 12:35The information is out there and easy to, to find, so stop lying." I feel like someone, like, I don't know, has stock in Tesla or something. Uh, we'll see what that is.
- 12:44But- I do wanna point out this one chart, um, or, or two charts where- Look, look at our objective, look at our objective journalism here from a site called Electrek. Yes.
- 12:51And that's the only place you should be getting information from. [laughs] Uh, I, uh, yeah. The, so there's two charts that were there.
- 12:58One is this chart showing just the, the difference in Q1 growth or decline, um, from different manufacturers.
- 13:05And you see, you know, some of the legacy manufacturers starting to dip in, uh, and, and, and get their toes wet. GM, obviously, with their, um, exclusion of the Bolt this year, saw a decline.
- 13:17And then Tesla, as everybody knows, saw a Q1 decline, but they're on the rebound in Q2. Um, so almost a balance in the market at a 7% increase.
- 13:26But then the one that we've been talking a lot about, and if you look at the difference between how, uh, plug-in hybrids, pure EVs, and, and, uh, and hybrids, right, gas-powered hybrids, and you see this, like, initial, uh, leading indicator and the, uh, i- in the, in the EV world for the past, like, five years.
- 13:47But hybrids quickly, over the last three quarters, starting to take, uh, a, a significant advantage, primarily due to a company called Toyota, um, but also other companies heavily, more heavily investing in hybrids.
- 14:00So, um, still a growth in the market outside of non, um, hybrid or electric vehicles. Um, but hybrids definitely still winning. They're less expensive. Yeah.They're, they're less ex-...
- 14:12Oy, you know, how many times are we gonna have to say this, right? And Toyota will be the first one to, to let everybody know that also, right?
- 14:17I mean, they're, they're able to produce hybrids that are, you know, less than $2,000 less expensive than their ICE counterpart. Yeah.
- 14:23You know, if it had to be purely, than if it had to go to be purely, um, electric, right? So $2,000 less than making an ICE completely electric, and you can still have a hybrid.
- 14:33So, like, that's been proven to just be a winning strategy.
- 14:35I think also if you look at the chart with manufacturers, the o- other OEMs, and again, I've always been one, 100% on board with the idea that Tesla has a core Tesla market share that is part of the electric and, and, uh, alternate energy vehicle market share, but that Tesla market share is uniquely theirs.
- 14:50There's every other OEM also in the electric space and what their market share looks like. And right, so I would... It'd be, this chart would be fair if we also threw on their average incentive spend- Ooh...
- 15:02and average d- average discount and average transaction price.
- 15:05Like, this chart would make a lot more sense to everybody sitting in dealerships if we looked at how much dealers are being pressured to discount these vehicles, what the average OEM incentive spend is on these vehicles.
- 15:15And some of these manufacturers on the chart, you're talking about average discounts nearing 20% on a new car. So are they transacting?
- 15:22Yeah, but it, maybe again, maybe we have a broader definition of what selling actually is.
- 15:28And also, let's not forget that manufacturers put a lot of pressure, manufacturers that have both fully electric as well as ICE vehicles, put a lot of pressure on the dealerships to make sure that they are moving the electric vehicles.
- 15:38And oftentimes the most common way to do that is with the threat, implied or otherwise, of holding back some of your ICE allocation until you can sell your EVs.
- 15:48So they are inextricably tied in a way that, like, the e- the non-EV segment never asked for. But the EV segment relies on the ICE segment in order to continue to be able to sell and to transact. Yeah.
- 15:59So is the EV segment still overinflated due to, due to discounts, not even just tax incentives?
- 16:05Um, still yet to be determined because, uh, the market is still reacting primarily to discounts, uh, i- in a lot of places, um, even though there is a core market share, like you said, that is Tesla or is early adopter EV.
- 16:19Um, hey, look, it's just one person's opinion, and we got opinions too over here. Uh, but you got things to go do today, people to serve, people to love.
- 16:29Uh, hey, go buy your first responders a, a nice lunch, a nice meal. Celebrate them. Thank them for all they do. This is America. Let's go. Absolutely. Thanks, guys.
- 16:38[upbeat music]