Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / David Copperfield (1935)
Transcript
- 0:13Hello everyone and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. We'll take that again. No, we
- 0:19use that. The show that takes you through every
- 0:22Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today. I'm
- 0:25Kyle. I'm Ryan and I just absolutely hand swatted
- 0:29this pop filter. Not again. Well, the good news
- 0:32is I didn't hurt anything. This was just kind
- 0:34of like a slight, you know, nudge and I had to
- 0:37reestablish. You immediately started with like
- 0:40a chuckle. And then when you tried to redeem
- 0:42yourself, you were like. I just Jackie channed
- 0:46this entire pop filter. My apologies to the pop
- 0:49filter family and that cable I just hit. So how
- 0:52do you feel about magic? Oh, I love magic. Did
- 0:56I tell you the story of when I was on set last
- 0:58time? You did. As a poker thing. Did I tell the
- 1:00podcast? You didn't. You told me off pod. Okay.
- 1:02Here's a really quick version of this. I was
- 1:04cast as a card dealer at a casino. And I was
- 1:09there for three days and man, I was sitting around
- 1:11bored for such a long time. But there was a deck
- 1:13of cards in front of me the entire time. And
- 1:15there was this trick that I learned in high school
- 1:17where you hold the entire deck of cards in your
- 1:20right hand and you flip one of the cards. It
- 1:24spirals through the air and lands in your left
- 1:27hand. So I just was practicing that for like
- 1:2924 hours, just bop, bop, bop. And at one point
- 1:33the director saw it and was like, that's really
- 1:35cool. You should maybe do that. Do that on camera.
- 1:39Tee hee, ha ha. And then the last scene we were
- 1:41filming, it was like a walkthrough of the casino.
- 1:43And he filmed it a couple times. And on the,
- 1:46almost the last take, he said, all right, we're
- 1:48going to change this. Sophie, you're going to
- 1:51do this. Alexandra, you're going to do this.
- 1:53And Kyle, when I point to you, do the trick.
- 1:55And I was like, okay. And he did the walkthrough.
- 1:59Boom, boom, boom. And he said, Kyle. And I went.
- 2:03perfect and i've never felt so cool in my life
- 2:06so magic's magic's all right you know whatever
- 2:09has that come out yet no and i probably got cut
- 2:13well please let us know when it drops because
- 2:17we would love to see maybe we can put this clip
- 2:19over that of that clip of you yeah that's cool
- 2:22it's it's one of those vertical shorts or not
- 2:25shorts but vertical soap opera things yeah so
- 2:28i'll probably have to pay like Twenty seven dollars
- 2:31over the course of scrolling 87 times and be
- 2:36like, yeah, I want to watch the next 30 second
- 2:37clip. But if it's there, I will share it with
- 2:40you all. I look forward to that. How do you like
- 2:43magic? I do. I do like magic. I tend to love,
- 2:47you know, the idea of what actually is happening.
- 2:51I know that. I don't believe like magic is real
- 2:54in that sense or anything, but magic, the process,
- 2:57I'm so sorry to, I just saw you. Absolutely.
- 2:59Your eyes widened. New host. New host. No, please.
- 3:03But no, in this sense, I love the. like veil
- 3:07and shadow behind it yeah i love the reason that
- 3:10it's given pen and teller is a group that i really
- 3:12appreciate because they will show you the trick
- 3:15and in some cases will then show you how they
- 3:17did it because that in itself is like a magic
- 3:19trick like how do you construct this right and
- 3:21i love that i love the ability to like fool audiences
- 3:25and know that there's a way to do it i don't
- 3:27always have to know most of the time you don't
- 3:29want to know right but in some cases you're like
- 3:31i think i kind of have to know actually how you
- 3:33did that So it's great. It plays with like, you
- 3:36know, reality a little bit, which I like. I like
- 3:39that a lot of magic tricks are kind of that either
- 3:42bait and switch or like they make you think one
- 3:44thing and then it's completely different and
- 3:47it catches you off guard, which I think is fitting
- 3:49because that's kind of what happened to me with
- 3:52this movie. That's true. It's very psychological
- 3:55in the sense of like you've secretly been saying.
- 3:59like elephant related things for the past hour.
- 4:01And then you have me draw something and I draw
- 4:04an elephant and you're like, you drew an elephant,
- 4:05didn't you? Because you've been planting that
- 4:06seed the whole time. Right. And you trick the
- 4:08audience into thinking that you're seeing something
- 4:10that, or you're doing something that you think
- 4:13is organic, but it's not. And you planted it.
- 4:16So that little trick you're talking about is
- 4:18of course the fact that we watched a David Copperfield
- 4:21movie that is not related to the magician at
- 4:25all. Nope. So us bringing up magic is completely
- 4:28off the point. I will say, I knew that this was
- 4:33a Charles Dickens novel. Yeah. But I never knew
- 4:35what the Charles Dickens novel was about. So
- 4:37I figured there was some kind of like, you know,
- 4:39magic element to it. Not that it's about a magician,
- 4:42but magic element to it that would inspire David
- 4:44Copperfield, the magician, to take the name.
- 4:47And I think in reality, it's just, I really like
- 4:50the Charles Dickens novel. So now I'm, or his
- 4:53name's actually David Copperfield. There's always
- 4:55that answer to you. That's probably the more
- 4:57likely thing. Do you really think he's a Charles
- 5:00Dickens fan? Oh, I think a lot of people are.
- 5:02Yeah, but him? Why are we saying, why are we
- 5:06doing the rest of development her thing for David
- 5:08Copperfield? I know nothing about this man. I've
- 5:11actually never seen David Copperfield perform
- 5:12a single magic trick, but I just imagine he's
- 5:16busy. You know, he can't read. He doesn't have
- 5:19time for a big old thick. Charles Dickens? He's
- 5:22too busy ripping open a time -space continuum
- 5:24for his new trick. Is that the level of trick
- 5:28he does? I know that his most recent thing on
- 5:30Vegas involved an alien where, like, a UFO came
- 5:34down. Well, that's science. I think he levitated,
- 5:37and you're like, how did you levitate? Well,
- 5:38he's an alien. No, no, no. There was an alien
- 5:41brought into the act. Okay. It's not, hey, I'm
- 5:44David Copperfield, I'm actually an alien. It's
- 5:46that he interacted with an alien. Like, there's
- 5:48an abduction. Who levitated? him because of the
- 5:51beam the tractor beam into the ufo that's my
- 5:53understanding of what he did so the alien is
- 5:55the magician like what are we doing anyway now
- 5:59i would watch uh las vegas residency of a new
- 6:03magic act and it's just alien yeah and it's just
- 6:06like a gray alien like and it just says alien
- 6:09at the top yeah you can't talk it's like the
- 6:11prometheus and bob tapes Do you remember that?
- 6:13Prometheus and Bob have been getting some traction
- 6:15in the Discord for the past month. I think about
- 6:17it a lot, so any opportunity. Any kablam I can
- 6:20bring up. We should talk about this movie. We
- 6:22should. So, David Copperfield is, as we mentioned,
- 6:25an adaptation of the Charles Dickens novel. I'll
- 6:29steal your job just a little bit here. The screenplay
- 6:31was by Howard Estabrook, and it had three nominations
- 6:34in total. We had... I hate that I just did that.
- 6:38Film editing by Robert J. Kern. Assistant director
- 6:41was Joseph... Newman, and Outstanding Production
- 6:44was MGM. Yeah, and I kind of want to change the
- 6:48way I do the cast here. Okay. I'm just going
- 6:50to say that, well, one, this was directed by
- 6:53George Cukor, but also starred Freddie Bartholomew,
- 6:58Frank Lawton. They both played David Copperfield.
- 7:01One the child, one the man. That's correct. And
- 7:03like a slew of other people. There's so many
- 7:06people in this movie. I mean, this spans a lot
- 7:07of time, so a huge cast of characters. Yeah,
- 7:10and I... I think I'm just going to kind of bring
- 7:13them up as we talk about them. Totally fine.
- 7:15Because there's so many. One I want to shout
- 7:17out is W .C. Fields. He is mentioned in the pilot
- 7:21episode of Twin Peaks. And like Cooper says a
- 7:25quote by W .C. Fields. So when his name popped
- 7:28up in the credits, I was like, is this the one
- 7:30where he says the quote? It's not. It's not.
- 7:32Well, there's an interesting story about W .C.
- 7:35Fields, and we'll get into it here. But I've
- 7:37seen a lot of specifically going like. physical
- 7:40media hunting i've seen a lot of w wc fields
- 7:42collections a lot of comedies uh so we'll talk
- 7:46a little bit about him uh once we get into the
- 7:48plot here but the plot of uh david copperfield
- 7:51essentially if you've never read the book is
- 7:53that a young boy uh and his mother uh deal with
- 7:56the loss of her husband his father is that right
- 7:59this is true i i wanted so bad to throw in a
- 8:02jab and be like this this is for you david copperfield
- 8:05the magician because i know you haven't read
- 8:07it But I thought of it so late, so I'm sorry
- 8:10I interrupted you. I just appreciate the fact
- 8:12that we're now shading, like throwing shade at
- 8:15the magician David Copperfield when he's like,
- 8:18my name is David Copperfield. He did nothing
- 8:21wrong. He did nothing wrong. And he may have
- 8:24read it. But I will go ahead and plant a flag
- 8:26right here and right now and say that David Copperfield,
- 8:29the Las Vegas residency magician, is not listening
- 8:32to this episode. Not yet. Well, not yet. And
- 8:35probably not anymore. I feel like it's going
- 8:37to be like a Back to the Future type thing where
- 8:39they're like, hey, Mr. David Copperfield, listen
- 8:42to this. Yeah. And it's like his intern's like
- 8:44holding it up. That's not happening. So after
- 8:47the loss of his father, David and his mother
- 8:51are struggling to find a way to move forward.
- 8:54And she brings in a suitor who... Did you also
- 8:59catch this? David at one point says he looks
- 9:01like a panther. Yeah. Yeah, it was really weird.
- 9:05Spooky. Very spooky. And this man then... causes
- 9:09some distance between David and his mother. And
- 9:13ultimately, through a tragic series of events,
- 9:15David finds himself traveling at a very young
- 9:18age and reestablishes his life with a new group
- 9:22of people. And this is told through the many
- 9:26years of David's life from beginning, not to
- 9:29end, but middle age, maybe? Yeah, yeah. Maybe
- 9:3230, 40 years old? Oh, yeah. I would have thought
- 9:36he'd been younger than that. Potentially. I mean,
- 9:39maybe like late 20s or something. I don't know.
- 9:41Anyways, point is, we're watching kind of the
- 9:44tragedies of David's life blossom into the opportunities
- 9:48that he gets later in life. Yeah. This is kind
- 9:51of an interesting story because the things that
- 9:55happen in David's life are very much tragedies.
- 9:59But the movie itself is kind of shaped like a
- 10:02comedy. A lot of the time? It is. Most of the
- 10:05characters you meet are very eccentric and kind
- 10:09of weird, a lot of them. I want to talk about
- 10:13the last frame of this movie because what a closing
- 10:16to it. Yeah, so much of it is like, look at this
- 10:20guy. Ha ha, he's so funny. Oh no, what's happening
- 10:24to David? It's rough. Yeah, it's, you know what?
- 10:28Honestly, I should have paired this with like
- 10:30a Safdie film. Because a lot of this, it's not
- 10:33quite as sad or as disturbing or stressful as
- 10:36those. Yeah. Might be as sad as those. But it
- 10:39feels like every five minutes, it's David doing
- 10:41something. You're like, I really like this kid.
- 10:43This kid's pretty cool. This is a good one. Hey,
- 10:46what happened to your mom? Like, it's something
- 10:48tragic happens. Or, you know, we've seen specifically
- 10:52how his stepfather, who is played. Mr. Murdstone,
- 10:58I believe is his name. Yeah. Basil Rathbone.
- 11:00Basil Rathbone. Thank you so much. Played extremely
- 11:02well. I did read that Basil Rathbone was specifically
- 11:06very overly kind when the cameras went off to
- 11:11be like, I'm so sorry I have to play this horrible
- 11:12person. That's good. But he, to David's point,
- 11:16looks like a panther when they see him at the
- 11:19funeral of his father. And as he gets closer
- 11:22to the family and starts like being romantically
- 11:24involved with David's mother, we start seeing
- 11:27his abusive nature. He brings his sister around
- 11:30and she is also very terrible to him and controlling.
- 11:35And we've seen David actually getting beaten
- 11:38and, you know, abused by Murdstone. Yeah. Yeah.
- 11:42This was, it was tough because at times it's
- 11:46really hard to feel the rhythms of this movie.
- 11:49Because at times it wants to be very joyous and
- 11:52celebratory, and other times it is extremely
- 11:55sad. And the majority of this movie, I'd say
- 11:58about 70 % to 75%, is David as a boy. So we are
- 12:03following specifically the performance by Freddie
- 12:06Bartholomew. And I want to go ahead and say,
- 12:08I thought Freddie Bartholomew was fantastic in
- 12:11this. I think he's the highlight performance
- 12:13in this movie. Easily. This is the first time,
- 12:16really, that we've seen... a child actor since
- 12:20The Champ. with Jackie Cooper, little Jackie
- 12:23Cooper. I almost forgot. It is so funny that
- 12:26that happened in this conversation about Freddie
- 12:27Bartholomew, because that is almost exactly what
- 12:31ended up happening between them. So Freddie was
- 12:34actually the second highest paid child actor
- 12:35right behind Shirley Temple by the late 1930s.
- 12:38So not quite at this point, but this was leading
- 12:41to the path where he became the second highest
- 12:43paid actor, child actor. And notice that in nowhere
- 12:47in that did we mention Jackie Cooper. Yeah. So
- 12:50Jackie Cooper is now kind of watching the new
- 12:52generation come in and take over that spot that
- 12:55he previously held. Yeah, I imagine it's one
- 12:57of those things at this point where that is constantly
- 13:00shifting. 100%. So Wallace Beery is not. top
- 13:05of the food chain at this point. And you'll notice,
- 13:07like, we haven't seen Wallace Beery this year
- 13:09yet, and I don't know that we will. So, you know,
- 13:12viva via, he shows up. But yeah, Jackie Cooper
- 13:15is kind of like the only example we have of a
- 13:19child actor really taking a lead role up until
- 13:22this point with Freddie Bartholomew. And I think
- 13:25he's fantastic in this movie. He, like, his performance
- 13:29feels kind of less adult than Jackie Cooper does.
- 13:34Jackie Cooper almost feels like we've said it
- 13:36like a 30 something year old in a child's body.
- 13:39Just like, yeah, you know, this is how I get
- 13:41my roles. I just pretend to be a kid. Well, the
- 13:44difference is that in Jackie Cooper's performances,
- 13:47he is playing like we said, like Joe Pesci as
- 13:50a child. Right. Yeah. Like Joe Pesci inside of
- 13:53a child's like body. So it's just him being like
- 13:56a wisecracking, like smart, no nonsense kid.
- 13:58Yeah. But he likes to goof off from time to time.
- 14:01In this, there's a curiosity. behind freddie
- 14:04uh in his performance that makes you feel like
- 14:07he he is a kid now he's not like some like you
- 14:10know i don't know how the world works and like
- 14:13you know i'm making mistake after mistake it's
- 14:15more he's doing the right thing yeah but life
- 14:17is just treating him terribly in this and that
- 14:20curiosity that you see out of freddie and like
- 14:22the heartbreak of like his mother and everything
- 14:24there's a really kind of heartbreaking scene
- 14:27of uh when he's leaving on a carriage with his
- 14:31uh i'm gonna say nanny i guess peggotty peggotty
- 14:36that's right he calls her peg which i thought
- 14:38was very funny yeah um couldn't stop hearing
- 14:40the steely dan song throughout that uh so he's
- 14:43leaving on a horse carriage with peg and he's
- 14:45waving at his mother and as he's waving by to
- 14:48his mother wrathbone comes in mr murdstone yeah
- 14:51and uh he kind of almost like is like death,
- 14:55like approaching on her and then grabbing her
- 14:57kind of like consuming her is how it seems. And
- 15:00you see like, uh, Freddie's wave or David, but
- 15:04the actor, you see his wave, uh, and his wave
- 15:06gets less enthusiastic as he sees Murdstone.
- 15:09Yeah. And you can kind of see the realization
- 15:11on, uh, Peggy's face. That, like, he realizes
- 15:15that, like, something's different after he leaves.
- 15:18And that, to me, was just kind of, like, it felt
- 15:20so hurtful. Like, so impactful that that happened
- 15:24to him. And I think the little, like, subtle
- 15:26performances, you know, it wasn't him bursting
- 15:28into tears and, like, falling into the shoulder
- 15:29of, like, Peggedy. It was more, like, just the
- 15:31kind of realization on his face. So I thought
- 15:34he was phenomenal. Yeah. To a point where when
- 15:38we get introduced to David the Man, played by
- 15:40Frank Lawton, completely fine. I have nothing
- 15:43bad to say about Frank Lawton. Just isn't Freddy.
- 15:47That's all I can say. It's not nearly as interesting.
- 15:51And it feels like this was a movie that I was
- 15:53so interested in the first, not even half, again,
- 15:57like 70 % of the movie. And then once it makes
- 16:01the switch, I just could not find much interest
- 16:03beyond that. Except when like... or some other
- 16:07people show up and you're like, oh, yeah, I remember
- 16:09you. I kind of liked you. But you just don't
- 16:11feel like you can connect as much with David
- 16:13the man as you could with David the child. No,
- 16:15and I think the story plays a lot in that disinterest
- 16:20that shows up because Freddie Bartholomew, he
- 16:24goes through so much in such a short amount of
- 16:27time. And even like his acting, there's such
- 16:31a demand for him to do different things. He does
- 16:34have those subtle bits of, you know, the sad
- 16:36wave and thing and the realization of, oh, things
- 16:39are about to get really bad for me. But then
- 16:41he also does have those moments where he breaks
- 16:43out into into tears. And there are so many just
- 16:46like extreme close ups of his face. And he's
- 16:49doing a great job. And I hope that his dog is
- 16:52OK. But like all of that goes away once David
- 16:57Copperfield ages and becomes Frank Lawton. The
- 17:04tragedies, while they still show up to a lesser
- 17:08degree, they're also not as, I don't know, big,
- 17:11as weighted. So it just feels like he has less
- 17:14to do. And the overall narrative is just kind
- 17:16of boring, really, once he's an adult. Yeah,
- 17:20it's kind of... I say I enjoyed the first 70
- 17:24% of this movie, and I did. But the things that
- 17:27happened to David and the cast of characters
- 17:29in this feel less like, here's this impactful
- 17:31thing, and here's how it's going to affect the
- 17:33rest of my life. And it's more like, here's terrible
- 17:35event A, and then here comes terrible event B.
- 17:37And it's just kind of like a series of events
- 17:39over and over, which makes it not as interesting.
- 17:42Uh, I felt like it was less shaping him and you
- 17:45could still see this again, great performance,
- 17:47but you could see less of like when we see David,
- 17:50the man, you're not like, Oh, you're so affected
- 17:52by this and this causes this. It's just more,
- 17:55no, I'm the man now. And I'm pretty much over
- 17:58all that. Yeah. It doesn't matter what you went
- 17:59through. You would have gotten to this point
- 18:01anyway. Right. And that kind of like negates
- 18:03the whole experience before that, which I didn't
- 18:06really didn't resonate with me. I wanted to point
- 18:09out to you that we talked about this. I think.
- 18:11Two years? One year ago? Smiling Through. Cedric
- 18:15Gibbons was the art director for this movie,
- 18:17as he was with Smiling Through. And in case you
- 18:20didn't hear our Smiling Through episode, we talked
- 18:21about how Cedric Gibbons was a big fan of kind
- 18:24of putting in some nods to his previous work.
- 18:28So in this movie, specifically in the beginning,
- 18:30when David and his mother are going to visit
- 18:32the gravestone of his father, you can actually
- 18:35see in the background the tombstone for Moon
- 18:39Yin. which was, of course, played by Norma Shear
- 18:43in Smiling Through. R .I .P. I thought this was,
- 18:46it's very cool to see this. Like, it feels kind
- 18:49of like, I know it's not this, and this is very
- 18:52vain of me to think, but it feels kind of like
- 18:54it rewards the exact thing we're doing, right?
- 18:57Yeah. Like, it's very cool that a year or two
- 18:59passes and people can see this and be like, oh,
- 19:02I think that's from that movie I saw that one
- 19:04time. But to us specifically with how quickly
- 19:06we're watching these movies and covering them,
- 19:08it feels like a, You know what? It feels like
- 19:11a checkpoint. And it feels kind of like a nod
- 19:14from someone in the movie being like, hey, yeah,
- 19:16look at this. This was only a couple months ago
- 19:18for you, wasn't it? Yeah. Isn't that cool? Feels
- 19:20neat. It really is cool. It feels like a conversation
- 19:23through history or through time where Cedric
- 19:26Gibbons is saying something in 1935 and we can
- 19:29hear it in 2026 and kind of like recognize it.
- 19:31It's very cool. I really, really like that. Yeah.
- 19:34And you hear all the time about how these studios.
- 19:37You know, they would have these sets that they
- 19:39would reuse and these props they would reuse.
- 19:41So not only is it cool for us in the like, oh,
- 19:43look, Easter egg. But it's also just like an
- 19:46example of how this was done and how frequently
- 19:48it was done, because that was only a couple years
- 19:52prior. So I just imagine that that that tombstone
- 19:55was sitting around in the prop house and he was
- 19:57like. Yeah, we'll use that one. No one will really
- 19:59care. See, and that's the thing is that like
- 20:00they could have turned it around and they could
- 20:02have like covered the name up and like, you know,
- 20:03put moss or snow or something over it so you
- 20:06can't see it. But it is displayed. So it is intentional.
- 20:09Yeah, you're right. It does feel like he thought.
- 20:13So maybe someone, maybe eagle -eyed viewers will
- 20:15get a kick out of this. Right. Because if you
- 20:17put it in the background and you can kind of
- 20:18see an M, you could be like, well, I guess it
- 20:20could be for Moon Yin, but really who could tell?
- 20:21Yeah. And it is like, I think front and center.
- 20:24It's pretty prominent. It's in the background,
- 20:25but it is in the center of the frame. Right.
- 20:29So it's pretty prominent. Definitely something
- 20:30I was looking for, but I could see it very clearly.
- 20:33So that felt intentional. I think you're right.
- 20:36They're like, hey, we have tombstones in the
- 20:37back. That's fine. But that specifically being
- 20:40Cedric Gibbons, that to me feels like, no, we're
- 20:42going to do a little nod here. I do like the
- 20:44thought that we're completely wrong. And he forgot
- 20:48even what that went to. He's like, I don't care.
- 20:50Just grab one. He reads it. He's like, who the
- 20:52hell is Mooney? Yeah. What's that? Speaking of
- 20:57Cedric Gibbons, though, I remember briefly you
- 21:00brought him up and you were like, oh, what else
- 21:02did he do? And I couldn't think of anything at
- 21:04the time. Wasn't it during Calvacade he did the.
- 21:08I almost called it bridge. Like it's a damn song.
- 21:11He does the section where it kind of like flashes
- 21:14through time and shows like montages of war.
- 21:17I don't think cavalcade was an MGM picture. So
- 21:20that wasn't him, but he, he does like the wizard
- 21:22of Oz and everything. Like every time he gets
- 21:26brought up, I'm like, he's one of the most celebrated
- 21:28production artists of all time. And we just went
- 21:31over that where, where you were like, what else
- 21:33did he do? And I was like, I don't remember.
- 21:35But here he is again. Like every time MGM pops
- 21:38up, just like Douglas Shearer, here is Cedric
- 21:41Gibbons. And this movie spans so many different
- 21:44settings and time periods that you do get a pretty
- 21:49solid dose of like Cedric Gibbons' work. However,
- 21:52there was no nomination for production design.
- 21:54So it's, I don't know, so far this year, like
- 21:58all of the nominees feel a little weird to me.
- 22:01Yeah, you know, it's funny you say that. I'm
- 22:04with you. I think that of what we've covered
- 22:07so far, I really enjoyed Les Mis. Lives of a
- 22:11Bengal Lancer, I thought was fine, but it just
- 22:14kind of feels like a swing and a slight miss
- 22:16with the majority of these. Yeah. And I think
- 22:19that trend will continue like with next week's
- 22:21episode or next week, next episode where, I mean,
- 22:25this year has 12 nominees, but this one's really
- 22:28feeling like, okay, you guys didn't. have to
- 22:31have 12 we could maybe have five to seven right
- 22:34yeah yeah it it feels weird not to spoil how
- 22:37we feel about this movie but what are we doing
- 22:39but spoil yeah yeah i'm with you on that and
- 22:43and it feels just kind of like maybe it's adaptations
- 22:47Maybe it's the sense of like, well, hey, we were
- 22:49going to make a very famous literary work into
- 22:52a movie because Little Women did that and it
- 22:55got great recognition. And plenty of movies have
- 22:58gotten adaptations and then have been like, you
- 23:00know, great critical successes. Les Mis. Les
- 23:03Mis, but also have done really well with awards.
- 23:06Les Mis. Farewell to Arms. Farewell to Arms.
- 23:09And it's worth pointing out that not only is
- 23:12this not the only adaptation this year, this
- 23:15isn't the only Dickens adaptation to be nominated
- 23:17for Best Picture. And not only that, it is not
- 23:19the only Dickens adaptation to be nominated for
- 23:22Best Picture that was produced by David O. Selznick.
- 23:24And that's Tale of Two Cities. Oh. I didn't even
- 23:27realize that. Yeah, there you go. More Dickens.
- 23:30So Selznick, we've talked a lot about how he's
- 23:32just like, we need more adaptations. Yeah. And
- 23:35that's going to work out for him in the long
- 23:37run. We'll get there. But it is something that
- 23:40we're seeing a lot of, you know, what's the word?
- 23:43We're seeing a lot of proof in the pudding of
- 23:45a lot of adaptations right now. And I think that's
- 23:48kind of what's murking the waters a little bit.
- 23:50where it's more important to kind of take these
- 23:52stories that have already established tragic
- 23:54events, and then how do you put that on screen?
- 23:57And it takes a skillful hand. It can't just be
- 24:00done by just about anyone. And George Cukor,
- 24:03who we've seen movies from before, and he's very
- 24:05competent. There's nothing wrong with this movie
- 24:07in terms of the way he structures it. It just
- 24:10feels flat. Yeah, and I don't put that on the
- 24:13director at all for this particular thing. I
- 24:15think it really is the story. I think some adaptations,
- 24:18some stories, really. are really exciting and
- 24:21catch our interest. And then some are like this.
- 24:24I, I want to talk a little bit more about the
- 24:27plot before we get into like the, the things
- 24:29that sound like our final thoughts. Right. But
- 24:32I did see someone mentioned in letterbox that
- 24:34this really feels like it should have been an
- 24:37example of an early split into two different
- 24:41movies. And maybe this year you had like the
- 24:44young David Copperfield movie. And then next
- 24:47year you had like an extended version of Frank
- 24:49Lawton's story as older David Copperfield. And
- 24:53while that really hasn't been done yet, I mean,
- 24:56we're not really getting sequels to say. I think
- 25:00that would have worked really well because you
- 25:02do have Freddie Bartholomew like. go through
- 25:06his entire story, and it is very effective, and
- 25:09we both enjoyed it, and we were excited for,
- 25:11you know, what was to come. But then the shift
- 25:14into Frank Lawton, you mentioned, like, he sees
- 25:18characters return. But since you just saw them
- 25:21five years ago, there's not a whole lot of, like,
- 25:23wait. to those meetings yeah i mean even the
- 25:26deck or i say decoration even the like costume
- 25:29designing and like the hairstyling and makeup
- 25:31has not changed for these characters because
- 25:33it hasn't been that long amount of time it looks
- 25:35like the only people that have aged are the children
- 25:38yes and everybody else is the same exact person
- 25:41wc fields may a little bit have some age to them
- 25:46but not too much and it just feels kind of like
- 25:49oh yeah the only way i know it's 10, 15 years
- 25:51later is that David isn't a child anymore. Right.
- 25:54And I think even though it is kind of boring,
- 25:58like I still, if they split it into two movies,
- 26:00I'd be like, boy, I really like part one. But
- 26:02I think extending the length of the older David
- 26:06Copperfield story and maybe adding some more
- 26:08weight to what I think are some of the bigger
- 26:12moments, like the ship sequence where he's out
- 26:17doing something. I wasn't following along very
- 26:22well with that whole thing. But it is like the
- 26:25action sequence of the movie where he goes out
- 26:28to sea to find somebody. Yeah, I don't know,
- 26:32man. I kind of checked out on this too, unfortunately.
- 26:35And I'll push back a little bit on that Letterboxd
- 26:38review that you saw that said it should be split
- 26:40into two movies. Because I think the issues with
- 26:42this movie are that second... Again, I keep saying
- 26:46second part, the last fourth of the movie, I
- 26:48guess, where it is David, the man. And to me,
- 26:51I think if you split that into a movie that just
- 26:54accentuates the problems. And in reality, anything
- 26:58that you could have done, you called it out there.
- 27:00Like, Hey, maybe if you like beef up the story
- 27:01a little bit and like massage, like, you know,
- 27:04the reasons why David is the way he is and like
- 27:07how that has kind of shaped to where he is now
- 27:09and confronting those things that could be done
- 27:12in this movie. Like that could have been done
- 27:14here to make it like more cohesive because to
- 27:17me that would be a scenario where I'm like, Hey,
- 27:19yeah, David Copperfield part one. It's great.
- 27:22Not going to watch David Copperfield part two
- 27:25because I'm not as interested in that. Yeah.
- 27:27But I think if, if you did add those things to
- 27:29Frank Lawton's section, it would be so long.
- 27:34This movie is already two hours and 10 minutes,
- 27:37which is wild for this time period. Well, and
- 27:40that's the thing is that I feel like it, It's
- 27:43kind of good and bad. Because again, I like the
- 27:45Freddie Bartholomew sections of David Copperfield.
- 27:47And that's a majority of the movie. And it waxes
- 27:51and wanes a little bit here and there. But ultimately,
- 27:54because you're enjoying it, you want to see more
- 27:57of it. And then we get to Frank Lawton's side
- 28:00and you're like... are we at the halfway point
- 28:01of this movie? Yeah. I feel like it's been going
- 28:04on for like an hour and 50 minutes. And it has.
- 28:07And it has. And then it continues on for another
- 28:1020 minutes with a pretty disengaging version
- 28:14of the story told on Frank Lawton's side. And
- 28:18again, I don't necessarily know if it's even
- 28:20the performance problem. I think it's the way
- 28:21that the character is written, which is strange
- 28:24because it's a Dickens adaptation, so you'd think
- 28:26it'd be pretty faithful to those events. And
- 28:29when we talk about Dickens adaptations, we have
- 28:31to talk about W .C. Fields. So W .C. Fields,
- 28:35I don't I'm not quite sure if he's known for
- 28:38comedy exclusively at this time, but is well
- 28:40known for his comedy efforts. And whenever he
- 28:43takes a project, he's always known for ad libbing
- 28:46and like having a distaste for child actors.
- 28:50OK. Right. He's like, I'm going to ad lib. And
- 28:52I'm going to not enjoy working with children.
- 28:55And they're like, well, hey, what are you doing
- 28:57in this movie where you absolutely cannot ad
- 28:59lib? Because it's a Dickens novel. Right. And
- 29:02you are cast alongside a child. Yeah. Like, how
- 29:06are you going to do this? That's a kid. I have
- 29:09bad news for who David the Child is portrayed
- 29:11by. A child. A child. W .C. Fields decided to
- 29:18forego both of these qualities to portray his
- 29:21character was a macabre. And it's because he
- 29:23admired Dickens so much and not even just Dickens,
- 29:26but this novel specifically. He was such a large
- 29:29fan that he was like, I don't have to ad lib.
- 29:31I will work alongside the kid. It does not matter.
- 29:33I got to play this character. Yeah. And he was
- 29:36so passionate about that. And there's something
- 29:38infectious about his performance in this. He's
- 29:41fun. Because you can see him like really excited
- 29:43to take this on. Yeah. And, again, this is just
- 29:47a comment on the caliber of acting at this time,
- 29:51and I'm sure still to a point now. But we commented
- 29:54on Wallace Beery and how much he was having fun
- 29:57acting alongside, you know, Jackie Cooper and
- 30:00a couple other people. And then you hear he was
- 30:02just kind of miserable to be on set with and
- 30:04specifically didn't want children acting with
- 30:07him. Right. Or at least sharing or stealing his
- 30:10camera time. To hear that and then hear this,
- 30:13it's just a testament to how well they're doing
- 30:16because I thought the relationship between David
- 30:18and McCobber was pretty fun. Am I saying that
- 30:22right? McCobber? Yeah. Okay. Yeah. I thought
- 30:25it was Macabre just by how you pronounced it.
- 30:28And then I looked at the spelling. I was like,
- 30:29nope. I thought that was it. Yeah. That's the
- 30:32one. Yeah. I thought he was great. He's so much
- 30:35fun. And his character has this shtick where
- 30:37he. He almost speaks like V from V for Vendetta.
- 30:42Yes. And then he follows it up with, in short,
- 30:45bleh. And just summarizes everything into like
- 30:48three words. Unfortunately, I felt so seen by
- 30:51Macabre because I feel like that's me professionally.
- 30:53Not even professionally, even personally. Where
- 30:56someone will ask me a question, and I hope you
- 30:59can relate. I hope you can't relate. They'll
- 31:02ask him a question, and he'll answer for about
- 31:0490 seconds, and then at the end be like, but
- 31:06in short, no. I'm like, that's great. Yeah, I
- 31:10do that too. Add a 90 -second pause before that,
- 31:12though, for me. You just start with, in short,
- 31:15no? I just go, and then, yeah. that's all uh
- 31:20a great little characterization from him and
- 31:23again so much you can kind of see the manic nature
- 31:25that wc fields brings to macabre in that and
- 31:28that he's not just saying it because that's how
- 31:30the character is written or like that's the line
- 31:32for him you can specifically see like the manic
- 31:35nature of his brain moving a mile a minute and
- 31:38him kind of catching us all and be like but in
- 31:40short we probably shouldn't do that right Very
- 31:42cool. I really, really liked his performance
- 31:45here. I think it's the second standout after
- 31:47Freddie Bartholomew. Yeah. And you could just
- 31:49see the passion kind of like pouring off his
- 31:52performance. But again, his interaction with
- 31:55David Copperfield in Freddie Bartholomew, it's
- 31:58just I would have never been able to tell that
- 32:01he had a distaste for child actors. Right. Yeah.
- 32:03No, I guess it's not even chemistry. It's just
- 32:07he's so great. That I can't imagine anything
- 32:09else. Well, I'd say it is chemistry because they
- 32:11bounce off each other a bit. Like, I think that
- 32:13Freddy is so used to being around. I keep saying
- 32:17Freddy. I think David the Child is so used to
- 32:19being around characters like Murdstone or his
- 32:22sister and feeling kind of rejected that when
- 32:25he finds someone who also has this very, like,
- 32:27excited nature and wants to help him, like, kind
- 32:31of, like, nurture that curiosity that David has.
- 32:35I think that he's kind of infatuated with that.
- 32:39No, I agree. That's kind of the bummer that we're
- 32:43talking about is David meets so many interesting
- 32:47characters and then ultimately they don't shape
- 32:49his character at all by the end of the movie.
- 32:52No, they really don't. But let's talk a little
- 32:53bit about some more of these interesting characters
- 32:55because that's also a major selling point of
- 32:57this movie. It feels... The Way Grand Hotel was
- 33:01an ensemble piece, also an MGM picture. MGM is
- 33:05doing the same thing here, where they're like,
- 33:06let's just throw everybody into this movie and
- 33:09have some fun with it. We mentioned Clara Peggedy,
- 33:12the nanny, played by Jesse Ralph. She's wonderful
- 33:16as well. She's very sweet. She's very charming.
- 33:19I will say, I had a moment where I looked at
- 33:22the cast while I was watching this, and I saw
- 33:26Lionel Barrymore's name popped up. And my eyes
- 33:29must have crossed, and I thought he played Peggedy.
- 33:31So I was sitting there squinting like, is he
- 33:35in there? So it's very funny that you say that.
- 33:37He played Dan Peggedy. Right. That's where the
- 33:41mix -up came from. You saw something Peggedy,
- 33:44and you were like, Mrs. Peggedy? She leans forward,
- 33:47and the button pops off the back of her dress.
- 33:49And I was like, Lionel would do that. Lionel
- 33:52Barrymore is pulling a Doubtfire. Hello! Yeah,
- 33:54that's exactly what I thought. So, very funny.
- 33:57He's doing really good work, though. And at times,
- 34:00I was kind of like, oh, my God, that is Lionel
- 34:01Barrymore. And really enjoyed his performance.
- 34:04Edna Mae Oliver is Aunt Betsy. And Aunt Betsy
- 34:07is one of the first people on screen. Yeah. There's
- 34:10a gif that I love sharing of Conan O 'Brien at
- 34:13a window. And it's him, like, peering in and
- 34:15kind of, like, clawing at the window to get in.
- 34:17And he's sad. And I send that and work all the
- 34:20time whenever someone's like, all right, well,
- 34:22I'm off to fly to this place. So I share that
- 34:27all the time. And as someone who shares that
- 34:29all the time, Aunt Betsy actually has that exact
- 34:31moment in the beginning of the movie. Yeah. Terrible
- 34:34storm outside. And it's just absolutely blustering.
- 34:37And she's standing at the window. She's just
- 34:40like banging on the window to get in. I was like,
- 34:42who is this crazy woman? Turns out it's her sister.
- 34:46But anyways. Yeah. When she's introduced, I was
- 34:49like, well, this is clearly the villain of the
- 34:51movie. Right. Like, she's just like, hey, it's
- 34:53going to be a girl. I know it. And as soon as
- 34:55they're like, hey, it's a boy. She's like, I'm
- 34:56out of here. Bye. I'm just straight up leaving
- 34:59the movie. I know. I thought she was trying to
- 35:00like steal an inheritance. And then because it
- 35:02was a boy, she was like, oh, well, there goes
- 35:04that plan. Yeah. And then she just absolutely
- 35:06exits. Yes. For like the majority of the movie.
- 35:08But she returns later on and we see that like,
- 35:11you know, we see the misunderstanding of that
- 35:13character and we see her actually being like
- 35:16a role model and a positive reinforcement for
- 35:19David. And I really liked her overall. Listen,
- 35:22she is. the only character that got like a genuine
- 35:26laugh out of me. She really, she's so funny because
- 35:31she's, she's awful. Like she's so rude and mean,
- 35:34but she doesn't believe she is right. She is
- 35:38the only one doing right in this movie. And there
- 35:41is such a great sequence where she is so particular
- 35:45about her lawn and her garden. And when. mr murdstone
- 35:49shows up to reclaim david copperfield they're
- 35:54riding donkeys and she runs outside with her
- 35:58her uh house maid yes yeah and she's like get
- 36:03those donkeys out of here and she like shoos
- 36:06away the poor guy who like wrangles the donkeys
- 36:09it's so funny it's so funny she's like getting
- 36:12in the face of mrs murdstone and god I laughed
- 36:15so hard. Well, the comedy of that scene for me,
- 36:18and I agree with you, that got a huge laugh out
- 36:20of me. But the comedy that I really appreciated
- 36:22was that she just got done telling David, hey,
- 36:26your stepfather's coming. I'm sure it's not going
- 36:28to go extremely well, but we got to try and make
- 36:30the best of it, okay? And then she looks out
- 36:33the window and sees the donkeys. And it happens
- 36:36to be like his stepfather on the donkeys. But
- 36:39she's like... And she just sees Red, and she's
- 36:42like, get those donkeys out of here. And he's
- 36:45like, no, Aunt, that's my stepfather. That's
- 36:48Murdstone. She's like, I don't care. Get the
- 36:50donkeys out of here. And she just shoos them
- 36:52away. And afterwards, when they leave, I think
- 36:55he tries to say something. He's like, that was
- 36:57him. She's like, I don't care. The donkeys did
- 37:01not need to be on my lawn. And it was just so
- 37:03funny to hear her just say the donkeys over and
- 37:06over. But hearing her specifically be like, hey,
- 37:08we got to be on our best behavior. And then shooing
- 37:10the donkeys away was great. I love it too when
- 37:12they're arguing like, okay, David's coming with
- 37:16us. And she kind of goes around the room and
- 37:18she's like, okay, well, Mr. Murdstone, what do
- 37:20you have to say about this? And like he says
- 37:22his piece and she's like, interesting. Mrs. Murdstone?
- 37:25And like everybody goes around and she asked
- 37:28David. And then she even asks her roommate, right?
- 37:31Yeah. And he says, I think we should get David
- 37:35a new suit. And she stands up and she's like,
- 37:37I want to shake your hand. She's just so zany,
- 37:42I think. And it's one of the best qualities of
- 37:46this movie is that even some of the most influential
- 37:48characters in David's life are just bonkers and
- 37:52off the wall. Yeah. And I think one way we can
- 37:54tell that is that Murdstone's sister, I guess
- 37:58her name is also Murdstone. She is. really vicious
- 38:03throughout the majority of the movie but then
- 38:05when she meets aunt betsy uh she is kind of like
- 38:08it's almost like she's met her match yes because
- 38:10she'll be like well this was perfectly polite
- 38:12and she'll just say like kind of the nice or
- 38:14the right things but still with a kind of a tone
- 38:16and you can kind of see her being like oh no
- 38:19This woman could actually defeat us. Yeah. And
- 38:22I appreciated that because, again, it's a subtlety
- 38:24that you don't really like. You didn't expect
- 38:26to come from her. So I really appreciate all
- 38:29these roles. I mean, whether it be Edna May Oliver,
- 38:32Basil Rathbone, W .C. Fields, Lionel Barrymore
- 38:34as Dan Peckety. Yeah. You're right. It's a cast
- 38:36of characters and you're really interested in
- 38:38them. And there's something very infectious about
- 38:41that cast of characters when it's surrounded
- 38:43by a performance that you can really get behind,
- 38:46like Freddie Bartholomew. Right. And it's when
- 38:48Freddie Bartholomew ages out and goes to Frank
- 38:51Lawton as David the Man. I don't know why I had
- 38:55to look that up. David the Man. With the power.
- 38:58Specifically, when Frank Lawton comes on a screen,
- 39:01you're like, okay, well, at least I have these
- 39:03cast of characters to kind of like, you know,
- 39:04carry this with me. And they just aren't really
- 39:07as involved with each other anymore. It's more
- 39:10kind of a reunion tour where it's like, cool,
- 39:12now David the Man is going to go see this person.
- 39:15And now David the Man is going to see this person.
- 39:17And they aren't together. So the movie can't
- 39:18sing like that anymore. Right. So a movie that's
- 39:21already overly long feels even longer. And I
- 39:25just, I couldn't get behind it. And I was just
- 39:27kind of like, that's why I can barely even remember
- 39:29what you're citing about like going on a ship
- 39:31for like a rescue or searching for someone. Yeah.
- 39:33I don't remember. In what should be the most
- 39:35exciting part of this movie, that is such a snooze
- 39:38fest because you are kind of like, okay, but
- 39:41why is he doing this? Do I care? Who is he looking
- 39:44for? And I think it's, he's gone to look for
- 39:47Emily, his childhood friend who's like run away.
- 39:51And maybe, maybe something happened with like
- 39:54her suitor. The guy that gets, like, knocked
- 39:57off the boat. I really... cannot remember. It
- 40:00is so pointless to me. Well, and that's the frustrating
- 40:03thing, is that there's plenty of three -hour
- 40:05movies that you and I enjoy that I could watch
- 40:08from beginning to end, no problem, because it
- 40:09keeps you engaged throughout. And this just has
- 40:12a real problem of keeping and holding that engagement.
- 40:15So I would absolutely recommend watching this
- 40:17movie for the first 70 % of it, because I think
- 40:20Freddie Bartholomew is doing some great work.
- 40:22And if we can see Jackie Cooper nominated for
- 40:25Best Actor... Why aren't we seeing Freddie Bartholomew?
- 40:28I have some questions about that. What's up with
- 40:29that? That's when we need our juvenile award,
- 40:32I guess. A couple of other names I want to throw
- 40:35out here. You have Lewis Stone makes a return
- 40:37appearance here as Mr. Wickfield. Elsa Lanchester
- 40:41also returns in this movie, and she plays one
- 40:44of the, like, nannies of... Honestly, I don't
- 40:49remember if it's W .C. Fields' character or if
- 40:53it's Lionel... Barrymore's character. But she's
- 40:55very briefly in it, but she's her typical Elsa
- 40:58Lanchester self where she's kind of like all
- 41:01over the place and just trying to take care of
- 41:04these children. If you haven't listened to the
- 41:06Horror of the Overlooked episode this month,
- 41:08be sure to tune in because we spent a lot of
- 41:10time discussing Elsa Lanchester. Honestly, I
- 41:13think this year specifically, or this month specifically,
- 41:16we'll be talking a lot about the Lottons and
- 41:18Lanchesters. So that relationship is going to
- 41:21have a lot of coverage this month. Oh, I forgot
- 41:23they were married. Yeah. Yeah. That's exciting.
- 41:26The last one I want to bring up, though, is Roland
- 41:28Young, who plays Uriah Heep. And he's like the
- 41:32last character you're kind of introduced to.
- 41:35He's like the business partner of somebody. I've
- 41:39forgotten. But he's this weird, creepy guy that
- 41:44you think is going to be villainous, and then
- 41:46he's not. But then, oh, wait, he is and ends
- 41:48up being the final boss in David Copperfield's
- 41:51life. So talk me through, talk us through this
- 41:55final shot that really stuck with you. Okay,
- 41:59I have to remember who this guy is because it's
- 42:02so awkward and uncomfortable. Well, ultimately
- 42:05with Uriah, it's like David Copperfield goes
- 42:08off and lives his own life. He gets married too,
- 42:10but even that is kind of uninteresting. It's
- 42:13swept under the rug. Yeah, he's married to Marino
- 42:15Sullivan. Honestly, the thing that bothers me
- 42:18about that marriage is David Copperfield is kind
- 42:20of a jerk to his wife. Yeah. So I'm like, well,
- 42:23did you learn anything from all of your childhood
- 42:26trauma, my guy? And they're probably going to
- 42:28say, like, he's a jerk because of his childhood
- 42:30trauma. But you just don't see that forming as
- 42:32a child. No, you don't. You don't. But all of
- 42:34that happens. She dies. It's very sad. Anyway,
- 42:38you. He like returns back to a business partner
- 42:42and solves the mystery of where money's been
- 42:44vanishing off to with Uriah Heep. And then he
- 42:47marries or falls in love with his childhood love,
- 42:51Agnes. But the way the movie ends, it's what's
- 42:56her name? Aunt Betsy. Aunt Betsy like sees the
- 43:00two together, their romantic love interests.
- 43:02And she says something kind of cutesy to her
- 43:05roommate, Mr. Dick, played by Lennox Paul. who
- 43:08is just this very large man with kind of a baby
- 43:12face. Yeah. And the last frame of this coming
- 43:16-of -age epic film is him making the goofiest
- 43:20face. Did that resonate with you at all? It didn't,
- 43:25no. It kind of felt like if maybe they filmed
- 43:30the sunrise, but then the camera turned a little
- 43:32to the left, and it just captures Lennox Paul
- 43:35just... Smiling at the camera for no reason.
- 43:37It's like that TikTok where the woman's filming
- 43:41the sunset and turns and the guy just goes, hi.
- 43:43Yeah. Hi. Okay. Oh, okay. Yeah, that's what it
- 43:47is. I love that. It's so funny. It's such a funny
- 43:49video. You're right. I mean, it just, it feels
- 43:51so out of left field. And this is a movie called
- 43:55David Copperfield. It is about the character.
- 43:58Why are we ending it on kind of a joke? Like
- 44:02the cast of characters, not David in his life
- 44:05and not him being like, you know, I think things
- 44:07are going to be okay. It feels incomplete. And
- 44:10it just feels like it's 30 minutes too long,
- 44:12which it is. Yeah. But then they just don't know
- 44:15what to do with it. Yeah. And it's based on a
- 44:18novel. It's all in the text there. So it just
- 44:21feels like a huge mess. I want to read the last
- 44:23page of David Copperfield and just see if it
- 44:25says, and then Mr. Dick made the dumbest face
- 44:28ever. The end. I actually would appreciate this
- 44:31movie much more if that was the final page. If
- 44:33they were just like, we got to do it. I mean,
- 44:35it's right there in the text. They're actually
- 44:37trying not to and W .C. Fields has a gun. Yeah.
- 44:40He's like, actually? It's exactly as it says
- 44:43on the page. Guess what, fam? We're doing it.
- 44:44I didn't really mention this before. Not only
- 44:46was he a huge fan, he was actually technically
- 44:48a Dickens scholar in real life. So, I mean, it
- 44:52just makes sense that he would really want to
- 44:53do this. But a weird ending. It's so bizarre.
- 44:56And I think that's one of the biggest sins that
- 44:58we've found in these older films is so many of
- 45:02them just don't know how to end. And they'll
- 45:04kind of set up a... small build -up to the most
- 45:09impactful scene of the movie and then it'll just
- 45:11completely fade away and end with huh like a
- 45:16dumb joke which is what this is yeah it feels
- 45:19like it just it lost the plot that's the best
- 45:23way to put it yeah i feel like we were on track
- 45:25with this being pretty great Not as much. I didn't
- 45:28enjoy it as much as Les Mis, but I was enjoying
- 45:31it completely fine. And then I just lost all
- 45:34steam in it because the movie loses steam. So,
- 45:37again, it's an odd duck because it's not Franklin
- 45:41Lawton's fault. And like you said, it's probably
- 45:43not George Cukor's fault. But somewhere in the
- 45:46last 30, 25 minutes of this movie. it just loses
- 45:50all momentum that it had previously. It really
- 45:53does. Even with those characters returning and
- 45:55like some new characters, like you mentioned,
- 45:56who was the character that you mentioned? Who
- 45:59was a kind of villainous towards the end? Roland.
- 46:02Uriel. That was. Roland Young. Is that right?
- 46:05Yeah. Yeah. It's Roland Young. Crazy face to
- 46:07make looking for that. It like disappeared. So
- 46:10Roland Young, even him being introduced, it's
- 46:14not enough to make you very interested in what's
- 46:17to come. Yeah. I don't know. I feel like the
- 46:21comedy that comes from a lot of the characters
- 46:24when David is young makes sense because it's
- 46:27almost like you're viewing them from an exaggerated
- 46:29child's perspective. His point of view. Right.
- 46:32And once he becomes old and then you see that
- 46:35he meets his wife in Marino Sullivan and she's
- 46:38kind of just like, I feel like this is kind of
- 46:40rude to say, but she's like the most ditzy person.
- 46:45Ever. She can't cook and things. Man, David gets
- 46:47so mad at her for that. It really bothered me.
- 46:50But Roland Young is Uriel. He's like Igor slinking
- 46:54around. And just the way he talks, he's like,
- 46:56I run the books. But I run them well. And you're
- 47:01like, okay, sure, I'll believe you. Why not?
- 47:03You don't sound suspicious at all. Uriel. There's
- 47:06also a couple weird jokes that Mr. Dick makes
- 47:09that involve his name that I just had some concerns
- 47:13about. especially when he's making them to kind
- 47:15of a child. I don't know if you remember that.
- 47:17There's a couple, like one weird line. They were
- 47:21all weird to me, especially coming from him.
- 47:23Cause I was like, is that like 12 babies in a
- 47:26trench coat? But then the biggest baby of them
- 47:30all is the head. Yeah. Yeah. That makes sense.
- 47:32It was so strange. Honestly, I wasn't sure what
- 47:36was going on with Mr. Dick because it felt inappropriate.
- 47:39Isn't the right word. It kind of is, but it just
- 47:42kind of felt like, I don't know. Aunt Betsy was
- 47:44like, she doesn't say this, but it felt like
- 47:47David, welcome to my home. Uh, by the way, I
- 47:50found this guy outside on a street like 10 years
- 47:54ago. I haven't had the heart to kick him out
- 47:56yet. And that's just what it feels like is just
- 47:59like, we have this person in the house that is
- 48:01kind of ditzy and also kind of like unaware of
- 48:04what's happening at all times. But isn't that
- 48:07like childlike wonder that we want to have in
- 48:10the household? It just kind of feels like, I
- 48:12don't know, 180 on Aunt Betsy from the beginning
- 48:15where she's giving off like big Wicked Witch
- 48:18vibes of like, well, if it's not a daughter,
- 48:21I don't want it. And then leaving. And later
- 48:23on, she's like, get those donkeys off my lawn.
- 48:26She's like, girl, what's going on here? Yeah.
- 48:28I'm glad that she turned around, though, because
- 48:30she did end up being one of my favorite characters.
- 48:32I agree. No, I had a great time. I really liked
- 48:35her performance. I liked a lot of the performances.
- 48:38And I thought that the cast behind I guess the
- 48:42David, the child's story I thought was a lot
- 48:46of fun. And then beyond that, it just kind of
- 48:48felt like it lost the plot almost literally.
- 48:50Yeah, no, I agree. This is a good time for ratings.
- 48:53Actually. I think that the, the ensemble cast,
- 48:57this might be one of the best uses of that for
- 49:01me because all of the cast is so much fun and
- 49:04they're playing such unique characters. Even
- 49:05if all of them don't really work for me, like
- 49:08Mr. Dick or Uriel, there's so many. Just cool
- 49:12moments of either, oh, look, it's Elsa Lanchester
- 49:14or great performances like W .C. Fields. And
- 49:19who was the other one that I just praised like
- 49:21the entire time? Aunt Betsy. Yeah, I guess it
- 49:24was Aunt Betsy. That was Edna May Oliver. Yes.
- 49:28Like there's just some great ensemble cast pieces
- 49:32here. But I really, really as much as I enjoyed
- 49:36the first. quote unquote, half or 60, 70 % with
- 49:41Freddie Bartholomew, that last half, I dislike
- 49:44it just as much. So it set me to a kind of even
- 49:49two and a half stars. That's exactly where I
- 49:52land. I think you actually had three. I did give
- 49:54it three. Do you feel like it's closer to two
- 49:56and a half? No, I think I do want to give it
- 49:58three because I had fun with this movie, like
- 50:0170 % of this movie. I should feel the same way.
- 50:06But there's something to me that just feels so
- 50:08like we have we have ruined the goodwill that
- 50:11we built for the first part of this that I just
- 50:15it almost makes me kind of like it's like repugnant
- 50:18to me. Like, I just don't want to do it again.
- 50:19Sure. And that sucks because I did really enjoy
- 50:22Freddie Bartholomew's performance and the cast
- 50:25of characters behind him and the performance
- 50:27that he's giving. Again, it's not just like a
- 50:29comedy. It's the seeing the heartbreak in this
- 50:32kid's face and seeing him kind of handle all
- 50:34these things. I thought that that journey was
- 50:37really strong and then it just kind of goes into
- 50:39nothing. Yeah. And maybe that's a problem with
- 50:41the core text. I can't say I'm very familiar
- 50:42with it. Maybe it's a problem with the adaptation
- 50:45of that core text. I don't know. Sure. But it
- 50:48did just make it kind of feel like, oh man, that
- 50:51just soured my taste completely of it. So instead
- 50:54of going like kind of, you know, a little higher
- 50:56on the middle of the road with three stars. It's
- 50:58two and a half for me. I couldn't do it. I think
- 51:01a two and a half and a three brings it closer
- 51:02to what I think the true rating is of a 2 .75.
- 51:06Something right around there. I could live with
- 51:08that. It does feel like a bowl of ice cream that
- 51:10sat out too long. It's just like, oh, this looks
- 51:12great. And then by the end of it, you're like,
- 51:14what was that? Yeah, that's a great example because
- 51:17I think people are like, yeah, but it was still
- 51:19ice cream, right? And you're like, yeah, but
- 51:20not the way it's supposed to be. But now you
- 51:22need a straw, but not in the milkshake way. It's
- 51:25more just like a soup. Yeah, and now instead
- 51:28of using the spoon, I have to lift the bowl up
- 51:30to get the rest. It's too much work. Too much
- 51:32work. Too much work. That's exactly right. Too
- 51:34much work. You're having to put too much into
- 51:36the final end of it than you were for the first.
- 51:39Yeah. Great comparison. Wow, look at us. Look
- 51:42at us. We got there. So for double features.
- 51:44Double. I decided to instead focus on the part
- 51:47of this movie that I really enjoyed, which was
- 51:49the coming -of -age nature of David the Child.
- 51:53Kind of, you nailed it. The idea of like a point
- 51:55of view from this child's, you know, perspective.
- 51:59You see the adults and you see like the communication
- 52:02between that character and these other casts
- 52:06of characters around them through their perspective.
- 52:08And it feels very kind of whimsical and airy
- 52:12and maybe like surreal to a degree. And that
- 52:16really made me think of the 1996 Danny DeVito
- 52:18film Matilda. Oh, Matilda. Okay. While there's
- 52:23not any of the telekinesis in Matilda as there
- 52:27is in David Copperfield, I felt like a lot of
- 52:30the characters, Trench Bull, Miss Honey, her
- 52:34parents, very much was a echo of what we saw
- 52:38here with Aunt Betsy and Macabre and Peggedy
- 52:44and Dan Peggedy and Mr. Dick. All those characters
- 52:48just kind of felt like... Rather, they became
- 52:51echoes into something like Matilda. Yeah. So
- 52:54I really liked that aspect. I decided to lean
- 52:57into that rather than focus on what I didn't
- 52:59appreciate about the end. I think that's great
- 53:01because I think all of those characters are zany
- 53:04while still working. You know, they never feel
- 53:07out of place while some of the characters in
- 53:10David Copperfield do. But yeah, that's I like
- 53:14it. Maybe the issue with. rather my issue with
- 53:18david copperfield the movie is with matilda it
- 53:21felt like dan devito leaned into kind of like
- 53:23the manic nature of like what this must seem
- 53:26like to a kid versus like what's actually happening
- 53:29And maybe that's what the kind of direction that
- 53:31David Copperfield needed. Was it needed something
- 53:33that kind of matched that point of view from
- 53:36David rather than like, well, this is what's
- 53:39really happening. And David can kind of like
- 53:41perceive that a certain way or maybe not. But
- 53:43this is what's really happening. Maybe we needed
- 53:45more of like insight into that perspective than
- 53:48just a report. Yeah. And that's what it felt
- 53:50like. It was a report. Yeah, it does feel like
- 53:53a report. You're right. That's how I put it.
- 53:55What do you have? I went with a. Film that covers
- 54:00like the beginning of one man's life, ultimately
- 54:04to the end. So it goes a little bit further than
- 54:05David's does. But he meets a slew of just bizarre
- 54:11characters as well. I keep saying slew. Is that
- 54:13even how you use that word? I have not picked
- 54:15up on it, but yeah. Okay. I hope that's how you
- 54:17use it. Cool. Perfect. And I was so worried because
- 54:20I feel like I've recommended this before, but
- 54:22I went with Tim Burton's Big Fish. Oh. love that
- 54:26movie yeah and albert finney is giving big um
- 54:29i don't mean it this way but he's giving off
- 54:31the mr dick vibes who who does he play again
- 54:35albert finney yeah uh he is uh ewan mcgregor's
- 54:39he's the old oh he's the old yeah i thought that's
- 54:42who it was but i didn't understand the comparison
- 54:44oh because they both look like big babies oh
- 54:47yeah okay you're right fair play yeah but this
- 54:51is this is Really, I think Tim Burton kind of
- 54:54at his best. I agree with you. Yeah. Well, I
- 54:57mostly agree with you. I'm a big, like, peewees,
- 55:00big adventurer. Right. But yes. I think it's
- 55:03his. It's modern. Perfect. Yes. Tim Burton. Yeah,
- 55:06yeah. I think it's almost his best storytelling,
- 55:09though. I agree. Because there's so many sequences
- 55:12in this movie. Again, you have Ewan McGregor,
- 55:15like. Learning about how he dies from like a
- 55:19psychic or something in the movie and then that
- 55:21becoming a huge plot point. And I love when he
- 55:25meets or when he goes outside of the love interest's
- 55:28window and he has all the daffodils. I get so
- 55:31like sappy romantic. And then the slow time slows
- 55:36down for everyone but them. Yeah. When they meet.
- 55:39Yeah. It's good. You know what we did accidentally?
- 55:42What we do? We did a Danny DeVito double feature,
- 55:44baby. Oh my goodness, you're right. He's the
- 55:46ringleader. He sure is. He's like a werewolf
- 55:48in that movie, isn't he? Yeah. Yeah. I think
- 55:51I have to go and re -watch this movie now. I'm
- 55:53forgetting that. I'm definitely remembering the
- 55:55giant man in the circus, but I don't necessarily
- 55:59remember Danny DeVito the werewolf. I think he's
- 56:01a werewolf, yeah. Steve Buscemi is in this movie.
- 56:04I think I need to go and re -watch this immediately.
- 56:05It's a good movie. I haven't seen it in so long,
- 56:08but I love it. Yeah, I used to watch it all the
- 56:10time. And Jessica Lange is in it, and she has
- 56:12a very soft spot in my heart. You have a soft
- 56:17spot in your heart for her. She doesn't have
- 56:18a soft spot. Not that she knows about. No, not
- 56:21yet. Call me, Jessica. If there's two people
- 56:25we know aren't listening to this podcast. David
- 56:28Copperfield and Jessica Lange. Maybe one day.
- 56:31The magician, we should specify. The real David
- 56:34Copperfield is probably like, I had a hard beginning,
- 56:37and you guys should appreciate the end of my
- 56:39life. Well, he's dead, so. Oh, R .I .P. Hey.
- 56:43Loved your double feature. Hey, I loved your
- 56:44double feature. And I love that we both watched
- 56:47David Copperfield and we were like, Danny DeVito.
- 56:51That'll do it. That'll do it. That makes some
- 56:53sense. As you mentioned, we did just have our
- 56:56Horror of the Overlooked episode, so feel free
- 56:58to double back and check that out. Yeah. One
- 57:02thing that we're doing is we are, you know what,
- 57:04we'll talk about it in that episode, but kind
- 57:06of an interesting thing where the coverage of
- 57:071935 is both in July and August, in which the
- 57:1013th falls on. Yeah. So you'll see two episodes
- 57:13for Horror of the Overlooked for 1935. But, you
- 57:17know, we'll get into that. Yeah. This last episode
- 57:20was a special covering The Bride of Frankenstein.
- 57:22Which, great movie. Feel free to go back and
- 57:24check out because we had a lot of fun talking
- 57:26about it. Yeah, absolutely. Before I forget as
- 57:29well, David Copperfield is available on physical
- 57:32media. There are a couple different versions
- 57:33of the DVD, including a Warner Archive copy.
- 57:37So check that out. The next episode we'll be
- 57:40covering is Ruggles of Red Gap and the return
- 57:43of Charles Lawton, who's just like... And not
- 57:46even for the last time. No. He just keeps coming.
- 57:48Of this year, that is. Yeah. But... He's going
- 57:52to be around for a long time. Yeah. If you have
- 57:54any thoughts about David Copperfield, the book,
- 57:57the movie, the magician, anything at all, shoot
- 58:00us an email at OUTAOPodcast at gmail .com. And
- 58:04if you want access to the Horror of the Overlooked
- 58:06podcast or any of the other cool perks we have,
- 58:08check out patreon .com slash OUTAOPodcast. And
- 58:12stay tuned for more movies of the eighth Academy
- 58:15year. Anything else? No, that sounds about right.
- 58:18Perfect. We'll wrap it up where we should, unlike
- 58:21David Copperfield. Nailed it. Thank you guys
- 58:24for listening. As always, I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan.
- 58:26And we'll see you at the movies.