Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Judge Rakoff Makes A Ruling On Unsealed Exhibits In The USVI/JP Morgan/Survivor Lawsuit (Part 2)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up everyone, and welcome back to the Epstein Chronicles.
- 0:03Speaker 1: In this episode, we're picking up where we left off
- 0:06Speaker 1: with the Judge Rakoff opinion and Order two First Amendment
- 0:11Speaker 1: right of access. Even where an item qualifies as a
- 0:15Speaker 1: judicial document, the First Amendment right of access attaches only
- 0:19Speaker 1: where the document satisfies at least one of two tests.
- 0:22Speaker 1: Under the first test, the right attaches to judicial documents
- 0:26Speaker 1: that have historically been opened to the press and general public,
- 0:30Speaker 1: and to which public access plays a significant positive role
- 0:33Speaker 1: in the functioning of the particular process in question Lugosh
- 0:37Speaker 1: four to thirty five ft three d At one twenty.
- 0:40Speaker 1: Under the second test, the right attaches if the documents
- 0:43Speaker 1: are derived from or are a necessary corollary of the
- 0:47Speaker 1: public capacity to attend the relevant proceedings. In the first
- 0:52Speaker 1: Amendment right applies, it does so with the highest weight
- 0:55Speaker 1: possible in sealing. The documents can only be justified with
- 0:58Speaker 1: specific on the record findings that sealing is necessary to
- 1:02Speaker 1: preserve higher values and is narrowly tailored to achieve that aim.
- 1:07Speaker 1: Applying either test, the Second Circuit has held that there
- 1:10Speaker 1: exists a qualified First Amendment right of access to documents
- 1:13Speaker 1: submitted to the court in connection with the sum rejudgment. However,
- 1:18Speaker 1: neither the Second Circuit nor any district court in the
- 1:21Speaker 1: Circuit has addressed whether the First Amendment right continues to
- 1:24Speaker 1: apply when a s rejudgment motion is mooted by settlement.
- 1:28Speaker 1: But as mentioned above, the Fourth Circuit has recently addressed
- 1:31Speaker 1: the question, ruling that First Amendment right does apply regardless
- 1:35Speaker 1: of the settlement ce Nell Net. One oh five four
- 1:39Speaker 1: Fourth at one seventy three. The Core finds the Fourth
- 1:42Speaker 1: Circuit's reasoning persuasive and in line with the Second Circuit precedent.
- 1:46Speaker 1: According to the Fourth Circuit, the First Amendment right of
- 1:49Speaker 1: access to some rejudgment materials does not depend on judicial
- 1:53Speaker 1: resolution of the sum rejudgment motion or judicial reliance on
- 1:57Speaker 1: the documents in resolving the motion Idea at one seventy two.
- 2:02Speaker 1: This is because the public has an interest in ensuring
- 2:05Speaker 1: basic fairness and deterring official misconduct, not only in the
- 2:08Speaker 1: outcome of certain proceedings, but also in the very precedings themselves.
- 2:13Speaker 1: For some cases that settle, it's up to the public
- 2:16Speaker 1: to decide why the case was brought and fought and
- 2:19Speaker 1: what exactly was at stake in it, including the question
- 2:22Speaker 1: of why the case was settled Idea at one seventy three. Thus,
- 2:27Speaker 1: access to filings attached to mooted motions satisfy the second
- 2:31Speaker 1: test for the First Amendment as a necessary corollary of
- 2:34Speaker 1: the right to attend protected proceedings. This position is consistent
- 2:38Speaker 1: with reasoning adopted by the Second Circuit. The Second Circuit
- 2:41Speaker 1: has suggested that some rejudgment is an adjudication, and an
- 2:45Speaker 1: adjudication is a formal act of government, the basis of
- 2:49Speaker 1: which should, absent exceptional circumstances, be subject to public scrutiny.
- 2:53Speaker 1: Since nothing about the timing of the ruling on some
- 2:56Speaker 1: rejudgment is relevant to whether the First Amendment right applies,
- 3:00Speaker 1: it is apparent that the First Amendment right attaches immediately
- 3:04Speaker 1: upon the filing of submarine judgment papers. See also Lugosh
- 3:08Speaker 1: four to thirty five ft three d At one twenty two.
- 3:12Speaker 1: Relevant documents which are submitted to and accepted by a
- 3:15Speaker 1: court of competent jurisdiction in the course of adjudicatory proceedings
- 3:20Speaker 1: become documents to which the presumption of public access applies,
- 3:24Speaker 1: a framing that has nothing to do with how court
- 3:26Speaker 1: ultimately comes out on a motion. The Second Circuit's rule
- 3:30Speaker 1: in Bernstein also weighs in favor of findings that the
- 3:33Speaker 1: First Amendment right of access applies here. Pleadings in settle
- 3:37Speaker 1: cases allow the public to understand the activity of the
- 3:40Speaker 1: federal courts, enhance the court system's accountability and legitimacy, and
- 3:45Speaker 1: inform the public of matters of public concern Bernstein, eight
- 3:49Speaker 1: fourteen f. Dot three d at one forty one. Conversely,
- 3:53Speaker 1: a sealed complaint leaves the public unaware that a claim
- 3:55Speaker 1: has been leveled and that a state power has been
- 3:58Speaker 1: invoked in public resources spent in an effort to resolve
- 4:01Speaker 1: the dispute. Since the district courts routinely engage and in
- 4:05Speaker 1: judicatory duties even in connection with complaints that are dismissed
- 4:09Speaker 1: or settled, a public right of access to monitor courts
- 4:12Speaker 1: is warranted even where speedy settlement of the claim means
- 4:15Speaker 1: that the court will not adjudicate the merits of the case.
- 4:19Speaker 1: The same broad rationales applied a mooted some rejudgment motions.
- 4:23Speaker 1: Public access to documents. Attaches to such motions allow for
- 4:27Speaker 1: a better understanding of the courts, improving public perception and legitimacy,
- 4:31Speaker 1: and informing the public of matters of concern, including how
- 4:35Speaker 1: public resources are being spent. These documents may also help
- 4:39Speaker 1: the public to understand why and how settlement was reached.
- 4:42Speaker 1: For example, a party's review of its adversaries collected evidence
- 4:46Speaker 1: and arguments after discovery may be sufficient incentive to force settlement. Finally,
- 4:52Speaker 1: the analogy between trial and some rejudgment adjudication helps to
- 4:56Speaker 1: understand why the presumption applies regardless of settlement. The First
- 5:00Speaker 1: Amendment right of access to judicial documents is derived from
- 5:03Speaker 1: a necessary corollary of the capacity to attend the relevant proceedings.
- 5:08Speaker 1: Where no hearing is held, as is the case for
- 5:10Speaker 1: some rejudgment, access to written documents filed in connection with
- 5:13Speaker 1: pre trial motions is particularly important since the public otherwise
- 5:18Speaker 1: lacks any ability to monitor court activity. If a case
- 5:22Speaker 1: settles in the midst of trial, all exhibits introduced to
- 5:25Speaker 1: that point would remain in the public record, regardless of
- 5:28Speaker 1: that fact. A some rejudgment motion is an alternative to
- 5:32Speaker 1: a resolution at trial, and so the fact that a
- 5:34Speaker 1: settlement makes such a motion moot similarly should not affect
- 5:38Speaker 1: the public's right of access to exhibits that have already
- 5:41Speaker 1: been filed for the aforementioned reasons, the Court finds the
- 5:45Speaker 1: First Amendment right of access to apply to some rejudgment filings,
- 5:49Speaker 1: regardless of whether the motion was mooted by settlement. Because
- 5:53Speaker 1: the Court finds the First Amendment right attaches, it need
- 5:56Speaker 1: not consider the weight of any common law right of
- 5:59Speaker 1: access to these documents three countervailing interests to the First
- 6:04Speaker 1: Amendment right. Since the First Amendment right applies to the
- 6:08Speaker 1: three exhibits attached to the summary judgment motions, sealing these
- 6:11Speaker 1: excerpts can only be justified with specific on the record
- 6:15Speaker 1: findings that sealing is necessary to preserve higher values and
- 6:19Speaker 1: is narrowly tailored to achieve that aim. The privacy interests
- 6:22Speaker 1: of those who resist disclosures are one such higher value.
- 6:26Speaker 1: Both Staley and Doe assert privacy interests. Staley argues his
- 6:30Speaker 1: interest is in keeping Doe's false and uncontested testimony confidential,
- 6:34Speaker 1: since unsealing the excerpts would not allow him any fair
- 6:37Speaker 1: opportunity to respond to any accusations contained therein Staley Opposition
- 6:43Speaker 1: Docket two ninety three f. Four. For her part, dou
- 6:46Speaker 1: argues that her identity as a survivor of sexual assault,
- 6:49Speaker 1: as well as a related psychological and emotional well being,
- 6:53Speaker 1: overcome the First Amendment presumption of access. Upon particularized review
- 6:58Speaker 1: of the excerpted testimony in the exhibits, the Court finds
- 7:01Speaker 1: these interests outweigh of the public right to access the
- 7:04Speaker 1: documents in their entirety. Those privacy interests, by itself warrants
- 7:09Speaker 1: complete sealing of the three exhibits. In determining the weight
- 7:13Speaker 1: to be accorded an assertion of right of privacy, court
- 7:16Speaker 1: should first consider the degree to which the subject matter
- 7:19Speaker 1: is traditionally considered private rather than public. The nature and
- 7:24Speaker 1: degree of injury must also be weighed. This will entail
- 7:28Speaker 1: consideration of the sensitivity of the information and the subject
- 7:32Speaker 1: amideoh two seventy one Ft three D ten fifty one.
- 7:37Speaker 1: Protecting the identity of sexual assault survivors and the details
- 7:40Speaker 1: of their assaults is traditionally considered a private and has
- 7:43Speaker 1: been widely recognized as a compelling reason to limit public
- 7:46Speaker 1: access to judicial documents. Countervailing interests are particularly acute given
- 7:51Speaker 1: that the psychological and emotional well being of survivors of
- 7:54Speaker 1: alleged sexual assaults may be implicated by such a broad
- 7:57Speaker 1: disclosure Given the specific graphic detail of the alleged non
- 8:01Speaker 1: consensual activity that Dough describes in these excerpts, the privacy
- 8:06Speaker 1: interest Doe has in non disclosure of her testimony is
- 8:08Speaker 1: robust on Sealing these documents would force Doe to relive
- 8:13Speaker 1: these traumatic moments from her deposition publicly, and that the
- 8:16Speaker 1: mere redaction of her name would not protect her from retraumatization. Moreover,
- 8:22Speaker 1: Doe's basic accusation that she was sexually assaulted by Staley
- 8:26Speaker 1: is already in the public record, as is Staley's denial.
- 8:29Speaker 1: The further information contained in the excerpts serves little value
- 8:33Speaker 1: aside from catering to a morbid craving for that which
- 8:36Speaker 1: is sensational and impure to which courts have long declined
- 8:40Speaker 1: to allow public access. Nor would target redactions of identifying
- 8:44Speaker 1: information rather than wholesale withholding suffice as a narrowly tailored
- 8:48Speaker 1: means to serving Doe's privacy interest. As the time suggests,
- 8:53Speaker 1: the Court has reviewed the relevant excerpts and finds that
- 8:56Speaker 1: the extent of redactions needed to protect those relevant privacy
- 8:59Speaker 1: interests would render that remains of little value. Where privacy
- 9:04Speaker 1: interests require reed actions so systematic that unsealing a document
- 9:08Speaker 1: is more likely to mislead than inform the public, As
- 9:12Speaker 1: would be the case here, sealing the entire document is
- 9:15Speaker 1: the more appropriate course, even assuming arguendo that those interests
- 9:20Speaker 1: are not independently sufficient to overcome the First Amendment right
- 9:23Speaker 1: of access. Staley's privacy interests are also compelling and would,
- 9:28Speaker 1: alongside those interests jointly warrant keeping the exhibits under seal.
- 9:33Speaker 1: When determining the weight of an individual's privacy interest, the
- 9:36Speaker 1: court should consider the reliability of the information. Raw unverified
- 9:40Speaker 1: information should not be as readily disclosed as matters that
- 9:44Speaker 1: are verified. Similarly, a court may consider whether the nature
- 9:48Speaker 1: of the materials is such that there is a fair
- 9:50Speaker 1: opportunity for the subject to respond to any accusations contained therein.
- 9:55Speaker 1: These considerations clearly militate against disclosure. Here is Staley points
- 10:00Speaker 1: out the deposition testimony was taken before he was even
- 10:03Speaker 1: made a party to the case, so his counsel never
- 10:06Speaker 1: had the opportunity to cross examine Doe about her claims. Indeed,
- 10:10Speaker 1: a deposition of Doe by Staley's council had been scheduled
- 10:14Speaker 1: at the time the case settled. Two Thus, the unsealing
- 10:17Speaker 1: her deposition would leave Staley devoid of any opportunity to
- 10:21Speaker 1: respond to any allegations contained therein. The Times contends that
- 10:25Speaker 1: Staley is not an innocent third party who somehow finds
- 10:28Speaker 1: himself caught up in a civil case in which he
- 10:31Speaker 1: has no real interest in the outcome. This argument, however,
- 10:35Speaker 1: ignores the fact that Doe never brought any claim against Staley,
- 10:38Speaker 1: and that Staley was only brought into the case via
- 10:40Speaker 1: third party complaint filed by JP Morgan. Indeed, Doe's original
- 10:45Speaker 1: complaint did not even identify Staley by name. The Times
- 10:49Speaker 1: also argues that Staley's interest against public disclosure of untested
- 10:52Speaker 1: allegations is not cognizable, because if it were, no complaint
- 10:56Speaker 1: ever filed in a civil case would be public unless
- 11:00Speaker 1: object to subsequent testing. But any allegation in a complaint
- 11:03Speaker 1: are by their nature untested, and so will be taken
- 11:07Speaker 1: as such by any reader. By contrast, untested deposition testimony
- 11:11Speaker 1: is a much more serious matter, with potentially more far
- 11:15Speaker 1: ranging consequences, and of course such untested testimony will remain
- 11:19Speaker 1: under seal only in the unusual instance such as that here,
- 11:23Speaker 1: where the matter is discussed in the testimony are particularly sensitive. Finally,
- 11:28Speaker 1: even if arguably Stalely's professed interests or insufficient standing alone
- 11:32Speaker 1: to preclude disclosure, his interests, when combined with the interest
- 11:36Speaker 1: of Doe, provides more than adequate basis to keep the
- 11:39Speaker 1: transcripts under seal B exhibits attached to the motion for
- 11:44Speaker 1: class certification. With respect to the two exhibits filed with
- 11:48Speaker 1: the motion for class certification which do not involve Staley,
- 11:51Speaker 1: Dough does not dispute their status as judicial documents, given
- 11:55Speaker 1: that the Court in fact ruled on the class certification motion.
- 11:59Speaker 1: Lord does d dispute that a First Amendment right of
- 12:02Speaker 1: access and or the common law presumption of access attached. Rather,
- 12:07Speaker 1: Doe argues that her privacy interests in maintaining the secrecy
- 12:10Speaker 1: of her identity warrants against disclosure. While the Court agrees
- 12:14Speaker 1: Doe has a privacy interest in connection with these transcripts,
- 12:18Speaker 1: the interest is less expansive than that in sealing the
- 12:21Speaker 1: summary judgment transcripts. Unlike the transcripts filed with Emotions for
- 12:25Speaker 1: some rejudgment that contain lurid descriptions of dose alleged non
- 12:29Speaker 1: consensual sexual relations with Staley, the transcripts that were filed
- 12:34Speaker 1: with the party's class certification briefing contain much more mundane
- 12:38Speaker 1: descriptions of Doe's recruitment by Epstein. There is much less concern,
- 12:43Speaker 1: if any, about disclosing intimate details of traumatic events. Further,
- 12:48Speaker 1: whereas the public interest in viewing the summary judgment transcripts
- 12:52Speaker 1: is nothing more than a morbid craving for that which
- 12:55Speaker 1: is sensational and impure, the public's interest in viewing the
- 12:58Speaker 1: class certification transcript extends to the reasonable desire to understand
- 13:03Speaker 1: how Epstein's organization operated and recruited victims. Ultimately, the Court
- 13:07Speaker 1: agrees that those interests in maintaining the secrecy of her
- 13:10Speaker 1: identity overcomes the First Amendment and common law presumption of access,
- 13:15Speaker 1: but the Court also finds that this interest does not
- 13:18Speaker 1: require complete ceiling of the excerpts. Rather, the Court finds
- 13:22Speaker 1: that redactions are capable of preserving those anonymity while still
- 13:26Speaker 1: leaving sufficient relevant material so as to not be misleading.
- 13:30Speaker 1: Class Council argues that merely redacting the Jane Doe one's
- 13:34Speaker 1: name is not sufficient to protect her identity or privacy interests,
- 13:38Speaker 1: because the excerpts contain intimate details about Jane Doe one's
- 13:41Speaker 1: life that are specific to her and whose publication would
- 13:45Speaker 1: reveal her identity to the public and to those who
- 13:48Speaker 1: harmed her, who she fears might retaliate against her. The
- 13:51Speaker 1: Court agrees that it's appropriate to redact more than simply
- 13:54Speaker 1: those names from the transcripts, and that other information that
- 13:57Speaker 1: might be used to identify her, such as the location
- 14:00Speaker 1: where Dough lived, should also be redacted. Similarly, portions of
- 14:04Speaker 1: the transcripts that could be used to identify other victims
- 14:08Speaker 1: should be redacted as well, but that still leaves much
- 14:11Speaker 1: non identifying information that can be unsealed. Three conclusion. For
- 14:17Speaker 1: the reasons set forth above, the Court grants in part
- 14:20Speaker 1: and denies in part the times motion to unseal. Specifically,
- 14:23Speaker 1: the motion to unseal the exhibits submitted with the summary
- 14:26Speaker 1: judgment motions is denied, but the motion to unseal the
- 14:29Speaker 1: exhibits submitted with the motion for class certification is granted,
- 14:33Speaker 1: subject to redactions. To preserve the anonymity of Doe and
- 14:37Speaker 1: other victims. Class Council is directed to, within two weeks
- 14:41Speaker 1: of the date of this opinion submit for the Court
- 14:44Speaker 1: in camera review proposed redactions of the relevant class certification
- 14:48Speaker 1: transcripts that are consistent with this opinion, so ordered July
- 14:53Speaker 1: twenty ninth, twenty twenty four, and this was signed by
- 14:57Speaker 1: Judge Raykoff. All of the information that goes with this
- 15:00Speaker 1: episode can be found in the description box.