Latest / AV SuperFriends / AV SuperFriends: Off the Rails - Forty-hundred-thousand
Transcript
- 0:07This is AV Superfriends Off the Rails,
- 0:10an almost regularly scheduled open
- 0:12discussion on audio and video in higher
- 0:14education.
- 0:15We'll sound off about our most brilliant
- 0:16ideas, our dumbest mistakes,
- 0:18and everything in between.
- 0:19And because this conversation will almost
- 0:21certainly go off the rails at some point,
- 0:23we'll end up covering just about
- 0:24everything else.
- 0:25And now, the AV Superfriends.
- 0:31For September fourth, twenty twenty six,
- 0:33it's the best sounding and most overly
- 0:35warm podcast in higher ed.
- 0:36This is the super friends off the rails.
- 0:39Episode number one hundred and forty five.
- 0:41That's a lot of them.
- 0:43Suffering through a late summer heat wave
- 0:45and broadcasting live across three time
- 0:47zones from coast to coast,
- 0:48the sidewalks are shimmering,
- 0:49the classrooms are packed,
- 0:51and every campus help desk staffer is
- 0:53already reconsidering their life choices.
- 0:56I'm your overheated host with the most,
- 0:57Chris Dechter,
- 0:58and you're tuned in for another Friday
- 0:59afternoon podcast adventure.
- 1:01And let's say hello to this August,
- 1:03no pun intended, this August,
- 1:04this September panel of AV Super Friends.
- 1:07Oops, where am I going here?
- 1:09Why's it not firing?
- 1:11Oh, helps if I hit the right key.
- 1:13Our first panel ensures AV and IT systems
- 1:16remain fully operational during that
- 1:17magical late summertime when every room is
- 1:19occupied, every project is late,
- 1:21and the HVAC has simply given up.
- 1:23He's a senior seasonal infrastructure
- 1:26readiness engineer from Kansas City.
- 1:28Say hello to Mr. Jamie Reinhart.
- 1:30I find when the AC gives out,
- 1:31just soak it with a good soaking of
- 1:33water.
- 1:33It cools it right off.
- 1:36And then it turns off.
- 1:37That's great.
- 1:38Problem solved.
- 1:39Our next panelist develops strategies for
- 1:41maintaining uptime while classroom racks
- 1:43begin functioning as supplemental building
- 1:45heat.
- 1:45He's a director of ambient technology
- 1:47resilience from Corvallis, Oregon.
- 1:48Say hello to Mr. Mark Kolozinski.
- 1:50If we just hold it up high enough,
- 1:52we can measure and see how long we
- 1:57can hold that thing up.
- 1:59Our next panelist serves as the primary
- 2:00liaison whenever a support ticket starts
- 2:02with the projector is overheating and ends
- 2:04with also it's eighty four degrees in
- 2:06here.
- 2:06He's a learning environments climate
- 2:08escalation coordinator from Greensboro,
- 2:09North Carolina.
- 2:10Say hello to Mr. Larry Darling.
- 2:12Oddly enough,
- 2:13I'm in a new office space today,
- 2:15and when I came in,
- 2:16it was seventy-eight degrees in my office.
- 2:18But it wasn't eighty-four.
- 2:19It's not eighty-four.
- 2:20It's not eighty-four.
- 2:21It's not, but it's getting there.
- 2:22Put a projector in there, it'll get there.
- 2:25Mark has a bunch of hot gear he
- 2:26can put in there.
- 2:27What would you like?
- 2:29And our final panelist provides executive
- 2:32oversight for classroom technology systems
- 2:34operating somewhere between within spec
- 2:36and too hot to handle.
- 2:38too cold to hold.
- 2:40He's a vice president of thermal learning
- 2:41environments from Bowling Green, Kentucky,
- 2:43Salem, Mr. Justin Rexing.
- 2:45All these titles sound like we just take
- 2:47a request and send it to facilities and
- 2:50then facility sits on it and waits till
- 2:52winter.
- 2:53I'm going to you're not the vice president
- 2:55of facilities ticket handoff coordination.
- 2:58I'm pretty sure at this part of the
- 2:59year,
- 3:00any like
- 3:01Heat-related incident tickets,
- 3:03that's a problem for next spring.
- 3:04That's not now.
- 3:06Well, we haven't done the changeover yet.
- 3:08We're just going to have to wait.
- 3:11And, you know,
- 3:12fall will be here before you know it.
- 3:13Just deal with the ninety-five degree heat
- 3:17in your office.
- 3:18Everything's going to be fine.
- 3:19Fall will be here before you know it.
- 3:21I love it.
- 3:22You think we have control over these
- 3:24things?
- 3:24We don't.
- 3:27It's the billing automation stuff.
- 3:29They're a little sour.
- 3:31Their own version of the network.
- 3:32It's like,
- 3:32we don't even know how to get into
- 3:33that stuff.
- 3:34It's BACnet or something.
- 3:38We don't have the login.
- 3:38We haven't had it since we took it.
- 3:39Justin, just put that ticket aside.
- 3:40You wait like two months.
- 3:41You come back and say, yeah,
- 3:42I'm here to make your office cooler,
- 3:44but it seems to be awful cold in
- 3:45here right now.
- 3:45Yeah,
- 3:46we're going to close this ticket now since
- 3:50it seems fine in here now.
- 3:51Open window, shut closed ticket.
- 3:53Yeah.
- 3:54Anyway, HVAC discussions aside,
- 3:57on today's show,
- 3:58we're going to discuss assembling a
- 3:59flexible kit of parts for your entire
- 4:02campus.
- 4:04Again.
- 4:05Again, but it's been a while.
- 4:07And we'll talk about taking ownership of
- 4:09stuff that you really don't do but kind
- 4:11of have to anyway.
- 4:13But first.
- 4:13What do you?
- 4:15But do you?
- 4:15What?
- 4:16Maybe.
- 4:17Hold on.
- 4:17It's called accountability, Justin.
- 4:18You're going to love it.
- 4:19Here we go.
- 4:21But first, some housekeeping.
- 4:24If you're listening to this as recorded MP
- 4:26three,
- 4:26we stream live on Fridays at about three
- 4:27fifteen eastern twelve fifteen Pacific or
- 4:28whenever Jamie finally makes it in from
- 4:30the parking lot after crossing six acres
- 4:32of sun baked asphalt.
- 4:33You can join us for that live on
- 4:34Twitter, LinkedIn,
- 4:35YouTube and all that fun stuff.
- 4:37If you can't join us live,
- 4:37we want you to we want you to
- 4:38connect with us live on the connect with
- 4:39us on the socials.
- 4:40You can follow us on Twitter at ABC
- 4:42for Friends, LinkedIn at ABC for Friends.
- 4:45YouTube at ABC for Friends,
- 4:46and Blue Sky at
- 4:47justinsfantasticveganrecipes.com.
- 4:49I'm sorry, at ABC for Friends.
- 4:53Please don't forget this.
- 4:54Oh, please tell me that's real.
- 4:55I don't know, but go register quick.
- 4:56It is now.
- 4:56It is now.
- 4:59Please don't forget to spread the word.
- 5:00Share this podcast with your friends,
- 5:02colleagues, enemies, exhausted faculty,
- 5:03sweaty AV technicians,
- 5:04and the student who already submitted a
- 5:05ticket because the classroom is, quote,
- 5:07too hot,
- 5:07even though we have absolutely nothing to
- 5:09do with the HVAC,
- 5:10but he's in the classroom space, so yeah.
- 5:12If you could chase people down across the
- 5:14quad with a Bluetooth speaker blasting old
- 5:16episodes while the heat index approaches
- 5:18triple digits, even better.
- 5:20If you want to support the show,
- 5:20please consider donating.
- 5:21Your contributions help us to keep
- 5:23bringing you the honest content that you
- 5:24love or love to hate and may eventually
- 5:25allow us to purchase one of those enormous
- 5:27industrial fans they use on the football
- 5:28sidelines.
- 5:29You can find the donation link for that.
- 5:31The mister.
- 5:32We need more money if we want the
- 5:33misters.
- 5:34Or the mister misters,
- 5:35which are my favorite ones from the
- 5:36eighties.
- 5:37You can find the donation link for the
- 5:38show in the show notes or at our
- 5:41website at avsuperfriends.com.
- 5:43Finally, if you have questions, comments,
- 5:45complaints, corrections, topic ideas,
- 5:46or just want to tell us about the
- 5:47classroom that worked perfectly all summer
- 5:49until eight oh one AM on the first
- 5:51day of classes,
- 5:52Please send them our way.
- 5:53Use Mailbag at ABC for Friends or ping
- 5:54us on the socials for that.
- 5:56We're a few weeks into the semester now.
- 5:57The campus is packed.
- 5:58Every room is booked and every support
- 5:59queue is full.
- 6:00And somehow it is still offensively hot
- 6:02outside.
- 6:03Fall is here, meteorologically anyway.
- 6:06It's not hot here.
- 6:09So thanks for your support.
- 6:10We could not do this show without you.
- 6:13Well, then.
- 6:14Yes.
- 6:15Speaking of that hot thing,
- 6:16our football team is traveling,
- 6:18and they had cooling trucks being brought
- 6:21in for the game.
- 6:22I think they're down in, like,
- 6:22Houston area or something like that.
- 6:23What's a cooling truck?
- 6:24I don't know.
- 6:25I'm like, is that just a meat truck?
- 6:26It's like one of those things that you
- 6:27keep ice on or meat, like a meat.
- 6:32They're just like walking them through
- 6:33that in this truck.
- 6:34I don't know.
- 6:35I'm pretty sure it's,
- 6:37it's a giant air conditioner that just
- 6:38blows air conditioned air across the
- 6:40outside.
- 6:41It's a pretty damn big space to be
- 6:42chilling down.
- 6:43That's why it's truck marked it.
- 6:46Did you maybe mishear them?
- 6:47And they just said they're bringing in
- 6:48cool trucks.
- 6:50it could be they could be like or
- 6:52a cooler truck or cooler that's filled
- 6:54with all the beer what are you doing
- 6:57i just knocked over oh this is all
- 6:59broken now yeah we're throwing microphones
- 7:01around house of cards this thing oh my
- 7:04god they were talking about it this week
- 7:06how they're traveling and but the big
- 7:07concern is everybody's gonna overheat on
- 7:09this this first week of
- 7:11football for them in their head.
- 7:12Bring it in the cooler trucks.
- 7:13I was like,
- 7:14I've never seen a cooler truck on a
- 7:15sideline.
- 7:16I've never seen a cooler truck than that.
- 7:18I'm going to have to hold this.
- 7:19You could bring the cooler truck to, to,
- 7:22to the next info.
- 7:22Oh, son of a, maybe,
- 7:24maybe I will have the ABSF branded cooler
- 7:27truck.
- 7:28It just says cooler than yours.
- 7:29Yeah.
- 7:31hold on, I'm gonna, I'm gonna leave,
- 7:34I gotta leave.
- 7:37This went sideways real fast.
- 7:38He's got a he's really in there.
- 7:39So yeah,
- 7:40that that's an oddball technology that the
- 7:42comms people that were
- 7:45Did they buy it or are they renting
- 7:47it?
- 7:47It's rented.
- 7:47Find out where.
- 7:50It's down in Houston area somewhere.
- 7:52Not where the truck is.
- 7:53Where they rented it from.
- 7:55You're in the market for this.
- 7:56I think it's kind of cool.
- 7:58It's Texas.
- 7:59They have those things down there.
- 8:00It's a hundred degrees outside right now.
- 8:02I want a cooler truck to drive home.
- 8:04But only for a little while.
- 8:06I wonder if they have cooler trains like
- 8:09the next step up.
- 8:11That sounds like a lot of infrastructure.
- 8:13Exactly.
- 8:14If I've got to bring a cooler train
- 8:15in here.
- 8:16Sounds very green and efficient.
- 8:17You know what?
- 8:17This sounds like an Atkins question.
- 8:19Where's Atkins?
- 8:21He's in Texas.
- 8:22I just talked to him this morning.
- 8:25All right, enough of this nonsense.
- 8:26We're waiting for you to come back.
- 8:29I am precariously balancing stuff here
- 8:31because my entire house of cards fell
- 8:33over.
- 8:34This is a long story.
- 8:36What closet are you in today?
- 8:38It's hot out.
- 8:39We're moving on.
- 8:39I've got a show to do.
- 8:42the the the prison visitor center here all
- 8:46right uh let's let's continue with our
- 8:48show with the uh let's do the news
- 8:50so justin can sing along do it yeah
- 8:57where's version two
- 8:59That was the Oh,
- 8:59you want the other one?
- 9:01That's actually you are version two.
- 9:02You missed it.
- 9:03Yeah,
- 9:04we're past version three is the fancy you
- 9:06want the fancier one?
- 9:06Nope.
- 9:08That's next week.
- 9:09Okay, tune in.
- 9:10All right.
- 9:11So today's news story is actually from I
- 9:12think was two weeks ago when we saw
- 9:14this and it's been quite the talk of
- 9:15the town that we were discussing it
- 9:17earlier that there's there's been
- 9:18different takes on this this new story.
- 9:22But we've got links in the show notes
- 9:23here from the New York Times from fortune
- 9:24from TechCrunch.
- 9:25It's all over the place.
- 9:26Basically, Harvard
- 9:28is now replacing professors, again,
- 9:30this is the headline,
- 9:31Harvard's replacing professors with AI
- 9:32versions of professors,
- 9:34which is kind of their worst nightmare
- 9:35from the old days of like,
- 9:36you can't record my class,
- 9:38you're just gonna replace me,
- 9:39but I will also sit down and help
- 9:40you create an AV avatar of myself so
- 9:44something can teach the class for me,
- 9:47I guess.
- 9:47Right.
- 9:48Where do those class reviews go to?
- 9:51It doesn't matter.
- 9:52Rate my instructor and it's like a whole
- 9:54new category of that.
- 9:56It's not really class either.
- 9:58It's not like this guy is teaching a
- 10:00class.
- 10:01It's for the entrepreneurial program.
- 10:03Larry, give us a background.
- 10:06As much background as I know because the
- 10:08story that's out there isn't
- 10:12easily understood.
- 10:13You're just saying because most people
- 10:14read the headlines.
- 10:16Easily understood.
- 10:17There's not a lot of details out there.
- 10:19And the details that are out there don't
- 10:21seem to be universally shared across all
- 10:25the platforms.
- 10:27But it sounds like their entrepreneurial
- 10:29program,
- 10:30they wanted to scale and the easiest way
- 10:33to scale is to create,
- 10:36one of the faculty members decided to
- 10:37create an AI version of themselves
- 10:41Which is cool,
- 10:43but in all the AI stuff I've used,
- 10:47every now and then it goes and makes
- 10:48up its own nonsense.
- 10:50And I'm just curious, like,
- 10:51since this is not a class,
- 10:53this is like entrepreneurial mentorship
- 10:56where they're actually going out into the
- 10:58community and testing their products and
- 11:01whatnot.
- 11:02Like, there is nobody...
- 11:05betting this and making sure it's
- 11:07continuously following what vetting equals
- 11:10how many dollars are in the till if
- 11:12people are buying it it's been vetted
- 11:15exactly like it is successful to be scaled
- 11:18is it successful in doing what they think
- 11:21it's supposed to do are we making money
- 11:23are they making money right that is the
- 11:25metric of success they it has been
- 11:27produced by i going back to what you
- 11:29said chris earlier on i i think this
- 11:30is the pinnacle of fear right we all
- 11:33live through like we're doing lecture we
- 11:34can't do lecture capture they're gonna
- 11:35take my intellectual property they're
- 11:37gonna replace me they're just gonna use my
- 11:39canned classes over and over and over
- 11:41they're not gonna pay me anything they're
- 11:42gonna fire me and then yet one of
- 11:44them says you know what
- 11:47I bet we could make this.
- 11:48And it's probably the guys that I can
- 11:50replace all my colleagues.
- 11:52I bet if we've dug deep in and
- 11:54got all the layers of the onion off,
- 11:56not sure if many of you had this
- 11:57conversation with the faculty oftentimes
- 12:00the instructional portion of the gig is
- 12:03the piece that they like the least right
- 12:06they're there to do their research and all
- 12:08this and it seems like that lazy person
- 12:11is the most intuitive right or the yeah
- 12:13like so how can i get out of
- 12:14doing all of this stuff that i don't
- 12:16they've already outsourced their own class
- 12:17now they're just trying to outsource
- 12:19everything else
- 12:19why do i need to pay a grad
- 12:21assistant i'll just make a duplicate of me
- 12:23and let's go right there's two ways to
- 12:25look at this is the ai agent is
- 12:28replacing someone versus what kind of mark
- 12:31said me as an instructor i want to
- 12:33create my own ai agent to teach this
- 12:35course but i'm responsible for all the
- 12:38material i'm going to develop my ai agent
- 12:41you know according to that i i'm the
- 12:44one who gets the reviews after class
- 12:46that's on me
- 12:47Right.
- 12:48And now it's just I'm able to teach
- 12:51more students and do more research.
- 12:53But again, this isn't teaching class.
- 12:55This is like that mentorship.
- 12:57And so each interaction is going to be
- 12:59unique.
- 12:59It's going to be difficult to create the
- 13:01knowledge base to do that exactly how the
- 13:05instructor would.
- 13:06Well, they did it, Larry.
- 13:08I know they did it, absolutely.
- 13:09I'm just saying.
- 13:12I wonder what their metrics are to say,
- 13:13yeah, this worked.
- 13:14I'm working on the student side of this.
- 13:16Are they okay with it?
- 13:18Or the people who are attending this?
- 13:19Do you have five people in the course?
- 13:24or five thousand people.
- 13:25I don't know.
- 13:25So, you know,
- 13:27if it is that they're doing the efficiency
- 13:29A.I.
- 13:30game here.
- 13:30Right.
- 13:30So how can I be more efficient in
- 13:33the things that are tedious to me as
- 13:34an instructor spinning this up as a tool
- 13:36that allows that instructor to scale as
- 13:37long as there's that human in the loop
- 13:39and they're
- 13:40doing that portion of the work, okay.
- 13:43But I still think this probably scares the
- 13:45hell out of a large swath of instructors
- 13:47out there who are already on edge because
- 13:49of the current financial state of a lot
- 13:51of institutions.
- 13:52This feels like Armageddon to many of
- 13:54them.
- 13:54What about the concept that, Larry,
- 13:57you brought up,
- 13:58this is not like a traditional course.
- 13:59This is a mentorship program in their
- 14:01entrepreneurship program or whatever.
- 14:03Mentorship thing in an entrepreneurship
- 14:04program, whatever's going on.
- 14:07this is probably like a trial balloon.
- 14:08Let's see how well this works.
- 14:09Let's see what the response is.
- 14:10Let's see what we need to do.
- 14:11Let's see to your point.
- 14:12Let's see to make sure it stays on
- 14:13task.
- 14:13It doesn't start making stuff up,
- 14:14all those things.
- 14:15Let's use this as our test case,
- 14:18as our pilot program.
- 14:19Then if it's successful,
- 14:20now we're firing all the professors and
- 14:22it's one dude and a keyboard.
- 14:24How do you know what was successful?
- 14:28How much money is in the till?
- 14:31We did this.
- 14:33Profits are learning outcomes.
- 14:34It's one or the other and
- 14:36How many semesters are you measuring that?
- 14:38Because if your profits go down by...
- 14:40Based upon the source university,
- 14:43I don't know if they care.
- 14:46Also true.
- 14:47They might just be doing this for fun.
- 14:50Right.
- 14:50We're talking about it.
- 14:51Let's go screw with them like a bunch
- 14:54of lab rats and see how this works.
- 14:59That that there's some truth, right?
- 15:01I'm spitting.
- 15:02I suspect I suspect we'll see to your
- 15:05point, Justin,
- 15:05but this is coming from Harvard and
- 15:07Harvard leads the way on a lot of
- 15:08this stuff, good or bad.
- 15:10I suspect we'll start to see this in
- 15:11a lot of other schools in the next
- 15:13six months to a year,
- 15:14that other schools are doing similar
- 15:15things.
- 15:15I mean,
- 15:15they're already leveraging AI as chat
- 15:18agents,
- 15:19as initial administration contacts and
- 15:22things, or not administration, sorry,
- 15:24admission contacts.
- 15:25A lot of those things are already,
- 15:27they're farming all that stuff out,
- 15:28so why not start integrating that into
- 15:31academic curriculum?
- 15:33So now you've got students in the class
- 15:35using AI to help them learn,
- 15:37and then you have students getting taught
- 15:39by AI,
- 15:39and you just have the AI bots representing
- 15:42students be in class,
- 15:44getting taught by AI,
- 15:47and actually no one's there.
- 15:49No one's learning either.
- 15:50You know what that's called, though?
- 15:52The classroom of the future.
- 15:55The banker's best friend because every one
- 15:57of those students has a loan.
- 15:59It's all about money.
- 16:01But the agents are helping pay for it
- 16:03somehow.
- 16:04There's still a cost to it.
- 16:07It's just like all the people,
- 16:08and you have them at all of your
- 16:09institutions right now,
- 16:10who simply click that co-pilot button in
- 16:12Outlook whenever you ask them something,
- 16:14and it's clear they send you a co-pilot
- 16:16drafted thing,
- 16:17and then when you ask for clarification,
- 16:18they click co-pilot,
- 16:19so now you have two co-pilot threads going
- 16:21back and forth.
- 16:21Talking to each other?
- 16:22Yeah, pretty much.
- 16:22Have you ever seen one of those email
- 16:24chains?
- 16:24Yes, I've been on them,
- 16:25and I just stop reading.
- 16:28I like to respond right away when I
- 16:30do that with my agent.
- 16:31So when they clearly have overwritten that
- 16:33giant block,
- 16:34I respond so fast that there's no way
- 16:36I could could have developed a fifteen
- 16:38page response to a one line question.
- 16:40If you just just for the sheer magic,
- 16:43I will say free tip, free top tip.
- 16:45If you want to mess with people who
- 16:46do that, type up your response in Outlook,
- 16:48Word, whatever, screenshot it,
- 16:50paste it in as an image.
- 16:51But
- 16:52Add the alt text of something unrelated
- 16:55because the alt text is what Copilot's
- 16:57going to read.
- 16:58Then you've got your message and the alt
- 16:59text is something, you know,
- 17:00purple monkey dishwasher and you watch the
- 17:02thing get confused.
- 17:03So good.
- 17:04I thought you were going to say something
- 17:05else there about footballs.
- 17:07Or, I mean,
- 17:07Justin's favorite pastime apparently for
- 17:09football.
- 17:10Monkeys and footballs.
- 17:11Monkeys and footballs competing.
- 17:13See who can do it.
- 17:13All right.
- 17:13So we're all in it?
- 17:15This is what we're doing from here on
- 17:16out?
- 17:16Classroom of the Future.
- 17:17It's all AI.
- 17:17It's AI people talking to AI.
- 17:19Everyone makes money.
- 17:20And goggles, right?
- 17:21We put this in goggles and they're like...
- 17:23Whatever happened to goggles?
- 17:24Yes.
- 17:25Whatever happened to goggles?
- 17:27What did happen to goggles?
- 17:29Mine,
- 17:30I keep right next to my twenty one
- 17:31by nine screen.
- 17:32You're wearing yours.
- 17:33My goggles are twenty way.
- 17:34Yeah, I have my man goggles.
- 17:36It's nice.
- 17:37But portrait.
- 17:38It's very vertical.
- 17:39Yeah, exactly.
- 17:41For all that scrolling.
- 17:42All right.
- 17:44Dual doom scrolling.
- 17:45All right.
- 17:46Well,
- 17:46we're going to move on to a quick
- 17:46break.
- 17:47We're going to come back.
- 17:47We're going to talk about being
- 17:49responsible.
- 17:49No, it's not the right term.
- 17:50Taking ownership and accountability for
- 17:53stuff that
- 17:54maybe should be done by others,
- 17:56or they don't want to do it.
- 17:57But I feel like it apart, you're lying.
- 18:00I was wrong.
- 18:01I'm looking at the wrong thing here.
- 18:03And then we're taking our show on the
- 18:05fly.
- 18:05Now we're gonna take a quick break,
- 18:06we're gonna come back,
- 18:07we're gonna talk about assembling a brand
- 18:10new modernized,
- 18:11streamlined common kit of parts for all of
- 18:13your classroom and meeting room spaces
- 18:15that we don't support.
- 18:19That's part of the second.
- 18:20That's the next topic.
- 18:21I can go back to that one.
- 18:22We're just mixing it all up.
- 18:23I don't know what's happening.
- 18:24Blender of topics.
- 18:25Hit the button.
- 18:26Just because there's notes doesn't mean I
- 18:28can see what's going on.
- 18:29All right.
- 18:29We'll be back in one minute and eight
- 18:31seconds.
- 18:33The AV Superfriends are supported by
- 18:35Computer Comforts,
- 18:36and they've got a brand new product
- 18:37hitting the lineup.
- 18:38Last year,
- 18:39CCI's Evolve lectern was a big hit,
- 18:41a push-button power table combined with a
- 18:43super flexible AV cabinet.
- 18:45But let's be honest,
- 18:46not every room needs twenty-four units of
- 18:48rack space.
- 18:49Shocking, I know.
- 18:50And that's where the new AV Hub comes
- 18:52in.
- 18:52It's a lighter,
- 18:53more space-efficient solution for
- 18:55classrooms that still need real AV
- 18:57infrastructure.
- 18:58You get eight units of rack space,
- 18:59and the whole thing sits only about ten
- 19:00inches off the wall,
- 19:01which makes it a great fit when you're
- 19:03pairing it with a sit-stand power table
- 19:04instead of building a massive lectern
- 19:06footprint into the room.
- 19:08And this wasn't designed in isolation.
- 19:09The AV Hub was developed in collaboration
- 19:11with Texas State University,
- 19:13so it's built around real higher ed
- 19:14classrooms and real deployment needs.
- 19:16And that means fewer compromises,
- 19:18cleaner installs, and way less,
- 19:20why is this furniture the size of a
- 19:21refrigerator?
- 19:22If you want to see photos, specs,
- 19:24and all the details,
- 19:25head over to computercomforts.com slash
- 19:27av-hub.
- 19:29That's the new AV Hub from Computer
- 19:30Comforts.
- 19:31Purpose-built, space-efficient,
- 19:33and designed for how classrooms actually
- 19:35work.
- 19:35And thanks again to Computer Comforts for
- 19:37supporting the AV Superfriends.
- 19:41And just as an update,
- 19:42I am working with our good friends there
- 19:44at Computer Comforts on a new commercial,
- 19:46which will be debuting soon.
- 19:47So you don't have to hear about what
- 19:49Atkins is up to at Texas State building
- 19:51giant refrigerator-sized cabinets.
- 19:53Today is all about Atkins.
- 19:54But you do the commercial first,
- 19:56and then they develop the product.
- 19:57That's why it's taking so long.
- 19:59So everybody understands the process here.
- 20:00That did come up in the discussions about
- 20:02I'll just write commercials for products
- 20:04that should exist and we'll just start
- 20:05running them.
- 20:06And whatever sticks,
- 20:06that's what they're going to go with.
- 20:08So it's iterative process.
- 20:08We'll create a whole bunch of fake,
- 20:10or not fake,
- 20:10of URLs and see which ones people actually
- 20:12go to.
- 20:13So we're going to make up a product
- 20:14for CCI to see if we can sell
- 20:16it and create a SKU.
- 20:17Yeah.
- 20:18It's the portable mic holder for Chris.
- 20:21Yeah.
- 20:21That's called a trick.
- 20:22It's called the house of cards clip.
- 20:23Yeah.
- 20:25Well, see, here's the problem.
- 20:25This is a clamping thingy,
- 20:27and the edge of this table is beveled,
- 20:29and the clamping thingy don't work on the
- 20:30beveling.
- 20:31The de-beveler.
- 20:31There it is.
- 20:32The de-beveler.
- 20:34That's called a circular saw,
- 20:35but they would get upset if I were
- 20:38to do that here.
- 20:39So anyway.
- 20:40All right.
- 20:40Here we are.
- 20:41We're new.
- 20:43Mark, this is your fault.
- 20:44Is it?
- 20:45Because you're the one who a couple of
- 20:47years ago came up with the phrase kit
- 20:48of parts.
- 20:49And I caught a lot of flack for
- 20:51that.
- 20:51I just want to reminisce on that.
- 20:53That whole year, you guys were just like,
- 20:55oh, here we go, kit of parts.
- 20:57And now I try to not say it.
- 20:59You all just keep peppering it in.
- 21:00Do we need to go back in time?
- 21:02That's two years,
- 21:03two weeks in a row we've gone back
- 21:05in time now.
- 21:06Which time are we?
- 21:06I think you caught a lot of flack
- 21:08because...
- 21:09You said you had one standard for a
- 21:11kit of parts, and you come up,
- 21:12and we talk,
- 21:13and we find out you have twelve.
- 21:14I had one aspirational goal of having a
- 21:17single kit of parts.
- 21:18You use the same thing in every room.
- 21:20The idea of kit of parts is solid.
- 21:22Your application of it is not so much.
- 21:23I use the same thing in every room
- 21:24until I'm in the next room,
- 21:25and then I use something different.
- 21:27And I want to remind people you've gone
- 21:28so far like in the last two years
- 21:30to work with a manufacturer to invent an
- 21:32entirely new product just for you because
- 21:35it Yes,
- 21:35it was and you still do not use
- 21:37that.
- 21:37I don't even use that product.
- 21:39Yeah, that's the best part.
- 21:41So you wasted all our time and research.
- 21:43Let's talk about the concept of a kit
- 21:46of parts.
- 21:46And I will try to summarize,
- 21:48and you guys can correct me here.
- 21:49But the idea is, as much as possible,
- 21:51I'm going to put some rails around this.
- 21:53As much as possible,
- 21:53you're leveraging mostly the same pieces
- 21:57of equipment in different scenarios
- 21:59throughout your campus.
- 22:00So instead of every type of room is
- 22:03a unicorn of equipment,
- 22:05you're using very similar equipment.
- 22:07pieces of equipment in different
- 22:09scenarios, so that the supportability is,
- 22:12is much easier,
- 22:13you've got the same stuff on the shelf,
- 22:15the same software that your team knows how
- 22:18to swap these things in and out,
- 22:19whatever it is.
- 22:20And in your case,
- 22:20market was AV over IP encoders and
- 22:23decoders.
- 22:23So like,
- 22:24if I'm doing a big lecture hall,
- 22:25I'm doing a, I'm doing a conference room,
- 22:28I'm doing an active learning room,
- 22:29I'm doing a
- 22:30basic classroom with two inputs and one
- 22:32projector,
- 22:33I'm using for the most part the same,
- 22:35literally the same model,
- 22:36AV over IP encoders and decoders,
- 22:38just different quantities and in different
- 22:39configurations,
- 22:41so that if one of them dies,
- 22:42I don't have to keep an entire inventory
- 22:44warehouse full of spare parts.
- 22:45Is that a fair,
- 22:47forty second version of the kit of parts
- 22:49theory?
- 22:50It's pretty close.
- 22:51You hedged it a lot.
- 22:52You put a lot of rails around it.
- 22:53It's a bucket of stuff that you can
- 22:55build other stuff out of.
- 22:56All right.
- 22:56Well, I'm glad we covered that.
- 22:58We'll be back next week with a new
- 22:59show.
- 23:00Talk about that.
- 23:01It's a real quick one.
- 23:02Yeah, I think so.
- 23:04I think as we embark down this twisted
- 23:07journey that we will never agree on when
- 23:09we get to the bottom,
- 23:12has much changed in any of your kits?
- 23:16Nope, because the industry hasn't.
- 23:18Didn't you have a conversation with us a
- 23:22week or two ago how you're starting to
- 23:24use HDBaseT again?
- 23:26Yeah.
- 23:27So did you just throw everything out the
- 23:29window with what you were doing?
- 23:30All of it.
- 23:31What Larry said.
- 23:32Six rooms in the trash.
- 23:34Moving on.
- 23:34No.
- 23:36I think we had rooms that were not.
- 23:38Fully converted over to AV over IP.
- 23:40They weren't part of your kit of parts?
- 23:41Think of that.
- 23:42I know.
- 23:43And so it's that elusive smaller tier of
- 23:46classroom,
- 23:46whichever magical tier that may be for you
- 23:48all.
- 23:49How much do you need to put in
- 23:50there?
- 23:50And so this became an exercise out of
- 23:53economics, mostly.
- 23:55Where's the cost-effective piece of this?
- 23:57Can we do it with all AV over
- 23:59IP as we move to our standard kit?
- 24:01Certainly can.
- 24:02But should you?
- 24:04And I don't know.
- 24:05I don't know the answer to that.
- 24:06Maybe you do, maybe you don't.
- 24:08I think the economics is what has always
- 24:10stopped me from going that path.
- 24:11Because I can do eighty to ninety percent
- 24:14of my rooms with HDBaseT and for most
- 24:17of those spaces it's still cheaper.
- 24:22That is my standard.
- 24:23But then the more complex spaces,
- 24:26it's still cheaper to do AV over IP.
- 24:29And for those rooms,
- 24:31it's still the same software,
- 24:32still the same majority of the same
- 24:34manufacturer and pieces for those other
- 24:37things.
- 24:37But it's a different technology.
- 24:40I think there's some nuance here that I'm
- 24:42gonna pull on.
- 24:43Must an AV over IP solution be completely
- 24:47flattened one encoder for every input or
- 24:50not?
- 24:50Now,
- 24:50I may have at one time said that
- 24:53that should be the preferred case,
- 24:54and I'm okay having that,
- 24:56but I reserve the right to change that
- 24:57opinion.
- 24:58I don't think the technology at the time
- 25:00gave us
- 25:02as much flexibility as we see now.
- 25:04You can have AV over IP and have
- 25:05the mini switcher version of that,
- 25:08and does that make more economic sense in
- 25:10today's environment where that same thing
- 25:12was not as feature rich two years ago?
- 25:14No.
- 25:15Okay, I guess not then.
- 25:19What if I recently, over the last, say,
- 25:21like two years,
- 25:22deployed close to a hundred and fifty
- 25:24multi-input,
- 25:25multi-output AV over IP encoders and
- 25:27decoders,
- 25:29but then immediately put an HD-based heat
- 25:31transmitter behind each one because I did
- 25:35not... Just because you could.
- 25:37Because I could,
- 25:37and I don't want to F with the
- 25:39network if I don't have to.
- 25:41So you're using an encoder as a switcher.
- 25:43Let me get that right.
- 25:44Is that what's happening?
- 25:45I'm using a switcher that has built-in
- 25:47encoding and decoding capabilities.
- 25:49But you're not using that?
- 25:50But I'm not using that.
- 25:50Oh.
- 25:51I'm using it as a switcher.
- 25:52Oh.
- 25:53No, I know what you're talking about.
- 25:55I'll tell you straight up what I'm doing.
- 25:56And to me, that's still, yeah,
- 25:57it's still a switcher.
- 25:59It's acting as the switcher,
- 26:00but it does other things too.
- 26:03The model was,
- 26:04let's keep this as straightforward and
- 26:05simple as possible.
- 26:06Why does this stuff need to touch a
- 26:07network?
- 26:08Why does it need to leave the room?
- 26:09Why does it need to go anywhere?
- 26:10Whoa.
- 26:11Whoa.
- 26:12Let's keep this as simple and
- 26:14straightforward as possible.
- 26:15And you injected another widget into that.
- 26:17And that is somehow simpler and
- 26:19straightforward.
- 26:20Yes.
- 26:20Because it's been a switcher that outputs
- 26:22HD based.
- 26:23Yeah, but this one also does more stuff.
- 26:28So you guys are all sociopaths.
- 26:30You know that?
- 26:33I don't know.
- 26:34So?
- 26:34If anyone's curious,
- 26:35what I'm talking about is a whole bunch
- 26:37of Q-SYS NV-XXX-Hs,
- 26:39but on the back side is a HDBase-T
- 26:42transmitter.
- 26:43That's the best way to use those.
- 26:44I got you.
- 26:45That's the best way to use those.
- 26:48Use it as your DSP, your controller,
- 26:49and just the basic switcher,
- 26:51and then extend some other way.
- 26:53And they're going to call us soon and
- 26:54yell at us for saying that.
- 26:56And there are times when I would use
- 26:57it to be part of a larger AV
- 26:59over IP ecosystem,
- 27:00and that's fully possible.
- 27:01Was that just to circumvent the cost of
- 27:03a managed switch?
- 27:04No, no, no.
- 27:05I had a managed switch sitting right
- 27:05there.
- 27:07It had nothing to do with that.
- 27:08I wanted it to be as straightforward and
- 27:10bulletproof simple as possible.
- 27:12He wanted it all in wonder.
- 27:13Why did I need to involve the network
- 27:15to get it from point A to point
- 27:16B?
- 27:19I've done the same.
- 27:22No, I get it.
- 27:22I understand the whole thing.
- 27:23I'm just kind of, okay.
- 27:25I'm going to go do it again.
- 27:26That's fine if that's where you're at on
- 27:28it.
- 27:30Cool.
- 27:30I guess that's the answer for that.
- 27:32Then I'm going to put an HDMI switcher
- 27:34in front of it,
- 27:35and I'm going to double switch it.
- 27:36Oh, that's kind of weird.
- 27:37I don't think I'd do that.
- 27:38No, I don't want to do that.
- 27:40I'll remove sources where I have to do
- 27:41that.
- 27:42So can you convert it to USB first?
- 27:46Oh, good.
- 27:48And then back.
- 27:51back again.
- 27:53So is there?
- 27:53So the kit that I mostly work with
- 27:56in the is the over IP kit when
- 27:59I speak of these things,
- 28:00but your kit can be HD based T
- 28:02just as well, right?
- 28:03Is there was is there any new pieces
- 28:05that was maybe harkening back to HD based
- 28:08T where you're like, I'm,
- 28:09we get really good mileage out of this.
- 28:11And maybe it's the same way you just
- 28:12said, Chris.
- 28:14But is there more cost effective ways to
- 28:16do it at this point in time?
- 28:18Or if you could do whatever you wanted,
- 28:19what would it be?
- 28:19Is this a cost-effectiveness thing?
- 28:21Or is this an inventory and a maintenance
- 28:23issue?
- 28:25What are we getting at here?
- 28:26Because it sounds like we're after finding
- 28:28savings.
- 28:29If I can save, I can do more.
- 28:32because for for me like quoting what i
- 28:34said in freaking the back chair the other
- 28:36day if i have i'm staring down a
- 28:39building it has twenty spaces in it my
- 28:41old kit cost me let's just call it
- 28:43fifteen thousand dollars a room whatever
- 28:45and then all of a sudden i can
- 28:46do this now for less than ten thousand
- 28:48every few rooms i'm getting a free room
- 28:50out of this you see i'm saying so
- 28:51that it's or a cooler truck oh so
- 28:54the cost the costco of av classrooms right
- 28:57there in oregon
- 28:59Just buy it in bulk, buddy,
- 29:01and you'll get a savings.
- 29:02So, Mark, you're not wrong.
- 29:03I think by streamlining and simplifying
- 29:05and bringing the cost down,
- 29:06the added bonus is then you can recoup
- 29:08that cost to be used somewhere else,
- 29:10whether that's maintenance updates,
- 29:11whether that's quality of life updates
- 29:13elsewhere,
- 29:13whether that's going to those terrible
- 29:14conference rooms that you didn't purchase
- 29:16or own by some other group,
- 29:17and you're just going,
- 29:18I'm going to fix these things right now
- 29:20sort of thing.
- 29:20That sounds oddly specific, Chris.
- 29:22Yeah, it does.
- 29:23I am on board as being the running
- 29:26the world's worst business at a university
- 29:28by fixing other people's stuff just to get
- 29:29it off of my plate.
- 29:31But that's me.
- 29:34It's okay.
- 29:35so i do think having the common kit
- 29:38of parts that will cover eighty percent of
- 29:41spaces is this is the smart play and
- 29:45and i've been doing that you can change
- 29:47interchange some of these parts right if
- 29:48you have an av over ip system and
- 29:50it engages but i that's essentially what
- 29:54i've been doing right and now i know
- 29:58that when something breaks something needs
- 30:00adjusted something needs added to
- 30:03typically it's on the shelf or god forbid
- 30:06it's an emergency i can go rob it
- 30:07out of the next project take it and
- 30:10put it in and then replace the project
- 30:12one that's not coming up for a month
- 30:13or so right because it's easier to get
- 30:15a ten day turnaround on that but it's
- 30:17the same with cameras it's the same or
- 30:19even protocols right so maybe the cameras
- 30:21changed but i use a lot of ndi
- 30:23cameras right so just plug in another ndi
- 30:26camera it's done justin does any of that
- 30:28make you nervous
- 30:30I sense like maybe there was some project
- 30:32management,
- 30:32like shuffling product from one project to
- 30:34another.
- 30:35Do you do any of that?
- 30:36And Justin,
- 30:36I want to make you feel better.
- 30:37If my common kit of parts were all
- 30:38MPS one hundreds.
- 30:41So he's got a deal for you.
- 30:44It'll be FedEx there next week.
- 30:47I feel like all of us have the
- 30:49same philosophy on ecosystems.
- 30:51Am I am I correct?
- 30:52Generically.
- 30:54We're not really all bought into
- 30:55ecosystems.
- 30:56The ecosystem is about flexibility.
- 30:59We like flexibility,
- 31:00so we go to standards-based,
- 31:02and we don't say, oh, we're an Extron,
- 31:04Crestron campus.
- 31:05We buy everything, whatever.
- 31:06Yeah, and that's not what standards mean.
- 31:08Correct.
- 31:10I feel like if you're talking about a
- 31:12common kit of parts and you're doing it
- 31:14correctly,
- 31:16that audience that we're speaking to isn't
- 31:20in ecosystem world.
- 31:24I think our audience is mostly in the
- 31:26ecosystem world.
- 31:26Is that what you mean?
- 31:27No.
- 31:29I think you're right.
- 31:31Who we're speaking to.
- 31:32I don't think...
- 31:33If you're all Q-Sys or Crestron or Extron,
- 31:37you're not really doing the comic kit of
- 31:39parts.
- 31:41Because it's all one company,
- 31:42so it is a common.
- 31:43You're doing the company kit of parts.
- 31:45Well,
- 31:45that company forces you to upgrade models
- 31:47all the time,
- 31:48and you're just in an ecosystem,
- 31:49so you're using the same software,
- 31:51but you're using various different types
- 31:53of parts and pieces,
- 31:55where ecosystem in my head is...
- 31:58You have your AB over IP that you
- 32:00use.
- 32:00You have your HD-based T.
- 32:02What if that company stops making HD-based
- 32:04T,
- 32:05and now they only make AB over IP?
- 32:06You still going to stick with that
- 32:07company?
- 32:09So are you really truly doing common kit
- 32:11of parts and doing your university
- 32:13justice,
- 32:13or are you just going the easy route,
- 32:15which is what integrators do to make more
- 32:17money because it's faster in ecosystems,
- 32:20but it's always more expensive?
- 32:21Well,
- 32:22I think that the dangerous part of what
- 32:24you suggested there is –
- 32:25leaning upon a manufacturer as your kit of
- 32:28parts, because let's say...
- 32:29That's my whole point.
- 32:31Think about the two big ones out there,
- 32:33Extron and Crestron,
- 32:34who have huge product catalogs.
- 32:36I can buy everything from those two
- 32:37companies,
- 32:38and yet they don't talk to each other.
- 32:40I mean, these different devices.
- 32:40It's not a common kit of parts.
- 32:41Correct.
- 32:42But I think a lot of people may
- 32:43be misunderstanding us by saying, no,
- 32:45we're going to go select a manufacturer,
- 32:47and that's my kit of parts,
- 32:48and that's wrong.
- 32:49No.
- 32:49That's not what we're saying.
- 32:51So I kind of wanted to talk about
- 32:53that a little bit and dive into that
- 32:55because that's not what really we're
- 32:58talking about here.
- 33:00I think that's fair.
- 33:01I think that's a fair observation.
- 33:03And for me, right now,
- 33:04if I'm going to do AV over IP,
- 33:07I buy a lot of visionary solutions.
- 33:10Or Turtle.
- 33:12I haven't yet, but boy,
- 33:13I'm going to turtle my POs coming.
- 33:17If it shows up.
- 33:20You know, it's like cameras, right?
- 33:23All my receivers and everything I do is
- 33:25usually with NDI,
- 33:26so it just needs to be an NDI-capable
- 33:29camera.
- 33:30And that's where I try to keep these
- 33:32common kit apart.
- 33:32So I just go grab one,
- 33:34whether it's bird dog or PTZ optics or
- 33:36a bird, as long as it outputs NDI,
- 33:39I don't give two rips,
- 33:40put it in and let's go.
- 33:42Um,
- 33:44So I think that's where I'm leaning.
- 33:46Like HD-based T,
- 33:47we try to stay within certain realms.
- 33:51But sometimes those turn over faster than
- 33:53we want anyway.
- 33:54So, I mean,
- 33:57there's a lot of HD-based T out there
- 33:58that's different next year than it was
- 33:59last year,
- 34:00whichever black box special they bought.
- 34:02There's also a lot of HD-based T out
- 34:03there that's not compatible with other
- 34:04HD-based T devices,
- 34:05which kind of defeats the purpose of the
- 34:06open standard.
- 34:07Right.
- 34:07So we do try.
- 34:08I do attempt to make it so that
- 34:10you can swap those out.
- 34:11Or really, my judgment there is,
- 34:14Do I trust it to go to a
- 34:15Panasonic projector?
- 34:16Because that's what we use,
- 34:17Panasonic projectors.
- 34:18So if that HD-based T will raw dog
- 34:22it right into that projector,
- 34:23then that's for me.
- 34:25Some of them won't,
- 34:25and that pisses me off.
- 34:27Raw dog it.
- 34:28That's one way of putting that.
- 34:30I think I'm in the same general boat
- 34:33that Jamie's in,
- 34:34where I do have the standards,
- 34:35like the HDBaseT, the SDI for my cameras,
- 34:38like all that.
- 34:38And on those endpoints, it doesn't matter.
- 34:42Whatever I have,
- 34:43as long as it's compatible and works
- 34:45within that system, that's fine.
- 34:47Now,
- 34:47where I will push back a little bit
- 34:49is,
- 34:50I do have a manufacturer that I use
- 34:54their processors for my control.
- 34:55And I have exactly the same processor in
- 34:59every room across campus.
- 35:00It's one of their smallest ones.
- 35:02For now.
- 35:02Because everything is controlled over the
- 35:05network.
- 35:05But that way I have...
- 35:07a bunch of them on my shelf.
- 35:09And if one dies,
- 35:09I can get that exact same one.
- 35:11Larry, that's a valid way to do it.
- 35:14Now, I will also say,
- 35:15what about in those big old complex rooms?
- 35:17Don't you need a giant rack mount IDF
- 35:20located building wide processor?
- 35:22Because I keep getting told that.
- 35:25Not really.
- 35:25And the thirty two by thirty two switch
- 35:27to go with it.
- 35:27Right.
- 35:27You're going to do all the rooms
- 35:28connected.
- 35:29It's a thirty two by thirty two chassis
- 35:32at every station.
- 35:33Right.
- 35:34So, you know, Larry,
- 35:35you're dead on on that.
- 35:35From the control standpoint,
- 35:37if you I understand physical I.O.
- 35:40on control processors,
- 35:41but find the right one.
- 35:42Move as much of that stuff to the
- 35:43network as possible.
- 35:44Streamline your stuff.
- 35:44Do that.
- 35:46Well, even if you had...
- 35:47I never plug anything into the physical
- 35:48I.O.
- 35:48anymore.
- 35:49Exactly.
- 35:50Even if you are doing I.R.
- 35:51and R.S.S.S.
- 35:52I do everything.
- 35:53I'd recommend just getting Ethernet-based
- 35:55processors and getting all your global
- 35:57cache widgets for those stupid endpoints
- 35:59if you're still controlling DVD players,
- 36:01which that's dumb.
- 36:02Whoa.
- 36:02Whatever.
- 36:03Why are you controlling DVD players?
- 36:04Wow.
- 36:05Again, attacking me.
- 36:06If you are.
- 36:07I'm not.
- 36:07Even if you are CEC, like...
- 36:10Or that.
- 36:10Yeah, that works well.
- 36:12So is this a common kit of problems?
- 36:14Like, we have this bucket of problems,
- 36:16and we want to have a known tool
- 36:18that we can throw at that problem
- 36:20continuously,
- 36:21and we know that we can support it.
- 36:22And we solve by saying,
- 36:24what standard in my kit solves for this
- 36:27problem?
- 36:28Mm-hmm.
- 36:29Because you have the big crazy room,
- 36:33Chris,
- 36:33your seven thousand seat active learning.
- 36:36It's a hundred.
- 36:38Are you talking about the banquet hall or
- 36:40whatever it is that shouldn't be?
- 36:42Yes, it should not be.
- 36:45Whatever you're using in that you're
- 36:47solving this set of problems,
- 36:48you need like infinite scalability.
- 36:49So what gives you the ability to drop
- 36:51a bunch of IO around the room as
- 36:53you need it?
- 36:54Well,
- 36:54this very granular AV over IP approach may
- 36:57have solved that.
- 36:58But in a normal three-source classroom,
- 37:02we don't necessarily have to solve that
- 37:03complex problem.
- 37:04It's just I need to get these three
- 37:06I's to that one O.
- 37:07How do I do it?
- 37:08Like, okay,
- 37:09this is the most simple way to do
- 37:10it.
- 37:10Right, exactly.
- 37:10So it's more cost-effective.
- 37:11And so I think agreeing that all of
- 37:13our problems can be solved by this box
- 37:16of crayons,
- 37:17and whether it be an eight crayon or
- 37:18a sixteen crayon,
- 37:19we're not exactly a hundred percent sure
- 37:20on or agree on,
- 37:21but
- 37:22How guarded are you to adding new things
- 37:26to your kit?
- 37:27Do you rapidly bring things in and take
- 37:29things out?
- 37:30How swift is that turnover?
- 37:31Weekly.
- 37:33Weekly.
- 37:34Standards every week.
- 37:35It's a common kit of parts for this
- 37:37room.
- 37:38I've even changed some of that out.
- 37:39The one thing that is changing my kit
- 37:41of parts a little bit is your camera
- 37:43ingestion point.
- 37:44We had that discussion a couple weeks ago,
- 37:46whenever that was, about...
- 37:48how would you design this room kind of
- 37:50thing.
- 37:50And there's like four different ways.
- 37:52All four of those ways are kind of
- 37:54in our kit of parts.
- 37:55Now you're like,
- 37:57Yeah, at that point, it doesn't matter.
- 37:59Just put it in.
- 37:59Yeah, just put one of them in, right?
- 38:01No, that didn't work.
- 38:02I'll get the other way.
- 38:03But since we've gone down that road of
- 38:05saying AV over IP,
- 38:06we've had these spaces where we said,
- 38:07this kit is in here.
- 38:09It has since unlocked new capabilities.
- 38:11Right now,
- 38:12I can start to think about NDI.
- 38:13Maybe I need to get rid of the
- 38:14SDI cable now.
- 38:15I have the managed switch.
- 38:16I have the infrastructure.
- 38:16It's all there.
- 38:17So now, does making that choice to say,
- 38:20this isn't my standard.
- 38:20I'm going to approach these problems this
- 38:22way
- 38:24do we have downstream benefits of like,
- 38:26oh, it's going to unlock this new feature.
- 38:28We've reached that point.
- 38:29It's like, oh,
- 38:29now it's just all flat network.
- 38:32And then if I go away from that
- 38:34and go back to HDBaseT, what happens?
- 38:37Why not?
- 38:37Isn't that the dream?
- 38:39No.
- 38:40As someone who currently lives in said
- 38:41dream,
- 38:43Well,
- 38:43somebody's stream could be somebody else's
- 38:45nightmare,
- 38:45so I don't know what's going on.
- 38:46It's more of a nightmare.
- 38:49I don't see why it changes.
- 38:51So, Jamie, you're across the stream.
- 38:53It doesn't matter.
- 38:53Go for it, right?
- 38:54Bring it all in.
- 38:57I probably rotate more than most.
- 38:59But for me, like when we put in,
- 39:01even if it's HDBaseT,
- 39:05it is all using the same network
- 39:06infrastructure.
- 39:07Yeah, the layer one is the layer one.
- 39:08So if I want to change it,
- 39:09I just change it.
- 39:11What do I care?
- 39:12I don't care.
- 39:14Now, one may be cheaper than the other.
- 39:15You're solving a problem,
- 39:16getting this O to that I or whatever
- 39:17it is.
- 39:17Right, and I have had to take,
- 39:20because malfunctions, repairs,
- 39:22I've had to take AV over IP
- 39:25transmit receivers into a room to fix an
- 39:27HD based tea room.
- 39:29Because it was that emergency thing.
- 39:30It's like, well, I have them on shelf.
- 39:32I'm right here.
- 39:33Just take them in there.
- 39:33Get this thing on the shelf because put
- 39:35them on point to point mode and let
- 39:36them rip for whatever reason.
- 39:39But we've had to do that before.
- 39:41You're not keeping up your inventory, sir.
- 39:44Well,
- 39:44but the beauty of this is I don't
- 39:45have to,
- 39:46I don't have to have that many spares.
- 39:48I just have to have enough to fix
- 39:49today's problem.
- 39:50Then I'll order the next one for tomorrow.
- 39:53Five percent.
- 39:54You want five percent.
- 39:54That's your threshold.
- 39:56Still, every now and then, crap happens.
- 39:59And we have to adjust.
- 40:02We've definitely collapsed our inventory.
- 40:05We've simplified that down.
- 40:07That's the other advantage to a...
- 40:10Let's say,
- 40:10instead of a common kit of parts,
- 40:11let's say a common approach to our kit
- 40:13of parts is that your inventory doesn't
- 40:14need to be thirty-seven thousand different
- 40:16SKUs to track.
- 40:20You can do the same thing with amplifiers,
- 40:21with speakers, with cameras.
- 40:23You can have similar approaches to those
- 40:24things where they are
- 40:25functionally interchangeable.
- 40:27Yes, there's always those outliers,
- 40:28but in your bread and butter,
- 40:29everyone has two hundred and fifty of
- 40:31these spaces that are pretty much all the
- 40:33same.
- 40:35You can swap out those.
- 40:36Oh,
- 40:36I don't I don't have any more PTC
- 40:37Optics cameras.
- 40:38I have some Averitt cameras.
- 40:38I'll go put that in.
- 40:39OK.
- 40:41I think it's nice that the amplifier's
- 40:43technology has gotten to a point where in
- 40:45a half rack or a single U amplifier
- 40:48has more than enough juice to cover ninety
- 40:50percent of your room.
- 40:51Amplifiers are the easiest one to do.
- 40:53And they're cheap.
- 40:55They're relatively inexpensive.
- 40:56So you can have a stack of them
- 40:57and they will go from the thirty seat
- 40:59room to the one hundred and fifty seat
- 41:01room.
- 41:02And then you start getting into kind of
- 41:04you need to be specialized,
- 41:05but they don't have to be smart.
- 41:07You have the dumb amps sitting there.
- 41:09You know,
- 41:10I had this conversation with a few people
- 41:12recently.
- 41:12It's like, well, now we have Dante amps,
- 41:15and we have regular analog amps.
- 41:16Like,
- 41:17it's going to be so hard to keep
- 41:18spins.
- 41:19Like, no,
- 41:19just keep this analog amps and get Dante
- 41:22widgets.
- 41:23Like, don't overthink this shit.
- 41:25I think there is that perception that once
- 41:27you make a choice,
- 41:27I have a Dante thing that all of
- 41:29a sudden,
- 41:30everything has to be a Dante thing.
- 41:32I've got a Dante projector up here.
- 41:33It's like, what?
- 41:36Well,
- 41:37it's similar to a few years ago when
- 41:39we're kind of talking the reverse here.
- 41:40But a few years ago,
- 41:41I literally remember being at a conference
- 41:44where I was literally asked,
- 41:46when are you transitioning your entire
- 41:48campus from HDBaseT to AV over IP?
- 41:50I'm like, never.
- 41:52Why would I do that?
- 41:52It's both right now.
- 41:54Why?
- 41:54But it was kind of,
- 41:55I think for a lot of people,
- 41:56they saw it the same way as like
- 41:59VGA or RGBHV into like HDMI digital.
- 42:01Like you have to kind of thing?
- 42:03You have to do that.
- 42:04No.
- 42:04Like Windows eight?
- 42:06Like, we got to get rid of Windows?
- 42:07I mean, whatever, whatever that may be.
- 42:08But like this, this new,
- 42:09there's this new thing,
- 42:10I have to go migrate everything over the
- 42:11next ten years.
- 42:12I'm like, why would you do that?
- 42:13This sounds like a lot of work for
- 42:15this room has a teaching station,
- 42:16lectern rack,
- 42:17whatever with five things in it.
- 42:18And there's one projector.
- 42:19Why am I again,
- 42:20why am I bringing the network into this
- 42:21conversation?
- 42:23Where on your campus does your kit not
- 42:25fit?
- 42:26The unicorn outlier spaces, maybe?
- 42:29Football stadium?
- 42:29Yes, I'm going to say those big spots.
- 42:32I'm going to start putting Maddie in all
- 42:34my rooms.
- 42:35What's the threshold of going against your
- 42:37kit?
- 42:38What's that look like?
- 42:39Well, for me,
- 42:39the threshold is based on the quantity of
- 42:41them.
- 42:41Yes, like Justin said, athletics venues,
- 42:43esports venues, the...
- 42:45you know, the, what do you call it,
- 42:47the divisible ballrooms over in the
- 42:49student union or whatever.
- 42:50No,
- 42:50I can do that with my common kid.
- 42:51No, no, I'm just saying, to me,
- 42:52that's all like outside that realm because
- 42:54there's only a handful of those anyway.
- 42:56So if that room has to be different
- 42:57because of X, Y, and Z reasons,
- 42:59so be it.
- 43:00So the moment that it's different,
- 43:01all bets are off,
- 43:02like just do whatever you want.
- 43:03No, no, no, no.
- 43:04I think there's certain places where you
- 43:06have to.
- 43:07You don't get a choice.
- 43:08You have to do something different because
- 43:10it's a unique situation.
- 43:13But no, like the ballrooms,
- 43:14like to Justin's point, the ballrooms,
- 43:17even some of the large auditoriums with
- 43:19too many displays,
- 43:21it's still the same common kit of parts.
- 43:23It's just twelve of them instead of one.
- 43:24Bigger projector and bigger speakers.
- 43:26I was using that example of the spaces
- 43:28of which you only have two or three
- 43:29on your campus, maybe.
- 43:30But to Justin, to your point,
- 43:32the gear underlying what's driving the
- 43:34transport in those spaces, for example.
- 43:35It's still an engine.
- 43:36is still, you know, between that,
- 43:38you know,
- 43:38an active learning room versus a large
- 43:40ballroom is pretty much the same as far
- 43:42as that transport.
- 43:43Same stuff.
- 43:44That's what I just said.
- 43:45I'm backing you up here, dude.
- 43:46Why are you fighting me?
- 43:46I'm agreeing with you.
- 43:47No, I'm not.
- 43:50Restating my point.
- 43:51No, we don't agree.
- 43:52I'm telling you.
- 43:53I know you told me I'm right, Chris,
- 43:54but I want to tell everybody I'm right
- 43:56also.
- 43:57I'm right.
- 43:58We keep rehashing this for some reason.
- 44:00All right,
- 44:00so let me ask this question then.
- 44:01Okay, ask it.
- 44:02Carte Blanche,
- 44:03you have your entire campus.
- 44:05Don't worry about funding.
- 44:06Don't worry about timing.
- 44:07You understand this is a multi-year
- 44:09process.
- 44:09BGA.
- 44:10Funding is there.
- 44:11I was going to say,
- 44:12so what is our approach here as you
- 44:14look out at an entire campus focusing on
- 44:18simplification,
- 44:19on the wrong way to phrase it,
- 44:21on keeping things simple,
- 44:22on keeping things reliable,
- 44:23focusing on putting teaching and learning
- 44:24first,
- 44:25making sure that faculty and student needs
- 44:28are met,
- 44:30where do you start with this do you
- 44:32have a mix of say like sixty five
- 44:34seventy five percent hd base t simple
- 44:36spaces and then you're that twenty five
- 44:38thirty percent of av over ip for the
- 44:39more complex ones or what are you what
- 44:41are you looking at i'm starting on nps
- 44:43one hundreds there you go we just ran
- 44:47into a little bit of money it's not
- 44:50not sure how but that's our goal is
- 44:53getting rid of all the nps one hundreds
- 44:54on campus
- 44:56We're going to try to finally analog
- 44:58sunset this bitch.
- 45:00Oh,
- 45:00DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS-DMPS
- 45:24But there's some new feature you want to
- 45:25get out of AV over IP.
- 45:26Is there, though?
- 45:29This is a fictitious scenario here, Larry.
- 45:30Let's pretend that there is.
- 45:31Flexibility or something.
- 45:33Yes, there is, Larry.
- 45:35But sometimes,
- 45:38where do you kind of start that?
- 45:42Because a lot of times, it's not that,
- 45:43oh,
- 45:44it's not in our ecosystem or whatever it
- 45:45is.
- 45:45It's really...
- 45:46the people who are supporting it and
- 45:48changing.
- 45:48And now you've created this unicorn out
- 45:51here that even though it's the first year,
- 45:52maybe you only have three of these rooms
- 45:54and you know that the entire time they're
- 45:56like, oh,
- 45:56that's that weird room that Chris did.
- 45:58It's got all that newfangled shit in it.
- 46:00It's like, you have to like...
- 46:02Work your way through that crap to get
- 46:04the new version of that and be strong
- 46:07enough to keep walking forward.
- 46:08Or you just keep buying the same thing
- 46:10over and over again,
- 46:10which we see a lot of smaller schools.
- 46:12It's just a thing.
- 46:13We can't afford to change.
- 46:15We can't afford to change.
- 46:16A lot of big schools are afraid to
- 46:17change because of the sunk cost in
- 46:21technology, the technology debt.
- 46:23But we already have all this stuff.
- 46:25Who cares?
- 46:25Get rid of it.
- 46:26Great.
- 46:27And tomorrow it's going to be different.
- 46:28It will take three or four years.
- 46:31Yeah.
- 46:31So there's advantages to that.
- 46:33Or just do it when it breaks.
- 46:35Or just do that.
- 46:36Swap them out when it breaks with a
- 46:37barrel around it.
- 46:38Put a long cable in.
- 46:40So to that, to that question, Hey,
- 46:41you've got a,
- 46:42you've got carte blanche on this entire
- 46:44campus.
- 46:45Don't worry about the history.
- 46:46Don't worry about, uh, you know, um, uh,
- 46:48don't worry about the existing gear on a
- 46:50shelf.
- 46:50Don't worry about, uh, you know,
- 46:52the what's been done in the past.
- 46:54What's you know, where are you,
- 46:55where are you guys eat starting on that?
- 46:56I mean,
- 46:57Justin's buying a DMPS is now he's going
- 46:59all digital, but can you still buy those?
- 47:01I don't know.
- 47:01Probably, probably on the black market.
- 47:04Yeah.
- 47:04I mean like out of a van new.
- 47:08A white van.
- 47:09I wonder who's buying those.
- 47:11It says free puppies on the side.
- 47:13It says cooler than yours on the side.
- 47:15If you are buying DMPS three hundreds,
- 47:18please email us.
- 47:20Crestron has tried to end of life the
- 47:22DMPS series like twice now,
- 47:23and it keeps coming back because of
- 47:25customer demand.
- 47:29i don't know i i always tend to
- 47:30greater demand because customer demand
- 47:32that seems i bet it's customer at
- 47:35universities education is huge on like the
- 47:37the giant all in wonders still still still
- 47:42i think if i had if i had
- 47:43the ability to just do it and not
- 47:45care about yesterday and i'm going to also
- 47:48adopt that i don't worry about supporting
- 47:49old it's all being changed right now
- 47:52I would probably go AB over IP for
- 47:53everything.
- 47:54Probably.
- 47:54Why?
- 47:55That's wrong.
- 47:57No, and when I say everything,
- 47:57I'm going to hedge that.
- 47:59You just said earlier,
- 48:00why would you do that?
- 48:01I'm not going to put it in conference
- 48:02rooms.
- 48:02I'm not going to put it in spaces
- 48:03that doesn't belong.
- 48:04And I'm not going to do HDBaseT in
- 48:06there.
- 48:06I don't need to do any of that
- 48:07extension in those spaces.
- 48:09So it's only going to be in these
- 48:10learning spaces and these flexible
- 48:13required spaces.
- 48:13I'm going to just go to a single-based,
- 48:15IP-based,
- 48:16managed switch scenario where I have the
- 48:18bandwidth to do what I think the future
- 48:20will also bring us.
- 48:21to adopt the flexibility of what may come
- 48:28up like, hey, I do.
- 48:29Are you all of it everywhere?
- 48:32If it is the if it is the
- 48:33plan,
- 48:34and if that's kind of where I'm at,
- 48:35if money is not really an option,
- 48:38cost effective,
- 48:38I think it's I didn't say that I
- 48:40didn't do it cost the future.
- 48:42Here's a challenge with AV over IP
- 48:43everywhere.
- 48:45You don't own your own transport.
- 48:48I should do private islands at the end.
- 48:50What are you talking about?
- 48:51So, Jamie,
- 48:52you work at an institution where you've
- 48:54got some very solid people running your
- 48:56transport.
- 48:56This is a you problem, Chris.
- 48:57This is not a universal problem.
- 48:58This is very much a me problem,
- 48:59absolutely.
- 49:00Don't speak for everybody.
- 49:01This is a you problem.
- 49:01I'm speaking for me.
- 49:03And Justin and me.
- 49:04I mean,
- 49:05there's more than half the college.
- 49:07I'm just saying, Jamie,
- 49:08what happens when somebody over there,
- 49:11you get a new person in charge over
- 49:12there,
- 49:13and they decide they're rolling out
- 49:15whatever the manufacturer says to because
- 49:17it's awesome.
- 49:19And then your shit falls apart.
- 49:21Because guess who's going to take the
- 49:22lumps?
- 49:23It ain't going to be them.
- 49:25And Jamie's going to quit.
- 49:26But that wasn't in the ask.
- 49:29That wasn't in the ask.
- 49:30The ask was,
- 49:32if you were able to do this,
- 49:33would you?
- 49:34And to me...
- 49:35All of it everywhere.
- 49:37I want the PoE.
- 49:38I want all the things.
- 49:39I'm with you.
- 49:40I want that ease of drop it in,
- 49:42plug in the one connector.
- 49:43Sure.
- 49:44And I will even say,
- 49:45even if it's not on the Enterprise,
- 49:47even if it was a whole bunch of
- 49:48islands, I would still do that.
- 49:50If I'm building islands and leveraging
- 49:52edge switches all day long.
- 49:54Right.
- 49:54So either way,
- 49:56as it exists on the Enterprise,
- 49:57all the traffic goes to the border router.
- 49:59That's not what I'm saying.
- 50:00Because I'm impressed with...
- 50:01You guys need to come up here and
- 50:02visit campus.
- 50:03I got a demo of the...
- 50:05It's all on the border router.
- 50:07Like the visionary device with just USB-C.
- 50:10What is that?
- 50:11XP-V or something?
- 50:12Yeah, I think it's sweet.
- 50:14In a conference room?
- 50:15I mean, again,
- 50:16we're not saying price here.
- 50:19I'm like,
- 50:20this is a pretty impressive piece of gear.
- 50:22Mm-hmm.
- 50:24So even to you, Mark, like,
- 50:25I wouldn't put it in conference.
- 50:26Oh, hell yeah, I would.
- 50:27That's a single network jack to the floor,
- 50:29a single network jack to the television.
- 50:31You're done.
- 50:32You're done.
- 50:32I don't have a need for it in
- 50:34a conference room.
- 50:34Oh, no.
- 50:35Why am I bringing the network into that
- 50:36if it's a conference room?
- 50:37Right.
- 50:38Because there's one compute.
- 50:40We're done.
- 50:41Like, I don't know what else we're doing.
- 50:43I'm not transporting anywhere.
- 50:44It lives behind.
- 50:44You've got to have your laptop.
- 50:46Everybody has a laptop.
- 50:47You're connecting via wireless,
- 50:48as God intended.
- 50:49Zoom can do that for you, Jamie.
- 50:51Can I interest you in some MTR appliances
- 50:53that you don't have access to?
- 50:54Share screens and teams.
- 50:55Put the USB-C cable on there.
- 50:57Power your laptop.
- 50:58Get everything you need.
- 50:59Go.
- 50:59All the stuff.
- 51:00Go.
- 51:02There is an argument to be made there.
- 51:05Now, this is huge.
- 51:07There's no boundaries.
- 51:08I think most of the time I would
- 51:09err on the side of what's appropriate
- 51:11budgetarily,
- 51:12what's appropriate in the space,
- 51:13what's appropriate for my maintenance and
- 51:15things.
- 51:16There's all kinds of the nuance that you
- 51:17get into there.
- 51:18But the question was, would you do it?
- 51:20Yes.
- 51:21If it was money and I was free
- 51:23to do whatever I wanted and I could
- 51:25change it in one month, do it.
- 51:27Go all in.
- 51:27Yeah, exactly.
- 51:28I think I would definitely do it.
- 51:30Right now, it's the...
- 51:31the cost of change and having to support
- 51:33the old crap.
- 51:34If I don't have any of that holding
- 51:36me back, let's go.
- 51:38Let's go.
- 51:38To the cost question,
- 51:39I do want to say this because I
- 51:41recently spent the last five years
- 51:45shifting without a clutch one ecosystem to
- 51:47another, one transport method to another.
- 51:49And then you shift it.
- 51:51Yeah, just double clutch it, downgrade it,
- 51:53granny style.
- 51:55Just downshift where necessary.
- 51:57Just force it.
- 51:57It'll go.
- 51:58But that was my method.
- 51:59At least once.
- 52:02To migrate an entire campus from one
- 52:06ecosystem, one transport method,
- 52:07one standard,
- 52:08one kit of parts from one to another,
- 52:10is exactly, if not less,
- 52:13the same amount of work as generally going
- 52:15around and updating those spaces that you
- 52:17would be doing anyway.
- 52:19You're still buying hardware.
- 52:20You're still having to set it up.
- 52:21And people are saying right now,
- 52:22I'm yelling at their car stereos, no,
- 52:23it's the same software.
- 52:24Still do this.
- 52:24Yeah, and there's new versions of it.
- 52:26And there's new things they abandoned and
- 52:27new things you have to go.
- 52:28So you're still touching everything.
- 52:29You're still doing it all.
- 52:30So it doesn't matter.
- 52:32The mechanical side,
- 52:32there's no savings in the mechanical side
- 52:34of this.
- 52:34Right.
- 52:35So the thing that it's all a multi-year
- 52:36lift.
- 52:37This is all a five, ten year process.
- 52:39But why not start today instead of keep
- 52:42hemming and hawing over what do I have
- 52:43to do over the...
- 52:43I think before you do that,
- 52:45you should really know what your goals are
- 52:46before you just dive in.
- 52:47Like, why would you do that?
- 52:50A lot of this also exists because they
- 52:53sold it to me.
- 52:54That's why.
- 52:55So Justin, I said at the beginning,
- 52:56simplification, reliability,
- 52:58putting teaching and learning first,
- 53:00which are not usually the way things get
- 53:03specified out.
- 53:05Not the people on this show.
- 53:07But I think this would coincide with a
- 53:09very solid infrastructure plan.
- 53:11This is not all about just the stuff.
- 53:13Well, that's part of it, absolutely.
- 53:15Do you have the ability to have a
- 53:17really quality layer one plan and the
- 53:18network plan and the enterprise strategy
- 53:20for this?
- 53:22Do people understand what they're doing?
- 53:25Right.
- 53:25And so to me, like,
- 53:26if the answer to all that's yes,
- 53:28we can do this and put the right
- 53:29flexible network in place and have that.
- 53:31And it's our own local managed network,
- 53:33but it's part of the enterprise.
- 53:35And we can do that.
- 53:36Like, to me,
- 53:36that unlocks a lot of future capability.
- 53:38Oh, absolutely.
- 53:40And I think that's where I want to
- 53:41be.
- 53:41It's like,
- 53:41I want to be future facing on this.
- 53:43I know we can meet the needs of
- 53:44the teaching, learning,
- 53:44a lot of stuff right now with this
- 53:45kit.
- 53:46But
- 53:47I don't know what's coming in two years
- 53:48when we're doing these avatars everywhere.
- 53:50I don't know what that looks like from
- 53:51an endpoint standpoint in the classroom.
- 53:53I don't know what capabilities you're
- 53:54getting by upgrading.
- 53:57Yeah.
- 53:58Upgrading what?
- 53:59I'm still missing that.
- 54:01I just had one.
- 54:02Let me show this.
- 54:03Ask it out.
- 54:03Put it in the chat.
- 54:04We had an HDMI transmitter receiver die in
- 54:07our van meter hall.
- 54:08Which was it, a transmitter or a receiver?
- 54:09Both.
- 54:11Simultaneously?
- 54:13Not sure.
- 54:14And so I could put in AV over
- 54:16IP for one input and one output.
- 54:19Or I could just get another HDBaseT
- 54:22transmitter receiver.
- 54:23You're making the exact point I said.
- 54:25You're bound to this other decision that
- 54:27was made already.
- 54:27If we're not bound to that,
- 54:28we can just replace it and move forward.
- 54:30Move forward.
- 54:31I'm not saying co-mingle your garbage and
- 54:33get chocolate all mixed in your peanut
- 54:35butter.
- 54:35Well, but Mark,
- 54:36what's move forward mean if it's a
- 54:37point-to-point thing?
- 54:38Exactly.
- 54:39Why spend the extra funds?
- 54:42I think that's where I keep getting hung
- 54:44up on is,
- 54:45Like, right now...
- 54:47I'm not saying AV over IP for general
- 54:49extension services.
- 54:50That's not what I'm saying.
- 54:52That's not what I'm saying.
- 54:54So why have anything?
- 54:57Why not just do three encoders on the
- 55:00wall on a wall box going up and
- 55:02just switch at the projector and be done?
- 55:03Why don't I spend that money I would
- 55:05have spent on the better transport on
- 55:07getting better quality things in the room
- 55:10that actually impact the...
- 55:13What's that?
- 55:13I think that's better projector,
- 55:16better speakers.
- 55:16That's the next topic we're going to get
- 55:18to.
- 55:20I mean, we're going to agree on this.
- 55:21We're not leaving here until we agree on
- 55:23this exact approach,
- 55:24how we're going to get this solved.
- 55:27The kit of parts approach?
- 55:28It always is a pleasure.
- 55:29It sounds like,
- 55:30and if I want to try to summarize
- 55:31what you just said there, Mark,
- 55:32that we need to agree,
- 55:33and we all agree that your kit of
- 55:35parts is not a kit of parts.
- 55:36You have about two and a half kits
- 55:38of parts.
- 55:39Yes.
- 55:40Depending on the scenario.
- 55:43I have a warehouse of parts.
- 55:45What is so hard to understand about this?
- 55:48You have things in which you know the
- 55:50price of really, really fast,
- 55:52and you can get those,
- 55:53and your programmer has worked with it
- 55:55enough so he can roll it out with
- 55:56speed.
- 55:56Programmer?
- 55:57We don't have programmers.
- 55:58Why do you have a programmer?
- 55:59We talked about that last week.
- 56:01Somebody who configures these things
- 56:02rapidly for you.
- 56:03You have a configuratorizer.
- 56:04Yeah, they can rapidly do these,
- 56:07and you can do it over and over
- 56:09and over again, and it's not painful.
- 56:11Hey, Jamie, out of curiosity,
- 56:12how many arcade buttons are currently in
- 56:15your warehouse kit of parts?
- 56:16Not enough.
- 56:19not enough honestly i ran out i think
- 56:23i bought a two hundred and i'm out
- 56:25you bought two hundred you're out wow
- 56:27jamie's exposed i'm out right i have to
- 56:30order more to tell you the truth
- 56:33You need an inventory person, sounds like.
- 56:35I absolutely need.
- 56:37I have a whole bunch of staff needs.
- 56:42I'll get to it someday.
- 56:43We're a learning crew.
- 56:44My crew, I'm so proud of them.
- 56:46They've come a very long way.
- 56:47You know,
- 56:47I can build you an agent that does
- 56:49that.
- 56:50Sometimes you just have to put things on
- 56:52the back burner, and that's it right now.
- 56:56It just sits there just burning.
- 56:58Well,
- 56:58once you've installed all these buttons
- 57:00and you've drilled them into the top of
- 57:01the desks, why do I need more?
- 57:04When they go bad?
- 57:05Yeah, when somebody hits them.
- 57:07They're arcade buttons, man.
- 57:08They're rated for like forty hundred
- 57:10thousand.
- 57:10Forty hundred thousand.
- 57:11Forty hundred thousand cycles?
- 57:13Yeah, put it in your calculator.
- 57:14It comes right up.
- 57:15Forty hundred thousand.
- 57:17Wow.
- 57:18That's a lot.
- 57:19Button presses.
- 57:20I'm stuck on this point.
- 57:21People love these buttons, man.
- 57:22I don't know why you guys are giving
- 57:24me a hard time about them.
- 57:25You and your cute touches.
- 57:26You don't have any more.
- 57:27Watch out, Jamie.
- 57:28All right.
- 57:28Well, I mean, on the...
- 57:30I'm not sure if Cam's supporting me or
- 57:32not.
- 57:32I'm...
- 57:34He's laughing with you, sir.
- 57:37Again, I feel like that's not the case.
- 57:39Did we get anywhere with this kit of
- 57:40parts discussion?
- 57:41No.
- 57:42I think we all kind of agreed that
- 57:43we have a common...
- 57:43I think use the right thing that works.
- 57:47Right tool, right job.
- 57:48Yeah, right tool, right job.
- 57:50And if I had a perfect environment,
- 57:52I'd love to change and embrace in the
- 57:53future,
- 57:54but sometimes it's hard to get there.
- 57:56Funny thing is,
- 57:56the future you're describing is the future
- 57:58that we all built towards about ten years
- 57:59ago.
- 58:00I thought we talked about some of us
- 58:01are back here.
- 58:05It doesn't have to be.
- 58:06I think the kit does not have to
- 58:08be AV over IP.
- 58:09You just ask which one I want,
- 58:11and that's the one I want.
- 58:12Okay.
- 58:13Fair enough.
- 58:13If you're saying for you,
- 58:14that's the one you want.
- 58:15Yes.
- 58:15Right.
- 58:16I'm not prescribing it to everybody.
- 58:17I'm saying I want to be there because
- 58:19I have other selfish reasons.
- 58:23All right.
- 58:23Okay, cool.
- 58:25We can take a quick,
- 58:26we're gonna take a quick break,
- 58:26we're gonna come back.
- 58:27And then in the next, uh,
- 58:29forty two seconds,
- 58:30we're going to cover this discussion about
- 58:32owning and owning spaces and stuff and
- 58:35things that need to be done or something.
- 58:38However, I described it before.
- 58:41Push the button.
- 58:42Space ownership.
- 58:43The AV Super Friends are supported by
- 58:45Neutrik Group Americas.
- 58:47And you know what the AV industry needs
- 58:49more of?
- 58:50No, not another cloud dashboard.
- 58:53We need training, hands-on training,
- 58:56because before the network,
- 58:58Before the room system appliance,
- 59:00before the AI camera that insists on
- 59:02looking out the window, there's layer one.
- 59:05The physical stuff, the connections,
- 59:08the infrastructure,
- 59:09the things that either work or ruin
- 59:12everyone's afternoon.
- 59:13That's why Neutrik is investing in
- 59:16practical education built around
- 59:18real-world skills and repeatable results.
- 59:21Their FAST method – Fit, Attach, Secure,
- 59:25Test – creates a simple,
- 59:27memorable workflow for proper termination
- 59:29practices.
- 59:30It's hands-on training for the people
- 59:32building, supporting, designing,
- 59:35and maintaining AV systems in the real
- 59:37world.
- 59:38Because Layer One gets it done.
- 59:42Neutrik.
- 59:42What to use.
- 59:44When to use it.
- 59:45Why it matters.
- 59:47To find out more,
- 59:48email fast.training at neutrikgroup.com.
- 59:55Neutrik's in my kit of parts.
- 59:57Yeah, Neutrik's good stuff.
- 59:59Get that stuff to connect and stay
- 1:00:01connected.
- 1:00:02All right,
- 1:00:02we have negative four seconds to cover
- 1:00:04this entire...
- 1:00:06I'm just looking at the timer, but...
- 1:00:08When has that ever stopped us?
- 1:00:09It's never stopped us.
- 1:00:10All right.
- 1:00:11So, however I described it before,
- 1:00:13we want to talk about the concept of
- 1:00:15taking ownership of stuff that may or may
- 1:00:18not be your responsibility,
- 1:00:19But ain't no one else going to do
- 1:00:21it.
- 1:00:21And it's adjacent to stuff that you are
- 1:00:22doing.
- 1:00:23And so they're going to call you anyway,
- 1:00:25like this room is too hot sort of
- 1:00:26thing, but in a very different way.
- 1:00:28Mark,
- 1:00:29this is based on an article you wrote.
- 1:00:30Was it two weeks ago?
- 1:00:31You've thrown me under the bus again.
- 1:00:33Well, you put words to paper,
- 1:00:35by which I mean you dictated into a
- 1:00:37thing.
- 1:00:37Yes,
- 1:00:38I had my agent help me do this.
- 1:00:41Weeks of prep.
- 1:00:42But this idea of having responsibilities
- 1:00:45that aren't necessarily yours,
- 1:00:47but no one else wants to seem to
- 1:00:49take ownership of it,
- 1:00:50and so they kind of fall to you
- 1:00:52to do it.
- 1:00:52Is that fair?
- 1:00:54I don't think it falls to me.
- 1:00:56In the article I wrote,
- 1:00:57that space between where we stop and a
- 1:01:01faculty member or somebody along those
- 1:01:03lines.
- 1:01:04Recap your article quick.
- 1:01:05OK.
- 1:01:06We do a lot of integration.
- 1:01:07We do a lot of really good work.
- 1:01:10Get to that point where we sign off,
- 1:01:12we commission,
- 1:01:12we do a lot of all that front
- 1:01:14end work.
- 1:01:15We put it in the room,
- 1:01:16we go into the space,
- 1:01:17we do our commission, it turns on,
- 1:01:19does all things, success.
- 1:01:20Arguably, yes,
- 1:01:21we've done everything we're doing,
- 1:01:22yet we do not know if it's being
- 1:01:24adopted.
- 1:01:24We do not know if people are using
- 1:01:25it effectively.
- 1:01:26We have no idea what's happening.
- 1:01:29And here we are.
- 1:01:30And like,
- 1:01:30so who owns that space between us
- 1:01:33delivering and true success of adoption?
- 1:01:38And that's kind of where I'm teasing out.
- 1:01:39Like, and who, like, do we do it?
- 1:01:41Is it, and I'm not saying a training.
- 1:01:43I'm not, that's not what I'm implying.
- 1:01:45Like who's doing training,
- 1:01:46but who owns making sure that what we
- 1:01:49do arguably successfully is truly adopted
- 1:01:53in a meaningful way.
- 1:01:55Oh,
- 1:01:55and see my previous conversation about
- 1:01:56building a common kit of parts,
- 1:01:57putting faculty and students first.
- 1:02:00Well, to answer that,
- 1:02:02you'd have to define what success means to
- 1:02:04you.
- 1:02:05It doesn't matter what it means to you.
- 1:02:10Justin's going to come over there and
- 1:02:12smack it to the university,
- 1:02:15not to the individual.
- 1:02:19I think we are in a weird position
- 1:02:21where we do have to step into these
- 1:02:23roles
- 1:02:25more often than we should,
- 1:02:29than we probably think,
- 1:02:30like according to our job titles,
- 1:02:33mostly because we are the only ones.
- 1:02:36For instance,
- 1:02:38we probably all are called to classrooms
- 1:02:40to talk and kind of work through how
- 1:02:44Zoom works, right?
- 1:02:46Like, well, we can move here, move there.
- 1:02:48Sometimes it's how do you make PowerPoint
- 1:02:51note sides work?
- 1:02:52How do you,
- 1:02:53there's all these little things that
- 1:02:54aren't technically our thing.
- 1:02:56We're all like biting our lips on this.
- 1:03:00And so I say people are like nodding
- 1:03:01their heads.
- 1:03:03So Justin, if it's not you, who?
- 1:03:06Who's doing it?
- 1:03:06Do you pick up any of that?
- 1:03:07Does your support crew pick up any of
- 1:03:09that?
- 1:03:10We do not do PowerPoint training, sir.
- 1:03:12But does somebody?
- 1:03:15In IT, we have some training sessions on,
- 1:03:18and I don't even know if we do
- 1:03:19this anymore.
- 1:03:20No, I'm in the heat of battle.
- 1:03:21The tickets come in.
- 1:03:23It's not working.
- 1:03:24It's not working.
- 1:03:25Can you come help me?
- 1:03:26You were just giving the example of
- 1:03:28helping me with my PowerPoint slide.
- 1:03:30This thing over here needs to be here.
- 1:03:32And PowerPoint in Zoom.
- 1:03:33Jamie's the one who said that.
- 1:03:34No.
- 1:03:34Right.
- 1:03:35I did.
- 1:03:35And because a lot of times we get
- 1:03:37those calls because it's a classroom.
- 1:03:39I'm in a classroom.
- 1:03:40It's your problem.
- 1:03:41Or we want to teach HyFlex.
- 1:03:43It's in a HyFlex classroom.
- 1:03:45Okay.
- 1:03:46Well,
- 1:03:46teaching and learning doesn't want
- 1:03:47anything about that.
- 1:03:48I'm doing HyFlex.
- 1:03:49Let's go.
- 1:03:50Right.
- 1:03:50Teaching and learning doesn't want
- 1:03:51anything to do with this.
- 1:03:53Admin,
- 1:03:54there are no YouTube videos on how to
- 1:03:55do this.
- 1:03:55So you go in there and you're like,
- 1:03:57well, this is what we try to do.
- 1:04:01It sounded like you were describing
- 1:04:02content creation the way you said it.
- 1:04:04No, no, no, no, no.
- 1:04:06It's more of you're in the room.
- 1:04:07How do I get dual screens to work?
- 1:04:08That's why I was shaking my head no,
- 1:04:09because when you said I need help with
- 1:04:11my PowerPoint, I'm like.
- 1:04:12Yeah, but then, Justin,
- 1:04:13you said we don't do PowerPoint training,
- 1:04:15sir.
- 1:04:15No.
- 1:04:16Yeah,
- 1:04:16and we don't do necessarily training
- 1:04:18either.
- 1:04:18Digital signage always falls into this.
- 1:04:21I don't own any of that crap,
- 1:04:22but yet we're always helping with it.
- 1:04:24Well, we own that,
- 1:04:24so we're used to that.
- 1:04:26Yeah,
- 1:04:26but you own the capability to make a
- 1:04:27picture appear on that thing over there.
- 1:04:29Do you just own, like,
- 1:04:30I installed a screen on the wall,
- 1:04:31there's a player behind it, it turns on,
- 1:04:32I'm done?
- 1:04:33Yes.
- 1:04:33Are you done at that point?
- 1:04:34Ideally, that's what we're supposed to be,
- 1:04:36and it never is that way.
- 1:04:38We go through a training.
- 1:04:40I would have figured you guys know how
- 1:04:42to do that already.
- 1:04:47It comes down to content, yes.
- 1:04:48Digital signage is its own worst enemy.
- 1:04:50But it's another one of those services
- 1:04:52that because we are the eighty percent
- 1:04:55part of how to implement this thing,
- 1:04:58we are also expected to know how to
- 1:05:00finish the last twenty percent of it.
- 1:05:03And I think that's kind of what we're
- 1:05:04talking about here.
- 1:05:06Are we responsible for the marker boards
- 1:05:09for cleaning those off?
- 1:05:10No,
- 1:05:10but they usually put in a ticket for
- 1:05:12it.
- 1:05:14Oftentimes,
- 1:05:16whatever your name of your organization
- 1:05:17may be,
- 1:05:18is the custodians of the learning space.
- 1:05:20All of it.
- 1:05:21Basically, yes.
- 1:05:21Every single bit of it.
- 1:05:23The lights are out.
- 1:05:25Clock's not working.
- 1:05:26Clock's not working.
- 1:05:27Somebody spilled whatever it may be on the
- 1:05:30thing.
- 1:05:31Who are they calling?
- 1:05:31Yeah, exactly.
- 1:05:32It's your group.
- 1:05:33Oh, there's shoes in here.
- 1:05:34My keyboard's sticky.
- 1:05:35Yeah, whatever it is.
- 1:05:36There's only one shoe in here.
- 1:05:38That's the weird thing.
- 1:05:38All complaints.
- 1:05:39Why is there one shoe?
- 1:05:40Because it is learning spaces or
- 1:05:42classrooms or whatever it is.
- 1:05:44You become the door.
- 1:05:45And it's an identity that's cast upon us.
- 1:05:49And I think personally,
- 1:05:51like when I apply for jobs,
- 1:05:53not that I've done that recently,
- 1:05:54but I look for places where classroom
- 1:05:58technology is underneath learning
- 1:06:00technology because all the stuff we're
- 1:06:02talking about, like that gap,
- 1:06:05like that's where I want to be.
- 1:06:06Like, I think I want to see.
- 1:06:08Right.
- 1:06:10I want to see the systems that we
- 1:06:12installed go from being well installed to
- 1:06:15being successful learning outcomes.
- 1:06:18Just because it turns on does not mean
- 1:06:19it's adopted.
- 1:06:20Yeah, that's why my team,
- 1:06:22if a ticket comes in saying,
- 1:06:24I have a student who has an accessibility
- 1:06:26need and we need to add teams to
- 1:06:28Canvas,
- 1:06:29we'll go out and walk that instructor how
- 1:06:31to do that and put their team in
- 1:06:33Canvas.
- 1:06:34Like, to me, like...
- 1:06:36These are all opportunities to get in
- 1:06:38front of the instructors to find out how
- 1:06:40the rooms are working to get that feedback
- 1:06:42loop because there's not a great way to
- 1:06:43get feedback.
- 1:06:44So we do that very much informally where,
- 1:06:47you know,
- 1:06:47we have a lot of needs analysis on
- 1:06:49campus and meetings.
- 1:06:50So we're regular meeting with faculty and
- 1:06:52office associates.
- 1:06:53So that room that we did down there,
- 1:06:55is that working for you?
- 1:06:56Is there any problems?
- 1:06:57Y'all seem to be using that just fine.
- 1:06:59There's a lot of that on our campus.
- 1:07:03From a business perspective, too,
- 1:07:05you always want to follow up with your
- 1:07:06clients to see how well something's
- 1:07:07working for them,
- 1:07:09no matter if you get tickets or not,
- 1:07:10right?
- 1:07:10So there's a lot of informal feedback.
- 1:07:13Well,
- 1:07:14I like Larry's secret feedback of like,
- 1:07:16yes,
- 1:07:16this is not our role to help you
- 1:07:18get your PowerPoint into Canvas.
- 1:07:19But we're going to come down and do
- 1:07:20it.
- 1:07:20And while we're there,
- 1:07:21we're going to be asking you questions to
- 1:07:23find out what you're doing in the
- 1:07:24classroom, which is interesting.
- 1:07:25Because a lot of times,
- 1:07:26and I'll just say it,
- 1:07:27it happens way more than we'd like to
- 1:07:29think.
- 1:07:30Faculty may get that one meeting,
- 1:07:32especially like a new building,
- 1:07:33they'll get that one meeting or two
- 1:07:34meetings with the architects like three
- 1:07:36years before the building opens.
- 1:07:37And then the building,
- 1:07:38and that's the last opportunity they had
- 1:07:39to share any of that.
- 1:07:40And there's this huge gap.
- 1:07:41And like, no one ever thinks to,
- 1:07:43not no one ever, but in most cases,
- 1:07:46rarely does anybody go back to them to
- 1:07:48check in to see, is this,
- 1:07:49does this work for you?
- 1:07:50Do we need to make changes?
- 1:07:51Is anything going on there?
- 1:07:52Are we still successful?
- 1:07:53Because to your point, Mark, yes,
- 1:07:55it is installed.
- 1:07:56Yes, it physically operates and works.
- 1:07:57Yes, it does all these cool things.
- 1:07:59Look at all the stuff I can send
- 1:08:00around the room.
- 1:08:00Do they use it?
- 1:08:01Do they care?
- 1:08:01Does that meet their teaching needs?
- 1:08:03And that conversation,
- 1:08:05that second part of the conversation
- 1:08:06rarely happens.
- 1:08:06But I think that's where that's this weird
- 1:08:09area.
- 1:08:10That's the weird area, right?
- 1:08:11Nobody's assigned this,
- 1:08:13but we usually take it on.
- 1:08:15Everybody on this call has just said that.
- 1:08:17We usually take that on because we care.
- 1:08:19The IT rules of the road say it's
- 1:08:21not your job.
- 1:08:22It's not for you to be doing.
- 1:08:24And I think therein lies the friction.
- 1:08:25Yeah,
- 1:08:25this does not fit into ITIL or ITSM.
- 1:08:27Exactly.
- 1:08:29If you're just in service delivery,
- 1:08:30what service is this?
- 1:08:33Because a lot of IT departments are like,
- 1:08:35is it working?
- 1:08:36Are you asking for something new?
- 1:08:37I don't see a ticket for this.
- 1:08:43whose goal and job is this to be
- 1:08:46shepherding this?
- 1:08:46I think I agree with Joe.
- 1:08:48It's an unpopular opinion.
- 1:08:49It's a good thing.
- 1:08:50It means space users see us as owners
- 1:08:51and champions of the space.
- 1:08:52Yes,
- 1:08:53I think we are the de facto champions
- 1:08:54of the space.
- 1:08:55We need to be.
- 1:08:56Because if we don't do it,
- 1:08:57we all know nobody will.
- 1:08:58No one will.
- 1:08:58So let me give two examples on this.
- 1:09:00One at a former institution where it was
- 1:09:02a discussion about getting rooms ready for
- 1:09:04classes and the furniture was shoved in
- 1:09:06the back of the room,
- 1:09:07was not shoved around the edges of the
- 1:09:09room by my team.
- 1:09:11Facilities cleared out the space so work
- 1:09:12could be done.
- 1:09:13but clearly some, you know,
- 1:09:15email got missed,
- 1:09:15something screwed up and the stuff wasn't
- 1:09:17gonna get put back.
- 1:09:18And I said, well,
- 1:09:19we need to spend this last two days
- 1:09:20before class started putting all the rooms
- 1:09:22back.
- 1:09:22And the response I got was that's not
- 1:09:24really our job.
- 1:09:24Like I understand that, but we are,
- 1:09:26are the classroom people.
- 1:09:27We're going to get the call.
- 1:09:28If someone walks in there and stuff is
- 1:09:30scattered all over the place.
- 1:09:31Now,
- 1:09:31maybe someone is planning to come in at
- 1:09:33five o'clock tonight and do all of that.
- 1:09:35That's fine.
- 1:09:36But I don't really want to rely upon
- 1:09:37that.
- 1:09:38So we need to,
- 1:09:39to take ownership of that and ensure the
- 1:09:41teaching environment is
- 1:09:43the holistic environment is appropriate
- 1:09:44and ready for teaching.
- 1:09:45Here's the second example I have.
- 1:09:47This happened just a few weeks ago.
- 1:09:49We got an email from clearly a very,
- 1:09:51very upset professor who basically pointed
- 1:09:54out that he teaches in one of these
- 1:09:56smaller departments, and we all know them,
- 1:09:57who don't have the same amount of funding
- 1:09:59as everybody else,
- 1:10:00and they're kind of making do with what
- 1:10:01they have.
- 1:10:02Dociology.
- 1:10:04or similar.
- 1:10:05They're in an older building on the other
- 1:10:07side of campus that all the attention is
- 1:10:08down here where all the new construction
- 1:10:10is and all this stuff.
- 1:10:11And he just laid out this litany of
- 1:10:13things that he finds wrong with the rooms,
- 1:10:15but it was not technology being broken.
- 1:10:16It was cables are a mess.
- 1:10:18The clock doesn't work.
- 1:10:19There's a broken chair in here.
- 1:10:21The electric has stuff all over it.
- 1:10:23Somebody took all the markers sort of
- 1:10:25thing.
- 1:10:25Um,
- 1:10:26you know,
- 1:10:27the sushi's too expensive at Whole Foods.
- 1:10:29You know, it was every little thing.
- 1:10:30And what he was really saying is you
- 1:10:32could just tell there was some frustration
- 1:10:33and something was the straw that broke the
- 1:10:34camera's back.
- 1:10:34You need to talk to the registrar and
- 1:10:35get in a new space.
- 1:10:36Well, and my response to this was,
- 1:10:40I had the typical response from the rest
- 1:10:41of the team, that's not really what,
- 1:10:42I was like,
- 1:10:43let's send someone over there for about an
- 1:10:44hour and just take a pass through these
- 1:10:46rooms, write down things,
- 1:10:47let's note a few things, send that off.
- 1:10:49And it made this guy's week because
- 1:10:53somebody...
- 1:10:53Somebody came by and helped,
- 1:10:56cleaned up a little bit and just tidied
- 1:10:57up.
- 1:10:58Yes, it's not our role,
- 1:10:59but we own that space.
- 1:11:01And that's a cultural shift for a lot
- 1:11:03of folks to take ownership of that.
- 1:11:06I'm going to go get stuff and clean
- 1:11:07off the whiteboards in there anyway,
- 1:11:08because I know no one else is going
- 1:11:09to do it before classes start.
- 1:11:10And everyone loves these marker boards
- 1:11:13with the markers,
- 1:11:13and they get that grayish, dingy,
- 1:11:15nasty color where they're no longer kind
- 1:11:17of that whatever it is.
- 1:11:18Marker patina.
- 1:11:19It requires someone to put some elbow
- 1:11:21grease in to clean it off.
- 1:11:21And I've done a bunch of those recently.
- 1:11:24It's just clearly not in somebody else's
- 1:11:25radar.
- 1:11:27But it's one little thing you can do
- 1:11:28to take ownership of that entire space.
- 1:11:30So it is a tough challenge for a
- 1:11:32lot of folks.
- 1:11:32And a lot of times it comes down
- 1:11:33to goodwill and just political equity.
- 1:11:36Doing the right thing.
- 1:11:38You will be the one that people will
- 1:11:39say, oh, you know what?
- 1:11:41You'll gain a voice and you'll gain a
- 1:11:43seat at the table from doing these things.
- 1:11:44Providing value.
- 1:11:45Right.
- 1:11:46And so it's that weird space.
- 1:11:49And I think everybody has it.
- 1:11:50And I think it's a lot of assumption
- 1:11:52that people are just taking care of it.
- 1:11:54We often deal with, no, there's not.
- 1:11:56Don't you guys just have somebody who
- 1:11:57comes in at night and fixes all the
- 1:11:58stuff and blah, blah,
- 1:11:59blah and puts the bed sheets on?
- 1:12:01No, we don't.
- 1:12:01We don't have that.
- 1:12:02I'm glad you think we do have...
- 1:12:04Because things are operational at that
- 1:12:06level more often than not.
- 1:12:07But it takes coordination.
- 1:12:09It takes work.
- 1:12:09And sometimes it does mean we're going to
- 1:12:11have to do things that are not clearly
- 1:12:12defined within our PDs.
- 1:12:14So Mark, in your article,
- 1:12:15you used the phrase,
- 1:12:16I'm going to quote it here because I
- 1:12:17like how it was written.
- 1:12:19We have to think more deliberately about
- 1:12:20the space between technical commissioning
- 1:12:22and faculty development,
- 1:12:23user operation sort of thing,
- 1:12:25not simply as training,
- 1:12:26but as operational transition.
- 1:12:28So simply because the thing works,
- 1:12:31doesn't mean it's being successful so do
- 1:12:33you have any follow-up thoughts on that on
- 1:12:35how to ensure that like you go that
- 1:12:37actually maybe like jamie said you get
- 1:12:39that ninety five percent let's go what's
- 1:12:40an extra five percent this room physically
- 1:12:43does what it's supposed to operationally
- 1:12:44it is working and done but
- 1:12:47Is it successful?
- 1:12:48Yeah,
- 1:12:48I think you have to go back to
- 1:12:51who were your champions where the idea
- 1:12:53came from, right?
- 1:12:54If somebody said, wait,
- 1:12:55I want to do X, Y, and Z.
- 1:12:56And that may be.
- 1:12:58That may be.
- 1:12:58That happens a lot here.
- 1:13:00It does.
- 1:13:01You get in a meeting and they're like,
- 1:13:03who did this dumb idea?
- 1:13:04Well...
- 1:13:06But if you're doing something that's
- 1:13:07different, it's nonstandard,
- 1:13:08you have some new capabilities coming in
- 1:13:10there,
- 1:13:11somebody was championing this to move this
- 1:13:13forward.
- 1:13:14Are they there?
- 1:13:15And it's not just deliberate walk away.
- 1:13:16Are we walking through?
- 1:13:18Do we have a clear defined group of
- 1:13:20faculty who want this new capability?
- 1:13:22And are we checking in with them?
- 1:13:24Just like you said,
- 1:13:24in that first three weeks of classes, hey,
- 1:13:26is this working?
- 1:13:27Is it what you expected?
- 1:13:29Is it more complicated than you
- 1:13:30anticipated?
- 1:13:32Is there something we can do to make
- 1:13:33it so that it's not an additional thing
- 1:13:35or lever you have to pull and figure
- 1:13:37out and learn?
- 1:13:38Because any little bit of that disruption
- 1:13:41is going to be magnified, right?
- 1:13:42And so how do we make sure the
- 1:13:44work we're doing was interpreted correctly
- 1:13:46and it is handing off?
- 1:13:48Doesn't mean we're going to own that
- 1:13:49forever, but at least...
- 1:13:51get some insight into it because that new
- 1:13:53thing we do in five years may be
- 1:13:55the new standard, right?
- 1:13:56And so maybe they are on the cutting
- 1:13:58edge.
- 1:13:58Or it may never do it again.
- 1:13:59But at least we are actually allowing
- 1:14:02folks to be involved in that process.
- 1:14:03We're keeping that an iterative process.
- 1:14:06We're keeping the conversation moving
- 1:14:07forward.
- 1:14:08And we all should be learning a little
- 1:14:09bit.
- 1:14:10Doesn't mean we're owning everything,
- 1:14:11but it's not an easy thing.
- 1:14:13And I don't think just punching the room
- 1:14:15out and saying it's done and walking away
- 1:14:17is actually completion of the job.
- 1:14:20Yeah.
- 1:14:21Well, for most of us.
- 1:14:25There's probably times where it is,
- 1:14:27but I'm really moving out into those
- 1:14:30non-standardized spaces.
- 1:14:30Well, I think this is my comment.
- 1:14:33Well, maybe it's a standard space,
- 1:14:34but you put some new technology in a
- 1:14:36standard space.
- 1:14:37Yeah,
- 1:14:38I think my smart-ass answer was more for
- 1:14:40us.
- 1:14:41We don't just get to punch out and
- 1:14:42walk home, right?
- 1:14:44But for a lot of places who have
- 1:14:46a lot of integrators, they do.
- 1:14:47They get to punch out and walk.
- 1:14:49Hey, that's something.
- 1:14:50For you integrators,
- 1:14:51if you want to provide value,
- 1:14:52start erasing whiteboards.
- 1:14:55It's not the erasing them that's the
- 1:14:57problem.
- 1:14:57Putting the shoes out of the room,
- 1:14:58getting everything cleaned up.
- 1:14:59Put the chairs back, fix the clock.
- 1:15:02If there's a dead mouse on the ground,
- 1:15:03maybe pick it up.
- 1:15:04You bring one portable power washer and
- 1:15:06they don't want you cleaning whiteboards
- 1:15:07anymore.
- 1:15:09Provide value.
- 1:15:10It was so fast.
- 1:15:10You should probably provide value by going
- 1:15:12above and beyond.
- 1:15:13We're going to keep using them.
- 1:15:14You need to do some CPR.
- 1:15:15Give them all our money.
- 1:15:16Yeah.
- 1:15:17Erase their whiteboards.
- 1:15:18All right.
- 1:15:19Larry,
- 1:15:19do you want to come back to you
- 1:15:19since this is very close to your passion?
- 1:15:24It's close to your heart.
- 1:15:25You have to say everything without using
- 1:15:26the words, learning outcomes.
- 1:15:28Go.
- 1:15:29Is there anything we missed or anything we
- 1:15:31did not cover?
- 1:15:31No student success either.
- 1:15:32I don't want to hear about any of
- 1:15:33that.
- 1:15:33Go.
- 1:15:34I mean,
- 1:15:34the one thing I will say is I
- 1:15:36do intentionally try to have meetings with
- 1:15:39the instructional designers in the spaces.
- 1:15:43And when we put together their training.
- 1:15:46They're just doing AI, dude.
- 1:15:47They're not even.
- 1:15:48They are.
- 1:15:48They only do Canvas, Larry.
- 1:15:50They don't do physical spaces.
- 1:15:52We can work through the thought process of
- 1:15:54how things were put in there.
- 1:15:55And so they know the tools that are
- 1:15:57actually in the spaces because not all
- 1:15:59requests will come to Classroom
- 1:16:01Technology.
- 1:16:02And they'll be in front of the people
- 1:16:03as well.
- 1:16:03I think that was kind of that weird
- 1:16:07transition is that...
- 1:16:09We've talked in the past about your
- 1:16:11faculty learning groups, your CTL,
- 1:16:13all those spaces,
- 1:16:14but oftentimes they really do everything
- 1:16:17they can to keep technology at an arm's
- 1:16:19length.
- 1:16:19They're like, no,
- 1:16:21we are not gonna get into tool.
- 1:16:23That's not what we do.
- 1:16:25But somebody in that pedagogical use has
- 1:16:29to use this stuff.
- 1:16:30They have to do it.
- 1:16:31And so is what we're providing allowing
- 1:16:35them to be successful?
- 1:16:36Yes or no?
- 1:16:37Who owns that metric?
- 1:16:39Right.
- 1:16:39And I think that's the crux of most
- 1:16:41of our work anyway.
- 1:16:43And you're going to get mixed results from
- 1:16:45that, too.
- 1:16:46It could be a split sixty forty where
- 1:16:49sixty percent are.
- 1:16:49Yeah, this is great.
- 1:16:50And forty percent.
- 1:16:51This is terrible.
- 1:16:52I can't do these things.
- 1:16:53Well, it wasn't designed to do that.
- 1:16:54You're not teaching the right spot.
- 1:16:56And then you provide value by talking with
- 1:16:58your register.
- 1:17:00I like telling people they're doing it
- 1:17:01wrong.
- 1:17:02That's the best way.
- 1:17:03You're teaching it correctly.
- 1:17:04But sometimes it's also about how ideas
- 1:17:07come to be.
- 1:17:08And somebody's like,
- 1:17:08I want to do all this stuff.
- 1:17:10We don't have a space.
- 1:17:10But listen, I want to talk to you.
- 1:17:12I want to make that connection.
- 1:17:13So if an opportunity comes up and we're
- 1:17:15going to do something different that
- 1:17:16enables some new pedagogical use case,
- 1:17:19I need to know where those champions are
- 1:17:21so I can bring those voices in on
- 1:17:22the design process.
- 1:17:22And then you can put it all on
- 1:17:23the network.
- 1:17:24But the other really powerful one is they
- 1:17:27get done explaining what they want to do,
- 1:17:28and then you say, oh,
- 1:17:30but it already does that.
- 1:17:31Let me show you.
- 1:17:32Exactly.
- 1:17:33And right now that tells you that you
- 1:17:35probably could have done something a
- 1:17:36little bit different, and it tells them,
- 1:17:38oh, I should have just asked.
- 1:17:40Well, I always say,
- 1:17:40I think it does that.
- 1:17:41Let me show you,
- 1:17:42because I may have heard him wrong.
- 1:17:44Well,
- 1:17:44but the point is that somewhere there's a
- 1:17:47gap.
- 1:17:48So how do we fill that gap?
- 1:17:49And I think that is one of the
- 1:17:50challenges we take on that we're not
- 1:17:52necessarily, quote, paid for.
- 1:17:56I remember several years ago showing an
- 1:17:57art history professor who does all the
- 1:18:01stuff was on his laptop,
- 1:18:02but he also teaches on Zoom.
- 1:18:04And
- 1:18:05But the computers or the classrooms are
- 1:18:08all set up, so the Zoom, the microphones,
- 1:18:09the cameras,
- 1:18:10and all that go to the computer in
- 1:18:11the room, like God intended.
- 1:18:13It's in the Bible.
- 1:18:14It's in the back called Book of
- 1:18:15Classrooms.
- 1:18:16Verse one.
- 1:18:19And he was talking about how his method
- 1:18:21was, and it was blowing my mind.
- 1:18:23His method was to, like,
- 1:18:24show the stuff on a screen and turn
- 1:18:25it towards, like,
- 1:18:26the camera and kind of aim it.
- 1:18:27It was like...
- 1:18:29Let me help you out here.
- 1:18:30And I showed him how to join the
- 1:18:33call,
- 1:18:34but from his laptop and then share into
- 1:18:36it.
- 1:18:37That's all he cared about.
- 1:18:38I'd walk past that guy on campus two
- 1:18:42months later.
- 1:18:42He was like, oh my God,
- 1:18:43this is the guy who showed me.
- 1:18:45That's the Zoom genius right there.
- 1:18:47That made that dude's year.
- 1:18:50and and to your point justin it already
- 1:18:52did the the room already did that but
- 1:18:54it wasn't really crazy about the gap
- 1:18:56between his teaching and what the
- 1:18:57operation was what's crazy about that is
- 1:19:00that everybody knows that it can do that
- 1:19:02they just don't understand it in the room
- 1:19:05do they can't comprehend sharing content
- 1:19:08sometimes laptop in the room and sometimes
- 1:19:10you have to show them that a couple
- 1:19:11of times and then there's like this moment
- 1:19:13you can hear their brain like click i
- 1:19:16Oh!
- 1:19:17I don't have to be remote for me
- 1:19:19to share my content.
- 1:19:20Oh.
- 1:19:22You know how to fix that?
- 1:19:25Arcade buttons.
- 1:19:26Arcade buttons.
- 1:19:27Arcade buttons everywhere.
- 1:19:29To control Zoom.
- 1:19:31USB switchers.
- 1:19:31Arcade button to launch Zoom.
- 1:19:33Just trust me.
- 1:19:35Any last thoughts on taking ownership of
- 1:19:38the holistic classroom teaching and
- 1:19:40learning experience?
- 1:19:41Be responsible.
- 1:19:42Be accountable.
- 1:19:43Own it.
- 1:19:45all right that's it yeah be be willing
- 1:19:49to provide value meet them where they are
- 1:19:53go out there these are all things that
- 1:19:54we talk about in my three-day course by
- 1:19:56the way you in this course you should
- 1:19:58sign up for the course yeah justin you
- 1:20:01should sign up for your three-day course
- 1:20:02it sounds good you have that weird avatar
- 1:20:05teaching i want to see you teach it
- 1:20:06sir
- 1:20:07Yes,
- 1:20:07when do we get AI version of Justin
- 1:20:09and Justin and Justin?
- 1:20:11Pocket Justin teaching the course.
- 1:20:12You know,
- 1:20:12we need to have Justin Watts on the
- 1:20:14show.
- 1:20:14Justin Watts, if you're listening.
- 1:20:15You keep saying that,
- 1:20:16and yet he's not here yet.
- 1:20:18He's in your contact list.
- 1:20:21We've got to plan a show.
- 1:20:22We'll see you next week, folks.
- 1:20:24Good gravy.
- 1:20:30Well,
- 1:20:30we've managed to ruin yet another episode
- 1:20:32of AV Superfriends Off the Rails.
- 1:20:34You can contact us with questions,
- 1:20:36topic ideas,
- 1:20:36or general complaints at mailbag at
- 1:20:38avsuperfriends.com.
- 1:20:40If you complain loud enough,
- 1:20:41we might just invite you on the show.
- 1:20:46Nice work, everyone.
- 1:20:48Sharp broadcast.
- 1:20:49Really good.
- 1:20:50Everyone on the floor as well.
- 1:20:52Really a lot of hustle.
- 1:20:52I liked it.
- 1:20:54The opinions expressed by the AV Super
- 1:20:55Friends are solely those of the
- 1:20:56individuals and do not represent their
- 1:20:58respective institutions, organizations,
- 1:21:00companies, or clients.
- 1:21:03Justin Watts, come on the show.