Latest / Gabriel Ellis, PhD | The Curious Mind Podcast / Adlerian Psychology, Part 1
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome everyone to episode 16 of the Curious mind podcast.
- 0:04Today, we deal with adlerian Psychotherapy and philosophy
- 0:09based on the book of to oddly Aryans for me, talk a Koga and
- 0:14issue. Rikishi, me both are Japanese
- 0:17sushi. Me is specialized in a Clarion
- 0:21philosophy. And kouga is an author who got
- 0:25inspired by adlerian thought and did many interviews with cushy
- 0:31me. And based on these
- 0:33conversations, we have two books.
- 0:36One, the courage to be disliked from 2013 and the courage to be
- 0:42happy from 2016. And based on these books we have
- 0:47this conversation today. My conversation partner is
- 0:51pallavi. And we discuss based on these
- 0:56books and not so much based on toddler himself, I'd like was a
- 1:03historical figure from the beginning of the 20th century
- 1:07and I guess for most readers, it's more interesting to read a
- 1:12contemporary take rather than to take the historical thoughts.
- 1:17That probably seemed out of date.
- 1:19If they are red from today's perspective, Enjoy the
- 1:23conversation. So welcome party to our podcast
- 1:27episode about adlerian, Psychotherapy psychology and
- 1:31philosophy. Just to mention a few words
- 1:36about Alfred Adler himself. He was living in Austria.
- 1:43He was a contemporary of Sigmund, Freud.
- 1:47It's a little bit too much said that.
- 1:49He was a direct disciple or anything, but he was surely a
- 1:53visiting. This circles.
- 1:55The discussion circles that Floyd invited to, which
- 2:00consisted of myths, Sighs group of people who were very much
- 2:09interested in the discovery sort of void and to enhance on them.
- 2:16Either was one of the guys who after some years a little bit
- 2:20less than a decade officially left forward and founded his own
- 2:25psychoanalytic movement, an organization and idler became
- 2:32famous for a couple of things. The thing that is interesting
- 2:34here. Now we're talking about the
- 2:38beginning of the 20th century. The first and second Decades of
- 2:42the 20th century that toddler was one of the first proponents
- 2:47of a connection between mind and body.
- 2:49So this was not as common also, not kind of offensive or
- 2:57revolutionary in that sense. There are many allusions to a
- 3:00mind-body connection with Freud himself from the very Meaning of
- 3:04psychoanalysis but oddly emphasized it a little bit more.
- 3:09Arla also had an emphasis more on the societal function of
- 3:14psychology so we can roughly make the distinction that while
- 3:19Ford was very much interested in the individual and the progress
- 3:23of the individual toddler was a little bit more interested in
- 3:28how Society can use psychology and the results of psychology
- 3:33to. Approved Society.
- 3:36One of the strong elements and uglier and site psychology.
- 3:41And that respect is the emphasis that toddler put on education.
- 3:46So cut, child psychology and how children should be treated in
- 3:49our children. Should be educated, which gave
- 3:53him a much more pragmatic spin so that when one reads are Larry
- 4:00and thoughts and his books and so on, he's is Rest is much more
- 4:04that people understand where he's coming from, to give them
- 4:09very pragmatic ideas of how for example, to educate children.
- 4:13And how to reform the education system rather than as Sigmund
- 4:19Freud would be to go into the most complex details of the
- 4:23unconscious, mind up to a level where people hardly understood
- 4:27what it all meant and how all this is all connected.
- 4:31So for it was much more complex. In his theories and last
- 4:37distinction is that, whereas hopeful Freud, his idea was not
- 4:46so much to become happy, and his psychoanalysis was not in in
- 4:52most narrow sense. Psychotherapy, as we understand
- 4:55it today, it had many more philosophical aspects and had
- 5:00much more to do with a deep understanding.
- 5:03And oddly, Joe was very clearly on the Spectrum on the side of
- 5:07therapy. He wanted to make people happy
- 5:10and to give them tools for that. So, again, in this sense, they
- 5:15that you have quite different perspective on things and how
- 5:19their teachings should be dealt with and applied.
- 5:27Nevertheless again, we cannot under state that to kind of
- 5:31develop their thoughts and more Low wail for about 10 years and
- 5:36I'm sure that they continue to be influenced by each other even
- 5:40if it wasn't a more antagonistic, way afterwards,
- 5:43the there many connection points even if they're not spelled out,
- 5:46and even if we don't find them explicitly, for example, in all
- 5:50those books, okay. So far for short introduction.
- 5:54On their many interesting documentaries on YouTube to
- 5:57Wikipedia article is not bad. So, anyone who's interested in
- 6:01the graphical personal files laid out Other as welcome to
- 6:06read into that. I think it's always interesting
- 6:08to go back to the history of psychotherapy, but this is not
- 6:12our topic today. Today, we feel watch much more
- 6:15with adlerian psychology and philosophy, which means what was
- 6:21elaborated, mostly by the students of followers of our
- 6:25lives and for many decades afterwards.
- 6:28So it's not so much about necessarily what the person live
- 6:32without long road but But people developed out of his assistants
- 6:36and techniques and probably you read into some books, you got
- 6:42interested into this topic. Please tell us your perspective
- 6:47on things and what got you into it in the first place.
- 6:51Absolutely. So sadaq.
- 6:54The reason why I got interested was almost just like the title
- 6:59of off. The book that is written by.
- 7:05I can't pronounce the name, so we'll add it to the book notes.
- 7:07But it's because she meets on and Congress on.
- 7:11It's called the courage to be disliked and the second book
- 7:15series is called the courage to be happy to me.
- 7:19What was interesting was it? If it's not, it's called the
- 7:22courage to be disliked, but the second line of it is to how to
- 7:30finally stop. It says, one second, I have to
- 7:36fit, pull out in my notes. How do finally, I believe it
- 7:43says, sort of how to free yourself, change your life and
- 7:47Achieve real happiness, right? That becomes the Title which is
- 7:52very different and from what I understood and I have two or
- 7:57three topics that I wanted to just Deep dive and understand
- 8:00from you about that I had Larry and psychology.
- 8:04So the funny part about the book is its with the both these books
- 8:07are written and that Greek and you refer to it too as well.
- 8:12Is it that Greek psychology methodology where youth ask the
- 8:17question and the Philosopher's answers as opposed to More the,
- 8:21you know, the 19th century Freud or Jung point of view, all
- 8:25right, like and I am not one. I haven't really read too much
- 8:29into Freud and Jung, well, some into young.
- 8:32But but Freud the Freudian philosophy is sort of like very
- 8:37common which is, you know, your path.
- 8:40Like to me that what was very interesting about the book was
- 8:45Freud, almost just like, and we all grew up in that thinking
- 8:49that So if you understand your past that really really, you
- 8:55know, that really helps, you understand it, right?
- 8:59Like for me like I came to you and I was trying to, you know,
- 9:03work with you when the hypnotherapist with the all of
- 9:07that and even doing things like past life regression.
- 9:10Because I came from that from that mindset, or that, if you
- 9:15understand your past, you know, the future like will change.
- 9:20And what Adler? Interesting.
- 9:23Lisa is. So if you just like you give
- 9:27context to your past, if you are in a good mind or if you're in a
- 9:31good safe, you'll be like, oh yeah, those are good
- 9:32experiences. I had the challenges.
- 9:35Whereas if you're going through a tough time, you end up saying
- 9:39this, you know, this was like, you know, because my parents did
- 9:44this to me or because this happened to me in my past.
- 9:48Hence I cannot become That's for famous whatever you desires you
- 9:52have. And even though, like I myself
- 9:57have like, you know, work through some of my own past
- 10:01issues. I don't know how much of it do
- 10:06to believe, like one of the titles are in the book and when
- 10:09they talked about earlier and psychology's and the believe
- 10:12that like the past does not matter, right?
- 10:15To really was like a fairly infuriating statement, right?
- 10:19Because Someone Club had has been raped or if you don't even
- 10:25want to go, that far, you can be like, you know, my parents
- 10:30always are comparing me to somebody to my older brother or
- 10:36sister and I always felt like I wasn't good.
- 10:39Like how do you what is your sort of tape on does the past
- 10:43matter, or does it not matter? Because, you know, there's so
- 10:46many different schools of thought around it.
- 10:49Yeah. Yes.
- 10:50So just before we started the recording, we agreed we would
- 10:54like to go deeply into topics. So there will be some branches
- 10:58to this and I would like to get a good grip on it in a certain
- 11:06way. I think it's super obvious that
- 11:08the past matters. There is just an effectual
- 11:13level. If my parents were rich and I
- 11:17inherited some of the fortune or I have access to these
- 11:22resources, I can do many more things I can.
- 11:26I can build companies in a different way than I could.
- 11:29If I was poor, I have access to social strata in a different way
- 11:33than I thought it was poor of access to people and other
- 11:36resources, Etc. This is not just because of the
- 11:40And or what I think now. And so on this is purely a
- 11:44result of a structural advantage that I got in the past.
- 11:48Similarly, if I if I was loved a lot, then I it's just a simple
- 11:57concept that I would have more confidence than people who were
- 12:00denied any kind of love or who were not reinforced as children.
- 12:06So what I'm saying is that obviously the past contributes
- 12:10to a different starting point. Right.
- 12:13Exactly right. So that's why that was my
- 12:15origination with the book itself was the past doesn't matter it's
- 12:21like you know those are all the facts you know that that play
- 12:28into who you are today, right? Yes.
- 12:31Now I'm not sure how the authors of these books on the stood out
- 12:36so we have to free float, a little bit but let's assume that
- 12:41there is something valid. To it.
- 12:43So under, which circumstances would it be right to say the
- 12:47past doesn't matter? And to me, one of the
- 12:50circumstances would be in a context to encourage people.
- 12:55If I want to encourage people, if I have them if I'm a
- 12:58motivational speaker, if I'm a coach then I would like to
- 13:02downplay the effect of the past because my goal is to support
- 13:09the individual, the person to change into improve for me.
- 13:13Whatever they do. So my goal in that sense would
- 13:16be to put them into a positive bubble and to brainwash them
- 13:21into thinking that everything is possible for them.
- 13:26And that, in this sense, the past does not matter.
- 13:30I would hope that they believe me all that.
- 13:31I kind of put a convincing bubble around them, so that they
- 13:35really feel encouraged and empowered.
- 13:38And that, then next steps, the next decisions would not be
- 13:42guided by the limitations that de facto came from the past.
- 13:47But they would mean much more oriented by their hopes, by
- 13:51their wishes by their own goals, and what would make them?
- 13:56Be. So here we have an interesting
- 14:00dynamic between past and present, right?
- 14:02Someone who believes that, they are entirely determined by the
- 14:05past, my dream of a positive future or whatever.
- 14:10They would like to do and their life.
- 14:12But they they would be held back probably by thinking that, in
- 14:19fact, they're very much limited. But by how they grew up and what
- 14:22they experienced in the past, Yeah, I see what you're saying.
- 14:27So you're saying that, you know what, you have to Like so what
- 14:35you're saying is like interview, what you do is you sort of talk
- 14:39about understand the past but then you start to encourage them
- 14:42to live the way they want to sort of love.
- 14:46Right? Is that is that what you're
- 14:48saying? So, yes, partly.
- 14:50I tap into this mindset, of course, I want to be careful,
- 14:53not to be too fantastic about it.
- 14:57I was thinking occasions are still there, but apart from
- 15:01psychology or Psychotherapy that Several contexts were actually
- 15:05something like this place. If you think about a military
- 15:09training for example it's hard to imagine the people's someone
- 15:13would say look, Lieutenant, don't treat me too harshly.
- 15:16I had a rough childhood and you know yeah, that would wouldn't
- 15:21go very well with the Educators there.
- 15:24Yeah. The same--and highly competitive
- 15:27companies, where the mindset would be look, we don't care
- 15:31where you're coming from, you have it, you have an
- 15:33opportunity. Here, if you want to grow, you
- 15:35better believe in yourself and you better bring some numbers.
- 15:39But it is a internal 9 PSI, right?
- 15:42Like, that is n. It's funny because in La he just
- 15:46says, oh, you can just switch and you can just, you know, you
- 15:50can like it literally is like sent in multiple times in these
- 15:53books is oh, you can just choose to be happy or you can just
- 15:58choose to have a different personality or an attitude in
- 16:03life. But how is that even possible?
- 16:06Right? Like take your example of that
- 16:08corporate. Right?
- 16:09Like you are you got you got into a company and they don't
- 16:12care. They just want you to prove the
- 16:15numbers be good, but it is your own mindset and your own, you
- 16:23know, you have those subconscious behaviors, like,
- 16:26you know, your ability to self sabotage or you feeling
- 16:31unconfident, not feeling confident because the you have
- 16:35always been told you weren't good enough.
- 16:38Like, how do they not play a path part in it?
- 16:42Right, like you cannot. Just tell yourself.
- 16:44Oh, starting today I'm now going to feel, you know, I'm not going
- 16:48to even though my parents told me that I wasn't good enough.
- 16:51I'm going to feel I'm good enough starting today, even
- 16:54though my parents, like, you know, how do you do that?
- 16:56That's it's not even. It's not even practical or
- 16:59possible. Is my question.
- 17:01Yes, I think it's very practical, but not in an instant
- 17:05decision, not at least, in the point.
- 17:07It's more of a process. That several people have to be
- 17:10committed to in order for it to work.
- 17:13Let's say in a company there is a mentoring system, right?
- 17:16Right. Mentos are supposed to be to be
- 17:20open to the potential of the people person that they're
- 17:23mentoring and to have, of course, you know, more growth
- 17:30more development in mind. They would not be interested so
- 17:33much of limitation. They would be very much
- 17:35interested in growth of the person.
- 17:38Okay. So They would come in with this
- 17:39mindset and they would generally encourage the person which I
- 17:42look you can do this. I've seen you for the last one
- 17:45and a half years, I know what you can do and then the person
- 17:49would come in with these limitations of look I don't know
- 17:52I don't believe in myself so much I'm not I don't know, if
- 17:55I'm cut out for this management position that you want to push
- 17:59me to, okay? And then the mental would would
- 18:02be cunning in the way of presenting.
- 18:06If if I were jogging, if I was talking to you, this is what
- 18:09you've done in the past. Look at this.
- 18:10This project was fantastic. You did that.
- 18:13It was good. Now there's a little bit of
- 18:15gouging is like morning, maybe. I can actually do that and then
- 18:17I come up with, okay. You know what I understand?
- 18:21Maybe you're not cut out for this.
- 18:23Maybe you're right. Let's try, let's experiment in
- 18:26the next three months. Go to work in the next three
- 18:29months with a mindset that you can actually do it, do things a
- 18:32little bit differently, be more open to conversations, allow
- 18:36yourself to think big and if it doesn't work then it doesn't
- 18:39work. And if it does then fine then
- 18:41maybe you are after all different than you thought.
- 18:44So in this kind of process, when I encourage someone to step out
- 18:47of their comfort zone and to make experiences that contradict
- 18:52my belief and my limitations, I might end up getting expelled.
- 18:57Appearances where indeed, after all, I tell myself, okay,
- 19:01thought that I was much more limited, but now I have to
- 19:04admit, I thought that I can do everything and anything but I
- 19:08have to admit. Yes, there's more there's more
- 19:11to get for me than what I thought before.
- 19:14So that actually brings us to sort of the second point in this
- 19:19whole at live in Psychology that I am very unsure about is he
- 19:25says not like Adler and his Department.
- 19:28Disciples have all said, you should not be praising.
- 19:32Anybody you should not obviously be revealed in anybody, but you
- 19:36shouldn't praise someone else either.
- 19:38Because if you praise me, or if you praise, and it comes back
- 19:43again to what you mentioned, Which is a child psychology,
- 19:46right now, you have, if you start to pray somebody or and
- 19:51say, you know what, you did a really great job here and you
- 19:53did a really great job. There you are now sort of making
- 19:59them dependent psychology psychologically on on yourself
- 20:04right now. There are they will always look
- 20:06for appreciation and the minute they get appreciation.
- 20:09They will be like, okay I'm going to work harder and the
- 20:13winner, they are appreciated. They won't get, they won't work
- 20:16harder and I know this is like some of my own personal problem
- 20:20where I always read that external validation.
- 20:25But the question like to me, like I kind of understood like,
- 20:31you know, you should you should encourage your child to be
- 20:34self-reliant and be happy. Like if they want to, you should
- 20:38praise them for reading a book. Well then they're just looking
- 20:41for the praising. Not looking to lawn or enjoy
- 20:43reading a A book or in your scenario the employee is going
- 20:49to just like work hard enough just so they can get praised and
- 20:53the minute they stop getting encouragement or Praises.
- 20:57They will Bill stop. You know they'll stop working on
- 21:00them working on a project and they'll get very demotivated and
- 21:05it will go back in that Loop now Adela Dusty.
- 21:09So he says, don't praise and do not rebuke, obviously, but you
- 21:15can encourage. So now the question is, like,
- 21:18what's even the difference between praising and
- 21:20encouraging? Because to me, they won't sound
- 21:22fairly similar, right? So, yes, obviously there is,
- 21:30there is some issue there, right?
- 21:33Because so much in our life, depends on encouragement of
- 21:36reinforcement. So, under which circumstances
- 21:39again, does it make sense to have a philosophy like this?
- 21:42Let me make the comparison to Alternative preschools and
- 21:48schools that exist with children are not compared to each other
- 21:52rights are literal children. Getting tasks if you want to do
- 21:55it, do it. Nobody tells you how to do it,
- 21:59you know, in the end. Everyone is the same and I don't
- 22:01want. I'm okay.
- 22:03Now, experience shows and some friends of mine have been to
- 22:07such a drink Of schools. But only a certain type of
- 22:10children benefit from this. This is not for everyone.
- 22:15Certain kids who are driven internally driven by their own
- 22:21motivation, who enjoy to discover things to find, things
- 22:25out, who enjoy to do things, their own way, they benefit from
- 22:29such an environment This who, for whatever reason be it, you
- 22:35know, the environment of the first years and how they grew up
- 22:39with their parents or because they're so disposed for the
- 22:42reasons, they don't, they, you know, they are lazy, they don't
- 22:47feel encouraged. They don't feel motivated, and
- 22:50they end up learning much much less because they don't have
- 22:53this in a driving force. Or they need much more
- 22:57structure, you know? So they would need at least some
- 23:00hints of how to do things or there would need to be told to
- 23:04it until then or do it like this and so on.
- 23:06So you know in different degrees they would need some support and
- 23:11structure and encouragement from the outside and for them more
- 23:16normal school. Environment is better Suited.
- 23:22So that's interesting because I do feel like I, you know, a lot
- 23:27of a lot, many people would be in that second category, where,
- 23:32you know, they just not internally motivated.
- 23:35So, what what even makes both of them?
- 23:38Like, I do believe that everybody would be internally
- 23:41motivated or, you know, and would figure it out.
- 23:45But like what makes one person be internally motivated and
- 23:49another not be internal. Motivated at all.
- 23:53Just want to do it but not not do it right?
- 23:57Yeah. So such an attitude from me is
- 24:00is too philosophical and not reality-based.
- 24:04I worked for a couple of years as a social worker, and I've
- 24:07mentioned that and doing, we're in a work with young adults.
- 24:14Who had psychological major psychological issues and we
- 24:19worked with the premise that everyone can change.
- 24:22Everyone can become rehabilitated.
- 24:24Everyone can have a simple job and provide for themselves and
- 24:28at least grow, you know, responsibility and so on.
- 24:34Yes. But some people need a lot more
- 24:38work for that a lot, more work and investment, physical
- 24:44investment. Like a needs a lot of money for
- 24:46the country to support and devils like this and social
- 24:50system and others obviously don't need encouragement at all.
- 24:54Like they in other cases that the state doesn't have to worry
- 24:59about the development of people because they do it themselves.
- 25:02So while philosophically I Say yes, it's probably true that
- 25:06everyone can be theoretically self-determined self-motivated
- 25:10and so on. But in practice what we as
- 25:14parents adults Educators, would have to pull off to bring that
- 25:19child that, that individual was not so inclined to that state of
- 25:23self-determination. It's just, it's not, it's not
- 25:30feasible, you know, on a pragmatic level at some point,
- 25:34the people in charge of the resources will have to cap it
- 25:36and say we're fine with how things are like, you will
- 25:41survive, she will survive. It's fine.
- 25:44We don't have to make them the most fully, liberated
- 25:47self-determined person. So this is where I think the
- 25:50pragmatics kind of bring a limitation to this kind of
- 25:53mindset. So that's, that's interesting,
- 25:58right? So and Adler.
- 26:02Or in this in these books. Especially the second one.
- 26:05They give the story about how Adler.
- 26:09There's this woman, who had been sort of like, sent to a mental
- 26:13institution and Austria and where she was literally acting
- 26:17like a dog, right? Like barking biting people take
- 26:21like snatching at them a tractor and like, all Adler's core of
- 26:26dead was like respected her as an individual and believed in.
- 26:32And acted like that friend. And and then apparently like,
- 26:37you know, somehow too long to the, to the counseling sessions
- 26:41duvet intense, he didn't say, you know, they were intense
- 26:44counseling sessions like a couple weeks.
- 26:47She became entirely self reliant and nobody would, you know, even
- 26:51know looking at her that like she had been acting so
- 26:54bizarrely. And in a Blow, he talks about,
- 26:58oh, you just need to, you know, as a human Being you need to
- 27:03realize that your you as a human being even if you are just
- 27:07sitting in your room and doing nothing at all, you're still
- 27:11contributing to the society to me that part was weird and then
- 27:17coming back to your point of view of, you know, motivating on
- 27:21on motivating. Like it's that internal voice
- 27:25for. Like I think I kind of agree
- 27:28with you and I don't agree with and live in Psychology that oh,
- 27:32you Just, you know, you can just sort of like, you can choose to
- 27:35just love yourself and give love to people and just by giving
- 27:41love the way Mother Teresa said it and all of that.
- 27:44Like, you can just choose to start loving one other people.
- 27:49But you can also you also need to simultaneously just build a
- 27:52belief system that you are needed in this world.
- 27:56And you're contributing by just even breathing and just living
- 28:00and not doing anything else sitting in a room.
- 28:02And You're still contributing to the world and that is good
- 28:05enough, but you need to build up belief system and that's what
- 28:08counselors are supposed to do. Yes.
- 28:12So it's something that we missed.
- 28:15Yeah. Fairly idealistic because to me.
- 28:19Okay, I do understand that, you know, and the way he explained
- 28:23it was even if you're just sitting in a room, all
- 28:26depressed, not meeting people, not doing anything.
- 28:29And and if you think that you don't have any You have to be
- 28:33doing because you go to the grocery store and you provide
- 28:37you know you're helping the growth the employee at the
- 28:41grocery store make money and you know we just sort of like
- 28:44helping that entire Logistics chain.
- 28:47So there's like you know even if you're not connected to the
- 28:49world you are kind of connected which is kind of interesting
- 28:53doing because I generally am off the opposite belief system.
- 28:57That says, if you're not contributing significantly, are
- 29:00you even you know, I really don't even need to exist kind of
- 29:05thing but that he believes he said that like you know every
- 29:09human being sort of like how it just because they're born is
- 29:14sort of like contributing to the world and they should have that
- 29:16belief system internally and Theoretically, I kind of like
- 29:22what he said, right? Like, it's sort of like,
- 29:24resonated deeply. But do you agree with with that?
- 29:28Like, it would that kind of thinking.
- 29:31Like, how do you make that kind of thinking stick in someone's
- 29:35head? Well, my question would be for
- 29:38whom. Is this message meant?
- 29:40Is it for the people who are just depressed and home and
- 29:44leave once a week to go out to the groceries and to support the
- 29:48economic system, a little bit like that.
- 29:50But these are the people are supposed to buy it that they are
- 29:54contributing to society. And the valuable people to me,
- 29:57it sounds like a political message for the people who are
- 30:00fortunate, not to look down on those who, who are not and to
- 30:07continue to encourage them and to continue to To have kind of a
- 30:11positive mindset towards that and so on, because I, if I would
- 30:17be depressed at home and someone came to me and told me, look,
- 30:20your valuable person, like, no matter what you do, still use
- 30:25somehow contribute, I would, I would think it's very
- 30:28condescending and, you know, bullshitting I would not buy it.
- 30:33I mean, maybe I already believe it yet to hear it right, but
- 30:36it's almost convincing attitude because Society is not like
- 30:42this, just have to turn on TV or Internet.
- 30:45Like, who are the people? Who are praised, the people who
- 30:47stay at home and are depressed? No, this is not the image that I
- 30:49get. Exactly is like, the people who
- 30:53found, the billion-dollar companies who all look,
- 30:55beautiful, who seem to have no issues, the Instagram models.
- 31:00And so on. This is so from the millions of
- 31:03voices, The carries carry this message.
- 31:06Then there is one person or, you know, kind of a depression
- 31:09self-help group, where these kind of messages, the positive
- 31:13messages that aren't worthy with this kind of messages on spread.
- 31:17Now, again, I'm not, I'm not saying what is true or not,
- 31:19which is almost a pointless philosophical point for me, I'm
- 31:24not really interested in the truth of something, but what is
- 31:29this message for who can use it? In the end, someone is addressed
- 31:37by it. And I don't understand exactly
- 31:39who because, in my experience, just for few people, maybe this
- 31:45would be working psychotherapeutic attitude,
- 31:50right? But most and most cases, I think
- 31:56that At least the therapeutic different.
- 32:01Therapeutic procedure of getting out of the depression and
- 32:04becoming more active, take care of oneself and so on would be
- 32:08more promising. Yes, but I would like a sort of
- 32:13like the question then becomes like how do you like in the
- 32:19book? It talks about like you know you
- 32:21are sort of like you contribute to the world, right?
- 32:25Like that feeling of contribution or sort of just by
- 32:28that existence of that example that I said but like and that is
- 32:32what leads you to sort of Happiness, right?
- 32:35Okay, but again, please answer me the question, who do you
- 32:38think is this message for Yeah. And like, I told you agree with
- 32:42you, like it is more for that individual like, you know, the
- 32:47very end the very much that Western world like first world
- 32:52problem of somebody who has all the money, and he's just like,
- 32:56you know, I think of it as like, Rockefellers care, it
- 32:59grandchild, really grandchildren, sitting in the
- 33:02room and wondering, oh, I don't add any value.
- 33:05I have so much money. I don't even need to work.
- 33:08What should I be doing? Then yeah, just like just the
- 33:12fact that their existing and they have like, you know, people
- 33:16helping them and the people that they pay salaries for to make to
- 33:20them, maybe that philosophy will work for example, middle-class
- 33:26families, where the kid, my kid comes home and says, well,
- 33:29there's a new kid in class and he's poor and you stings, I
- 33:32don't like him. I wish it would go away this
- 33:35kind of thing and then I would come in with my educational
- 33:38acutely, look, everyone is Is worthy, you shouldn't look down
- 33:42on other people, Everyone contributes in some way you know
- 33:46it would be kind of a nice but but what but would that kid
- 34:06kids or even? Yes, well, this is a complex
- 34:15process, which goes back to when you introduce the second point
- 34:20of reinforcement and encouragement and so on, because
- 34:25one of the processes is not necessarily that I become
- 34:29dependent on the praise. One of the idea is one of my
- 34:34hopes as an educator one parent. Is that my praise gets
- 34:38internalized. And that, the kids does it
- 34:41because not because I praise the kid for reading a book, but
- 34:46because the kid starts to praise itself for reading a book, And
- 34:51that's what he said. Yeah.
- 34:52Like yeah. Like that was that's the whole
- 34:56psychology behind craving is eventually you'll get
- 34:59internalised but Adler says that should not be done at all
- 35:03because the kid needs to get the voice internally and you're
- 35:07saying that some people will never have that internal drive
- 35:11or yes. Yes and let's let's go a little
- 35:14bit further. There would be negative about
- 35:18such a process of having an internalized.
- 35:20Voice of Praise obviously. The good thing is that it frees
- 35:24me as a parent to constantly reinforce, right?
- 35:27So yeah, let's not get into this dependency but what would be a -
- 35:31why, why to discover some such a process?
- 35:36I think then you have now a person who is very much who's
- 35:42very much like, oh I know what I'm doing and I'm very happy
- 35:45with what I'm doing and they're just like, you know, the
- 35:48self-satisfied Weirdos that sometimes we run against like
- 35:54who are unable to learn because they are just like, oh yeah, I
- 35:58know everything. And I'm I'm worked on this for
- 36:00like the past. I've worked you find these
- 36:03people right over. Like I've worked in this for the
- 36:06I've worked on this thing for the past 15 years.
- 36:09Hence I'm an expert and I'm I'm I'm now going to learn anything
- 36:13new, all right? Because they've internalized,
- 36:15the thing that they are they're very satisfied internally from
- 36:20Where they are. Yes.
- 36:22So that little bit to satisfy the too complacent about how
- 36:26much they should be open to me from from my work, I see
- 36:34potential big problem there, when kids are encouraged to do
- 36:37something, then internalize it and then it becomes a rigid
- 36:42formula for feeling good. So if I as your parent encourage
- 36:48you to study and learn might be successful in school and so on
- 36:54and that would get internalised and a relatively rigid way.
- 36:58What I mean with the rigid is that whenever you feel
- 37:01uncomfortable we'll go to way to feel good again with yourself.
- 37:07As you would pick up a skill and learn something, right?
- 37:11And that would make you feel good.
- 37:15Okay, possibly, but it has a limitation that's the thing.
- 37:19So if for example, there are some things that we extension we
- 37:23need, for example, friendship, and relationship, and intimacy
- 37:25right now, I would raise you in a rather secluded way.
- 37:29So you wouldn't have great social skills and you would
- 37:33comfort yourself with skill development and reading.
- 37:37And because of that, you would be very discreet, social
- 37:42situations and partnership stuff.
- 37:44And so on would be so uncomfortable that you with
- 37:47years would get much less experience with that other kids.
- 37:51So, kids obviously have a learning curve there, and you
- 37:55have to go through some horrible experiences, unfortunately, in
- 37:58your puberty and your early adulthood.
- 38:01So that eventually, you know, a little bit what to do with
- 38:03yourself, and how to deal with relationships.
- 38:05So you have to go through this discomfort Right.
- 38:08But the way that I've raised you would effectively prohibit you
- 38:12to go through this discomfort. Because each time when you feel
- 38:15lonely, or if along comfortable, you would get a gonna learn
- 38:18something. Then you might end up as a 25 30
- 38:21year, old without prior experience, and relationship
- 38:25being great at skills, but not knowing what to do with this.
- 38:29Excellent existential part of yourself.
- 38:31That cannot be compensated, where, you know, part of you
- 38:35mind body screams that you Really want to be loved and to
- 38:38love someone being relationship. So, you know that but it seems,
- 38:42you know, like the Gap seems unbridgeable. so because none of
- 38:47the skills that you have because your default mode is kind of
- 38:51learning and skill building All right, so this rigidity this for
- 38:55me, what I see kind of as practical limitations for, when
- 39:00you get, when I am a difficult parent, but I put say, I'm
- 39:05allowed alcoholic father, right? You would learn a very specific
- 39:10approach of how to avoid trouble, which is often to be
- 39:14quiet. Especially a to be quiet and to
- 39:17disappear right now to relationships and as an adult
- 39:22you You have at your hand and you should have that your hand
- 39:27versatility of tools to sometimes be quiet, kind of
- 39:31given and compromise to sometimes.
- 39:33Stand up for yourself to sometimes be proactive.
- 39:36Like all these things should be there to have a good
- 39:38relationship, but because of your past because of
- 39:41circumstances encouraged you to pursue a very specific style
- 39:46when it comes to stress, which is fighting to disappear, you
- 39:49would not have those more active tools available to you.
- 39:54Right. So, in this would be a direct
- 39:56effect of a very specific reinforcement, appraisal, and
- 40:01encouragement as we can, which is very interesting.
- 40:07Things like sort of like the other topic.
- 40:09That, and he did mention around that fact was, you know, like
- 40:14some somewhere on the age of 10. He said, like you said a form
- 40:17that personality that you live like that, most people live with
- 40:21throughout their life, right? Right, you know, like you said,
- 40:24write like that kid who has allowed abusive father, just
- 40:28the, you know, the girl child decides to become more quiet and
- 40:32withdraw and just uses that tool throughout their life.
- 40:37What he says, is at any given moment, right?
- 40:41Like, as you grow up, You, you can just choose to say, okay,
- 40:47you know what, I'm not going to be held down by, by that, and
- 40:50I'm going to just choose one, new personality and we can
- 40:56determine our. Like, the line that I think he
- 40:58said was we can determine our lives.
- 41:02According to the meaning, we give to the past experiences and
- 41:05we can sort of change change that attitude immediately.
- 41:09We can just say, you know what, from now on, I'm not going to
- 41:12let that Behavior drive me anymore and I'll just change and
- 41:17to meet that did not really resonate because if if there's a
- 41:21tool around, hola me now, try to engage or speak up.
- 41:26If I have never practiced already done that too, little be
- 41:29very tough for me to just suddenly say, oh yeah, sure, I'm
- 41:33going to like that, that tool isn't even on my radar, right?
- 41:37Like to read that. That was very fairly annoying
- 41:40about about this whole whole system.
- 41:45And then, then the questions out of the guns is like, how do you
- 41:49know what is the right tool, right?
- 41:51Like, what does the right mindset and in a guy he
- 41:56obviously didn't like they didn't like these are like two
- 41:59big box that you end up reading and you have you're not thinking
- 42:03about it, but they never talk about.
- 42:06How do you like, how do you know what's the right thought
- 42:11process, right. Like What does the right tool to
- 42:14use in a particular situation? Or if what you're thinking of
- 42:19is, even the right thing to think of, right?
- 42:21So an example that I had was, you know, people in kids in the
- 42:27u.s. in the 20s and 30s, they have a very different mindset,
- 42:33right? Like they are there.
- 42:34Move to New York City. Their parents come and visit,
- 42:38and they'll come stay in a hotel and they'll just go spend a
- 42:41couple hours with them. They'll spend.
- 42:43Perhaps a full day, the parents will buy them food or whatever,
- 42:47right? Like it's a very much like, the
- 42:49parents are gonna, go stay in a hotel, not gonna stay with you.
- 42:52Whereas, in India, like I come from India and in India when my
- 42:57parents come and present their going to stay for six months and
- 43:00there's no question that they're going to stay in a hotel,
- 43:02they're going to stay in my house and they expect to be
- 43:07close to be 24/7 and neither do. I agree with that whole bastard.
- 43:13Then the us or the American way of saying that old, my parents
- 43:17need to know stay in a hotel and just like we're going to stay as
- 43:20guests but neither do I like what I see neither.
- 43:26Do I like, my, the traditional Indian mindset either because
- 43:30that's also not certain well, but I don't know what the right
- 43:33answer is right. Like, how do you use that new?
- 43:37How do you set a new person thinking or that you way and
- 43:41say, okay, I am I'm going to, you know, just use some other
- 43:47something else altogether, whereas, you know that like you
- 43:49know, there's going to be there's going to be pushed back
- 43:52with the people you've left with right, your parents, your family
- 43:55at Sakura that he never really answers in the book and just
- 44:00choosing a new personality or in choosing to be happy to meet
- 44:04that. As something that is, I do not
- 44:07agree with kind of and I'm not sure how it even works.
- 44:12Does it even make sense? Yes.
- 44:14But to me it sounds again, it sounds to me, inspirational.
- 44:17It's not to be meant to be a guideline of how to actually
- 44:22achieve this. But rather to open up the
- 44:25possibility that this is somehow possible and that then as an
- 44:29individual and go on the journey to find out how it's possible
- 44:33for me, but if this is not provided by them, they sound
- 44:37much more philosophically minded can person actually.
- 44:43Psychologically. So that there would show a path
- 44:46of. Okay, that's hard.
- 44:47You start and the beginning, you will get to these obstacles in
- 44:52the middle. You will get two different
- 44:53obstacles and them hardest obstacles.
- 44:55These, you deal with them so it's not procession professional
- 44:59in that sense. And obviously the question that
- 45:04you raised for example, in such mixed culture circumstances,
- 45:10where not only are you Modern Indian descent woman but living
- 45:16in the US with your family, Fairly spread out over the
- 45:22continents. So how to deal with that?
- 45:24Well, for such a complex thing. How can you imagine that you
- 45:28will find the answer in a book. You won't.
- 45:31So that's a book like that. Best can give you maybe The
- 45:38Inspirations like yes, damn it. They're right.
- 45:41There must be a better way for me.
- 45:43The most new way for me to reinvent myself.
- 45:45So that I'm not just stuck with the expectations of my parents
- 45:49or the overly distant formula of the West, that it provides must
- 45:55be something that just fits for for me very well.
- 45:58And I want to be happy. Like when folks say you can
- 46:02choose to be happy, then I can take this as the starting point.
- 46:06Yes, I want to be happy. Right.
- 46:09Yeah, when it comes to the question of how and this how is
- 46:15a very specific thing highly specific which does not mean
- 46:21much except for you have to try you have to think and you have
- 46:26to try it will not figure it out entirely by books and there you
- 46:29will have good ideas but unless it's a book that is specifically
- 46:34written for you and you're very rich, it will be a mixture.
- 46:38Our of tools that somehow prove to be interesting or effective.
- 46:43So what we do as a process is we do take these books, we read
- 46:48them, we go to therapy with to cook two councillors.
- 46:51We want YouTube videos and inspirational talks, and we
- 46:55start to implement small things to see how they work.
- 47:00We get discouraged if they don't work at all.
- 47:02If there's a lot of pick, a lot of backlash and we get
- 47:05encouraged when we see that, we can fairly nicely implement it
- 47:09and that the environment reacts with maybe a little bit of
- 47:13irritation that we do something different.
- 47:15But logically, they seem to accept it, then I'm encouraged
- 47:18to go on in this direction. So there's a lot of Missin,
- 47:22Missin hit their pajamas and a lot of trial and error And in
- 47:28the end, I hope that because I tried a verse things and I
- 47:31continue to be confident and this is again, where these
- 47:33operational aspect of these kind of books come and I don't get, I
- 47:37don't let kind of Misfortune discourage me.
- 47:41I continue I'm stubbornly insisting on my right to be
- 47:46happy and that somehow it could and should be done with this
- 47:51Force. I continue to experiment, I
- 47:53continue to evaluate and eventually with such an open
- 47:58mindedness and encouraged to continue to try new things.
- 48:03It will in comparison with someone who's much more timid of
- 48:06course with time. I will amass so many more tools
- 48:09that I have experience with and More or less the other person
- 48:13who does not believe that they have the right to be happy.
- 48:16What does not believe that they can change themselves?
- 48:18They will naturally. As a result of this kind of
- 48:21mindset, they will try much much less and we'll be at the whims
- 48:24of Fate, you know, they might need a great friend and then
- 48:29that was luck, the friend encourage them and they will
- 48:32find something. You the proactive person with
- 48:35kind of inspirational mindset just has a much higher
- 48:38probability to We stumble upon those things that makes them a
- 48:44little bit happier or in the end, quite much happier.
- 48:49So that's actually interesting because he does.
- 48:53Like sort of say that, you know like you have to have you said
- 48:57like you know that mentality or that want to continue trying to
- 49:01be happy, right? And he uses the word in the
- 49:03courage to be happy and he does sort of like mention that you
- 49:07know you need to be self-reliant.
- 49:11In a way that like, you need to say to yourself, you need to
- 49:15stop expecting others. To love you.
- 49:19Write, like, you need to stop expecting your parents like,
- 49:24nobody's gonna love. You like your mother.
- 49:25I'd like to give to that example.
- 49:27Even though, you know, not everybody has like a super
- 49:32loving mother, but, but like, you need to say to yourself
- 49:37that, oh I I am. I need to Love my self, right?
- 49:43Like you need to love your own self and then you choose the
- 49:47life to be happy. And you say, okay I'm going to
- 49:50continue trying and like I said, right?
- 49:52Like undoubtedly a massive yourself but how do you build
- 49:56that like it? I keep coming back to that same
- 50:00thing as like. How do you build that voice in
- 50:02your head or that mindset to say?
- 50:05Okay. I'm going to love myself right?
- 50:07Like and how do you choose that like to me that is the That I
- 50:12don't think either the book or I have still understood now, is
- 50:17how do you, how do you say? Okay, you know what, I do love
- 50:21myself. I do to visual upon myself,
- 50:24right? Like, even though I'm not
- 50:26perfect, or even though I have like 10 inferior, like, I have
- 50:30an inferiority complex. And I have all these different
- 50:33issues that in the book, he talks about just sort of like,
- 50:39you know, choosing to do. And this Which kind of like
- 50:42really irritating me. But, but how would you, how
- 50:46would you? How would you recommend?
- 50:48Like people go about just saying, okay, you know what, I
- 50:53am going to choose to like try and figure out go on this route.
- 51:00Again, this is very difficult to depends on where the person is,
- 51:03Right? Some people are fortunate, such
- 51:06unfortunate that they are a point at the point where they
- 51:09have nothing more to lose And for some of these, now, this is
- 51:14not guaranteed path but some of these who are in such a
- 51:19desperate situation for them, a flip like this happens, you
- 51:25know, they would have thoughts like what am I afraid of?
- 51:30I'm already ridiculed. I'm already alone.
- 51:33I already have no job. Yeah.
- 51:35The people who had like a rock bottom.
- 51:37Yes they hit. Rock bottom was like okay I've
- 51:39nothing else to lose. And I'm not even interested in
- 51:42any part of my personality anymore.
- 51:44I don't care. Nothing.
- 51:47Nothing of this means anything to me anymore.
- 51:49So they have a mental Readiness of dispassion often, not holding
- 51:54on of not attack, being attached to parts of their personality or
- 51:57parts of the biography. And they're my everything that
- 52:00they went through is just shit and they're not interested in it
- 52:02anymore. Which might under certain
- 52:05circumstances. Open up a window off.
- 52:08Okay, everything past gone. I'm just rested in the now.
- 52:13No bullshit anymore and so on, right?
- 52:18For most people that are too weak.
- 52:20When a very desperate, they cannot achieve this, but for
- 52:23some people, it works. And if you read books like a
- 52:26Cataldo, for example, he was, yeah, he's like that, right?
- 52:31The other people who are by far not so, so bad.
- 52:38And such a bad state to have many more resources at hand and
- 52:43they would come through to, as a conclusion like this.
- 52:47A much more observation you know they might be middle class, they
- 52:53might be guided through the limitations of their life then
- 52:56they go to a workshop and they hear stories of kind of real
- 53:01people, you know not YouTube. Inspirational stuff.
- 53:05That is making me suspicious anyhow if it's real or not, but
- 53:10I go to a workshop, let's say, you know, a woman workshop and
- 53:15and there's a woman's life. Look I This is what my life was
- 53:18like, and I recognized it as well I am.
- 53:21And then I realized the relationship is not right for
- 53:24me. So I divorced from my husband
- 53:27and it's like, oh, I'm in a bad relationship.
- 53:30I never thought, I could allow myself these thoughts of
- 53:33divorcing. And since I'm divorced, The
- 53:35Other Woman continues, I continued to be good to myself
- 53:40and to live the life that I want to live and so on.
- 53:43Okay. And I have such an experience, I
- 53:45go home. It's like, oh man, this is a
- 53:47real person. And it never occurred to me that
- 53:50I could do something like this, like, this courage, and then I
- 53:53sit with it for a while and it starts to grow like a positive
- 53:57two more inside of me until it cannot be denied anymore.
- 54:00It's like, I have to do this. Where was this coming from?
- 54:04Through an inspirational real convincing and counter with
- 54:10another person with a blueprint. That seems so relatable to me
- 54:15that it has an immediate and effect that I can't forget.
- 54:20So this is, I think something like this is more likely and
- 54:26it's based on real encounters that we have in life that can
- 54:30truly Inspire us. You know, it doesn't have to be
- 54:32in such a big way but just that makes me understand.
- 54:36Why am I limiting myself like this?
- 54:39Such a big world out there and I can do so much more than what
- 54:43I've done. Why do I settle for?
- 54:45The unhappiness that I've been going through so this will be
- 54:49much more common. Now if people go to therapy or
- 54:53counseling or something that has unfortunately the touch of being
- 54:58fake right? Because I go to someone and I
- 55:02pay them to tell me what to do and this will immediately change
- 55:06the situation so I cannot fully take them for seriously and what
- 55:14they say because So I think that, well, Kate Spade job.
- 55:17They don't really like me be the like me, but it partly like me
- 55:20because of my job. They talk to me because of their
- 55:23job. It's better than being them.
- 55:25Yeah. Yes.
- 55:27Which is why in a therapeutic relationship, trust is so
- 55:30important. And which is why for me, it's so
- 55:33important not to cuddle too much.
- 55:37My clients that I a lot of kind of honest feedback.
- 55:41Yeah. You don't come at all, I am.
- 55:45An idea. Yeah, in the beginning, you were
- 55:50knife, then it's all being nice. So, yes, which is which has its
- 55:55downside. But at least I think it adds
- 55:57more authenticity, and people might take a little bit more.
- 56:01Seriously, the things that I do recommend over you, give
- 56:04positive feedback. It gives it a different light,
- 56:09so maybe these are three. Contexts that again, I cannot
- 56:14take as Of a path for myself. But these are things that I've
- 56:18encountered to hit rock bottom second to have an authentic
- 56:23encounter with people who went through something similar.
- 56:27But I'm going through and who show me with the, a development
- 56:30of the path that I can emulate mu8 somehow, or to get
- 56:36professional help. Okay.
- 56:39That yeah. That I think that makes sense.
- 56:43Perfect. So do we want to continue?
- 56:46I have one or two more topics or do we want to move it to another
- 56:49podcast? I think we should move it to
- 56:52another podcast, but I'm interested to wrap it up with
- 56:54you. How do you view our discussion
- 56:59on topics? You open questions that you have
- 57:01and how do you think about them now?
- 57:04And what is your stand on the Clarion?
- 57:07Maybe let's call it attitude and not so much better view of
- 57:11philosophy. I think some part to me some
- 57:16guards of the earlier in Psychology, did resonate with
- 57:19with my work with you. All right?
- 57:21Which was sort of Having the courage or how like he's using
- 57:26the word current science type of movement or twice, but like
- 57:30wishing your you you always use the term that do you really wish
- 57:34yourself, well, right? Like, which is saying okay.
- 57:37I I am going to try and what has happened in the past is no it's
- 57:42not working anymore. And the tools that I had in the
- 57:45past that I was using to deal with my life stopped working at
- 57:51some point and now I'm going to try and use a couple different
- 57:56ways and I'm going to wish myself well or like, you know,
- 58:00have the courage to be happy and say, okay, I'm going to try and
- 58:03do other things and I'm going to do internally.
- 58:06I'm going to Try and become more positive or more better like to
- 58:12me that that part I kind of like you know I think this discussion
- 58:19definitely helped write like for me to think through and say,
- 58:22okay I do need to go on that Journey even if even effect will
- 58:28take me like a long time and and I think I kind of agree with
- 58:34you. It is like you can't like Like I
- 58:38do, I finally understood when he said, okay just choose a new
- 58:41personality and do we that that just sounded like bullshit to me
- 58:45this, you know, saying that? Okay, I'm going to go on that
- 58:49path and let it build a couple tools along the way to be.
- 58:52That sounds more of a. Like, I think that is what Adam
- 58:56had long band, right? Like to just stop Stopping with
- 59:01that whole, you know, stop using saying that.
- 59:05Okay, I'm going to stop using those tools and like try and
- 59:07your life to me that definitely absolutely makes make sense.
- 59:14Yeah. So this was really helpful.
- 59:16Thanks though. And what are some open questions
- 59:20or something that you're still not satisfied with do something.
- 59:24I think like the one part that I'm still not sure is, and maybe
- 59:30we can. A deeper dive around.
- 59:31It is the in the book, he talks about inferiority complex and I
- 59:37obviously very well resonated with that.
- 59:41And, and you and I have been working on talking about how do
- 59:46you dress yourself while or love yourself well and I'm still not
- 59:50sure. How to do that, right?
- 59:53Like what are the tools that you would give to your listeners and
- 59:57to your patients? Like, how do you start to just
- 1:00:01if you don't like yourself, but how do you wish yourself well
- 1:00:04and say, okay? You know what?
- 1:00:06Let me at least not hate different aspects of myself,
- 1:00:10right? Like this move from that Cape
- 1:00:12to, okay, I wish myself. Well, even though I do not like
- 1:00:16three or four or five different things about myself, what was
- 1:00:21really interesting To me. And I'm going back to your
- 1:00:24question is, what was something that, you know, was made clear?
- 1:00:29Was this kind of thinking and saying, oh, you just need to not
- 1:00:34encourage people. And all may actually work for
- 1:00:38some students may not, or some people may not work for others,
- 1:00:42right? Because you know, I work, I have
- 1:00:44a foot, you have a full team of people and the way I've been
- 1:00:48always approaching a good job like, you know, really Getting
- 1:00:52them and do we like what was funny in the book?
- 1:00:55Was you said, like, oh, you're just creating more vertical
- 1:00:59relationships and putting people down and saying, oh, you're beat
- 1:01:04me, which is why I'm encouraged like giving yourself praised but
- 1:01:08actually depends on the person, right?
- 1:01:11Like, if some people may like May Thrive by me just
- 1:01:16encouraging and praising and some some may not right?
- 1:01:20So like trying to like Understanding that it's not a
- 1:01:24that whole black and white scenario of doing one thing for
- 1:01:28someone and more. So that was definitely very
- 1:01:30helpful and just to add on this thing before we before we end.
- 1:01:36It's kind of misleading to put so much stress on personal
- 1:01:42encouragement, especially in the work life and the work context
- 1:01:46because companies have much more efficient ways to educate
- 1:01:50people, which is through Depends where celery so we can skip the
- 1:01:54whole. You did a nice job.
- 1:01:56If at the end of the year, you got the promotion and you get a
- 1:01:59raise of 15%. I don't have to add any verbal
- 1:02:02level to it and the person that still feel rewarded and
- 1:02:06encouraged. Yeah, something like this is
- 1:02:09systemically how the workplace all industry kind of Praises
- 1:02:14people. In fact I would argue, I don't
- 1:02:16care much if my boss tells me how great I did but then doesn't
- 1:02:20follow up on it with Celery and reputation, you would think
- 1:02:26that. But a lot of us thrive in the
- 1:02:30corporate environment. When more I did not like I
- 1:02:33didn't care. But I was getting like, you
- 1:02:36know, of course, the money mattered and all, but to me that
- 1:02:39verbal, praise our lovable appreciation was way more
- 1:02:43valuable than another like, you know, like boring my salary
- 1:02:50right? Like yes.
- 1:02:52I was at the end of the year was like Vaughn data point but like
- 1:02:55that continuous praise and and it is kind of sad to think that
- 1:03:00like I don't have that you know you don't have that internal
- 1:03:03voice that says I'm good enough for and all of that by giving
- 1:03:07that constant validation, which is a whole different.
- 1:03:12I can pinpoint. But yeah.
- 1:03:19Okay, thank you very much for this.
- 1:03:21I think we should follow. Follow it up.
- 1:03:23And maybe in the meantime, you will have developed different
- 1:03:26thoughts and what we already spoke about.
- 1:03:28But for sure, we have some other topics that we didn't touch
- 1:03:31today and at least I'd learn adlerian thought proves
- 1:03:37interesting as starting points for conversations like these,
- 1:03:42Thanks everyone for listening. As you can see at larian thought
- 1:03:45proves to be quite consequential for our time today.
- 1:03:49It was inspirational back in the days and it has influenced
- 1:03:53positive psychology and inspirational psychology
- 1:03:56throughout the twentieth. And as we can see also in the
- 1:03:5921st century, so we decided to to a second episode where we
- 1:04:05will continue to deal with some other thoughts, offered letter
- 1:04:08in Psychology that we have not touched in this conversation.
- 1:04:12And I will upload the second episode in the following weeks.