Latest / Bloomberg Law / Weekend Law: SBF Trial, Trump Immunity and Legal Hot Tubs
Transcript
- 0:01Speaker 1: Welcome to Bloomberg Lawn. I'm June Grosso. Ahead in this hour,
- 0:04Speaker 1: the Supreme Court appears ready to restore South Carolina's Republican
- 0:09Speaker 1: John Mapp, the star witness and former girlfriend, takes the
- 0:12Speaker 1: stand in the Sam Bankman Freed trial. Trump is looking
- 0:16Speaker 1: for a get out of jail free card, claiming absolute
- 0:19Speaker 1: presidential immunity and what is a legal hot tub. Prosecutors
- 0:27Speaker 1: have built their criminal fraud case against Sam Bankman Freed
- 0:30Speaker 1: by tapping into his inner circle and reaching cooperation deals
- 0:34Speaker 1: with three of his closest confidants, and one of them
- 0:38Speaker 1: is undoubtedly the government's star witness, Caroline Ellison, the former
- 0:43Speaker 1: CEO of Alameda Research and Sam Bankman Freed's former girlfriend.
- 0:48Speaker 1: She took the stand this week and testified that Bankman
- 0:51Speaker 1: Freed was the mastermind behind the scheme to use FTX
- 0:55Speaker 1: customer funds for speculative illegal trading at Alameda. Prosecutor has
- 1:00Speaker 1: played clips of the all hands meeting days before Alameda
- 1:04Speaker 1: file for bankruptcy.
- 1:05Speaker 2: Then, with Crypto being down, the crash the like credit
- 1:09Speaker 2: crunch this year, most of Alia's loans got called. In
- 1:13Speaker 2: order to meet those loan recalls, we ended up like
- 1:17Speaker 2: borrowing a bunch of funds on NTX, which led to
- 1:19Speaker 2: FTX having a shortfall in user funds.
- 1:22Speaker 1: In the tape ubchained by Business Insider, Ellison admitted that
- 1:26Speaker 1: she and bankman Freed knew Alameda was taking funds from
- 1:29Speaker 1: customers on FTX without their permission.
- 1:33Speaker 3: Did Alameda have the ability to touch user funds without
- 1:37Speaker 3: getting approval from FTX each time?
- 1:40Speaker 1: Uh?
- 1:42Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean I think basically the structure was that,
- 1:44Speaker 2: like Alameda could like kind of go negatives in coins
- 1:49Speaker 2: without needing to actually borrow.
- 1:50Speaker 4: Them on the stock market.
- 1:52Speaker 1: Joining me is Bloomberg legal reporter Chrys Dolmesh, who's been
- 1:55Speaker 1: covering the trial. Chris tell us about Ellison's demeanor on
- 1:59Speaker 1: the stand.
- 2:00Speaker 5: So she was pretty calm. She didn't raise her voice
- 2:02Speaker 5: really at all. She did get emotional near the end
- 2:06Speaker 5: of her direct testimony when she started talking about the
- 2:09Speaker 5: collapse of FPX and Alomatia in November twenty twenty two,
- 2:13Speaker 5: kind of recounting how she had been extremely stressed out
- 2:16Speaker 5: and worrying before that and was just kind of relieved
- 2:19Speaker 5: to be able to tell the truth about the whole situation.
- 2:21Speaker 5: And they played some audio clips of the all hands
- 2:24Speaker 5: meeting that she held on November ninth, after kind of
- 2:27Speaker 5: it had been revealed that Alameta's balance sheet was kind
- 2:29Speaker 5: of not accurate, and in that she's nervously laughing, but
- 2:33Speaker 5: she testified she really felt just reliefed at being able
- 2:36Speaker 5: to tell the truth. She seems just as calm on
- 2:38Speaker 5: that it's very straightforward. She really never raised her voice
- 2:42Speaker 5: or got upset except when she started to cry.
- 2:45Speaker 1: Were there texts or notes or documents that they used
- 2:50Speaker 1: to support her testimony.
- 2:52Speaker 5: Yeah, so there were quite a few. She and FBF
- 2:54Speaker 5: kind of communicated through the obvious ways that people communicate
- 2:58Speaker 5: nowadays in business, like slat, signaled, those sort of things.
- 3:01Speaker 5: You know, they had auto delete on their signal messages,
- 3:04Speaker 5: which she turned off in November and as things started
- 3:06Speaker 5: to get bad, but there were plenty of other documents.
- 3:09Speaker 5: They kind of talked about their relationship through a Google
- 3:12Speaker 5: docs and discussed, you know, how she was uncomfortable with
- 3:15Speaker 5: the relationship and she said that that made her feel
- 3:17Speaker 5: like an unequal partner. So, you know, a lot of
- 3:20Speaker 5: these communications between them, even though they were in the
- 3:23Speaker 5: same penthouse in the Bahamas, were going through electronic means
- 3:27Speaker 5: through chaps and Signal and Google docs, and they presented
- 3:31Speaker 5: quite a few, you know, of her documents. She had
- 3:33Speaker 5: one document she kept it called things that Sam is
- 3:36Speaker 5: freaking out about, and there was time spent on that.
- 3:39Speaker 5: It's one of the things he felt that it would
- 3:41Speaker 5: be a good thing that if there was an enforcement
- 3:43Speaker 5: regulatory action against Finance, because that would help FPX get
- 3:46Speaker 5: more customers.
- 3:47Speaker 1: The prosecutors seemed to spend some time on, you know,
- 3:50Speaker 1: Sam Bankman Freed personally and his desire to shape his image.
- 3:56Speaker 5: Sure, yeah, she said his image was pretty important to him.
- 3:59Speaker 5: At one point she said that if he felt his
- 4:01Speaker 5: hair was very important and that it was kind of
- 4:03Speaker 5: a calling card and that it helped him get visibility.
- 4:06Speaker 5: So at times when he wanted to use publicity to
- 4:09Speaker 5: kind of improve their image or to improve the amount
- 4:12Speaker 5: of publicity they got or get more customers, he did.
- 4:15Speaker 5: And at times when he kind of wanted to downplay
- 4:17Speaker 5: everything he did. That also like switching from a luxury
- 4:20Speaker 5: car to Toyota Corolla.
- 4:22Speaker 1: From the prosecution's point of view, what was the most
- 4:26Speaker 1: important part of her testimony, I think it.
- 4:28Speaker 5: Was then getting her to say that while she was
- 4:31Speaker 5: co CEO and CEO. At one point she was still
- 4:34Speaker 5: kind of taking orders from Sam, and she took orders
- 4:38Speaker 5: from Sam throughout. She consulted him on nearly every decision
- 4:41Speaker 5: that she made, and that you know, while he was
- 4:44Speaker 5: not always day to day involved in Alameda, he was
- 4:49Speaker 5: the owner. He had control, and he would dip in
- 4:51Speaker 5: from time to time, especially in May of twenty two
- 4:54Speaker 5: when things started to get intent and kind of direct
- 4:57Speaker 5: trading strategies. There was testimony from another witness that he
- 5:00Speaker 5: just kind of came in and said, well, we're an
- 5:02Speaker 5: avidents all Japanese bonds and by currency as a hedge.
- 5:05Speaker 5: So he was clearly involved in the day to day
- 5:08Speaker 5: I would say the defense scored some points just kind
- 5:10Speaker 5: of getting her to admit that he wasn't there every day,
- 5:14Speaker 5: that he wasn't always hands on, that she was running
- 5:17Speaker 5: the show at least for part of the time.
- 5:19Speaker 1: So she admitted that she altered documents. You know, she
- 5:24Speaker 1: knew what she was doing was wrong, but kept saying
- 5:27Speaker 1: that Sam Bankman Free directed it.
- 5:30Speaker 5: Yeah, that's pretty much the narrative that she gave. She
- 5:32Speaker 5: made it clear that you know, sometimes she made decisions,
- 5:35Speaker 5: you know, after consulting him, and that those decisions were hers,
- 5:38Speaker 5: but ultimately she said that Sam made most decisions. And
- 5:41Speaker 5: one powerful part of her testimony I would say was
- 5:44Speaker 5: when things started to go bad in the summer, there
- 5:48Speaker 5: was one meeting that they had in the penthouse in
- 5:51Speaker 5: the study or he basically blamed her and said that
- 5:54Speaker 5: the reason that they were in the situation that they
- 5:56Speaker 5: were in was because she hadn't hedged enough. And she said, yeah,
- 5:59Speaker 5: I could have done more. There's definitely I could have
- 6:01Speaker 5: done more. She admitted she could have been a better leader,
- 6:03Speaker 5: and she could have pushed people to do more innovative things.
- 6:05Speaker 5: But in the end, she said this was Sam making
- 6:08Speaker 5: the decision.
- 6:09Speaker 1: And so on cross examination, how much headway did the
- 6:13Speaker 1: defense make? Were they able to poke holes in her testimony?
- 6:16Speaker 5: A little bit? They had a tough time, mostly because
- 6:19Speaker 5: there were a lot of objections from the prosecution. I
- 6:21Speaker 5: mean you could even characterize it as almost every time
- 6:23Speaker 5: they started to ask a question that the prosecution would
- 6:26Speaker 5: object due to form or some other problem. So in
- 6:29Speaker 5: the end, you know, during a full day on the stand,
- 6:31Speaker 5: she started around nine thirty and ended around three thirty
- 6:34Speaker 5: or four, she only really spent three full hours on
- 6:38Speaker 5: the stands there were a few sidebars. There were debates about,
- 6:41Speaker 5: you know, admissibility of some of these audio clips of
- 6:44Speaker 5: the November ninth meeting. So while they made a little headway,
- 6:48Speaker 5: like I said, and kind of driving a wedge between
- 6:51Speaker 5: management of Alameda and Sam Bankman Freed, it was definitely
- 6:54Speaker 5: a slog for them, and how much progress they made
- 6:57Speaker 5: the can only really be measured at the end of
- 6:59Speaker 5: the trial.
- 7:00Speaker 1: She's been billed as the star witness. Do you think
- 7:02Speaker 1: her testimony lived up to that?
- 7:04Speaker 5: I would say so. Gary Wong spent a similar amount
- 7:08Speaker 5: of time on the span. She's a key witness. She
- 7:10Speaker 5: was there for a lot of it. She was obviously
- 7:12Speaker 5: his partner for a good amount of time. There's a
- 7:15Speaker 5: lot of testimony as to their personal relationship, so she
- 7:19Speaker 5: was certainly crucial.
- 7:20Speaker 1: Thanks Chris. That's Bloomberg Legal reporter Chrystal Mesh. Joining me
- 7:24Speaker 1: now to analyze the prosecution's case is former federal prosecutor
- 7:28Speaker 1: Jordan Estez, a partner Kramer Levin. It seems like the
- 7:32Speaker 1: government here has an overwhelming amount of evidence against Bankman Freed.
- 7:37Speaker 1: Witnesses who were in on the alleged fraud code that
- 7:41Speaker 1: was altered balance sheets, texts, internal documents. As a defense attorney,
- 7:46Speaker 1: how do you defend against that kind of a case.
- 7:50Speaker 6: It's certainly very challenging in these circumstances. The one thing
- 7:54Speaker 6: I think the defense is trying to do is create
- 7:57Speaker 6: a record that this was actually legitimate business. Nobody thought
- 8:01Speaker 6: they were doing anything wrong. So they're going to try
- 8:04Speaker 6: to do that through the cross examination of the witnesses
- 8:07Speaker 6: of the company. I do think it's a real challenge
- 8:09Speaker 6: in a case where witnesses like Caroline Ellison seem to
- 8:13Speaker 6: have fully embraced that the conduct was wrongful. So if
- 8:18Speaker 6: you have a witness like that, they're really going to
- 8:20Speaker 6: have to attack her credibility. But I do think from
- 8:24Speaker 6: my read of her testimony it was very overwhelming. It
- 8:28Speaker 6: seemed very dramatic and compelling. So they're going to have
- 8:31Speaker 6: to do a lot of work and discrediting her, which
- 8:33Speaker 6: will be hard.
- 8:34Speaker 1: I mean, she is the state star witness. How much
- 8:37Speaker 1: depends on the jury believing her.
- 8:39Speaker 6: So I think in a cooperator case, the government really
- 8:42Speaker 6: does need the jury to believe the cooperators. They need
- 8:46Speaker 6: them to believe not necessarily every cooperator, but at least
- 8:51Speaker 6: one of the principal wanes like Caroline Ellison, They're certainly
- 8:54Speaker 6: going to have to believe her, but you can imagine
- 8:56Speaker 6: the government has documents that support her testimony. Often, as
- 9:00Speaker 6: the cooperator testifies, you then introduce exhibits that confirm what
- 9:05Speaker 6: the cooperating witness is saying, or perhaps another witness from
- 9:10Speaker 6: FTX who testifies later may say something that's consistent with
- 9:14Speaker 6: Caroline Ellison's testimony. So there are a number of ways
- 9:17Speaker 6: to try to get the jury to believe the witness,
- 9:20Speaker 6: but that is ultimately it's very critical to the case.
- 9:23Speaker 1: The first four witnesses, one is his former girlfriend, another
- 9:27Speaker 1: is one of his oldest friends, another an mit friend.
- 9:31Speaker 1: Does that help or hurt their credibility that they were
- 9:34Speaker 1: friends who turned on him when things fell apart?
- 9:38Speaker 6: The government's view is typically that that helps their credibility.
- 9:42Speaker 6: These were the people who were closest to the defendant.
- 9:45Speaker 6: They were inside the conspiracy, and they're the ones who
- 9:49Speaker 6: can tell you every detail of what happened. If you
- 9:52Speaker 6: have an outsider, it's easier to distance them from the
- 9:56Speaker 6: defendant and suggest how would they actually know what he
- 9:58Speaker 6: intended or what was really going on. But because they
- 10:01Speaker 6: have people that were right on the inside that worked
- 10:04Speaker 6: side by side with him, that have admitted their guilt.
- 10:08Speaker 6: That's really tough for the defense.
- 10:10Speaker 1: Was there anything about Caroline Allison's testimony that struck you? So?
- 10:16Speaker 6: I thought a lot of the anecdotes he provided are
- 10:19Speaker 6: the kinds of things that really dick out to a juror.
- 10:22Speaker 6: They may not be direct evidence of fraud, but their
- 10:25Speaker 6: dramatic moments, like when she said that he said there
- 10:28Speaker 6: was a five percent chance that he would be president.
- 10:31Speaker 6: I'm sure that's something that stands out and just I
- 10:34Speaker 6: think raises questions about his judgment. But she seemed to
- 10:37Speaker 6: have a lot of dramatic moments in her testimony. I think,
- 10:40Speaker 6: in particular, given their relationships, there's this added drama on
- 10:44Speaker 6: top of what you have in a fraud case. So
- 10:47Speaker 6: it's very good for the government and that when there
- 10:50Speaker 6: is drama when you have a complicated case, jurors can
- 10:53Speaker 6: go to sleep if you're talking about code and cryptocurrency
- 10:56Speaker 6: and things like that. But when you have a witness
- 10:58Speaker 6: who was in a romantic, really relationship, when there was
- 11:01Speaker 6: this power dynamic, that's something that certainly captures the jury's
- 11:05Speaker 6: attention and I think creates this extra element there that
- 11:10Speaker 6: her boss and her former boyfriend is also asking her
- 11:14Speaker 6: to commit fraud, committing fraud with her. It's an interesting
- 11:18Speaker 6: power dynamic that I think will stand out to a jury.
- 11:20Speaker 1: A lot more trial ahead. Thanks so much, Jordan. That's
- 11:24Speaker 1: Jordan Esdez of Kramer Levin. Coming up next. A lower
- 11:27Speaker 1: court throughout South Carolina's congressional map, But will the Supreme
- 11:31Speaker 1: Court restore it. I'm June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 11:38Speaker 4: This is Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 11:44Speaker 7: We have said that the burden that you're assuming of
- 11:48Speaker 7: disentangling race and politics in a situation like this is very,
- 11:53Speaker 7: very difficult.
- 11:54Speaker 1: The Chief Justice described the key problem in the case
- 11:57Speaker 1: before the Supreme Court how to determine whether South Carolina's
- 12:01Speaker 1: congressional map was the result of racial gerrymandering, which is unconstitutional,
- 12:06Speaker 1: or part is in jerrymandering, which has been okayed by
- 12:09Speaker 1: the court. The court's conservative justices expressed skepticism about a
- 12:14Speaker 1: lower court's decision finding that Republican lawmakers had engaged in
- 12:18Speaker 1: unconstitutional racial jerrymandering in drawing South Carolina's first congressional district.
- 12:25Speaker 1: Here are Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito.
- 12:29Speaker 7: But we've never had a case where there's been no
- 12:32Speaker 7: direct evidence, no map, no strangely configured districts, a very
- 12:39Speaker 7: large amount of political evidence.
- 12:42Speaker 8: Well, the clear error standard, if that's the standard that
- 12:45Speaker 8: we are required to reply, is a very demanding standard.
- 12:49Speaker 8: But it is not an impossible standard. And it doesn't
- 12:52Speaker 8: mean that we simply rubber stamp findings by a district court.
- 12:59Speaker 1: But the liberal justice has suggested the lower court had
- 13:02Speaker 1: enough evidence to conclude that South Carolina lawmakers improperly relied
- 13:07Speaker 1: on race to get to their target of seventeen percent
- 13:10Speaker 1: black voters in the first district by moving thirty thousand
- 13:13Speaker 1: black voters out of the district. Here Justice is Elena
- 13:17Speaker 1: Kagan and Sonya so to Mayor.
- 13:19Speaker 9: Is this gerrymander based on politics or is it a
- 13:23Speaker 9: way to get to an ultimate goal? An ultimate political goal?
- 13:26Speaker 9: But the gerrymandarin is based on race. And what the
- 13:29Speaker 9: two of them do is that they show that black
- 13:31Speaker 9: Democrats are excluded from District one at a far greater
- 13:36Speaker 9: percentage than white Democrats are. I think Cooper was petulutely
- 13:42Speaker 9: clear that you don't need a smoking gun, and if
- 13:47Speaker 9: you don't need a smoking gun, you don't need to
- 13:48Speaker 9: wreck evidence.
- 13:49Speaker 1: Joining me is elections law expert Richard Brofald, a professor
- 13:52Speaker 1: at Columbia Law School. Rich tell us about the issues
- 13:56Speaker 1: in this case where the NAACP is challenging the South
- 14:00Speaker 1: Carolina that.
- 14:01Speaker 10: So this case is about a challenge to the redistricting
- 14:04Speaker 10: of South Carolina's congressional plan in twenty twenty two following
- 14:09Speaker 10: the twenty twenty census. The major development affected District one,
- 14:12Speaker 10: which is basically around Charleston, and it made the district
- 14:16Speaker 10: more Republican by moving out of a significant number of
- 14:18Speaker 10: black voters into an adjacent black majority district. District one
- 14:22Speaker 10: had been a Republican district, but in recent years had
- 14:25Speaker 10: been more closely contested, and in twenty eighteen the Democrats
- 14:28Speaker 10: actually won it for one term. Twenty twenty, the Republicans
- 14:31Speaker 10: wanted that, but very narrowly. So one of the things
- 14:33Speaker 10: the legislature did in twenty twenty two was changed the
- 14:36Speaker 10: composition to make it more Republican, and in so doing
- 14:40Speaker 10: it basically moved about thirty thousand black voters from Charleston
- 14:44Speaker 10: out of the district into an adjacent district. By the way,
- 14:46Speaker 10: District one is the district that elects Nancy Mace, who
- 14:49Speaker 10: had been previously considered a moderate that since our district
- 14:52Speaker 10: was change, seems to become more conservative. So the question
- 14:55Speaker 10: before the core, it's a tough question, is whether the
- 14:58Speaker 10: legislature was motivated by race or by party. You might
- 15:02Speaker 10: say that in a state where race and party are
- 15:04Speaker 10: so intertwined, that's an impossible question answers. It's the same thing,
- 15:07Speaker 10: but it's crucial because the Supreme Court has said that
- 15:10Speaker 10: racial gerrymandering, that is to say, the intentional movement of
- 15:14Speaker 10: voters because of their race from one district to another,
- 15:17Speaker 10: is unconstitutional. But partisan jerrymandering, as we all know since
- 15:21Speaker 10: the Ruco decision in twenty nineteen, is not on constitutional,
- 15:24Speaker 10: it's notn justiciable. So it's okay for the state to
- 15:27Speaker 10: engage in partisan gerrymandering, it's not okay for the state
- 15:30Speaker 10: to engage in racial gerrymandering. South Carolina says it was
- 15:34Speaker 10: both the following traditional district lines but also had a
- 15:37Speaker 10: partisan political purpose. What the lower court found was that
- 15:40Speaker 10: actually the movements of voters did exhibit racial predominance. That
- 15:45Speaker 10: given away the voters, which voters were targeted, and relying
- 15:48Speaker 10: on the testimony of experts, they basically said that a
- 15:51Speaker 10: disproportionate number of Black Democrats relative to white Democrats for
- 15:55Speaker 10: the ones who were moved, and therefore the District Court
- 15:58Speaker 10: was able to conclude that this was a racial gerry manager.
- 16:02Speaker 10: That's what's being tested in the Supreme Court right now.
- 16:04Speaker 1: The three judge federal panel referred to the revised map
- 16:08Speaker 1: as effective bleaching of African American voters out of the
- 16:11Speaker 1: Charleston County portion of the district. And they came to
- 16:14Speaker 1: that conclusion after an extensive eight day trial featuring forty
- 16:18Speaker 1: two witnesses and six hundred and fifty two exhibits. So
- 16:23Speaker 1: doesn't the court usually defer to the factual findings of
- 16:27Speaker 1: lower court judges.
- 16:28Speaker 10: Yes, I mean, indeed, that is the standard. They're supposed
- 16:30Speaker 10: to apply, what's called the clearly erroneous standard. Not just
- 16:33Speaker 10: but the district court right on balance. But as long
- 16:36Speaker 10: as the district court did was plausible, long as they
- 16:39Speaker 10: didn't something which was clearly wrong as opposed to debatably wrong,
- 16:42Speaker 10: they're supposed to defer. And you definitely heard the liberal
- 16:45Speaker 10: justices emphasizing the importance of adhering to the clearly erroneous
- 16:48Speaker 10: standard that there was evidence to support with the district
- 16:51Speaker 10: court found and indeed, the United States had not been
- 16:53Speaker 10: a party to the case originally, but this listener General's
- 16:56Speaker 10: office came if the United States had actually emphasized importance
- 16:59Speaker 10: of following the court of the erroneous standard.
- 17:02Speaker 1: Chief Justice John Roberts said that the challengers of the
- 17:05Speaker 1: map had no direct evidence that race had predominated in
- 17:09Speaker 1: the decision making process, just circumstantial evidence. This would be
- 17:14Speaker 1: breaking new ground in our voting rights jurisprudence. Is that true?
- 17:18Speaker 1: I mean, isn't circumstantial evidence enough?
- 17:21Speaker 5: Right?
- 17:22Speaker 10: They've often relied on circumstantial evidence, But Hill said it
- 17:26Speaker 10: was not an oddly shaped district. In the number of
- 17:28Speaker 10: the early other cases in which the Court has found
- 17:31Speaker 10: racial gerrymandering, the district was oddly shaped. On this one,
- 17:35Speaker 10: there was a big change the district. People were moved
- 17:37Speaker 10: around a lot, but the district itself didn't flunk any
- 17:40Speaker 10: kind of test of odd shape, which is somethings the
- 17:43Speaker 10: Court has sometimes used. And the other issue that came
- 17:46Speaker 10: up was the fact that the plaintiffs had not presented
- 17:50Speaker 10: an alternative map. Basically, the question was could the state
- 17:54Speaker 10: have gotten its partisan goals without moving as many black
- 17:58Speaker 10: voters around? And the question came up, should the plaintiffs
- 18:01Speaker 10: have been required to present an alternative map showing that
- 18:04Speaker 10: the state could have made the district just as Republican
- 18:08Speaker 10: without moving as many black voters. And there was a
- 18:10Speaker 10: debate in the court as to whether the plaintiffs had
- 18:12Speaker 10: to do that, and the President is that they don't
- 18:15Speaker 10: have to. Indeed, Justice Kagan was quite strong on that,
- 18:18Speaker 10: because she'd actually written the case that said that, a
- 18:20Speaker 10: case called Cooper about five years ago. But nonetheless, the
- 18:23Speaker 10: other justices sort of came back and said, well, maybe
- 18:26Speaker 10: you didn't have to, but why didn't you Why wouldn't
- 18:29Speaker 10: that have helped your case if you could have shown
- 18:31Speaker 10: that they could obtain their partisan goals without using race
- 18:35Speaker 10: quite as much. I mean, it really went into this
- 18:37Speaker 10: difficulty of separating out race and party. In effect, the
- 18:40Speaker 10: conservative justices were sort of creating even though the prior
- 18:43Speaker 10: case Cooper had said there's no such requirement, you saw
- 18:46Speaker 10: some of them basically suggesting either that there is, or
- 18:50Speaker 10: that there should be, or that it's a problem when
- 18:52Speaker 10: there isn't.
- 18:53Speaker 1: So after the oral arguments, most legal experts concluded that
- 18:57Speaker 1: the conservative majority is going to uphold Republican drawn mapp.
- 19:01Speaker 1: What's your take on it?
- 19:03Speaker 10: There were certainly a lot of negative questioning, even from
- 19:05Speaker 10: some of the so called more moderate conservative justices. Remember
- 19:09Speaker 10: the most recent case involving race and voting, Allen versus
- 19:12Speaker 10: Milligan went off five to four, with two of the conservatives,
- 19:16Speaker 10: Roberts and Kavanaugh joining the liberals. Roberts was clearly pretty
- 19:20Speaker 10: skeptical about the lower courts finding in this case. He
- 19:23Speaker 10: seemed less likely. Kavanaugh's questions were a little bit harder
- 19:26Speaker 10: to read. I mean, some of it was again about
- 19:28Speaker 10: the evidence, but some of it also seemed to indicate
- 19:30Speaker 10: that he was thinking about what's the burden on the
- 19:33Speaker 10: defendants in this case? Showed that the district court was
- 19:35Speaker 10: clearly wrong. It was certainly a tough argument for the
- 19:38Speaker 10: NAACP defending the lower courts finding. I think if they
- 19:41Speaker 10: have any chance, it's going to be the extent that
- 19:43Speaker 10: the court decides to rally around the idea that unless
- 19:47Speaker 10: it's clearly erroneous, there should be difference in lower courts finding.
- 19:50Speaker 10: On the other hand, this is the court's first sort
- 19:52Speaker 10: of race party intertwine case since Rucho four years ago,
- 19:57Speaker 10: when the Court said that partisan jerrymandering is not on constitutional,
- 20:00Speaker 10: it's not justiciable. So it's the first time that they
- 20:03Speaker 10: will speak to the how do you separate out race
- 20:06Speaker 10: and party? And one could imagine they may want to
- 20:10Speaker 10: shut down the idea that you could get around Rucho
- 20:13Speaker 10: by reframing things around race. Now, the Court in the
- 20:16Speaker 10: past has said, even if there's a partisan factor, that
- 20:19Speaker 10: the state can't use the race as a proxy for
- 20:21Speaker 10: party when I trys lines to favor a party. But
- 20:24Speaker 10: one could imagine this is a case where the Court
- 20:26Speaker 10: might want to address how do you disentangle race and
- 20:29Speaker 10: party in a world in which racial jerry mannering is
- 20:32Speaker 10: unconstitutional but partisan jerry mannering is not.
- 20:35Speaker 1: It just doesn't seem like the NAACP has the numbers
- 20:39Speaker 1: here to win, But you never know. Thanks so much,
- 20:41Speaker 1: rich that's Professor Richard Brofault of Columbia Law School. Coming
- 20:45Speaker 1: up next. Donald Trump says he's immune from prosecution in
- 20:49Speaker 1: the federal trial over January sixth. I'm June Grosso and
- 20:52Speaker 1: you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 20:57Speaker 4: This is Bloomberg Law with you from Bloomberg Radio.
- 21:03Speaker 11: And did you see today that deranged Jack Smith. He's
- 21:07Speaker 11: the prosecutor, He's a deranged person, wants to take away
- 21:11Speaker 11: my rights under the First Amendment, wants to take away
- 21:14Speaker 11: my right of speaking freely and openly.
- 21:18Speaker 1: Donald Trump never seems to miss an opportunity to ridicule
- 21:22Speaker 1: Jack Smith, the special counsel who's bringing charges against him
- 21:25Speaker 1: in d C and Florida. The trial date in d
- 21:28Speaker 1: C on charges of trying to overturn the twenty twenty
- 21:31Speaker 1: election is less than five months away, but Trump is
- 21:35Speaker 1: looking for a complete pass by arguing that he has
- 21:39Speaker 1: absolute presidential immunity from criminal prosecution, and he's asking federal
- 21:44Speaker 1: Judge Tanya Chutkin to toss out the indictment. Here to
- 21:48Speaker 1: discuss the issue which courts have never settled, is former
- 21:52Speaker 1: federal prosecutor Jessica Roth, a professor at Cardozo Law School.
- 21:56Speaker 1: Jessica tell us about Trump's claim of president immunity.
- 22:01Speaker 12: So their argument is that Trump enjoys absolute presidential immunity
- 22:07Speaker 12: from prosecution because he claims that the indictment brought by
- 22:12Speaker 12: the Social Council related to January sixth is based on
- 22:16Speaker 12: what they contend are his official acts while president. I
- 22:19Speaker 12: would submit this is the most significant motion that Trump
- 22:22Speaker 12: has filed to date in all of the cases that
- 22:24Speaker 12: are pending against him, and that the court's decisions on
- 22:28Speaker 12: this motion could establish new law regarding whether a president
- 22:31Speaker 12: is beyond the reach of the criminal law for acts
- 22:33Speaker 12: taken while president, even after he leaves the office.
- 22:37Speaker 1: What do you make of his attorney's arguments? They make
- 22:39Speaker 1: several levels of arguments. Are they convincing?
- 22:43Speaker 12: Unlike some arguments we've seen from Trump's counsel and some
- 22:46Speaker 12: of the cases brought against him. This motion is well
- 22:48Speaker 12: written and it does present a very important issue of law,
- 22:53Speaker 12: one that the courts will have.
- 22:54Speaker 3: To take seriously.
- 22:55Speaker 12: No court has ever squarely decided the question of whether
- 22:58Speaker 12: a president enjoys absolute immunity from prosecution at all, because
- 23:04Speaker 12: there's never been a precedent for criminal charges being filed
- 23:07Speaker 12: against a former president. But there are two issues that
- 23:10Speaker 12: the courts will have to address in ruling on the motion.
- 23:13Speaker 12: The first is whether, in fact, presidents do enjoy absolute
- 23:17Speaker 12: immunity from criminal prosecution for acts taken during the presidency,
- 23:22Speaker 12: and if they find that there is such a thing
- 23:25Speaker 12: as absolute immunity for president from criminal prosecution, then they
- 23:29Speaker 12: would have to apply that doctrine of immunity to the
- 23:32Speaker 12: facts presented in this case. If the court told that
- 23:35Speaker 12: there is no absolute immunity for a president from prosecution
- 23:39Speaker 12: even after they leave office, then they don't necessarily have
- 23:43Speaker 12: to address this second question of whether or not Trump's
- 23:46Speaker 12: actions fall within the scope of such immunity.
- 23:49Speaker 1: This motion was just filed last Thursday, so prosecutors haven't
- 23:53Speaker 1: had time to respond. But what do you envision their
- 23:56Speaker 1: argument will be against the claims of presidentiality.
- 24:00Speaker 12: I imagine what they're going to argue is first that
- 24:03Speaker 12: the courts should not extend the doctrine. It's a judge
- 24:06Speaker 12: made doctrine of immunity for presidents to the criminal context,
- 24:10Speaker 12: and I think they have very good arguments. But secondarily,
- 24:13Speaker 12: they will argue that even if the court were to
- 24:15Speaker 12: find that in some cases a president could enjoy immunity
- 24:19Speaker 12: from criminal prosecution for actions taken while president, that it
- 24:23Speaker 12: would not apply to the conduct that is alleged in
- 24:26Speaker 12: this case, because if the courts were to follow the
- 24:29Speaker 12: doctrine they have applied in the context of civil suits
- 24:33Speaker 12: for damages, brought against a former president, which asks whether
- 24:37Speaker 12: or not the conduct in question falls within the outer
- 24:39Speaker 12: perimeter of the president's official responsibility. The Special Council would
- 24:44Speaker 12: argue that these actions do not fall within that outer perimeter.
- 24:48Speaker 1: This is uncharted territory. What has the Supreme Court ruled
- 24:52Speaker 1: in the past in the area of presidential immunity.
- 24:55Speaker 12: So, the Supreme Court has ruled on presidential immunity in
- 24:59Speaker 12: the content textive damages, actions and civil suits. In the
- 25:03Speaker 12: most important cases a case called Nixon versus Fitzgerald, in
- 25:06Speaker 12: which the Court said, there is a doctrine of absolute
- 25:09Speaker 12: presidential immunity that shields the president even after he leaves
- 25:14Speaker 12: office from damages actions brought by individuals for actions taken
- 25:19Speaker 12: within the outer perimeter of the president's official responsibilities. The
- 25:24Speaker 12: Court in that case drew on precedents those cases that
- 25:27Speaker 12: recognized absolute immunity for prosecutors and judges said, essentially, if
- 25:32Speaker 12: we don't adopt this doctrine, these individuals who perform these
- 25:36Speaker 12: very public and important duties will be distracted and concerned
- 25:40Speaker 12: as they perform their duties about the potential of being
- 25:43Speaker 12: subject to innumerable suits. And so in Nixon versus Fitzgerald,
- 25:48Speaker 12: the Court said, essentially, we're going to adopt that reasoning
- 25:50Speaker 12: which applies with great force to the president of the
- 25:54Speaker 12: United States, who, in addition, as to whom there's real
- 25:57Speaker 12: separation of powers concerns if the courts were intrude upon
- 26:01Speaker 12: the executive's ability to perform his functions as president. But
- 26:05Speaker 12: the Court, again in Nixon versus Fitzgerald, talked about how
- 26:09Speaker 12: those cases did not opine on the availability of criminal prosecution,
- 26:14Speaker 12: And in fact, in Nixon versus Fitzgerald, the Court was
- 26:17Speaker 12: very clear to say, and it has said in subsequent
- 26:20Speaker 12: cases on the question of absolute presidential immunity, that those
- 26:23Speaker 12: cases are limited to the question of civil damages in
- 26:27Speaker 12: civil suits brought by private parties. So I think there's
- 26:30Speaker 12: a very strong argument to be made that the Court
- 26:33Speaker 12: would not extend that doctrine of immunity to criminal prosecution.
- 26:38Speaker 1: What about the case of Trump the Vance, where the
- 26:42Speaker 1: Supreme Court ruled on the Manhattan DA's grand jury subpoena
- 26:46Speaker 1: to Mazar's Trump's accounting firm.
- 26:50Speaker 12: I think that's instructive as well, and that builds on
- 26:52Speaker 12: this idea that the Court sees a distinction between criminal cases,
- 26:56Speaker 12: including investigations and prosecutions and civil lawsuits. In the Trump
- 27:01Speaker 12: Vizance case, I mean that involved a subpoena from a
- 27:04Speaker 12: state grand jury seeking documents from Trump while he was president,
- 27:08Speaker 12: and he asserted absolute immunity and that he shouldn't have
- 27:11Speaker 12: to respond to that state grand jury subpoena, and the
- 27:15Speaker 12: Court said the public interest in criminal investigations is really paramount.
- 27:21Speaker 12: It's a similar interest that the Court talked about in
- 27:24Speaker 12: the United States versus Nixon when President Nixon as president
- 27:28Speaker 12: was ordered to comply with a subpoena from the grand
- 27:30Speaker 12: jury working with the special prosecutor Archibald Cox, seeking evidence
- 27:35Speaker 12: in the grand jury's investigation related to Watergate. So in
- 27:39Speaker 12: both cases, the Court has talked about essentially the paramount
- 27:43Speaker 12: public interest in criminal prosecutions and investigations and how that
- 27:47Speaker 12: is really quite distinct from the private interests involved in
- 27:51Speaker 12: civil lawsuits against former president.
- 27:54Speaker 1: So Trump is all about delay with these cases, and
- 27:58Speaker 1: his lawyer said they'll try to take to the Supreme
- 28:00Speaker 1: Court if they lose at the DC's Circuit rulings, denying
- 28:05Speaker 1: motions to dismiss an indictment normally wouldn't be appealable until
- 28:09Speaker 1: after a verdict, right, But is this different?
- 28:13Speaker 12: This is different, And that's one of the reasons why
- 28:15Speaker 12: I think this motion is so significant, not just on
- 28:17Speaker 12: the merits and for the new law that it could establish,
- 28:20Speaker 12: but for the fact that the motion, because of its
- 28:23Speaker 12: nature and the fact that I think it is going
- 28:24Speaker 12: to be deemed immediately appealable, could derail the trial simply
- 28:29Speaker 12: by going through the appellate process and the time it
- 28:32Speaker 12: will take for the matter to be decided, and how
- 28:35Speaker 12: that may well go beyond the March twenty twenty four
- 28:38Speaker 12: trial date that's been established.
- 28:40Speaker 1: We don't have the prosecutions brief yet, but does this
- 28:43Speaker 1: seem like an upheal battle for Trump?
- 28:46Speaker 12: I expect that the trial court and the DC Circuit
- 28:49Speaker 12: will rule against Trump, But when it gets to the
- 28:52Speaker 12: US Supreme Court, and I do anticipate the Supreme Court
- 28:55Speaker 12: would take this case, then it's a much harder outcome
- 28:59Speaker 12: to predict. I think on the merits that the Supreme
- 29:02Speaker 12: Court should rule against him, but it's hard to predict
- 29:05Speaker 12: how this Supreme Court will rule and if they get
- 29:08Speaker 12: to the second question, which is whether or not these
- 29:11Speaker 12: acts fall within the outer perimeter of the presidential functions
- 29:15Speaker 12: and duties. Then again, it's going to turn on how
- 29:18Speaker 12: the court chooses to characterize the acts, what level of generality,
- 29:23Speaker 12: and whether they look at them collectively and in context
- 29:26Speaker 12: or essentially separate them out individually the ways the former
- 29:30Speaker 12: president has invited them to. I also think that there's
- 29:34Speaker 12: a sort of a larger context here decisions about recognizing
- 29:38Speaker 12: immunity and to what extent do require courts to consider
- 29:42Speaker 12: the consequences of ruling one way or the other. Here
- 29:46Speaker 12: we have the former president who says that he should
- 29:49Speaker 12: not be subject to prosecution in part because of the
- 29:53Speaker 12: impact on future presidents and thinking about their ability to
- 29:57Speaker 12: carry out their duties without being distracted by worries they
- 30:00Speaker 12: themselves would be hauled into court subsequently and charge. And
- 30:04Speaker 12: he is saying on the campaign trail that if re elected,
- 30:07Speaker 12: he would direct his attorney general to prosecute his political enemies,
- 30:11Speaker 12: including now President Behiden. And so I do think that
- 30:15Speaker 12: part of the mix and the court evaluating the consequences
- 30:18Speaker 12: of its ruling would be if they do rule that
- 30:21Speaker 12: a former president can be subject to criminal prosecution will
- 30:24Speaker 12: acts while president will that mean that we would subsequently
- 30:28Speaker 12: see future prosecutions of former presidents sort of ramp up
- 30:32Speaker 12: in the way that we are seeing essentially an escalation
- 30:34Speaker 12: in the threat of impeachment for presidents while in office.
- 30:37Speaker 1: This presidential immunity claim presents so many issues. Thanks so much, Jessica.
- 30:43Speaker 1: That's Professor Jessica Roth of Cardozo Law School coming up next.
- 30:47Speaker 1: It's a hot tub, but it's a legal hot tub.
- 30:50Speaker 1: Just what does that mean? I'm June Grosso. When you're
- 30:53Speaker 1: listening to Bloomberg.
- 30:57Speaker 4: This is Bloomberg Law with Russo from Bloomberg Radio.
- 31:08Speaker 5: I don't want to say how.
- 31:11Speaker 4: Must be some kind of hot tub turchine.
- 31:15Speaker 1: We all know what hot tubs are, and we even
- 31:18Speaker 1: know what hot tub time machines are from the movies.
- 31:22Speaker 1: But what exactly is a legal hot tub. Well, it's
- 31:26Speaker 1: not as exciting as it may sound, and it really
- 31:28Speaker 1: has nothing to do with hot tubs. It's formally called
- 31:32Speaker 1: concurrent expert testimony or a concurrent expert evidence proceeding, and
- 31:38Speaker 1: it's like a discussion among experts. But it's not very
- 31:42Speaker 1: popular in US courts, at least so far. Here to
- 31:45Speaker 1: tell us about it and how it got that name
- 31:48Speaker 1: is Bloomberg Law reporter Dan papskin So tell us exactly
- 31:52Speaker 1: what this legal hot tub is.
- 31:54Speaker 7: Dan.
- 31:55Speaker 3: You can kind of think of it as a debate
- 31:56Speaker 3: between experts, often economic experts, but not necessary boroughly, where
- 32:01Speaker 3: instead of one sitting on the stands in a trial
- 32:04Speaker 3: or in the pre trial hearing and getting examined and
- 32:07Speaker 3: then cross examined by one size attorneys and then the other,
- 32:09Speaker 3: both or all of the witnesses sit together before the
- 32:13Speaker 3: judge and are basically prompted to debate each other on
- 32:15Speaker 3: a series of predetermined topics or questions.
- 32:18Speaker 1: And where did they get the name hot tub for this?
- 32:21Speaker 3: Australia. These originated pretty much right around the beginning of
- 32:25Speaker 3: the decade and it was deployed originally by the Australian
- 32:28Speaker 3: Competition Tribunal. They're kind of anti trust dedicated port system
- 32:33Speaker 3: basically to get a clear understanding of what experts we're
- 32:36Speaker 3: talking about and make them really drill down on their
- 32:38Speaker 3: agreements and their disagreements. It was pretty successful there and
- 32:42Speaker 3: it's taken off in a bunch of other countries in Europe,
- 32:44Speaker 3: in South Africa, Canada has used it, mostly been unpopular
- 32:48Speaker 3: in the US. We've only found a little less than
- 32:50Speaker 3: two dozen instances of federal judges using on it hasn't
- 32:54Speaker 3: it hasn't taken off.
- 32:55Speaker 1: Maybe the name has something to do with that. I
- 32:57Speaker 1: know you witness one of these legal hot tubs when
- 33:00Speaker 1: federal Judge James Denado held one in San Francisco. So
- 33:04Speaker 1: tell us about that.
- 33:05Speaker 3: So Donato held the second hot tub he's held in
- 33:08Speaker 3: this case. This is a lawsuit alleging Google basically has
- 33:12Speaker 3: anti competitive control over the payment systems in his playstore,
- 33:17Speaker 3: and so the second hot tub was to basically determine
- 33:20Speaker 3: whether the plaintiffs experts have reached kind of valid models
- 33:25Speaker 3: for figuring out how much consumers were harmed by these
- 33:29Speaker 3: playstore policies and what the impact was on the market.
- 33:32Speaker 1: Is the judge the only one asking questions or are
- 33:35Speaker 1: the lawyers asking questions? Is their cross talk between the experts.
- 33:40Speaker 3: There's a lot of crosstalk. It's almost exclusively Tonato asking
- 33:43Speaker 3: the questions. He allows a couple of attorneys to sit
- 33:46Speaker 3: with the experts in the hot tub, but they're really
- 33:49Speaker 3: only allowed to ask questions right at the end if
- 33:51Speaker 3: they have kind of clarifying questions for either expert. Otherwise
- 33:54Speaker 3: Donato prompts one side or the other. We'll say like, yeah,
- 33:58Speaker 3: I read your report, this question about this, you know,
- 34:02Speaker 3: one part of the model, and then we'll prompt the
- 34:04Speaker 3: other expert to be like, do you disagree with that?
- 34:07Speaker 3: So why it got pretty heated several times if there was,
- 34:11Speaker 3: I don't know if you would call it yelling, but
- 34:12Speaker 3: definitely raised voices. The court reporter had to interrupt I
- 34:16Speaker 3: think three separate times because two experts and the judge
- 34:20Speaker 3: were talking over each other and she couldn't transcribe that
- 34:23Speaker 3: in real time. So it definitely is a little more
- 34:25Speaker 3: chaotic than your average court oral testimony.
- 34:28Speaker 1: Is this because the expert testimony is so complex for
- 34:32Speaker 1: the judge to understand? Or is it because this is quicker?
- 34:38Speaker 1: I mean, what's the real reason behind this?
- 34:40Speaker 3: The reason do not outheld the hants up was to
- 34:42Speaker 3: answer this Google motion over whether the experts should be
- 34:46Speaker 3: allowed to testify or not. And Nato told me in
- 34:49Speaker 3: an interview afterwards that it's very useful for him understanding
- 34:53Speaker 3: their testimony and their models. It is really complicated and
- 34:56Speaker 3: that's a big reason why judges are deploying hot tubs.
- 35:00Speaker 3: Haven't deployed too many of them. But it's not just
- 35:02Speaker 3: as a complexity it's also faster to another side. It's
- 35:06Speaker 3: a lot cleaner compared normal expert testimony, non hot tub
- 35:10Speaker 3: testimony to a game of telephone. Right, You've got the
- 35:12Speaker 3: expert on the stand, you've got their attorney questioning them,
- 35:15Speaker 3: and then you've got the judge hearing their answers. So
- 35:17Speaker 3: it's kind of filtered through what questions the attorney wants
- 35:20Speaker 3: to ask, and then how the economist in this case
- 35:23Speaker 3: answers those questions. The judge might not necessarily be getting
- 35:26Speaker 3: the exact answers they're looking for.
- 35:29Speaker 1: Well, we'll see if the use of these legal hot
- 35:31Speaker 1: tubs picks up, but I think a name change is
- 35:33Speaker 1: in order. Thanks so much, Dan. That's Bloomberg Legal reporter
- 35:37Speaker 1: Dan Paskin, and that's it for this edition of The
- 35:39Speaker 1: Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can always get the latest
- 35:42Speaker 1: legal news on our Bloomberg Law Podcast. You can find
- 35:45Speaker 1: them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at www dot Bloomberg
- 35:50Speaker 1: dot com, slash podcast slash Law, and remember to tune
- 35:54Speaker 1: into The Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight at ten pm
- 35:57Speaker 1: Wall Street Time. I'm June Grass and you're listening to Bloomberg.
- 36:02Speaker 1: M mm hmm,