Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When Your Company Is Struggling Financially
Transcript
- Lucas: So you've been in your role for a year, maybe two. You're delivering strong results. You've checked salary sites, you know you're under market. But your company just announced a revenue miss, or there were layoffs in another department, or the CEO sent a somber memo about 'tightening belts.' And now you're thinking: can I even ask for a raise? Luna: It's a really uncomfortable spot. You don't want to seem tone-deaf, but you also don't want to leave money on the table. Lucas: Right. And the instinct is often to either stay silent or to over-apologize. Neither is great. So let's talk about a framework for this. First question: is the company actually in existential trouble, or is it just a rough quarter? Because that changes everything. Luna: How do you tell the difference? Lucas: Look at the public signals, if it's a public company—stock price trends, earnings call tone. For private companies, you can sometimes check VC funding news or ask trusted colleagues in finance. But a lot of it is reading between the lines. If the company is cutting perks, freezing hiring, delaying vendor payments—that's more serious than one bad quarter. Luna: So if it's truly dire, maybe you don't ask at all, or you focus on non-cash compensation. Lucas: Exactly. But let's start with the scenario where the company is stable, just feeling pressure. In that case, you absolutely can ask. The key is to anchor your ask in market data and your contribution, not in your personal financial needs. Luna: So no mentioning rent increases or student loans. Lucas: Never. The company doesn't pay you based on your expenses. They pay for the value you create. So you say: 'I've benchmarked my role, and similar positions at companies of our size and stage pay between X and Y. My performance has been—here are three specific results—and I'd like to bring my compensation in line with market.' That's a business conversation, not a personal plea. Luna: And you're giving them an out—they can say yes, or they can say 'we can't right now but here's what we can do.' Lucas: Exactly. And that's where you prepare your Plan B. If they can't increase cash salary, what about equity? A lot of startups and even some public companies will grant additional stock options or RSUs when cash is tight. Luna: Or a title change that sets you up for a better job later. A senior title can be worth real money in your next role. Lucas: Yeah, I've seen people negotiate a promotion in title only, with a promise to revisit comp in six months. If you get that in writing, it's a solid fallback. Another option: ask for a professional development budget—certifications, conferences, coaching. That's cash the company can spend on you that doesn't hit the same budget line as salary. Luna: Or a one-time bonus tied to a specific project. That's often easier for managers to approve than a permanent salary increase. Lucas: Great point. A project bonus says 'we can't commit ongoing, but we can reward this specific thing.' And it's a foot in the door for future conversations. Now, timing matters a lot. Don't ask right after a layoff announcement. Wait a few weeks, let things settle. And when you do ask, frame it as 'I want to have a career development conversation' rather than 'I need more money.' Luna: That changes the tone entirely. It becomes collaborative, not confrontational. Lucas: Right. You're saying: 'I want to grow here. Help me understand how we can make that work given the current constraints.' That invites them to problem-solve with you. And if they really can't do anything, you then have honest information: this company can't pay market, and you may need to leave to get your worth. Luna: One thing I'd add: sometimes people don't ask because they feel guilty. They think 'the company is struggling, I shouldn't add pressure.' But if you're underpaid and you leave, that costs the company way more—recruiting, training, lost productivity. Lucas: That's a really important reframe. It's in the company's interest to retain top performers, especially when times are tough. Great employees are harder to replace. So if you're delivering, you're actually being responsible by raising the conversation. You're giving them a chance to keep you. Luna: And if they say no, you've at least planted the seed. They know you're paying attention to market value. Lucas: That's right. Now, let's talk about the actual script for a moment. You want to schedule a dedicated meeting—not a hallway chat. Say: 'I'd like to set aside fifteen minutes to discuss my role and compensation.' Then in the meeting, open with appreciation: 'I really enjoy working here and I'm committed to our team's success.' Then state the data. Then ask: 'Based on this, I'd like to request a raise to X. I understand the company's current situation, so I'm open to creative solutions.' Luna: That last line is gold. It shows you're empathetic but serious. Lucas: And it gives them space to say 'we can't do cash, but we can do equity,' or 'we can do a title bump and revisit in six months.' If they still say no, ask: 'What would need to change for this to be possible? Can we set a check-in date?' That keeps the door open. Luna: One thing I've seen work: ask for a smaller increase spread over time. Like 'can we do 5 percent now and another 5 in six months?' That's less painful on the budget. Lucas: Yeah, phased increases are a good tool. Also, if they offer a one-time bonus, ask for it in writing with a note that it's not a one-off but a recognition of sustained performance. That helps later. Luna: And if you have an offer from another company, that's a different conversation. But that's a whole other episode. Lucas: It is, and we've done a few on that. But today's scenario is specifically when you don't have an external offer—you just know you're under market and the company is squeezed. That's harder, but not impossible. Luna: It's also worth noting: if the company is truly in a death spiral, maybe the best raise is a job at a healthier company. Sometimes the courage to ask reveals that it's time to go. Lucas: That's a really honest point. And if that's the case, you've lost nothing by asking. You've gained information. And that's valuable. Luna: You know, we talk about these career moves a lot on the show, and I think one reason listeners keep coming back is that we try to be really practical. No fluff. Lucas: Absolutely. And that's by design. We deliberately don't run ads on these episodes because we want the advice to be direct and unbroken. If you find that approach useful, and you want to support it, the link is buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small way to keep this ad-free. Luna: Yeah, it really helps. And we appreciate everyone who's ever chipped in. Now, back to the raise conversation—one more point I want to make is about your mindset going in. Lucas: Sure, go ahead. Luna: Don't let the company's financial struggles make you feel like you're being greedy. You're not. You're asking to be paid fairly for the value you create. That's business. If you don't ask, you're subsidizing the company. Lucas: That's a great way to put it. And honestly, most managers respect an employee who can have that conversation professionally. It shows you understand the business context, you've done your homework, and you're invested in staying. That's exactly the kind of person they want to keep. Luna: Even if they can't give you everything right now. Lucas: Right. So to wrap up: assess the severity of the company's situation, prepare market data, lead with your contribution, and come with alternatives. And if the answer is no, get a timeline for revisiting. You'll either get what you're worth or you'll have clarity on your next move. Luna: And that clarity is worth a lot. Lucas: It really is. That's all for today. See you next time.