Latest / Inflation and Your Money with Fexingo: Protecting Purchasing Power and Beating Inflation / Why Gold Is Falling Despite Sticky Inflation
Transcript
- Lucas: So gold is down nearly eleven percent in the last five trading days — and that's after it had already been drifting lower for weeks. GDX, the gold miners ETF, is off almost eleven percent just this week. And this is happening while CPI and PCE are both still running hot. Luna: That seems backwards, right? Inflation's sticky, core PCE is at 129.6, CPI at 332.4, both up from last month. Isn't gold supposed to be the ultimate inflation hedge? Lucas: That's exactly the puzzle. And I think the answer tells us something important about how markets are actually pricing inflation right now — versus the narrative you hear in headlines. Luna: Okay, walk me through it. What is the market seeing that the 'gold as inflation hedge' story misses? Lucas: The key number isn't CPI — it's real yields. The ten-year real yield — that's the nominal Treasury yield minus expected inflation — has been climbing. The ten-year breakeven inflation rate actually dipped to 2.35 percent this week, down from 2.36. That's a tiny move, but the direction matters. Luna: So the breakeven is falling even though actual CPI is still elevated. That suggests the market thinks inflation is going to cool eventually? Lucas: Exactly. And when real yields rise, gold loses its appeal because gold pays no interest. Why hold a non-yielding asset if you can get a higher real return from Treasuries? The opportunity cost of gold goes up. Luna: Right, so the sell-off makes sense if you think of gold as a duration asset — long-duration, zero-coupon, sensitive to real rates. But the speed of this move still feels extreme. Eleven percent in a week? Lucas: That's where the carry trade unwind comes in. A lot of investors — hedge funds especially — were borrowing in low-yielding currencies like the yen or Swiss franc to buy gold futures. That's a leveraged bet. When gold starts falling, margin calls force unwinds. That accelerates the drop. Luna: So the move is partly mechanical — forced selling from levered players — not just a reassessment of inflation. Lucas: Right. But here's the thing: even the 'inflation hedge' part is more complicated than people think. Gold has historically been a good hedge against unexpected inflation — inflation that surprises to the upside. But if the market believes the Fed has inflation under control, or that rate cuts are coming, the hedge premium deflates. Luna: And the hot jobs report from last Friday — what was it, nonfarm payrolls came in well above expectations? — that pushed rate cut expectations further out. Chair Warsh is facing a test. Lucas: Exactly. The Fed funds effective rate is still at 3.63 percent, and the daily rate is flat at 3.62. No cuts imminent. So the narrative is: the economy is strong, the Fed stays on hold, real yields stay elevated, and gold has no catalyst. Luna: But what about the longer-term inflation story? You've had episodes before about how corporate profits, shrinkflation, rent — those aren't going away just because the breakeven dipped a basis point. Lucas: No, they're not. And I think that's the tension. The market is pricing a soft landing with gradual disinflation. But the actual inflation data — CPI at 332.4, core PCE at 129.6 — those are still running well above the Fed's 2 percent target. If you look at the three-month annualized core PCE, it's still around 3.5 percent. Luna: So there's a disconnect between what the bond market is pricing and what the actual data says. That could either mean bonds are wrong — inflation stays higher — or that gold is about to get a reprieve. Lucas: Yeah, and that's what makes this moment interesting for listeners who own gold or are thinking about buying. The sell-off might be an opportunity if you believe the market is underestimating inflation persistence. But you need to understand the mechanics. Luna: What do you mean by mechanics? Lucas: Well, look at the gold miners index — GDX down almost eleven percent this week. That's double the drop in gold itself. Mining stocks are leveraged to the gold price because their costs are relatively fixed. So a ten percent drop in gold can hit margins hard and knock twenty or thirty percent off earnings. That's what you're seeing. Luna: So the miners are getting hit disproportionately. If you're holding individual mining stocks, that's a lot of volatility. Lucas: Right. And if you're a long-term inflation hedge investor, you might not care about the short-term noise. But you should at least understand why your hedge is down while inflation is still hot. It's not that the hedge is broken — it's that the market is looking forward, not backward. Luna: Looking forward to lower inflation and higher real yields. So gold's weakness is actually a vote of confidence in the Fed. Lucas: That's one way to read it. But you could also read it as the market being complacent. If inflation re-accelerates — say from a supply shock or wage pressure — then gold could snap back quickly. But you have to have the conviction and the time horizon. Luna: So for someone listening who has a diversified portfolio, maybe with a five or ten percent allocation to gold or miners — should they hold, trim, or add? Lucas: I'm not going to give personal advice, but I can tell you what the data suggests. If you bought gold in 2022 or 2023 as an inflation hedge, you're still up significantly. This pullback might just be a correction in a longer-term trend. But if you're a tactical investor, the momentum is clearly against gold right now. The real yield trend is your enemy. Luna: And the carry trade unwind could have further to go. When leveraged positions start to liquidate, they can overshoot. Lucas: Exactly. So the safe play might be to wait for stabilization — watch for a few days where gold doesn't make new lows, or for the real yield to peak. But I think the bigger lesson is about how inflation hedges actually work in practice. They don't always move in lockstep with CPI. Luna: That's a good point. Speaking of which — if today's conversation helped you think about your own portfolio or just made the macro picture a little clearer, honestly, if it was worth a coffee to you, that's the link: buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just listener support keeps this ad-free. Lucas: Yeah, and we appreciate it. So, back to gold — let's talk about what might change the story. What would make gold rally from here? Luna: A weaker jobs number, a surprise Fed pivot, or a geopolitical event that pushes safe-haven demand. But none of those seem imminent. Lucas: Right. And that's why the path of least resistance is still lower. But if you're a long-term investor, this might be one of those moments where you add to a position that's out of favor. The key is knowing which camp you're in — trader or allocator. Luna: And if you're in the allocator camp, you probably don't even look at gold's week to week moves. But it's still helpful to understand why it's happening. Lucas: Absolutely. So to sum up: gold is down because real yields are up, carry trades are unwinding, and the market is pricing in lower future inflation. But actual inflation data is still sticky. That tension is what makes this a fascinating moment. Thanks for listening.