Latest / The Morning Rundown / Moonshots, Iran Showdown, and the Supreme Court: Your Morning Rundown
Transcript
- 0:13[Maya] Good morning, everybody,
- 0:14[Maya] and welcome back to the morning rundown.
- 0:16[David] Yeah,
- 0:17[David] grab that coffee,
- 0:18[David] settle in, we've got a busy one today,
- 0:19[David] Maya.
- 0:20[Maya] Totally! So first up,
- 0:22[Maya] NASA's Artemis II plan to send four astronauts around the moon,
- 0:26[Maya] what that price tag really buys us, and how SpaceX and the other private guys fit in.
- 0:31[David] And then we go from peaceful rockets to the ugly stuff,
- 0:34[David] right?
- 0:35[David] Trump talking about bombing Iran back to the Stone Ages,
- 0:38[David] Iran firing in the Gulf,
- 0:39[David] and why that mess shows up in your gas bill.
- 0:42[Maya] Right. Plus, how the media spins it, Europe kind of wags a finger,
- 0:46[Maya] but still...
- 0:46[Maya] still wants cheap energy,
- 0:48[Maya] and what that means for inflation here.
- 0:50[David] So anyway,
- 0:51[David] on the home front we'll hit Trump's push on birthright citizenship,
- 0:55[David] the five little constitutional words the Supreme Court is fighting over,
- 0:58[David] and this whole birth tourism thing.
- 1:00[Maya] And we'll connect it to the latest short-term DHS funding patch,
- 1:05[Maya] why both parties are ducking the real border fight,
- 1:08[Maya] and what that means for security.
- 1:10[David] All right,
- 1:10[David] let's get into it.
- 1:11[Maya] Okay,
- 1:12[Maya] first segment.
- 1:13[Maya] Artemis 2,
- 1:14[Maya] the moon loop and the money behind it, right?
- 1:16[Maya] Right after this.
- 1:18[Maya] Okay, picture this.
- 1:19[Maya] You're driving to work,
- 1:21[Maya] coffee in hand,
- 1:22[Maya] and four people are literally getting ready to fly around the moon.
- 1:27[Maya] Not in a movie.
- 1:28[Maya] For real.
- 1:29[David] Yeah, this is not a reboot of Apollo.
- 1:31[David] This is Artemis 2,
- 1:33[David] NASA's first crewed trip to the moon area in more than 50 years.
- 1:37[Maya] Right,
- 1:37[Maya] so quick who's who.
- 1:39[Maya] You've got Reid Wiseman,
- 1:40[Maya] he's the mission commander.
- 1:42[Maya] Victor Glover,
- 1:43[Maya] first Black astronaut heading toward the moon.
- 1:45[Maya] Christina Koch,
- 1:46[Maya] who already did the longest space flight by a woman,
- 1:49[Maya] and Jeremy Hansen from Canada.
- 1:51[David] That Canada part is interesting.
- 1:53[David] It's basically NASA saying if you help build parts of the program,
- 1:57[David] you get a seat.
- 1:57[David] Literally a seat.
- 1:59[Maya] That is one pricey frequent flyer perk,
- 2:02[Maya] but this is what I love.
- 2:04[Maya] These are real people with families who have to strap into a rocket and say,
- 2:09[Maya] yeah,
- 2:09[Maya] I'm cool leaving Earth for a bit.
- 2:11[Speaker 3] And all of this is a test run.
- 2:12[Speaker 3] They're not landing.
- 2:13[Speaker 3] They'll loop around the moon,
- 2:15[Speaker 3] check the life support,
- 2:16[Speaker 3] the heat shield,
- 2:16[Speaker 3] the whole system,
- 2:17[Speaker 3] then come back.
- 2:18[Maya] So basically this is the dress rehearsal before NASA sends people down to the surface again,
- 2:24[Maya] you know, maybe later this decade if everything works.
- 2:27[Speaker 3] And it ties into something fun for folks listening right now.
- 2:30[Speaker 3] If you're up early this month, you can catch the Lyrids meteor shower,
- 2:34[Speaker 3] little streaks of dust burning up while we talk about big fancy rockets headed out.
- 2:38[Maya] Yeah, if the skies clear,
- 2:40[Maya] look northeast late at night.
- 2:41[Maya] late at night or super early.
- 2:43[Maya] You might see a few shooting stars while these astronauts are literally training to fly past where those rocks used to be.
- 2:50[Speaker 3] Okay,
- 2:50[Speaker 3] so that's the wonder,
- 2:52[Speaker 3] now the wallet.
- 2:53[Speaker 3] This stuff is not cheap.
- 2:55[Maya] Here's the thing.
- 2:55[Maya] People hear moon and think blank check.
- 2:58[Maya] What are we talking money-wise?
- 3:00[Speaker 3] NASA's Artemis program is in the tens of billions,
- 3:03[Speaker 3] one government review pegged a single early mission in the several billion range.
- 3:07[Speaker 3] range,
- 3:07[Speaker 3] and that's one flight!
- 3:08[Maya] Wow. That's like setting a pile of cash on fire,
- 3:12[Maya] letting it orbit the moon,
- 3:13[Maya] and hoping it lands safely.
- 3:15[Speaker 3] Exactly!
- 3:16[Speaker 3] And when families are dealing with high prices on groceries and gas,
- 3:20[Speaker 3] asking taxpayers to fund giant government rockets forever is a hard sell.
- 3:24[Maya] But-and I'm torn here-space also gives you tech,
- 3:28[Maya] GPS,
- 3:29[Maya] weather,
- 3:30[Maya] a lot of stuff we use every day.
- 3:32[Maya] So it isn't just flag on a rock and go home.
- 3:35[Speaker 3] Totally. The question is, who runs it?
- 3:38[Speaker 3] Because now you've got SpaceX and others flying cargo and crew cheaper than the old school government only model.
- 3:44[Maya] Yeah, SpaceX is launching like crazy,
- 3:47[Maya] landing boosters on ships and doing it for a fraction of what the big NASA rocket costs,
- 3:53[Maya] at least from what we've seen.
- 3:54[Speaker 3] Investors are basically drooling over the idea of a SpaceX IPO.
- 3:59[Speaker 3] You've got satellites,
- 4:00[Speaker 3] internet service,
- 4:01[Speaker 3] contracts with NASA...
- 4:02[Speaker 3] Then the Pentagon,
- 4:03[Speaker 3] that is real revenue.
- 4:05[Maya] And yet it's still the old government rocket that's taking these four around the moon.
- 4:10[Maya] So you get this weird mix-private companies doing the day-to-day,
- 4:15[Maya] Washington still writing monster checks for the prestige missions.
- 4:19[Speaker 3] Which raises a fair,
- 4:21[Speaker 3] slightly conservative question:
- 4:23[Speaker 3] If private companies can launch safer and cheaper,
- 4:25[Speaker 3] should the government still be building its own giant rocket at all?
- 4:28[Speaker 3] At all?
- 4:29[Maya] Or should NASA just focus on the science,
- 4:32[Maya] the how do we live on the moon,
- 4:34[Maya] how do we get to Mars part,
- 4:36[Maya] and let SpaceX and friends be the Uber?
- 4:39[Speaker 3] Uber to the moon!
- 4:40[Speaker 3] Surge pricing would be brutal.
- 4:42[Maya] No way I'm paying a late night moon surge.
- 4:45[Maya] But seriously,
- 4:46[Maya] if we're going to spend that kind of money,
- 4:48[Maya] I want it tied to something clear:
- 4:51[Maya] jobs,
- 4:51[Maya] tech,
- 4:52[Maya] maybe even mining stuff out there one day.
- 4:55[Maya] Not just cool posters for classrooms.
- 4:57[Speaker 3] And you also have to ask what happens if something goes wrong.
- 5:01[Speaker 3] A launch failure,
- 5:02[Speaker 3] a heat shield issue,
- 5:03[Speaker 3] anything.
- 5:04[Speaker 3] The public tolerance for risk is a lot lower now than it was during Apollo.
- 5:08[Maya] Yeah,
- 5:09[Maya] we say we like bold missions,
- 5:11[Maya] but the second there's a tragedy,
- 5:13[Maya] everybody points at the price tag and screams,
- 5:15[Maya] you know what I mean?
- 5:16[Speaker 3] So here's the tension.
- 5:18[Speaker 3] We still want to lead in space,
- 5:20[Speaker 3] we want that edge.
- 5:21[Speaker 3] But we're broke and nervous at the same time.
- 5:24[Maya] And while we're talking about rockets taking people around the moon,
- 5:28[Maya] there are other rockets aimed at cities and oil fields right now.
- 5:32[Maya] How much are we really willing to pay,
- 5:34[Maya] in dollars and in risk,
- 5:36[Maya] when those launches start changing the price at your gas pump?
- 5:40[Maya] Shifting gears for a second,
- 5:43[Maya] we go from moon rockets to missiles over the Persian Gulf.
- 5:46[Speaker 3] Yeah, so headline here.
- 5:48[Speaker 3] Trump said if Iran keeps hitting targets in the Gulf,
- 5:51[Speaker 3] he will quote bomb them back to the Stone Ages.
- 5:54[Speaker 3] That is strong language.
- 5:56[Maya] Yeah,
- 5:57[Maya] that's not exactly diplomatic speak.
- 6:00[Maya] Walk us through what actually happened,
- 6:02[Maya] though,
- 6:02[Maya] because people hear that and think World War III.
- 6:05[Speaker 3] Right,
- 6:05[Speaker 3] so Iran has been firing drones and missiles across the Gulf.
- 6:09[Speaker 3] Gulf,
- 6:09[Speaker 3] taking shots at oil infrastructure and shipping lanes.
- 6:12[Maya] Hmm.
- 6:12[Speaker 3] Think tank folks call it gray zone, but bottom line,
- 6:15[Speaker 3] it threatens energy and U.S. forces.
- 6:17[Maya] So they poke at tankers, pipelines,
- 6:20[Maya] bases,
- 6:20[Maya] but try to stay just under the line where America hits back hard.
- 6:25[Speaker 3] Exactly.
- 6:26[Speaker 3] And Trump is basically saying that line is gone if they keep pushing.
- 6:30[Speaker 3] He has a history of that.
- 6:31[Speaker 3] Remember when he took out Soleimani instead of sending a big ground force?
- 6:35[Maya] Yeah, that was more hit the guy calling the shots instead of rolling tanks across the desert.
- 6:40[Speaker 3] Right.
- 6:41[Speaker 3] Deterrence without another Iraq.
- 6:43[Speaker 3] Conservatives tend to like that mix,
- 6:45[Speaker 3] be scary enough that they stop,
- 6:47[Speaker 3] but don't get stuck babysitting their country for 20 years.
- 6:50[Maya] Okay,
- 6:51[Maya] but when people hear bomb them back to the Stone Ages,
- 6:55[Maya] they picture a city flattened.
- 6:57[Speaker 3] Totally.
- 6:58[Speaker 3] And that's where media tone comes in.
- 7:00[Maya] Listen-a lot of coverage turns into "Trump-loose cannon,
- 7:03[Maya] bad man says scary thing," and you almost forget Iran is the one firing first.
- 7:09[David] Yeah,
- 7:09[David] funny how Tehran's rockets end up on page two.
- 7:12[Maya] Exactly-you can criticize Trump's wording and still say,
- 7:16[Maya] "Hey,
- 7:17[Maya] maybe the regime launching drones at tankers is not the good guy here.
- 7:21[David] So,
- 7:21[David] um,
- 7:22[David] bring this down to earth.
- 7:23[David] Somebody filling up their SUV this morning is like,
- 7:26[David] all right, but what does this do to my gas bill?
- 7:29[Maya] Good question.
- 7:30[David] Because markets freak out on vibes.
- 7:32[David] If traders think the Gulf might go hot,
- 7:35[David] oil prices jump,
- 7:36[David] even if no pipeline actually gets hit.
- 7:38[Maya] Yeah,
- 7:39[Maya] we've already seen crude swing on every headline. A threat here,
- 7:42[Maya] a strike there,
- 7:43[Maya] boom,
- 7:44[Maya] future spike.
- 7:45[David] And a little bump in oil turns into higher gas,
- 7:48[David] and that feeds into inflation.
- 7:49[David] Groceries get shipped,
- 7:51[David] planes need jet fuel,
- 7:52[David] it ripples everywhere.
- 7:54[Maya] Exactly.
- 7:55[Maya] So when leaders talk tough,
- 7:57[Maya] it's not just chest beating.
- 7:58[Maya] It can move prices before a single bomb drops.
- 8:01[David] Which is why energy independence matters so much.
- 8:05[David] I know it sounds like a bumper sticker,
- 8:07[David] but if you're less hooked on Middle East oil,
- 8:10[David] Iranian missiles matter a bit less to your wallet.
- 8:13[Maya] Yeah,
- 8:13[Maya] that's the conservative critique.
- 8:15[Maya] We shut down production at home.
- 8:17[Maya] Then act shocked when we're back begging OPEC while Iran plays chicken in the Gulf.
- 8:22[David] And then politicians say,
- 8:24[David] wow,
- 8:25[David] inflation?
- 8:25[David] Who could have guessed?
- 8:27[David] You know exactly what happened.
- 8:29[David] You squeezed supply and increased risk.
- 8:31[Maya] Meanwhile,
- 8:32[Maya] Europe and the UK are clutching pearls about Trump's language.
- 8:36[Maya] A lot of European leaders are calling it escalatory,
- 8:39[Maya] irresponsible,
- 8:40[Maya] all that.
- 8:40[David] Sure, but some of those same governments were happy buying cheap Russian energy for years.
- 8:46[David] And now yell at us to keep the Gulf calm!
- 8:48[David] Little selective outrage.
- 8:51[Maya] Yeah,
- 8:51[Maya] there's this pattern where Trump is always the unique danger,
- 8:54[Maya] while Iran,
- 8:55[Maya] Russia,
- 8:56[Maya] whoever,
- 8:56[Maya] are described as complex actors with security concerns.
- 9:00[David] Oh,
- 9:01[David] their concerns!
- 9:02[David] like their concern about having less money if they can't jack up energy prices!
- 9:07[Maya] Exactly.
- 9:08[Maya] Look,
- 9:08[Maya] nobody's sane is cheering for war.
- 9:11[Maya] The real question is what actually keeps the peace.
- 9:13[Maya] pretending everything is fine or clear red lines that hostile regimes believe.
- 9:18[David] And for families here,
- 9:19[David] peace looks like stable gas prices,
- 9:22[David] not getting drafted,
- 9:23[David] and not paying for a 20-year occupation on their taxes.
- 9:26[Maya] Right.
- 9:27[Maya] Strong enough that Iran thinks twice,
- 9:29[Maya] careful enough that we don't own their problems.
- 9:32[David] Speaking of strength and lines,
- 9:34[David] this whole question of how far a president can go isn't just about missiles.
- 9:38[Maya] Yeah, we're seeing it at home, too.
- 9:40[David] Next up we have Trump in court again,
- 9:43[David] this time over birthright citizenship and whether those famous five words in the Constitution cover every baby born here or not.
- 9:51[Maya] And Congress trying to end the record DHS shutdown without giving away the whole border debate.
- 9:56[Maya] So immigration,
- 9:57[Maya] power and the law all colliding.
- 9:59[David] Grab your coffee,
- 10:01[David] that one's spicy.
- 10:03[David] Shifting gears real quick, we go from security abroad to security at home.
- 10:07[Maya] Yeah. Same core question, though. Who gets to decide how strong the border is?
- 10:12[David] So, um,
- 10:14[David] birthright citizenship.
- 10:15[David] People keep saying Trump ended the 14th Amendment.
- 10:18[David] That sounds dramatic.
- 10:20[David] What did he actually do?
- 10:22[Maya] He signed an order that targets a slice of birthright citizenship,
- 10:25[Maya] specifically kids born here to parents who are in the country illegally or only here to...
- 10:29[Maya] We hear temporarily.
- 10:31[David] And the fight is over those five words,
- 10:33[David] Right?
- 10:34[David] What are they,
- 10:35[David] plain English,
- 10:36[David] no law school required.
- 10:37[Maya] The line in the Fourteenth Amendment says you're born here and subject to the jurisdiction of the United States.
- 10:43[Maya] Those five words are the whole fight.
- 10:45[David] So one side says,
- 10:46[David] born here,
- 10:47[David] done deal; and the other says,
- 10:49[David] hang on,
- 10:50[David] that jurisdiction phrase matters.
- 10:52[Maya] Exactly.
- 10:54[Maya] Conservatives argue it means you owe full political loyalty.
- 10:56[Maya] loyalty,
- 10:57[Maya] not just that you're standing on U.S. soil for a weekend,
- 11:00[Maya] liberals say it basically just means you're not a foreign diplomat.
- 11:03[David] Okay, but what did the Supreme Court just hear?
- 11:06[David] Like, what were the actual questions they were throwing at the lawyers?
- 11:10[Maya] A lot of,
- 11:10[Maya] does the text lock in automatic citizenship for anyone born here versus did Congress and states leave room for limits?
- 11:17[Maya] Some justices pressed history,
- 11:19[Maya] others pushed on practical stuff,
- 11:21[Maya] like what happens to millions of people if the rule changes.
- 11:23[David] So is this where that old Wong Kim Ark case comes in?
- 11:28[Maya] Yeah,
- 11:28[Maya] that case said a guy born in San Francisco to Chinese immigrant parents was a citizen.
- 11:33[Maya] The argument now is whether that ruling covers kids of people who are here illegally or if that goes too far.
- 11:38[David] And media framing, because of course, how are they splitting on this?
- 11:43[Maya] Fox leans hard into Trump is finally testing a broken system and talks about border chaos and cartels.
- 11:49[David] Mm-hmm.
- 11:50[Maya] Axios does more here's the legal chessboard with less judgment.
- 11:54[Maya] The Wall Street Journal worries about long-term incentives.
- 11:57[Maya] CNBC mostly touches it when markets care about migration and labor.
- 12:00[David] Yeah,
- 12:01[David] the vibe I get from a lot of cable is,
- 12:03[David] if you even question birthright citizenship,
- 12:06[David] you're some villain from a History Channel documentary.
- 12:09[Maya] Right.
- 12:09[Maya] No room for,
- 12:10[Maya] hey, maybe the Framers in the 1860s didn't foresee Instagram birth tourism packages.
- 12:15[David] Wait,
- 12:16[David] talk about that.
- 12:17[David] Birth tourism sounds like a joke until you see the ads.
- 12:20[Maya] Totally.
- 12:21[Maya] You have companies abroad selling U.S.
- 12:23[Maya] baby trips,
- 12:24[Maya] fly in on tourist visa,
- 12:25[Maya] stay at a rented house near a hospital,
- 12:27[Maya] give birth,
- 12:28[Maya] fly home.
- 12:29[Maya] Now your kid has an American passport for life.
- 12:31[David] Wow. I mean, from a parent angle,
- 12:34[David] I get wanting the best for your kid.
- 12:36[David] From a taxpayer angle,
- 12:37[David] you're like,
- 12:38[David] did I just pay for your anchor baby to my Social Security?
- 12:41[David] Ready?
- 12:41[Maya] That's the conservative worry; not just money but fairness.
- 12:45[Maya] People wait years in line and others work the loopholes.
- 12:48[David] Okay,
- 12:49[David] quick lightning round:
- 12:50[David] What are the big risks either way for the court?
- 12:52[Maya] If they back Trump fully,
- 12:54[Maya] critics scream "second class kids"
- 12:56[Maya] and you get legal chaos sorting out who's in and who's out.
- 12:59[Maya] If they block him,
- 13:00[Maya] you probably lock in this very broad version of birthright citizenship for decades.
- 13:05[David] And politically,
- 13:06[David] either ruling hands both parties a giant campaign talking point.
- 13:09[David] Talking point.
- 13:10[Maya] Oh, yeah.
- 13:11[Maya] Ads for days.
- 13:12[David] All right, tie this into the other big grind in D.C., the DHS shutdown saga.
- 13:18[Maya] So Republicans on the Hill say they have a deal to finally reopen Homeland Security after the record shutdown.
- 13:24[Maya] In exchange for funding, they get more money for Border Patrol,
- 13:27[Maya] some wall repairs,
- 13:28[Maya] and tighter rules on how many migrants can be paroled into the interior.
- 13:32[David] And Democrats get what, mainly?
- 13:35[Maya] They dodge deeper structural changes. No full new asylum.
- 13:38[Maya] asylum system,
- 13:39[Maya] no hard statutory cap on parole,
- 13:42[Maya] and they keep leverage for the next funding round.
- 13:44[David] So it's like we'll turn the lights on,
- 13:47[David] but we'll argue again in six months.
- 13:49[Maya] Exactly.
- 13:50[Maya] The shelf life is short.
- 13:51[Maya] These fights pop right back up with the next caravan,
- 13:54[Maya] the next crime story,
- 13:55[Maya] the next election ad.
- 13:57[David] Meanwhile,
- 13:58[David] people just want airports safe,
- 14:00[Maya] forts safe,
- 14:01[Maya] sentinels stopped,
- 14:02[Maya] and some basic sanity at the border.
- 14:05[David] And that is what to watch next-the courts ruling on those five words,
- 14:09[David] and whether this DHS deal survives the next wave of headlines.
- 14:12[Maya] Yeah,
- 14:13[Maya] keep an eye on both.
- 14:14[Maya] One is about who gets to be an American.
- 14:17[Maya] The other is about who actually protects America.
- 14:21[Maya] Alright,
- 14:21[Maya] that's our Rundown.
- 14:22[Maya] I keep coming back to that Artemis moment.
- 14:25[Maya] You know,
- 14:25[Maya] four regular people strapping in to loop the moon while the rest of us are stuck in traffic.
- 14:31[David] Yeah. And meanwhile,
- 14:32[David] Iran,
- 14:33[David] Trump,
- 14:34[David] birthright fights,
- 14:35[David] it all circles the same point.
- 14:37[David] Who actually has power and what it costs you at the pump and at the border.
- 14:41[Maya] Exactly.
- 14:42[Maya] Takeaway today?
- 14:43[Maya] Policy isn't abstract.
- 14:45[Maya] It hits your gas receipt and your kid's future.
- 14:47[Maya] FAST
- 14:48[David] Hmm,
- 14:49[David] if you dug this,
- 14:50[David] hit follow,
- 14:51[David] drop a quick review,
- 14:52[David] and share the show with one friend who loves straight talk in the morning.
- 14:55[Maya] Thanks for starting your day with us.
- 14:57[David] We'll be back tomorrow.
- 14:58[Maya] See you then.