Latest / Politics with Paul / How to Read Ballot Measures | Politics with Paul #90
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast, your home for a nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:05political science and civics.
- 0:07I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:09Today we're gonna talk about how to read ballot measures.
- 0:12With election season in full swing, many states and local areas will have ballot measures for
- 0:18you to vote on, which means that there are some policies that you, the voters, get to decide
- 0:24whether they become law.
- 0:26And they'll cover a wide range of policy areas including redistricting, citizenship
- 0:31requirements for voting, ranked choice voting, campaign contribution limits, government
- 0:36official salaries, transgender policies, taxes, and age limits for officials, just to name a
- 0:41few.
- 0:41And some have even been voted on already, including a couple of high profile ones you've
- 0:46probably already heard about.
- 0:47And as such, you should really know what these ballot measures say.
- 0:52But of course, that is easier said than done.
- 0:55They can be difficult to research and when you do find them, they can still be difficult to
- 1:00read.
- 1:01Fortunately, I'm here to help you today.
- 1:04Today, I have plenty of tips that you can use to help make yourself the most informed you can
- 1:10be when you go to the ballot box.
- 1:12And I'll be covering where you can find these measures, why it can be difficult to read them,
- 1:18tips for making them easier to read, the different parts of a ballot measure, the tug
- 1:23and pull between a measure summary and its full text, and what to watch out for when it comes
- 1:29to the political games that are played with these ballot measures.
- 1:34And some of these principles I've adapted from a webinar I do where I teach companies and
- 1:39organizations how to read and interpret bills and legislation being written and debated by
- 1:45state and federal governments.
- 1:47And if you want to learn more about that and have the webinar presented to your own
- 1:51organization, message me about it on LinkedIn or email me at paulraderwritesgmail dot com.
- 1:57But for now, let's talk about ballot measures.
- 2:00So where do you find ballot measures?
- 2:05Two basic ways to really find out what ballot measures you can vote on and what they say.
- 2:10You can either go to Ballotpedia's ballot measures content or you can go to your chief
- 2:15elections official website.
- 2:18And so the basic process of how to find these ballot measures, if you're gonna go the
- 2:24Ballotpedia route, you go to ballotpedia.org.
- 2:27You can either search for ballot measures in the search bar up at the top, or you can scroll
- 2:31down the page, the front page to the link for ballot measures.
- 2:35There'll be a specific link for that somewhere sort of in the middle of the page, or you can
- 2:41go all the way down to the bottom and you'll see amongst the plethora of links there, links
- 2:47to both the state and local ballot measures content on the website.
- 2:53And when you're in that portal for ballot measures, there's a drop down option near the
- 2:57top of the page that will include a link directly to the current elections measures.
- 3:03And there are also options you can use to search ballot measures by subject matter or
- 3:08topic.
- 3:09There are states, campaign finance reports, polling, signature drives, history, and so on.
- 3:15If you go the chief elections official's website, you it's hard to really give you a
- 3:22specific this is how you do it because all these websites are so different and how they
- 3:28are navigated and so on.
- 3:30And in a large majority of cases, the chief elections official is going to be the state's
- 3:35secretary of state.
- 3:37Just like there's a secretary of state for the federal government, there is a secretary of
- 3:42state for the vast majority of states.
- 3:44I believe it's 47 out
- 3:45of 50 that have one.
- 3:48But in certain cases, there will be a specific elections administrator that will be in this
- 3:53role.
- 3:53There might be an elections commission.
- 3:55And in a couple of cases in Utah and Alaska, there will be the lieutenant governor who is
- 4:00the chief elections official.
- 4:02And so you could search for that official's respective website and navigate to their ballot
- 4:07measures section that way.
- 4:09Sometimes there'll be a search bar you can use or they'll have a specific section of what's on
- 4:13your ballot and you can go click on that or they might even say ballot measures.
- 4:17Again, because there's so many of these different states and they all vary and how
- 4:21difficult it can be to navigate these websites, it's really hard to give you a concrete, this
- 4:26is the process you use.
- 4:27So you'll probably have to be using the search bar several times, but you'll wanna look for
- 4:31that chief elections official in that state for their website.
- 4:37And to find that, if you wanna look up who the state or the chief election official in your
- 4:42state is, you can go to the National Conference of State Legislature Latures.
- 4:46Excuse me.
- 4:47They have that information on hand.
- 4:49They have a nice handy list telling you who that is, but chances are it's going be your
- 4:53state's secretary of state.
- 4:56Now, let's say you've found these ballot measures that you're trying to look for.
- 5:00You also can
- 5:00get the sample ballot sent to you that's going to
- 5:04be sent to you sometime before your actual election that you voted, and you'll be able to
- 5:10get that there.
- 5:11But now, let's say that you've come up to your ballot measures and you have them on hand.
- 5:17How difficult is it to read ballot measures?
- 5:21Ballot measures are potentially going to be put into law, obviously, that's why they're being
- 5:25voted on.
- 5:26So, have to look like something you'd see in laws in some fashion.
- 5:31Reading policies and laws and such can be intimidating for many people.
- 5:36That's part of the reason why I have a webinar about how to read legislation that governments
- 5:41and legislatures are debating.
- 5:44Besides having to take the time to figure out where to find these measures, you have to
- 5:49actually be able to parse the words.
- 5:50And sometimes these words can be very dense.
- 5:53They're often written in what is called legalese, which is an actual word.
- 5:58It's not just a funny remark that people make to try to poke fun at how laws are written.
- 6:05It's actually called legalese.
- 6:07And so that can look very dense and highfalutin.
- 6:10And to be honest, a lot of times it is.
- 6:13And that density often contributes to a plethora of court cases about the meaning of
- 6:18these legal texts.
- 6:19And it's notoriously difficult for the public to understand.
- 6:23Even if you could actually understand what the words mean, just the way they're constructed
- 6:27and the way that they're packed together and just how much text you have to read, it can be
- 6:33very exhausting, intimidating, or just like, you know what?
- 6:37I'm going to spend my time doing something else.
- 6:40And to some extent, the powers that be kind of hope you do that.
- 6:44More on that in a second.
- 6:45But how do we calculate the difficulty of reading ballot measures?
- 6:51Because the average level of readability of ballot measures is typically quite higher than
- 6:56the literacy level of the average voter.
- 6:59Sometimes you can require bachelor's, master's, PhD to really be able to fully comprehend or at
- 7:05least to be able to comprehend easily without having to spend time reading that ballot
- 7:10measure.
- 7:11So there are some formulas that are that can be used to sort of quantify that level of
- 7:19readability.
- 7:20And two examples that are highlighted by Ballipedia in that regard are the Flesch
- 7:24Reading Ease, FRE, and the Flesch Kinkade grade level formula.
- 7:30And Flesch Kincaid is really a revision of the FRE because it's that's I forget his first
- 7:35name, but mister or doctor Flesch has a hand heavy hand in both of those.
- 7:41But both are formulas that involve a count of the total words and total sentences in these
- 7:48measures, and not just necessarily for ballot measures, just for things in general.
- 7:52It's a mathematical calculation based on total words and total sentences.
- 7:57But there isn't really a formula that exists that can account for the difficulty or
- 8:03complexity of the ideas and valid measures themselves.
- 8:07Sure, somebody could maybe read what the actual words are, maybe even know what the words are
- 8:14saying, but trying to put the idea together of, okay, what is this exactly trying to do is not
- 8:19always straightforward.
- 8:20And sometimes you need to spend time to think about that, especially if it's a really long
- 8:24ballot measure because some ballot measures are longer than others, which we'll talk about in a
- 8:28little bit too.
- 8:29But some subject matter is going to be more comprehensible for one group of people, but not
- 8:35others.
- 8:35And then that other group of people might find another topic to be more comprehensible than
- 8:41that first group would.
- 8:43So there's no real one size fits all policy when it comes to figuring out, oh, okay, this
- 8:50is how difficult this content is to read.
- 8:54It's one thing to know what the words are and what they're actually saying, how to pronounce
- 8:58them, but it's another to really understand what the law is trying to get at.
- 9:03Again, it goes back to that whole legalese concept.
- 9:07So why not just make legal writing easier, make these ballot measures easier to read, making
- 9:14these laws that are already on the books easier to read?
- 9:17Why not write it in Legalese?
- 9:19Why not just write it in plain English?
- 9:22Because the benefits are, well, the intention of the laws would become more concrete and
- 9:28understandable because anybody can read them or at least most people can read them.
- 9:32It would help improve civic knowledge because it's a lot easier for people to know what laws
- 9:36are on the books.
- 9:37The public would be better educated on what the laws are.
- 9:43Problem is, legalese also allows for greater precision in making laws.
- 9:49It's a lot more applicable to court cases than it is just to write it in plain English.
- 9:55It's kind of hard to get at.
- 9:57But it would also be very costly and time consuming to rewrite all the laws that we do
- 10:03have to be more modern.
- 10:05And to be honest, a lot of poor old lawyers would be out of a job because their services in
- 10:10reading and arguing law would be much less required.
- 10:14And now it's easy for me to make fun of lawyers for that, but also modernizing legalese would
- 10:20also admittedly hinder me because then my webinar on how to read and interpret
- 10:26legislation would be a lot less valuable because a lot more people can do it.
- 10:29So I guess I shouldn't throw too many stones in my glass house, so to speak.
- 10:35But some of it is just because lawyers want to keep their jobs and get paid and and make you
- 10:43have to go to them.
- 10:43So it behooves them to to defend legalese.
- 10:47But in fairness, it is also difficult to just have everything just rewritten in plain
- 10:54English.
- 10:54And also how do you codify it so
- 10:56you say, oh, yeah.
- 10:56This is just plainly written.
- 10:59It's one
- 11:00of those things that sounds easier to do than it actually is, and you unfortunately find that
- 11:04to be the case a lot of times when it comes to making things laws.
- 11:08But that said, there are some measures in place that do make ballot measures easier to read.
- 11:14As of twenty twenty five, twenty one states have laws on the books that govern ballot
- 11:20measure readability according to Ballotpedia.
- 11:23And sometimes these laws are a simple, vague ballot measures need to be in simple language.
- 11:30They need to be written in plain English.
- 11:32And then sometimes explicit criteria is required, like a number of words for the
- 11:39summary or even references to those reading formulas.
- 11:43Like, I think it's Arkansas that specifically references the Flesh Kinkade grade level
- 11:50formula or could could be some other sort of stipulation.
- 11:54So sometimes it's a vague requirement to be readable.
- 11:58Other times they have more stipulations for it to be readable.
- 12:02And then indirectly related to that readability requirements, but still has some level of
- 12:09relevance.
- 12:10You have a single subject rule and you have separate vote requirements.
- 12:15So a single subject rule means that each ballot measure can only address one topic or issue.
- 12:22And of the 26 states that allow for citizen initiated measures, because that's what the
- 12:27single subject rule is applied to, 16 of them require each ballot measure to only focus on a
- 12:33single subject.
- 12:34So 10 states do not require you to have a single subject for your ballot measure, so they
- 12:40can cover a whole bunch of different things.
- 12:41So you wanna have a ballot measure that talks about marijuana, recreational marijuana, but
- 12:47then you wanna also talk about bump stocks on guns.
- 12:51Well, you can do that in several of those states.
- 12:54States that require a single subject rule, not gonna be able to do them, but there can also be
- 12:59some instances where the single subject rule is not necessarily clear cut.
- 13:05Healthcare, for example, is one big topic.
- 13:09But could you try to argue that certain aspects in healthcare are not related to each other and
- 13:16therefore it's not single subject?
- 13:17Like if you talk about how to help mothers in childbirth versus transgender transitioning
- 13:25healthcare policies, are those two different subjects?
- 13:28Some people might say, well, that's under the umbrella of healthcare.
- 13:32So yes, it is one subject.
- 13:33Some people will say those are two very disparate subjects within the sphere of
- 13:38healthcare.
- 13:39So really they're actually two different subjects.
- 13:41It can be sometimes not a clear cut answer and different interests will argue one way or
- 13:49another.
- 13:50And then the separate vote requirement means that a proposed or proposed constitutional
- 13:55amendments must be made into separate ballot questions.
- 13:59You can't just all cobble them all together, and 32 states have that requirement.
- 14:03So not necessarily explicitly about readability of legislation, but when you do have single
- 14:09subject rules and you do have separate vote requirements, it does inherently make these
- 14:15ballot measures easier to read because there's a lot less content that is compiled within each
- 14:20of these ballot measures.
- 14:22But regardless of any of that, what are the parts of a ballot measure?
- 14:28Because it's not just simply, oh, hey, here's a ballot measure, yes or no.
- 14:31No.
- 14:31There are specific pieces that you need to know before you actually decide whether to vote yes
- 14:37or no.
- 14:38So there
- 14:38are four main pieces that you need
- 14:41to know.
- 14:41There's the title of the ballot measure, there's the summary, there's the full text, and
- 14:47when available, a fiscal impact statement.
- 14:51Each state has different requirements as to what their fiscal impact statements need, who
- 14:57makes those fiscal impact statements, how in-depth they need to be, whether they actually
- 15:03appear on the ballot, all sorts of different things.
- 15:05But in a lot of cases, will see a fiscal impact statement where it says, if this ballot measure
- 15:11passes, here's the impact on government revenues and taxes and and and all that jazz.
- 15:19Here's what's going to happen.
- 15:21And of course, their projections, you can't necessarily say for sure this is what's gonna
- 15:25happen, but they have to make those projections and estimates.
- 15:30And all of these are important, but the most important one is the text.
- 15:34But first, let's talk about the title.
- 15:37So the title of the measure is it's the official name of the ballot measure, and it
- 15:43showcases the main subject areas of the measure.
- 15:46In a way, it's it's the summary of the summary, really.
- 15:49So I'll say, amendment one or question number one, should the state legislature do blah blah
- 15:58blah, and that's your title.
- 16:01And sometimes the titles will be a little bit lengthier.
- 16:05Sometimes they'll be a little bit shorter, and each state might have different laws as to how
- 16:11long those titles can be.
- 16:13But in any case, that's the shortest part of the amendment, typically speaking.
- 16:19Then you've also got the summary of the ballot measure.
- 16:23It's a brief synopsis of what the ballot measure does.
- 16:27So it tries to take as much of what is in the ballot measure as possible and describe what it
- 16:33does in plain English, and that's where a lot of these
- 16:35readability laws come into play.
- 16:38A lot of
- 16:39times they talk about the summary.
- 16:41So the full text can be that higher literacy level and then the summaries tend to be lower
- 16:48requirements to understand.
- 16:50So they're meant to make ballot measures clearer as to what they do, in theory at least,
- 16:57because some text is so long that summaries cannot possibly cover every little piece of
- 17:06information in those texts.
- 17:08And each state has their own laws as to how summaries can be written, who writes them, what
- 17:14the approval process is, in order to have that summary be put on the ballot, because sometimes
- 17:21the summary that they have at one point may be ruled by the chief elections official in that
- 17:28state as insufficient.
- 17:30And so they have
- 17:30to go back and rewrite that summary, even if the ballot measure itself has technically been
- 17:36approved for the ballot.
- 17:38It can
- 17:39get very convoluted and of course each state has its own ways of doing that.
- 17:44And then the most important part of a ballot measure is of course the full text.
- 17:49It's the full transcription of what the measure does.
- 17:52If it gets passed into law, this is exactly what the measure is going to look like when
- 17:57it's put into law.
- 17:58So sometimes, in fact, a lot of times, it will be written in legalese.
- 18:03So it may look a little jargony.
- 18:04But in state laws, they also oftentimes,
- 18:09if there is jargon, they will have a separate section that says what words are defined as.
- 18:15Even if they think you think that there are words that are pretty straightforward or terms
- 18:19that are pretty straightforward, they won't necessarily be.
- 18:22You have to specifically codify what they are.
- 18:24Like with the rise of artificial intelligence, you have to specify what counts as artificial
- 18:29intelligence.
- 18:30Because really artificial intelligence has been around for quite a while.
- 18:33It's been around in all sorts of technical applications, and it's been around in things
- 18:39like video games for a while.
- 18:40It's just this level of artificial intelligence, these capabilities, these large
- 18:45language learning models or large language models, the LLMs, these are relatively new.
- 18:52With it becoming more and more complex and more and more powerful very quickly, you really have
- 19:00to come
- 19:00up with specific laws to really figure
- 19:05out how to handle this explosion in artificial intelligence.
- 19:09And so the text, sometimes the text can be very short, like one or two sentences, and then
- 19:16sometimes it can be very convoluted passages.
- 19:18Really just depends on what the intention of the ballot measure is, what the subject matter
- 19:24is, where in the law it's trying to amend things.
- 19:27Sometimes it's really just trying to tweak one thing, and then other times it's trying to
- 19:31tweak a lot of things.
- 19:33And sometimes that also depends on that single subject rule.
- 19:37But in any case, the full text of the ballot measure almost never actually appears on the
- 19:44ballot.
- 19:45That's why we have summaries because you can't fit all that text onto a ballot.
- 19:51You you go and look up some of the ones that you're gonna be voting on.
- 19:54Imagine if you had the entire text of that ballot measure on your ballot.
- 19:59And if they if people did not read them ahead of time, they're certainly not gonna read them
- 20:04when they get to the ballot box, at least in
- 20:06a lot of cases.
- 20:07But
- 20:09in any case, most times, the text is gonna be just way too long to fit onto the ballot
- 20:14because you've got a whole bunch of other offices to vote on.
- 20:17You might have other ballot measures to vote on.
- 20:19Like, some areas will have a ton of local measures.
- 20:21There's, like, some places in Texas that will have a bajillion local ballot measures to vote
- 20:27on.
- 20:27You you they gotta be able to fit them as many as possible.
- 20:31So summaries are paramount in those cases.
- 20:35You can't just have all the text on there.
- 20:39Even if some ballot measures are short enough to do that, you'll still get the summary for
- 20:44it.
- 20:45So the summary is what gets placed on the ballot instead, and so you have to search for
- 20:50the text yourself.
- 20:52Now, when you're looking at the text, you'll notice some interesting typographical, what do
- 20:59they call
- 20:59it, typographical emphasis that is placed on these words.
- 21:06And so I'm going to
- 21:07tell you how to parse all those because sometimes you'll see things that are underlined
- 21:11or struck through or in green text or in red text.
- 21:15Here's how you determine what the whole point of all that is.
- 21:19Relevant passages that are not necessarily being changed but are right next to passages
- 21:24that are being changed will be shown and they will not have anything special done to them.
- 21:30In most cases, there may be some exceptions, but in most cases, any text that is underlined
- 21:37is being added or it's proposed to be added or that font may be green because usually that
- 21:42indicates that something is trying to be put into something.
- 21:46On the other hand, if text is struck through or if the font is red, it tends to mean that that
- 21:52text is projected or proposed to be deleted.
- 21:56Plain text that has no sort of typographical emphasis means that this, that specific bit of
- 22:02existing law is staying the same.
- 22:04And so you might even see like one or two words by themselves just struck through.
- 22:10And then a lot
- 22:11of the rest of that passage is being kept the same.
- 22:15And sometimes it's not necessarily anything important.
- 22:18It's just to make the words, the paragraph grammatically make sense with the rest of the
- 22:23function.
- 22:23Maybe they'll change is to are, for example.
- 22:27But if plain text doesn't exist at all in that ballot measure and it is all underlined, that
- 22:33means an entire section of law is being added.
- 22:36Nothing was there in that specific section prior to this ballot measure if this ballot
- 22:41measure gets passed.
- 22:42And if a plain text does not exist and it is all struck through, that means an entire
- 22:47section of a
- 22:48law is proposed to be deleted.
- 22:51So if you like all those changes being made, typically speaking, if you like what is being
- 22:57added, being added, or you like deleting what is proposed to be deleted, then you probably
- 23:02want to vote yes on that measure.
- 23:05If you don't want what is being added to be added, or you don't want what is being deleted
- 23:10to be deleted, then you probably want to vote no on that measure because it is changing
- 23:15things you don't want to change.
- 23:16Sometimes you may actually want what is being deleted to be deleted.
- 23:21Sometimes you may want what is being added to be added, but there's not necessarily anything
- 23:26inherently more valuable about what is being added versus what is being struck through.
- 23:33It really just depends on whether you the thing that's being gotten rid of is something you
- 23:37don't like and you think it needs to be removed or changed or something that is being added
- 23:43that you think needs to be added.
- 23:45And then if you
- 23:46don't like those changes, then
- 23:47you vote no on the measure.
- 23:48And then lastly, pass the text, is
- 23:51the fiscal impact statement.
- 23:52Again, not always available, but this tells you what the potential economic effect on the bill
- 23:59is.
- 24:01So it may tell you that it'll cost X number of dollars or that it may generate X amount of
- 24:11revenue or that it may increase taxes by X percent.
- 24:18All those kinds
- 24:19of things can be part of
- 24:21the fiscal impact of the proposed ballot measure.
- 24:26And not every state requires a fiscal impact statement for all measures.
- 24:30And states that do have some sort of requirement for fiscal impact statements, they
- 24:40may have different criteria for them.
- 24:42What exactly is in them, whether they
- 24:44are actually on the ballot, and
- 24:47maybe it's not on the ballot, but it's it's if you look it up online, could be a whole bunch
- 24:53of different criteria.
- 24:54But it's not always gonna be concrete numbers either.
- 24:57Sometimes you'll you'll just get a very generic, well, this could lead to more revenue
- 25:02or this could be very pricey.
- 25:04Obviously not quite in those, or not necessarily in those words.
- 25:08Well, certainly won't say pricey, but it could say this could lead to more expenditures for
- 25:13the government.
- 25:14Could lead to more taxpayer revenue for the government.
- 25:18So it might not necessarily be anything all that informative.
- 25:22Sometimes the fiscal impact statement will just flat out say this impact is too hard to tell at
- 25:27this time.
- 25:28And at something it kind of begs the question why even have a fiscal impact statement in that
- 25:35case.
- 25:36But in any case, even when they are required, they won't necessarily be all that informative.
- 25:44And then lastly, if you look at some state government websites, I believe Nevada does
- 25:49this, they may also include official arguments from the support and the opposition for a
- 25:55ballot measure.
- 25:56Or a lot of times you can find that find these arguments on ballotpedia because they will have
- 26:03a
- 26:04lot of that information and a lot of
- 26:05the other context of these ballot measures.
- 26:09So I've kind of hinted at this already because I've talked about summaries versus text
- 26:16because the full text of the ballot measure is by far the most important piece of the puzzle.
- 26:21It is what's going to show up in the law after all.
- 26:25But the full text is seldom read by voters because they rely on summaries.
- 26:30Kind of like how many elected officials don't always read full bills before they vote on
- 26:36them.
- 26:36Sometimes they'll just pawn it off to their legislative staff, which is part of the role of
- 26:42a legislative staff, or they just see the way their party is voting, and they're gonna go,
- 26:46oh, okay.
- 26:47I'll vote that way too.
- 26:48But it's similarly to that.
- 26:50You have a lot
- 26:51of voters that don't read ballot measures all the way.
- 26:56But you may be asking, the summary is supposed to be basically
- 27:00a synopsis of the full text, right?
- 27:02So why can't we rely on summaries?
- 27:04Why can't
- 27:04we just say that the summaries got everything covered?
- 27:09What is the big deal about doing that?
- 27:11Well, if the full text is too long and it often is too long to fit on a ballot, summaries can't
- 27:18cover everything.
- 27:20The text is ultimately what's going into the law, not the summary.
- 27:24So the summary may make things more plain as to what the bill is trying to
- 27:31do or what the ballot measure is trying to do.
- 27:34But the way that the texts in the ballot measure is written can be possibly interpreted
- 27:40a different way when it goes into law, whether it's because of partisan or ideological
- 27:45interest trying to twist the meaning of the words, or it's really just not clear cuts what
- 27:51it's trying to do.
- 27:52Because the the intention behind a ballot measure isn't necessarily the same as what the
- 27:57ballot measure ultimately does, just like for legislation in general.
- 28:00It's not necessarily anything nefarious.
- 28:01Sometimes the ballot measure may have been made with good intentions, but it just wasn't worded
- 28:07very well.
- 28:08And it's the same thing with legislation in some cases too.
- 28:12So there's this sort of tug and pull that we all have to wrestle with when it comes to
- 28:16reading summaries versus text.
- 28:18Each of us only has so much time, energy and reading capability to spend, all
- 28:24of us do.
- 28:26And so it's not always
- 28:29as simple as just, I have to read both the summary and the text, what
- 28:32are you doing?
- 28:33It takes a lot of resources to do that in some cases.
- 28:38Every once in a while, you might have in your jurisdiction, you
- 28:42might only have one or two ballot measures to read, and maybe they are short.
- 28:45But a lot
- 28:45of times, ballot measures will be longer and you'll have a bunch
- 28:48of them to vote on, especially if you have a local area that has a lot of local measures to
- 28:54vote on like bonds, for example.
- 28:56So if you're gonna use just a summary, here's some of the pros and cons of using just a
- 29:02summary.
- 29:03Summary is
- 29:05much easier to read and all of us, every single one of us likes making things easier on our
- 29:11brains.
- 29:11Some of us have a higher threshold for what will put our brains through before we say,
- 29:17okay, that's enough.
- 29:18I'm not I'm not trying to think anymore.
- 29:22We all have those limits.
- 29:24The summary also covers most, if not all, the main points,
- 29:28and it's what will show up on the ballot to vote on.
- 29:31So, you know, it's, it's, it's, it's a very useful guide as to what the texts, the full
- 29:36text of the ballot measure is trying to do, but summaries cannot account for everything in
- 29:43really long ballot measures.
- 29:45It's not what the law is ultimately gonna say.
- 29:47That's what the full text is.
- 29:49And games can be played.
- 29:51Political games can be played with how the summary is worded either by the people that
- 29:57campaign for the measure or the state government that has a vested interest in
- 30:02whether that ballot measure passes or is defeated.
- 30:06And we'll be talking about that in just a moment.
- 30:09Ideally, the summary for your ballot measure should be your guide for what is in the text,
- 30:14but don't assume it's the end all be all.
- 30:17So now you know the pieces of a ballot measure and you know where to find it, but
- 30:24it doesn't end there because debates
- 30:27about ballot measures, just like in most things in politics, isn't exactly fully reasoned.
- 30:33It's not just about logic a lot of times.
- 30:35There's a lot of political games played because like in all things politics, all sorts of games
- 30:40are being played to try to steer you towards someone's goal with ballot measures.
- 30:46It's not always underhanded or seedy, though, and some arguments do come from people that
- 30:52aren't trying to manipulate or pull the wool over your eyes.
- 30:57They're just biased.
- 30:58They might have a really good intention, but they are still biased.
- 31:03Or sometimes it's just pitfalls in logic or understanding that can lead to a vote that
- 31:09isn't fully informed, and it happens to everybody.
- 31:12I'm no exception.
- 31:14But here are some of the biggest obstacles to watch out for and other things that could trip
- 31:19you up when it comes to trying to read and interpret ballot measures.
- 31:23We're gonna talk about five of these.
- 31:25There's vague versus specific wording.
- 31:28There's emotionally charged words, purposefully murky language, heavy partisan or ideological
- 31:35leanings for or against a measure, and state governments overstepping their bounds and
- 31:40trying to influence an outcome.
- 31:42Outcome.
- 31:43So first of all, vague versus specific wording.
- 31:47Ballot measures can vary greatly in length.
- 31:50Like we said before,
- 31:51it could be as short as one or two sentences, and then other times it could
- 31:56be paragraphs long and you
- 31:57can feel like reading a short story or a novel.
- 32:01And that's in large part dependent on how granular and detailed that these provisions and
- 32:06these measures get because some of them may be vague provisions, which usually means that the
- 32:11measure is going be shorter because it doesn't explain as much.
- 32:14And then sometimes it may be specific, which usually means that the measure is going to be
- 32:18longer because you're taking the time to detail things.
- 32:21Vague wording can mean the law can be adaptable to emerging challenges.
- 32:26That's part of the ethos of The US constitution because if you read that, it's a pretty short
- 32:31document, relatively speaking,
- 32:33and it was designed partly to be able to be adapted to times as time rolled on, but
- 32:42it can also be twisted to serve the purposes of partisan and ideological interest in the
- 32:48government.
- 32:48If things aren't specifically laid out to mean one thing, government can try to use it to mean
- 32:56what they want it to mean.
- 32:57So it can be the vague wording of a ballot measure can be attacked by the opposition
- 33:02because the true intention of the measure could be obfuscated and shrouded where it says it's
- 33:09it's trying to do this one thing, but really it's actually about this and it's trying to
- 33:13open the door for this other nefarious end.
- 33:16Or the opposition to the ballot measure might say that the measure isn't tough enough because
- 33:21it doesn't detail anything.
- 33:22So it just basically has no teeth.
- 33:26But that doesn't necessarily mean specific wording is the way to go because specific
- 33:32wording can mean the law is more clear cut on its intentions, but it could also be too rigid
- 33:38in what it's trying to do.
- 33:39And so it can be attacked by the opposition to a ballot measure because there are a lot more
- 33:43points of discussion that can be taken issue with or maybe it missed some other details that
- 33:50should be part of this measure.
- 33:52So when you're hearing all sorts of arguments about the vagueness or the specificity of these
- 33:58measures, these
- 34:00are the things to keep in mind.
- 34:02What about some emotionally charged words in these ballot measures,
- 34:08whether it's in the summary or sometimes even in the text, because laws can be biased and so
- 34:14can ballot measures try to become law.
- 34:16So when you read certain words, do you have a knee jerk reaction that sways your opinion
- 34:21immediately or at least heavily influences it?
- 34:24Because when you see words like fair, freedom, justice, rights, and so on, hold up a
- 34:33moment Because chances are when those words appear, it's really just trying to
- 34:40underhandedly, maybe not even underhandedly, but it's still trying to impose its own bias on
- 34:47you as to what the measure is trying to do.
- 34:50Because is the measure really about what's fair, what's free, what's just?
- 34:56Is it really about rights or patriotism or safety?
- 35:00Because it's very easy to say that kind of thing.
- 35:02And one particular instance is we can talk about all these attempts to gerrymander by both
- 35:09parties, by both the Republican and Democratic parties, and both of them trying to say that
- 35:15their gerrymandering is fair and that the other side's gerrymandering is not fair.
- 35:20And case in point, one example being in Virginia where it just passed their ballot
- 35:26measure that allows the general assembly there, the state legislature there, to redraw
- 35:32congressional districts between 2025 and 2030 if another state redraws its districts for
- 35:38reasons other than completing decennial redistricting or complying with a court order.
- 35:44And in that ballot measure, it says, basically, will you allow the general assembly to restore
- 35:50fairness?
- 35:51But is that really fair, though?
- 35:53Because Republicans are acting like their gerrymandering is fair.
- 35:57Democrats are acting like their gerrymandering is fair.
- 36:00But is either attempts at redistricting really actually about fairness, or is it about power?
- 36:06Is it about just benefiting their own state?
- 36:09What is it really about?
- 36:11And I try to make sure that I levy this at both parties because it is a both party issue.
- 36:17And in general, and this is not even just a Democrat or Republican thing, this is all of us
- 36:22thing.
- 36:22We all like to think that whenever we do things that we would call underhanded from other
- 36:28people, we like to say, no, I'm justified in this though because blah blah blah, when really
- 36:33it's just because it benefits us.
- 36:35Be a democrat, can be a republican, can be an independent, can be
- 36:38a third party, doesn't matter.
- 36:39We're all capable of doing that.
- 36:42In the case
- 36:42of gerrymandering though, it's the two main parties because they're the ones that control
- 36:47these kinds of processes, one side or the other does.
- 36:51So really think about whether any of these ballot measures when somebody says this is
- 36:57about fairness, this is about freedom and safety and justice and all that.
- 37:03Is it really about that?
- 37:04Because a lot of times it's really not.
- 37:07It's really about what benefits a certain partisan or ideological interest,
- 37:13not about what's actually right.
- 37:16And in a similar vein, you can talk about purposely murky language also being a hindrance
- 37:24to really trying to interpret ballot measures and at least what somebody would consider the
- 37:33right thing when it comes to a specific ballot measure.
- 37:35Because sometimes ballot measures aren't biased so much as they're just purposefully
- 37:40convoluted, where they're made deliberately one way.
- 37:45They're not actually necessarily using emotionally charged words, but they shift words
- 37:50around so that it's harder to really understand what they're trying to do.
- 37:55Obviously just talking about the text of legislation because some states, even though
- 37:59they have those legal requirements for readability of ballot measures, that doesn't
- 38:04always have the intended effect because first of all, some
- 38:07of those readability laws are vague.
- 38:09Go back to
- 38:10the vague and specific dichotomy.
- 38:13And so it can be hard to enforce comprehensibility in some cases.
- 38:18And the words of the ballot measures themselves may be easy to understand, but they're ordered
- 38:23in such a way that you have to swing around all sorts of passages in existing law to figure out
- 38:28what in the world this measure is trying to do because it could be taking section two of
- 38:34article one and then all of a sudden it goes to like section 20 of article three, but it
- 38:41somehow is still relevant to each other.
- 38:45Or if you're talking about a state that doesn't require a single subject rule, it might be
- 38:49covering a whole bunch of things and now you're trying to keep track of, oh, woah, okay.
- 38:53This is one provision here.
- 38:55This is another provision.
- 38:56This is another provision.
- 38:57And wait.
- 38:58What was that first provision again?
- 38:59So it
- 39:00can get really tricky to try
- 39:02to remember what's going on and how things are put together.
- 39:07Not necessarily in states that don't have a single subject rule.
- 39:11Sometimes the single subject rule doesn't make that an easier thing to deal with either.
- 39:16And we still have many ballot measures that are above people's literacy level.
- 39:21Again, this is talking about summaries versus text.
- 39:24The readability is often applied to the summaries of the text.
- 39:28The text itself doesn't necessarily need to be all that readable, and summaries won't
- 39:33necessarily capture everything about those about the full text.
- 39:40And then some partisan and ideological and economic interests behind these measures, they
- 39:44might not use emotionally charged words, but they may deliberately write measures in a way
- 39:49that obscures what they're actually trying to do because they know a lot of people won't read
- 39:55the full text of the measure.
- 39:57They'll rely on the summary.
- 39:58And sometimes these interests will be
- 40:00the ones who are writing these summaries too.
- 40:03A lot of
- 40:04very underhanded wheeling and dealing instances here, and sometimes it's not necessarily about
- 40:10partisanship or ideology,
- 40:12it might just be an economic interest.
- 40:14But a lot of times it
- 40:16is a heavy partisan or ideological leaning in support or opposition to a measure.
- 40:23So a lot of times ballot measures can actually make strange bedfellows, so to speak.
- 40:29It can lead to unusual coalitions of Democrats and Republicans either for or against a ballot
- 40:36measure.
- 40:36In most cases, it'll have groups that are normally Democrat or normally Republican work
- 40:42together, and you would never see them work together in other instances except for this one
- 40:48particular case.
- 40:49But if you see a ballot measure where there's a stark partisan divide in ads and editorials and
- 41:01so on where Republicans are clearly on one side and Democrats are clearly on the other, you
- 41:07should take a moment.
- 41:09You should immediately pause and think, well, wait minute.
- 41:11Just like in pretty much anything that's hyper partisan, you should take a moment to think
- 41:16about, Wait a minute.
- 41:18Hang on.
- 41:18Something's going on here.
- 41:19Is this measure really trying to do what it says it's
- 41:22trying to do?
- 41:23Or conversely,
- 41:25maybe the opposition is full of a suit.
- 41:27Maybe both sides are full of it.
- 41:29There's a thought.
- 41:30Sometimes it's not clearly just, oh, this ballot measure is completely a good thing.
- 41:37This ballot measure is completely a bad thing.
- 41:39A lot of times it's not.
- 41:40Sometimes there is good and bad, and you have
- 41:43to balance the good with the
- 41:45bad and how much good needs to be in that ballot measure for you to actually support it.
- 41:51And that threshold is gonna
- 41:53be different for a lot of people.
- 41:54But in any case, a
- 41:56heavy partisan or ideological lean doesn't necessarily mean the ballot measure is bad per
- 42:01se, but there are the chances are that it isn't or that it's just one party that is benefiting
- 42:09from that ballot measure.
- 42:12So you should still be careful.
- 42:14And then lastly, state governments getting overly involved in the wording of ballot
- 42:19measures is another big problem that they run into.
- 42:23And you're seeing more and more examples recently of state governments trying to push
- 42:28through or kill ballot measures far more than they should.
- 42:32Not just simply, oh, the governor of a state is saying, I think this ballot measure sucks and
- 42:37people shouldn't vote for it.
- 42:38No.
- 42:38There are cases where the governments are using their own websites, which are ostensibly
- 42:43nonpartisan, which are purely supposed to be there just for everybody to be able to access
- 42:48and not dictate it towards one party, at least ideally.
- 42:53But these websites might start telling these voters, Hey, this measure is bad.
- 42:58You shouldn't vote against it.
- 42:59It's costly.
- 43:00It's lying to you.
- 43:01This is not what it's actually trying to do.
- 43:03Or it might conversely try to say, Oh, you really need to push through this ballot
- 43:06measure.
- 43:07Or they may use these fiscal impact statements to say something is going to be economically
- 43:11adverse to the state when they didn't actually try to analyze it.
- 43:17They just said that outright because their bias says, Oh, this is going to be costly for the
- 43:22state.
- 43:22They didn't actually try to run analysis on it.
- 43:25Or even perhaps even worse, they've taken out ads with taxpayer dollars to attack certain
- 43:33measures or to prop up certain measures.
- 43:36It's not just enough for them to use their website or anything.
- 43:40They'll actually use taxpayer dollars to try to campaign for or against, which is not supposed
- 43:45to be legal, but it does happen.
- 43:49And sometimes it's not necessarily fully proven that that's what happened, but you know that
- 43:55the state government has done that, that it has used taxpayer dollars for means that it's not
- 44:03supposed to be used for, for partisan and ideological lobbying.
- 44:08And then in other cases, governments will try to kill a ballot measure before it even reaches
- 44:13the ballot.
- 44:14They may try to say that the ballot measure doesn't meet the single subject requirement for
- 44:22ballot measures.
- 44:22Try to say, oh, no.
- 44:23See, it actually covers two different things here.
- 44:26And a lot of times, not saying that that's necessarily inaccurate, but a lot of times, say
- 44:32government is just trying to use and abuse the single subject rule for its own purposes, not
- 44:37because it actually that ballot measure is violating single subject rule, but because the
- 44:44people who are running that government have a vested interest, partisan, ideological, or
- 44:49economic against that ballot measure.
- 44:52Or same thing for the separate vote requirement, trying to take a ballot measure to
- 44:56court, or even if the ballot measure passes with passes the voters and the voters approve
- 45:02it, they may still try to take it to court afterwards to try to put in one last ditch
- 45:09effort to try to kill a ballot measure.
- 45:12This isn't necessarily unjustified in every case.
- 45:14I don't wanna say it like it is, but a lot of times it is based on partisan considerations
- 45:21rather than a truly legal basis.
- 45:23So that is going to do it for today's episode of the podcast.
- 45:26Hopefully, this became a lot easier for you to read and interpret ballot measures.
- 45:32And like I said, I have a webinar where I talk about how to read and interpret state
- 45:37legislation, which is a similar concept.
- 45:39There are some similarities in how to read ballot measures versus state legislation.
- 45:43You can reach out to me about that either on LinkedIn or at paulraderwritesgmail.
- 45:49Other links in the show notes, my LinkedIn, my Facebook, medium.com profile, websites, five
- 45:55day educational email course about how we can all more effectively mitigate polarization and
- 46:00some of the ways that we accidentally make polarization worse, and my book on Amazon and
- 46:07believe that's it.
- 46:08So thank you all so much for listening.
- 46:10Please like, comment, share, and subscribe.
- 46:12This is on YouTube, Spotify, and Apple Podcasts.
- 46:15Hopefully we'll expand to more podcasting platforms and we'll see
- 46:19you next time.