Latest / Bloomberg Law / Cheerleader's Profane Post Tests Speech Rights
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Clause. The Supreme Court justice has struggled with a case
- 0:04Speaker 1: about a high school cheerleader who claims her First Amendment
- 0:08Speaker 1: rights were violated when she was suspended from the team
- 0:11Speaker 1: because of a profane snapchat post. Some of the justices,
- 0:15Speaker 1: like Selia Sotomayor and Brett Kavanaugh, seemed to think the
- 0:18Speaker 1: punishment of a year long suspension from the team was excessive.
- 0:22Speaker 1: You're punishing her here because she went on the internet
- 0:27Speaker 1: and cursed and used to curse word related to what
- 0:32Speaker 1: to her unhappiness with the school and cheering right. She's competitive,
- 0:38Speaker 1: she cares. She blew off steam like millions of other
- 0:43Speaker 1: kids have when they're disappointed about being cut from the
- 0:45Speaker 1: high school team or not being in the starting lineup.
- 0:48Speaker 1: While others were concerned that any sort of broad ruling
- 0:51Speaker 1: would have unforeseen consequences, here's Justice Stephen Bryer standard joining
- 0:58Speaker 1: me his First Amendment expert Eugene Va, a professor at
- 1:01Speaker 1: u c l A Law school. So fifty million public
- 1:04Speaker 1: school students in the country, they're all on social media.
- 1:09Speaker 1: How significant is this case? Well, it could be huge
- 1:14Speaker 1: or it could be narrow. It all depends on how
- 1:17Speaker 1: the justices decide that indeed, it could be huger even
- 1:20Speaker 1: than social media. So the funny thing about the way
- 1:23Speaker 1: the argument went is the lawyer for the school, the
- 1:28Speaker 1: local government entity least of last, leading leading Supreme Court advocacy,
- 1:33Speaker 1: starts out with this very speech protective art. She says, Look,
- 1:37Speaker 1: Tinker is the official test war First Amendment protection fork
- 1:42Speaker 1: through closed students. It's actually very speech protective. It's so
- 1:45Speaker 1: speech protective that it's not a problem to apply it
- 1:48Speaker 1: to social media and apply it to other off campus speech.
- 1:52Speaker 1: To be sure, in certain situations, such as when somebody
- 1:55Speaker 1: is saying something that might interfere with the way that
- 1:58Speaker 1: their athletic programs is operating or something like that, then
- 2:01Speaker 1: the speech can be punished. But generally speaking, most political, religious,
- 2:05Speaker 1: and other such speeches really strongly protected on campus and
- 2:08Speaker 1: off And the lawyer for the federal government, who was
- 2:11Speaker 1: mostly supporting the school district position on this, said the
- 2:14Speaker 1: same thing. On the other hand, upcomes David Cole, the
- 2:19Speaker 1: director of the a c l U, who is the
- 2:20Speaker 1: lawyer for the student, and he says, oh, this Tinker test,
- 2:23Speaker 1: which is actually very unprotected. It allows all sorts of
- 2:27Speaker 1: restrictions death school and that's why it can't be extended
- 2:31Speaker 1: off campus because it provides so little protection that it
- 2:35Speaker 1: has to do cabins to school speech. So because of
- 2:38Speaker 1: the imperatives of the litigation, they were just trying to
- 2:40Speaker 1: win the case for their clients, they in a sense
- 2:44Speaker 1: almost flipped size on the bigger picture question of the
- 2:48Speaker 1: scope of Tinker. So that question is going to be
- 2:51Speaker 1: very much in play. Potentially, the court could hand down
- 2:54Speaker 1: a decision, for example, that says yes, Tinker applies on
- 2:57Speaker 1: campus as well as off campus because Tinker is just
- 3:00Speaker 1: speech protective standers, and that could affect be tried for
- 3:03Speaker 1: through twelve students everywhere. Tinker is a landmark case from
- 3:07Speaker 1: nineteen sixty nine where the courts said that students don't
- 3:10Speaker 1: shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech at the
- 3:13Speaker 1: schoolhouse gate. Can you explain the standard established in Tinker? Sure?
- 3:19Speaker 1: The Tinker standards says, generally speaking, through twelve student speech
- 3:23Speaker 1: can be restricted if it is reasonably likely to create
- 3:27Speaker 1: material and substantial disruption. So think about it as a
- 3:31Speaker 1: disruptive speech. Sanders Generally speaking, you can't punish ordinary citizens
- 3:36Speaker 1: speech because it's disrupted. For example, if you're picketing some
- 3:39Speaker 1: government building that could be quite disruptive of the activity
- 3:43Speaker 1: in the building. But unless you're actually blocking entrances, are
- 3:45Speaker 1: threatening people, or whatever else, you have the right to
- 3:47Speaker 1: do that. But at least at school, Tinker says, if
- 3:50Speaker 1: the speech is substantially and materially disruptive, then in that
- 3:55Speaker 1: case it can indep be restrict So the question presented
- 3:58Speaker 1: to the court here is what if this is beach
- 4:00Speaker 1: off campus but it risks creating disruption on campus, does
- 4:05Speaker 1: the school have the power to restrict that speech too,
- 4:09Speaker 1: or would that unconstitutionally give the school sort of twenty
- 4:13Speaker 1: four seven power over students speech in a way that
- 4:17Speaker 1: the First Amendment cannot tell. At one particular thing that's
- 4:21Speaker 1: really important that played a big role with the argument
- 4:23Speaker 1: is this question of the Heckler's Vito say, somebody standing
- 4:26Speaker 1: in the street corner and is saying things that offend
- 4:30Speaker 1: the crowds. Could be political, religious, could be about race,
- 4:33Speaker 1: about sexual orientation, about religion, about whatever else. And somebody
- 4:37Speaker 1: in the crowd threatened to attack, and and the police
- 4:38Speaker 1: officers and says, Okay, I'm gonna break all this up
- 4:41Speaker 1: by removing the speaker, by telling the speaker to stop,
- 4:44Speaker 1: because the hecklers are endangering the speaker and potentially causing
- 4:49Speaker 1: a fight and others breach of the peace, that's not allowed.
- 4:52Speaker 1: That would be a so called heckler's veto. Um. It
- 4:55Speaker 1: would be the government essentially stepping in on the side
- 4:57Speaker 1: of the hecklers to suppress the speaker. And the court
- 5:00Speaker 1: has said that is not permissible because otherwise that we
- 5:03Speaker 1: give heckos too much power. But lower courts applying Tinker
- 5:08Speaker 1: have said well. Tinker says that speech can be restricted
- 5:12Speaker 1: on campus if it's disruptive enough, and that disruption could
- 5:16Speaker 1: very well come from people heckling, which is to stay
- 5:18Speaker 1: in this context, either interrupting class or possibly fighting with
- 5:23Speaker 1: a student or something along those lines. So the lower courts,
- 5:26Speaker 1: at least some of them, have said the heckler's veto
- 5:29Speaker 1: is a good basis for restricting speech on campus. One
- 5:32Speaker 1: particularly notorious case involved some students at a California school
- 5:36Speaker 1: wearing t shirts with the American platform the American flag,
- 5:40Speaker 1: and this is because it was sincer demyo and apparently
- 5:44Speaker 1: some students were upset at these American Flag wars because
- 5:48Speaker 1: they thought that that was disrespectful and kind of anti
- 5:51Speaker 1: Hispanic or anti Mexican when that's done on sincer demayo
- 5:54Speaker 1: and the school said, well, yeah, you have to take
- 5:57Speaker 1: off your American flag t shirts. And the ninth or
- 6:00Speaker 1: it said yeah, the school was allowed to do that
- 6:03Speaker 1: because there was a threat of disruption, and yeah, the
- 6:05Speaker 1: Heckler's Vito is a good basis first strict in speech
- 6:07Speaker 1: on campus. Now, Lisa Blad, the lawyer for the school
- 6:10Speaker 1: district in the BM case, said no, no, no, no, no.
- 6:13Speaker 1: Heckler's Vito can't be used as a basis for restricting
- 6:17Speaker 1: speech on campus. And that's why the Tinker standards Because
- 6:20Speaker 1: it rejects the Hecklers viso. The Tinker standard is actually
- 6:24Speaker 1: quite speech protective and thus can be applied off campus.
- 6:27Speaker 1: This speech didn't cause any disruption to school functions. How
- 6:31Speaker 1: does that fit in here? Well, so, the lower court
- 6:35Speaker 1: says that the destruction test doesn't even apply to off
- 6:39Speaker 1: campus speech. Off campus speech if it's protected against criminal
- 6:44Speaker 1: punishment or against the aliabilities, protected against school discipline, at
- 6:47Speaker 1: least generally speaking. So as a result, it doesn't matter
- 6:50Speaker 1: if it's a disruptive or not. The school wants to
- 6:52Speaker 1: be able to show that it was disruptive not to
- 6:54Speaker 1: all of the school, but to the operation of the
- 6:58Speaker 1: cheerleading squads. They say, Look, as she wasn't expelled from school,
- 7:02Speaker 1: she wasn't suspended from school. She was only suspended from
- 7:05Speaker 1: secheer leading because her speech being disrespectful to the whole
- 7:10Speaker 1: enterprise of cheerleading and being disrespectful therefore to the coach
- 7:14Speaker 1: and her teammates, is disrupting the effectiveness of this particular
- 7:19Speaker 1: cheerleading program. So that would be the school dark. Some
- 7:22Speaker 1: of the justices seemed to pick up on the point
- 7:25Speaker 1: that this was an extracurricular activity. Does that give the
- 7:29Speaker 1: school more leeway to limit outside speech. So that's a
- 7:33Speaker 1: good question, and we don't know what the court will
- 7:36Speaker 1: say about that. The question presented to the court in
- 7:39Speaker 1: the petition, the question that the Court agreed to hear
- 7:42Speaker 1: Justin's focus on that. It just asks whether the Tinker
- 7:45Speaker 1: standard of plastoff campus. And usually the court tries to
- 7:49Speaker 1: stick with a question presented, So some justices might say, look,
- 7:53Speaker 1: we're going to leave this question of were there any
- 7:55Speaker 1: special rules for rest for curricular activities. We're going to
- 7:58Speaker 1: leave them to a different case where that is the
- 8:00Speaker 1: issue that we agreed to hear. In this case, we
- 8:03Speaker 1: are deciding the question presented, which is all about our
- 8:06Speaker 1: campus speech, regardless of whether it relates to an extracurricular activity.
- 8:10Speaker 1: At the same time, you could imagine some of the justices,
- 8:14Speaker 1: or maybe the majority of the justice is saying, look,
- 8:16Speaker 1: we ought to decide the case narrowly with an eye
- 8:19Speaker 1: towards the particular facts of this particular situation. And in
- 8:24Speaker 1: this situation, the punishment for the student was simply suspensioned
- 8:28Speaker 1: from an extracurricular activity. That kind of the threat of
- 8:31Speaker 1: that kind of punishment isn't this chilling speech. It doesn't
- 8:34Speaker 1: deprive somebody of their right to an education. It only
- 8:37Speaker 1: deprived them of the ability to be on the cheerleading squad.
- 8:40Speaker 1: And that's not a big deal. So you can imagine
- 8:42Speaker 1: the court coming up with this rule, although you could
- 8:44Speaker 1: also imagine some justice is setting that for many students,
- 8:47Speaker 1: participation to me in an extracurricular activity is very important
- 8:51Speaker 1: for them, both kind of personally and some respects educationally.
- 8:55Speaker 1: Um and threatening removal from that kind of activity for
- 9:00Speaker 1: your speech is indeed going to be chilling. Because the
- 9:02Speaker 1: recall in this case, you know, the speech was just
- 9:05Speaker 1: kind of this girl complaining about about not making a
- 9:08Speaker 1: varsity But in principle, you can imagine somebody saying something
- 9:12Speaker 1: political or saying something about a religious topic or some
- 9:15Speaker 1: other topics that might cause tension within the team, and
- 9:19Speaker 1: then you could imagine the coach the case, fine, you're
- 9:22Speaker 1: off the team because you're saying things about immigration or
- 9:24Speaker 1: about race or about religion that people don't like, and
- 9:27Speaker 1: that again could be quite chilling, a really quite valuable speech.
- 9:31Speaker 1: So those are the kind of questions of the court
- 9:33Speaker 1: might have to consist. So you had Justice Alito saying
- 9:38Speaker 1: they needed a clear rule and Justice Brier saying, I'm
- 9:42Speaker 1: frightened to death of writing a standard. Do you have
- 9:45Speaker 1: any idea where they might come out in this? You know,
- 9:48Speaker 1: it's very hard to tell. It's always hard to tell
- 9:50Speaker 1: for moral argument what the justices are going to do,
- 9:52Speaker 1: because often the justices really are asking questions because they're
- 9:56Speaker 1: not really sure what the answer is, or sometimes they're
- 9:58Speaker 1: just floating possible to areas or envisioning possible objections to
- 10:02Speaker 1: the position that they that they might want to ultimately
- 10:04Speaker 1: come to, likewise, of course, through nine of them. So
- 10:08Speaker 1: some justices might go one way some justices might go
- 10:10Speaker 1: another way. Some justice is might go a third or
- 10:12Speaker 1: fourth way. So it's really hard to tell what the
- 10:16Speaker 1: justices are going to decide. I do think there was
- 10:19Speaker 1: general concern on the part of many justices about schools
- 10:25Speaker 1: having undo power um to restrict students speech, especially speech that,
- 10:31Speaker 1: unlike the speech in this particular case, really does deal
- 10:33Speaker 1: with kind of bigger picture political, religious, social issues, including
- 10:38Speaker 1: those issues as they intersect with the school like, for example,
- 10:40Speaker 1: claims of maybe misconduct or sexual misconduct by teachers or
- 10:44Speaker 1: classmates or whatever. On the other hand, I do think
- 10:47Speaker 1: that you saw a lot of justices recognizing that schools
- 10:50Speaker 1: need considerable authority to make sure that the schooling goes
- 10:53Speaker 1: on effectively. So again, I think it's very hard to
- 10:58Speaker 1: figure out what they're going to do until one reached
- 11:01Speaker 1: the opinion. A couple of months from that, Justice Brett
- 11:05Speaker 1: Kavanaugh suggested a narrow kind of ruling that might not
- 11:10Speaker 1: give much guidance to lower courts. Well, that's what I
- 11:13Speaker 1: started with. You know, you could imagine this opinion being
- 11:16Speaker 1: written very narrowly, or you could imagine this opinion being
- 11:19Speaker 1: written relatively or only A lot depends on whether they
- 11:23Speaker 1: justices want to resolve this issue now themselves or leave
- 11:28Speaker 1: it to lower courts. So, for example, you can imagine
- 11:30Speaker 1: the Court saying Tinker does apply off campus because it's
- 11:36Speaker 1: important to prevent disruption on campus, and off campus speech
- 11:40Speaker 1: can cause on campus disruption. But we're not resolving, for example,
- 11:44Speaker 1: whether Tinker allows speech to be restricted because of a
- 11:46Speaker 1: Heckler's veto. We're not resolving how disruptive the speech needs
- 11:50Speaker 1: to be. We're not resolving whether there would be a
- 11:53Speaker 1: different standard for speech that's disruptive nearly of an extracurricular
- 11:58Speaker 1: activity and the only thing that's happening to the student
- 12:00Speaker 1: is the students suspended from that activity. We leave that
- 12:03Speaker 1: for lower courts to resolves. You can imagine the Court
- 12:06Speaker 1: doing that, and if it does well, then if the
- 12:10Speaker 1: things will go back to lower courts and then have
- 12:12Speaker 1: that to reconsider some of these questions. You could also
- 12:15Speaker 1: imagine the court, for example, making the decisions that is
- 12:18Speaker 1: on its face quite narrow, but by flagging certain issues
- 12:22Speaker 1: by saying, you know, it's an interesting question whether speech
- 12:25Speaker 1: can be restricted on or off campus because of the
- 12:27Speaker 1: hecklers veto. Then in that case, perhaps lower courts will
- 12:31Speaker 1: be emboldened to try to resolve that, and then maybe
- 12:33Speaker 1: another such case will go back up to these to
- 12:36Speaker 1: the Supreme Court. It's possible. At the same time, I
- 12:39Speaker 1: do think that Justice Alito has a good point that
- 12:41Speaker 1: government officials and students deserve some guidance as to what
- 12:46Speaker 1: can be said and what can be punished, and if
- 12:49Speaker 1: the Court just sort of just just leaves things uncertain,
- 12:52Speaker 1: then there won't be much protection for speech, and there
- 12:55Speaker 1: won't be much protection for the legitimate interests of school boards.
- 13:00Speaker 1: Does it seem though, that they're likely to reverse the
- 13:05Speaker 1: Third Circuit because that decision was so broad, Well, I'm
- 13:10Speaker 1: not sure. I'm not sure. Again, I think it might depend,
- 13:14Speaker 1: for at least some justicesum how much speech restriction they
- 13:18Speaker 1: see Tinker as allowing. So if, for example, just as
- 13:21Speaker 1: the leader is persuaded that on campus, Tinker does allow
- 13:24Speaker 1: restriction of political speech, religious speech, speech on social matters
- 13:28Speaker 1: so long as classmates can be offended enough, I don't
- 13:32Speaker 1: think he'd want to extend that off campus. So you
- 13:34Speaker 1: can imagine him saying, look, on campus, which has to
- 13:37Speaker 1: be pretty heavily restricted, or at least schools have to
- 13:40Speaker 1: have the power to to restrict speech. But if that's so,
- 13:44Speaker 1: then in that case we need to have a more
- 13:46Speaker 1: speech protective rule of or he could even say I
- 13:49Speaker 1: think that speech on campus should be pretty broadly protected,
- 13:52Speaker 1: but my colleague is disagreed. And given that my colleagues
- 13:56Speaker 1: disagree and view Tinker as giving schools a lot of
- 13:58Speaker 1: power on campus all than in that case, at the
- 14:01Speaker 1: very least, I think they should be denied that power
- 14:03Speaker 1: off campus. You can imagine some of the justices taking
- 14:06Speaker 1: but again you could also imagine some of the justices saying, well,
- 14:09Speaker 1: speech off campus should be treated the same way as
- 14:11Speaker 1: on campus because both can have pomful effects on campus,
- 14:14Speaker 1: and because it's often so hard to tell what's up
- 14:17Speaker 1: what counts is on or off campus thatst all. A
- 14:19Speaker 1: lot of these things can be viewed on campus, even
- 14:22Speaker 1: if they're sent from uf campus. But given that this
- 14:25Speaker 1: is so, we need to make sure that there is
- 14:27Speaker 1: a pretty bright line exception for for get political, religious,
- 14:32Speaker 1: and similar kinds of speech. So it's really hard to predict.
- 14:35Speaker 1: I think what it is that the justices are going
- 14:37Speaker 1: to do here. Have Supreme Court decisions in the past,
- 14:41Speaker 1: let's say, at ten, fifteen, twenty years, have they weakened
- 14:45Speaker 1: generally weakened protections for students speech. Yes, after Tinker, which
- 14:51Speaker 1: after all came out in favor of the students there
- 14:54Speaker 1: the students wearing the black armbands because the court said
- 14:56Speaker 1: there wasn't enough evidence of disruption after things are In
- 15:00Speaker 1: case Bessel School District coursus Fraser, that said, well, vulgar
- 15:04Speaker 1: speech speech about kind of a full of sexual innuendo
- 15:08Speaker 1: can be restricted on campus. And by the way, I
- 15:11Speaker 1: think it's pretty clear that this Fraser doctrine does not
- 15:15Speaker 1: apply off campus. You can't punish a student for off
- 15:18Speaker 1: campus sulgarity if they're not disrupted. Likewise, in in Morse Frederick,
- 15:24Speaker 1: the court said, well, on campus speech that seems to
- 15:28Speaker 1: encourage illegal drung you can indep restricted. And again though
- 15:33Speaker 1: the court stressed that this was limited to on campus
- 15:36Speaker 1: or at least that school sponsored activities there. The speech
- 15:39Speaker 1: was physically off campus, but it was in the context
- 15:42Speaker 1: of a school and sponsored school in school endorsed it too.
- 15:46Speaker 1: So yes, the court has authorized more restrictions on student
- 15:51Speaker 1: speech in some measurement. That having been said, I don't
- 15:54Speaker 1: think that the tenor of the argument in this case
- 15:58Speaker 1: was just well, the school boards need to win in
- 16:00Speaker 1: because schools. Schools should have broad power. I think many
- 16:04Speaker 1: of the justices recognized that the power of the schools
- 16:07Speaker 1: has to stop at some point, especially when we're talking
- 16:10Speaker 1: about speech that's offensive for politically. So, finally, you wrote
- 16:15Speaker 1: an amiguous brief in this case, what was your position?
- 16:19Speaker 1: So our position was it looks like at least lower
- 16:22Speaker 1: courts seemed to say that Tinker does allow a lot
- 16:27Speaker 1: of political speech and the like to be restricted on campus,
- 16:31Speaker 1: so long is it's offensive enough to be disruptive. If
- 16:34Speaker 1: that's the rule, then in that case that has to
- 16:37Speaker 1: be limited to on campus speech. You can't authorize twenty
- 16:40Speaker 1: four seven control over student speech where every time a
- 16:44Speaker 1: student says something that might offend classmates, even at a
- 16:48Speaker 1: political rally, war online, where at a church, or in
- 16:51Speaker 1: a letter to the editor of a newspaper, that the
- 16:53Speaker 1: student would have to worry about about possibly being suspended
- 16:58Speaker 1: or expelled at that So that was our position, and
- 17:00Speaker 1: again that position rested on the lever courts generally speaking,
- 17:05Speaker 1: viewing Tinker is not very speech protective, and you can
- 17:08Speaker 1: imagine the court saying, well, we don't care what that
- 17:10Speaker 1: brief said, because we really think the tinker is very
- 17:13Speaker 1: speech protective, and if it broadly speech protective on campus
- 17:17Speaker 1: with only a few mirror restrictions allowed, then maybe it
- 17:20Speaker 1: should be applied dot campus. So you can imagine the
- 17:23Speaker 1: court saying that, thanks Eugene, that Professor Eugene Vallak of
- 17:26Speaker 1: u c l A Law School, did you order You
- 17:32Speaker 1: don't have to answer that question. I'll answer the question
- 17:36Speaker 1: you want answers. I think I'm entitled. You want answers?
- 17:39Speaker 1: What the truth? You can't handle the truth? The confrontation
- 17:44Speaker 1: between Tom Cruise and Jack Nicholson in a Few Good
- 17:46Speaker 1: Men is high drama, but cross examination just doesn't happen
- 17:51Speaker 1: that way in a real courtroom. Still, every criminal defendant
- 17:54Speaker 1: has the constitutional right to confront the witnesses against them,
- 17:58Speaker 1: and the Supreme Court is going to concern it or
- 18:00Speaker 1: whether defendants weighed that constitutional right when they open up
- 18:04Speaker 1: the door to certain evidence. Joining me as former federal
- 18:07Speaker 1: prosecutor Robert Mints, a partner Macarter and English Bob, just
- 18:11Speaker 1: about everyone's heard about a defendant's right to confront witnesses,
- 18:14Speaker 1: but explain the confrontation clause the Sixth Amendment gives a
- 18:18Speaker 1: defendant and a criminal prosecution the right to be confronted
- 18:21Speaker 1: with the witnesses against him. What that means is that
- 18:25Speaker 1: at a criminal trial which you're charged with an offense,
- 18:28Speaker 1: your lawyer has the right to cross examine any witnesses
- 18:31Speaker 1: who testifies against you. Prosecutors are not allowed to admit
- 18:35Speaker 1: statement by other witnesses to present before the jury in
- 18:39Speaker 1: culpatory evidence without giving the defendant lawyer the right to
- 18:43Speaker 1: test the strength of that testimony by cross examining them
- 18:47Speaker 1: in court in front of the jury. What happened in
- 18:50Speaker 1: this case tell us a little bit about the facts
- 18:53Speaker 1: in this case. This is a case of Darryl Hemphel,
- 18:56Speaker 1: who has tried for murder in New York State after
- 18:59Speaker 1: another defendant was tried for the same crime. The facts
- 19:03Speaker 1: are actually quite unusual because it involved another defendant who
- 19:08Speaker 1: ended up seeding guilty to possession of a firearm after
- 19:11Speaker 1: the murder prosecution against him had ended in a mistrial.
- 19:15Speaker 1: The case was about the two thousand and six shooting
- 19:18Speaker 1: death of a child who was a passenger in a
- 19:20Speaker 1: car that drove by a fight on the street and
- 19:22Speaker 1: the bronze. The first defendant was tried and the jury
- 19:26Speaker 1: could not agree on the guilt of the defendant and
- 19:29Speaker 1: so it ended into the mistrial. Instead, what prosecutors did
- 19:32Speaker 1: as they allowed this second defendant to plead guilty to
- 19:36Speaker 1: possession of a handgun. But it was critical here is
- 19:39Speaker 1: that that defendant pled guilty to possession of a three
- 19:42Speaker 1: fifty seven revolver, which was not the gun that was
- 19:46Speaker 1: used in the murder. So what happened at trial to
- 19:50Speaker 1: lead the judge to allow in the statement of another defendant.
- 19:55Speaker 1: At the trial, Misterhampful, his defense lawyer, advanced one of
- 19:59Speaker 1: the most based defenses that you see in criminal cases,
- 20:02Speaker 1: and that is that his clients did not commit the
- 20:05Speaker 1: crime and some other person did. They tried to point
- 20:08Speaker 1: the finger at the other defendant who had already pled
- 20:11Speaker 1: guilty to possession of that different firearms. The court ruled
- 20:15Speaker 1: in that case that once the defendant made that argument
- 20:19Speaker 1: in front of the jury, the defense player had opened
- 20:22Speaker 1: the door and allowed prosecutors to use the plea elocution,
- 20:26Speaker 1: which is the statement that the other defendant made when
- 20:29Speaker 1: he entered his guilty plea admitting possession of the three
- 20:33Speaker 1: fifty seven revolver at the scene of the shooting that
- 20:36Speaker 1: was not the gun. That killed the child, and so
- 20:39Speaker 1: the judge said that the defense lawyer had created a
- 20:43Speaker 1: misimpression in front of the jury. The prosecutors were entitled
- 20:47Speaker 1: to correct by admitting that statement in evidence at the trial.
- 20:52Speaker 1: The problem from the defense side is that the defense
- 20:55Speaker 1: lawyer never had a chance to challenge that statement. The
- 20:59Speaker 1: defendant six Amendment rights across examine that witness who was
- 21:03Speaker 1: essentially testify against him, was never permitted at the trial.
- 21:06Speaker 1: And that's the question that now before the Supreme Court.
- 21:09Speaker 1: And in fact, that statement that the other defendant made
- 21:13Speaker 1: in his plea elocution that was never subject to cross
- 21:17Speaker 1: examination at all. Now that's exactly right, because it was
- 21:21Speaker 1: a plea elocution. It's just a statement that's made at
- 21:26Speaker 1: a guilty plea where a defendant has to admit the
- 21:29Speaker 1: elements of the crime in order for a judge to
- 21:32Speaker 1: accept that plea. So it's not cross examined by the
- 21:35Speaker 1: prosecution or anybody else at the time. And what the
- 21:38Speaker 1: defense here is arguing is that any competent defense attorney
- 21:42Speaker 1: who had the ability to cross examine this other defendant
- 21:45Speaker 1: could have PopEd holes in that narrative by asking the
- 21:49Speaker 1: other suspect whether he, for example, also possessed the murder
- 21:53Speaker 1: weapon in addition to the weapon that he fled guilty to,
- 21:56Speaker 1: or by exploring the motivations of that defendant to plead
- 22:00Speaker 1: guilty to that weapon's charge when he had originally been
- 22:03Speaker 1: charged with murdering. Lower courts around the country are split
- 22:07Speaker 1: on this issue. One reason that the Supreme Court might
- 22:09Speaker 1: have taken the case. In your opinion as a former prosecutor,
- 22:13Speaker 1: do you think the court should have allowed in that
- 22:15Speaker 1: plea elocution. I think there's a good argument by the
- 22:19Speaker 1: defense that that statement should not come in without the
- 22:23Speaker 1: ability for the defense to cross examine the witness for
- 22:26Speaker 1: the very reason you mentioned earlier, which is when the
- 22:29Speaker 1: statement was made, was not even in the context of
- 22:32Speaker 1: another trial where it was said that the cross examination
- 22:35Speaker 1: by some other lawyer. It was simply a statement that
- 22:38Speaker 1: was necessary in order to allow that defendant to enter
- 22:41Speaker 1: a guilty plea, and it was not in any way
- 22:43Speaker 1: challenged by any other lawyer as to its veracity or
- 22:47Speaker 1: its completeness, And there were other defenses available. Even if
- 22:51Speaker 1: the defendant in that case did possess the other handgun,
- 22:54Speaker 1: there was no testimony about whether he possessed other handguns,
- 22:59Speaker 1: or whether he might not have been telling the truth
- 23:01Speaker 1: in order to try to get a better plea from
- 23:03Speaker 1: the prosecutor since he was facing a murder charge and
- 23:06Speaker 1: ultimately only played guilty to a weapon's violation. Thanks Bob.
- 23:10Speaker 1: That's Robert Mints of McCarter and English and that's it
- 23:13Speaker 1: for the edition of the Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you
- 23:15Speaker 1: can always get the latest legal news honor Bloomberg Lawn podcast.
- 23:19Speaker 1: You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and wherever
- 23:22Speaker 1: you get your favorite podcasts. I'm June Grosso and you're
- 23:25Speaker 1: listening to Bloomberg