Latest / Secrets of the Centuries / Did Civilization Begin At Karahan Tepe?
Transcript
- 0:00I want you to close your eyes for a second, assuming
- 0:02you aren't driving, and just picture a landscape
- 0:04for me. Safety first, of course. Right, exactly.
- 0:08So transport yourself to the southeastern provinces
- 0:10of Turkey, specifically a place called the Tek
- 0:13Tek Mountains. And if you were to stand there
- 0:16today, like in the height of summer, the first
- 0:18word that would come to your mind is probably
- 0:20just, um, scorched. Oh, absolutely. It is incredibly
- 0:24unforgiving. Yeah, it feels like the sun -baked,
- 0:28totally alien world, just these endless, dry,
- 0:32arid hills, you know, like a topography of cracked
- 0:34earth and just relentless heat. You can practically
- 0:38feel the dust coating the back of your throat
- 0:40just looking at it. It really is. I mean, if
- 0:42you look at the soil profile today and the modern
- 0:45hydrology of the region, it feels almost hostile
- 0:48to human life, at least, you know, without modern
- 0:50irrigation. It's a landscape that seemingly just
- 0:53resists habitation. But now I want you to rewind
- 0:56the clock. We are going back roughly 12 ,000
- 0:58years ago. The ice age is taking its final bow,
- 1:01the vast glaciers to the north are retreating,
- 1:03and the global climate is shifting in a huge
- 1:05way. A massive, sudden shift, yeah. Right. And
- 1:08if you stood in that exact same spot in the Teteca
- 1:11Mountains 12 millennia ago, it is completely
- 1:13unrecognizable. It is a humid, lush, vibrant
- 1:17paradise. Rivers and streams are flowing heavily
- 1:19through these valleys that are now just dry,
- 1:22cracked riverbeds. Yeah, the ecology was totally
- 1:24inverted. Exactly. The hillsides are coated in
- 1:27thick, wild winter grasses, and most importantly,
- 1:29it is absolutely teeming with life. Colossal
- 1:32herds of wild game are moving through these valleys,
- 1:34grazing in this sort of prehistoric Eden. We
- 1:36call it a post -glacial epoch of absolute plenty.
- 1:40Ecologically speaking, the sudden warming and
- 1:42the increased rainfall turned this very specific
- 1:45pocket of the Near East into a hyperproductive
- 1:48environment. Which is perfect for a hunter -gatherer,
- 1:51right? Oh, it was a dream. For a hunter -gatherer,
- 1:53it was essentially a world without scarcity.
- 1:55You didn't have to struggle to find calories.
- 1:57And in this paradise, a group of roaming hunters
- 1:59stopped wandering. They had no farms, they had
- 2:02no wheels, no draft animals, and certainly no
- 2:04metal tools. None at all. Just stone and wood.
- 2:07Right. Yet, they decided to build a sprawling,
- 2:11impossibly complex stone metropolis. So today
- 2:15we are going on a deep dive into the dirt of
- 2:18a site known as Karahan Tepe to find out how
- 2:21a prehistoric religion basically accidentally
- 2:24invented the modern world. It is a profound story.
- 2:27It really changes everything. It really does.
- 2:29We're looking at a place that completely rewrites
- 2:31the textbook on human prehistory. So, okay, let's
- 2:36unpack this. How is a group of nomadic campers
- 2:39building a permanent megalithic site because
- 2:42I mean my high school history book definitively
- 2:44stated we had to invent farms before we could
- 2:47build monuments. Yeah. Well your high school
- 2:49history book was relying on a consensus that
- 2:52we have confidently taught for over a century.
- 2:55The traditional paradigm it's it's highly logical.
- 2:58It makes sense on paper. Right. The logic goes
- 3:00you cannot build massive stone architecture without
- 3:03a specialized labor force and you cannot have
- 3:05a specialized labor force unless you have surplus
- 3:08food which requires agriculture. Because if you're
- 3:11hauling rocks, you can't be out hunting. Precisely.
- 3:14Karahan Tepe entirely shatters that sequence.
- 3:16I mean, we're dealing with a site that is roughly
- 3:1833 hectares in size. To give you a visual, that's
- 3:21about the size of 60 American football fields.
- 3:2460 football fields. That is insane. We have only
- 3:29excavated about 5 % of it. Yet that 5 % is already
- 3:33forcing us to rethink the cognitive evolution
- 3:35of our species. So imagine you're standing on
- 3:38a hill where Every rock you trip over turns out
- 3:40to be an 11 ,000 -year -old monument. Because
- 3:43that is literally what happened. A Turkish archaeologist
- 3:46named Bahattin Çelik first noticed the site in
- 3:491997. But what blows my mind is how you even
- 3:52realize what you're looking at. It's surprisingly
- 3:54difficult to spot. Right, because for thousands
- 3:56of years, shepherds and travelers probably walked
- 3:59right over this hill. They saw these weird rocks
- 4:02jutting out of the earth and probably thought
- 4:03they were natural formations, maybe, I don't
- 4:06know, petrified tree trunks or something. It's
- 4:08incredibly easy to miss if you don't know what
- 4:10to look for. The limestone in that region erodes
- 4:13in a very specific way. And over 11 millennia,
- 4:17these structures were deliberately buried and
- 4:19then naturally weathered. Just blending right
- 4:22into the landscape. Exactly. But when Chellick
- 4:24and his team conducted their initial surface
- 4:26surveys, they started counting these massive
- 4:29T -shaped megalithic obelisks just protruding
- 4:32from the dirt. And they counted over 250 of them
- 4:36across those 33 hectares. Let's actually talk
- 4:39about these T -shaped obelisks, because the word
- 4:41pillar doesn't quite do justice to what these
- 4:43are. I mean, they aren't just rectangular blocks
- 4:46holding up a ceiling. No, they are highly stylized.
- 4:50The T -shape is widely understood by anthropologists
- 4:52to be an abstract anthropomorphic form, basically
- 4:55a human figure. So the rock itself is a person.
- 4:58Right. The vertical shaft of the T represents
- 5:01the body, and the horizontal block on top represents
- 5:04the head. And... You know, we know this isn't
- 5:07just academic guesswork because on the sides
- 5:09of the vertical shafts, the builders actually
- 5:11carved arms coming down with hands folding over
- 5:15what would be the belly or the waist of the pillar.
- 5:17It's so haunting. You have these faceless stone
- 5:21giants standing in a circle. And these aren't
- 5:23small. We are talking about pillars that can
- 5:25weigh several tons. Massive pieces of limestone.
- 5:29So going back to my confusion about the timeline.
- 5:32How do we know for an absolute fact that these
- 5:35people were hunter -gatherers? If they have the
- 5:37engineering chops to quarry, move, and erect
- 5:39a 10 -ton limestone giant, why couldn't they
- 5:42just have a hidden wheat field somewhere? It
- 5:44comes down to the forensic reality of the dirt.
- 5:47In archaeology, absence of evidence is sometimes
- 5:49just as loud as the evidence itself. What's fascinating
- 5:53here is that despite decades of surface surveys
- 5:56and systematic full -scale excavations that finally
- 5:59begin in 2019. They have not found a single shard
- 6:03of pottery. Zero pottery, which means no long
- 6:08-term grain storage in clay vessels. Precisely.
- 6:12You need pots to store agricultural surplus.
- 6:14Furthermore, they use a technique called flotation
- 6:17to sift through the excavated soil, looking for
- 6:19microscopic plant remains and seeds. Right, so
- 6:22they're looking for the actual crops. Yeah. And
- 6:24they have not found a single grain of domesticated
- 6:27wheat or barley. They have not found a single
- 6:29bone of a domesticated animal. Every single animal
- 6:32bone discarded in their ancient trash pits belongs
- 6:35to wild game. Oh, wow. So it's a hundred percent
- 6:39wild. Every plant remnant is wild. The forensic
- 6:42profile overwhelmingly points to a society of
- 6:45highly affluent foragers. They were hunting wild
- 6:48herds that moved down from the slopes of Mount
- 6:51Crocodog to the north and just foraging in the
- 6:54lush valleys. I am having a really hard time
- 6:57wrapping my head around the physics of this.
- 6:59Like, let's look at the mechanics. You are a
- 7:02nomadic hunter. You don't have a bronze chisel.
- 7:05You have flint and obsidian. How do you cut a
- 7:08multi -ton block of limestone out of the bedrock
- 7:11and then actually move it? It requires a staggering
- 7:14amount of time and a massive coordinated labor
- 7:17force. Limestone is relatively soft, but to carve
- 7:20it with a flint hand axe is an incredibly tedious
- 7:23process. Because it just chips away a tiny bit
- 7:26at a time? Right. Flint is harder than limestone,
- 7:29so it will cut it, but flint is also brittle.
- 7:32It flakes and breaks. This means they needed
- 7:34an entire supply chain just for the tools. Someone
- 7:37has to be constantly napping new flint axes while
- 7:40the carvers are working the bedrock. Just a constant
- 7:43stream of new tools being made. Exactly. They
- 7:46would trench around a massive block in the living
- 7:48rock. slowly undercut it, and then use wooden
- 7:50levers and ropes made from plant fibers to pry
- 7:53it free. And no wheels to roll it to the site.
- 7:56None. They are likely using wooden rollers, sledges,
- 8:00and sheer human muscle. Moving a five -ton block
- 8:03of stone up a hillside without draft animals
- 8:05requires dozens, perhaps hundreds of people pulling
- 8:08in perfect unison. Which means someone has to
- 8:12be feeding those hundreds of people. I mean,
- 8:14if half the tribe is hauling a rock, they aren't
- 8:16hunting. So the other half has to hunt double
- 8:19the game, process the meat, and bring it to the
- 8:21construction site. It implies a level of hierarchical
- 8:25organization and logistical planning that we
- 8:28previously thought was impossible without a king
- 8:30and a tax system. It's like building a skyscraper,
- 8:34but you're just camping in the woods. That is
- 8:37the monumental paradox of the Tos -Tepeler or
- 8:40the Stone Hills culture. which Karahan Tepe is
- 8:43a part of. The organization required is astronomical,
- 8:46and it forces us to look deeply at the architecture
- 8:49itself. Because you wouldn't do this just for
- 8:52fun. Right. A society doesn't exert that much
- 8:55caloric energy, basically risking starvation,
- 8:58unless the building serves an absolutely critical
- 9:00function. And the architecture of Karahan Tepe
- 9:03reveals a worldview that is radically, almost
- 9:06violently different from the farming societies
- 9:08that evolved thousands of years later. Okay,
- 9:10let's dig into that contrast. Because when I
- 9:13think of early human settlements in that part
- 9:15of the world, I think of places like Chattelhoyuk,
- 9:17which came a bit later. And the vibe there is
- 9:20very different. Very different. Chattelhoyuk
- 9:23is a classic Neolithic farming community, built
- 9:26several thousand years after Karahentapi. And
- 9:29the symbolism there is deeply tied to agriculture
- 9:31and fertility. Right, like those famous little
- 9:34statues. Yes. The most famous artifacts from
- 9:36those later sites are the Mother Goddess figurines.
- 9:39They are these plump, maternal, heavily pregnant
- 9:42female figures. They represent the fertility
- 9:45of the earth, the cyclical nature of the seasons,
- 9:48you know, the birth of the crops. It's a very
- 9:51grounded, nurturing symbolism. Kara -Han Tepe
- 9:54is the exact opposite of that. It is aggressively,
- 9:57almost overwhelmingly masculine. There is no
- 10:01plump earth mother here. Not at all. In 2023,
- 10:05archaeologists at Kara -Han Tepe unearthed a
- 10:07striking, almost disturbing statue. It is a depiction
- 10:12of a masculine figure, seated, tightly holding
- 10:15his own prominent penis. Just right out there
- 10:18in the open. Yes. But what is truly arresting
- 10:22about this statue is the torso. The ribs are
- 10:25deeply carved and clearly showing. The figure
- 10:27looks emaciated, almost skeletal. So not exactly
- 10:30a symbol of abundance and big harvests. Exactly.
- 10:34It is the visual antithesis of agricultural abundance.
- 10:38It is raw, harsh, and heavily focused on male
- 10:42virility, and perhaps the thin line between survival
- 10:45and starvation. And this hyper -masculine theme
- 10:49isn't just a one -off statue. It is quite literally
- 10:51carved into the floor plan of the site. I want
- 10:55to walk you through some of these specific spaces,
- 10:57starting with what archaeologists call Enclosure
- 10:59AB. Fascinating structure. Yeah, they dug this
- 11:02chamber right out of the living hillside. The
- 11:04researchers noted that the pillars filling this
- 11:06space are undeniably phallic in shape. It's colloquially
- 11:11been dubbed the penis room. And the craziest
- 11:14part? Overlooking this entire space is a massive,
- 11:18ominous human head carved directly out of the
- 11:21bedrock, just staring down at the pillars. It
- 11:23creates a highly intimidating atmosphere. And
- 11:26when we examine how these spaces interlock, we
- 11:29realize this site was a labyrinth of highly specialized,
- 11:32rock -cut architecture. Take enclosure AA, for
- 11:35instance. Yeah, the one with the pit. Right.
- 11:37This isn't just a room. It features a deep, excavated
- 11:40central pit. But the genius of the engineering
- 11:43is around the perimeter. Carved directly into
- 11:45the rock wall are continuous benches. Like a
- 11:49prehistoric stadium? That is the most accurate
- 11:51mechanical comparison. A bench carved into the
- 11:54perimeter of a pit has only one functional purpose.
- 11:56It is designed to seat an audience. It dictates
- 11:59that whatever happens in that central pit is
- 12:02a performance meant to be observed by spectators.
- 12:05Then you move over to enclosure AD, which looks
- 12:07like the main chamber. It's this vast space surrounded
- 12:11by those large T -shaped pillars. But it connects
- 12:14to two smaller adjacent rooms. It almost feels
- 12:16like a backstage area, or I don't know, a way
- 12:19to separate the general public in the large room
- 12:21from the initiated elites in the small rooms.
- 12:25A separation of sacred status, very likely. Yeah.
- 12:28And enclosure AD has one specific T pillar that
- 12:31I find genuinely terrifying. It has the human
- 12:35arms carved in relief down the sides, just like
- 12:37you described earlier. But the hands that wrap
- 12:40around the front of the pillar only have four
- 12:42fingers each. It is deeply unsettling. It is
- 12:46anthropomorphic, but it is distinctly other.
- 12:49It's a deliberate abstraction. I mean, they knew
- 12:51how to carve five fingers. They chose to carve
- 12:53four. So it's not a mistake. No, it suggests
- 12:57a representation of a being that is not entirely
- 13:00human, perhaps an ancestor spirit. or some kind
- 13:03of deity. And we know they were moving things
- 13:06between these rooms, too. Connecting enclosures
- 13:08AB, AA, and AD are these intricate channels cut
- 13:13right into the rock. Yes, the prevailing hypothesis
- 13:15is that these channels were hydraulic. They were
- 13:18engineered to move water between the chambers.
- 13:21But not for drinking, right? Right. We have to
- 13:23be careful not to view this through a modern
- 13:25lens. This wasn't plumbing for sanitation. This
- 13:28was highly controlled, sacred water likely used
- 13:31in ceremonial ablutions or rituals taking place
- 13:35in those pits. But honestly using terms like
- 13:39enclosures or chambers or even channels severely
- 13:42limits our understanding. Why? Because it sounds
- 13:44like we're describing an office floor plan. Exactly.
- 13:48Our modern vocabulary is entirely shaped by our
- 13:50modern utilitarian built environment. Words like
- 13:54room or temple or facility fail to capture what
- 13:58these spaces were to a Paleolithic mind. It's
- 14:01too clinical. It is. We are applying alphabetical
- 14:05sterile designations like enclosure A, enclosure
- 14:08B, to spaces that were likely the pulsating center
- 14:11of their entire cosmological universe. Well,
- 14:14let me throw a different word at it then. What
- 14:16if we completely abandon the idea of a quiet,
- 14:19solemn temple? Because when I hear temple, I
- 14:22think of hushed voices, echoing footsteps, you
- 14:25know, solemn prayer. But you just described a
- 14:28deep pit with audience seating, hydraulic channels
- 14:32for ceremonial water, and distinct public and
- 14:35private staging areas. That is a very different
- 14:37setting. Right. What if this wasn't a church,
- 14:40but a loud, crowded, chaotic, prehistoric theater?
- 14:44The archaeological evidence strongly supports
- 14:47that interpretation. And the atmosphere of that
- 14:50theater becomes even more intense when we look
- 14:52at the structural mechanics of Enclosure AC.
- 14:55For a very long time, The default assumption
- 14:58in archaeology was that these megalithic circles
- 15:01in the Near East were open to the sky. Right,
- 15:03similar to how we view Stonehenge. You assume
- 15:05they want to look up at the stars or the sun.
- 15:08But the forensics in enclosure A .C. tell a different
- 15:11story. Archaeologists found a specific scattering
- 15:15of large, flat, plate -like stones at the base
- 15:18of the pillars. More importantly, they found
- 15:22deliberate engineered grooves carved into the
- 15:25tops of the T -pillars. Oh, to hold something
- 15:27in place. Yes. The mechanical physics of those
- 15:30grooves and those flat stones strongly suggest
- 15:33a roofing system. They were slotting beams into
- 15:36those pillars to support a massive roof. Hold
- 15:39on. If there's a roof over these enclosures and
- 15:42they are dug deep into the hillside, you aren't
- 15:45sitting in a sunlit meadow. You are sitting in
- 15:48pitch black. You are entirely cut off from the
- 15:50outside world. You are enclosed in a dark, subterranean
- 15:54environment. you have crossed a physical threshold
- 15:58from the world of the mundane, sunlit earth into
- 16:01a dark, manufactured underworld. That is terrifying.
- 16:06It was meant to be. And to understand what they
- 16:08were doing in the dark, we have to look at the
- 16:10set design of this theater. We have to look at
- 16:13the art. Because they weren't staring at blank
- 16:15walls. Yeah. To understand the builders, we have
- 16:18to look at the monsters they carved. And I mean
- 16:21monsters. If you go to the Sanliorfo Museum today,
- 16:24you can see a dizzying array of idols and stone
- 16:27carvings pulled directly from the site. The craftsmanship
- 16:30is incredible. It is. And they are not carving
- 16:33cute little deer or bunnies. They are carving
- 16:36the things that go bump in the night. We are
- 16:38talking about massive, deeply threatening depictions
- 16:41of wild boars with massive tusks, crocodiles,
- 16:44snarling wolves and bears. They are carving apex
- 16:47predators. They are carving the creatures that
- 16:49actively competed with humans for survival and
- 16:52frequently hunted humans. But there's a vital
- 16:55piece of evidence that changes how we view these
- 16:58carvings, and that is pigment residue. Right,
- 17:00because we just see gray limestone in the museum.
- 17:03We assume it was all gray. But the limestone
- 17:05is porous, and microscopic analysis reveals that
- 17:08these stones were vividly painted. Imagine being
- 17:11in that dark, subterranean room with just the
- 17:14flickering light of a fire or a torch. Oh man,
- 17:16the shadows. Right. You aren't looking at gray
- 17:19stone. You are looking at aggressively colored,
- 17:22deeply shadowed, three -dimensional monsters
- 17:24leaping out of the walls. And the king of these
- 17:28monsters at Carahontepa, without a doubt, is
- 17:31the leopard. The ecological context here is crucial.
- 17:34The Anatolian leopard flourished in this exact
- 17:37region for tens of thousands of years, right
- 17:40up until it was hunted to extinction in the mid
- 17:42-20th century. So they were definitely dealing
- 17:45with these cats. Oh, constantly. In a post -glacial
- 17:49environment, the leopard was the undisputed silent
- 17:52assassin of the hills. It was the apex predator.
- 17:56And the people of Karhan Tepe didn't just carve
- 17:58leopards walking around looking majestic. No,
- 18:02this is where it gets deeply weird. The most
- 18:05brain -breaking figures they found are these
- 18:07human -animal hybrids. There is a specific sculpture
- 18:10of a human being and a massive beast, undeniably
- 18:13a large feline, likely a leopard, physically
- 18:16entwined. It's a very dynamic pose. Yeah, it's
- 18:20this half -man, half -predator fusion bursting
- 18:23out of the stone. Why on earth would a human
- 18:26being want to depict themselves merging with
- 18:28a very animal that stalks them in the tall grass?
- 18:31If we connect this to the bigger picture, this
- 18:34isn't just an isolated quirk of Karahan Tepe.
- 18:37It taps into a profound cognitive and spiritual
- 18:39tradition that spans the entirety of the Upper
- 18:42Paleolithic period. To really understand the
- 18:45psychology of this hybrid carving, we have to
- 18:47pull back and look at the broader human timeline.
- 18:50Let's go to the cave system of Trofraire in France.
- 18:53Wait, that's a completely different continent
- 18:56and time period, right? Yes, roughly 14 ,000
- 18:59years ago. Deep inside that cave, painted in
- 19:02black pigment, is a figure known to anthropologists
- 19:05as the Sorcerer. It features human legs and a
- 19:09human posture, but the upper body and head of
- 19:12a bison or a stag complete with antlers. Okay,
- 19:14so a human -animal hybrid in France. Now let's
- 19:17travel even further back in deep time. 30 ,000
- 19:20to 40 ,000 years ago to the Hohlenstein -Stadel
- 19:23cave in Germany. There, an early human took the
- 19:27incredibly hard tusk of a mammoth and over hundreds
- 19:30of hours carved the lion man. Out of ivory. That's
- 19:34so difficult. Very difficult. It is one of the
- 19:37oldest known undisputed examples of figurative
- 19:40art in the world. It is a human body standing
- 19:43upright, but with the head of a European cave
- 19:45lion. It makes me think of early comic books.
- 19:48Like it's essentially an ancient superhero origin
- 19:51story. Think about Peter Parker. He gets bitten
- 19:53by a spider, a creature he might otherwise fear
- 19:56or ignore, and he physically takes on its traits
- 19:59to become powerful. That's a great analogy. Or
- 20:01like Bruce Wayne, right? He is terrified of bats.
- 20:05So he physically wraps himself in the imagery
- 20:08of about to become the apex predator of Gotham's
- 20:10underworld. It's this primal human psychological
- 20:14desire to mentally and physically merge with
- 20:16the most dangerous, powerful force in your specific
- 20:18environment. In Ice Age Germany, it was the cave
- 20:21lion. In prehistoric Turkey, it was the leopard.
- 20:24They wanted to ingest its power. That is an excellent
- 20:27modern framework for understanding an ancient
- 20:30psychological mechanism. Anthropologists refer
- 20:32to this as a profound mimetics. It is a ritual
- 20:36state where the hard boundary between humanity
- 20:39and the natural world is completely dissolved.
- 20:42So you become the animal. The duality vanishes.
- 20:46The eater in the eaten, the hunter in the hunted
- 20:48become one singular entity. The individuals who
- 20:51were orchestrating this dissolution the ones
- 20:54actually taking on these hybrid forms in the
- 20:56minds of the community, were the religious practitioners.
- 21:00The shamans. Because you don't just naturally
- 21:02wake up feeling like a leopard. You need someone
- 21:05to guide you across that psychological bridge.
- 21:08And the answer to why humans were obsessed with
- 21:10this blending of man and beast lies in the altered
- 21:13states of consciousness these shamans were exploring
- 21:16inside those dark, roofed enclosures at Karahan
- 21:19Tepe. We have to rely on the robust work of anthropologists
- 21:22here, notably David Lewis Williams, who has extensively
- 21:26studied prehistoric rock art. He argues, quite
- 21:30convincingly, that these hybrid depictions, whether
- 21:33the Lion Man or the Leopard Man of Carahantepe,
- 21:36are not just wild imagination or fictional storytelling.
- 21:40Right. It's not just the fairy tale they made
- 21:42up around the campfire. No. They are literal
- 21:44translations of intense visual hallucinations
- 21:47experienced during shamanic trance. And we know
- 21:51these trances weren't just achieved through like
- 21:53deep breathing or fasting. We have hard chemical
- 21:56evidence from this region. We absolutely do.
- 21:59If you look at the Shanidar cave system in Kurdistan,
- 22:02there is a famous burial designated Shanidar
- 22:044. Alongside the remains, archaeologists found
- 22:08pollen and plant material that included specific
- 22:11known psychotropic substances. So Prehistoric
- 22:15psychedelic use. Yes. These plants contain alkaloids
- 22:18that fundamentally alter neurochemistry, breaking
- 22:21down the brain's default mode network, which
- 22:24is the part of your brain that maintains your
- 22:26sense of a separate self. So you ingest this
- 22:29plant, your sense of self dissolves, and the
- 22:32shaman acts as the bridge. The shaman's primary
- 22:35social function was to cross the fluid border
- 22:38into the spirit world. They did this to contact
- 22:40ancestors to ask for success in the hunt or to
- 22:44heal a sickness But a human soul cannot easily
- 22:47navigate the spirit world. It needs a vessel
- 22:49It needs an animal alter ego a spirit guide essentially
- 22:53exactly Depending on the local ecology that vessel
- 22:57changes in some North American cultures. It was
- 23:00an owl or a deer in Mesoamerica It was the Jaguar
- 23:04and here in the Stone Hills. The leopard was
- 23:07the chosen vehicle to the divine But the stones
- 23:10show they didn't make the trip alone. It wasn't
- 23:12just the shaman and the leopard hanging out.
- 23:14No. The spirit world is dangerous, and a shaman
- 23:16needs a retinue. Anthropologists call these friendly
- 23:19spirits, or familiars. And we see them carved
- 23:22profusely across the Tos -Tepeler sites. They
- 23:25are the secondary cast of characters on the pillars.
- 23:28Like the scorpions and snakes? Yes. Scorpions,
- 23:31snakes, lizards, frogs, foxes, hares, and various
- 23:34birds. What is particularly fascinating is a
- 23:38point of divergence between neighboring sites.
- 23:41At Gobekli Tepe, which is very close by, the
- 23:44carvings heavily feature the fox, suggesting
- 23:46their specific shamanic lineage might have favored
- 23:49the fox as their primary guide. But at Karahan
- 23:52Tepe, it is undeniably, aggressively the cult
- 23:56of the leopard. I want to pause here because
- 23:59I really want you listening right now to try
- 24:02and simulate this experience in your own mind.
- 24:04Put yourself in the bare feet of a hunter -gatherer
- 24:0712 ,000 years ago. Your entire existence is the
- 24:10wind, the rustling winter grass, tracking animal
- 24:13prints, and the brutal reality of survival. A
- 24:16very quiet, natural world. Right. You have never
- 24:19seen a building? You don't even know what a wall
- 24:22is. Then, you are brought up this dusty hill
- 24:26and you step down into enclosure AA. The roof
- 24:29overhead completely blocks out the sky and the
- 24:32sun. The air is thick. suffocatingly thick with
- 24:36the smoke of burning incense and animal fat.
- 24:39And the sound. We haven't even talked about the
- 24:42sound. The acoustics would be overwhelming. We
- 24:45know the instruments they possessed from the
- 24:46archaeological record. They used bone scrapers,
- 24:49which create a harsh rhythmic rasping. They had
- 24:53clappers. They had animal skin drums. But most
- 24:56importantly, they had the bullroarer. Explain
- 24:59how a bullroarer works physically because It's
- 25:02not a drum. It's something entirely different.
- 25:05A bullroar is a piece of carved wood or bone
- 25:07attached to a long cord. When you swing it in
- 25:11a large circle over your head, the aerodynamics
- 25:13of the carved piece cause it to spin rapidly
- 25:15on its own axis while traveling through the air.
- 25:18Oh, like a propeller? Yes. And this creates a
- 25:21deep, unearthly vibrating hum. In an enclosed,
- 25:25subterranean stone space, that low -frequency
- 25:27sound wave literally vibrates in your chest cavity.
- 25:30It alters your brainwaves. So you are packed
- 25:33shoulder to shoulder in a dark pit with your
- 25:35tribe. The drums are pounding. The bone scrapers
- 25:38are tearing at the air. The bullroarer is humming
- 25:41inside your ribs. You have ingested a psychotropic
- 25:44plant. And in the center of the pit, illuminated
- 25:47only by the frantic flickering light of a fire,
- 25:50a shaman is dancing. It would be a complete sensory
- 25:54overload. Totally. They are wearing the skinned
- 25:57pelt of a leopard. physically embodying the vividly
- 26:01painted stone monsters looming over you in the
- 26:03dark, the psychological impact wouldn't just
- 26:06be a neat show. It would shatter your reality.
- 26:10It would completely override your sensory processing.
- 26:13You would leave that enclosure believing without
- 26:14a shadow of a doubt in the physical reality of
- 26:17the spirit world because you just visited it.
- 26:20Your ego was dissolved and you were merged with
- 26:22the divine. And doing that takes a lot of effort,
- 26:24right? Tremendous effort. And the power of that
- 26:27shared, manufactured experience is the hinge
- 26:29upon which human history turns. Because the sheer
- 26:33logistical effort required to build that theater
- 26:35forces us to ask the most revolutionary question
- 26:38in modern archaeology. Did this shamanic religion
- 26:41invent the farm? OK, let's talk about the farm.
- 26:45Let's look at the old dogma, the rules we all
- 26:47learned. Back in the 1930s, a highly influential
- 26:50archaeologist named V. Gordon Child coined the
- 26:52term the Neolithic Revolution. A very famous
- 26:54concept. Right. His theory was heavily based
- 26:58on environmental determinism and practicality.
- 27:01He argued that as the Ice Age ended, geographical
- 27:04and climate changes literally forced humans to
- 27:06figure out agriculture just to avoid starving.
- 27:09His logic was basically humans planted wheat,
- 27:11which forced them to stop moving and settle in
- 27:14one place. Settling down allowed them to store
- 27:16surplus food. Surplus food allowed some people
- 27:19to stop farming and become priests or stonemasons.
- 27:21And then finally, they built temples. So in Child's
- 27:24view, the stomach led the mind. Exactly. First
- 27:27you eat, then you pray. And that framework was
- 27:29the absolute gospel of archaeology for nearly
- 27:31a century. It makes perfect intuitive sense to
- 27:34the modern pragmatic mind. But Karhan Tepe and
- 27:38the broader Tos -Tepeler culture completely disproves
- 27:41child's sequence of events. Because the monuments
- 27:43are already there. Yes. The monumental buildings
- 27:45came first. There was no agriculture yet. The
- 27:49wild food was abundant enough to temporarily
- 27:50support them, but the cognitive drive to build
- 27:53was already there. This sequence aligns perfectly
- 27:56with the groundbreaking, initially highly controversial
- 27:59work of a French archaeologist named Jacques
- 28:01Coving. Coving wrote a book called The Birth
- 28:03of the Gods and the Origins of Agriculture, right?
- 28:06And he basically flipped child's theory upside
- 28:08down. Completely inverted it. Coving argued that
- 28:10a fundamental shift in human psychology and ideology,
- 28:14basically the birth of religion, was the prime
- 28:16mover of human civilization, not a change in
- 28:19the weather or a desire for a stable food source.
- 28:22So under Kovan's theory, the mind led the stomach.
- 28:24We wanted to pray, so we had to figure out how
- 28:27to eat. Precisely. If we connect this to the
- 28:29bigger picture, Kovan argues that humanity experienced
- 28:32a cognitive revolution first. We developed an
- 28:36agricultural mindset thousands of years before
- 28:38we ever figured out how to domesticate a single
- 28:41grain of wheat. Wait, I need you to explain that.
- 28:43What does an agricultural mindset mean for a
- 28:45nomadic guy with a spear who has never seen a
- 28:48farm? That sounds contradictory. It comes down
- 28:51to how a human being conceptualizes their place
- 28:53in the universe. A traditional hunter -gatherer
- 28:57generally views themselves as an integrated part
- 28:59of the landscape. They move with the herds. They
- 29:02are equal to the animals. The world is a fluid,
- 29:05continuous space. Right. There are no property
- 29:07lines. Exactly. But building something like enclosure
- 29:11AD requires a radically new rigid way of thinking
- 29:14it requires Segmentation you are suddenly carving
- 29:18a hard line into the earth separating the inside
- 29:21from the outside You are separating the sacred
- 29:25space from the profane space. You are drawing
- 29:27boundaries Which is exactly what a farmer does
- 29:30when he builds a fence. Yes Furthermore building
- 29:33these monoliths requires a hierarchical organization
- 29:36of labor to coordinate hundreds of workers It
- 29:39requires a central authority, the shaman or the
- 29:42proto -priest, directing the action. Because
- 29:44you can't have 200 people just moving rocks randomly.
- 29:47No. It has to be managed. Anthropologists like
- 29:51Brian Hayden and Elaine Testard have built on
- 29:54this, arguing that the social drive to hold these
- 29:56massive communal feasts and shamanic rituals
- 29:59created an intense need to gather and store huge
- 30:02surpluses of wild food to feed the pilgrims.
- 30:05So they were hoarding wild food. By gathering
- 30:08surplus wild food and by segmenting the landscape,
- 30:12they were cognitively pre -adapting to the mechanics
- 30:14of farming. The work of Ian Hodder at Kettle
- 30:17Hoyook really backs up this idea that the spiritual
- 30:20and the practical were totally enmeshed, right?
- 30:23It does. To understand Hodder's work, we have
- 30:25to look at the sociologist Emile Durkheim. Durkheim
- 30:28famously argued that all religion is based on
- 30:30a strict dichotomy between the sacred and the
- 30:32profane. Basically, the church versus the workplace.
- 30:36the holy day versus the workday. Which makes
- 30:38sense to us. We in the modern world live very
- 30:41Durkheimian lives. But Hodder excavated Katalhoyuk,
- 30:45that later farming community, and proved that
- 30:47Durkheim's dichotomy didn't exist in prehistory.
- 30:50Hodder found that the spiritual was suffused
- 30:52into every single mundane act. Every house was
- 30:55a temple. Ancestors were buried under the sleeping
- 30:58platforms. Art, ritual, and daily survival were
- 31:02a single, inseparable fabric. Okay. I hear you,
- 31:06Kavin and Hodder, but I have to push back hard
- 31:09here because the math is bothering me. Think
- 31:12about the sheer brutality of early farming. It
- 31:14is awful labor. You are out in the blistering
- 31:17sun breaking hard soil with a stick. You are
- 31:19weeding constantly. It is incredibly taxing on
- 31:22the body. Yeah. Early farmers had terrible arthritis,
- 31:26their teeth rotted from the grain carbohydrates,
- 31:28and they actually had a worse diet than foragers.
- 31:31Hunting and foraging actually takes less time
- 31:33and gives you better protein. Why would a nomadic
- 31:35hunter, who has it pretty good in a lush post
- 31:38-glacial world, choose to subject himself to
- 31:41the backbreaking labor of farming, just to host
- 31:44a religious festival? Hunger is a much stronger
- 31:46motivator than spirituality. Your logic is sound,
- 31:49but it ignores the ecological trap they set for
- 31:52themselves. You are absolutely right that foraging
- 31:55is generally easier and healthier than early
- 31:57farming. They didn't choose the farm because
- 32:00they wanted an easier life. They were forced
- 32:02into it. Forced by who? By their own rituals.
- 32:07Imagine bringing 2 ,000 nomadic people together
- 32:10at Karahan Tepe for a month -long festival to
- 32:12build a pillar and perform rituals. What happens
- 32:15to the local environment? Well, 2 ,000 people
- 32:19eating every day. I mean, you would... instantly
- 32:22hunt out all the game in a 10 -mile radius. You
- 32:24would strip every wild grain stalk and berry
- 32:27bush bare. It would be devastated. Exactly. The
- 32:31intense psychological religious obligation forced
- 32:34them to gather in massive numbers. That gathering
- 32:37completely exhausted the wild ecology of the
- 32:39immediate area. The land could not support the
- 32:42sheer density of humans required to build the
- 32:44temple. So they were starving themselves by building
- 32:47it. But they couldn't just leave. because the
- 32:50ritual had to be completed to keep the cosmos
- 32:51in balance. So that local ecological exhaustion
- 32:55is what forced them to figure out how to aggressively
- 32:58manage the wild stands of wheat, to save seeds,
- 33:01to plant them, and to pen up wild sheep so they
- 33:04didn't wander away. They invented agriculture
- 33:07to sustain the rituals. They did. Religion invented
- 33:11the farm. That is just... Staggering. We literally
- 33:16domesticated wheat and broke our backs in the
- 33:19dirt so we could keep throwing prehistoric wood
- 33:21stock. But bringing all these nomadic people
- 33:24together in one place for these intense rituals
- 33:26wasn't always just a peaceful festival of unity
- 33:29and leopard men, was it? We are talking about
- 33:32hundreds, maybe thousands of people who normally
- 33:34live in tiny groups suddenly rubbing shoulders.
- 33:37That introduces totally new volatile dynamics,
- 33:40anxiety, competition, and violence. It introduces
- 33:43a completely new set of psychological pressures
- 33:45that the human brain was not fully evolved to
- 33:49handle. For hundreds of thousands of years, humans
- 33:52lived in small, highly egalitarian bands. These
- 33:55bands are usually capped around what evolutionary
- 33:58psychologists call the Dunbar number. Break down
- 34:00the Dunbar number for us. How does that work
- 34:02mechanically in our brains? The Dunbar number
- 34:05proposed by Robin Dunbar suggests that the physical
- 34:08size of the human neocortex limits our ability
- 34:11to maintain stable, personal social relationships
- 34:14to roughly 150 people. It's like a CPU limit
- 34:17on a computer. OK, so 150 people is the max.
- 34:21Right. In a group of 150, you know everyone.
- 34:24You know their reputation. You know who is a
- 34:27good hunter. You know who is trustworthy. Social
- 34:30cohesion is maintained through direct personal
- 34:32relationships and peer pressure. But when you
- 34:35bring 2 ,000 people to Karahan Tepe, you blow
- 34:38right past that CPU limit. Instantly. Suddenly,
- 34:42You are surrounded by strangers. You don't know
- 34:44their reputations. Mistrust spikes. Paranoia
- 34:48about the other sets in. To manage a group that
- 34:51large, egalitarianism collapses and society becomes
- 34:54stratified. You need leaders, rule makers, and
- 34:57enforcers to maintain order. You get the rise
- 35:00of elite proto -priests. And when a stratified
- 35:03society gets anxious and the food supply is stressed,
- 35:06things can get incredibly dark. We see the terrifying
- 35:09evidence of this at a sister site in the region
- 35:11called Keanu. They found a specific building
- 35:14there that archaeologists literally christened
- 35:17the House of Skulls. And the forensic evidence
- 35:19is not ambiguous. The findings at Keanu are profoundly
- 35:23disturbing and point directly to the darker side
- 35:26of this societal transition. In this specific
- 35:30structure, archaeologists uncovered the remains
- 35:33of over 450 individuals. Which is a lot for one
- 35:37room. wasn't just a crowded graveyard. They found
- 35:41headless torsos. Even more chillingly, they found
- 35:44human vertebrae with distinct deep cut marks
- 35:47indicating that the heads were violently axed
- 35:50off while the flesh was still attached. Decapitation.
- 35:53Yes. The prominent archaeologist Robert Braidwood,
- 35:57who was instrumental in investigating early agricultural
- 35:59sites, looked closely at Chayunu. He noted a
- 36:03massive flat stone structure adjacent to a public
- 36:06plaza. Forensic testing revealed it was heavily
- 36:09stained with human and animal blood. So it wasn't
- 36:12just a butcher block for deer? No. Braidwood,
- 36:16looking at the decapitations and the bloodstained
- 36:18slab, did not shy away from the heavily supported
- 36:21conclusion that it was a sacrificial altar. Human
- 36:25sacrifice. It's like the ultimate stressed relief
- 36:28valve for a society that has grown too large,
- 36:31too fast, and is terrified of starving. It is
- 36:33the ultimate expression of the scapegoat mechanism.
- 36:38As soon as you have a complex, stratified society
- 36:40with shadowy elites leading the rituals, human
- 36:44sacrifice almost universally appears in the archaeological
- 36:47record globally. It is used to alleviate societal
- 36:50anxiety, appease angry spirits, and consolidate
- 36:54the political power of the priests who hold the
- 36:57axe. But... Amidst all this, the massive labor,
- 37:01the incredible art, the psychedelic rituals,
- 37:04the potential for brutal violence, there is one
- 37:07detail about these sites that I simply cannot
- 37:09fathom. I need you to explain the ephemeral nature
- 37:12of these monuments. Because after they spent
- 37:15generations carving 250 limestone pillars, hauling
- 37:19them into place without wheels, and performing
- 37:21these intense, blood -soaked, drug -fueled rituals,
- 37:25they buried them. Deliberately. Yes. Astonishingly,
- 37:30every single enclosure at the neighboring site
- 37:32of Gobekli Tepe, and it appears many, if not
- 37:35all, at Karahan Tepe as well, were intentionally
- 37:39buried. But how do you even do that? You're talking
- 37:42about 33 hectares of massive pillars. Where do
- 37:46you even get the dirt? It requires almost as
- 37:48much labor to bury it as it did to build it.
- 37:51They didn't just... pushed dirt over the edges.
- 37:54They systematically filled these enclosures with
- 37:56thousands of tons of limestone rubble, soil,
- 37:59flint tools, and massive amounts of animal bone
- 38:02refuge. Just burying it in trash and dirt. They
- 38:07painstakingly packed the space until the towering
- 38:11pillars were completely entombed under an artificial
- 38:13hill. Why on earth do you build the prehistoric
- 38:16Sistine Chapel just to immediately throw garbage
- 38:19on it and bury it? It makes absolutely zero sense
- 38:23to the modern mind. We build skyscrapers out
- 38:26of steel and glass because we want them to stand
- 38:27forever. We want our legacy to be permanent.
- 38:31And that is our modern bias blinding us. For
- 38:34the people of the Stone Hills, the finished permanent
- 38:37building wasn't the goal. The act of creation
- 38:41was the point. The physical journey of making
- 38:44it was the ritual, not sitting in it afterward.
- 38:48Exactly. but on a massive cosmic scale. The physical
- 38:52grueling labor of quarrying the stone, the immense
- 38:55communal effort of moving it, the rituals performed
- 38:58inside during its brief lifespan. That is what
- 39:01forged the social bonds. That is what appeased
- 39:04the ancestors and maintained the cosmic order.
- 39:08So once it's done, it's done? Right. Once the
- 39:11specific shaman who commissioned that enclosure
- 39:13died. Or once a particular social crisis had
- 39:16passed. The spiritual utility of that specific
- 39:20space was exhausted. Its power was spent. It
- 39:23might even be considered dangerous to leave open.
- 39:26Like leaving a live wire exposed. Yes. So they
- 39:30ceremonially entombed this theater of memory,
- 39:34sealed its power in the earth, and simply moved
- 39:36over a few yards to start carving a new one.
- 39:39That is beautiful, but so alien. Is this unique
- 39:43to this part of Turkey? Because it sounds so
- 39:46specific. Not at all. It is a recurring pattern
- 39:49in human history. Look at the Kukuteni -Tripillia
- 39:52culture in Eastern Europe, which existed thousands
- 39:54of years later. They would build sprawling, incredibly
- 39:57elaborate settlements, live in them for 60 to
- 40:0080 years, and then systematically set fire to
- 40:02the entire town and burn all their houses to
- 40:05the ground, only to rebuild nearby. Wow, just
- 40:07burning down your own town. Or look at the Ainu
- 40:09people of northern Japan, who maintained a strict
- 40:12tradition of burning the home of a deceased person.
- 40:14well into the 19th century to release the spirit.
- 40:19The physical structure is temporary. The ritual
- 40:22act of making and unmaking is eternal. This constant
- 40:25building and burying makes me think of these
- 40:27different hills in the Taas -Tepelar region like
- 40:30Karhan Tepe, Gobekli Tepe, Chayunu. Like, they
- 40:33were engaged in a prehistoric arms race because
- 40:36we know they weren't living in isolation. They
- 40:38were interacting with people from incredibly
- 40:40far away. Oh, the trade networks were vast. Yeah.
- 40:43Archaeologists found obsidian at these sites
- 40:46that traces back to central Anatolia, hundreds
- 40:48of miles away. They found seashells from the
- 40:51Red Sea and the Mediterranean. People were traveling
- 40:54huge, dangerous distances to get to Karahan Tepe.
- 40:58Were these different hilltop sites competing
- 41:00with each other? Like, were they trying to build
- 41:03the biggest most intimidating enclosures to attract
- 41:06pilgrims, corner the trade networks, and assert
- 41:09ideological dominance over the neighboring tribes?
- 41:12It's highly probable. In a world without written
- 41:15laws or standing armies, monumental architecture
- 41:18is the ultimate flex of power. A grand enclosure
- 41:22is a massive billboard for the potency of your
- 41:25local shaman and the logistical strength of your
- 41:28community. It's basically saying, look how powerful
- 41:30we are. Exactly. It signals to pilgrims and trading
- 41:33partners, look at what our spirits can command.
- 41:37Look at the labor we can organize. It is ideological
- 41:40warfare waged in limestone. But I think the most
- 41:44important takeaway here is that this isn't just
- 41:46a quirky localized phenomenon that only happened
- 41:49in the Stone Hills of Turkey. This exact sequence
- 41:52of events, gathering as nomads, performing mind
- 41:55-altering rituals, and building monumental architecture
- 41:58before inventing agriculture is seemingly baked
- 42:02right into the human operating system across
- 42:04the globe. It appears to be a global imperative.
- 42:07The renowned British archaeologist, Aubrey Burrell,
- 42:10has argued forcefully that sites like Karahan
- 42:12Tepe and Stonehenge belong in the exact same
- 42:14functional category of megalithic architecture.
- 42:17Wait, Stonehenge is in England. It's separated
- 42:20from Karahan Tepe by more than 6 ,000 years,
- 42:23and it was built by pastoral farmers who had
- 42:26domesticated animals, whereas Karahan was built
- 42:29by foragers. How are they in the same category?
- 42:31Because functionally, geographically, and psychologically,
- 42:34they serve the exact same purpose. Both were
- 42:37seasonal gathering places built on prominent
- 42:40natural landscapes deeply tied to celestial or
- 42:42natural cycles. So the mechanics of the society
- 42:46were the same? Yes. Both were designed to unite
- 42:49scattered, roaming populations through monumental,
- 42:52back -breaking communal effort. The specific
- 42:54technological level of the builders, whether
- 42:56they were a forager or a pastoralist, matters
- 42:59less than the cognitive drive to build the monument.
- 43:02And it doesn't stop in Eurasia. We see this phenomenon
- 43:05sprout up independently, completely disconnected
- 43:08all over the planet. Look at the Jomon culture
- 43:10in Japan roughly 15 ,000 years ago. Hunter gatherers
- 43:14building massive stone circles. A prime example,
- 43:16yes. Or look at North America, the Mississippian
- 43:18mound builders who constructed the incredible
- 43:20earthworks at Watson Break and Poverty Point
- 43:22in Louisiana in the fourth millennium B .C. They
- 43:25built massive geometric monuments and they did
- 43:28not farm corn, they were foragers. Or the sunken
- 43:31circular plazas of Caral in Peru. This universality
- 43:34is what makes Carahantepe so crucial. It implies
- 43:37a shared cognitive lineage that likely stretches
- 43:40back 50 ,000 years to our deepest Paleolithic
- 43:43ancestors before they migrated out of Africa.
- 43:46So it's just in our DNA to do this? The drive
- 43:49to ritualize our existence is not just some dusty
- 43:52archaeological curiosity or a primitive superstition.
- 43:56It is the fundamental biological mechanism by
- 43:59which human beings manufacture meaning and order
- 44:02out of a chaotic universe. And the crazy part
- 44:05is we still do it. We think we are so advanced,
- 44:08but we are still ritual animals. We do it constantly.
- 44:12Every single day. The term ritual isn't sequestered
- 44:15to a church or an ancient temple. When you place
- 44:18a framed photograph of a deceased loved one on
- 44:20a specific mantelpiece, you are engaging in a
- 44:23spatial ritual of memory, designating a sacred
- 44:26space in your home. Oh, that's such a good point.
- 44:29Or when you make your coffee and sit in the exact
- 44:31same chair every morning to read the news. That
- 44:33is a ritual of comfort and psychological order
- 44:36that prepares your brain for the day. Ritual
- 44:38is the invisible scaffolding that binds us to
- 44:41our reality, and more importantly, to each other.
- 44:44So if we take everything we've learned today
- 44:46and bring it all the way home for you listening,
- 44:49when entire tribes of nomadic hunters came together
- 44:52at Karahan Tepe 12 ,000 years ago, when they
- 44:55engaged in that hypnotic chest rattling music,
- 44:59ingested psychedelics, and carved terrifying
- 45:01monsters into limestone, it wasn't just an ancient
- 45:04party. It physically and psychologically altered
- 45:07their cognitive makeup. The sheer sensory overload
- 45:10dissolved their individual isolated egos and
- 45:14bound them together into a shared, undeniable
- 45:17story. A story so powerful and a gathering so
- 45:20massive that it decimated their local food supply.
- 45:24It forced them to fundamentally change their
- 45:26relationship with the earth, inventing the grueling
- 45:29labor of agriculture just to keep the story alive.
- 45:32The monuments literally birthed the civilization.
- 45:35The human need for meaning forced the invention.
- 45:38of the modern world. We started this deep dive
- 45:40looking at an empty, dusty, scorched hilltop
- 45:43in Turkey, and we ended up discovering that art,
- 45:46religion, and the burning human need to physically
- 45:49manifest our dreams and terrors into stone actually
- 45:52preceded and caused the invention of farming,
- 45:56cities, and eventually us. The mind truly did
- 45:59lead the stomach. Which raises an incredibly
- 46:02important question. A final thought, I'd like
- 46:05to leave you to mull over today. We've seen how
- 46:07the sheer overwhelming psychological need to
- 46:10build monuments and perform rituals is what accidentally
- 46:13forced our ancestors into the grueling labor
- 46:15-intensive life of agriculture, completely altering
- 46:18the trajectory of the planet. It changed everything.
- 46:22So look around at our modern world. What modern
- 46:25rituals or ideological obsessions are we currently
- 46:28pursuing with that same blind fervor today? And
- 46:32what unintended irreversible technological realities
- 46:35are they secretly forcing us to invent right
- 46:38now without us even realizing it? That is an
- 46:41amazing thought to chew on. Thank you so much
- 46:44for joining us on this deep dive into Karahan
- 46:46Tepe. Keep questioning the past because it's
- 46:48the only map we have to understand where we are
- 46:51going. And next time you're out in the heat looking
- 46:53at a scorched barren landscape, remember the
- 46:56Tek Tek mountains. Remember that beneath the
- 46:58dust, there might just be an 11 ,000 year old
- 47:02monster. waiting to tell you how the world began.
- 47:05Catch you next time.