Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E048: Navigating the ETF Era with Hong Kim of Bitwise
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10If you are enjoying On RAMP media content, please like
- 0:13subscribe and share as it goes a long way in helping others find
- 0:17the signal through the noise. Now for a word from on RAMP.
- 0:20On RAMP is a Bitcoin asset management platform built on
- 0:23multi institution custody leveraging our partnership with
- 0:26Bit Go and their 10 plus year track record in securing assets
- 0:29and Coincover, the premier digital asset risk mitigation
- 0:32company on ramps. Multi institution custody is a
- 0:35segregated institutional grade vault requiring two of three
- 0:39institutions at any point in time to sign once a client's
- 0:43unique permissions have been met at on RAMP we understand that
- 0:47your Bitcoin journey is a multi generational pursuit catalyzed
- 0:50by the ideals of perseverance, aspiration and legacy.
- 0:54That's why we're proud to introduce on RAMP Heritage, a
- 0:57suite of private client services dedicated to ensuring your
- 1:00Bitcoin legacy is preserved and passed on, embodying the true
- 1:04essence of wealth that goes beyond mere numbers.
- 1:07If you would like to learn more, please schedule a consultation.
- 1:10What you're telling me is that music is about to stop, and
- 1:15we're going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous
- 1:18extremism ever assembled in the history of Darkness. 1974,
- 1:26198792972000, and whatever we want to call this.
- 1:29It's all just the same thing over and over.
- 1:31We can't help ourselves. I say when we sell, hey, I say
- 1:43when we. Sell.
- 1:44We're live, gentlemen. What a week.
- 1:47What time to be alive? What a week.
- 1:50It's feeling exhilarated. Feel like bad boys in the
- 1:53Bitcoin space, huh? I.
- 1:58I I don't feel any different. I don't.
- 2:00Feel Jesse, you're Jesse. This Stanford MBA turned into a
- 2:04bad boy by association in the Bitcoin.
- 2:07Space. That's right.
- 2:09I don't feel any different than I did last week, but suddenly
- 2:12government seems to like what I'm interested in a little bit
- 2:15less. It's a timely week for Hong to
- 2:18join. You got a, you know, Hong Kong
- 2:21ETFs, you got the the Hoseki announcement for the
- 2:24attestation. So a lot of, a lot of good stuff
- 2:26happening. But then also, yeah, a lot of
- 2:28interesting dynamics happening at the state level and their
- 2:31interest in Bitcoin and money service, business and money
- 2:34transmission, yeah. Absolutely.
- 2:39Seeing the senator Cynthia Lomas put out that tweet of like come
- 2:44and get it I thought was still kind of encouraging in a way
- 2:48like that those types of memes of like, come and get it, like
- 2:52what are you gonna ban math or people memorizing 12 words in
- 2:56their in their brain type of energy always existed.
- 3:01But ultimately these things do require a lot of people to
- 3:08believe in it to have real resistance and political power.
- 3:11And I do think I'm grateful that we are taking on this fight now
- 3:16than like four years ago or eight years ago or yeah this
- 3:20having this epoch feels like there's enough understanding and
- 3:26broad kind of awareness of the value and there is a lot of
- 3:29people that are holding it as well.
- 3:31So yeah, we're we're more kind of prepared than ever to I think
- 3:38take on some of these fights, so.
- 3:40Yeah, it's. Kind of beautiful.
- 3:42It's kind of beautiful how Bitcoin grows just ahead of you
- 3:47know what it needs to be in order to to keep ahead of the
- 3:50threats to be large enough to overcome the barriers that pop
- 3:55up. And you know, to your point,
- 3:58like 4-8 years ago, maybe this doesn't work out well.
- 4:03But I, you know, I, I am heartened by how many people in
- 4:07power and particularly in the financial sector, like with the
- 4:12ETFs. And you know, now we have the
- 4:14likes of BlackRock on Team Bitcoin, And that that's that's
- 4:18gonna be enough for us to, you know, stick up for freedom of
- 4:23speech and property rights. I think, I don't know though.
- 4:26I mean I as what's I represent firms in Wall Street et cetera.
- 4:30I don't know if those firms are what we can really depend on.
- 4:36I think ultimately what we depend on is like the the open
- 4:43source developers that are doing ready to code and maintaining
- 4:49code bases for kind of interest beyond just their financial
- 4:53motivations. And a community of people that
- 4:58maintain the network, run nodes, do self custody, use Bitcoin as
- 5:03money in a way that kind of brings sovereignty themselves.
- 5:06And that's like the that foundation and that foundation
- 5:14being possible and continuing to be possible.
- 5:16I think it's a premise and then everything kind of builds on top
- 5:21of that. Yeah.
- 5:23That's and that's that's very powerful.
- 5:26Coming from your position you should, you should introduce
- 5:28yourself after. I'll just say yeah, we just
- 5:33jumped in, but this notion of it's everything, right, Like
- 5:37it's the banks that just came out that are holding you know
- 5:40shares and ETFs and their influence.
- 5:42But then to your point and where it's powerful is because you you
- 5:44have vested interest in the existing market structure that
- 5:48requires you know custodians and all the things that are the
- 5:51opposite of what you described. But in the day, I think what
- 5:54Bitwise very been very interested in being a native
- 5:56firm to the industry and recognizing that there's certain
- 5:59ways that you can map financial products to the protocol that
- 6:02benefit everybody. And that's what we've seen a lot
- 6:05of Wall Street traditional players have been, have gone
- 6:07away from. And there's this other dynamic.
- 6:11And Marty, I want to just drop this because if we want to pick
- 6:14it up on at some point during this episode and I won't name
- 6:16the name. But if you remember a few years
- 6:18ago, we're sitting at coffee with a notable person building
- 6:21this space and he referenced that the way Bitcoin wins is not
- 6:24via like privacy tools. Like people say we can all go
- 6:27and there's not a stance on privacy tools or not and being
- 6:30anonymous, it is by having a movement and people mobilizing
- 6:34around a movement because that's what's powerful.
- 6:35So rather than being secretive and hiding, you're out there and
- 6:38you're basically explaining this is what we're doing, this is
- 6:40what we're building. Similar to how long opened up.
- 6:43I haven't seen that tweet, but Lum is saying come and take it
- 6:44like, look, this is what we're here.
- 6:46Because this maps to everything constitutional, whether it's
- 6:48like a commodity and Bitcoin and all the things free speech and
- 6:52all the things that we know that there's nothing wrong that we're
- 6:54doing foundationally. I think it's that's the story
- 6:57and the narrative that we want to like rally behind versus like
- 7:00some of the other things that are happening.
- 7:02I think they're relevant, but it's getting people and the
- 7:05preservation of wealth and all the things we know that are
- 7:07being built here. That's like how we get a
- 7:09movement around that and preserving people's capital and
- 7:12storing it versus like some of the other I think things that
- 7:14get kind of like lost in the shuffle.
- 7:18Yeah, come and take it. And I agree.
- 7:22I think. I think we need both though.
- 7:23I think we need the tools, the code that enable people to
- 7:27preserve their privacy against an encroaching states that wants
- 7:31more control over individuals. But also we should not be afraid
- 7:37to be unabashed advocates for Bitcoin, which represents
- 7:43freedom and sovereignty in the digital age, particularly as it
- 7:47pertains to money. I mean, we took, I mean last
- 7:50week's episode with Peruvian bull right before.
- 7:54I mean recorded that on Wednesday, Tuesday or Wednesday
- 7:58last week before anything that before everything that happened
- 8:03last week, towards the end of last week, began to happen.
- 8:07And to juxtapose that conversation with how we're
- 8:11starting this conversation today, it's hilarious because it
- 8:13is abundantly clear that the incumbent financial system is
- 8:18woefully overburdened with debt. The central banks of the world
- 8:22and the governments are losing control both of their monetary
- 8:25and fiscal policies. And individuals and in aggregate
- 8:30societies around the world need a solution to a problem created
- 8:34by governments and central banks.
- 8:36And Bitcoin provides that solution.
- 8:40And we shouldn't be afraid to advocate for that solution and
- 8:44advocate for using it in a sovereign fashion.
- 8:48I I think personally, when you add up everything from Samurai,
- 8:56the DOJ response to the tornado cash motion, to dismissal, the
- 9:03FBI warning that came out right after Samurai Roger Burr's
- 9:07arrest cash app under attack, it it seems like moves of
- 9:13desperation. Everything all at once in a
- 9:16basically strong arm attempt to scare the shit out of everybody
- 9:22to to keep them away from building this sovereign
- 9:25technology. And to me that signals it's
- 9:28similar to a wounded animal that is trying to project strength,
- 9:33that it's most vulnerable when it's most vulnerable.
- 9:37And so, well, it is very scary and there are people that are
- 9:42rightfully scared out there with all these actions.
- 9:45I think you should read between the lines and notice that the
- 9:49state, particularly in the United States, is very
- 9:51vulnerable right now. And I think they recognize that
- 9:54Bitcoin is an exit valve that people are going to opt into and
- 9:58they're trying to scare people away from the exits and keep
- 10:01them in the ship to go down with the ship.
- 10:07My heart really goes out to the depths that are mostly just
- 10:11building open source tools that they think are good for people
- 10:13and people's privacy and there's having to make very hard
- 10:17decisions. Phoenix Wallet leaving the US?
- 10:21Heartbreaking, but you can't really blame them.
- 10:25That's the hard part. I think, like, I think it's easy
- 10:28to say that like, oh why don't you take a stance and blah blah
- 10:32blah. But like a lot of them, yeah.
- 10:36If you, if you look at Phoenix particularly, I think they had
- 10:38something like $100 million where they have something like
- 10:40$100 million tied up in lightning channels.
- 10:42So that's a lot of capital at stake.
- 10:46So again, I agree with you, you can't can't fault them.
- 10:51No, they're not the ones that fault.
- 10:53Yeah, it is. It is disheartening to see kind
- 10:58of the scare tactics really bring a lot of scare to these
- 11:02people that are just trying to build tools for individual
- 11:06property. But that's just the world that
- 11:08we live. In it it's a little the timing
- 11:12is a little funny to me Hong, because you and I were at the
- 11:16MIT Bitcoin Expo a couple weeks ago.
- 11:19We we had lunch together and and got to chat then and I was on a
- 11:24a privacy and custody panel and we were talking about the
- 11:27importance of privacy tools and you know and and whether or not
- 11:31they're legal and and obviously the perspective of the panel was
- 11:36that there are some Gray areas but overall privacy is is
- 11:41protected And then Fast forward a couple weeks and and suddenly
- 11:45there's moves against developers who are just trying to produce
- 11:52open source privacy tools for people to you know utilize if
- 11:55they if they you know if they want it's kind of kind of a bit
- 12:02of a shock in terms of the timing right there but but Hong
- 12:06we we we we need to let you introduce yourself here and all
- 12:10the great work that you've been doing.
- 12:12Yeah. Yeah.
- 12:18Oh, amazing. Yeah.
- 12:19Hello everyone. Thanks for inviting me to share
- 12:25about About the Wise and my Journey.
- 12:28I'm the CTO and Co founder of Bitwise, started the firm with
- 12:32my Co founder Hunt Reportsley who was the CEO together seven
- 12:35years ago and we've been on a journey to to be a bridge
- 12:43between Bitcoin and the Tri fi world.
- 12:46So, so making it easier for people to get exposure to
- 12:54Bitcoin from the existing kind of traditional financial system.
- 12:59I know it kind of ties to kind of the stuff that we're talking
- 13:02about. But I think my view and our view
- 13:06has always been that it is still valuable to make it easier for
- 13:09people to have their first taste and first step into Bitcoin.
- 13:14We think of it more and more as like a top of funnel, increasing
- 13:17that top of funnel and making it safer and more efficient and
- 13:20effective. Yeah, we've been on that journey
- 13:23for the past seven years. We've worked on the Bitcoin ETF
- 13:26for the past six years until it was launched this year.
- 13:28So it's an incredible moment for our firm and excited to see it
- 13:32out live. And yeah, my background is in
- 13:36software security. I'm from Korea.
- 13:40I did software security research in the Korean military for a few
- 13:44years and then started the firm with Bitwise with yeah Hunter,
- 13:48my Co founder. We're talking about 60 person
- 13:52firm offices in San Francisco and New York and all based in US
- 13:58Yeah, we're primarily focused in the US market.
- 14:00And and and I have to compliment you guys.
- 14:04You know we talked to a lot of people about Bitcoin and the
- 14:07most common, the most common charts that get brought up are
- 14:11from Bitwise. And you know when when we're
- 14:14talking to to folks and they and they want to you know say hey I
- 14:18saw this cool presentation and look and look at this particular
- 14:22chart, what do you think about this?
- 14:24More often than not it's from Bitwise.
- 14:25So you guys are are doing great work about promoting Bitcoin as
- 14:29an asset class and being at the front of the ETF charge right
- 14:32now. Yeah I think what's really
- 14:35impactful and I didn't know you're gonna come out with that
- 14:37take Hong transparently of like the self custody and and all
- 14:41that dynamic is that you you understand it like you
- 14:43fundamentally grok it in the sense of that has to exist in
- 14:47the in the same way as like I don't think on the other side of
- 14:50that people would say on the hardcore bitcoins I would say
- 14:53well like ETFs or pulled asset vehicles don't need to exist and
- 14:56I foundation I fundamentally don't think that's true.
- 14:58I think they both play off of each other right like you can't
- 15:00have a scalable there's not a scalable way for people to get
- 15:03all 8 billion or however number large cohort 100 million to get
- 15:07exposure in the same way that if if that's the only position I
- 15:12think you guys recognize it probably a lot of the ETF for
- 15:14hiders don't believe that if it was all there that's that's the
- 15:17same set. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 15:19We totally don't have to be done under brush.
- 15:21I think maybe just making that clear at the top of the
- 15:25conversation was helpful is that I totally believe that everyone
- 15:32that is willing and capable of doing self custody should go in
- 15:35that direction. But I believe in increasing the
- 15:38top of the funnel making it easier for the for people to
- 15:42have take the first step to start carrying and paying
- 15:45attention to Bitcoin because they have some financial
- 15:47exposure to it. If if all yeah just because we
- 15:52provide ETF and and they are custodial solutions doesn't mean
- 15:55that like that is what I think is what everyone should be doing
- 15:59or with all of their Bitcoin. The the main goal is like, let's
- 16:08put it this way like we're we're trying to increase ultimately
- 16:12there people go down a rabbit hole and we're trying to get
- 16:16people to enter that rabbit hole and to make it right now the
- 16:22like before ETFs, the world where we're living in, it's like
- 16:24OK, how does someone buy Bitcoin?
- 16:26Well, you have to open up an account at like Cleanbase or
- 16:29etcetera. And then you need to go through
- 16:31all this like onboarding and then you need to usually wire
- 16:33money. And then that's when you can
- 16:36like finally buy $1000 or $10,000 worth of Bitcoin.
- 16:39And if you can make that conversation into, OK, I'm
- 16:43convinced. But then I just open up Schwab
- 16:45or Fidelity and then get $100, a $1000 or $1,000,000 depending on
- 16:50what your wealth level is with the with the two two taps,
- 16:54that's just so much easier And it will it the conversion of
- 16:58like the amount of people that will like, take the first step
- 17:01can be increased tenfold. And I think that's what we're
- 17:04seeing. I think people underestimated
- 17:07like, oh, it's still like it like you can buy the Queen so
- 17:09many different ways. Like why do we need an ATF?
- 17:11Well, we saw that about $12 billion net of GBTC outflows
- 17:16flowed in the first three months.
- 17:18There's like $12 billion that we're like, I'm I'm like
- 17:21thinking about doing it, but it's like a little too hard that
- 17:24I'm not like going to go through all that like opening up
- 17:26accounts and buying money and managing another thing.
- 17:30And we would rather have those dollars engaged and convert over
- 17:35to being in the economic zone of Bitcoin rather than the economic
- 17:39zone of Fiat. And of course it is still not
- 17:43the most ideal thing and if everyone had the Bitcoin in in
- 17:47Bitcoin ETS, then the Bitcoin of the system and network would not
- 17:50work and it would not be any different from gold.
- 17:54But I think there is definitely room and value for the spectrum
- 17:58of of kind of where people can begin and where people can to
- 18:02end up. And and always there's people
- 18:04that are going to be earlier part of their journey and always
- 18:07more dollars that are still stuck in the old system and
- 18:11making it incrementally easier for those dollars to change
- 18:14position is still very valuable. Can you double down on some of
- 18:20that like you mentioned the long road, I think we all have known,
- 18:22you know, Marty has been around for a very long time and and the
- 18:25ETF, what was it, the Winklevi since like 2012 we're trying or
- 18:28whatever of like 20? 14. 2014, like what that road
- 18:33was like and then the kind of surprising things that have
- 18:37happened in the past, call it three to six months, both maybe
- 18:39positive and negative or just anything that stands out on
- 18:42things that since these have been approved, what you guys are
- 18:45been pleasantly surprised at and also maybe even less so.
- 18:51Yeah. So it's it was really like a
- 18:53decade and 10 years of the industry looking to launch of
- 18:56the Queen Chef and the SEC has been denying them year after
- 19:01year. Bitwise is kind of amongst the
- 19:05issuers. Finally ended up launching the
- 19:0620 tips with the lost ones ultimately stepped off.
- 19:10Amongst the issuers that are currently here, we've been
- 19:13working on it for the longest for six years.
- 19:15We had three different filings along those six years and yeah
- 19:20the last one was the one that was approved.
- 19:23I think there is a bit of a meme that like oh like between ETF
- 19:27sub were suddenly launched when BlackRock showed up and the
- 19:31reality of the matter is that it it wasn't like that.
- 19:34It wasn't like oh finally Wall Street is interested in an SEC
- 19:37kind of caved The the vested interest to try to kind of push
- 19:42Bitcoin away from and keep it away from the people are much
- 19:45stronger than kind of what an individual company like
- 19:49BlackRock kind of showing up and and push over the line.
- 19:52The reality of how how things happened was that it the
- 19:55ridiculousness of kind of like the goal posts that kept moving
- 19:59on the SEC side piled up and at some point just Grayscale
- 20:04decided to sue the SEC. And that lawsuit went up to the
- 20:09second second appeals court in DC, and three very respected
- 20:13judges ruled unanimously that. The FEC was on the wrong side
- 20:20here, that they were acting arbitrarily and capriciously and
- 20:23if you read that order, the final order, it's just scathing.
- 20:27But you just couldn't imagine that that's what the 3:00 and if
- 20:32judges of their level were writing about the national
- 20:35financial regulator. But the the BlackRock filing was
- 20:40around in August. But and and the the order came
- 20:44out in October, but reality is, is that around May or so there
- 20:48was an oral hearing that was available to the public.
- 20:52And if you listen to that, it was very clear that the judges
- 20:55were going to rule in favor of grayscale.
- 20:57They were like whenever the SEC lawyer said anything they were
- 20:59like Oh my God, what are you saying?
- 21:02Like you're not not making any sense like how can you have
- 21:04approved the futures products and not prove the spot products
- 21:07in this kind of very arbitrary way.
- 21:09And so it's more more like the BlackRock kind of saw that
- 21:13listened to that and then decided that they wanted to have
- 21:16a piece of the pie. And then but really it's that
- 21:19the judicial system ruled the that the SEC was acting in bad
- 21:23faith here and then they had to approve a product.
- 21:25And I think that lesson is a little bit timely in the current
- 21:28moment because I think even I, when I started bit wise, I think
- 21:35I had a certain kind of rosy view of how the world worked and
- 21:39how regulation worked and how the political system worked and
- 21:42that you just keep working in in good faith.
- 21:47We did so much research like, like we had probably over over
- 21:5230 meetings with the SEC over those six years and hundreds of
- 21:57pages of research that we published publicly and more
- 22:00privately and just did everything that we were asked to
- 22:04do. And ultimately that had no
- 22:06bearing on this outcome. And I think that's just a very
- 22:10sobering reality of how the world works and that sometimes
- 22:16you just have to go again. It's a really sad reality, but
- 22:21sometimes you have to go against the national financial regulator
- 22:24in the United States to to get to what is fair.
- 22:28Not even asking for something that is completely favour us for
- 22:32us, but just to get fair treatment for Bitcoin as as
- 22:36every other asset. And yeah, so that was kind of
- 22:39the journey and I think probably the biggest kind of a lesson
- 22:44that I took away from from from going through that journey.
- 22:47We can talk more about the launch, but yeah.
- 22:53Yeah, very interesting. When when you talk about the
- 22:56futures product that the the SEC did approve that that was back
- 23:00in, was that, was that 2017? Yeah, so that was right at the
- 23:05top in 2017 there there was some speculation.
- 23:08There's always been some speculation since then that the
- 23:12existence of the futures product potentially gave a vehicle for
- 23:17large interest to short. What's your perspective on that
- 23:20because you would be closer to that information.
- 23:22Yeah, that's CME futures. Yeah.
- 23:25Just to clarify. Yeah.
- 23:27Mixing 2 things up. Yeah, CME futures, which is the
- 23:30kind of regulated futures contracts, started trading in
- 23:332017, you're right. But the specific thing that the
- 23:37court was pointing out that the SEC had no kind of consistency
- 23:41over is that I think in 2020 or so they approved, well 2021,
- 23:45they approved a ETF based on the futures products.
- 23:49So the holdings of the Bitcoin ETF, for example.
- 23:52BITO is the largest product by pro shares, holds the futures
- 23:56contracts as the underlying and it is an ETF that is regulated
- 24:00and trades on stock exchanges and the SEC approved and the SEC
- 24:05was making arguments around, oh, we can't approve a spot between
- 24:09ETF because the markets can be manipulated etcetera, etcetera.
- 24:12And the court's opinion was OK, markets might be manipulated
- 24:16etcetera, etcetera. But if that's the case, then why
- 24:19were you OK with the futures product?
- 24:21And you're saying that spot product is not not OK And
- 24:24there's just like a number of these things that are kind of
- 24:28inconsistent. And that's kind of, yeah, yeah,
- 24:32the main thing that ultimately was like so obviously not
- 24:36consistent that the court ruled against the FC CS disapproval of
- 24:39small products. And I guess I mean maybe this is
- 24:42impossible question for you to answer, but do you think that
- 24:45that was self-serving that that there was some interest in
- 24:49having a futures product in order to potentially stymie
- 24:53Bitcoin's growth by being able to to short more effectively?
- 24:57Or do you think that was just like a random thing where for
- 25:00whatever reason they they justified futures and they
- 25:03couldn't come around to accept the spot?
- 25:07No, I I I think what you need to kind of like when when thinking
- 25:10about kind of regulators etcetera, I think we like the
- 25:13reality is that the people in the leadership positions of
- 25:17those those agencies do change and administrations do change
- 25:21and the BITOO and also even within just one time period of
- 25:32like let's say Genzer's time, the beginning of Genzer's time
- 25:36and now is a very different climate like pre FTX and post
- 25:41FTX the the kind of the way that the Democratic Party engages
- 25:48with Bitcoin has changed a lot. So I think a product that is
- 25:52futures based that most people know, it's not going to have as
- 25:56much of kind of like the blockbuster success that spot
- 25:59products have. I think it was less threatening
- 26:02or like less of a problem to like, approve that.
- 26:05And also the political climate was very different.
- 26:08And then things change and then goal posts change and priorities
- 26:12change. So the reality, Yeah, yeah, it
- 26:15kind of exposes that like if the decisions aren't really made on
- 26:20a consistent kind of rule based on law, but rather is made more
- 26:25on kind of where the political direction is leaning, then it's
- 26:29very hard for it to be consistent.
- 26:31And from the court's perspective, looking at that is
- 26:33very frustrating. So I think that's why we're,
- 26:36we're having a lot of success in the judicial system because the
- 26:39court is looking for consistency and a kind of agency actions
- 26:45that move in based on the political wind.
- 26:48It's very hard to be consistent. Yep.
- 26:52And maybe switching gears back to the approval would be very
- 26:56curious like on your side what you guys have seen from because
- 27:01there's a lot of different narratives around it's retail,
- 27:04it's pent up institutional adoption, You know the RA's are
- 27:07coming like what you guys have seen since then.
- 27:09And then because you've been out in the market so long telling
- 27:13the story of Bitcoin, how is the narrative changed around like
- 27:19lack of interest, you know, FUD that comes up and is it still
- 27:22consistently the same, it's just every it's, you know, different
- 27:25formats of it or is or they have they gotten past certain things
- 27:28and is it new stuff, like curious how the all those
- 27:31conversations are tying together now?
- 27:33Yeah, a lot of good questions just to so post launch we we're
- 27:39now about three to four months. In the first month there was
- 27:45immediately a fair amount of success where there was about 9
- 27:51billion of inflows into the new products and but there was a lot
- 27:55leaving GBTC. So about 3 billion was net new
- 27:59and people and everyone kind of recognized that as successful.
- 28:02But ultimately that people thought that was kind of the end
- 28:04of like, OK, we had some kind of like big latent demand and then
- 28:08it kind of applied it down. But then I think month two and
- 28:11three was really surprising for people where the GBTC outflows
- 28:16roughly started to catch a plateau, but then the inflows
- 28:18into the new products continued in full force.
- 28:22And then we saw another $10 billion of net new dollars even
- 28:26despite the outflows come into these products.
- 28:29And the most recent months, I I think end of April, things have
- 28:36quieted down a fair amount and now we're kind of at a bit of a
- 28:38steady state. And so it's really like in some
- 28:42ways to think about the Bitcoin ETS moment.
- 28:44I like, I think we otherwise often talk about it as like an
- 28:47IPO moment. I think people think of it.
- 28:50There's a tendency to think about it as like an event like,
- 28:52oh, it happened and went like in any type of market event.
- 28:56But the reality that is that it is more like a state change.
- 29:00It's more like a company going public where like before the IPO
- 29:03it's all private market liquidity.
- 29:05And then after the IPO you have access to public market
- 29:08liquidity always. And I think that is closer to
- 29:13the ETF moment for Bitcoin. So that Bitcoin now has access
- 29:17to public market kind of liquidity and public investors
- 29:22being able to access it in the same way that they access any
- 29:24other assets. And that capability can live
- 29:27with us forever. And also I think that's really
- 29:32exciting as like someone who wants for bitcoiners because
- 29:38always in kind of market mania whenever that is in 2017 or 2021
- 29:44etcetera, always The thing is people just want to buy Bitcoin,
- 29:48but their way to access it, the the avenues become bottlenecked
- 29:53and then things start to break like GBTC was an example of
- 29:56that. It had so high premiums that
- 29:58like people started creating hedge funds to trade that and
- 30:01then those hedge funds blew up and then we have three AO
- 30:03Capital, we have Luna and then all the that problem in our
- 30:06hands. FTX is another example.
- 30:09I think people just want to buy Bitcoin but then it's not simple
- 30:13and straightforward. So then people set up scam
- 30:16operations to take that those dollars and then we had a
- 30:21problem that we had. So what's really exciting about
- 30:24the between ETF one and from my perspective is that forever what
- 30:27we have now is that we don't have any trouble kind of the net
- 30:30new dollars coming into the space that that just simply want
- 30:33to buy Bitcoin. Schwab infidelity is not going
- 30:37to have trouble taking in $10 billion over a few months.
- 30:41Even if that was $100 billion that's not a problem.
- 30:45And so and and and what we've seen is that we've like since
- 30:48then markets moved up about 50% in prices and we're here like no
- 30:53fuss, no crazy scams popping up, no things breaking down.
- 30:59And I think that's kind of one exciting aspect of the Bitcoin
- 31:03at the moment that I think about.
- 31:05You asked about who's buying. I think largely a lot at the
- 31:09beginning was self-directed retail investors.
- 31:12And even though those that cohort has had ways to access to
- 31:17space for a long time, ultimately people still do have
- 31:20retirement accounts, 401 KS or people that still had some more
- 31:24money in the brokerage account and hadn't kind of made the move
- 31:28to move it over to Coinbase or so.
- 31:31And and and those dollars kind of easily moving over to the
- 31:34coin ETFSI think was a large part of what the $12 billion
- 31:38were. Another category is our actually
- 31:42kind of main client base is actually wealth managers like
- 31:48financial advisors and financial advisors.
- 31:53Market breaks off in many different ways, but there's kind
- 31:56of an independent financial advisors they're called RI as
- 32:00that don't aren't tied to any kind of platform or Home Office
- 32:03and they can just make decisions by themselves about which
- 32:05products to buy. Those Rias have been moving into
- 32:08Bitcoin ETFs pretty, pretty quickly And and then the kind of
- 32:15the where a lot of the other dollars is, is in kind of the
- 32:19wire houses like Morgan Stanley or or UBS or Wells Fargo
- 32:22etcetera or these kind of larger banks broken.
- 32:26The other platforms, those platforms are still very much in
- 32:29due diligence. We've had a few kind of really
- 32:33the earliest movers make some moves there after like two or
- 32:36three months of due diligence and those are finally starting
- 32:39to land. But really that's those channels
- 32:43still have not mostly been live yet.
- 32:46So it's kind of crazy to think about from kind of the Bitcoiner
- 32:49perspective when we're on Twitter and like the Bitcoin ETF
- 32:52is so old news. But for the largest kind of
- 32:56wealth management platforms, they usually do diligence with
- 33:00products for like 6 to 12 months and they're like sprinting
- 33:02towards it and like putting Bitcoin ETS in private queue.
- 33:05But still largely have not gone through that yet.
- 33:08So we're having kind of the first conversations with that
- 33:13those worlds just now and just to kind of put into perspective
- 33:18like why that is important, I think we, we we in the in the US
- 33:24and kind of in the investable dollars world let's say kind of
- 33:29self-directed individuals managed about four to $5
- 33:32trillion and that's a lot of money and that's but still it's
- 33:36not the largest pool of money and that's mostly the money
- 33:38that's been engaging with Bitcoin so far.
- 33:42Another four or five times larger than that, about 20
- 33:45trillion or so is ultimately managed wealth.
- 33:49So people that ultimately delegate the wealth kind of
- 33:52investment decisions to financial advisors and that pool
- 33:56ultimately like has largely been unable to access Bitcoin because
- 34:01if if it's hard for like individuals to access or like
- 34:05open up accounts and do all these things, if you have like
- 34:0730 or 50 clients, you're not opening up coin based accounts
- 34:10for each of them. So.
- 34:12So then that has been a large kind of roadblock for that
- 34:15audience and kind of the ECS makes it very easy to fit into
- 34:20the work flows. So yeah, anyways, that that was
- 34:25kind of trying to paint, paint a picture a bit about how how we
- 34:29think about what what's kind of like the meaningful state change
- 34:32here, the audiences that have taken the first step, but kind
- 34:36of the exciting road ahead on the kind of larger pools of
- 34:40dollars that are opening up to Bitcoin trying to access through
- 34:46these products. Thanks for tuning in.
- 34:48If you're interested in exploring any of these topics
- 34:51further, or want to learn more about how we can help you secure
- 34:54a new or existing Bitcoin allocation, get in touch with
- 34:57our team at on rampbitcoin.com. We look forward to supporting
- 35:01you on your Bitcoin journey. That was awesome.
- 35:05I love how you characterize it as a state change.
- 35:09I think on this show we've we've talked about how it's kind of
- 35:12before ETFs and after ETFs. It's going to be a major
- 35:15demarcation in the life of Bitcoin.
- 35:18From my point of view, that was mostly because of the narrative
- 35:21in Tradify and in the broader society about Bitcoin.
- 35:25Because we've lived for 15 years in a world where Bitcoin,
- 35:28whenever it's talked about in Tradify or in the media has
- 35:32been, you know, negative. It's it's, it's always been
- 35:36about how it's, you know, illicit drug money on the
- 35:39Internet and what not. And then now we live in a world
- 35:42where Wall Street is incentivized to promote Bitcoin
- 35:47ETFs and talk about how it makes sense for anybody's portfolio.
- 35:51And you know, that has a cumulative effect that has a
- 35:53societal level effect over time as the Overton window about
- 35:59Bitcoin shifts from this is, you know, risky drug money on the
- 36:04Internet to oh, this makes this is digital gold and everyone
- 36:08should own it And you know that that before ETF after ETF is
- 36:11that state change. I think that's an even better
- 36:13metaphor for yes. One thing I want to be clear
- 36:18though is that like state change on liquidity or like financial
- 36:21access is is what I'm what I'm putting.
- 36:24Ultimately the value of Bitcoin isn't coming from the ease of
- 36:29financial access. I think the value of Bitcoin has
- 36:32always been there as a mutual sovereign kind of non government
- 36:36money that is that is global and interoperable and and that has
- 36:41always been the case. But it was, it was always kind
- 36:46of up against a a, a kind of a tougher challenge to to grow as
- 36:51kind of its economic bandwidth because it had, it was kind of
- 36:56unfairly limited to private market liquidity.
- 37:00And then and then now we're just figuring out like, oh, now it
- 37:03just is able to get out of that discrimination and be on evil
- 37:09even footing with gold, even footing with real estate.
- 37:12Like you've been able to buy Reit's real estate in in ETFs
- 37:15forever. You can buy out gold and ETS
- 37:18forever. Like it's just on an even
- 37:20playing field now and in public market liquidity.
- 37:23And that is exciting. But yeah, also just wanted to
- 37:26clarify. Yeah, yeah.
- 37:29The public market liquidity part is, is, is a is a such an
- 37:32important part of of understanding why the ETFs are
- 37:35huge. The the other thing I wanted to
- 37:36dig in there though is like it. It has been interesting trying
- 37:41to understand the behavior of how customers are engaging with
- 37:46the ETFs. Because big question for me was
- 37:50has been will the ETFs exhibit the same kind of reflexivity of
- 37:55demand that we have seen with Bitcoin in general in the past
- 38:01on Coinbase or whatever crypto exchanges.
- 38:04And you know, very, very interesting that you know
- 38:08obviously we saw the GBTC outflows and then a really good
- 38:12month or so for all of the ETFs with a ton of inflows.
- 38:16And then in the last month where the price has been stuck at
- 38:19prior all time high around you know high 60s.
- 38:25Now for the last week or so, we've had like very little
- 38:29inflows, 0 net flows in Black rocks product in, in particular
- 38:33for the last four days I think. And so that sort of to me says
- 38:38that we are seeing the classic reflexivity of like when the
- 38:41price is going up, there's more demand and when the price is not
- 38:45going up, there's less demand, Which I, you know, I I think
- 38:50it's been a philosophical question of like what type of
- 38:52demand will flow into the ETFs? Is it is it baby boomers who
- 38:56have, who are sitting on a bunch of wealth and then they keep
- 38:58hearing about Bitcoin going up and they tell their wealth
- 39:00manager, you know what, it's time let's buy some Bitcoin?
- 39:03Or is it the the RI as who are saying we're going to, we're
- 39:08going to slowly, methodically scale into Bitcoin for you?
- 39:12And that's kind of independent of whatever's going on recently
- 39:15with the price of Bitcoin. Any any thoughts there?
- 39:21Yes, definitely I I I think it's a blend of all the above where
- 39:24in some cases it's going to be a client saying that I just want
- 39:26exposure to Bitcoin. Like I've been convinced like my
- 39:28friend has been talking to me about this and I want to hold
- 39:30this thing. In some cases we're we're
- 39:33starting to see real kind of model portfolio allocations.
- 39:36So given kind of advisory firm can have a new view about the
- 39:41macro and say that that Bitcoin deserves to exist in model
- 39:44portfolios 2 percent 5% etcetera and they just have discretion
- 39:49over their their clients assets and they move in and that kind
- 39:52of it's just kind of a a consistent allocation.
- 39:57But then another reality is that ETS are also trading vehicles
- 40:00for like hedge funds and so. So if a if a existing kind of
- 40:03track five hedge funds that is like I wasn't really going to do
- 40:08much here because I like I don't want to set up another
- 40:10infrastructure to trade Bitcoin and open up these accounts if
- 40:13these like shady crypto exchanges and then now they have
- 40:16the asset. Readily available in the
- 40:18existing infrastructure and then as they trade everything else,
- 40:21as they trade gold, real estate, oil, they can just trade Bitcoin
- 40:26and and then so those types of flows and activity is merging
- 40:31into it as well. The reality that like the ETF is
- 40:33like a very kind of neutral vehicle that kind of all sorts
- 40:39of people can, can, can trade in and kind of move in and out
- 40:44from. So we'll see a lot of different
- 40:46behavior that kind of is, is ultimately mixed into the final
- 40:49inflows and outflows that show up.
- 40:51But but as a blend, I would say there's a good chance ultimately
- 40:56the the kind of advisory channel, the financial advisors
- 40:59or even individuals like mostly they're buying and a lot of
- 41:02people are buying them like the retirement accounts etcetera.
- 41:04These are sticky dollars. So I I I do think that that on
- 41:08balance it would be less reflexive and more kind of
- 41:11steady because it's just more of a portfolio allocation than like
- 41:17oh shit like my friend told me about this and like I have this
- 41:20app now and this app sent me an like of alerts that says prices
- 41:23going up let me buy. So more people it.
- 41:26It's kind of a more steady kind of portfolio allocation type of
- 41:31of dollars net than I think the the existing kind of retail
- 41:37crypto exchanges. I mean another aspect that is
- 41:39nice is that it's also yeah not part of that kind of like there
- 41:44is a, there is a way in which retail crypto exchanges are a
- 41:47little bit more casino like like they show you price charts like
- 41:50they they send you notifications like it's it's it's not just
- 41:53Bitcoin like they see all these like coins there and then kind
- 41:55of feel like we need to something else is going up and
- 41:57like you should buy that etcetera and none of that exists
- 42:03in the Bitcoin ETF world or like a brokerage like the you you can
- 42:06decide whether to buy it or not but it's kind of, it's a little
- 42:10bit more kind of like calm world in a way.
- 42:15So I think, I think that is also a plus.
- 42:17That's the thing that, that's the thing that was like kind of
- 42:20naive personally. And I think even just us being
- 42:22native of the industry, it's like we really wanted Bitcoin.
- 42:25So we figured out how to go buy it and it wasn't that hard.
- 42:27You had to sell some assets or move them over to a a Coinbase
- 42:30or whatever the app is and figure out how to buy and then
- 42:32move it to self custody. That progression for something
- 42:34that they may want a little position in.
- 42:36So they just naturally are like ask her, I don't want it.
- 42:41You have to really want it in a similar way.
- 42:43Like I think about it as like a Bovada or like some gambling
- 42:46website. You have to really want to go
- 42:47and find out how to gamble online to make it make sense.
- 42:52And most people just aren't there.
- 42:53They're not going to like go that they're going to D jet into
- 42:55gambling or go and try to find how to buy Bitcoin versus if
- 42:58it's in a brokerage account and you can click a button.
- 43:00It's a natural like first order and you touched on like change
- 43:05of state. It's like when you change
- 43:07states, you change planets, you have to acclimate to the new
- 43:10environment before you kind of go and and start to like size
- 43:13in. So it makes complete sense that
- 43:14we kind of like have this state change.
- 43:16You have a having you see like what's you know currently
- 43:18happening on the like more you know, geopolitical government
- 43:21side of things. So you're going to have this
- 43:23volatility, but over time that state will consistently go up
- 43:26and to the right with larger pools coming in.
- 43:29Another thing I'll. Just add is that ETF is
- 43:31ultimately again like not the thing that is generating value
- 43:35here or or or or like. It is not what makes the asset
- 43:38valuable. So it's flows will come in when
- 43:44more people believe Bitcoin is valuable and flows will go out
- 43:47when when when more people believe that it is not.
- 43:51And there's a natural reflexivity to people's beliefs
- 43:55because like when the price is going up, more people are tended
- 43:58into believing it. But ETS is not the thing that
- 44:00convinces some someone they're like, oh, Bitcoin is now
- 44:03valuable. So I think we will just see kind
- 44:07of inflows and outflows ebb with the whole market and ETS is what
- 44:12makes it easier for people to dabble and kind of move in and
- 44:16out in in some ways. But, but yes, it will just kind
- 44:19of be part of the whole reflectivity that that that
- 44:21already exists. And just one more thing to that
- 44:26that I would say is to kind of just like highlight that a
- 44:27little bit is that I think the the even the state change, I
- 44:32think there's there's a sense that we have kind of like oh,
- 44:34because the state change has been made like everyone that
- 44:37kind of would allocate as a result of that would have
- 44:39already done so or not. But as I said, like the large
- 44:42platforms still very much early due to diligence and like gold
- 44:48ETF I think is a good example. GLG launched as the first gold
- 44:53US ETF in 2004 and had like a blockbuster success in the first
- 44:57week brought in about like a billion or so in inflows in the
- 45:02first three days. And that was like more than any
- 45:04other ETF in the past and it broke all records.
- 45:07And then in the next kind of three months or so, it brought
- 45:11in maybe another 300 million. So like it kind of looked like,
- 45:13OK, we brought in a million at at the beginning and the next
- 45:16three months brought in like another 300 million or so.
- 45:18And then like, OK, now this thing is over.
- 45:22The reality is that for the next 8 years, it had positive inflows
- 45:26that were mostly growing. So the the next year it had like
- 45:293 billion inflows and next year it had like 5 billion inflows
- 45:32and then it got to 10 and then it got to like 15 and it just
- 45:35like kept going for another eight years until it had its
- 45:38first outflow year. So I think when when a thing
- 45:41goes through a state change as kind of like accessing public
- 45:45market liquidity, not everyone decides and not everyone makes
- 45:49moves immediately. It just is a trickle to kind of
- 45:52saturate that market. Like oh, the thing becomes from
- 45:55going from not possible to possible then kind of saturating
- 45:58that whole opportunity in the gold case took about a decade
- 46:02and Bitcoin usually things move faster, but it's still going to
- 46:06take years. So I think to see the full
- 46:08extent of like the net new dollars that will flow into
- 46:12this, this asset class as a result of public market
- 46:14liquidity, I think we're very early in the innings and each
- 46:18cohort will like have a different moment in which they
- 46:21they take the big step or they might kind of wait until there's
- 46:24like another mania to to decide to like prioritize this thing.
- 46:28But but it's just going to be a long road ahead and I think
- 46:32that's a good thing. Yeah, Yeah.
- 46:36It's it's it's an encouraging thing that even with kind of a
- 46:41small amount of engagement is already kind of the has brought
- 46:45in a meaningful amount of kind of economic bandwidth to the
- 46:49network and that we still have a large pool of dollars that we
- 46:52haven't touched totally it. It's really it's it's so
- 46:55beautiful how it's playing out. And like if you can really just
- 46:59see how this continues through the combination of the the
- 47:04cumulative effect of the ETFs being out there and Wall Street
- 47:09talking positively about Bitcoin and it becoming part of society.
- 47:13At the same time that the halvings keep occurring,
- 47:16increasing scarcity keeps causing the price to drift
- 47:19upwards post halving in the 1212 to 18 months post halving
- 47:23triggering the bull market and enforcing the next cohort.
- 47:26The next slice of the bull of the the bell cover of technology
- 47:31adopters to pay attention to finally dip a toe.
- 47:36And they probably dip a toe with the ETF.
- 47:38And then maybe they move on to self custody as they get further
- 47:41down the rabbit hole and learn more about this asset.
- 47:44And just those two trends playing out of of increasing
- 47:49access to the global pools of capital that are sitting in
- 47:55analog assets to date. You know, whether that's
- 47:57equities, bonds, real estate or whatever.
- 48:02ETFs are a. Big part of that story.
- 48:05Increasing access to that world of value at the same time that
- 48:09bitcoins in endogenous mechanics will keep driving the price
- 48:13higher through increasing scarcity and forcing the next
- 48:18slice to pay attention and make that switch themselves, yes.
- 48:24Given that we're kind of all saying positive things about
- 48:27ETFs, I I think it's also worth kind of noting the negatives and
- 48:32one of the one of the main product flaws at the moment is,
- 48:35is the fact that you can't withdraw in clients, yeah.
- 48:40And. That's something that I'm really
- 48:44hopeful that we can improve upon soon.
- 48:48Because if not, then the games will lead them to be people to
- 48:54be stuck. They might learn more, they
- 48:56might kind of want to do self custody, but then being stuck in
- 48:59the ETF product, the vehicle because of the vehicle structure
- 49:03would be much worse than exchanges.
- 49:06And so yes, the only aspect that the FCC has made kind of
- 49:13incredibly arbitrary decisions on, they've said in kind
- 49:18creations and redemptions and all these types of things are
- 49:21common and and available in all of the commodity ETFs, like in
- 49:24gold, you can do that. There are gold ETFs where if you
- 49:27say that you want to withdraw in the actual gold coins and they
- 49:30will send those gold coins to your door.
- 49:33So it's not that inclined redemption should not be
- 49:36possible or they're they should be illegal or it's impossible to
- 49:39for the ETF structure to support those things.
- 49:41But just the SEC at the moment has made a kind of an arbitrary
- 49:45line saying that inclined redemptions in in kind of spot
- 49:50Bitcoin form should not be allowed and that it has to go
- 49:52through cash. And that's kind of kind of if
- 49:57you put it into perspective of the whole thing of like this all
- 50:01the actions that are being taken against self custody and kind of
- 50:05kind of the software and peer-to-peer transactions.
- 50:10Then it kind of makes sense that that is position that the
- 50:12government is taking. But it But it is an arbitrary
- 50:15position and we need to fight for it.
- 50:17What what about the other side? We.
- 50:19We were missed you, you were gracious enough to bring out
- 50:21some of the the negatives. So the other one would be
- 50:24custody and and 90% of the ETFs being with a single custodian.
- 50:27How do you guys think about that in like long term?
- 50:30Yeah. That the total aspect is
- 50:36definitely a problem but but but I I think that like I can go at
- 50:40it closer to we we still think that custodial services are have
- 50:45kind of a role to play in the onboarding step Like if
- 50:48somebody's buying like Bitcoin on river and they're buying like
- 50:52$50.00 or $100 like does it really make sense that we force
- 50:56them to like buy a buy a hardware wallet and like go
- 50:59through cold storage all these things like not really.
- 51:03I think there is a step kind of even in in like the the like
- 51:09financial transactional sense. Like I think we we want to get
- 51:13to a world where everyone is running like lightning nodes and
- 51:15such in in a self solving way. But that requires a lot of of
- 51:20upfront investment to open up channels and and and pay the
- 51:24unchanged fees for that. And I think that like the
- 51:26direction that mutiny wallet for example is going makes a lot of
- 51:28sense to me in the sense that in in the beginning you can use E
- 51:32cash through like like vetiments, federations and such.
- 51:35And if you're just like putting in $100 balance to send like
- 51:39some some few dollars to your friends or whatever for payments
- 51:43then that's kind of fine like like that.
- 51:46But when you are you, you are actually saving up and you have
- 51:49more and then like you're you're actually just in a Bitcoin
- 51:52economy and you're paying rent through it etcetera etcetera and
- 51:55you're really the the the volume and your your balance grows then
- 51:58definitely you should you should consider if the kind of
- 52:01custodial convenience and trust assumptions is what you want to
- 52:06live in. But but there there is kind of a
- 52:09reality of that custodial experience at the beginning of
- 52:13the funnel enabling kind of the financial transaction cost to be
- 52:17lower to make it easier for someone to take that first step
- 52:19of $100 or $1000 without without incurring all the costs of being
- 52:25fully custodial, self custodial. And I think I think about ETS in
- 52:28a very similar way. Like, is there a value in being
- 52:31a river or a Coinbase or a kind of that, that type of custodial
- 52:36first step that you can, you can dabble into?
- 52:39Yeah. And I think ETFs are the
- 52:41ultimate, easiest first step that you can make at someone's
- 52:45take. You don't have to open up
- 52:45accounts. You don't have to wire money.
- 52:47It's just already there where all of your rest of your money
- 52:49is. You don't have to worry about
- 52:52any kind of new system that you need to learn besides just
- 52:56building some conviction about Bitcoin.
- 52:58And then you can take the first step and then and then ideally
- 53:02if that balance grows like you you you learn more, you buy
- 53:04more, you learn more, you buy more and the price goes up And
- 53:07at some point you're sitting on an an amount of Bitcoin that
- 53:10you're like why like I I have these new different beliefs and
- 53:14I have so much of my net worth in this thing like and and they
- 53:17can take it off of the of the ETF and kind of inclined to draw
- 53:21away. Then I think it has now just
- 53:24kind of blended into the same kind of on ramp like on ramp and
- 53:28off ramp that we we kind of think of as the existing
- 53:30custodial services and they do have a role in kind of the
- 53:34journey that the people play currently.
- 53:36Unfortunately they can be stopped with capital gains and
- 53:39that is definitely an aspect that I think is, is problematic
- 53:43and we should try to improve upon.
- 53:44But I don't necessarily think that the existence of custodial
- 53:48kind of first steps is bad. Stepping stones, Yeah and and
- 53:56and Hong. So we just.
- 54:00We've seen. The now the Hong Kong ETFs being
- 54:04launched and correct me if I'm wrong, but they are going, they
- 54:07do allow in kind redemption and it seems like that is a
- 54:12differentiator, a competitive edge perhaps that that Hong Kong
- 54:17ETFs would have over AUS based ETFs in in the global capital
- 54:21landscape. Do you think that that will
- 54:23require a a response from the US?
- 54:27How do you see that playing out? Not not, not really.
- 54:31It's. Just the reality is that the
- 54:32financial markets US is king. US is not not self-conscious or
- 54:37insecure about any other market. It's just the order of magnitude
- 54:41larger than anything else. Hong Kong Europe you can play to
- 54:46any market and it just doesn't compare And the SEC and the and
- 54:49the financial regulators in the US don't think that they take
- 54:54cues from anyone else like every other financial regulator does.
- 54:58Like I'm from Korea. The Korean financial regulators
- 55:00are always looking at U.S. financial regulators and looking
- 55:02at oh like what are they doing? Like what are they doing on all
- 55:04these different things. And like I would guess that
- 55:06there's a a Bitcoin ETF in Korea.
- 55:09It's more likely now because we have one in the US but the US
- 55:13financial regulators do not think that they have peers and
- 55:17and rather that that they just make their own minds.
- 55:19And the whole world has had Bitcoin spot ETF for many, many
- 55:23years and that had no, no bearing on whether the ACC
- 55:27thought it that it was justified or not or or or worthy or not.
- 55:31And they ultimately kept rejecting until they were forced
- 55:35to approve fund by the court. So like just the like it's just
- 55:39not comparable and it doesn't really have much of an effect on
- 55:42what the ACC think. Yeah, it's a fight that's going
- 55:45to have to be won. Through different means rather
- 55:48than natural competitive forces, Yeah, I mean the.
- 55:53The, the, the, the reality. Is that we we we think that the
- 55:55US has all these problems and they it does and it's like
- 55:57struggling and and it is but the reality is that it's it's still
- 56:04doing so much better than than anywhere else.
- 56:07Like the US financial markets are stronger than any other
- 56:10market and that trend has actually been in the upward
- 56:13direction than in the downward direction.
- 56:15So with all the problems that it has, it still is so dominant
- 56:18that it's not really feeling any competitive pressure like, oh,
- 56:22we should change our regulatory approach because we're under
- 56:26this competitive pressure must be nice to be king.
- 56:33Yeah, yeah. I guess that's the question is.
- 56:37The way to the monetary and fiscal malfeasance and the
- 56:42overall hubris at some point lead to a collapse.
- 56:47I mean they're they're making it very hard.
- 56:50ET FS had the struggle. Obviously we had the attacks in
- 56:52the last week, but Bitcoin is an idea.
- 56:56As time has come, people will get it.
- 56:57There will be bumps in the road. There will be hurdles to
- 57:00overcome. A bit wise, this that very well
- 57:04working at this for for more than six years and it's exciting
- 57:09time to be live. I'm very happy to be here right
- 57:11now, even though it's chaotic, excited to be here.
- 57:15One thing that I just like highlight about in in in the
- 57:19kind of broader conversation that we're having, I think it's
- 57:23so important to support our open source devs.
- 57:26And I think it in in some ways that it's kind of crazy to me
- 57:30that that is a controversial thing sometimes these days it
- 57:33feels but like we've been working on this thing for six
- 57:42years and like we've been gas lit so many times.
- 57:45So Tim, I didn't really believe it when I when everyone well it
- 57:49was like looking like it was going to get approved and I had
- 57:51a really hard time believing it. But then ultimately when it was
- 57:55like becoming sure that it's happening.
- 57:56I think one of the first things that I gravitated towards trying
- 58:00to make sure that we can built into the product of our ETF was
- 58:06that it would have a profit sharing with the the devs.
- 58:11And I think that's that kind of like tragedy of the Commons
- 58:16where a lot of people hold Bitcoin but then nobody feels
- 58:18that they are kind of they should pick up the bill in in
- 58:23funding the development and maintenance and security of the
- 58:25work that is that's just necessary for the networking
- 58:28asset to exist. Is is, is a thing.
- 58:32And in in some ways it's a thing that an ETF like structure can
- 58:35actually be a bit helpful in because just the way that it
- 58:39exists, it pulls a lot of the Bitcoin together and we take
- 58:44fees, so we already take fees, so, so then sharing those fees
- 58:49to a direction that helps everyone's Bitcoin become more
- 58:54secure and resilient is just good for everyone, including
- 58:57ourselves. And so, yeah, we decided to
- 59:02share 10% of our profits to to devs and put a fair amount of
- 59:07thought into it. I I think I understand all the
- 59:11concerns that people have, but so we decided to do it through
- 59:17organizations, nonprofit organizations that already do
- 59:19that rather than us making arbitrary decisions about who
- 59:22which dev to donate to. We chose three open, Sacks, HRF,
- 59:27and Brink rather than one. Because one, if we the product
- 59:31grows for a lot then that can also kind of create biases and
- 59:36they're all no strings attached to donations.
- 59:38And that was stated from the beginning in the press release
- 59:40and has been consistent in, in, in with with all the orbs.
- 59:44And so that I think was was something that we took very
- 59:50seriously and put a fair amount of time into leading up to the
- 59:53launch in in arranging with all those organizations.
- 59:57And yeah, I I believe very strongly that.
- 1:00:02It's important and it's a differentiator for our product I
- 1:00:04think as well. So if if people have been
- 1:00:06meaning to want to support devs and they just kind of like
- 1:00:10haven't don't have an easy or didn't didn't act on it, and
- 1:00:14they have some between ETF and their 401K or something or their
- 1:00:18or their retirement accounts, then I think our ETF, unlike the
- 1:00:23other top three by Black and Fidelity and aren't are
- 1:00:26supporting devs. So I'd love people to consider
- 1:00:29that feature as well. Yeah, Justin, we're on the.
- 1:00:32We're on the hook. Matt's been pinging us about.
- 1:00:34You know we need to support Open Sats, but we'll have to pick one
- 1:00:37because Stan Druckenmiller isn't backing us.
- 1:00:39So we we we have to pick one out of three.
- 1:00:40We can't do we can't do all three hung the to start.
- 1:00:46But. All jokes aside.
- 1:00:48Insanely to your point, it's crazy.
- 1:00:50You have to bring it up simply because if the tools don't
- 1:00:53exist, this thing doesn't work. Found like full stop and Marty
- 1:00:58alluded to you when wrapping up is that things are very
- 1:01:01positive. We have to look at what they're
- 1:01:02doing, not what they're saying. And So what they're doing here
- 1:01:05or what's been seen is the ETFs exist, banks are stepping in,
- 1:01:09central banks are stepping in. And that if you mirror this, I
- 1:01:13like the analogies to like it's obviously a different order of
- 1:01:16magnitude, but similar with piracy and Torrentine in like
- 1:01:20the late 90s and early 2000s and that the infrastructure and the
- 1:01:23technology is there, You cannot stop it now.
- 1:01:25You have to develop the tools around it and map it to the
- 1:01:28world. And now it's here, it's never
- 1:01:29leaving and it's certain parties that are doing things, whether
- 1:01:32it's malicious. And we can debate if it's
- 1:01:34malicious and how you tout it and how you get licensed.
- 1:01:36Like we still have to exist in the rule of law.
- 1:01:37But at the end state this isn't going anywhere.
- 1:01:40These things exist. There's capital markets forming,
- 1:01:42there's revenue being derived from it.
- 1:01:44And so now we just have to figure out how to make it to
- 1:01:46make sure that it's commercial from a large scale.
- 1:01:48But we've already played this out via open source software and
- 1:01:51tools, and that's where I think ties into your point about like
- 1:01:55the developers, the software providers, we have to like Lean
- 1:01:57In and provide services and value around it because that's
- 1:02:00how this thing makes it to the other side also just.
- 1:02:03Lastly, like leveraging the the capabilities that are like core
- 1:02:06to the the the Bitcoin blocks. Like like things like proof of
- 1:02:09reserves should be table states like every ETF should be
- 1:02:14published with addresses and the kind of taking advantage of the
- 1:02:19inherent properties of Bitcoin that you can privately secure
- 1:02:22them but also be publicly auditable.
- 1:02:26What about multi? What about multi Institution
- 1:02:29that's native? We can get into that.
- 1:02:32About no Marty, Marty yesterday. I was just just, yeah, yeah,
- 1:02:37yeah, yeah, yeah. Please help.
- 1:02:38Convince the SEC that multi institutions to custody is is
- 1:02:43the thing that is possible. But anyways, yeah, like I, I
- 1:02:45think we should always be pushing for what's what's what's
- 1:02:47natively possible and not kind of yeah, that that's also an
- 1:02:53aspect which I'm I'm, I'm proud and excited about our ETF is
- 1:02:55that we can be the the kind of champion of those things and
- 1:02:59push the boundaries and envelope in the conversation about like,
- 1:03:01oh, you can do it. You can do it for reserves.
- 1:03:03Like you can't say that you can't when, when, when there's
- 1:03:05$2 billion product out there that is doing it.
- 1:03:08And the kicker is you're incentivized to do it because.
- 1:03:09It's the best product. It's not about ideologic.
- 1:03:12It's ideological. It's literally you show your
- 1:03:14reserves now you can prove that you have the asset.
- 1:03:17Yeah, I think you guys. Definitely have to align with
- 1:03:19us. I think it's, yeah, it's in our
- 1:03:22self-interest as well. Yeah, you guys are partying with
- 1:03:24Hoseki to do that. Correct, Yes.
- 1:03:27So we. Do just publish the addresses
- 1:03:28directly on our ETF site as well.
- 1:03:30But currently Quinn based doesn't have a way of allowing
- 1:03:34us to sign back signatures to say that attest to the fact that
- 1:03:39those addresses are owned by us. We're just making a claim.
- 1:03:42So then Coinbase kind of extends that attestation in a in a
- 1:03:47private format to Huzeki and then Huzeki is saying that yes
- 1:03:50these addresses that the wife claims to have or is indeed at
- 1:03:54least in in their private kind of verification with with
- 1:03:57Coinbase true. So they're they're kind of
- 1:03:59bridging the part of the the trust model that's currently
- 1:04:04cannot be done in a public kind of trustless way.
- 1:04:09It's it's just a limitation that the Coinbase custody has you
- 1:04:14should be able to sign and take messages but let's put that at
- 1:04:18the moment. So it's kind of a a way to
- 1:04:21bridge that and still give more kind of public audit ability to
- 1:04:27people that's very. Commendable in both parts.
- 1:04:31The profit share with open source devs with no string
- 1:04:35attached contributions and then leveraging bitcoins native
- 1:04:40properties to trail Blaze improve to the rest of the
- 1:04:43financial industry. That's getting acclimated with
- 1:04:46Bitcoin that there's a new way to do things.
- 1:04:48This is a new asset, new Ledger and new accounting system that
- 1:04:52gives you more powers that were not possible in the previous
- 1:04:56financial system, the incumbent financial system like we are
- 1:05:00building a whole new it's not, it's not gold.
- 1:05:03Like it's it's a different thing and we should like leverage the
- 1:05:06the, the ways and that it's different and treat it
- 1:05:08differently. Not just yeah, it's if it's just
- 1:05:12the same number on a chart it's like everything else.
- 1:05:14Yeah, well hung. Really appreciate you joining us
- 1:05:19today. This was a fascinating
- 1:05:21conversation. I think you're an example of
- 1:05:25somebody who's doing things the right way and is approaching
- 1:05:28Bitcoin with what I would argue is the earnest philosophy and
- 1:05:36really understands why this asset exists in the 1st place
- 1:05:40and the power that it has to give not only institutions but
- 1:05:43individuals as well. And it's good to know that at
- 1:05:49the layer of the world where the ETFs are being created and
- 1:05:53distributed, there's individuals like you that really grok this
- 1:05:56stuff because we need people like you in positions of power
- 1:06:01within the world of traditional finance.
- 1:06:04We're trying. We have about 5%.
- 1:06:06Market share, I mean we have 2 billion in assets when Black
- 1:06:10Rock has 15 and and Fidelity has 8.
- 1:06:12And so you know we're we're we're trying to survive and and
- 1:06:17continue to be relevant and so that we can champion these these
- 1:06:19values and still build a profitable business of ourselves
- 1:06:22that we can continue to do that sustainably for for a long time.
- 1:06:25And so yeah it's it's it's ruthless like public markets are
- 1:06:29ruthless and that kind of the incumbents competing with them
- 1:06:33is also not an easy task but that's what we're here to do.
- 1:06:37So I'm excited that we have kind of a foothold and are at the
- 1:06:42table in the major leagues and that we can try to compete and
- 1:06:47to demonstrate that people do care about these features and
- 1:06:50that people do care about the ethos and that that you can
- 1:06:53build a better Bitcoin business doing so.
- 1:06:58Hell yeah, Hell yeah, brother. Appreciate you joining, Han.
- 1:07:02Thank you of course. Enjoy the rest.
- 1:07:05Of your day. Jesse, you want to end with?
- 1:07:08Anything. No, no.
- 1:07:09That was great. I'm we're all on the same team
- 1:07:13doing you know trying to trying to get the right values of
- 1:07:17Bitcoin to to be celebrated, embraced, adopted, and for those
- 1:07:24values to win. Next week.