Latest / Shiny New Object - a Marketing Podcast / Episode 273 / Caitlin Dodd / Church & Dwight / Director of Marketing, Specialty Hair Care
Transcript
- 0:00Caitlin Dodd: Consumers are telling you how they're using
- 0:02your product. They're telling you how they love your product.
- 0:05And if you can bring that to life, it is so rich.
- 0:16Speaker: Are you a fitness loving foodie? Then defy snacks
- 0:18is for you. Defy offers real high quality chocolate you love,
- 0:21combined with functional ingredients, giving you as much
- 0:23as 26 grams of protein per bag. So you can be both a little bit
- 0:27bad and a little bit good at the same time as a female owned
- 0:31brand, defy dedicates a portion of its profits to other women
- 0:34owned businesses currently sold in the US. You can find us on
- 0:37defy with an eye snacks.com, and follow us on social at the five
- 0:42Tom Ollerton: Hello and welcome to the shiny new object podcast.
- 0:42snacks.
- 0:53My name is Tom Ollerton. I'm the founder of automated creative,
- 0:56the creative effectiveness ad tech platform, and it is my joy
- 1:00and massive pleasure to interview some of the most
- 1:03amazing people in our industry, and this week is no different.
- 1:07I'm on a call with Caitlin Dodd, who is director of marketing in
- 1:11the hair and skin care team at Church & Dwight. So Caitlin, for
- 1:15anyone who doesn't know who you are and what you do, could you
- 1:19give them a bit of background?
- 1:19Caitlin Dodd: Absolutely, Tom. Great to be here. Thank you so
- 1:23much for the invite. I am the director over our hair care
- 1:23Right. I have very high expectations for this podcast
- 1:27businesses. So I've been at Church and Dwight for nine
- 1:31years, and consumer goods brand management was always a goal of
- 1:35mine. Dialing back to my undergrad university days, I
- 1:39double majored in economics and advertising. I've always had
- 1:43this balance of creativity and analytics right out of school, I
- 1:48spent a lot of my time in consulting, but quickly realized
- 1:52there wasn't enough creative outlet for me in that career, so
- 1:56I decided to pursue my MBA with the specific goal of
- 2:00transitioning into CPG brand management, and I was fortunate
- 2:04enough to be able to do that. I've been at Church and Dwight
- 2:09ever since I graduated McCombs business school, so I've been at
- 2:13Church and Dwight now for nine years. I've worked in fabric
- 2:17care, I've worked in personal care, and now I'm in the beauty
- 2:22space with hair care. It's been an amazing journey, and I am
- 2:26thrilled to lead an amazing team with amazing brands.
- 2:32now, so thank you for the introduction. So what advice
- 2:36would you give to a student who wanted to follow in your
- 2:40footsteps, they're doing all the sensible things. But what advice
- 2:43would you give someone to get ahead and maybe replicate your
- 2:46path?
- 2:46I love this question, and I think there's two mantras that I
- 2:51try to follow, that I love to pass on to any you know, young
- 2:57individuals looking to get into this career. And those two
- 3:00things are, you don't ask, you don't get, and just because it's
- 3:04different doesn't mean it's wrong. So some examples of how
- 3:07I've used those in my journey. For you don't ask, you don't
- 3:11get, while I was doing full time recruiting in business school,
- 3:16looking at various jobs, I came across a press release from a
- 3:23company that I admired and I thought what they were doing was
- 3:26so interesting, so I emailed the email address at the bottom of
- 3:31that press release, explained why I thought it was interesting
- 3:35and told them I wanted to work on it. That ultimately led to
- 3:38interviews and a job offer. It's not where I ended up. It wasn't
- 3:43Church and Dwight, but that opportunity never would have
- 3:45presented itself if I didn't reach out and I didn't ask for
- 3:49that opportunity to get involved. My second piece of
- 3:53advice that I mentioned was just because it's different doesn't
- 3:56mean it's wrong. In a career like marketing, you are
- 4:00constantly faced with new things, test and learn is a
- 4:05concept we hear all the time, and I'm going back many, many
- 4:11years now, but when I was going through recruiting processes,
- 4:17you know, over a decade ago, video calls were not a thing, so
- 4:22all interviews were phone calls or in person interviews, right?
- 4:26Technology has changed that, but I wanted to make myself stand
- 4:29out as a candidate, so I recorded a video resume and put
- 4:34it on YouTube with a link in my on my actual resume, so people
- 4:38could see me and hear me I get an impression before I went in.
- 4:42So I just encourage people to find ways, you know, to both
- 4:48stand out, but also be open to change and be willing to try new
- 4:53things.
- 4:54Tom Ollerton: I'd probably go even further, certainly in a
- 4:55marketing realm, and say, if it's not different, it's wrong.
- 5:00Yeah, because I think there's too much copying. There's way
- 5:02too much copying in advertising. Everyone's like, hey, let's do
- 5:06what they're doing, because that's best practice. But if
- 5:08everyone copies each other, then no one's marketing, right? And
- 5:10you've said that even in... you know job hunting, right? You
- 5:13know, putting your own video resume on there, or CV, as we
- 5:16call them in the UK, and YouTube's bold man, you're not
- 5:20shy, like just emailing someone out of the blue go and give us a
- 5:23job. That's fantastic.
- 5:24Caitlin Dodd: The interesting thing is, it got followed by a
- 5:26video of me on a flying trapeze. So that always led to very
- 5:29interesting questions on the actual interview.
- 5:33Tom Ollerton: Right. Brilliant. So unfortunately, I would love
- 5:36to hear more about that. Yeah. Go on. Go. Tell me the trapeze
- 5:38story. What was that like? You have to tell me, I need to hear.
- 5:41Caitlin Dodd: Absolutely. I spent three years in my early
- 5:4520s as a flying trapeze student. It was something I was so
- 5:49passionate about and loved. I did basically recitals,
- 5:52performances. I was never a professional, always just a
- 5:55student. And as I moved around. You know, there are not flying
- 6:02trapezes everywhere. So that was a hobby that I had to give up.
- 6:06But just one month ago, I had an opportunity to take a class
- 6:09again, and I'm thrilled to say that I, uh, I still got it. I
- 6:13was able to do my old tricks. I was pleasantly surprised.
- 6:16Tom Ollerton: Describe your best trick.
- 6:17Caitlin Dodd: Well, my most consistent trick was doing a
- 6:20back end split. So that is where you are swinging. You kind of
- 6:26turn yourself upside down and backwards with your legs in a
- 6:30split against the bar. And then when you're at the peak of your
- 6:34swing, you let go of the bar and catch the professional on the
- 6:38other side of the trapeze.
- 6:40Tom Ollerton: Things I never thought I'd hear on this
- 6:41podcast. There you go. That's there's been a few weird things,
- 6:45but it's definitely up there.
- 6:52So moving on. What is your ... feels like such a ridiculous
- 6:56question, but what is your best bit of data driven marketing
- 6:59advice you've been in around this a while now, and what, what
- 7:03do you find yourself sharing most often?
- 7:05Caitlin Dodd: The number one piece of advice I actually
- 7:07share, especially to entry level marketers, is pay attention in
- 7:13finance class, you know, as a, you know, in the brand
- 7:19management career, we are responsible for the P and L, the
- 7:23top line, the bottom line. I wish I had paid a lot more
- 7:27attention in that class so that I came into career more
- 7:32comfortable with that aspect of the job, because every time I've
- 7:36been promoted, I find myself learning so much more about the
- 7:42finances of my brands and diving into lines of a P and L I never
- 7:47knew existed before.
- 7:48Tom Ollerton: So we're now going to talk about your shiny new
- 7:52object, which is storytelling with data. I think I know what
- 7:57that is, but what is your version of that? And why is it
- 8:00your shiny new object?
- 8:01Caitlin Dodd: Now, I gave a lot of thought to this Tom, and I
- 8:05wanted to come up with something unique and different, but also
- 8:09something really practical that people could put into into use
- 8:14in their careers or in their experiences and storytelling
- 8:20through data, to me, means leveraging the information we
- 8:24have available. So as marketers, we are constantly storytelling.
- 8:29You know, every asset we touch is going to, you know, be part
- 8:33of that consumer decision journey. But one of the biggest
- 8:37pieces is an ad campaign, right? And so as you are concepting a
- 8:45campaign, what doing that through data would mean, mine
- 8:49your consumer reviews to inspire your story, because consumers
- 8:55are telling you how they're using your product. They're
- 8:57telling you how they love your product. And if you can bring
- 9:01that to life, it is so rich.
- 9:05Tom Ollerton: So practically, how do you do that? So you just
- 9:07do a scrape of everything that is being said on on different
- 9:11platforms, and then group it all together. Absolutely. Yeah. So
- 9:14can we give someone a sort of a how to on that?
- 9:17Unknown: Yep, absolutely. So we've absolutely done this
- 9:19before, and at Church and Dwight, we have a partner. We
- 9:22use a tool called yogi, and they pull all of the consumer reviews
- 9:27together from various different platforms, right? Like Amazon,
- 9:31our websites, retail sites, wherever they exist and and
- 9:36there's so many different ways you can look at it, right,
- 9:38sentiment analysis, trends, word clouds, and finding little
- 9:44nuggets or even piecing nuggets together, can really bring that
- 9:46story to life and and we had done that in my prior role as
- 9:51director on therapy mouthwash. We absolutely did that to
- 9:55inspire some of the ad campaigns. But honestly, it goes
- 9:59beyond. Just concepting, it's the whole process, right? So as
- 10:04you're casting for commercials, you want to make sure that the
- 10:08actors you're bringing in are representative of the consumers
- 10:12using your product, right? So look up your advanced shopper
- 10:17profiles, understand the demographics of who that person
- 10:21is, whether it's race, age, religion, even eating
- 10:25preferences, right? You're telling a whole story here.
- 10:28There's so many different nuances that can come to life.
- 10:31And then as you're planning where you want all your media to
- 10:34be, I think your media mix is a huge part of where data comes
- 10:38into play. So on my team, you know, we have a a partner called
- 10:46theme, which helps us understand the ROI for all of the
- 10:49investments that we're making in all of the different channels,
- 10:52right? So, learning from prior years, where are we spending our
- 10:56money? Where does it make the most sense to continue to pull
- 11:00back to ad optimize every single year.
- 11:10Tom Ollerton: This episode of the shiny new object podcast is
- 11:13brought to you in partnership with madfest, whether it's live
- 11:16in London or streamed online to the global marketing community,
- 11:20you can always expect a distinctive and daring blend of
- 11:23fast paced content, startup innovation pitches and
- 11:26unconventional entertainment from madfest events. You'll find
- 11:29me causing trouble on stage, recording live versions of this
- 11:32podcast and sharing a beer with the nicest and most influential
- 11:35people in marketing. Check it out at www dot madfest
- 11:39london.com.
- 11:46How do you then take it from into a more creative realm? And
- 11:50what I love about your shiny new object is just talking about
- 11:52storytelling, which is a very gooey, fluffy creative
- 11:55discipline, and data which is like, quote, unquote, a bit more
- 11:59hard, bit more scientific. But someone listening to this might
- 12:03still be like, Well, look, how do I actually do that? So
- 12:05you've, you've scraped all your reviews. You know which channels
- 12:08are giving you the best ROI, so you know where it's going to go.
- 12:12You've cast successfully because you've, you've taken into
- 12:15account all of the different measures that you you mentioned.
- 12:19But then when it comes to the idea like the the genesis of the
- 12:23creative, the gooey, hooky, emotional thing. How do you use
- 12:28data to get to that?
- 12:30Caitlin Dodd: What I've done in the past is it really ends up
- 12:32coming mostly the data we use is the consumer reviews. That's
- 12:36where it's coming from, and then it is on living and breathing
- 12:41your brand in a way that it becomes a part of you. And
- 12:45saying, you know, I think you can just identify those concepts
- 12:50that align to your your brand and your products promise to
- 12:56their consumers, right, like the and your positioning in the
- 13:00marketplace.
- 13:01Tom Ollerton: So you're using that data as a, as a, like a
- 13:03validation for creative concepts. Is that right?
- 13:06Caitlin Dodd: Absolutely.
- 13:07Tom Ollerton: So the so internal agency or external agency will
- 13:09go, Look, we're launching this new product. This is our
- 13:13creative idea. And then then your chin scratching moment is
- 13:15like, right? Okay, well, we, you know, here's all the reviews you
- 13:18did it, and that becomes a sense check or a guide for the
- 13:21creative idea?
- 13:22Caitlin Dodd: 100% yes. So there's usually, to your point,
- 13:26a couple of concepts coming in from, you know, the agency, the
- 13:29partner and the gut check that we need. Or the way to elevate
- 13:34it is using those consumer reviews to say, how do we make
- 13:37this real? How do we make this resonate?
- 13:40Tom Ollerton: And why have you gone so big on on that
- 13:44particular data point? I'm not saying you're wrong. I'm just
- 13:46just want to get a bit deeper, because, like, you know, social
- 13:49listening, for example, might, for example, might exist in the
- 13:51same way. Or is it a focus group? Is that just not reliable
- 13:54enough, or customer service center, for example? So I'm
- 13:58curious. Like, I love that you're so specific about it, but
- 14:01that's quite rare. Like people, people tend to want a kind of a
- 14:04kind of a basket of data, I've heard it referred to.
- 14:06Caitlin Dodd: Yeah, no, that's totally fair. Well, so where we
- 14:06Tom Ollerton: I think what's a refreshing about this view is in
- 14:09really put this into place was on that Therabreath campaign,
- 14:12contrast to what is happening with the conversation about AI
- 14:13and the first version we did of the swishy time campaign, used
- 14:18this, we used true consumer stories to bring to life in our
- 14:22in our advertising. And it worked so well. The results were
- 14:26phenomenal. I mean, the brand just exploded. And so we
- 14:30realized that the truth that was there was just something that
- 14:35couldn't be replicated. You know? Otherwise, it was
- 14:38something really unique, because no other brand in the space can
- 14:43tell the story that's true to Therabreath if the consumers are
- 14:47already saying it's true about you, right? It's not like we
- 14:52talked about earlier. So often copycats and copying happens in
- 14:56marketing. One brand's doing it. Oh, we love that. Let's do that
- 15:01for us. But when, when the story that a brand is telling is so
- 15:05unique, no one else can tell that same story.
- 15:17at the minute, and everyone's losing their minds about how AI
- 15:19can save them loads of time and money, I think, which is fine.
- 15:22It's great. Be my guest. Go ahead, do that stuff, but I'm
- 15:28writing a book at the minute about the relationship between
- 15:31data, creativity and advertising. And the thing that
- 15:33really has come through that research over like 40 interviews
- 15:37with senior marketers, is this idea that it's all about being
- 15:42empathetic towards the consumer, like, do you care about them?
- 15:45Have you gone deep with them? Do you understand them? Are you
- 15:48listening to them? Do you see what they see? And then that
- 15:51becomes the foundation for something that's emotional, that
- 15:54actually moves the needle, not plugging in something and just
- 15:58having it whir away in the background and spew out some
- 16:01copy. And I think what, what you've said here is exactly
- 16:04that, right? You're being data centric, really, right?
- 16:07Caitlin Dodd: And you're reminding me that another
- 16:09genesis for us is what we call like in the wild. So I was
- 16:16wearing like, you know, a Therabreath sweatshirt on
- 16:19vacation, and someone was like, Oh my gosh, Therabreath, you
- 16:22know, Therabreath and tell me why they love the brand. What
- 16:25was so great about it that happens a lot... one of those
- 16:28occasions helped spur a one of our ad campaigns, right? So a
- 16:37consumer telling me they like to use Therabreath before they give
- 16:42a big speech, because, you know, it helps with dry mouth before
- 16:47public speaking. And now we have an ad campaign with a best man
- 16:53about to go out onto the dance floor to give his best man
- 16:55speech using Therabreath dry mouth.
- 16:58Tom Ollerton: Brilliant. So, yeah. So when? So when you say
- 17:01storytelling with data, what you're really it's almost like,
- 17:05sorry to kind of rewrite your your words, but it's finding
- 17:08stories within the data, as opposed to like, right? We've
- 17:11got a script now we must data validate every word in that
- 17:14script. It's not like you're not putting storytelling through a
- 17:17machine. You have a process for finding stories from existing
- 17:20data, either with on online or in the wild. As you say.
- 17:23Caitlin Dodd: I think that's fair.
- 17:24Tom Ollerton: So if someone wants to get into this, like, so
- 17:27you're in a category where people talk about the product,
- 17:31and people come with you on holiday and accost you and all
- 17:34that kind of stuff. What if you're in a category where that,
- 17:36where that doesn't happen, like a lower interest category where,
- 17:40I don't know, insert whatever low interest category you want
- 17:44for the sake of argument, but they're not going to
- 17:46passionately talk about it in in a review or within a social
- 17:50place. Or have I got that all wrong? Like every brand has some
- 17:54vocal people?
- 17:55Caitlin Dodd: Well, I'll ask you this, did you expect people to
- 17:58be passionate about mouthwash?
- 18:01Tom Ollerton: Yeah, it's, it's home, it's home of personal
- 18:03care, right? So it's, it's your it's your part. It's part of how
- 18:06people perceive you, right? So that, you know, then or or
- 18:09health is usually like, yeah, it's, it's in your head. So yes,
- 18:14I think people would be very passionate about it, but I don't
- 18:16know, like, car insurance or something else. Like, sorry,
- 18:20sorry, car insurance people, but, yeah, anything to do with
- 18:23the body tends to promote quite strong views though.
- 18:26Caitlin Dodd: I have not ever worked in a category where
- 18:30consumers aren't passionate. I've worked in laundry
- 18:33detergent. People are passionate about their laundry detergent. I
- 18:38now work in hair care, right products that support hair
- 18:41thinning, Dry Shampoo to get you in between washes. There's a lot
- 18:46of passion, you know, in all of the spaces that I have worked.
- 18:50So I don't think it's fair for me to shed light on on something
- 18:53that I don't really have experience in.
- 19:02Tom Ollerton: And so where do you want to go next with this?
- 19:04So you have this tried and tested technique, what? Where
- 19:08are you like? Maybe we could look at this like...
- 19:11Caitlin Dodd: Well, I'll tell you, I just transitioned teams a
- 19:14few months ago, so I'm now on hair care. I'm excited to bring
- 19:17this process to that team and to those businesses for sure,
- 19:22because there's always opportunity to bring those
- 19:27consumer truths and consumer stories to life. And I don't
- 19:36know where it's going to go next. You know, I think
- 19:38consumers need, need to tell us a little bit. I love leveraging,
- 19:43you know, the data and the tools that are available to us. So
- 19:49it's constantly challenging myself, my team, my partners, on
- 19:55making sure is this all right? Is this all true? Is this is.
- 20:00Can we? Can we go back and validate it right? Are we
- 20:02casting the right way, like I mentioned before, are we
- 20:05spending our money in the right places, like, are we reaching
- 20:08the right consumers with this message?
- 20:13Tom Ollerton: So unfortunately, we've run out of time now, and I
- 20:16would love to carry on talking about this and trapeze acts,
- 20:20etc, but if someone wants to get in touch with you to discuss
- 20:25anything we've talked about today, where's a good place to
- 20:27get you and what makes a message that you will reply to?
- 20:31Caitlin Dodd: LinkedIn is definitely the best place to
- 20:35connect with me. I'm pretty active on there, and I think the
- 20:40best way to reach out is comment on one of my posts before you
- 20:46show up in my inbox. Like, that would be my recommendation.
- 20:49Tom Ollerton: I've never had that. That's so good.
- 20:52Caitlin Dodd: Yeah right? Like, pay the price of entry.
- 20:53Tom Ollerton: Yeah right, yeah. But your comments aren't busy,
- 20:56basically, well, but I'm sure they are, so I'll take that
- 20:59back. Okay, brilliant. That is, that's an excellent bit of
- 21:03advice for people who want to contact you. Caitlin, that was
- 21:07perfect. Thank you so much for your time.
- 21:10Caitlin Dodd: Thank you, Tom it's been a pleasure.
- 21:18Tom Ollerton: Hi. Just before you go, I'd really appreciate it
- 21:22if you could take the time to write a review of the shiny new
- 21:25object podcast on Apple podcasts, or iTunes, whatever
- 21:29it's called these days, or whichever podcast provider you
- 21:32use. We're at any new podcast, so it would go a long way for us
- 21:36if you could just share the Word and give us a bit of a support
- 21:39on those channels. That'd just be fantastic. If you haven't got
- 21:41time, that's also cool. And yeah, if you could tell your
- 21:44colleagues about the podcast, and also, if possible, don't
- 21:47forget to subscribe. And I'd love to hear your feedback. If
- 21:51you'd like to speak on the podcast or be a guest, or you
- 21:54think I'm asking the wrong questions, anything, I'd be
- 21:56super interested to hear what you think. So please email me
- 22:00Tom at, automated creative.net that's Tom at, I'm not going to
- 22:06bother spelling it anyway. You'll work it out. Thanks so
- 22:09much.