Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️108 |Public Inquiry Week Beginning 5th Oct. Water conditions Day 3 |
Transcript
- 0:10Unknown: Welcome back. I'm Marella, your host, and I'm part of the Save Our Sperrins campaign. And this podcast is following the Coronalt public inquiry and the proposal for a gold mine in The Sperrins. If you're new to the podcast and wondering how we got here, I'd suggest going back to podcast
- 0:28number 43, the first in this public inquiry series, that will give you some of the background before joining us here. As the inquiry continues, I'll be following the evidence and the arguments and trying to make sense of what they could ultimately mean for the people, the water, and the landscapes of
- 0:50The Sperrins. Today at the Coronel's public inquiry, we got into one of those parts of the process that could sound dry, except was about water. Sorry, I couldn't resist the pun. Water conditions, actually, and now I feel like taking another ironic swipe at that phrase. What I'm really talking about is the
- 1:15conditions that NAEA proposed to attach to licences for water abstraction and discharge. On the off chance that is that the mine ever gets permission to operate, but of course that's not going to happen. As NIEA spoke today, it became blindingly obvious that there are many things left to be
- 1:34adjusted within these conditions. So much so that the old adage of the conditions are not worth the paper they are written on seems to be holding true. There are numbers missing from the conditions. Sampling locations still have to be nailed down. Maps and grid references have to be attached.
- 1:56Trigger levels need actions connected to them. Responsibility between DFI and NIEA needs to be made clear. Monitoring frequency, laboratory standards, and telemetry still need detail, and there are outstanding questions around engineering certification and financial security. And I'm not.
- 2:22speaking about the finishing touches; these are the nuts and bolts determining how these conditions would actually work. After NIEA had completed, the air protectors were allowed to comment, and it was clear Sean Tracy had listened to enough. You could hear the frustration begin to spill over. His
- 2:45response to the conditions was pretty uncompromising. One of the conditions gave NIEA the ability to require a review, an amendment of the water management and monitoring action plan, where monitoring showed that it was no longer adequate to protect the water environment. Dalradin wanted
- 3:06that provision removed. Sean wanted it strengthened. He described the conditions as weak at best, and pointed out that this is a huge industrial development proposed in an area of outstanding natural beauty, surrounded by protected waters, priority species, and an ecology that people have been warning
- 3:27about throughout this inquiry. His concerns centred on what actually happens when monitoring shows there is a problem. There are references to monitoring, assessment levels, and compliance levels, but Sean kept coming back to the absence of a clear requirement to stop abstraction when a defined
- 3:50trigger is reached. An assessment level is supposed to provide an early warning. A compliance level marks a breach. There was broad discussion about having both with actions and mitigations attached to each stage. Sean also said monitoring had to be continually checked against what was actually
- 4:12happening on the ground, using water levels, laboratory results, and physical observations to test the modelling against reality, he called it constant calibration through observable facts. Then Dr. Stephen Emermann drew attention to something even more elemental. One proposed
- 4:35abstraction condition says that the quantity of water abstracted shall not exceed x x x cubic metres per calendar day. As Stephen pointed out, x x x is not a number, and this isn't a figure that can simply be filled in at leisure. Steve explained that the abstraction figure affects. Peat de-watering,
- 5:02groundwater subsidence, and potential impacts on buildings and the wider environment. He specifically mentioned the church at Ruski and the possibility of subsidence and cracking. There was discussion about whether Dalradin had already supplied a figure, and whether NIEA had reviewed it,
- 5:24but Stephen kept the distinction clear. The applicant providing a number and the regulator reviewing that number are two separate parts of the process. And there was no shortage of numbers floating around today. Figures of 1700 cubic metres a day, 2250 cubic metres a day, and 540 cubic metres a day, all
- 5:48relating to water flow, all appeared in the discussion.
- 5:53So one of the immediate jobs before these conditions can be finalised is simply to establish the definitive abstraction figures and put them into the actual conditions. Stephen later found the same problem in the discharge conditions where XX and TBC were still sitting, where actual values will
- 6:17eventually have to go. Today's phrase of the day was not necessary. The ladies' barrister, mr. Beatty, argued that a number of provisions were unnecessary, duplicated elsewhere, or could be dealt with through other mechanisms. One was Condition 6.8, which allowed NIEA to require the
- 6:40Water Management and monitoring action plan to be reviewed, and amended, if information showed that it was no longer adequate to protect the water environment. Dalradian wanted it removed. NIEA's barrister, mr. Byass, was prepared to let it go on the basis that NIEA could do that anyway. A similar thing
- 7:03happened with discharge condition 1.7, another provision concerned with protecting the water environment. Already in said it wasn't necessary, and NIEA was again content for it to come out. And that was where the whole business start to feel a little like regulatory smoke and mirrors. A condition written
- 7:26into a licence gives everybody something definite to work from. If NIEA intends to exercise that protection anyway, putting it clearly into the condition gives certainty to the regulator, the company, and the communities living around the mine. Instead, two provisions concerned with protecting the water environment
- 7:48were challenged by Delranian, accepted for removal by NIEA. Dot dot dot dot dot dot dot. Darcy Rollston, barrister for Save Our Sperrins, picked up on the repeated use of not necessary, and made a simple point: nobody had demonstrated any detrimental effects from leaving that protection in
- 8:12place. The Earth Protector spent a lot of today trying to make these conditions clearer, measurable, and enforceable. Padhoughtie concentrated on what happens when a trigger is actually reached. He wanted conditions capable of stopping a discharge, diverting it to a pond, and where necessary,
- 8:33stopping production. He also raised telemetry, historical monitoring data, laboratory accreditation, and the frequency of sampling. There also needs to be clarity about who is responsible for what. Some matters sit with DFI through planning conditions; others with NIEA through licencing. There
- 8:56were requests today for reports and management plans to be provided to both bodies, so that information isn't sitting in one part of the system while another part is expected to act upon it. Dr. Emmern then raised another issue that gives some idea of what these technical conditions can mean once water begins
- 9:18leaving the site. He looked at where compliance with water quality standards would actually be assessed. For some substances, including cadmium, nickel, lead, and mercury, assessment appears to take place within the burns. Stephen described the potential result as literally creating sacrifice
- 9:39zones. His preference was for the mine effluent to be assessed as it leaves the outlet pipe. Miss Rulston followed that by pointing out that the absence of clearly identified sampling locations made proper scrutiny extremely difficult, and just as an aside. While all of this is going on, and I'm sitting there
- 10:02trying to capture it, there's a part of me that wants to scream at the sheer madness of human beings contemplating giving permission for discharges containing nickel, lead, mercury, cadmium, chromium, and other contaminants into these high mountain burns. We can talk about consent limits, assessment
- 10:22levels, compliance levels, and sampling points until the cows come home, but sometimes you have to remember what we're actually talking about. These are the living headwaters supporting entire ecosystems, and we are discussing how much contamination we are prepared to permit them to receive, for me
- 10:44there's something profoundly wrong in that. It feels like a travesty, an insult to the life these burns support, and in the deepest sense, a moral injury, knowingly accept harm to something we should be protecting. To get back to the conditions, another job still sitting on the table tonight.
- 11:06The final conditions need actual sampling locations and grid references, along with defined sampling frequencies, laboratory standards, and detection limits. Fedelmo Kane raised the problem of annual averages masking shorter periods of high concentrations, and supported end of pipe assessment. She also
- 11:29returned to the temperature limit with the LOX agency recommendation of 18 degrees Celsius because of the potential effects on fish. The 18 or 20 degree issue still needs to be resolved.
- 11:47There was also concern about the impoundment pond stroke reservoirs, and the volumes of water that could be held in them. Calls were made for proper engineering specifications, certification by a registered engineer and assurance of their structural integrity before commissioning, and Pat Hardy
- 12:08raised another issue that will last long after the construction phase is forgotten. Who carries the responsibility if a licence is transferred, and who pays for problems after closure that brought financial security and a bond into the discussion. For a project with long-term water management requirements, those
- 12:34responsibilities need to follow the mine owner, regardless of what happens to the company structure in the years ahead, Emmett McAller picked up on the fact that the conditions being examined will require further redrafting. So people are being asked to scrutinise wording today, which may not be the
- 12:55wording that ultimately appears in the final document. At the same time, the commission was enforcing deadlines for additional conditions. Parties were told that proposed conditions needed to be submitted early enough for everyone to have a fair opportunity to consider them,
- 13:14and additional non-water ecology conditions had to be in first thing the following morning. That became noticeable when the historic environment division wanted additional archaeological conditions considered. The commissioner would not entertain new conditions at that stage and explain that late matters could
- 13:35be taken through the appropriate statutory process outside the oral hearings. Emmet was clearly taken aback that consultants from HED who are present could not add to the conditions being discussed. The procedural explanation was clear, but it leaves us in an unusual position. There is a firm
- 13:56deadline for the public and consultees to put forward changes, while the conditions themselves remain subject to further redrafting by the various authorities, apparently the deadline for getting it right applies to everyone except the people still rewriting it. There is also the extraordinary
- 14:17confirmation that the updated NIEA modelling and the figures that come from it will not be available before the end of this public inquiry. These are not peripheral figures; they feed directly into the water conditions we are being asked to scrutinise now. Yet, the inquiry will finish without the public
- 14:38or the third parties ever having the opportunity to examine them, you could feel the disbelief and the disgust amongst those attending the inquiry by the silence in the room after we heard this. We have heard so much about scrutiny, transparency, and the importance of this public. Process, but
- 15:01yet, some of the figures on which these water conditions depend will apparently arrive when the process of public scrutiny is over. You really couldn't make it up. Hold the public inquiry first, produce the figures it relies on afterwards, and call it transparency. The work left to
- 15:25do under conditions after the public inquiry has closed includes: the correct abstraction and discharge figures have to be inserted, sampling points and grid references have to be identified, assessment and compliance levels need defined actions attached to them.
- 15:46Monitoring frequency, laboratory standards, and telemetry need to be specified. Responsibility between DFI and NIEA needs to be clear. The impoundments need engineering assurance, long-term financial responsibility for the site needs to be secured, and then remember that the provisions that NIEA originally
- 16:09included to protect the water environment are being removed because we are now told they are not necessary. These are the same conditions that may one day govern a mine operating in The Sperrins, where the impact on these fragile water systems will continue long after the mine itself is closed, potentially in
- 16:31perpetuity. And to finish up, there were two incidents that occurred today unrelated to the conditions, but definitely say something about the atmosphere around this process. Our artist in residence was stopped from sketching proceedings by staff working at the inquiry, not to blame the staff that were only
- 16:52doing their job. Afterwards, investigative environmental journalist Sean Ore approached the commissioners seeking a statement, and the position subsequently given was that the artist was not to be prevented from continuing to sketch.
- 17:10Sketching did continue, but the but the interruption still happened, and for me it joins a growing list of incidents that are begin to feel like a war of attrition against the people who have spent years trying to protect this place, we already operate within tight restrictions on how these
- 17:29proceedings can be recorded and shared publicly, including the inability to video record the inquiry for the publication. So, when an artist sitting quietly with a sketchbook is temporarily stopped as well. It becomes difficult to to dismiss these things as insignificant. Every little obstacle makes it a bit
- 17:52harder to document what is happening in that room and to bring it to people outside it, and that is why these seemingly small incidents matter. A public inquiry should make it easier for the public to see and understand what has been done in their name, not leave the people trying to get that information
- 18:11out feeling as though they are fighting for every inch of daylight, for every breath that they speak. On another unrelated matter: Two local priests had come to the public inquiry because they were concerned about their schools, their church, and the communities they serve. There are procedures
- 18:31governing who can speak at the inquiry, and nobody was disputing that. Because they had not submitted a statement of case, they were not permitted to make any statement. What caused real anger in the room was the way the decision was handled. The commissioner did not address the priest directly, choosing
- 18:50instead to communicate with them through a member of staff. The sense of disgust amongst those sitting in the audience was palpable. Whatever procedural rules were being applied. There was simply no need for that level of discourtesy towards two respected local religious leaders who had taken the time
- 19:09to come into the room because they were worried about the people and churches and schools in their care. They deserved the simple courtesy of being looked in the eye and having the position explained to them directly and respectfully. An instance like this do nobody associated with this project any
- 19:28favours. Delray Din may ultimately be seeking the legal permissions to operate, but there is also that much talked about social licence. Every time people leave this process feeling dismissed, belittled, shut out of decisions affecting their own communities, that social licence takes another
- 19:49knock. For a company already facing deep opposition and The Sperrins, this public inquiry was an opportunity for people to feel that their concerns were at least being heard. And treated with respect. Experiences like this risk hardening that opposition and further damaging a relationship with the
- 20:08community that is already deeply strained. Planning permission, if it ever comes, may be granted on paper. A social licence cannot, and treating people like this is a very effective way ensuring you never get one. And I leave it there with that thought. See you all tomorrow. You've been listening to the
- 20:30Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from the Frontline. Thank you for joining us today. All the links you need, from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared by today's guests and resources mentioned in the conversation, are available in the show notes. Please take a
- 20:50moment to share this podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares about protecting our land and communities. And don't forget to hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these voices further. Together, our voices are stronger. Thanks for
- 21:09listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people who protect them.