Latest / Ego and Other Things / Communism Vs. Capitalism - Do We Need Either? | Applied Philosophy
Transcript
- William: Which is the best system? Communism, capitalism, or socialism? Well, I think this is the wrong question to ask. And today I'm going to try and step outside of this classic debate and ask the question: why do we need to force one economic system on everyone at all? I'm going to break down the morality of this through my voluntarist philosophy. critique some force-based economic systems both from the left and from the right, and show you how the state interferes in the market to benefit itself. Now to make my position clear from the outset, I want to say here that I'm not anti-any of these economic systems. I'm not anti-communist, I'm not anti-capitalistic, I'm not even anti- Socialist or feudalist or whatever kind of economic arrangement that you can bring to your mind. I'm anti-force. That is to say, that I believe that the ideal economic system is the economic system in which every single person is able to voluntarily and autonomously. cooperate in whatever economic structure that they find to be the most beneficial and valuable for their individual ends and goals. And so this may end up being something like communism or capitalism or some sort of mix or some sort of third economic or fourth economic system that we've yet to really conceive of or understand. But my position isn't to be pro or anti-any any given economic system, but anti-force and pro-voluntarist. And This means an economic system which is truly free, a truly free market, in which people have autonomous control over their own Labor, time, talents, and property. For the sake of their own individual Voluntarily acted upon ends. Part of the reason that I'm not anti or pro any given economic system is because I think it's easy to recognize that any given economic system marginalizes some group of people. Whenever you use force to ubiquitously impose any given economic system, there are going to be a class of people who benefit from it and a class of people who are disadvantaged by it. There are gonna be people who are perfectly happy to participate in that economic system, either because they trust in the the market forces of a capitalist society or because they Trust in the collective wisdom of the communist bureaucracy, or else because they benefit in some individual way from the economic structure that is imposed. But of course, it's going to be masses of other people who wish to participate in a different economic system and are prevented to by the power and the caution of the state. And so Part of reason why I'm anti-any particular economic system is from the sick s from the simple fact that there are would be masses of people, no matter what system, no matter how apparently perfect it is, there would be masses of people who would be marginalized within that given system, prevented from acting for the sake of what they truly value, and prevented from experimenting or changing or going off and creating new kinds of economic structures that would be actually beneficial to their interests. In the voluntary society there is no necessary dividing line between Communist structure is a capitalistic structure. Bartering, so socialism, volunteering, charity work. Cooperatives. Syndicalist organizations, agrarian organizations, there's no necessary or state-imposed dividing line that is maintain maintained through a monopoly of violence by the state. In a voluntarist society, all of these structures, insofar they're as they're even identifiable structurally, are mixed, are mingled. are dependent on the free and voluntary choices of of the people within the given society. And so a person may involve himself in a number of so-called economic structures. Which they share with or are different from. the activities of the other people in that civilization. But the through line there would be that such participation would be voluntary, that that the individual would have autonomous control in in Determining. what kind of economic system they're going to participate in and how. This is not something that happens today. Either in the so called free market capitalist societies of the West or in the alternative economic structures of other countries such as Russia or China. Now this argument really breaks down in in into two different kinds of strands that you can go. One is the moral strand. It's the it's where we try to critique systems like communism and capitalism, or forced communism and forced capitalism from a moral standpoint and ask ourselves, is this economic arrangement moral over and above the use of force? And that's one discussion to be had. And the other discussion to be had is the conversation around economic efficiency. Is the given forced economic system actually efficient in producing goods and services for the vast majority of people? Now I'm going to start in with the morality because I think it's tends to be much more much more important and central than the argument over economic efficiency, which is ultimately something that ends up being largely subje subjective. So we'll start in with with the moral. analysis here. And I think it's actually it I think it actually might be best to begin this by illustrating the the moral two moral distinctions that were made by Karl Marx and Ayn Rand in Critiquing opposite economic structures from a moral perspective that ended up pointing in the same direction, in my analysis. Now, famously, Marx had a gripe with the capitalist economic system because from his analysis what he saw was that the laborer had to sell his labor or his talents or whatnot to the capitalists in order to be able to receive wages that were necessary for his survival. He couldn't sort of the laborer couldn't just sort of go off on his own and survive. He was in the position of of being forced to sell his labor for wages so that he could Receive at least the basics of survival. And the capitalists, because of their ownership over capitalism, was in a position to exploit that circumstance and pay the laborer the least amount of wages possible, which ultimately alienated the laborer from a significant portion of the production of their labor. So the capitalists ended up owning the fruits of their labor rather than the laborer themselves and It was argued that what the capitalist calls Profit is essentially the difference between the wages that are paid back to the laborer and the excess production. Produced by the laborer himself. And though Marx never Explicitly developed a moral critique. This was something that bothered him in the sense that he felt this alienation of the laborer from the fruits of his product by the capitalist in the structure. Was perverse, or at least something that would over that would be overcome in the historical development of the proletarian overcoming the bourgeois class. That they would reclaim the fruits of their labor through the the communist ideal society. And so they would no longer be alienated from the fruits of their labor. In essence, the capitalists would no longer steal the fruits of their labor by only giving back them them their wages and maintaining control over the means of production. And in the same way, but perhaps in different language, Ayn Rand, who had grown up in in the authoritarian communism of the Soviet Union, was critical of communism in essence because the communist bureaucracy, the so called society, the so called collective, would alienate the individual from the fruits of their own labor by requiring that individual to give up both control over what they were going to labor for and the fruits of that labor, given up to the bureaucracy, given up to the collective, and then the collective would, by its own wisdom, by its own arbitrary definitions of what was just and equal, would redistribute the fruits of that labor to the rest of society in an equal way. And what Ayn Rand partially was arguing was that this violates the individual's right to the fruit of their own labor, to their own body, their own property that comes as a result of their labor, beyond just the ability to labor after what they actually wanted to. And so in both instances, what these thinkers have a gripe with is that some structure, whether it be the the communist bureaucracy on the one hand, or whether it be the capitalist who owns the mean production on the other hand. in one sense steals or alienates the the individual from the from profiting from the direct fruits of their own labor and work. And Karl Marx thought that that communism would liberate the labor in a capitalist society from this relationship of alienation to to the capitalist. And Ayn Rand thought that a a a capitalist society, a sort of libertarian capitalist society, would free the individual from the Theft and alienation by society by the collective and by the communist bureauc bureaucracy that would be necessary in order to actually execute the collection and redistribution of wealth. And what's always stood out to me that as interesting between these two thinkers is that as they were kind of, at least along this line, they were Sharing the same kind of gripe. They both, at some level, wanted the laborer, the individual, to have control over the fruits of their labor, or at least benefit directly from the fruits of their labor. They wanted each to have a kind of autonomous control over what they were going to labor for. and to receive the actual benefits of that labor. And it was interesting to me to see that you could make a pretty interesting critique of both communism and capitalism along this kinds of line, that both communism and capitalism alienated the individual from the fruits of their labor, forced them to work in ways which they did not actually value, and set up relationships of exploitation either along the lines of the the capitalist or along the lines of the communist bureaucracy. And so they shared the same kind of concern and working it out but in opposite directions. And my contention here is essentially that both of them really missed the fundamental mark because the fundamental problem was not with communism as an economic system as regards Ayn Rand's critique, nor was it capitalism as an economic system as regards Marx's critique. It was the fact that Both had had direct experiences of these economic systems being ubiquitously enforced by state violence on their on the societies which they lived, and they saw the direct harm of that ubiquitous force in their life. Because of course, there were people in in Karl Marx's day who were going through. the upheavals of capitalism. And while some sections, maybe even large sections of the society were directly benefiting from that, there are of course large sections of society that were being completely harmed by that, that were suffering greatly, and that had no other option but to go back to the capitalist and sell their labor because the state had come in in order to promote and preserve the the capitalist structures of that society. And in the same way, Ayn Rand grew up in a in a communist Soviet Union where the the communist bureaucracy had ubiquitous control over the the factors of economic production. The individual had little to no control over Either what they were going to labor for or how or whether or not they were going to receive the fruits of their labor. And she saw some people benefiting from this, particularly the the bureaucracy and the intelligentsia that grew up around the communist regime. but of course experienced How that economic system harmed a lot of people around her, including her family and and many others who were unable to escape from this forced ubiquitous economic structure. But of course, the fault of these systems were not the systems themselves. It was not capitalism in and of itself that was causing the alienation of the labor, and it was not communism in and of itself that was causing the alienation of the fruits of labor. From the worker, in either case. It was the forced ubiquity, the forced ubiquity, the fact that these people could not escape the economic structures under which they lived, which were supported by state violence. They could not escape those structures and decide to participate in some other form of of market exchange, some other form of utilizing or trading their labor. Rather again, the state forced a ubiquitous economic structure which crowded out other opportunities and which marginalized some group of society caused them great harm and caused and at least influenced these two thinkers to to make critiques of of opposite economic structures by the harm that they were selling, right? Or by the harm that they were seeing. And just taking these these two. big or these two common economic structures of communism and capitalism, can't we sort of make a critique here, right? Can we can't we sort of make a moral critique here? and I think what we can start this with with communism, which is you know one of the things that Marx described this exploitative relationship between the worker and the capitalist and The idea that the capitalist was profited by stealing the excess production from the worker, you know, minus the wages given to them for essentially sub subsistence, for basic subsistence. Kind of simplified. But this idea was that because of the needs of survival, the laborer was forced to sell their labor to the capitalist for the sake of wages. So that they could survive it. That was a necessary circumstance. And certainly at certain points in history this was true. But the question, it's less true today. But the question is: did the laborer have the right to sell their labor to the capitalist for wages? Right. So for instance, if The laborer looking at their options said, you know, on the one hand, I could labor for myself, right? I could go out and use my labor or barter or what have you in order to procure the things I need for survival. I could individually do that. Or I could enter into a voluntary relationship with you know, this this capitalist and say, I'm going to give you some of my time, my labor, my my talents, what have you, in exchange for wages, because the wages in and of themselves allow them, let's say, more fluidity and the ability to purchase, or perhaps those are the greatest wages that they can get, or perhaps the wages that they get are going to be of higher value to them than whatever they could get out of their direct. labor out of whatever they could get out of the direct ownership. Perhaps the fact that the capitalist organizes the factory in such a way as to make the collective labor of the workers more efficient in a way that he could then pay them wages which are of higher value than if the individual labor went off and and did his own his own kind of laboring or did a commune or whatnot. Perhaps you know again through The market options, that was the best option for the laborer. Does the laborer have the right to sell their labor to the capitalist instead of giving it up to the so-called wisdom of the bureaucracy or the state? This was the right that people didn't have in places like communist China, communist Russia. Things that Iran, for example, experienced where people were suffering. and It would have been much more beneficial for them to go out and sell their their labor to a capitalist or to somebody who wanted to to invest in that, then it would have been to to sit around waiting for the state to to dole out whatever the state determined to be to be just. The the individuals in that kind of circumstances couldn't have benefited from subjectively benefited from control over how they were going to sell their labor and how How they were going to utilize her time and treasure instead of giving it up to the state to make that decision for them. But they didn't have the ability or the right to do that in these kinds of societies. And the question I've always had in relationship to communism is what if I find that the capitalist arrangement is valuable to me? You know, either as a laborer or as a capitalist? Do not have the right to participate in that if I make that judgment. Why is it that The bureaucracy, which is just made up of other people and other other kinds of individuals. Why does the state get to decide what I'm going to do with my my economic labor, right? In in a situation of freedom, in an in a true free market, not necessarily a capitalist market, but in a true free market, the individual gets to make the decision as to what is going to be of benefit to them to sell their labor or to produce for. And that can be you know trading that labor for wages to the capitalist. That can be giving up control to a voluntary commune. That can be A million different variations in between, and it can be kinds of economic arrangements that again we haven't even developed or conceived of yet. But the point is to say that in a free market, in a free market the person has the right to sell their labor to wages? And why doesn't the person have the right to do that? Because of course, the parallel critique of capitalism is that when you have a ubiquitously forced state. Of capitalism, like you do in the United States. The same sort of moral critique applies. The same sort of question of do I have the right not to sell my labor for wages? Do I have the right to give up, you know, direct autonomous control to my labor, my resources, what I'm going to do, because I I put my faith in the wisdom of the collective or in a bureaucracy or in a worker-owned factory or what have you. Why don't I have the right to do that? And there are those who might say that, the United States, it is a free market. It's capitalistic, but it's free, and which is complete nonsense. it's it's neither capitalistic nor free. It's sort of a mixed economy where the state regularly intervenes in the market to redistribute goods and services and whatnot. And it also uses the power of the state to entrench the the capitalist mode of of production through subsidizations and tax incentives and regul regulations that push out competition and Soft monopolies. And the ability for people who are are rich or who have built up a company within the free market to then use the state to help them create that kind of entrenchment and soft monopoly. so the state actively imposes the sort of corporate capitalism and corporations themselves are are state entities or state fictions. So the state Helps to entrench kind of corporate capitalism that we have, such that, you know, if you had a a commune, for example, that was really successful, really popular, would have a really hard time actually competing economically for the resources it needs with the broader economic system, which is propped up by the state, again, through through subsidization, through debt, through soft monopolies, through regulatory pressures. All kinds of of different ways a state executes its power. Such that in the United States you really can't functionally escape a kind of capitalistic society. You are forced to participate in a capitalist society in order to get the basics of what you need in in order to survive. And so that that relationship of exploitation between you know the one who owns the company or the means of production and and the laborer are is is real. And There are not these there there aren't these alternatives to the system. It's sort of a a softer power. It's not as direct as as the Soviet Union the Soviet Union was. but it is a s a softer power that Trends everybody towards the same kind of commodification, the same kind of capitalist society, in which at some point you either have to sell your labor for wages or you have to try to create a company in order to achieve financial independence. There is no all economic alternative to these kinds of things to the point where we don't even think about them. we're this is just what we're presented with with our options. We either become better laborers or we create our own company. And these are kind of the two paths in American Catholic society. But of course, the person, as much as they have the right to sell their labor to a capitalist for wages, they ought to have the right not to sell their labor to a capitalist for wages. They ought to have the right to be outside or to have alternatives to the or at least access to natural alternatives to selling their labor to the capitalist, meaning that not that the state needs to enforce and create alternative options, but that The state needs to essentially ne needs to be dismantled so that it doesn't use its force to entrench the same kind of capitalist system that we have, which would allow individuals to actually go out and progressively develop alternatives to a strict capitalist system. And you would sort of naturally get the the sort of mixed economy that wasn't perpetuated by the state. And wasn't solely a mixture of corporate capitalism and the welfare state, but would be a variety of different economic structures structures that would be able to meld together into in in in it in in which people could enter in and exit economic systems or economic structures or economic relationships insofar as they felt they wanted to. It wouldn't be this over. riding, over-girding economic system that was directing all of economic life, there would be a multiplicity and a great diversity of different kinds of approaches, market approaches, that would be probably as Various as there were individual interests and individual market desires. And when one thing failed, we could move on to the next. But so the moral test in you know when it comes to talking about these forced economic systems is again not the systems themselves. There's nothing inherently immoral about capitalism. There's nothing inherently immoral about communism, insofar as they are voluntary. There are going to be some people who benefit greatly and and and love to participate in a communist style kind of system or a capitalist style kind of system or a feudalist kind of system or you know some kind of economic alternative to what they're to what they're currently experiencing. There's gonna be people who are who are interested in that and because these systems are not forced, but rather they're a person can enter into them or exit out of them because these economic arrangements are not forced. by a state, by state violence, and people can enter and exit as they please because they have autonomous control over what they do with their own labor, time, resources, talents, whatever. Those who are s those who are marginalized or who are suffered by any given econom or suffer in any given economic system can simply go experiment with a new one or go enter into another a different kind of economic arrangement instead of being perpetually forced to suffer by the state. There's nothing wrong with communism so long as it's voluntary. There's nothing wrong with capitalism so long as it's voluntary. And this applies to any given economic structure that that you can think of. So the moral test here is not the economic structure itself. The moral test is autonomy. The moral test is choice. The moral test is is this voluntary or not? And if it's not, it's going to cause destruction and pain. It's going to cause economic pain. difficulties for a a vast majority of people because the economic values of people are different and there's always going to be some group that's going to be marginalized by a given economic structure, no matter how you structure. And this sort of circles back to what why I mentioned briefly in the beginning is that the you know the moral analysis of markets is always going to be far more important than the analysis of economic efficiencies. You know, one of the things that disappoints me about libertarianism, and one of the reasons why I don't consider myself a libertarian, is because it's it's been so captured by this economism, right? This especially the Austrian school of economics, where It argues for freedom or it argues for voluntarism on the basis of that it's going to be more economically efficient for the majority of people. But of course, the analysis of economic efficiency, I mean, there's some you know rational standards of analysis when it comes to economics, but economics is based on subjective value standards. It comes down to what an individual actually wants out of an economy, what they actually want to. produce or consume. And so every analysis of economic efficiency comes down to a subjective analysis of what you think what you think an economic system would benefit you for. And as I mentioned before, all those analyses of economic efficiency inevitably marginalize large swathes of people who simply don't benefit from from the same kind of system. This is just an aside about libertarianism in general. because I really want to get some distance between me and that movement. Is that I think and and this is this is specifically related to state libertarians, the minarchists, the people who believe in a in perhaps a minimal state or Yeah, very minimal state. I think part of the reason why the whole movement has has drifted into economism is because the the moral foundations of state libertarianism are contradictory and incoherent. The basic moral premise of libertarianism is that we should be free, that we should be free to act to make choices for ourselves, right? And that the state shouldn't interfere in how we live our lives. But the state libertarian at the same time arguing that we should be free, that we should have liberty, at the same time argues that we should have a military, a judicial system. An executive branch, post office, firefighters, these kinds of things. And so they're essentially making this argument: like we should be free to decide for ourselves how we're going to run our lives, except for you know these areas over here, which are necessary and beneficial to society as a whole. And we should use force in order to fund and proliferate these institutions that are basic, right? But we shouldn't go any further than that. And the premise that People should be free unless we th I think it's b necessary or beneficial to use force against them, is the same premise that the conservatives and the liberals have in different directions. You know, conservatives are more interested in social control and building up the military-industrial complex, and the liberals are more interested in using force and violence to produce the welfare state. And economic equity and whatnot. But the they're not shy about saying, yes, we should use state violence to achieve our subjective goals about what is right and wrong and force it on everybody else. They're not shy about that. They're very explicit about that. But the libertarian says, no, I'm about freedom, and then makes the same move subtly about using force and violence against people to create institutions that they think are beneficial to the rest of society. And so I think that. state libertarian morality ends up being incredibly underdeveloped. Because a consistent consistent libertarian ideology would lead you into to anarchism, anarchism or extreme voluntarism, like like myself. I consider myself a voluntarist, anarchist, different kind of beast, but you know, stateless voluntarist, right? And The state is libertarian, if they're going to be morally consistent, either has to say, We get rid of the state altogether, and comes an anarchist or a voluntarist, or They're going to embrace the use of state power and violence for the sake of their own ends. And i it it's more rationally coherent for them to sit in one of the the conservative or liberal camps. But they they s occupy this strange, morally incoherent position. And I think the more perceptive of state libertarians recognize this. And so when you can't argue morally for your position. you have to depend on arguments of economic efficiency. And this is where the bulk of libertarian state libertarian intellectual thought has gone into the question of okay, well, wouldn't a capitalistic or wouldn't a free society be economically efficient for the most amount of people? And they're hoping that that's going to be compelling for people, though. No philosophical movement has gotten off the ground by arguing for economic efficiency, not even Marxism. Marxism at the very least tries to smuggle in moral arguments for equality and historical inevitability where the status libertarian focused on economism doesn't do this. They're just arguing for economic efficiency. And then not only that, but the arguments themselves get incredibly bogged down into Subjective economic analysis and technical language, which the vast majority of people really can't follow unless they themselves, you know, study Austrian economics or or Milton Friedman or you know certain aspects of the Chicago school incredibly in depth, right? And so it's not it's not even compelling and the sorry, the economism is not really compelling except to a very few amount of people who are willing to dedicate themselves to an understanding of it. And ultimately it doesn't have the same bite as the morality, right? The moral argument is the is the most important argument because it it comes before economic efficiency. People are willing to to suffer you know economic pain for the sake of what they perceive to be right. Because what is right is ultimately more important than the money in your pocket. Or at least that's the way it should be, and that's the way w human beings intuit it. And so I think libertarianism has, you know, completely well, it's the state libertarianism is i is simply incoherent on the moral side, which is why they've been captured by this economism, but it completely fails. And I think if you're going to be a morally consistent libertarianism, it's important that you you take that to his logical concl conclusion, which is in voluntarist anarchism. But all that aside, and that's a little bit of a side, I I I just get frustrated with libertarians sometimes because it's almost it's almost easier to have a conversation with with statists, right? With conservatives and liberals. It's it's easy to have a conversation with statists because you know where the argument is. The argument is in a disagreement over the morality of force and violence. But with libertarian, it it's like on the one hand they agree with you that force and violence is wrong, except over here. And trying to bridge that gap is tr one of the most frustrating things. And then the conversations tend to always slip again back into these, you know, arguments of economics necessity. So they start talking about the minarchist state as necessary for a stable economy, as if a stable economy were were the goal of most people. so you try to bring it to the moral level and it just gets brought back and back into economism. And I wish the whole movement would just either buck up and have some moral consistency enough to come to the anarchist voluntarist per perspective, or else, you know, go be go be a statist with the rest of them and and promote whatever you want subjectively through force and violence. But anyway, getting back to you know, the discussion of morality applied to The nature of the market. Some people might be looking at, you know, my description of a free market where all these different kinds of systems blend together as unrealistic for one for one reason or another. Now, I would say on a mass scale, this really hasn't been allowed to happen throughout history. There's always been the state there violently promoting its own economic kinds of structures. But one model I can give to you. just so you can might might be imagining it, is actually everyday life. for the most part in our day-to-day interactions, we kind of follow this intuitively. I mean we we you know we go to work and we let's say we participate in the the capitalist system there, right? And but a lot of us are You know, we'll we'll we'll make these sort of side deals with people, right? So we say, well, you know, my my daughter needs some some money for college. Like can you can you can she babysit for you, right? And then there'll be some sort of payment for for babysitting on the side, right? Or we'll go to our churches and they'll ask us for donations and we'll donate to them, right? Or we'll work we'll work for free them, we'll barter with each other and borrow things and we need to. my church, for example, I mean, interestingly enough, for being such a a relatively conservative church, it's kind of communistic in the sense that people people voluntarily and collectively donate to its organization, to the organization. And then, you know, if I or somebody else ever needed something for whatever reason, we could very well go to the church as members and say, you know, hey, I I need I I really need my my rent covered this week for you know, cause something happened. And the church has and will just help people out that way. besides using that money for for donating to other kinds of organizations and causes and whatnot. You know, there are people out there who they have these these little farms that they run and they make j like just enough money in order to, you know, sell that produce on at the farmers market and kinda just live in their homes or whatnot. The the family unit is incredibly communistic in the sense that we don't have the expectation that our children are going to sort of y you know, pull their weight and contribute to the economics of the household as much as we sort of self sacrificially give to them. On an on an almost unconscious basis, we we in our everyday lives, even though we're structurally dominated by a capitalist society, we weave in and out of different economic arrangements all the time. Without even noticing it. And in the same way, this can happen on a larger scale. I mean, again, it's you know, economics just comes down to individual people. And people, if we get rid of the the force and violence to inflict one kind of economic system on a society, then we'll be able to. Weave in and out of different economic s scenarios and situations, which have a variety of flavors, if you will, to produce and get the things that we that we want and need, because it will be a free voluntary exchange. And it'll be the economic systems, the things that pertain to the world, the economic arrangements that pertain in the world will be a representation of what people actually value, not what they're forced to participate in. Because when those systems break or or don't work, people will voluntarily and freely move on to those things Which will work, right? Again, as a as another aside, just I want to talk about, you know, how the state benefits from this this our the sort of mixed economy that we have. Like why does the state use its violence to promote this kind of economy, which is neither purely capitalistic nor is it purely socialist, but rather it's sort of corporate socialism, if you will. You know, one of the things you have to understand about the state and the bureaucracy is that it's trying to sustain itself by exploiting the the citizens through through taxation, right? So it's it's trying to extract as many resources as it can from the population without sort of destroying it, right? It's it's useful to kind of think of of the state to citizen relationship as like, you know, farmers and chickens. Right, farmers have all different kinds of of methods for raising chickens and collecting their eggs, right? And you know, some farmers benefit, believe they benefit from you know, caging the chickens up really tightly, not giving them any room, you know, pumping them full of antibiotics and just you know having this sort of machine-based collection. And some farmers over here. believe if you have free-range chickens that are allowed to roam and kind of do what they want, they'll produce more and better eggs. And there's debates about that. But but this kind of exploitative relationship or or the ways that the state molds its economic system is based on okay, what economic system is going to produce the the most so that we can extract the most. And this is what the the sort of mixed economy does for the state. on the one hand, the the capitalist mode of production seems to be pretty efficient at creating goods and services in such abundance that the state then can can tax at a relatively ro l low rate while still raking in, you know, trillions of dollars or trillions of of of resources every year without upsetting the Apple cart too much. Because of course, you know, the the people as a whole, they they if you tax them too much, they They sort of get mad at that, right? They're gonna vote you out. So the kind of tax rate that you need to keep is just just high enough to get as much resources as you as you can without pissing them off. And this is best achieved on our capitalistic system because the resources produced are so abundant that the state can can can tax at a lower rate, but still receive a tremendous amount of resources from the population. On the other hand, if you're somebody who wants to to gain and maintain power in the kind of democracies that you have, then you have to be willing to sort of prostitute yourself and the state f for their perceived benefits, right? So this is essentially where the welfare state comes about, where a lot of the safety nets, social safety nets and and entitlement programs, these things kind kind of come from is that Politicians come up and they promise the people who are are going to vote that if you vote for me, I am going to use the violence of the state to you know, either steal from future generations or steal from other people, or use the violence of the state in in some way to to benefit you directly through these different kinds of programs. So I'm gonna pay for your retirement, I'm gonna pay for your healthcare, I'm gonna pay for when you lose your job, I'm gonna do this for you, I'm gonna do that for you. I'm gonna continually increase the power of the state for the sake of of benefiting benefiting you, right? And that's how they get elected, is that they they kind of just prostitute the power of the state to people to the highest bidder. And who whatever politician does this in the best way is typically the one that that or the most convincing way usually gets this usually gets the votes. If they're not busy utilizing the strategy of blaming the problems. on you know, foreigners or whatnot. And so the mixed economy allows the politicians and the state to kind of do both at the same time, right? On the one hand they can prostitute the power of the state, to essentially bribe the people who are gonna vote for them, whether or not it ends up having long term consequences or not. And on the other hand, the the capitalist mode of production that underlies the the main thrust of the economy allows them to tax at a lower rate while still receiving a tremendous amount of resources to sustain their own their own lifestyle and bureaucracy. We have to understand the degree to which force actually derail derails economic creativity and experimentation in the world. because the state has has ubiquitously forced these economic systems in the past, whether it was in Russia or China or in the US today, this delimits and derails all kinds of economic creativity and experimentation that could have happened. If it weren't for the the force and violence of the state. a kind of economic creativity that honestly we it's hard to really imagine. I mean, imagine if you you tried to go back in time to you know, s a medieval peasant and explain to them our economy, right? Explain to them that, you know, the majority of work that's done is done these little boxes that communicate through a cloud and that, you know, only one percent of the population actually does the agriculture anymore. And people live in these in these you know humongous buildings that reach up to vast heights. I mean just just trying to explain the daily economic structure of our lives to somebody even a thousand years ago would prove incredibly difficult. And so speculating on on actually how different our economic systems would be if the government would just allow us to act for the sake of what we truly value and create our own economic systems as we saw fit, it it it's really almost impossible to to speculate on or To give you a concrete example of, but we know that whenever the whenever there's force involved, it derails creativity, derails experimentation. People are forced to just conform themselves to whatever they have available rather than being able to to experiment and and develop different kinds of of systems. what this creates economically is this cycle cycle of economic marginalization and and power grabbing. As, you know, you get one economic system that dominates, right? So you get the the industrial revolution comes up, right? And, you know, the something like the Industrial Revolution in in England, for example, was forced by the state through, you know, forcing people off their land into the cities, creating all kinds of different kinds of problems. And tons of people were marginalized and suffered because of that. There was massive exploitations that didn't really have anything to do with capitalism in and of itself, but from the power of the st from the violence and the power of the state. And of course this creates disenchantment, this creates the underclass, the proletariat, whatever. And then these people who have been marginalized, then they get riled up. They they seek a change in the economic structure. They're, you know, in Marx's analysis, they would they would eventually transform into communists, but it looks like basically the people agitated for what we now call socialism, safety net these kinds of things, they changed the the economic structure into something that's more socialistic, something that we have today in the United States and in Europe and those kinds of economic systems ultimately create marginalization and disenfranchisement and then another group of people that the n the new group of people who are marginalized and they seek power in order to change the the social order. And now you're seeing the rise of like neo-fascist movements and and nationalist movements that are coming out as a reaction to social socialist economic system and Eventually that will create a a new marginalization a new marginalized group who will seek power to rearrange the the the economic system once again. And it just creates this cycle again and again and again of, you know, economic system which marginalizes a group of people who then seeks power to change the economic system, which marginalizes a new group of people, who then seek power to create a new economic system that marginalizes a group. And it's the same mistake over and over again. It's the same mistake of I'm going, we're going to use force to impose this one economic structure on everybody else, causing that same marginalization, that same exploitation, and that same upheaval. And all of this results in incredible economic inefficiency, right? Instead of people just being able to directly act for the sake of what they value within the market, they have to go through all of these hoops in order to literally try to structurally change society so that they can act for the sake of what they value. They're completely cut off from economic creativity and experimentation of different kinds of economic arrangements which should be beneficial to People in ways that we can't yet really understand. And so all this force, all the the force of the ubiquitous economic system and force in general just causes incredible economic efficiency, even after the fact that it's it's immoral and it's it's violence and force base and we wouldn't accept it on any kind of individual level. And really just to show you kind of how absurd I I think this is, you know, it kind of reminds me of if somebody, if somebody with some politician or state or government said, you know, you know, this country, we we are a vanilla country. You know, we are a we are a vanilla country. We do not eat anything other than vanilla flavored things, right? or let's say we're a vanilla ice cream country. So instead of saying, We're a capitalist society. We're a vanilla ice cream society. And the government or the state or whatever use the violence of the state to impose vanilla ice cream as the only kind of ice cream that you could eat, right? And imagine how absurd that would be. Imagine how absurd it would be that the different societies would be arguing with people, the entire disciplines of knowledge would be arguing with one another about, you know, whether or not we should have a a vanilla ice cream based society or chocolate ice cream based society. And and just going back and forth on that, right? And and you know, using all their their time, energy and intellect in order to to kind of discuss that and and force it on people. And how that would completely destroy anybody's ability to kind of just have the ice cream that they wanted and experiment with different kinds of flavors or maybe have swirls of vanilla and chocolate or go out there and create new flavors or what have you. I believe that economic conversations can can get to the point of being as as really as trivial and as subjective as you know conversations over the best flavor of ice cream. Because eventually, ultimately they come down to subjective evaluations. But the presence of force, the presence of forcing these economic systems ubiquitously, makes it so that people have to devote all kinds of time and thought and energy to combating the economic system of their society that marginalizes, disenfranchises, and harms them in order to gain the freedom to pursue another. d are different kind of economic system. But again, they just repeat the same mistake by forcing the new economic system on everybody else, marginalizing, disenfranchising, and harming other people who go on to do the same kind of thing. But I believe that we can get to a point, you know, if we take this philosophy of voluntarism seriously, we can get to a point where the the different economic arrangements of one's day are as fluid and as subjective and as trivial decisions to make. as the next flavor of ice cream that you're going to eat. So so what do you guys think? You know, do you do you think that these different kinds of economic structures can coexist? You know, do you think is it is it moral to force any kind of system at all on society at the exclusion of others? Comment down below and and let me know what you think. And if you like this video, please like it. If you think this would be interesting to somebody else, please share it with them. If you want to see more videos like this, please subscribe. And as always, thank you for listening.