353: Police Took Years To Solve Her Murder... Her Killer Hid In Plain Sight

Mile Higher · Jul 10, 2025 · 1h 13m

Support our Sponsors:

Rocket Money: https://zocdoc.com/milehigher

Upwork: https://upwork.com/save

Function Health: https://functionhealth.com/milehigher

Hungry Root: https://hungryroot.com/milehigher

Intro 0:00

Katelyn Markham's Early Life 4:56

Meeting John Carter 10:02

Katelyn Goes Missing 12:27

The Search Begins 14:24

John's Concern for Katelyn 21:58

Pointing Fingers 27:47

Finding the Remains 28:47

Investigating a Homicide 33:57

The Police Drop the Ball 39:08

John Becomes More Suspicious 43:02

The Facade Falls 51:23

Arrested for Murder 1:03:01

No Justice 1:10:37

Final Thoughts & Outro…