Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Seeking the Truth—Applying the Dependency Hearsay Exception to Family Law DVPA Matters
Transcript
- 0:03I'm Jack McMorrow. I am the co -chair of the
- 0:08Beverly Hills Bar Association Family Law Section.
- 0:11Welcome to Seeking the Truth, Applying the Dependency
- 0:15Hearsay Exemption to Family Law DVPA Matters.
- 0:19The Family Law Section is sponsored by White,
- 0:22Zuckerman, Worzowski, Luna, and Hunt. Lawyers
- 0:27Mutual Insurance Company, Soberlink, and Our
- 0:30Family Wizard. White, Zuckerman, Worzowski, Luna,
- 0:34and Hunt provides a wide variety of resources
- 0:37to complete almost any project, large or small.
- 0:40They also provide traditional accounting and
- 0:42tax practice services. We invite you to contact
- 0:46them to discuss your specific accounting needs
- 0:48and learn how they can be of service to you.
- 0:51Learn more at WZWLH .com. Silverlink provides
- 0:56objective, real -time data that can be used to
- 0:59reduce disputes over alcohol consumption, leading
- 1:01to less conflict in custody cases. To help ensure
- 1:04smoother negotiations for a more efficient legal
- 1:08process, consider using Silverlink's trusted
- 1:11alcohol monitoring system to eliminate hearsay
- 1:14and protect your client's best interests. With
- 1:17an unprecedented combination of features, including
- 1:20advanced reporting, facial recognition, tamper
- 1:23resistance, real -time results, and customized
- 1:26testing, this discrete system has been the leader
- 1:29in remote alcohol monitoring since 2011. Learn
- 1:33more at soberlink .com. For five decades, Boyer's
- 1:38Mutual Insurance Company has been the only California
- 1:41-based company to continuously provide throughout
- 1:45the state with professional liability insurance
- 1:48coverage. Their experience and expertise are
- 1:52complemented by the fact that LMIC is directed
- 1:55by a group of dedicated lawyers. They offer special
- 1:58rates with competitive premiums for a wide range
- 2:01of areas of practice, including family law. Learn
- 2:04more at lawyersmutual .com. Our Family Wizard
- 2:07is a co -parenting platform designed to help
- 2:10families communicate more effectively, reduce
- 2:12conflicts, and create reliable court admissible
- 2:15record. Features like tone meter, AI, shared
- 2:20calendars, expense tracking, and in -app audio
- 2:24and video calling help support compliance and
- 2:28better outcomes for families navigating custody
- 2:30matters. With that said, I am delighted to introduce
- 2:34our speakers for today. Judges Janine Idarte
- 2:39and Hank Goldberg. Judge Idarte, I asked about
- 2:46this. I'm so sorry. Oh, that's okay. Why don't
- 2:50you say it? Idarte. Judge Idarte serves as a
- 2:55judge of the Superior Court of Los Angeles County
- 2:58in California. She was appointed to the bench
- 3:01by Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger in 2009 and
- 3:04has been reelected. Her current term extends
- 3:08until January 8, 2029. Judge Ediarte earned her
- 3:14bachelor's degree from California State Polytechnic
- 3:17University, Pomona, and her JD from Loyola Law
- 3:21School. Before her judicial appointment, she
- 3:24worked as a deputy district attorney for the
- 3:26Los Angeles County. Judge Goldberg has earned
- 3:30a statewide reputation for his expertise in family
- 3:34law and general litigation matters. Appointed
- 3:36to the Los Angeles Superior Court as a judge
- 3:39in 2003, he spent six years in criminal court
- 3:43and 10 years in family law court. He managed
- 3:46all types of family law disputes and also has
- 3:49extensive experience handling high profile and
- 3:52celebrity cases as an assistant supervising judge
- 3:55of family law. For four years, Judge Goldberg
- 3:58ran the Family Law Settlement Court, where he
- 4:01settled thousands of family law matters and related
- 4:04civil cases. His exceptional settlement rate
- 4:07earned him an excellent representation for resolving
- 4:10matters and offering creative solutions for complex
- 4:14financial and child custody matters. He served
- 4:18two terms as the assistant supervising judge
- 4:22of the Family Law Division. And now... Let's
- 4:25get started with a wonderful presentation. Thank
- 4:28you so much. Take it away. Thank you. Good afternoon.
- 4:37Thank you to the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 4:39for your continued dedication to continuing education
- 4:43to the bar and to the bench. Today we're talking
- 4:45about a hearsay exception that was developed
- 4:48in dependency court that allows admission of
- 4:51hearsay statements of children to prove abuse
- 4:54and neglect. That's a dependency. But this exception
- 4:57is now applicable in the DVPA in sexual abuse
- 5:01cases. You need to pay special attention to this
- 5:05case law and fully understand the history of
- 5:08how this exception was developed and came about
- 5:11so you'll be prepared when you encounter this
- 5:14one in court. For many years, the dependency
- 5:18has had their own statutory and case law exceptions
- 5:21to the hearsay rule. And we in family law thought
- 5:25that we were witnessing all of it from a safe
- 5:28distance. But apparently that is not the case.
- 5:32The gates have been opened, so to speak, and
- 5:35it remains to be seen how much hearsay is going
- 5:38to come through. This is a new area of law for
- 5:44us. Our goal is that by the end of this presentation,
- 5:48you will feel a level of expertise and comfort
- 5:52with it. You will know more than about 95 % of
- 5:57family law attorneys. And if you're still a little
- 6:00confused, don't worry. That just means you understand
- 6:03it. Okay, so the case is in Ray marriage of MP
- 6:12versus MC. And in this case, wife and husband
- 6:17were getting a divorce after six months of marriage.
- 6:20In July of 22, she filed for the dissolution.
- 6:23And then nine months later, she sought a domestic
- 6:26violence restraining order alleging that husband
- 6:29had sexually abused her 13 year old daughter.
- 6:32That was from a separate relationship. Please
- 6:35note that wife and husband did have a four year
- 6:38old child together. So contained within this
- 6:41litigation were the custody and visitation issues
- 6:44as to that four year old child. Now the 13 year
- 6:47old daughter of the wife alleged that the husband
- 6:50had touched her vaginal area. And then upon further
- 6:53reporting, she had indicated that there was a
- 6:55second day where he had actually stuck his fingers
- 6:58into her vaginal area. During the hearing, the
- 7:02Wife's affidavit brought in the child's statements.
- 7:07And the husband objected to those statements
- 7:09in the affidavit saying, look, the 13 -year -old
- 7:12child didn't testify. That's hearsay. I object.
- 7:16Well, the court allowed it in. And then the court
- 7:18issued the domestic violence restraining order.
- 7:21It was appealed. And the court of appeal said
- 7:23the child dependency hearsay exception applies
- 7:27to the DVPA proceedings. based on sexual abuse
- 7:31of a minor. And the court articulated three prerequisites
- 7:39to getting in this evidence that actually come
- 7:41from one of the seminal cases we're going to
- 7:43be discussing with you, which is the Cindy Yale
- 7:45case. And in Cindy Yale, it says that these are
- 7:51requirements, presumably the proponent has to
- 7:54establish to get the evidence in. The first is
- 7:58the proponent has to show that the time, content,
- 8:02and circumstances of the statement must provide
- 8:05sufficient indicia of reliability. So I just
- 8:09want to highlight this. So this exception, like
- 8:12many statutory hearsay exceptions, contains a
- 8:16reliability requirement. If it's not reliable
- 8:19in the trial judge's view, it's not coming in.
- 8:25mp vs mc they said that it was reliable because
- 8:30the thirteen -year -old had made consistent statements
- 8:33on different dates in different settings to different
- 8:36people and the court of appeal at least felt
- 8:39that that was an addition of reliability. Second,
- 8:45the minor must either be available for cross
- 8:48-examination, or there must be some evidence
- 8:51which corroborates the statements made by the
- 8:54child. Now, again, Cindy L. said this was a requirement,
- 8:59but there was no evidence in MP versus MC regarding
- 9:04the child's availability one way or the other.
- 9:08So it seems as if we're going to talk a little
- 9:11bit more about that. This element number two
- 9:14may be downplayed or maybe even ignored by this
- 9:19new case. They said that the respondent could
- 9:23have subpoenaed the child or witness to the statements
- 9:26and apparently did not do so. And then the third
- 9:30requirement is the opposing party must have had
- 9:34adequate notice that the statements would be
- 9:36introduced at the hearing. However, it would
- 9:39appear that the declaration, the DVRO, disclosing
- 9:45what those statements are in and of itself is
- 9:48considered to be adequate notice in order to
- 9:52be able to introduce those statements. So if
- 9:56we if we look at that element three No, actually
- 9:58element two where the respondent could have subpoenaed
- 10:01the child or the witness in this case So does
- 10:04that now mean Judge Goldberg that before you
- 10:07start a restraining order hearing you actually
- 10:09have to subpoena the other parent to the hearing
- 10:11Thereby subpoenaing the child requesting that
- 10:14yeah Perhaps the other parent because because
- 10:16it may be that the respondents in the DVRO Has
- 10:20no potentially no custody or maybe monitored
- 10:23visits as is so frequently the case. There's
- 10:29an unwritten rule, or at least there used to
- 10:31be an unwritten rule in family law, that you
- 10:34don't subpoena a child to the hearing or ask
- 10:38a child to participate in a hearing without clearing
- 10:41it first with the court. And as a practical matter,
- 10:45that may be difficult to do, impossible to do,
- 10:48unless there's a continuance. But I would try
- 10:51in some manner to discuss it at least with opposing
- 10:55counsel, you know, gosh, I know that you're relying
- 10:59on this relatively new for us and family law
- 11:02hearsay exception. Are we going to subpoena the
- 11:05kid? Are we going to bring the kid in? And then
- 11:07better yet, try to get some pre -authorization
- 11:10by the court. Correct. And then once before the
- 11:13court, if the court allows it, you actually don't
- 11:15have to issue the subpoena, but just have the
- 11:17court order the parent to make the child available
- 11:19if that's what the decision is in the case. But
- 11:22I agree with you. I don't think we should have
- 11:24children waiting outside the courtroom because
- 11:26we have to be prepared on the hearing. I do think
- 11:28that it is something that we should be approaching
- 11:30with the court for the protection of the minor
- 11:32children. Judge Ariarte, as a practical matter,
- 11:37are you either yourself or your colleagues seeing
- 11:41this, again, for us relatively new hearsay exception
- 11:45being argued? Are they applying it? Are the attorneys
- 11:49trying to get evidence in? What's your experience
- 11:52with what's happening? I have a case is relatively
- 11:55new. I haven't had any cases before me where
- 11:58the attorneys have argued it. However, I have
- 12:00been speaking with lawyers within the community
- 12:02and they have told me, in fact, the judges are
- 12:05using the dependency exception in just everyday
- 12:09hearings, in dealing with abuse, sex, just regular
- 12:13physical abuse, including sexual abuse, and the
- 12:16judge is letting it in. So it's already being
- 12:19applied, but I think it's going beyond what MP
- 12:22and MC is saying currently. So what is the practical
- 12:28application of this look like? And I wanna share
- 12:31with you a case that I had. I had a case where
- 12:34a 13 year old child made an allegation that her
- 12:38father had molested her. The mother filed the
- 12:40affidavit and in the affidavit, the mother attached
- 12:44the child's diary, which went on and on and on.
- 12:47I can't tell you how many pages that this child
- 12:50was writing about her struggles of how much she
- 12:52loved her father and how she was so devastated
- 12:56about how he was touching her. But, you know,
- 12:59breaking up the family would be something that
- 13:01she wouldn't want to do. And she was completely
- 13:03tormented in her diary. The child was outside
- 13:06the courtroom. So when I did the hearing, I noted
- 13:09the age of the child, and these two were in pro
- 13:12-per. So what I did is I noted the age of the
- 13:15child, that she was 13 years old. I noted who
- 13:18was involved in the initial report. And in this
- 13:20case, she had actually went to school and she
- 13:22reported it to a friend. The friend reported
- 13:25it to the teacher. Teacher then reported it to
- 13:27law enforcement. Social workers got involved.
- 13:30Mom ended up. getting obviously being reported
- 13:33to her through that realm. But I noticed how
- 13:36many people were involved in the initial report.
- 13:39I noticed that the statements were being made
- 13:41to other people. They were consistent. There
- 13:44was some indicia of reliability also noting that
- 13:47the statements were contained within the diary
- 13:49and again noted the additional reporting. I noted
- 13:53again the child was outside the courtroom. available
- 13:57for testimony. And then I turned to the father
- 14:01in this case and I And I asked him, do you want
- 14:03to tell me what happened in this case? And, you
- 14:06know, might you have touched her, you know, just
- 14:09on accident? And he said, well, yeah, on accident,
- 14:11I may have just touched her breast. I may have
- 14:14touched her vaginal area. Because what we do
- 14:16every week is we play with teddy bears and we
- 14:19wrestle pretty much so every single day. So there
- 14:21was some type of grooming testimony that was
- 14:24elicited during this hearing. And based upon
- 14:27that, I really felt like there was enough reliable
- 14:30information before the court. to move on and
- 14:33actually assert this dependency exception. The
- 14:37final thing that I did is I did also ask mom,
- 14:40tell me about your relationship. Where are you
- 14:42two at? And the mother was just bawling in court
- 14:45and saying how much she loved the father and
- 14:48she's not intending on divorcing him and she
- 14:50has no idea what they're going to do from here.
- 14:53There's no divorce pending. And so after I went
- 14:55through all of those criteria, again, I said,
- 14:58I'm invoking the dependency exception and I'm
- 15:00bringing the minor statement in through that
- 15:02exception. So the minor child did not testify
- 15:05in that case, but that is a more recent practical
- 15:08application that actually took place in my courtroom.
- 15:13Let's look at where did this dependency exception
- 15:16begin? Where did it all start? There's two cases.
- 15:20Two dependency cases. The first one is Inri Carmen
- 15:23O, and the second one is Inri Cindy L. And again,
- 15:27these are dependency cases. And so Inri Carmen
- 15:33O is the seminal case on this, and the case that
- 15:37apparently coined this statement, child dependency
- 15:42exception, which before that had not been recognized,
- 15:46I don't think, anywhere, let alone California.
- 15:50uh... in that particular case carmen's thirteen
- 15:53-year -old sister ruby testified that carmen
- 15:57was crying and said that she hurt her private
- 16:00parts carmen said the daddy put his cucumber
- 16:03in my private part in a few days before dad put
- 16:07his finger in in my but i want you to notice
- 16:10here this is the the the language that was used
- 16:13at the childlike language which was important
- 16:17to the court uh... in this particular case and
- 16:20others uh... carmen's psychologist advised the
- 16:24court that carmen would be afraid to testify
- 16:26in front of her father she did not speak english
- 16:30uh... she would not testify with the use of an
- 16:33interpreter and she would have difficulty in
- 16:35general testifying the doctor's predictions were
- 16:39accurate carmen would not respond to questions
- 16:42by the court she kept her head down and was staring
- 16:45at her hands And the court found at the jurisdictional
- 16:49hearing that Carmen was not competent to testify
- 16:53as a witness likely due to fear. I want, again,
- 16:56to highlight another significant point here.
- 16:59The court found that she was not competent due
- 17:02to fear. The court did not find that she was
- 17:05not competent due to an inability to distinguish
- 17:08truthful from false testimony. And the Court
- 17:12of Appeal itself thought that that was an interesting
- 17:15distinction. Now, would the result have been
- 17:18different if the court said that she was not
- 17:19competent to distinguish truth from falsity?
- 17:22Maybe, but not entirely clear. Carmen repeated
- 17:29her accusations of sexual abuse to the children's
- 17:32hospital social workers saying that her father
- 17:35had put his penis in her private parts many times.
- 17:38I believe she used cucumber there again also.
- 17:42And this is another important feature I want
- 17:45you to take note of. The medical examination
- 17:48indicated consistency with possible hymen injury.
- 17:53So there was physical corroboration at another
- 17:55point that was mentioned by the Carmino Court.
- 17:59And they found that the evidence was admissible.
- 18:03They listed a number of factors that they felt
- 18:06were important in determining that the statements
- 18:10were reliable. Again, reliability, one of the
- 18:13elements of this exception. I'm not going to
- 18:16read all of them to you, starting with the first
- 18:19one. These were spontaneous statements which
- 18:23did not result from suggestive or leading questioning.
- 18:28Very important, and what I suggest you do, take
- 18:32the slide out when this issue comes up and use
- 18:36as a checklist to compare it against your case.
- 18:40If you're trying to get the evidence in, how
- 18:42many of these factors are present in your case
- 18:45in order for you to argue it should be admitted?
- 18:49Conversely, you're trying to keep it out. How
- 18:51do you distinguish this case and others? from
- 18:55your particular case. So starting with the spontaneous
- 18:58statements, what we have seen, I've seen over
- 19:02and over again, family law cases, you know, often
- 19:05follow certain patterns, is we are submitted
- 19:10a tape recording from a parent in which they
- 19:15were questioning the child, sometimes in a leading
- 19:20and suggestive manner, and saying something like,
- 19:23Oh, Billy, did mommy give you a bad touch? And
- 19:28the kid says, I don't want to talk about it,
- 19:31dad. And the dad's, well, it's OK. You can talk
- 19:35about it. Remember, we talked about good touches
- 19:37and bad touches. And finally, the kid makes some
- 19:41statement. That's very, very different, very
- 19:47different from the Carmen O case, from the Cindy
- 19:51L case. from even MP versus MC. So I want you
- 19:57to be sensitive to that. Skipping over to the
- 20:03last two items on the slide. No motive for Carmen
- 20:07to lie or exaggerate in her statements. And also,
- 20:12she loved her father, played with him, and apparently
- 20:15did not become disaffected. from him because
- 20:19of the sexual acts with her. Now, obviously it's
- 20:22understandable that a child that was abused might
- 20:26become disaffected, right? It's understandable.
- 20:30But frequently what we are faced with in our
- 20:34cases is a situation in which the child has become
- 20:39estranged from the accused parent and where sometimes
- 20:43there's evidence that the child themselves may
- 20:47have an agenda in the case. And so that may be
- 20:51a point of distinction between the typical family
- 20:54law case that we're likely to see, that you're
- 20:56likely to handle, and what happened in some of
- 20:59these other three published cases that we're
- 21:02going to be discussing with you. The next case
- 21:07is in race Cindy L. Again, this is the other
- 21:09dependency case. And in this case, the child
- 21:12was three years old. During a nap time, she was
- 21:15at her daycare and the teacher's aide noticed
- 21:18that Cindy was lying on her back with her legs
- 21:20spread open, touching her vaginal area with both
- 21:23hands. And when asked, hey, Cindy, like, what
- 21:26are you doing? You shouldn't be doing that. Don't
- 21:28do that. The little child said, well, my father
- 21:31always touches me right there. The court of appeal
- 21:36in this case said really focused on the specific
- 21:40due process protections that Judge Goldberg has
- 21:42already gone through with you and said we really
- 21:44need to develop and make sure that those due
- 21:47process protections are there. The other thing
- 21:49that they looked at in this case was they found
- 21:52that the child in this case was not competent
- 21:54to testify, similar to the other case that Judge
- 21:58Goldberg spoke about. But in this case, what
- 22:00happened was when the child was testifying, the
- 22:03child shut down during the testimony and was
- 22:06really non -responsive to a lot of the questions.
- 22:09And then when asked who touched you in your private
- 22:12part, the child said that the clown did. So the
- 22:16court found that the child was actually incompetent
- 22:19to testify that the child didn't understand the
- 22:22difference between a truth and a lie. And if
- 22:24you're found incompetent right now, today at
- 22:27the hearing, then you are not competent when
- 22:31you made the statements. But the court said,
- 22:34that's okay. It doesn't matter that the child
- 22:37is not competent to testify. It should not be
- 22:39an absolute bar to the admission of the child's
- 22:42statements. It's simply one circumstance which
- 22:45is to be considered in determining whether the
- 22:47child's statement is reliable or not. So let's
- 22:54take a really close look at in -ray marriage
- 22:56of MP and MC. In this case, there are a lot of
- 23:02factors that the court of appeal considered.
- 23:04And the way I look at this is I'm like the court
- 23:06of appeal was going in many different directions
- 23:09in this. And so that's why you're gonna see when
- 23:11I come down and tell you there's so many different
- 23:14directions. But I think you really need to look
- 23:16at these statements closely and understand what
- 23:19is the court of appeal saying. So first of all,
- 23:23the Court of Appeal looked at evidence code section
- 23:251360, which is a code that's applicable in criminal
- 23:29cases that say if there's an allegation of sexual
- 23:33abuse and the child is unavailable and there's
- 23:35corroborating evidence, that statement can come
- 23:38in with the hearing beforehand. But they're saying
- 23:41this code section here, because the statements
- 23:44are admitted in criminal court, it's further
- 23:46support that this dependency exception should
- 23:49in fact be extended to the DVPA. And please note
- 23:52that in 1360, it applies to child abuse or neglect.
- 23:58The appellate court stated that they can create
- 24:00hearsay exceptions for classes of evidence where
- 24:03there is a substantial need for the evidence.
- 24:07In other words, the only way to get the evidence
- 24:10is if we use this exception. And Judge Goldberg,
- 24:14in regard to trial courts, what do you think
- 24:15about that? It's not 100 % clear that the case
- 24:21law that we're citing does use the term appellate
- 24:24court and also uses the term decisional law.
- 24:29They're relying on evidence code sections 1200
- 24:32and 160, which in combination say that the exceptions
- 24:39to the hearsay rule are not limited to those
- 24:42that are contained in the evidence code, but
- 24:44that uh, the, the, the, to the extent that the
- 24:47law recognizes other exceptions, there may be
- 24:51other exceptions, but that's referring to decisional
- 24:53law. So that the, I think the better argument,
- 24:56in my opinion, is that courts of appeal can make
- 25:00these exceptions, that a trial court cannot,
- 25:03cannot, uh, render its own exception to the hearsay
- 25:07rule. The Court of Appeal mentioned California
- 25:12Rules of Court 5 .250, and that says that a trial
- 25:16court must note that it is in the child's best
- 25:19interest to testify in custody and visitation
- 25:22matters. And what I note here is are we dealing
- 25:26with the custody and visitation matter? Because
- 25:28we separate out custody and visitation in the
- 25:31DVPA proceedings. We're specifically dealing
- 25:34with did abuse occur, but the court of appeal
- 25:37thought it was important to mention that code
- 25:39section. They stated that the notice requirement
- 25:43the statement will be used is the actual filing
- 25:47of the DVRO that contains the child's statement.
- 25:53And they said the respondent didn't subpoena
- 25:56the child, therefore it's on you. So again, you've
- 25:59been noticed by the filing and you didn't subpoena
- 26:01the child. They noted that. Oftentimes in the
- 26:07DVPA proceedings you have self -represented litigants
- 26:09and they stated that the child will have to face
- 26:12cross -examination from their abuser and the
- 26:15purpose of the restraining order hearing is to
- 26:17prevent further acts of abuse and the DVA protective
- 26:21purpose is broad. We must similarly broadly construe
- 26:25the DVPA to accomplish the statute's purpose.
- 26:29So what they're saying here is that the actual
- 26:33DVPA hearing itself, if you subject the child
- 26:36to cross examination, that is abuse with which
- 26:40the statute intended the child to be protected
- 26:44from. They stated that the legislator envisioned
- 26:52the admission of the out -of -court statements
- 26:55from a minor for the truth at a restraining order
- 26:58hearing when it enacted the DVPA. The legislator
- 27:03empowered the trial court to issue a restraining
- 27:05order solely on the affidavit of the minor child
- 27:10or the person requesting the restraining order.
- 27:13And because the DVPA defines abuse and DV to
- 27:16include acts against the child, the legislator
- 27:19contemplated that the parent or the non -abusive
- 27:22parent or guardian, let me just say non -abusive
- 27:26parent, would be the one filing the request.
- 27:28So essentially what they're saying is that the
- 27:31legislator envisioned hearsay statements from
- 27:34minors being admitted via the affidavit without
- 27:38examination. And the legislator contemplated,
- 27:42hey, the parent's going to file on behalf of
- 27:44the child. Therefore, that hearsay statement
- 27:47should come in. This language I thought was somewhat
- 27:51confusing from the case and subject, perhaps.
- 27:54being misinterpreted as saying that the parent
- 27:58can directly file a DVRO on behalf of the child.
- 28:05I don't believe that's what it's saying. What
- 28:08actually happened in MP versus MC was the mom
- 28:13is seeking her own protective order. She was
- 28:18the petitioner. in that protective order. And
- 28:21then the children were included as protected
- 28:24parties. So we'll discuss that a little bit more
- 28:27and why that is in a little bit. They said that
- 28:35the DVPA proceedings are not subject to heightened
- 28:38pleading or proof requirements. The requirements
- 28:42of a DVPA is lower than a civil harassment restraining
- 28:45order hearing because it's by a preponderance
- 28:47of the evidence rather than clear and convincing
- 28:50evidence. And these factors show that the legislature
- 28:53was less concerned about strict procedural or
- 28:56evidentiary constraints and instead was focusing
- 28:59on giving the trial court's liberal discretion
- 29:01in deciding whether or not to grant the DVRO.
- 29:04And I think we already know this from case law
- 29:06that keeps coming down, that the Court of Appeal
- 29:09keeps saying, we give the trial court broad discretion.
- 29:12They have very broad discretion. And this suggests
- 29:15to me that there's even a broader application
- 29:17in regard to the DVPA with less evidentiary restraints.
- 29:23And then finally, the Court of Appeal stated,
- 29:26we're not creating a new hearsay exception. Instead,
- 29:29we are applying an existing exception to a comparable
- 29:33courtroom setting in which there is a substantial
- 29:36need for this class of evidence, as long as the
- 29:41evidence is otherwise reliable. And those words
- 29:44are going to be very important in your analysis
- 29:46in the future. So as I said in the introduction
- 29:52as Judge Iriarte also mentioned The question
- 29:55that we all have is exactly how far is this going
- 29:59to go? How far is it going to expand in our family
- 30:02law courts? And for instance, is it going to
- 30:07get into the area of physical abuse and neglect?
- 30:11So we all learned in law school and our professors
- 30:14drilled into us that case law can only be cited
- 30:20or has to be confined to the facts of the case.
- 30:23contained in that case. And what were the facts
- 30:28in these three cases? We were dealing with allegations
- 30:34of abuse, more particularly allegations of sexual
- 30:38abuse, not physical abuse. And then an MP versus
- 30:43MC, we said that it could apply in a restraining
- 30:47order case. So the question is, can it apply
- 30:51when some or none of those facts are present?
- 30:56And I think you're going to start confronting
- 30:58that argument. So we have a little hypothetical
- 31:00that we're going to play out. And we're actually
- 31:04going to make some arguments. I'm going to argue
- 31:07that the evidence is admissible. Judge Iriarte
- 31:10is going to say it isn't. We don't necessarily
- 31:12agree or disagree with either argument. We're
- 31:15trying to illustrate these are arguments that
- 31:18you can make. that are lawyer -like, that are
- 31:21plausible, or that you're going to need to refute
- 31:24and that you're probably going to see in the
- 31:26coming months. So in this hypothetical, a kid
- 31:30falls into a pool. I like to base my hypotheticals
- 31:34on realistic to the extent that I can scenarios
- 31:38that seem like in every fifth case I had, there
- 31:42was an allegation about a kid falling into a
- 31:45pool. So it's something we see a lot. So father
- 31:48files an ex parte for sole physical custody of
- 31:52the child. His declaration says that the five
- 31:55-year -old child told him that he fell into a
- 31:58pool in mother's house and almost drowned. So
- 32:02we have some childlike language there. And he
- 32:06was alone in the pool area when he fell in. Now,
- 32:09this is the only little bit unrealistic part
- 32:12of my hypo is that the trial court then invites
- 32:16the attorneys in to argue on the applicability
- 32:21of the child dependency hearsay exception. And
- 32:24now we're going to hear the argument that it
- 32:27is not admissible. Okay. So I'm going to argue
- 32:31first that a trial court cannot create a new
- 32:34hearsay exception. MP and MC creates an exception
- 32:38applicable only in DVRO cases. And in creating
- 32:43this exception, they said that it only applies
- 32:46to sexual abuse cases, right? And here, we're
- 32:49talking about custody and visitation. We're not
- 32:52talking about protective orders. And they really
- 32:55relied on the public policy of protecting children.
- 32:58And so, no, it doesn't apply in this type of
- 33:01hearing. And the dependency exception, again,
- 33:05focusing on it only involves sexual abuse allegations.
- 33:10So extending it over into physical abuse is no,
- 33:13we cannot do that. In Elkins versus Superior
- 33:15Court, the court held that trial courts may not
- 33:18establish legal rules conflicting with statutory
- 33:22or case law, and they specifically addressed
- 33:24hearsay. And the basis for the Cindy L. dependency
- 33:27exception is evidence code 1200 and 160 that
- 33:31says that hearsay exceptions may be recognized
- 33:34under decisional law. And under California rules
- 33:37of court, 8 .115 only published decisions have
- 33:41precedential value. Therefore, Your Honor, this
- 33:44should not come in in this request for order
- 33:47where the child may have drowned. And Your Honor,
- 33:51we argue that the court should receive this evidence.
- 33:54First, it is true that Cindy Yale did use the
- 33:58term appellate courts, but they also then repeatedly
- 34:02said over and over that courts could create new
- 34:07hearsay exceptions. They did not absolutely restrict
- 34:11it to appellate courts. we contend that this
- 34:15court, if the court thinks it is a new exception,
- 34:17has the ability to create it. But second, we
- 34:20are not asking the court to create a new exception.
- 34:25We are simply asking this court to define the
- 34:28scope and applicability of the child dependency
- 34:31exception. Cindy Yell itself specifically said
- 34:36that the scope of the exception would have to
- 34:39be determined by the courts. They specifically
- 34:42left that open. We're asking your honor to do
- 34:44this. Trial courts have, quote, broad discretion
- 34:49to determine whether a party has established
- 34:52the foundational requirements for a hearsay exception,
- 34:55end quote. That's people versus chism. So the
- 34:59court has a lot of discretion to determine the
- 35:01applicability of a given hearsay exception. It
- 35:05is true that a DVRO can be used to protect a
- 35:08child, yes. However, the health, safety, and
- 35:11welfare of a child, quote, shall be the court's
- 35:14primary concern, end quote, under family code
- 35:18section 3020A in making custody orders. So the
- 35:22child's health, safety, and welfare is every
- 35:26bit as relevant here, perhaps more relevant than
- 35:29it would be in a DVRO matter. I'd like to quote
- 35:34a little bit from the opinion, from MP versus
- 35:38MC. It says, quote, moreover, dependency cases
- 35:43and DVPA restraining order hearings involve a
- 35:48minor, share a similar goal of protecting the
- 35:51minor. On page 1111, it said, quote, but the
- 35:56Supreme Court in Sindial did not rely. on any
- 36:00particular procedural safeguard or statutory
- 36:03framework that was unique to dependency proceedings
- 36:07in recognizing the hearsay exception. Instead,
- 36:12the Supreme Court focused on creating hearsay
- 36:15exceptions for classes of evidence for which
- 36:18there is a substantial need and which possess
- 36:21intrinsic reliability, end quote. It would simply
- 36:25be illogical completely illogical to conclude
- 36:30that this type of statement would come in in
- 36:33a DVPA hearing, but not in an RFO hearing. That's
- 36:39not a logical distinction. We ask the court receive
- 36:42it. And one thing, Judge Goldberg, remember that
- 36:46in MP versus MC, they did talk about California
- 36:50rules of court 5 .250, where, again, they specifically
- 36:53noted that the trial court must note that it's
- 36:56in the best interest in custody and visitation
- 37:00matters, that they have to note it's in the best
- 37:02interest of the child to actually testify. And
- 37:04so they're saying that that code applies in evaluating
- 37:08this. Yeah, even though strictly speaking, it
- 37:11really applies to kids expressing an opinion
- 37:15about custody matters, but they seem to be suggesting
- 37:19that by analogy, we'd have to consider it outside
- 37:22of that limited context. Right. So that's what
- 37:26we're talking about. You really need to look
- 37:28at this closely and look at what gatekeeping
- 37:30needs to take place. So Let's take a look. Let's
- 37:34kind of take that bird's eye view and look at
- 37:37the three cases that we've been talking about.
- 37:39Number one, we have Inray Carmen O. Again, four
- 37:43-year -old child, sexual abuse allegation, physical
- 37:47corroborating evidence, child incompetent to
- 37:51testify. Inray Cindy L, three -year -old child,
- 37:56sexual abuse allegation. physical corroborating
- 38:00evidence, and the child is incompetent to testify.
- 38:03And then when we come to MP versus MC, we have
- 38:07a 13 -year -old child, child is available to
- 38:10testify, sexual abuse allegation only, no physical
- 38:15corroborating evidence. And I think if we really
- 38:19take a close look at these cases, I think there's
- 38:21been a big jump from Inray Carmineau and Cindy
- 38:24L to MP versus MC. A huge jump. Yeah, because
- 38:31the features of those cases that were so important
- 38:35to the courts were the corroborating evidence
- 38:38and the unavailability of the child. And there
- 38:42was no corroborating evidence in MP versus MC,
- 38:45and there was no showing of unavailability of
- 38:48the child. So it's a significant leap forward.
- 38:55So I guess my question is, I think my question
- 38:58is, does MP and MC go too far? That's my question.
- 39:02Because I think what we have now is we have a
- 39:04door wide open. And I've already told you that
- 39:07courts are already applying this outside of the
- 39:09DVPA. And I think what's going to end up happening,
- 39:12and this is why you have to understand the case
- 39:14law and where this came from, is that cases are
- 39:16going to start going up on appeal. And I think
- 39:18it needs to go to the United States Supreme Court
- 39:21for an actual decision in this matter. Or we're
- 39:24going to have to have a statutory legislative
- 39:27law written in this area that put those guards
- 39:31well up and make sure that it is safe and that
- 39:34due process is being upheld. Some food for thought.
- 39:41Okay, I want to tell you guys a little bit about
- 39:43a case that I had. I had a 13 year old bring
- 39:46a domestic violence protective order. request
- 39:50and the dad was represented in court and the
- 39:53girl alleged that dad had been hit put his put
- 39:56his hand on her leg and touched her inappropriately
- 39:59and he was showing her pornographic movies. She
- 40:02was online during the proceeding and you know
- 40:06we started the proceeding I just felt like something
- 40:08wasn't right in the proceeding and I said you
- 40:10know do me a favor right now I want you to take
- 40:13that that. computer screen I want you to turn
- 40:15it around and I want you to scan the room for
- 40:17me. So she scans the room for me and sitting
- 40:20right there was her mother and then the mother's
- 40:22boyfriend and there were stacks of paper and
- 40:25I said I can't I can't evaluate the credibility
- 40:27in this case I need you to actually come in.
- 40:30So the child came in and this was before MP versus
- 40:33MC. So the child came in and I examined her there
- 40:37and counsel had questions as well. But one of
- 40:40the questions that I asked her during the examination
- 40:43was, I want you to tell me what this pornographic
- 40:47movie looked like from beginning to end. And
- 40:50because in in the pleading she had reported this
- 40:53to individuals at school. It had been reported
- 40:56to social worker had been reported to police
- 40:58and everything was consistent and she had also
- 41:02made a prior report that he had touched her when
- 41:04she was like three by putting his fingers in
- 41:06her vagina and. So i said tell me about this
- 41:09movie from beginning to end i want to know everything
- 41:11about it so she says well okay these guys come
- 41:14in and they have guns and there are these girls
- 41:17on poles and they're naked and there's dancing
- 41:20and then the guys pull the guns out and there's
- 41:22drugs everywhere and then they start shooting
- 41:24everyone and people are dying and then the movie
- 41:27goes on like this and then i looked at the other
- 41:30side and i'm like do you know what movie this
- 41:32is and it was apparently good fellas from what
- 41:35i can recall I've never seen the movie, but apparently
- 41:38it was good fellas. This certainly was not. The
- 41:40bottom line is what I'm trying to get the point
- 41:43to you is that it was not a pornographic movie.
- 41:47But I want you to imagine in the era of MP and
- 41:51MC that had the dependency exception been used.
- 41:55And this 13 year old child was not subject to
- 41:59cross examination based upon the pleadings. Cause
- 42:02there was a TRO issued based upon the pleadings
- 42:05alone. that would have been sufficient to restrain
- 42:09the father. Please note that also in this proceeding,
- 42:13there was some type of custody and visitation,
- 42:15some bad custody and visitation that was going
- 42:18on between the parties. And I believe it was
- 42:19in another county where DCFS had been called
- 42:22historically, police had been called. There was
- 42:24all kinds of conflict between the parties. Huge
- 42:28injustice could have been done in that case had
- 42:31that child not been subjected to cross examination.
- 42:33And so when I talk about Gatekeeping the truth
- 42:37we have to be really careful in the use of this
- 42:41exception to make sure that we really are getting
- 42:43to truth Judge Goldberg, what do you what do
- 42:52you think about reliability? They're placing
- 42:56a great emphasis on it and it's obviously a fact
- 43:00driven issue that needs to be resolved and argued.
- 43:05And again, I used that checklist that came from
- 43:08Henry Carmen O. And then anything else, the checklist
- 43:11isn't exclusive. Anything else that you logically
- 43:15think either supports or detracts from the reliability
- 43:19of the out -of -court statement. I think a lot
- 43:21of courts are going to be focusing on this issue,
- 43:25and it in essence will become the beginning,
- 43:29middle, and end of the analysis. If the judge
- 43:32thinks it's reliable, likely to come in. Judge
- 43:35thinks it's unreliable, the judge is going to
- 43:38keep it out. Let's really think about MP and
- 43:42MC, because the child, and think about our everyday
- 43:44family law cases, the child made the statement
- 43:46to, I can't remember an MP versus MC, but the
- 43:50child made the statement to one person, then
- 43:52made it to a social worker, made it to the please,
- 43:55made it to the parent. And they said, you know
- 43:57what, that's reliability. And how often do we
- 44:01have that? Because in my case, I had that. I
- 44:04had multiple statements to multiple people. And
- 44:06how often do we have that in our family -like
- 44:09cases? And I guess my question is that, is that
- 44:12really the establishment of reliability? Yeah.
- 44:14I mean, and they say it is. And so you can obviously
- 44:18cite it. It's published law. But the evidence
- 44:22code defines a prior consistent statement, recall.
- 44:27as as being a statement that's consistent with
- 44:30the in court testimony and that was made before
- 44:35an inconsistent statement or before a motive
- 44:37to fabricate and and i do think that that is
- 44:41very reliable i i consider that to be extremely
- 44:45important evidence in uh... a variety of contacts
- 44:49including dvd matters where the person before
- 44:53there was any motive to fabricate was saying
- 44:55the same thing. But that is not the type of consistent
- 44:59statement they were talking about in MP versus
- 45:03MC. Right. So what does it look like if you're
- 45:08making a record? I'm just going to play the hat
- 45:11of if I'm on the respondent side and I'm faced
- 45:15with this. What is your what's your record going
- 45:18to look like? I suggest that you file written
- 45:21points and authorities I think it's going to
- 45:23be so important to protect yourself on appeal
- 45:26and so a written points and authority addressing
- 45:28all of the areas remember when I said when we
- 45:30took that when we took a close look at MP versus
- 45:33MC and the court was kind of all over the place
- 45:35and saying it's coming in because of this this
- 45:38and this I would really analyze all of those
- 45:40areas and but the first part is obviously I'll
- 45:43say due process due process due process because
- 45:46it's so important in these cases the gatekeeping
- 45:49of evidence and understanding the due process
- 45:53rights that parties have in hearings and making
- 45:57sure that is fully upheld they had said initially
- 46:01right we're just applying it to a similar court
- 46:03but are we really applying it to a similar court
- 46:06because the consequences are very different in
- 46:10dependency court Further, we have different rules,
- 46:13completely different rules in dependency versus
- 46:15family. They're totally different. I can remove
- 46:17a child on day one under emergency jurisdiction
- 46:20where it takes them months to remove the child,
- 46:23and they have to go through all kinds of hoops
- 46:25to remove a child. And it can be done with no
- 46:28notice. Correct. No notice. Completely different.
- 46:33But they said that they're similar. DVPAs are
- 46:36subject to lifetime renewals. Had I issued that
- 46:41restraining order against that gentleman for
- 46:44the pornographic movie, he's subject to lifetime
- 46:46renewal. He's also subject to potential gun,
- 46:50well actually gun loss for the rest of his life
- 46:52if it's renewed. CHROs do in fact have a higher
- 46:57standard, but they're full of admissible hearsay.
- 47:00You can do that entire hearing based upon hearsay.
- 47:03So are we really comparing an apple to an apple?
- 47:06That's my question. The court, by analogy, discussed
- 47:131360, as Judge Iarte mentioned before, which,
- 47:19again, is applicable only in criminal cases,
- 47:21but they were using it by analogy. But take a
- 47:26look at the section anyway. If you're having
- 47:28trouble sleeping tonight, read the section before
- 47:31you go to sleep. It is actually interesting.
- 47:35But you will see procedural safeguards that are
- 47:38built into that evidence code section that go
- 47:41way beyond MP versus MC. And one of them is that
- 47:47the section requires a separate hearing where
- 47:49the court determines based on the time, content,
- 47:53and circumstances of the statement that there's
- 47:55sufficient indicia of reliability. Again, going
- 47:58back to reliability. But since we know that this
- 48:02is arguable by analogy in our courts, I think
- 48:07that you should utilize it in asking for a 402
- 48:12hearing in our family court courts where appropriate.
- 48:15And I can see either side doing this. I can see
- 48:18the side who wants to keep the evidence out asking
- 48:21for a 402 hearing. where the court would determine
- 48:25whether or not it's going to come in and think
- 48:27about it. If the court ruled, no, I'm not going
- 48:30to listen to this evidence, and that is the only
- 48:33sufficient evidence there is, the 402 hearing
- 48:37could be followed by a motion to dismiss. On
- 48:40the other hand, if the proponent of the evidence
- 48:43gets the idea that the court perhaps is not inclined
- 48:47to receive the evidence, maybe the proponent
- 48:50would want it. suggest a 402 hearing so that
- 48:54the court could take a second look and determine
- 48:56whether or not it should be admitted. Judge Ariarte,
- 48:59what about 402? I know courts are extremely busy.
- 49:03Is that something that you'd be receptive to
- 49:06in this context? Oh, 100%. I would be, I think
- 49:10you should, everybody make a 402 motion that
- 49:13you should have a separate hearing where you're
- 49:15actually evaluating this. Because as I've indicated,
- 49:17you're not just talking about, oh, hi, I'm going
- 49:19to restrain you because the child fell in the
- 49:22pool or because, you know, you were using reasonable
- 49:26physical restraint on your child, okay? This
- 49:30is sexual abuse. This will affect your client's
- 49:35cussing and visitation for years and years and
- 49:37years to come. And I believe a 402, especially
- 49:40with all the due process issues that I'm seeing
- 49:42here, I think it should be held, period. I'm
- 49:46gonna hold it in my courtroom if you ask for
- 49:48it. And then further in evidence code section
- 49:521360, there's a requirement that either the child
- 49:59testifies during the proceedings or the child
- 50:03is unavailable. or there's corroborating evidence,
- 50:08which kind of hearkens back to Cindy L. and Carmen
- 50:12O. and some of the requirements that were expressed
- 50:16in those cases. So maybe by analogy, cite those
- 50:19to the court as well. I would look at the strong
- 50:29factual analysis of N -ray Carmen O and Cindy
- 50:32L because I think when you look at that bird's
- 50:34eye view and you look at those two cases, to
- 50:36me, N -ray Carmen O and N -ray Cindy L, they
- 50:39really do make sense because those were cases
- 50:41where there's no available way to get the evidence
- 50:44in but through that exception. And when I look
- 50:47at the corroborating evidence, incompetent testimony
- 50:51of the child, it makes sense to me. MP and MC,
- 50:56It just has gone very, very far. But understanding
- 51:00where it came from, and I think a reviewing court
- 51:03understanding where it came from is going to
- 51:05be crucial. I would actually consider expert
- 51:08testimony regarding coaching, gatekeeping, and
- 51:10alienation. Because remember, in MP versus MC,
- 51:14the court said, well, there's no motive in this
- 51:16case, yet there was child custody and visitation
- 51:18that was an issue in that case. And I'm not saying
- 51:21that the mom in that case was lying or anything
- 51:24like that. I'm just saying I think the Court
- 51:27of Appeal needs to be informed regarding issues
- 51:30that we deal with every day. Don't assume that
- 51:32they understand it. And then the other thing
- 51:35that I would note is the new burden shifting.
- 51:38Because in a DVPA, the burden is on the petitioner.
- 51:43The burden of proof is on the petitioner. But
- 51:44when we read MP versus MC, and I'm now requiring
- 51:48you to have somebody subpoenaed, that child subpoenaed
- 51:51and waiting in the hallway, it's kind of like
- 51:53there's a burden shifting. here. And is that
- 51:56appropriate? I think the lawyer in that case
- 51:59was like, I don't need to subpoena anybody. It's
- 52:01not my burden, right? They should be able to
- 52:03sit there and they put on their case and see
- 52:06whether whether it has been met or not. I would
- 52:09have never expected in that case. And I don't
- 52:11think the lawyer did either that that statement
- 52:13was going to come in through some dependency
- 52:16hearsay exception. I bet that lawyer was shocked.
- 52:26Okay, so let's talk about a couple more points,
- 52:34whether the DVPA, the concepts that were developed
- 52:38in MP versus MC in DVPA hearings, whether those
- 52:43should bleed over into, for example, routine
- 52:48RFO hearings, kind of like in a hypothetical.
- 52:52And so a couple other points that I wanted to
- 52:56make. One is about the affidavits written by
- 53:00a parent on behalf of a child. Recall we saw
- 53:04some, I thought, confusing language in MP versus
- 53:08MC in that regard, which almost seemed to suggest
- 53:12that the parent could seek a restraining order
- 53:15on behalf of a child. Just, again, to highlight
- 53:18the facts of that case, what happened was The
- 53:22mom in that case claimed that her piece had been
- 53:26disturbed. She had been abused. Her piece was
- 53:29disturbed. Why? Because her child told her that
- 53:34she had been molested, and that disturbed her
- 53:37piece. And so she was entitled to a restraining
- 53:41order, and then the children were protected parties
- 53:45in that restraining order. However, under Family
- 53:48Code Section 6301B, which references Code of
- 53:53Civil Procedure Section 372B, if a child under
- 54:0012 years old cannot seek a restraining order
- 54:03on their own behalf, without having a guardian
- 54:07ad litem. So if it is the case that for some
- 54:10reason the child themselves is the petitioner
- 54:13trying to seek a restraining order and they're
- 54:16under 12, then they need to get guardian ad litem.
- 54:19Over 12, it's discretionary with the court whether
- 54:22or not it's going to require a guardian ad litem.
- 54:27But I just want to highlight that distinction
- 54:29there. The dependency court uses hearsay, but
- 54:39there is a distinction that was alluded to by
- 54:43Judge Iriarte, and that is that in dependency
- 54:46court, the guy alluded to it as well, the social
- 54:50study reports which are chock full of hearsay
- 54:52come in. So hearsay is used to a much greater
- 54:56extent in dependency matters than it is in family
- 54:59law matters. And then finally, as I think both
- 55:03of us talked a little bit about, let's concentrate
- 55:07a little on a motive to fabricate. So in MP versus
- 55:11MC, they said that mom was credible and there
- 55:15was no motive to fabricate. But think about how
- 55:18that compares to our typical family law proceeding
- 55:21where usually what happens is there was a lot
- 55:25of litigation and a high conflict custody dispute
- 55:29that Occurred even before the allegations of
- 55:33sexual or physical abuse or neglect had ever
- 55:36been made So so in in many of our cases not all
- 55:41of them But in many of our cases there is going
- 55:44to be a significant showing of a motive to fabricate
- 55:48And can I also stay going back to should the
- 55:51DVA protection be extended to the actual hearing?
- 55:54Remember that the court of appeals said the DV,
- 55:56one of the protections of the DVPA is to protect
- 55:59that child from the actual hearing. And is that
- 56:02really what was intended by the legislator? Because
- 56:05I think that argument, if you want to say that,
- 56:08then anybody who files a DVPA, whether it be
- 56:11an adult or a child, everybody suggested subjected
- 56:15to future abuse just by the hearing itself. And
- 56:18I don't and I don't think that's what the DVPA
- 56:21was intended to protect. at all. I just, that's
- 56:24not the way I see it. The other thing I want
- 56:26to make note of with MP and MC is the fact that
- 56:30the court found true that the parent's piece
- 56:34was in fact disturbed. Just keep this in mind,
- 56:36because historically it's been, if you see the
- 56:38child being abused, that would disturb your piece,
- 56:41but it has to be done in your presence. But now
- 56:44we've taken another expansion and more broad
- 56:47view, which is what we're doing here with MP
- 56:51and MC. Yeah, just hearing about your child being
- 56:55abused. Yes can cause your piece to be disturbed
- 56:59and therefore Abuse within the meaning of the
- 57:01DVPA. Yes Okay, so let's talk a little bit more
- 57:11generally then about other rules of evidence
- 57:13relating to the admissibility of out -of -court
- 57:16statements by children that are applicable in
- 57:19our family law courts. And so I take a three
- 57:23pronged approach or three element test approach
- 57:26to the issue of admissibility of out of court
- 57:29statements. And the first question is, is it
- 57:32a statement at all? Does it qualify as a statement?
- 57:37The second is, is it hearsay? In other words,
- 57:40is it coming in for the truth of the matter asserted?
- 57:43And then and only then can we get to element
- 57:45number three or question number three, which
- 57:48is there an exception, which is what we've been
- 57:50talking about so far, which is a new exception
- 57:52to the hearsay rule. But I want to talk a little
- 57:54bit more about elements one and two, because
- 57:58so often we, and when I say we, I mean even us
- 58:01judges skip over that. And we simply jump to,
- 58:05OK, counsel, what's the exception? But we haven't
- 58:08really analyzed. Is it a statement? Is it hearsay?
- 58:12All right. So step one, is it a statement? A
- 58:16statement under evidence code section 1200 and
- 58:20225 is either oral or written verbal expression
- 58:26or nonverbal conduct intended as a substitute
- 58:31for oral or written verbal expression. So it's
- 58:34where someone is trying to express something
- 58:37out of court that's going to constitute a statement.
- 58:42There's another dependency case. Again, a lot
- 58:45of the cases in this area are dependency cases.
- 58:50Inri Dorindo, another very interesting case for
- 58:54us. And in that case, the child was playing with
- 58:58anatomically correct dolls with a mental health
- 59:02professional who had observed that the child's
- 59:06knowledge of sexual issues was inconsistent with
- 59:10the child's age, thereby indicating exposure
- 59:13to sexual incidents, which was in turn circumstantial
- 59:18evidence that the child had been abused. Because
- 59:21the child wasn't trying to express anything,
- 59:24that was not hearsay. It was not coming in for
- 59:27the truth of the matter asserted. It was simply
- 59:30circumstantial evidence of abuse. Continuing
- 59:34with element number two. All right. Circumstantial
- 59:38evidence of state of mind is not hearsay. So,
- 59:44for example, a child's statement expressing fear
- 59:48of her father was relevant for the non -hearsay
- 59:52purpose of proving her fear and whether or not
- 59:55contact with the dad would be in her best interest.
- 59:58Another dependency case, this Henry Clarabee.
- 1:00:01And I know, you think of that You read that,
- 1:00:05oh my gosh, that's so startling. But here's what
- 1:00:08the court said. The court said that, quote, there
- 1:00:11is authority for the proposition that a minor's
- 1:00:14out of court statement, that a particular individual
- 1:00:17molested her, are admissible not to prove that
- 1:00:21he actually did, but has circumstantial evidence
- 1:00:25that the child believed that he did. In other
- 1:00:29words, these statements support Supply circumstantial
- 1:00:33evidence that she had a certain state of mind
- 1:00:35that is a belief that her father had hurt her
- 1:00:38and dislike and fear of him based on that belief
- 1:00:41whether the statement is true or not is irrelevant
- 1:00:45to this use of the statement and quote so so
- 1:00:50It was not hearsay at all. I know that seems
- 1:00:54kind of startling, but think about how we could
- 1:00:56apply that in many, many of our child custody
- 1:00:59cases where a child is making a statement that
- 1:01:02is circumstantial evidence of their attitude
- 1:01:05about visitation and custody. The same argument
- 1:01:11was attempted to be made, however, in MP versus
- 1:01:14MC itself. And it was accepted erroneously by
- 1:01:18the trial court. The trial court said, oh, all
- 1:01:20right, I'm going to let in the child's statements
- 1:01:23not for the truth of the matter asserted, but
- 1:01:25for the effect that they had on the state of
- 1:01:27mind of mom. In other words, that they disturbed
- 1:01:29her peace. But the court of appeal correctly,
- 1:01:34in my view, found, no, it's coming in for the
- 1:01:37truth of the matter asserted. Therefore, it is
- 1:01:40hearsay. Why? Because The the statement by the
- 1:01:46child to the bomb would only be relevant if it's
- 1:01:49true because dad committed abuse only if this
- 1:01:54the sexual abuse actually occurred and Therefore
- 1:01:58its relevancy determines on it. It turns on whether
- 1:02:02or not it was true So think about that for a
- 1:02:04second if the statement is relevant even if it's
- 1:02:08not true It's not hearsay if the statement is
- 1:02:13only relevant if it is true It is hearsay a very
- 1:02:17simple test to apply to these cases So let's
- 1:02:23continue on with element number two of my three
- 1:02:26-part test Which is is it for the truth of the
- 1:02:28matter asserted? So let's use a little hypo to
- 1:02:31to illustrate this the child says Repeatedly
- 1:02:35during custodial exchanges there are ghosts at
- 1:02:38dad's house and the court asks you, why are you
- 1:02:41admitting this counsel? Your answer probably
- 1:02:44isn't going to be, I want to prove that dad's
- 1:02:47house is haunted. Your answer is probably going
- 1:02:51to be it's circumstantial evidence about the
- 1:02:54child's attitude about custody and circumstantial
- 1:02:59evidence that for some reason, maybe we don't
- 1:03:01know why this child is afraid of transitioning
- 1:03:05to dad's house. It's clearly not coming in to
- 1:03:08prove the truth of the matter asserted. Similarly,
- 1:03:12false statements are not coming in to prove the
- 1:03:14truth of the matter asserted. So for instance,
- 1:03:18in the Zack case, it's a criminal case, the prosecution
- 1:03:24put on evidence of a false alibi. They wanted
- 1:03:27to show, to introduce evidence that the defendant
- 1:03:30in that case said that he was fishing in Carmel
- 1:03:33at the time of the murders. And they also had
- 1:03:36evidence that there was a major storm at that
- 1:03:39time with 10 -foot waves, so it was highly unlikely
- 1:03:43that he was actually fishing at that time. In
- 1:03:45other words, they wanted to introduce the statement
- 1:03:48not for the truth of the matter asserted, but
- 1:03:50for the falsity of the matter asserted. You'll
- 1:03:53also have occasion to be able to use that argument
- 1:03:57in our family law cases. And finally, another
- 1:04:00doctrine that is very relevant here is the fresh
- 1:04:03complaint doctrine. Which comes out of criminal
- 1:04:06cases and the seminal case is the Brown case
- 1:04:10by the California Supreme Court and They found
- 1:04:14that a 12 year old statement that she had been
- 1:04:18molested Could come in not for the truth of the
- 1:04:22matter asserted but under this fresh complaint
- 1:04:24doctrine In that case, the 12 -year -old complained
- 1:04:29to various individuals and the complaints were
- 1:04:31made about two or three months after the alleged
- 1:04:34incident. The California Supreme Court noted
- 1:04:38that this doctrine emanates from the 13th century
- 1:04:42doctrine of hue and cry. It used to be in the
- 1:04:46merry old days of England. That one of the elements
- 1:04:50of a rape case was you had to prove as part of
- 1:04:54the case that the victim Disclosed it promptly
- 1:04:58to someone so we no longer have that doctrine
- 1:05:01But it's it's kind of morphed into according
- 1:05:04to our Supreme Court the fresh complaint doctrine
- 1:05:07The statement is admissible to establish the
- 1:05:11circumstances of the victims reporting of the
- 1:05:14crime. And here are some further things that
- 1:05:16the court said regarding the fresh complaint
- 1:05:18doctrine. They said that... Sorry. That's okay.
- 1:05:25The evidence of the victim's conduct following
- 1:05:27the alleged crime, including the circumstances
- 1:05:30under which he or she did or did not promptly
- 1:05:34report are admissible. They said that only the
- 1:05:38fact that a complaint was made and the circumstances
- 1:05:42of its making are admissible. The detailed statements
- 1:05:46themselves are not admissible. And this is not
- 1:05:51confined to sexual assault cases. So you could
- 1:05:54use it in many kinds of cases, including just
- 1:05:57our routine domestic violence cases. So to emphasize,
- 1:06:02this is going to the issue of credibility. This
- 1:06:05is going to the argument, Your Honor, that the
- 1:06:08witness is credible because they made a complaint,
- 1:06:12and that's what we would expect a victim to do.
- 1:06:16Or conversely, you could also argue, but be a
- 1:06:19little bit careful with this argument and how
- 1:06:22you phrase it. Maybe the victim isn't as credible
- 1:06:25because they did not report or they delayed reporting
- 1:06:28or the reporting was inconsistent, etc. It is
- 1:06:31relevant on the issue of credibility. And I think
- 1:06:35when you look at everything you've been talking
- 1:06:37about on the state of mind, even when you look
- 1:06:40at RFOs and DVPA, it's all relevant. The child
- 1:06:44may not have been molested, but the fact that
- 1:06:46the child believes they've been molested, that's
- 1:06:48still relevant. Maybe not offered for the truth
- 1:06:51of the matter, but it's definitely offered for
- 1:06:53the state of mind and to show where the child's
- 1:06:55at. And the court has to consider that. So you
- 1:06:58can use it for that non -hearsay purpose. In
- 1:07:02our most recent case on the fresh complaint doctrine,
- 1:07:07the court and people versus Flores was dealing
- 1:07:10with a situation which a 14 -year -old disclosed
- 1:07:13that she had been molested to fellow students
- 1:07:16eight years. after the incident, and they emphasize
- 1:07:21that freshness is not really an essential element
- 1:07:25of the fresh complaint doctrine. And they recommend
- 1:07:28that California courts and commentators should
- 1:07:31now refer to this doctrine as the prior disclosure
- 1:07:35doctrine. So the circumstances under which the
- 1:07:39incident was first disclosed, again, are relevant
- 1:07:43on the issue of the credibility of the witness.
- 1:07:48So there are a number of avenues that you have
- 1:07:51for getting in statements under the argument,
- 1:07:55A, it's not a statement at all, step one, or
- 1:07:59step two, it's not for the truth of the matter,
- 1:08:02without even necessarily and always resorting
- 1:08:05to the child dependency exception. And I want
- 1:08:10to say that I just appreciate the direction that
- 1:08:12we're going in regard to getting evidence in
- 1:08:14where there are really issues where we do need
- 1:08:17it. I do see why the court did what they did,
- 1:08:19and I do appreciate it. But I think that, as
- 1:08:23we've indicated in the beginning and in the name
- 1:08:24of this program, that that gatekeeping to make
- 1:08:27sure that we are really eliciting the truth is
- 1:08:30so important and emphasizing due process and
- 1:08:33proceedings for all parties, I think, is something
- 1:08:36that we really have to keep at the forefront
- 1:08:38in using this exception. Yeah, I agree. And the
- 1:08:42dependency hearsay exception does represent an
- 1:08:46admirable commitment by the courts of appeal
- 1:08:48to the protection of children. And they should
- 1:08:50be applauded and are applauded for doing that.
- 1:08:53It must also be tempered. however, with a commitment
- 1:08:57to fairness, and most importantly, in my view,
- 1:09:02to reliability, that we're relying on evidence
- 1:09:07that contributes to the truth -finding process
- 1:09:11and allows us to determine the truth. As a judge,
- 1:09:17I appreciate, I think most judges do appreciate,
- 1:09:21creative advocacy and maybe even pushing the
- 1:09:24boundaries a little bit. A creative advocacy
- 1:09:27is to be encouraged and applauded. However, creative
- 1:09:34overreach can be very memorable to us judges.
- 1:09:39And it is your function as attorneys to try to
- 1:09:42figure out where exactly is that line drawn.
- 1:09:46Hopefully not cross it. And so good luck to you
- 1:09:50in that effort. Thank you for attending today.
- 1:09:53And may all your peers say be reliable. Yes.
- 1:09:57And then we have a few questions that we can
- 1:09:59answer. We can stay a little bit longer. You're
- 1:10:02all welcome to stay or go if you need to. Can
- 1:10:04any new statutory formulation actually override
- 1:10:07Sixth Amendment right across examination and
- 1:10:10how? And I think that's the issue. I think that's
- 1:10:12the issue that we're hitting on. these cases,
- 1:10:16a lot of them really do require cross -examination.
- 1:10:20I think that's why that bird's eye view of the
- 1:10:23Cindy case and the Carmen case, when you look
- 1:10:26at that, I understand why the court did that.
- 1:10:28But again, we're making a big jump in MP versus
- 1:10:31MC in taking away really the right for cross
- 1:10:35-examination and the reasoning for that. And
- 1:10:38so that's why I'm saying I think we really have
- 1:10:39to be careful because if it does come to that,
- 1:10:42You guys are going to be tasked with many many
- 1:10:45appeals and we're going to see what either the
- 1:10:47United States Supreme Court Says or we're going
- 1:10:49to see whether there's going to be new laws written
- 1:10:51in this area What do you think? The Sixth Amendment
- 1:10:54right to cross -examination doesn't apply Per
- 1:10:58se in non -criminal matters. It doesn't it doesn't
- 1:11:00apply to civil cases however Due process still
- 1:11:05applies. Okay, so so you you may I believe even
- 1:11:10cite Sixth Amendment cases, but if you're going
- 1:11:13to do it you do want to point out to the judge
- 1:11:16Otherwise the judge is going to get angry with
- 1:11:18you your honor I know the Sixth Amendment doesn't
- 1:11:21strictly speaking apply in this context but nevertheless
- 1:11:24the considerations in some of these cases should
- 1:11:27be Taken into account by you in determining whether
- 1:11:31or not this complies with due process that would
- 1:11:34have yard and particularly in those cases where
- 1:11:37you think your opposing counsel is crossing that
- 1:11:41boundary that I talked about from creative advocacy
- 1:11:45into overreach on this exception. And that's
- 1:11:49the way I understood that question, that you're
- 1:11:51really talking about cross -examination and due
- 1:11:53process. And there was a case that we have in
- 1:11:56the packet where a child was taken into chambers.
- 1:11:59I can't remember the name of it, where the parties
- 1:12:01really didn't have the opportunity. And you already
- 1:12:04have case law and support with the fact that,
- 1:12:06no, the parties have the right to examine. they
- 1:12:09do. So I think that those cases are going to
- 1:12:11be important in looking at that. The next question
- 1:12:13is when and how would you make a 402 hearing
- 1:12:16request? And then if you make a 402 hearing request,
- 1:12:19is it going to potentially ring the bell on inadmissible
- 1:12:22evidence? And I mean, I guess this is good for
- 1:12:27me. I think it's going to go to your discussions
- 1:12:28with counsel and what's going on in the case.
- 1:12:32If counsel is not familiar with it, I suppose,
- 1:12:35and you see they're just submitting on the affidavit.
- 1:12:38At that point, mid -hearing, you can ask for
- 1:12:41the 402 and then proceed that way. Because again,
- 1:12:44I think this brings up the issue of are you going
- 1:12:47to subpoena the child for the initial hearing
- 1:12:49or the actual hearing itself and the problems
- 1:12:53with that. Go ahead. Yeah. On the 402 hearing,
- 1:13:01there is no requirement per the case law, and
- 1:13:04it's mostly criminal case law on this, that you
- 1:13:07have to file them in writing. So you can do it
- 1:13:12orally. And the reason for that is just the common
- 1:13:15sense concept that if you wanted to, you could
- 1:13:18just wait until the evidence. was sought to be
- 1:13:22elicited and that moment object to it. So you're
- 1:13:25simply advancing an argument that you'd be able
- 1:13:28to make later on. But I nonetheless think that
- 1:13:31on something this important and that may be pivotal.
- 1:13:37absolutely pivotal. Maybe you win the case or
- 1:13:39you lose the case based on the court's ruling.
- 1:13:42That doesn't happen a lot, quite frankly, I think,
- 1:13:45in family law, except in this situation. I would
- 1:13:50probably want to write out a formal motion and
- 1:13:55eliminate and probably include appoints and authorities.
- 1:13:59And I think we have the most of the authority
- 1:14:01that you need to put into that. that points in
- 1:14:05authorities and most of the arguments they're
- 1:14:07gonna wanna make. The other thing is, remember,
- 1:14:10you don't, your bench officer may just invoke
- 1:14:12it himself. I mean, look what happened during
- 1:14:14my hearing. And I said, I'm bringing the statement
- 1:14:16in through the dependency exception hearing,
- 1:14:20hearsay exception. So your judge may do it on
- 1:14:23their own. So I think the 402 is appropriate
- 1:14:25and just ask for it. That's all you have to do
- 1:14:27is ask for it. I think those were it. Thank you.
- 1:14:38Thank you so much. This concludes today's presentation.
- 1:14:41Thank you so much, Judge Goldberg. And thank
- 1:14:44you so much, Judge Iriarte, for an excellent
- 1:14:46presentation. And thank you to our audience.
- 1:14:48Have a great day, everybody. Thank you.