Latest / Gone Cold - Texas True Crime / The Assassination of Alton Peek

Transcript

The Assassination of Alton Peek · Gone Cold - Texas True Crime

0:01
The Gone Cold. Podcasts may contain violent or graphics subject matter. Listener discretion
0:06
is advised. Boxelder, Texas. To call it a small town is an
0:13
overstatement, named for a type of maple tree that plentifully lines the area's creeks.
0:19
The rural community is home to a church, a cemetery, and in
0:24
the mid nineteen nineties, about two hundred residents scattered throughout, with expansive thickets
0:30
or ranch land between them. There's not much more other than the Boxelder Store,
0:37
which sold everything from hunting and fishing licenses, first aid supplies, and
0:42
livestock feed to coffee, cold drinks, and gasoline. Political arguments and business
0:50
advice were available at the Boxelder store for no charge. About seven and a
0:56
half miles north of Boxelder is Anna. Unlike Boxelder, Anona is an incorporated
1:03
city, but in nineteen ninety six was home to only one hundred more residents
1:07
if that. Anona is about eight and a half miles east of Clarksville,
1:14
Texas, the area's big city, at around four thousand or so residents in
1:18
the mid nineteen nineties. It's the seat of the county that encases all of
1:23
these places Red River County, which sits at the Texas, Oklahoma border.
1:30
On the front page of the city's newspaper, the Clarksville Times, you'd most
1:34
often find stories that fit squarely within what most folks considered normal life in their
1:41
slow paced and Bucolic environs. An article about the groundbreaking for the new site
1:47
of the Baptist church in a nearby community, perhaps, or all the information
1:53
you need to attend the stew cookoff, a fundraising effort for the County Fair,
1:59
maybe something. Now, it was almost unheard of to pick up the
2:02
Times and find a missing person's or murder investigation story, particularly any such mystery
2:09
that took place in the small towns and communities that surrounded Clarksville. But nineteen
2:16
ninety five and nineteen ninety six saw one of each. What gave area residents
2:22
even more cause for alarm and more fuel for rumors and baseless speculation was that
2:29
both happened in the sparsely populated town of Boxelder. At two thirty am on
2:37
Thursday August seventeenth, nineteen ninety five, friends of thirty two year old Jennifer
2:43
Joyce Bench arrived at her home. Her car was in the driveway, but
2:47
Jennifer wasn't there, although her cigarettes and purse were items her friends said she'd
2:54
never have left the house without. Jennifer's dogs were up in the bedroom.
3:01
After searching the premises surrounding their friend's southeast Red River County home and finding no
3:08
sign of her, they called the sheriff's office. Later, Sheriff Bob Eddington
3:14
told a Clarksville Times reporter that it appeared Jennifer had left with someone, though
3:20
whether or not it was voluntary, let alone who that person might have been
3:25
remained a mystery. At five feet five inches tall and ninety pounds, Sheriff
3:31
Ederington figured the brown haired, green eyed woman wouldn't have been hard for a
3:37
strong male to overpower, although he refused to commit to the theory that foul
3:42
play was involved. With few leads and even less evidence, the missing person
3:47
investigations stalled and articles about the disappearance of Jennifer Bench stopped, although a large
3:55
advertisement offering a three thousand dollars reward for information leading to her whereabouts continued to
4:02
run in the newspaper, at least until another crime took place, one that
4:08
utterly shocked the residents of the Boxelder community and the surrounding areas. When Precinct
4:15
four County Commissioner Alton Peak was gunned down in cold blood, a crime that
4:20
appeared to be a methodically planned execution, the Red River County Sheriff's office struggled
4:28
to gather the evidence needed to close the case. Alton Douglas Peak was born
4:57
on April twenty fourth, nineteen sixty two, to parents Alton Blaine Peak,
5:01
better known around town as Tebow, and Hazel Lucille Peak. Tebow was a
5:08
World War two VET, a Precinct for road maintenance official, and a rancher.
5:14
Both he and Hazel were active and popular members of the Boxelder community,
5:18
where they raised Alton and his sister, Jamie Sue, twelve years older than
5:25
her brother. Jamie was married and off to college before Alton was out of
5:29
Junior high. The Peaks weren't necessarily well to do, and around their neck
5:35
of the woods, it wasn't money that made you popular or influential anyway.
5:42
Rather, it was active citizenship and being there for your neighbors. Tebow and
5:46
Hazel's good standing was inevitably passed down to their son, Alton, who some
5:53
knew as simply owl. Alton made good grades throughout his school years, most
5:59
often a's. While at Clarksville High he was a runner up in student chosen
6:04
categories like Mister chs and Most Handsome Boy. He was a class favorite his
6:11
junior year and named the school's favorite Boy. As a senior, Alton was
6:16
on the yearbook staff, but from an early age it seemed to be local
6:23
government service and politics that most interested him. Where he was from that required
6:30
taking a keen interest in ranching and agriculture. By the time he graduated,
6:35
he'd reached the ranks of president of Clarksville High School's Future Farmers of America and
6:42
was named the chapter's Outstanding Farmer for nineteen eighty. These were among his other
6:47
many achievements with the FFA, which included an award based upon his performance in
6:54
leadership, among other characteristics, the Agricultural Accomplishment Award. None of this ended
7:01
with high school. In fact, Alton Peak was just getting started as an
7:08
official for the Texas Farm Bureau before he was twenty years old. Alton became
7:13
an active fixture in county and precinct politics early on in his adult life.
7:18
The Farm Bureau, in simple terms, is a lobbying group representing the interests
7:24
of farm and ranch families in Texas. Of course, that means having representatives
7:30
ever present in Austin at the state capitol and in Red River County at the
7:35
local courthouse. Alton Peak represented the fulk he knew his folk, which required
7:43
a watchful eye and open ear while speaking with locals about their needs and ideas
7:47
for their industry's betterment, whether it was protesting illegal trash dumping along county highways
7:55
and roads, demanding no dumping signs be erected, or life for things like
8:01
changes in crop rotation or irrigation requirements. Alton took his community's needs seriously,
8:09
but he also had family responsibilities. In nineteen eighty three, his mother,
8:13
Hazel was declared a quote person of unsound mind end quote. Both she and
8:20
Alton's father, Tebou were ailing in fact, although precisely what they were suffering
8:26
from is unclear. Tbou died on July eighth, nineteen eighty eight, at
8:31
age sixty six, and Hazel the following year on August fourth, at age
8:37
sixty eight. The death of his parents devastated Alton. He'd put his life
8:43
on hold to care for them. It likely came as no surprise to anyone
8:50
when a few months later, the Clarksville Times announced Alton Peake's engagement to Andrea
8:54
Boswell, who went by her middle name Michelle, from Paris, Texas,
9:01
and was working as a licensed vocational nurse at mccoiston Medical Center in that city.
9:07
By this time, Alton had worked his way up to the vice president
9:11
position at the Red River County Farm Bureau and served on the Red River County
9:16
Agriculture Improvement Board. These civic responsibilities were on top of his family business farming
9:24
and ranching, alongside his work as a bulldozer and back hoe contractor. Alton
9:31
and Michelle were married on March seventeenth, nineteen ninety in a small ceremony at
9:37
his church and Box Elder, Salem Baptist. In May the following year,
9:41
Michelle gave birth to a son, Aaron. Their family grew by one more
9:48
in December of nineteen ninety three, when their second son, Caleb, was
9:52
born. By this time, the Peaks were living in Anona. Seeking to
9:58
grow his political career, though his interests seemingly only local, Alton entered the
10:03
nineteen ninety four Democratic primary race for Precinct four County Commissioner. He smoked opponent
10:11
Jimmy D. Cox for the party's nomination, since the incumbent wasn't seeking a
10:16
second term. Alton Peak ran unopposed in November's election and became Red River County
10:24
Precinct four Commissioner the following January. He'd have likely had a good chance of
10:30
winning even if he'd had an opponent. If the number of times he served
10:35
as a pallbearer at local funerals was any indication of his popularity. In the
10:41
Clarksville Times, you might find him doing so a dozen or more times a
10:45
year. There's no doubt Alton Peak loved his community and the folks in it.
10:52
The feeling was, by all accounts mutual. In late nineteen ninety five,
10:58
Michelle Peak was chosen and to represent the small town of Anona at the
11:01
nineteen ninety six missus Texas International Pageant. From the outside looking in, the
11:09
Peak family seemed to have it all influence, the respect and admiration of the
11:15
community, and a beautiful family. In November of nineteen ninety six, they
11:20
gained something else, the Boxelder community's sympathy. On Monday, November eleventh,
11:39
nineteen ninety six Veterans Day, Alton Peak pulled up to the Boxelder Store to
11:45
purchase cattle feed. The thirty four year old Red River County Precinct four commissioner
11:50
was heading down to a property whereas cows grazed land he leased for that purpose.
11:58
At nine oh five am, Alton's purchase was rung up on the cash
12:01
register. A few minutes later, he exited the store, hopped in his
12:05
pickup truck, and headed south. At about nine point fifteen, Alton stopped
12:11
by the home of thirty nine year old Jimmy Humphreys, from whom he leased
12:16
the land in the days before. They both agreed to fix a fence on
12:22
the property after Alton finished feeding his cattle that day, but Jimmy, for
12:26
reasons never specified, backed out of the plans, he later told police.
12:31
Alton left at approximately nine to twenty a m not far from an abandoned farmhouse.
12:39
On the least property was a barn and other outbuildings places Alton's hungry cows
12:46
new to come for a good meal. He parked his pick up and began
12:50
unloading the feed. Later that day, Alton failed to meet his uncle sixty
12:56
six year old Tom Peak. It was unlike his nephew to completely neglect plans,
13:03
so Tom set out looking for him. Farmers and ranchers aren't necessarily creatures
13:09
of habit and knowing Alton's routine, Tom headed to the least Land. When
13:16
he arrived at around four pm, he saw his nephew's truck parked about twenty
13:20
feet from the gate that leads to the barn. He walked back toward the
13:26
barn and saw Alton laying face down on the dirt path with the feedsacks he'd
13:31
been carrying near He was unresponsive. Tom's initial thought that was Alton had suffered
13:39
a heart attack. When Tom flipped him over, the cause of Alton's death
13:43
was apparent. He'd been shot in the chest. After racing to a nearby
13:50
phone and alerting authorities, Tom Peak headed back to the scene. Years later,
13:56
it was reported that by the time Red Rivers shared Briff's deputies arrived at
14:01
the crime scene, bystanders had trampled the dusty path and destroyed any chance of
14:07
finding evidence in the form of shoe or boot prints. At first, the
14:11
rumors about the tragic death of one of their most beloved locals were innocuous.
14:18
Anyone in Boxelder or Anna would tell you Alton Peak had not a single enemy,
14:24
and everyone figured he'd simply been hit with a deer hunter's stray bullet,
14:30
a freak and tragic accident, and nothing more. But rumors quickly became,
14:37
as Wan Debray of The Clarksville Times poignantly wrote, limited only by the reach
14:43
of people's imaginations. Baseless speculations were in no small part thanks to erroneous reporting
14:50
by the Paris News. The day after Alton's death, the newspaper reported that
14:56
he was one of two county commissioners under investigation for abuse of official capacity,
15:03
someone this claim suggested, might have reason to silence him. Red River County
15:09
District Attorney Jack Harrington attempted to put an end to the false allegations and any
15:16
rumors that resulted as quickly as possible. He said, there was never an
15:20
investigation on Alton Peak, and there'd never even been any former complaints against him.
15:28
It was Precinct three County Commissioner Elmer Catton who was to go to trial
15:31
for using gravel belonging to the county on his private property. While Alton's body
15:39
was in Dallas to undergo an autopsy. Sheriff Bob Eddington did his best to
15:46
quell rumors by insisting an accidental death had not been ruled out, but his
15:50
decision to call in the Texas Rangers suggested the law man knew the results of
15:56
the procedure would show something far more so. Thirty four year old Alton Peak
16:03
was memorialized at Lindemann Chapel at the Clarksville Funeral Home on the afternoon of Thursday,
16:08
November thirteenth, nineteen ninety six, and buried later that day at Boxelder
16:15
Cemetery. Reporter Janda Bray wrote that along Highway forty four, folks had tied
16:21
white ribbons to signposts, mail boxes, and trees in tribute and as a
16:26
symbol of their mourning from Anona, where he lived, all the way to
16:30
Boxelder, his hometown, and where he died. That same day, the
16:37
Denton County Medical Examiner that performed the autopsy released his results. Alton had been
16:44
shot multiple times in the chest several hours before his body was discovered. One
16:51
of the bullets punctured his heart, killing him almost instantly. Powder burns on
16:56
his shirt showed that he was fired upon at a extremely close range with a
17:02
handgun. The death was a homicide, carried out, perhaps in one of
17:07
the most cowardly ways possible, while Alton Peak was carrying heavy feedsacks to his
17:12
cows at the time. Ballistics tests were yet to be conducted, the weapon's
17:19
caliber yet to be determined, If it ever was anyway, that information was
17:26
never released. The investigation got off to a rocky start. Red River County
17:33
Sheriff Bob Edrington was admittedly in a sort of denial before the autopsy was completed.
17:41
He'd commented that Alton was a guy who was well liked and respected,
17:45
a friend to everyone who knew him, which made it hard to imagine his
17:49
death was a homicide. They had tried to find evidence he had been in
17:55
a dispute or feud with another local, but no one seemed to carry any
18:00
animosity toward him whatsoever. In fact, all they heard were glowing reviews of
18:07
the man's character. His close friend Raymond Long, compared to shooting al Peak
18:14
with shooting Santa Claus. He was a generous, god fearing family man who
18:18
put everyone's needs ahead of his own. His friend Billy Bratton remarked the entire
18:26
community, particularly those in his home town of Box Elder, were stricken by
18:30
grief. Alton and the rest of the Peaks weren't just good neighbors and friends,
18:37
they were family. The community demanded justice, and judging by the way
18:42
some of them spoke of that very thing, they might have meted it out
18:47
themselves if a clear suspect became known. But nothing about this was clear.
18:53
A motive was going to be hard to come by. Alton had no financial
18:59
troubles. He wasn't involved in drugs or any other illegal activity that anybody knew
19:03
of. Robbery could be ruled out since Alton's wallet, which contained several hundred
19:10
dollars in cash, was still in his pocket. It was the lack of
19:15
motive perhaps that drove folks crazy and resulted in confident whispers of grand conspiracy theories
19:22
that were more sensational with every telling, even if that wasn't the intent.
19:29
These began early on, but as the investigation crept along with no arrest in
19:34
sight, some thought the sheriff too might be hiding something or worse. Bob
19:41
Edrington became lumped into a group of county commissioners, constables, and judges that
19:48
without an ounce of proof themselves became a sort of criminal cabal that had to
19:52
silence Alton Peak before he blew the whistle on the whole lot of them.
19:57
Not impossible, but in reality, Sheriff Edrington might have actually been onto something.
20:04
He was keeping it close to the chest. When interviewing the last known
20:11
person to see Alton Peak alive, Red River County Sheriff's investigators took pause at
20:17
a detail the man wouldn't let go. Alton had visited this individual from whom
20:22
he leased land and box, elder James Kelly Humphreys or Jimmy, just before
20:29
driving his truck to feed his cattle less than a half mile away. The
20:33
two were supposed to fix a fence, but Jimmy backed out at the last
20:37
minute. When questioned, certainly a routine step in the investigation, Jimmy refused
20:45
to admit he was the last person to see Alton. The last person to
20:51
see him would have been the killer, Jimmy insisted. According to Sheriff Edrington,
20:57
perhaps this response was nothing, but there was no denying that it was
21:02
strange. They hadn't seen anything yet. On the afternoon of Tuesday, December
21:21
tenth, nineteen ninety six, a relative entered the home of thirty nine year
21:26
old Jimmy Humphreys. What they found was shocking devastating. On the living room
21:33
couch, Jimmy laid with a plastic bag over his head. It was tied
21:38
securely around his neck. Near him sat a prescription pill container and liquor bottle,
21:45
both empty. According to a Dallas County medical examiner, Jimmy had washed
21:51
the entirety of the prescription pills down with the liquor. He then strapped the
21:56
plastic bag over his head. The cause of death was listed as suffocation.
22:03
Jimmy died by suicide. It was determined the community of Boxelder was crushed by
22:10
the death. In a place that didn't even have two hundred and fifty residents,
22:15
two deaths by unimaginably violent means was simply too much to bear. After
22:22
his death, a source told the Clarksville Times that Jimmy Humphreys was the Red
22:26
River County Sheriff's office prime suspect in the Alton Peak murder case, though they
22:33
remarked there were more sheriff Ederington, in fact, said no one had been
22:38
ruled out, but the sudden lull the investigation appeared to have experienced told a
22:45
different story. Outwardly, it looked as though the suicide of Jimmy Humphreys had
22:51
grinded everything to a halt. On February twenty third, nineteen ninety seven,
22:57
citizens of Red River County began circulating a petition requesting outside assistance in the Alton
23:03
Peak investigation, which they intended to send to state and federal authorities and officials,
23:11
including Texas Attorney General Dan Moralees and Governor George W. Bush. The
23:17
petition was started by resident Jody Dooley and three other unnamed women to give the
23:22
people a voice. The community, her husband, Charles, told the Clarksville
23:27
Times needed to know what was happening in the investigation. Jody added that the
23:33
petition was not a criticism of Sheriff Edrington. Rather, his friends in the
23:40
community believed the lawmen simply didn't have the staff or resources needed to properly work
23:47
the Alton Peak case, nor the county's other unsolved murders that dated back to
23:52
the mid nineteen eighties. The call to action was something Alton would have done
23:57
for anyone else in Red River County, they said, but Edrington wasn't happy
24:03
about the petition. He already had Texas Ranger Roger Loff and the FBI involved
24:10
in the case, all of whom he'd invited in himself. State and federal
24:15
resources, he said, were already at his disposal. He understood the people's
24:22
frustrations, the sheriff said, it was something he also felt. After all,
24:27
it was his duty to solve Alton's case. Perhaps, he pondered while
24:33
speaking to the press, he could be a little more open with the media
24:37
so folks would know what was happening. Red River County District Attorney Jack Harrington
24:42
was crystal clear about one thing in his defense of Sheriff Edrington. It was
24:48
not the man power that was the problem. Necessarily, it was the lack
24:52
of physical evidence. Despite the disapproval of the county's top cop, the petition
25:00
was getting overwhelming support, Jody Dooley remarked. In August of nineteen ninety seven,
25:07
Sheriff Eddrington told reporters he had sent evidence to the FBI for testing an
25:11
analysis, but refused to specifically identify that evidence. Later that year, the
25:18
lawman told a reporter for the Texarcana Gazette that he had suspects, and that
25:23
evidence and testimony would be submitted to a grand jury. Eddrington was not blowing
25:30
smoke. As the months went on with nothing about Alton Peake's murder in the
25:37
newspapers other than sporadic short stories quoting the Red River County DA Jack Harrington or
25:44
Sheriff Bob Edrington commenting that nothing new has materialized. Rumors that the sheriff was
25:51
somehow involved were intensifying. When asked if the lawman was a suspect in the
25:56
case, Texas ranger Roger loff called the notion the craziest thing he'd ever heard.
26:03
Loffe had been assisting the investigation since the beginning. Another year passed with
26:10
virtually no word about the Alton peak murder case, but as the second anniversary
26:17
drew near, a major investigative effort unexpectedly took place. On the afternoon of
26:25
Tuesday, October twentieth, nineteen ninety eight, the phone at the Boxelder's store
26:30
rang. The woman working the counter picked up. It was the first of
26:34
many calls inquiring about the day's goings on at the Boxelder's Cemetery, and the
26:41
store was usually the place to get the scoop not today. After piecing together
26:48
the information gleaned by the many calls and customers two sins that day, it
26:53
was determined that the grave of Alton Peak was roped off and his body exhumed.
27:00
Everyone claimed they didn't know what was happening, and that included Red River
27:04
County Sheriff Edterington, the local Justice of the Peace, and even the county
27:10
judge. The only way the exhumation could have been handled worse, an editorial
27:15
in the Paris News later read, would have been if disinterment had been ordered
27:21
in the dead of night. The comment was certainly dramatic, but it also
27:26
captured the continued frustration of area residents who felt they were continually left in the
27:33
dark when it came to their beloved county commissioner and friends murder case. A
27:40
couple days later, the mystery behind the surprise exhumation was resolved in a press
27:45
release issued by District Attorney Harrington. The president of the Boxelder Cemetery Association and
27:52
Alton's widow, Michelle, had signed off on the disinterment, which was at
27:57
the request of the one hundred nith second District Grand Jury and under the supervision
28:03
of the District Attorney's office. A grand jury investigation, secret by definition according
28:11
to Texas state law, had been under way since the previous May. The
28:15
exhumation made it impossible to hide going forward. Suggesting that his department's investigation had
28:23
come to a standstill, Sheriff Edrington said that he and da Harrington had used
28:30
the grand jury investigation in order to utilize their subpoena powers to their advantage.
28:37
The proceedings the entire six months had been used solely for the purpose of the
28:41
investigation of Alton Peak's murder. After another autopsy had been performed by a medical
28:48
examiner in McKinney, Alton's body was reburied at Hopewell Cemetery in Paris, Texas,
28:56
at Michelle Peake's request. It isn't clear what, if anything, was
29:00
learned as the result of the exhumation, but after six months of hearing testimony
29:07
and reviewing evidence, the grand jury ultimately adjourned on October twenty eighth, nineteen
29:11
ninety eight, without issuing an indictment. In fact, it ended anti climactically
29:18
with no big announcements following the case was turned back over to the Red River
29:25
County sheriff's office, and another couple years passed without any answers whatsoever. After
29:33
defeating incumbent Sheriff Bob Edrington in the Democratic primary, Bob's Story ran for the
29:40
position in two thousand and inherited the Alton Peak murder case. When he took
29:45
office in two thousand and one, Edrington was known as Young Bob, while
29:52
Story was called Old Bob. Old Bob had been sheriff of Red River County
29:57
previously, first taking that office in nineteen seventy nine and then remaining there until
30:03
Edrington defeated him in nineteen ninety two. Sheriff Edrington's inability to solve Alton's case
30:11
was likely a major factor in his defeat, and it's a talking point Bob
30:15
Story relied heavily upon during the race whether or not the incumbent was at fault.
30:22
The voluminous case file described by one deputy suggested he was doing his best.
30:29
Not long after the new sheriff took his oath of office, however,
30:33
there was a big problem, a problem that again gave rise to the once
30:37
swirling rumors that had finally settled the case file. The thousands of pages of
30:44
supplemental reports and witness statements seemingly vanished into thin air or by means more nefarious.
31:06
When Sheriff Bob's Story began his new term in January of two thousand and
31:10
one, he quickly discovered that the physical files for a handful of active cases
31:15
were missing. After searching the department's computer system, things got worse when he
31:21
realized files had been deleted. The missing files included two of Red River County's
31:27
biggest, highest stakes cases, the nineteen ninety five disappearance and likely abduction of
31:36
thirty two year old Jennifer Joyce Bench and the nineteen ninety six murder of Precinct
31:41
four County Commissioner Alton Douglas Peak. Both were cases out of the small community
31:47
of Box Elder. The sheriff and his deputies scrambled to locate the missing files,
31:53
but they had no luck until May two thousand and one, when they
31:57
were told of a storage building next to the Sheriff's office in Clarksville where the
32:01
files were kept. The news was a huge relief, though it didn't explain
32:08
the missing computer files. Deputies were told stacks of physical boxes had simply been
32:15
moved to storage, but it seemed the Red River County Sheriff's Office was never
32:20
a safe distance from rumor and controversy, and another problem was waiting for them
32:25
right around the corner, one that could have been ripped right from the pages
32:30
of a dime store detective novel. Upon their visit to the storage building on
32:35
May seventh, two thousand and one, deputies discovered the lock had been cut
32:40
and the large metal door had been lifted from the track and pulled out.
32:45
The files the department reported to the Clarksville Times had been stolen. The FBI
32:52
was called in to assist in the investigation of this burglary, and new rumors
32:57
of grand conspiracy explode did As an investigation ensued. Chief Deputy Larry Taylor made
33:05
a phone called a Burbank, California. After explaining the Alton Peak case to
33:10
a producer of Unsolved Mysteries, the execution, the prime suspect's suicide, the
33:16
exhumation, and now the missing files. The television program agreed to come to
33:22
Red River County, Texas to look into it. The Sheriff's office was looking
33:29
forward to putting both Alton Peak's murder case and Jennifer Bench's missing persons case in
33:34
front of both the fresh eyes of Unsolved Mysteries investigators and a national television audience.
33:43
Jennifer's case was actually seeing some movement. At this time. Texas rangers
33:49
and DEA agents were digging on a northwest Red River County property after receiving a
33:54
tip that was where her body was located. They never found Jennifer Joyce Bench,
34:00
and she remains missing to this day. A month after agreeing to come
34:07
to Texas, Unsolved Mysteries backed out, citing as the reasons the lack of
34:13
rock solid evidence oddly something to show itself lacks by its very nature, that
34:19
the story was too complicated, and most likely the actual reason the politics involved.
34:28
In January of two thousand and two, a year after Sheriff Bob's story
34:31
came into office and realized several case files had gone missing, it came to
34:37
light that the files had never been missing at all. In fact, most
34:43
of them were safe and secure at the Red River County Jail in Clarksville apparently
34:49
the entire time. The single brown file folder that contained the entirety of the
34:53
information in the Jennifer Bench case was found in the top drawer of a sheriff's
34:59
office filing cabinet by sheer accident, and the Alton Peak case file two boxes
35:06
was found in the evidence locker room. Likely, the absurdity of this debacle
35:12
had locals and disbelief, and exactly why the department thought anything was ever missing
35:17
at all, let alone the apparent break in at the Sheriff's office storage building
35:22
was never explained. By this time, Sheriff's Story had resigned due to poor
35:30
health, and retired highway patrolman Jerry Conway was assigned to temporarily take his place.
35:37
Conway was at a loss. He had no idea what had happened,
35:42
but it was suggested he'd have no such embarrassment at the department under his watch.
35:49
Both Alton and Jennifer's cases remained cold, but eventually one of them heated
35:53
up. In March of two thousand and six, when specifically asked what he
36:00
might do about County Commissioner Alton Peake's cold case, candidate for Red River County
36:06
Sheriff Royce Abbott told the Paris News there was an incarcerated person who might be
36:12
able to clear it up. The current Sheriff's office administration was also aware of
36:17
this individual. He added It's unclear if Abbot's remarks had anything at all to
36:23
do with what came next. He did not win the election. On September
36:29
ninth, two thousand and eight, Andrea Michelle McClure, formerly known as Michelle
36:35
Peak, Alton's widow, was arrested at her home in Paris, Texas.
36:39
She'd been charged, in Alton's case, a second degree felony charge, conspiracy
36:45
to commit murder. It had long been rumored in Box Selder in the surrounding
36:52
area that Michelle was having an affair with Jimmy Humphreys, the man who leased
36:55
Alton Land for his cattle, who was the last man to see the victim
37:00
alive, and who died of suicide a month later. After being questioned by
37:06
Sheriff Bob Edrington, newspaper reports heavily implied that the arrest of Alton's widow was
37:13
based upon this theory, though how the conclusion was reached and what evidence had
37:17
been collected remains a mystery. The cold case murder of Alton Peak, Red
37:23
River County Sheriff Terry Reid said was one of the few cases he and his
37:29
investigators had been working on since he took office. Michelle was released on a
37:35
twenty five thousand dollars bond on October third, two thousand and eight. In
37:39
January of two thousand and nine, it was announced that a grand jury held
37:44
the previous month had returned a full blown murder indictment against Michelle McClure. She'd
37:51
see trial in September. News reports announced in July of two thousand and nine.
37:58
For whatever reason, nothing happened for more than three years. Michelle remained
38:04
free on bond. In November of twenty twelve, sixteen years after the murder
38:09
of Alton Douglas Peak, an article in the Paris News said Michelle McClure would
38:15
go to trial the following February. The trial was to take place in Bowie
38:20
County after a change of venue request was approved by a Red River County judge.
38:27
When February twenty thirteen arrived, however, charges were dropped against Michelle.
38:34
Just like that, the last piece of news about Alton's nineteen ninety six murder
38:39
came and went. Evidence against Michelle McClure has never been expounded upon publicly.
38:46
The dropped charges were an abrupt pause in a long cold case steeped in decades
38:52
of controversy, rumor, and speculation. If you have any information about the
39:00
nineteen ninety six murder of Alton Peak or the nineteen ninety five disappearance of Jennifer
39:06
Bench, please contact the Red River County Sheriff's Office at nine zero three four
39:10
two seven three eight three eight. If you like Gone Cold's mission to renew
39:17
the public's interest in cold cases, you can support the show at Patreon dot
39:22
com slash Gone Cold podcast. There for as low as two dollars and fifty
39:28
cents. You'll get the show at free. Leaving a five star rating and
39:32
written review at iTunes also helps immensely, as it bumps the algorithm and gets
39:37
us into the ears of more folks. However you choose to support the show,
39:43
we appreciate it more than words can express. You can find Gone Cold
39:47
online at goncold dot com or on nearly all the social media platforms by searching
39:54
at Gone Cold podcast. You can also find a link in bio in the
39:59
ep pisodes description. Thanks for listening, y'all.