Latest / The So What? / Electricity - Green is the New Gold Pt. 1
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to the So What podcast, in which political economic analyst JP Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of South Africans.
- 0:15You can find a written version of this content on JP's website, jplandman.co.za.
- 0:21I am Ruda Landman and I am your host.
- 0:28These first few recordings were done at our dining room table, but we will soon be moving
- 0:33into a studio.
- 0:35Hello, and a very warm welcome, as always, to another recording which goes with JP's
- 0:43latest newsletter.
- 0:46This one dated the 1st of August 2022 and the title, Electricity, Green is the New Gold.
- 0:55We are going to do this in two sections because it is a much longer newsletter than usual
- 1:01and it has so much information in it that we are going to split it up.
- 1:06So this is part one of this recording.
- 1:09JP, I think before we get to the major thrust of this newsletter, we have to go back to
- 1:16the elephant in the room and that is load shedding.
- 1:19The moment we talk about electricity, that is what is in all of our minds.
- 1:25So how do you see it?
- 1:27When will we be rid of this horrific thing that has been hanging over us for so long?
- 1:34Indeed, it is the big elephant in the room and it is the big constraint holding South
- 1:39Africa back.
- 1:40No question about that.
- 1:41It is our biggest crisis.
- 1:43The short answer today is, I think towards the end of 2024.
- 1:47It means two and a half years from now.
- 1:50Why do I say that?
- 1:51Well, it is now beyond all doubt that we need 6,000 megawatts or 6 gigawatts, if you want
- 1:59to talk like that, of additional capacity that must be installed, additional capacity
- 2:06that must be created to avoid load shedding.
- 2:08S-COM is not capable of meeting that 6,000 megawatt deficit or shortfall.
- 2:15So as soon as the 6,000 megawatts are installed, then load shedding can end.
- 2:19If you look at what is currently going on, with all the decisions that have been taken
- 2:23up to date, about 14,000 megawatts of electricity, mainly renewable electricity, have been procured
- 2:32and are in the process of being set up.
- 2:36In other words, the different projects by different entrepreneurs and companies must
- 2:41reach financial closure, then they must get technical approval and link up to the S-COM
- 2:46grid and they must be built.
- 2:49On average, it takes about 12 to 18 months to build a solar farm, a wind farm, perhaps
- 2:55a little bit longer.
- 2:57So if you say that we wait two years from where we are now with the 14,000 that we have
- 3:04that have been procured, then you're looking at the middle of 2024, throw in a few extra
- 3:09months and you're looking at the end of 2024.
- 3:13So I think there's a very good chance that by the end of 2024, the country will be able
- 3:17to produce from a variety of sources the electricity that it needs and that will end load shedding.
- 3:23But I think the one thing we must all accept, internalize, is that there is no switch that
- 3:31can be thrown to just end load shedding tomorrow.
- 3:35Oh, absolutely.
- 3:36It's a very critical point.
- 3:37Indeed, we must accept that.
- 3:39This is a problem that has built up over many, many years and it's a problem that got worse
- 3:44as the years went along.
- 3:46And you're not going to fix it in, as you say, with the flick of a switch.
- 3:50It's not going to happen.
- 3:52What is also not going to happen in the short term is that we're not going to see a substantial
- 3:56improvement in S-COM's efficiency in what is called the energy availability factor.
- 4:01That used to run above 75%.
- 4:05That's the benchmark that has always been worked to.
- 4:07At some stage it ran above 80%.
- 4:10That has now come down to 60% and some weeks even lower than that.
- 4:14That's the reality of an old plant.
- 4:16That's the reality of old equipment.
- 4:18And that reality will not change.
- 4:20So I think there's a growing acceptance of that.
- 4:23The Minister of Energy, Mr. Guilherme Antáce, would like to jump up and down, up and down
- 4:27and say S-COM has become more efficient and so on and so forth.
- 4:30Well, you can't get blood from a stone.
- 4:33It's not possible.
- 4:34So yes, there's no quick fix.
- 4:36It's old equipment.
- 4:37The deficit is 6,000 megawatts.
- 4:40It'll take until the middle end 2024 to fix the deficit.
- 4:44That's how long load sharing will be with us.
- 4:46Okay.
- 4:47So now let's turn to your newsletter.
- 4:50The heading is, green is the new gold.
- 4:53It makes me think of Mango Groove and the Springbox.
- 4:56And when they're saying we go for gold, our blood is green.
- 5:01But this is a different quote.
- 5:03There have been three major announcements.
- 5:07Is it in the last week?
- 5:08Yes, indeed.
- 5:09In the last week of July, we got three very big announcements around electricity.
- 5:14The first one was the president making a TV address to the nation on electricity, where
- 5:19he spoke about the short term problems and fixing S-COM.
- 5:22But they also spoke about the longer term.
- 5:25The second one was two days later, when S-COM revealed their vision of electricity going
- 5:30forward, what they think the demand is, what will have to be supplied, built and supplied,
- 5:36and how much that will cost.
- 5:37And the third one came at the end of last week, Friday, when the national treasury confirmed
- 5:42that they are looking at taking over the substantial portion of S-COM's debt.
- 5:48Now you will recall that up till now, there were lots of speculation around that and so
- 5:53on and so forth.
- 5:54But it looks as if that's not the direction things are going.
- 5:56Now what is remarkable about these three announcements, Ruda, is that they tie together.
- 6:01They are clearly coordinated.
- 6:03They're clearly coming from the same place, so to speak, and it's clearly part of the
- 6:08bigger government program of tackling electricity.
- 6:12And those three announcements, when you look at them jointly, signal a huge game changer
- 6:16for South Africa, a game changer that really can change the country's trajectory and where
- 6:23it is.
- 6:24And I want to say, if you go back, in November 2017, before Mr. Ramaphosa was elected president
- 6:31of ANC, he was still deputy president then, in November 2017, he basically spelt out what
- 6:38is happening now.
- 6:39He said that what we need is a new energy dispensation that is much more reliable on
- 6:45renewables, saying we could again…
- 6:48Reliant, much more reliant on…
- 6:51Yeah, reliant on renewables.
- 6:53To quote his words, we could again become the investment destination of choice for activities
- 6:59that are electricity intensive.
- 7:02So against that background, one must look at these three announcements.
- 7:06Now why do I say it's a game changer?
- 7:09There are four reasons.
- 7:12The first one is we're ending a monopoly in South Africa in the provision of electricity.
- 7:17It's commercial monopoly has been for a long time in its existence.
- 7:22It provides most of South Africa's electricity.
- 7:25It has been a state run monopoly.
- 7:28For a long time it was successful and then it has become, for a variety of reasons, unsuccessful.
- 7:34And what's happening in this change is not just that you're trying to make an unsuccessful
- 7:38company successful.
- 7:40What's happening with this change is that we're moving from a monopoly electricity
- 7:44market to a free market in electricity where a variety of producers and consumers can buy
- 7:50and sell electricity as they see fit at prices that they negotiated amongst themselves.
- 7:59This is the modern trend in electricity, modern as in about 20, 30 years old.
- 8:05We have not followed that modern trend.
- 8:07We will now follow it with this change.
- 8:10It's a dispensation which is used in many countries from the Netherlands to China and
- 8:15it's successful.
- 8:16So that's the first thing.
- 8:17We're moving from a state run monopoly industry to an industry that's opened up for competition,
- 8:26opened up to the private sector and basically giving us the benefit of competition.
- 8:32The second reason why it is a game changer for South Africa is that we will be moving
- 8:37from a coal based electricity system to a system that is largely reliant on solar, wind
- 8:44and gas.
- 8:45Now, this will not happen overnight.
- 8:47Again, it's not a switch that can be flicked, but it will play out over the next 10 years.
- 8:54The role that coal is playing in providing our energy, which is three quarters of our
- 9:00energy needs being satisfied from there, that role will drop to below 50% by 2030.
- 9:06And after 2030, it will drop down further.
- 9:09We will still use coal for a long time.
- 9:11In Dupuy and Kusili, those two big power stations are coal fired.
- 9:17They're new.
- 9:18They will run for the next 40 years.
- 9:20They must in any case run because you've got to pay back the loans of the money that
- 9:24you borrowed to build them.
- 9:26But they're coal fired and we will use them for a long time.
- 9:29But I don't think South Africa will see again a new coal fired power station.
- 9:34Not a big one and also not a small one.
- 9:37The whole world is moving against coal fired power stations, also the banks and they will
- 9:41no longer finance it.
- 9:43So that on which South Africa's electricity system was built, i.e. cheap coal, will now
- 9:49be replaced by solar gas wind.
- 9:53It's a completely different ballgame.
- 9:56Now that change over, that change over will require enormous investment.
- 10:02Wind farm doesn't come for free.
- 10:04Solar farm doesn't come for free.
- 10:05The transmission lines don't come for free.
- 10:08And ESCOM, this is where the ESCOM numbers come in.
- 10:11ESCOM has calculated that up till 2030, South Africa will need between 50,000, yeah, about
- 10:1850,000 megawatts of new capacity, solar gas wind.
- 10:23And that will cost the best part of a trillion rand.
- 10:26It's an enormous amount of money.
- 10:28If you bear in mind that our economy is about a six trillion rand economy.
- 10:32So one trillion rand of investment in one industry is an enormous amount of money.
- 10:38Then there's more money needed for transmission lines, for new substations and so on.
- 10:42So you'll probably end with investment of about 1.2 trillion between now, 2022 and 2030.
- 10:51And most of that money, in fact, probably all of that money will come from either the
- 10:55private sector or concessional funding.
- 10:58There will be very little state money in that amount of 1.2 trillion.
- 11:04So huge investment opportunity for the country, huge ability to create jobs, particularly
- 11:10in rural areas of South Africa.
- 11:12One doesn't find solar plants in cities and you don't find wind farms in cities.
- 11:17It is out in the rural areas.
- 11:19And that's where we need jobs and that's where we need development.
- 11:22And the fourth reason why I think it's a game changer is that this massive swing from coal
- 11:28to renewables, this massive new investment in renewables infrastructure, this breaking
- 11:33up of the monopoly and allowing a free market and electricity to develop will bring with
- 11:40it industrialization possibilities and benefits.
- 11:43You have to manufacture a lot of solar panels.
- 11:47You have to manufacture a lot of batteries, cables, transmission lines.
- 11:50Now, some of that can be done here.
- 11:52A lot of it cannot be done here, but you can do parts.
- 11:55You can do portions of these products.
- 11:59And I quote two examples in the written piece.
- 12:02The one is the Swedish company Polarium.
- 12:06They specialize in battery storage systems and they've got two factories in the world,
- 12:10one in Mexico and one in Vietnam.
- 12:13Swedish company having factories there.
- 12:15They've now put up a battery manufacturing facility, storing and battery facility in
- 12:21Montague Gardens in Cape Town.
- 12:23And then the mining company Bushveld Minerals want to be more than a mining company and
- 12:28they're putting up a huge battery and electrolysis factory in East London.
- 12:34So these are examples of industrialization benefits that can flow from energy.
- 12:40And that is for me in line with our history.
- 12:43If you look back at South Africa's economic history, what made us a modern economy?
- 12:48Well, it was the discovery of first diamonds and then gold, actually copper and then diamonds
- 12:55and then gold and later on other minerals.
- 12:57Our entire industrial and financial system was germed, if you want, by the discovery
- 13:05of precious metals and minerals.
- 13:09And I think the same thing is going to happen again.
- 13:11This enormous investment that we have to make in renewables will be like the discovery of
- 13:17gold or diamonds, and that's why the title of this piece is Green is the New Gold.
- 13:21And in fact, it's a formulation that the president himself used.
- 13:25He said that our energy program is a case of green is the new gold.
- 13:30And I think that's why it's a game changer for South Africa.
- 13:33You take the three announcements together, it's a big story.
- 13:36Can I just ask, if you have gold and diamonds, you know that you will have a buyer.
- 13:43But electricity, energy needs to, it needs economic activity to find a buyer.
- 13:52How do we know that that is going to happen?
- 13:54Well, we have millions of buyers all over the country, households, businesses, factories,
- 13:59malls, mines.
- 14:00The clients are already there.
- 14:02But not an increase of the kind that you are describing.
- 14:05No, but remember you're switching from coal too.
- 14:08So at the moment you buy your electricity from Eskom and 95% of that comes from coal.
- 14:15So when Eskom switches from coal to something else, or when the system switches from coal
- 14:19to something else, we are already there.
- 14:22We are the clients.
- 14:23So we know that they are consumers that will buy the product.
- 14:27The problem is not that we don't have consumers, the problem is we don't have enough product.
- 14:31And that's what makes this investment so interesting.
- 14:35Talk us through what it has taken politically to get here.
- 14:40Mr. Ramaphosa, the president at the moment, was put in charge of the so-called Eskom war
- 14:46room, when was it, in 2014?
- 14:48December 2014.
- 14:51Why has it taken eight years?
- 14:52That's a very good question.
- 14:54A very, very good question.
- 14:56He was put in charge by then President Zuma in December 2014.
- 15:00In the beginning of 2015, it looks like if it was March 2015, February or March 2015,
- 15:07in other words, two or three months after he was put in charge of the war room, he reported
- 15:12back to President Zuma and he said, look, I cannot get my hands around Eskom.
- 15:17There are too many entry points and there are too many people involved and coming in
- 15:22with all kinds of ideas and agendas.
- 15:25Now we can only speculate on who the people were and what their agendas were.
- 15:29So he recommended to President Zuma that the war room be disbanded and that the CEO was
- 15:35appointed.
- 15:36That stage he was only an acting CEO.
- 15:39That the CEO was appointed and let's run the place and we can be held accountable.
- 15:43Zuma accepted those recommendations and in April 2015, the then minister of public enterprises,
- 15:51Lyn Brown, appointed Brian Wollefe as the chief executive of Eskom.
- 15:58So by March, April 2015, four or five months after he was put in charge of the war room,
- 16:04the war room was gone, Ramaphosa was out, Brian Wollefe was in charge and as the saying
- 16:09goes, the rest is history.
- 16:11So it is incorrect to suggest that he's been around for eight years dealing with electricity.
- 16:17That's not the case.
- 16:18I think, you know, one can only speculate, but I think Mr. Zuma had all kinds of nefarious
- 16:25intentions about putting Ramaphosa in charge.
- 16:28Ramaphosa probably saw through the game, then moved himself from the scene and to play
- 16:34out the way that he did.
- 16:36We got two very early indications of what Ramaphosa is thinking about electricity.
- 16:41The first one, as I said in the beginning of this broadcast, was in November 2017, while
- 16:46he was still deputy president and before his election, where he made the case that South
- 16:51Africa should do more about renewables and that is the way for South Africa to become
- 16:56an investment destination again.
- 16:58That was in 2017.
- 17:00He became president in 2018, president of the country.
- 17:05Seven weeks after he became president of the country, after he took power, his government
- 17:09signed the 27 independent power producer contracts that Brian Wollefe suspended in 2015.
- 17:17Brian Wollefe at the time argued in the same year that he became the CEO of Eskom 2015,
- 17:23he argued that these independent power producer contracts were too expensive.
- 17:27The price per kilowatt hour was simply too high and on that he was right, but one must
- 17:33see it in a particular context.
- 17:35And he said nuclear would be a better option.
- 17:38He punted the example of Kuberg and how well Kuberg has served Eskom and how well Kuberg
- 17:42has served South Africa and he wanted to go for nuclear.
- 17:46Now he then suspended those 27 independent power producers contracts and it was a tragedy.
- 17:52It was a tragedy because they brought the whole independent power producer program to
- 17:56his pedestal.
- 17:57There was a factory in Durban that produced solar panels.
- 17:59Well, it had to close down.
- 18:01People lost their jobs and the capital was gone.
- 18:04So what Wollefe did was a real, real tragedy.
- 18:08Seven weeks after he took power, the Namibian government signed those agreements and the
- 18:13process could get going again.
- 18:15So those two very early indications told you very clearly where Namibia was going.
- 18:21Then of course it took time.
- 18:23In 2019, we got February 2019, a year after he became president.
- 18:28He made a very important policy speech in the state of the nation and he said Eskom
- 18:31will be broken up.
- 18:32At that point in time, a lot of people were against this.
- 18:36Unions were against it.
- 18:37People in Eskom were against it.
- 18:40Consumers were against it.
- 18:41Activist NGOs and so on were against it.
- 18:44I think it's safe to say that a minority of people understood and supported the decision
- 18:49in 2019, but he announced and he went for it.
- 18:52And he did so three months before the general election.
- 18:55Let's not forget that.
- 18:56He could have waited until after the general election.
- 18:59He did not.
- 19:00That was in 2019.
- 19:01It's now 2022.
- 19:03And what you see if you look back over time is that he's consistently pursued this vision
- 19:09that is now busy unfolding.
- 19:11In the written piece, there's a timeline of political decisions taken by the government.
- 19:16And since 2018, the Ramaphosa government has taken 12 political decisions, 12 political
- 19:22decisions on electricity supply.
- 19:25And the cumulative effect of that is now coming through very, very strongly.
- 19:29And that's what we saw in the last, in the announcements, the three announcements last
- 19:33week.
- 19:34So it is worth our while, without reflecting back, that when those independent power contracts
- 19:40were signed, there were strikes and blockades in Chuanhe on the end for coal truckers blocked
- 19:47the highways and the streets.
- 19:49Nobody could move.
- 19:50They did that not once, but more than once.
- 19:53They launched court applications all the way to the appeal court in Blomfontein to try
- 19:57and get the government to stop signing those agreements.
- 20:01Those against the splitting up of ISCOM didn't let up.
- 20:04So what looks today like very logical things that were supported by everybody, in fact,
- 20:10were not logical things for many people.
- 20:12And people, there are still people opposed to it.
- 20:14I mean, this past weekend, we had the ANC's policy conference and the SACP was very unhappy
- 20:20about what's happening in energy.
- 20:22You can now go on certain Twitter feeding lines and you will see the unhappiness with
- 20:28the decision.
- 20:29So it's not that the nation is behind the idea.
- 20:33In fact, the nation is not behind the idea, but he's pushing ahead slowly and he's getting
- 20:38to where he wants to be.
- 20:39So my view on this is you can love Ramaphosa or hate him.
- 20:43That's absolutely fine.
- 20:45You can love his strategy of moving slowly, building consensus, getting people to come
- 20:50along or you can hate it, but you can't deny the results.
- 20:54What we're having today started in 2017, if you go by public pronouncements, it's now
- 21:00five years later and it's playing out in the way that he set the vision five years ago.
- 21:05I think that's a testimony to his political ability.
- 21:09I almost want to say it feels as if the role that Gwere Mantash has been playing is almost
- 21:16indicative of this tug of war, political tug of war that's going on.
- 21:22You say the nation, but more specifically within the ANC.
- 21:27Oh, absolutely.
- 21:28It is indicative of that.
- 21:29And the fact that these things are happening and that Mantashia is coming along tells you
- 21:34the success of the president's strategy.
- 21:37We know that he's a coal man.
- 21:39We know that he would like to extend the life of the South African coal industry.
- 21:43We know that he's skeptical about renewables.
- 21:45None of these are secrets, but he's coming along.
- 21:49He's not resigning from cabinet.
- 21:51He's not mobilizing opposition against it.
- 21:54In fact, he's helping the president to get the ANC over the line on these issues.
- 21:59So his obstructionist approach is indicative of how divided South African society is and
- 22:06the fact that the president is bringing him along is indicative of the success of the
- 22:11president's approach and strategy.
- 22:13And that's why I say you can love him, of course, or hate him, but you can't deny the
- 22:16results.
- 22:17Okay.
- 22:18Let's break this recording here simply because it gets too long.
- 22:23And then we'll make a second episode to cover what looks to me like frequently asked questions.
- 22:32Will it be implemented?
- 22:34How much of the IRP 2019 has been implemented?
- 22:38And is that an indication of the future of what's happening now or not?
- 22:44Eskom's debt.
- 22:46What about Eskom's debt?
- 22:48So let's do that in a separate package.
- 22:51So for the moment, thank you very much and goodbye.
- 22:59Thank you for listening to the So What podcast.
- 23:01If you enjoy this content, please don't forget to leave a review and a rating and please
- 23:06consider subscribing so you don't miss any future episodes.
- 23:10Also tell your friends.
- 23:12Remember you can find a written version of all JP's content at JPLandman.co.za.