Latest / Film And Whiskey / Charlie Chaplin vs. America: A Talk with Author Scott Eyman
Transcript
- 0:01Today on the Film and Whiskey Podcast, we're revisiting one of
- 0:04our favorite directors of the season as we chat with author
- 0:07Scott Eyman about his new book on the life and films of Charlie
- 0:11Chaplin. That's all ahead on the Film and
- 0:14Whiskey Podcast. Well, hey there, everybody.
- 0:35Welcome into the Film and Whiskey Podcast.
- 0:38I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad G, and we're coming at
- 0:41you with another special bonus episode.
- 0:43Bonus episode Brad. Last week I went to my mailbox
- 0:49and I opened it up. And you know, one of the
- 0:50benefits of doing a whiskey related podcast is that
- 0:53sometimes your mailbox is full of booze.
- 0:55And I had a package. Very true.
- 0:58I had a package in the mailbox and it was not booze.
- 1:01I said what is I can't drink this?
- 1:02What is this thing? And it was a book, Brad.
- 1:05It's a book that we specifically requested too because it is a
- 1:08super fascinating new book by the author Scott Eyman.
- 1:12The book is called Charlie Chaplin Versus America When Art,
- 1:16Sex and Politics Collided. We had just done a series on
- 1:20Charlie Chaplin and we kind of hinted at some of his personal
- 1:23life and how it bled into his work and how we look at his work
- 1:27in in response to that. And lo and behold, Simon and
- 1:31Schuster is putting out this new major work about the Life and
- 1:34Times of Charlie Chaplin and Brad.
- 1:37Spoiler alert, we're going to talk about that book today.
- 1:39We sure are, and we are joined by author of said book, Scott
- 1:44Ayman. And I will say this, he has
- 1:47written so much and been so influential as a film historian
- 1:52that. His bio takes up two paragraphs.
- 1:54So how about I take the first one, You take the second one,
- 1:57Bob. Does that sound good?
- 1:58It sounds great, man. Let's tag team it.
- 1:59Yeah, so Scott, as I said, he is a film historian and author of
- 2:03best selling biographies on the golden age of Hollywood,
- 2:05including, and this is Scott. We'll we'll have to talk about
- 2:09this later. Well, after the interview, my
- 2:11favorite actor of all time, Cary Grant.
- 2:13He's written biographies on John Wayne, Cecil B DeMille, John
- 2:17Ford, Louis B Mayer, Henry Fonda and Jimmy Stewart.
- 2:20Yeah, Scott's also worked as a book editor and art critic for
- 2:23the Palm Beach Post. He's a reviewer for the Wall
- 2:26Street Journal, Film Comments, The New York Observer.
- 2:29He's had articles published in the New York Times, The
- 2:31Washington Post, the Chicago Tribune.
- 2:33You know, basically all the major players at this point.
- 2:36Brad. I've never heard of him, Bob.
- 2:38You might have even caught him on TVA couple weeks ago.
- 2:41I just watched him introduce 4 films on Charlie Chaplin on
- 2:44Turner Classic Movies. Scott, it is great to have you
- 2:47here. Oh, thanks for inviting me guys.
- 2:49It's. It's good to be on a show with
- 2:51such an enticing title. Yeah, we try.
- 2:53We get right to the point. We we often find that that our
- 2:57guests enjoy the Whiskey Ave. just as much as the film.
- 3:00If you have a lot of writers on that, that they'll definitely
- 3:03opt for the whiskey. Yeah.
- 3:04Yeah, for sure. All right, Scott, let's dive
- 3:06right in talking about this book.
- 3:08First of all, thank you for writing this.
- 3:10It's a, it's a phenomenal piece of writing.
- 3:12And you know, it's as suspenseful as it is
- 3:15informative, I have to say. Thanks.
- 3:17Thanks. It was a.
- 3:18It's a. It was a tough narrative to keep
- 3:20straight because there's four or five things going on at the same
- 3:23time a lot of the time. So it's about a fairly
- 3:27compressed period in his life. And there were times when I
- 3:31thought, OK, I'm losing the thread here.
- 3:33You know, you have to go back and make sure it has clarity
- 3:36because clarity is crucial with a story like this.
- 3:40Well, I think that's a great segue into my first question.
- 3:41So this really hyper focuses on one period of Chaplin's life and
- 3:46that is his exile from America post war.
- 3:49And I'm wondering, as a biographer, how do you decide or
- 3:53like, you know, especially with this period in Chaplin's life,
- 3:57how did you identify that this was kind of the lens through
- 4:00which to look at the rest of his life and career?
- 4:02Well, in one sense it was it it it felt inevitable To me.
- 4:07It was the culmination of of decades of his political
- 4:13beliefs. His sexual behavior, his
- 4:16aesthetic contract with his audience and hit with his own
- 4:19self-image. Chaplin was not a man to trim
- 4:25his sails. No matter what he was told by
- 4:28smart people he was going to go ahead with what he thought was
- 4:32the right thing to do from hell or high water.
- 4:34His whole life pointed him towards towards that point of
- 4:37view he had the catastrophic childhood.
- 4:40Which basically taught him, if it could be boiled down to one
- 4:43thing, it was that you can't depend on anybody but yourself.
- 4:48And he was lucky in that he had a brother that he adored and who
- 4:51adored him in return. And Sidney, his brother, who was
- 4:54two years older, was always there for Charlie, and Charlie
- 4:57was as as much there for Sidney as was humanly possible as well.
- 5:02So they each had each other in a very close bond.
- 5:06But still, Sidney was also a comedian.
- 5:09Of of some skill and in some success.
- 5:12So it had to be difficult for him on on some level to have a A
- 5:16a brother who was Hale, was a genius and is a extraordinary
- 5:22primary artist of the 20th century.
- 5:25But you never know it. From his letters he was just
- 5:27100% on Charlie's team. But Charlie, with very few
- 5:32exceptions, didn't trust society at large.
- 5:36Didn't trust the things people said.
- 5:39You can only trust the things people did.
- 5:41And in his experience, people acted basically out of
- 5:44self-interest. If you couldn't do them any
- 5:47good, they tended to ignore you, not necessarily step on your
- 5:51face with their boot heel, but they weren't going to expend a
- 5:54huge amount of effort on your behalf.
- 5:57So he early on learned that you had to depend on nobody but
- 6:00yourself. So as a result, he allowed very
- 6:03few people in. He had very few intimate
- 6:05friends. He had one close friend, close
- 6:08male friend, Douglas Fairbanks, Senior Douglas Fairbanks died
- 6:12young. It was in his 50s in 1939 and
- 6:16after that he never really had another close male friend.
- 6:20He had employees that were there for decades.
- 6:23He was very loyal to and they were very loyal to him.
- 6:26But intimate friendships? Not really, no, no.
- 6:30He he was very much self-directed and self oriented.
- 6:34Until he met his last wife when O'Neill Chaplin.
- 6:38He gave himself over to another human being completely, probably
- 6:42for the first time in his life. And I I think that's what's like
- 6:45so fascinating for me about this book is that, you know, before
- 6:49you even get to the table of contents, you have a a a quote
- 6:53from him. And I'll read just a tiny bit of
- 6:56it, where he says my ego edits my life more than any moral
- 7:00code. And I would never do anything to
- 7:02shame it, for I have to live with myself.
- 7:05And I think that as I've been reading your book, the
- 7:08psychological profile of Chaplin is just fascinating, you know,
- 7:13And as you said, you were pulling all the different
- 7:16threads of these narratives swirling about his life, the
- 7:21ability to stay connected to his psychological profile.
- 7:25And you know, as you said, how at the end of his life he's with
- 7:28Uno O'Neill and. And it seems to be the first
- 7:30person he's ever opened himself up to.
- 7:32I I mean that just that makes for compelling reading, Scott.
- 7:36Well thanks. Thanks.
- 7:37The the the relationship with Una is really I think indicates
- 7:42his character in a way that nothing else does because the
- 7:45reason that the relationship was they were married.
- 7:47She was 18 when they married. He was 53, I believe 53 or 54.
- 7:52And nobody was suspicious about it at all.
- 7:54No, no, no, no. Nobody.
- 7:56Nobody raised an eyebrow. Nobody was upset.
- 7:58No, not. But the reason they had they
- 8:01were married for the rest of his life.
- 8:02They were basically idyllically happy.
- 8:04They had eight children together.
- 8:06The reason it worked was because each of them gave the other what
- 8:11they've been looking for their entire life.
- 8:13O'Neill was the daughter of Eugene O'Neill, who was a
- 8:16bastard. Great writer, but a bastard.
- 8:19And he had basically taken a dislike to the child, all of his
- 8:25children. He had two sons and a daughter.
- 8:27And he was really never a part of any of their lives to speak
- 8:30of. And he regarded them as mistakes
- 8:33or with disdain that seems completely out of proportion to
- 8:37who they actually were. Both of his sons committed
- 8:40suicide. Una was saved by her marriage to
- 8:43Chaplain. What Una gave Chaplain was
- 8:46complete acceptance, and for who he was and what he was.
- 8:50She didn't try to change him. She didn't try to mold him.
- 8:54She didn't try to make him into something he wasn't.
- 8:56He was a man in middle, the middle years.
- 8:57By that time she understood that he was a workaholic and
- 9:01compulsive, and if he didn't get his his work, in his writing, in
- 9:05his filmmaking, in whatever happened to be doing at that
- 9:08moment, he didn't feel he'd earned his dinner because that
- 9:11was the way he was raised. He raised himself, and in return
- 9:15he gave her complete acceptance as well, which she'd never been
- 9:18able to get from her father. So it was a perfect perfect.
- 9:23Match in terms of their emotion, each of their emotional needs.
- 9:27Well, if I can, if I can, go from a complete acceptance with
- 9:30his, his, his last wife to complete rejection.
- 9:34I mean the the way the book is centered on this crucial moment
- 9:39in Chaplin's life when he goes to take his film basically on
- 9:42tour in Europe and then is denied entry into the United
- 9:45States and essentially never returns except for when he
- 9:48collects his honorary Oscar in the 1970s.
- 9:52It seems that the tipping point though comes in the early 1940s
- 9:56and I believe it's 1942 you say in the book Chaplains basically
- 9:59starts advocating for a second front in World War 2,
- 10:04essentially to support Russia, and the FBI takes that as I
- 10:09guess the the nail in the coffin to start investigating him and
- 10:12they write a 2000, almost 2000 page dossier on him.
- 10:17I'm wondering what was it about that specific stance that tipped
- 10:22the FBI into investigating him when there had been rumors for
- 10:27years? What was it about that public
- 10:30stance that that became the tipping point?
- 10:33They had. They'd opened a file on him in
- 10:341922. Because he'd been attending some
- 10:38socialist meetings in Los Angeles, he had neglected to
- 10:42welcome Will Hayes to Los Angeles when Will Hayes was
- 10:45named the Tsar. The movies.
- 10:47In order to forestall censorship because of a series of scandals
- 10:51that have broken out into Hollywood, so the industry felt
- 10:53they had to do something to defuse it.
- 10:55So they brought in Will Hayes, who had been in the cabinet of
- 10:58Warren G Harding, which is of course tantamount to being a
- 11:03criminal as to run a kind of loosely defined oversee
- 11:11production of films. Censorship, in essence.
- 11:14Chaplin had greeted this with a a great deal of sardonic humor,
- 11:18which got the attention of what became the FBI and they and they
- 11:22they opened a file on him, but nothing really came of it.
- 11:25Things heated up in in the late 1930s there were some people
- 11:28that felt Modern Times was politically on the edge.
- 11:35I think it was, but people really started paying attention
- 11:38in in the late 1930s when he began production on The Great
- 11:42Dictator. The film comes out in October of
- 11:441940, at a time when both the public and the Congress are
- 11:50isolationist by a considerable amount.
- 11:54There was no interest on the part of the American public or
- 11:58of the American government outside of the White House.
- 12:01Franklin Roosevelt to get involved in either the problems
- 12:05of Europe or the problems of Jews of Europe.
- 12:08Chaplin felt otherwise. He felt that immigrants needed
- 12:11to be welcomed. And he felt that Hitler had to
- 12:13be confronted directly, in spite of the fact that the Motion
- 12:19Picture Association didn't want the film made.
- 12:22The British Foreign Office didn't want the film made
- 12:24because at the time Neville Chamberlain was the Prime
- 12:26Minister and he was trying to basically buy Hitler off and
- 12:31avoid World War 2. So Chaplain went ahead and did
- 12:34what he always did, which is what he thought was the best
- 12:36thing to do. He financed the film personally,
- 12:39which he had been doing since 1918.
- 12:41All those films were self financed.
- 12:42That way nobody could tell him what to do and nobody could edit
- 12:45his films with him and nobody could release his films in any
- 12:48way they wanted except him. So he financed the film himself
- 12:53and it was a considerable critical and commercial success
- 12:56in spite of everybody saying it was going to be a disaster.
- 12:59But by making the film, in spite of all the objections and all
- 13:04the resistance, Chaplin had branded himself as a premature
- 13:07anti fascist. And there's nothing worse.
- 13:10In American politics than being a premature anti fascist and and
- 13:15and at that point the FBI started sniffing around.
- 13:18They started sniffing around obviously.
- 13:20So about 18 months later, after Pearl Harbor, when the Russia,
- 13:25Russia was now our ally in the fight against Hitler and Chaplin
- 13:29began making speeches advocating the opening of a second front to
- 13:34aid our Russian allies in fighting fascism, certainly
- 13:39within conservative movement. In Congress and in the public at
- 13:43large, it was regarded as a non starter because they simply
- 13:47didn't regard Russia as, as ever being able to be our ally.
- 13:52They could only be our enemy in waiting, and Chaplin argued that
- 13:57they may very well be our enemy in waiting, but at this moment
- 14:01in time, at this moment in history, they're our ally and we
- 14:03have to make sure they don't lose that, or really any, he
- 14:08began making a series of speeches.
- 14:10Advocating the opening of the 2nd and the FBI began taking
- 14:14dictation. They began going to these
- 14:17speeches and noting what was said and noting who else was at
- 14:22the meetings. Sometimes they were left
- 14:24wingers, sometimes they weren't, but they basically began
- 14:28surveilling. And all this is, as I said,
- 14:311940, two 1943. While all this is going on, he
- 14:35also gets embroiled in a paternity suit.
- 14:40In a with a woman that he's been having an affair with.
- 14:43After the release of The Great Dictator, he got involved with a
- 14:46young woman named Joan Berry. She was 22 or 23.
- 14:50She had been the mistress of J Paul Getty in Oklahoma before
- 14:52this. She thought it would be fun to
- 14:54be in the movies. Got a letter of introduction.
- 14:57Came to Los Angeles to meet people in the movie industry.
- 14:59Got introduced to Chaplin. One thing led to another.
- 15:04They were together for about a year.
- 15:06They broke up. She came back.
- 15:09Some months later to LA and said she was pregnant and he did the
- 15:15math and he realized that he couldn't be the father.
- 15:18She insisted he was the father. Then she went to Hedda Hopper,
- 15:22and at that point the wheels of injustice began to grind because
- 15:27Hedda Hopper had had a how to put this delicate hard on about
- 15:31Charlie Chaplin? Well, and just real quick, Hedda
- 15:36Hopper being probably the most famous gossip columnist in in
- 15:40Hollywood. Right.
- 15:41There's nobody like, remotely in that league now.
- 15:43But I mean, she was syndicated through the Los Angeles Times
- 15:46Syndicate to hundreds and hundreds of newspapers.
- 15:49Everybody, daily column, everybody read her.
- 15:52She was also she was a former actress, a character actress.
- 15:56But she was saved by the Los Angeles Times, who had her start
- 16:01writing a column, and it turned out.
- 16:02She was a good columnist and she knew everybody in Hollywood and
- 16:08she had an edge. And she was also extremely
- 16:12conservative. I call her the Madame Defarge of
- 16:14the Red Scare. So she disliked chaplain on
- 16:17political grounds and she disliked chaplain on sexual
- 16:20grounds because Hetta Hopper's back story was very specific.
- 16:24She's been married to a man in De Wolf Hopper who is a well
- 16:26known vaudeville star in Rouet with the five or six wives.
- 16:31And he was much older than her. And they married, and he dumped
- 16:35her, leaving her with a child and no visible means of support.
- 16:40But because of her own background as well as her
- 16:42political beliefs, Chaplin checked all the boxes, and she
- 16:46went after him with a vengeance. And she enlisted other columnist
- 16:51who had similar political affiliations to go after him
- 16:56with a vengeance. So before you knew it, you had.
- 17:01The Chicago Tribune syndicate filling their daily pages with
- 17:06anti chaplain columns and articles.
- 17:09The Los Angeles Times syndicate. The Hearst papers.
- 17:12Three major newspaper chains. At a time when newspapers were
- 17:16the way people got all their information and people began to
- 17:20think what about this chaplain guy?
- 17:23He never became a citizen and here he is saying we should be
- 17:27in bed with Russia. And here he is with all these
- 17:31young girls and so forth and so on.
- 17:34And then at that point Chaplain married O'Neill, who was 18 and
- 17:38he was 53 or 54, and that seemed to confirm everything that was
- 17:43being brooded about in the newspapers, all these, these
- 17:48domino and the dominoes began to fall, and the public at large,
- 17:52who had always basically gone wherever Charlie Chaplin LED.
- 17:56But finally, the combination of his political beliefs, his lack
- 18:00of citizenship and the paternity suit began to turn the public
- 18:05against him. And it didn't really change.
- 18:08Even when he took a blood test and the blood test proved that
- 18:10he was not the father of the child, he lost the case.
- 18:14He lost the paternity case. His appeals were denied.
- 18:18So he had to start paying child support for a child that wasn't
- 18:22his. And you can imagine how that
- 18:25made him feel. Well and it it all culminates
- 18:29in, you know you you go into great detail in the book,
- 18:32especially about Hopper petitioning Richard Nixon who
- 18:36was on the, you know, coming up in the political scene about to
- 18:39run for vice president. And it culminates in chaplain
- 18:42getting barred from entry into the US and he really is on an
- 18:46island. And you There's a really
- 18:48interesting tidbit that the only three people in Hollywood where
- 18:52he was king for decades that came to his defense were Samuel
- 18:57Goldwyn, Cary Grant and William Wyler, and they publicly decried
- 19:01what was happening to him. Did he have a personal
- 19:04relationship with any of those three?
- 19:06And to what extent was that relationship?
- 19:09He and Goldwyn went back to the 20s.
- 19:12They were friends, not intimate friends.
- 19:14I mean, they didn't hang around socially particularly.
- 19:16Goldman was a strange character, and Chaplin was a strange
- 19:19character too. But they, I mean they they liked
- 19:21each other because they were both independent, fiercely
- 19:23independent. Cary Grant.
- 19:25No, he had no social relationship with Cary Grant.
- 19:28Tyler, I just found this out last week.
- 19:31A friend of mine is friends with Catherine Wyler, William Wyler's
- 19:34daughter. And he put her on the phone with
- 19:37me because she read about the book and she wanted to talk to
- 19:39me and I'd never met her. And she told me that she.
- 19:44It was the last survivor of the Chaplin Wyler tennis tournaments
- 19:47because Wyler lived on Summit Drive a couple doors up from
- 19:50Chaplin and Chaplin had a tennis court and Wyler had a tennis
- 19:54court and they would get together for these week weekend
- 19:57tennis tournaments where you know, Chaplin was a very serious
- 20:01tennis player and evidently Wyler and his was too.
- 20:04So they would really go at it. Their wives were not so serious
- 20:09and the kids thought the whole competition thing was
- 20:11ridiculous, so they would throw things at the.
- 20:14The wives when they tried to play tennis, because neither
- 20:16Wyler's wife or Chaplin's wife could play tennis at all, no,
- 20:21But he said, she said they they were Wyler and Chaplin played
- 20:24for blood. So he and Wyler had a social
- 20:26relationship, but that was where it ended.
- 20:29They. Just happened to be neighbors,
- 20:31basically. But no.
- 20:34Cary Grant? No.
- 20:35But Cary Grant had a kind of libertarian streak about
- 20:38behavior, and he also stood up for Ingrid Bergman a few years
- 20:41later when she had her affair with Roberta Rossellini and got
- 20:43pregnant. And he said it was nobody's
- 20:46business. You know, what people do in
- 20:47their private life is nobody's business.
- 20:49But by 1952, which is when, September 1952, when Chaplain
- 20:53got kicked out of the country, the blacklist is in full sway.
- 20:58And most of the people that had been persecuted by the blacklist
- 21:03were either in New York, in Mexico or hiding out, you know,
- 21:09are working under pseudonyms. They were out of the industry,
- 21:12effectively out of the industry. So everybody that was within the
- 21:15industry was not going to stand up and say this is wrong, this
- 21:19is ridiculous. He's not a communist.
- 21:21They didn't want to be guilty of guilt by association, you know,
- 21:24with someone who's obviously unpopular with the general
- 21:27public and extremely unpopular with the probably 60% of the
- 21:33American public. Yeah.
- 21:35And as you look at his career then you know the hindsight is
- 21:39gives you certain benefits. Is there any, like certain
- 21:42poignants to some of his earlier works, knowing the exile and
- 21:47kind of pain that came along with that, that was ahead for
- 21:50him? Well, the the tramp is always an
- 21:53outsider. The tramp is always an outsider.
- 21:57And it's not that it's interesting because I was
- 21:59watching Modern Times recently and you guys remember the
- 22:04opening. You know, the factory starts,
- 22:06it's people are streaming into the factory to go to work and
- 22:10the production line starts up and everybody's working
- 22:14frantically to keep up with the production line.
- 22:16And then we cut to the president of the company who's sitting at
- 22:20his desk working a Jigsaw Plaza because he has nothing else to
- 22:23do. And it's very funny because I
- 22:27think that's a very apartment way of characterizing reality,
- 22:31because it's not that people are evil or, you know, wearing iron
- 22:34boots to keep put on the throats of the working man.
- 22:38It's much less complicated than that.
- 22:40People are just interested in their own lives, and they're
- 22:43not. They're only interested in other
- 22:44people up to a point. And after that point, they don't
- 22:48really care. And that's that's basically
- 22:53reality. That's basic reality, and
- 22:56Chaplain's position as an outsider is rigorously
- 23:01maintained in his films. Rigorously maintained.
- 23:05He's always at the end of the film.
- 23:07Whatever happens during the film, at the end of the film,
- 23:11he's usually, he's almost always isolated and heading down the
- 23:13road or or alone on some psychologically, emotionally,
- 23:18physically and the ending of City Lights, you know, where he
- 23:21stares at the girl and she recognizes him what's going to
- 23:24happen next and he ends it on the close up, you know, because
- 23:28there's no way to go beyond that recognition scene.
- 23:32It's a it's one of the great endings in movies.
- 23:34The the The Tramp is that not just a character he played, it's
- 23:38his alter ego. It's his way of expressing his
- 23:41feelings about an outsider, an eternal outsider in a society
- 23:46that isn't really interested in outsiders except in a kind of
- 23:50romantic guy in a Horace Western way.
- 23:54You know, we don't really trust outsiders.
- 23:57We trust people who are like us, people who have mortgages and
- 24:01families and and and we can see around the swimming pool.
- 24:04You know and aren't marrying a girl 30-40 years younger than
- 24:08that. Oh no, that happens all the
- 24:10time. Sure.
- 24:11That happens all the IT happened all the time in Hollywood.
- 24:14It happens all the time outside of Hollywood.
- 24:16You know, I'm. I live I live very near Palm
- 24:19Beach, where any night on Palm Beach you can see guys who are
- 24:2370 and 80 years old with a cluster of 25 and 30 year old
- 24:29blondes clustered around them. Now why is this happening?
- 24:34Is it happening because they're so devastatingly charming and
- 24:36their their conversation is so sparkling.
- 24:39They're. All pretty.
- 24:40They're all pretty much Cary Grant.
- 24:42Oh yeah, imagine they're Cary Grant.
- 24:44They may have an Ascot, but that's where they resemble, you
- 24:47know, No, they're clustered around them because they have
- 24:49money and chaplains. Saw it all the time in Hollywood
- 24:52and saw it all the time in London growing up.
- 24:55Because that is, that's a common transaction.
- 25:00Men and women. Yeah, it's not.
- 25:02It's not unheard of. He didn't vent it in his private
- 25:05life. He took advantage of it, but he
- 25:07didn't. Yeah, well, and.
- 25:11And he might have been one of the few to actually find
- 25:13happiness in that. And you know, as you said at the
- 25:15start, it seems like he and Uno O'Neill did find happiness.
- 25:19Yeah. Now, Scott, I'm curious.
- 25:22As as somebody who knows more about Charlie Chaplin than I
- 25:27would have, I would wager Bob, you can correct me if I'm wrong.
- 25:30I'd wager you know more about Charlie Chaplin than 99% of the
- 25:33human. Population.
- 25:34I think it's probably a fair assumption.
- 25:36Probably. Probably a fair assessment.
- 25:38What what questions do you still have about his life?
- 25:42Like it? You know, A lot of times when we
- 25:44dig into something it, you know, we get answers, but the answers
- 25:48raise more questions than. You know we we had to start
- 25:51with. So is there anything that you're
- 25:52still curious about that you're like, man, I want to know more
- 25:55about this part of his life or this relationship or is there
- 25:59anything that stuck out to you as as I want to know more about
- 26:02his life. My favorite story in the book
- 26:05came from Groucho Marx, and Groucho saw that they were
- 26:10friends in vaudeville before they went to the movies, and
- 26:14they but they didn't socialize much because Vaudevillians were
- 26:18in constant motion. They always worked, occasionally
- 26:20working the same bill with somebody who actually knew
- 26:22generally you didn't. But one night in 1913, this is
- 26:26in September, I believe 1913, they were both in Salt Lake
- 26:30City. Chapman was leaving Salt Lake
- 26:31City because his show had closed and the Marx Brothers were just
- 26:35coming in and they had one night where they were both in Salt
- 26:38Lake City and the Marx Brothers wanted to go to a whorehouse
- 26:42because they were the Marx Brothers and Groucho invited
- 26:46Chaplin to go with him. That's a great line.
- 26:49They wanted to go to a whorehouse.
- 26:50Why? Because they were.
- 26:53That's incredible. So they invited Chaplin to go
- 26:56with him. So Chaplin had nothing else to
- 26:58do because his laundry had been done.
- 27:00So they go to the whorehouse and the Marx Brothers pick out
- 27:03girls, and they go in the back to do what you do.
- 27:08Chaplin was too shy to take a girl.
- 27:11Chaplin stayed in the lobby and played with the madam's dog all
- 27:15night until the Marx Brothers were through and came out, and
- 27:18then they all went back to the hotel.
- 27:20To me, that is so indicative of his crippling social shyness
- 27:25that never really left him and how much fame enabled him to
- 27:32come out of his shell. Because when you're famous and
- 27:35when you're rich, you don't have to introduce yourself to people.
- 27:39People introduce themselves to you and people come up to you
- 27:43and women come up to you. And this guy who was so
- 27:48cripplingly shy that he couldn't, he could barely have a
- 27:51conversation with a girl, let alone a physical relationship
- 27:54with a girl he had. It has a choice, has its choice,
- 27:58and his world changes. Not because he's any different
- 28:02as a human being, but because his opportunities are suddenly
- 28:06opened up. Because he's got a whole
- 28:08different world, a whole different lifestyle.
- 28:10Because he becomes a star on a level that nobody had been
- 28:15before him. Literally.
- 28:17There had never been a movie star like Chaplin before
- 28:21Chaplin. He invents what we think of as
- 28:24modern stardom, where nobody knows who you are in January of
- 28:28one year and 18 months later you're a multi millionaire.
- 28:33The money is rolling in so fast you can't count it and everybody
- 28:36knows who you are. That's the kind of start of the
- 28:38event. What I would ask him is if I'm
- 28:42right in imagining that becoming famous was simultaneously
- 28:47liberating for him on a emotional level and on a sexual
- 28:51level, and also terrifying for him, because how could you
- 28:55possibly live up to that when inside you feel like this scared
- 28:59little child from London? Yeah, yeah.
- 29:03I think that's an incredible question and I it it segues into
- 29:06what I wanted to finish with and Scott, I wanted to tell you that
- 29:10part of what? I love about this book is it
- 29:12does what all great biographies do.
- 29:14It is it's an incredible look into one man's unique personal
- 29:19lived experience. But it really taps into
- 29:21something I think much more universal than that.
- 29:23And in the case of Chaplin, you know, it is this long history of
- 29:28the suppression of art and artists.
- 29:30And I wonder, you know, if if there is one main take away or
- 29:34one main lesson that you would like others to take away from
- 29:38the story of Chaplin. And his involvement with the
- 29:41government? What did you learn in writing
- 29:43this book, and what are you hoping to impart to the readers
- 29:46here? What I learned in writing this
- 29:48book is that everything that's happening in America today has
- 29:53happened before. the US government using its leverage to
- 29:59enforce, try to enforce behavior, not not legalities.
- 30:05That's within government's purview but behavior it's
- 30:08regarded it regard it might regard as untoward or speech it
- 30:13regards as untoward. That is is the what makes the
- 30:18book an ugly word relevant I think in that it's 75 years have
- 30:24gone by 70 years have gone by since the events the book is
- 30:27about culminating in the events. The book is about 1952, but
- 30:33nothing's really changed because everything that happened that is
- 30:36happening now. And I have no doubt that unless
- 30:39we're swamped by it this time, it will happen again in 20 years
- 30:42or 40 years or 70 years. Because I see this kind of
- 30:47incipient Footsie dance with the under the table, with
- 30:52authoritarianism as like a staph infection in the American body
- 30:57pond. And no, no, no antibiotics seems
- 31:02to cure it. Not really because it's it's
- 31:05always, it's always ready to rear back as the bitch is always
- 31:09an eat, you know the the antibiotics don't work and it's
- 31:12simply lies in wait until the body politic is weakened
- 31:17sufficiently and then it comes roaring back.
- 31:19And it came roaring back and obliterated Chaplain's career in
- 31:23America and it's doing the same thing today, you know.
- 31:28And I'm sure it's not going to go away anytime soon.
- 31:31I was going to say author and political commentator Scott
- 31:36Iman, everybody. I was going to say, Scott, we
- 31:39cannot thank you enough for being with us today.
- 31:41The author is Scott Iman. The book is Charlie Chaplin
- 31:44Versus America When Art, Sex and Politics Collided.
- 31:48Scott, thank you for your time today.
- 31:50Happy to do it. Call me anytime.
- 31:52We'll be back on Tuesday with another regularly scheduled
- 31:54episode. But until then, I'm Bob.
- 31:56Book. I'm Brad G.
- 31:58And we'll see you next time.