Latest / Coffee and Crime with Mom / The Woman in the Cupboard | The Bizarre Kasuya, Japan Case
Transcript
- Nicholle: Kasuya, a small town in Fukuoka Prefecture, on the southern Japanese island of Kaiushu. 2008, a fifty-seven-year-old man lives alone. He's between jobs, his days are quiet and they follow a pattern. The kind of pattern a person falls into when there's no one else in the house to disrupt it. He wakes, he eats, he leaves, he comes back, he sleeps, and for a long time nothing about any of it was remarkable. And then the food started going. not a lot, not all at once. Just a little less in the refrigerator than he remembered. A few bites missing here, a container not quite as full as he'd left it, the kind of absence you'd explain away a hundred times before you'd ever let yourself be afraid of it. So he did what many of us do. He blamed himself, wondered if he was sleepwalking, getting up in the night, eating, forgetting. And let's be honest, we've all stared into the fridge at midnight and wondered the next morning, did I really finish that? So at first, this is almost a joke. A man alone in his house losing track of his own leftovers. But it didn't stop. It kept happening. And the thing about a small mystery is this, it's only charming until it repeats. once a pattern shows up, your brain stops making excuses and starts looking for an answer. So he tightens up. He locks the doors, secures the windows, becomes careful in a way that a person only becomes when something has started to feel wrong. And the food still disappeared, which leaves a thought that none of us want to think. If the doors are locked and you didn't eat it yourself, then whatever is taking your food is already inside. Hey everyone, welcome back to Coffee and Crime with Mom. I'm Nicole. Zalle: And I'm Zale. Today's case starts with something incredibly ordinary, a door left unlocked, and ends with a woman who spent nearly a year secretly living inside a stranger's closet. Nicholle: We're talking about a quiet town in Japan, a single man living alone, and a fifty-eight-year-old woman named Tatsuku Horikawa, who turned his Oshire, his built-in closet, into a hidden home. Zalle: we'll move from the discovery of what was happening behind the sliding door into what daily life inside that space actually looked like and into the theories about what this really was. Survival, something stranger are both. Let's get started. Nicholle: For nearly a year a woman lived inside a stranger's house, and he never knew. While he slept, she was there. While he ate breakfast at his own table, she was there. While he watched television, showered, and lived every ordinary day of his life, she was a few feet away, behind a sliding door the entire time. Zalle: And here's the detail that changes everything. She wasn't crammed into some tiny coat closet. She fit in there. She lived in there. Which means whatever that space was, it wasn't what most of us picture when we hear the word closet. Nicholle: What she crawled into is called in Oshire. I'm not sure if I'm saying that right, I'm positive, I'm not. But it's a traditional Japanese built-in closet, almost always sealed behind sliding, paper covered doors called Fusuma. And here's the part that matters. An O'Shire is not a shallow little space for hanging shirts. It's deep, roughly the size of one tatami mat, About ninety centimeters deep and one hundred and eighty centimeters long. One source puts it plainly. A standard OSHIR is big enough that you could sleep in one if you wanted to. Zalle: So she wasn't stuffed in there like luggage. She was lying in a small shelf like room, split into a upper and lower compartment by a middle shelf. The top compartment, that's where she was. Nicholle: That space would have been empty enough to move into for a simple reason. In a traditional Japanese room, the room is everything. Bedroom at night, living room by day. There's no bulky furniture standing guard. Every morning the futon, the thin floor mattress gets folded up and pushed into the OSHIR to clear the floor for the day. Leaving your bedding out is even considered a little rude. Zalle: So the closet is designed to sit empty for hours. Most of the day and all night. If the man was sleeping on a bed instead of a futon. The sliding doors close silently and hide everything behind them. And because They're partly paper, air moves through. She could breathe in there. Nicholle: I mean, picture it, a deep, quiet, breathable cavity sitting empty for hours at a stretch inside the home of a single man on a predictable schedule. The space is so woven into Japanese life that Doriman, the robot cat from one of the country's most beloved cartoons, famously sleeps in an OSHIR. It's practically a character's bedroom. There are even people in Tokyo today renting out closet sized Oshire rooms, windowless about two and a half square meters for as little as six hundred yen a night. She just found one for free. Zalle: According to the reports, she gotten in one day when the man had left his door unlocked. She found the place empty and she just stayed. Nicholle: She came out only when he was out or asleep. She took small amounts of food, she used his shower. She used his toilet, but two details define this entire case. First, she stole nothing, no money, no valuables, nothing but a little food. Second, she kept everything immaculate. She cleaned up after herself. She even cleaned the toilet in the shower after using them. Police described her in their own words as as neat and clean. That's why he never caught her. For a whole year. Zalle: When they finally asked her why, she gave them one sentence. I had nowhere to go. Nicholle: So this is where it gets complicated because usually the theories mean figuring out who did it. Here we already know, we pottered. So the theories aren't about identity, they're about what this actually was. Zalle: Right. So theory one and the one the police record basically supports is that this was pure survival. Horikawa was homeless, fifty-eight, unemployed. She found an unlocked door, found a warm, dry, empty space, and took shelter. She stole nothing, like we said, hurt no one and cleaned up after herself because she was trying to be invisible, not to harm anybody. On this reading, she's not a predator. She's a desperate person who found a hiding place and clung to it, which would make sense if she literally had nowhere else to go. Nicholle: Right, and the evidence for this one's strong. Her own words, I had nowhere to go. The absence of theft or violence, the care she took not to be detected, because Doing you. But I get where it breaks down. A year is a long time to keep calling something pure survival. Sleeping feet from him, learning his schedule, emerging to watch his television, that stretches shelter into something a lot more intimate than the word usually means. It's the TV detail that gets me. She wasn't just surviving in there, she was relaxing in his living room. Zalle: It sounds like she was what do they what what they call it? Frogging is the term where people like live in your walls and you don't know that they live there. Some people do it one because they're cuckoo for cocoa puffs. But if she did do this because she didn't have anywhere to go, I mean, what the hell do you expect her to do during the day when he's not there? Stay in the closet? I would've watched T V too. I mean, it's there. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Right. I know. I would have two. Right. Zalle: For free. Okay, but theory two theory two comes from the police themselves. She was a serial squatter, that's what I thought. A closet hopper, which that's insane. Investigators suspected she may have moved between different homes in the neighborhood during that year, that this man's closet wasn't her first and maybe not her only one at the time. It explains the about a year. But not all the time qualifier in their statement against it, it's never been confirmed. No other victims, no other documented closets. It's a theory that patches a lucid and not one that's been proven, but that does if if if she wasn't there all the time and there were spouse where he was there and he never saw her, it would make sense that she wasn't there all the time. Nicholle: And it he That's what I was about to say. He didn't know she was there until he started noticing the food growing she had been there a long time. So the police floated it, but there's no public evidence behind it. Okay, so theory three. Zalle: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Okay. Theory three is the one that sits heaviest with me. This was something more psychological than survival. Not malicious in a criminal sense, but parasitic. The cleanliness, the duration, the choice to emerge and watch his television, the willingness to sleep, feet from a stranger for a year. That's a level of intimacy with a stranger's life that goes past I needed a place to sleep. The home wasn't just a shelter. It was a life she quietly attached herself to. The evidence is behavioral. Patterns, not theft. Against it, we don't actually know her mind. A desperate person behaving carefully can look a lot like a calculating one. I don't want to hand you creepy dressed up as diagnosed. I'm telling you how it feels in being honest that feeling isn't proof. Nicholle: That's the reading that makes my skin crawl because it's the one with no crime attached and somehow the most violation attached. What's theory for? Zalle: Theory four is the most honest one. We don't have enough of her story to know. Beyond homeless and unemployed, her background is largely absent from the record. We have a year of behavior and one sentence of explanation. Any confident reading is built on thin ground. So mom, where do you land with this? Nicholle: Well I'm with you on the survival part, Ben Griel, I keep coming back to the man. Whatever she was, survivalist, squatter, something harder to name, he was a person who lived alone in a home he thought was his. And for a year it wasn't. The law looked at that and called it trespassing. So honestly, I land here. I believe it started as survival, and I believe it became A quiet theft of his safety that the law didn't have a word for. Zalle: Quiet theft of his safety. I like how you said that. Yeah. That's the line I put on this whole case too, definitely. Nicholle: so if we're being honest about where this leaves us. A woman caught a trespassing charge, a man whose home was never quite his again, what do we actually have? Well, we have more questions than answers. Let's put them on the table, co-conspirators. No tidy bow, this case doesn't happen. So I do believe that it started as survival. She needed somewhere to be. Whether she was between his house and other houses, we don't know because not having anyone report it doesn't mean it didn't happen. But I think that she got comfortable. Is it what it got beyond survival? Because when I think of survival, I think you're doing what you have to do to make it. It went beyond that because she got comfortable there. Zalle: Yeah. Right, the bare necessity. Nicholle: And that's where you you see the lines being crossed. Zalle: I definitely, definitely agree with everything you just said. It definitely was her being comfortable. I mean, what would you do? You were homeless for all this time and now you find somewhere you can go and it's not I mean it's not a huge area, but you comfy, you got free food, I got TV. I I would get comfortable too if I had nowhere to go. It's better than being under the bridge. Nicholle: I mean I mean she was she was benefit. I would feel I'm sure I'm sure that he could never fear right, but I could never feel safe in my house again. Like we could have no doors. This is the studio home. The whole home is a studio home because people can clearly hide there. Zalle: but still we have people who come and know you're gonna be there and they're dirty. Me neither. Right. The whole home. Hide, yeah, we no longer own a closet. Okay, but what we f what is left open? Nicholle: No, we don't have walls, we don't have doors. The kitchen is in the den is in the bedroom. Zalle: Is it a picture? So what's left open? How she got in, right? The unlocked door per most reporting, but at least one wire service says it's genuinely unclear how she came and went undetected. So we don't really know where that goes. How long she was there? They said about a year, but not all the time. So she's in this closet either continuously or she just wasn't there. We it's so much we don't know, right? Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: And then that goes back to the closet hopping question or her life before moving into this man's closet. Cause really her record is thin. We don't really have much on her before that. And so we wanna know if she was watching him, like was she there whenever he came like whenever he went to sleep? Because that's the only time she came out when he wasn't there or asleep. So was she standing over him watching him or like I just came to eat? All of it's Nicholle: We're out. Mm-hmm. Right. That's weird. Zalle: It's so much weirdness. And then for the duration shoe, Nicholle: That's so weird because I'm thinking Zalle: a year inside another person's most private space afoot from their bed and the charge was trespassing. I don't know if that would be enough. Like, yes, she did trespass, but you also stayed here for a year. You took my food and like yeah, that's not enough for me. I definitely feel like the man lost his safety in the one place a person is supposed to be able to be and Nicholle: Yeah. Zalle: that got taken for granted because clearly he didn't feel safe anymore. He had to live the rest of his life inside the gap between my home is mine and what actually happened. Cause I don't know if he he ever figured that out. Nicholle: Right, I'm sure. And that's the part that doesn't leave. Because we can all we can all try to imagine what that's like, but I'm sure you can't imagine it until issues. Zalle: Well, that that that one's going to sit with me for a while. And I think what stays with me most isn't the woman in the closet. It's the man who didn't know she was there. A person who trusted his own home the way we all trust ours and learned that for a year the most ordinary part of his day, coming home, closing the door, going to sleep, had been shared in the dark by someone he never invited in. That part leaves me with the heebie jeebies. Nicholle: Yeah, because whatever happened in Casuya in the spring of two thousand and eight, the disappearing food belongs to history. But the man behind that locked door belonged to himself. His home was supposed to be the one place that was only his, and for nearly a year it wasn't. Not because someone broke in, but because someone was already there, waiting in the part of the house nobody ever looked at. He was violated, definitely. He was unseen in his own home. And he deserves to be remembered, not as a punchline, not as a weird news item, but as a person whose safety was quietly stolen in the one place he had every right to take it for granted. That's why we tell these stories. Zalle: Thank you for being here with us, co-conspirators. If this episode moved you, please leave us a review, share it with someone who appreciates the kinds of questions that don't have clear answers, and subscribe so you don't miss the next one. And tell us what you're thinking while you listen. Tag us or drop it in the comments. because last week one of you posted that you were drinking chamomile tea and eating graham crackers. And honestly, that is the most unsettling combination I've ever heard. We see you, we respect you, weirdly perfect for true crime. Nicholle: Send us your cases, send us your theories on this one, we read everything. We'll be back soon All right, co-conspirators, stay safe, and we'll see you next time. Zalle: See you next time.