Latest / The So What? / Budget 3.0 A Moment of Decision
Transcript
- 0:04Hello and welcome to the So What podcast in which
- 0:08political economic analyst JP Landman discusses
- 0:11the issues uppermost in the minds of South Africans.
- 0:15You can find a written version of this content
- 0:17on JP's website JPLundman .co.za. I am Ruda
- 0:22Landman and I am your host. Hello and a very
- 0:28warm welcome to a newsletter dated the 12th of
- 0:32May 2025 with the title Budget 3 .0, A Moment
- 0:38of Decision. Two weeks ago on Freedom Day, the
- 0:43Cape High Court prohibited the Minister of Finance
- 0:47from proceeding with the VAT hike. Heavens, it
- 0:50feels like ages and ages ago. But even before
- 0:54that, the minister himself withdrew his proposal
- 0:57for that vatike. Why did he do that? Because
- 1:00he lost political support. If you go back to
- 1:02our previous note on the budget, there are four
- 1:05decisions to be taken in the budget. The first
- 1:08decision is the approval of the fiscal framework.
- 1:11That was approved on the 2nd of April, almost
- 1:14six weeks ago. But there already one could see
- 1:17it was, as we called it in that note, a very
- 1:19close -run thing. The fiscal framework was approved
- 1:23by a majority of 12 members of parliament, but
- 1:27there were 24 members of parliament not present
- 1:29in the assembly when the vote was taken. So it
- 1:32was a marginal thing anyway. And we raised in
- 1:35that note the prospect that the other three decisions
- 1:39that awaits the budget may not be approved. And
- 1:44what has happened is simply that some parties,
- 1:47particularly actions of South Africa, action
- 1:49essay, has walked back from their support for
- 1:52the fiscal framework. And I think the minister
- 1:54realized he didn't have the votes and he runs
- 1:57a very real risk of losing the vote in the subsequent
- 2:00three approvals that awaits the budget. And then
- 2:04the court decision came on top of that, so it
- 2:06was back to zero base. But all these complications
- 2:12basically also arose because the legal situation
- 2:16in South Africa has changed. Pretty much so,
- 2:19in South Africa, before and after 1994, followed
- 2:24the Westminster model of budget approval. And
- 2:27the Westminster model was simply that Parliament
- 2:29converted the budget up or they converted it
- 2:32down, but they cannot change it. The detail is
- 2:35frozen. You can say yes or you can say no, but
- 2:37you can't change it. We've had that system in
- 2:41our budget approval for many, many years. The
- 2:441996 constitution had a clause section 77 which
- 2:49made it clear that legislation must be passed
- 2:51by parliament to give that authority to parliament
- 2:54not just to approve or reject but also to change.
- 2:58For many many years before and after we became
- 3:02a democracy our lower -round budget approvals
- 3:05were fairly straightforward. Parliament could
- 3:08approve a budget, they could vote it up, or they
- 3:10could reject a budget voted down, but they could
- 3:13not change the budget. The detail of the budget
- 3:16was frozen. That was the arrangement before and
- 3:18after 1994. Then the final constitution in 1996
- 3:22contained a clause in section 77 that Parliament
- 3:27must make legislation, must approve legislation
- 3:29to give itself the power to change budgets, not
- 3:33just to approve or reject them. That was done
- 3:36in 2009, some 13 years after the final constitution
- 3:42was approved. Now for the first couple of years
- 3:45after that change or amendment it didn't really
- 3:48matter because the ANC was still the majority
- 3:50party and the Minister of Finance was always
- 3:53ANC so if he proposes a budget then the party
- 3:56votes it through and off it went. After last
- 3:59year's election of course those numbers have
- 4:01changed. The ANC is no longer in control on its
- 4:06own, it needs to form coalitions with other people
- 4:08and now you need the support of opposition parties
- 4:11to get to get the budget through parliament.
- 4:14So it's interesting to do that just to look back
- 4:17a little bit at 1993, the year just before we
- 4:19became a democracy, Derek Keyes was Minister
- 4:22of Finance and he in one budget, in one move,
- 4:27he took the VAT rate from 10%, which is what
- 4:30it was, to 14%. It's an absolutely incredible
- 4:34move. It was really a political achievement.
- 4:38And so how did he do it? Well, he did it by consulting
- 4:42with everybody inside and outside parliament.
- 4:45Parliamentary parties, people outside like the
- 4:48ANC at that stage, Kusato, Communist Party and
- 4:51so on, about what the budget numbers are. He
- 4:54shared it with them and he said, look, this is
- 4:55the picture. What do you think we should do?
- 4:58And in the end, nobody opposed. People may not
- 5:01have supported But nobody opposed the movement,
- 5:05the move of that from 10 % to 14%. At that point,
- 5:09there also wasn't a majority party who could
- 5:13just push it through. In a sense, yes. I mean,
- 5:16you had a majority party in Parliament, but Parliament
- 5:18was de facto already no longer the only people
- 5:22governing the country. And Keyes had the insight
- 5:24to see that and to bring the extra parliamentary
- 5:27people along. Now, what happened now in 2025
- 5:30is that the Minister of Finance, he missed this
- 5:35very simple process trick. Just involve people,
- 5:38give them all the facts, let them understand
- 5:41what the situation is and then let them decide
- 5:43what they want to do. He missed that simple process
- 5:46trick and he paid a political price for it. Where
- 5:48do we stand now? Well, where we stand now is
- 5:52that The minister must table a new budget, which
- 5:54he will do on 21 May, more or less 10 days from
- 5:58now. And the numbers are quite frightening. First
- 6:02of all, with NOVAD increasing the budget, the
- 6:06deficit on the income side will be over a three
- 6:09-year period, 75 billion round. It will be 13
- 6:13.5 billion rand for this year. But remember next
- 6:16year that was supposed to grow up another half
- 6:18a percent. And then over the three year period,
- 6:21which is the period of our budgets, that would
- 6:23have gone up to 75 billion. So that's number
- 6:25one. You're now 75 billion down on the income
- 6:28side. Then secondly, when the budget was repaired
- 6:32and submitted in February, it assumed a growth
- 6:36rate for the economy of 1 .9%. Since then we've
- 6:39had the Trump tariffs and all the shenanigans
- 6:41around that. And global growth has been forecast
- 6:46to be lower. Also South Africa's growth, more
- 6:48or less by half a percent. The budget is made
- 6:50at 1 .9. We can now work with a budget of say
- 6:531 .4, half a percent lower. If you have half
- 6:57a percent less economic growth, obviously you
- 6:59will have less tax income. And then the third
- 7:02thing that has happened is that Trump has cut
- 7:04all the direct transfers or grants that he has
- 7:08given to South Africa for AIDS treatment, for
- 7:11health research and so on. All that has been
- 7:14cut and that amount adds up to just under 10
- 7:17billion, about 9 .5 billion. So if you take those
- 7:20three numbers you lose that, you lose economic
- 7:23growth and you've lost the cash grant that came
- 7:26into the country every year. You're looking at
- 7:29billions and billions of a shortfall. It's really
- 7:32a huge amount of money that has now been covered.
- 7:35You say we are faced with a fundamental question.
- 7:40What do you mean? The fundamental question is
- 7:42now, given this huge shortfall in both income
- 7:45and extra expenditure, what will our parliamentarians
- 7:49who now have the ability to change the numbers
- 7:52in the budget, what will they do? Will they be
- 7:55willing to cut back expenditure or will they
- 7:59simply ignore the fact that there's a huge deficit?
- 8:03and simply borrow more money. That is really
- 8:06the essence. We know there will be an income
- 8:09shortfall. We know that expenditure is much more
- 8:12than income. So where do you go now? Now the
- 8:14important point here is in the last three years
- 8:18under the under minister Gordon Gwana, there's
- 8:20been a concerted effort to stabilize debt. How
- 8:23do you stabilize debt? You run a primary surplus.
- 8:27A primary surplus is simply your income is more
- 8:29than your expenditure before you pay interest.
- 8:33Once you've made interest, of course, you're
- 8:35still down. There's a deficit. You must borrow
- 8:36money. But at least it is the beginning of a
- 8:39process of working down your debt. Now, for this
- 8:42year, in the first budget, he had a number of
- 8:45$71 billion round as a primary surplus. That's
- 8:49a big number. That's a big number. If you can
- 8:51run with $70 billion a year for a couple of years'
- 8:54primary surplus, you will stabilize your debt
- 8:57and you will start working that down. So the
- 8:59critical issue now, the critical decision that
- 9:02parliament must take, is will they stick with
- 9:05a primary surplus of roughly $71 billion? It
- 9:08can be a bit lower, it's not a strange motion.
- 9:10Or will they simply ignore that run with the
- 9:13expenditure which is there and run up more debt?
- 9:17That is the question that's now facing parliament.
- 9:21Why shouldn't we just borrow more? All those
- 9:25expenditure items are incredibly important. No,
- 9:29absolutely. Whether it's education or health
- 9:31or AIDS or capital expenditure on infrastructure,
- 9:34indeed. And that is the point about the budget.
- 9:37There are a huge number of very important items
- 9:39that nobody wants to cut. But you don't have
- 9:42enough money. We don't have a money tree. We're
- 9:45still looking to plant that. So you've got to
- 9:48cut your cloak according to your cloth. And so
- 9:55the cost of borrowing is what is important. Now,
- 9:58let's just look at the numbers that the minister
- 10:00had in his Swiss budget, which are the numbers
- 10:02that we now have before his new budget. He was
- 10:06penciling into borrow 394 .6 billion rand. It's
- 10:11an enormous amount of money. That was after the
- 10:14VAT increase. That was after the VAT increase.
- 10:17Now he's lost the VAT increase, so that number
- 10:19will obviously go up. The difference that it
- 10:21makes Runa is for every 0 .01 % or as it is called
- 10:28in the jargon one basis point. A percentage consists
- 10:31of 100 basis points. Every one basis point increase
- 10:36in the interest rate increases the actual interest
- 10:40payment by an enormous amount. This 394 billion
- 10:47that the minister wants to borrow it means he
- 10:49will pay with 0 .01 % extra, you will pay an
- 10:53extra 39 million rand a year in interest or to
- 10:57put it more graphically, more than 100 ,000 rand
- 11:00per day for every day of the week. So you're
- 11:03talking big money here. You can employ a lot
- 11:05of teachers and doctors for 100 ,000 rand a day.
- 11:09Absolutely. So that's why it matters. You cannot
- 11:12just borrow more because the more you borrow,
- 11:15the more interest you have to pay and you lose
- 11:17control of your situation. So what we've seen
- 11:22when the budget was not approved and we had the
- 11:24whole budget kerfuffle in February is that that
- 11:28has already led to an increase in the interest
- 11:30payable. And that increase will cost us more.
- 11:35That is just the reality. Why is the bond market
- 11:40part of what you're writing about? Where does
- 11:42that fit in? The bond market is the place where
- 11:44politics and economics meet. That's the place
- 11:47where those two forces come together and they
- 11:50result in a particular thing and that particular
- 11:52thing is the interest rate. So the bond market
- 11:55or the capital market is simply a market where
- 11:57people with money come, pension fund, insurance
- 12:00companies and so on, banks. They come there and
- 12:03they offer money to the government which government
- 12:06wants to borrow. Capital market is where governments
- 12:08go worldwide to finance their deficits. It's
- 12:12a standard institution worldwide. So you've got
- 12:15people of money and you've got a government who
- 12:17wants to borrow money. They come together. There's
- 12:19an auction where people bid. This happens in
- 12:22South Africa every Tuesday. And an interest rate
- 12:25is set at which the government then can borrow
- 12:29money from the investors. Now that rate is called
- 12:32the long rate. Why the long rate? Because normally
- 12:35the duration is for 10 years. It can also be
- 12:38a little bit shorter, five years, seven years.
- 12:41It can also be 20 years or 30 years. But the
- 12:43average standard that we use worldwide is the
- 12:4610 -year yield, which is the product of that
- 12:50auction that takes place at the bond market.
- 12:53So the bond market is really a very substantial
- 12:56institution and an important institution. Without
- 13:00that, the government will struggle to finance
- 13:03itself and to finance particularly its deficit.
- 13:07But it's also the place, as I say, where politics
- 13:09and economics meet. political decisions impact
- 13:12on a bond market. When, for example, we had the
- 13:15Karfuful around the budget, the long raid went
- 13:17up, because people were saying there's more risk
- 13:20now. And because there's more risk and we don't
- 13:22know whether we will be repaid, therefore we
- 13:25have to charge more for our money. So politics
- 13:28affect the bond market. There's no question about
- 13:31that. And if you want to keep the long raid down,
- 13:34you want to keep your long... interest rates
- 13:37as low as possible. You need sensible politics,
- 13:40but you also need sensible fiscal policies. We
- 13:44actually saw this play out when the GNU was formed.
- 13:48Absolutely. Since the formation of the GNU about
- 13:5111 months ago, the long rate has dropped by as
- 13:54much as 80 basis points. It reduces the amount
- 13:57of interest that we have to pay substantially.
- 14:00Since we've had the budget car full full, that
- 14:02being reversed again and so on, Trump's tariffs
- 14:04influenced that Many things play a role. The
- 14:08big thing is to try and keep that number as low
- 14:10as possible. And it's not just really because
- 14:12it's about what the government pays in interest.
- 14:16It also sets the cost of capital in the economy.
- 14:19Everybody looks at the 10 -year yield. Companies
- 14:22who want to expand, who want to invest, who want
- 14:25to buy machinery. they look at the long yield
- 14:28and they calculate the cost of capital from that.
- 14:31So if that number goes up, your cost of capital
- 14:34rises, investment becomes more difficult. That
- 14:37number goes down, cost of capital goes down,
- 14:40investment becomes easier. So it's a really important
- 14:43number to manage in the national economy. In
- 14:46fact, I want to go so far as to say that that
- 14:48number, the long rate, is more important than
- 14:52what the vet rate is. It's more important than
- 14:55the vet rate. We saw the impact in America recently.
- 15:00Even President Trump is not... What's the word?
- 15:04Immune. Absolutely. We saw two big U -turns by
- 15:07Trump. The first one was when he announced these
- 15:10tariffs on Liberation Day, the 2nd of April.
- 15:13There was a violent reaction from the financial
- 15:15markets, including the bond market, three, four
- 15:18days later he capitulated. And he said, OK, he's
- 15:21suspending them for 90 days. Now we will have
- 15:24to see whether those tariffs come back after
- 15:2690 days. There's increasingly a view that they
- 15:29won't. But that's not the point, the point is
- 15:31he made a U -turn. His other U -turn was when
- 15:34he after he threatened to fire Jerome Powell,
- 15:37the chairman of the American Central Bank, Federal
- 15:39Reserve. Once again, a huge reaction from the
- 15:43bond market, Trump retreated. So much so that
- 15:46the Financial Times talk about Tarco, Trump again
- 15:50chickens out. Now he chickens out before the
- 15:54power of the bond marker. We've also seen it
- 15:57in the UK where less trust in 2022 became the
- 16:01shortest -serving Prime Minister in British history,
- 16:0450 days. Why? She submitted a budget to parliament
- 16:07which was not funded at all, with no possibility
- 16:11of funding it. And the bond marker just said
- 16:13no, and she was out. We also saw it earlier here
- 16:17in South Africa when Des van Ruin was our Minister
- 16:19of Finance for four days. Why was he out after
- 16:23four days? Because of a violent reaction from
- 16:25the bond market. So the bond market is where
- 16:28politics and economics meet. It determines the
- 16:31long -rate and you cannot escape from that discipline.
- 16:34In summary, so what? I think the so what is first
- 16:38of all for the first time in our South Africa's
- 16:41history, not just our democratic history, but
- 16:44also before 1994, parliament now has the right
- 16:47to change a budget, not just approve it or reject
- 16:51it, not just vote it up or vote it down, but
- 16:54actually change the numbers inside the budget.
- 16:56They now have that ability. With that power of
- 17:00course comes a huge responsibility. Parliament
- 17:02now has the responsibility to exercise there
- 17:06we can change at discretion or we can change
- 17:10at power in a way which doesn't undermine the
- 17:15broader economy in a way which is reconcilable
- 17:18with what the constraints of the bond market.
- 17:21Our biggest challenge at the moment is a challenge
- 17:23that Gordon Gwana has been working on for three
- 17:26years now and that is to stabilize our debt.
- 17:28That you can only do if you run a primary surplus
- 17:31and the decision now before Parliament is not
- 17:35to take that surplus which is there and just
- 17:39throw it to the wind and run a bigger deficit
- 17:41because then we won't make it in the long run.
- 17:44So politics and economics meet in the bond market.
- 17:48Yes, the will of the people are important. We've
- 17:51seen the will of the people expressed around
- 17:53that debate. It's also now important to look
- 17:57at long -term fiscal stability and we've got
- 17:59to balance the will of the people with long -term
- 18:02fiscal stability. That is the challenge which
- 18:04is now before Parliament, before 21 May. Thank
- 18:09you very much. We will be watching that with
- 18:12great interest. Get the popcorn ready for 21
- 18:14May. Thank you for listening to the SoWhat podcast.
- 18:21If you enjoy this content, please don't forget
- 18:24to leave a review and a rating, and please consider
- 18:27subscribing so you don't miss any future episodes.
- 18:30Also, tell your friends. Remember, you can find
- 18:33a written version of all JP's content at jplandman
- 18:37.co .za.