Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Anatomy of a Trademark/Merchandising License Agreement with Danny Simon & Greg Battersby
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome to Anatomy of a Trademark slash Merchandising
- 0:09License Agreement. I'm Adrian Saian, Chair of
- 0:12the Beverly Hills Bar Association's IP Law Section,
- 0:15and I'm delighted to introduce today's speakers,
- 0:18Greg Battersby and Danny Simon. Gregory J. Battersby
- 0:22is the managing partner of the Battersby Law
- 0:23Group, LLC's intellectual property law firm in
- 0:27Westport, Connecticut. He has over 50 years experience
- 0:30in patents, trademarks, and licensing law. Before
- 0:33founding the Battersby Law Group, he had been
- 0:35a founding partner in Grimes and Battersby. He
- 0:38had previously been associated with two major
- 0:40New York City IP law firms and was senior counsel
- 0:43at Gulf and Western Industries, now Viacom, and
- 0:47the then owner of Paramount Pictures. Danny Simon
- 0:51is a 40 plus year licensing industry veteran
- 0:53with expertise in all phases of the merchandising
- 0:56and licensing process. Having built the licensing
- 0:59divisions for Lorimar Productions, 20th Century
- 1:02Fox, and Carlco Pictures, he opened his licensing
- 1:06agency in 1992 in Los Angeles, called the Licensing
- 1:10Group Limited. Danny has pioneered entertainment
- 1:13licensing, focusing on material geared to the
- 1:16teen plus market. Beginning with the television
- 1:19program Dallas, he was among the first to license
- 1:21adult, primetime television entertainment. And
- 1:25with Dynasty, he was the first to apply branding
- 1:27techniques to television shows. So with that,
- 1:30we're very fortunate to have these two prominent
- 1:32speakers with us, and let's get started. Welcome.
- 1:37Welcome all. We're going to be going through
- 1:39a pretty basic trademarks last merchandising
- 1:44license agreement. I would say it's plain vanilla.
- 1:49It's not the studio type agreements, which can
- 1:50run anywhere from three or four times the length
- 1:53of this agreement, but it hits all the high points
- 1:55that we're going to try to do. I'm going to be
- 1:58giving it a little overview as we go through
- 2:00a number of the provisions in the agreement.
- 2:02And then Danny will address it from the licensors
- 2:04perspective. I'll address it from the licensees
- 2:07perspective. And we'll see if we can come up
- 2:08with some sort of a compromise because there's
- 2:10always a push and pull between licensors and
- 2:13licensees. As I said, this is going to be a very
- 2:16basic agreement, mostly directed to merchandising,
- 2:18and it starts on page one with an identification
- 2:21of the date of the agreement, which is the effective
- 2:23date, and the parties to the agreement. The licensor
- 2:27is listed in this case as Big Time Baseball.
- 2:29The licensee is listed as MLB LLC, a Grand Cayman
- 2:34Limited Liability Company with officers in Grand
- 2:36Cayman. Danny, you have any thoughts on that?
- 2:42Yeah, just always be careful as to where the
- 2:45company is located. I see Grand Cayman Island.
- 2:47I get just a tad nervous. And the reason for
- 2:53that is pretty simple, because when you wind
- 2:55up, the licensee is going to have obligations
- 2:57under the agreement. If the licensee is a major
- 3:01licensee with financial wherewithal, you've got
- 3:04no problems. If it's a shell company set up offshore.
- 3:07you're going to have trouble trying to enforce
- 3:09the obligations against them. So be careful when
- 3:12you identify who the parties are. The next thing
- 3:15we walk to is the whereas clauses. And we use
- 3:17the whereas clauses here for definitional purposes.
- 3:20We'll identify the property, which is being licensed.
- 3:23We'll identify the trademark. If there's a trademark,
- 3:26the licensed products, the territory, and the
- 3:29channels of distribution, there's a difference
- 3:31between territory and channels of distribution.
- 3:34The territory is typically the geographical area.
- 3:37The channels of distribution would be the stores
- 3:40or the venues where the product is sold. For
- 3:43example, if it can be sold online, if it can
- 3:46be sold in major retailers, mass market, specialty
- 3:50stores or what have you, that would be channels
- 3:51of distribution. What we typically do with this
- 3:54agreement is we use the Schedule A, which is
- 3:57the back of the agreement, to do all the definitional
- 4:00purposes. The logic is simple, frankly, because
- 4:03we... We structure an agreement this way, and
- 4:06we turn it over to the business people to negotiate.
- 4:09They literally have an outline in the schedule
- 4:11to negotiate, and then come back to us as the
- 4:14lawyers, which we can kind of fill in the pieces
- 4:16in drafting the agreement. The next step we want
- 4:20to go to is the license grant. Most license grants
- 4:27in merchandising are non -exclusive, and the
- 4:29reason for that is fairly simple. When Danny
- 4:33and I first started in this in the 70s and 80s,
- 4:36the vast majority of the agreement were exclusive.
- 4:38Then the laws of bankruptcy stepped in, and licensees
- 4:41got tired of finding a licensee who was underperforming
- 4:45with an exclusive agreement and couldn't enforce
- 4:47it against it. So as a result, the pendulum swung,
- 4:51and it got back to more of a non -exclusive agreement.
- 4:54You'll see a provision at the end of the paragraph
- 4:561A. I call it backdoor exclusivity. But if the
- 5:02licensee is not in breach of any provision of
- 5:04the agreement, the licensor agrees not to grant
- 5:07a license to any third party that may be in conflict
- 5:10with the licensee during the term. Significance
- 5:13of that is that if the licensee is performing,
- 5:16the licensor is not going to find another licensor.
- 5:18Danny, what's your thoughts on that? Well, that
- 5:22works for most categories. There are a number
- 5:24of categories out there where Not exclusive means
- 5:28not exclusive because no one company could handle
- 5:32the volume to satisfy the market best example
- 5:36is t -shirt product for There's no company out
- 5:41there that can really provide the whole marketplace
- 5:44As the number one selling item in the country
- 5:47t -shirts get sold at a variety of places that
- 5:50are a wide range of price points So we generally
- 5:55are going to look for multiple licensees in a
- 5:58category like that. So if you're talking about
- 6:01a major toy product where there's heavy expense
- 6:04in development of molds and there's a smaller
- 6:08volume potential, we generally can agree to that.
- 6:13We wouldn't agree to it on a product that has
- 6:17a better potential to allow multiple manufacturers
- 6:22in. The category is an interesting category because
- 6:27there are many types of toys. And when you're
- 6:29granting a license, particularly on an exclusive
- 6:32basis, but even on a non -exclusive basis, you
- 6:35want to identify the particular product with
- 6:38specificity. Granting a license for toys is difficult
- 6:41because it covers the entire range of all toys,
- 6:44as opposed to action figures made of PVC, not
- 6:49to exceed two inches in length or in height.
- 6:52That would be a more appropriate grant for a
- 6:55toy product. One of the things, if you're going
- 6:57to add to paragraph 1C, there's no sublicensing.
- 7:01Sublicensing is typically not mandated or not
- 7:05allowed, but it's not generally granted in a
- 7:09merchandising license agreement. There's a difference
- 7:12between sublicensing means that the licensee
- 7:15can step in and assign his rights over to a sublicensee.
- 7:21step into the shoes of licensing and perform.
- 7:24They're a distributor or manufacturer, typically
- 7:27and not sublicensees, they're distributors and
- 7:30manufacturers. Lastly, here is the term of the
- 7:34agreement. Again, this is going to tie back to
- 7:36the schedule in Schedule A at the back end of
- 7:39the agreement, but there's all sorts of various
- 7:41theories on the term of an agreement. Remember,
- 7:46in an entertainment property, which may be a
- 7:49motion picture, not necessarily a television
- 7:50show, a motion picture. The terms tend to be
- 7:52short. If it's a television show, the terms are
- 7:55going to be much longer. If it's a classic property
- 7:58like a Winnie the Pooh or a Donald Duck or a
- 8:00Mickey Mouse, they'll be much longer. If there's
- 8:03a, depending upon the particular product, food
- 8:07products take a long time to be developed and
- 8:11tested and into the marketplace. Those license
- 8:14agreements tend to be longer. electronic agreements
- 8:17similarly tend to be longer for the simple fact
- 8:19that the time it takes to develop the product
- 8:22is much longer than it does to make a t -shirt.
- 8:25Danny, what's your thoughts? A classic example
- 8:29of the disparity in timing of the amount of time
- 8:33you would grant in the license. The best example
- 8:36is to talk about an A title video game. where
- 8:40you're talking about multiple millions of dollars
- 8:42of investment costs at anywhere between one to
- 8:46three years to actually get the product out to
- 8:50retail. A company comes in and they're going
- 8:53to want at minimum probably a 10 -year license.
- 8:57The other factor can be if you're licensing something
- 9:02where there's a brand opportunity, where the
- 9:04manufacturer is trying to build a brand name
- 9:08out of the license in his product category, let's
- 9:12say perfume, for example, they're going to want.
- 9:16either a longer term license or definite easy
- 9:21way to continue to renew the agreement on an
- 9:24ongoing basis because they're trying to build
- 9:27a position in the marketplace for a long term
- 9:32play. Things I try to do when I draft a license
- 9:37agreement is to build in landmines for the one
- 9:40of the better term. I want to make sure that
- 9:42if the licensee is performing they should be
- 9:46able to continue the license. If they're not
- 9:47performing as a licensor, I'm going to want the
- 9:50ability to get out of the license. A long -term
- 9:53license agreement can be problematic because
- 9:55if the licensee isn't performing under a 10 -year
- 9:58deal, it's going to be difficult to terminate
- 10:01them. Now, you can do this a number of different
- 10:02ways. You can have a two -year deal with options
- 10:05to renew for a period for one option, two options,
- 10:09multiple options, provided they have certain
- 10:12performance milestones. If they meet those milestones,
- 10:15the licensee has a right to renew the agreement
- 10:19under the same terms as the agreement provides.
- 10:23If they do milestones, then they can... A milestone
- 10:26that's often used is to utilize a guarantee or
- 10:29a multiple number, amount of the guarantee as
- 10:33a revenue base to continue to renew the agreement.
- 10:38For example, 150 % of the guarantee paid in royalties
- 10:43over the term is a pretty usual benchmark for
- 10:50a number of licenses. Also, too, the amount of
- 10:55money you spend in advertising and or the number
- 10:59of retail outlets you've penetrated or the geographic
- 11:04territory that you have under license if you
- 11:07have penetrated it Totally. Those things can
- 11:11all be used as benchmarks. The common thread
- 11:15is obviously performance. If the licensee is
- 11:17performing, they should be able to hold on to
- 11:19the agreement. If they're not performing, the
- 11:21licensor should be able to terminate them and
- 11:23move on. Next slide is compensation. In merchandising
- 11:30in particular, the vast number of majority of
- 11:35the compensation forms are royalties, a percentage
- 11:38of the sales of licensed products by the licensee.
- 11:42Royalty rates, it's a whole study we do. We actually
- 11:45have a book published by Walters -Kluver, which
- 11:48is licensing royalty rates, which take eight
- 11:50different categories of licensed properties against
- 11:541 ,500 or so licensed products and identify and
- 11:58report on the average royalty rates as well as
- 12:00the median royalty rates. But that's the heart
- 12:03and soul on the financial portions of an agreement.
- 12:05That goes hand in glove with a guaranteed minimum
- 12:09royalty, which is paragraph E. Danny, what's
- 12:12your position on guaranteed royalties? On royalties,
- 12:16what we should note is that there is no fixed
- 12:20royalty in any product category for any property
- 12:25at all. These are numbers that are arrived to
- 12:28by mutual agreement. However, there are what
- 12:32we'll call standard rates within various product
- 12:35categories as to what the usual amount of royalty
- 12:39that's charged by the licensor. That doesn't
- 12:43mean that's what the parties in this contract
- 12:46will agree to, but that is an average or a standard
- 12:52range. you also have to discuss is what is the
- 12:58royalty based on? Generally, it's the wholesale
- 13:02selling price of the product because that's the
- 13:06amount of money that the manufacturer or the
- 13:09licensee controls. However, in the direct market
- 13:14where the licensee is acting as both manufacturer
- 13:17and retailer, we often want to see the royalty
- 13:21based on the retail sales price of the product.
- 13:25So our position in royalty on a direct sales
- 13:28considerably better. Is that fair? Well, yes,
- 13:32it's fair because the the remuneration to the
- 13:37manufacturer is considerably greater. So. we
- 13:41want to share in that. Now, a lot of licensees
- 13:45will want some discount between the wholesale
- 13:48rate, say it's 10 % of wholesale sales, they
- 13:53may be asking for five to eight percent on direct
- 13:57sales, whether you grant it or not as a negotiation.
- 14:01There's another type of royalty called an FOB
- 14:03royalty. What the trend, particularly at a lot
- 14:06of the consumer products, is that a licensee
- 14:09will actually manufacture a product abroad, let's
- 14:12say in China, for example, and they will sell
- 14:15the product to the retailer on an FOB basis in
- 14:18China. The retailer then is responsible for bringing
- 14:22the product back from the offshore manufacturing
- 14:24facility and selling it in the States. The FOB
- 14:29prices are typically lower than the domestic
- 14:32selling price. For example, If the net sales
- 14:35price domestically is $10, the FOB price may
- 14:39be $7. So what the licensors are going to want
- 14:43to do, they're going to want to adjust the royalty
- 14:45rate because they want to make sure the ultimate
- 14:47earned royalty, the amount of money they make
- 14:50is the same because it's going to be a lower
- 14:52selling price. So be careful of FOB rates because
- 14:56you're seeing it more and more as product gets
- 15:00manufactured offshore. Well, what I think is
- 15:03going to happen, Greg, is I think that with this
- 15:05new issue of tariffs, that FOE pricing is going
- 15:09to get more popular because it's going to allow
- 15:12the manufacturer to buy the product cheaper as
- 15:15a tariff rate, I think, unless it gets taxed
- 15:18with the added cost of shipping and other onboarding
- 15:24costs. Danny mentioned the wholesale selling
- 15:28price. If we look at paragraph F on the next
- 15:30slide, that's the definition of net sales. Now,
- 15:33that provision is negotiated every day in every
- 15:36license agreement. And I will tell you, as a
- 15:38practical matter, that same agreement will be
- 15:41read by the CFO of the licensee in a different
- 15:44manner than the CFO of the licensor, because
- 15:46that's the corpus for the want of a better term
- 15:49of what the royalty is going to be based on.
- 15:51The licensee is going to want to be able to throw
- 15:53as much expenses as he can against sales to reduce
- 15:58the royalty rate. The licensor is going to want
- 16:02to limit the amount of deductions or allowances
- 16:04which they can give. One of the common solutions
- 16:07is that typically it's gross sales less discounts,
- 16:11allowances, and returns in a broad sense. what
- 16:15constituted discount and allowance, always a
- 16:17subject negotiation. And as a return, a return
- 16:20for defective products or return across the board.
- 16:24Most licensors and licensees will agree upon
- 16:27a cap for that. It eliminates a lot of the negotiations
- 16:30back and forth and aids in the auditing down
- 16:33the road. Caps for anywhere from 5 % to 10%.
- 16:37So that in surprisingly, magically, the licensee
- 16:42always manages to have enough deductions to reach
- 16:44just below the cap or right at the cap. It's
- 16:47always surprising when that happens. I want to
- 16:52add that one thing that we will never agree to
- 16:55is to allow for your advertising costs to be
- 16:59a deduction because that's just simply a way
- 17:03to allow the licensee to utilize what would be
- 17:09your royalties to pay for marketing of their
- 17:12product. So one thing we do not allow is advertising
- 17:17costs. Well, Danny raised the issue, too, about
- 17:20tariffs. I haven't seen tariffs identified as
- 17:24an allowable deduction, but you're going to see
- 17:26it more and more, I think. Oh, yes. So be careful
- 17:30of that and think about that. And there's also
- 17:32tariffs the other way, tariffs from if the stuff's
- 17:34going out of the United States into abroad. into
- 17:37China or whoever. So be careful of that and think,
- 17:40you know, consider how you want to how you want
- 17:42to handle it in the combination of definition
- 17:44of net sales. What you don't want to do on tariffs
- 17:48is if the licensee is not going to rate prices
- 17:52substantially, but will eat some of the tariff
- 17:55costs, you don't want to be in a position where
- 17:57you're giving him the full allowance of the tariff
- 18:00if he's not actually losing that money. The provision
- 18:07J is acceleration. That happens to be one of
- 18:09my favorite provisions if I'm a licensor. What
- 18:12it means is that if a licensor terminates a licensee
- 18:15and there's a balance of a minimum royalty required,
- 18:19those balances are accelerated. They're due and
- 18:23payable upon termination or expiration of the
- 18:25agreement. It avoids a licensor being in a situation
- 18:28where he's got to collect monies from a terminated
- 18:31licensee. this year, next year, and the year
- 18:34after. So important provision in the agreement.
- 18:40Yeah. Great. Also, currency is another issue.
- 18:47Whether or not it's paid in dollars, if you're
- 18:50the US company doing business with a foreign
- 18:54licensee. Do you want to see monies coming in
- 18:58in dollars or their local currency? Generally,
- 19:02we don't like to play currency games in terms
- 19:05of betting on the value, so we'll peg it to the
- 19:09dollar rather than to the local currency. Audit
- 19:14provisions. Danny, what's your position on auditing
- 19:18a licensee? Mixed. Audits are expensive and time
- 19:26consuming and a royal pain for everybody involved.
- 19:31If you have a good licensee and you've done business
- 19:36with them and you don't suspect there's an incorrect
- 19:42count, then we generally believe the royalties
- 19:46as they're being submitted. If we have any question
- 19:51or if we feel that we see more product in the
- 19:56market than we think we're being accounted for,
- 19:59we'll definitely audit. But it's our right and
- 20:02one which we always want to have whether we use
- 20:04it or not. As a licensor, I kind of prefer an
- 20:08audit. What I also recommend to licensor clients
- 20:10is audit early. And the reason I like auditing
- 20:13early is because if there's a problem on the
- 20:16licensing, it could be an innocent misunderstanding
- 20:20of what net sales are. or misunderstanding as
- 20:22to how we should account, it's better you find
- 20:25that early than later because if you find it
- 20:27early, they can make the change and it's not
- 20:29a lot of money. If they find it later, two or
- 20:33three years worth of sales, the number could
- 20:35be substantial and then it becomes a fight. Well,
- 20:39it also impacts how long the audit will take.
- 20:42If you're auditing somebody in the first year
- 20:45versus a third year, there's simply going to
- 20:48be a much faster answer as to whether or not
- 20:51there's any improprieties with regard to the
- 20:54amount being paid. Especially orders. I mean,
- 20:57we work with a couple of firms over the years
- 20:59which probably do 30 or 40 audits, licensee audits
- 21:03every year or maybe every quarter actually. You're
- 21:06probably, if you're looking for auditors, you're
- 21:08probably better off finding somebody who has
- 21:11the experience in auditing. They know what they
- 21:13look for. Most of the audits now are not done
- 21:15in person. Most of them are done electronically
- 21:17and they work fairly well. There are provisions,
- 21:21I'm sorry, go on Danny. No, there are some auditors
- 21:24too that will work on a contingency basis. There
- 21:29is, if you look at paragraph B, that's the penalties
- 21:32for Usually, the licensor is responsible for
- 21:37the cost of the audit unless they find a problem.
- 21:40And depending upon what the problem is, then
- 21:42that obligation may pass to the licensee. In
- 21:46this case, it's usually a percentage of what
- 21:48the underpayment is. Typically, it's 3 % to 5%.
- 21:52If the underpayment is more than that, then the
- 21:55licensee is responsible for the cost. We have
- 21:58a separate division in here. If it's gross, if
- 22:01it's much greater, 25%, or pick a higher number,
- 22:05then that should give the license or the right
- 22:07to terminate the agreement in the event, because
- 22:09they're not dealing with a misunderstanding.
- 22:11They're not dealing with a misstatement. They're
- 22:15potentially dealing with fraud on the model licensee.
- 22:19Look for record retentions, because that's important,
- 22:22because it's a practical matter. If the licensee
- 22:25isn't maintaining the records, Running an audit
- 22:27can be meaningless. You're not going to be able
- 22:30to find the records. There's a lot of provisions
- 22:32in some of the more sophisticated agreements,
- 22:35which provide specifically that if the books
- 22:37and records aren't kept properly, aren't maintained,
- 22:41then there'll be a penalty. And the penalty could
- 22:43be 100 % royalty on everything sold. They can
- 22:48be draconian. I've seen a couple of them, which
- 22:52are truly draconian. Warranties, reps and warranties.
- 23:02Danny, as a licensure, what are you looking for?
- 23:05On warranties and reps, I'm looking to make sure
- 23:10that I'm protected from anything the licensee
- 23:14may do that could cause damage or could cause
- 23:19litigation of any sort. We also want to make
- 23:24sure that the licensee is performing in a positive
- 23:32business practices and that essentially we are
- 23:40protected. If we could throw in there to the
- 23:45insurance indemnification, because it kind of
- 23:48flows with that, where we're going to require
- 23:52product liability insurance of a minimal amount,
- 23:56which tends to be a minimal $2 million per occurrence.
- 24:04And it goes higher depending on what the product
- 24:06is. We want to make sure that we're protected
- 24:10from any problem with the product as well as
- 24:13with the operation of the licensee. As a licensee,
- 24:19I'm looking for a rep and warranty about non
- 24:21-infringement. You'll see paragraph B. I want
- 24:24to make sure that when I take a license, I'm
- 24:28paying the license or a royalty for the right
- 24:30to use their property, and I'm marketing products.
- 24:32I'm not going to get sued by anybody else. Surprisingly,
- 24:35over the last few years, I've been seeing more
- 24:37and more licensors abrogate their responsibilities
- 24:40for this. To me, the grand bargain is a simple
- 24:42one. The licensor has a property, should be protecting
- 24:46it. The licensee agrees to take a license under
- 24:49it and pay the licensor a royalty, but they want
- 24:52protection. I'm seeing more and more licensees
- 24:55backing out of this rep and warranty on non -entringement.
- 25:00The argument they'll come back to is that I'm
- 25:02indemnifying you in the event you get sued by
- 25:05a third party, and that's wonderful, but I'm
- 25:08still... forced as a licensee under that agreement.
- 25:12I can't terminate the agreement even in the middle
- 25:14of a lawsuit. So a licensee should be looking
- 25:18for that rep and warranty on non -intringement.
- 25:21I'm generally happier with reps and warranties
- 25:26to the licensee about my property, then I am
- 25:30being forced into a situation where I have to
- 25:33cover with trademark filings every product category
- 25:37in every country imaginable. So sometimes we
- 25:42will rather risk not having to go to the expense
- 25:46of filing in a particular country for a very
- 25:49specific item if we don't think it's going to
- 25:54cause problems, and then give the rep and warranties
- 25:58to the licensee instead. Probably if E is an
- 26:03important provision, because remember we're drafting
- 26:05license agreements with landmines in there. They
- 26:10have to be performance -oriented, and the product
- 26:12introduction and initial shipment dates are some
- 26:15of those landmines. The licensee has to have
- 26:18a product, the toy product, for example, has
- 26:21to have that product introduced a toy fair of
- 26:23a date certain has to be shipping product on
- 26:26a date certain. And if they don't meet those
- 26:29dates, the licensure should have the right, not
- 26:32the obligation, but the right to terminate in
- 26:35that event. The opposite is also true that you'll
- 26:39have situations, and particularly with things
- 26:41like movies, where you don't want product out
- 26:44before a certain date. So there's also the opposite,
- 26:48where you're being, we want to withhold the licensee
- 26:51from shipping product until a certain date? Notice
- 27:00is quality controls and samples. A trademark
- 27:02license, the heart of a trademark license from
- 27:04a trademark point of view of the quality control
- 27:07provisions. A licensee, a licensee who does not
- 27:11enforce the quality control rights on a licensee
- 27:14runs the risk of being accused of naked licensing,
- 27:17which can result in a loss of trademark rights.
- 27:19That's the biggest liability. a potential licensor
- 27:23has. So you'll take a look at these agreements
- 27:25which have, this is a relatively modest provision
- 27:29with regards to quality control. The studio agreements
- 27:31are seven, eight, nine, 10 pages long on the
- 27:35quality control provisions. They want to be able
- 27:37to make sure that the licensee is getting, is
- 27:40submitting product for review and approval at
- 27:43various steps of the operation, as well as after
- 27:46they've started manufacturing product, they have
- 27:48a periodic, review and approval thereafter. One
- 27:55thing about a licensed product for review, that's
- 28:03something that we take extremely seriously and
- 28:06certainly one of the things we give the most
- 28:08attention to as quickly as we're served with
- 28:12the product to review. But it's also a problem
- 28:19in that Most products will generally go through
- 28:24a multiple cycle of review, meaning that a lot
- 28:28of times product the first time around isn't
- 28:31approved. The manufacturer is required to give
- 28:34comments as to what the problems are. I can't
- 28:38just say I don't like it, fix it. I've got to
- 28:41tell you what I don't like about it and the ways
- 28:44in which you need to fix it. That's my obligation.
- 28:49In the meantime, it's your obligation as the
- 28:52licensee to continue to submit it until it satisfies
- 28:55our demands. Now, we don't want to be unreasonable,
- 29:00but in the case of a character, we want it to
- 29:05resemble exactly the character. And if you choose
- 29:09not to use an image that I provided for you,
- 29:13but create your own, then you've got to take
- 29:16great care in duplicating that image. And I'm
- 29:19going to make you work on it until it is correct.
- 29:25One of the things that people complain about
- 29:28the most is the time it takes for licensed oars
- 29:31to respond. And that is a problem in our industry.
- 29:36My brother and some time are not great at taking
- 29:40seriously the fact that manufacturers are on
- 29:44a schedule and my sitting on an approval for
- 29:47no reason. can cause a lot of problem with the
- 29:52manufacturer meeting those deadlines. So great
- 29:56attention has to be paid here by both parties.
- 30:00When it works, it works well. When it doesn't
- 30:02work, it causes big problems. One of the twists
- 30:07always, as Murphy's law applies, is a product
- 30:10will be a sample resubmitted, which never gets
- 30:13received by the licensor. And as a result, the
- 30:16licensee doesn't get approval. going forward.
- 30:19The licensee is going to want a non -response
- 30:23by a licensor as approval. Licencies will never
- 30:26grant that. It'll always be as approval. Because
- 30:28that's the one product they don't want to make
- 30:30sure is in the marketplace, which hasn't met
- 30:33either the quality control provisions or complied
- 30:36with the marketing provisions. So be careful
- 30:38about that. Danny made a comment about wanting
- 30:40to be reasonable. I will tell you, when I represent
- 30:43licensees, I ask all the time. about putting
- 30:46a reasonableness provision in there that the
- 30:50refusal cannot be unreasonably withheld or delayed.
- 30:54Every time I ask for it, I'm denied that. Wait,
- 30:58what's reasonable to you may not be reasonable
- 31:00to me, and it's my property, so I'm the arbiter
- 31:03here. That's what they tell me, Danny. That's
- 31:05what they tell me. Of course. It's usually at
- 31:07the sole discretion of the licensor. So if you
- 31:10want to try to negotiate reasonableness, good
- 31:12luck. What's made this process much easier is
- 31:17that 99, if not almost 100 % of all approvals
- 31:21today are done electronically. When we started
- 31:24out in licensing, you actually had to mail that
- 31:27physical sample again and again and again, and
- 31:32it gets expensive and time consuming. Today approvals
- 31:37are much easier, and most licensors of any substance
- 31:42are using electronic submission platforms, electronic
- 31:49apps that are dedicated to the submission of
- 31:54product for approval, which has made the whole
- 31:57process much easier. Next provision, ownership
- 32:03of rights. Pretty simple. The property owner,
- 32:06the licensor, owns the property rights and the
- 32:08property. What the licensor is also going to
- 32:12want to do, when he can, is own any IP or any
- 32:18works which are developed jointly between the
- 32:21licensee and the licensor during the term of
- 32:22the agreement. Danny, how far do you want to
- 32:25go on that? All the way. All the way, of course.
- 32:32What did you have in mind? Well, the provision,
- 32:35if you take a look at 8C, it's a work -for -hire
- 32:39provision, and basically the agreement provides
- 32:41that anything which is developed, potentially
- 32:43copyrightable, but anything developed by the
- 32:46licensee during the term of the agreement. is
- 32:48deemed to work for hire just to be owned by the
- 32:51licensor. It's a testy issue because technically
- 32:55I can claim whatever you do as my property, meaning
- 32:59you create a design, although it's one you created,
- 33:04it's of my property and I therefore own it. I
- 33:07think licensors have to give due consideration
- 33:12to how they apply that because is it fair to
- 33:16take and create product in the marketplace that
- 33:20replicates a licensee's design of your property
- 33:24that could create competition to his product,
- 33:27which is possible. Particularly if you have,
- 33:31again, t -shirts and you have licensees giving
- 33:35you great designs, would I turn around and hand
- 33:38that design to another t -shirt company? Technically,
- 33:41I can. The question is, should I? And I don't
- 33:44think you should. As representing a licensee,
- 33:49what I will typically try to do is to carve out
- 33:52anything which was owned by the licensee prior
- 33:54to the effective date of the agreement. That
- 33:57remains the property of the licensee. It won't
- 34:02get picked up as a work for hire or an ownership
- 34:05of design or rights by the licensor. A lot of
- 34:09times you'll find that video game engines fall
- 34:13in that category where we'll do a license for
- 34:16a video game where in fact the manufacturer is
- 34:20taking an existing game engine and reskinning
- 34:25it with my property, maybe making some changes
- 34:28to the play action, but essentially using the
- 34:31same engine. I don't claim any rights to that
- 34:35engine. but he can't claim any rights to the
- 34:38image of my characters. It will also relate to
- 34:41product configurations too because frequently
- 34:43what a toy company will be manufacturing a particular
- 34:46product and all of a sudden slap a licensed property
- 34:50on it. But it's the configuration of the structure
- 34:54of that property was owned by the toy company
- 34:56before the agreement they should be able to retain
- 34:58rights to it. Use in yours to the benefit of
- 35:09the license or just paragraph G. It's kind of
- 35:11a technical term because what's you when would
- 35:15trademark rights are based on use a license or
- 35:18goes out to file a trademark application and
- 35:20prosecutors prosecute the application based on
- 35:23a licensees use. We'll have to demonstrate that
- 35:26the use was in urine to its benefit in the trademark
- 35:28office frequently will require or ask at least
- 35:31ask for to look at the provision of the agreement.
- 35:34which states that any use by the licensee shall
- 35:37endure to the benefit of the licensor. That covers
- 35:41the use of a requirement. I'm going to go back
- 35:47to your last question about using licensee's
- 35:50material. We've entered into a number of some
- 35:54agreements where The intent is upfront is to
- 35:58reuse that material. For example, we just did
- 36:02a big art book on the property Ultraman and it's
- 36:06original art by probably 150 plus artists all
- 36:11under work for hire and going into it, the deal
- 36:15was made that we own that artwork and we will
- 36:17and do intend to use it for other product. the
- 36:23licensee knows that going in, so we've acknowledged
- 36:26upfront our intent, which I think is the way
- 36:30you should operate when you want to reuse material
- 36:33that you haven't actually created of your property.
- 36:37Makes sense. Termination, which is on paragraph
- 36:41nine. Over the years when I've done this program,
- 36:45I've asked people when they go into it to pick
- 36:48before we start the program as to what they believe
- 36:51the most important provision in a license agreement
- 36:53is. And generally, it's royalties, it's guarantees,
- 36:57it's quality control, what have you. To me, the
- 36:59most important provision in a license agreement,
- 37:02if I'm representing a licensor, is termination.
- 37:05I want an ability to terminate a non -performing
- 37:07licensee. And there are a number of things which
- 37:11are absolute requirements of the licensee. And
- 37:15if they fail to meet those requirements, I have
- 37:17the right to terminate immediately. It's another
- 37:19more amorphous issues, which there may be a cure
- 37:23provision. But if you can see in paragraph 9A,
- 37:27it's a list of the ones here. I think you've
- 37:29got to change the screen, Greg. I thought I was
- 37:33there. There you go. Yeah, 9A, immediately terminate
- 37:40the agreement. Failure to meet the product introduction
- 37:42date, failure to meet the initial shipment date,
- 37:45failure to pay royalties on time more than once.
- 37:48failure to maintain product liability insurance,
- 37:51on and on and on. Those rights are really non
- 37:54-curable. They should be at the basis of an immediate
- 37:57right to terminate. And you'll see them here.
- 38:00The next step, Danny, what's your thoughts? Well,
- 38:04I think the case of curing breaches, if it's
- 38:09a payment issue, If it becomes chronic, that's
- 38:13another issue. I don't consider one time payment
- 38:16late being chronic. And I think licensees should
- 38:19be given the right to fix the breach. And same
- 38:26is true for those of lesser import. Because you
- 38:33have the right to terminate doesn't mean you
- 38:35should. And sometimes a mistake is just that,
- 38:40a mistake. I think these have got to be used
- 38:44judiciously and not for an attempt to grab back
- 38:52rights that you've got another licensee will
- 38:55take it on if you can get rid of this one. Frequently,
- 38:58my experience has been that you're in a bad relationship
- 39:03with a licensee. You're not happy what they're
- 39:06doing. and now you're looking to terminate, but
- 39:09you need a basis to terminate if you want to
- 39:11terminate them. So that's where these provisions
- 39:13become important. In and of itself, failure to
- 39:16make a payment, paying royalties on time once
- 39:19or twice should not be a big deal. But if it's
- 39:23done continuously, then it becomes more of a
- 39:26problem, particularly if the licensee's not selling
- 39:28in an amount you want them to sell into. So that's
- 39:31why these provisions are here. But you'll see
- 39:33the next is an immediate right to terminate a
- 39:36portion. or the right to terminate by the licensee.
- 39:40Rarely do you see a licensee having a right to
- 39:43terminate, but they should as a practical matter
- 39:46because it is a bilateral agreement. But on the
- 39:50paragraph B is the right to terminate or paragraph
- 39:53C, right to terminate on notice. The notice provision
- 39:55is a 30 -day, typically a 30 -day notice provision
- 39:59for cure. If it's a financial issue, it should
- 40:02be less than that. It should be 10 days, maybe
- 40:0510 business days. But you want to accelerate
- 40:08that cure period in the event of a financial
- 40:10issue. Danny? You know, it's funny. I was just
- 40:15thinking about what we as a licensor need to
- 40:19do to satisfy an agreement. And you mentioned
- 40:22the licensee looking to maybe terminate agreement
- 40:26for failure. What I've never been asked for when
- 40:29I've been asked, I asked for a marketing date.
- 40:33Nobody ever has asked me, well, what date will
- 40:36we get the materials from you to begin development?
- 40:41Which is a reasonable question, but one that
- 40:44generally never gets asked. So when you're committing
- 40:48to making these dates as a matter of course for
- 40:53the licensee and now I'm going to play your side,
- 40:55Greg, is you really should be asking for certain
- 40:59benchmarks for the licensee to perform. Although
- 41:03I'm not going to give you a reasonableness in
- 41:06approvals, I will give you a term of time by
- 41:12which I need to reply. The problem is if I don't
- 41:16reply within that time, I'm going to deem it
- 41:18not approved. So you don't win much on that basis.
- 41:23But if you're acting or have to act within a
- 41:26term of a specific time frame, then you should
- 41:30build into that the fact that the license or
- 41:32has to perform certain functions that allow you
- 41:36to get to that date or meet that date. It makes
- 41:39sense. Do you do that, Danny, in your agreements?
- 41:42No. No, I don't give them anything more they
- 41:44don't ask for. OK. That makes sense. That makes
- 41:46sense. OK, sell -off period, which is 10 -B,
- 41:51upon termination or expiration of the agreement,
- 41:53the licensee typically has the right to sell
- 41:55products for a period of time. And that period
- 41:58of time is always negotiable. What do you normally
- 42:01give for a sell -off, Danny? Usually, 180 days.
- 42:08If you can't get rid of the merchandise in that
- 42:10period of time, then it's not gonna get moved
- 42:12probably. We have to end it, whether it gets
- 42:16junked or I demand it and you have to give it
- 42:20to me or I give you a fee, a price rather for
- 42:25it on a heavily discounted price. However, it's
- 42:31agreed to, it should get be... relieved by no
- 42:37longer than 180 days. I put provisions in there
- 42:42as opposed to returning it to the license or
- 42:45I'll donate it to charity, a charity mutually
- 42:48acceptable to both bodies. But there are a number
- 42:50of organizations, mostly out of New York, I'm
- 42:54not sure worldwide, which will take it for underprivileged
- 42:58children, particularly the children's products.
- 43:00And it's a wonderful thing to do. Better than
- 43:03burying it in the desert. or rolling over with
- 43:06a steamroller. You know, can I just regress for
- 43:10a moment? What we didn't talk about when we talked
- 43:14about going way back to the advances guarantees,
- 43:18the actual dollar values of the license. Everybody,
- 43:24the biggest question I always get is what is
- 43:27the license cost? Which is a question that I
- 43:33know if I'm asked that question, somebody is
- 43:36a neophyte in licensing because there is no fixed
- 43:39cost to a license. It could be free if I wanted
- 43:43to be, if I'm controlling the rights. The question
- 43:46is, how do you get to a fair agreement as to
- 43:50what an advance or a guarantee should be? What
- 43:54I always think is the most important element
- 43:56of this contract is the royalty provision. The
- 44:00amount of money I'm going to get paid per product
- 44:03sold. That's how I make a living. That's how
- 44:08licensors thrive. So for me, everything else
- 44:13is second to what am I going to see as the value
- 44:18back on the sale of that item. And as I said,
- 44:22there's no fixed, technically there's no fixed
- 44:26royalty rates out there. There are significant
- 44:30amount of averages being paid for various categories.
- 44:38In the toy business, it used to be 8%, it went
- 44:41to 9%, 10%, now it's 12 to 14%. foods, which
- 44:49is a commodity that is a very, very small profit
- 44:52margin to it, because it's a volume item, you're
- 44:57going to see royalties anywhere from a half a
- 44:59percentage to maybe 3%. Occasionally, you might
- 45:03get five on something that can demand a higher
- 45:07price point. But once we set a royalty, now all
- 45:13I need to do is to get an idea as to what amount
- 45:17you think you could sell during the term of the
- 45:20license. And that's going to kind of create at
- 45:25least some framework around making a deal. Now,
- 45:29I know you're going to lie to me when you give
- 45:31me a amount that you think you're going to manufacture.
- 45:39I know that you're going to under report that
- 45:44number to me. I know that going in. So I've already
- 45:47factored that into the conversation. You say
- 45:50you're going to sell 10, I know you're going
- 45:51to sell 12 to 15, possibly 20. So you look at
- 45:57those projections, and that's where I've often
- 46:03found the way to make a fairest deal. I'm going
- 46:07to give you some leeway in it. And you know that
- 46:13I'm going to try to get as high as I can. You're
- 46:16trying to get as low as you can. But reality,
- 46:20the amount of goods that get sold over the period
- 46:22of the license is what the value of the license
- 46:26is. The problem is neither one of us knows what
- 46:29that number is at the beginning of the deal.
- 46:33So estimates of sales volume, I think, are one
- 46:38of the fairest ways to get there. But just know
- 46:41the games that are being played by both sides.
- 46:44I think it's a two -edged sword for a licensee,
- 46:48though, to underestimate what their sales are
- 46:51going to be. Because if they underestimate or
- 46:55not, they may lose the license. Yeah, exactly.
- 46:57They may lose the interest of the licensed sword.
- 47:00Now, typically what I'll do is I'll rely on those
- 47:02numbers and I'll, let's say we negotiate a 10
- 47:05% royalty. and the licensee says that I'm going
- 47:08to, I'm going to sell a million dollars. So that's
- 47:11a 10 % royalty. My royalty is going to be a hundred
- 47:14thousand dollars. I'll ask him to guarantee half
- 47:16of that and pay half of that as an advance. Right.
- 47:21That's a simple, easy way to do it. But I rely,
- 47:24I tend to rely more on what the licensee is telling
- 47:27me than maybe you do, Danny. Well, I do align
- 47:31what they're telling me. I just know that there's
- 47:33going to be some underreporting. And frankly,
- 47:37you'd be crazy to report what you thought you
- 47:41actually could sell because if you overestimate
- 47:46your sales and your deal is based on those numbers,
- 47:50you may be in a position to have not met your
- 47:53guarantee by the end of the license, which is
- 47:56in a position neither of us want to be in. I
- 47:59don't want to have to go after you for unrecruited
- 48:04guarantees, and you don't want to have to pay
- 48:08me on sales you never made. I have a rule of
- 48:14thumb in that situation. I call it an effective
- 48:16royalty rate. I may negotiate a royalty rate
- 48:20of 10 percent, but because the guarantee is so
- 48:23high and my sales are so low, the effective royalty
- 48:26rate can be 100 percent. And that just is inequitable,
- 48:30certainly for the licensee. And it's not a good
- 48:35position for the licensure because they're going
- 48:37to have to try to find another licensee and they
- 48:40have that inventory behind them. Right. Next
- 48:46provision is insurance. That's a good provision.
- 48:51That's a good provision, which is paragraph 14.
- 48:56Typically, this provision typically focuses more
- 48:59on product liability. And there are products
- 49:02which tend to be more prone to a product liability
- 49:07claim than other products. Product liability
- 49:10generally is a U .S. based problem. We see it
- 49:14occasionally internationally, not as much, not
- 49:17nearly as much, but it is a problem in the United
- 49:19States and particularly certain products. Toys
- 49:22have a tendency to have a higher product liability
- 49:24rate. maybe than t -shirts. So children's clothing
- 49:29is prone to product liability claims and we negotiated
- 49:33back and forth with regards to what the claims
- 49:35are. Danny mentioned that his standards are about
- 49:38two million. I go generally a little higher in
- 49:41the toy category in particular, maybe as much
- 49:43as five million. Oh, sure. Watch out for. I've
- 49:47done a lot of knife licensing, and we get a minimum
- 49:51of five million. You do a lighter deal, you got
- 49:56to have plenty of liability insurance. I mean,
- 49:59if it shoots a projectile, whether you want to
- 50:04license it or not is a question, but products
- 50:07that are hazardous by their very definition require
- 50:11greater protection. Be careful with product liability
- 50:16insurance, because it's like any insurance policy.
- 50:18There's a deductible. If the deductible is so
- 50:21high, it becomes almost ineffective. So we'll
- 50:24require, if I'm a licensor, I'm going to actually
- 50:27not only have the limits of liability, but also
- 50:29the maximum deductible that keep it relatively
- 50:32low. The other thing which I want to do is I
- 50:34want to qualify the carriers they're using. In
- 50:38this case, it's a best rating of A minus or better.
- 50:41We had situations way back when, with toxic shock
- 50:44syndrome, where light, where carriers were going
- 50:47bankrupt. And that doesn't help you in a product
- 50:49liability case. So last but not least, the licensor
- 50:53is going to want to be named as an additional
- 50:54insured under the licensees' policy. Generally,
- 50:58there's no cost for that. So as a practical matter,
- 51:01every licensee, licensor should not be reluctant
- 51:04to grant that. And if you have an agent, we also
- 51:09as agents have asked for the same protection,
- 51:12along with the licensor. There's force majeure,
- 51:18which is becoming an issue during COVID. I make
- 51:22sure that the provision, excuse me, I make sure
- 51:24a provision about pandemics is in there. I try
- 51:27to also put a provision in there with regards
- 51:29to supply chain disruptions and things like that.
- 51:34there's jurisdiction dispute. A licensor is always
- 51:40going to keep the law of his home state there
- 51:42as a practical metaphor for governing law, because
- 51:45they don't want a dozen licenses out there with
- 51:49the jurisdiction of a dozen different states
- 51:51governing it. It should be the home state or
- 51:54a single state by the licensor. New York has
- 51:58a provision which permits you to use New York
- 52:02law, even though the parties aren't in New York.
- 52:06Disputes is another provision which is always
- 52:09negotiated. Litigation, arbitration. I'm an advocate
- 52:13of mediation. That's a requirement before you
- 52:15even get into arbitration or litigation. Danny,
- 52:18what's your question? Greg, change the screen.
- 52:23I'm on it. I thought I'm on it. 16. Is it there?
- 52:33Yeah, it's there. Okay. Add a provision that
- 52:39the parties will agree to agree to a mediation
- 52:44before they initiate disputes. It's just hopefully
- 52:47it'll save some time. It'll save some money and
- 52:49get the parties talking to each other. My experience,
- 52:52frankly, has been a lot of the clients will They
- 52:55don't want to talk to their adversaries, so they
- 52:56want their lawyers to talk to the adversaries.
- 52:59That's probably the most inefficient way of resolving
- 53:02a dispute. So get them in a mediation room with
- 53:04a mediator who knows what they're doing and try
- 53:08to resolve it. Next provision is assignability
- 53:12and transfer. And this leads to a provision called
- 53:15the transfer clause, which is becoming more and
- 53:18more prominent in most license agreements. And
- 53:21basically, a licensee who wants to sell their
- 53:26business, transfer the license along with the
- 53:28business, a licensor is going to want to charge
- 53:30a transfer fee in order to do that. Danny, what's
- 53:34your position on transfer fees? Well, we talk
- 53:36about this, whether this is a fair... question
- 53:40from the licensor or not. If I have a license
- 53:44that's significant like a Disney license, has
- 53:47that propelled my company into doing better and
- 53:51therefore more financially viable for purchase
- 53:55by a larger company? Disney will make the case.
- 53:59Yes, it does. And therefore we want a taste of
- 54:02that of that transfer, that sale. because we've
- 54:06helped you become more profitable as a corporation,
- 54:09not just within the product category that we've
- 54:13licensed you. So one can make the argument that
- 54:16there's some justification for it, but it's what
- 54:21I think of as a greed clause. Some people will
- 54:25try to get what they can. It's hard to prove
- 54:29it. It's hard to disprove it. And I don't know
- 54:33how you go to court and make this work if you
- 54:36had to, but it's getting to be a problem as people
- 54:41value licensing more. Well, I'm seeing more,
- 54:45I see frequently, more frequently than I'd like
- 54:48is an amorphous number as opposed to a fixed
- 54:50number to be determined by the licensor. The
- 54:53problem I've got with that is a licensee, if
- 54:57they are in play, they're going to sell the company
- 54:59or transfer the business. If they know what the
- 55:02number is going to be for a transfer fee, they
- 55:04can build it into the selling price of the business.
- 55:07If they don't know what the number is going to
- 55:08be, and it's amorphous, it becomes more difficult
- 55:11to build it into the selling price of the business.
- 55:15So I always insist upon some sort of a number.
- 55:17We can negotiate the number, but a stated number.
- 55:23As we talked about before, Greg, it depends too
- 55:28what the status of the license is. Is the agreement
- 55:32reasonably new with the number of years to run
- 55:34or is the license about to terminate within six
- 55:41months? So the question is the time that's left
- 55:46on the license is also a factor to be considered.
- 55:49And how much has been paid already? If the guarantees
- 55:51have already been met at that point, the idea
- 55:55of transferring, it should be a nominal fee,
- 55:57not a major fee. Schedule A, that's what we talked
- 56:00about as an outline for the business executives
- 56:03to negotiate. We identify the property, the trademarks,
- 56:07the licensed products. And again, the licensed
- 56:09products with specificity, not just toys or not
- 56:12just apparel, but it's men and women's cotton
- 56:15t -shirts, sleeved. size is small to extra, extra
- 56:19large, as detailed as you can. Similarly, the
- 56:24territory and the channels of distribution and
- 56:26the terms. We didn't talk, I guess we talked
- 56:30a little bit about the guarantees before in the
- 56:32royalties, and you see under the royalty rates
- 56:34here, you're seeing a domestic rate, an FOB rate,
- 56:37and a rate on direct sales. I think it tends
- 56:41to be more aggressive on the direct sales rate.
- 56:44than I am. I tend to believe that the direct
- 56:47sales royalties should be lower because the selling
- 56:50price is going to be higher. But wait a minute.
- 56:54Wait a minute. You're making sometimes double
- 56:57the income on a direct sale because you're not
- 57:00selling it for wholesale price. You're selling
- 57:02it for a full retail price. So you're making
- 57:05a significantly bigger margin. Why aren't I entitled
- 57:10to some of that? Classic licensor. I love them.
- 57:14Yeah, well, you know You want my mouse you got
- 57:20to pay for my mouse, okay The this is the code
- 57:25of Lima's licensing internationals code of business
- 57:27practices one of the conditions Which is what
- 57:30you want a licensee to follow and it's basically
- 57:32labor fair labor There's a number of groups out
- 57:36there which have it Fair Labor Association has
- 57:38one most of the major retailers have ones, but
- 57:41you want to hold the licensees feet to the fire
- 57:43with regards to what I refer to as the Kathie
- 57:45Lee Gifford clause, because that can be a black
- 57:48eye down the road if the licensee all of a sudden
- 57:51has been manufacturing product wherever, using
- 57:54child labor or prison labor or unsanitary conditions,
- 57:59because that's going to be a reflection of the
- 58:00license war. So this should be built into the
- 58:04agreement as an exhibit, and it should be a termination
- 58:06right. I'm going to go through a couple of Battersby's
- 58:11laws on licensing. Danny's got a couple of Simon
- 58:14Says on licensing. But my biggest one, number
- 58:17one and number two, when you say - Turn the page,
- 58:21Greg. Got it. Is it there? Yep. When you sleep
- 58:27with dogs, you get fleas. Basically, what I'm
- 58:30saying is the licensor, make sure the licensee
- 58:33has manufactured the type of products of a quality
- 58:36which you want to see your brand on. If they're
- 58:39manufactured schlock products all along, and
- 58:42all of a sudden you're Tiffany and you're trying
- 58:43to license them to use the Tiffany label, they're
- 58:46not going to manufacture the products of the
- 58:48quality you want. The other one is to, no partnerships
- 58:51in licensing. I attend, Danny and I have talked,
- 58:56we've talked at many licensing conferences, and
- 58:58licensors and licensees alike all talk about
- 59:01partnerships. There is no partnership. If you
- 59:03look at a license agreement, take a Disney license
- 59:07agreement. put it into a word processor and look
- 59:09for the word partner. You'll see it once, and
- 59:13it'll say, this is not a partnership. So just
- 59:16understand that. The other thing is too, every
- 59:18license agreement is negotiable. No matter what
- 59:20they're told, everyone should be negotiable.
- 59:23Danny, want to go Simon's Rules? Yeah, if you
- 59:26put them up there, I can do them. Oh, this is
- 59:28also how not to negotiate. The objective is not
- 59:31to drive a stake through your adversary's heart.
- 59:34You're going to be dealing with these people
- 59:37down the road. And people, licensed executives,
- 59:41have memories like elephants. Give them a hard
- 59:43time. You're not showing your image, Gregory.
- 59:45You're going to have trouble the next time. Danny.
- 59:49There you go. You got your knife through the
- 59:50heart. Now go to mine. I won't talk about, we're
- 59:58not talking, this isn't a sales conference. So
- 1:00:01selling, this really applies to selling. The
- 1:00:06third point is, to me, one of the core elements
- 1:00:10of any deal I do. If you don't make a deal fair,
- 1:00:13it's not going to work. Somebody isn't going
- 1:00:17to be happy at the end of the day. What I want
- 1:00:22to do is I want to find licensees that I can
- 1:00:24work with on multiple licenses. And so I want
- 1:00:28to spend the time getting to know your company
- 1:00:30so I can work with you, not for just this license,
- 1:00:33but for others in the future. Go forward, will
- 1:00:39you, Greg? As I said, on sales projections, beware.
- 1:00:47They're always going to be low. Know that going
- 1:00:51in, but try to remember that if the deal isn't
- 1:00:56fair going back to the last one, you're never
- 1:00:59going to make it work. Keep going, Wade Gregory.
- 1:01:11The one I want to really say is the last one.
- 1:01:16A business law teacher gave me this years ago.
- 1:01:21The strongest memory is weaker than the palest
- 1:01:25ink. If it isn't written down, good luck proving
- 1:01:29your point. I always say to everybody, write
- 1:01:33it down. I don't do deals on handshakes. I do
- 1:01:39them by paper. And anything I want in an agreement,
- 1:01:45that I want to enforce, I want it written down.
- 1:01:51That's my rules. And then we come to some books
- 1:01:54Danny and I have done together. As reference
- 1:01:58books, you may want to consider them, all of
- 1:02:00which are on Amazon. There's a couple of additional
- 1:02:03books with Walters Kluver and Thomson Reuters,
- 1:02:07Licensing and Royalty Rates, Agreements and Law
- 1:02:09of Merchandising Character Licensing. And any
- 1:02:12questions? If you have any questions, raise them
- 1:02:14now. drop us an email and we're happy to answer
- 1:02:17them. Sure. And we can help where we're around.
- 1:02:25Okay, so it actually looks like we have a few
- 1:02:27questions in our Q &A box, actually. We'll try
- 1:02:32to stifle through all this. Are you, let's see.
- 1:02:37Are you saying licensors grant tariff relief?
- 1:02:40If so, what does that relief look like? Say that
- 1:02:43again. Are you seeing licensors grant tariff
- 1:02:47relief? If so, what does that relief look like?
- 1:02:51Well, the tariff relief would be obviously pegged
- 1:02:55to what the tariff cost is. So the question is,
- 1:02:59and that has yet to come up, at least I haven't
- 1:03:02negotiated one that has it in it, but I'm sure
- 1:03:05it's going to become a factor if these tariffs
- 1:03:08continue. It's like a tax, and taxes have always
- 1:03:14been generally deductible. So the question is,
- 1:03:19will we consider the tariff to be a tax and therefore
- 1:03:23deductible? So it's yet to be tested, I think,
- 1:03:27in the marketplace. But I've got to tell you
- 1:03:29that the toy industry is clamoring for that point
- 1:03:32of view, that tariffs should be something that
- 1:03:35is a deductible allowance. It'll fall under the
- 1:03:39definition of net sales as deductible allowances.
- 1:03:42So, and again, if you're a license or, that's
- 1:03:46what you're going to be focusing on. The licensees
- 1:03:50are going to want to be able to deduct it. The
- 1:03:51licensure is not going to let them deduct it.
- 1:03:53So you got the push and pull of licensure versus
- 1:03:55licensee, but it is going to be an issue going
- 1:03:57forward, certainly. Oh, yeah. OK, there's another
- 1:04:00one. What do you think about royalty waterfall
- 1:04:03provisions for sales? I'm not sure I understand
- 1:04:08what was meant by waterfall. Yeah, I'm not sure
- 1:04:11either. I do either. Okay, let's see. If it's
- 1:04:18a fountain, that's agreeable. Explain the consequences
- 1:04:23of a quote unquote naked license or a license
- 1:04:26without approvals of quality of the merch, please.
- 1:04:29Immediate loss of trademark rights, possible
- 1:04:32erosion of trademark rights. It's called naked
- 1:04:35licensing and what it is is the licensing of
- 1:04:37your trademark without enforcing the quality
- 1:04:39control provisions I'm forcing quality control
- 1:04:42at all So I grant you a license to use my my
- 1:04:46trademark, but I'm not look I'm not inspecting
- 1:04:49property. I'm not giving you I'm not asking for
- 1:04:52samples. I'm not approving samples Trademarks
- 1:04:57and there there are a slew of cases Dunkin Donuts
- 1:05:00happens to be one of the cases which talks about
- 1:05:03it, but there's a slew of cases. That's one of
- 1:05:06the major potential liabilities for a licensure.
- 1:05:09And that's the reason you'll see extensive quality
- 1:05:12control provisions in any trademark or merchandising
- 1:05:14license agreement, because the licensure doesn't
- 1:05:17want to run the risk of losing their underlying
- 1:05:20trademark. All right. Perfect. Thank you. And
- 1:05:25let's see, we have a few more. If the licensor
- 1:05:29agrees not to grant to third parties, isn't it
- 1:05:32effectively an exclusive license? Wouldn't a
- 1:05:35court interpret it as such? Well, it depends.
- 1:05:40It depends how the license is written. With Greg's
- 1:05:42clause, there's a provision that allows him to
- 1:05:52consider it exclusive. Could you answer that
- 1:05:59question one more time? I'm not sure I fully
- 1:06:01understand it. Yes. If a licensor agrees not
- 1:06:04to grant to third parties, isn't it effectively
- 1:06:07an exclusive license? So wouldn't a court interpret
- 1:06:11it as such? I think it could be argued that certainly.
- 1:06:17It's kind of a backdoor exclusive license. But
- 1:06:22usually, there's a provision before it. which
- 1:06:25talks about identifying it's either exclusive
- 1:06:27or non -exclusive. So I'm assuming the question
- 1:06:29means if the agreement states non -exclusive,
- 1:06:33but they agree not to, does that make a non -exclusive
- 1:06:36license an exclusive license? I think an argument
- 1:06:38can be made. It does. But whether it would hold
- 1:06:44up in a bankruptcy court is a whole other factor.
- 1:06:49The other thing, which is a little bit of a twist
- 1:06:51when you talk about licensed grants, There is,
- 1:06:55and this agreement doesn't provide for it, but
- 1:06:57does an exclusive license mean to the exclusion
- 1:07:00of the licensor or just to the exclusion of third
- 1:07:03parties? And that's something which has to be
- 1:07:05identified in the provision. Yeah, generally,
- 1:07:08we maintain the right to be able to sell product.
- 1:07:12irrespective of your right, whether it's exclusive
- 1:07:15or not, and primarily because we want to be in
- 1:07:19the business of maybe making a premium to promote
- 1:07:22our property, or now with print -on -demand,
- 1:07:27may want to actually be in the business and want
- 1:07:31to have that right to do that. Disney, for example,
- 1:07:34maintains a right to be able to sell product
- 1:07:38in their store no matter what license you have.
- 1:07:43So they can make their own product to sell in
- 1:07:46the stores They alluded to a car that there's
- 1:07:50always this typical always a car that for premiums
- 1:07:52and promotions The reason that for the car that
- 1:07:55is the royalty structure the compensation structure
- 1:07:58of those deals are radically different than a
- 1:08:00typical merchandise license agreement So the
- 1:08:03license or typically retains those rights and
- 1:08:06will normally even if it's if I've got a toy
- 1:08:09licensee manufacturing toy action figures But
- 1:08:13I retain the rights to enter into a premium deal
- 1:08:17for action figures with a premium manufacturer,
- 1:08:20which could be a different person. That doesn't
- 1:08:22violate the original merchandising agreement.
- 1:08:26It was born out of the fact that the studios
- 1:08:28didn't want to ever be in a position where they
- 1:08:30couldn't market against their movie a premium
- 1:08:34that would promote the film. I mean, that's really
- 1:08:38where it stemmed from. Well, the royalty -rate
- 1:08:40structure is different, too, with a merchandise
- 1:08:42and a license. Yeah, but its structure, irrespective
- 1:08:45of the structure, the whole thing is I didn't
- 1:08:47want to, I couldn't stop a studio from creating
- 1:08:50a Burger King tie -in for their movie because
- 1:08:54I have a license with a company for a toy that
- 1:08:58would conflict. Right. All right. Well, that
- 1:09:00looks like we're at time. Thank you so much for
- 1:09:03your time, Greg and Dan, and thank you so much
- 1:09:05to our audience for joining us today. Have a
- 1:09:08good afternoon, everybody. Thank you. Thank you.
- 1:09:11You may be eligible for CLE credit in your state.
- 1:09:14Visit bhba .org slash podcasts for more information.