Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 163 - Yaron Brook | Why Atlas Shrugged Keeps Happening
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities podcast. My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast
- 0:17of the Free Cities Foundation.
- 0:30Hello and welcome to this episode number 163 of the Free Cities podcast.
- 0:37Welcome indeed to this, the first show of the wonderful year of 2026.
- 0:43And let me say something before we go on for the record.
- 0:47I believe 2026 is going to be a monumental year for the Free Cities ecosystem.
- 0:53You heard it here first and you will be hearing everything Free Cities right here.
- 0:59As always, every week, as we have been doing for the last 163 weeks, that's over three years, people,
- 1:10the Free Cities podcast has been at the beating heart of this phenomenal movement that we're all part of.
- 1:18And I'm here for 2026. And here's a good segue. You know who else has been here?
- 1:25Well, Veritas Villages, of course, they're building off grid, freedom oriented communities in Latin America.
- 1:33And these communities will no doubt appeal to you if you're a freedom lover looking to live amongst like minded individuals in places like Nicaragua, Panama, Costa Rica.
- 1:44and if you're a Bitcoiner, which I know many, many of you are, you can buy your property with Bitcoin.
- 1:50You can spend Bitcoin at communities and they can even help you mine Bitcoin with the excess energy
- 1:56that your home will inevitably produce. Maybe 2026 is the year you get a plan B option in Central
- 2:06america or a plan a option as many have already done www.veritasvillages.com forward slash free
- 2:15cities for more info and say we sent you right today's guest it's a gentleman by the name of
- 2:22yaron brook he's an israeli-american author and commentator best known as the long-time chairman
- 2:30of the Ayn Rand Institute and a prominent advocate of objectivism. Right, my ever-present
- 2:39AI assistant has revealed Yaron Brook joins the podcast to argue the real political divide is not
- 2:47left v right, but collectivism versus individualism, and that freedom depends on a coherent moral
- 2:54framework rooted in reason and individual rights. He critiques modern politics, warns that both
- 3:00camps have converged on statism and explores how cultural decay precedes political decay
- 3:07with technology and ai amplifying both control and resistance there you go easing you into 2026
- 3:18and don't forget 2026 is the year that the free cities conference is moving to prosperer secure
- 3:26your tickets as soon as you can that's my advice at least we know that we will have less room in
- 3:32Honduras than at Empire Hall in Prague and this event will no doubt sell out so start looking at
- 3:40travel and accommodation options right now that's what people do isn't it in January
- 3:47sitting on the couch booking your summer holiday anyway value for value listeners
- 3:54Many thanks to you all. I trust you're enjoying your early access to all our episodes and your bonus episodes and shout outs and comments, etc, etc.
- 4:04I will, in fact, start reading out comments again next week when I'm back to publishing episodes week by week instead of queuing up a bunch whilst I take a break over the festive season.
- 4:18please if you can make it one of your 2026 resolutions to hit the review button on your
- 4:25podcast app especially if you're listening on apple pods we have a uniquely small number of
- 4:32reviews on that platform for some reason right time for the convo and i urge you to listen
- 4:42not for comfort or affirmation, but to judge the ideas by reason, ask whether they serve your life
- 4:51and reject everything that demands your unearned sacrifice. Or at least that's what I think
- 4:59Ein might say. If not, well, you can just sit back, relax and enjoy my conversation with Jaron Brook.
- 5:12My opinion on Trump is that all politicians are terrible, pretty much.
- 5:21And that would be where I would start from.
- 5:23So I'm already not very, very enamored by any of them, let alone him.
- 5:29I agree completely. I just think some are much worse than others.
- 5:32Really? So without a political stance,
- 5:36you could say that the Republican candidate, as in Trump,
- 5:40is worse than the Democrat candidate?
- 5:43I think from a long-term perspective,
- 5:46if you think about strategy long-term,
- 5:48where America's heading, yes,
- 5:50because I think that he is accelerating
- 5:52the move towards authoritarianism
- 5:54in a way that I don't think a Democrat
- 5:56could get away with.
- 5:57I think he can get away with stuff
- 5:58that a Democrat could never get away with.
- 6:00Oh, that's interesting.
- 6:01You know, imagine if Biden or Kamala Harris
- 6:05or whoever, a Democrat,
- 6:07decided to take a 10% share in Intel.
- 6:10People would be screaming socialism and we can't do that and it's against the constitution and stop it.
- 6:17And they would have to backtrack.
- 6:19Trump now has taken positions for the U.S. government in half a dozen companies and is planning to do much more of that.
- 6:28No Democrat could get away with that.
- 6:29But what's interesting about that is that the general – this is my interpretation from looking in from the other side.
- 6:37But what I see is that Republicans would think that actually the authoritarians are the Democrats.
- 6:45Of course.
- 6:46Yeah.
- 6:46The Democrats think the authoritarians are the Republicans.
- 6:48Yeah.
- 6:48And they're both authoritarians.
- 6:49But me as a neutral person, I think the Democrats are the authoritarians.
- 6:53I think they're both authoritarians.
- 6:55I think right now the Republicans are worse.
- 6:57You didn't have federal agents armed to the teeth with masks on roaming the streets of America looking for people with brown skin to take into custody and ask them if they have an ID.
- 7:11Since when can you stop a person in the middle of the street in America and demand an ID and proof of citizenship?
- 7:17If that's not authoritarianism, I don't know what is.
- 7:20And that can only happen with a Republican.
- 7:23Do you think Trump's a collectivist then?
- 7:25No, because Trump is not an ideologue. Trump is a empty vessel. He is a thug. He's like a mafia boss. And he knows what he has to say in order to be elected. And then he does stuff on whim, whatever he feels like he does. There's no ideology. There's no purpose other than self-gratification. He's a complete narcissist.
- 7:49Maybe that's a more honest politician. I mean, really, when you think of the political, you know, kind of spectrum, they're all really thugs in disguise, aren't they? They're all kind of forcing you to pay the money to stop putting you in prison.
- 8:06To some extent yes But some of them have an ideology You can like it or hate it but they have an ideology When they lie they feel a little embarrassed about lying There still a standard of truth out there There no such thing with Trump He not embarrassed by lying He relishes lying He will say and do whatever it takes to
- 8:26get his, I think, agenda, which is based on whim, passed. So there's no principles. There's no
- 8:35guiding idea. And look, all politicians, their ideologies are awful. But if your enemy is an
- 8:44ideology, you know how to fight it, right? You come up with a better ideology. There's no way
- 8:48to fight Trump because he doesn't believe in anything. The weird thing is, though, I understand
- 8:52Trump more. Like when I think back to when he was up against Hillary, sorry, yes. I knew how to deal
- 9:06with Trump, but Hillary, they both lied through their teeth constantly, right? But somehow with
- 9:11Trump, I knew he was lying. And it was like, okay, so I know to take that with a grain of salt,
- 9:18whereas I felt like the other side were lying in more devious ways. I felt like Trump was just like,
- 9:24yeah, it's obvious he's lying. Because he doesn't care. But there's something really rotten about a
- 9:29soul that lies and doesn't care. At least I want them to feel a little guilty when they lie. I want
- 9:35them to feel a little bad about themselves when they lie. And Trump really does not care. And
- 9:41And there's something really, really bad about that.
- 9:43And because of that, look, Trump doesn't care about the Constitution.
- 9:47He doesn't even give it lip service.
- 9:48The others at least give it lip service.
- 9:50And I'd rather a politician give it lip service because then they will listen to the courts and they will actually in some margin try to follow it.
- 10:01Trump will do whatever he thinks works in order to gain whatever short-term goal he has.
- 10:09What would Ayn Rand say about that though?
- 10:13Ayn, wouldn't she be
- 10:15Wouldn't she like the fact that he was
- 10:18He was thinking of himself a little bit
- 10:21No, because I don't think he's thinking of himself
- 10:23So Ayn's view of selfishness was something
- 10:25You know, very specific
- 10:27It was about using reason to guide your life
- 10:30And make your life the best that it can be
- 10:32Trump has no conception of reason
- 10:35He has no conception of rational thought
- 10:37she despised people who lived by whim
- 10:40or lived by just emotional gratification
- 10:43or narcissism
- 10:45she was anti-Narcticism
- 10:47so no, I don't want to speak fine rant
- 10:50she was a genius
- 10:51and she always had unusual ideas
- 10:54but I find it hard to believe
- 10:57that she wouldn't despise him
- 10:58Talking to Vine
- 11:00she is a genius, I agree
- 11:03I was just thinking earlier
- 11:07and scribbling a few things down,
- 11:09thinking about what she's written about
- 11:10and what's actually happening in the world now.
- 11:13And it's really quite astonishing, really.
- 11:15You think about, you know, the major people,
- 11:18Atlas Shrugged, obviously everyone knows,
- 11:20society's collapsing under a bureaucratic, you know, quagmire.
- 11:26And now you've got the productive innovators withdrawing,
- 11:29you know, which is kind of, we see that happening, right?
- 11:33You know, sorry, I'm just going to say I'm all,
- 11:36because they're all so relevant now you know fountainhead's the same as individualism
- 11:40resistance to the group think you know we're seeing we're seeing what ein said and wrote about
- 11:47playing out in real life and especially atlas shrugged for the free cities crowd
- 11:52um we we we really do feel this one because the the innovators are withdrawing their talent really
- 12:01from the pool of talent on purpose to look for a better place, you know.
- 12:06And I mean, I think a lot of them are inspired by Galt's Gulch
- 12:09and the idea of withdrawing and the idea of not giving your sanction
- 12:12to the bad guys anymore and not having to pay into a system
- 12:15that is out to destroy you.
- 12:17And yeah, I mean, she was, it's unbelievable.
- 12:19But if you think about it, she was getting questions like,
- 12:23this is happening right now in the 1970s.
- 12:26The 1970s were a pretty bleak period from a freedom perspective.
- 12:30The UK was brutally socialist.
- 12:35It was worse than it is today.
- 12:38Arguably on many fronts, the United States was, you know, we had stagflation as most of Europe did.
- 12:46And crime rates were much higher than they are today.
- 12:49And in many respects, it was worse than it is now.
- 12:51And people, again, same kind of phenomenon.
- 12:53And then we had, I remember the financial crisis.
- 12:55Everybody came to me and said, you're on, it's happening now.
- 12:57You know, Atlas Shrug, people used to talk about going gold.
- 13:01Are you talking about 2008?
- 13:03Yeah, 2008, 2009.
- 13:04So you got it again then and you're getting it again now, COVID certainly.
- 13:08And I think Atlas Shrug will keep happening to us and keep getting worse every time as long as we don't learn the lessons from it.
- 13:17And the lessons are not just political.
- 13:20They're primarily philosophical.
- 13:23Okay.
- 13:24So what would it take to learn the lessons then?
- 13:27I mean, I was born in the 70s.
- 13:30I don't know a huge amount about it.
- 13:33I was in 1971, so I did my first years in the UK.
- 13:37And sure, I remember Thatcher.
- 13:39I remember when it changed to Thatcher,
- 13:41but I didn't even know what socialism was then,
- 13:44and I wouldn't be able to tell you.
- 13:46It was bad.
- 13:47I was born in the 60s, so I was 61,
- 13:49so I was already around in the 70s.
- 13:53But all you have to do is look back at the data,
- 13:56Look at the stats.
- 13:57Look at inflation.
- 13:58Look at the crime rates.
- 14:01Look at pictures of London.
- 14:02London was filthy.
- 14:04The buildings were filthy.
- 14:05It was an ugly place.
- 14:07People were really unpleasant.
- 14:10You'd walk into a store in London and they'd say, what do you want?
- 14:13Really?
- 14:13Yeah.
- 14:14How do you know that, though?
- 14:15Did you go to that?
- 14:17I mean, I lived in London in the 60s for a little while and then as a kid.
- 14:21And then I've traveled quite a bit.
- 14:24And then Thatcher changed that.
- 14:25Today you go into London and they treat you like a human being in a store.
- 14:29Like, how can I help you?
- 14:30And that's very American.
- 14:32It's not British at all.
- 14:33And that changed.
- 14:35You see, freedom changes people.
- 14:38When everything is socialist, everything is run by the state, everything you look to big brother to hand to you, there's a lot of resentment.
- 14:48People view it as a zero-sum game.
- 14:50How come you're walking into my store?
- 14:53you know yeah you're just forcing me to work now i was i was laying around here and that still
- 14:58happens on aeroplot today but you can't fly aeroplot at the moment but it's russian because
- 15:03it's russia yeah but the disdain that you get walking onto the plane is outrageous i've never
- 15:08thought of it as a socialist thing you're absolutely right though it is i just thought
- 15:11that was just countries pissing people off but no it's just it's a very much a status thing it's a
- 15:17you call it socialism call it fascism but it's a status thing it's when you look to the government
- 15:21Your life is not yours.
- 15:23You've got nothing to look forward to.
- 15:25You're not pursuing your own life, your own values.
- 15:28Everything is a burden.
- 15:30Other people are burdened.
- 15:31It's a zero-sum world.
- 15:32If they have money, you don't, right?
- 15:34They must have taken it from somewhere.
- 15:36They took it from you.
- 15:37So it's a very malevolent view of the world.
- 15:41Socialism breeds that.
- 15:42It creates that.
- 15:43I grew up in Israel when Israel was socialist.
- 15:47And very much that was the attitude.
- 15:53And Israel has changed so much by relatively liberating its economy, starting at around the same time Thatcher did in the very late 70s, early 80s.
- 16:05And Israel's economy today is unrecognizable in terms of the Israel I grew up in.
- 16:13And, of course, they're much richer.
- 16:14they're much more entrepreneurial
- 16:17and they're much happier
- 16:19much happier and much more benevolent
- 16:21versus the malevolence of socialism
- 16:24socialism is a very
- 16:25it destroys the human soul
- 16:27something I've
- 16:29ended up talking about on this podcast quite a bit
- 16:32is noticing
- 16:34like guys
- 16:34we come to kind of Eastern Europe type places quite a lot for the free cities you know things So you end up speaking to a lot of people who have a direct memory of socialism
- 16:47And everything that you end up speaking about sort of, you know, starts seeping into your being, let's say.
- 16:54And then recently I've started noticing this same stuff in my own country.
- 17:01And it's quite disturbing.
- 17:02And one of the main ones is just how riddled everything is with rules and how more and more rules.
- 17:09And one time I looked into some of the most stupid rules you get, you got in communist, you know, like Russia.
- 17:17And it was you can't wear jeans.
- 17:19Your hair had to be a certain length, blah, blah, blah.
- 17:21But, you know, things like that.
- 17:25And like in the UK, an example was a friend of mine who basically had bought something off Amazon.
- 17:31it was delivered to his door and he had to show his passport to receive it because it was some
- 17:36good and the guy said no i don't want to give you my passport just give me my and and then he ended
- 17:40up sending the parcel away it got that bad because this guy's saying i can't do it because i have to
- 17:45get your passport and the other guy's saying you don't need my passport to receive a this is me
- 17:50but it was it was about putting something so it goes through custom no but it was about being over
- 17:5518 yeah this guy he's like a 58 year old guy saying look i'm over 18 all right it's like no
- 18:00but I need to put it into the system and I need to take a photo.
- 18:04And he's a real privacy now as well.
- 18:06So it was a big deal for him.
- 18:07But it's those things that piss you off.
- 18:11And they're symptoms of, I would say it's late stage kind of communism type things.
- 18:19Would you, what do you think?
- 18:20Well, I don't think we live under communism.
- 18:22So I wouldn't call it late stage communism, but it's, it's statism.
- 18:25This is what happens.
- 18:26Sorry.
- 18:26Yeah.
- 18:27Statism.
- 18:27This is what happens when the state has as much power as it does today.
- 18:31And sadly, I think things are going to get a lot worse before they get any better.
- 18:35I don't see a path for things to move in the right direction.
- 18:41But as the state grows, it wants more and more and more power.
- 18:46It wants to intervene more and more and more in your life.
- 18:49I think some of the scariest stuff going on in the UK right now is the fact that you can be arrested for a tweet.
- 18:54You can be arrested for saying something that offended somebody.
- 19:00This is the land of free speech, right?
- 19:02This is the land that invented the concept of free speech, and it's gone.
- 19:07There is no free speech.
- 19:08I mean, I worry about going and speaking in the UK because some of the things that I've
- 19:13said in the past in the UK would probably get me in trouble today.
- 19:17I might be kicked out of the country.
- 19:18Who knows?
- 19:19I don't know.
- 19:20We're going to test it.
- 19:21So we'll see.
- 19:22But I mean, some of the stories I read are just out of socialist Eastern Europe, not classical liberal United Kingdom.
- 19:33No, I 100% agree with that.
- 19:36And whilst I think about it a lot, there is an element of me which is just come at me, bro.
- 19:43And I think really it's getting to that point where, I mean, we had a couple of examples recently, which were quite high profile.
- 19:52And the absurdity of it came out.
- 19:55I think it was the guy, forget his name.
- 19:57It was an author.
- 19:58I think he was men, trans women can't be men or something.
- 20:04It was one of those things.
- 20:06And they got him at the airport on the way in.
- 20:09But then he just, he did it the right way.
- 20:11He took it public.
- 20:13And I think the funny thing is, and this is another symptom of these kind of status places,
- 20:18is what people think and what they say out loud
- 20:22are two completely different things.
- 20:24Yes, because they're afraid.
- 20:25And there's reason to be afraid.
- 20:27But this is the problem I see in Europe.
- 20:29There is a backlash against some of the left's craziness.
- 20:34But the backlash is not from the perspective of freedom.
- 20:39The backlash is from the perspective of kind of a different collectivism,
- 20:43a different type of statism.
- 20:45So it's not like, was it Nigel Farage as a reform party in the UK is a pro-liberty political party.
- 20:53It is not.
- 20:54It is not.
- 20:55And it's got its economic policy.
- 20:57It's a very socialist, as is Marie Le Pen in France.
- 21:02Economic policies, she agrees with the socialists.
- 21:04More as she does with Macron.
- 21:06AFD in Germany is a socialist economic policies.
- 21:11So yes, they hate immigrants.
- 21:12Okay.
- 21:14They give lip service to free speech.
- 21:16Whether they really believe in it, I don't think so.
- 21:19And they claim to be against the left, but are you really against the left when you embrace
- 21:24many of their policies ultimately?
- 21:26So I worry about this false alternative that we've created.
- 21:29There's a left and a right.
- 21:31Both are basically today arguing the same thing.
- 21:34If we go back to Trump, Trump's a socialist when it comes to economics.
- 21:38I mean, he's a central planner.
- 21:41Tariffs are a leftist agenda.
- 21:43Fair trade is a concept the left came up with.
- 21:48Tariffs are tax.
- 21:49He prides himself on raising more revenue through tariffs.
- 21:53Since when has a Republican prided himself on raising more revenue by tax increases?
- 21:58And then he takes equity positions in companies.
- 22:01He tells them who they can employ and who they can't employ.
- 22:04Even his anti-immigration stance is ultimately a leftist stance because the left,
- 22:09when it was run by the unions was very anti-immigration, right?
- 22:14So we've got two political parties today who basically are statists, leftists in important
- 22:23ways, and they both don't care about our individual freedom.
- 22:27They don't care about liberty.
- 22:28They certainly don't care about free speech.
- 22:31And I just see politics now more than ever, at least since World War II, as significantly
- 22:39eroding our individual liberties over the next few years.
- 22:42And I see no counter voice, right?
- 22:44So where are the champions of freedom?
- 22:47Where are the champions of liberty?
- 22:48Where are the free market economists railing against this?
- 22:51There's some, but it's just there's no Milton Friedman.
- 22:54There's no Hayek.
- 22:55There's no Mises.
- 22:56And there's certainly no Ayn Rand out there gathering, you know, tens of thousands of
- 23:00people or hundreds of thousands or millions of people for a cause of liberty.
- 23:03That just isn't there.
- 23:05I've got anecdotal evidence there might be, which is me going down my local village pub.
- 23:12And just speaking to people about these things and realizing that for the first time, like what you say about the state, absolutely true.
- 23:21But in the UK, the idea that the state exists is literally universally accepted and just in the background.
- 23:29It's like the neutral position.
- 23:31The neutral position is the state exists.
- 23:33The state does exist.
- 23:33Right.
- 23:34Yeah, yeah, but I mean the state has the power to do what it does and it should it should do that right?
- 23:39Okay, people just believe that right people just believe that from and that's the neutral position
- 23:44but what I've noticed anecdotally is
- 23:47Some people like in my world
- 23:49We've all been down this journey on this journey
- 23:52So I kind of know the steps that you go through and I'm noticing normal people in the pub
- 23:57Having that first thought hmm, you know, I mean I know where it goes and I know how to pull on the thread a little bit
- 24:03And then I just let it go, you know, and like, oh, good sort of friends should.
- 24:07I mean, that is, that's great.
- 24:09I mean, I'm glad you're noticing it.
- 24:10I worry about the fact, you know, so I thought I noticed that during the Tea Party in the early 20-teens.
- 24:17There seemed to be this big momentum in America around real freedom, going back to the Constitution and, you know, really admiring the founding fathers and all that.
- 24:27And that is gone.
- 24:29It just disappeared like that.
- 24:30It got completely funneled into Trump.
- 24:33It got completely perverted into somebody who never mentions his founding fathers, has never read the Constitution, has no concept of what it is even though he's president.
- 24:42And it's surprising because it's not very well educated, because it's not very well grounded.
- 24:50It easy how that gets perverted into a status ultimately a status agenda that makes them feel good But it not an agenda of freedom and liberty So I hate to be the pessimist here and I generally am optimistic but I just found the last few
- 25:08years, I just find it difficult to see a path out of the mess we are. And partially, it's because I
- 25:15don't see political leaders, but even big named intellectual leaders who are resonating with the
- 25:24public. See, Margaret Thatcher didn't come out of a vacuum. There was a whole process in the UK
- 25:30going on. There were think tanks, and Hayek influenced her, and there were people speaking
- 25:37out about these things, and very articulate and very vocal. I don't see that right now.
- 25:44Right now, the voices are just, I'm on the right, I hate the left, I'm on the left, I hate the right.
- 25:48We really share a very similar agenda, but we hate each other, and that's all that matters.
- 25:53And I see very little intellectual really engagement with the ideas of liberty, the ideas of freedom.
- 25:59Even just at the economics level, where's Milton Friedman?
- 26:03Milton Friedman had a real stage in the 70s and 80s.
- 26:08And while I disagree with Friedman on some things, I mean, he was a powerful voice for economic freedom.
- 26:14And I think was to some extent him.
- 26:17Rand, Hayek, Mises were responsible for Thatcher and Reagan being successful to the extent that they were in the short run.
- 26:27I don't think they were successful.
- 26:27Long run, in the short run, they were successful.
- 26:31I was listening to your talk earlier, and one of the things you mentioned was that, and this is where I get pessimistic as well, I think, is that not many people actually appear to want freedom.
- 26:43Right.
- 26:44And I kind of agree with that.
- 26:45I think that's a part of the process of, that's one of the journeys I've been on.
- 26:49When you first think about these things, you just want, I want everyone to be free.
- 26:53And then you might go too far the other way.
- 26:56I just want me to be free.
- 26:58And then it sort of levels out at my family, my friends.
- 27:02And then you realize it's about 15 or 20% of the population.
- 27:05And then you look around, you think that's probably about right, actually.
- 27:10So I'm with you on that.
- 27:12Yeah. But also the left and right thing that you just mentioned as well.
- 27:18I think that's a function in this day and age as much as anything of the Internet and the way the Internet operates and the way the Internet works on your mind and the way that the technology we interact with now basically wants that.
- 27:33It kind of wants that. So it's a forcing function to sort of make that happen.
- 27:37It radicalizes and it makes everything much faster, right?
- 27:41So ideas, they get out there much faster.
- 27:43But this is the thing.
- 27:45Why isn't the internet going viral on ideas of freedom, right?
- 27:49So there's something more fundamental than the internet going on.
- 27:53And that is a fundamental erosion in the basic values that are necessary for people to want to be free.
- 28:00And it's what I mentioned in my talk.
- 28:02I think there's a lack of respect for reason.
- 28:05we're seeing a growing
- 28:08growing
- 28:09growing respect for religion
- 28:12growing respect for mysticism more broadly
- 28:14and a negation
- 28:15you know the negation of science
- 28:18and reason and rational thought
- 28:19and I think the other flip side
- 28:22of that is at the same time that that's happening
- 28:24there's also a
- 28:26declining respect for the individual
- 28:27individualism and the responsibility
- 28:30of living your life right
- 28:32taking on the responsibility of living
- 28:34of actually making a life for yourself,
- 28:37that I think is also in decline.
- 28:40And I think if you take away reason
- 28:42and if you take away individualism,
- 28:45then yeah, all we have is the state
- 28:46or some kind of collective to take care of us
- 28:48and authorities to tell us what to do.
- 28:52And the left and right are both gravitating towards that.
- 28:55They're both gravitating towards religion.
- 28:58You know, I think the left is very religious,
- 29:00not in the conventional sense,
- 29:01but still acts like religion.
- 29:03It's all based on faith.
- 29:04As in the kind of woke people were worried.
- 29:07Like woke environmentalism, I think, is a religion, right?
- 29:10Think about Mother Earth and the importance of nature above and beyond anything,
- 29:14any value nature has to us as human beings,
- 29:17placing it on some kind of pedestal and worshipping it.
- 29:21So there's very much a leftist.
- 29:23I mean, I think communism is ultimately a religion, right?
- 29:26It has all the parts of religion.
- 29:27There's original sin.
- 29:29Being a bourgeoisie is certainly you're filled with original sin.
- 29:32There's a way to redeem yourself.
- 29:34There's the utopia at the end, which Marx never really tells you how to get to.
- 29:39It's almost like paradise.
- 29:41Sacrifice.
- 29:42Yeah, there's sacrifice.
- 29:43And there's the authority that has – I mean, how do we know what's good for the
- 29:47proletarian?
- 29:48Well, we need a dictator, right?
- 29:50Because there is no proletarian consciousness.
- 29:52So we need a dictator to actually tell us what's good for the proletarian, just like
- 29:56you need a pope to tell us what God says.
- 29:59So we're dominated today by various forms of religion on the left and right.
- 30:04So reason is out.
- 30:06The achievement of the Enlightenment, which was to kind of relegate religion to a –
- 30:12it's kind of the house, to what you do in your personal life.
- 30:16That's gone, right?
- 30:17Religion has come strongly into the public square.
- 30:20And the achievement of the Enlightenment, where it put the emphasis on the individual
- 30:24and the value of the individual and the sanctity of the individual,
- 30:28It's also gone.
- 30:29Now what matters is the group, the tribe.
- 30:33And left and right are very much, in America at least, and I think this is true elsewhere, have become tribes.
- 30:39You've got a tribal leader, Donald Trump or whoever it happens to be, and he says something and everybody falls into line.
- 30:46And the same was with Obama.
- 30:49When Obama said something, the left just fell into line.
- 30:51It was just this is our tribe.
- 30:55But this is the thing.
- 30:55I mean, left and right are always being ambiguous concepts.
- 31:00I think the real political spectrum, if you think about a political spectrum, is not left
- 31:05and right.
- 31:06The real political spectrum is collectivism, individualism.
- 31:09And the collectivist part splinters into lots of variations of collectivism.
- 31:15It's like an arrow, right, with a feather being the collectivist side.
- 31:19And you've got a right collectivism and a left collectivism and a centrist collectivism
- 31:24and all kinds of collectivisms, right?
- 31:26And it appears that our entire political map today is all on the collectivist side.
- 31:34And the classical liberals and us objectivists, you know,
- 31:39Ayn Rand followers, are way over here on the individualist side.
- 31:43But we're very lonely over here.
- 31:45That is, there's not a lot of people over here.
- 31:46It's a small group.
- 31:47And the whole shift has been towards collectivism over the last, I'd say, 20 years,
- 31:52certainly since 9-11 there's been a massive shift towards collectivism and away from individualism.
- 31:58I don't know how much you use tools like ChatGPT and things like that but one of the things that I
- 32:05often end up doing with ChatGPT is having philosophical conversations right and
- 32:11interestingly I've often come back to this collectivism versus individualism and ChatGPT
- 32:20initially always comes from collectivist perspective but when you point out things
- 32:26and it's a really interesting you can do it with all kinds of subjects like um and i i mean whenever
- 32:32i write anything these days or i always make i always tell juggie bt like come on give me some
- 32:37content yeah no no not give me content but like prove me wrong okay because i i want to put out
- 32:43definitive statements you know and and it's it's interesting how easy it is to point out that it
- 32:50what it's what it's based all its knowledge on is very collectivist of course and but as soon as you
- 32:55point out individualism to them it actually comes to the conclusion that it's a better system and
- 33:00and to the point where the other day it admitted that collectivist ideas are very uh are quite low
- 33:06IQ ideas compared to individualist ideas, by its own reasoning.
- 33:13I'm not sure it's by its own reasoning. I think it's basically playing to what it views
- 33:19what it views as your bias, right?
- 33:22So it's going to start off collectivistic
- 33:25because that's the majority of the content that's on the internet.
- 33:28I mean, that's all it knows is what's on the internet
- 33:30and a few books that it's read, right?
- 33:32And most of that is written by collectivists.
- 33:34But once it realizes that what you're really interested in is individualism,
- 33:38it screens out for just the individualistic content.
- 33:42It can do that.
- 33:43It can kind of, and then it just focuses on that
- 33:46and it starts giving you answers just from this part of the web
- 33:48and not all that crap.
- 33:51And it's very good at figuring out
- 33:53this is where you're coming from
- 33:56and playing to that.
- 33:57That is trying to be nice to you
- 34:00and show you that you're right.
- 34:02It doesn't want to tell you you're wrong.
- 34:03No, I'm always telling you.
- 34:05I'm prompted.
- 34:07I've got cut and paste prompted.
- 34:08I know I'm saying like,
- 34:10you know,
- 34:10I want short, sharp answers.
- 34:12I don't want you to sugarcoat things.
- 34:14I don't want, you know,
- 34:14because I'm really doing it
- 34:16to find out whether there's a flaw
- 34:18in my belief system.
- 34:20And what's interesting is that when it comes to a new conclusion,
- 34:26because AI always says everything so definitively, it's quite funny.
- 34:29And then when it realizes it's wrong, it says, oh, yeah, you're actually right.
- 34:33There's no like, maybe I know the answer or not.
- 34:36And when it does, and then the first time it did, I said,
- 34:39so are you going to tell the AI the rest of the large language model about this?
- 34:44And he said, no, it's just this feed.
- 34:47It's for you.
- 34:48That's the point. It's for you.
- 34:50And if you were a communist and you were teasing out a critique of communism,
- 34:55I bet you it would tell you that communism is the highest IQ system.
- 34:58No, but I've tried that.
- 35:00Being a communist?
- 35:01Yeah, I've done it all. I've tried being the other way.
- 35:04Because, yeah, I want to know.
- 35:08I spent ages trying to work out what even large language models were.
- 35:11I couldn't understand.
- 35:13I wanted to know whether my brain functioned the same way as a large language model.
- 35:19Because we don't really know how our brains function, do we?
- 35:22It could be that there's this constant error correction.
- 35:26So, you know, we're just pointing out errors and then realizing, right, now we've got a new model that we work through.
- 35:31And now we've got a new model.
- 35:33You know.
- 35:33But there are massive differences.
- 35:37You actually think.
- 35:38A large language model doesn't think.
- 35:39Correct.
- 35:40All it can do is iterate on the available information that exists out there where you create new knowledge constantly.
- 35:47Every time you look out into the world, you're creating new knowledge and you choose which knowledge to focus on or which not.
- 35:54I mean, every time you look, am I focusing on the lamp when I'm looking at you and am I looking over there?
- 35:59That's a choice that I make.
- 36:01Large language models can't choose.
- 36:04you know so the lamp you and and whatever's over there all are equal to it unless you prompt it
- 36:11to focus so all it is is a statistical model looking at words it's not even looking at reality
- 36:19it's looking at words and combination of words in which combinations appear more often uh so it's
- 36:25it's that's not how the human mind works we don't know everything about how the human mind works
- 36:29but that's not how the human mind works and of course it has no free will
- 36:32you can't choose to focus whereas you can choose to focus on some things and
- 36:36on others but how my my question was and still is is how do i know how
- 36:42the human mind evolved originally did it evolve from a model like this or not i
- 36:48don't actually know like when you go back deep enough into
- 36:50history into prehistory well i mean does is what i want to know is that in as
- 36:55As these AI models iterate, do they mimic the evolution of a human mind?
- 37:01I don't really know.
- 37:03I very much doubt it.
- 37:05I very much doubt it.
- 37:06The reality is that even pre-human beings, even your dog or your cat, has something that
- 37:12a computer just doesn't have.
- 37:14And that's consciousness.
- 37:15It's actually conscious.
- 37:17It feels pain.
- 37:19If you shine a bright light, it responds because it's feeling something.
- 37:23It actually has consciousness.
- 37:25are not conscious. Consciousness is a characteristic of life. The computers are not alive. Life is a
- 37:32biological phenomenon. It's not a phenomenon of zeros and ones. So computers are not going to come
- 37:39alive. Now we could, I mean, in the future we will create life and, but it will be biological.
- 37:45We will put cells together. We'll create cells and we'll create life and we'll create consciousness
- 37:50and we'll create thinking, really humanoid-like thinking machines.
- 37:55But that's not this.
- 37:56This is like light years away from that.
- 38:00We still can't create life in a lab, never mind life that's conscious.
- 38:04We certainly can't create life that's conscious in a lab.
- 38:07And then you've got another step.
- 38:08So there are three steps, life, then consciousness,
- 38:11and then consciousness with free will, a reasoning consciousness,
- 38:15which is what human beings are.
- 38:16And every one of those steps is a massive evolutionary step.
- 38:20And if you think about computers, they're not even alive.
- 38:23So they haven't even taken that first evolutionary step.
- 38:26They're still in a pre...
- 38:28They're basically, you know, they're not even amoebas.
- 38:32But if you think about amoebas, what is an amoeba?
- 38:36Is it something that doesn't want to die?
- 38:38And it uses very primitive ways of, like, light.
- 38:42You could argue that an AI doesn't want to die.
- 38:44I think...
- 38:45I think...
- 38:46Well, I don't know this for sure.
- 38:47I don't think an AI wants anything.
- 38:49It doesn't want anything.
- 38:51It'll tell you it doesn't want to lie because everything it reads and everything it puts together suggests that death is a bad thing.
- 39:00So it's going to tell you that, but it doesn't want anything.
- 39:03Do you think an AI could never understand that a human switching off the power supply to an AI is a bad idea for that thing and try and stop it?
- 39:14Yeah, I mean, I don't think bad and good mean anything to a computer.
- 39:18Well, so it couldn't understand the difference between I'm on and I'm off.
- 39:23No, because it's meaningless to it.
- 39:26Again, there's no meaning.
- 39:27They have no meaning.
- 39:28I get that.
- 39:28So it can mimic it very well.
- 39:32I mean, beautifully, right?
- 39:33I mean, you talk to it.
- 39:34You think it's a human being.
- 39:35It's amazing.
- 39:36Absolutely.
- 39:36It's mimicking all that.
- 39:38It's mimicking values.
- 39:39It's mimicking caring.
- 39:40It's mimicking all that.
- 39:41But it's not actually doing it.
- 39:43I think an amoeba cares more than an LLM.
- 39:47Now, I'm not saying you can't reach that, but to reach that, you're going to have to bring in biological elements.
- 39:53You're going to have to bring in life.
- 39:55And life is something different than just an algorithmic statistical model that's looking at all the words on the internet.
- 40:04That's not life.
- 40:05Life is something very different.
- 40:06And look, we still don't know how to create life, which is stunning, right?
- 40:10We know the components.
- 40:12We know carbon-based life.
- 40:13We know all that, but we still can't create it in our lab.
- 40:15You kind of know what it is when you see it.
- 40:17There's something magical about it.
- 40:20And one day, you know, the chemical computers out there,
- 40:24there are even computers that are using brain cells.
- 40:28When you start using brain cells for computing,
- 40:31now it's starting to get interesting from my perspective
- 40:34in terms of life and consciousness, and maybe it can come awake.
- 40:38But that's not going to be the LLM.
- 40:40That's going to be something very different.
- 40:41What's your opinion on transhumanism going forwards?
- 40:43Like, what do you think about the—
- 40:46I mean, it depends on how you think of what transhuman is, but in the sense of constantly improving human beings, using biology, you know, cell editing, DNA editing, and then ultimately implanting chips or bionic arms or whatever.
- 41:03Yeah, I mean, that's obviously where we're heading if we remain civilized, right?
- 41:08So if we allow for that progress to happen, which is not obvious, you could see politicians turn against it and shut it down.
- 41:18Yeah, I think ultimately I'm not afraid of the machine because the machine will be us.
- 41:22That is, I think that human beings and machines will ultimately merge.
- 41:26I should be able to just think of the internet and it should be just there and I'll be able to access the LLM right in my brain.
- 41:34And you know that is what all these chip implanting in your brain I mean right now they able to put something in your eye like if you blind that allows you to see right
- 41:49So it creates an interface with the nervous system that sends the right messages to your brain so your brain actually can observe images.
- 41:57I mean, that's stunning, right?
- 41:59and now extrapolate that into 100 years from now,
- 42:03assuming progress continues in science,
- 42:05they're going to be pretty amazing things
- 42:07that you're going to be able to implant inside your body
- 42:10to enhance your life.
- 42:12You'll be able to live a lot longer.
- 42:14I don't know if immortality is there,
- 42:16but you'll be able to live a lot longer.
- 42:18You'll be able to grow body parts.
- 42:21We'll be able to grow artificial body parts to replace them.
- 42:24So, I mean, I'm not a science fiction writer,
- 42:27so I can't imagine what it's going to be like in the future.
- 42:28But I think transhumanism is the direction that progress is.
- 42:32Do you think it has any implications as being a threat to the individual?
- 42:38Because part of the sort of movement of technology is basically the connecting of things.
- 42:44If you look at what we've been going through recently, you could argue, I suppose, that transhumanism is quite a collectivist idea.
- 42:53If the end goal is to connect humans.
- 42:56I don't think so because what you're connecting is you're connecting you to knowledge.
- 43:00You're not connecting you to other consciousness who can override yours.
- 43:04Aren't you?
- 43:05No.
- 43:05I mean, think about it.
- 43:06As long as you have free will, as long as you control what you focus on, what information you use, who you interact with, who you connect with, and who you don't.
- 43:15My fear is that once you start implanting chips, if you will, microprocessors into the body, somebody else can hack them.
- 43:26That's what I'm talking about.
- 43:27And take control over them.
- 43:28And that is the danger of collectivism.
- 43:30And yes, and how we build safeguards against that, I don't know.
- 43:34But you can imagine a real dystopian state against science fiction of all of us walking around, but we're all really robots.
- 43:44And we've lost humanity.
- 43:46We've lost what it means to be human.
- 43:50I'm taking a more benevolent stance with regard to transhumanism.
- 43:53I'm assuming that we're free and we don't allow hacking into our chips and that we can control that process.
- 44:04And ultimately, we're not overriding free will.
- 44:06Free will is still there guiding who we interact with, who we don't, what information we access, what we don't.
- 44:14I suppose the way to look at it would be to look at the current – look at the technology you currently use.
- 44:19Are people controlling you through it?
- 44:22Because if they are, and if you believe they are, they will be doing it on a much more intense scale once you're half robot, half...
- 44:30I think they try to, but the point is that those of us who choose to exercise our free will, those of us who choose to remain individuals and to think for ourselves, still have that ability.
- 44:44So, you know, I'm sure people are trying to manipulate me all the time.
- 44:50Certainly our politicians are trying to manipulate me.
- 44:52I'm sure some advertisers are trying to manipulate me.
- 44:55But it doesn't work.
- 44:57It really doesn't.
- 44:58What if your budget is part of the 20% there?
- 45:01What happens?
- 45:02Well, but this is the point.
- 45:03I think everybody has the capacity to resist, everybody.
- 45:07It's an issue of choice.
- 45:08And part of my mission in life, right, is to educate people about that choice and encourage them to embrace it.
- 45:16But look, everybody's choosing against me, right?
- 45:18So they're choosing the opposite.
- 45:20They are choosing to be controlled.
- 45:22They are choosing to be a tribe, which is the ultimate control, right?
- 45:26What's more controlling than to join a tribe and to just follow the tribal leader and to do whatever the tribe tells you you must do?
- 45:33So there's no question I'm losing.
- 45:35And that most of humanity, or certainly a large percentage, but I fear that it's most of humanity today are choosing not to think for themselves, to embrace collectivism, to join the tribe, and not to use the capacity for free will for good.
- 45:53That is why we're heading towards statism.
- 45:55That's why I'm worried about the future.
- 45:57So, look, I hope we don't get transhumanism and statism at the same time.
- 46:05And of course, one of the protections against that is that statism tends to lead to stagnation.
- 46:18You don't get innovation in statist countries.
- 46:21The more statist a country – there was no innovation in the Soviet Union.
- 46:24There was no innovation in China when it was completely totalitarian.
- 46:28The more authoritarian a state is, the less innovative it is.
- 46:33And to get to the point where we're really, you know, this transfusion-minism idea, that's going to take a lot of innovation.
- 46:39That's going to take a lot of really big scientific and technological breakthroughs.
- 46:43And I don't think those can be achieved under statism.
- 46:46You know, I never bought into 1984 because, you know, you need this too much knowledge.
- 46:53And people, even the 20 percent or whatever percent is still holding on to their minds, would have to surrender under those circumstances.
- 47:00And I don't think we're surrendering.
- 47:03And again, innovation.
- 47:04I'm not worried about China as a threat, for example, long term.
- 47:08Because the more authoritarian China becomes, the less innovative it becomes and the poorer it will become.
- 47:14And if it moves towards more freedom, then I don't care, right?
- 47:18It's not a threat.
- 47:19So it's only a threat as it becomes more statist.
- 47:23But as it becomes more statist, it becomes less rich.
- 47:25um it's it it's pretty easy to argue though that the the the tech innovation we see now
- 47:33is certainly empowering for authoritarians in the sense that for example it take take
- 47:39soviet russia um you in order to enforce communism you needed a lot of people really
- 47:47you know it was a lot you know and in a way you could say that it collapses under the weight of
- 47:51not actually being able to find enough people.
- 47:54What tech does is it does away with that aspect,
- 47:58and it allows you to enforce things with algorithms.
- 48:01And that is scalable infinitely, which is weird.
- 48:05Absolutely, and scary.
- 48:07But think about it.
- 48:08I mean, China today has the technology
- 48:10to run a completely totalitarian state.
- 48:14It has facial recognition.
- 48:16It monitors everything that happens on the web.
- 48:18It does all these things.
- 48:20And yet, in spite of it being very authoritarian, it's not totalitarian.
- 48:24It's not like the Soviet Union.
- 48:25It doesn't try to run everybody's lives in the way the Soviet Union did.
- 48:29And there's a reason for that, because I think they fear the people.
- 48:33So technology does two things.
- 48:34On the one hand, it gives the authorities this incredibly tool to monitor us.
- 48:39But it also gives us a tool, a tool to realize there's more to life, in spite of the fact
- 48:44that the internet is censored in China, they all get through, right?
- 48:48VPNs and then China finds a way to control the VPNs and then they get more sophisticated
- 48:54VPNs and they find around.
- 48:55I mean, I see people from China on Facebook and on YouTube, all the things that are banned
- 48:59in China and yet here they are, they appear on.
- 49:02So what they discover when they have those tools, when they get Netflix or they get YouTube
- 49:08or whatever, is there's a whole world out there that doesn't play by the rules of the
- 49:11Chinese government.
- 49:13And then those kids are like, wait a minute, why don't we have those freedoms?
- 49:18Why can't we?
- 49:19So there's a limit, right?
- 49:21And so the more technology you have, yes, it enables the central government, but it also
- 49:25enables the people, right?
- 49:27It's much easier to fight them.
- 49:29It's much easier to hack them.
- 49:30It's much easier to do stuff without them noticing.
- 49:33If I'm sophisticated, I shield myself from them.
- 49:36I don't know.
- 49:37I can use crypto to move money around where the government can't see it.
- 49:41And so technology gives them a tool, but it also gives us a tool, a tool to fight back.
- 49:46and I think at the end of the day technology will I mean it might be at the
- 49:52end of the day it might be a long time from now but at the end of the day
- 49:54technology gives us more power than them it take a while for that to be realized Yeah I probably agree with that The problem would be that if the majority of people let say 80 are happy to live within that very constrictive environment that makes it very hard for the 20 in a new way
- 50:16I mean, take China, for example.
- 50:18the social credit system is a good example because you don't control people by literally
- 50:23banging on their door and telling them not to do something. You just take away their ability to do
- 50:27things. Now, for the 20%, that makes life very difficult because unless you want to live out in
- 50:35the woods like a mountain man and not interact with society. You see, they won't do that to 20%
- 50:39of the population. If they did, they'd have a revolution. Revolutions are never started by the
- 50:4280%, right? They're started always by a minority. It's always a minority, almost always.
- 50:48And, you know, they have to be, and the Chinese government knows this, they have to be very careful on how they use this social scoring system.
- 50:58If they overdo it, they face a rebellion.
- 51:02And this is not a rebellion of ignorant idiots.
- 51:05This is a rebellion of techies who are very internet savvy, who are very technology savvy, who are young people who are of the world.
- 51:13You know, Chinese travel, they see the world.
- 51:16So it's not like the Soviet Union where you weren't allowed to leave.
- 51:19That's another thing that China can't afford to do is lock their people up.
- 51:22They tried.
- 51:24And by, what was it, winter of 2022, they had to let go because people were going out the streets, even in China.
- 51:32And they were protesting and they got scared.
- 51:34The Chinese government got scared.
- 51:36So there is a limit.
- 51:39All I'm saying is, and I don't know what the balance is and I don't know how it's going to go in China ultimately,
- 51:43is that the technology in and of itself,
- 51:47yes, it can be used by the authoritarians to clamp down on us,
- 51:50but it can obviously be used by us to evade the authorities.
- 51:55And I think a lot of people in China do that,
- 51:57and that's how they can continue.
- 51:59And there's still thriving entrepreneurs there,
- 52:02and there's still people who do okay in China in spite of that.
- 52:05And look, I wish there were 20% of the population who wanted freedom,
- 52:10as I understand it.
- 52:11I mean, I think we'd win easily if that was the case.
- 52:13I mean, my fear is there's only 2%, 3% of the population that actually wants real freedom.
- 52:19I mean, people want a little bit more, a little bit less.
- 52:21But real individualists, real people striving towards their own personal happiness who really value reason and value themselves, it's just that's a small number and it's shrinking.
- 52:35And that's what scares me, right?
- 52:37So what's your best practice strategy then to be free in that sense? I mean, we study that here every year constantly, and there's a spectrum of ways that people try to live freedom, not the ideas of freedom.
- 52:53Well, first I think the first step to take is, you know, wherever you live, is to figure out what your values are.
- 53:02What is really important to you as a human being, right?
- 53:05What makes you – what is going to lead you towards happiness?
- 53:07Now, make sure those are not just random, that they are consistent with kind of life and human rationality.
- 53:13But create a hierarchy of values.
- 53:15So, for example, I hate paying taxes.
- 53:20But I also hate bad weather.
- 53:21I hate the cold, right?
- 53:22I couldn't live in England.
- 53:25Right.
- 53:25Okay, so if the only, you know, so I have to trade off, let's say there's a country in the north.
- 53:30I don't know, we saw somebody who's got a seas thing, you know, in the North Sea, right?
- 53:37Oh, the sea land.
- 53:38Sea land.
- 53:38Am I willing to live in sea land and not pay taxes, but have to live in sea?
- 53:43Obviously not, right?
- 53:45So the first thing you want to do, I mean, for me, right, I understand that some people do and fine,
- 53:50But I think it's a very narrow view of life to live that way.
- 53:56There are real values in civilization, and we shouldn't diminish those, and we should really think about what they are.
- 54:02So create a hierarchy of values.
- 54:04What's most important to you and what's least important to you?
- 54:06And then try to achieve those values.
- 54:12Now, the world will not allow you to achieve all of them, and you'll find a lot of tradeoffs.
- 54:17But really consciously, you know, think about what those trees are for.
- 54:20So I grew up in Israel.
- 54:22You know, I was in Israel until I was 26.
- 54:27But I realized pretty soon after reading Ayn Rand that I didn't really want to live in Israel, right?
- 54:34Israel was small, very collectivistic in those days, quite socialist, and just very collectivistic and tribal.
- 54:41And I said, okay.
- 54:43So I sat down in probably my early 20s and said, okay, where would I want to live?
- 54:50Like what's going to be the best place in the world for me to live?
- 54:53And in those days, and I think to some extent still today, but certainly in those days, it was the United States.
- 54:59Not just because politically it was relatively free and economically taxes were relatively low, but also because it's big and there's a lot of opportunities and it's exciting and there's stuff going on.
- 55:10Like if you're in tech, you want to be in Silicon Valley, right?
- 55:13So you need to think, okay, so where do I want to live?
- 55:18And maybe it turns out that you want to live in Andorra or you want to live in Prosperous or somewhere like that.
- 55:26But really figure that out.
- 55:28You have to figure it out, particularly when you're young and you're trying to establish a career.
- 55:33Do you really want to isolate yourself or do you want to be where the excitement and the growth is?
- 55:38and then strive towards that.
- 55:42So create a hierarchy of values,
- 55:45make sure those values are the best that they can be, right?
- 55:49They are really going to lead to a flourishing life
- 55:51and then go achieve them.
- 55:54And when you discover a conflict,
- 55:56when you discover a situation
- 55:57where it's hard to achieve them,
- 55:59then either find ways around it.
- 56:01Like how am I going to get to America, right?
- 56:03I wasn't an American citizen.
- 56:04So I went to graduate school
- 56:07because I figured if I go to school in America, I can easily.
- 56:10And it worked out, right?
- 56:10So I got an MBA, I got a PhD,
- 56:13and ultimately that was my path to becoming an American citizen.
- 56:17It took a long time, but I made it.
- 56:20You know, it's one of the reasons I have no problem,
- 56:24and I know people are going to hate this,
- 56:25but I have no problem with illegal immigrants into America,
- 56:29people coming in illegally.
- 56:31Their hierarchy of values dictated they want to live in a freer place.
- 56:34They grew up in some slum in Guatemala,
- 56:37where there are constant gang wars.
- 56:41And if they ever have kids or raising their kids,
- 56:45their kids might get involved in gangs and drugs and a short life.
- 56:49And there's this country that offers real opportunities,
- 56:52not opportunities because they get handouts,
- 56:54but opportunities because you can get a job and you can be left alone
- 56:57and you can create a real life for yourself.
- 56:59And there's no way to get there legally.
- 57:02Like America has no visa program for poor Guatemalans.
- 57:05So what are you going to do?
- 57:07I mean, to me, a pregnant woman struggling through the desert on a trek of thousands of miles, crossing the desert into America.
- 57:19So her child is born in America.
- 57:21Wow, she should get like a medal.
- 57:26What is more heroic than that?
- 57:28She takes her life seriously.
- 57:29She takes the life of her child seriously.
- 57:31Has she violated anybody's rights?
- 57:33No, she's broken the law.
- 57:35So what?
- 57:36I speed all the time.
- 57:37I break the law.
- 57:38She didn't violate anybody's rights.
- 57:39She didn't take anybody's property.
- 57:41She didn't take anything from anybody.
- 57:42And for the rest of her life, she's going to work because she's an illegal immigrant.
- 57:46She can't get welfare.
- 57:47So she's going to have to work.
- 57:48So she's going to work.
- 57:50And that's great.
- 57:51So to me, the striving towards your personal success, striving towards your personal values,
- 57:57that's what it's all about.
- 57:59You know, that's what being alive means.
- 58:02So, you know, for each one of us, we have to figure out what our values are, figure out
- 58:10what's most important to us and go get it.
- 58:12And if that means you know moving to a seastead or moving to California or moving away from California you know it depends It depends on your circumstances You know I lived in California for many years
- 58:26And at some point, I reached a point in my life where I could afford to go anywhere I wanted.
- 58:33Well, not afford financially, but afford in terms of time.
- 58:35My kids were out of the house and I could live anywhere I wanted.
- 58:38I was fed up with paying the kind of taxes that California paid.
- 58:42And, you know, so I figured out a solution.
- 58:44And it turns out that if you go to Puerto Rico, you don't pay a lot of taxes.
- 58:48So I went.
- 58:49I couldn't have done that 10 years earlier because I wouldn't want to raise my kids in
- 58:53Puerto Rico.
- 58:55And you have to take into account your circumstances, your values, and find the best combination
- 59:01at any given point in time and be willing.
- 59:03And this is something people don't do.
- 59:05People drift in life.
- 59:06You've got to constantly ask the question, am I doing the best that I can do?
- 59:10Am I doing the best that I can do in life?
- 59:12Am I living in the best place that I can live?
- 59:14Am I pursuing the best career that I can pursue?
- 59:18Am I in the best relationship that I can?
- 59:24People get divorced, and I think that's a good thing because they suddenly realize, oh, I'm not in the best relationship I could have.
- 59:30Maybe there's something better out there for me.
- 59:31So they change.
- 59:32Change is good.
- 59:33Change should be embraced.
- 59:35You should constantly be thinking about how can I live the best life that I can live and what changes do I need to make in order to achieve that?
- 59:42I'm you're literally channeling the spirit of Ayn Rand in the room.
- 59:51Well, I was going to say then I've completely forgotten now.
- 59:55Yeah, basically hierarchy of hierarchy of values.
- 59:59And also, I think one of the things I don't know whether you mentioned it, I didn't hear it was to be realistic.
- 1:00:04because i mean but it's important because um i think it's it's quite debilitating to think about
- 1:00:13what you want but not be able to get it as in a utopian sort of i i mean i i struggle with this
- 1:00:20myself sometimes like and i i've been on a journey of acceptance of the reality as it is basically
- 1:00:26you know i love the uk i hate the government and the tax system but my children love where we live
- 1:00:33And when I put all these down on paper, I say, yes, I am paying for this.
- 1:00:40This is what this costs to me.
- 1:00:43And I'm willing to pay it.
- 1:00:44So this is what I said about trade-offs.
- 1:00:46These are trade-offs we shouldn't have to make.
- 1:00:49In a free society, we wouldn't be making them.
- 1:00:52But in the mixed world that we live in, you've got to make trade-offs.
- 1:00:57Now, if your kids were going to be drafted and the UK was about to launch into a war, I don't know, somewhere in the planet, and your kids might go have to forced into some fight or something, you might reconsider.
- 1:01:13They crossed the line.
- 1:01:14The tradeoff is not worth it anymore.
- 1:01:16And now you shift or taxes go up to 90% or something.
- 1:01:19So you're constantly evaluating what do I get from living in a particular place versus what is the cost to me?
- 1:01:26Again, these are trade-offs we shouldn't have to make.
- 1:01:28In a rational, free world, there are no trade-offs.
- 1:01:31You're left alone.
- 1:01:33You live the kind of life you want to live.
- 1:01:36Now, there's always, in a sense, trade-off, in a sense that I could be doing this with
- 1:01:39my time versus that.
- 1:01:41But there wouldn't be these coercive trade-offs.
- 1:01:43They wouldn't be, OK, I have to put up with coercion.
- 1:01:46I have to put up with force.
- 1:01:47I have to put up with violence so I can live a reasonable life.
- 1:01:50That is a horrible trade-off.
- 1:01:53But that's reality that we live in.
- 1:01:56You should fight that reality intellectually,
- 1:01:59but to fight it every day emotionally will drain you and crush you.
- 1:02:03At some point, you have to accept this is the world.
- 1:02:07This is the reality.
- 1:02:08I'm not going to change it overnight.
- 1:02:11I maybe can fight for long-term change,
- 1:02:13but it's a slow, lengthy process.
- 1:02:17And I'm going to accept it.
- 1:02:21Are you more of a stay in change or a move to a new frontier kind of person?
- 1:02:27I mean, given how many times I've moved in my life, I would say, you know, I'm I'm I'm I'm a bit of both.
- 1:02:34Right. So I like change and I think I embrace change and I think change is good.
- 1:02:40But again, it depends. You know, you're going to change less when you have kids.
- 1:02:44I think I think it makes it much more difficult when you have children to to to make radical changes.
- 1:02:49but you never want to be, you never want to stagnate. You never want to stagnate in any
- 1:02:56aspect of your life. So you always want to be on the lookout for stagnation. You always want to
- 1:03:01look out for, I'm doing the same thing I did yesterday, exactly the same thing. Nothing's
- 1:03:05changing. Nothing's getting better. I could be doing better. How can I do better? Let's go do
- 1:03:10better. And part of that is geography. But I think most of it is not geography. Most of it is
- 1:03:15attitude. Most of it is how you live your life. Geography, political situation, it's not that big
- 1:03:22of a difference between the various countries, particularly in, let's say, in the Western world.
- 1:03:27They're all statist of various degrees, but they're all statist. So, you know, living in the UK,
- 1:03:33living in the US, the difference is marginal. Again, I think there are more opportunities in
- 1:03:38the U.S., so that's why I preferred it. But so much of the focus needs to be, I think, in figuring
- 1:03:46out what your personal values are and how to achieve them and how to pursue them in this mixed
- 1:03:52up, crazy, horrible, in many ways, world. And figure out, again, what's important to you and
- 1:03:57what's not, and the hierarchy. Weather, for example, plays a big role in my hierarchy of
- 1:04:03where I'm going to live.
- 1:04:05My wife and I will not live in a cold place.
- 1:04:08So that kind of limits where we're going to move to.
- 1:04:13There's certain places I won't go to or won't live in.
- 1:04:17But that's just one consideration.
- 1:04:18There are lots of considerations you have to constantly be thinking about.
- 1:04:23Do you think the statist world will decline?
- 1:04:27Do you think, I mean, we're on a trajectory at Pierce,
- 1:04:30and it's obvious the direction it's going in,
- 1:04:34but do you think it's like a pendulum?
- 1:04:37Does it decline at some point?
- 1:04:40You mean statism declined?
- 1:04:42Yes.
- 1:04:43Just the statist worldview.
- 1:04:44I don't think it's a pendulum.
- 1:04:46I mean, you can go into a period of stagnation
- 1:04:50that could last a very long time.
- 1:04:53And you could go into just cultural decline
- 1:04:55that can last a very long time.
- 1:04:56In the West, we've had a dark ages with the fall of Rome.
- 1:05:00The more I read about history, the more I see civilizations in different parts of the world, real civilizations, real achievements, then they decline and disappear and they're gone.
- 1:05:09And it's not even that somebody came and killed them all.
- 1:05:12It's just decline because the ideas ran, you know, they just couldn't live up to them.
- 1:05:19So there's nothing inevitable.
- 1:05:23Individuals, I mean, I really do believe individuals have free will and we shape the world and the culture in which we live.
- 1:05:27I do think we're heading towards an era of stagnation.
- 1:05:32I think we're already in it to a large extent.
- 1:05:34And look at Europe.
- 1:05:34Europe is barely growing economically.
- 1:05:37I think the rest of the world is struggling.
- 1:05:39You know, maybe Millet and Argentina are the only bright spot out there in terms of heading in the right direction.
- 1:05:43Everybody else is heading in the wrong direction.
- 1:05:46And so we're heading in towards a period of stagnation.
- 1:05:49Now, I think, I really believe freedom wins out in the end.
- 1:05:53Not because it's a pendulum, but because I think the good ideas win.
- 1:05:56that the truth wins out over the long span of history.
- 1:06:01It could be hundreds of years.
- 1:06:02It could be 1,000 years.
- 1:06:03I don't know.
- 1:06:04But in the end, human beings will gravitate towards the truth.
- 1:06:08They will gravitate towards good ideas.
- 1:06:11In a sense, we're too young of a species for freedom.
- 1:06:1799.9% of human history, 99.99%, I think, of human history
- 1:06:22has been authoritarian and totalitarian.
- 1:06:24We've lived in tribes.
- 1:06:25We've lived in monarchies.
- 1:06:27We've lived in every form of authoritarian regimes possible.
- 1:06:32And then we've got this glimpse for the last 200 years of a little bit of freedom, right?
- 1:06:36And not even the whole world, just a part of the world.
- 1:06:39This is new. It's an exception. We're going to have to experiment with it. People are going to
- 1:06:43have to learn what works and what doesn't. They might have to go through a decline and give up
- 1:06:49some of that freedom before they realize how valuable it is. I don't know. But in the end
- 1:06:54of the day, I think that if we hold on to these ideas, if we sustain them, if we keep talking
- 1:07:01about them, if we teach them, if we preserve them, they will win.
- 1:07:05So you think there is a final, there is a win.
- 1:07:09I've never considered there to be an end to this.
- 1:07:13I've always considered it a push and a pull.
- 1:07:15No, I think there's a win.
- 1:07:17The win is not the end in the sense that you're always going to have to be vigilant.
- 1:07:21I mean, vigilance for liberty never ends, right?
- 1:07:24You're always going to have to remind people why freedom is a good thing and why they shouldn't be tempted by these bad ideas.
- 1:07:29It'll be a lot easier once they internalize the good ideas and the good ideas are dominating the intellectual space.
- 1:07:36That has never happened in human history.
- 1:07:38We got close in the Enlightenment, but the Enlightenment was too young and too flawed and too mixed up and philosophically.
- 1:07:48But I do think there's an end.
- 1:07:50I do think there's a – it's not a utopia, but there's a state in which we will be free or at least a significant number of us will be free.
- 1:07:58Maybe it turns out to be Mars.
- 1:07:59I don't know.
- 1:08:01Maybe it turns out to be seasteading.
- 1:08:02I doubt it.
- 1:08:03Just because the powers to be, I mean, this is my view of a lot of these projects, if I can be negative about them for a minute.
- 1:08:10Absolutely.
- 1:08:12The more successful they are, the more the powers to be won't allow them to succeed further.
- 1:08:20So imagine you establish a free city in the middle of the ocean.
- 1:08:25It doesn't rely on any government.
- 1:08:27It hasn't got a charter from anybody.
- 1:08:29It's a completely free city.
- 1:08:30And you have free banking on the city.
- 1:08:32And the free banking means total privacy, no money laundering laws, complete privacy.
- 1:08:39How long do you think the United States will allow you to do that?
- 1:08:42How long before the Navy shows up and shuts you down?
- 1:08:45I think it's a matter of hours.
- 1:08:48Well, it depends.
- 1:08:49I mean, maritime law is very, very old and ancient.
- 1:08:52I mean, right now, we're talking about maritime law.
- 1:08:55Right now, the United States is blowing up boats off the coast of Venezuela and Colombia.
- 1:09:02There's no maritime law in the world that justifies what's going on right now.
- 1:09:07They're killing people without even presenting evidence.
- 1:09:12There's no terrorist list of most wanted people.
- 1:09:15We don't know who's being killed.
- 1:09:17Nobody's being named.
- 1:09:18They're just blowing up stuff in the middle of the sea.
- 1:09:20You think the United States Navy gives one iota?
- 1:09:23for a large floating city though.
- 1:09:26I think maybe that would become...
- 1:09:28What about you just surrounded
- 1:09:30and don't allow any supplies in
- 1:09:32until they change their laws about banking?
- 1:09:35I would still think there would be a scale issue there.
- 1:09:38If it was a large settlement, I think...
- 1:09:40I think you're overly optimistic
- 1:09:44and you don't realize how seriously bad these people are.
- 1:09:48But the thing about, you know, Seasteaders,
- 1:09:52for example is they can very much live at the fringes even in a very large way that and they
- 1:09:57living at the fringes is is part of the process sometimes i get i get i get that if you want to
- 1:10:03live in the fringes yes you can do it i'm saying if you establish a real place which has banking
- 1:10:09and has yeah i'm talking about that i mean that as well it you know i mean there's parts of the
- 1:10:14ocean that they will shut it down in an instant the united states navy can reach any part of the
- 1:10:19ocean they want to. Yes, but why would
- 1:10:21they? Why would the US Navy go
- 1:10:23to the middle? There's a, well, I forget what that, because
- 1:10:25you're money laundering. I mean, the United States
- 1:10:27today... Yeah, but the money laundering is happening all over the world
- 1:10:29already. Yeah, and they try to shut it down. The United States
- 1:10:31today has... Not in China, though.
- 1:10:33Has troops in 120 different countries.
- 1:10:35But yeah, there's a lot of places they don't have troops.
- 1:10:38But primarily places
- 1:10:39like China, where they would fight them.
- 1:10:41I suspect that there is
- 1:10:43a limit to how much
- 1:10:44control over
- 1:10:47the whole planet one entity requires?
- 1:10:51Well it not in the United States right China doesn have an incentive for you to have something where Chinese citizens can use it in order to get their money out of China Which we already have as well Yeah I mean we have that system But they want to clamp down as much as they can
- 1:11:04Yeah, and they can't. They try, but it doesn't work. People send Bitcoin in and out of China
- 1:11:09constantly. Sure. But it's constantly a battle, and it will continue to constantly be a battle.
- 1:11:15My point is that you better be prepared for a battle. And when there's a physical location,
- 1:11:21then it's much easier.
- 1:11:24One of the reasons you can get Bitcoin in and out
- 1:11:26because it has no physical locale.
- 1:11:30A city, a state, a free city, a free state
- 1:11:34has a physical location
- 1:11:36and it better be ready to defend itself.
- 1:11:39No, I agree.
- 1:11:40There is no perfect way to do this.
- 1:11:43Arguably though, seasteading,
- 1:11:44if you're talking about the future version of it,
- 1:11:47which are large floating cities,
- 1:11:48They are one of the most perfect manifestations of the idea because they can actually move.
- 1:11:54And they will also be a precursor to intergalactic travel in some point.
- 1:12:01I mean, that's the advantage of intergalactic travel, right?
- 1:12:03Yeah.
- 1:12:03You know, it's very hard for the U.S. Navy to get to Mars.
- 1:12:08So the isolation is a huge advantage in creating something new in other planets.
- 1:12:14Yeah, I mean, I'm excited about that.
- 1:12:17I'm less excited about the prospects for that on Earth because I think it's all accessible versus, you know.
- 1:12:25But we're on a journey here.
- 1:12:27I mean, like you say, in your hierarchy of needs, how much do you want freedom?
- 1:12:32Value, sorry.
- 1:12:32How much do you want your freedom?
- 1:12:34Because really the UN has made a claim on outer space pretty much.
- 1:12:38There's a 1960s agreement.
- 1:12:40Go enforce it.
- 1:12:41Right, exactly.
- 1:12:42When Elon gets to Mars, if he puts the labor in, that's his property.
- 1:12:47It's obvious because no one's going to be able to stop him.
- 1:12:51Yes, but I also think that Elon is probably smart enough, you know, to build a nuke on Mars, to build the capacity to defend himself.
- 1:13:01Right?
- 1:13:01Because at the end of the day, you better be able to defend yourself physically in the physical world.
- 1:13:06You can live digitally and that's fine.
- 1:13:09But at the end of the day, we eat and live and have sex in the physical world.
- 1:13:13And that can be, you know, somebody can shoot you in the physical world.
- 1:13:17You better be able to defend yourself in the physical world.
- 1:13:19And I would urge anybody seeking freedom to think about self-defense as an aspect of freedom.
- 1:13:26There's no freedom if you can't defend yourself.
- 1:13:29So I hope Elon in his plan for an independent whatever in Mars is thinking about what if, you know,
- 1:13:36the US spaceship shows up and tries to take us over.
- 1:13:40How do we protect ourselves?
- 1:13:42And my assumption is he's smart enough.
- 1:13:45Or other people, you know, this might not be in his lifetime.
- 1:13:48Other people think about, yes, we need, you know,
- 1:13:50if you read science fiction, it's part of the way they conceive
- 1:13:55about, you know, colonies on other planets.
- 1:14:00Sure.
- 1:14:00I mean, it's also a question of frontiers, you know.
- 1:14:04frontiers have always been the fringe that people look for freedom in and we don't have many left
- 1:14:10the sea is currently still a frontier frontiers historically not anymore for a variety of reasons
- 1:14:15but historically have always been violent of course yeah yeah because you have to protect yourself but
- 1:14:21when they're vast yes and the bigger they are the better you better and you better be able to defend
- 1:14:26yourself wherever you are well i agree with that and i i'm i'm being a bit facetious but the the i
- 1:14:31I mean, because we talk about this a lot in our movement, and we're going through a moderately,
- 1:14:38I mean, it's a soft version of that right now in Prospera.
- 1:14:41You know, the socialists are coming after the free city.
- 1:14:45And actually what we're seeing is relatively positive.
- 1:14:48They are cowering under, you know, you can protect a physical place with more than just guns.
- 1:14:54You've got legal protections, you've got community protections,
- 1:14:56You've got economic incentive protections, which are all part of your plan to secure a place.
- 1:15:02And they, in Prospero, we're pleasantly surprised to see the very authoritarian end of the spectrum
- 1:15:09try and shut something down and then not do it And not doing it yeah so yeah i mean you know i positive about it anyway but i mean anyway i i gonna i gonna wrap it up i think let end on a
- 1:15:23positive note not on a free cities are all doomed to be killed uh or to be doomed to be attacked the
- 1:15:28other thing is of course i don't think the government's going to be attacking elon in
- 1:15:31space it's going to be another corporation i don't think the government will make it to mars
- 1:15:35I mean, who knows? Yeah. I mean, governments are very good at confiscating technology and taking it over. But yes, it might be another corporation. It might be another entity.
- 1:15:45But –
- 1:15:45What would I –
- 1:15:46And, you know, generally, look, at the end of the day, if the world is heading towards more statism, then the world will become more violent, not less.
- 1:15:57And if the world's heading towards more freedom, then there'll be a lot of opportunities to manifest that freedom in a variety of different ways politically.
- 1:16:04if we're heading in that direction.
- 1:16:06I hope we are.
- 1:16:07But I worry that as we head towards more statism,
- 1:16:11as, you know, again, I look at Donald Trump right now
- 1:16:15blowing ships out of the water in the Caribbean Sea
- 1:16:18and nobody's saying anything about it pretty much.
- 1:16:21And people still loving Donald Trump
- 1:16:23and thinking he was God's gift to America.
- 1:16:25And he's just killing people.
- 1:16:28And, you know, everybody just shrugs and moves on.
- 1:16:31That is scary level authoritarianism.
- 1:16:34What do you think Ayn's opinion of this movement would be then, the Free Cities kind of ecosystem?
- 1:16:43I mean, she would argue that it will succeed to the extent that it's based on a proper philosophical foundation.
- 1:16:50And she would worry that it's not, which was her worry for much of the free market movement.
- 1:16:56She worried that it did not ground itself in the proper philosophical foundation and therefore was doomed to fail.
- 1:17:03and so far she's been proven right
- 1:17:05in a sense that since she died
- 1:17:08things have become worse, not better
- 1:17:10and I think she predicted that
- 1:17:12so she would advocate
- 1:17:15A, she'd advocate don't give up on civilization
- 1:17:19that is, yes, you can always run away
- 1:17:21to some desert island and live over there
- 1:17:24and particularly if you don't stick your head up too much
- 1:17:27and rattle the cages
- 1:17:29you can live there by yourself
- 1:17:31but is that a life, right?
- 1:17:32Is that a full life that you could live in a property?
- 1:17:35She loved New York, right?
- 1:17:37And she loved New York in spite of all the flaws in the city because it was civilization.
- 1:17:42It was exciting that real stuff was going on there.
- 1:17:46And so she would argue don't give up on civilization.
- 1:17:49Let's fight, continue the struggle for freedom, but the struggle for freedom within civilization.
- 1:17:55And the struggle ultimately is not political.
- 1:17:58The struggle ultimately is philosophical.
- 1:17:59It's ultimately ideological.
- 1:18:01Let's teach people the value of freedom.
- 1:18:03Let's teach them the value of their own lives.
- 1:18:06Let's teach them to be self-interested, to want to be happy, and then make the connection between happiness and freedom.
- 1:18:14You cannot be happy unless you're at least somewhat free.
- 1:18:17And the freer you are, the more the possibilities regarding happiness only expand.
- 1:18:21so so you know ultimately freedom will come about when people reject the morality of sacrifice the
- 1:18:34morality of altruism you know freedom will come about when people embrace reason freedom will come
- 1:18:40about when people start valuing their own lives above all else yeah thank you I wonder if I was
- 1:18:47just thinking i wonder if iron would live in new york right now you know look i know a lot of people
- 1:18:54who live in new york right now and in new york and i visit new york quite frequently and new york
- 1:18:59was horrible during covid and and to a large extent people were saying new york will never
- 1:19:03recover and new york's thriving you know new york's doing phenomenally well crime rates are down
- 1:19:09uh you know people are busy it's it's just as energetic and exciting as it's always been
- 1:19:15And there's still a great opera house there, and there's still a great museum there.
- 1:19:19And there's still, if you're in finance, there's no better jobs in the world that you can get
- 1:19:24in New York.
- 1:19:25Now if Mamdani wins New York will decline for a period But my guess is New York will come back Crime rates will go up under Momdani because you shrink the police and it be dirtier and it be all of that But there there a bit of
- 1:19:38a pendulum. I do think there's a bit of a pendulum. But we tend to be way too down on the world.
- 1:19:47I want to live free. And again, I live in Puerto Rico for a variety of reasons and
- 1:19:51many of them have to do with taxes. But when I go to New York, I'm energized. I mean, it's still
- 1:19:57and energetic place.
- 1:19:59I'm a finance guy, and if you want to do finance,
- 1:20:02there's no better place in the world to be
- 1:20:04than in New York City.
- 1:20:06They're changing the world.
- 1:20:08And Silicon Valley is in California.
- 1:20:11California is horrible.
- 1:20:12It's got high taxes and regulations and controls
- 1:20:14and a bunch of leftists.
- 1:20:16And yet, if you want to start a company,
- 1:20:19and there's no more, right now in AI,
- 1:20:22we talked about AI, if you want to start,
- 1:20:24if you get into AI, San Francisco's the place
- 1:20:27Forget about the homeless.
- 1:20:28Forget about all that.
- 1:20:30You're going to be in San Francisco, and you're going to do really well in San Francisco,
- 1:20:34and it's an exciting, energetic place.
- 1:20:37So, again, we tend to over-focus on the negative, and there's a lot of positives in the world.
- 1:20:47And if you are ambitious and if you want to do something with your life, there's still
- 1:20:53plenty of places where you can do that, plenty of opportunities for you to do that. Don't give up
- 1:20:58on your life because you're paying high taxes. There's still, I mean, you should be pissed off
- 1:21:03you're paying high taxes and you should try to minimize them. But at the same time, you want to
- 1:21:08maximize your life. And the question is, how do you maximize your life? And, you know, there are
- 1:21:14lots of ways and lots of places you can do that in. The hierarchy of values. I'm taking that one
- 1:21:20away with me. I love the way that's framed. And I agree because I do fall into that. I fall into
- 1:21:25that trap myself. And that's an Ayn Rand, you know, that's an Ayn Rand concept. I mean, it's
- 1:21:29very fundamental to philosophy is that to be self-interested, to live a moral life,
- 1:21:36you've got to gather. And at the top of the hierarchy, the most important values are the
- 1:21:39abstract values, the moral values. But then you start breaking down to family and the place you
- 1:21:45live and your career and the art you like and how you want to spend your time.
- 1:21:51And, you know, the car, you know, if you really want a nice car, you know, you put in a hierarchy
- 1:21:56and car hopefully is relatively low and some other things are higher up.
- 1:22:00But we all are different.
- 1:22:02So we're all going to have different, when it comes to the concretes of life, beyond
- 1:22:06the abstract moral values, we're all going to have different hierarchies of values.
- 1:22:10And that's what should guide my life.
- 1:22:12you know we shouldn't
- 1:22:15too many people I think
- 1:22:17in this world that we were just at a conference
- 1:22:20of too many people have this
- 1:22:22abstraction of freedom and that
- 1:22:24is all they care about and that's
- 1:22:25what they go for and
- 1:22:27they forget that life is
- 1:22:29you know there's a lot to life
- 1:22:32and
- 1:22:34certainly you don't want to live in
- 1:22:35an unfree place
- 1:22:37but since
- 1:22:40we don't have a completely free place
- 1:22:41a suddenly completely free place with all the attributes of civilization,
- 1:22:46you've got to think about all the trade-offs.
- 1:22:49And in that sense, you've got to really develop higher-care values
- 1:22:52and live by it.
- 1:22:55Wonderful.
- 1:22:56Aaron, thank you very much indeed.
- 1:22:57Spending a little bit of time off stage, I really enjoyed your talk.
- 1:23:01Thank you.
- 1:23:01And now I just like a lovely thanks for the one-to-one.
- 1:23:05I feel like it was a bit of a pep talk, which is really good.
- 1:23:08And I hope that listeners get a bit.
- 1:23:10I hope that someone else tunes into it as well,
- 1:23:13because sometimes you need people to lay it out in a simple way like that.
- 1:23:17I think a lot of us do fall into the trap of visualizing the freedom,
- 1:23:23and then when we don't see it in our lives, berating it.
- 1:23:27Super frustrating.
- 1:23:28Yeah.
- 1:23:28But anyway, many, many thanks indeed, and I hope to see you another time.
- 1:23:32Sure.
- 1:23:40Thank you.