Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De'ah 292:4-8. Shiluach HaKen: How To Send Away the Mother and Acquire the Egg or Chick. By Rav David Genish

Transcript

Yoreh De'ah 292:4-8. Shiluach HaKen: How To Send Away the Mother and Acquire the Egg or Chick. By Rav David Genish · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:00
  All right, we were doing Shiloh. I can at the end we mentioned in
• 0:03
  the last year the idea that we tried to do every mitzvah that
• 0:06
  were able to do tariag mitzvahs. Obviously we know we can't be
• 0:09
  Makaiam every single mitzvah, but someone seemed to have asked
• 0:12
  what about doing it gets should I divorce my wife?
• 0:15
  Now the truth is, I'll be honest with you, of Kaim Kanievski was
• 0:18
  known for being extremely mockery about this.
• 0:20
  He went out of his way to be able to be Mckheim every Mitzer
• 0:22
  that he could, his grandfather, his grandchildren, I heard them
• 0:25
  by the Hespedia mentioning many, many different mitzvahs that he
• 0:28
  did. So one time one of the
• 0:29
  grandchildren went to a crime and they said and Saba, why
• 0:34
  don't you remember Kheim, the mitzvah of Matsu Gushasa, You'll
• 0:36
  get 2 mitzvahs. You can divorce EMA Isafta, you
• 0:39
  can divorce after and you can be Matsu Gushasa.
• 0:41
  You could take her back. You could take her back.
• 0:44
  They were known for having an incredible relationship when she
• 0:46
  passed away, he was too broken. He actually was not functional
• 0:49
  for for a little while. And so he what did he respond?
• 0:52
  You know, Klein was a very serious guy, but he was very
• 0:54
  witty. He said, I'm afraid that Safta
• 0:56
  won't want me back again. He's afraid of Safta won't be
• 0:59
  back. And so he didn't do but the idea
• 1:01
  behind it is as we know that we try to do the best miss so we
• 1:04
  can't we can't do anything. We're not go haunt him.
• 1:05
  So we can't even cut him. Some women and misses that men
• 1:07
  don't have men and men to the women don't have but you try to
• 1:10
  do the best that you can muscle the Rama says after Yom Kippur
• 1:16
  that you're supposed to go immediately and try to do the
• 1:18
  mitzvah of Suka. You're supposed to do the
• 1:21
  mitzvah of suka. I don't know about you, but I
• 1:23
  want to Yom Kippur. I cannot pick up a board.
• 1:25
  I don't know. It's just that it's that's not
• 1:26
  my thing, but I have kids to the solutions for me, but it's a
• 1:29
  little bit hard thing. So I do the other kum of the
• 1:32
  mitzvah, which brought in the Misha bro over there and that is
• 1:34
  to learn the halakhas of suka by learning the halakhas of Suka,
• 1:38
  you can actually also be Makai and Kabhiyah, the mitzvah of
• 1:40
  suka. So they say that also with the
• 1:42
  mitzvah, just by learning it like we're doing right now, even
• 1:45
  if you don't actually get the mitzvah, you're able to be
• 1:47
  Makayim the mitzvah. So if someone asks, should I be
• 1:49
  Makayima get with my wife, I think they might say something
• 1:52
  about the Shalom bais. I'm not sure.
• 1:53
  But anyways, if the person says I should do that.
• 1:55
  So the answer is you should learn the halakhs of Gitin or
• 1:58
  maybe learn mesakahs. Gitin should be able to do that
• 2:00
  and that'll be Makayima Shalom, right, In order to be able to do
• 2:05
  that. And that would be a key of that.
• 2:07
  OK, we're out to see Dalib in a person has to send away the
• 2:14
  mother bird until she you're not.
• 2:17
  Let it take the kids until you see her garden.
• 2:20
  If she's still hovering around, as we're going to see soon, it
• 2:23
  does not make the mitzvahs before she's more on coolant.
• 2:29
  If you want to cut off the wings before you send her.
• 2:33
  In other words, if she's going to go hopping away, but she's
• 2:36
  not going to be going flying away.
• 2:38
  Kadesha Lloyd to holy frog because then a no rushite that
• 2:41
  does not count. That doesn't be my kind of the
• 2:43
  mitzvos. I'll quote you right now in the
• 2:44
  Gemara in a second. Eliyashaws Henna Miyad in Cafea
• 2:48
  Kadesha to holy frog. Rather, you should send her away
• 2:52
  with her wings that you should take off and then and then
• 2:55
  you're able to take the children after he's away.
• 3:02
  But if you did clip its wings, if you did clip the mother's
• 3:05
  wings, so forget about it. You're not doing a good job of
• 3:09
  the mitzvah. She's going to be walking away.
• 3:11
  Now this actually is coming based on a Gemara because the
• 3:14
  Gemara brings a cool in Kufman olive.
• 3:16
  But Mehmah asks, how are you able to send away the mother
• 3:20
  bird with Una says with its feet and review the says with its
• 3:23
  wings. That's Ravuna and revuta with
• 3:26
  the wings or with the feet. Rashi says in the first pirush
• 3:29
  like we see will be here in the chauhanar, how should she take?
• 3:32
  Does she have to take, take off? Does it have to be that she
• 3:35
  physically flies or is it enough that she walks or is it enough
• 3:39
  that she also walks away? And we see the chauhanar is
• 3:42
  being machmere, like the sheeta comes out that way in the also
• 3:46
  like revuta that says she's better, she has to fly away.
• 3:49
  If she's just going to walk away, forget about it.
• 3:51
  You're not being the kind of mitzvah.
• 3:52
  Mitzvah is chalet after Shala. Let her fly away, not let her
• 3:58
  walk away. And that's why and that's why
• 4:00
  there's Shalom passes that we have to do with her feet.
• 4:02
  That's one Pierce from Rashi. But it's important to know
• 4:04
  there's another Pierce there which says how do you send away
• 4:08
  the mother bird? How do you send her away?
• 4:10
  And he says the way is by actually picking her up and
• 4:14
  sending her away with her wings or with her feet.
• 4:17
  In other words, according to that Pierce, the Pierce says do
• 4:19
  you take her out from the bottom or do you take her out from the
• 4:22
  side? Those are the 2 Pirushin that
• 4:24
  are given there. Now there's a problem with doing
• 4:29
  that. According to this idea would
• 4:32
  mean to get her there by kind of pushing her and getting her.
• 4:35
  I'm not saying that's how we pass him and then I'm going to
• 4:37
  get to see if he right now, but you're going to see that's not
• 4:39
  how we pass him. If a person wants to take the
• 4:45
  mother and to send away the children in Rashad, most people
• 4:49
  think that is to take children from underneath the mother.
• 4:52
  But if you remember the pussy, says Lady Shalaka M Alabani,
• 4:55
  you're also not allowed to send away the mother.
• 4:57
  Believe it or not, to take the mother while she's on the
• 5:00
  children, That's also a sewer that's also being Mavato lab.
• 5:04
  You're also being Mavato lab. So meaning just snatching a
• 5:07
  mother while she's on top of her chicks, on top of her eggs is
• 5:10
  also an isser. What you can see is not as bad
• 5:13
  as it sounds like taking her children underneath her, but it
• 5:15
  also applies on to the children or possums here before she
• 5:18
  answered this boy about that. It's a possible Yeah, aim
• 5:23
  Alebani, if you look come upon me, even if you send her away
• 5:32
  many times, you still have to go ahead and send her away just
• 5:35
  like we have. It's the shock points out by
• 5:37
  Hashaba Saveda. Hashaba shaved Tasheed Afilu man
• 5:41
  upon me. And even if you go, you gave it,
• 5:43
  you lost it again. You lost the same, the same
• 5:45
  klutz. It keeps losing the same thing
• 5:47
  over and over again. There's still a mitzvah to go
• 5:49
  ahead and do a shava saveda for that guy, Aval.
• 5:51
  You shall cover not all about him.
• 5:53
  But if you sent her away, you successfully took the children
• 5:56
  and then she came back on top of the children.
• 5:59
  I aim alaim then you're putter Mila Shalaya.
• 6:01
  So then you're already putter Mala Shalaya.
• 6:03
  If you did the job of taking the Bunny, even though she came
• 6:06
  back, then you should know that you're basically our our putter
• 6:10
  veer 0 Lakhan putter me Shalaya, you return the egg.
• 6:15
  I took that, I took the kids, I put the egg kids back, and then
• 6:17
  she came back. That's what we're talking about,
• 6:20
  right? Somebody else doing the mitzvah
• 6:22
  now. That's what I'm getting to.
• 6:23
  No, no, that's what I'm getting to.
• 6:24
  That's that's exactly what I got with this.
• 6:26
  Yeah, we're getting right there. OK, so first of all, we're
• 6:28
  describing how to do the mitzvah.
• 6:30
  And then what the question is as I'm going to get to.
• 6:32
  OK, so you go ahead. And we said the way to do the
• 6:34
  mitzvah, simply speaking, seems to be according to where we run
• 6:37
  the chocolate to send away the motherboard.
• 6:38
  The problem is the Rashba and many of the Rashbin and others
• 6:44
  say that to pick up the bird and send it away could be a mitzvah
• 6:50
  Baba Avera. In other words, you're doing an
• 6:51
  avera because we just said that's why we're both sleeping
• 6:54
  together. You're not allowed to pick up
• 6:55
  the mother on the child. So one second, how am I supposed
• 6:58
  to send away this bird? You just told me to pick up the
• 7:00
  mother and send her. I was over this, Sir.
• 7:02
  So they actually called the Rashba says, and this will be
• 7:05
  relevant when we talk about the bracha.
• 7:07
  He calls it a lava Nitrica essay, believe it or not, just
• 7:10
  like a person steals and then he returns what he stole as 11 into
• 7:14
  class, eh? So he says also here, you pick
• 7:16
  up the mother and you're over an insert again, it's a Rashba.
• 7:19
  I can't argue with the Rashba. You pick up the mother, you're
• 7:22
  over an insert and then you send it away and you fixed up what
• 7:24
  you did wrong. I know that's a shocker a little
• 7:26
  bit. So most of the police can
• 7:28
  disagree with the Rashba and they say, well, therefore, and
• 7:31
  it's important if you actually are picking up the mother, OK,
• 7:34
  if you're doing it with this, if you're picking up the mother to
• 7:38
  send her away, have in mind, I'm not being cling to the mother.
• 7:41
  I don't want them. I'm not I'm doing this only for
• 7:44
  the she can. I don't want the mother and then
• 7:46
  you won't be over the answer at all if you pick it up.
• 7:49
  I don't know if what your mind is your Stam das or something
• 7:51
  like that. It could be your awareness or
• 7:52
  taking an aim all about him, which is an insert, which again,
• 7:55
  according to the rest, but it's a reason why you don't even make
• 7:57
  a bra because the old it's a mitzvah could be that's
• 8:00
  understand that, but you pick up the mother you have in mind.
• 8:04
  I don't want to be kind of the mother I don't want to have.
• 8:06
  I'm only doing what the sake of the mitzvah.
• 8:08
  And then you send her away and then that is Besedo Gomorrah.
• 8:12
  And then that's OK. That's how that's the way to be
• 8:14
  Mikayem, the mitzvah. However, many post teams say
• 8:18
  let's avoid this problem of picking up mothers and kavanas.
• 8:22
  And we know 99% of people didn't come to this year, right?
• 8:25
  I mean, there are a lot of people this year, but I'm just
• 8:26
  not to say that many people who didn't hear this year, they're
• 8:28
  not going to have these kavanas. Well, what should we do?
• 8:30
  So that's why we have the stick, OK.
• 8:32
  That's the idea of having a stick or kind of pushing it away
• 8:36
  without actually physically touching the mother, kind of
• 8:39
  scaring her away would also be sufficient.
• 8:42
  That would be a sufficient way of being makayam, the mitzvah.
• 8:47
  The benischai was asked this question.
• 8:49
  He says I want to just go and scare away the the bird.
• 8:53
  Is that good enough to do so? The benischai says that if you
• 8:57
  do it in a way that she runs away because of you, so that is
• 9:03
  also sufficient. He says that's also good enough.
• 9:07
  The menischai was incredible because he had such piques and
• 9:10
  shot and saw his chubas. He interchanges back and forth.
• 9:14
  So over there he mentions that we find also by Srita.
• 9:18
  You guys don't Srita, we have a Mukhani.
• 9:24
  A Mukhani is you know what I'm talking about.
• 9:25
  Recline, spin the the circle. What?
• 9:30
  No, no, the thing that turns around with the water or water
• 9:32
  thing that picks up water all the days.
• 9:34
  What a water wheel. A water wheel that has a knife
• 9:37
  on the end and it sheds the animals.
• 9:39
  So if it happens because the waters is going on its own, so
• 9:42
  you're not. But if you're the one pouring
• 9:44
  the water, if you pour the water and it goes and spins.
• 9:47
  So it's important. So let's see what's going on.
• 9:49
  I appreciate that. And then go on call in that says
• 9:51
  that that works. That's called a mesoschito
• 9:55
  because it came as a result of my actions.
• 9:57
  Even though I didn't do it the world the the water wheel did
• 10:00
  it, but I did as a result of action.
• 10:01
  He says the British guy also here, as long as she runs away
• 10:05
  because of my actions, because I was the one who went ahead and
• 10:08
  scared her. So then that's also considered
• 10:11
  sufficient. That's the finish that the the
• 10:13
  Manish guy says and that's how we passing that you can use a
• 10:15
  stick to push her away. You can do it.
• 10:17
  Well, the truth is the window or turn on the lights.
• 10:19
  I've done this many times and we've got we've had this issue
• 10:22
  many times because many of them are on windowsills.
• 10:25
  And the second you want to get to her, and I've always tried to
• 10:27
  try to, you know, slowly open the windowsill so you can, you
• 10:30
  don't have to touch her, but just so you can be the one to
• 10:32
  actually physically pull, push her out.
• 10:35
  Ideally speaking, that's the best way to do it.
• 10:37
  That you can physically push her out as opposed to just going
• 10:40
  like that is not as good. I know they're both your
• 10:43
  actions, but one is you actually doing something.
• 10:45
  Who says this or Strombot? It's your energy, It's your
• 10:49
  energy, but it's indirect energy.
• 10:51
  You're right now this is the hittership of Storm, but I'm
• 10:54
  telling you, not everybody agrees to him.
• 10:55
  He says that you can use a stick.
• 10:57
  You don't have to touch the the bird or anything.
• 10:59
  It's because of you that you're coming and pushing him away and
• 11:02
  that's fine. If I say he and she understand
• 11:04
  she and you're pushing her away, it doesn't that's fine.
• 11:07
  He tightness and everybody agrees to him that as long as it
• 11:10
  comes as a result of me that if it's coming just a result of me
• 11:13
  indirectly from far away, I'm a mile away and because of that,
• 11:16
  somehow I scared her away. He says that maybe that's not
• 11:18
  considered sufficient. He wants to be that you actually
• 11:21
  do something together. You do an action so that that's
• 11:24
  what he says one second. There are many that disagree
• 11:27
  because as long as I'm the one that causes her to run away,
• 11:30
  then that would be enough, but it has to be that you have been
• 11:32
  mind to do it. So I tell people that if the
• 11:34
  windows, it happens all the time.
• 11:36
  You try to open the window, she's gone, That's it.
• 11:37
  Once you can open the window, so open the window.
• 11:40
  I'll ask can't to scare it. Don't open the window because
• 11:42
  you want to do something. If you have open the window, you
• 11:43
  want to knock her out and she runs away.
• 11:45
  Before that, you weren't my kindness.
• 11:46
  Everyone says that, so open the window.
• 11:48
  That's that's the way I'm gonna scare it if she still stays,
• 11:51
  which is not so common, but if she still stays so then you can
• 11:54
  go ahead and push her with a stick or something like that or
• 11:55
  even push her if you want to be able to get her out.
• 11:58
  But ideally speaking, you want to be able to get there that
• 12:00
  you're the 1 causing it because you wanted to be the instigator
• 12:03
  of this whole event. Okay, that's who doesn't that's
• 12:06
  called that. It came it came from me.
• 12:09
  OK, that's that's turn on the light switch turning on the
• 12:12
  light switch. If you do it on the light switch
• 12:14
  as a way to be able to get her to run away.
• 12:16
  That's good. I will try to do.
• 12:17
  I think the window's more direct.
• 12:19
  I think it's a lot more direct for sure.
• 12:20
  The light switch for stomach 1 is not so proud of, but if
• 12:24
  you're able to do it, that's fine.
• 12:25
  That's that's a way to do it. Well, my said, if you look in
• 12:28
  the picture books, that many picture books of the Shalek, the
• 12:30
  Shalek you see most of them were sticks right as a picture of the
• 12:33
  Shomo Zalman or the Stipeler or the Khreim Kanievsky.
• 12:36
  They're all doing the midstrel at least once in the lines.
• 12:38
  Oh my to do the mitzvah and almost most of them were doing
• 12:40
  these are big with a bird, you know, and that is stick and they
• 12:44
  just sent them away. That's, that's a picture with
• 12:46
  her of shots and and and others. They all were doing it was
• 12:49
  sticks and it seems to be OK, but you should try your best to
• 12:52
  get get the stick. So ideally, if you know that
• 12:54
  she's building a nest over there, try to leave the window a
• 12:57
  little bit ajar, a little bit open.
• 12:59
  And by doing that, hopefully you'll be able to stick the
• 13:01
  stick in and you'll be able to get her out.
• 13:03
  But you actually physically doing it.
• 13:06
  OK, that's that's what we have here this this idea I might say
• 13:09
  it's important to know before we continue it is important to know
• 13:12
  that the Rambam says almost clearly and many are in the
• 13:15
  dyke. The Ramam Kate said Michelle FM
• 13:17
  or Hezbic Nafaya Umafrija. He learns the Gemara kept
• 13:21
  shooter that you should hold her by the wings and send her away.
• 13:24
  So this is a point as you can understand of a if you say a
• 13:27
  brisket homework to be able to go look the ramam says you have
• 13:29
  to send her away. They don't want sticks and
• 13:31
  people who who tried to be more mockman to be Mckimer.
• 13:36
  And they say you should actually try to grab her and throw her
• 13:39
  away, try to get her out, try to push her away if you could
• 13:42
  somehow physically toucher. Like I said, the MNIG is not
• 13:46
  like that. We're definitely Makil.
• 13:48
  But the reason why some people are mocking is A, it's a Rambam
• 13:51
  and B, the custom cipher. If you remember yesterday, I
• 13:54
  said the custom cipher is really worried about Tsar Balakhain.
• 13:57
  He says if you're not Makai in the mitzvah, then why are you
• 13:59
  doing this whole thing? I don't like it.
• 14:00
  So he says that if there's a Rambam that says you're not
• 14:03
  being Makai in the MIT if you don't do it properly.
• 14:05
  So he says maybe you should make sure to do it properly.
• 14:07
  Otherwise, who knows, maybe you're being over this or Tsar
• 14:09
  Balakhain. We don't pass on the custom
• 14:11
  cipher, but at least we see this idea why there's room for for
• 14:17
  these for these for these home runs.
• 14:19
  So to be able to do it. Yeah, for the labs of of what?
• 14:23
  Of picking it up. So like I said, if you do it,
• 14:25
  first of all, it's become fair means I don't if you have to
• 14:27
  actually pick her up, you can go like this like kind of like, you
• 14:29
  know, be the instigator to touch her and she kind of pushes away.
• 14:33
  So he never made a Kenyan on her.
• 14:34
  That's one way. And second of all, we mentioned
• 14:35
  if you have a mind, I'm not doing it for the Rambam knew the
• 14:38
  whole lot, right. So he I don't have a mind to
• 14:40
  have a Kenyan on the on the bird.
• 14:42
  I just have a mind to get rid of it.
• 14:43
  So then I won't be over the years.
• 14:46
  All right, See, if I took the mother on top of the children
• 14:53
  and I didn't successfully send her away.
• 14:55
  So then so now you shall kind of oh patter and you don't get
• 14:58
  malchus. He's just going with that.
• 15:00
  I told you that taking a mother on the child is an ISR and a
• 15:04
  person should be hive malchus. The only reason you don't get
• 15:08
  whipped is because you have a way of fixing yourself up by
• 15:11
  sending her away. If a person steals your hive
• 15:14
  malchus, you deserve to be whipped.
• 15:15
  But the only thing is there's the myths of the Shaveda of
• 15:19
  Shaveda. You can go ahead and return it.
• 15:21
  So therefore we don't whip you. But if you burn the thing you
• 15:24
  stole, you get rid. Let's say you stole $1,000,000
• 15:27
  and you spent it all. So then you actually get whipped
• 15:29
  for it because now you can't return the money anymore.
• 15:32
  Well, dollars is not a good right?
• 15:33
  But let's say that OK, dollars not a good right?
• 15:35
  Let's say if it's an object or something.
• 15:37
  But over here, when with the mother, if the mother I took it,
• 15:40
  I could send her away. So therefore I don't get malkas.
• 15:42
  However, if you shoot the bird or if you shack the bird and
• 15:45
  let's go, that's me. So gory, right?
• 15:47
  I shack the bird and eat it. So then you do get whipped.
• 15:50
  Then the person actually is whipped because you already were
• 15:52
  a laugh are you abates him. Muzaras are frankly my freaking
• 15:57
  OSHA and traifa. I OSHA zaka rabbits alekan Tommy
• 16:04
  rabbits al beta of tar or avatar rabbits al beta of Tommy.
• 16:09
  Here he mentions that anytime you can't do anything with the
• 16:14
  children, with the chicks or the OR the beitzin.
• 16:17
  So then you are not obligating the mitzvah.
• 16:21
  There is no mitzvah of Shiluwa. I can't, I'll just tell you
• 16:24
  quickly. The Mitzius by the Bates in is
• 16:26
  that it takes 12 to 15 days for enough for us to grow.
• 16:30
  The first three days you don't see anything.
• 16:32
  It's kind of like a yoke. And the next three days after
• 16:35
  that, it's starting to be what we call Mitra chem starting to
• 16:38
  develop anyway. So that that's, that's the
• 16:40
  that's the idea here. At least we see from here an
• 16:42
  important idea though, that it needs to be somewhat of a kosher
• 16:46
  egg zones. We know that it's considered as
• 16:49
  long as we know that it's considered a kosher bird.
• 16:50
  So then it's okay. Now, making a Kenyan what you
• 16:52
  asked before, I just want to address it because we saw over
• 16:55
  here that if I picked it up and put it down a number of times,
• 16:58
  if I picked it up and put it down a number of times, it's
• 17:01
  still considered beseder. So over here it comes a
• 17:04
  question. Why after I put it down and the
• 17:06
  bird goes back on it, am I you? It said.
• 17:08
  I'm putter, Mila Shalaya had said, Because you finished the
• 17:11
  mitzvah. So from here many boys came,
• 17:13
  right, that the eggs that you picked up, even if you, you can
• 17:17
  pick it up and 1st after we see is you can put it back.
• 17:20
  You don't have to throw it away. What we spoke about yesterday,
• 17:23
  we see from here, according to the Chauchon or the way it
• 17:25
  sounds, I'm allowed to pick it up and put it back.
• 17:27
  I don't necessarily have to have to eat it and I don't have to go
• 17:31
  ahead and throw it away. That's what we see from this
• 17:34
  thing. That's A.
• 17:35
  But B, what else we see from the Chauchon or is that once I put
• 17:39
  it down, it's put them in the shellac because it's already you
• 17:42
  made a quinion on it and it cannot be used again.
• 17:46
  So over here, the police came to discuss how do I get the same
• 17:49
  nest to be done a few times and most of the people did it.
• 17:51
  Now, Klein said, I saw my father use the same nest a number of
• 17:55
  times and for different people. And the answer is 2 eights is
• 17:59
  basically or you have two eggs underneath every day every and a
• 18:02
  bird, like we said before. So you pick up only one egg and
• 18:05
  you let someone else do the other egg.
• 18:07
  That's one option. OK, that's one option.
• 18:10
  In other words, the same egg that you picked up don't have
• 18:12
  someone else do it. That's a or the other option is
• 18:16
  to make a Kenyan and then to make it Hefker again.
• 18:19
  You can go ahead and pick it up and make it Hefker again.
• 18:22
  If Hefker has to be in front of three people or one per person,
• 18:25
  it's a look like this, a little egg which fits into your whole
• 18:28
  hand. According to the Nesivos, it's
• 18:31
  enough that you don't have to pick it up, even three.
• 18:33
  You can just pick it up at tefa. It's enough that you made a
• 18:36
  Kenya Kutzer and then you can go ahead and that's enough of a
• 18:39
  tefa and then you can go ahead and make a Hefker again after
• 18:41
  that Kenyan, after you make that, can you put it back down
• 18:45
  according to the majority of POI scheme and then someone else can
• 18:48
  go ahead and and do the mitzvah again.
• 18:50
  OK. That's the that's the way they
• 18:53
  get around this issue about how I can go ahead and do the
• 18:56
  mitzvah a number a number of times.
• 18:58
  And like I said, we found a number of places say again, the
• 19:03
  bird will come back. Yeah.
• 19:04
  Better. Yeah.
• 19:04
  Yeah, hopefully we'll come back. Well, first of all, if for that
• 19:07
  matsias is if you use gloves, it works.
• 19:09
  I also tell people who use gloves, he, he was mentioning
• 19:11
  yesterday that the matsias is not always like that, which is
• 19:14
  also true. Sometimes they come back.
• 19:15
  I have seen, sometimes they don't.
• 19:17
  Sometimes they don't. OK, I'm just telling you that
• 19:18
  there's matsias both ways. But anyways, if you do it with
• 19:20
  gloves, they definitely come back using gloves by not being
• 19:25
  doing mitzvah. But you're saying you're not
• 19:26
  doing with the mitzvah itself. You're saying you're not, you're
• 19:28
  not touching the mitzvah itself. Right.
• 19:30
  Latex gloves, I think most people are making it.
• 19:32
  I don't think you've been quite with the kidney.
• 19:35
  It shouldn't be a problem. I think the exciting size would
• 19:37
  have the seats are like let's say by a two or something.
• 19:39
  I think it's totally fun and I don't think I don't have a
• 19:41
  problem with it. And you make a kidney that's
• 19:43
  that. And also we saw another Alaka
• 19:45
  based on CFA, which says that if she comes back a number of
• 19:48
  times, you have to do with this. I've seen a couple times if it's
• 19:50
  in a window cell, they'll usually fly away.
• 19:52
  I saw an air conditioning, which she just asked in the beginning
• 19:54
  of this year. I saw this a couple times that
• 19:56
  someone had on top of an air conditioning in front of their
• 19:58
  door and they try sending and sending and sending and.
• 20:01
  Come back and back and back. You should know that as long as
• 20:03
  they're coming back, it's a problem and you can and you are
• 20:06
  not Mikaya Dmitry, you have to try harder to be able to do.
• 20:08
  If you can't, you can't. But you have to actually get
• 20:10
  them to physically fly away in order for it to happen.
• 20:14
  OK, But at least we see at least we see them Making a Canyon is
• 20:17
  high. If you're obligated to make a
• 20:18
  Canyon and after making the Canyon, you're allowed to put it
• 20:21
  back and other people can do it, Try with two separate eggs.
• 20:23
  If not, you can actually make it.
• 20:24
  Hefker, you're not touching the nest.
• 20:27
  Then it's no. If he's hovering around.
• 20:29
  You can't. That's no.
• 20:30
  If he's hovering around. There's a difference about not
• 20:32
  touching the nest if the bird is still around.
• 20:34
  You didn't send away. You can't take the kids.
• 20:35
  That's what we saw over here. You send away the bird, He's
• 20:38
  hovering around. You're not allowed to take the
• 20:39
  kids. The bird has to be away.
• 20:41
  Not super far away, but a little bit far away in order to take
• 20:44
  the kids. But Cole's not.
• 20:45
  She's hovering around. It's still it's still not
• 20:47
  allowed. OK, That's not all right.
• 20:52
  Let me just read one more, Steve, and I'll finish.
• 20:54
  OK, Haisa, revisit salabonim Sheina Mina Ventarima Raisin a
• 20:58
  shaleh. If she's ravensis on batesim,
• 21:02
  which do not are not similar to her, meaning she's on top of
• 21:06
  other eggs, the chicken on top of a dove egg or things like
• 21:08
  that. Ventarima Raisin a shaleh.
• 21:10
  Reima shaleh. If she didn't send it away, if
• 21:12
  you didn't send it away, then there's actually no malchus, OK,
• 21:16
  Because there's a Suffolk in the Gumar about this.
• 21:18
  And it's a different bird if you're high, so you don't get
• 21:20
  monkers. But we're mocked, obviously, to
• 21:21
  say not to you have a cube of shala, but that you have it.
• 21:25
  If you didn't do it, you don't get a cube of of of monkers.
• 21:30
  And if you do stand the way you're Makai mitzvah them.
• 21:33
  Yeah, yeah, you're Makai mitzvah, at least me Suffolk,
• 21:36
  but you're makai mitzvah. But sometimes I'll finish with
• 21:38
  this, OK. And sometimes it's very hard to
• 21:40
  get to the things. And we just said you have to
• 21:42
  make a Kenyon on it based on what we just saw and see if,
• 21:44
  hey, that you need to make a Kenyon on the children on the
• 21:48
  Bates in. So how are you able to to do
• 21:51
  that? So the the one way to do it is
• 21:55
  by sending a Shalia. Believe it or not, sometimes a
• 21:57
  person is older, can't do it. But now they say don't put
• 21:59
  yourself in Sakana. Don't start climbing 12 stories
• 22:02
  in order to get on top of it to be able to do it.
• 22:03
  But the if you don't have an ETA, they go into the whole din
• 22:06
  of schleich was I'm allowed to go ahead and send a schleich and
• 22:08
  it's based on the Hakira we spoke out yesterday because the
• 22:11
  mitzvah is the actual sending away of the mother loved after
• 22:14
  the taking of the bird, the eggs.
• 22:15
  If you remember, we mentioned the mitzvahs be Etzem to send
• 22:18
  away the bird and the the the the taking of the eggs is the is
• 22:23
  the tinsa to be makai to do the mitzvah.
• 22:26
  So according to that idea, you can go ahead and do a Schleich
• 22:29
  was to send someone else to be able to go do it, which is many
• 22:32
  times What happened with the Doylin, like I said, was
• 22:34
  Schammel Zalman had one which was up a little bit high.
• 22:36
  They he took a stick. He sent away the bird and
• 22:38
  someone else went up, climbed up on the ladder shows on the
• 22:40
  climbing ladders and he went ahead and and took the eggs for
• 22:44
  the roof and he gave he made a Canon for the roof.
• 22:46
  I think he gave it to the roof to make a Canon, but I'm just
• 22:48
  saying so you could do it with a slit, but you do need to egg
• 22:51
  somehow. A Canon one last ATA is if it's
• 22:53
  in the haunts or mishtameris. If it's in your place.
• 22:55
  I never want to be coined. I know it's in my backyard.
• 22:58
  It's my tree. I never want to be coined.
• 23:00
  You send away the bird and now the the eggs are there.
• 23:03
  I want to be cleaning now so you don't actually have to
• 23:05
  physically pick it up anymore. You're acquainted with Kutzer.
• 23:07
  I had in mind that now you should be cleaning.
• 23:08
  That's the best ETA to be able to go ahead and do it.
• 23:11
  Like I said here, it's a bit easier because we have window
• 23:13
  sills and that's how you can be able to do it.
• 23:15
  Next week, tomorrow, the next time we'll speak about the Brock
• 23:18
  and we'll finish up the sea from only a moment.
• 23:20
  That is OK.