Latest / Bourbon Bytes Podcast / Weller Full Proof Review + 2025 Pappy Collection & Nintendo Direct Surprises
Transcript
- 0:00Today on the Bourbon Bytes Podcast, Buffalo Trace announces their 2025
- 0:04Pappy Van Winkle collection, Elijah Craig releases their youngest barrel-proof batch yet,
- 0:10and I recap the September Nintendo Direct with all the biggest announcements,
- 0:14plus I review a new bottle of Weller Full Proof bourbon.
- 0:30Hello everyone and welcome back to the Bourbon Bytes Podcast. This is the week of Thursday,
- 0:35September 18th, 2025, and I have some whiskey and video game news for you. If you're new here,
- 0:42welcome. My name is Clifton. This is the Bourbon Bytes Podcast, a whiskey podcast with a gaming
- 0:48twist. Thank you for joining me this week because we have some of the biggest news in bourbon of all
- 0:532025 to talk about today, and that is the Pappy Van Winkle 2025 collection that was just announced.
- 1:01This year, they're rolling out six expressions, Old Rip Van Winkle 10 year, Van Winkle Special
- 1:06Reserve 12 year, Van Winkle Family Reserve Rye at 13 years, Pappy Van Winkle 15, 20, and 23 year
- 1:13as usual, but they are also releasing one bottle of Old Rip Van Winkle 25 years old that was
- 1:22recently discovered, as they say, and will be included in the National Bourbon Heritage Month
- 1:26auction. And yes, you heard that right. There is literally one bottle of this release. And while
- 1:33only one lucky person will get their hands on this bottle, only a select few will get their hands on
- 1:38the other bottles as well. But it does make a new statement in the world of Pappy. There's been some
- 1:43special one-off releases in the past, usually released for special occasions or auctions like
- 1:48this, but it adds just another blip on the radar of bourbons I'll never see in the wild. But we
- 1:54always still get excited about it every year. Same with the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection.
- 1:58They're bottles that you want to seek out, and maybe in a lottery you'll have a chance to buy
- 2:02one of them, or maybe two of them. But just don't get your hopes up unless you got big bucks to
- 2:07spend. But we might as well talk about their retail prices, because, you know, why not? The
- 2:13Old Rip Van Winkle bourbon, the 10 year old, is $149.99. The Van Winkle Special Reserve bourbon
- 2:21is $169.99. The Family Reserve Rye 13 year is $229.99. The Pappy 15 is $239.99. Pappy 20 is $359.99.
- 2:36And of course, Pappy Van Winkle 23 comes in at the highest price, $499.99. Now, will you find any of
- 2:45under $500? Absolutely not. But we like to talk about retail. You know, like I said,
- 2:50if you have a chance to buy something in the lottery, there's a chance you can buy it at MSRP.
- 2:55And actually, even though it's far, far down the lineup from Buffalo Trace, I did buy today's
- 3:01bottle that I'm reviewing on my Byte-Sized Review at MSRP because, well, it was a leftover from the
- 3:07Total Wine Grand Reserve Lottery. And I didn't get picked for it, but they're like, hey, we have a
- 3:12few extra bottles of this if you want it at retail. So I had a chance to buy it. So we'll get
- 3:16into that later. But I wanted to review it because it is relevant to the Buffalo Trace Limited Edition
- 3:22releases. Now, this is the season where we're going to expect to see the Buffalo Trace Antique
- 3:27Collection as well. We talked about it a few months ago, about the new releases, the new
- 3:31E.H. Taylor inclusion in it. I don't think we have details yet as to the exact proofs and everything
- 3:37going into the 2025 release. We just know that the E.H. Taylor is going to be a new inclusion in
- 3:43the lineup. So stay tuned for that. I will report on that as soon as I have an update. I will try
- 3:47my best to get a sample of any slash all of these Buffalo Trace Limited Edition releases, but I want
- 3:54you guys to at least know about them, you know, know they exist out there in case you hadn't heard.
- 3:59Now, one quick mention of Bourbon News, only quickly mentioning it because I'll probably
- 4:03review it in the very near future. Elijah Craig has just announced their C Batch of Elijah Craig
- 4:08Barrel Proof, and it's actually the youngest ECBP yet. This one's actually only coming in at nine
- 4:13years and one month old. Now, it is coming at 129 proof, so it's still a relatively high proof
- 4:19release, but this is kind of what people feared when it came to Elijah Craig Barrel Proof losing
- 4:23the age statement. Now, they have been including the age statement on each batch, but everything
- 4:28used to be at least 12 years old. There's been some variation, there's been some younger, there's
- 4:31been some older releases, but nothing's come quite as young, at least for the batch releases,
- 4:37as nine years, one month. I know quite a few single barrels have come in close to that or
- 4:41even younger at eight years, and you know, there's a place for them, but it does hurt my heart just a
- 4:47little bit to see a lower proof batch, but I'm going to give it a shot as I do with every Elijah
- 4:52Craig Barrel Proof, and especially since this is the last one of the year, I'm going to try to get
- 4:56my hands on it so I can do a blind flight for A-Batch, B-Batch, and C-Batch, because when we do
- 5:00it blind, we don't know how old it is, and maybe there's a chance it's the best tasting batch yet.
- 5:05Now, I will mention Elijah Craig normally sends me a sample of every single Elijah Craig Barrel Proof
- 5:10for the past several years. Now, this is the only one that I haven't received a sample of yet. Now,
- 5:15that doesn't mean it's not coming, but it almost makes me wonder, like, maybe they didn't want to
- 5:19send it to the guy who's reviewed every single batch, just in case, you know, it doesn't hold
- 5:23up, but we'll see. You'll be seeing that on my YouTube channel once I get my hands on it. Like
- 5:27I said, I always do an end-of-year blind flight of all the batches that year. I sometimes put them
- 5:32head-to-head against my favorite batch of last year. If you're curious about that and you want
- 5:36to see it, make sure to check out my YouTube channel, youtube.com/bourbonbytes. I go
- 5:40live every Thursday night at 7 p.m. Pacific, 10 p.m. Eastern. That's always one of the favorites
- 5:45of the year for me and for you guys, so really looking forward to doing that. Now, as I mentioned
- 5:50on last week's podcast, Nintendo was due for a Nintendo Direct this month, and it happened,
- 5:56and there were some huge announcements that I want to tell you guys about. The first of which,
- 6:00I have to acknowledge being the retro gamer that I am, this is the 40th anniversary of Super Mario
- 6:06Bros. I've been a lifelong fan of this franchise. Growing up with Super Mario World and things like
- 6:12that, I just always have a special place in my heart for the classic Mario games. And to celebrate,
- 6:18they're actually doing a special light display at the Kyoto Nintendo Museum starting this December,
- 6:24and they'll be also sponsoring the Kyoto Marathon in February with special Nintendo race bibs.
- 6:31I love to see such a historic moment being recognized and celebrated. I wish we could
- 6:34do a little bit more for it here in the U.S., but that was only the start of the Nintendo Direct
- 6:39because there were so many announcements. I'm only going to highlight some of my favorites.
- 6:42You can go watch the replay. It's about an hour long, but here are a few of my favorite things
- 6:47that were announced. While we're talking about Mario, the Super Mario Galaxy movie is coming
- 6:51out in April of 2026. Did you guys see the Super Mario Bros. movie that came out? I think it was,
- 6:56was it last year or the year before? I actually thought it was pretty dang good. I don't know
- 7:01what my expectations were. You know, usually video game movies, you're kind of like about,
- 7:04but I think coming off the heels of Detective Pikachu, which I thought was a fantastic film,
- 7:09I was really excited and I think the Super Mario movie held up. So I'm excited to see the Super
- 7:14Mario Galaxy movie coming next year. Speaking of Super Mario Galaxy, they are releasing a
- 7:19two-parter release. Super Mario Galaxy and Super Mario Galaxy 2 are going to be bundled and
- 7:24released on October 2nd for Nintendo Switch. Now, even though this is coming out on Nintendo Switch,
- 7:29it's going to be playable on Switch 2, and of course, enhanced to being the resolution up to
- 7:334K on that platform, as well as a few extra features specifically for the Switch 2 edition.
- 7:39Now, another game that was announced that's part of a very familiar IP is Yoshi and the Mysterious
- 7:44Book. This is a brand new game in the Yoshi universe, and in this game, a mysterious book
- 7:49falls from the sky known as Mr. E. Get it? Mystery? And throughout the game, you'll be meeting all
- 7:56these new creatures, and it seems like a lot of fun. It seems like these new creatures that you
- 8:00discover introduce different ways to play the game, whether they help you break rocks or help
- 8:05you fly across water. It looks like a lot of fun and a lot of discovery to be had in this game. So
- 8:11it's definitely one I'm interested in picking up. I just think Yoshi is one of my favorite
- 8:14Nintendo characters and always love to see a new Yoshi game. Now, there were quite a few other
- 8:19things announced, including some DLC to Donkey Kong Bonanza, a new Fire Emblem game was announced
- 8:24at the end of the game, and a new Metroid Prime 4 release coming out this December,
- 8:29but there was one game that caught my eye more than all the others. If you know me and you know
- 8:34my type of games, you know how excited I am for Pokemon Pokopia. So this is a life sim, farming
- 8:41sim type game, but with Pokemon. It's everything I've wanted since I was a child. It's basically,
- 8:47from what I can tell in the announcement video, Animal Crossing, but with Pokemon. It's very
- 8:53Minecraft inspired, kind of like how Animal Crossing is, but instead of villagers, you have
- 8:58Pokemon that can move into your town, and you can specialize certain areas for them, you can build
- 9:03homes for them, and it's featuring some of my favorite classic Pokemon. The reveal trailer, of
- 9:08course, started with Bulbasaur, Squirtle, and Charmander, but I'm sure there are a ton more
- 9:12Pokemon to discover in the game. But what I think is the most unique part is your character, or the
- 9:18player's character, is actually a Ditto. So Ditto takes on a human form, whether it's a boy or a girl,
- 9:24depending on who you would like to play as, and you can actually communicate with the Pokemon.
- 9:28You can talk to them, you can understand them, and I think that brings a whole new level of
- 9:32falling in love with your favorite Pokemon. Just getting to know their personalities,
- 9:36getting to know what they like, what they dislike, it just makes the inner child of me so excited to
- 9:41see something like this. Now, whether or not it's going to kind of be a flop, and it kind of just,
- 9:45you know, is very, very basic, or if it's going to live on as a classic, we have yet to see,
- 9:50but it is probably the most excited I've been for a new Nintendo game in a long time, and that
- 9:55even includes Pokemon Legends. I'm actually more excited for this than those games, even though
- 9:59that game looks like a lot of fun. I saw they announced the new Mega Raichu X and Mega Raichu
- 10:04Y, which is fun and all, but I love my cozy little farming life sim games. Judge me, I don't care.
- 10:12So we don't have a specific release date for this game, but it will be coming out in 2026.
- 10:17Usually that probably means later in the year, but I'm excited to follow this one and see how
- 10:21they continue to develop it, and make it more exciting, because I'm already very, very intrigued,
- 10:26and I will be absolutely picking up a copy of this game. Alright, well that does it for this
- 10:31week's whiskey and gaming news, but we do have a very special Byte-Sized review.
- 10:43Alright, well as I teased earlier in the review, I managed to get my hands on a new bottle of
- 10:48Weller Full Proof at MSRP. So according to the laser code, this appears to be a 2025 batch,
- 10:55and that excites me because I haven't had any one of these since they first came out.
- 10:58Funny enough, a lot of Full Proof store picks became available here in Southern California
- 11:03more than the standard release, so I had the opportunity to try several of those back when
- 11:07that first came out, but I only tried the Full Proof regular edition once. I only had one bottle of it,
- 11:13and that's long, long gone. So when I got the email from Total Wine that there were a few of
- 11:18these left over at the store from the lottery, I knew I couldn't pass it up. I paid $74.99 for it,
- 11:24which seems fair. I'm not sure if MSRP has changed. I know originally it was closer to $50,
- 11:30but again, it's been several years, so I was willing to pay a bit of an increase even if
- 11:34that wasn't necessarily MSRP. Now as with all Weller Full Proof releases, this is 114 proof,
- 11:40so it's technically not cask strength. It's just what they're labeling as Full Proof
- 11:43compared to their Weller 107, which I actually have been drinking throughout this podcast just
- 11:49to kind of refamiliarize myself with the palate. I love 107. It's always been one of my favorite
- 11:53Weller releases, but I've had some fantastic Full Proof, so I'm excited to see how this
- 11:57compares. Now, of course, this is the same wheated bourbon mash bill that they used in the Pappy Van
- 12:02Winkle collection. Of course, a lot more available than that, and also certainly not nearly as old.
- 12:08We don't know how old, but we assume this is between 6 to 7 years old based on what Buffalo
- 12:13Trace has told folks, and that would make sense because Weller 12 is, you know, of course,
- 12:17advertised as the older brother of these releases. So, you know, I think 6 to 8 sounds about right to
- 12:24me. It would be great if these did have an age statement on them though. Alright, well, let's
- 12:27go in and get this Weller Full Proof poured and a fresh bottle crack for us here. This is the
- 12:31first time I've tried this this year. I always get nervous doing a Weller review because I know
- 12:37people have a lot of thoughts on it. I really haven't seen it much lately. I used to could find
- 12:42107 at least a couple times a year, but I can't tell you the last time I saw a bottle of it.
- 12:47I've seen Special Reserve here and there, and then the 12 Year is something that I've surprisingly
- 12:51seen a couple times this year, but it's not one of my favorites. I do have a bottle that I
- 12:55recently revisited, and I still feel kind of the same way as I have always felt about that one.
- 13:00Just the 12 Year never hits right for me. 107 is where it's at for me. Always a fantastic bottle.
- 13:06Full Proof has been, you know, sometimes better, sometimes equal to, sometimes not as good in my
- 13:11opinion, but I'm going to reserve all those previous judgments and hold them back for this
- 13:152025 Weller Full Proof release. Let's go ahead and give that one a nose.
- 13:21Oh, yummy. Yeah, that's kind of what I expected with the nose. I mean, it's kind of what I always
- 13:25get on a wheated Buffalo Trace. It is a dessert shot, but specifically a fall bakery note. It's
- 13:32straight up pie season. I'm getting apple pie, maybe a little bit of mixed berries there as well,
- 13:36some toasted vanilla, and just the right amount of oak that it's not overpowering. I think the
- 13:41dessert notes are first and foremost what I'm getting on this whiskey, on the nose at least.
- 13:46I think this gives you a really fantastic just down home country fall bake shop note. There's
- 13:53a little bit of baking spice there too. I'm thinking more along the lines of nutmeg compared
- 13:57to cinnamon. Not really spicy like cinnamon. It's definitely a very mellow approachable nose.
- 14:02All right, I could nose this all day, but we got to go in for a taste. So let's try this 2025
- 14:06Weller Full Proof. Cheers! Mmm, yeah, that stays the course. The first thing I get is that
- 14:13pie crust note. This one is strangely enough giving me the very specific type of pie crust
- 14:19for like a chicken pot pie, which is crazy. It doesn't have any of the savory chicken pot pie
- 14:24notes, but it does have that flaky buttery kind of pie crust note that you get on top of one of those
- 14:30and a little bit of char. You know, sometimes when you have a chicken pot pie, the edges are a little
- 14:34bit more charred than the fluffy, buttery center. This is definitely both of those combined.
- 14:40Definitely more in the buttery territory, but there's some hints of that toasted pie crust
- 14:45note that just is, it makes my mouth water. And right alongside that is some vanilla. I mean,
- 14:50if you combine those two notes, it kind of is almost in the realm of Crème Brûlée,
- 14:53like a little bit of like a toasted sugar and vanilla note there as well. I'm sure you can
- 14:57have it on other pies too, but in my experience, that's where I've experienced it the most,
- 15:01just delicious buttery crust. Again, there's that baking spice. It's not cinnamon. It's
- 15:06not spicy at all. It's just a little bit, maybe more like clove or like I said earlier,
- 15:10nutmeg or all spice. Can't quite pinpoint it, but it definitely goes kind of fall,
- 15:16but not quite cinnamon. I know I said this is like a fall whiskey or a fall bake shop,
- 15:20but I'm missing some of those really spicy cinnamon notes that you would get on something
- 15:24that I would consider a holiday whiskey. I think a fall whiskey and a holiday whiskey
- 15:28are close, but not exactly the same. This one's leaning more towards just the sweet,
- 15:33the delicate, the almost like toasted marshmallow element of fall. It's just overall sweet vanilla,
- 15:40toasted oak pie crusts. I mean, this is a flavor profile that it would be hard to not like if you
- 15:46are a fan of bourbon, especially if you're a fan of wheated bourbon. You're not seeking out that
- 15:50really spicy rye that I sometimes love, but sometimes I like to settle in with a bourbon
- 15:55that's high proof. Like I said, 114 is nothing to turn your nose up at, but does not drink that
- 16:01high proof and just is very approachable, easy, great mouthfeel. Finish wise is probably a medium
- 16:07finish. It's not super short, but it doesn't linger too long. It doesn't overstay its welcome,
- 16:11I guess I would say. But overall, just experience wise, it's hard to fault this bourbon.
- 16:17Now when we think bang for your buck, of course, I'm thinking of this as a $75 bourbon,
- 16:21which is what I bought it for. I think it's a great bourbon anywhere up to $100. I think it's,
- 16:27you know, unique. It's a great expression of what Buffalo Trace can do with a full proof
- 16:32wheated mash bill. Now if you see the Weller 107 at the same price, there's some debate whether
- 16:38which one is better. I sometimes prefer the 107, but I say you do you. If you have a chance to
- 16:43buy them both, definitely do at $100. And I think it stands toe to toe with other wheated bourbons at
- 16:48similar proof. I mean, I really love the Maker's Mark Private Selects that have the different
- 16:53oak stave finishes on them. Those are definitely a bit more in the spicy territory. This one is a
- 16:58lot more approachable, a little more nuanced with that sweet, you know, fall pie element.
- 17:04It's hard to say which one I prefer just because I really do like Maker's Mark, those high proof
- 17:09releases. But this one is always got a place on my shelf. It's just a really good, approachable,
- 17:14delicious bourbon whiskey. Now, in terms of rating, which I've been trying to do more on
- 17:19these podcast reviews, you know, I didn't know what to expect going into this. I haven't had it
- 17:25in years. My experience from them have gone from great to good to a little bit subpar. But this one
- 17:30is probably between good and great. I mean, it's not the best Weller I've ever had, but it really
- 17:36is holding its ground here. And at $75, I don't regret this purchase at all. I think I would
- 17:41absolutely buy another if I had a chance to at the same price. So with that being said, of course,
- 17:45not considering the prices that some people pay on secondary, I gave this a solid eight and a
- 17:50half out of 10. I would love to see an age statement on it. I would love to have a little
- 17:54bit more of a finish there. But just as a standalone Full Proof Weller wheated bourbon
- 17:59release, I mean, there's not much I can complain about. I'm a big fan of it. So, yes, you may
- 18:03consider me a tater, but I don't think it's being a tater just giving something a fair review after
- 18:07paying retail for it. I think if I would have spent several hundred dollars on this and then
- 18:11I gave it a raving review, that would be a whole different scenario. There are people that do that.
- 18:15And you know what? More power to them. But I am someone that treats all bourbon fairly. I review
- 18:20them based on retail. And if you are able to get it retail, what rating would I give it? So that's
- 18:26my thoughts on this bourbon. I think it's a must buy at under $100. I would love to get a more
- 18:31recent 107. The one I'm drinking is a pick from several years ago, actually have not
- 18:36seen 107 hit my area in a long, long time. So I will keep an eye out. I will hold on
- 18:41to the rest of this Weller Full Proof to do a comparison. Maybe I'll do another Weller full
- 18:44lineup review. I've done that in the past on YouTube. If you've been curious, check it out.
- 18:48YouTube.com/bourbonbytes. I'm promoting the YouTube channel a lot as podcast. It's not
- 18:52intentional, but that's kind of my second home on the Internet. It's the podcast and the YouTube
- 18:56channel. You can find all of it bourbonbytes.com and get a link to our Discord server and our
- 19:00Byte Club membership. But yeah, that's usually where you'll find me, YouTube or the podcast.
- 19:04So yeah, there's plenty of Buffalo Trace content between the two. All right, well,
- 19:09that does it for this week's episode. Thank you all so much for listening. Don't forget that you
- 19:13can leave a rating on your favorite podcast platform. You can also call into the show and
- 19:16leave your questions or comments. You can reach me at 916-64-BYTES. That voicemail inbox is still
- 19:23open. Of course, you can also send a text or post a message on Discord. But I'd like to hear your
- 19:27voice. I'd love to feature you on the next episode. So give me a call or shoot me a message.
- 19:31I'd love to hear from you. But until next time, this has been Bourbon Bytes,
- 19:34a whiskey podcast with a gaming twist. Cheers. And I'll talk to you guys next episode. Bye!