Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / Asking for a Raise When You Were Just Laid Off
Transcript
- Lucas: So you just got laid off. And somewhere between the shock and the paperwork, you realize you never got that raise you asked for six months ago. Maybe you asked twice. Luna: And now it feels like the door just slammed shut on that conversation. Lucas: Exactly. But here's the thing nobody tells you: the moment you're laid off might be the single best time to negotiate your pay. Not for a job you no longer have — for the package they're handing you on the way out. Luna: Wait, so we're talking about negotiating severance? Lucas: Yeah. And not just the severance itself — the whole exit package. Because here's the reality: when a company lays you off, they have a number in mind, and that number is often more flexible than you think. But most people just sign the paper and walk out. Luna: I mean, I get it. You're in shock, you're embarrassed, you just want out of the building. The last thing you feel like doing is haggling. Lucas: Right. And that's exactly why so many people leave money on the table. But here's the counterintuitive part: you actually have leverage in that final conversation. Think about it — they want a clean exit, they don't want lawsuits, they don't want you bad-mouthing them on LinkedIn. That gives you room. Luna: So what's the first move? Do you storm into HR and demand a raise? Lucas: No, no. You don't walk in demanding anything. The first move is actually preparation. You need two numbers before you even schedule that meeting. First, your true market rate — what someone with your skills and experience actually commands right now. Not what you were making, not what you hope to make. What a company would realistically pay to hire you today. Luna: Okay, so how do you get that number? Like, where does someone find that? Lucas: You can look at salary data from places like a salary aggregator or industry surveys. But the best source is actually your network — people at other companies who do similar work. Ask three or four of them what they'd expect to pay for your role. That gives you a real range, not a generic one. Luna: And the second number? Lucas: The cost of replacing you. This is the one people almost never think about, and it's your strongest card. Think about what it costs a company to find your replacement: job posts, recruiter fees, interviewing time, onboarding, plus the lost productivity for the first few months. For a mid-career hire, that's easily fifty to one hundred percent of that person's annual salary. Luna: So you're basically saying your severance offer should be compared to what it would cost them to just keep you for a few more months, not just what's in the standard policy. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the framing that gets you more than the standard two weeks per year of service. When you bring up the cost of replacement, you're not begging — you're showing them that a slightly bigger exit package is cheaper than the disruption of a sudden departure. Luna: But wait — aren't you already laid off? They've already decided to let you go. Why would they care about replacement costs? Lucas: That's the key insight. The layoff decision is made by a different part of the brain than the severance negotiation. Once the decision is made, they still want to minimize total cost and risk. And a one-time extra payment can actually be a bargain compared to the risk of you filing a discrimination claim or leaving with a bad taste that spreads. Luna: So you're saying you have more leverage after the layoff than before it, because they want closure? Lucas: Exactly. And the beauty is, you don't even have to threaten anything. You just have to ask the right way. Here's a script that's worked for people I've coached: 'I understand the decision is final, and I respect that. But I want to make sure we part ways in a way that feels fair to both of us. Given my market rate and the time it would take to bring someone new up to speed, would you consider adjusting the package?' Luna: Hmm, that's pretty smooth. But what if they just say no? I mean, a lot of companies have a standard formula and they don't budge. Lucas: Then you ask for something else. There's more than just the dollar amount. You can negotiate for continued health insurance coverage, outplacement services, or even keeping your company laptop. And one thing people forget — you can negotiate the date of your official termination. Pushing it back a few weeks can mean an extra paycheck, and it can also help your benefits. Luna: So basically, you're saying that the exit package is a negotiation, not a form letter. Lucas: Yes. And the biggest mistake is treating it like it's not. A lot of people worry that asking will burn bridges. But think about it — if you're being laid off, the bridge is already being dismantled. The question is whether you walk away with a fair settlement or just whatever they offered first. Luna: Yeah, that's a good point. But I want to push back a little. What about the people who want to return to that company one day? Or who need a reference? Isn't there a risk that asking for more makes you look difficult? Lucas: That's a real fear, and I get it. But here's the thing: in most cases, the people you'd be negotiating with are HR or a manager who's already moving on. And a well-framed, professional ask — one that acknowledges the layoff is happening and focuses on fairness — doesn't burn bridges. It actually shows you know your worth. And the companies that would punish you for that are probably not places you'd want to return to anyway. Luna: That's fair. I've also seen data that says most people who ask for a better package get at least something, even if it's not the full ask. Lucas: Absolutely. And that's the second mistake — not asking at all. You've got to get over the idea that you're being ungrateful. You gave them your time and skills. This is a professional transaction, and there's nothing wrong with asking to be treated fairly. Luna: So let's say someone's listening and they just got laid off this week. What's the first thing they should do tomorrow morning? Lucas: First, take a breath. Don't sign anything. Ask for the offer in writing, and ask for a few days to review it. Then start gathering your two numbers: your market rate and your replacement cost. And don't feel pressured to respond quickly — you have more time than they want you to think. Luna: And when you do go back to them, do it over email or in person? Lucas: Email is actually best, because it gives you a paper trail and gives you time to craft your words. You can write a short, polite note that says something like, 'Thanks for the package. I've reviewed it, and I wanted to see if there's any flexibility given my experience and the market.' And then you can attach your market data. That's a lot easier to do in writing than in a face to face meeting. Luna: I love that. And I think people also don't realize that they can negotiate the timeline. Like, asking for an extra week or two of pay — that's often easier for them to say yes to than a bigger lump sum. Lucas: Exactly. And that's a good lead-in to something I want to mention. If you found this conversation helpful — and honestly, if thinking through a career move like this is worth a coffee to you — you can support the show at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small way to keep these episodes free and ad-free, and it genuinely helps us keep doing this. Luna: Yeah, and we always appreciate it. And it's a nice way to say thanks without it being a big deal. Lucas: Right. So back to the strategy. Once you've sent that email, don't just sit there waiting. Even if they say no, you've started a conversation. And that conversation can lead to other things — like a better reference, or a lead on another job, or even a future contract gig. Luna: Oh, that's a good point. Sometimes the severance negotiation can open the door to other opportunities. Like, they might say, 'We can't do more, but we know someone who's hiring.' Lucas: Exactly. And that's another reason to keep it professional and positive. You never know where the next opportunity comes from. But the core message is this: don't leave money on the table just because you're in the middle of a layoff. You have more leverage than you think, and the worst they can say is no. Luna: And if they do say no, you're no worse off than before, right? Lucas: Not at all. You've lost nothing by asking. You might gain a few extra weeks of pay, or a better exit package, or even just the confidence that you stood up for yourself. And that confidence is going to be really valuable in your next job search. Luna: That's a nice way to end. So, to recap: prepare your numbers, frame it as a fair request, be flexible, and don't sign anything immediately. Lucas: That's the whole thing. And if you're in that situation right now, take a breath, open a blank email, and start typing. You might surprise yourself with what you can get.