Latest / Saladin: The Muslim Leader Who Defeated Crusaders — Fexingo History / Saladin's Siege of Kerak 1183 The Battle That Never Happened
Transcript
- Lucas: If you've been stepping into history with us episode by episode, you'll remember we've talked a lot about Saladin's sieges. But there's one siege that historians still call the battle that never happened. Luna: The one at Kerak, right? I've heard the name but never the details. Lucas: Exactly. Kerak — or Krak des Moabites, as the Crusaders called it — was the fortress of Raynald de Châtillon, the lord of Oultrejordain. By 1183, Raynald had become Saladin's most hated enemy. Lucas: Raynald wasn't just a thorn in Saladin's side; he actively broke truces, raided Muslim caravans, and even threatened Mecca. Saladin had sworn to kill him with his own hands. Luna: So this siege was personal. Lucas: Very personal. In the autumn of 1183, Saladin gathered a massive army — according to Baha ad-Din ibn Shaddad, probably around 20,000 men — and marched on Kerak. The castle sat on a high ridge, commanding the trade routes between Syria and Egypt. Lucas: He arrived in late November. The timing was strategic: the harvest was in, so he could feed his army, and he hoped to catch the garrison low on supplies after the summer. Luna: But Kerak was famous for being nearly impregnable. Lucas: It was a monster. The castle had massive double walls, a deep dry moat, and it was built on such steep rock that assaulting directly was almost suicidal. Saladin knew he couldn't storm it quickly. Lucas: So he settled in for a blockade. His engineers set up siege engines — heavy stone-throwing trebuchets that could hurl projectiles over the walls. For weeks, they pounded the fortifications. Luna: Did the defenders have any hope of relief? Lucas: They did. Raynald had sent desperate messages to King Baldwin IV of Jerusalem — the Leper King — and to Guy of Lusignan, who was then regent. Baldwin, despite his illness, mustered a relief army. Lucas: But it wasn't just any relief force. The Crusader army included the Knights Templar, the Hospitallers, and contingents from Antioch and Tripoli. They marched south quickly, knowing that if Kerak fell, all of Oultrejordain would follow. Luna: So Saladin had to decide: keep besieging or face a two-front war. Lucas: Exactly. On December 4th, scouts reported the Crusader army approaching. Saladin held a war council. His commanders were divided. Some wanted to fight the relief army before it arrived, others argued that Kerak was nearly starved and could fall any day. Lucas: But Saladin made a cautious call. He had learned from his earlier failures — like the siege of Mosul — that overextending could be disastrous. He ordered a withdrawal. Luna: He just left? After all that preparation? Lucas: He dismantled the siege engines, burned what he couldn't carry, and retreated toward Damascus. The Crusaders arrived to find an empty field. Some chroniclers say they pursued a little, but mainly they just reinforced the garrison and went home. Lucas: Imad ad-Din al-Isfahani, Saladin's secretary, later wrote that the sultan chose to withdraw because he had 'reached his goal' — he had tested the enemy's strength and avoided a risky battle. But Ibn al-Athir is more critical, suggesting Saladin missed a golden opportunity. Luna: So who was right? Was it a smart retreat or a missed chance? Lucas: Historians still debate it. On one hand, Saladin preserved his army and lived to fight another day — and that day came at Hattin four years later. On the other hand, leaving Kerak intact allowed Raynald to continue his raids, which would eventually provoke the Third Crusade. Luna: And Raynald didn't exactly learn his lesson. Lucas: Not at all. In fact, just a few years later, he captured a huge Muslim caravan, including Saladin's own sister, according to some accounts. That was the final straw that led to the invasion of 1187. Lucas: If today was actually useful to you, the way these stay ad-free is listener support — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Just a small way to keep these deep dives coming. Luna: Yeah, and it really helps. We love doing this, and every coffee makes a difference. Lucas: Now, back to Kerak — what makes this siege so fascinating is not just what happened, but what didn't. Saladin's withdrawal showed his strategic patience, but also his limits. The castle would remain a Crusader stronghold until 1188, when Saladin finally captured it — after Hattin. Luna: So the siege of 1183 was really a dress rehearsal for the final act. Lucas: Exactly. And when Saladin did come back in 1188, he didn't even bother with a long siege. The garrison, knowing the main army was destroyed, surrendered quickly. But that's a story for another episode. Lucas: The Kerak siege of 1183 reveals something important about Saladin's military thinking. He was not a reckless conqueror. He calculated risks carefully. And he understood that sometimes, not fighting is the smarter strategy. Luna: It's almost a lesson in patience — he waited for the right moment, and it paid off at Hattin. Lucas: Exactly. Baha ad-Din wrote that Saladin often said, 'Be patient; victory comes slowly.' The Kerak siege is a perfect example of that philosophy in action. Luna: So what happened to Raynald in the end? We know he was at Hattin. Lucas: He was captured there, and Saladin personally executed him — with his own hand, as he had sworn. It was one of the few killings Saladin carried out personally after a battle. The True Cross, which Raynald had allegedly mocked, was also captured that day. Lucas: So the siege that never happened set the stage for the battle that ended everything. It's one of those 'what if' moments in history that makes you wonder how different things would be if Saladin had pressed harder. Luna: Maybe the Third Crusade wouldn't have happened at all. Lucas: Maybe. Or maybe it would have happened anyway. But that's the great thing about history — we can only follow the threads that actually happened. Lucas: Next time, we'll look at another forgotten siege — this time one that did happen, with a very different outcome. Luna: I'm looking forward to it.