Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Used Cars Get Cheaper, Car Loan Interest Tax Rule Disappoints, FTC Drops Asbury Complaint
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning. It is Wednesday, October 7th. It's the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. It's Kyle Mounts here.
- 0:06Today we're talking about used cars getting cheaper, car loan interest, uh, tax rule disappointing everybody, and the FTC dropping a case against Asbury Automotive.
- 0:16[upbeat music] It's hard to find good news these days, Kyle. Look- I just want you to know that. When I'm looking at stories- But I, I think-... I'm like, "How do I not depress everybody?"...
- 0:24I think normally, normally lower, lower and less is better. Yeah. Like, it, not always, you know, uh, unless you're playing like sports- Unless you're talking about net profit. Right. Right.
- 0:33Net profit in sports is, is, uh, but- Unless golf... like, yeah. Oh, yeah, golf. It's always golf. See? We're playing golf today, fam. Yeah. [laughs] Like the best of them.
- 0:42Golf- That's a dealer sport, you know what I mean? Golf rules. [laughs] Hey, everybody, we have a webinar going on this afternoon. Don't miss it. It's gonna be with our friends at AutoHub.
- 0:50We're gonna be talking about accelerating inventory, how a 16-store group, that's DG DG, super sharp over there, uh, how they built an acquisition process that, uh, didn't, they didn't just try out. It actually worked.
- 1:02Scott Pettit of DG DG is gonna be w- here with us as long, as well as, uh, Dan Goggin of AutoHub. Awesome conversation we're gonna have. You can go to asotu.com, scroll down- Yeah...
- 1:12just a wee bit, click the button, register. So you can either be there in person or you get the recording so you can still catch up on what you missed. Um, always something to learn from our friends at DG DG.
- 1:23Please make sure to do that. Jam on that one. I know. Let's go. We're also, uh, ASOTU CON West is heating up. You're gonna start seeing a lot more about this on the interwebs. But you- Full heating up. Good night...
- 1:30you've been hearing about it already. Um, November 18th, we're gonna be in LA, one-day event. Oh, look at the new graphic. Six weeks to go on the billboard. Ooh. Get on the billboard action. I feel it.
- 1:41We're gonna hit them with that, fam. I wanna see it. But I so badly wanna buy a billboard in LA so when people come in for this, they see that billboard. Just for the heck of it. I know. Well, we'll do that one day.
- 1:49Maybe ASOTU CON this year, we'll, we'll- Maybe someone knows a billboard- We'll pick up one or two-... back there... around, around Baltimore. But, uh- Ooh...
- 1:54you can go to asotuconwest.com to see the full agenda, see all the details. We got some ballers at this event. It's smaller than the other ASOTU CONs, so seats are way more limited.
- 2:03Um, but you will be in the room all day with everybody. We're going through this process together. You get to talk to the speakers, ask them questions, make relationships.
- 2:11Maybe you get their phone number and have a little thought partner for- Maybe... the rest of your career. Maybe. That's the way, that's the way rubbing elbows works, fam.
- 2:18Thanks to our friends at Mia, Plug, and Kirby for being the presenting sponsors of that event. Kyle, we designed the final swag packaging yesterday. Ooh. And, oh, I'm so excited to show you. Oh my goodness.
- 2:29The best piece of swag we're ever gonna give away or we've ever given away so far. We'll top it at some point. But, uh, it's gonna be here.
- 2:35Speaking of people with great swag, today's show is made possible by our friends at Mia, the enterprise AI communication partner trusted by one in four of the top 150 dealer groups- Wow... in the US.
- 2:45Learn more at mia.inc. That's mia.inc. That's a lot. That's a lot of, that's a big percentage, 25%. That's, it is. That's kind of bold. That's, yeah, that's not the lower and less.
- 2:53That's like the more the merrier kind of thing- [laughs]... when you have that 150 groups in your ecosystem.
- 2:57Uh, but speaking of lower and less, used car asking prices are actually lower in October according to oav.io, an automotive data platform that bills itself as the automotive answer engine.
- 3:08Its first weekly national pricing snapshot of, uh, found broad price cuts across more than 1.4 million dealership listings.
- 3:15Average asking prices of used cars fell 2.5% over four weeks comparing vehicles listed on both September 5th, comparing those to October 3rd.
- 3:24OAV found 58% of those vehicles had asking price reductions of more than half a percent. SUVs and EVs saw the a- largest declines at 2.7%, followed by vans at 2.5%, trucks at 2.3%, and cars at 2.2%.
- 3:38Those cars are more in demand it looks like. OAV plans to publish the asking price report weekly.
- 3:43Founder CEO Sky Hallman said for shoppers and dealers alike, that's useful evidence of how actively asking prices are being adjusted. I love that metric. First of all, you gotta go check out oav.io.
- 3:54When we, when I read this story, I check it out just a little bit. It's really cool. They're not sponsoring the show, by the way. This is a- They're not at all. Like, I, I think it's a really cool platform.
- 4:01Like, kudos to them. I don't know when they started this. I, I, I don't really know who-- It looks like they're, it's kind of their own, uh, uh, own thing here. They're probably sitting on top of some other data.
- 4:10Uh, but, but it's just a really cool platform. And as a dealer, you can use it too. Um- That's so fun... but, hey, look, 2%, 2% on like what average used car prices are in, uh, around 40K? Yeah. That's a lot.
- 4:23Like, we're t- we're talking about some, some price gains, uh, and some affordability for, for consumers. So I think you should talk about this.
- 4:30Talk, talk about it to your, um, uh, to your sales staff as they're talking about used cars pricing and affordability with their customers and, and try and find that stuff on the lot that moves a little bit quicker.
- 4:40Speaking of affordability. Stop. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] Dealer and lender groups are jointly, as well as I am too- Hey...
- 4:50disappointed with the final rules for the federal car loan interest deduction, particularly the decision to exclude any interest tied to when you roll negative equity into your new car loan. Uh, the deduction- Oh...
- 5:01applies to qualifying new vehicles with final assembly in the US, capped at 10,000 annually. Benefits reduce once you make, uh, above 100%, or I'm sorry, $100,000 in income for single filers, 200% for joint filers.
- 5:14The IRS and Treasury declined an NADA and American Financial Services Association request to include interest paid on financing the negative equity that's a part of the macro new car loan.
- 5:26Um, nearly 30% of new vehicle purchases with a trade-in included negative equity. We all know this in Q2. Ooh, we know that. Averaging about $6,800 according to Edmunds.
- 5:36Um, the AFSA, the American Finance whatever we just said, says lenders now have to track- [laughs]... lenders now have to track burdens on them, how much interest is specifically attributable to negative equity.
- 5:48General Counsel Philip Bowie said there's never been a reason to break any of this stuff out before. The deductions has seen relatively limited use so far.
- 5:56Treasury said more than 1.4 million filers claimed it in 2025 with an average deduction of $1,800. But everyone seems disappointed. Yeah. It's comp- They made it, they made it complicated. They made it complicated.
- 6:08$1,800 in deduction isn't gonna move the needle on your tax liability for that year that much. With so many people in negative equity, it's really interesting.
- 6:16I think that putting the onus on the bank, because the bank is the one that reports that interest on new car, uh, there's... I, I can't remember what the form is called- Yeah...
- 6:23but you essentially get that form at the end of the year. Um- And, and having to break out and like, "This is interest attributed to this, this is interest attributed to the primary of the new car loan." Yeah.
- 6:33It's a really, really- Not helpful... interesting... It's, it's not helpful.
- 6:36I'm sure someone's got a little agro- algorithm calculator in the background, but like, uh, you know, this is like one of those woo, aw, you know, moments.
- 6:44Um- Yeah, no, this, you know, this is one of those things where the g- you know, the, the Fed said, "Hey, we're gonna help you out. We're gonna do this thing.
- 6:51We're gonna try to make things more affordable," but here's another th- I, I really think like in the back, you know, you push the glasses up, [laughs] "I have an idea," right?
- 6:57Like, we're gonna do this thing, but most people that make under $100,000 a year don't do deductions anyway. They take the standard deduction- That's right...
- 7:07it's a little more- They don't do deductions, and they definitely don't, like, buy new cars on the regular, right? Um- I mean, not on the regular.
- 7:14They do buy new cars, but it's like, I think it's just literally like, it's a nothing. It's a, it's a- 1.4 million- It's a nothing burger...
- 7:21filers claim the deduction, but I think the number that's probably even lower, maybe you claim the deduction, but did it actually give you money back- Stuck... on your tax return? Yeah. Oh, yeah, yeah. That's right.
- 7:30Right. You can claim it. "Hey," claimed it. Yeah. I, I think it's, it's, you know. Speaking of claiming it and giving it back. Stop. Segway time. [upbeat music] All right.
- 7:39[laughs] Little more government involvement here.
- 7:42So the FTC has officially dismissed its 2024 administrative complaint against Ad- Asbury Automotive Group and three North Texas dealerships, ending that proceeding while reinforcing that auto dealer price transparency remains an enforcement priority.
- 7:56The FTC previously had alleged that three David Mc- David, uh, dealerships- Mm-hmm... charged customers for unwanted add-ons, and that Black and Latino customers paid additional amounts for add-ons.
- 8:06Asbury denied the allegations and sued in federal court, challenging the agency's structure and procedures.
- 8:12The FCC said continuing could mean years of federal litigation before reaching administrative, uh, adjudication, and cited its limited agency resources in dismissing the case.
- 8:22So they're like, "Oh, we're just, we're just, uh-" Oh... "we're not equipped to handle this." They couldn't, couldn't back it up. Uh- Yeah...
- 8:27KPA Chief Legal and Strategy Officer Adam Cowell said he expects the FTC to move away from administrative actions against dealers and instead go directly to federal court. Pretty wild.
- 8:38Despite dismissing the Asbury action, the FTC reiterated its commitment to pursuing price transparency, specifically including automotive dealers. Okay, this is what happens.
- 8:47Now, I, I don't know who did what or who didn't do what. Obviously, what they were accused of is very wrong, right? For sure. That doesn't mean they did it.
- 8:55But it also means that when the FTC puts together fast and sloppy policy, this is exactly what happens, and I'm glad that this is, this is how the legal system works. You have- Yep...
- 9:06sloppy administrative policy, sloppy, um, you know, sloppy execution, then it is, what should happen is that the defense- For sure... should say, "Hold on a second. I don't think so."
- 9:16That's what keeps the system, like, honest. Obviously, the FTC- Checks and balances...
- 9:19understand it was not work, but reiterated the most important part for all of us is that they are still, this doesn't change anything about their pursuit of transparency and pricing, meaning we should, as an industry, it's good.
- 9:32We should pay attention to those. We should comply. It makes it better for anybody. And now they're gonna- If you haven't heard us yet... skip the administrative.
- 9:37Well, they said, "We're gonna skip the administrative part. We're actually just gonna take you right to court." So that's a warning. Straight to, straight to the throat. Yeah.
- 9:43Like, if we haven't said it, if you haven't heard us, get off your hind honchos, check in on your pricing, and stop being stupid. Let's go.
- 9:52I think that's probably the best way to end today's show, right on the 10-minute mark. [laughs] Stop being stupid. Start being smart. Start caring for the people around you. Or keep caring- Come on... not start.
- 10:02Keep caring about the people around you. We'll see you here tomorrow morning, everybody. [upbeat music] Keep dancing. Keep dancing. Keep dancing. And move the right. Keep dancing. Keep dancing. Keep dancing.
- 10:20And move the right.