Latest / The Vegan Report / Inside the Mad World of Meatistan. With John Sanbonmatsu | Ep. 79
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Vegan Report, my name is Ryan
- 0:03and today I am happy to talk with John Sanbonmatsu,
- 0:07the author of the new book, The Omnivore's Deception,
- 0:11which is a fascinating guide into who are the
- 0:15intellectual handmaiden of the animal exploitation
- 0:18world. To put it simply, think the carnest version
- 0:22of Peter Singer or Gary Francione. People like
- 0:26Michael Pollan, and if you don't know who Michael
- 0:29Pollan is, you're in for a surprise. The Omniform
- 0:33Deception is available for order. I highly, highly
- 0:37recommend it. Link in the episode notes. We had
- 0:42the chance to discuss some really interesting
- 0:44passages of the book, like the myth of humane
- 0:48meat, or how farming animals is empowering to
- 0:52women. But first we talked about John's position
- 0:56against cultivated meat. He thinks that cultivated
- 1:00meat is a profound strategic miscalculation for
- 1:04our movement. I had the chance to hear him make
- 1:08the case against cultivated meat in a debate
- 1:11against none other than Léa Garcès, president
- 1:15of Mercy for Animals, and Bruce Friedrich, CEO
- 1:18of the Good Food Institute. And he did that dressed
- 1:23as a pirate. It is an epic debate that deserves
- 1:27a listen, and you are in luck because it is available
- 1:30as a bonus episode of the podcast. You are welcome.
- 1:35And as always, if you want to support a podcast
- 1:39that does not shy away from questioning the status
- 1:42quo and covering the under -reported struggles
- 1:46of this movement, then please share this episode
- 1:49with your fellow vegan. Also, I love to read
- 1:53your good reviews. It is always so encouraging.
- 1:56So feel free to leave a good review. Thank you.
- 2:00So John, welcome to the show. Thank you so much
- 2:03for being here. I'm delighted to be here. You
- 2:06have a great show. Thanks for having me. So I
- 2:09discovered you through the debate you've done
- 2:12about the cultivated meat thing. And I have to
- 2:17say Before hearing you speak, and before talking
- 2:22to Miyoko Shiner a few episodes ago, I thought
- 2:29that cultivated meat was the messiah. I thought
- 2:32that this was the end of the animal rights movement,
- 2:35that it is the solution to every one of our problems
- 2:41and the end of factory farming of slaughterhouses
- 2:44of the whole deal. And you just opened my eyes
- 2:48to the hidden, you know, face of that whole world
- 2:53and the whole push to make it legitimate and
- 2:57make it front and center of the movement. Why
- 3:02have I not ever questioned the narrative that
- 3:08cultivated meat is the answer to all of our questions.
- 3:12It's a really good question. I mean, I think
- 3:14there are a few dimensions to this. One is it's
- 3:17sort of like, why is everybody talking about
- 3:18AI all of a sudden? Why is this technology being
- 3:21shoved down our throats in academia, in industry,
- 3:26in daily life? And it's not because AI is good
- 3:29for us. It's because you have these extremely
- 3:32wealthy, powerful, unscrupulous people, mostly
- 3:36men, billionaires who have decided that they
- 3:41want this because it will make them richer and
- 3:44give them more control. And so it is taking over
- 3:47society. Well, the cellular me technology is
- 3:50not as powerful or hegemonic, but it's coming
- 3:54from the same place of people with a lot of resources
- 3:57and not necessarily the best of intentions who
- 4:02want to make this happen. So that's number one.
- 4:04Number two, though, for those of us in the movement
- 4:07who felt who feel demoralized by the fact that
- 4:11no matter what we do or say, after centuries
- 4:16and even millennia of descent to the animal system,
- 4:22to our violence against animals, after centuries
- 4:25of this resistance, things are worse for animals
- 4:28than ever before. The animals of the earth are
- 4:31being wiped off the face of the earth in the
- 4:34mass extinction crisis. the number of animals
- 4:36being killed every year is increasing. Even the
- 4:39number of animals being consumed or the amount
- 4:42of meat being consumed is growing per capita
- 4:45in the United States and elsewhere. I don't know
- 4:53if you know the expression, a Hail Mary Pass,
- 4:56but it's the idea that, okay, nothing else is
- 4:59going to work, so we're just going to try something
- 5:01completely different. So you have these guys
- 5:04who were part of the animal welfare wing of the
- 5:06movement, particularly Bruce Friedrich, who used
- 5:09to work with PETA, people like Paul Shapiro.
- 5:13So kind of cast -offs of the mainstream animal
- 5:17welfare organizations, the lobbying organizations
- 5:20who've just glommed onto this idea, and they
- 5:23have sold the movement a bill of goods, telling
- 5:27them that, oh, well, this is going to solve the
- 5:29problem. But it isn't going to solve the problem.
- 5:32And it isn't even meant to solve the problem,
- 5:34actually, because the same people who try to
- 5:38tell the animal advocates, oh, well, this is
- 5:41how we're going to get rid of animal agriculture,
- 5:43out of the other side of their mouth, they're
- 5:46telling the animal industry people, the factory
- 5:48farming people, don't you worry. This is only
- 5:51a supplement. to what you already do. We think
- 5:56about the future, we're going to have a diverse
- 5:59protein portfolio that's going to include insects,
- 6:03cellular meat, regenerative animal agriculture,
- 6:08smaller farms, and conventional agriculture,
- 6:12meaning factory farming. So there's just so many
- 6:18problems with this technology and anyone who's
- 6:20interested, I would urge them to go to a website
- 6:22that I curate called cleanmeathoax .com. And
- 6:27I wanna note, just to start to go on this one
- 6:29last thing. Bruce Friedrich, of course, runs
- 6:32the Good Food Institute, which promotes both
- 6:37vegan, plant -based foods, as well as cellular
- 6:39agriculture. And they're bringing in millions
- 6:41of dollars to lobby for this stuff. the cellular
- 6:44meat stuff in particular. And when I and a group
- 6:48of animal rights scholars created this website,
- 6:51cleanmeathoax .com, the Good Food Institute created
- 6:56a fake shadow site called cleanmeathoax .com,
- 7:01but with a slightly different URL to steal traffic
- 7:06from our website and to send it to the Good Food
- 7:10Institute. And what was so striking to me about
- 7:13that is that we were paying like $20 a year for
- 7:17this website or something. And the GFI has millions,
- 7:20tens of millions of dollars. And yet that was
- 7:23such a threat that they did that. And it was
- 7:26only when I threatened to expose this publicly
- 7:29and take the possible legal action that they
- 7:32took that down. But it just goes to show, I mean,
- 7:35this is not... This is a complex thing and an
- 7:39untested technology that many people don't think
- 7:41is even feasible. So there's a lot to be said
- 7:45about it, but it's not good. I mean, how did
- 7:48United Poultry concerns even got Bruce to debate
- 7:54you? That's what I want to know. You know, what
- 7:56was it like? Because that debate was epic. I
- 7:59actually contacted United Poultry concerns and
- 8:03asked them if I could release that. debate as
- 8:06an episode of the of the show. And I think I'll
- 8:10release it at the same time as our episode. But
- 8:13I want to know, you know, what it felt like,
- 8:16what was the tension like in the room? And, you
- 8:19know, do you have any insight on how they were
- 8:23able to bring Bruce, you know, to debate you?
- 8:28You know, to be honest, I was looking at that,
- 8:29I hadn't looked at that debate a long time. And
- 8:31I looked at it again, recently, and I'm a bit,
- 8:33I just, you know, I'm a bit embarrassed because
- 8:35I was so upset. It's interesting. Karen Davis,
- 8:39who of course founded and until tragically she
- 8:43died a couple of years ago, was the director
- 8:45of United Poultry Concerns. She had reached out
- 8:47to me a few years back and said, John, what do
- 8:50you think of this? just in the cellular meat
- 8:54stuff and I didn't know anything about it. So
- 8:55I looked into it briefly and I was so upset by
- 8:58it I wrote her a note and then she published
- 9:00my letter and being Karen she didn't even bother
- 9:03to ask and she just put it in you know the newsletter.
- 9:07And so Karen and Hopa Hanek I think was involved
- 9:11too organized this debate and with Leah Garces
- 9:19from Mercy for Animals, and my friend Vasili
- 9:23Stanescu, who's a wonderful scholar in animal
- 9:26ethics and an expert on animal agriculture. And
- 9:29to answer your question, I don't think Leo or
- 9:35Bruce had ever heard of me. And honestly, they'd
- 9:40never had pushback that I can tell from within
- 9:44the movement. So they weren't expecting anyone
- 9:47to like I don't think they were expecting anyone
- 9:49to really challenge the fundamental premises
- 9:53of what they were doing. That's how I think how
- 9:56that happened. But it makes me so upset even
- 10:01now because, I mean, my God, the violence that
- 10:05we're committing to other animals is so vast.
- 10:08It's really important that we not throw them
- 10:10under the bus. And that's what the GFI, Good
- 10:13Food Institute, has done. Bruce Friedrich has
- 10:16given interviews, like with the New York Times,
- 10:18where he says, we're taking ethics off of the
- 10:21table, quote unquote, when we're going to talk
- 10:24about how delicious meat is and how everybody
- 10:28needs meat, but it just should come from the
- 10:30technology and not from the animals. Well, if
- 10:34you're going to reinforce the dominant narrative
- 10:36that eating flesh, whether it's grown in a laboratory
- 10:41setting, or it's from an animal that's slaughtered,
- 10:44if you're going to reinforce that narrative that
- 10:45it's an eternal, benign commodity, you've given
- 10:51the game away. And also, if you're going to say
- 10:53in the same breath, oh, we're not going to talk
- 10:55about animal ethics anymore. And then if you
- 10:58can even go further and make fun of vegetarians,
- 11:00which is what these people also do, because they're
- 11:03trying to appeal to the mob, which is the same,
- 11:06to meat eaters. So we can all poke fun at those
- 11:08pesky vegans by telling you, here's clean meat.
- 11:13Here's meat that's sustainable. Here's meat that's
- 11:18healthier for you, meaning, you know, cellular
- 11:22meat. And you don't have to change your behavior.
- 11:25You don't have to question human domination over
- 11:28nature and animals. You can just keep doing what
- 11:30you're doing and just have another delicious
- 11:32commodity. And we just know that that's just
- 11:35not going to work. In my view, anyway. Yeah.
- 11:38Yeah, I mean, the more I learn about this movement,
- 11:42the more I meet people and see how many initiatives
- 11:46exist out there that are dying to get resources
- 11:50and funding that could do so much good. And to
- 11:54see that all of those resources and funding are
- 11:57going to this you know, Frankenstein situation.
- 12:02It also makes me a bit mad, I have to say. How
- 12:07do you explain that there is a lack of debate
- 12:10in the animal rights movement? Because I think
- 12:13that I've come across just this once debate,
- 12:18you know, on the appropriate strategy going forward.
- 12:23I've organized a debate myself. uh called you
- 12:27know i think can we do better or something like
- 12:29that but i don't know of any other you know debate
- 12:34that gathers different activists and we're just
- 12:38there talking about what is the the right way
- 12:41forward wow so yeah you're asking such important
- 12:45questions i mean my first book uh which was called
- 12:48the postmodern prince really looked at the crisis
- 12:50of left intellectual thought and you know i went
- 12:52to grad school in the 90s, because I just didn't
- 12:56understand why things always seem to get worse
- 12:58all the time. And that the left is just completely
- 13:02disorganized and marching in circles and preaching
- 13:05to the choir and all of that. So in my first
- 13:09book, I was trying to understand that. So there's,
- 13:13first of all, that context, which is social movements
- 13:17and the question of praxis or theoretically informed
- 13:20collective action, how we go about changing the
- 13:23world? It's as simple as that. And what are the
- 13:26cultural forces and economic forces that get
- 13:28in the way of our having an effective activism?
- 13:32Because we're really trying to change the whole
- 13:33civilization. We're trying to change the norms
- 13:36and values and social practices and institutions
- 13:39that give rise to these problems of domination
- 13:45and violence. But there's another part, and it's
- 13:50related, but there's a part of this which has
- 13:51to do with capitalism and money. I mean, the
- 13:54reason that so many grassroots movements or organizations
- 13:58are struggling is they're being starved of funds
- 14:01by effective altruists. So effective altruism
- 14:05is this philanthropic movement that's been inspired
- 14:08by Peter Singer's brand of utilitarianism. And
- 14:13the effective altruists, well, who are they?
- 14:14Well, they're Tony professors at elite institutions
- 14:17and backed by billionaires. So the billionaires
- 14:22are on board with this. Sam Bankman Fried, of
- 14:24course, is now in federal prison for... his role
- 14:28in the effective altruism movement. These people
- 14:31are dangerous and they're not just dangerous,
- 14:34they're destroying the animal justice movement.
- 14:37I've spoken to several people in the movement,
- 14:41activists who run nonprofits, and they say the
- 14:44same thing, which there's this kind of McCarthyist
- 14:47chilling atmosphere in animal advocacy. because
- 14:52people at the grassroots understand that the
- 14:55effective altruists have all the money, and they
- 14:58have the power, and they can and do act as kingmakers
- 15:02to decide who gets to live and who gets to not
- 15:05live in the movement, I mean, in terms of resource
- 15:09allocation. So this is a serious problem, and
- 15:13it's just not spoken about. I haven't seen any
- 15:15press coverage about it. Why? Because the nonprofit
- 15:19leaders I've spoken to are afraid. that what
- 15:23little money that they can scrounge will be taken
- 15:26away from them. There are a whole lot of strings
- 15:29that get attached to the effect of altruism money.
- 15:33They're basically not abolitionists. They're
- 15:36welfareists. They're pro -capitalism, explicitly
- 15:41pro -capitalism. You've got to understand open
- 15:43philanthropy, which gives a lot of money to critique
- 15:48of animal agriculture and so forth. they are
- 15:54very clear they're pro -growth, pro -neoliberalism
- 15:57really is the only word for it. So there's a
- 16:00disconnect between the message of open philanthropy
- 16:05and effective altruism, of the joys of the free
- 16:09market and blah, blah, blah. And then the fact
- 16:11that the entire terrestrial food web is shutting
- 16:14down and we're in the middle of an ecological
- 16:16collapse deepening every day because of the free
- 16:19market, complete disjuncture. So again, it isn't.
- 16:26And I think for hardworking people who volunteer
- 16:29with animal groups and struggling nonprofits,
- 16:32what can they do to resist this? And I think
- 16:36ultimately it's that we need to call this stuff
- 16:39out and form alliances with other movements and
- 16:43outside the animal movement too to chip away
- 16:46at capitalism because this system is anathema,
- 16:51it's inimical to animal interests, the capitalist
- 16:55system. And that's just one example. Well, let
- 16:57me push back a little on the capitalism thing.
- 17:01Don't you think that the problem really here
- 17:07is not free markets, but the opposite the monopolies,
- 17:13the, you know, you talked about neoliberalism,
- 17:15but the governments, you know, being weaponized
- 17:19by corporations. You know, if I talk to someone
- 17:23who believes in free market, like a libertarian,
- 17:27this is not the different the definition of capitalism.
- 17:31Well, I mean, you know, I think that Marx Karl
- 17:35Marx laid this to rest 150 years ago. Because,
- 17:39you know, Marx pointed out that so called free
- 17:42markets, that's what people call them then to
- 17:44laissez faire economics and so forth. he pointed
- 17:46out that it's simply part of the DNA of capitalism
- 17:49to create larger and larger monopolies. So the
- 17:54idea is you start with free competition, right?
- 17:56You know, this group, this company competes with
- 17:59this one, and somehow everybody, you just have
- 18:01multiple small companies all giving the consumer
- 18:04better choices and blah, blah, blah. That isn't,
- 18:07we know just empirically that's false, okay?
- 18:09That what happens is the bigger a company gets
- 18:12because of competition, The more powerful it
- 18:15gets, and it gobbles up another company and another
- 18:18company. And so, in my classes, I show a chart
- 18:21of this process of mergers and acquisitions and
- 18:25monopolization. And you see this in every industry.
- 18:28You see this in the media industry, entertainment.
- 18:30You see this in the defense or military industry.
- 18:33You see this certainly in the animal industry.
- 18:36You see this in the newspaper industry, et cetera,
- 18:38et cetera. People chart this out, economists,
- 18:42right? You start with 100 different competing
- 18:44companies in the 1980s, and then by the 90s,
- 18:47there are like 50, and then by the 2000s, there
- 18:50are 12, and now, right? So that they're just
- 18:53a hand, it's like publishing, right? I mean,
- 18:56Penguin Books is now owned by, I don't even know,
- 18:59if you look, it's like Penguin Random House Knopf,
- 19:02it's like one gigantic company. And so what does
- 19:04that mean? It means that you're seeing a homogenization
- 19:07of information and literature, just in publishing,
- 19:10where the people who get published are celebrities,
- 19:13you know, YouTube influencers, books are becoming
- 19:16shorter and shorter, as the attention span of
- 19:20the public gets attenuated through digital capitalism
- 19:23and da da da da da. So the idea that capitalism
- 19:28can be regulated and controlled and made into
- 19:31a benign thing, I mean, you know, after five
- 19:34centuries of the system, it's not like we don't
- 19:38have something to look at. And what we can look
- 19:40at is the way it actually functions, not the
- 19:42idealized version. Of course, I mean, this is
- 19:45the standard thing, going back to the founding
- 19:48of what we call political economy, which is the
- 19:50way that pro -capitalist economists depict how
- 19:55capitalism works. There's always an idealized
- 20:00the chemist and the economist in the lifeboat.
- 20:03You ever heard that story? No, never. Well, it's
- 20:06worth listening to very briefly. So there's an
- 20:08economist, a chemist, and a physicist in a lifeboat.
- 20:13And it's been shipwrecked, but they're just in
- 20:15the ocean. And they have all these cans of food,
- 20:18but they have no way to open them, open the cans.
- 20:21So the physicist says, OK, well, she takes off
- 20:25her glasses and focuses the sun's rays and when
- 20:28the can explains it by focusing the energy on
- 20:31the can, it'll build up and then the can will
- 20:34explode and they'll be able to eat the food.
- 20:36So they try that for a while, it's clear that's
- 20:38never gonna work. So the chemist says, okay,
- 20:40I'm gonna, we take the can and we'll put it outside
- 20:43the boat in the water and the salt will lead
- 20:47to rust and then it'll weaken the metal and we'll
- 20:50get the food. So they try that, clearly it would
- 20:53take like 50 years. So then they turn to the
- 20:56economist, and the economist says, first, assume
- 21:00a can opener. Yeah, sure. If you had a can opener,
- 21:06then you could open up the cans, but you don't
- 21:08have a can opener. So, you know, bourgeois political
- 21:11economists always assume that there's a can opener.
- 21:14In other words, if you make certain assumptions,
- 21:17yeah, capitalism and the free market all works
- 21:19out well. But no, and actually, because the whole
- 21:22system depends on a division of labor where one
- 21:25group of people is able to control the labor
- 21:29and the means of life of 90 % of the other people
- 21:33who don't have property. So that is just the
- 21:37nature of the system. And I understand people
- 21:39who might be listening to us who think, oh, this
- 21:41guy is just some radical nutcase. I just want
- 21:44to be clear. I'm not saying I'm not a radical
- 21:46nutcase. But I've come to these ideas, honestly
- 21:50enough, from someone who, of course, like everybody,
- 21:53was pro -capitalist and believed all these myths
- 21:55about the market. But honestly, if you look into
- 21:59it and you study it, it's just a lot of hooey.
- 22:02Let me give you one example, which is vegan food
- 22:05products. You think, well, the free market is
- 22:08creating impossible burgers and beyond meat.
- 22:13And that's true. But for every vegan product
- 22:15that it produces, it produces 100 new animal
- 22:18products. So now you can get bacon flavored potato
- 22:21chips, and you can get this and you can get that.
- 22:23And there's something even worse, which is what
- 22:25the capitalist system says, is that all of these
- 22:27commodities are equal in status. Everybody has
- 22:31a right to their bacon and to their vegan burger.
- 22:35You know, the market doesn't care. And so the
- 22:38message that the consumer gets is, you know,
- 22:41who cares? Do what you want to do. Fulfill your
- 22:46heart's desire. And that's why cellular meat
- 22:48will never outcompete meat from living animals,
- 22:51because the meat from the living animal is perceived
- 22:54and marketed as authentic, as real. And people,
- 22:57if they have the choice between something that's
- 22:59real and something that they perceive as fake,
- 23:01guess what? They'll even pay a little more for
- 23:03it, if necessary, to get the authentic thing.
- 23:05So again, I mean, I go on and on about this,
- 23:08but capitalism is absolutely, in my view, it's
- 23:12contrary to animal interests, like it in every
- 23:15possible way. You reminded me of my economy classes
- 23:19in college, they would always say that Latin
- 23:22phrase, citrus paribus, you know, so in this
- 23:29imaginary ideal world, this is how things would
- 23:32work. So yes, you're right about that. Let me
- 23:37mention something that is very much covered in
- 23:41the vegan community, which is how conservative
- 23:45states in the US respond to cultivated meat.
- 23:49And they often will ban, you know, cultivated
- 23:54meat from being available in their state. And
- 23:57this is often presented as You see, if this was
- 24:01not threatening animal agriculture, as we know
- 24:05it animal exploitation, then they would not try
- 24:08to ban our products from their state. What do
- 24:12you make of that claim? I don't think Yeah, it's
- 24:15a really interesting question. I don't like when
- 24:18Ron DeSantis issued an actual government an order
- 24:22from the government's office, accusing a the
- 24:26global elite of trying to force people in Florida
- 24:30to eat insects and cellular meat. He has this
- 24:35conspiracy theory about a liberal elite trying
- 24:40to do away with animal agriculture, which is
- 24:44of course funny, but also ridiculous. This is
- 24:49my reading of it. My reading of it is not that
- 24:52they're taking this stance. It's true that maybe
- 24:54some of them do think this is potentially a threat
- 24:56to live animal farming. I grant that point. But
- 25:01honestly, what I really think it is, is that
- 25:06any technology or any sensibility that rakes
- 25:11with the dominant narrative about animals and
- 25:15meat and our natural right to exploit them is
- 25:20seen as a threat. In other words, it's not that
- 25:23cellular meat technology is showing so much promise
- 25:27that literally it's going to put animal farmers
- 25:30out of business because that's not true. It's
- 25:33that even to question the self -evident status
- 25:41of meat as a commodity from a living being is
- 25:45a threat. That is true. As I said, in my view,
- 25:51the cellular meat lobby is robbing Peter to pay
- 25:54Paul in the sense that it's often enough throwing
- 25:57ethics out the window and saying, oh, don't worry
- 25:59about the animals. Think about how much healthier
- 26:01this is for you, consumer. But I do grant the
- 26:06point that from the paranoid location of the
- 26:10far right, anything that challenges the standard
- 26:16conventional way we have of thinking about animals
- 26:18in the food economy is perceived as as a threat
- 26:21to be attacked. Well, to be fair, it is not very
- 26:27appetizing, you know, the idea of eating that
- 26:30lab grown meat. I also believe that, you know,
- 26:34normal animal muscles and flesh is not appetizing.
- 26:40But you know, the idea of having something grown
- 26:44in a lab and eating that is just So far away
- 26:49from gastronomy and food culture and all of that
- 26:53Not something I was, you know raised with and
- 26:57that is culturally And you know, we before this
- 27:01conversation we were talking about conservative
- 27:03podcasts Aren't you know those cultivated meat
- 27:08people? Aware that as soon as the their product
- 27:13is available commercially every one of those
- 27:16big platforms and podcasts will take position
- 27:20against them and will do bad PR against them.
- 27:24I don't see Joe Rogan going on on his podcast
- 27:28about how delicious live -grown meat is. I mean,
- 27:32how are they going to win the public with this
- 27:36obstacle in the way? Have they not thought about
- 27:39that? Well, on the one hand, it's amazing what
- 27:44a powerful corporation and powerful economic
- 27:47interests can do to manipulate human mass psychology,
- 27:51and desire, and so forth. So, in theory, you
- 27:56know, if there were major capitalist interests,
- 27:59wanted to convince the public to switch to synthetic
- 28:04meat, you know, they have powerful weapons at
- 28:07their disposal to do that. But the problem is
- 28:09they'd be they'd be on the other hand, they'd
- 28:11be up against centuries and millennia of tradition
- 28:16around meat. And as I say, in my book, meat is
- 28:19not just another commodity, it's very closely
- 28:21tied into all sorts of cultural ideas, including
- 28:24and especially masculinity. You know, eco feminist
- 28:28theorists like Carol Adams, Josephine Donovan,
- 28:31Marty Keele, and others have pointed this out
- 28:33for decades that meat has a gender. strangely,
- 28:38at least meat eating does and it's been seen
- 28:41for centuries that men need to eat more and dead
- 28:44animals than women so they can be strong and
- 28:47still to this day like 80 percent of hunters
- 28:49and fishers are men and men are the guys who
- 28:52fire up the barbecue in the summer and they're
- 28:55not going to be making a tofu quiche in the kitchen
- 28:58because that would be a sign of their femininity
- 29:00and the right wing calls liberals soy boys so
- 29:04they associate veganism with effeminacy. PETA
- 29:10charged back with an advertisement of a woman
- 29:13who was so battered by the sexual pleasure she
- 29:17got from her vegan boyfriend that she was wearing
- 29:20a neck brace and was bruised. Really disgusting
- 29:23misogynistic ad by PETA, by the way. But they
- 29:27were doing that because there's the currency.
- 29:31Women are the common degradation of women is
- 29:33a common currency in our culture. And as people
- 29:38like Carol Adams pointed out for years, that
- 29:40intersects with our degradation of non -human
- 29:43animals. You know, they often overlap, right?
- 29:45So women are degraded by being called bitches
- 29:47and cows and etc. pigs and so forth. And then
- 29:51farmed animals are often feminized. So it's not
- 29:56an accident that the very same moment that right
- 29:58historically that we're seeing the rollback of
- 30:01civil rights, the rollback of rights for gay
- 30:07and non -cisgender people, and this incredible
- 30:12misogyny, that that is all happening during a
- 30:16period of resurgence of meat culture with per
- 30:21capita meat consumption going up. There was just
- 30:24an article in the Atlantic Monthly, I don't know,
- 30:27five weeks ago, called America has stopped, Americans
- 30:31have stopped pretending about meat. And the journalist
- 30:34argued that, you know, there was this moment
- 30:38during COVID when people were eating beyond meat
- 30:40and impossible burgers and stuff. And then that
- 30:44moment kind of went and now meat consumption
- 30:47is the highest it's ever been. It's going up
- 30:50and people just don't give a shit about animals.
- 30:53That's kind of what the, person, the journalist
- 30:56was saying, yeah, people know somehow it's not
- 30:59right, but they sure taste good. So that is that
- 31:04is the cultural moment. But it's again, it's
- 31:06part of a larger shift towards fascism and the
- 31:10decline of liberal democratic institutions in
- 31:13our society, the attack on a free society is
- 31:16bound up with a defense of the animal economy.
- 31:19I've been thinking a lot. um, lately these past
- 31:25few months that, um, the problem here with, um,
- 31:31the problem of animal exploitation comes back
- 31:35to religion. I feel like, and it is weird coming
- 31:38from me since, you know, I platform lots of religious
- 31:42leaders who make the religious argument for going
- 31:45vegan. And I do approve of that and encourage
- 31:49that and supports that effort. But I feel like,
- 31:53you know, historically and philosophically, it
- 31:57all started with religion in a way. And that
- 32:02having made that part of our culture, so humans
- 32:09become have dominion and animals are less than
- 32:13and all of that. Well, you had business interests
- 32:18appearing so merchants or businessmen looking
- 32:23at that and thinking, oh, this is my way in.
- 32:26This is how I can I can exploit that concept.
- 32:29I can exploit those ideas and beliefs then religion
- 32:33has imposed on animals to create factory farms
- 32:38and slaughterhouses and so on. So I feel like
- 32:42this is where the responsibility lies. Not so
- 32:45much on the merchants themselves on you know,
- 32:49their economic system. What do you make of that?
- 32:53Well, you know, there's so many different religions,
- 32:55but certainly, especially monotheistic religion,
- 32:59but not just monotheistic religion. I mean, you
- 33:01know, in Buddhism and Hinduism too, even though
- 33:04vegetarianism is a big deal in both of those
- 33:06traditions, you also find certain ideological
- 33:09conception of animals as degraded and inferior,
- 33:12right, so that you get reincarnated as if you're
- 33:15a bad person, your bad karma. uh as part of the
- 33:18larger cycle you end up being reincarnated as
- 33:21a quote lower animal so those religions also
- 33:23have a problem i grant all of that so uh and
- 33:26but as you said you know there are certainly
- 33:28resources within pretty much every religious
- 33:32tradition that can be used and have been used
- 33:35by some religionists in favor of animal justice
- 33:38and animal rights although the preponderance
- 33:41of the scripture is very much against animal
- 33:44interests but um So that's absolutely right.
- 33:50But I think that what happens when you move to
- 33:56a commodity system, which is what capitalism
- 33:58is, is before, for thousands of years, humans
- 34:02more or less produced what they needed. And by
- 34:05that, I mean to say even, I don't mean that they
- 34:08lived necessarily simply. I don't mean that there
- 34:12weren't differences of wealth. different classes
- 34:16of people, but basically the point of production
- 34:19of animals and other goods was to maintain a
- 34:22certain homeostatic state of a culture, of a
- 34:26civilization, you know, so that you would continue
- 34:29to worship your gods and you would continue to
- 34:32celebrate the harvest. And so it was cyclical,
- 34:34right, cyclical time. You've returned to where
- 34:37you started. That was human culture for thousands
- 34:39of years, right? commodity production does is
- 34:44it basically with capitalism it basically says
- 34:47the the only reason to produce anything is to
- 34:52create value in the form of profit so people
- 34:57have this idea that well the reason that we are
- 35:00raising animals is to feed people nothing could
- 35:02be further from the truth that has nothing to
- 35:04do with it at all i mean except that you for
- 35:08any commodity there has to be a market for it
- 35:11But it doesn't mean that that commodity is even
- 35:13healthy for you, as we know. You can buy tobacco
- 35:17or whatever. So animals are being produced today
- 35:23not to feed people, but in order to create profit.
- 35:27So as long as that is a structural imperative
- 35:31of the system, you're going to continually have
- 35:34the overproduction of animals to achieve that
- 35:38ends. So I totally agree with you that, you know,
- 35:40if we look at the idea of domination, which isn't
- 35:46in every religious tradition, I mean, if you
- 35:48look at indigenous cultures, they didn't have
- 35:50an idea of domination per se, that really is
- 35:53a monotheistic thing that you can trace back
- 35:55to the Old Testament, right? When God gives Moses
- 35:58dominion over everything that crawls and everything
- 36:01that swims and Peter Singer, by the way, in animal
- 36:05liberation, although I'm a critic of Singer's
- 36:07philosophy in a variety of ways, he has a very
- 36:09good chapter in animal liberation called Man's
- 36:11Dominion, where he traces back some of this idea
- 36:14of domination. So I totally agree with you that
- 36:16that's part of it. But today, if you ask a scientist
- 36:21how he or she justifies tormenting some animal
- 36:25in the laboratory, they're not going to say,
- 36:27well, God said I can do it. Instead, they're
- 36:30going to revert to some crude conception of natural
- 36:35supremacy like, well, you know, either that well,
- 36:39it's just, it's other animals eat other animals,
- 36:44and we're just kind of using other animals to
- 36:47and, and other animals are machines, right, which
- 36:52is, which we get that idea of animals as machinic
- 36:55comes from Rene Descartes, chiefly, Francis Bacon
- 36:58in the 17th century. Well, that idea of animals
- 37:02as machines is itself an artifact of capitalist
- 37:04development. No one for thousands of years, even
- 37:08the religionists, they never thought that animals
- 37:10were just stuff, machines. They thought that
- 37:14God had created man, quote unquote, in his image,
- 37:18right? But they also thought that God created
- 37:21in his wisdom all these living beings. And ancient
- 37:25peoples understood that these were beings with
- 37:27consciousness and feelings. They weren't stupid.
- 37:31But by the time we get to early mechanization
- 37:34and then finally industrialization, animals lose
- 37:37a kind of status in capitalist culture where
- 37:39they just become things, commodities. Which isn't
- 37:43to say that they were ever treated well before
- 37:45but now it's worse because if you look at the
- 37:47sheer numbers of animals being exploited It's
- 37:50just you can't we can't even get wrap our minds
- 37:51around it 80 billion Land animals every year
- 37:54and up to almost three trillion marine animals
- 37:57being killed every single year and that's growing
- 38:00Well, why is that that isn't because of Christianity
- 38:03or Buddhism or Islam? That's because of capitalism
- 38:06Yes, I would admit that if you showed Christians
- 38:14from even a hundred years ago, what is what we're
- 38:18doing, what we're up to in terms of animal exploitation,
- 38:21they would be really shocked. I do believe that
- 38:26they would not be, they would not be agreeable
- 38:30with, you know, the ways we, we have brought
- 38:33things, you know, in terms of scale. Yeah. So
- 38:36I do admit that that's true. You mentioned quickly,
- 38:42disbelief that there is a natural hierarchy.
- 38:44And that is something I want to get to get back
- 38:47to because you bring up so many myths that have
- 38:51been built by carnists. But first, you know,
- 38:57let me ask this. What you're saying, you know,
- 39:01about capitalism, about hierarchies and liberal
- 39:09democracies, That should be very appealing to
- 39:13a progressive audience. So why do we have so
- 39:18many progressives right now who are not only,
- 39:22you know, in majority not vegans, but many of
- 39:27them are against veganism and oppose this movement?
- 39:33How do you explain that? Back in 1989, I wrote
- 39:38an article for Z Magazine, a leftist magazine
- 39:42here in the US on animals in the left and why
- 39:45the left ought to care. I'll tell you, when I
- 39:48wrote that, I braced myself for what I thought
- 39:50would be an explosion of outrage by the left.
- 39:54Nothing, because the people on the left care
- 39:57so little about animals. They were like, they
- 40:00shouldn't even read it, let alone care about
- 40:03what I had to say, you know. So, you know, I'm
- 40:07not alone anymore. There are some excellent thinkers
- 40:11in critical animal studies who are Marxists,
- 40:14who are writing on animal issues. My friend Dinesh
- 40:17Wadiwell, Marco Morizzi, an Italian theorist,
- 40:22and so forth. So, there's a lot of work that's
- 40:27being done by leftists on the animal issue, but
- 40:31you're absolutely right that not only are most
- 40:35leftists not vegans, they're actually hostile
- 40:39to anyone who brings it up. Now, okay, so why
- 40:42is that? Well, in the first instance, it's because
- 40:46they're like every other human on the earth,
- 40:48which is that they defend themselves psychologically
- 40:52and existentially against the knowledge of their
- 40:55own complicity and an injustice, and they don't
- 40:57want to confront that. It's cognitive dissonance,
- 41:00because I know these leftists, and they have
- 41:01cats and dogs who they would sacrifice their
- 41:04lives for, some of them. So it's total hypocrisy.
- 41:08But worse than that, it's an ideological bind
- 41:12that they're in. They're not able to see past
- 41:15their own egoistic interests, and they're not
- 41:18able to see that they're behaving in ways that
- 41:22are Surely at odds with the Emancipatory Project,
- 41:26like how can you support enslavement of other
- 41:30beings, torture, killing, violence, degradation?
- 41:35Is that what you mean by socialism? Is that what
- 41:37you mean by feminism? What are you talking about?
- 41:41So on the one hand, leftists are like anyone
- 41:43else. Stupid, I'm sorry if I can say, can I say
- 41:47that on the air? They're ignorant, they deceive
- 41:51themselves, they're in bad faith. Now, I think
- 41:54there is this other dimension to the problem,
- 41:56which is that the left tradition is staunchly
- 41:59humanist. And there's a way in which there's
- 42:05what I would call when others have called Promethean
- 42:07Marxism, which is the idea that nature should
- 42:11be democratized. And so Marx's view of nature
- 42:15really is that it's privatized and that its goods
- 42:18are not being not available to everybody. And
- 42:24Marx actually calls nature, quote, man's inorganic
- 42:27body, unquote, man's inorganic body. In other
- 42:31words, rather than a separation between me and
- 42:34the trees, like that's my body. Well, I mean,
- 42:37that's kind of imperialist, isn't it? And anthropocentric.
- 42:42So you can't get around the anthropocentrism
- 42:45of the left tradition. It's always been there.
- 42:48write the idea that only humans have history,
- 42:51the only only humans have self consciousness,
- 42:53only humans struggle against power and blah,
- 42:57blah, blah. But it's if you examine it, it's
- 43:02a silly position. And again, I do think it, you
- 43:04know, you get the right down to it. And it's
- 43:05simply about privilege and not wanting to confront
- 43:09the facts out of defensiveness. That's what I
- 43:12think. By the way, having those conversations
- 43:14about how You know the world is completely against
- 43:19us makes me feel optimistic weirdly enough not
- 43:22you know glue me because it just I'm in all wonders
- 43:27of the miracle of us being vegan and having Kind
- 43:32of waken up to this reality despite this world
- 43:36being against us okay, a bit of Difficult question
- 43:42I was really curious about your opinion on John
- 43:47Mackey, the founder of Whole Foods. What do you
- 43:51think of him? He's one of the most prominent
- 43:53vegans out there. And he at least labels himself
- 43:59and is perceived, I think, as very much on the
- 44:02progressive left. At the same time, he's at the
- 44:06head of Whole Foods, and he's a billionaire.
- 44:09And, you know, so his, his character intrigues
- 44:13me. What do you make of him? I think he's a,
- 44:16I think he's a person without any moral scruples
- 44:18whatsoever. I'm a very bad person. That's judgmental.
- 44:23I shouldn't say that. Let me just say that he's
- 44:25played a very destructive role in a variety of
- 44:27ways. First of all, he no longer owns, I believe,
- 44:30I don't think he owns Whole Foods. He sold that
- 44:32to Amazon. So Amazon is owned by Jeff Bezos,
- 44:35another billionaire. Mackey, of course, is a
- 44:38union busting pro -capitalist kind of fanatic
- 44:43who wrote a book called Conscious Capitalism,
- 44:45which he had, I remember going into Whole Foods
- 44:47and they were all the Conscious Capitalism books.
- 44:49And so he has this I want to say naive faith
- 44:56in the free market, but it's not so naive, really,
- 45:00because he's a ruthless businessman who is actually
- 45:03one of the largest traffickers in the bodies
- 45:05of animals. I mean, he is part of this myth of
- 45:10the enlightened omnivore. He promoted that. You
- 45:13go to Whole Foods and you see animal compassion,
- 45:16this big sign and the global animal partnership
- 45:20program, which he helped create, which papers
- 45:24over and legitimizes mass violence against animals.
- 45:30I think it's really good that you raised it because
- 45:33there's a certain sense in which we think of
- 45:36politics in identity politics terms. Well, like
- 45:39I'm holier than some of my neighbor because I'm
- 45:41a vegan, and that now I've done my job because
- 45:43I don't eat animals, so I'm a good person. That's
- 45:46just the wrong way I think of it. of looking
- 45:48at the system and how we're going to change it.
- 45:51I don't care if John Mack is a vegan. Why on
- 45:54earth would that matter to me? It doesn't matter
- 45:56to me at all. It matters to me that he's engaging
- 46:01in violence against animals and legitimating
- 46:03that. It matters to me that he's exploiting workers
- 46:08and ruining the environment. That stuff matters
- 46:13to me a great deal. And I think that confusion
- 46:15that people have within the vegan movement, I
- 46:20think the problem with even just talking about
- 46:22veganism in isolation is that it ends up mystifying
- 46:26the social relations that give rise to these
- 46:29institutions. What do I mean by that? I mean
- 46:31that I don't even like to think of myself as
- 46:34a vegan. Now I have been a vegan for over 30
- 46:36years. Is it almost 40 years? I don't know, a
- 46:38long, long time. But really, I'm an animal justice
- 46:43advocate. I'm for animal liberation. When people
- 46:49hear the word vegan, they just think it's another
- 46:53food choice, like being gluten free. They don't
- 46:56think that to be a vegan means to be opposed
- 46:59to animal experimentation, for example. They
- 47:03wouldn't think that, well, since I'm a vegan,
- 47:06I'm against cargill. for destroying the rainforests
- 47:09of Borneo and the habitat of the orangutans.
- 47:13So there's a delinking, right, between the vegan
- 47:18kind of lifestyle movement and ecological politics
- 47:23that would name the destruction of all life on
- 47:27earth by these systems. And it's just so peculiar
- 47:31to me. Like, how can I, why should I care about
- 47:34a pig or a chicken, which I do obviously? and
- 47:37not about the lemurs and the avians who are on
- 47:44the brink of starvation because of global warming,
- 47:47which is a function of the market economy. It's
- 47:49all one totality. I think of our job as really
- 47:55showing that totality to the public, really explaining
- 48:00how it works. Because in my experience, no one
- 48:03in the public realm knows anything about the
- 48:08animal system. I'll tell you, when I was researching
- 48:11and writing this book, which took me a very long
- 48:13time, people would ask me, what's your book about?
- 48:18And I would say, well, it's about our violence
- 48:20against animals. And the look of confusion on
- 48:24their faces, they really, they nodded like, you
- 48:28mean dog abuse? You mean like when people are
- 48:34hoarding animals and they do these undercover
- 48:37rescue? They have no idea that we've organized
- 48:44our entire economy, society, and existential
- 48:48identity around dominating, exploiting, and killing
- 48:52billions, trillions of animals with such insistence
- 48:56that it's destroying the means of life. No idea.
- 49:00So surely that is our job is to say, oh, by the
- 49:03way, take their head and turn and say, hey, look
- 49:07at that. I mean, that's why right? Vegans have
- 49:10a reputation as being proselytizers. You know,
- 49:12how do you know when there's a vegan in the room?
- 49:14Because they'll tell you. But that is our job.
- 49:18It is to try to explain to people what's happening
- 49:20and they don't want to know. Let me get to another
- 49:23sensitive point that you touch on in the book
- 49:26and that truly triggered me, which is the plan
- 49:33to infiltrate the animal rights movement by Big
- 49:37Ag. Can you talk more about that? And also, if
- 49:43Big Ag right now is maybe in this infiltration
- 49:49point, because I do believe, if you're smart,
- 49:52if you're rational, of course, this gigantic,
- 49:57this Titan of wealth will think about ways to
- 50:03destroy your movement because you're a threat.
- 50:05So why wouldn't they not, you know, think about
- 50:08ways to infiltrate your movement? And are they
- 50:12also taking into the equation, this cultivated
- 50:16meat thing, you know, tying, tying it back to
- 50:19the first topic we, we discussed? Well, I don't
- 50:25know about infiltration per se, but there's been
- 50:27a concerted effort for decades within the animal
- 50:30agriculture industry to deflect criticism by
- 50:34environmentalists and by animal rights people.
- 50:38No question about it. It's really worried, right,
- 50:42the animal industry. And this is true of the
- 50:44biotech and animal research industry as well.
- 50:47I mean, they've created what are called astroturf.
- 50:50campaigns, as I say, seemingly grassroots movements
- 50:54to defend consumer rights, but actually their
- 50:57corporate driven efforts to defeat animal rights
- 51:02people who are questioning our torture of animals
- 51:04and laboratories. And so we see the same thing
- 51:07in Big Ag. And one of the strategies I mentioned
- 51:10in the book is the hiring of consultants to create
- 51:18a public perception around animal advocacy in
- 51:23which abolitionists, people who want to shut
- 51:27down the animal system, are positioned in the
- 51:30discourse as crazy radical extremists. And then
- 51:36the industry appeals to the moderate, practical,
- 51:41welfare -oriented people who are given incentives
- 51:44to play along. And we do see this with leading
- 51:47men in the movement who have become openly allied
- 51:55with capitalist industry. For example, Wayne
- 51:57Paselli in his book, The Humane Economy, which
- 52:01argues that capitalism is a wonderful thing for
- 52:03animals and it's going to lead to their liberation.
- 52:08Paul Shapiro, I'd have to look at my book, but
- 52:11there are others who are working with Purdue
- 52:13to create hybrid products that have both animal
- 52:17and vegetable materials in them to blur the distinction
- 52:24between animals and plants and so forth. So James
- 52:28Levesque from Tribe of Heart, the filmmaker,
- 52:33had an article many years ago about invasion
- 52:37of the body snatchers. You can Google that and
- 52:39you can see how the industry maneuvered to isolate
- 52:47ethically oriented vegans and justice people
- 52:51by presenting them as fanatics. And now that
- 52:55has become taken up by the capitalist state,
- 52:58so that the United States has all of these laws.
- 53:02After the 9 -11 attacks, Congress passed the
- 53:06Animal Enterprise Terrorism Act, which in its
- 53:09first iteration basically said that if you even
- 53:13did nonviolent civil disobedience to stop pigs,
- 53:17say, from being taken out of a facility. You
- 53:19could be charged as a terrorist under US federal
- 53:23law and sentenced to prison for 20 years. So
- 53:26the state, we think of the state, the government
- 53:29as neutral. It isn't a neutral thing. It's very
- 53:33much influenced by business, by big corporations,
- 53:37right? So the FBI certainly has persecuted and
- 53:43indeed, no doubt infiltrated, I'll say that,
- 53:47infiltrated animal movements to try to survey
- 53:53them and disrupt them. My friend Laura Donna
- 53:58Loy, who is a sociologist, is doing some kind
- 54:02of cutting edge research on how the cattle industry
- 54:06manipulated the public and hid the facts that
- 54:13they were themselves discovering about climate
- 54:15change and animal agriculture. That link, Jeremy
- 54:20Rifkin has done work on this too. So there's
- 54:22a lot on this. So there's no question that when
- 54:25you're talking about a billion dollar, multi
- 54:28-billion dollar industry and the government in
- 54:31cahoots with it, passing ag -gag laws, in other
- 54:34words, criminalizing undercover investigations
- 54:36of animal agriculture, that's not an accident
- 54:39that people in that are being demonized in the
- 54:43movement as a threat to society. Yeah, why is
- 54:48the FBI attending big ag conferences? Why, you
- 54:53know, and we can't, we can see footage of that
- 54:56of those conferences, transcripts of what was
- 55:00said in those rooms. It's all kept hidden. Weird.
- 55:07I do want to say that, yeah, and it isn't even
- 55:10just economic interests. It's tied in with a
- 55:13certain conception of masculinity, right? So
- 55:15a lot of people in law enforcement, particularly
- 55:17men, are hunters and fishers. And they identify
- 55:21with a kind of a grieved white rural masculine
- 55:24project. So again, they're not ideologically
- 55:29neutral. They're not just police officers or
- 55:32part of law enforcement, they have their own
- 55:35identities as human beings. And that identity
- 55:39is more and more tied to masculine aggression
- 55:42against immigrants, against women, against animals
- 55:48and against those who sympathize with those groups.
- 55:52Yeah, since, you know, reading about that, you
- 55:57know, the the article and also that passage in
- 56:03your book, I can't help being a bit paranoid
- 56:07in thinking, you know, if I was big ag and if
- 56:10I wanted to infiltrate this movement or derail
- 56:13this movement, how would I go about it? That's
- 56:18a weird reflection to have, but yeah, I can't
- 56:21help it. It's in a way very interesting intellectually
- 56:24to think about it. Okay, I want to get to the
- 56:30different myths that your book addresses, and
- 56:35I just love it so much. I think it's my favorite
- 56:39parts of your book. You talking about those myths
- 56:44and then dismantling them. I just absolutely
- 56:48love that. And let's start with one that just
- 56:52gets under my skin every time, which is look
- 56:55-a -verism. I think I'm pronouncing it. right?
- 56:59Um, what is that about? And why is it wrong?
- 57:07So local vorvism is a is a movement that began
- 57:102005, there were four young women in the San
- 57:14Francisco Bay Area who coined that term. And
- 57:17on the face of it, it's it's harmless and even
- 57:20admirable. It's the idea that by eating locally
- 57:23grown foods, We keep resources in our community.
- 57:28We encourage maybe organic or less ecologically
- 57:32damaging modes of food production. We eliminate,
- 57:37quote, food miles. So if I eat a tomato, I'm
- 57:40getting it from my local neighbor. I'm not getting
- 57:43it from Nebraska shipped in a refrigerated truck
- 57:471 ,000 miles and so forth. And that movement,
- 57:51the local vorism. kind of dovetailed with a resurgence
- 57:54of agrarianism and the idealization of farmers
- 57:58as being, you know, virtuous and close to the
- 58:01earth and that, you know, farms and consumers,
- 58:06farmers need to be in closer contact with consumers
- 58:09and so on. And so it was in 2006 that Michael
- 58:13Pollan wrote The Omnivore's Dilemma, published
- 58:16that huge bestseller, one of the most influential
- 58:18books really of the late 20th century in America.
- 58:23and consolidating this. Now, he didn't use the
- 58:25word local war in his book, but it was kind of
- 58:28implicit that it's better to have local stuff
- 58:34and to not rely on big agribusiness. Now, I go
- 58:38into great length in this book about why this
- 58:40whole thing is ridiculous. It's the Latin that
- 58:45you quoted from your economics class earlier.
- 58:48Yeah, if all things were equal, then sure, you
- 58:52know, it's better for me to eat a tomato that
- 58:54I just grew than to get one from Florida. Yeah,
- 58:58yeah, that's true. But I can't grow oranges in
- 59:03my backyard. So I'm going to have to get some
- 59:06things from outside my area and that's actually
- 59:10just called trade right and humans have been
- 59:12trading across continents for thousands of years
- 59:15that's simply the way the economy works and now
- 59:18never more so than under capitalist relations
- 59:20when we live in a global economy where production
- 59:24is by nature distributed geographically and the
- 59:30thing is it's like The myth of food miles, for
- 59:33example. Yeah, if all things are equal, then
- 59:37I should get the tomato from my farmer's market.
- 59:41But in fact, we know that most of the resources
- 59:43that are consumed, that are applied in food production,
- 59:48or that are related to food, are at the point
- 59:51of production, not transportation. So first of
- 59:55all, that idea of food miles has been more or
- 59:57less debunked. Second of all, the locavore movement
- 1:00:00from the beginning was very animal -centric.
- 1:00:04It was very much about rebranding animal products
- 1:00:08as benign commodities, as nice to the animals,
- 1:00:11as a way to achieve a form of authenticity so
- 1:00:15you could kill the animal yourself and feel like
- 1:00:19you were not being hypocritical and you were
- 1:00:22participating in the great cycle of life. Namaste
- 1:00:27to the animal. I've actually sat down with people
- 1:00:30who've said a prayer to the chicken at the steakhouse
- 1:00:33before they eat the chicken, thanking the chicken
- 1:00:35for its sacrifice. Well, all of that comes out
- 1:00:39of this moment. of, quote, locovorism and omnivorism.
- 1:00:45So there's this huge cultural production. And
- 1:00:48it's really important to understand that systems
- 1:00:50of power don't get established once and done.
- 1:00:53It's not once and for all. You set up slavery.
- 1:00:56You set up patriarchy. And then that The thing
- 1:00:58just runs on its own. That is never the case.
- 1:01:01And same with the animal system. At every moment,
- 1:01:03it must be continually reinforced and reinforced
- 1:01:06and reinforced. All of the lies, all the myths,
- 1:01:09all the self -deception, all of that has to be
- 1:01:12reiterated again and again. And then as people
- 1:01:15say in the animal movement, the environmental
- 1:01:18movement, begin to criticize aspects of that,
- 1:01:22it has to be adjusted. All the little messaging
- 1:01:25has to be adjusted. It has to be, you have to
- 1:01:27have new narratives, new stories, new tropes
- 1:01:29to justify the unjustifiable. So the one -two
- 1:01:37punch, the one -two punch as it were of Michael
- 1:01:39Pollan's omnivores dilemma followed the following,
- 1:01:42the next year by Barbara Kingsolver's book, Animal
- 1:01:45Vegetable Miracle. which is an account of her
- 1:01:48family raising animals on an organic farm. Those
- 1:01:51two national bestsellers have been, really I
- 1:01:55can't exaggerate, their cultural influence. I
- 1:01:59mean, Michael Pollan, it's funny. I just got
- 1:02:02a note from a friend of mine who is an animal
- 1:02:05advocate in the United Kingdom. And he was at
- 1:02:10a nature preserve. in England the other day and
- 1:02:14he came across this sign. He took a picture of
- 1:02:16it and it was something about getting along with
- 1:02:19animals and nature and then there was a long
- 1:02:23quote from Michael Pollan. Michael Pollan is
- 1:02:26the patron saint of animal agriculture and he's
- 1:02:30done enormous damage. I mean his book is even
- 1:02:33part of the state mandated curriculum in middle
- 1:02:35schools and high schools in different states
- 1:02:38around the United States. And his book is taught
- 1:02:42at every educational level. Little kids are reading
- 1:02:45it, graduate students, PhD researchers, because
- 1:02:51he's telling the public what they want to hear,
- 1:02:53which is that we can have our meat and our conscience
- 1:02:55too. So my book is an attempt to take all that
- 1:03:00down piece by piece. Yeah, your book is this
- 1:03:04counter book to all of that. I'm sorry for my
- 1:03:11language, but bullshit. I ask people to support
- 1:03:19your book just for that reason and to also make
- 1:03:23this book available in public library. This is
- 1:03:27something I try to emphasize. You can purchase
- 1:03:32more than one copy and then give it as a donation
- 1:03:36to public libraries. Make it available to everyone,
- 1:03:40not just yourself. There are also those boxes
- 1:03:44that you find outside with book donations and
- 1:03:51stuff. You can add them there. So yeah, it is
- 1:03:55important to do our share of counteracting this.
- 1:04:01culture of exploiting animals. Do you want to
- 1:04:05maybe discuss humane meat because it's the center
- 1:04:11of Poland's book and contribution to this industry.
- 1:04:23So there is this anime where there are those
- 1:04:29demons who feed on the brains of humans. And
- 1:04:34because they want smart, happy humans, they need
- 1:04:40to create the best conditions to harvest those
- 1:04:44brains. And so there's a system of farms and
- 1:04:48in those farms, those children are stimulated,
- 1:04:51you know, they are given so much, you know, woods
- 1:04:55to play and all of that. And that's what I think
- 1:04:58about when I think about humane meat. And I don't
- 1:05:02understand how carnists cannot just feel like
- 1:05:07this is weird and spooky. This this whole concept
- 1:05:12of humane meat. I personally feel more freaked
- 1:05:18out by this label than you know, the usual meat.
- 1:05:23It's it's it's this idea of humane meat is pivotal.
- 1:05:28I really think it's pivotal to the whole legitimation
- 1:05:31of the larger system, right? I mean, so that
- 1:05:34so what happens is if you know, people who think
- 1:05:38that there's such a thing as humane animal agriculture
- 1:05:41or fishing, it gives them an opportunity to distance
- 1:05:45themselves psychically from so -called bad meat
- 1:05:49and bad fishing. And so that in their heart of
- 1:05:53hearts, if they could do it, they would always
- 1:05:56get their meat humanely killed, et cetera. uh
- 1:06:01so it gives them gives the consumer kind of out
- 1:06:03gives them a loophole to continue to participate
- 1:06:06in behaviors that are supporting uh factory farms
- 1:06:11too so it plays this very important psychological
- 1:06:14role the very notion of humane meat right it
- 1:06:17it it hides the animal or what carol adams calls
- 1:06:20the absent reference in other words we we would
- 1:06:23never say happy violence Yes, I'm in favor of
- 1:06:29humane violence. I'm in favor of humane exploitation.
- 1:06:34I'm in favor of humane destruction of animals.
- 1:06:38People would look at you like you were like a
- 1:06:40psychopath, which is really what is at stake.
- 1:06:42And I argue in my book that the way we treat
- 1:06:45other animals as a society is psychopathic. Because
- 1:06:50clinically, Clinical psychopaths lack empathy.
- 1:06:53They lack sympathy. They lack remorse. They believe
- 1:06:57that they have a right to their own aggression
- 1:07:00towards others. And that just check through the
- 1:07:03boxes, the test for antisocial personality disorder.
- 1:07:10And that fits us to a T. So this discourse of
- 1:07:15humane meat is doing enormous damage. And the
- 1:07:18reason it's doing damage is not only because
- 1:07:20it's a lie, because actually there have been
- 1:07:22exposés of what happens on these so -called humane
- 1:07:25farms, animals being gassed to death and suffering
- 1:07:30horribly on organic farms and gas chambers, animals
- 1:07:34being brutalized on these farms. But more importantly,
- 1:07:39I think it provides a smokescreen. Because as
- 1:07:44long as the public thinks, well, there's bad
- 1:07:47meat. But there's also good meat Then they can
- 1:07:51maintain the illusion That the animal economy
- 1:07:55as a whole is getting better and better or every
- 1:07:57time all the time. We're making progress And
- 1:08:01that in their heart of hearts, they're really
- 1:08:02good people because they would prefer the humane
- 1:08:05stuff when they could get it But of course, it's
- 1:08:07too expensive and plus my kids are hungry. So
- 1:08:10we're gonna stop at McDonald's So there's no
- 1:08:12work being done. There's no and this is why I'm
- 1:08:14against animal welfare ism which is the idea
- 1:08:17that, well, we just need to improve the conditions
- 1:08:21in which animals are raised. The public has yet
- 1:08:24to hear a compelling case for abolition. And
- 1:08:27that's one reason I wrote this book, because
- 1:08:29in my experience, people, first of all, people
- 1:08:34identify animal rights exclusively with one organization,
- 1:08:38which is PETA. Well, animal advocacy precedes
- 1:08:42PETA. by centuries. They were vegans, Buddhist
- 1:08:47vegans, a thousand years ago. So that's number
- 1:08:52one. And number two, the way that the cultural
- 1:08:58forces are rallying the wagons, circling the
- 1:09:02wagons to defend against the knowledge of what
- 1:09:06we do is It's not something that people are even
- 1:09:12aware of. And so I wrote this book to try to
- 1:09:15say, hey, you're enmeshed in a system of deception
- 1:09:19without even knowing it. So the title of my book,
- 1:09:22The Omniverse Deception, is actually about three
- 1:09:25modes of deception when I think about it. One
- 1:09:28is just the way the animal industry, restaurants,
- 1:09:31and farmers, and cattle ranchers, they all are
- 1:09:34deceiving the public about what they do. and
- 1:09:36what they are actually doing is engaged in enslavement,
- 1:09:39exploitation, and mass violence. The second mode
- 1:09:42of deception, which is the newer one that we're
- 1:09:44just talking about, is the local vorism enlightened
- 1:09:48omnibor discourse, which tells us that there
- 1:09:51are two kinds of agriculture, good, mean, unsustainable,
- 1:09:57and then, I'm sorry, bad, unsustainable, and
- 1:10:01so forth. And then there's the good form of agriculture,
- 1:10:05happy meat, compassionate killing. Not true.
- 1:10:09And then finally, there's self -deception. I
- 1:10:13begin the book with a quote from Herman Melville's
- 1:10:17novel, Moby Dick, because it's this wonderful
- 1:10:22quote where the narrator Ishmael is talking about
- 1:10:25how if I'm involved in some matter, and I know
- 1:10:32deep down it's not right, I hide that truth from
- 1:10:34myself. And that's what the philosopher Jean
- 1:10:37-Paul Sartre called bad faith. It's like, because
- 1:10:42if I confronted something that I know is bad,
- 1:10:45that I'm doing, then I would have to take responsibility
- 1:10:48for my freedom, for who I am, for the choices
- 1:10:52I make. So instead I pretend I'm not doing what
- 1:10:55I'm doing. And so the consumer can think, Oh,
- 1:11:00well, I, again, I'm a guy can pat myself on the
- 1:11:02back. I'm a good person. I don't I don't hate
- 1:11:04animals. I don't want to hurt animals. Well,
- 1:11:08while continuing to harm animals, and in fact,
- 1:11:11treat them with a kind of contempt for their
- 1:11:14very lives. Yeah, freaky. It is freaky. It's
- 1:11:17like a like they're playing a magic trick on
- 1:11:22you on on society as a whole. Okay, quickly.
- 1:11:28Um, and this is maybe one of the most shocking,
- 1:11:32um, myth you, um, uncovered this belief that
- 1:11:36they have, uh, which is that animal exploitation
- 1:11:40is female female empowerment. Now this, you know,
- 1:11:45this took me a while to wrap my mind around this,
- 1:11:48you know, how did they come up with that? Um,
- 1:11:52can you say a few words about that? So for about
- 1:11:5720 years, I've been tracking this in the media,
- 1:12:00maybe 15 years. And it's quite striking. I mean,
- 1:12:03on the one hand, the animal industry is patriarchal
- 1:12:07in structure, in origin. It's men who control
- 1:12:11these industries. It's men primarily who hunt
- 1:12:14and fish. Masculinity is really tied in closely
- 1:12:18with domination of animals. So it was very odd
- 1:12:20to see that there are dozens and dozens of women
- 1:12:23who maybe hundreds, who have been giving up well
- 1:12:27-paying jobs in the city to buy animal farms
- 1:12:31or to take up hunting. And then in dozens of
- 1:12:35cases, writing memoirs about their experiences
- 1:12:38hurting animals, dominating, controlling, hurting,
- 1:12:42killing animals as a form of empowerment, self
- 1:12:45-empowerment. In, I think it was 2010, the New
- 1:12:50York Times journalist Peggy Orenstein wrote an
- 1:12:53article in the magazine section referring to
- 1:12:57these women as, quote, Femivores. And the title
- 1:13:00of the article was the Femivores Dilemma. It's
- 1:13:04like, well, why are women taking up the gun and
- 1:13:08the knife against animals and justifying that
- 1:13:11as a form of empowerment, and even in some cases
- 1:13:13as, quote, feminist empowerment. So I read, unfortunately,
- 1:13:19I forced myself to read dozens of these books.
- 1:13:22And by the way, these are not marginal books.
- 1:13:25If my book has half the success of any one of
- 1:13:28these books, I will consider myself fortunate.
- 1:13:31These books are published by the top presses
- 1:13:34in the United States, the biggest publishing
- 1:13:36houses out of New York. They're read by millions
- 1:13:38of people, mostly women. around the country.
- 1:13:41So what is this about? And I come, you know,
- 1:13:43having thought about this, I go into this in
- 1:13:45great depth, as you know, I, you know, I have
- 1:13:48two kind of theories. And one of them has to
- 1:13:50do with what happened to the women's movement
- 1:13:53and the fact that, you know, the early promises
- 1:13:56of the second wave feminist movement, particularly
- 1:13:58for white women, were frustrated, have been frustrated.
- 1:14:01I mean, right, so you're seeing a rollback of
- 1:14:03women's equality. And so this is a way for some
- 1:14:06women to feel like of feeling a sense of power,
- 1:14:10but power over others, power over the animals
- 1:14:14themselves, right? So there's that dynamic culturally.
- 1:14:17But at the same time, you know, we've been talking,
- 1:14:20speaking in this conversation about humane meat.
- 1:14:23It's really important that the animal, for the
- 1:14:26people in the animal economy to present this
- 1:14:28image of animal agriculture as benign and compassionate,
- 1:14:33and that we can nurture the animals and then
- 1:14:35kill them. And so women are playing this really
- 1:14:37interesting and disturbing role culturally in
- 1:14:43giving justification to this violence. Temple
- 1:14:46Grandin, who I talk about, is the perfect, she's
- 1:14:49the poster child for this, right? I mean, I mean,
- 1:14:52there's been these Hollywood pictures, a Hollywood
- 1:14:54picture biopic about her. She was called praised
- 1:14:57as a quote, animal rights activist by the Museum
- 1:15:00of Modern Art in New York. She was like time
- 1:15:03as she was, I mean, whatever she's like a celebrity.
- 1:15:06And what has she done? She spends her whole life
- 1:15:10trying to find more efficient ways of animals
- 1:15:12to be killed in the millions and billions, and
- 1:15:15to go to their deaths uncomplainingly. And she's
- 1:15:19called an animal rights activist. Well, Grandin
- 1:15:24is simply one of many, you know, she's the leading
- 1:15:27figure, but it's the same idea that if you can
- 1:15:30feminize this violence, then that, again, it
- 1:15:33gives the public an out. They can think, oh,
- 1:15:35well, you know, well, Temple Grandin respects
- 1:15:38animals. and I like Temple Grandin, therefore
- 1:15:41I respect animals, so I'm going to keep eating
- 1:15:45them. It was hard to write that chapter and it's
- 1:15:49hard for readers to read because there's such
- 1:15:52sadism in these accounts. On the one hand, the
- 1:15:55women describe the animals on their farms in
- 1:16:00loving terms as infants and children and they
- 1:16:04help them in the middle of the night and then
- 1:16:06they just slit their throats and they practice
- 1:16:09violence against other animals who wander onto
- 1:16:12their farms, and they do so in this kind of bloodthirsty
- 1:16:15way. But the point is not to vilify these particular
- 1:16:18individuals who wrote these books, it's to open
- 1:16:20a window onto the entire culture and the way
- 1:16:24that we live with this contradiction where we
- 1:16:26think we love animals, you know, and then at
- 1:16:29the same time, we treat them with utter contempt
- 1:16:32as worthless beings whom we can kill in the billions
- 1:16:37and trillions. forever without harming their
- 1:16:41interests and without doing violence to our own
- 1:16:43moral souls. And so the book is about the myth
- 1:16:46of that. I think it's really helpful to know
- 1:16:49who are the people behind this animal expedition
- 1:16:53business, who are the enablers, who are the intellectuals
- 1:16:58who support this activity. um and and the culture
- 1:17:03makers um i think it's it's truly revealing to
- 1:17:08know who are those people and what are they thinking
- 1:17:11and luckily enough they do write about it they
- 1:17:15are vocal about it we just have to read what
- 1:17:18they're um talking about and you did that you
- 1:17:22did that and you created this book which is a
- 1:17:25wonderful book again the omnivore's deception
- 1:17:29um the counter book to the evil book the omnivores
- 1:17:34uh dilemma um i do i i am so happy to participate
- 1:17:40in promoting it and i'm uh really um happy to
- 1:17:46have you on and as a as an intellectual of this
- 1:17:50movement um it is you know we are lucky um to
- 1:17:56have so many great bright minds in this movement,
- 1:18:01and you are one of them. Did you want to add
- 1:18:04something before we stop the recording? Oh, first
- 1:18:08of all, thank you. That's very, very flattering.
- 1:18:11Indeed. I just appreciate the work that you are
- 1:18:15doing. And I just want to say that for those
- 1:18:17of us who care about animals, it's a very difficult
- 1:18:21time. It's a difficult time for others who are
- 1:18:26concerned with elemental claims of justice and
- 1:18:30we just, you know, I am not an optimist by nature.
- 1:18:33It's just not me, not my temperament, but I'm
- 1:18:37sorry to say something as banal as this, but
- 1:18:38we really have to continue the struggle and we
- 1:18:41have to, I learned this from Karen Davis of United
- 1:18:45Poultry Concerns, never to apologize in defense
- 1:18:48of animals. You know, you can do that without
- 1:18:50necessarily being self -righteous and getting
- 1:18:52up in people's faces, but never apologize for
- 1:18:58standing up for them. You know, it's so vital
- 1:19:02that we do it. And yeah, so I do hope that people
- 1:19:08begin to challenge more forthrightly this humane
- 1:19:11narrative. And as you say, look at the intellectuals
- 1:19:14who are promulgating it. Thank you everyone for
- 1:19:27listening. I kindly invite you to share this
- 1:19:51podcast with the vegans you know. Let's encourage
- 1:19:53more people to take action. Again, thank you
- 1:19:57so much for caring and I will see you next Tuesday
- 1:20:00for a new episode.