Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / YouTube's New Role in Creator Monetization: Legal Implications of the Partnership Model
Transcript
- 0:05Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:09YouTube's New Role in Creator Monetization, Legal
- 0:12Implications of the Partnership Model. I'm Alla
- 0:15Policastro, Director of Education and Professional
- 0:17Development at Beverly Hills Bar Association,
- 0:20and today I'm delighted to introduce our speaker,
- 0:23Nianza Shah. Ms. Shaw is the founder and principal
- 0:26attorney of Shaw Esquire and is known as a strategic
- 0:30advisor who bridges the gap between creative
- 0:32ventures and business operations. Her firm provides
- 0:35comprehensive business and legal services to
- 0:37entrepreneurs, creatives, startups, and brands
- 0:41with particular expertise in contract negotiations
- 0:44and intellectual property matters. She also serves
- 0:47as outside general counsel to entertainment,
- 0:50media, and management companies and offers production
- 0:53counsel services for film and television production.
- 0:56We can't wait to hear what she has to share with
- 0:57us today, so I'm gonna turn it over to her. Hi,
- 1:01thanks, Ala. Good afternoon, everyone. I wanna
- 1:04thank the Beverly Hills Bar Association and the
- 1:07intellectual property law section for having
- 1:09me. As Ala mentioned, my practice is an intersection
- 1:15of entertainment, media, technology, and business.
- 1:20And I advise clients across those things, not
- 1:23only giving strategic advice, but obviously legal
- 1:25advice, legal counsel, et cetera. And I recently
- 1:29wrote an article for the Daily Journal examining
- 1:32YouTube's expanding partnership programs with
- 1:36creators and the legal implications. And so I'm
- 1:39looking forward to discussing that today. But
- 1:42I'd also like to build a little on those ideas,
- 1:46because I believe YouTube's announcement is part
- 1:49of a broader Shift in the industry. It's more
- 1:52than just a platform update It's about how the
- 1:56creator economy is growing and how YouTube and
- 1:58other platforms are doing businesses I mean creating
- 2:02business opportunities with these creators and
- 2:04partnerships, but let's start first with YouTube
- 2:07so earlier this year at their new front YouTube
- 2:11introduced their new partnership program and
- 2:16In this program they partner with creators to
- 2:19match them with advertisers and sponsors to create
- 2:23additional monetization opportunities that YouTube
- 2:26now shares in. So they are now taking a revenue
- 2:30share of what those opportunities and connections
- 2:33are. So let me say this. Traditionally, creators
- 2:38on YouTube generally make money from AdSense,
- 2:42which means they get a share of revenue from
- 2:44the ads. that play during their content and YouTube
- 2:48plays pays them out a share of that and of course
- 2:52they also have the opportunity to do brand deals
- 2:54or sponsorship deals outside of that but generally
- 2:57speaking um again the core of how they make money
- 3:00on YouTube is through ads so this shift to a
- 3:05partnership program where they are now matched
- 3:09with potential sponsors and advertisers through
- 3:12YouTube, and YouTube is now getting a share of
- 3:14that revenue, is more than a product update.
- 3:17It's definitely a shift. And thinking about how
- 3:21it works, so they match them through Gemini AI,
- 3:27existing creator data, and they figure out which
- 3:31brands may want to partner with which creators
- 3:34and they match them from there. So that already
- 3:38creates some legal implications relative to what
- 3:41those deals look like. And so in figuring out
- 3:47the deals that are brought to the creators from
- 3:51YouTube, there are a few things to consider.
- 3:55First and foremost is just protecting the intellectual
- 3:59property that the creator owns before doing any
- 4:01monetization deals. That's foundational. Then
- 4:06it's important to understand that these deals
- 4:08are more modular. So you want to think about
- 4:10as a lawyer, which modules fit your client's
- 4:14needs, fit the client's audience, and also making
- 4:18sure that the platform's obligations are ones
- 4:21that the creator can actually accomplish and
- 4:26agree to. There's also still concerns relative
- 4:31to FTC disclosures and advertiser compliance.
- 4:36There's regulations regarding the FTC relative
- 4:40to paid promotions, sponsorship, paid ads, et
- 4:44cetera. But also there's language relative to
- 4:49demonetization in these partnership programs.
- 4:52For example, a big one is relative to the originality
- 4:56of the content. So they want to make sure that
- 4:59if you are partnering with a brand or creating
- 5:04sponsor or paid promotional advertising materials
- 5:08that is original and or that you have permission
- 5:12to use the content so that you are not infringing
- 5:15on anybody's copyright. And also that it's not
- 5:19AI created. That's also a way that if you don't
- 5:22disclose that, you know, some of the materials
- 5:25that you're using as a creator and or your representative
- 5:29is not disclosing that in the negotiations, that
- 5:31is a way that you can actually not get paid.
- 5:37And then it's important just to understand just
- 5:39the provisions of brand deals. So that includes,
- 5:43first off, usage rights. How is the content going
- 5:46to be used? That is where, on what platforms,
- 5:51reuse, what territories, for how long, etc. It
- 5:58also includes obviously the compensation, whether
- 6:02this is exclusive. You want to discuss and negotiate
- 6:07approval rights on the creative. And this is
- 6:10extremely important because creators have built
- 6:13out their brands. They have a certain audience.
- 6:15And so brand authenticity is really, really important.
- 6:18And so you don't want to do a deal that goes
- 6:21against something that is consistent to your
- 6:25brand. So again, just within this new partnership
- 6:30program, those are already considerations that
- 6:33arise. But in my opinion, that's part of the
- 6:37question, right? So YouTube is setting this up.
- 6:40YouTube is understanding that creators are now
- 6:42creating businesses and they want to be in business
- 6:45and partner with them. But I want to talk about
- 6:48the why of it all. And the fact is that creators
- 6:51are not just making content. They are building
- 6:54media companies. And this is really why YouTube
- 6:58wants to invest in them. They're building intellectual
- 7:01property portfolios, they're launching brands,
- 7:03they're hiring teams, they're producing premium
- 7:07content, all of those things, right? So right
- 7:10now, YouTube is the most viewed streaming service
- 7:14with more viewers than Netflix, more viewers
- 7:18than Disney +, et cetera. And so they understand,
- 7:22again, that there is a monetization opportunity.
- 7:27as these content creators are growing, expanding,
- 7:31and becoming business enterprises. And YouTube
- 7:33and the platforms are not the only people recognizing
- 7:37this. Mainstream media is also definitely taking
- 7:41notice. Mainstream companies, media companies
- 7:45such as Fox, Apple, Revolt, A &E Global Media,
- 7:51and others have launched creator networks or
- 7:56creator studios to also partner with creators.
- 7:59And this is not about just expanding their reach
- 8:02or their platform. This is to invest in their
- 8:05existing media and content. This is to help give
- 8:08them infrastructure. This is to even help them
- 8:11develop new media projects within the traditional
- 8:15media structure. In addition, there's traditional
- 8:19agencies that are now representing creators.
- 8:24Another evidence of this is some recent major
- 8:27deals in which like Oprah just did a deal with
- 8:30Amazon where the Oprah podcast will now be broadcast
- 8:34on Amazon Prime and Audible. Some of the programming
- 8:39will still remain on YouTube. But another big
- 8:44deal recently which shows the growth of this
- 8:47space and how audiences creators are taking their
- 8:50audiences to new platforms Netflix and Spotify
- 8:54reportedly paid over $100 ,000 to acquire Jay
- 8:59Shetty's On Purpose podcast. This deal is exclusive
- 9:04and so his podcast will now be exclusively on
- 9:07Netflix and Spotify and will no longer be on
- 9:11YouTube where it was launched, where he built
- 9:14his audience, etc. The other way that the industry
- 9:18is seeing the shift is that creators are creating
- 9:21mainstream media. A great example of that is
- 9:25a recent film, Backrooms. So, Backrooms was a
- 9:28movie that was developed by a 20 -year -old YouTuber.
- 9:33It was a web series on YouTube that was acquired
- 9:37by A24. It had a $10 million budget. and to date
- 9:44has made over $300 million in theaters. So that
- 9:48is again, much beyond and much bigger than just
- 9:52uploading videos to YouTube. And we're also seeing
- 9:57this on the advertising side and how audiences,
- 10:02media and advertising dollars are also shifting.
- 10:04And that again means that legal work that follows
- 10:08media advertising as these deals shift, lawyers
- 10:12also need to shift, right? So I saw this firsthand
- 10:17at the press published conference. This is a
- 10:20one day creator summit actually sponsored by
- 10:24YouTube. And at that summit, a lot of the conversations
- 10:28were around ownership, development, scaling.
- 10:34and building enduring media businesses. There
- 10:37was a whole panel on infrastructure and when
- 10:42is it time to hire a CEO, when is it time to
- 10:47add to your team, etc. So creators are thinking
- 10:51about this, media is understanding that this
- 10:55is happening and I want to tap into this. And
- 10:58brands want to tap into reaching the audiences
- 11:01that these creators have. Similarly, I know that
- 11:08some of the buzz even coming from Kyan Lyons
- 11:10this year, which is a traditionally advertising
- 11:13and marketing conference, was also about creators.
- 11:15There were creator lounges, creator beaches.
- 11:18There were panels about doing brand deals and
- 11:23what that means. And then another example of
- 11:27this extension and growth in the creator economy
- 11:30and the creator ecosystem and how creators are
- 11:33launching into full -blown media enterprises
- 11:37is at can lions Lowe's Lowe's the hardware store.
- 11:43Yes, that Lowe's um which is obviously not a
- 11:46streaming platform and not a social media platform
- 11:49actually launched a program to partner with creators
- 11:53where creators can develop products of course
- 11:56you know thinking about that brand consistency
- 11:59and brand authenticity something that fits within
- 12:02their brand ecosystem that they can develop as
- 12:05a product to sell at lows again the thread here
- 12:10is that As these creators are doing different
- 12:13deals and entering into different partnerships,
- 12:17there's so many different types of agreements
- 12:19that come up that I'm going to talk about shortly.
- 12:21And so I just want to kind of lay the landscape
- 12:23of what that means and then discuss all of the
- 12:27implications and the different ways that lawyers
- 12:30now need to evolve as this business is evolving
- 12:34and what that looks like. Because this is a far
- 12:39cry from you know just again doing influencer
- 12:43deals or doing brand deals this is not saying
- 12:45a brand is writing a check to a creator and they're
- 12:48posting something on instagram and they get paid
- 12:50and they hope that the engagement delivers a
- 12:53return on that investment etc right so it's estimated
- 12:58that the creator economy ad spend is projected
- 13:02to hit 44 billion dollars it's billion with a
- 13:06b which mean advertisers and marketers are then
- 13:10spending money, not on traditional advertising
- 13:13and marketing, but tapping in, again, to these
- 13:16creator ecosystems and audiences. And creators
- 13:20need to be set up to do these types of deals.
- 13:24I mean, again, one of the foundational things
- 13:26is most of these big brands don't want to do
- 13:28a deal with an individual, right? So we'll also
- 13:31talk about even the importance of entity formation.
- 13:36So again, as this world is expanding, and we're
- 13:40thinking about all of these other things that
- 13:41come up. If a successful content creator walked
- 13:47into your office, these are some of the things
- 13:51and just a few because it can can expand even
- 13:54beyond this. But I just wanted to, you know,
- 13:57kind of tap into some foundational main legal
- 14:02issues that arise and now representing creators
- 14:05in a different way and really representing these
- 14:09businesses and in my practice because I've advised
- 14:12excuse me media companies and media businesses
- 14:15in this space I am now doing the same for creator
- 14:19businesses right so starting with foundationally
- 14:24business structure setting up an LLC or setting
- 14:27up a corporation potentially setting up a holding
- 14:30company Thinking about and working with a tax
- 14:35advisor on tax planning because this is new income
- 14:38and new revenue coming in and how to address
- 14:40that. Also foundationally thinking about IP issues,
- 14:46right? What IP do they own? What intellectual
- 14:48property do they own? How is it protected? What
- 14:52do you want to register? Their copyrights, their
- 14:55trademarks, etc. Are you thinking about? how
- 15:00you might be able to license those rights, how
- 15:04you may be able to franchise those rights, excuse
- 15:07me. And then even beyond that, negotiating deals
- 15:12for production distribution. Again, if they're
- 15:17creating content or creating projects, media
- 15:19projects in the film and TV space, what that
- 15:22looks like, potential employment and equity deals.
- 15:28because these creators that have leverage are
- 15:31going in and doing partnerships with brands where
- 15:34they are, again, there's levels to types of brand
- 15:38partnerships and the base level is an influencer
- 15:42brand deal. A mid -level looks something like
- 15:47maybe a brand or line where you'll see creators
- 15:51or influencers that do a one -off line or a capsule
- 15:55line with a brand. and in that they might get
- 15:59a revenue share and or they might get equity
- 16:02in negotiating that and or they might launch
- 16:07their own product and or just partner with a
- 16:10brand so that they are founders have equity and
- 16:16are looking at really building out a again a
- 16:20separate new business based on what they've already
- 16:23done. And this also just brings us to even the
- 16:29overall brand extension and expansion of what
- 16:34this happens, what happens when the creators
- 16:37are expanding into books and podcasts and live
- 16:41events, et cetera. Tom Segura is a well -known
- 16:46comedian. He was actually at Press Publish. did
- 16:50a panel and talked about the idea that, you know,
- 16:53and this is a perfect example of kind of this
- 16:55growth model. He launched a podcast during COVID,
- 17:02became successful, so then they launched a live
- 17:05event. So now you're looking at potential sponsorship
- 17:08deals, venue deals, insurance liability issues,
- 17:14all of these things relative to having a live
- 17:16event. That then extended into, they had a studio
- 17:21here in Los Angeles where they were renting out
- 17:24studio space to other folks to produce podcasts.
- 17:30And then under their own production company,
- 17:32they started producing other podcasts. They produced
- 17:36a show that was sold to Netflix. So again, now
- 17:39you're having licensing distribution contract.
- 17:43conversations, negotiating those types of deals.
- 17:46And then more recently, his company did a deal
- 17:50with Fox creator studios. And again, these companies
- 17:54and creator studios are using their traditional
- 17:57model to figure out a way to enhance and amplify
- 18:01what these creators are already creating, but
- 18:04understanding this business model of we want
- 18:08to invest in you. because you have the audience
- 18:11and we know that the audience goes where you
- 18:13go. And so that does look like not only, again,
- 18:19expanding what they're already doing, but also
- 18:21helping them develop new content, new media,
- 18:25new projects, new brand extensions, even beyond,
- 18:30again, what was traditionally seen as creator
- 18:35media partnerships. This is also happening, I
- 18:40think I mentioned with agencies, right? So agencies
- 18:42are not only representing creators, but they're
- 18:45also helping with infrastructure, determining
- 18:48strategy around what that expansion looks like
- 18:52and working on that team as a lawyer and thinking
- 18:55about what are the elements that make sense strategically
- 18:58for this creator, for this business model. etc.
- 19:03And of course, one of the business examples of
- 19:05this of how media companies that are no longer
- 19:08going to look like, you know, Disney or Netflix
- 19:11or Warner Brothers in the future, they may just
- 19:14start with like one person, one person, one camera
- 19:18in somebody's basement, I don't know, and grow
- 19:21into a whole empire. We've seen that with Mr.
- 19:25Beast. His, I believe, head of HR recently spoke
- 19:33on a podcast and I saw this interview. Mr. Beast
- 19:37has 700 employees and has a deal with Netflix
- 19:41and has products and etc. Again, YouTube is tapping
- 19:46into this. They're not creating this partnership
- 19:49as a product update, like I said, per se. They're
- 19:56thinking about how can we partner differently
- 19:59as creators are doing business differently and
- 20:02then as lawyers we're thinking about okay as
- 20:05creators are developing this business how can
- 20:08we make sure that we're advising them strategically
- 20:12legally contractually in a new way yeah to protect
- 20:16their rights to expand their base to grow their
- 20:21business scale their business and what that looks
- 20:24like and again if certain things are outside
- 20:26of your wheelhouse um it's always good to get
- 20:30outside counsel to get additional counsel etc
- 20:34but it's important to understand what this shift
- 20:37means what it looks like and some things are
- 20:42evolving really really quickly so you want to
- 20:44make sure that even in that that you're staying
- 20:46abreast of what that looks like right because
- 20:48terms are changing rapidly um The other opportunities
- 20:54that are coming are growing rapidly and some
- 20:58of these creators are having huge success in
- 21:01a very very short period of time and so they
- 21:04need to be set up foundationally to kind of bear
- 21:09the burden of that growth right I equate this
- 21:12similarly to The shark tank effect there's some
- 21:18founders that will go on shark tank and not have
- 21:21their foundational issues kind of like structured
- 21:24in place. And so you hear stories about them
- 21:28doing a deal on Shark Tank, but then their website
- 21:30crashed, or they didn't have the supply to meet
- 21:33the demand of the sales just from the exposure,
- 21:36et cetera, right? And so as business advisors,
- 21:40and not only in entertainment, but thinking about
- 21:43the media space and the convergence with business,
- 21:47you're thinking about. What are the foundational
- 21:49things that I need to set up for a client to
- 21:52make sure that they are primed, protected, and
- 21:58ready to expand and to evolve? And again, in
- 22:02a very quickly evolving space, being considerate
- 22:07of all the things that you should be thinking
- 22:09about so that you can best advise your clients
- 22:12in this space. And I think it's important to
- 22:15note that that readiness again happens really
- 22:20really quickly because there are influencers
- 22:22right some of it is strategy and building it
- 22:24out but there are also influencers that really
- 22:26quickly go viral and there might be someone again
- 22:30made a video goes viral a brand reaches out and
- 22:35a brand is one who represents you who's on your
- 22:39team do you have a company you know that we can
- 22:42contract with what does this look like um it
- 22:45might be a deal for a lot a lot of money so again
- 22:48going back to making sure you're addressing the
- 22:51tax implications and and not only uh getting
- 22:54advice from a lawyer but also a tax accountant
- 22:57um and all of those things again some of them
- 23:01are more strategic because you can kind of figure
- 23:04out from advising a client, like what does your
- 23:07brand look like? Where is it going? How is it
- 23:10growing? How do you want to grow it? And then
- 23:13also based on the IP and the audience that you
- 23:15built, and especially using the data as leverage,
- 23:20how do you want to address how you're growing
- 23:22your business? And it's up to us lawyers to be
- 23:25able to advise them on what that looks like and
- 23:27the best course. of action not only in building
- 23:31the business, but how they contract with third
- 23:33parties relative to their IP, their ideas, their
- 23:39media projects, and how they're partnering in
- 23:42business. So again, it's very interesting that
- 23:45YouTube is taking this step, but As you can see,
- 23:50in my opinion, it is much more relative to a
- 23:52bigger convergence between traditional media
- 23:55and the creator economy. And we've seen this
- 23:58coming, but this move, the conversations at places
- 24:02like Press Publish or the conversations at Cannes
- 24:05Lions this year are affirming these changes in
- 24:09the industry. And as we know, as industries change,
- 24:13as business needs change, as client needs change,
- 24:16That's when lawyers need to change. And I believe
- 24:20that the lawyers who understand how this is changing
- 24:23and evolving are going to be the frontline of
- 24:26advising folks in the media space, in business,
- 24:29and are going to make sure that their clients
- 24:32are protected, that they're doing great deals,
- 24:35and that they really can benefit and monetize
- 24:39from their IP, their ideas, et cetera. So I wanted
- 24:44to wrap it up there and thank you all, because
- 24:47there are a couple of questions in the Q &A that
- 24:49I want to address before we wrap up. But I hope
- 24:53you have enjoyed this conversation and found
- 24:55it informative. I'll answer a couple of questions
- 24:59really quickly before we land. One of the questions
- 25:05is, do these partnerships only apply to creators
- 25:07who are on camera or are creators who don't appear
- 25:10on camera but produce high quality videos also
- 25:15eligible? That's an easy question. Yes, there
- 25:19are a lot of influencers and creators that are
- 25:24doing very, very well, have a lot of followers,
- 25:27have gained a certain trust with their audience,
- 25:29et cetera, that are not on camera. And some of
- 25:34these deals are definitely eligible to them.
- 25:37And still, whether you're on camera or not, as
- 25:39a client, the lawyer should be advising about
- 25:42the IP, the business structure, the types of
- 25:47deals that are coming down the pike. All of those
- 25:50still apply. So the other question that is posed
- 25:56that I wanted to address was, As the contractual
- 26:00terms are changing, can I discuss some of those
- 26:03specifics about how they're changing and what
- 26:06the new terms comprise? I talked about this a
- 26:09little, and yes, definitely more general because
- 26:12there's a lot of different ways in which things
- 26:15are changing. But I will say that the biggest
- 26:19thing is that as creators are building their
- 26:22businesses, they have more leverage. That is
- 26:25the biggest thing and so if you're protecting
- 26:27your IP and you own your IP you want to be able
- 26:31to address and go into any sort of partnership
- 26:34and deal understanding that you want to be able
- 26:37to the extent you can retain that ownership.
- 26:41If you're creating new content or new media you
- 26:44want to be able to negotiate what that looks
- 26:46like if it's incorporating your existing IP.
- 26:51Now this is very similar to existing IP, whether
- 26:54it's a book or a magazine or other things, but
- 26:57the difference is, is in the use because content
- 27:01creators are still, let me say this, still creating
- 27:05content. They're not, they didn't stop creating
- 27:07content. They're just evolving and doing these
- 27:10other things. And so as you're balancing both,
- 27:14and you want to be able to hold on to and or
- 27:17carve out certain rights in what you're doing
- 27:19with your IP that's the biggest thing right because
- 27:22even with brand expansion and brand extension
- 27:25you want to think about what exclusivity really
- 27:31means um and not give up certain rights too soon
- 27:38or too broadly. That's kind of going back to
- 27:41whether it's a usage question of if you are creating
- 27:45content or creating media in a partnership, how
- 27:50long can it be used by the brand? Where can it
- 27:53be used by the brand? All of those things are
- 27:56very, very important to kind of pay attention
- 27:58to. And if you're doing an actual brand or product
- 28:01deal, the same thing, like if you're creating
- 28:04a film and TV project about your IP, you don't
- 28:08want that to be exclusive of doing a product
- 28:10or a book or a podcast or even continuing to
- 28:14do the types of content that you're already doing.
- 28:18And so those are the ways that you're thinking
- 28:20about more specifically the types of terms that
- 28:24you're paying attention to and also just thinking
- 28:28about like what that looks like for again what
- 28:32you own as a creator and making sure as lawyers
- 28:36that we are setting up that foundation to make
- 28:41sure that that IP and initial IP is protected
- 28:45that they created. And then the last question
- 28:51that I will address in our short time is how
- 28:54do these partnership deals interact with monetization
- 28:57of other content on YouTube? And so again, this
- 29:01is in addition to and can be negotiated. They're
- 29:05very modular contracts. So there's different
- 29:07modules and specifically the YouTube partnership
- 29:10program that a lawyer would want to address relative
- 29:14to the types of client needs, the client's audience.
- 29:20and what that partnership looks like in terms
- 29:22of compensation usage, et cetera. And I know
- 29:26I keep saying that, but that's really the core
- 29:28and crux of what it is. And so those are things
- 29:31that you're thinking about. It's not exclusive
- 29:33to other monetization on YouTube or off of YouTube,
- 29:37et cetera, which is why, again, the important
- 29:41thing is to protect the underlying IP and make
- 29:44sure that that's registered and that you're very,
- 29:47very clear about the usage and exclusivity of
- 29:51how your content as a creator is being used.
- 29:56And again, as lawyers advising content creators
- 30:00and creators as they're building their businesses
- 30:03on the best course of action for protecting their
- 30:07IP rights. So again, I hope this was informative.
- 30:11I know it's a quick 30 minutes. If you'd like
- 30:13to connect with me, feel free to connect with
- 30:15me on LinkedIn, Nianza Shaw. Again, I want to
- 30:18thank the Beverly Hills Bar Association and the
- 30:21intellectual property law section for having
- 30:23me. And thank you. Have a great day, everybody.