Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: BP chairman ousted - The board strikes back
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:04podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:07the UK energy market. This week, BP sacked as
- 0:12chairman. We speak about the impact on
- 0:15overseas taxation in the UK and we were off at the Renewable
- 0:20Supply Chain Conference in Aberdeen.
- 0:22That's a lot to talk about if you're just me.
- 0:24Aberdeen features lead Ryan Duff, but thankfully I'm joined
- 0:27by Ed Reed. E Forward editor, How are you
- 0:29this weekend? I'm doing all right, thank you.
- 0:31I'm doing all right. I, I'm, I'm, I'm so I'm down
- 0:33South and I'm sort of, you know, sweltering somewhat in the heat.
- 0:36And I've got to say, I don't want to get this in early, but I
- 0:38feel like the conservatives coming out this week and saying,
- 0:41like, we believe in air conditioning.
- 0:43So it really resonated with me. I'm just like, oh, do you know
- 0:45what? Yeah, let's.
- 0:46That's a political message I can really get behind.
- 0:48Is that why? You're wearing a blue tie this
- 0:50episode. I mean, sometimes you just
- 0:52gotta, you know, fly, fly your flag.
- 0:54And I'm also joined by Matt Perry, news reporter.
- 0:57How are you doing this week, Matt?
- 0:58Well, it's not. Quite as warm as down in London.
- 1:00It's about 23° here in Glasgow. So it's just on the precipice of
- 1:04Taps F weather, but not quite there.
- 1:07And I'll tell you, I didn't ever think I'd be saying that coming
- 1:11from Brisbane in Australia that 23° would be balmy.
- 1:14But here we are. You can acclimatize truly.
- 1:18And he's really. Become one with the culture,
- 1:20with that taps. I've comment as well.
- 1:22And like that I was able to throw that in there very
- 1:24slightly. But you know, this week I'm, I'm
- 1:27looking forward to going to see the new Star Wars movie at the
- 1:30weekend. I don't know if anyone else has.
- 1:32But before we get to that, I'm going to get to the revenge of
- 1:36the chairman, which is, you know, we had.
- 1:38The boardroom strikes back. Exactly.
- 1:40We had we had BP oust its chairman manifold earlier this
- 1:46week and then he's come out and sort of said, oh, this is
- 1:49absolutely nonsense and sort of had his own peace to defend
- 1:53himself. But Matt, you were, you were on
- 1:56the spot for this, this particular story.
- 1:58Could you just run us through the the the the overview before
- 2:02we get into? That, well, it kind of came out
- 2:04of nowhere really on Tuesday. It was kind of just, you know,
- 2:07shaping up to be, you know, post bank holiday, not much in the
- 2:10news on the morning shift. And then out of nowhere, BP
- 2:13dropped this statement saying that it's chairman, Albert
- 2:16Manafort, who had only taken the reins, I believe, at the start
- 2:19of October last year, had been removed with immediate effect.
- 2:23And their statement cited serious and unacceptable
- 2:25governance and conduct concerns, which is suitably vague, which,
- 2:29of course, given some of the history of BP executives in the
- 2:33years gone by, set speculation A flutter.
- 2:37You know, everyone probably remembers Bernard Looney, but
- 2:40turns out it was not one of one of those cases.
- 2:44It was well, it wasn't stated in BP's statement, but some
- 2:50reporting came out from the likes of Sky News and the BBC
- 2:53that it was down to bullying and the temper allegations.
- 2:57Lots of shouting, you know, in in the boardroom.
- 3:03But yes, they interesting that this doesn't happen often that
- 3:08do we see a chairman move in the BP statement said that it was a
- 3:11unanimous decision of by its board, which I guess goes to
- 3:16show that these were, yeah, quite a few people that didn't
- 3:19want to work with Albert anymore.
- 3:21You know, it's quite interesting, isn't it?
- 3:22Because you know, when we think of like essentially it's a
- 3:24sacking. Let's face it, the board had to
- 3:26vote on it, but it's a sacking. And you know, when you think of
- 3:29these sort of people in high up positions, you know, you think,
- 3:32oh, well, they'll, you know, they'll know the writings on the
- 3:35wall. They know what's happening.
- 3:36Like, you know, if they're going to get let go.
- 3:38But yeah, manifolds are said in a statement on Wednesday.
- 3:41You know, I was removed without warning and without explanation,
- 3:45which I think is quite an interesting one.
- 3:46But Ed, you pointed to the AGM that took place just what, a few
- 3:52weeks ago and you were saying you, you pointed out the fact
- 3:55that you know he was on thin ice then, right?
- 3:58Yeah, Yeah. I mean, I think that's the
- 3:59thing. It feels like, you know, maybe
- 4:01all executives at BP are on thin ice.
- 4:04I mean, the, the, the extraordinary amount of turnover
- 4:06that we've seen at that company is, is something to behold.
- 4:09I mean, obviously, as Matt has said, you know, the various of
- 4:12them have, you know, kind of gone with sort of slightly
- 4:16shorter terms than expected in the past.
- 4:18And it feels like in some ways they're accelerating.
- 4:21But yeah, so so the, you know, the AGM there was, there was
- 4:23what it was about sort of it was quite a significance of vote
- 4:26against him. Obviously, you know, he he
- 4:27remained in position following the AGM, but he was, you know,
- 4:31there was a sort of a question mark over here.
- 4:33But I think it kind of plays into that big a question,
- 4:35doesn't it, around actually, what's the future for BP?
- 4:38Clearly with Megan Neil coming in in April, becoming as a
- 4:43company more American thinking again about sort of slimming
- 4:47down that sort of hydrogen project in Teesside that we've
- 4:50seen questions about the North Sea, you know, like is who?
- 4:54I think the big question is, who's the next?
- 4:56Who's the next person to be in that spot, right?
- 4:59Is it an American? Is it maybe somebody who has
- 5:01experience in, say, finessing companies into the New York
- 5:05Stock Exchange? Is this sort of the final nail
- 5:08in the coffin of of, of BP's sort of European?
- 5:12It's it's definitely an interesting thing to think
- 5:14about, especially, you know, after the after the break, we'll
- 5:17be we'll be hearing from Ashley or guilty of Panmure Liberum and
- 5:21his takes on the the new tax regime.
- 5:25That said to come into place that Rachel Reeves announced was
- 5:28it last week where, you know, essentially overseas profits
- 5:33could, you know, could end up being taxed in the UK as well
- 5:37for UK's based companies. This, you know, this sort of
- 5:41raised sort of questions as to does that end BP and shells time
- 5:46in the UK and now it feels like BP are poised to take that
- 5:51decision in, in a way of through a leadership change, right?
- 5:56It's interesting to see as well, like the investor reaction to
- 5:59the removal of Manifold, because I think he'd been really seen.
- 6:01He was quite a prominent chair, you know, not a lot all of the
- 6:03time. Chairs are sort of working in
- 6:05the background and maybe not as outspoken, but Manifold was kind
- 6:09of quite, quite prominent coming in to replace Helgoland.
- 6:12And I think in the last five days, BP's share prices down
- 6:15about eight, 8 1/2 percent or so and it, you know, dropped 5%
- 6:19following the news of Manifold ouster just on on Tuesday.
- 6:22So obviously a lot of investors saw Manifold as a driving force
- 6:26of that operational change. He was also a big part of
- 6:29recruiting mega O'Neill from from Woodside.
- 6:31And I guess I think it it is also, you know, obviously a lot
- 6:35of eyes will be on who comes next into the the chair
- 6:38position, but a lot of eyes will also be on Meg O'Neill and how
- 6:41how she sort of handles this because you know, with, with the
- 6:44the chair who hired her out the door.
- 6:47It's basically all all responsibility is kind of
- 6:50falling on on her shoulders when she's barely a month into the
- 6:54barely two months into the job. At this point I.
- 6:56Mean, I think there's a really interesting question there
- 6:58around people, isn't there? And I, I suppose like, in many
- 7:00ways, I mean, my, my theory about like the, you know, like
- 7:03how industry works is kind of change, right?
- 7:05Initially when I got into this, you know, like writing about
- 7:08the, the energy sector, like I was thinking about sort of, you
- 7:10know, the big sort of geopolitics.
- 7:12And I think as time has gone by, I think actually more and more
- 7:15I'm thinking about the people who are kind of, you know,
- 7:18driving these changes, who are taking these decisions.
- 7:20And frankly, that kind of weird question that kind of, you know,
- 7:23kind of goes, goes back to the school room is like, actually,
- 7:25can you get on with the person that you're working with seems
- 7:27as much as an an indicator of success as anything.
- 7:30And I feel like actually it, it seems that, you know, obviously,
- 7:33you know, manifold has, you know, kind of hit back kind of
- 7:36quite strongly. And I think there's, you know,
- 7:37there's kind of an interesting question there about, you know,
- 7:39are we going to look at some sort of, you know, is there
- 7:41going to be like a legal sort of challenge to, to, to, to that
- 7:45dismissal, which I think is, is like an open question.
- 7:47But I think that question around actually, who do you want to be
- 7:50on the team? Who do you not want to be on the
- 7:51team? Is is is like one of those kind
- 7:53of weird indicators of success that I think is really
- 7:55fascinating. Yeah, I think it's definitely an
- 7:57interesting case and I think it's it's it's pertinent that
- 8:00you point out that he has hit back against this, this claim of
- 8:05misconduct. He said that he's going to
- 8:06challenge this quote, false narrative.
- 8:09There's been created around around his sacking.
- 8:12But even if even if this does go to court at the end of the day,
- 8:15he's not going to be chairman again, right?
- 8:17That's not going to happen because I mean, even from, you
- 8:20know, if we're speaking about the human side of things, would
- 8:23you want to be manifold going back into that company even if
- 8:27even if you were allowed to? I don't know.
- 8:28It's it's an interesting point. But I think, yeah, you're right
- 8:32to say that this is, you know, at the end of the day, companies
- 8:35are run by people, even if they are, you know, billionaires.
- 8:40But they, you know, they still need to be able to to work hand
- 8:44in hand and to achieve whatever their goals are.
- 8:48And that's something, again, that BP's been sort of
- 8:51criticized for in recent years of like, they doubled down on
- 8:55renewables, you know, before the pandemic.
- 8:57And then they were kind of slower to, you know, backtrack
- 9:00and, you know, was manifold the the man to sort of like be a
- 9:04firm hand at the rudder, maybe too firm if the bullying
- 9:06allegations are true. But it's an interesting
- 9:09situation. What do you what do you see
- 9:11going forward? I think it's it'll be
- 9:13interesting to see. Again, it all all comes down to
- 9:16I think who falls into the position next will be a key
- 9:20indicator of where BP is looking to go.
- 9:23I think it'll be interesting to see, you know, Ian Tyler has
- 9:26been put in as interim chair and you know, not a lot of obvious
- 9:32oil and gas experience. I believe in his, but he's a
- 9:34former CEO of Atkins, sort of an infrastructure and engineering
- 9:38background there. So VP has had in the past a
- 9:43tendency to hire from within. So if if Tyler takes on the the
- 9:47role, it might be sort of a steady as she goes.
- 9:49But if we see, you know, someone parachuting in from, from the
- 9:54US, you know, I think as as Ed was saying earlier, that's been
- 9:57a pretty indication of the direction of travel BP might
- 10:00want to be taking. I don't know.
- 10:01Ed didn't. Do you have any speculative
- 10:05choices if if you were on the BP board, who would you be be
- 10:08picking for for chair? Probably just mostly be
- 10:11thinking, my God, how much money have we spent on headhunters?
- 10:16There's some very there's some executive search firms in London
- 10:20and New York that are rubbing their hands together with Glee.
- 10:22Absolutely, absolutely. Yeah.
- 10:24I mean, I think, I think, I mean, like, I think that's the
- 10:26thing. I mean there's there's, there's
- 10:27obviously like a very broad, you know, like range of of, of, of,
- 10:31of areas that can be tapped. I think obviously.
- 10:33So Manafort, I think he was from the CRH, wasn't he, Which I
- 10:36think was kind of constructions of cement in the past.
- 10:39So it feels like, look, it, it doesn't need to be from the
- 10:41energy industry, but I think actually the, the nationality is
- 10:45going to be like a kind of a crucial indicator to watch,
- 10:48right? If the next person is an
- 10:50American, that would be, you know, quite telling, I think.
- 10:54And also I think, you know, the other thing is like, you know,
- 10:56would it be, you know, another woman, right?
- 10:58We've, we've, we've had clearly a sort of a run of, you know,
- 11:02sort of white men running BP who have lost their positions in
- 11:09sort of various stages of, you know, distress over the last few
- 11:14years. Like, God, Can you imagine how
- 11:17notable it would be if they had Aceo and a chair who was a
- 11:20woman? I mean, I don't.
- 11:21Know I mean not just a interesting because the CFO is
- 11:24chief financial officers Kate Thompson, the deputy CEO is
- 11:27Carol Howell. So if they do bring in a
- 11:29chairwoman, that would be, yeah, all women at the top of BP.
- 11:34But yeah, I see if there's in an American chair, having two
- 11:37Americans steering British Petroleum would be certainly an
- 11:42interesting change. I.
- 11:43Think they would dispute their name being British?
- 11:45Petroleum. I'm sorry, I'm not petroleum.
- 11:48And then it's just BP, it doesn't stand for anybody
- 11:51anymore. But it's and to see it's a
- 11:53lowercase BP that always annoys me.
- 11:55I just I can't get behind that branding decision.
- 11:58I refuse. Well, there you go.
- 11:59And you know, any, any long term readers of Energy Voice would
- 12:02know that we can't get behind that because our house style is
- 12:04still capping bring up BP. But anyway, enough about the
- 12:07nitty gritty of of how we write our articles.
- 12:11We should stick around because after this break, BP is no doubt
- 12:14still going to be part of the conversation as editor Erica
- 12:17Askland chats with Panmure Liberum's Ashley Kelty.
- 12:22Hello, I'm Ed Reid, the editor of E Ford.
- 12:25E Ford is a membership community that brings together the entire
- 12:28UK energy supply chain, every hub, every sector, every stage.
- 12:33Our aim is to deliver growth to the energy sector, working with
- 12:35industry and policy makers to unlock the UK's opportunities
- 12:39and advantages. This is the movement to secure
- 12:43increased investment, improved policy making and better
- 12:46collaboration by providing our members with visibility,
- 12:49influence and access. Join me forward today.
- 12:56Hi, it's Erica Ascoland here, the news editor of Energy Voice.
- 13:00And I'm thrilled to welcome a special guest on to Energy Voice
- 13:04Out Loud, Ashley Kelty, who's the oil and gas analyst at Pan
- 13:10Merit Liber. And welcome.
- 13:11Lovely to see you. Thanks for joining.
- 13:13US morning and how are. You excellent.
- 13:15Thank you. So we just have a lot to
- 13:18discuss. I mean, just looks like Rachel
- 13:22Reeves is at it again, deciding that in order to fund a nice
- 13:27swishy VAT cut for the summer to various soft play areas, maybe
- 13:32if you want to take the kids, you know, out to the beach, you
- 13:37get a VAT cut. And in order to fund that, you
- 13:41know, the she's decided to impose a tax on the trading
- 13:47activities, particularly with regards to Shell and BP because,
- 13:52hey, no one loves buying ice cream more than BP and Shell for
- 13:59the nation's children, right? Tell us what your take is,
- 14:02Ashley. This it's, it's a bit of a
- 14:06strange one. I mean, I think the one thing
- 14:08we're we're sort of seeing as being that the sort of
- 14:12overriding approach of Starmerism, if you can call it
- 14:17that, other than U turns is around trying to address a big
- 14:23problem with lots and lots of small solutions.
- 14:27So basically taking the VAT off, going to the circus.
- 14:31I mean, obviously not Holy Rood or Westminster included in that.
- 14:37It's not really making much of a difference.
- 14:39I mean, for, for families that are that, that are struggling,
- 14:41they're not going to be spending vast amounts of money running
- 14:44off to Alton Towers or, or, or whatever, you know, but it's,
- 14:49it's just optics, I think really more than anything else.
- 14:53But the the key point is that the Treasury, Rachel Reeves, Ed
- 14:59Miliband, is he the chancellor in waiting?
- 15:02Is he quite? Are looking at there was nasty
- 15:06evil oil companies and the fact that they've been making large
- 15:09profits in first quarter of the year.
- 15:13I mean the real profits are going to be made in the second
- 15:15quarter and I think that's going to kick off even more of a storm
- 15:20when people realize just how much money these companies can
- 15:23generate. But the the actual treasury
- 15:30specifically name checked BP and Shell and complained about them
- 15:35making windfalls from war, which is pretty pejorative language,
- 15:41particularly for the government to actually use directly and I
- 15:47think totally unfair. They haven't commented in any of
- 15:52the other companies that will have made supernormal profits.
- 15:57Certainly didn't target the pharma companies when they were
- 15:59making supernormal profits during the COVID pandemic.
- 16:03But anyway, without addressing too much that the plan is to
- 16:08target their trading operations which obviously make large
- 16:11amounts of of money, but they can also lose large amounts of
- 16:15money if they if they make a bet on the oil price moving in the
- 16:19wrong direction. Well, funnily enough, I spoke to
- 16:22Alex Kemp, who you you may have spoken to in the past.
- 16:26He's said lovely. Yeah, Yeah.
- 16:29I mean, you know, the, you know what he knows about, you know,
- 16:32petroleum taxes in the UK. You know, is, is, is, you know,
- 16:37almost, you know, beyond, you can imagine.
- 16:39But, you know, he was saying that this is about trading
- 16:43activities and on, you know, the global scale.
- 16:47And I guess to a certain extent, you kind of think, well, are
- 16:50people going to think that, you know, you should cry too many
- 16:54rivers, you know, for, you know, these traders who, you know, are
- 16:59living and dying on, you know, just arbitrage.
- 17:02But he also said that this means that the UK government will
- 17:06benefit from the like the traders will benefit from the
- 17:09upside, but they're also at risk from losing when there's a
- 17:12downside and say, for example, in the Middle East breaks up,
- 17:16their losses go down. That means losses for the
- 17:18Treasury, too. Well, the two elements, one, the
- 17:24fact that now they will have the government will have to give tax
- 17:27relief on the half a billion that Shell are going to have to
- 17:31pay to prepare the parole GTL facility that wouldn't have been
- 17:36included in the past, but now it is.
- 17:38So that's half, that's quite a lot of essentially tax loss
- 17:42through the release that will have to be given for that.
- 17:45But the one thing that they haven't picked up on is the
- 17:48government is already benefiting from the uplift in energy prices
- 17:51through fuel duty. I mean, it's, it's been
- 17:53estimated that the government are making 25 to 30 million a
- 17:57day in extra fuel duty. There's no mention of that.
- 18:02And that certainly goes a long way to their messing around the
- 18:06fringes with with that, which realistically is a lot of
- 18:09companies just will not bother with for the simple reason that
- 18:13it's just too difficult to to implement.
- 18:16But the the idea of closing the, the sort of foreign branch
- 18:22exclusion is going to impact a lot of much smaller companies.
- 18:27Oh, is it right as well? I mean, if you look at all the
- 18:30companies going down the, the oil sector that so that are
- 18:36listed in the UK, the if people have operations overseas, these
- 18:40will probably fall into the foreign branch rule.
- 18:45Some of them will incorporate it at, some of them won't.
- 18:49I do know of several that have registered an exemption just
- 18:57now. And now they're running around
- 18:59trying to figure out what the implications are going to be,
- 19:01because obviously they need to now consolidate that into their
- 19:04accounts before the start of September.
- 19:07So obviously there's only so many tax accountants and lawyers
- 19:12available. So that that's going to be a
- 19:13real problem certainly for the smaller companies that might
- 19:16have one or two assets overseas. So basically it's ruining
- 19:18everyone's summer unless you're going to Alton Towers.
- 19:22Yes, absolutely. But it's, yeah, it just seems to
- 19:26be tinkering around the edges and the whole point is it just
- 19:32seems to be more performative, I I'd say than anything else.
- 19:35Sure. Well, you know that.
- 19:37So you, you think hundreds of millions of pounds are not going
- 19:40to be coming into the treasury because of this brilliant move.
- 19:43That's, you know, she pulled out of the hat without consultation,
- 19:45might I add. Pretty much everyone said, are
- 19:47you kidding me? Like how is this happening that
- 19:50you know this is been announced and no one's mentioned it
- 19:53before? No, it it seems to be they're,
- 19:56they've looked, they've done their psalms, realized that.
- 20:00There's not enough money being generated, probably because of
- 20:03their other policies, which should have stifled growth and
- 20:08they would be better addressed rather than trying to go after
- 20:11one or two companies. I mean, in terms of the UK, it's
- 20:16it's pretty pointless hitting BP and Shell.
- 20:19They don't really have an awful lot here in terms of their
- 20:22global operations. I mean Shell essentially is no
- 20:24longer in the UK because it it basically rolled his UK
- 20:29operations into a Jura. So in terms of.
- 20:32On States and a few joint ventures, sure, sure.
- 20:35Yeah, they must be thinking, you know, what, do we really need to
- 20:38be in the UK now? I would imagine that the New
- 20:42York Stock Exchange is making a big pitch for them to redomicile
- 20:48to the US and, and arguably if the the Shell directors want to
- 20:53pay themselves a big bonus, that's the easiest way to do it.
- 20:56Because the shares would be re rated and treated as a new, as
- 21:01an American oil and gas major rather than a European one.
- 21:05And the sort of credibility discount that they all bear
- 21:11around policy fiscals and so forth, that would evaporate.
- 21:15So you would see a big uplift in the share price and they'd be
- 21:20able to pay themselves an awful lot for essentially doing very
- 21:23little other than moving their operations or their domicile to
- 21:28the US. And presumably BP could do the
- 21:31same thing. I mean, you know, they're now in
- 21:33the market for a new chairman. We have reported that, you know,
- 21:39speculation that they're considering also looking for
- 21:45joint venture or exiting operatorship of the North Sea,
- 21:49which would be a huge in a change for again, you know, one
- 21:55of EU KS biggest and most historic companies.
- 21:59But they too probably would benefit from that same UP rating
- 22:03that you get by a welcome from the New York.
- 22:05Yeah, to to a laster extent I think because I think everyone
- 22:09knows that all of the majors, BP is probably the, it's certainly
- 22:15more of a shambles than than any of the others.
- 22:18It's certainly lost its way over the last few years.
- 22:21Now the this sort of exiting the UK problem, not exiting by
- 22:27rolling it into a into a new venture that that's actually
- 22:30been tried a few times. Now you've got obviously a Jura
- 22:33Neo next, arguably Ithaca, which is the means that E and I used
- 22:38to to exit the the North Sea and as a result, it it seems to
- 22:44work. I mean, why not ring fence
- 22:46everything in there? I'm sure Harbour would love to
- 22:48do that if they could. That would be a waste for them
- 22:52to offload their old UK assets. But but for them it doesn't
- 22:58really contribute that much now. But certainly Linda Cooks been
- 23:04very vocal about the progressive fiscal policy, certainly
- 23:09probably the most of the UK. Yeah, she has.
- 23:14And so you know the, if you know the potential that once again, I
- 23:21think you use the phrase cash cow that the North Seas once
- 23:26again, you know, for the, the treasury, you know, kind of when
- 23:30does the cash cow break? It can break very, very quickly.
- 23:34I mean, it, it was actually breaking last year when everyone
- 23:37was looking at it at, at oil dropping to sort of below $60.00
- 23:44and everyone saying no oils finished.
- 23:45If these companies aren't going to make money now, now they have
- 23:49to look at other ways to do it. And that was part of the reason
- 23:52that everyone was single. Exploration needs to come back
- 23:56onto the the agenda now. It's certainly more so because
- 24:02of the fact I think everyone recognizes that the traditional
- 24:07supply chains have been broken and the operating in the Gulf is
- 24:11now far more risky than than anyone actually thought because
- 24:15Iran have now discovered that they can hold the the world's
- 24:18grants. So even if a peace deal is done,
- 24:22the the proof is there already that they can stop things very,
- 24:27very quickly. Yeah, I mean, you know, who knew
- 24:30that this is where we're going to end up?
- 24:31But I was thinking about, you know, how when Rachel Reeves
- 24:35first kind of announced the plans, you know, I was thinking
- 24:38of juvenile, we'll say, describing how the Romans, you
- 24:40know, loved bread and circuses. But instead, maybe we have
- 24:43cotton candy and and fun fairs, you know, in the UK, but you
- 24:48know, at the expense of maybe our industrial heritage.
- 24:50It's it seems ridiculous to push through this deindustrialization
- 24:57in the midst of an energy shock and global events, demonstrating
- 25:02that domestic energy security is even more important in the short
- 25:07term than ever. But the government seems to take
- 25:10this as a signal to double down on their they're moving to the
- 25:14low margin renewables it which ultimately could provide the
- 25:19solution, but it certainly can't in the next four to five years
- 25:24at the very least. Even if they had been able to
- 25:28meet their targets, it still wasn't going to meet UK energy
- 25:32needs. So it seems lunacy to leave
- 25:36everything in in the ground just now just for virtue signaling.
- 25:41When we look at our neighbor in Norway, who is they're
- 25:45reactivating fields that were decommissioned 40 years ago to
- 25:49meet energy demand in guess what, the UK.
- 25:53Now. That that is just sheer lunacy
- 25:56for us to pay other nations the tax which we could actually
- 26:02receive ourselves. Yes, the UK will be a net
- 26:05importer in perpetuity, but the fact is we don't need to import
- 26:10as much as it looks like we will do when we have all this in the
- 26:16ground just now. It it seems ridiculous and it I
- 26:20find it particularly oxen that the NSTA is is working against
- 26:24its core mandate to maximize the economic recovery by actively
- 26:29blocking deals going through. Well, that's probably something
- 26:34that we'll talk about next time we have you on energy voice out
- 26:37loud, Ashley. Well, thank you very much for
- 26:40joining us. Thank you for sharing your
- 26:42insights. Much appreciated.
- 26:44And hope that are you going to go to Alton Towers later on in
- 26:48the summer? Well, who knows?
- 26:49I'll I'll have to have. I suspect that the cost of
- 26:53driving there will probably be outweigh any bad savings.
- 26:56Offset the VAT savings. OK.
- 26:58Well, thank you very much and we'll speak to you soon.
- 27:02Be the first to hear breaking energy news through the Energy
- 27:06Voice app, available to download for free.
- 27:09You get features like saving the articles you want to return to,
- 27:13access to the Energy Voice supplement.
- 27:15You can read exclusive E Forward content and even listen to the
- 27:20Energy Voice Out Loud podcast. If you work in the UK energy
- 27:24sector, stay in the loop by saving the Energy Voice app to
- 27:28your home screen. Download the app through the
- 27:30Apple App Store or Google Play for breaking energy news on the
- 27:35go by searching Energy Voice App.
- 27:39I'm here at the Renewable Energy Supply Chain Conference here in
- 27:42Aberdeen, where my editor Erica Askeland caught up with the Port
- 27:46of Inverness and Johnston Carmichael.
- 27:49Let's hear what they had to say. You're here with Sinclair Brown,
- 27:52who's the chief executive of the Port of Inverness.
- 27:55Welcome back to Aberdeen. Thank you very much.
- 27:57Always lovely to see you. From someone from the Highlands,
- 27:59come and talk to us. So you just touched on something
- 28:04that seems to be yet another one of those remarkable
- 28:08opportunities for the Highlands, and it might involve the
- 28:13Caledonian Canal and the major plans for a number of pump
- 28:19storage hydro schemes that are in planning.
- 28:23So tell us a little bit about, you know, what you're kind of
- 28:27thinking. So thoughts are these schemes,
- 28:29you're correct, there's three or four of them proposed down the
- 28:31Great Glen pump storage schemes. And the idea is that we're
- 28:36looking at, in conjunction with Scottish Canals, looking at
- 28:40trying to find a water based or water boarding solution for
- 28:43transportation, trying to take vehicles off the road and
- 28:47repurpose the Caledonian Canal back to what it was originally
- 28:49built for. Because 220 years ago it was
- 28:53built with Thomas Telford, prime example of connecting the East
- 28:57Coast, the West Coast of Scotland.
- 28:59Now it's very much used now as a Ledger facility.
- 29:01But we see this as an opportunity in the port and
- 29:05Scottish Canals to repurpose the canal and bring it back into
- 29:08more of a commercial use focused vehicles off the road and
- 29:13environmental benefits decarbonising the supply chain
- 29:16for these schemes. Sure.
- 29:18I mean, it was a good idea then, but then things moved on.
- 29:20It's almost like it can fulfill what its initial purpose was.
- 29:24Well, that's in a way. That's quite the nice story
- 29:26about it is it's repurposing it back to what it was what's
- 29:28originally there for. And you know we've been at this
- 29:31for three to four years with Scottish canals starting to come
- 29:34to a bit fruition. Things are starting to move
- 29:36forward. And as a trust port and we got a
- 29:38duty to our stakeholders and all that and tried to maximize the
- 29:41benefit for the stakeholders and we see this as one of our main
- 29:44planks. So excited about that, but still
- 29:47early stages. Yes, very much.
- 29:49So that's OK. You know, we're also though
- 29:52waiting for some of these long duration energy storage schemes.
- 29:59You mentioned Kurukan, That's also one of my favorite things
- 30:02in the Highlands, loves going to visit that amazing feat of
- 30:06engineering that hasn't been replicated for decades.
- 30:10But we're hopefully seeing more of these projects coming online,
- 30:14but we're still waiting for certainty in those projects too.
- 30:17Is that something that's maybe a source of frustration or how
- 30:22long is a piece of string I guess well.
- 30:24I guess all the developers are going through a process to
- 30:28applying to government for what the term cap and floor
- 30:30mechanism, which is a pricing mechanism.
- 30:32And once they've got that and we're expecting an announcement
- 30:35of that. We've had the first phase.
- 30:37So we know the ones that have got through the first phase and
- 30:39we're now waiting or the developers are waiting for
- 30:41what's going to happen in the second phase and that's supposed
- 30:44to be an announcement. It's always imminent.
- 30:46Yes, well, hopefully this is imminent.
- 30:49Yeah, yeah, yeah. And then I'm invernessing
- 30:51Cromartie Green Freeport. Really great initiative.
- 30:56Bit of a shame on Ming Yang isn't gonna be coming, but give
- 31:01us maybe an outlook on going to where the organisation is and
- 31:06maybe just a port of Inverness. I mean, it's such an important
- 31:09part of that. So founding member of the
- 31:11Invernessing property for Green Freeport on the 2 Green Free
- 31:14ports in Scotland. We've already had significant
- 31:17success in the Freeport with the Sumi Total Factory, cable
- 31:20factory that's going to bring jobs to the area.
- 31:22There's other things happening as well up in the Freeport.
- 31:25We've got inquiries from organisations and we're just
- 31:27waiting now for the next phase of the development, offshore
- 31:29wind to happen. And once that starts to happen
- 31:31then we'll really see the benefits, all the
- 31:33infrastructures in place. We're just waiting now for just
- 31:36the next phase to come through. A very positive outlook.
- 31:39Very good. Bring it on.
- 31:40Right. Yes.
- 31:42Thank you very much for joining us.
- 31:43Nice to meet you. Thanks very much.
- 31:45So I've found David Wilson, who's the Aberdeen Managing
- 31:51Partner for Johnston Carmichael and you are very engaged with
- 31:58the supply chain. A lot of them are your clients
- 32:01and as well you're very knowledgeable.
- 32:03In fact, I just saw you earlier this week at the launch of the
- 32:10Aberdeen Chamber of Commerce Supply Chain Report, which you
- 32:15were really involved in supporting, but you were
- 32:18thinking we've just listened to representatives from Vestas and
- 32:23from the Inverness port and then interestingly also tarmac.
- 32:31Tarmac, Thank you and interesting chat about the
- 32:36supply chain, but what were your initial thoughts?
- 32:38I mean, you know, are they thinking enough about oil and
- 32:41gas? Are we thinking about the and
- 32:42and the OR are we still talking about silos?
- 32:45Yeah, very, very much. As we discussed earlier, I felt
- 32:49there was very much an ether or and part of being here today is
- 32:56for me to understand that. Learn more here From the other
- 32:59perspective, I can understand Scottish Renewables and the
- 33:04attendees and investor are very much looking at their investment
- 33:09strategy and the return for them, which seem to be very
- 33:15supportive of both the Scottish Government and the UK Government
- 33:18at this point in time with their policy towards renewables.
- 33:22However, I did feel that while they face the same challenges,
- 33:27it was very much us and them rather than it being, let's
- 33:31think about this cohesively, let's talk more about an energy
- 33:35sector rather than oil and gas and renewables.
- 33:40But there was certainly the same theme and some surprising themes
- 33:44coming through skill set. You know, resource labour was
- 33:50touched on in an earlier session this morning where she thought
- 33:53naturally and certainly for offshore that would come from
- 33:58the existing subsea oil and gas. Sure.
- 34:03That just transition we keep on hearing about right you.
- 34:07Know it, Russell explained. Yeah, very clearly.
- 34:10Again, you know, it's about change over time.
- 34:13It's not overnight. Yeah, right.
- 34:16Are you seeing anything here that is giving you reasons for
- 34:23hope or, I mean, Tuesday, you know, had some positives coming
- 34:28out of the report in the chamber.
- 34:30You know, there's still some people saying that, you know,
- 34:32the North Sea supply chain, you know, has some things to look
- 34:36forward to. But there was a lot of, like,
- 34:38grim in that report. I mean, I thought there was a
- 34:41brave face kind of being put on that a little.
- 34:43Bit you know what 1 positive highlight was 93% of the
- 34:47respondees seeing that there's a future for oil and gas in the
- 34:51UKCS. That's something to cling on to.
- 34:57It was very much a bit of Deja vu from the previous reports.
- 35:01This is the third report that we've been involved in and it's
- 35:08ensuring that we don't get frustrated by the at times lack
- 35:14of traction is taken by government policy decisions.
- 35:19That is fundamental to everything that happens.
- 35:22You know, we're talking about decision making processes that
- 35:27don't last. A political cycle is much longer
- 35:31and looking for adequate confidence was a word that's
- 35:35been mentioned. Certainty again has been
- 35:38emphasized today to be able to make those longer term
- 35:42investment decisions. And especially if I were going
- 35:45into renewables and offshore, it's not 1-2 years, it's
- 35:5310/15/20 years. It's going to be the the kind of
- 35:58window that needs to be looked at for a return in that
- 36:01investment. And and interestingly then you
- 36:04had Catherine on Tuesday kind of from what logic talking about
- 36:09the kind of fragility, yeah, of the infrastructure to support
- 36:14that. Yeah, that was a bit.
- 36:18There's still people talking about that, that's for sure.
- 36:20Absolutely. But even what is interesting is
- 36:23just from that discussion, it kind of seemed like they were
- 36:28also saying what we need more than five years, you know, we
- 36:33need to kind of think about, you know, beyond that as well.
- 36:37And, you know, even they're still, when I see they, we're
- 36:41not talking about us and them, but like, you know, the
- 36:43renewable sector that is kind of like being the one that has all
- 36:47the pressure from central government or and UK government
- 36:50to say this is the big plan. Even they're waiting for
- 36:54certainty, which is like, you know, you know, we need, I guess
- 36:57we just need more of it. Yeah, we we need confidence.
- 37:01We need the good news stories, you know the investment again
- 37:06this afternoon they touched on GB Energy, SNIM and National
- 37:11Wealth fund investments, equity investment, which I thought was
- 37:14quite a good tack for that public sector and it's equity
- 37:18investments that are then reflecting the long term
- 37:21partnership that we any business would wish to be in.
- 37:26So I think if that could, it's just, you know, the, the, the
- 37:31chamber put forward and there was the North Seal Transition
- 37:35Authority and committee put together.
- 37:39And one of the things that came out loud from that was it needs
- 37:44to actually on a sit above like the Bank of England, yes, sit
- 37:49outside the kind of normal political cycle.
- 37:53So there's longer term, but they felt it was too late for that
- 37:57because in the process it would just take too long to get there.
- 38:02OK, again, creating a gap, this gap that we're talking about
- 38:06ever widening between the transition from one resource to
- 38:11the other. Well, one of the things they
- 38:14said was other places are having difficulty too.
- 38:17So I guess we all just gotta try to grapple with this.
- 38:20Yeah. Yeah.
- 38:22Well, thank you so much. That was really great to chat
- 38:25with you. And it kind of feels like we've
- 38:26been kind of meeting each other all week.
- 38:28And so maybe we can kind of finally settle this question and
- 38:32get it all done. Yeah.
- 38:33Thank you very much, Erica. That does it for another episode
- 38:36of Energy Voice Out Loud. Thank you, Erica, Ed and Matt
- 38:39for joining me and thank you for listening.
- 38:42If you'd like to hear more from uswellenergyvoice.com is the
- 38:45place to be and we'll be back same time, same place next week.