Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / MG Windsor EV: India's Electric Crossover Revolution
Transcript
- 0:10OK, imagine this. You walk into a car showroom
- 0:13today and you know, you see this car that looks like he just
- 0:17drove out of a sci-fi movie. It's big.
- 0:19It's futuristic. Very distinct look.
- 0:22Totally sweeping shape, huge glass roof.
- 0:26You look inside and the seats, yeah, they look like business
- 0:30class on an airplane, right? You're thinking, OK, this has to
- 0:33be what, a ₹20,00,000 car? At least it definitely has that
- 0:37kind of presence. I agree.
- 0:39Right. But then you look at the sticker
- 0:40price and it says 9.99 lakh rupees.
- 0:44Which is the price of a basic manual compact SUV.
- 0:46Exactly. And your brain just get it.
- 0:49It does a double take. You're thinking, Is that a typo?
- 0:51Did they forget A1 in front of it?
- 0:53Or if you're a bit cynical, you're wondering, am I only
- 0:55buying like half the car? And that is exactly where we're
- 0:58going today because in a way you sort of are welcome to the deep
- 1:03dive. We are looking at the MG Windsor
- 1:05EV and honestly the car is interesting, but the real story
- 1:08here is this massive financial experiment that JSWMG is
- 1:13running. That's right.
- 1:14We're talking about battery as a service or bus, and it's a
- 1:18concept that sounds amazing in a headline pay.
- 1:21As you go. Simple, but the devil is, as
- 1:24always, in the fine print and it gets complicated fast.
- 1:27So our mission today is pretty simple.
- 1:29We're going to explain this clearly.
- 1:31We've dug through the Auto Car India reviews, the official
- 1:33press releases, the spec sheets and the really dense terms from
- 1:38the finance companies. Yeah, those are fun.
- 1:40We want to figure out two things.
- 1:41One is the Windsor EV actually a good car?
- 1:45And two, is this pay as you go thing a genius move for your
- 1:49wallet or is it a bit of a trap? Both are critical questions.
- 1:53I mean, if the car is no good, the financing doesn't matter.
- 1:55And. If the car is amazing but the
- 1:56financing is a nightmare, that's even worse.
- 1:58Exactly. So let's start with the car
- 2:00itself, the metal, before we get into the money.
- 2:02MG calls it an intelligent CUV. I feel like the car industry
- 2:06just invents a new acronym every six months.
- 2:09What exactly is a CUV? So CUV is crossover utility
- 2:14vehicle, and in this case it's a bit of a genre Bender.
- 2:16It's trying to be a sedan, an SUV and an MPV all at once.
- 2:19So it's a mix of everything. Think of it as a bridge, really.
- 2:22The comfort of a sedan with the sheer space of an MPV or a van.
- 2:28Visually, it's different. I've seen the pictures.
- 2:30It's not your typical boxy SUV that sells so well in India.
- 2:33It's all curves. That's what they call their Aero
- 2:36glide design. The whole idea is to be more
- 2:39efficient. Efficient, cut through the air
- 2:40better short hood, steep windshield.
- 2:44It almost looks like a pod from the future.
- 2:46And we have to mention the headlights.
- 2:47Someone called them banana style lights, yes.
- 2:49That's the nickname that's sticking online.
- 2:51The main headlamps are positioned way down low on the
- 2:53bumper. Is it just for looks?
- 2:56No, actually there's a very practical reason for that whole
- 2:58shape. It's all about maximizing the
- 3:00space inside the car. How so?
- 3:03Well, the car is about 4.3 meters long, so you know CRETA
- 3:07or Celtos territory, but the wheelbase, the distance between
- 3:10the front and rear wheels is 2700 millimeters.
- 3:13And that's big for this class. It's massive and a longer
- 3:17wheelbase means more room inside the cabin.
- 3:19They've pushed the wheels to the absolute corners, which gives
- 3:23you a startling amount of legroom.
- 3:25Which brings us to the interior, which they're marketing is
- 3:28business class. And very aggressively.
- 3:30And look, usually that just means they've added some fake
- 3:32leather, but they have a feature that might actually live up to
- 3:35the name. You're talking about the air
- 3:37lounge seats in the back. This is their party trick.
- 3:40Yeah, they recline to 135°. 135 it's almost flat.
- 3:45That's not a car seat, it's a dentist.
- 3:47'S chair hopefully a lot more comfortable, but yes, it's a
- 3:50first in this segment and you have to think a lot of people in
- 3:54this price bracket are chauffeur driven.
- 3:56Being able to lie back like that in a car with this price tag,
- 4:00that's a huge deal. It changes the whole use case,
- 4:02right? It becomes a mobile lounge and
- 4:04they have that huge Infinity view glass roof too.
- 4:08It makes the whole cabin feel incredibly airy.
- 4:11And then there's the tech centerpiece, this massive 15.6
- 4:15inch screen in the middle of the dash.
- 4:17It's basically a laptop screen. It's the biggest in the segment
- 4:20and almost everything is controlled through it.
- 4:22There are very few physical buttons.
- 4:24Which looks great, but I always worry about trying to change the
- 4:26AC fan speed on a bumpy Rd. It's a valid concern.
- 4:30It's what they call a 0 clutter philosophy, but it means you're
- 4:34tapping through menus for everything.
- 4:36OK, so we have a car that's spacious, it's techie ventilated
- 4:40seats, a good sound system, all the cameras.
- 4:43It feels like it should be much more expensive, but it's 9.99,
- 4:46right? So now we have to talk about the
- 4:48battery that isn't included in that price.
- 4:50Exactly, this is Batia battery as a service.
- 4:53I'm going to break this down really carefully.
- 4:55When I hear subscription, I think Netflix.
- 4:58I don't think about a core component of my car.
- 5:00How does it work? The best analogy is probably a
- 5:03printer in ink. When you pay that 9.99 Lac,
- 5:07you're buying the printer. The metal, the seats, the
- 5:09software. But the ink cartridges, the
- 5:13batteries. You don't own those, you rent
- 5:15them. OK.
- 5:16And the main reason is just to get that sticker price down.
- 5:19Well, yes, but it solves a huge problem in any EV.
- 5:22The battery is the single most expensive part.
- 5:25We're talking 30 to 40% of the total cost.
- 5:27By taking that out of the initial price, they instantly
- 5:30slash the cost to buy the car by, you know, 3 or ₹4,00,000.
- 5:34So I own the car but JSWI mean G or their partners, they own the
- 5:38battery that's literally underneath my seat.
- 5:40Correct. And to use that battery, you pay
- 5:43a rental fee based on how far you drive.
- 5:46The rate they're advertising everywhere is 3 1/2 rupees per
- 5:49kilometer. Rs 3.5 per kilometer on the
- 5:52surface that sounds pretty cheap.
- 5:53It's designed to they want you to compare it to petrol, which
- 5:56might be 8-9 maybe ₹10 a kilometer.
- 5:59So 3.5 looks fantastic. Wait a second, and this is a key
- 6:02point that 3.5 rupees is just for renting the battery right?
- 6:06It doesn't include the actual electricity.
- 6:08That is the crucial distinction, yes.
- 6:10You pay the rental, plus you pay to charge it.
- 6:13So at home, that's maybe another rupee per kilometer.
- 6:15Your actual total running cost is closer to 4 1/2 rupees.
- 6:18OK. So 4.5 versus 8 or 9 for petrol.
- 6:21Still a big saving. It is.
- 6:23MG claims you could save around 3,00,000 / 3 years.
- 6:27But, and this is where it gets tricky, the payment isn't as
- 6:30simple pay as you go for everybody.
- 6:33Right, this is the part that confused me.
- 6:35It's not like I just send them my odometer reading at the end
- 6:38of the month, no. MG has four different financing
- 6:41partners for this. And here's the twist.
- 6:44They all have different rules. It's not one standard plan.
- 6:47OK, let's walk through this. Say I'm a typical commuter.
- 6:49I drive maybe, you know, 40 kilometers a day.
- 6:53Who would I sign up? With you'd probably look at
- 6:54Bajaj Finance or Hairfin Corps. They're the main ones, but they
- 6:59have a catch. What's that?
- 7:00A minimum monthly charge. A minimum, yes.
- 7:03They bill you for a minimum of 1500 kilometers every month.
- 7:07Wait. 1500 that's that's a lot. That's 50 kilometers every
- 7:11single day, including weekends. What if I only drive 800
- 7:14kilometers in a month? You still pay for 1500.
- 7:16Ouch. So 1500 * 3.5 that's ₹5250.
- 7:21Exactly. So your car could be parked for
- 7:23three weeks while you're on holiday, and you're still paying
- 7:26over ₹5000 for the battery rental on top of your car loan.
- 7:30That feels like a bit of a hidden cost for people who don't
- 7:32drive a lot. For a low mileage driver it is,
- 7:35but if you're a heavy user, say a salesperson driving 2000
- 7:38kilometers a month, the math is fantastic for you.
- 7:41OK, So what about those low mileage users?
- 7:43Is there an option for them? There is.
- 7:45That's where a partner called Video Tech comes in.
- 7:48They offer a true pay as you go plan, no minimums.
- 7:52That sounds much better. Why doesn't everyone just pick
- 7:54that one? Well they might have stricter
- 7:56credit requirements or maybe a higher security deposit.
- 7:59You have to qualify for their specific plan.
- 8:01It's not a free for all. I see.
- 8:03And what about the fourth option?
- 8:04That's a pair, Ecofy and autovert.
- 8:07They seem to be for people with maybe less than perfect credit
- 8:11scores. And the catches?
- 8:13The weight jumps from 3.5 rupees to 5.8 per kilometer.
- 8:17Yeah, that's almost double. It is at that point the savings
- 8:20over petrol really start to shrink.
- 8:21So you, the listener have to be so careful.
- 8:24Don't just look at the Billboard.
- 8:26Find out which partner you qualify for and what their
- 8:28minimums are. OK, here's the nightmare
- 8:30scenario. I buy the car for 9.99 lakhs but
- 8:35then I lose my job or something and I stop paying the battery
- 8:38rent. I still own the car itself,
- 8:40don't I? No, and this is the sting in the
- 8:43tail. The agreement treats the car and
- 8:45battery as one single asset if you default on the battery,
- 8:50rent. They can take the whole car.
- 8:52They can repossess the entire vehicle even though you paid for
- 8:55the metal part. That's intense.
- 8:57It means you never really fully own the car.
- 8:59Not while you're in the bass program.
- 9:01There's a perpetual Lin on it. So is there an exit?
- 9:04Can I just say I'm done renting? Here's a check for the battery.
- 9:07Yes you can. There's a foreclosure option to
- 9:09pay the remaining value of the battery, and then you own the
- 9:12whole thing free and clear. OK.
- 9:13That's a relief. So there is an off ramp?
- 9:15There is, and interestingly MG is also just selling the car the
- 9:19old fashioned way with the battery included if you want to
- 9:21skip all this. Oh really?
- 9:22So you don't have to do baths? Not at all.
- 9:24What's the price for the whole enchilada them?
- 9:26It ranges from 13 point 50,00,000 to 15.50 lakh
- 9:30depending on the trim level. OK, so 13.5 to 15 point
- 9:335,00,000. So now I'm comparing it to the
- 9:36Tata Nexon EV, the Mahindra XUV 400.
- 9:40Those are the direct rivals and here the comparison gets really
- 9:42interesting. Both the Nexon and the XUV 400
- 9:46in their top trims offer a bit more range.
- 9:48They're quoting over 450 kilometers.
- 9:50And the Windsor, what's its range?
- 9:52It has a 38 kilowattered battery and the certified ARAI range is
- 9:57331 kilometers 300. And 31 which in the real world
- 10:01means. You're probably looking at 200,
- 10:0450, maybe 260 kilometers. So it is very much a City car,
- 10:08not a long distance cruiser. Absolutely.
- 10:10You're not driving from Mumbai to Goa without a serious
- 10:12charging stop. That's the trade off.
- 10:14The Windsor gives you all that space and luxury, but it
- 10:16compromises on outright range compared to its rivals.
- 10:19So. It's for the person being driven
- 10:21around the city, not the person doing weekend Rd. trips.
- 10:23That's a very fair summary, but we should touch on the battery
- 10:25chemistry because that's important for safety fears,
- 10:27right? Fire safety.
- 10:28It uses LFT chemistry, lithium, iron phosphate.
- 10:31It's just generally safer, more stable, and it lasts longer.
- 10:34You can charge it to 100% all the time without as much worry
- 10:38about degradation. And what about resale value?
- 10:40That's the other big EV fear. MG has two very strong answers
- 10:44for that. First, a lifetime battery
- 10:47warranty for the first owner. Lifetime.
- 10:49Wow. It takes away that anxiety.
- 10:51And second, they have an assured buyback plan.
- 10:54They guarantee 60% of the value back after three years. 60% is
- 10:58actually very good. That puts a floor into the
- 11:00price. It's a huge confidence booster
- 11:02for a first time EV buyer. So let's pull all this together.
- 11:06It's a car that breaks the mold on design, on interior space,
- 11:10and definitely on how you pay for it.
- 11:11I really see the Windsor as a massive test for the Indian
- 11:14market. MG is betting the main barrier
- 11:17to EV adoption isn't the tech, it's that huge upfront cost.
- 11:21Betting that if they can get the price under that psychological
- 11:2310,00,000 mark, people will sign up for monthly payments.
- 11:26It's turning a car from a capital expense into an
- 11:29operating expense, a monthly bill.
- 11:32And for a lot of families, managing cash flow is more
- 11:34important than the total cost over 10 years.
- 11:36But the. Key take away for you the
- 11:38listener has to be do your homework, read the contract,
- 11:42know your own mileage. If you drive a ton, this boss
- 11:45model could be an incredible deal.
- 11:48But if you barely drive and you get stuck with a plan that has a
- 11:50huge minimum, you're just subsidizing the experiment.
- 11:54You have to do the math for your own situation.
- 11:56Exactly. Before we finish, I want to
- 11:58leave you with one final thought.
- 12:00We're used to subscriptions for software, right?
- 12:04Netflix, Spotify. Now we're renting a battery.
- 12:08If this works, what's next? This is slippery slope, isn't?
- 12:12It right? I mean, could you imagine buying
- 12:13a car but you have to pay a monthly fee to unlock its full
- 12:17horsepower? Or you subscribe to the Comfort
- 12:20suspension package. It sounds a bit dystopian, but
- 12:23some car makers have already tried subscriptions for things
- 12:25like heated seats and other countries.
- 12:27If this hardware as a service model works here, who knows.
- 12:30Sorry, can't overtake that truck.
- 12:32My Torque subscription just expired.
- 12:33Let's hope it doesn't quite get to that.
- 12:35Indeed, it's a fascinating experiment, and the Windsor is
- 12:38the first big test case we'll be watching very closely.
- 12:42Thank you so much for tuning in. We know your time is valuable
- 12:45and we really appreciate you spending it here with us.
- 12:47Yes, thank you. Always a pleasure.
- 12:50Got to Belasco to. See you on the next deep dive.