Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP286: How To Scale An Ecommerce Business Using Marketplaces, With Furniture Box Co-founder Dan Beckles
Transcript
- 0:00A lot of assistants will say you have an order from Mrs. Jones
- 0:03here, you need to go and pick her full order before and it
- 0:05could be dispatched. So we needed a system that we we
- 0:08were able to customize. We want a setup where we could
- 0:11go and pick Mrs. Jones tabletop here.
- 0:13Someone else is going to go and pick her chairs and in an hour's
- 0:16time I'm going to go and pick the legs.
- 0:18But it doesn't matter because when I get to the pack station,
- 0:21I can still print the consignment label for just that
- 0:24individual piece. People Box gave us great
- 0:27flexibility for that and it's been super useful.
- 0:30You listen to Inside Commerce, a weekly E Comm strategy,
- 0:33technology and CX focus podcast hosted by experienced digital
- 0:36consultants and re platform specialist James Good and Paul
- 0:38Rogers. Get insights into E Comm
- 0:40strategy leading brands, hear from industry thought leaders
- 0:42and leading tech vendors with practical advice to help you
- 0:45improve your online CX. This episode is sponsored by
- 0:50Shopify, and our topic is we're talking to the Furniture Box Co
- 0:54founder Dan Beckles on marketplace growth strategies.
- 0:57So another topical episode this week.
- 0:59There's a lot of talk about marketplace commerce.
- 1:02It was growing quite rapidly over the last few years.
- 1:04But there's more interest I'm seeing as well in businesses
- 1:07that haven't historically really pushed into marketplaces,
- 1:09looking at how they extend and open up to new sales channels.
- 1:12So we're really looking forward to having this conversation.
- 1:13So welcome to our guest, Dan. How are you, Dan?
- 1:16Yeah, very well. Thanks, James.
- 1:18Thank you very much for having me on.
- 1:19Yeah, I really appreciate you taking on.
- 1:20I'm really looking forward to it.
- 1:21I've been, I know through Route 5874 is your big commerce
- 1:26partner. I've been hearing a lot of
- 1:28really, really positive things from over the last few months
- 1:31about what's happened in your growth story.
- 1:33So I'm really looking forward to hearing a bit more about what's
- 1:35behind it. So before we get into the nitty
- 1:37gritty about the the ECOM strategy of that growth beans,
- 1:39let's start with the founder stories.
- 1:40I think it's really interesting like where did you monitor your
- 1:42Co founder get the idea or furniture box from?
- 1:45Because the furniture space has got quite a lot of competition,
- 1:48quite a lot of heritage businesses and large sheds as
- 1:50well. So where did the idea come from?
- 1:52I I guess how much has the concept evolved since you
- 1:55launched in 2015? Yeah, so we, I'd known Monty for
- 1:59years and years and years. So we we were best friends
- 2:01throughout school. Whilst we were at school, he was
- 2:04one of those young entrepreneurs selling things on eBay.
- 2:07So all sorts of bits and bobs throughout our school journey.
- 2:11We played in sports teams together.
- 2:13I was actually going to go off to university so I I had my
- 2:16place at Loughborough. I was going to go and study
- 2:18economics. And just before I did that,
- 2:22Monty turned around to me and he'd heard that there's a
- 2:24potential opportunity in furniture because it was quite
- 2:27big and bulky. And at the time, in 20, 2015,
- 2:31there wasn't a huge amount of competition on eBay and other
- 2:34marketplaces because the barriers to enter are pretty
- 2:37high. If you wanted to get into the
- 2:39furniture space, you had to buy a big container and then you'd
- 2:43have to sell this big bulky furniture throughout the UK
- 2:46where it could get damaged. So it wasn't the easiest
- 2:50industry to go into. And so we saw that there was
- 2:52actually quite a big opportunity for us to be one of the first
- 2:55people doing that on a large scale throughout marketplaces.
- 2:58So the idea very much at the start was a case of let's find a
- 3:03supplier, get one container and then see what sells.
- 3:06At that point we were going on trends and styles we'd seen
- 3:09elsewhere, getting inspiration from other people.
- 3:12And because we had that eBay store built up for years and
- 3:15years, we're already a top seller on eBay.
- 3:18So we we started there. And I guess in terms of how it's
- 3:23evolved, marketplace has always been a huge thing for us and
- 3:27they still are to this day. We sell at about 9 or 10
- 3:29different marketplaces. So that strategy's never left
- 3:32us. But I think the way that the
- 3:35business is evolving now is we've got a bit more purpose to
- 3:38us. Back then we were just buying
- 3:40and selling furniture in any way, shape or form, whereas now
- 3:44we're doing it with a bit more purpose and direction.
- 3:47What I'd say. Interesting.
- 3:49You only said to you about 9 marketplaces now.
- 3:51I find this really interesting because a lot of businesses,
- 3:54their first port of call when they launch on e-commerce is
- 3:58right, let's get our own website and then maybe we'll use 1
- 4:00marketplace Like I've seen that a lot where eBay or on Amazon
- 4:04rather than marketplace 1st and and then I guess build out your
- 4:08own web presence. So what what was the reason to
- 4:11go down that route and just go right?
- 4:12We're going to focus and get the marketplace strategy right first
- 4:15rather than try and expand a massive DTC piece of our own.
- 4:19Plain and simple, pretty much capital.
- 4:22So we bootstrapped everything and we were 218 year old boys.
- 4:27So we didn't have money behind us and that meant that we can
- 4:30afford to build a website, develop a website.
- 4:33And so because we had the experience on on the likes of
- 4:36eBay, we knew how it worked. We could transfer that straight
- 4:39across lots of marketplaces. So we used the likes of an eBay
- 4:43and Amazon initially to grow our brand and, and, and leverage
- 4:48capital that we could then invest in a website.
- 4:50So the dream is always to have our own website.
- 4:52But I guess the thing that stopped us initially was we, we
- 4:55just couldn't afford it. And using the likes of an eBay
- 4:59and Amazon are brilliant because it sort of catapulted us.
- 5:02They, they pay for a lot of the marketing, the advertising and
- 5:06we're merely just using their platform.
- 5:08There are obviously fees involved, but it meant that we
- 5:10could be seen by thousands and thousands of people without
- 5:13having to pay the traditional marketing costs associated with
- 5:16the website. And on the strategic side, I've
- 5:19got, I guess I'm going to split this into two bits.
- 5:21The second bits will be out where, where you factors and how
- 5:24you get from like one or two up to 9 mark.
- 5:26So the first bit would be you touched it earlier.
- 5:29The big challenge of furniture is bulky lead times can be
- 5:33complicated to manage and they be shipping from various places
- 5:35around the world and you've got supply chains to manage, which I
- 5:38imagine that age 18 is quite daunting to come in and go
- 5:40right. How do you know this?
- 5:41Because if you don't get the proposition right and you can't
- 5:44fulfil and you start missing order delivery dates and in
- 5:47marketplaces that can massively hamper your seller reputation.
- 5:50So how did you approach that to make sure you got that piece
- 5:53working and how much of A learning curve was that?
- 5:56Yeah, it was a huge learning curve.
- 5:58I I think the thing that really helped us is that we did
- 6:01everything. So we started to understand,
- 6:04particularly with the marketplace in the channels, how
- 6:06we needed to behave with those. So you talk about furniture
- 6:10items being big and bulky, they absolutely are.
- 6:12And at the start, our packaging probably wasn't that great.
- 6:15Because our packaging wasn't that great, we would see the
- 6:18complaints first hand. And because we saw the
- 6:20complaints first hand in in support of the customers, it
- 6:23meant that we cared a lot more about our packaging.
- 6:25So we would then go to our suppliers and make sure the
- 6:28packaging was even better because if it wasn't and we kept
- 6:31getting complaints, we didn't have the capital to then buy
- 6:33more furniture. But also on marketplaces, what's
- 6:37really important is your feedback.
- 6:39And this is where I think it's helped us to evolve over time
- 6:41because we've always hugely cared about customers and and
- 6:45serving customers in the best way possible.
- 6:48And that started really at that core, core premise that we
- 6:51wanted to do the best possible job we could.
- 6:53And that's kind of where we saw the gap there because there were
- 6:56lots of sellers selling similar products, some cheaper than us,
- 7:00but we said actually how can we be better than all of them.
- 7:04And so merchandising is one part of it in terms of our image, our
- 7:07descriptions, but actually that service proposition to customers
- 7:10was huge for us. So it was a massive, massive
- 7:14learning curve because we didn't know anything about furniture
- 7:18where we went into furniture and we were still very fresh on
- 7:20business. So we did make a lot of
- 7:22mistakes, but we learnt from those pretty quickly.
- 7:25But what was at the core of everything we did was that
- 7:28customer. And so it would be myself and
- 7:31Monty calling up a customer at 6:00 PM in the evening to
- 7:33apologise if something went wrong and making sure we
- 7:36rectified it. It would be us in, in the
- 7:38warehouse adding additional packaging and fragile take to
- 7:41make sure that that customer got the item.
- 7:44So any problems we dealt with ourselves.
- 7:45And I think it, it really helped us to appreciate the nuances in,
- 7:49in the industry and maybe how we could be better.
- 7:52So yeah, I, I think it's it, it definitely was the, the right
- 7:57move for us to do that. And that was for the first
- 7:59three, 3 1/2 years. And we did actually everything,
- 8:02even from the unloading of containers and sourcing the
- 8:04products. Do you know that it's a really
- 8:07important point of differentiation because a lot of
- 8:09big retailers, the leadership teams won't have that, that
- 8:13ground level experience of being involved in the nitty gritty,
- 8:17having to see what the issues are, having to fix them, phone
- 8:19up customers, you know, apologise, handle issues, deal
- 8:22with direct customers, turn them into happy ones.
- 8:25Now, like Fast forward to where you are now as a leader, who I
- 8:30imagine you're probably not doing so many calls to customers
- 8:32to say what's going on with your order because you have teams.
- 8:35How, how does that help you in terms of like managing the
- 8:38business, managing teams to have seen that first hand?
- 8:42I think it gives that perspective and appreciation for
- 8:44the jobs that everyone does because we've done every single
- 8:48job. We know how hard they can be and
- 8:50how stressful they can be. And I think particularly in
- 8:53operational roles, a lot of business leaders don't
- 8:55understand that whereas we're still regularly for Black Friday
- 8:59in our busy periods, we go into the warehouse and we do the full
- 9:01day with everyone. We, we appreciate how difficult
- 9:04that can be. And I think by by going through
- 9:08that as well, we know what worked for our customers and,
- 9:11and what made people happy. And so the, we've got a
- 9:14brilliant, brilliant management team around us and they
- 9:16transferred the way that we started the business as we grow.
- 9:21So our service level's still superb.
- 9:23We still treat every single customer individually with their
- 9:26their own needs and we we cater to that.
- 9:28So I think it's it's been hugely important for us as we grow into
- 9:33Keen that that culture and everyone we've brought in has
- 9:37has managed to fit into that perfectly.
- 9:41What do Mattel, Victoria Beckham, Sennheiser and Glossier
- 9:46all have in common? They power their businesses with
- 9:49Shopify. Shopify is the most innovative
- 9:53and scaled commerce platform on the planet.
- 9:57It also happens to have the best converting check out on the
- 10:00planet Shopify Powering the future of enterprise commerce.
- 10:06Find out more at Shopify dot. Com slash enterprise.
- 10:10Yeah, and it's recruit. Recruitment is challenging when
- 10:13you grow to get people who combines the gold.
- 10:15But the culture come always comes from the top down if it's
- 10:18when it's done properly, and I think that's really important
- 10:20because empathy towards other people's stresses and challenges
- 10:24is important. And you, you said earlier about,
- 10:27you know, lessons learned because no matter who, not any
- 10:30of us working in E com whatever we've been managing and, and
- 10:34growing, we make mistakes, we learn from it and we sharpen up.
- 10:37And only in marketplaces, a lot of times people's main focus is
- 10:40the right, have we got the right price?
- 10:41Have we got the right images and product data?
- 10:43And if we get the product data wrong, it that's and that's
- 10:46generally where the E com lens focuses.
- 10:48What else have you seen now? What were the mistakes outside
- 10:50of just that product data peaks, and what have you learned from
- 10:54it and how does it help you sharpen up your marketplace
- 10:56strategy? Yes, I, I think there's, there's
- 10:59so many mistakes that we've made along the way.
- 11:01There's the obvious ones with the products.
- 11:04So sometimes we've had product that's come in that's been
- 11:06defective and we didn't have our own QC teams at the time.
- 11:10So you would get an inspection report from a supplier, the
- 11:13product would come in, we didn't have the time to open it up and
- 11:15check it. And so before you know you've
- 11:17sold 10 tables someone and there's a defect on every single
- 11:21one. You've then got 10 customers who
- 11:23are angry. You've got product that you have
- 11:25to have to quarantine that you can't sell.
- 11:27And so we went through a few of those those hurdles before we
- 11:30got it right. I think in terms of marketplaces
- 11:34more generally, we it's, it's a mistake maybe that we've made
- 11:37later on that on reflection we did it for the right reasons,
- 11:42but it it's maybe not the best way of managing marketplaces.
- 11:45We have about 10 to 15,000 skews as variations and we thought it
- 11:50would be a fantastic idea to load every single one of them
- 11:53onto every single platform. Now the typical sort of 8020
- 11:57rule, we've got 20% of our products that are making up
- 12:00about 80% of our revenue rather than focusing on those.
- 12:04And we almost spread ourselves a little bit tooth then.
- 12:06And at the start it was fantastic because you might have
- 12:0920 products that you've got to manage.
- 12:10And so you can merchandise them, you can track them, you can make
- 12:14changes to them, you can you can put all of your time and
- 12:17attention to those products and they're making all of your
- 12:20revenue. Now Fast forward to where we are
- 12:24today, when you've got to do that on 10,000 products, you
- 12:27can't put the time in on all of them.
- 12:29And so we've probably stretched ourselves quite thin and we've
- 12:31actually found a lot of marketplaces, we're pulling back
- 12:34our selection a little bit now to try and focus on those core
- 12:37ranges. So I'd say that's probably a
- 12:40mistake that we made rather than going after just our our best
- 12:44selling products and and doing those even better, we sort of
- 12:47spread ourselves quite thin by by having everything.
- 12:51Do you know that that resonates to me when I before I was a
- 12:54consultant, I was head of E com, I launched a brand onto Amazon
- 12:58and I made that classic mistake. It was like, let's get
- 13:00everything on. We maximize our sales and
- 13:02actually just diluted it. And, and I as a result, the
- 13:06quality of the listing wasn't the strong and my marketing
- 13:08wasn't. And I learned the hard way as
- 13:10well. I was like that really copped
- 13:11up, strip it back, focus on your top 20 and that's exact.
- 13:14I went from 200 to 20 skews and was like, right, that feels
- 13:18manageable. Now I can actually see some
- 13:19sales. Exactly that.
- 13:22And I think it's the, the logic was there and it's, it's the,
- 13:26the reasoning in your own head, you say, ah, the more products
- 13:28we have on there, the more we sell.
- 13:29But when you actually strip it back and let's say you've got a,
- 13:32an ads budget of £100 a day, if you're spreading that over
- 13:3610,000 products, you're, you're not going to actually generate
- 13:39any sustained good ad revenue. So it's definitely something
- 13:43we're we're looking at more and more now to strip.
- 13:46Yeah, exactly. Then you've got the knock on
- 13:47impact of of stock is precarious sometimes not you can't
- 13:51guarantee every SKU's going to have constantly good solid
- 13:54supply and managing the ones that don't have that volatility
- 13:57to establish your accelerator is far more sensible and then
- 14:00gradually add in. Yeah, exactly.
- 14:03And all this. So I saw read an article
- 14:05recently about your U.S. sales tripling last year and you said
- 14:10that was driven a lot by Wayfair.
- 14:11And I'm really intrigued by this because I mistakenly assumed it
- 14:14was Amazon and you said Wayfair. So I'd love to know why is
- 14:17Wayfair so, so pivotal to you in the US?
- 14:19And coming back to that question about range, how do you approach
- 14:22the range bit for the US lot? Sure.
- 14:26So Wayfair have been a fantastic partner for us over the last six
- 14:30or seven years. And although we didn't start out
- 14:33on Wayfair, we we went on to the marketplace after about 3 or 4
- 14:37years. And the difference with Wayfair
- 14:40is that they are just furniture. So that is all they focus on.
- 14:44It's where they specialize and the likes of Amazon, eBay are
- 14:47brilliant platforms, but they sell everything.
- 14:50Whereas Wayfair are very focused on furniture and we built really
- 14:54good relationships there and grew quite a lot in the UK
- 14:57market with them. And because of that, they're
- 15:00they're AUS based company, but they have global ambitions.
- 15:03So they sell into Ireland, they sell into Germany.
- 15:07They have facilities in each of those to enable sellers like
- 15:10ourselves and wholesalers to sell into that marketplace
- 15:14without having to have a presence there.
- 15:15So almost like an Amazon FBA they call Castlegate themselves.
- 15:20And the opportunity came about because we were doing a a big
- 15:23bit of business with them in the UK market.
- 15:25And we've been pushing for for a number of months to say, look,
- 15:28we really want to try the US market.
- 15:30We think our our products offering is something a little
- 15:33bit unique. A lot of the US market's quite
- 15:36traditional. We're very modern and we had a
- 15:38lot of glass and Cray metal, which is reasonably popular in
- 15:42the US market, but it's not their the most popular category.
- 15:46So have we pestered them for, for quite a while and eventually
- 15:49they said, yeah, okay, fine, we'll we give give this a go.
- 15:53And they'd only allowed a handful of suppliers to do this
- 15:56throughout the whole of the UK. And we were able to do is send
- 16:01our product directly from our suppliers into their facilities
- 16:04in the US. They then handle all of the
- 16:07fulfilment, all of the couriers shifting.
- 16:10So in theory, all we needed to do was set up our listings, make
- 16:14sure that the products have been converted from centimetres to
- 16:17inches, that sort of thing. And we could just have free
- 16:21reign of the US marketplace. The beauty of that is that, as
- 16:25you'll be aware, the US is a lot, lot bigger than the UK.
- 16:29But every single, every single way.
- 16:31And a lot of three girls we'd spoken to before, we're talking
- 16:35about how we'd have to forward position a lot of our stock in
- 16:38maybe 3 or 4 locations around the US And that was a big risk
- 16:41for us. We didn't want to do that
- 16:43straight about, whereas Wayfair, they do that for us.
- 16:47And so we managed to yeah, to to run a bit of a pilot trial found
- 16:52that actually there was a bit of a unique gap for us in that
- 16:55market because although our product is maybe the most
- 16:58popular product in the US, there weren't many people selling it.
- 17:01And in terms of going back to your point as well around
- 17:04selection of products, we took the approach with this that we
- 17:09would go to trial all of our best sellers in the UK, in the
- 17:12US market, some would work and some wouldn't work.
- 17:16And part of the reason for this is that we could carry across
- 17:18our reviews. So this was really key.
- 17:21So all of the reviews we generated in Wayfair UK, we were
- 17:25able to carry across into the US market.
- 17:27So we weren't necessarily starting from a brand new
- 17:30listing and that meant with our best selling products that had
- 17:33hundreds of great reviews, it gave us that nug up.
- 17:37So yeah, it was a a big thing for us and it's now now growing
- 17:41hugely as we're ramping up the Rangers and trialling lots of
- 17:44different product. Yeah, that makes that makes a
- 17:47lot of sense about focusing on one strategic parliament that
- 17:50sort of even if you're not the most popular category in there,
- 17:53if you're the category leader within then the visibility you
- 17:57get in those journeys is really high.
- 17:59And I mean took about it's from a resource in and and who manage
- 18:02it. Because I've I've done some work
- 18:04with brands in the UK who want to sell more through other
- 18:08retailers, whether that's a marketplace like a Wayfair or
- 18:12it's through a strategic partner where they're putting their
- 18:13products onto there. And the bit that they often
- 18:16underestimate is the time and effort it some natural
- 18:18relationships with the E com equivalent so that you have are
- 18:22directed and you can plan marketing and you can use your
- 18:24marketing budget effectively rather than just using some
- 18:27generic selling tools and hope it so lovely.
- 18:29How do you do that? How how do you have like E com
- 18:32to E com connections so that you are getting the most out of any
- 18:35marketing spend for like search and discovery?
- 18:38We, we take a lot of time and effort to go and see people and
- 18:41both. So I think COVID was, was great
- 18:46in terms of it allowed more people to work remotely and to
- 18:49be flexible. But I think a lot of businesses
- 18:52have lost touch with sort of the the person to person in face
- 18:56meetings. And we find that that helps
- 18:58hugely. You can sit on meetings
- 19:01virtually and that's that's brilliant.
- 19:02But actually going and seeing people and interacting and
- 19:05building those relationships are so key.
- 19:06So we take a lot of time to go and go and visit the likes of
- 19:10Wayfair, go and see them. And I guess if I was to sort of
- 19:15put an analogy on it a little bit, it's, it's kind of like
- 19:17playing in a football team where you're initially on trial, not,
- 19:21not much is known about you. So when we went to Wayfair,
- 19:24they, you know, they didn't really know who we were and we
- 19:26had to prove ourselves to them. So we had to prove ourselves
- 19:29inside to our products, the right quality, that we, we could
- 19:33adhere to their standards as well.
- 19:35And but also that we good people to deal with.
- 19:38And I guess in a football team, if you you go on trial somewhere
- 19:41and your attitude's really poor and you don't care about
- 19:44anything other than yourself and you're not doing the extra work
- 19:47behind the scenes, you're not going to get very far.
- 19:49But actually, if you buy into to what they're trying to achieve
- 19:52and and you support them in in aspects that you can, these
- 19:58opportunities come about because they recognise that they need
- 20:01suppliers that that are on board that will help learn in their
- 20:04journey and sort of a two way relationship that return to
- 20:07farm, but a lot of it's in person to help build those
- 20:10bonds. And that's a really nice thing
- 20:12to highlight actually, because this, the thing I spend quite a
- 20:15lot of time talking to people about is you have to put the F
- 20:17in because a retailer that's selling 200 brands or a
- 20:21marketplace has got everyone wanting to be top of search, top
- 20:24of category, product shelf, you name it.
- 20:28And actually, if all you're doing is asking and you're not
- 20:30build a relationship and understanding their strategy and
- 20:32how you can help them with better content or better product
- 20:35data, then it's not a two way St.
- 20:38And that partnership doesn't build.
- 20:39And actually they, they tune out more from brands who just want
- 20:42rather than what you're doing, which makes a lot of sense,
- 20:44which is build a strategic relationship.
- 20:47Absolutely. And it's, it's every aspect of
- 20:50it. And outside of obviously
- 20:52marketplaces, this is the same with all of our partners.
- 20:55It's a two way relationship. How can you help us and how can
- 20:57we help you? And with the likes of Wayfair,
- 21:00they, they have promotions that go on and we often cut our
- 21:03margins, sometimes even make negative margin to get on board
- 21:06and support them with their promotions.
- 21:08But then they might help us in a great examples with the US with
- 21:13all the uncertainty going on at the moment, they're offering
- 21:15free storage of three months new key lines.
- 21:18So that's really helped us because we're in a situation
- 21:21where our import costs have gone up.
- 21:23There's a lot of uncertainty, but they've actually taken that
- 21:26on to support suppliers. So it's it's a two way
- 21:28relationship and we find when you you both lean in, you get
- 21:32the best results. Yeah, excellent.
- 21:35And let's let's move on to like the, the tech and your
- 21:37operations because you're not just in marketplaces, you've got
- 21:40your own e-commerce site. So you can give them channel
- 21:42slash. You work with Rupa Cross and the
- 21:45team at 5874. I've got a lot of time for, I
- 21:48think they've done a lot of really good projects,
- 21:50especially, especially with like larger product catalogues and
- 21:52complex product catalogues. And you went on to Big Commerce.
- 21:56So I'd love to know what were the, what was the rationale for
- 21:58selecting Big Commerce and how much was Big Commerce's
- 22:03integration capability in marketplace as a driving force
- 22:05in that decision? Sure.
- 22:07So we, if I go back three years, we're in a position where we're
- 22:12on a Magento site, we host patched on top of patch on top
- 22:16of patch and we're in a position where we just didn't have
- 22:20stability on our site and things were constantly going wrong.
- 22:24We couldn't change things ourselves.
- 22:27It wasn't it wasn't a good platform for us to work on when
- 22:30we were trying to build our brand.
- 22:31So although marketplaces have been very key in our journey and
- 22:35they always will have have their place for sure and will always
- 22:38be a big part of our business. We realised that actually we
- 22:41want to grow our website because we can have a unique offering
- 22:44for coming was on a service proposition.
- 22:47Actually, we want want the option where come to us directly
- 22:51or they can go to their favorite marketplace and buy there as
- 22:54well. And so when we started scoping
- 22:57out new websites, the key things we were looking for was
- 23:00reliability. So a website platform that in
- 23:04its core was very stable. So what I mean by that is that
- 23:09you you're not having to apply a huge amount of custom work to
- 23:13get great out-of-the-box functionality.
- 23:15And we also want to shop with relatively low code where we
- 23:17could actually make a lot of changes ourselves.
- 23:20So the ability to change our own banners and do the small things
- 23:25like that without having to use developers or to customise
- 23:29things. And we also wanted a really key
- 23:33thing for us was longevity. So we wanted to move to a
- 23:36channel where we could stay on that that website platform for
- 23:40years to come. But we didn't want to have a bit
- 23:42of a flash in the pan 2 years to leave on because it's a big
- 23:45undertaking and there's a lot of risks.
- 23:47So when we were escaping, those were the key things.
- 23:50We came across big commerce and thought they tipped all of the
- 23:53boxes for us. We felt that it, it offered that
- 23:58hybrid of reliability as well as functionality.
- 24:00And yeah, so it, it was probably about a year.
- 24:04You also build then Rupert and the guys are taking it on and
- 24:07we're really starting to see those games now, which is, yeah,
- 24:10incredibly exciting. And yeah, 5/8 have been been
- 24:13awesome for us. But it's given us that stability
- 24:16that we haven't had for genuinely four or five years.
- 24:20I, I'm now a bit in this, this dreamland.
- 24:24Previously I was expected to wake up every day and there'll
- 24:26be a big issue on the website, a check out.
- 24:28Was it working or something, a collapse.
- 24:31Whereas now it's, it's not that it's, it's about looking further
- 24:34ahead for us on the developments and conversion rate
- 24:37optimization. Yeah.
- 24:39And this it's an interesting related question that do you
- 24:41find that because it's typically I'd see and I would never
- 24:44criticise any platform because they both they all serve
- 24:46different purposes and they fit different business models.
- 24:49But I typically with with Magento is more money is spent
- 24:52on support and maintenance and keeping it going and you spend
- 24:55less of your your budget on proactive development, road map
- 24:59and optimization. Are you seeing now that you're
- 25:01freeing up more time to push forward the improvements then?
- 25:04Exactly that. And these are improvements that
- 25:07are going to make the customer experience on site a million
- 25:11times better than it was before. And I guess with marketplaces,
- 25:14the theme that you can satisfy and frustrating is that you
- 25:17don't have the ability to carve out your own destiny there.
- 25:20You're guided by by their parameters in essence.
- 25:24And a good example is we do next day delivery up until 8:00 PM in
- 25:27the evening. Now most of our marketplaces
- 25:29can't support that. So we can't actually offer
- 25:31customers on those marketplaces the best possible service we'd
- 25:34want to. Likewise, if we we wanted to
- 25:37bundle products together that would be suitable for customers
- 25:41or upsell, that sort of thing. We can't do that easily on a lot
- 25:44of marketplaces. So I think it's for us, we're
- 25:47now seeing these these big gains on our site and compared to some
- 25:51of the marketplaces because our hands aren't tied behind our
- 25:54back. We can, we can make the changes
- 25:56that you know customers want. Let's get on to the the fun
- 26:02topic of inventory management, which is always a challenge when
- 26:05you're set across multiple channels.
- 26:07And it it it's obviously it's critical to your, your direct to
- 26:10consumers, critical to marketplaces to have stock and
- 26:12be out and not have fragmented stock where an item has got like
- 26:16half of its variants out of stock.
- 26:18How do you handle this so that you don't like oversell or over
- 26:21commit in one channel a detriment to another?
- 26:24So fortunately we we have a really good tech set up where we
- 26:28we have an ipass system as well as RARP that that actually fires
- 26:33out inventory on a live basis. So when a customer orders a
- 26:37product that's allocated straightaway against that
- 26:39marketplace. If we go back a few years, we
- 26:42didn't have integrations for all of our Marshall Spences.
- 26:44So we'd have to feed slightly lower inventory on a daily
- 26:48basis. Whereas now it's all live.
- 26:50We very rarely see any overselling.
- 26:53I think the, the inventory managed piece in inventory
- 26:56management piece in general is really tough though for us
- 26:59because you have eight or nine different marketplaces, you have
- 27:02different customers on the golfers.
- 27:04So you might be on sale in one marketplace for a few days and
- 27:08then off sale and in a sale on another one for a few days.
- 27:12And it's quite hard to decipher when you're looking at your
- 27:15monthly figures why that product's jumped up by 100% or
- 27:19why it's dropped off. And so we, we, we have found it
- 27:22difficult in terms of forecasting and we also have
- 27:27quite a lot of bundled products. So we have things like dining
- 27:30chairs where you can sell them individually, but also then they
- 27:32could be part of a dining set. So it does make it quite
- 27:36difficult. But we built out robust project
- 27:39behind it and it, it's helped us to achieve a 90, a 90% plus in
- 27:43stock rate throughout the years. So so we're quite happy.
- 27:46Yeah, I'd love to to get a bit more into the inventory
- 27:49forecasting because I, I had a couple of conversations recently
- 27:52with people saying, how do you do this?
- 27:54Because do you just use sales rates then do you factor in
- 27:58your, your ambient sales rate plus the fact you've got a big
- 28:01promotion coming up? But hang a minute.
- 28:03No, there's external factors influence in there.
- 28:05Oh, and there's competitors and you suddenly realise that
- 28:07inventory forecasting, if you're trying to do it manually at
- 28:10scale, is a nightmare. So how much are you automating
- 28:14this and using like modern AI tools, for example, to to put
- 28:17intelligence in versus you've built your own algorithms or
- 28:21models to do it? The answer to that is not
- 28:24enough. So we, we actually had a bit of
- 28:28a, a bit of a Eureka Bayman in a sense, because last year we, we
- 28:34thought right to get this as accurate as we possibly can,
- 28:38myself, our head forecaster and Monty are going to go through
- 28:41the forecast every two weeks and we're going to manually adjust
- 28:44every single product. We're going to go and use our,
- 28:47our nuanced knowledge that we know I could it's been on a sale
- 28:50at X price. It's going to be on a sale for,
- 28:53for why next month. All of this data through to our,
- 28:57our strategy maybe on each channel.
- 28:59We, we said right, we're going to do this manually.
- 29:01And it probably took us every two weeks, about six hours each
- 29:05to go through meticulously on every single product.
- 29:08We didn't have any data over the first month or two to see how we
- 29:11performed. But we then looked at that
- 29:14looked back window over the course of that three or four
- 29:16months and found that the products that were within 15%
- 29:21accuracy, so either 15% higher or lower than our, our forecast.
- 29:27It was only 20% of all of our, our manual figures hit that
- 29:31number. So it was kind of a bit, a bit
- 29:34of a, a Eureka moment, but not a fun Eureka moment because it was
- 29:38all those hours you spent were kind of pointless because we
- 29:41weren't being anywhere near as accurate as we'd like.
- 29:43So we've scaled this back down and said, OK, we need to look at
- 29:46a tool that can can help us with this, that can pull in our
- 29:49marketing data that that maybe looks at a blended average.
- 29:53And we sort of appreciate that doing it individually isn't the
- 29:57best way. But using that that logic around
- 30:00and we, we tend to look at a three month period.
- 30:03So we pick three stable marks. And then the way that we manage,
- 30:07manage this going forward is saying during promotional
- 30:10seasons, we will put a percentage uplift on our base
- 30:13figure. So rather than trying to guess
- 30:15that number and say, OK, this one will go up by 100%, this one
- 30:18will go up by 5%, we just put a base percentage.
- 30:21So it's a really, really difficult thing to get right.
- 30:24But what we sort of realised is actually the more you can
- 30:27automate this, use intelligence like a itools pulling in
- 30:31marketing data, the better for your results more generally.
- 30:37I know that you, you relatively recently invested in the
- 30:39state-of-the-art warehousing and distribution.
- 30:41So coming back to that, I'll go like fulfilment management
- 30:43peaks, but what business challenges were you facing as a
- 30:46business as you're growing that prompted that investment?
- 30:49And I guess what capabilities have you now got that you
- 30:52previously didn't have? We were bulging at the seeds, to
- 30:56be honest with you. We had run out of space on our
- 30:59current site. We're having to use some third
- 31:02party storage, which logistically also causes
- 31:05problems when you're trying to manage inventory.
- 31:08And it was really inefficient. So the way that we'd grown is
- 31:11that we'd moved into an old chimney factory.
- 31:14It had four joined units, all with slightly different heights
- 31:17to each other and all conferring challenges as well.
- 31:20Because where it was an old chimney factory still had the
- 31:23rail markings, It was, it was incredibly dusty.
- 31:26The the surface wasn't very flat.
- 31:29And as we grew, we managed to take on every single unit there.
- 31:33So we, we didn't have any space anymore and, but also really
- 31:37wasn't very efficient. So the way that we were picking
- 31:40and packing was limited. We were taking a long, long time
- 31:45to, to process orders because we'd have to go in between all
- 31:49of these different units. And also the final thing for us
- 31:52was location was we knew that we wanted to to be that service
- 31:56destination and we were coming up against hurdles when it came
- 32:00to next day delivery because we are based in, in a remote part
- 32:04of Wiltshire. So all of the hubs that we tried
- 32:06to go to and quite a distance away from us and we didn't have
- 32:10great transport routes. So I guess those three things
- 32:14really prompted us to live at a new warehouse.
- 32:17And it's, it's been completely game changing for us.
- 32:22It's solved all of those. We wouldn't be able to do our
- 32:248:00 PM next day delivery cut off point without having access
- 32:27to the M4 like we do at the moment.
- 32:30It means that you can just go straight up to the Bedlands
- 32:32where most of our hubs are and at 8:00 PM and still process
- 32:34orders on time. Not just orders, but any
- 32:37replacement parts or anything we need to do for the customer.
- 32:39We can serve much better. We've got space and we built a
- 32:43multi multi level mezzanine pit tower.
- 32:46So that means that we actually can bring in a lot more new
- 32:49product and we won't run out of pickable space.
- 32:52The problem we used half before was you could only pick products
- 32:54from the bottom. So we didn't have anything
- 32:57above. So we'd run out of pickle space
- 33:00at our old site as well. So it's great having that.
- 33:03And from an efficiency piece, it's been phenomenal.
- 33:06I mean we used to to struggle with every single member of the
- 33:11warehouse team as well as myself and Monty in the warehouse to
- 33:14get through 200 overs a day during peak.
- 33:17Now we can do up to about 1000 and it's still not that much of
- 33:21an issue. And so it's, yeah, the
- 33:23efficiency gains have been in pretty huge for us.
- 33:26That's much. And how do you manage?
- 33:28Is this yours and you have your own team or is it a three PL.
- 33:32that manages it for you and I? Yeah, who owns the tech bit from
- 33:35the warehousing point of view? It's us and our team.
- 33:38So we use a system called Peoplevox and it's managed by
- 33:41our own, our own teams. And we're still building on this
- 33:45and every, every month we're always covered with new ways to
- 33:48try and get the best out of the system.
- 33:51But yeah, we run it ourselves because I think a lot of the
- 33:55time with third parties, they maybe don't have the same level
- 33:57of care as you do. And by by being able to control
- 34:01it ourselves, we can decide if if a vehicle breaks down, it's
- 34:05it's up to us on whether we want to go and get another vehicle
- 34:08in. We're not relying on other
- 34:09people. So yeah, it's always been done
- 34:12in house ourselves. And that's interesting because
- 34:14that's, yeah, the, the controls, amazing.
- 34:19It's quite challenging to get to that point of justifying
- 34:21investment into your own logistics rather than just
- 34:24outsourcing to three PL. Ah, so yeah, so we sorry, we
- 34:29don't, we operate our own warehouse, but we do use third
- 34:34parties like Pastor Force, DPD, yeah, yeah, etcetera.
- 34:37So sorry. Yeah, it's we use external third
- 34:41party couriers, but our operation we run ourselves.
- 34:44Yeah, yeah, that makes sense. That's interesting to have that
- 34:47level of control. And what led you, how did you
- 34:49get to Peoplevox? I always find it interesting how
- 34:51people select their their WM S s.
- 34:54So we needed a system that could be quite customisable to us.
- 34:58The setup of our warehouse is different to a lot of other
- 35:01warehouses. And one thing that we had
- 35:04started in Mir, our old site that we had to carry on was that
- 35:08we were picking orders on a part level.
- 35:12So very early on, myself and Monsieur realised that the most
- 35:15efficient of picking packing orders wasn't to take a trolley
- 35:19and go in and pack every single part of the dining set on one
- 35:22trolley first, then go and do it again.
- 35:24It was to actually go and just pick the individual part
- 35:27separately based on their location.
- 35:29So what we used to do is we would take pallets and pump
- 35:33trucks around and all of the table tops that were nice and
- 35:35flat, we would go and pick one by one.
- 35:38And the way we used to do this was that we'd print out the full
- 35:42stack of labels and we'd write on the back top, base leg and
- 35:45RIP off each part. So we found that this was the
- 35:48most efficient way of doing that.
- 35:50But a lot of warehouse management systems don't allow
- 35:53you to do that. So a lot of assistants will say
- 35:55you have an order from Missus Jones here, you need to go and
- 35:58pick her full order before it could be dispatched.
- 36:02So we needed a system that we we were able to customise as
- 36:05actually we don't want that set up.
- 36:07We want a set up where we could go, OK, I'm going to go and pick
- 36:11Missus Jones tabletop here. Someone else is going to go and
- 36:14pick her chairs, and in an hour's time I've got to go and
- 36:17pick the legs. But it doesn't matter because
- 36:19when I get to the pack station, I can still print the
- 36:22consignment label for just that individual piece.
- 36:26So people, Vox gave us great flexibility for that, and it's
- 36:29been, yeah, been super useful. That's interesting.
- 36:31Yeah. So it's essentially zonal
- 36:33picking for efficiency for all the different, all the different
- 36:37elements of across all the orders you need in a particular
- 36:40pick time. OK, interesting.
- 36:42And how, how does that work from a consolidation once you get to
- 36:45the packing stations and you've got tops, legs, you know, other
- 36:49components, how does that work spatially in order for those who
- 36:53all to come together into the same shipment to get out to that
- 36:56customer? Yes, I guess from from our side
- 37:00it doesn't actually matter how the product's stacked because it
- 37:04will all go on the same trailer and it gets palletised
- 37:07separately, so you'll have collections for DPD.
- 37:09It could be DX another one. And so we'll palletise
- 37:12everything based on the furrier and when it's, it's sent to the
- 37:16central hub, that's when they're sorted.
- 37:19So we don't actually have to wait for for those consignments.
- 37:21So we we stack everything as efficiently as we can.
- 37:24And it's a bit like playing Jenga sometimes where you're
- 37:27you're trying to stack the the flat on top of these oddly
- 37:31shaped boxes. But yeah, because of that, that
- 37:34flexibility and because of the fact that our couriers can
- 37:37consolidate at the hubs, it means we don't have to worry
- 37:39about that ourselves. Do you know, I hadn't even
- 37:41thought about that. That makes so much sense because
- 37:43the consignment labels are correct.
- 37:45It's going to the right address and it's in different packages.
- 37:48Then yeah, I can see why that's a massive time saver for you to
- 37:51to do the Zodal piece. Absolutely.
- 37:54It's sort of a weird, weird process in a sense that we
- 37:58become exponentially more efficient the more we send out.
- 38:03So over a Black Friday period, the most recent Black Friday, we
- 38:06came in ready to, to, to store as many parcels as we could on
- 38:11on Black Friday with the full asylum.
- 38:12And we were finished by 2:00 PM Because the difference between
- 38:16us going collecting 2 table tops compared to 10 is so minimal
- 38:22because you, you're only having to see that move on.
- 38:25And so it's, yeah, it's been a game changer for us to be able
- 38:28to do that. Yeah, that's really interesting.
- 38:30I've got another business I've just been to where, where their
- 38:32big drive for change in WMS was to increase their rate of, of
- 38:38picking stuff to get to the packing benches because they
- 38:41were having exactly the same somebody's picking an order and
- 38:43it's up that aisle, down that aisle rather than, well,
- 38:47actually, if, if we do zonally on different types of products
- 38:50based across the orders and we get all the, all of the products
- 38:52there, then people can then pack, but we'll speed up the
- 38:55rate at which we get the product to the packing benches.
- 38:59Interested. So I'm going to bring us back to
- 39:02we've got into the inventory management and the, the, the
- 39:05operation side. Let's bring it back to the, the
- 39:07original discussion around marketplaces.
- 39:10And I imagine anyone listening who's working in E com and is
- 39:13doing some marketplace and maybe think about how they scale that
- 39:15this year. What was your advice to people
- 39:18wanting to drive marketplace growth like skills, resources,
- 39:21What do you need in house to make this work?
- 39:25So. I, I guess what you need in
- 39:28house to make this work, a good solid text systems like a PIM
- 39:31system. So we use, we use Pimbley for
- 39:34ours, but then also a feeding tool.
- 39:37It's quite useful. So something like a feed
- 39:39inomics, a channel engine, something like that.
- 39:43I think a crucial because what you don't want to be doing is
- 39:46uploading and making changes manually across all of these
- 39:49marketplaces. All of them have evolved to have
- 39:52integrations as well. So I think having a really solid
- 39:56tech stack that can support it is absolutely vital.
- 40:00We started off going on to marketplaces doing everything
- 40:03manually and you just can't do that scale and it takes a lot of
- 40:07time. So using tools, as I say, like a
- 40:11PIM system, a channel integration tool, there's,
- 40:14there's lots on them out there. And potentially also seeing what
- 40:18your ERP capabilities have in terms of plugging and play?
- 40:22So we use, we use Bright Pile and it has integrations to a
- 40:25number of marketplaces straight off the bat.
- 40:28So you don't actually have to do that much additional work.
- 40:31I guess then in terms of personnel, it's kind of similar
- 40:36to what you would have in a a marketing team for a website or
- 40:39an E Comm team. You can't do quite as much, but
- 40:42you need people that can look at the opportunities that you have.
- 40:45You can see what donations you can get involved in with a lot
- 40:48of the marketplaces. You get great data around visits
- 40:52on your your store and also to your products.
- 40:54So, and, and there's ads as well that you can run.
- 40:57So they're kind of like mini versions of your website, but
- 41:01you don't obviously have quite as much control.
- 41:03But you still need the same same eye around opportunities there
- 41:07because there's lots of them and a lot of people on marketplaces
- 41:10don't take those opportunities. So it's something we spend a lot
- 41:13of time doing, working with with the marketplaces, but also
- 41:17testing things ourselves to see what works and doesn't work.
- 41:22Yeah, the the use of data, having somebody who actually
- 41:24understands the data points and how you can use them to get
- 41:26inside to make better decisions, that's a really nice thing to
- 41:29pull out. Actually.
- 41:30It's a lot of times the, the focus is on getting things on
- 41:32and manage and looking at sales, but not necessarily looking at
- 41:35the, the everything that's happening before the sale to
- 41:38know which areas you should push on and in terms of your own
- 41:42personal future direction for the, for the business.
- 41:44You said, yeah, I think you said about 9 marketplaces.
- 41:46How do you see your marketplace strategy evolving like this year
- 41:49and beyond? Is it consolidation in existing
- 41:51ones? Are you looking to expand into
- 41:53new territories or new marketplaces?
- 41:55Yeah. So marketplaces are brilliant
- 41:58for expansion into other countries.
- 41:59So in the US market, we've gone onto Amazon and Walmart now and
- 42:03we're going to be using them alongside Wayfair to expand
- 42:06initially in the US. So we see that as a, a strategy
- 42:09we want to take further forward. In the UK, we're very much going
- 42:13to be consolidating. So the problem you can sometimes
- 42:17have it and I think you mentioned it start the podcast
- 42:19is everyone wants to marketplace now.
- 42:21And what you don't want to do is spread yourself and your teams a
- 42:24bit too thin. 9 is probably right at the maximum of what we
- 42:28can, we can deal with at the moment.
- 42:30So we're being a lot more selective in terms of our market
- 42:33basis and joining marketplaces that that I guess can can align
- 42:39with our company goals and our aims and potentially scaling
- 42:42back some marketplaces if they don't don't align with that
- 42:46because they will work in slightly different ways.
- 42:49And if you're trying to update price points manually on on 10
- 42:53different sides, it just doesn't work.
- 42:54So I would say it's consolidation in the UK for us
- 42:58and trying to get the best out of the relationships we do have
- 43:01with marketplaces and the likes of the US Mike, it's, it's
- 43:05looking at new ones we can go on to that, that can help us get
- 43:08out to more people. Excellent.
- 43:10I really, really appreciate you taking the time.
- 43:12I've really enjoyed this. I'm loving this success story.
- 43:15I hope you guys continue to to to have stellar growth as well.
- 43:18Look forward to seeing what comes next, but appreciate you
- 43:20taking the time to come on the podcast.
- 43:23Thanks, James. I really appreciate you having
- 43:24me on. Thank you very much.
- 43:26Cheers and everyone listen. I hope you've enjoyed it.
- 43:29Do reach out, let us know what you think and any other
- 43:31questions you've got about marketplace, commerce and the
- 43:35topics brought up in this podcast.
- 43:36Do let me or Paul know. Thanks very much everyone.
- 43:40You're listening to the Inside Commerce podcast hosted by
- 43:42experienced consultants James Gert and Paul Rogers.
- 43:45Inside Commerce is your fast tracked additional knowledge
- 43:48featuring interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 43:51industry thought leads and the C-Suite, key tech companies to
- 43:53explore the latest digital strategy, customer experience
- 43:56and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 43:58really mean and get practical advice based on experience to
- 44:01help fine tune your E Comm strategy and text.
- 44:04Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James and Paul if you'd
- 44:07like to discuss an E comms project.
- 44:09We hope you enjoy the latest episode.