Latest / Catalyst: A Podcast of Thought / Flow With Force: Chapter 5 - Golf Is Not a Game of Control
Transcript
- DrG: There is a particular kind of frustration that shows up, on a golf course. You stand over a ball knowing exactly what you're supposed to do because you've done it many times before. You've practiced it, maybe you've even done it beautifully a time or two. And then without warning, something changes. The swing tightens. You start thinking about your hands, your hips, your backswing, your follow through, your grip, your stance. Before long you've got what my buddy calls swing thought thirty-two running through your head. And then you try harder, which of course tends to make everything worse. Welcome to Catalyst, a podcast of thought. I'm Dr. G, and today I'm talking about golf. But as usual, I'm not really talking just about golf. I'm talking about the unique role the game of golf played in my learning about my relationship with force. In how I've learned the difference between performing and participating, between true and false urgency, and how it can all lead to a more engaging experience both on and off the course. Golf I've learned is not a game of control, it is a game of presence. When I began playing golf consistently about ten years ago, I brought with me a very specific understanding. I had spent most of my athletic life playing football and hockey, and those sports had taught me a very linear relationship between effort and performance, which had become part of my identity as an athlete. I learned emotional intensity drove physical performance. If I wanted to perform better, I would increase the intensity of my preparation. Sprint harder, lift harder, skate harder. Push myself beyond the person next to me, outwork the other guy, outwork my past self. While competing, I became more emotionally aggressive to increase my competitive advantage. And that equation worked. In football and hockey, emotion had a role. Force had a purpose. I played the positions where force wasn't really tolerated. It was part of the job. I was to absorb force and redirect it. I controlled gaps, I controlled space. I controlled my body and my response to the people around me, all driven by emotional intensity. So when I began playing golf, I did what my body and mind had been trained to do, be intense, swing hard. That was pretty much the plan. I would grip the club tightly, flex my forearms the way I might when handling a hockey stick, and engage my back, tightening my entire body and try to drive all that force through the club into the ball. I was trying to make the golf club respond to me through sheer. Physical commitment and of course emotional intensity. I wore the grips out on my clubs. Literally. I was squeezing them so tight, I was wearing them down. My biceps would hurt. My biceps, which shouldn't be involved in the first place, I was so intense. My back would tighten. if someone stood behind me, they could see I was flexing. Before I even begins the swing. I wasn't swinging a golf club. I was preparing emotionally for combat with this little white orb and the landscaping in front of me. The strange thing is that I knew almost immediately this wasn't the way to play this game of golf effectively, surely not joyfully. I knew it ten years ago, I still know it today, yet I keep falling back into it because the default to intensify is so deeply ingrained. When something matters to me, my instinct is to use more emotion, more force, more control. The harder I try to control the golf swing and its varied elements, the less fluid it becomes. The more I think about each component, the less natural the movement feels. What I gain in conscious precision, which I love, I lose in timing. And timing is everything. In contrast, when I have a good swing, I'm not directing any part of it. I'm just with it. I'm active, I'm engaged, I'm focused, but I'm not forcing. My body moves in sequence without me having to consciously control each piece of it. The club follows, contact happens, and for a moment the swing feels just effortless. The moment I experience one of these good swings, my mind wants to take control of the very process. I had just successfully outsourced to my body. What did I just do? How do I repeat that? In trying to answer that question, those questions, I leave behind the very thing that made the swing impossible in the first place. I moved from experiencing the swing back into managing it. From flow back to force. I remember one shot recently that was so strange I had to wait for the ball to finish its journey before it could even process what had happened. It was a very short shot, maybe thirty yards, and somehow I managed to produce a snap hook that would travel nearly ninety degrees to my left. I had never seen this kind of result before. I remember thinking, What did I do there? A new error. On bad golf days, I can become almost fascinated by the possibilities of what I can create. If the last mistake was new, perhaps I can discover another one. My mind starts trying to create the conditions to remedy the most recent error, only to create room for the next one. And that is the moment when force becomes over analysis, hypervigilance. Overanalysis is simply force that wears intellectual clothing, right? The more I try to control the swing, the less I am actually swinging. And that is what golf reveals so clearly. It doesn't reward my intentions, it reveals my tendencies. if control actually worked the way we think it does, the solution would be simple: focus more, try harder, force more, tighten the process. But anyone who has spent enough time on a golf course knows that's not how it plays out. Eventually, usually after enough frustration, something shifts. You get tired of forcing it, you loosen your grip, literally and figuratively. You stop trying to control every piece of the swing. You just let it happen a little more, then you make it happen. When this occurs, something changes. Not perfectly, certainly not permanently, but enough to feel the difference. The swing returns, not because I solved it, because I stopped interfering with it. That's a difficult lesson to accept. It challenges something deeper than mechanics. It challenges my identity. If you, like me, had built your sense of athletic competence around emotional intensity and gaining control. Stepping back can feel risky. It can feel like you're doing less than it can feel as though you're giving up. Now I'm still learning that less force, less emotional intensity, does not mean less commitment. And that distinction matters. I don't want to become passive. I don't want to just care less. I don't want to stop preparing. I don't want to stop competing. What I'm learning is that intensity is not the same thing as focus. I've now learned that I can be deeply focused without becoming emotionally intense. And that is a very different experience for me. When I'm performing on a golf course, I feel everything physically. I feel the grip, I feel my back, I feel my face. My face. I know. Odd. But it's true. I feel the pressure throughout my body. I feel myself trying to make the swing happen. Beneath this physical awareness is another awareness that has nothing to do with the golf swing. I consider, how am I being viewed? What do other people think? Am I good enough to be here right now? Did that look like a good shot? How's my swing look? What will they think if I do it again? I'm no longer simply playing golf. I'm performing golf. Conversely, when I'm present, almost the opposite happens. If you use what really smart golf coaches call think box play box, right? In the think box, I decide what I want to do. I'm standing behind the ball. I choose the club, I identify a small target, and then I move beside the ball. I don't feel my feet, I don't feel my hands, I don't feel my back, nope, I don't feel my face, I don't monitor my grip, I don't consciously experience the mechanics that I'm about to perform. I look at the target and I swing. That's it. The difference is remarkable in that play box, because I'm fully present. I don't feel anything physically, just an emotional centeredness, a balance. My best round this particular year happened just a few weeks ago. A buddy and I were Talking almost the entire round, beginning well before we even loaded our bags onto our carts. We talked about everything except golf. By the seventh hole or so, my wife finally asked, Are you two gonna chit chat all day or are you gonna play golf? We were both playing well. I was playing extremely well for my caliber. I wasn't thinking about golf very much at all. Every once in a while our conversation would stop because it just happened to be my turn to hit a ball. I would step behind the ball, identify where I wanted to go, walk beside it. Look toward the spot and swing, and then I returned to the conversation. That was my round. Conversation, target, swing, conversation, blah blah blah. We were still competing. We were in a competitive game between us and between us and our wives. But they beat us by the way, like on the thirteenth hole. I knew the score was being kept, I knew there was something at stake, kind of. It simply wasn't monopolizing my thoughts. The social experience came first. The golf experience came second. And most importantly, the evaluation of the golf experience was somewhere way far behind that. Days behind it in this case. If it was there at all, I didn't know how well I played until the last hole. I had a wonderful day that just happened to include a round of golf. And that matters because I can now see what was actually happening. I wasn't trying to perform, I was just participating. Presence. Doesn't require the absence of competition. It requires the absence of self-conscious performance. I was still trying to hit good golf shots. I still cared about the outcome. I still wanted to compete. I honestly intended to and made a bender of a seven footer on 17 to put my buddy Dormy going a dating. I simply wasn't using the outcome to make a statement about myself. I wasn't asking my performance in the round to prove anything about me to anyone. Including myself. I was there to participate in a social hobby with people I enjoy being with. And that is what golf really is for me now a social hobby. So by the way, two days later, I scored even better. Okay, that's a lie. I was all over the place because I began forcing the shot to occur rather than just swing. I mistakenly thought that if I shot so well on Friday, of course it should be just as easy to perform at the same level on Sunday. I strayed from participation. The moment I turn an experience into an outcome that I feel I must reproduce, I change my relationship to the experience. I've I created an imagined future, and now the present me was responsible for delivering it. And what I created is what I call, and others call the fal a false urgency. And I like to think of false urgency as. The body's response to an imagined future. I want to play as well as I did yesterday. I want to prove I can do it again. I should be better by now. I need to get this round back on track. All these thoughts. These are statements that are spoken and even my mind with a sense of panic. A shortened breath. In reality, there's no emergency. I'm playing golf. Yet my body responds as though something important is about to be taken away from me, as if a threat has appeared to my ego. Grip tightens, the shoulders rise, the muscles engage, the mind starts calculating. This imagined future has arrived in the body before it has arrived in reality. That's false urgency. It also explains why a bad shot used to cause me so much trouble. The bad shot happened. Then I would immediately begin trying to recover from it. The next shot became responsible for repairing the previous one. The next all became an opportunity to make up for what I had felt as if I had lost. The previous shot created an imagined future, and then I tried to force the present to correct it. And that's how the spiral used to to to play out. It is important to note that we don't always need to feel threatened to create a false sense of urgency. Sometimes it begins with a personal desire. I don't have to be afraid of the future to become overly urgent about it. I only have to believe I need to reproduce it. Over the years, these types of experiences have changed the language I use with myself. I began thinking about the shot as the outcome and the swing as the process. It's not revolutionary, but for me, shots are about performance. Swings are about presence. If the shot doesn't work, I can examine it later, meaning the outcome. But the swing itself is an opportunity to participate in something that is happening right now. Be present in the social hobby of golf with friends. That distinction has helped me recover from bad stretches on the course. I can, or at least attempt to, leave the previous shot behind and refocus on the process. Next swing. I don't say next shot. The word shot pulls my attention toward the outcome. I don't want to focus on that. The word swing returns me to the experience. My body knows how to swing a golf club. My body had already learned the basic movements. My mind was the one interfering. You know, we joke on the golf course and other places and other sports about being a second team All American, that phenomenon in golf especially. So you chunk a shot, take another ball out of your pocket, and suddenly hit the most beautiful shot you've seen all day. Or you hit a terrible drive, and then the mulligan finds its way to the center of the club face and the distant fairway. Well what happened? Your body knew what to do, but your mind got involved in your first attempt. It doesn't mean technique doesn't matter, it does. Preparation does matter, so does practice. And understanding golf and all of its intricacies does matter. But there's a point at which conscious control becomes interference. The body knows, the mind starts talking, suddenly something that was relatively simple becomes overly complicated. And these all these realizations began traveling with me beyond gol the golf course. I was doing it when I played my guitar. I was doing it In my podcasting. I was doing it in relationships. I was interfering with my body and mind and parenting and coaching and with doing chores. For years I couldn't walk past grass clippings on my lawn without removing them. I would rake them, blow them away, clean them up. Because they were evidence of something unfinished, evidence of a character flaw. My identity was at risk, a threat, false urgency initiated. Now, at this very moment, there are grass clippings on my lawn. That have been there for a couple days. I see them every time I walk by them. I will get to them eventually. It's going to be fine for now, but I will get to them. But I'm not creating this false urgency anymore. That may sound insignificant, but to me, it isn't. I used to control and seek to control everything. It was exhausting. And I now understand through my experience in golf, particularly, that the physical tension associated with that constant vigilance. Wasn't confined to one area of my life. It showed up in my bodies, my shoulders, my back, my knee, my relationships, work, thinking. I was always preparing for something, always anticipating, always trying to get ahead of the next problem. It means I need to stop confusing preparation and evaluation with control. Preparation happens before the moment. Evaluation happens best after. I know that as an educator. Control is what I try to impose upon the moment. And there's a difference. So before around, I can establish an intention. Why am I here? What do I want from this experience? For me, the answer increasingly has less to do with the score and more to do with participation. I want to participate in the social experience, the social hobby of golf. I want to talk to people about themselves. I want to celebrate their successes on and off the course. I want to be present. I want to enjoy the people I'm with, participate with them. When I first began playing golf with very good players, I was concerned about my lack of ability. A now good friend said, Hey, man, you don't have to be good. Just be fun and fast. Fun and fast. Those are both focused on how to participate with others in golf, not how to perform the game of golf. The same principle has begun finding its way into conversations. I can enter a conversation with an intention without expecting exactly how it must unfold. That distinction is useful. An intention gives me direction. An expectation gives me a prescribed outcome. I can have intentions without expectations. Intentions create momentum without necessarily creating urgency. Expectations can create disappointment before anything has actually happened. I can want a golf ball to land somewhere without believing I have to force it to do so. I can want a conversation to move somewhere without insisting that it arrives somewhere. I want the relationship to deepen without having to manage every interaction that might make it happen. I want my work to influence people without needing every piece of my work to prove my usefulness. And that brings me to something I think is changing in me. And it has very little to do with golf. For much of my life, I felt I need to justify myself and validate my usefulness. I needed to demonstrate that I could contribute. I needed to make things better. I needed to be dependable. I needed to prove that I belonged. I don't think I was consciously walking around saying those things to myself. They were simply embedded in how I approached the world. Able meant ought. Useful meant valuable. Performance meant evidence. The way that way of living served me well for a long time. Or at least I thought it did. I'm beginning to recognize I'm beginning to recognize that there is another way to live. I no longer need to justify myself and validate my usefulness. I need to focus on justifying why I am present and validating my influence. Those are very different things. Justifying myself as what have I accomplished that proves I deserve to be here? Validating my usefulness as what did I actually produce? Justifying my choice to be present as why am I choosing to be here? And how do I choose to participate? Validating my influence asks, what did my presence make possible for me and others? The second set of questions regarding my presence and influence feels much more mature and manageable to me. Nobody's going to remember my golf handicap. Nobody's going to remember how many podcasts I produced. Nobody's going to care how many of them were monetized. Nobody will remember whether I perfectly maintained every square foot of my lawn. Those things can matter in their proper context. They simply don't carry the existential weight at once assigned to them. False urgency. What remains is the experience, the conversation with a friend, the walk onto the tee, the sound of the club striking the ball, the laugh after a terrible shot, the satisfaction of a beautiful one, the people standing beside me, The opportunity to influence the experience without controlling it. It doesn't mean outcomes don't matter, they do, but outcomes are no longer the only evidence that the experience had value. Perhaps that's what growing older has begun to teach me. I don't need to manufacture significance. I don't need to turn every interest into an accomplishment. I don't need to turn every hobby into evidence of competence. I don't need to turn every relationship into something I manage. I can simply participate. I can simply influence to a degree that is reasonable. I can enjoy. I can let the experience be just what it is. That's not giving up control. Choosing what deserves to be controlled. That is the more mature relationship with force I have been looking for all along. Force can make things happen. Presence allows us to participate in what is happening. And influence, I've come to believe, lives somewhere between the two. So golf has taught me that the game is not one of control, that I don't have to make everything happen. I don't have to prove that I made it happen. I can simply be present enough to influence what happens next. That is a different way to play golf. More importantly, it is a different way to live. Golf has taught me that I can care deeply about an outcome without letting it control the moment. I can prepare, I can compete, I can have an intention, I can choose a target, I can want the ball to land in a specific spot. And then I can step beside the ball and swing. Not control. But presence, just flow. If flow is not controlled, it can be tempting to mistake it for simply letting go as passivity, as doing nothing, as waiting for things to happen. That's not what I've discovered. Flow still requires intention. It still requires preparation. It still requires participation. It still requires us to make choices and take action. The difference is in how we act. That's where we'll go next. In chapter six, flow is not passive. We'll explore the other side of this equation. If we're not supposed to force everything into existence, what does it actually mean to participate fully? How do we act without forcing? How do we remain intentional? without becoming controlling. The alternative to force isn't passivity. It's an altogether different kind of action. I'm Dr. G. Those are my thoughts. Thanks for listening.