Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL X Aspen Technology: Network model management
Transcript
- 0:05Hello and welcome to a very special edition of Energy Voice
- 0:08Out Loud, brought to you by Emerson's Aspen Technology
- 0:12business. I'm Aberdeen Features Lead, Ryan
- 0:15Duff and I'm joined by the firm's Senior Director for
- 0:18Digital Grid Management, Alan Mcmoran.
- 0:21How are you this afternoon, Alan?
- 0:22I'm very well and although we're from the same part of the world,
- 0:25obviously Ryan, I'm currently in Minnesota, which is one of the
- 0:30of large offices for Aspen Tech is here.
- 0:33So we have our customer advisory this week.
- 0:35There's over 100 people coming, 50 utilities from all over the
- 0:39world. So I'm here to take part in
- 0:42that. Should be an interesting week as
- 0:44we discussed through various parts with customers and what
- 0:46they want for the future. Yeah, it's interesting isn't we
- 0:49were speaking about this last week about how your your
- 0:51stateside for this this week. So I did say good afternoon, but
- 0:55for you it's good morning. And working for an American
- 0:59company, it means that they might just not understand this
- 1:02conversation between two Scots. So we could just speak about
- 1:05football, but with the Iceland result last week, that might be
- 1:08a little bit more painful than our upcoming conversation.
- 1:11Yes, and then combined in Glasgow Warriors losing to Lane
- 1:14Star and it was not a good weekend for Scottish sport at
- 1:17all. But I guess we've just come to
- 1:19expect that. I've tried to explain that to
- 1:20Americans, that as a Scott you kind of expect to lose and
- 1:24winning as a bonus. I think that's that maybe that
- 1:27reflects our state mine with some things it's not necessarily
- 1:29healthy, but I think that we see a win as a bonus for as many
- 1:32other countries expect. Yeah, I think with major
- 1:34international tournaments, we're there for a good time, not a
- 1:37long time. Look at last year's EUR.
- 1:39But I guess for A to get on topic, so I don't start, you
- 1:44know, bemoaning the state of Scottish sport.
- 1:47We probably should have a little bit of a yap about the energy
- 1:50market. But first, Alan, people might
- 1:53recognize your name attached to a different company than Aspen
- 1:57Technology. They might recognize you from
- 1:59Open Grid Systems and they're going there.
- 2:01What what happened there? So could you just give me a
- 2:04little bit of a background as how how you ended up where you
- 2:08are now? Sure.
- 2:09So yes, Open Grid Systems, a company that I founded 15 years
- 2:13ago, I had before that I'd done my undergraduate, gone straight
- 2:17into doing a PhD, University of Strathclyde and then I did few
- 2:21years postdoctoral work there and decided I was just going to
- 2:25go off and start a company. So I left and the first year was
- 2:29going to be my own and then joined by a couple of colleagues
- 2:34moving on from that. And then over the last few years
- 2:37we actually grew quite quickly. We reached about 20 people and
- 2:42we had number of big clients in the US as well as in the UK and
- 2:48in Europe. And so we reached that point
- 2:51where we were struggling to meet the demand people had for our
- 2:54software. So we were turning down work.
- 2:56We were saying, well, we can't really deliver to Australia, we
- 2:59don't have anybody there any resources and the time
- 3:01difference and we're kind of picking and choosing the work
- 3:03that we were doing. And Aspen Tech had recognised
- 3:07what we were doing, the kind of value of our software and, and
- 3:10they approached us to see if we'd be interested in being
- 3:13acquired by them. So we ultimately, as much as
- 3:17they did an assessment of us, we did an assessment of them.
- 3:19We looked to see where they were strong, where we would fit in,
- 3:23would be a good fit, what the culture would be and ultimately
- 3:26decided we thought it would work.
- 3:28And so we became part of the Aspen Tech last November.
- 3:34And then I think it was maybe a day after they announced that
- 3:36we're buying us, Emerson announced that they were buying
- 3:38Aspen Tech. So we went from being 20 people
- 3:42last November to 4000 people when we became part of Aspen
- 3:46Tech. And then I think it's now 80,000
- 3:48people or something or that for for Emerson.
- 3:51So it's been a bit of a change for everybody over the last six
- 3:54months, but it's been the integration as part of a large
- 3:57global corporation. We go from being a small that
- 4:00kind of like team of 20 people to being part of something
- 4:03bigger. But with that brings more
- 4:05resources though there's some of the sales teams in Australia,
- 4:08there's services teams over there.
- 4:09So some of the work that we previously would have said, not
- 4:12sure we could do that, we're now saying, well, maybe we can.
- 4:15And we're big access to lots of new customer base sales teams or
- 4:19resources. It's all been a very interesting
- 4:22kind of transition over and we're very excited about how we
- 4:25continue doing. That I feel like the LinkedIn
- 4:27LinkedIn buzzword crowd would call that a rapid expansion.
- 4:30Yes, yeah, I'm not very good at the whole LinkedIn kind of stuff
- 4:35like that. It's.
- 4:36Yeah, to be fair, neither am I. I know I probably should be as a
- 4:39journalist and I probably should be more active on social media,
- 4:41but I do we find it difficult to stay on top of them all.
- 4:44But I get we're digressing. We're clearly so happy having
- 4:47this conversation. We keep veering off, but we
- 4:50really should get onto the meet and veg of this conversation and
- 4:53get into digital grid management.
- 4:55But before we before we sort of dive into the how's and the
- 5:00what's and what I think we should probably do is discuss,
- 5:04you know, what is digital grid management?
- 5:06I think sometimes when we're speaking about tech and
- 5:08industry, people can assume that everyone knows what they're
- 5:12speaking about. You tend to find that like, you
- 5:13know, events, someone always Speaking of a digital twins or
- 5:16something, and then no one will actually go.
- 5:18By the way, for those that have never heard this, this is what
- 5:20it is. So do you mind just explaining
- 5:23Aspen techs or role in digital grid management?
- 5:26Sure. I mean Aspen Tech as a company
- 5:27covers a lot of different parts of kind of technology running
- 5:31through kind of oil and gas and various other kind of
- 5:34geotechnical solutions and so forth.
- 5:36But the digital grid management unit, which is what we are now
- 5:39kind of part of, and it's about providing essentially control
- 5:44software for the electrical grid.
- 5:46So how you control the sessions, grid reliability monitoring real
- 5:51time. So when you when people see like
- 5:54photos and videos of power system control centers, no big
- 5:57wall boards, big complex diagrams operators sitting there
- 6:01looking like there's something from war games, that's control
- 6:05software. And that's the thing then
- 6:06basically that Aspen Tech provides know whether it's for
- 6:10generation plants, high voltage transmission, distribution
- 6:14pipeline for gas as well. And so it's all about managing,
- 6:18controlling those systems because they're big, they're
- 6:21complex and people have to basically make sure everything's
- 6:25secure and reliable. And you can also imagine that
- 6:28these systems can't be things that can be no left open to the
- 6:33world. No, these things have to be
- 6:35highly secure. It's critical national
- 6:36infrastructure. So the digital grid management
- 6:39is there to provide control and management of these and, and as
- 6:42a company, this has been provided by decades by Aspen
- 6:45Tech DGM. And so what's happening now,
- 6:48though, is that the grid is starting to change quite quickly
- 6:52because it used to be power and at the high voltage, either big
- 6:57coal-fired power station, nuclear power station, gas
- 6:59station providing power, and it flowed all the way down to
- 7:02consumers and it was fairly predictable what would happen.
- 7:06But now the grid's becoming a lot more dynamic.
- 7:08We're seeing batteries and generation appearing at low
- 7:12voltages, and you're seeing demand change because in the UK,
- 7:17we moved to gas in the 80s. So electricity load was never as
- 7:21high as like over here in the US because it's gas central heating
- 7:25and we don't really have air conditioning.
- 7:27And so people had predictable load profiles of what a load
- 7:30would be for a typical house. That gets turned in its head
- 7:34when people start buying electric vehicles, for example,
- 7:36because suddenly at 5:00 PM, somebody can come home, plug in
- 7:39something that pulls kilowatts of power that they weren't
- 7:43expecting. So you can start to understand
- 7:45that managing the grid now when you've got lots more loads
- 7:49coming in or in the middle of the day, everyone's got solar
- 7:52panels because you're in a nice sunny part of the world and
- 7:55suddenly powers flow in the opposite direction.
- 7:57How do you control that? How do you manage that?
- 7:59So what Aspen Tech provides is the kind of software around
- 8:02about the control and management of all of that data.
- 8:05And then how you actually manage the data being fed into these
- 8:08things is where we as Open Grid systems had basically built up
- 8:12software that's now part of Aspen Tech DGM's portfolio.
- 8:16And you know, for context, some people might have already used
- 8:19the technology developed open grid systems.
- 8:22When we were chatting before the podcast, I realized that I'd
- 8:26used it and hadn't, you know, had a had never noticed.
- 8:28A couple of years ago, I was living outside just within the
- 8:32city centre in Aberdeen, just off Auburn St. and we had a
- 8:35power outage and I quickly checked SSE NS website and it
- 8:40was your tech, right? That's.
- 8:42Exactly, that was one of our has been a big success for us.
- 8:45We built that up as our innovation project initially
- 8:48with SSEN. So it's Scottish and Southern
- 8:51Electricity Network. So they're the operator for
- 8:53North Scotland. And we'd kind of went to them
- 8:55and said Invert, we're talking 10 years ago people were
- 8:58starting to mobile phones were becoming or the kind of like
- 9:01they're moving from being the secondary phone to being the
- 9:04primary phone and now it's probably your only phone.
- 9:07I mean, I know I don't have a landline anymore and I think
- 9:09it's fairly common. But we said to them though, we
- 9:11need to look to see how you're going to respond to customers
- 9:14wanting to report via phone. So we'd actually built out as an
- 9:17app and that people could report power outages, but also they
- 9:21could report damage. So you can take a photo and see
- 9:25there's damage here. Everything from notice maybe
- 9:28there's a door missing in a little plastic kind of box on
- 9:31top of a pole through to there's a pole jaunty angle, there's a
- 9:35cable lying in the floor, lying in the ground.
- 9:38And know how people can report all of this and it helps them
- 9:42assess and deal with it better. But it's also about how can you
- 9:45quickly capture large amounts of data?
- 9:48How can you leverage cloud computing software as a service?
- 9:51And so we built this software out and we deploy that to SSEN
- 9:56and we manage it for them. Software as a service.
- 9:59And during storms, I think we handle about 80% of the customer
- 10:03interactions through those portals.
- 10:05It's all SSEN staff dealing with it, though.
- 10:07They're logging in, managing it. They're the ones dealing with
- 10:10the customers. We just provide the software and
- 10:12we manage and run it in the cloud for them.
- 10:15So it's been a huge success for us doing that with them.
- 10:18SSCN has been a great client working with us through that,
- 10:21helping us build it out, develop it.
- 10:22And we've now run that for them for several years.
- 10:25And yeah, it's software people use and they don't realize it's
- 10:28ours because software like that shouldn't be branded with the
- 10:32company making it, because it should be branded for the
- 10:35utility. It's for them.
- 10:37The other one is that we don't want customers phoning our
- 10:39office saying they've got power cut.
- 10:40It's about them, contact and utility.
- 10:43But yeah, that's software that we worked and developed on, and
- 10:45that's the best games. People use it, find it, create,
- 10:48don't realize it's ours, and people in industry notes ours.
- 10:51That's the kind of key part. Yeah, that's the key messaging.
- 10:54I'd imagine your phone lines would get an awful lot more busy
- 10:56if Salkey Hall St. went out of power and all of a sudden
- 11:01everyone was folding folding Aspen Tech to get that fixed.
- 11:05That's one of that's one of the things has been a bit
- 11:07frustrating is that we don't actually know.
- 11:09None of us live within the territory of SSE and I live
- 11:11within SP Energy Networks territory.
- 11:14So we don't actually use the software that we developed to
- 11:17report our Powerpointages at the moment we're we're trying in
- 11:21that. Well, do you know, you touched
- 11:22on, you know, the utilities of the folks that are that are
- 11:25using this and we've spoken about what, you know, what
- 11:28network management is. We've spoken about, you know,
- 11:30who's using it with SSEN. But you know, I guess, I guess
- 11:34the question is why, why are these firms showing an interest
- 11:38in in tech like, like yours? It's all about.
- 11:41Basically understanding what's there better and it's about be
- 11:44able to use it better because as I said though it used to be
- 11:47permanent at the top float all the way down and you could
- 11:50basically say well, there's cables there providing it and
- 11:54there's sufficient headroom in there.
- 11:56The analysis doesn't have to be done to a great deal.
- 11:59But now as more people are connecting, what's happening,
- 12:02it's becoming more dynamic. In order to manage that better,
- 12:06in order to allow people to connect and understand the
- 12:09capacity that's available and you need better data, you need
- 12:13to know what's there. And the other part is that
- 12:15there's going to almost two kind of parts to the way network data
- 12:18is used in the utilities. One is for the real time
- 12:21operational control that's been used to manage the grid and
- 12:25control it in real time. The other one is planning.
- 12:28So you're saying what can connect, who can connect?
- 12:31And and and many customers, they are two separate models of the
- 12:36same electrical network maintained separately and they
- 12:39have to manually keep them synchronized because people are
- 12:42making decisions and saying to customers, yes, you can connect.
- 12:45There's sufficient band name bandwidth here to sufficient
- 12:48capacity in the network and you don't want to find it gets the
- 12:52operational side. And they say, well, we don't
- 12:54think there is capacity because our network model says something
- 12:56different. And we've spoken to kind of like
- 13:00utilities who have run into problems at that, where one
- 13:03model says one thing, one says another.
- 13:05And so they want to make sure that they're making planning
- 13:08decisions on the same data as we use for operational.
- 13:11They want to make sure things are updated the same frequency.
- 13:13So you don't find somebody's updating their data daily and
- 13:15somebody's doing every six months.
- 13:17And you also want to try and move to automation.
- 13:20You want to try and get to the point where if a customer says
- 13:23I'd like to connect solar or a wind turbine or batteries, they
- 13:27can give them a decision within weeks instead of months.
- 13:31And many of them have to provide decisions within a set time
- 13:36period because it's set for the regulatory body.
- 13:38So in order to do all this, they need better data and they need
- 13:42to be able to because they want to enable next generation
- 13:45technologies. You want to be able to see if
- 13:48you're a company with EV fleets you can be managing when they're
- 13:54charging so that you're basically get everyone's spread
- 13:57the load out. Not everyone charges at 5:00 PM,
- 13:59six PM, Some people charge then, some people charge it 9:00 PM,
- 14:03midnight, 4:00 AM. Is there a lot of excess wind
- 14:06capacity at 3:00 in the morning? Well, why don't we charge
- 14:08everything then? But to do all of that, you need
- 14:11to understand what does a network look like where people
- 14:13connected, what's the capacity? And that now also helps
- 14:16decisions like where do we install additional equipment?
- 14:20Where do we go in and put reinforcement and, and help
- 14:23optimize that so that it becomes a better use of assets.
- 14:26Things are used closer to their limits, closer to capabilities,
- 14:31and it ultimately saves the utility money, saves the
- 14:33customer money, and gets more clean energy onto the grid.
- 14:37Yeah, it's quite interesting because you touched on electric
- 14:39cars at the start of this and I suppose that's a major issue in
- 14:43the sense that people are changing how they use
- 14:45electricity is, you know, I guess the user use an example
- 14:48that your American colleagues probably won't understand the
- 14:51whole idea of everyone putting the kettle on when Coronation
- 14:54Street goes to an ad break with streaming services and stuff.
- 14:57People aren't following these those same patterns.
- 15:00So that data, you know, probably is is more more crucial than
- 15:04just knowing where, you know, all these peaks always happen at
- 15:07the same time kind of thing. But speaking on that alignment,
- 15:11you know, for operations planning and data and data from
- 15:15assets, you know, I guess the the question, the spell out for
- 15:20me, how, how does that specifically help utilities
- 15:24companies? I get you've got that sort of
- 15:26left hand doesn't know what the right hands doing kind of thing
- 15:28some of the times you know that you described there.
- 15:31But in practice, how does that help?
- 15:34So it becomes kind of single source of truth.
- 15:36So if you look at the way that utilities are moving, and I mean
- 15:40the UK is a good example where there's a big push for open
- 15:42data. So it's a big push to allow
- 15:45third parties to access network data that's there so people can
- 15:49make their own assessments. So instead of saying to the
- 15:51utility, I'd like to connect here, waiting six weeks and they
- 15:55come back and say, no, we can't, then asking for another site,
- 15:59people can download the data and run their own analysis.
- 16:02And The thing is now that's a third person using your data
- 16:06because you've got your internal planning, internal operations
- 16:09and then you've got public data and and then other network
- 16:13operators around about you. So if you're a distribution
- 16:15network operator in the UK, you have to provide data to the
- 16:18transmission company. So you want to make sure that
- 16:20all of this data is aligned. It's all the same data, the same
- 16:22decisions are being made and it makes things faster and better
- 16:26to do. And you want to align, see your
- 16:28IT kind of OT world into that. And then you run into the world
- 16:32of saying, well, if you're sharing all of this data that
- 16:35we've got 14 license areas in the UK for distribution
- 16:38companies. the US, there's thousands of distribution
- 16:41companies, but Norway, I could sit at over 100.
- 16:44There's lots of network operators.
- 16:46And if everybody said, well, we're inventing our own way of
- 16:49describing the grid, then suddenly you've got to deal with
- 16:52lots of different data formats. And so a lot of my work for the
- 16:56last 20 odd years has been on standardization.
- 16:59So how do we define data standards for electrical data
- 17:04for great data covering everything from actual network
- 17:08through to generation customers, asset data.
- 17:12So how to provide a standardized way so that if you pull your
- 17:15network model from SSEN or SPAN, you keep our networks, basically
- 17:22any of the kind of network operators, you're going to get
- 17:24the data in the same format and the same structure, which means
- 17:27you can more easily compare them.
- 17:29And that requires alignment not just within companies, but
- 17:32across companies. And there was huge work done by
- 17:36the European network operator. And so we over the last 1516
- 17:42years to build a standard for this and for the European
- 17:46transmission operations. And UK network operators will
- 17:50basically provide data in that because we're still connected to
- 17:53European network operators. So if companies start to use the
- 17:57same standardized data internally to feed their
- 18:00systems, then it also means that they can start to use the best
- 18:04applications you're not tied to. I'm using a format by one
- 18:09particular software company, and I have to use the software from
- 18:13that same company for everything else because it's the only thing
- 18:15that understands it. Now read the world of
- 18:17everything's in the standard, so we can pull out.
- 18:19You can share data and it's documented.
- 18:21That's understood. And it's much easier to then say
- 18:24why there's a new application come along from somebody and
- 18:27it's great and we want to try using that.
- 18:29Moving your data into is much easier at that point.
- 18:33So we built our software out to be built upon standards.
- 18:36So we're saying to utilities, not only are we going to help
- 18:38you with a single source of truth for your data, we're going
- 18:42to make sure it's done in a standardized way.
- 18:44So you feed all of your internal systems, you can feed external
- 18:47systems if you want to, and you can manage it all in open,
- 18:50documented format and you can use the best of the applications
- 18:54with it. But that requires a lot of data
- 18:57migration because people have had 2025 years of building up
- 19:01data in different places and other systems and Excel
- 19:05spreadsheets, everything seems to be Excel spreadsheets for
- 19:07lots of data because it's a quick and simple way to capture
- 19:10information. And I think the power industry
- 19:13is the same as many other industries.
- 19:14Something that starts off as we'll just put it in Excel
- 19:17spreadsheet and then we'll put it into a proper system later,
- 19:2010 years down the line. It's that maintained Excel
- 19:22spreadsheet and a shared drive somewhere that is the only
- 19:24source of truth for that data. Nobody's tracking the history of
- 19:27it because it just overwrites the previous version.
- 19:30So you want to get the world of tracking the history of data,
- 19:33the fidelity of it, and also validating it, making sure it's
- 19:36correct, finding errors without it, and so forth.
- 19:38I suppose that makes a lot of sense because you know, things
- 19:41thinking about my focus on the sort of reporting is mainly
- 19:45North Sea operations with oil and gas and renewables.
- 19:48And you do often hear these sort of stories crop up, especially
- 19:52the decommissioning of oil and gas assets where they've, you
- 19:55know, the, the engineer that designed a platform, you know,
- 19:5940-50 years ago is obviously retired.
- 20:01He's not around. Didn't his drawings have been
- 20:04stuffed in the back of a filing cabinet?
- 20:05And now we need to find out how, you know how this works.
- 20:08Similar kind of idea standard, you know, so.
- 20:11Align all the information, especially right now where, you
- 20:14know, the grid ends are it's our connections for renewable
- 20:19infrastructure and how how the power system is going to look in
- 20:23the future has become headline news in national papers, not
- 20:28just, you know, industry publications.
- 20:31But the average person on the street, you know, is interested
- 20:34in roll out pylons. So I guess, I guess that does
- 20:39that highlight the importance of standardizing now, you know, as
- 20:43we're looking to reform the grid almost.
- 20:45Yeah. And I think that's, well, let's
- 20:46see, a lot of distribution companies are in the position of
- 20:48saying we now need to basically capture and formalize data that
- 20:53they've maybe had in systems for years, but they've never tried
- 20:57to pull it all together to build something for analysis.
- 21:01A good example of that was we, we had a customer who had an
- 21:05area of their network that they were wanting to assess for
- 21:07saying, well, what would happen if everybody here got an
- 21:09electric vehicle? How does that impact on us?
- 21:12So they went to their geographical information system,
- 21:15which for distribution companies tends to be where their network
- 21:18model lives because people have drawn it in there.
- 21:22It's been, you know, as people do field work, they mark where
- 21:26cables are going, where the equipment is, and that's the,
- 21:29the source of basically where the electrical connectivity is.
- 21:32And they pulled out all of the data from there and they pulled
- 21:35it into the analysis application and it showed like 30 metering
- 21:39points, load points on the network.
- 21:41But if you looked at the satellite view, you could see
- 21:43there was 300 houses. And they went, well, why is
- 21:45there only, why is there only 30 within there?
- 21:48And they went back to what the kind of what the geographical
- 21:51team and said, well, could you add in all of these cables
- 21:54joining up the metering points? Because we know there's metering
- 21:57points there. Can you join them up?
- 21:59And they said no, because the data within there, we'll only
- 22:02add it if it'd been surveyed. So because it's a safety case,
- 22:06you didn't want to find that somebody just drew a straight
- 22:08line from the street to the house.
- 22:10And it showed us the cable is running across your your garden,
- 22:13across your lawn, when it actually ran up your driveway.
- 22:16But nobody had surveyed it. So because these houses were
- 22:19built 120 years ago and the cabling that you've been put in
- 22:22at some point in the last century and nobody.
- 22:26And if the data was captured, it was probably in a paper map that
- 22:29was in the basement of a building that's not been owned
- 22:31by the utility for 50 years. And nobody's had the case to go
- 22:36out and survey all of these houses because they know the
- 22:38cable's there. And so from a safety
- 22:40perspective, they would treat it as unknown.
- 22:42So they would go out and say we know the cable's there because
- 22:44you've got power, but we will treat as an unknowns or do like
- 22:48sensing equipment to work out with the cable.
- 22:49As before, we dig, but if they look at a map and see how cables
- 22:52marked in, then they go in the assumption that somebody has
- 22:55surveyed that and it's there and they don't have to do that.
- 22:57So they said, no, we're not going to add in all of these
- 22:59cables for you just to make your life easy for doing analysis
- 23:02because it breaks the safety case and you go, that actually
- 23:05makes perfect sense. You don't want them to do it.
- 23:07So you say, well, but we need a network model for doing
- 23:09analysis. So where do we capture this
- 23:11additional data without impacting the GIS?
- 23:14And that's where systems errors come along by saying you do that
- 23:17effort once as a standardized process of an export from with
- 23:21the geographical and you capture it and manage it within our
- 23:23system. And then we can provide that out
- 23:26to other systems that want to pull that data all together.
- 23:29And it's like it was just an interesting one where ultimately
- 23:32people said, well, why don't you start all add into geographical
- 23:34as soon as safety case is mentioned, you go, all right,
- 23:37actually that makes a lot of sense because you're coming at
- 23:39different perspective of analysis is important and field
- 23:42crew guys are going, we don't necessarily care about your
- 23:45analysis, but we care about the safety part of it.
- 23:47And so that's where you end up with additional systems for
- 23:50managing the net analysis model to support all this and work
- 23:54that's having to get done on assessing what's going to happen
- 23:57if 50% of people get solar panels and or happen or another
- 24:0150% get electric vehicles and so forth.
- 24:04So yes, you know, we touched on sort of grid connection for
- 24:07renewable energy just there and it'd be interesting to hear how
- 24:13with all this data sort of coming in in one place, how does
- 24:16that how does this tools or shape future projects like
- 24:20renewable energy infrastructure? Yeah, I think it's about if
- 24:23you've got this data here, you're managing it, You're not
- 24:26only tracking, make it easier to track what's there because we've
- 24:30got customers where the problem is.
- 24:33Customers have been connecting rooftop solar, they've been
- 24:35connecting EV, no charging points, but they don't know
- 24:39about them. And that was fine when there was
- 24:41a couple of them that suddenly when you've got huge numbers of
- 24:43them out there, they need to capture the data of it, what's
- 24:45there currently and need to store it, manage it and make it
- 24:48part of their analysis. But they also want to make sure
- 24:51they can make it quicker and easier for people to connect.
- 24:54So it can be things like we've provided a couple of utilities
- 24:57hosting capacity maps. So how can they make available
- 25:00to customers a map that says here's where there's capacity
- 25:04and that's automatically calculated, updated frequently
- 25:07and and making it easier for people to assess though where do
- 25:10they actually go? Where do they want to connect
- 25:12things? So if we're using the same data
- 25:14sets and basically for internal planning made in public data as
- 25:18well, it means they can operations planning team and
- 25:22start to see an advance. Well, now we've got a pipeline
- 25:25that we can see what's coming and we can automate it out.
- 25:28And in the software development world, you can think of
- 25:31continuous integration, whereby when you make changes, you
- 25:35basically rebuild everything, check everything works, you
- 25:37haven't added any bugs or problems.
- 25:39And by doing that, running through automated tests.
- 25:42And we want to get to the same thing with electrical network
- 25:45data. Every night something runs
- 25:47through because what happens is that it's gone from being,
- 25:51there's a few people wanting to connect because they want to add
- 25:54in a gas fire power station or a large one, kind of like in one
- 25:57farm. It's become hundreds of people
- 26:00wanting to connect because you've got people wanting to add
- 26:03small scale batteries, small scale and generators, single
- 26:07wind turbines, rooftop solar, all of that kind of stuff.
- 26:10So if you can start to manage the kind of queue within there,
- 26:15plug it into automated analysis. Suddenly somebody can come in
- 26:18the Monday morning and there's an e-mail with an orange warning
- 26:21saying you might have a problem in six months time because a
- 26:24project was delayed. And that has a knock on effect
- 26:27to these five other projects at the moment.
- 26:30If there's not something doing that automatically, it relies on
- 26:33people manually updating things or talking and finding out and
- 26:38that just leads to kind of errors.
- 26:39So you want to reach the point where all of this enables
- 26:42automation and all enables kind of like things to be done so
- 26:45that problems can identify the earlier things we made more
- 26:49efficient and you can ultimately get things connected.
- 26:51Faster, you know, it's quite interesting speaking about the
- 26:53the role of renewables in in how how you operate, especially
- 26:57considering where we're speaking about an industry that is right
- 27:01now in a state flux. We're obviously evolving, we're
- 27:03going through the energy transition.
- 27:05So how do you how do you future proof this technology for as the
- 27:10energy, energy transition progresses, you know this, this
- 27:14data remains is is as it is now. That gets into both internal
- 27:20processes for utilities, making sure that the having single
- 27:24source of data and data quality checks and everything like that
- 27:28and governance around about it means that you try and get away
- 27:31from what many utilities got to where you buy.
- 27:34You just had disparate data sets sitting out there being manually
- 27:38updated and, and if, and that just doesn't become feasible
- 27:42anymore, but we want to kind of accelerate energy transition.
- 27:46So it needs more infrastructure. And to do that, you need to make
- 27:49more decisions. And if you're doing it in bad
- 27:52data, you're going to get bad decisions.
- 27:54And you need an enterprise level, you need to share it.
- 27:56So you have to make sure that you've got automated links
- 27:59between systems going on there. And notice DER mandates are
- 28:03spreading, no utilities. They need to share accurate
- 28:06standards based data not only with market operators with
- 28:11neighbors, but potentially public.
- 28:13And so aligning with standards though helps prevent people
- 28:18having to do disruptive retrofits later.
- 28:21That's a huge problem. It can be customers might choose
- 28:24to move to another software provider.
- 28:26They don't want to necessarily say, well somebody else has got
- 28:28something great and you and we want to move to that one.
- 28:32And one of the barriers to doing that right now can be getting
- 28:35data out of one system into another as a multi year project,
- 28:40if you can do it at all. And so that kind of prevents
- 28:44people from potentially upgrading.
- 28:45They end up stuck with where they are.
- 28:47So we want to try and make sure that kind of data becomes
- 28:51something that's highly important and basically treated
- 28:54as being critical to all of this, rather than just being a
- 28:57kind of like secondary 1. I had a conversation with a
- 29:00friend recently who was talking about know like how they can
- 29:04basically try and get more renewables onto the grid in in
- 29:07the country and they're in. And they were, they were
- 29:10focusing very much on all the kind of what their their
- 29:13planning and the physical aspect.
- 29:15And I'd said to them, they had, have you considered know
- 29:17basically that the challenges around about data and all of
- 29:20this and where if you're going to be doing things to try and
- 29:23speak to government and regulators, they're starting to
- 29:27think about how they can actually help with standardized
- 29:30data is a big part of that. So it's not even just about us
- 29:33as the software vendors, it was much about the regulators.
- 29:37And that's why Ofgem, several years ago, we worked with them
- 29:41to build out a standard for GB Grid data built on top of the
- 29:46IEC standards, which is the common information model, which
- 29:50is the same one used by NSOE. So we were kind of leading that
- 29:54for them, working with a couple of other small companies, 1
- 29:57based in Ireland, 1 based in Hungary to help us develop these
- 30:00standards for the GB Grid because Ofgem had recognized
- 30:04that we couldn't just do another British standard that's
- 30:07different to the rest of the world.
- 30:09There was no too small a market to do that.
- 30:12No software in this industry tends to be.
- 30:15You're aiming at every country and with a small British sort
- 30:18data format, people will go, is that really worth our while
- 30:21supporting? Because we've got no other
- 30:24places in the world, bigger markets like Europe or the US
- 30:27And so we built it on top of that and now other countries are
- 30:30looking at what we're doing in the UK.
- 30:31They're saying that's a good approach.
- 30:33No, we want to make data publicly accessible as well.
- 30:36You know, can we look at these standards, something that goes
- 30:38with that. So that means that you've got
- 30:41everyone looking at the same thing, looking at the same data,
- 30:44and it means that the data volumes are expanding.
- 30:47You've also got a data format that can help to move with that
- 30:51because that's one of the things we've been doing for 20 years
- 30:53with the standards. And it started off for control
- 30:56systems at high voltage, and now it covers everything from
- 31:00distributed energy resources to customers to markets.
- 31:04And it's all integrated. And it's all a way of based on a
- 31:06single view of the data governed by that.
- 31:08So we can start to build out the data that's stored and managed
- 31:11together and make it kind of easier basically for utilities
- 31:15to use and share and increase the data there without it
- 31:19becoming our right. We want to add plus a little bit
- 31:21of data. This becomes a multi month
- 31:23project. It becomes right.
- 31:25It's a place to store it, manage it, track changes and you also
- 31:28get into the provenance of things.
- 31:31If I cheat, no. If a mistake has been made, can
- 31:34you trace back to where it came from?
- 31:36So if somebody's put a wrong rating and can you trace it all
- 31:39the way back to find out where it was entered, where it came
- 31:41from, what the problem was, and try and make sure these things
- 31:44don't happen again? You know, you touched on the
- 31:46common information model in your answer there, and that's
- 31:50obviously quite critical to what you're doing.
- 31:52But can you maybe just explain a little bit about, you know, how
- 31:56it solves problems specifically so?
- 31:59The common information model is a data model.
- 32:01So it's really a bit sort of describing data.
- 32:03And you think that would be simple, but you take something
- 32:06as something like a substation. No, most people say, well, I
- 32:09know what a substation is. No, I drive past one.
- 32:11I see what it is. If you go to different people,
- 32:13that means different things. If you're somebody conserved
- 32:16with geographical data, a substation is a boundary.
- 32:19It's an area where things are contained within it.
- 32:22Or it might if you're the asset management, you say, well, no,
- 32:24it's a building that's there. If you go into control system
- 32:28say well, it's just it's a grouping of equipment that we
- 32:30have there. So and other systems will say we
- 32:34don't really care about substations, we only care about
- 32:36the equipment within them and the substation is just this
- 32:38rough thing for naming. So the whole idea is that you
- 32:42see, right, we have one definition for this and we see
- 32:44it is it is for this, it's this type, it's for recruiting
- 32:47together equipment for control purposes.
- 32:49And then you run into other things which we are dealing with
- 32:52noise with American clients, which is things like units know
- 32:56what you see that that cable has a length, What unit is it
- 32:59within? You know, is it meters,
- 33:01kilometers, miles, feet entries though, because you can look
- 33:05through a kind of like some of these data structure and it's
- 33:08just a number next to it and you go, what unit is that?
- 33:10And then so imagine scaling all of this up into something that
- 33:13covers everything for the control analysis of the system.
- 33:16So you start to say, right, we now have one definition of what
- 33:19this is. Some people may disagree with
- 33:21it, but it's the standard. So they have to work to that.
- 33:24So it removes ambiguity. And so really what happens for
- 33:28utilities as they reach the point of saying they either if
- 33:30they're going to make their data the same across everywhere, they
- 33:34either pick a software vendors way of doing it, which can run
- 33:39into issues of are you tying yourself to that software
- 33:41vendor? Do they have licensing controls
- 33:45around about the documentation, for example, and of that?
- 33:48So you can, you suddenly find you've got data, but you can't
- 33:50explain it to somebody because then you're the shared
- 33:53documentation you're allowed to do.
- 33:55They could build their own, but then you're basically building
- 33:58your own thing and you're turning to people and say you
- 34:00need to support our custom thing that we designed and built and
- 34:03you have to manage control of that.
- 34:05Or you go with a standard, you go with something that's already
- 34:07defined. It's basically a public
- 34:09standard. So you can get the documentation
- 34:12for that. And that's, that's the challenge
- 34:14they run into. So for, for 20 years I've been
- 34:17on the standards groups and that basically help to define these.
- 34:20So, and the way they work is we, we, we had a meeting last week
- 34:23in Paris and you have utilities from all over the world.
- 34:26You've got software vendors from all over the world.
- 34:28You get people from universities, from research
- 34:30labs. And you come together and you
- 34:33argue and you say, no, you're wrong, you're wrong.
- 34:36That's not the way to do it. We do it this way, people make
- 34:38the case and you end up with ultimately a decision around
- 34:41about this is how we are going to describe it.
- 34:44And we drive some consistency in how we do it.
- 34:46And that's ultimately then a one way of describing it that
- 34:49everybody can agree on. And that's how they basically
- 34:54make sure when we're building out standards, it's built on
- 34:56that data model with one definition.
- 34:58And see, it's been 20 years of work by people across the
- 35:01industry. And I've said a lot of people
- 35:04look at it and say it's very complicated.
- 35:05You say, well, it covers so much stuff.
- 35:07Of course it's complicated. It has to, because we're trying
- 35:10to cover everything from individual houses all the way up
- 35:14to big nuclear power plants and have a way of describing things
- 35:17in that kind of common manner. And it has to cover everything
- 35:20from complex controls to market operations.
- 35:23But you look at the little bits of the standard that you need,
- 35:25it's easy. Well, I just described a bit of
- 35:27data for doing electrical connectivity.
- 35:29You don't need, you only need a few percentage of it.
- 35:32But the idea is that you can trace everything right the way
- 35:35through. You could have a customer meter
- 35:36point and have all the data linkages to trace from that
- 35:40right the way through to where they are on the network, how
- 35:42they're controlled, ultimately, basically where they fit into an
- 35:46analysis. I suppose at the end of the day
- 35:48there's a massive difference between a 5 foot line and a 5m
- 35:51line. I suppose is the at the long and
- 35:53short, right? That's exactly if somebody looks
- 35:55at it and says and that's the unit conversion fits into
- 35:58exactly as in metric can be OK because you can look at
- 36:01something go amount by a factor of 10 or 100 or 1000.
- 36:03But we're in a world where some formats are, the diameter is an
- 36:07inches, it's ohms per mile, and the length is measured in feet.
- 36:12And you're having to go away and look up all your stuff to try
- 36:14and remember, you know, I mean, I'm 45 and I wasn't really
- 36:18taught how many basically all that stuff in school.
- 36:20We were all metric. And so I come over here and have
- 36:22to go and look all that stuff up again because it's in North
- 36:25America still very much like that.
- 36:27But it gets into the data can be stored internally in what
- 36:30metric, but presented to users for units and formats they want.
- 36:34So yeah, that's the kind of the standards at least provides one
- 36:37way of doing it and you have to buy it I.
- 36:38Suppose the UK is also a unique microcosm of that, you know,
- 36:42that exact issue. You know, I guess if you want to
- 36:45understand the frustrations of people using different
- 36:48measurement systems for different things within the same
- 36:50industry, you should need to look around a UK supermarket.
- 36:53You know, your milk is in pints, but you're, you know, fizzy
- 36:56juices in litres. It just, it seems a bit.
- 36:59Yeah. It's.
- 36:59The same as a maintained we are kind of the UK can be casually
- 37:03imperial and then basically about everything's metric when
- 37:06it comes to industry. Not my brother's an architect
- 37:08and if you see all the room ceilings are no like 10 feet
- 37:12high, he's like, what's that metric?
- 37:13He's like, are you talking about the width or something?
- 37:15Because everything seems as everything scientific is done
- 37:18and basically metric, but you're still talking with being 6 foot
- 37:22or you win. The butcher isn't a pound of
- 37:23mints and they see a pint of milk.
- 37:25And although I haven't, I have noticed my younger colleagues
- 37:27just do everything in metric. So I think I'm just showing my
- 37:30age now a bit as well. But yeah, that's the that's a
- 37:33perfect example in this industry whereby the units is an easy one
- 37:37for people to understand. But I was once I once arrived
- 37:40and it was in Canada and the guy the border said, no, what are
- 37:44you here for? Said I'm here for standards
- 37:46group meeting. So what does that involve?
- 37:48Said explain it to me in a way I'll understand, right.
- 37:51And I said, well, I said, you know how mobile phones you can
- 37:53buy multiple mobile phones from different operators?
- 37:56He said, yes, your Apple, Samsung said, but you can make
- 38:00phone calls between all of them fight.
- 38:02I said yes. I said we do the same thing but
- 38:05for basically power system control software.
- 38:07So software from different vendors can all speak to each
- 38:10other so they can pretend to operate and they went, OK, that
- 38:12makes sense and let me in. But so coming up with analogies
- 38:15for what you do in such a way that people can understand,
- 38:17because you can understand that we need it for a mobile phone
- 38:20because everyone uses it, but not everybody has to use power
- 38:22system control software. If I'm honest, the main take
- 38:25away from me from this conversation is going to be
- 38:28you've given me a new fear of every time I say a pint of milk,
- 38:31people, people are going to think I'm really old.
- 38:34That's slightly, slightly concerning.
- 38:38But I suppose I, we've run through everything I wanted to
- 38:41ask you today other than I suppose we touched on utilities
- 38:44and how they are interacting with your technology when it
- 38:48comes to, you know, those that are on the fence going on,
- 38:51should I use a network model management tool?
- 38:54Should I not? What's the big take away?
- 38:56Yeah, I think that we've, a lot of the customers we've worked
- 38:58with recently are breaking over the early movers in this.
- 39:01And because people quite often start with, we don't want
- 39:03another system and it's kind of understandable, there's lots of
- 39:05software in there, but they start saying, well, we can.
- 39:08The example I gave the GIS was one we ran through the customer
- 39:11who were like, well, we can just use our existing GIS system to
- 39:15manage our network model. And suddenly they realized that,
- 39:18oh, we, it doesn't actually have all of the data that we need
- 39:21within it and we can't add it because this is being used for
- 39:23another purpose. And I think it just gets into,
- 39:27you suddenly realize that how many people start to need your
- 39:30network model now? How many systems are being
- 39:32sourced by it? And then the data quality, if
- 39:35you're going to basically it turns into if you're going to
- 39:37improve the data quality, because I think many utilities
- 39:40we speak to have issues with, we know, they know they need to
- 39:44improve the quality of data they have.
- 39:45They need to basically make sure that all of their parameters are
- 39:48up to date. They need to make sure things
- 39:50are actually all fully connected.
- 39:51You need to basically go through all and make sure everything
- 39:53aligns and you just want to do that once.
- 39:56You don't want to do it for every single system that needs
- 39:59that data. Do it once, do it correctly,
- 40:02make sure it feeds to everything else.
- 40:04So as I said, I'm, I'm going to wear my, my undergraduate degree
- 40:08was a kind of hybrid of computer science and electrical
- 40:10engineering. So I've could have always
- 40:12approached a lot of these things the same way as you do or
- 40:14software version control. Know basically make sure you've
- 40:17got a single place for all everyone who she's into the same
- 40:20place. You deal with conflicts there,
- 40:22you manage it, and you track history.
- 40:24And you make sure that you know everything that's going on
- 40:26within that and you can basically have a single source
- 40:28for everything to be built from. And that's the approach we've
- 40:31been taking here saying data is critical to everything that's
- 40:34going on here to be connections and supporting analysis.
- 40:39And it's the whole, if you don't have good quality data, then
- 40:43you're just going to run into problems.
- 40:45And the other one that we're seeing as well for the problem
- 40:47touched on for utilities is that so transmission companies, they
- 40:52operate the high voltage network.
- 40:53So in the UK that's a NISO or national energy system operator
- 40:57now operates the high voltage network.
- 40:59But it used to be they were basically only concerned the
- 41:02high voltage because below that they just treated it as being
- 41:05there's loads they're coming from distribution.
- 41:08But suddenly as distribution starts to become this dynamic,
- 41:10complex thing with lots of little generators applying, they
- 41:14need a lot more visibility, need to understand what's down there,
- 41:17what's going on. So they need to start expanding
- 41:20out how much of the credit they're assessing, how much
- 41:22they're analyzing. And that means they need to get
- 41:24data from these other network operators because in the UK,
- 41:27they're separate companies, they're separate entities, and
- 41:30they have to share the data back up.
- 41:32And that's common, I think around the world.
- 41:35Because if you don't understand what's going on further down
- 41:37becomes a lot more copies, comes a lot more complex, comes a lot
- 41:40more difficult for you to understand how the grid is going
- 41:44to behave, how it's going to respond.
- 41:46So you can end up in situations whereby the lower voltage part
- 41:50of the grid is suddenly behaving in strange ways that then impact
- 41:53up into the high voltage part of the grid.
- 41:55And if they don't understand what's down there, that's a
- 41:58problem for them. So I think everybody, every
- 42:00level is wanting to capture more data to understand.
- 42:04If you're a distribution company, you want to find out
- 42:06how many people are getting EVs and solar battery to the
- 42:09transmission company. You kind of want to know that
- 42:11kind of stuff as well because you want to start to understand
- 42:14that. Wait, suddenly that, you know,
- 42:1620 years ago that was a predictable load of nice little
- 42:18graph. Now suddenly powers flowing into
- 42:21your grid from that part of the network where previously it was
- 42:24always a load. Is your equipment set up for
- 42:27that? Are you says your protection
- 42:29schemes configured for all of this?
- 42:30Can your Transformers handle all of that?
- 42:32If you don't understand what's there, it's very difficult to
- 42:35do. And so there, there's a whole
- 42:37bunch of additional data sharing having to go on here.
- 42:39And if you're not managing this correctly, you're going to end
- 42:42up in situations whereby you're telling one system one thing,
- 42:45one system something else, and you're just going to end up with
- 42:49problems that is a multiply on top of each other.
- 42:52So it's basically treat the data as something that really needs
- 42:54to be stored and managed correctly and to give you that
- 42:59kind of confidence that everyone's using the same thing.
- 43:01And also critically, if you correct it in one place, it goes
- 43:05to everybody instead of being corrected in one system.
- 43:09And somebody else never gets that correction because it was
- 43:11in an e-mail that was sent to somebody that get lost in a spam
- 43:14filter somewhere and never appeared.
- 43:16Well, like I say, I think that does it for everything I wanted
- 43:19to ask you today, Alan. So thank you very much for
- 43:21joining me and thank you very much for listening.
- 43:24If you'd like to stay up to date with the comings and goings of
- 43:27the energy sector, ensuring you get the first word, remember
- 43:31stay tuned to Energy Voice Out Loud.