Latest / MBA Training Data / Why most data culture initiatives fail before they start
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Leaders Insights Podcast.
- 0:07Today's episode, why most data culture initiatives fail before they start, a fresh survey out
- 0:12this month says 92% of companies have a documented data strategy and only about a quarter say
- 0:18it actually changed how anyone works.
- 0:21So what's the point of the other 68%?
- 0:23The point is the PowerPoint.
- 0:25That's the whole deliverable.
- 0:27Nobody presented a slide, everybody nodded, and then went back to hoarding spreadsheets
- 0:32on their laptops.
- 0:33That number's from a vendor, isn't it?
- 0:35New vantage partners, the data leadership survey, people who sell you the fix.
- 0:40Right, and that's exactly why the We Have a Strategy figure is inflated.
- 0:45Nobody tells the consultant their strategy is a corpse.
- 0:48But the failure rate lines up with what I see in the field, so I'll trust the shape
- 0:51of it.
- 0:52Fine.
- 0:53Note that most data culture initiatives fail before they start.
- 0:57Before.
- 0:58That's a strong claim.
- 1:00Because the launch is already the mistake.
- 1:02You get a chief data officer hired, big kickoff, a new platform bought, and the org
- 1:07treats it as a tech project.
- 1:09It isn't.
- 1:10The silos aren't technical.
- 1:12They're political.
- 1:13Marketing doesn't want finance seeing its numbers because finance will ask why the
- 1:17campaign missed.
- 1:19So the data is fenced off on purpose.
- 1:21On purpose, I watched a European retailer—I won't name them, still a client—spend
- 1:279 million euros on a unified data lake, a single place to pool all their data.
- 1:3218 months later, three business units were still keeping shadow copies in Excel, because
- 1:38whoever controlled the numbers controlled the budget conversation.
- 1:42The lake was full.
- 1:43Nobody drank from it.
- 1:45That sounds like a people problem you can't buy your way out of.
- 1:48You can't.
- 1:49And here's the uncomfortable part for my own profession.
- 1:52Hiring a CDO doesn't fix it either.
- 1:55Gartner reported the average tenure of a chief data officer is under two and a half years,
- 2:00shorter than most enterprise software rollouts.
- 2:03So the person meant to change the culture leaves before the culture notices they arrived.
- 2:08Why so short?
- 2:10Are they bad at the job?
- 2:11They're set up to lose.
- 2:13They get accountability for outcomes and zero authority over the teams that hold the data.
- 2:18It's like being made fire chief with no water and no trucks.
- 2:22Just a title and a memo.
- 2:24Okay, so what does a real one look like?
- 2:27Give me somebody who got it right.
- 2:28Let me push back on the hero CDO framing.
- 2:31That's part of the disease.
- 2:33The place I'd point to is a midsize insurer that stopped treating data as a department.
- 2:38They tied one number, quote to bind time, how long from a customer asking for a price
- 2:43to actually buying, to every team's bonus.
- 2:47Suddenly the underwriters wanted the marketing data because it made their number go up.
- 2:52So they didn't sell culture.
- 2:53They rewired incentives.
- 2:55They made sharing data the selfish choice.
- 2:58That's the trick.
- 2:59Culture isn't a poster in the break room.
- 3:01It's what makes you money on Friday.
- 3:03If hoarding pays and sharing doesn't, people hoard.
- 3:07They're not villains.
- 3:08They're rational.
- 3:09But incentives take years in a friendly CFO.
- 3:12What's a listener supposed to do Monday morning?
- 3:15Kill the launch.
- 3:16Do not announce a data transformation.
- 3:18Instead, pick one decision that's currently made on gut and one team that's sick of guessing.
- 3:24One decision.
- 3:25One.
- 3:26Say, which customers do we call before they cancel?
- 3:30Give that team clean data for that one question and let them win visibly.
- 3:34You want colleagues asking, how did they do that?
- 3:38Envy spreads faster than any strategy deck.
- 3:41That's the opposite of the enterprise-wide rollout everyone's proud of.
- 3:45Re-is-wide is how you fail everywhere at once.
- 3:48Nobody remembers the retailer's 9 million lake.
- 3:51Everyone remembers the team that stopped losing customers.
- 3:54So if I'm a leader listening right now, the takeaway is, don't launch anything.
- 4:00Don't launch.
- 4:01Find one painful decision made on instinct this quarter.
- 4:04Hand the right team the data to make it better.
- 4:07And make sure the whole building sees the win.
- 4:09Skip the strategy document entirely.
- 4:12Please ever change their behavior because of a slide.
- 4:15One decision.
- 4:16One win.
- 4:17No launch.
- 4:18That's the whole show.
- 4:19That's it.
- 4:20The CDO Decision Tools are live at MBA-training.com.