Latest / Special Episodes Archives - The Partial Historians - Ancient Roman History with smart ladies / Special Episode – Gladiators in the Greek World with Alexandra Sills
Transcript
- Dr Rad 0:15 Welcome to the Partial Historians. We explore all the details of ancient Rome, everything from political scandals, the love affairs, the battles waged, and when citizens turn against each other. I'm Dr. Rad, Dr G 0:33 and I'm Dr. G. We consider Rome as the Romans saw it by reading different authors from the ancient past and comparing their stories. Dr Rad 0:44 Join us as we trace the journey of Rome from the founding of the city. Dr Rad 0:57 Welcome to a special episode of The Partial Historians. I am one of your hosts, Dr. Rad Dr Rad 1:06 And I am Dr. G. Dr. G. We are joined by a repeat guest, special indeed. We're joined by Alexandra Sills, who holds a BA in Classical Studies from Berkbeck College, the University of London and an MA in the Classical Mediterranean from the University of Leicester. Alexander's MA dissertation was awarded the Mark Pluciennik Prize in Archaeology and Ancient History. I certainly hope I said that correctly. She specializes in spectacle, classical reception, and public-facing history. Alexandra is a qualified member of the Institute of Tourist Guiding and a certified City of London guide and host of the Ancient History 101 podcast. Some of this may sound very familiar because I've said she's actually been on our show before you must check out our episode on Gladiator II one of the worst ancient history movies ever made. Dr G 2:10 Never to be watched again. Dr Rad 2:13 However, we're going to be returning to the subject of gladiators today-not the kind that you're probably all familiar with. We're venturing into the arenas in the Greek world to celebrate the release of Alexandra's new book, aptly titled *Gladiators in the Greek World: How a Roman Bloodsport Took Ancient Greece by Storm* Welcome to the show, Alexandra. Hello. Alexandra Sills 2:39 It is so nice to be back. Thank you for welcoming me back. Dr Rad 2:43 We are delighted to have you here. Although I do have a bone to pick with you, I believe there is a phrase in your book that says anything the Romans can do, Greeks can do better. And quite frankly, maybe we just should end the interview right now. Dr G 2:58 It's over. Alexandra Sills 3:00 In cheek, a lot of the book is tongue in cheek. It was tongue in cheek. Dr G 3:04 Well, that remains to be seen. Let us be the judge of that after this interview. So, to get us started, I'm interested to understand more about what we mean when we talk about the Greek world when it comes to this whole subject area, Alexandra Sills 3:24 It's a tough one, isn't it? Because the idea of the Greek world, everyone has a different idea of what it is, and I'm sure that mine will differ from other historians. But from what I can gather, Greekness isn't something that you're born with. It's something that you can become and something that you do. So we think of the Greek world, and obviously we think of what is now Greece. But because of colonization and because of Alexander the Great, the Greek world just exploded over these centuries. There's a Greek city in the south of France, Marseille was Massalia. There are Greek cities as far as Syria. It's a huge area, and all of these areas outside of the Greek Peninsula have differing levels of Greekness because all of these people are mixing with the local populations. So being Greek is something that you do. It's the gods that you worship, the language that you speak, the cultural festivals that you have, the buildings that you have in your city. So you can become Greek, you can be Greek and something else. But the Greek world is a fuzzy concept that comes a huge area, and I think there were definitely Greeks on the peninsula thinking we are purely Greek, and everyone else is half Greek and not as good, but they're still Greek. So we have this huge geographical span, which ends up being about half of the Roman Empire that definitely consider themselves at least partly Greek, and that includes Egypt. Greece, what's now Turkey, massive, massive geographical span, which doesn't count as Greece today, but definitely did back then. Dr G 5:11 Sounds kind of dangerous. It sounds like the Romans might actually be Greek. Alexandra Sills 5:16 I would argue that at least some of them were. They won't like it, but I would argue. Dr Rad 5:23 Well, as much as I hate to admit it, I I know the Greeks did make it into Italy in those early days. Well, there is that Dr G 5:30 whole section called magnification, exactly. Dr Rad 5:33 Yeah. So let's maybe explore this relationship between the Romans and the Greeks a little bit more. I know there is an unfortunate idea out there in the world that the Romans just stole everything from Greece. So, please tell us how did these two peoples come into contact? What happened when they came into contact? Alexandra Sills 5:52 Well, they came into contact mainly through Magna Graecia, which was obviously the southern tip of Italy and Sicily, and all of these Greek cities, and as the Romans expanded, they were coming into contact not just through conquest but through trade and cultural exchange, getting all of these ideas. The Etruscans were getting ideas from the Greeks as well. You know, the Etruscans definitely loved things like the Iliad, for instance, and they're in contact with the Etruscans too, so they're getting all of this bruteness first hand, second hand, seeing all of these cultural things and thinking, "Wow, okay, we like some of this. It's not what we're usually into, but we can we can jam with it. So, when we think about Romance, we think about conquest first, but actually that comes much later. The Romans were definitely aware of what the Greeks were doing for centuries, and yeah, they were copying a little bit of it, and they were changing bits and bobs. But it was more of a conversation rather than just stealing, and that goes both ways as well. The Greeks were looking at Rome and thinking, okay, we don't like this bit, this bit, and this bit, but that bit we can take. So there's this idea of Romanization, where the Romans were just forcing their ideas on everybody that they came into contact with. That's not quite the case. It's more of a complicated discussion between cultures, where they decide what they like, what they don't like, what they're going to take, what they're going to share. So it's a it's a difficult one, and of course there was there was a lot of conquest. It's the Romans, but they go into the Greek world quite late compared to where they're going into other places. So it's a place that they knew well already when they were started getting involved militarily. Dr Rad 7:45 Yes, as Dr. G and I know all too well, the Romans spend an enormous amount of time just fighting with their immediate neighbors when they're first established. So much so that we're still dealing with that. Dr G 7:58 Yeah, Rome is kind of like this scrappy little bully in central Italy, but the the influence of the Greeks sort of even predates a lot of Rome's early history because Magna Graecia sort of also is rising up at the same time. So there's kind of no way on some level to separate the two because by the time we get into the historiographical period of exactly, they're already well influenced by the Greeks. So separating these two things out is incredibly challenging. So then it's a matter of are there things that we can really establish as being quintessentially Roman and then quintessentially Greek and be like, yes, they're they're doing a cultural exchange here. It's really happening, and so I think this is why gladiators actually forms a really nice, a sort of bridge between these two groups because the Greeks don't have gladiators for a long time, and they adopt them. So thinking about how Greeks feel about the gladiators, there is a traditional view on in scholarship about Greece and their relationship with gladiators, and your book is really challenging that position. So I'm interested, first of all, what's the traditional scholarship position, and how are we looking at challenging it and revising it potentially, Alexandra Sills 9:23 I think the main book that talks about Greek gladiators that exist so far comes from 1940, and it's by an archeologist named Louis Robert, and he was collecting inscriptions of all kinds in Greece and Turkey and areas such as, and he discovered that a lot of them seem to mention gladiators. So he decided to turn all of these inscriptions into a monograph, which is fine, and he made some excellent points. However, he does seem to have a little bit of an issue. With gladiators being in the Greek world, if he'd have been finding these in Italy, I think he would have written a very, very different book. But because they were in the Greek world, for instance, he writes the Romans infected the Greeks with this plague of gladiators, from which they didn't recover, describing that as a play immediately suggests to me, okay, you're putting a value judgment on different kinds of entertainment first off, but also you're not giving this one a lot of value, and I find this in a lot of academia, wherein gladiators are a bit of a hot topic with the public, definitely. However, there's a bit of a reluctance for certain people to read a lot about them because it's gladiators. It's disgusting. It's violent. It's immoral to our modern sensibilities, and that kind of becomes where a lot of scholars stop and say, "I'm not going to study this in any great detail. It's not my thing. I was watching a documentary series where a gentleman who I won't name, I think it was eight or 10 parts, and he did one on the Colosseum and said, "This is where my great respect for the Romans starts to waver, and I'm thinking. So it's not the sexism, it's not the slavery, it's not the genocides. Those are fine. It's the gladiators that you have an issue with. Dr Rad 11:36 Totally acceptable. Yeah. All Dr G 11:37 good. Yeah, yeah. It's the entertainment I've got a problem with. Alexandra Sills 11:43 So there is this kind of idea that even talking about gladiators kind of taints the scholar that's talking about them. But I think the problem with that is that you start to miss a lot of the context, a lot of the nuance, and you fail to dig deep enough to understand what gladiators were for, what they represented, and I think that that's a kind of trap that Louis Robert fell into. He wasn't interested in why the gladiators were there. He was interested in the fact that gladiators were there, and that disgusted him. And I think that also goes into this idea, which still happens in universities everywhere, that after the first year or so of undergrad, Rome and Greece get siloed. I know that I was certainly encouraged to think: Am I going the Greek route? Am I going the Roman route? And then, obviously, if I'd have gone into a PhD, it would have been: Am I going into epigraphy? Am I going into archeology? The more that we specialize, the more we kind of isolate ourselves from what's going around, and it's starting to change that people are poking their heads up and thinking, "What's happening around me? And I'm hoping that this is what I've done with this book. Instead of thinking of Rome and Greece as two very separate, different entities, trying to see what they had in common instead. So this idea that the Greeks were infected with this foreign, disgusting practice-he collected all of this evidence, but he doesn't seem to have noticed that the Greeks were really huge fans of it. That's why they had so much evidence to put in the book. So I think that by challenging these stereotypes as the Romans are the brutes, the himbos, the the bullies, and Greeks are all of these bearded philosophers sitting in a store all day discussing poetry, by challenging those stereotypes, you realize that people are just people, and something that's popular in one place is probably going to be at least slightly attractive to a portion of the population in a different place for pretty much the same reasons. And I think that's what I've found. So it's an area of study that doesn't have a lot of people working in it. It's an area of study that I think the people working in it at the moment are narrowing themselves down to. I'm going to look at art. I'm going to look at epigraphy. I'm going to look at this particular city, and this book is bringing all of that together, trying to stitch it together, and say, right, okay, so this must be the bigger picture. Then, that's what I think. Dr Rad 14:30 No, I think that's a really interesting way of looking at it because I think certainly most people would have a bit of a picture in their heads that the Greeks are so much more refined. The Romans come across as somewhat brutish and coarser and cruder the way that people tend to think about them, and just more violent. And yeah, I really appreciated as a fan of the Romans that you were challenging that someone. Alexandra Sills 15:01 Yeah, and the Greeks are the sophisticated ones, and the Romans are the ones that are constantly trying to copy the Greeks, trying to look up to the Greeks, whilst still making a lot of fun of them. Let's not forget, but still trying to live up to living up to the Joneses next door. We can do anything that they can do, and the Greeks are this idealized society that even some scholars who should know better are constantly looking at and saying this is the pinnacle. You're not going to get better than Greek culture. Look at the plays. Look at the poetry. And I'm thinking to myself, have you read this poetry? Have you watched these plays? Because there is intense violence in them. It's not a huge leap to connect the two, actually. Dr Rad 15:46 Yeah, and I think it's easy sometimes to look, obviously, at other cultures and other time periods and make those sorts of value judgments. It's easier, I think, in some ways, to be blind to the violence and cruelty inherent in your own society. I promise, Doctor G, I'm not going to get too distracted by this tangent, but I always have to bring it up. I do not like the way that the Romans treated animals, and I do not like the way they treated slaves, gladiators, etc. However, I do have to always note the immense suffering and pain that is caused to animals by modern-day human society, particularly in practices like factory farming, and I think a lot of us are just blind to that because it is hidden to the point where anyone who tries to investigate it can find themselves going up against massive legal cases and that sort of thing. And I just think at some point people are going to look back at our society and think how disgusting that this is the kind of practices that were allowed and embraced by the common people. This is how most people were getting their food, and they were just completely fine with it. So yeah, I do think that there is a bit of a a judgment sometimes that comes with those sorts of things. And even though I don't love it myself, I'm not saying I am a fan of Roman violence. I do think there is a failure sometimes to recognize that there is a lot of violence and cruelty still in this world that we don't look at. Absolutely, Alexandra Sills 17:13 and you can expand that. You can expand that to so many parts of modern culture, and we have this idea that we're We're better. We're civilized. We've evolved from the people that lived 2000, 3000 years ago, but we haven't. We haven't at all. If you look at some of the things that are happening politically in the world right now, they are awful. We haven't evolved at all. We still have hatred. We still have violence. We're still absolutely fine killing people for various reasons, and this is one of the things that the Romans did with gladiators. They othered them. They made them dress in armor of conquered foes, historic conquered foes. So they're dressed as the people that the Romans once defeated in war, so that's okay because they're dressed as the enemy, so we can kill them, right? They stripped them of their civic rights and they gave them this status, this social status of infamia, which is where we get infamy. They stripped them of that so that they're barely Roman at all anymore. They're not even allowed to do a lot of the things that Romans were allowed to do, you definitely wouldn't want to sit next to a gladiator at the theater, even if you're happy to screen their name in the Colosseum. You don't want them near you because they're othered, right? And we think that that's terrible. How could they do that? How could they strip these people of their personhood, so that they could watch them die, so they could justify it to themselves. But we're killing people based on their religion, based on their ethnicity, and that's fine. And also the idea of enjoying entertainment that has violence in it. When you look at what entertainment is, it is horrifically violent. If I had a penny for every true crime podcast that earned money from talking about the pain and horrific deaths of particularly young women, because there does seem to be a fascination with how women are murdered, and they they're treating it as some cutesy kind of murder mystery when it's a real person. I think that's disgusting. I think that's on a par with watching someone die because they happen to be a gladiator. When we look at what we watch on television, we have CGI, so that makes it okay. But does it does it do something to our psyche when we watch, for instance, Game of Thrones had some particularly horrific scenes. I'm watching Interview with a Vampire at the moment. Oh my god! I was just Dr Rad 19:52 thinking about that. It's so OTT, right? It is Alexandra Sills 19:56 extreme, but I'm not going to stop watching. Yeah. And I tell my Dr G 20:00 don't ruin it for me because I'm just thinking about watching it now. Alexandra Sills 20:04 You should. And here's me saying it's a great show, not because of its violence, maybe despite of its violence, but it's not like I fast forward those parts. I'm still consuming it. Yeah, Dr Rad 20:16 I was consuming it and I was enjoying it, but I must admit the the violence and gore in that show is so extreme that I actually generally don't. I kind of look away and look up at the ceiling because I'm like, I know what's going to happen here. I don't really need to see the details. It's so full on. Yeah, it is. Alexandra Sills 20:35 But people watch in their millions, and I think you know, if we had othered groups of people, and we forgot to use the CGI and started giving ourselves reasons to justify watching actual blood sports. Now, I don't think it would take many years for me to sell out an arena, depending on who I'm having fighting and who I'm inviting into the audience. I don't think we're evolved. I don't think we're civilized, and I think there are significant portions of the population who hate a group of people enough that they would take joy out of seeing them fight to the death. So we're not better than the Romans. The Greeks were not better than the Romans. It's something that we have to face as humans that this isn't a matter of civilization. There seems to be something inside us that we're not getting rid of after 1000s of years. We're just finding different ways of doing it and different justifications for it, and that's where the kind of the the challenge comes in is to ask every single person, oh, what do I watch? What do I consume? What do I enjoy? That one day a historian is going to write a book about me and say, "Whoa, that's that's intense. Dr G 21:50 Those people in the 21st century-I don't know-they had some weird tastes. The things they did for entertainment. Yeah, I think I think you're on the money because, as one of the ways that I was thinking about this and that you mentioned in the book is the the sense in which the Greek do have like physical competition. It's not like they don't have their own forms of it, but it's interesting that it that their forms of like sort of wrestling and boxing and stuff don't sort of translate in the same way. Like the Romans don't seem to pick them up in the same way that it seems like the Greeks pick up the gladiatorial combat. So I think that's quite an interesting nuance as well. Yeah, Alexandra Sills 22:32 the Romans do take on Greek athletics, and they take on the things like boxing and wrestling. We don't see them seem to take up Pankatrion as much because Pankration just bonkers, but they do take it on, but not to the same level. I'd say is what I'm seeing with gladiators in the Greek world. So you have these festivals. Augustus definitely had a an athletic festival that had Greek style athletics, including the contact sports. But the Romans are looking at them, thinking, "This is interesting. We're happy to see it once every four years. We're not going to make a huge deal out of it. This is just a pleasant diversion. Whereas the Greeks, on the other hand, they view these sports as these the pinnacle of human achievement, and it's not just people running from one end of the stadium to the other. The contact sports are insane. The boxing, the wrestling, Pankration-we see in the sources. These were fatal events, and that was fine. There was one-I think it was a wrestler-who was about to die in his match, and his coach yelled out to him, "You can die, but you'll be a loser. But if you sweep his leg, you'll die an Olympic champion. And this guy immediately swept his leg and died because he was in a chokehold. But he died a champion, so he valued winning over death. Where does that sound vaguely familiar? So when you value winning and excellence over death already, it doesn't. Again, it doesn't take a huge leap to get to gladiators, and the gladiators noticed this immediately. They started using the lingo of Greek athletes when they went to Greece. They started to model themselves. They started using their tombstone reliefs to make themselves look like contact athletes. They had the same prizes. They had the wreaths, the laurel wreaths. So, to all intents and purposes, they're saying, and I think with quite a lot of justification, we're just an extension of your contact sports. The only thing that we've added is a pointy stick and some armor. And to be fair, I actually think that gladiatorial combat. We don't know the rule book, and if they're. Was one thing that I wish we had surviving. It is a gladiatorial rule book. We know that there were rules. We can kind of work out what some of them were. The rest is going to have to be a mystery, and unfortunately conjecture. But they do seem to have a considerable list of rules for gladiatorial combat. Whereas Pankration, the only rules are no biting and no gouging the arts. Dr G 25:16 Very important. Everything else is okay. Alexandra Sills 25:30 Everything else is okay, which means in a Pankration match, the Greeks, these bearded philosophers reading poetry in a store, are cheering on people who think that breaking bones is an entirely fine thing to do. Yeah, to win, I'm going to break your bone. That's fine. Dr G 25:48 First strategy, kick him in the nerve. You Alexandra Sills 25:50 were absolutely allowed to do that. You were allowed to grab the balls and tug if that's what was going to get you to win. You could do whatever you wanted, and people again, they died during this, and this was just par for the course. So Pankration, to my mind, just because it doesn't have weapons, it has fewer rules, and it seems far more savage compared to the ordered combat of gladiatorial gladiatorial sports. So again, it's this this idea that we've got to shed that the Greeks had one idea of what violence for entertainment was, and the Romans had another idea. The Greeks were doing things that the Romans don't seem to have copied. They don't seem to be doing Pankration. Dr Rad 26:38 They saw what happened, and they were like, "Ouch! I'm not up for that, man. Alexandra Sills 26:44 They they may have even looked at it and said that's a bit barbarian. Yeah, Dr Rad 26:48 not my manhood. I actually think it completely fits with my vision of who the Romans were-that they had a lot of rules. Yeah, I think that's very much what I would expect from the Romans, and I agree. It's one thing I think that a lot of people don't understand about gladiatorial combat that there is an element of regulation there. Alexandra Sills 27:11 Absolutely, Dr Rad 27:12 yeah. It Alexandra Sills 27:13 was very ordered, and we see particularly the the thing that I love about the Greek gladiators is that they leave us really detailed gravestones. In Rome, you might get the name, the number of fights in a numeral, and the type of gladiator they were. So three words, and that's it. That's all you get. But the Greeks left metrical epitaphs. They left their statistics. They left the names of their wives and their children. They left so much information, and a lot of them say, "I am really proud that during my entire career, I did not harm my opponents more than I absolutely had to. And actually, when they encounter a gladiator who seems to be a bit psychopathic and a little bit too into it. They criticize him and say my opponent was not acting in a sportsman-like, gentlemanly manner. So that definitely gives you the idea that this was a meeting of equals. They were both displaying their skill set in an ordered, regulated way, we know that they had at least one referee present at every single match. That they had rules, that they had this code of conduct, that they did not stray from; otherwise, they would be castigated by their colleagues. And you don't get that in Pankration at all, not even slightly. So the Romans, even the Greek gladiators in a Roman sport, do seem to have taken this kind of code of conduct aboard, almost chivalry. That this is how we're going to do it. We're not going to harm each other more than we absolutely have to. We'll put on a good show, but we know the rules. We know how this is going to go. We're going to try and do this as gentleman as much as possible. Dr Rad 29:07 Sounding positively lovely, the way you're describing it. Alexandra Sills 29:12 I should stress that it wasn't always. Still not lovely, yeah. Dr Rad 29:15 Still not lovely, yeah. So you've given us a bit of an indication there about what some of the sources are that you're consulting to try and get a better understanding of gladiators in the Greek world? So you've mentioned inscriptions and you've mentioned gravestones and that sort of thing. Are there any other sources that you were using to try and build this picture? Alexandra Sills 29:35 Yeah, and the the thing that I'm most proud of, I think, is putting it all together. Whereas before, it's been I'm specializing in this one type, so I'm trying to bring as many things as possible together. And it is incredible how much there is once you start looking. So we have again the gravestones and the reliefs are as much of an interesting facet of those gravestones as the epitaphs are. So much so that actually as. I said they they were trying to present themselves as a an arm of Greek athleticism so much so that earlier archeologists said this is the gravestone of the Pankration. Don't know why he's got a helmet and a sword, but he's clearly in the style of an athlete, so he must be an athlete, right? And it was Louis Robert who said, "No, I think this is a gladiator in Greece. Weird. So we have the gravestones. We have hundreds of them, which is fabulous. Which goes again into a little bit of the the Greekness, the the love of putting everything that you can onto a stone, and it's very un-Roman compared to the to the gravestones in the West, but we also have mosaics of gladiators. We have graffiti, loads of examples of graffiti. We have merchandise, which I love. We've got souvenirs, so there's terracotta lamps and flasks and statuettes and little dollies that you could move the arms and legs so that a little child could play like they do with a Barbie, and we have inscriptions from the people that were putting on the games as well, so we have their perspective and the terminology that they use is different. So we can see a real difference in the fact that they tend to mention nemesis as a deity, whereas the gladiators are talking more about the fates. We have the fact that the people putting on the games are talking about the gladiators as monomachoi, which is the Greek word that was used in Aeschylus, for instance, to mean dualists, one-on-one fighters. So it's a very archaic word in a way by the Roman period that's got this idea, this cultural idea behind it of one-on-one heroes in either the Theban cycle or the Trojan cycle. Whereas the gladiators are saying, no, we're not going to use that word. We're not going to use the word gladiator either. We're going to transliterate all of the words into Greek. We're going to write them in Greek. We're not interested in using that posh word from the plays. We're going to use transliterated words that are for us. So it's interesting to see the two kind of sides of the coin of the people producing and the people participating, using this different terminology that they're really really fond of, using different ideas of religion. We also have the venues that they fought in, which is amazing. And the fact that sometimes when you have a grave in a polis, and it says I fought here, and then you can go and stand in the place that you know that it definitely happened. That's pretty spectacular, really, when that happens. And it's interesting because the venues haven't been particularly the focus point of gladiatorial combat studies in the Greek world-they they've been noticed, but I believe I'm the first person to actually count them all and to map them all out. And all of a sudden, that idea of the Greeks were forced to have gladiators, or the Greeks were convinced that it was a good idea, but they didn't really want it. They just put up with it to satisfy the Romans. Disappears in a second. We've always counted how popular gladiators were by how many amphitheaters that that place has, but when you look at modern Greece and Turkey and Cyprus all together, that huge area has fewer amphitheaters than Great Britain, which is odd, right? Dr G 33:48 Yeah, that is odd. That that is a big difference. Alexandra Sills 33:52 At first glance, it's it's really odd. On the other hand, when the Romans came to Britain, we didn't have cities yet. We didn't have great monumental entertainment buildings. Yet they had to do everything from scratch, and also they had a huge military presence. So, and the veterans and the serving soldiers loved gladiators. If you want to keep them happy when they're stuck in a cold, rainy place like Britain, you give them some gladiators. Whereas when the Romans went to Greece, they found these mature, great civilization cities. There were no mud huts. There were cities that had ancient theaters, ancient stadiums, ones that had been used for centuries. Why are you going to build an outfit theater? You don't need one. So, when you start looking, you start seeing these very subtle changes to stadiums and theaters, just safety measures, really, like barriers and and separating the front row of seating in a theater from the gladiators by building a small wall, for instance, like the one that you can see in the Theater of Dionysus in Athens. That's got a safety barrier wall, which is for gladiators. And when you map those, as well as the very few amphitheaters in that area, all of a sudden, the Greek world goes from being the least interested in gladiators to being the third densest distribution of gladiatorial venues, after Tunisia at number two, and the Italian Peninsula at number one. So all of a sudden, Spain goes away. Britain falls right down the rankings because the Greek world shoots up to be incredibly interested in gladiatorial combat. Around 20% of all theaters have some modification, and there were a lot of Greek theaters. We're talking well over 100 Greek theaters had gladiatorial combat, and we know this because they permanently changed their theaters to make it safe to have them. You don't do that if you're just going to do it once. You do that if it's going to be a regular thing. Dr G 35:58 Ah, the evidence is in the same. Everybody, just look carefully. This is really fascinating because obviously it gives a completely different lens to contextualize what is the other evidence, like the Stele funerary works and things like that. Are there also challenges with the source material? Alexandra Sills 36:19 Absolutely, there are challenges, unfortunately. A lot of the epitaphs are partial, which means that we can very rarely recreate a full career. And also, the understanding that not every gladiator could afford one, so we have hundreds that we can read at least one word, or at least one image, but there are others, 1000s potentially of gladiators who could never afford one, or theirs has been lost, or it hasn't been found yet, and we will not know their stories, and we won't know anything about their careers. We assume, I assume, that it was the more successful ones who could afford a gravestone because that's a significant investment, or ones that had maybe some family wealth because we know that just as in the Roman West, in the Greek East it wasn't just enslaved people and prisoners of war fighting against gladiators. You had thrill seekers and people who had run up huge debts and needed a quick way of finding a lot of money because they could earn a lot of money. So perhaps it's the more successful ones are the ones that weren't fighting necessarily just because they were enslaved, but they had a bit of wealth. They just really liked adrenaline. They might be able to afford a gross stone. On the other hand, we can't assume that everyone of a certain wealth bracket had a gravestone or mentioned their career on a gravestone. We've got 1000s of gravestones from the Greek world that don't mention a career, presumably because certain professions would have thought talking about their job seemed a bit gauche. So we can't say we have this many that say gladiator on them. That means that there are more gladiators than there are than this profession, because they weren't mentioning their jobs. So it makes statistics difficult. There are a lot of venues, for instance, that have been unexcavated, or the stone has been robbed from them, so that even if it was excavated now, we probably will not know if a theater had or had no gladiators at all. So that's you know a node of of data that's disappeared forever. There are venues that have been covered over by modern buildings that we're never going to get to, unless something drastic happens, Dr Rad 38:47 and we don't want that. We don't want that. We don't want an earthquake Alexandra Sills 38:51 that levels a city just so that I can go and see if there's an amphitheater under there. And again, there's there's geopolitical issues about who can excavate and where, and can we go and excavate? No, there's currently a war going on, so we're not going to get there. So there are issues around how much data we can get, how much of it is going to be complete, and the interpretation of all of it is always going to be difficult. And there will be people that look at my dataset and interpret it differently from the way that I do, which is fine. That's how academia works, and I'm constantly hoping that we're getting more information as it comes in. But I'm very, very conscious of the fact that this is a partial representation of what we've got, and therefore I can really only make a best guess, but that's what every archeologist is doing. So, I'm trying to make my peace with the fact that I'm never going to have a full picture. Dr G 39:49 It's a real challenge of being a historian. In the end, is like certainty is so elusive. Dr Rad 40:12 Now, I'd love for you to tell us, actually, how gladiators first arrive in the Greek world, because we've talked a bit about the fact that this is something that happens a little bit later, but we haven't really specified exactly when. And actually, again, people might be surprised to learn that gladiators weren't even always a part of Rome's history. I mean, they're comparatively late if we are looking at all of Rome's history. Yeah, and we don't get as much information from that earlier period about gladiators in Rome either. You know, there are big gaps in between. There Alexandra Sills 40:48 are big gaps. Dr Rad 40:49 The examples that we have. So yeah, I'd love to know how they wind up in Greece. Alexandra Sills 40:53 I mean, they start in Rome as part of a funeral festival because funerals were a big deal, and they started off as we think, because again, this evidence is partial, and we've got several different sources giving us bits of information. So we have to try and put it all together and work out what's plausible. It seems to be that at a funeral of a consul, and consul obviously means also head of the military, when he died, he had just conquered an area to the west of Italy, I believe, and some of the guests decided to bring prisoners of war from that conquest to the funeral as a way of saying, "Look how great this man was in his role as consul and head of the military, he conquered these people. Here are the prisoners to prove it. Fantastic! That seems to be quite a common thing to do. Trophies, essentially human trophies, and someone we are told had the bright idea of. Wouldn't it be great to make them fight? Dr Rad 41:56 Because nothing says sorrow like man-on-man combat. Alexandra Sills 42:00 But again, when you look back at the Iliad, what do you have when some of the Greek heroes die? You see people being sacrificed, you see funeral games, and you do see people fighting at funerals. So it's not that much of a Roman idea. I'm pretty sure that the Romans didn't come up with the idea of gladiators anyway. We don't know whether they came from the Etruscans or or perhaps from the area of Campania, which is Pompeii, Naples, that kind of area. But they seem to have copied it from someone, so they didn't invent it. They didn't invent it. They just perfected it, if you like. So it's not Roman; it's Romanized, and then the Greeks take on gladiatorial combat, which is Romanized, and then they reify Dr Rad 42:50 it. Alexandra Sills 42:50 So obviously, we expect the first gladiators in Greece to be following Romans, and they were doing a lot of conquest. However, it was actually the Greeks that beat Rome to bringing gladiators to Greece by about a century. Dr Rad 43:08 Shocking! Shocking! The Romans really letting down a team here. Alexandra Sills 43:15 Rome was really slow, and they weren't particularly interested in taking gladiators as a cultural export, they were interested in taking gladiators around with them to entertain the Romans, who were doing the the trade, the conquest. The locals screw them. Who's interested in what they're entertained by? It was a Greek. It was a Hellenistic king who was the first person to put on Roman-style combat in the Greek world. His name was Antiochus the Fourth. He was the king of the Seleucid Empire, and he had been a hostage in Rome during his youth. So he had seen these cultural institutions. He'd been paying a lot of attention. So he had looked at the military, and he was thinking to himself, "I can use that. When I get home, I'm going to get my troops to do that, to wear this, to to stab this weight. I can use that. He was also looking at cultural institutions and saying, "Ah, okay, I can see the value in this. So when he got home and became the king of the Seleucid Empire, he did exactly that. He started revolutionizing his military, and he was very keen to use out this legion-style army that he was growing because the Hellenistic kings were very good at fighting other Hellenistic kings-they all had the same style of army, but once you go outside of the Hellenistic world, they were finding, oh, we're we're actually not the best at this. We're getting absolutely decimated. We need to evolve, or we're going to be destroyed. Which spoiler alert is what happened. They didn't evolve quickly enough, but Antiochus was definitely thinking, "I can use these Roman military ideas, and the Romans were getting their military ideas from gladiators. We know that there were certain occasions where generals were getting gladiators in to train their soldiers. In this is a different way of using the sword that we both use for our day-to-day work. You're using it like this. I use it like this. I find it quite useful. Do you want to give it a try? And the Romans were finding gladiatorial techniques a good way of their defeating their enemies. So it's entirely plausible that a Hellenistic king was looking at both gladiators and Roman soldiers and thinking, "Yeah, let's steal some of this. So he had a massive festival in Syria at a place called Daphne, which is just outside Antioch, and he had the typical Hellenistic festival. So he had his Seleucid elephants. He had chariots. He had dancers. He had a feast. He had all of this. He also had his new Roman style legion for everyone to look at. And this was a festival where other Hellenistic kingdoms were sending diplomats, etc. So they were looking and thinking, wow! These Seleucids have got some top-notch gear. All of a sudden, we should probably not attack them. So he was putting all of his wealth, all of his might, on display, and we are told he had multiple pairs of imported Roman gladiators to fight for the entertainment of the locals. Who we can imagine this first time we're thinking this is weird, but we can we can get with it. Okay, all right, and yeah, that was a whole century before Roman generals brought the first gladiators for their shows over, and we do know that at least one Roman diplomat was there shortly afterwards. I don't think he was there for the actual show, and was told we had gladiators. We imported them from Rome. Are you impressed? And he was. He was absolutely impressed. So yeah, the Romans didn't introduce gladiators to the Greek world at all. It was one of the people that they'd held hostage, who had been watching their every move when they didn't think he was, and stealing. Dr G 47:32 The history of gladiators is getting more controversial. I love this. Can the Romans not have one thing that is their own? I Dr Rad 47:38 love this because it actually makes me feel that the Romans were using gladiators the same way that I use Tim Tams. In that, when I travel and I take Tim Tams with me, it's not because I'm planning to share them. I'm taking them to eat them myself. Dr G 47:57 I see. I see. A very Australian. I know. Now everyone's going to be googling Tim Tams. Dr Rad 48:03 If you haven't tried a Tim Tam when you came to Australia, you've missed something because that's the real Australia. Everybody. Alexandra Sills 48:11 I mean, my mum takes tea bags on holiday with her, so we understand. Dr Rad 48:15 Yeah, exactly. Yep. Dr G 48:17 And it's fair enough. You don't want to be without your special tea. Yeah, but you're not going because you're trying to Dr Rad 48:22 colonize people. You're going because it's for you. Dr G 48:25 So I think this is a really interesting trajectory now that we're on in terms of where do gladiators come from, how do they get places, how do they end up in combat situations instead of just sort of funerary ceremonial moments, and this leads us into thinking more about like how do we see the spread of gladiatorial combat in the Greek world? Because we have this moment with Antiochus, and then we're saying about a century later the Romans are sort of on board with that concept now, and then I'm guessing there's like a second wave of gladiatorial spread into the Greek world. Alexandra Sills 49:04 That's another annoying issue that I have is that a lot of things aren't dateable, and we've got this kind of black hole of what's happening between Antiochus and then the Romans coming over. Did he continue to to perform with them? We don't know. We do know, for instance, that they didn't seem to build any venues for it at that time. But we don't know whether it was one-off or whether it lasted a decade or so. He died quite soon after afterwards, so we don't know whether his heirs were watching and thinking, "Yeah, we're going to copy the Romans because it's a cool thing to do. So we do have this gap. We don't know what's in it, and then the Romans start coming over about a century later, and we have literary evidence of them being there. So Lucullus, Julius Caesar, he does leave archeological evidence. Thank you, Caesar. The last time you'll hear me thank you, Dr Rad 50:02 Caesar. Alexandra Sills 50:03 He built two amphitheaters, and we have one of them. Fantastic! That's great. And then Mark Antony, he had a troupe of gladiators that he kept in Turkey. We don't know how often they performed. We know where they were based, so we have these these tidbits of information. Not a lot that's concrete at all, but we do get the impression that these early gladiatorial fights weren't for locals. We don't know if they were invited even. They were for Dr Rad 50:38 rude Alexandra Sills 50:39 Roman soldiers and expats who were living in that area who wanted a taste of home, but we can kind of recreate the spread of it by comparing it to Romanisation in air quotes in other places. So, for instance, in the book, I have a small kind of case study of what's happening next door. So I looked at Judea, and we have Herod, the same Herod who tried to kill Jesus. He's more famous outside of the Bible as being a very prolific builder. He loved building, but he also loved culture, Greek culture and Roman culture alike. He loved it all. He thought himself very cosmopolitan, and he wanted to show off his expansive cultural education in buildings that he felt deserved attention. So he built circuses, he built stadiums, he built theaters, and all of these are very, very interesting because he doesn't build any of them in a Greek or a Roman design. So none of them are typical, not a single one. And one of the reasons for this is they all seem to be hybrid. So a theater doubles up as an amphitheater, a stadium doubles up as a circus. Some of them are attached to each other, so we have all of these buildings that are a mishmash of architectural styles and purposes that are very Herodian, and we have mentions of him putting on chariot races, gladiatorial games, Greek athletic festivals. He's putting on all of these things that he's taken from the world around him, and he's showing them to the locals and saying, "Isn't this great? And he's putting on these amazing shows, and then he dies, and nothing. We don't have any information. It seems that in Judea, at least, it disappears for a little while. Then we have one mention of his grandson in the Tiberian period. He built what is now Beirut Hippodrome, but again, it's not one thing. It also seems to be an amphitheater. It also seems to be a circus because circuses and crimes were different as well. So he's also building something. So we've got this gap in between those that we don't know what's happening, and then we've got a gap after that as well. So gladiators in Judea seem to disappear off of the map after that period as well, until the Bar Kokhba revolt way into the future, so we've got these gaps. Is this because the locals didn't have that kind of cultural background of reading about duels in the Iliad and one-on-one combat in the plays and the sports that were insanely violent? Are they not being able to look at gladiators and saying this fits in with our existing culture? We don't know. What we do know is that by the time of the Bar Kokhba Revolt, amphitheaters start being built. Typical Roman amphitheaters by the legions, because at this point the emperors are saying, "Right, Judea, we can't trust you to remain quiet. We can't trust you to not rebel. We're going to have a permanent, huge military presence of Roman soldiers, and those Roman soldiers, as they did everywhere else, demanded in their days off Roman entertainment. So you see the amphitheaters. What we see there is very vocally the Talmud Jewish Talmud says, "Do not go. We don't want to see Jews going to the theater, going to the circus, or to the amphitheater. We don't want to see you there. It's foreign. It's not in our culture. We don't want you doing it. However, what we do see is if you see a fellow Jew who has been sold into slavery and bought as a gladiator, or he's been condemned to die in an arena, then you can attend the games. And the reason for this is because in that Jewish tradition, you have to witness a death. So that it can be recorded properly, and so that the widow can be recorded correctly as a widow, and allowed to remarry, etc. You have to have Jewish witnesses to that death, not to enjoy it as entertainment, but so that they can report back. Yes, this definitely did happen. So Jews were forbidden from going to any foreign cultural institutions unless it was to witness the death of one of their peers, and they didn't go. They they hated the idea of it. So in that area of the Roman Empire, we don't see the locals saying, "Yeah, this is great. Alexandra Sills 55:35 Give me more. It is happening in Greece. They do want more, and they are taking it far beyond where the legions are. So they're not waiting for a legion to camp in their city before they build an amphitheater. They're happily putting it on in their theaters and stadiums without the Romans having to tell them to. They don't seem to need any encouragement from Rome to do it, they don't need any convincing to do it, and the people putting on the games in the Greek world are the priests of the imperial cult. And as part of their role, as part of their year-long position in their city, they have to, out of their own pocket, give a gift to the local populace. In Rome, they would call that munera gift. In Greece, they call it filatimio, and they can do whatever they want. They can spend money on putting on a dramatic festival, an athletic festival. They can build a new fountain or a new temple or something, something that benefits the city and that everyone can enjoy as part of their role as priests of the imperial cult. They put on because they want to be re-elected. They put on what the people want, and what we see is a lot of these priests are constantly putting on games. They would not put on games if the people were refusing to attend, they would not put on games. If the people thought it was disgusting, they are putting on. They are providing what is demanded of them. And what we see clearly is people saying we want gladiators. We actually have a letter from Aphrodisias, from the priests of the imperial cult to the emperor, saying the people are asking us for gladiators. That's ridiculously expensive, but we kind of need a new aqueduct as well because our drinking water is getting a little bit iffy and people are getting sick. The people are asking for gladiators, though. What do you think we should do? And the emperor writes back, "Are you kidding me? Build the aqueduct. Don't don't worry about the gladiators. Dr G 57:45 Clean water supply or entertainment. It's a I don't know which one. The aqueduct is going to last for Alexandra Sills 57:52 decades. You can put your name on it. Build the aqueduct, obviously. And he's also making a point in that letter as well of saying, if there are any people trying to weasel their way out of being a priest of the imperial cult because they can't afford it, then we're going to start auditing all of you, because gladiators were so expensive and so in demand that there are clearly some people saying I can't be an imperial priest because I have to spend half of my wealth on gladiators, a percentage of which aren't even going to survive the day. It's an ephemeral gift compared to something like an aqueduct, which yes would bankrupt me, but at least there's a tangible benefit for it. So, in comparison to next door in Judea, where the locals are saying, "We do not want this. You are forcing it upon us. We do not want to participate in the arena or in the seating. We don't want it. The Greeks are clamoring for it. They're begging for it, and their local magistrates are saying, "I'm sorry, we can't afford it, or we need this more, and the Greeks aren't happy when they don't get it. So, Dr Rad 59:06 thanks for the water. Yeah, Alexandra Sills 59:09 clean drinking water. I don't want that. I want you know one afternoon of of combat instead. Dr Rad 59:16 What's the point of living with clean water if I can't then see gladiators? Alexandra Sills 59:20 But I mean, it does give you a hint, doesn't it, that this was not something that was forced on them, and that they really, really do love it and demand it, which completely ruins the idea of the bearded philosophers reading poetry to each other in the stoa. They don't want to do that. If if they'd have written to the emperor saying, "Can we build a stoa instead of the gladiators? We can imagine that the the people of Aphrodisias would have still been furious. No, we want the gladiators. Forget the poetry. Dr Rad 59:53 Now, for the Romans, when they would put on these displays, they. Our connections with their concept of virtus, which listeners of our show will recognize, is one of the things that we like to score the Romans on. It is a uniquely Roman concept, has definite masculine connotations. Is there a Greek equivalent you feel to that concept, and is that tied up with the way that gladiators are presented in the Greek world. Alexandra Sills 1:00:25 Yeah, so there definitely is something comparable, and that is arete. I'm going to pronounce that wrong. I'm sorry to the whole of the Greek world, but it is again the idea of masculine virtues, and in the Roman world, as I'm sure you've discussed, virtus is something that is different for every person because it's an umbrella term of a lot of different traits that you're supposed to have, and each profession, each man is going to have to take a different combination of traits to do their job well. Exactly the same in Greece. So the idea of being excellent essentially can apply to any man, depending on what they're doing, and it's not even just men. It it applies to things. Things can be described as being particularly excellent. So in the Greek world, in Homer, for instance, being excellent is being the best hero that you can possibly be, and that doesn't necessarily-that's not a moral thing. That's not being the kindest necessarily. It can mean being the most brutal on the battlefield. That's your job in that moment, and if you kill more people than the person next to you, then you are being particularly excellent, having a beautiful body that you tone in the gym, being cultured, knowing literary things, having that cultural background, and and knowing all of these connections between myth and history, that could make you Particularly excellent, being witty, having a strong body. So that's a tip for gladiators. Discipline, fortitude, courage. All of these things are in the Greek idea of being an excellent man, and we see this in their soldiers. We see this in their athletes. For those people, having strength, courage, discipline, fortitude, but also being strong, being skilled, being the best that you can possibly be, and fulfilling your potential in that is being excellent. In Rome, exactly the same thing, and for gladiators specifically in Rome, their job was to embody this idea of fearlessness, of physical strength being the most skilled possible. Because though the Greeks and the Romans, neither of them had any interest at all in underdogs. What's the point? What's the point of rooting for an underdog? You want to see people who have trained to the nth degree to be perfect going up against someone who has that same level of training and seeing who's the best of the best. You don't want to see this David and Goliath thing. That doesn't work for either side of the Mediterranean. No interest. You want to see two insanely talented people put to the utmost test of their mental courage, their physical strength, all of the skills that they've learned, putting them to the test. For the Romans, they were viewing gladiators as how to be brave, how to how to be courageous. How to make tough decisions. How to face death with courage. Gladiators were taught to accept death without flinching, without complaining, and that was incredibly important facet of it. They were there to perform death in front of an audience as a way of teaching the people death is going to come to all of us. You can either face it crying for your mum and screaming and begging to live another day, or you can do it the way I'm about to show you, which is to look death in the eye as a challenger and to not flinch even slightly, this is how a good Roman man dies, and then they die, and then everyone says, "Wow, look how courageous they were! They didn't even blink. So there's this idea of even in death, the gladiator is the master of his emotions, as well as someone who has performed skills to the utmost level, and the Greeks could get on board with that because, as we've seen at athletic festivals, including the ones at Olympia, Nemea, Isthmia, you know, all the big ones, Delphi, as well as in local games, you were seeing people put through these amazing physical. Trials of of combat and watching them use their mind that was made as strong as their body through this training through this discipline. So absolutely, whereas there are slight differences between Roman and Greek versions of masculine excellence. There are slight differences. It was definitely something that was transferable. So the Greeks were able to look at Roman gladiators and think, this person has all the athleticism of a pankratius or a boxer. Alexandra Sills 1:05:39 They have all of the military skills of a heroic soldier, they have all of the mental fortitude of our great heroes. So, instead of replacing any of those things, they seem to become this amalgamation of all of these things. There's still a performance of Greekness as far as the Greeks were concerned. They didn't need all of the the Roman ideology bit about imperialism-they didn't need that bit, but they were taking all of these ideas of this performance of excellence whilst you know very much masculine excellence. This performance of masculinity of strength was definitely something that they very very quickly got on board with not just the people watching, but the gladiators themselves. And when you see their epitaphs and the way that they depict themselves in art, as well as in the inscription, they are definitely playing up to that and saying, "I am as strong as Hercules. I am as beautiful as Narcissus. I am as quick. They give themselves stage names as well that emphasize the areas of excellence that they particularly embody. So, if they're beautiful, they will choose a name that includes Kali, beautiful, or Charis, golden. They love being called the Golden Boy, or you'll see them choose. Dr G 1:07:02 Of course they do. Alexandra Sills 1:07:06 Yeah, exactly. Of course they do. But they'll also choose names. So if if they're a retiarius, who are the nimble type of gladiator, they're not heavily armed. They move quickly. They tend to be more live. Then you see those are the people calling themselves Mr. Nimble, Mr. Swift, or they might name themselves after one of the winds, or if one of them is particularly strong, you'll see them name themselves after one of the sacred rivers. But they're also choosing about 25% of them choose their stage names from Greek plays and myths and poems. So we have at least six people calling themselves Achilles, and we have people calling themselves Odysseus. We have, we have definitely at least one set of people in the same city who called themselves Eteocles and Polynices, the the brothers of Thebes, and we can only imagine that when they fought each other, people were thinking to themselves, "Wow, I watched, I watched the the the play last week, and now I'm seeing it recreated in ultra realism in the same theater. I'm seeing the same fight because, of course, in Greek plays, all the violence is off stage. It all happens away. You don't see it. You have some messenger coming on saying there was this great dramatic fight, and I'm going to tell you about it in this speech, which is fine. And then you go and hear a poetry reading of the Iliad, and you hear someone describing one-on-one combat. And can I mention as well, Homer? I mean, there are scholars that believe that Homer must have been a veteran because of the way that he describes combat and the specifically the the wounds that you get from combat and what kinds of wounds different weapons inflict. Because he goes into a lot of detail in the Iliad. You talk about spears going through people's necks and cutting off the tongue at their base. You talk about eyes filling with blood. You talk about guts spilling out. None of that is sophisticated. None of that is particularly elegant. It's brutal. It's animalistic in a way, and this is what people in Greece were brought up on as their bedtime stories. So you go to hear the Iliad either in snippets or maybe there's a guy that comes to town and over you know a week he says I'll do a couple of books a night and you hear the whole thing over a week. People are hearing the Iliad and hearing about these these combats and thinking wow that's dramatic, but it's not until the gladiators come along where you actually get to see these mythical fights that you've been talking about for centuries. Now you get to see them, so it must have had quite a powerful effect. These stories that were part of your your bone. Your heritage, your generations back, we're talking about these same stories, but now you've got people recreating them with the stage names in the plays that you have seen the plays and heard the poems being recited. There must have been quite a strong emotional response to finally seeing it, rather than just hearing about Dr Rad 1:10:20 it. Like when I finally got to see Brad Pitt as Achilles, that was satisfying to me. Alexandra Sills 1:10:26 I think it was satisfying to quite a lot of people in the audience. I have to say though, I'm a Hector girl, Eric Bana all the way. Dr Rad 1:10:33 Look, you know, I have to also say that you know, obviously as an Australian, naturally I also have an affinity for Hector, but you know Achilles is the one that we tend to focus on. So Speaker 1 1:10:45 yeah, Dr Rad 1:10:46 Brad Pitt seemed like a good match. The Dr G 1:10:47 trouble is, as as Australians, we grew up with Eric Bana, so we we've seen him in many things, and this wasn't the first time we've saw him. And it was a surprise to see him there, to be honest. Yeah, at the Dr Rad 1:10:57 time that he did that, that was when he was starting to transition, like in Australia. For those of you who don't know, we've we've said this many times, but it bears saying again, Eric Bana came out of doing things like sketch comedy, and so seeing him transition into these very serious dramatic roles was a bit of a shock. See, I can't imagine that. I can't Alexandra Sills 1:11:15 imagine him doing a sketch comedy. Oh, seriously, you have to look him out. You Dr Rad 1:11:17 have to look him up. Dr G 1:11:19 Just so confusing to us. Yeah, and he's done really well, and he is amazing in Troy. There's no doubt about that. Thinking about this situation with the value systems that are going on, I'm also wondering about the social aspect of this for gladiators in the Roman world versus gladiators in the Greek world. What kind of differences are we seeing in status? Alexandra Sills 1:11:43 So this idea of infamia, of this lowering in status and the stripping of civic rights, the issue that I have with it is that we know what the idea of that is, but even in Rome, we only have anecdotal evidence of it being put into practice. So, for Rome and for the West, we can say yes, there was infamia and it meant this, this, this, this. But we only see it occasionally. So I can tell you that the idea was that gladiators was the untouchables. They were put in the same category as people who sold their bodies for entertainment, so sex workers, actors, funeral directors because they touch corpses. They they are the unclean, the untouchables, and they weren't allowed to vote, etc. They are outcasts from society who don't invite any of them to dinner parties. On the other hand, we also know that people, including quite high up people, hired gladiators-the ones that had retired, perhaps, or the ones that just weren't fighting at the time, because fights only happened a couple of times a year. These guys had to do something in the meantime as bodyguards. So, for instance, the the famous assassination Clodius and Milo on the Appian Way, that big fight, they had gladiator bodyguards with them. Didn't help one of them, obviously. So you have these people being hired to do a job for you. There's got to be some kind of interaction there, in the same way that we hear people of having affairs with actors and charioteers and sex workers, and you know, they are put into this category of you shall not touch them. But we're constantly seeing people desperate to touch them. Human nature, right? These people are still celebrities. Dr G 1:13:46 I was going to say, and as soon as you say you can't touch that, do not press that big red button. Alexandra Sills 1:13:53 Exactly, it's that same kind of thing. So we can understand that. Definitely, we know that people found Gladiators very sexually appealing. As soon as you say you can't touch them, you know what's going to happen. So yes, we know that there is this status in the Roman world of they are unclean. Don't go near them. We know that people did. That being said, we also have evidence in the Roman world, of gladiator, the word gladiator being used as an insult. So, for instance, Cicero throws it at Mark Antony in the Philippics. That man's no better than gladiator. Dr Rad 1:14:30 Burn Cicero. Alexandra Sills 1:14:31 It's it's a clear insult in that context. Dr G 1:14:36 Burn Cicero Alexandra Sills 1:14:38 is a gladiator. Whilst so the gladiators were strong, brave celebrities. However, their profession could still be turned around as an insult. So it's that weird kind of nebulous. Who are they? What I would say is I don't see the same kind of derogatory. Approach in Greece, we do see the same. They're sexy, obviously. They're very well muscled men. Don't wear a lot, you know. Dr Rad 1:15:11 Yeah, exactly. Alexandra Sills 1:15:12 People are going to find them sexy. I'm sorry, they are. And also, again, and I mentioned this in the Gladiator II episode, I believe they should be wearing less in the movies, so then they're not wearing a lot, and they're doing these fantastic things with their bodies. People are going to find them sexy. Dr Rad 1:15:27 Yeah. Do you hear that, Russell Crowe? Go back 25 years and change the first gladiator. The top half. Yeah. Exactly. Alexandra Sills 1:15:36 So we see that transfer, and we see the celebrity transfer. So we definitely see, for instance, in the graffiti we see names being written and specific people being mentioned. In the mosaics, even they have mosaics of gladiators with names above them. They're not just images of gladiators; it's of a specific person that that person living in the house either presented themselves or just really really appreciate it, so we see that transfer. I don't see the same kind of derision towards them, and I see that in the gravestones as well. For a start, the gravestones speak of themselves as being part of the Greek cultural landscape, so they're comparing themselves to not only athletes and soldiers. They're comparing themselves to heroes, saying again, "I am like Hercules. That's the kind of hubris that, if the public weren't agreeing with them, you might imagine the public would never let them get away with putting up a monument in the city, saying, "I am like this great hero that we all love. We don't see these things being defaced. We don't see these things being torn down. We we have an interesting issue with the gravestones in that very few of them are recorded as having a specific find spot. When you look in the archeological records; it will say it was found in this city. Well, yeah, thanks. Where? But what we do see, for instance, in Ephesus, we know that they didn't have an amphitheater in Ephesus. They fought in the theater and the stadium. The theater specifically has been changed. When you visit it, you can see the change to turn the theater orchestra into an arena, and we know from the fine spots there because the archeologists there, I thank them every day, did say specifically where they found the stones with gladiator names on, and those aren't gravestones actually. Those are stones put up by, we think, the people putting on the games, the high priests to say, remember these guys? I I provided these for you, aren't I? Great, wait for me again. And they were put right next to the entrance of the theater, which is, as we know, a hugely culturally significant place in a Greek polis, and everyone is happy to have images of gladiators at the entrance as they're going in, even for a play, they're not saying, "Oh, we'll watch them, but you can't commemorate them. That's disgusting. They are othered. They're beneath us. So I don't think we see the same lowering of social status, because I don't think the gladiators would be allowed to get away with what they say, I don't think their high priest would be allowed to get away with monumentalizing gladiators where they monumentalize gladiators, and I don't think that you would have the same level of othering. You don't need to, because again, when you look at the Olympics, these athletes who are, as I say, killing each other on occasion, they don't need to be lowered in status for us to enjoy watching them fight. In fact, they are the celebrities. If you win in Pancratius at the Olympics or at Delphi, etc. you become a hero in your time. You get a statue up of yourself. You don't need to justify watching this person hurt themselves and others by saying that they're almost not human. That they're not they're not civilized. They're not one of us. They are one of us, and that's what makes it great. That's why we're so proud of them because they're from our city, and they broke both this guy's legs and both his arms, and that's fantastic. So you don't need in the Greek world that same separation of gladiators from the city. They're part of your city. They're part of your cultural landscape. They live with you. They're part of your community. You don't need to exclude them to justify watching them do these things to each other because you already see it elsewhere in your community and you're fine with it. So again, I think a lot of scholars before and some even now I think are going to read this book and think she's. She's got it wrong. This desire to have the Greeks be different from the Romans. The Greeks are pure. The Romans tainted them, but the Greeks didn't want to be tainted. This idea that the Greeks didn't think in the same ways. Alexandra Sills 1:20:16 I think they're not going to enjoy the fact that I'm saying that the Greeks didn't have to justify to themselves in the same way. However, it's as far as I interpret it, I can't see it happening. It's it's going to be. I'll be interested to see the response from from certain people. But yeah, the the idea that the Greeks would have looked at gladiatorial combat as something disgusting that they needed to forgive themselves for, which is, I think, part of the infamia of gladiators. If we make them the lowest of the low, then we can forgive ourselves for watching them hurt and watching them die, because they are the lowest of the low. We've made them disposable. I don't see the Greeks making their gladiators disposable. I see them celebrating them. I see the gladiators feeling comfortable to celebrate themselves. They are using the imagery of athleticism and militarism. They are using the meter of their epitaphs match poetic meters. They are comparing themselves to heroes. They're naming themselves after heroes. And rather than the Greeks turning around and saying to them, "How dare you? The audacity. They're saying, "Yes, you are like Hercules. This is incredible. So I think that's I think that's probably the biggest difference between the two, is the Greeks celebrate their gladiators as a whole rather than celebrate the parts that they want and try and exclude the bits that they don't. the The mental gymnastics. I'm not saying mental gymnastics. I'm just seeing an enthusiastic response to this thing that they can say this is like our athletic games. This is like our military. This is like our poems. It's like a mashup. It's like the ultimate. We love it. It's Greek, but they're not Dr G 1:22:10 bring it on Alexandra Sills 1:22:12 exactly. Dr Rad 1:22:13 Well, I think that's probably a fantastic point for us to start wrapping up, listeners. I am sure you will want to get your hands on a copy of this provocative new take from Alexandria, who, as you can see, is wonderfully articulate and knowledgeable about this topic, and has left me with a very important new image of the Greeks, which is of them sitting in their theaters, going, "Whoa, dude, that's totally excellent when they're watching the Gladiators, and I think that that is a valuable lesson for us all. So, thank you so much for coming on the show, Alexandra. Tell us, is there anything new on the horizon for you that we should be looking out for apart from this wonderful new book? Alexandra Sills 1:22:59 You can definitely check out the podcast Ancient History 101, where we take a different topic every week, kind of approach it from a beginner's perspective straight off the bat, and then work our way up to knowing the absolute basics, essentially, but also being able to put things into context, being able to analyze sources. So for someone who hasn't been able to go to university or maybe needs to brush up on their skills, this is the podcast for you because we go from absolute base level and work our way up to expert slowly but surely. Dr Rad 1:23:33 I like the sound of that. All right, well, thank you so much for joining us on the show again. That book is "Gladiators in the Greek World: How a Roman bloodsport took ancient Greece by storm. You are definitely going to want to check this out. It will give you a whole new perspective on gladiators. Alexandra Sills 1:23:49 Thank you for having me on. Dr Rad 1:23:58 Thank you for listening to this episode of the Partial Historians. You can find our sources, sound credits, and an automated transcript in our show notes. Our music is by Bettina Joy de Guzman. The Partial Historians is part of the Memory Collective, creators and educators dedicated to sharing knowledge that is accessible, contextualized, socially conscious, and inclusive. To find more from the Memory Collective, you can head to collectivemem.com. Today, we would like to send our gratitude to all our Patreons, but particularly the fabulous Furii, our top tier Patreon supporters: M. Furius Camillus, Venieii, Veniara, Linda, Lex, Fredrik, Alex, Kyle, Ted, Jacob, and Joel. If you would also like to enjoy early access to our special episodes and ad-free content, please consider becoming a partial Patreon too. However. If you are also needing to volunteer in the arena for extra cash, please just tell someone about the show or give us a five-star review. Until next time, we are yours in ancient Rome. Transcribed by https://otter.ai